psyclaw 0.27.22 → 0.28.0

package/vendor/ars/scripts/temporal_integrity_audit.py

@@ -0,0 +1,840 @@
+#!/usr/bin/env python3
+"""v3.9.4 Phase 4 → 5 boundary temporal integrity verifier.
+
+5 passes per spec §3.2:
+  P1 — Mode 1 future-as-past arithmetic (TEMPORAL-ARITHMETIC-IMPOSSIBLE)
+  P2 — Mode 2 version-as-evidence-past anachronism (TEMPORAL-ANACHRONISTIC-CITATION)
+  P3 — Mode 3 comparator unmaterialized (TEMPORAL-COMPARATOR-UNMATERIALIZED)
+  P4 — Mode 4 causal inversion (TEMPORAL-CAUSAL-INVERSION)
+  P5 — Mode 5 time-bomb deictic (TEMPORAL-DEICTIC)
+  + TEMPORAL-METADATA-MISSING surfacing where ground truth is unavailable.
+
+All findings advisory in v3.9.4 (CC1).
+Inputs: finalized draft markdown with v3.7.3 <!--ref:slug--> markers, timeline.yaml, citation_provenance.yaml.
+Output: phase4_composition/temporal_audit_results.yaml (machine-readable) + .md (human-readable, Task 17).
+
+This Task 9 ships the scaffold. P1-P5 implementations land in Tasks 10-16. Markdown output in Task 17.
+"""
+from __future__ import annotations
+
+import argparse
+import re
+import sys
+from datetime import date
+from pathlib import Path
+
+import yaml
+
+DEICTIC_PATTERN = re.compile(
+    r"\b(currently|now|at present|most recent|the latest|new(?:est)?|recently|"
+    r"last\s+year|this\s+year|nowadays|presently|today|emerging|recent\s+cycle|"
+    r"latest\s+available)\b",
+    re.IGNORECASE,
+)
+
+MONTH_NAMES = "January|February|March|April|May|June|July|August|September|October|November|December"
+DATE_REGEX = (
+    r"\d{4}-\d{2}-\d{2}"
+    r"|(?:" + MONTH_NAMES + r")\s+\d{4}"
+    r"|(?:19|20)\d{2}"
+)
+
+PATTERN_A = re.compile(
+    r"(?:as of|on|in|reported in|stated in|noted in)\s+"
+    r"(?P<anchor>" + DATE_REGEX + r")"
+    r".*?\b(?:had already|already|completed|finished|delivered)\b.*?"
+    r"(?P<event>" + DATE_REGEX + r")",
+    re.IGNORECASE | re.DOTALL,
+)
+
+PATTERN_B = re.compile(
+    r"(?P<event>" + DATE_REGEX + r")"
+    r".*?\b(?:will be|to be|scheduled for|forthcoming|upcoming|planned)\b.*?"
+    r"(?:as of|in|by)\s+"
+    r"(?P<anchor>" + DATE_REGEX + r")",
+    re.IGNORECASE | re.DOTALL,
+)
+
+REF_MARKER_PATTERN = re.compile(r"<!--ref:([A-Za-z][A-Za-z0-9_:-]*)-->")
+
+COMPARATOR_FORM_A = re.compile(
+    r"(?P<adj>prior|previous|earlier|older|preceding)\s+"
+    r"(?P<noun>edition|version|edition\s+\(\d{4}\)|version\s+\(\d{4}\))",
+    re.IGNORECASE,
+)
+COMPARATOR_FORM_B = re.compile(
+    r"\b(?P<year>(?:19|20)\d{2})\s+"
+    r"(?P<noun>edition|version|standard|handbook|guideline)\b",
+    re.IGNORECASE,
+)
+COMPARATOR_FORM_C = re.compile(
+    r"(?P<noun>edition|version|standard)\s+(?:of|from)\s+"
+    r"(?P<year>(?:19|20)\d{2})\b",
+    re.IGNORECASE,
+)
+
+# 8 verb-to-required-ordering triggers per spec §3.2 P4
+CAUSAL_TRIGGERS = [
+    (re.compile(r"\benabled\b", re.IGNORECASE), "left<right"),
+    (re.compile(r"\bcaused\b", re.IGNORECASE), "left<right"),
+    (re.compile(r"\bled\s+to\b", re.IGNORECASE), "left<right"),
+    (re.compile(r"\bin\s+response\s+to\b", re.IGNORECASE), "left>right"),
+    (re.compile(r"\bsuperseded\b", re.IGNORECASE), "left>right"),
+    (re.compile(r"\bpreceded\b", re.IGNORECASE), "left<right"),
+    (re.compile(r"\bfollowed\s+by\b", re.IGNORECASE), "left<right"),
+    (re.compile(r"\bfollowed\b(?!\s+by)", re.IGNORECASE), "left>right"),
+]
+
+MONTH_TO_NUM = {name.lower(): f"{i+1:02d}" for i, name in enumerate(MONTH_NAMES.split("|"))}
+LAST_DAY = {"01": "31", "02": "28", "03": "31", "04": "30", "05": "31", "06": "30",
+            "07": "31", "08": "31", "09": "30", "10": "31", "11": "30", "12": "31"}
+
+
+def _date_to_interval(raw: str) -> tuple[str, str]:
+    """Normalize a date capture into (start, end) ISO 8601 day strings.
