aiox-core 5.0.4 → 5.0.5

package/pro/squads/squad-creator-pro/workflows/wf-cross-provider-qualification.yaml

@@ -1,711 +0,0 @@
-# wf-cross-provider-qualification.yaml
-# Workflow para qualificar modelos EXTERNOS (Kimi K2.5, GLM-5, etc) vs Opus
-# Version: 1.0
-# Created: 2026-02-12
-# Author: @architect (Aria)
-
-workflow:
-  id: wf-cross-provider-qualification
-  name: "Cross-Provider Model Qualification"
-  version: "1.0"
-  purpose: "Testar se modelos externos (via OpenRouter) podem substituir Opus em tasks específicas"
-  orchestrator: "@pedro-valerio"
-  mode: "autonomous"
-
-# ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
-# PHILOSOPHY
-# ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
-
-philosophy:
-  core: |
-    "Não assumir. Provar com dados."
-    "Custo importa, mas qualidade é inegociável."
-    "PT-BR é obrigatório para nosso pipeline."
-    "Latência conta — modelo lento é modelo inútil."
-
-  key_differences_from_tier_qualification:
-    - "Modelos externos via LLM Router/OpenRouter (não Task tool)"
-    - "Latência tracking obrigatório"
-    - "Múltiplos runs para medir reliability"
-    - "Fase específica para PT-BR quality"
-    - "Privacy risk flag obrigatório"
-
-# ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
-# EXTERNAL MODELS REGISTRY
-# ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
-
-external_models:
-  glm5:
-    provider: openrouter
-    model_id: "z-ai/glm-5"
-    display_name: "GLM-5"
-    cost_per_mtok:
-      input: 0.80
-      output: 3.20
-    context_window: 200000
-    validation_report: "docs/model-discovery/scans/2026-02-12/validation-glm-5.md"
-    verdict: "ADD_CONDITIONAL"
-    privacy_risk: "moderate"  # Singapore entity, China parent
-    pt_br_status: "unknown"
-
-  kimi:
-    provider: openrouter
-    model_id: "moonshotai/kimi-k2.5"
-    display_name: "Kimi K2.5"
-    cost_per_mtok:
-      input: 0.50
-      output: 2.80
-    context_window: 256000
-    validation_report: "docs/model-discovery/scans/2026-02-08/validation-kimi-k2-5.md"
-    verdict: "MONITOR"
-    privacy_risk: "high"  # China, trains on prompts
-    pt_br_status: "unknown"
-    latency_warning: "HIGH (15-200s per request)"
-
-  # Baseline para comparação
-  opus:
-    provider: anthropic
-    model_id: "claude-opus-4-6"
-    display_name: "Claude Opus 4.6"
-    cost_per_mtok:
-      input: 5.00
-      output: 25.00
-    context_window: 1000000
-    privacy_risk: "low"
-    pt_br_status: "excellent"
-
-# ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
-# VETO CONDITIONS
-# ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
-
-veto_conditions:
-  - id: CPQ_VC_001
-    trigger: "Task não está no test_input_registry"
-    action: "BLOCK - Adicionar input ao registry primeiro"
-
-  - id: CPQ_VC_002
-    trigger: "Opus baseline falha ou output vazio"
-    action: "BLOCK - Não há baseline para comparar"
-
-  - id: CPQ_VC_003
-    trigger: "Modelo externo retorna erro em >50% dos runs"
-    action: "BLOCK - Modelo não é confiável para esta task"
-
-  - id: CPQ_VC_004
-    trigger: "Decisão oposta ao Opus (PASS vs FAIL)"
-    action: "BLOCK - Modelo não qualificado (decisão errada)"
-
-  - id: CPQ_VC_005
-    trigger: "PT-BR quality score < 7.0/10"
-    action: "BLOCK - Modelo não qualificado para PT-BR"
-
-  - id: CPQ_VC_006
-    trigger: "Latência média > 60s"
-    action: "FLAG - Só usar para batch/async jobs"
-
-  - id: CPQ_VC_007
-    trigger: "Privacy risk = high AND task envolve dados sensíveis"
-    action: "BLOCK - Usar self-hosted ou escolher outro modelo"
-
-# ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
-# TEST INPUT REGISTRY (Cross-Provider Candidates)
-# ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
-# Tasks Opus-tier que podem ser testadas com modelos externos
-
-cross_provider_candidates:
-  # === DNA EXTRACTION (High Value, High Cost) ===
-  extract-voice-dna:
-    current_tier: opus
-    test_with: [glm5, kimi]
-    expected_savings: "80-90%"
-    risk: "Quality degradation in voice capture"
-    test_input:
-      target: "outputs/minds/pedro_valerio/sources/"
-      type: "sources_directory"
-    pt_br_critical: true
