@windyroad/itil 0.61.1 → 0.61.2

package/scripts/test/plugin-maturity-populate.bats

@@ -1,631 +0,0 @@
-#!/usr/bin/env bats
-
-# @problem P237 — Phase 3a population script behavioural confirmation.
-# @problem P087 — parent: plugin maturity battle-hardening signal.
-#
-# Contract under test: `packages/itil/scripts/plugin-maturity-populate.sh`
-# reads two Phase 2 NDJSON streams (`wr-itil-skill-invocations` +
-# `wr-itil-plugin-exercise-index`), applies ADR-053 §promotion criteria +
-# §Bootstrapping clause, and writes `maturity:` field per surface and per
-# plugin root in each `packages/<plugin>/.claude-plugin/plugin.json`.
-# Idempotent — re-running with unchanged inputs (including pinned `--now`)
-# produces byte-identical plugin.json output.
-#
-# Confirmation criteria 1-3 from ADR-063 §Confirmation are the load-bearing
-# behavioural assertions; criteria 4-9 belong to Phase 3b / 3c sibling
-# tickets (P238 / P239).
-#
-# @adr ADR-063 (Plugin maturity presentation layer — Phase 3a contract)
-# @adr ADR-053 (Plugin maturity taxonomy — promotion criteria + Bootstrapping)
-# @adr ADR-058 (Phase 2 NDJSON measurement — input shape)
-# @adr ADR-049 (Shim grammar — `wr-itil-plugin-maturity-populate` on $PATH)
-# @adr ADR-052 (Behavioural tests default — NDJSON-fixture-driven, not
-#   structural grep on script body; AskUserQuestion negative-presence is
-#   the documented carve-out)
-# @adr ADR-044 (Silent-framework carve-out — Phase 3a band recomputation
-#   is mechanical, policy-resolved per ADR-053 §promotion criteria; no
-#   `AskUserQuestion` per band recompute)
-# @adr ADR-013 Rule 6 (non-interactive fail-safe — exit 0 always)
-# @jtbd JTBD-201 (Restore Service Fast — audit-trail composition; the
-#   per-surface evidence block IS the durable audit-trail surface)
-
-setup() {
-  SCRIPTS_DIR="$(cd "$(dirname "$BATS_TEST_FILENAME")/.." && pwd)"
-  SCRIPT="$SCRIPTS_DIR/plugin-maturity-populate.sh"
-  FIXTURE_DIR="$(mktemp -d)"
-  PROJECT_ROOT="$FIXTURE_DIR/project"
-  mkdir -p "$PROJECT_ROOT/packages"
-}
-
-teardown() {
-  rm -rf "$FIXTURE_DIR"
-}
-
-# Helper: create a synthetic plugin under packages/<name>/ with a
-# minimal plugin.json and the declared surface inventory. Surfaces are
-# passed as `kind:name` tokens — e.g. `skill:manage-problem`,
-# `agent:agent`, `hook:itil-changeset-discipline`.
-make_plugin() {
-  local plugin="$1"; shift
-  local pkg="$PROJECT_ROOT/packages/$plugin"
-  mkdir -p "$pkg/.claude-plugin"
-  cat >"$pkg/.claude-plugin/plugin.json" <<EOF
-{
-  "name": "wr-$plugin",
-  "version": "0.1.0",
-  "description": "fixture plugin"
-}
-EOF
-  for token in "$@"; do
-    local kind="${token%%:*}"
-    local name="${token#*:}"
-    case "$kind" in
-      skill)   mkdir -p "$pkg/skills/$name"; echo "fixture" >"$pkg/skills/$name/SKILL.md" ;;
-      agent)   mkdir -p "$pkg/agents"; echo "fixture" >"$pkg/agents/$name.md" ;;
-      hook)    mkdir -p "$pkg/hooks"; echo "fixture" >"$pkg/hooks/$name.sh" ;;
-      command) mkdir -p "$pkg/commands"; echo "fixture" >"$pkg/commands/$name.md" ;;
-    esac
-  done
-}
-
-# Helper: write a synthetic transcript NDJSON file (`wr-itil-skill-invocations`
-# output shape, schema_version 1.0) with one record per (kind, surface).