+
+    Handles all v3.9.4 schema-valid date shapes:
+    - YYYY-MM-DD → (date, date) point interval (day precision)
+    - YYYY-MM → YYYY-MM-01 .. YYYY-MM-last (month precision, v3.9.4.1 hotfix)
+    - YYYY-MM-DD..YYYY-MM-DD → parsed interval (interval precision, v3.9.4.1 hotfix)
+    - 'MonthName YYYY' → first of month .. last of month (prose form)
+    - YYYY → YYYY-01-01 .. YYYY-12-31 (year precision)
+
+    v3.9.4 only handled 3 prose forms — Crossref month-precision lookups from
+    bootstrap_timeline_yaml.py emit `YYYY-MM`, and effective_date_range with
+    precision:interval emits `YYYY-MM-DD..YYYY-MM-DD`. Both were schema-valid
+    but raised ValueError here, causing P2/P4 to silently skip the check.
+    """
+    raw = raw.strip()
+    # Day precision: YYYY-MM-DD
+    if re.fullmatch(r"\d{4}-\d{2}-\d{2}", raw):
+        return raw, raw
+    # Interval precision: YYYY-MM-DD..YYYY-MM-DD (v3.9.4.1 hotfix)
+    m_interval = re.fullmatch(r"(\d{4}-\d{2}-\d{2})\.\.(\d{4}-\d{2}-\d{2})", raw)
+    if m_interval:
+        return m_interval.group(1), m_interval.group(2)
+    # Month precision: YYYY-MM (v3.9.4.1 hotfix)
+    m_month = re.fullmatch(r"(\d{4})-(\d{2})", raw)
+    if m_month:
+        yr = m_month.group(1)
+        mo = m_month.group(2)
+        if mo not in LAST_DAY:
+            raise ValueError(f"invalid month in date: {raw!r}")
+        return f"{yr}-{mo}-01", f"{yr}-{mo}-{LAST_DAY[mo]}"
+    # Prose form: "MonthName YYYY"
+    m = re.fullmatch(r"(" + MONTH_NAMES + r")\s+(\d{4})", raw, re.IGNORECASE)
+    if m:
+        mo = MONTH_TO_NUM[m.group(1).lower()]
+        yr = m.group(2)
+        return f"{yr}-{mo}-01", f"{yr}-{mo}-{LAST_DAY[mo]}"
+    # Year precision: YYYY
+    if re.fullmatch(r"(?:19|20)\d{2}", raw):
+        return f"{raw}-01-01", f"{raw}-12-31"
+    raise ValueError(f"unrecognized date format: {raw!r}")
+
+
+def _date_diff_days(a: str, b: str) -> int:
+    """Days between two YYYY-MM-DD strings (a - b)."""
+    da = date.fromisoformat(a)
+    db = date.fromisoformat(b)
+    return (da - db).days
+
+
+def _sentence_around(draft: str, char_pos: int) -> str:
+    """Extract the sentence containing char_pos."""
+    pre = draft[:char_pos]
+    post = draft[char_pos:]
+    # Find last sentence terminator before char_pos
+    m_pre = re.search(r"[.!?]\s+(?=\S)", pre[::-1])
+    start = char_pos - m_pre.start() if m_pre else 0
+    # Find next sentence terminator at/after char_pos
+    m_post = re.search(r"[.!?](\s|$)", post)
+    end = char_pos + m_post.end() if m_post else len(draft)
+    return draft[start:end].strip()
+
+
+def _next_finding_id(findings: list[dict]) -> int:
+    """Compute the next sequential TF-NNN id (1-indexed) from existing findings."""
+    counter = [int(f["finding_id"].split("-")[1]) for f in findings] or [0]
+    return max(counter) + 1
+
+
+def _compute_line_number(draft: str, char_pos: int) -> int:
+    """Return 1-indexed line number of char_pos in draft."""
+    if char_pos <= 0:
+        return 1
+    return draft[:char_pos].count("\n") + 1
+
+
+def _provenance_confidence(slug: str, citation_provenance: dict) -> str | None:
+    """v3.9.4.1 hotfix: look up citation_provenance.entries[*].confidence for a ref slug.
+
+    Returns the confidence string ('high' | 'medium' | 'low' | 'conflict') or None
+    if the slug has no provenance entry (treated as 'not first-party verified').