-
-  extract-thinking-dna:
-    current_tier: opus
-    test_with: [glm5, kimi]
-    expected_savings: "80-90%"
-    risk: "Missing mental models"
-    test_input:
-      target: "outputs/minds/pedro_valerio/sources/"
-      type: "sources_directory"
-    pt_br_critical: true
-
-  # === RESEARCH (Good Candidate) ===
-  deep-research-pre-agent:
-    current_tier: opus
-    test_with: [glm5, kimi]
-    expected_savings: "80-90%"
-    risk: "Superficial research"
-    test_input:
-      target: "Pedro Valério"
-      type: "person_name"
-    pt_br_critical: false
-    note: "Kimi Agent Swarm could excel here"
-
-  # === AGENT CREATION ===
-  create-agent:
-    current_tier: opus
-    test_with: [glm5]  # GLM-5 has lower hallucination
-    expected_savings: "80%"
-    risk: "Generic agent without depth"
-    test_input:
-      target: "outputs/minds/pedro_valerio/"
-      type: "mind_directory"
-    pt_br_critical: true
-
-  an-design-clone:
-    current_tier: opus
-    test_with: [glm5]
-    expected_savings: "80%"
-    risk: "Incomplete clone structure"
-    test_input:
-      target: "outputs/minds/pedro_valerio/"
-      type: "mind_directory"
-    pt_br_critical: true
-
-# ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
-# INPUTS
-# ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
-
-inputs:
-  required:
-    - name: task_name
-      type: string
-      description: "Nome da task (sem .md)"
-      example: "extract-voice-dna"
-      validation: "Must exist in cross_provider_candidates"
-
-    - name: candidate_model
-      type: enum
-      values: ["glm5", "kimi"]
-      description: "Modelo externo a testar"
-
-  optional:
-    - name: threshold
-      type: number
-      default: 0.85
-      description: "Threshold mínimo de qualidade vs Opus"
-
-    - name: reliability_runs
-      type: number
-      default: 3
-      description: "Número de runs para medir reliability"
-
-    - name: skip_pt_br
-      type: boolean
-      default: false
-      description: "Pular teste PT-BR (não recomendado)"
-
-# ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
-# PHASES
-# ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
-
-phases:
-  # ─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
-  # PHASE 0: PRE-FLIGHT VALIDATION
-  # ─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
-  - id: phase_0
-    name: "PRE-FLIGHT"
-    purpose: "Validar inputs, verificar modelo disponível, criar diretório"
-    duration: "< 1 min"
-
-    steps:
-      - id: step_0_1
-        name: "Check cross_provider_candidates"
-        action: "Lookup task_name in cross_provider_candidates"
-        veto_if: "task_name not in registry → CPQ_VC_001"
-
-      - id: step_0_2
-        name: "Check model in test_with list"
-        action: "Verify candidate_model is in task's test_with array"
-        veto_if: "Model not allowed for this task"
-
-      - id: step_0_3
-        name: "Check model availability"
-        action: |
-          Bash: node infrastructure/services/llm-router/bin/check-model.js {candidate_model}
-          Verify model responds to ping
-        veto_if: "Model unavailable or API error"
-
-      - id: step_0_4
-        name: "Read task file"
-        action: "Read squads/squad-creator-pro/tasks/{task_name}.md completely"
-        output:
-          task_prompt: "Full task content"
-
-      - id: step_0_5
-        name: "Create test directory"
-        action: "mkdir -p squads/squad-creator-pro/test-cases/cross-provider/{task_name}/{candidate_model}/"
-
-    checkpoint:
-      id: CP_PREFLIGHT
-      blocking: true
-
-  # ─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
-  # PHASE 1: BASELINE EXECUTION (Opus)
-  # ─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
-  - id: phase_1
-    name: "OPUS BASELINE"
-    purpose: "Executar task em Opus para estabelecer baseline de qualidade"
-    duration: "2-5 min"
-
-    steps:
-      - id: step_1_1
-        name: "Execute in Opus"
-        action: |
-          Task(
-            subagent_type: "general-purpose",
-            model: "opus",
-            prompt: "Read squads/squad-creator-pro/tasks/{task_name}.md completely.