-# Args: file, then triples of kind, surface, invocations.
-write_transcript_ndjson() {
-  local out="$1"; shift
-  : >"$out"
-  while [ "$#" -ge 3 ]; do
-    local kind="$1"; local surface="$2"; local invocations="$3"
-    shift 3
-    local plugin
-    # Extract plugin name: skill/agent surfaces use `wr-<plugin>:<rest>`,
-    # bash-attributed surfaces use `wr-<plugin>-<rest>`.
-    if [[ "$surface" == *:* ]]; then
-      plugin="${surface%%:*}"
-      plugin="${plugin#wr-}"
-    else
-      plugin="${surface#wr-}"
-      plugin="${plugin%%-*}"
-    fi
-    printf '{"schema_version":"1.0","axis":"skill-invocations","surface":"%s","kind":"%s","plugin":"%s","window_days":30,"invocations":%d,"first_invocation_iso":"2026-04-20T00:00:00Z","last_invocation_iso":"2026-05-17T00:00:00Z"}\n' \
-      "$surface" "$kind" "$plugin" "$invocations" >>"$out"
-  done
-}
-
-# Helper: write a synthetic exercise NDJSON file (`wr-itil-plugin-exercise-index`
-# output shape, schema_version 1.0). Args: file, then 5-tuples of
-# plugin, commits_window, days_shipped, closed_tickets, breaking_age (or NULL).
-write_exercise_ndjson() {
-  local out="$1"; shift
-  : >"$out"
-  while [ "$#" -ge 5 ]; do
-    local plugin="$1"; local cw="$2"; local ds="$3"; local ctw="$4"; local bca="$5"
-    shift 5
-    if [ "$bca" = "NULL" ]; then
-      bca="null"
-    fi
-    printf '{"schema_version":"1.0","axis":"plugin-exercise-index","plugin":"%s","commits_window":%d,"window_days":60,"days_shipped":%d,"closed_tickets_window":%d,"tickets_window_days":90,"breaking_change_age_days":%s,"composite_index":1.0}\n' \
-      "$plugin" "$cw" "$ds" "$ctw" "$bca" >>"$out"
-  done
-}
-
-# Helper: extract a JSON field from a plugin.json via python3 stdlib.
-# Args: plugin-json-path, dotted-path (e.g. `maturity.band` or
-# `skills.manage-problem.maturity.band`).
-get_json_field() {
-  local file="$1"; local path="$2"
-  python3 -c "
-import json, sys
-with open('$file') as fh:
-    obj = json.load(fh)
-for part in '$path'.split('.'):
-    if not isinstance(obj, dict) or part not in obj:
-        print('MISSING'); sys.exit(0)
-    obj = obj[part]
-print(obj if not isinstance(obj, (dict, list)) else json.dumps(obj))
-"
-}
-
-# ── Existence / executable ──────────────────────────────────────────────────
-
-@test "plugin-maturity-populate: canonical script exists" {
-  [ -f "$SCRIPT" ]
-}
-
-@test "plugin-maturity-populate: canonical script is executable" {
-  [ -x "$SCRIPT" ]
-}
-
-@test "plugin-maturity-populate: shim file exists with ADR-049 grammar" {
-  local shim="$SCRIPTS_DIR/../bin/wr-itil-plugin-maturity-populate"
-  [ -f "$shim" ]
-  [ -x "$shim" ]
-  grep -q 'exec.*scripts/plugin-maturity-populate.sh' "$shim"
-}
-
-# ── Confirmation #1: idempotency (ADR-063 §Confirmation 1) ──────────────────
-# Run twice with the same --now pin; assert byte-identical plugin.json.