+
+    Per spec §3.4: when confidence is 'low' or 'conflict', P2/P4 must NOT use the
+    timeline dates for arithmetic; instead emit TEMPORAL-METADATA-MISSING. v3.9.4
+    audit() never threaded citation_provenance through to P2/P4, defeating this
+    safety check.
+    """
+    if not citation_provenance:
+        return None
+    for entry in citation_provenance.get("entries", []):
+        if entry.get("citation_key") == slug:
+            return entry.get("confidence")
+    return None
+
+
+def _pass_1_arithmetic(draft: str, findings: list[dict]) -> None:
+    """P1 Mode 1 future-as-past arithmetic.
+
+    Pattern A: retrospective claim '(as of X) ... had already (Y)'; violation when event Y > anchor X.
+    Pattern B: prospective claim 'X (will be) ... (as of Y)'; violation when event X <= anchor Y.
+
+    If multiple violations match in the same sentence, emit the one with the largest
+    |event.start - anchor.end| gap (most clearly impossible).
+    """
+    pos = 0
+    for sentence in re.split(r"(?<=[.!?])\s+", draft):
+        sentence_start = draft.find(sentence, pos)
+        if sentence_start == -1:
+            sentence_start = pos
+        line_no = _compute_line_number(draft, sentence_start)
+        pos = sentence_start + len(sentence)
+
+        violations = []
+        m_a = PATTERN_A.search(sentence)
+        if m_a:
+            anchor_raw = m_a.group("anchor")
+            event_raw = m_a.group("event")
+            try:
+                anchor_start, anchor_end = _date_to_interval(anchor_raw)
+                event_start, event_end = _date_to_interval(event_raw)
+            except ValueError:
+                pass
+            else:
+                if event_start > anchor_end:
+                    violations.append(("A", anchor_raw, event_raw,
+                                       anchor_start, anchor_end, event_start, event_end))
+
+        m_b = PATTERN_B.search(sentence)
+        if m_b:
+            event_raw = m_b.group("event")
+            anchor_raw = m_b.group("anchor")
+            try:
+                anchor_start, anchor_end = _date_to_interval(anchor_raw)
+                event_start, event_end = _date_to_interval(event_raw)
+            except ValueError:
+                pass
+            else:
+                # Pattern B violation: forthcoming event already past at anchor time
+                if event_start <= anchor_end:
+                    violations.append(("B", anchor_raw, event_raw,
+                                       anchor_start, anchor_end, event_start, event_end))
+
+        if not violations:
+            continue
+
+        # Emit one finding per sentence — pick the largest-gap violation.
+        violations.sort(key=lambda v: abs(_date_diff_days(v[5], v[4])), reverse=True)
+        which, anchor_raw, event_raw, anchor_start, anchor_end, event_start, event_end = violations[0]
+        rationale = (
+            f"Pattern {which}: anchor '{anchor_raw}' ({anchor_start}..{anchor_end}) "
+            f"{'before' if which == 'A' else 'after'} event '{event_raw}' "
+            f"({event_start}..{event_end}); "
+            + ("event has not yet occurred at anchor time" if which == "A"
+               else "forthcoming event already past at anchor time")
+        )
+        findings.append({
+            "finding_id": f"TF-{_next_finding_id(findings):03d}",
+            "finding_kind": "TEMPORAL-ARITHMETIC-IMPOSSIBLE",
+            "severity": "HIGH",
+            "mode": 1,
+            "block_eligible": True,
+            "draft_locator": {
+                "file": "phase4_composition/draft.md",
+                "line": line_no,
+                "sentence": sentence.strip(),
+            },
+            "matched_span": None,
+            "bound_refs": [],
+            "bound_event": None,
+            "bound_dates": {
+                "left": {"role": "anchor",
+                         "value": f"{anchor_start}..{anchor_end}",
+                         "source": "draft_capture", "ref_slug": None},
+                "right": {"role": "event",
+                          "value": f"{event_start}..{event_end}",
+                          "source": "draft_capture", "ref_slug": None},
+            },
+            "rationale": rationale,
+            "suggested_fix": "Restate the claim to match the anchor's true time horizon, or hedge.",
+        })
+
+
+def _pass_2_anachronism(draft: str, timeline: dict, citation_provenance: dict, findings: list[dict]) -> None:
+    """P2 Mode 2 version-as-evidence-past anachronism.
+
+    For each <!--ref:slug--> marker:
+    1. v3.9.4.1 hotfix: Lookup slug in citation_provenance. If confidence is 'low' or
+       'conflict' → emit TEMPORAL-METADATA-MISSING and skip arithmetic (spec §3.4 promise:
+       first-party-unverified dates are NOT used as ground truth).
+    2. Lookup slug in timeline sources. Absent → emit TEMPORAL-METADATA-MISSING.