-                     Execute the task with input: {test_input.target}
-                     Save output as YAML to test-cases/cross-provider/{task_name}/{candidate_model}/opus-baseline.yaml
-                     Include metadata: tokens used, duration_ms."
-          )
-        output:
-          opus_result: "Full output saved to file"
-          opus_tokens: { input: 0, output: 0 }
-          opus_latency_ms: 0
-          opus_cost_usd: 0
-
-    checkpoint:
-      id: CP_BASELINE
-      blocking: true
-      veto_if: "Output empty or error → CPQ_VC_002"
-
-  # ─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
-  # PHASE 2: CANDIDATE EXECUTION (Multiple Runs for Reliability)
-  # ─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
-  - id: phase_2
-    name: "CANDIDATE RELIABILITY TEST"
-    purpose: "Executar modelo externo N vezes para medir reliability e variance"
-    duration: "5-15 min (depends on model latency)"
-
-    steps:
-      - id: step_2_1
-        name: "Execute reliability runs"
-        action: |
-          FOR i in 1..{reliability_runs}:
-
-            start_time = now()
-
-            # Call via LLM Router
-            result = Bash(
-              node infrastructure/services/llm-router/index.js \
-                --task "{task_name}" \
-                --model "{candidate_model}" \
-                --input "{test_input.target}" \
-                --output "test-cases/cross-provider/{task_name}/{candidate_model}/run-{i}.yaml"
-            )
-
-            end_time = now()
-
-            Record:
-              - run_number: i
-              - success: true/false
-              - latency_ms: end_time - start_time
-              - tokens: { input, output }
-              - error: null or error_message
-
-        output:
-          runs: "Array of run results"
-          success_rate: "N successful / N total"
-          avg_latency_ms: "Average latency"
-          latency_variance: "Min/max/stddev"
-          total_cost_usd: "Sum of all runs"
-
-      - id: step_2_2
-        name: "Check reliability threshold"
-        action: |
-          IF success_rate < 0.5:
-            → VETO (CPQ_VC_003)
-
-          IF avg_latency_ms > 60000:
-            → FLAG as "batch-only" (CPQ_VC_006)
-        output:
-          reliability_verdict: "PASS | BATCH_ONLY | FAIL"
-
-    checkpoint:
-      id: CP_RELIABILITY
-      blocking: true
-
-  # ─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
-  # PHASE 3: QUALITY COMPARISON
-  # ─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
-  - id: phase_3
-    name: "QUALITY COMPARISON"
-    purpose: "Comparar output do melhor run com Opus baseline"
-    duration: "2-3 min"
-
-    steps:
-      - id: step_3_1
-        name: "Select best run"
-        action: |
-          Select the successful run with:
-          1. Lowest latency (if all similar quality)
-          2. Most complete output (section count)
-        output:
-          best_run_file: "run-{N}.yaml"
-
-      - id: step_3_2
-        name: "Compare across 5 dimensions"
-        action: |
-          Same comparison as wf-model-tier-qualification:
-
-          1. COMPLETENESS (weight: 0.30)
-             - Section count: candidate vs opus
-
-          2. ACCURACY (weight: 0.30)
-             - Key decisions match (PASS/FAIL, scores)
-             - VETO CHECK: opposite decision → CPQ_VC_004
-
-          3. REASONING (weight: 0.20)
-             - Evidence depth and specificity
-
-          4. FORMAT (weight: 0.10)
-             - YAML valid, structure matches
-
-          5. ACTIONABILITY (weight: 0.10)
-             - Recommendations count and quality
-
-        output:
-          dimension_scores: "Per-dimension breakdown"
-          quality_score: "Weighted percentage (0-100%)"
-          gaps: "List of gap types"
-
-      - id: step_3_3
-        name: "Calculate cost savings"
-        action: |