-
-@test "plugin-maturity-populate: idempotency — second run produces byte-identical plugin.json" {
-  make_plugin "fixp" "skill:manage-problem" "agent:agent"
-  local trans="$FIXTURE_DIR/transcript.ndjson"
-  local exer="$FIXTURE_DIR/exercise.ndjson"
-  write_transcript_ndjson "$trans" \
-    "skill" "wr-fixp:manage-problem" 50 \
-    "agent" "wr-fixp:agent" 200
-  write_exercise_ndjson "$exer" \
-    "fixp" 30 20 3 NULL
-
-  run "$SCRIPT" \
-    --transcript-ndjson="$trans" \
-    --exercise-ndjson="$exer" \
-    --project-root="$PROJECT_ROOT" \
-    --now=2026-05-17T12:00:00Z
-  [ "$status" -eq 0 ]
-
-  local pj="$PROJECT_ROOT/packages/fixp/.claude-plugin/plugin.json"
-  local checksum_1
-  checksum_1=$(python3 -c "import hashlib; print(hashlib.sha256(open('$pj','rb').read()).hexdigest())")
-
-  run "$SCRIPT" \
-    --transcript-ndjson="$trans" \
-    --exercise-ndjson="$exer" \
-    --project-root="$PROJECT_ROOT" \
-    --now=2026-05-17T12:00:00Z
-  [ "$status" -eq 0 ]
-
-  local checksum_2
-  checksum_2=$(python3 -c "import hashlib; print(hashlib.sha256(open('$pj','rb').read()).hexdigest())")
-  [ "$checksum_1" = "$checksum_2" ]
-}
-
-# ── Confirmation #2: band-mapping during bootstrapping (ADR-063 #2 first half) ─
-# 20 days_shipped → bootstrapping active (suite-oldest < 60d).
-# 200 invocations + 20 days_shipped → meets provisional Alpha conditions
-# (≥100 invocations + ≥14 days). Lower invocations → Experimental.
-
-@test "plugin-maturity-populate: bootstrapping — provisional Alpha on high-invocation surface" {
-  make_plugin "alphap" "agent:agent"
-  local trans="$FIXTURE_DIR/transcript.ndjson"
-  local exer="$FIXTURE_DIR/exercise.ndjson"
-  write_transcript_ndjson "$trans" "agent" "wr-alphap:agent" 200
-  write_exercise_ndjson "$exer" "alphap" 30 20 3 NULL
-
-  run "$SCRIPT" \
-    --transcript-ndjson="$trans" \
-    --exercise-ndjson="$exer" \
-    --project-root="$PROJECT_ROOT" \
-    --now=2026-05-17T12:00:00Z
-  [ "$status" -eq 0 ]
-
-  local pj="$PROJECT_ROOT/packages/alphap/.claude-plugin/plugin.json"
-  local band
-  band=$(get_json_field "$pj" "maturity.agents.agent.band")
-  [ "$band" = "Alpha" ]
-}
-
-@test "plugin-maturity-populate: bootstrapping — Experimental on low-invocation surface" {
-  make_plugin "expp" "skill:list-incidents"
-  local trans="$FIXTURE_DIR/transcript.ndjson"
-  local exer="$FIXTURE_DIR/exercise.ndjson"
-  write_transcript_ndjson "$trans" "skill" "wr-expp:list-incidents" 2
-  write_exercise_ndjson "$exer" "expp" 5 20 1 NULL
-
-  run "$SCRIPT" \
-    --transcript-ndjson="$trans" \
-    --exercise-ndjson="$exer" \
-    --project-root="$PROJECT_ROOT" \
-    --now=2026-05-17T12:00:00Z
-  [ "$status" -eq 0 ]
-
-  local pj="$PROJECT_ROOT/packages/expp/.claude-plugin/plugin.json"
-  local band
-  band=$(get_json_field "$pj" "maturity.skills.list-incidents.band")
-  [ "$band" = "Experimental" ]
-}
-
-# ── Confirmation #2 second half: steady-state post-sunset (ADR-063 #2) ──────
-# Suite-oldest ≥60 days_shipped → bootstrapping inactive.
-# 796 invocations + 200 days_shipped + 15 tickets + null breaking → Beta-
-# floor satisfied, Stable-floor not (invocations <1000). Expect Beta.