+    3. Lookup effective_date_range. Absent or start unverified/low → emit METADATA-MISSING.
+    4. Find nearest event date in ±200 chars around the ref marker.
+    5. Predicate (future-version): start > event.end → emit TEMPORAL-ANACHRONISTIC-CITATION.
+    6. Predicate (superseded-version): end < event.start (only when end.open_ended: false
+       and end.value known and confidence high/medium) → emit TEMPORAL-ANACHRONISTIC-CITATION.
+    """
+    sources_by_key = {s["citation_key"]: s for s in timeline.get("sources", [])}
+
+    for m_ref in REF_MARKER_PATTERN.finditer(draft):
+        slug = m_ref.group(1)
+        ref_line_no = _compute_line_number(draft, m_ref.start())
+
+        # v3.9.4.1 hotfix: provenance confidence gate (spec §3.4)
+        prov_conf = _provenance_confidence(slug, citation_provenance)
+        if prov_conf in {"low", "conflict"}:
+            findings.append({
+                "finding_id": f"TF-{_next_finding_id(findings):03d}",
+                "finding_kind": "TEMPORAL-METADATA-MISSING",
+                "severity": "LOW",
+                "mode": None,
+                "block_eligible": False,
+                "draft_locator": {
+                    "file": "phase4_composition/draft.md",
+                    "line": ref_line_no,
+                    "sentence": _sentence_around(draft, m_ref.start()),
+                },
+                "matched_span": None,
+                "bound_refs": [{"ref_slug": slug, "timeline_entry": None}],
+                "bound_event": None,
+                "bound_dates": None,
+                "rationale": f"<!--ref:{slug}--> citation_provenance confidence={prov_conf}; per spec §3.4 not used as arithmetic ground truth.",
+                "suggested_fix": None,
+            })
+            continue
+
+        source = sources_by_key.get(slug)
+        if source is None:
+            findings.append({
+                "finding_id": f"TF-{_next_finding_id(findings):03d}",
+                "finding_kind": "TEMPORAL-METADATA-MISSING",
+                "severity": "LOW",
+                "mode": None,
+                "block_eligible": False,
+                "draft_locator": {
+                    "file": "phase4_composition/draft.md",
+                    "line": ref_line_no,
+                    "sentence": _sentence_around(draft, m_ref.start()),
+                },
+                "matched_span": None,
+                "bound_refs": [{"ref_slug": slug, "timeline_entry": None}],
+                "bound_event": None,
+                "bound_dates": None,
+                "rationale": f"<!--ref:{slug}--> has no entry in timeline.yaml; cannot verify temporal claims against this citation.",
+                "suggested_fix": None,
+            })
+            continue
+
+        edr = source.get("effective_date_range")
+        if not edr:
+            findings.append({
+                "finding_id": f"TF-{_next_finding_id(findings):03d}",
+                "finding_kind": "TEMPORAL-METADATA-MISSING",
+                "severity": "LOW",
+                "mode": None,
+                "block_eligible": False,
+                "draft_locator": {
+                    "file": "phase4_composition/draft.md", "line": ref_line_no,
+                    "sentence": _sentence_around(draft, m_ref.start()),
+                },
+                "matched_span": None,
+                "bound_refs": [{"ref_slug": slug, "timeline_entry": slug}],
+                "bound_event": None,
+                "bound_dates": None,
+                "rationale": f"{slug} has no effective_date_range; anachronism check cannot run.",
+                "suggested_fix": None,
+            })
+            continue
+
+        start = edr["start"]
+        start_conf = start.get("provenance", {}).get("confidence")
+        if start.get("value") is None or start_conf in {"unverified", "low"}:
+            findings.append({
+                "finding_id": f"TF-{_next_finding_id(findings):03d}",
+                "finding_kind": "TEMPORAL-METADATA-MISSING",
+                "severity": "LOW",
+                "mode": None,
+                "block_eligible": False,
+                "draft_locator": {
+                    "file": "phase4_composition/draft.md", "line": ref_line_no,
+                    "sentence": _sentence_around(draft, m_ref.start()),
+                },
+                "matched_span": None,
+                "bound_refs": [{"ref_slug": slug, "timeline_entry": slug}],
+                "bound_event": None,
+                "bound_dates": None,
+                "rationale": f"{slug} effective_date_range.start absent or low/unverified confidence; cannot verify anachronism.",
+                "suggested_fix": None,
+            })
+            continue
+
+        # Find nearest event date in ±200 chars around ref marker