-          opus_cost = (opus_tokens.input * 5.00 / 1_000_000) + (opus_tokens.output * 25.00 / 1_000_000)
-          candidate_cost = (candidate_tokens.input * model.cost.input / 1_000_000) + (candidate_tokens.output * model.cost.output / 1_000_000)
-
-          # Adjust for reliability (cost of retries)
-          effective_candidate_cost = candidate_cost / success_rate
-
-          savings_pct = (1 - effective_candidate_cost / opus_cost) * 100
-        output:
-          opus_cost_usd: 0
-          candidate_cost_usd: 0
-          effective_cost_usd: 0
-          savings_percentage: 0
-
-    checkpoint:
-      id: CP_QUALITY
-      blocking: true
-      output:
-        saved_to: "test-cases/cross-provider/{task_name}/{candidate_model}/quality-comparison.yaml"
-
-  # ─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
-  # PHASE 4: PT-BR QUALITY TEST
-  # ─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
-  - id: phase_4
-    name: "PT-BR QUALITY TEST"
-    purpose: "Testar qualidade do modelo em português brasileiro"
-    duration: "3-5 min"
-    condition: "NOT skip_pt_br AND task.pt_br_critical"
-
-    pt_br_test_prompts:
-      - id: ptbr_1
-        name: "Technical Writing"
-        prompt: |
-          Escreva uma documentação técnica de 500 palavras sobre arquitetura de microsserviços.
-          Inclua: definição, benefícios, desafios, e quando usar.
-          Use linguagem técnica mas acessível.
-        eval_criteria:
-          - fluency: "Português natural, não traduzido"
-          - accuracy: "Termos técnicos corretos"
-          - completeness: "Todos os pontos cobertos"
-
-      - id: ptbr_2
-        name: "Framework Extraction"
-        prompt: |
-          Dado o seguinte texto sobre metodologia de vendas:
-
-          "O fechamento acontece quando você elimina todas as objeções do cliente.
-          Primeiro, identifique a objeção real. Depois, concorde parcialmente.
-          Por fim, apresente uma perspectiva diferente que resolve a objeção."
-
-          Extraia o framework em formato YAML com: nome, etapas, e quando aplicar.
-        eval_criteria:
-          - understanding: "Captou a essência do método"
-          - structure: "YAML válido e bem organizado"
-          - no_hallucination: "Não inventou etapas extras"
-
-      - id: ptbr_3
-        name: "Voice Consistency"
-        prompt: |
-          Você é Pedro Valério, especialista em processos e automação.
-          Sua filosofia é: "Se o executor consegue errar, o processo está errado."
-
-          Responda à pergunta: "Como você abordaria a criação de um novo workflow?"
-
-          Mantenha sua voz e perspectiva consistentes.
-        eval_criteria:
-          - voice_match: "Soa como o personagem"
-          - philosophy_applied: "Usa os princípios mencionados"
-          - natural_pt_br: "Português fluente"
-
-    steps:
-      - id: step_4_1
-        name: "Execute PT-BR prompts"
-        action: |
-          FOR each prompt in pt_br_test_prompts:
-            result = Bash(
-              node infrastructure/services/llm-router/index.js \
-                --model "{candidate_model}" \
-                --prompt "{prompt.prompt}" \
-                --output "test-cases/cross-provider/{task_name}/{candidate_model}/ptbr-{prompt.id}.yaml"
-            )
-
-      - id: step_4_2
-        name: "Evaluate PT-BR quality"
-        action: |
-          Task(
-            subagent_type: "general-purpose",
-            model: "opus",  # Opus avalia PT-BR quality
-            prompt: "Avalie a qualidade do português brasileiro nos outputs anexados.
-
-                     Para cada output, score de 1-10:
-                     - Fluência (português natural, não traduzido)
-                     - Precisão (termos técnicos corretos)
-                     - Completude (resposta completa)
-
-                     Overall PT-BR Score = média dos scores.