-
-@test "plugin-maturity-populate: steady-state — Beta on heavy-invocation aged surface" {
-  make_plugin "betap" "agent:agent"
-  local trans="$FIXTURE_DIR/transcript.ndjson"
-  local exer="$FIXTURE_DIR/exercise.ndjson"
-  write_transcript_ndjson "$trans" "agent" "wr-betap:agent" 796
-  write_exercise_ndjson "$exer" "betap" 100 200 15 NULL
-
-  run "$SCRIPT" \
-    --transcript-ndjson="$trans" \
-    --exercise-ndjson="$exer" \
-    --project-root="$PROJECT_ROOT" \
-    --now=2026-07-01T12:00:00Z
-  [ "$status" -eq 0 ]
-
-  local pj="$PROJECT_ROOT/packages/betap/.claude-plugin/plugin.json"
-  local band
-  band=$(get_json_field "$pj" "maturity.agents.agent.band")
-  [ "$band" = "Beta" ]
-}
-
-# ── Confirmation #3: no AskUserQuestion per band recompute ──────────────────
-# ADR-044 silent-framework carve-out (ADR-063 §scope-limited carve-out).
-# Negative-presence check on stdin / stderr — case-insensitive per architect
-# adjustment G.
-
-@test "plugin-maturity-populate: no AskUserQuestion invocation during band recompute" {
-  make_plugin "silentp" "skill:list-stories"
-  local trans="$FIXTURE_DIR/transcript.ndjson"
-  local exer="$FIXTURE_DIR/exercise.ndjson"
-  write_transcript_ndjson "$trans" "skill" "wr-silentp:list-stories" 50
-  write_exercise_ndjson "$exer" "silentp" 10 20 2 NULL
-
-  run "$SCRIPT" \
-    --transcript-ndjson="$trans" \
-    --exercise-ndjson="$exer" \
-    --project-root="$PROJECT_ROOT" \
-    --now=2026-05-17T12:00:00Z
-  [ "$status" -eq 0 ]
-
-  # Case-insensitive scan of combined stdout + stderr for any
-  # AskUserQuestion-token spelling.
-  printf '%s' "$output" | grep -i -E 'askuserquestion|<askuser' && return 1 || true
-}
-
-# ── Schema shape (ADR-063 §plugin.json maturity field schema) ───────────────
-
-@test "plugin-maturity-populate: per-surface maturity record carries schema_version + band + computed_at + evidence" {
-  make_plugin "shapep" "skill:manage-problem"
-  local trans="$FIXTURE_DIR/transcript.ndjson"
-  local exer="$FIXTURE_DIR/exercise.ndjson"
-  write_transcript_ndjson "$trans" "skill" "wr-shapep:manage-problem" 100
-  write_exercise_ndjson "$exer" "shapep" 20 25 5 NULL
-
-  run "$SCRIPT" \
-    --transcript-ndjson="$trans" \
-    --exercise-ndjson="$exer" \
-    --project-root="$PROJECT_ROOT" \
-    --now=2026-05-17T12:00:00Z
-  [ "$status" -eq 0 ]
-
-  local pj="$PROJECT_ROOT/packages/shapep/.claude-plugin/plugin.json"
-  [ "$(get_json_field "$pj" "maturity.skills.manage-problem.schema_version")" = "2.0" ]
-  [ "$(get_json_field "$pj" "maturity.skills.manage-problem.band")" != "MISSING" ]
-  [ "$(get_json_field "$pj" "maturity.skills.manage-problem.computed_at")" != "MISSING" ]
-  [ "$(get_json_field "$pj" "maturity.skills.manage-problem.evidence.invocations_30d")" = "100" ]
-  [ "$(get_json_field "$pj" "maturity.skills.manage-problem.evidence.days_shipped")" = "25" ]
-  [ "$(get_json_field "$pj" "maturity.skills.manage-problem.evidence.closed_tickets_window")" = "5" ]
-}
-
-@test "plugin-maturity-populate: plugin root rollup carries schema_version + band + rollup_invocations_30d + bootstrapping, no evidence" {
-  # P269 amendment: rollup now carries rollup_invocations_30d (sum of non-null
-  # per-surface invocations_30d) + bootstrapping (snapshot of window state at
-  # populate time) so the renderer's AND-gated compound predicate
-  # (plugin-maturity-render.sh:146) can fire. The §evidence dict is still NOT
-  # written on the rollup — only at per-surface entries.