+        # Exclude dates that overlap the ref marker itself (slug digits are not event dates)
+        window_start = max(0, m_ref.start() - 200)
+        window_end = min(len(draft), m_ref.end() + 200)
+        window = draft[window_start:window_end]
+        date_pattern = re.compile(DATE_REGEX, re.IGNORECASE)
+        # Compute ref marker span relative to window
+        ref_in_window_start = m_ref.start() - window_start
+        ref_in_window_end = m_ref.end() - window_start
+        event_dates = [
+            d for d in date_pattern.finditer(window)
+            if d.end() <= ref_in_window_start or d.start() >= ref_in_window_end
+        ]
+        if not event_dates:
+            continue  # no event date → no finding
+
+        # Pick closest to the ref marker position within the window
+        rel_ref = m_ref.start() - window_start
+        nearest = min(event_dates, key=lambda d: abs(d.start() - rel_ref))
+        event_raw = nearest.group(0)
+        try:
+            event_start, event_end = _date_to_interval(event_raw)
+            edr_start_start, _ = _date_to_interval(start["value"])
+        except ValueError:
+            continue
+
+        # Future-version check (spec §3.2 P2 step 5 first clause): start > event.end
+        if edr_start_start > event_end:
+            findings.append({
+                "finding_id": f"TF-{_next_finding_id(findings):03d}",
+                "finding_kind": "TEMPORAL-ANACHRONISTIC-CITATION",
+                "severity": "HIGH",
+                "mode": 2,
+                "block_eligible": True,
+                "draft_locator": {
+                    "file": "phase4_composition/draft.md", "line": ref_line_no,
+                    "sentence": _sentence_around(draft, m_ref.start()),
+                },
+                "matched_span": None,
+                "bound_refs": [{"ref_slug": slug, "timeline_entry": slug}],
+                "bound_event": {"event_id": None, "date": f"{event_start}..{event_end}"},
+                "bound_dates": None,
+                "rationale": (
+                    f"{slug} effective_date_range starts {start['value']}, after cited "
+                    f"event {event_raw} ({event_start}..{event_end}). Cited version postdates the event."
+                ),
+                "suggested_fix": f"Cite the version of the source that was in effect during {event_raw}.",
+            })
+
+        # Superseded-version check (spec §3.2 P2 step 5 second clause)
+        end = edr.get("end", {})
+        end_open_ended = end.get("open_ended", False)
+        end_value = end.get("value")
+        end_conf = end.get("provenance", {}).get("confidence")
+        if (not end_open_ended and end_value is not None
+                and end_conf in {"high", "medium"}):
+            try:
+                _, edr_end_end = _date_to_interval(end_value)
+            except ValueError:
+                pass
+            else:
+                if edr_end_end < event_start:
+                    findings.append({
+                        "finding_id": f"TF-{_next_finding_id(findings):03d}",
+                        "finding_kind": "TEMPORAL-ANACHRONISTIC-CITATION",
+                        "severity": "HIGH",
+                        "mode": 2,
+                        "block_eligible": True,
+                        "draft_locator": {
+                            "file": "phase4_composition/draft.md", "line": ref_line_no,
+                            "sentence": _sentence_around(draft, m_ref.start()),
+                        },
+                        "matched_span": None,
+                        "bound_refs": [{"ref_slug": slug, "timeline_entry": slug}],
+                        "bound_event": {"event_id": None, "date": f"{event_start}..{event_end}"},
+                        "bound_dates": None,
+                        "rationale": (
+                            f"{slug} effective_date_range ended {end_value}, before cited "
+                            f"event {event_raw} ({event_start}..{event_end}). Cited version was "
+                            f"superseded before the event."
+                        ),
+                        "suggested_fix": f"Cite the version of the source that was in effect during {event_raw}.",
+                    })
+
+
+def _pass_3_comparator(draft: str, timeline: dict, findings: list[dict]) -> None:
+    """P3 Mode 3 comparator unmaterialized.
+
+    Detects prose comparator framing (Form A: 'prior edition', Form B: 'YYYY edition',
+    Form C: 'edition of YYYY'). For each match, binds version_family_id via the
+    nearest <!--ref:slug--> in the sentence/paragraph. If no timeline entry in that
+    family has a matching year, emits TEMPORAL-COMPARATOR-UNMATERIALIZED.
+
+    Per spec §3.2 P3: each match independently emits up to one finding per match;
+    there is no per-sentence cap.