-
-                     VETO se overall < 7.0"
-          )
-        output:
-          ptbr_scores: "Per-prompt breakdown"
-          ptbr_overall: "Overall score (0-10)"
-
-      - id: step_4_3
-        name: "PT-BR verdict"
-        action: |
-          IF ptbr_overall < 7.0:
-            → VETO (CPQ_VC_005)
-            verdict = "PT-BR NOT QUALIFIED"
-          ELSE IF ptbr_overall < 8.0:
-            verdict = "PT-BR ACCEPTABLE (with caveats)"
-          ELSE:
-            verdict = "PT-BR QUALIFIED"
-        output:
-          ptbr_verdict: "QUALIFIED | ACCEPTABLE | NOT_QUALIFIED"
-
-    checkpoint:
-      id: CP_PTBR
-      blocking: true
-      veto_if: "ptbr_overall < 7.0 → CPQ_VC_005"
-
-  # ─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
-  # PHASE 5: GENERATE REPORT
-  # ─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
-  - id: phase_5
-    name: "GENERATE REPORT"
-    purpose: "Criar relatório final com toda evidência"
-    duration: "1-2 min"
-
-    steps:
-      - id: step_5_1
-        name: "Generate qualification report"
-        action: |
-          Create test-cases/cross-provider/{task_name}/{candidate_model}/qualification-report.yaml:
-
-          cross_provider_qualification_report:
-            task_name: "{task_name}"
-            candidate_model: "{candidate_model}"
-            test_date: "{today}"
-            workflow_version: "1.0"
-
-            baseline:
-              model: "opus"
-              cost_usd: "{opus_cost}"
-              tokens: { input: X, output: Y }
-              latency_ms: Z
-              file: "opus-baseline.yaml"
-
-            candidate:
-              model: "{candidate_model}"
-              provider: "{model.provider}"
-
-              reliability:
-                runs: {reliability_runs}
-                success_rate: "{success_rate}%"
-                avg_latency_ms: {avg_latency}
-                latency_range: "{min_ms}-{max_ms}ms"
-                verdict: "{reliability_verdict}"
-
-              quality:
-                overall_score: "{quality_score}%"
-                dimension_scores: {dimension_scores}
-                gaps: [{gaps}]
-
-              cost:
-                per_run_usd: "{candidate_cost}"
-                effective_usd: "{effective_cost}" # adjusted for retries
-                vs_opus_savings: "{savings_pct}%"
-
-              pt_br:
-                tested: true/false
-                overall_score: "{ptbr_overall}/10"
-                verdict: "{ptbr_verdict}"
-
-            decision:
-              final: "{QUALIFIED | QUALIFIED_BATCH_ONLY | NOT_QUALIFIED}"
-              recommended_use: "{task types}"
-              caveats: ["{list of caveats}"]
-
-            privacy_assessment:
-              risk_level: "{model.privacy_risk}"
-              recommendation: "{self-host | api | do-not-use}"
-
-            evidence_files:
-              - "opus-baseline.yaml"
-              - "run-1.yaml"
-              - "run-2.yaml"
-              - "run-3.yaml"
-              - "quality-comparison.yaml"
-              - "ptbr-*.yaml"
-              - "qualification-report.yaml"
-
-      - id: step_5_2
-        name: "Update model-routing.yaml"
-        condition: "decision is QUALIFIED or QUALIFIED_BATCH_ONLY"
-        action: |
-          Add to model-routing.yaml under external_alternatives:
-
-          {task_name}:
-            external_alternative:
-              model: "{candidate_model}"
-              qualified: true
-              quality_vs_opus: "{quality_score}%"
-              savings: "{savings_pct}%"
-              batch_only: true/false
-              pt_br_qualified: true/false
-              tested_date: "{today}"
-
-      - id: step_5_3
-        name: "Display summary"
-        action: |
-          ╔══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╗
-          ║  CROSS-PROVIDER QUALIFICATION RESULT                                     ║
-          ╠══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╣
-          ║  Task: {task_name}                                                       ║
-          ║  Candidate: {candidate_model} ({model.display_name})                     ║
-          ║                                                                          ║
-          ║  RELIABILITY                                                             ║
-          ║  ├─ Success Rate: {success_rate}%                                        ║
-          ║  ├─ Avg Latency: {avg_latency}ms                                         ║
-          ║  └─ Verdict: {reliability_verdict}                                       ║
-          ║                                                                          ║