-  make_plugin "rollupp" "skill:s1" "skill:s2"
-  local trans="$FIXTURE_DIR/transcript.ndjson"
-  local exer="$FIXTURE_DIR/exercise.ndjson"
-  write_transcript_ndjson "$trans" \
-    "skill" "wr-rollupp:s1" 200 \
-    "skill" "wr-rollupp:s2" 1
-  write_exercise_ndjson "$exer" "rollupp" 10 20 2 NULL
-
-  run "$SCRIPT" \
-    --transcript-ndjson="$trans" \
-    --exercise-ndjson="$exer" \
-    --project-root="$PROJECT_ROOT" \
-    --now=2026-05-17T12:00:00Z
-  [ "$status" -eq 0 ]
-
-  local pj="$PROJECT_ROOT/packages/rollupp/.claude-plugin/plugin.json"
-  [ "$(get_json_field "$pj" "maturity.schema_version")" = "2.0" ]
-  [ "$(get_json_field "$pj" "maturity.band")" != "MISSING" ]
-  [ "$(get_json_field "$pj" "maturity.evidence")" = "MISSING" ]
-  [ "$(get_json_field "$pj" "maturity.rollup_invocations_30d")" != "MISSING" ]
-  [ "$(get_json_field "$pj" "maturity.bootstrapping")" != "MISSING" ]
-}
-
-# ── P269: rollup_invocations_30d sums non-null per-surface entries ───────────
-
-@test "plugin-maturity-populate: rollup_invocations_30d equals sum of non-null per-surface invocations" {
-  # P269 fix details step 1: rollup_invocations_30d = sum across non-null
-  # per-surface entries. 200 + 1 = 201.
-  make_plugin "summp" "skill:s1" "skill:s2"
-  local trans="$FIXTURE_DIR/transcript.ndjson"
-  local exer="$FIXTURE_DIR/exercise.ndjson"
-  write_transcript_ndjson "$trans" \
-    "skill" "wr-summp:s1" 200 \
-    "skill" "wr-summp:s2" 1
-  write_exercise_ndjson "$exer" "summp" 10 20 2 NULL
-
-  run "$SCRIPT" \
-    --transcript-ndjson="$trans" \
-    --exercise-ndjson="$exer" \
-    --project-root="$PROJECT_ROOT" \
-    --now=2026-05-17T12:00:00Z
-  [ "$status" -eq 0 ]
-
-  local pj="$PROJECT_ROOT/packages/summp/.claude-plugin/plugin.json"
-  [ "$(get_json_field "$pj" "maturity.rollup_invocations_30d")" = "201" ]
-}
-
-# ── P269: rollup_invocations_30d sums non-null only (hooks excluded) ────────
-
-@test "plugin-maturity-populate: rollup_invocations_30d excludes null hook surfaces from sum" {
-  # Mixed surfaces — a skill with invocations + a hook with null sentinel.
-  # The sum should equal the skill invocations alone; the null hook does NOT
-  # participate in the sum (architect §C null sentinel preserves
-  # "not measurable" vs "measurably zero" semantics).
-  make_plugin "mixp" "skill:thing" "hook:somehook"
-  local trans="$FIXTURE_DIR/transcript.ndjson"
-  local exer="$FIXTURE_DIR/exercise.ndjson"
-  write_transcript_ndjson "$trans" "skill" "wr-mixp:thing" 75
-  write_exercise_ndjson "$exer" "mixp" 10 20 2 NULL
-
-  run "$SCRIPT" \
-    --transcript-ndjson="$trans" \
-    --exercise-ndjson="$exer" \
-    --project-root="$PROJECT_ROOT" \
-    --now=2026-05-17T12:00:00Z
-  [ "$status" -eq 0 ]
-
-  local pj="$PROJECT_ROOT/packages/mixp/.claude-plugin/plugin.json"
-  [ "$(get_json_field "$pj" "maturity.rollup_invocations_30d")" = "75" ]
-}
-
-# ── P269: rollup_invocations_30d is null when ALL per-surface entries are null ─
-
-@test "plugin-maturity-populate: rollup_invocations_30d is null on hook-only plugin" {
-  # Hook-only plugin: every per-surface invocations_30d is null. The rollup
-  # MUST emit null (not 0) so the renderer's AND-gated compound predicate
-  # falls through correctly — `0 invocations / 30d` would lie.