+    """
+    sources_by_key = {s["citation_key"]: s for s in timeline.get("sources", [])}
+    sources_by_family: dict[str, list[dict]] = {}
+    for s in timeline.get("sources", []):
+        fam = s.get("version_family_id")
+        if fam:
+            sources_by_family.setdefault(fam, []).append(s)
+
+    pos = 0
+    for sentence in re.split(r"(?<=[.!?])\s+", draft):
+        sentence_start = draft.find(sentence, pos)
+        if sentence_start == -1:
+            sentence_start = pos
+        line_no = _compute_line_number(draft, sentence_start)
+        pos = sentence_start + len(sentence)
+
+        for pattern_name, pat in [("A", COMPARATOR_FORM_A), ("B", COMPARATOR_FORM_B), ("C", COMPARATOR_FORM_C)]:
+            for m in pat.finditer(sentence):
+                # Resolve version_family_id via ref marker in sentence
+                refs_in_sentence = REF_MARKER_PATTERN.findall(sentence)
+                if not refs_in_sentence:
+                    continue  # binding ambiguous — emit no finding
+                bound_slug = refs_in_sentence[0]
+                bound_source = sources_by_key.get(bound_slug)
+                if not bound_source or not bound_source.get("version_family_id"):
+                    continue
+                family = bound_source["version_family_id"]
+
+                # Determine comparator year
+                if pattern_name == "A":
+                    year_match = re.search(
+                        r"\b(?:19|20)\d{2}\b",
+                        sentence[max(0, m.start() - 60):min(len(sentence), m.end() + 60)],
+                    )
+                    if not year_match:
+                        continue
+                    comparator_year = year_match.group(0)
+                else:
+                    comparator_year = m.group("year")
+
+                # Check whether any source in this family has matching published_date year
+                family_sources = sources_by_family.get(family, [])
+                matched = False
+                for s in family_sources:
+                    pd = s.get("published_date")
+                    if pd and pd.get("value") and comparator_year in pd["value"]:
+                        matched = True
+                        break
+
+                if not matched:
+                    findings.append({
+                        "finding_id": f"TF-{_next_finding_id(findings):03d}",
+                        "finding_kind": "TEMPORAL-COMPARATOR-UNMATERIALIZED",
+                        "severity": "MEDIUM",
+                        "mode": 3,
+                        "block_eligible": False,
+                        "draft_locator": {
+                            "file": "phase4_composition/draft.md", "line": line_no,
+                            "sentence": sentence.strip(),
+                        },
+                        "matched_span": {
+                            "text": m.group(0),
+                            "char_start": m.start(),
+                            "char_end": m.end(),
+                        },
+                        "bound_refs": [{"ref_slug": bound_slug, "timeline_entry": bound_slug}],
+                        "bound_event": None,
+                        "bound_dates": None,
+                        "rationale": (
+                            f"Comparator '{m.group(0)}' (Form {pattern_name}, year={comparator_year}) "
+                            f"references version family '{family}' but no timeline entry exists for that year. "
+                            f"v3.9.4 reports this as claim-unsupported; v3.10 CC5 may escalate to phantom."
+                        ),
+                        "suggested_fix": (
+                            f"Either add a timeline entry for the {comparator_year} version of {family}, "
+                            f"or rewrite the prose to remove the comparator claim."
+                        ),
+                    })
+                    # do NOT break — spec allows one finding per match
+
+
+def _pass_4_causal(draft: str, timeline: dict, citation_provenance: dict, findings: list[dict]) -> None:
+    """P4 Mode 4 causal inversion.
+
+    For each causal trigger phrase, identifies left and right arguments. Each side
+    may bind to either a <!--ref:slug--> marker (preferred) or a direct date capture
+    in the sentence (v3.9.4.1 hotfix: spec §3.2 P4 fallback).
+
+    v3.9.4.1 also adds citation_provenance gate (spec §3.4): if either bound slug has
+    confidence:low or conflict, emit TEMPORAL-METADATA-MISSING and skip predicate.
+
+    Looks up refs' published_date OR uses direct date capture, then verifies the
+    required ordering. If violated, emits TEMPORAL-CAUSAL-INVERSION.