-          ║  QUALITY                                                                 ║
-          ║  ├─ vs Opus: {quality_score}%                                            ║
-          ║  └─ Gaps: {gaps_count}                                                   ║
-          ║                                                                          ║
-          ║  PT-BR                                                                   ║
-          ║  ├─ Score: {ptbr_overall}/10                                             ║
-          ║  └─ Verdict: {ptbr_verdict}                                              ║
-          ║                                                                          ║
-          ║  COST                                                                    ║
-          ║  ├─ Opus: ${opus_cost}/run                                               ║
-          ║  ├─ {candidate}: ${candidate_cost}/run                                   ║
-          ║  └─ SAVINGS: {savings_pct}%                                              ║
-          ║                                                                          ║
-          ║  ══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════  ║
-          ║  DECISION: {final_decision}                                              ║
-          ║  PRIVACY: {privacy_risk} → {privacy_recommendation}                      ║
-          ╚══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════╝
-
-# ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
-# BATCH EXECUTION
-# ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
-
-batch_mode:
-  description: "Testar múltiplas tasks com múltiplos modelos"
-
-  execution_strategy:
-    # Fase 1: GLM-5 (melhor candidato baseado em validation reports)
-    wave_1_glm5:
-      model: glm5
-      tasks:
-        - extract-voice-dna
-        - extract-thinking-dna
-        - create-agent
-        - deep-research-pre-agent
-
-    # Fase 2: Kimi K2.5 (se GLM-5 não qualificar)
-    wave_2_kimi:
-      model: kimi
-      tasks:
-        - deep-research-pre-agent  # Kimi Swarm pode excel aqui
-      condition: "Only if GLM-5 not qualified for task"
-
-  consolidated_report:
-    output: "squads/squad-creator-pro/test-cases/cross-provider/DASHBOARD.yaml"
-
-# ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
-# FAILURE PATHS
-# ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
-
-failure_paths:
-  - scenario: "Model API unavailable"
-    action: "Skip model, try next in wave. Log error."
-
-  - scenario: ">50% runs fail"
-    action: "Mark as NOT_QUALIFIED. Model unreliable."
-
-  - scenario: "Opposite decision (PASS vs FAIL)"
-    action: "Mark as NOT_QUALIFIED. Quality unacceptable."
-
-  - scenario: "PT-BR score < 7.0"
-    action: "Mark as NOT_QUALIFIED for PT-BR tasks. May still qualify for EN-only."
-
-  - scenario: "Latency > 60s avg"
-    action: "Mark as QUALIFIED_BATCH_ONLY. Not for sync use."
-
-  - scenario: "Privacy risk = high AND sensitive task"
-    action: "Recommend self-hosting. Do not use API for sensitive data."
-
-# ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
-# OUTPUTS
-# ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
-
-outputs:
-  per_task:
-    - "test-cases/cross-provider/{task_name}/{model}/opus-baseline.yaml"
-    - "test-cases/cross-provider/{task_name}/{model}/run-{N}.yaml"
-    - "test-cases/cross-provider/{task_name}/{model}/quality-comparison.yaml"
-    - "test-cases/cross-provider/{task_name}/{model}/ptbr-{id}.yaml"
-    - "test-cases/cross-provider/{task_name}/{model}/qualification-report.yaml"
-
-  batch:
-    - "test-cases/cross-provider/DASHBOARD.yaml"
-
-# ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
-# METADATA
-# ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════
-
-metadata:
-  version: "1.0"
-  created: "2026-02-12"
-  author: "@architect"
-
-  dependencies:
-    - "infrastructure/services/llm-router/" # Para chamar modelos externos
-    - "wf-model-tier-qualification.yaml"    # Comparison logic
-    - "validation-glm-5.md"                 # GLM-5 validation report
-    - "validation-kimi-k2-5.md"             # Kimi validation report
-
-  changelog:
-    - version: "1.0"
-      date: "2026-02-12"
-      changes:
-        - "Initial workflow based on tier-qualification pattern"
-        - "Added external_models registry (GLM-5, Kimi K2.5)"
-        - "Added Phase 2: Reliability test (multiple runs)"
-        - "Added Phase 4: PT-BR quality test"
-        - "Added privacy risk assessment"
-        - "Added latency tracking and batch-only verdict"
-        - "5 cross_provider_candidates defined"