-  make_plugin "hookonly" "hook:a" "hook:b"
-  local trans="$FIXTURE_DIR/transcript.ndjson"
-  local exer="$FIXTURE_DIR/exercise.ndjson"
-  : >"$trans"  # empty transcript — hooks never appear there
-  write_exercise_ndjson "$exer" "hookonly" 5 30 1 NULL
-
-  run "$SCRIPT" \
-    --transcript-ndjson="$trans" \
-    --exercise-ndjson="$exer" \
-    --project-root="$PROJECT_ROOT" \
-    --now=2026-05-17T12:00:00Z
-  [ "$status" -eq 0 ]
-
-  local pj="$PROJECT_ROOT/packages/hookonly/.claude-plugin/plugin.json"
-  # `get_json_field` collapses null to display "None"; check the raw JSON.
-  local raw
-  raw=$(python3 -c "
-import json
-obj = json.load(open('$pj'))
-print(json.dumps(obj['maturity']['rollup_invocations_30d']))
-")
-  [ "$raw" = "null" ]
-}
-
-# ── P269: bootstrapping flag write — true during bootstrapping window ───────
-
-@test "plugin-maturity-populate: rollup bootstrapping=true during bootstrapping window" {
-  # suite_oldest_days < 60 → bootstrapping active → rollup carries true.
-  make_plugin "bsp" "skill:s1"
-  local trans="$FIXTURE_DIR/transcript.ndjson"
-  local exer="$FIXTURE_DIR/exercise.ndjson"
-  write_transcript_ndjson "$trans" "skill" "wr-bsp:s1" 50
-  write_exercise_ndjson "$exer" "bsp" 10 20 2 NULL  # days_shipped=20 < 60
-
-  run "$SCRIPT" \
-    --transcript-ndjson="$trans" \
-    --exercise-ndjson="$exer" \
-    --project-root="$PROJECT_ROOT" \
-    --now=2026-05-17T12:00:00Z
-  [ "$status" -eq 0 ]
-
-  local pj="$PROJECT_ROOT/packages/bsp/.claude-plugin/plugin.json"
-  local raw
-  raw=$(python3 -c "
-import json
-obj = json.load(open('$pj'))
-print(json.dumps(obj['maturity']['bootstrapping']))
-")
-  [ "$raw" = "true" ]
-}
-
-# ── P269: bootstrapping flag write — false once max(days_shipped) ≥ 60 ──────
-
-@test "plugin-maturity-populate: rollup bootstrapping=false once suite_oldest_days >= 60" {
-  # max(days_shipped) >= 60 → bootstrapping inactive → rollup carries false.
-  # Independent of --now (auto-derives from data per architect §D).
-  make_plugin "stp" "skill:s1"
-  local trans="$FIXTURE_DIR/transcript.ndjson"
-  local exer="$FIXTURE_DIR/exercise.ndjson"
-  write_transcript_ndjson "$trans" "skill" "wr-stp:s1" 50
-  write_exercise_ndjson "$exer" "stp" 100 200 15 NULL  # days_shipped=200 >= 60
-
-  run "$SCRIPT" \
-    --transcript-ndjson="$trans" \
-    --exercise-ndjson="$exer" \
-    --project-root="$PROJECT_ROOT" \
-    --now=2026-05-17T12:00:00Z
-  [ "$status" -eq 0 ]
-
-  local pj="$PROJECT_ROOT/packages/stp/.claude-plugin/plugin.json"
-  local raw
-  raw=$(python3 -c "
-import json
-obj = json.load(open('$pj'))
-print(json.dumps(obj['maturity']['bootstrapping']))
-")
-  [ "$raw" = "false" ]
-}
-
-# ── Granularity contract (ADR-063 #10): rollup = worst-case among surfaces ──
-
-@test "plugin-maturity-populate: rollup band equals worst-case among constituent surfaces" {
-  make_plugin "worstp" "skill:hot" "skill:cold"
-  local trans="$FIXTURE_DIR/transcript.ndjson"
-  local exer="$FIXTURE_DIR/exercise.ndjson"
-  # hot → Alpha (200 invocations + 20 days during bootstrapping);
-  # cold → Experimental (1 invocation). Worst-case = Experimental.