+    """
+    sources_by_key = {s["citation_key"]: s for s in timeline.get("sources", [])}
+    date_pattern = re.compile(DATE_REGEX, re.IGNORECASE)
+
+    pos = 0
+    for sentence in re.split(r"(?<=[.!?])\s+", draft):
+        sentence_start = draft.find(sentence, pos)
+        if sentence_start == -1:
+            sentence_start = pos
+        line_no = _compute_line_number(draft, sentence_start)
+        pos = sentence_start + len(sentence)
+
+        for trigger_pat, required_order in CAUSAL_TRIGGERS:
+            m_trig = trigger_pat.search(sentence)
+            if not m_trig:
+                continue
+
+            pre = sentence[:m_trig.start()]
+            post = sentence[m_trig.end():]
+
+            # Bind left: nearest ref BEFORE trigger; else nearest direct date BEFORE
+            left_refs = list(REF_MARKER_PATTERN.finditer(pre))
+            left_slug = left_refs[-1].group(1) if left_refs else None
+            left_date_raw = None
+            if left_slug is None:
+                # v3.9.4.1 fix #3: direct date fallback (spec §3.2 P4)
+                left_dates = list(date_pattern.finditer(pre))
+                if left_dates:
+                    left_date_raw = left_dates[-1].group(0)
+
+            # Bind right: nearest ref AFTER trigger; else nearest direct date AFTER
+            right_refs = list(REF_MARKER_PATTERN.finditer(post))
+            right_slug = right_refs[0].group(1) if right_refs else None
+            right_date_raw = None
+            if right_slug is None:
+                right_dates = list(date_pattern.finditer(post))
+                if right_dates:
+                    right_date_raw = right_dates[0].group(0)
+
+            # At least one side must bind
+            if not (left_slug or left_date_raw) or not (right_slug or right_date_raw):
+                continue
+
+            # v3.9.4.1 hotfix: provenance gate for either slug
+            for chk_slug in [left_slug, right_slug]:
+                if chk_slug is None:
+                    continue
+                prov_conf = _provenance_confidence(chk_slug, citation_provenance)
+                if prov_conf in {"low", "conflict"}:
+                    findings.append({
+                        "finding_id": f"TF-{_next_finding_id(findings):03d}",
+                        "finding_kind": "TEMPORAL-METADATA-MISSING",
+                        "severity": "LOW",
+                        "mode": None,
+                        "block_eligible": False,
+                        "draft_locator": {
+                            "file": "phase4_composition/draft.md", "line": line_no,
+                            "sentence": sentence.strip(),
+                        },
+                        "matched_span": None,
+                        "bound_refs": [{"ref_slug": chk_slug, "timeline_entry": None}],
+                        "bound_event": None,
+                        "bound_dates": None,
+                        "rationale": f"<!--ref:{chk_slug}--> citation_provenance confidence={prov_conf}; per spec §3.4 not used as arithmetic ground truth for P4.",
+                        "suggested_fix": None,
+                    })
+                    # Skip this trigger after emitting METADATA-MISSING for either side
+                    break
+            else:
+                pass  # no provenance issue, continue to predicate
+            # Re-check: if any prov gate fired, the for-else didn't run, we want to skip predicate
+            if any(
+                _provenance_confidence(s, citation_provenance) in {"low", "conflict"}
+                for s in [left_slug, right_slug] if s is not None
+            ):
+                continue
+
+            # Resolve left date
+            if left_slug:
+                left_src = sources_by_key.get(left_slug)
+                if not left_src:
+                    continue
+                left_pd = left_src.get("published_date", {}).get("value")
+                if not left_pd:
+                    continue
+                try:
+                    left_start, _ = _date_to_interval(left_pd)
+                except ValueError:
+                    continue
+                left_source = "timeline_ref"
+            else:
+                try:
+                    left_start, _ = _date_to_interval(left_date_raw)
+                except ValueError:
+                    continue
+                left_source = "draft_capture"
+
+            # Resolve right date
+            if right_slug:
+                right_src = sources_by_key.get(right_slug)
+                if not right_src:
+                    continue
+                right_pd = right_src.get("published_date", {}).get("value")
+                if not right_pd:
+                    continue
+                try:
+                    right_start, _ = _date_to_interval(right_pd)
+                except ValueError:
+                    continue
+                right_source = "timeline_ref"
+            else:
+                try:
+                    right_start, _ = _date_to_interval(right_date_raw)
+                except ValueError:
+                    continue
+                right_source = "draft_capture"
+
+            violated = (
+                (required_order == "left<right" and left_start >= right_start)
+                or (required_order == "left>right" and left_start <= right_start)
+            )
+            if not violated:
+                continue
+
+            # v3.9.4.1 hotfix: bound_refs and bound_dates.source vary by binding mode
+            bound_refs_list = []
+            if left_slug:
+                bound_refs_list.append({"ref_slug": left_slug, "timeline_entry": left_slug})
+            if right_slug:
+                bound_refs_list.append({"ref_slug": right_slug, "timeline_entry": right_slug})
+
+            findings.append({
+                "finding_id": f"TF-{_next_finding_id(findings):03d}",
+                "finding_kind": "TEMPORAL-CAUSAL-INVERSION",
+                "severity": "MEDIUM",
+                "mode": 4,
+                "block_eligible": False,
+                "draft_locator": {
+                    "file": "phase4_composition/draft.md", "line": line_no,
+                    "sentence": sentence.strip(),
+                },
+                "matched_span": {
+                    "text": m_trig.group(0),
+                    "char_start": m_trig.start(),
+                    "char_end": m_trig.end(),
+                },
+                "bound_refs": bound_refs_list,
+                "bound_event": None,
+                "bound_dates": {
+                    "left": {"role": "left_arg", "value": left_start,
+                             "source": left_source, "ref_slug": left_slug},
+                    "right": {"role": "right_arg", "value": right_start,
+                              "source": right_source, "ref_slug": right_slug},
+                },
+                "rationale": (
+                    f"Trigger '{m_trig.group(0)}' requires ordering {required_order}, "
+                    f"but left.date={left_start} and right.date={right_start} violate predicate."