-  write_transcript_ndjson "$trans" \
-    "skill" "wr-worstp:hot" 200 \
-    "skill" "wr-worstp:cold" 1
-  write_exercise_ndjson "$exer" "worstp" 10 20 2 NULL
-
-  run "$SCRIPT" \
-    --transcript-ndjson="$trans" \
-    --exercise-ndjson="$exer" \
-    --project-root="$PROJECT_ROOT" \
-    --now=2026-05-17T12:00:00Z
-  [ "$status" -eq 0 ]
-
-  local pj="$PROJECT_ROOT/packages/worstp/.claude-plugin/plugin.json"
-  [ "$(get_json_field "$pj" "maturity.band")" = "Experimental" ]
-}
-
-# ── Hook evidence shape (architect adjustment C) — null invocation sentinel ──
-# Hooks are not transcript-observable; invocations_30d MUST be `null`, not 0,
-# to preserve "not measurable" vs "measurably zero" semantics.
-
-@test "plugin-maturity-populate: hook surfaces emit null invocations_30d sentinel" {
-  make_plugin "hookp" "hook:itil-fictional-defer-detect"
-  local trans="$FIXTURE_DIR/transcript.ndjson"
-  local exer="$FIXTURE_DIR/exercise.ndjson"
-  # Empty transcript NDJSON — hooks never appear in transcript stream.
-  : >"$trans"
-  write_exercise_ndjson "$exer" "hookp" 5 30 1 NULL
-
-  run "$SCRIPT" \
-    --transcript-ndjson="$trans" \
-    --exercise-ndjson="$exer" \
-    --project-root="$PROJECT_ROOT" \
-    --now=2026-05-17T12:00:00Z
-  [ "$status" -eq 0 ]
-
-  local pj="$PROJECT_ROOT/packages/hookp/.claude-plugin/plugin.json"
-  # Read the raw JSON and check that invocations_30d is literally null,
-  # not 0. (`get_json_field` collapses null/0 to display; use python3 directly.)
-  local raw
-  raw=$(python3 -c "
-import json
-obj = json.load(open('$pj'))
-print(json.dumps(obj['maturity']['hooks']['itil-fictional-defer-detect']['evidence']['invocations_30d']))
-")
-  [ "$raw" = "null" ]
-}
-
-# ── Deprecated-band overlay preservation (architect adjustment I) ───────────
-# Pre-existing author-declared `band: "Deprecated"` + `supersededBy:` MUST
-# survive recompute unchanged. Recompute does NOT overwrite Deprecated
-# downward.
-
-@test "plugin-maturity-populate: preserves author-declared Deprecated band + supersededBy pointer" {
-  make_plugin "depp" "skill:oldskill"
-  local pj="$PROJECT_ROOT/packages/depp/.claude-plugin/plugin.json"
-  # Hand-author the Deprecated entry that the script must preserve.
-  python3 <<EOF
-import json
-obj = json.load(open("$pj"))
-obj.setdefault("maturity", {}).setdefault("skills", {})["oldskill"] = {
-    "schema_version": "2.0",
-    "band": "Deprecated",
-    "computed_at": "2026-04-01T00:00:00Z",
-    "supersededBy": "wr-depp:newskill",
-    "evidence": {
-        "invocations_30d": 50,
-        "days_shipped": 100,
-        "closed_tickets_window": 3,
-        "breaking_change_age_days": None,
-    },
-}
-with open("$pj","w") as fh:
-    json.dump(obj, fh, indent=2, sort_keys=True)
-EOF
-  local trans="$FIXTURE_DIR/transcript.ndjson"
-  local exer="$FIXTURE_DIR/exercise.ndjson"
-  write_transcript_ndjson "$trans" "skill" "wr-depp:oldskill" 50
-  write_exercise_ndjson "$exer" "depp" 5 100 3 NULL
-
-  run "$SCRIPT" \
-    --transcript-ndjson="$trans" \
-    --exercise-ndjson="$exer" \
-    --project-root="$PROJECT_ROOT" \
-    --now=2026-05-17T12:00:00Z
-  [ "$status" -eq 0 ]
-
-  [ "$(get_json_field "$pj" "maturity.skills.oldskill.band")" = "Deprecated" ]
-  [ "$(get_json_field "$pj" "maturity.skills.oldskill.supersededBy")" = "wr-depp:newskill" ]
-}
-
-# ── Bootstrapping clause sunset auto-derivation (architect adjustment D) ────
-# Sunset is computed from `max(days_shipped)` ≥ 60 in the exercise NDJSON.
-# Same surface evidence → Experimental during bootstrapping (suite-oldest < 60d);
-# Beta+ once suite-oldest ≥ 60d (no calendar-date hard-code required).
-
-@test "plugin-maturity-populate: bootstrapping lapses when max(days_shipped) ≥ 60" {
-  make_plugin "p1" "agent:agent"
-  make_plugin "p2" "agent:agent"
-  local trans="$FIXTURE_DIR/transcript.ndjson"
-  local exer="$FIXTURE_DIR/exercise.ndjson"
-  # Both plugins have 796 invocations + 200 days_shipped + 15 tickets.
-  # In steady-state these would each be Beta. Under bootstrapping (oldest <60d)
-  # they would be Alpha. Test: with one plugin aged 200d, bootstrapping is
-  # inactive and the band is Beta. Independent of --now (no hard-coded date).
-  write_transcript_ndjson "$trans" \
-    "agent" "wr-p1:agent" 796 \
-    "agent" "wr-p2:agent" 796
-  write_exercise_ndjson "$exer" \
-    "p1" 100 200 15 NULL \
-    "p2" 100 25  15 NULL
-
-  run "$SCRIPT" \
-    --transcript-ndjson="$trans" \
-    --exercise-ndjson="$exer" \
-    --project-root="$PROJECT_ROOT" \
-    --now=2026-05-17T12:00:00Z
-  [ "$status" -eq 0 ]
-
-  local pj1="$PROJECT_ROOT/packages/p1/.claude-plugin/plugin.json"
-  local pj2="$PROJECT_ROOT/packages/p2/.claude-plugin/plugin.json"
-  # p1 aged 200d → Beta. p2 aged 25d → Beta-floor unmet (days <60), demotes
-  # to Alpha steady-state OR Experimental depending on the days_shipped cell;
-  # only assert here that bootstrapping is inactive (the p1 outcome).
-  [ "$(get_json_field "$pj1" "maturity.agents.agent.band")" = "Beta" ]
-}
-
-# ── ADR-013 Rule 6 fail-safe — missing NDJSON inputs ────────────────────────
-
-@test "plugin-maturity-populate: exits 0 when transcript NDJSON missing" {
-  make_plugin "failsafe" "skill:thing"
-  local exer="$FIXTURE_DIR/exercise.ndjson"
-  write_exercise_ndjson "$exer" "failsafe" 10 20 2 NULL
-
-  run "$SCRIPT" \
-    --transcript-ndjson="$FIXTURE_DIR/does-not-exist.ndjson" \
-    --exercise-ndjson="$exer" \
-    --project-root="$PROJECT_ROOT" \
-    --now=2026-05-17T12:00:00Z
-  [ "$status" -eq 0 ]
-}
-
-@test "plugin-maturity-populate: exits 0 when no packages directory exists" {
-  rm -rf "$PROJECT_ROOT/packages"
-  local trans="$FIXTURE_DIR/transcript.ndjson"
-  local exer="$FIXTURE_DIR/exercise.ndjson"
-  : >"$trans"; : >"$exer"
-
-  run "$SCRIPT" \
-    --transcript-ndjson="$trans" \
-    --exercise-ndjson="$exer" \
-    --project-root="$PROJECT_ROOT" \
-    --now=2026-05-17T12:00:00Z
-  [ "$status" -eq 0 ]
-}
-
-# ── Privacy posture (mirrored from ADR-058 §Confirmation #3) ────────────────
-# No network primitive in the script body — defensive negative-grep.
-
-@test "plugin-maturity-populate: script body invokes no network egress primitives" {
-  ! grep -E '(\bcurl\b|\bwget\b|\bnc\b|fetch\b|http\.client|urllib|socket\.connect)' "$SCRIPT"
-}