+                ),
+                "suggested_fix": "Rewrite to match the actual ordering, or revise the causal claim.",
+            })
+            break  # one finding per sentence
+
+
+def _pass_5_deictic(draft: str, findings: list[dict]) -> None:
+    """P5 Mode 5 time-bomb deictic regex lint."""
+    lines = draft.splitlines(keepends=True)
+
+    for m in DEICTIC_PATTERN.finditer(draft):
+        line_no = _compute_line_number(draft, m.start())
+        line_text = lines[line_no - 1].rstrip("\n") if line_no <= len(lines) else ""
+
+        findings.append({
+            "finding_id": f"TF-{_next_finding_id(findings):03d}",
+            "finding_kind": "TEMPORAL-DEICTIC",
+            "severity": "LOW",
+            "mode": 5,
+            "block_eligible": False,
+            "draft_locator": {
+                "file": "phase4_composition/draft.md",
+                "line": line_no,
+                "sentence": line_text,
+            },
+            "matched_span": {
+                "text": m.group(0),
+                "char_start": m.start(),
+                "char_end": m.end(),
+            },
+            "bound_refs": [],
+            "bound_event": None,
+            "bound_dates": None,
+            "rationale": f"Deictic phrase '{m.group(0)}' anchors claim to writing time; rewrite to specific date or version identifier.",
+            "suggested_fix": "Replace with 'as of YYYY-MM-DD' or a specific edition/year reference.",
+        })
+
+
+def audit(draft: str, timeline: dict, citation_provenance: dict,
+          report_reference_date: str, audit_run_id: str) -> dict:
+    """Run the 5-pass verifier. Returns an aggregate matching temporal_audit_results.schema.json.
+
+    v3.9.4.1 hotfix: citation_provenance now flows through to P2 and P4 (per spec §3.4).
+    """
+    findings: list[dict] = []
+    _pass_1_arithmetic(draft, findings)
+    _pass_2_anachronism(draft, timeline, citation_provenance, findings)
+    _pass_3_comparator(draft, timeline, findings)
+    _pass_4_causal(draft, timeline, citation_provenance, findings)
+    _pass_5_deictic(draft, findings)
+    return {
+        "schema_version": "1.0",
+        "audit_run_id": audit_run_id,
+        "report_reference_date": report_reference_date,
+        "findings": findings,
+    }
+
+
+def _render_markdown(result: dict) -> str:
+    """Render the temporal audit results dict as a human-readable Markdown report."""
+    lines = [
+        "# Temporal Audit Results",
+        "",
+        f"- audit_run_id: `{result['audit_run_id']}`",
+        f"- report_reference_date: `{result['report_reference_date']}`",
+        f"- total findings: **{len(result['findings'])}**",
+        "",
+    ]
+    if not result["findings"]:
+        lines.append("_No temporal-integrity findings in this draft._")
+        return "\n".join(lines) + "\n"
+    for f in result["findings"]:
+        lines.extend([
+            f"## {f['finding_id']} — {f['finding_kind']} ({f['severity']})",
+            "",
+            f"- mode: {f['mode']}",
+            f"- file: `{f['draft_locator']['file']}` line {f['draft_locator']['line']}",
+            f"- sentence: \"{f['draft_locator']['sentence']}\"",
+            f"- rationale: {f['rationale']}",
+        ])
+        if f.get("suggested_fix"):
+            lines.append(f"- suggested fix: {f['suggested_fix']}")
+        lines.append("")
+    return "\n".join(lines) + "\n"
+
+
+def main(argv: list[str] | None = None) -> int:
+    parser = argparse.ArgumentParser(description="v3.9.4 temporal integrity verifier (Phase 4 → 5 boundary)")
+    parser.add_argument("--draft", type=Path, required=True)
+    parser.add_argument("--timeline", type=Path, required=True)
+    parser.add_argument("--citation-provenance", type=Path, required=True)
+    parser.add_argument("--output", type=Path, required=True)
+    parser.add_argument("--markdown-output", type=Path, default=None,
+                        help="Optional path for human-readable .md report")
+    parser.add_argument("--report-reference-date", required=True)
+    parser.add_argument("--audit-run-id", required=True)
+    args = parser.parse_args(argv)
+
+    draft = args.draft.read_text()
+    timeline = yaml.safe_load(args.timeline.read_text())
+    citation_provenance = yaml.safe_load(args.citation_provenance.read_text())
+
+    result = audit(draft, timeline, citation_provenance,
+                   args.report_reference_date, args.audit_run_id)
+
+    args.output.write_text(yaml.safe_dump(result, sort_keys=False))
+    if args.markdown_output:
+        args.markdown_output.write_text(_render_markdown(result))
+    return 0
+
+
+if __name__ == "__main__":
+    sys.exit(main())