@playcraft/cli 0.0.44 → 0.0.46

package/project-template/skills/playable-validate/SKILL.md

@@ -0,0 +1,260 @@
+---
+name: playable-validate
+description: >-
+  PRIMARY entry when user asks to optimize a playable ad or "current page".
+  Agent MUST run ensure-project first, then headed MP4 validate, fix, and report.
+  Use for whole-flow delivery, ENDCARD/GAMEPLAY polish, or when unsure which
+  sub-skill to pick — orchestrates art, UI verify, debug auto-clear, record,
+  animation/FX skills, and L→G playground. User never runs shell manually.
+---
+
+# Playable Validate（Video Validate Loop）
+
+> **用户**：「用 video validate loop 优化当前 playable / 当前页面」  
+> **Agent**：先 [agent-prep](../_shared/agent-prep.md) → 本 skill **Agent 入口** → 全程自执行。
+
+---
+
+## Agent 入口（必读）
+
+### Step 0 — 自举（勿让用户手工）
+
+```bash
+cd <playable工程根>    # 含 game/index.html
+npm run ensure:project
+npm run verify:contract   # 录屏前：window.__playable 必须已接线
+```
+
+读 JSON/日志：profile 新建 → 补全 `playable.ui.profile.yaml` 再 verify；playground 新建 → 已 bootstrap。
+
+### Step 1 — 定 Zone + 基线
+
+| 用户话                | Zone  | 首轮动作                                                              |
+| --------------------- | ----- | --------------------------------------------------------------------- |
+| 整片 / 当前页面（泛） | FLOW  | `npm run record:mp4 -- --headed --fps=60`                             |
+| ENDCARD / 结算        | PHASE | `npm run playground -- record integration:PHASE:endcard-win --headed` |
+| 消牌 / 碎裂           | EVENT | `integration:EVENT:match-once` + decompose/peak skills                |
+| 未指定                | FLOW  | 整片录屏 → validate 报告 → 定下一 L                                   |
+
+基线 MP4：`test(N-1)/recordings/*.mp4` 或工程内最新 `recordings/playable-*.mp4`。
+
+### Step 2 — Image Gate（改 manifest/PNG 后）
+
+```bash
+npm run verify:ui
+```
+
+FAIL → 读 `playable-verify-ui` 修 → 重跑。PASS 才能声称素材进工程 OK。
+
+### Step 3 — 一键通关（录屏前）
+
+读 `playable-debug`：`SHOW_DEBUG_BUTTON: true`，确认 `_onDebugAutoPlay` 可达 ENDCARD。
+
+### Step 4 — Video Validate
+
+```bash
+npm run record:mp4 -- --headed --fps=60
+```
+
+看 MP4 + [validation-rules §⑥](./validation-rules.md#⑥-video-validator整片)。问题必须写成：`[MM:SS] visible symptom → P0/P1/P2 → recommendedSkill → alphaStrategy`。
+
+可选增强：`npm run verify:vision` 会在 Reviewer `ui_diff` 前自动标注截图（消费 bg-clean/tile/text-overlap findings 或 `playcraft tools detect` JSON）；但最终仍必须由模型/Reviewer 看 MP4/截图，不能只凭 vision evidence 判定 PASS。
+
+### Step 5 — 选子 skill fix（Agent 读对应 SKILL § Agent 入口）
+
+| 现象               | 子 skill                     |
+| ------------------ | ---------------------------- |
+| atlas/布局/budget  | `playable-verify-ui`         |
+| 白边/绿边/alpha 脏 | `playable-art`               |
+| 帧动画 drift/clip  | `playable-fx-peak`           |
+| 破碎语义/黑框      | `playable-fx-decompose`      |
+| 时序/手感          | `playable-animate`           |
+| 局部穷举           | `playable-focus` sweep L1/G1 |
+
+每条问题 **最小 diff** → 回流 Step 2–4。
+
+### Step 6 — 交付报告
+
+写 `validate/PLAYABLE-YYYYMMDD-HHmmss.md`：[validation-rules.md](validation-rules.md) §⑨。  
+更新相关 `skills/*/SKILL.md` 实验记录。
+
+### 给用户回复模板
+
+```
+结论：通过 / 有条件通过 / 未通过
+录屏：recordings/….
+相对基线：改善 … / 仍存 … / 回归 …
+报告：validate/PLAYABLE-….md
+```
+
+---
+
+## 九步一览（编排参考）
+
+| #   | 阶段                             | Validator | 主 Skill                                                                                             |
+| --- | -------------------------------- | --------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
+| 1   | 分图 → 精灵图 + **设计约束文档** | —         | `playable-art`                                                                                       |
+| 2   | gpt-image-2 重生（带约束）       | —         | `playable-art`, `playable-fx-peak`, `playable-fx-decompose`                                          |
+| 3   | **Image Validator**              | verify:ui | `playable-verify-ui`                                                                                 |
+| 4   | 合并进项目代码                   | dev 加载  | `playable-verify-ui`                                                                                 |
+| 5   | **一键通关**                     | 整局可达  | `playable-debug`                                                                                     |
+| 6   | **Video Validator**              | MP4       | 本 skill + `playable-record`                                                                         |
+| 7   | 动效                             | MP4       | `playable-animate`, FX skills                                                                        |
+| 8   | **L→G 螺旋**                     | MP4       | `playable-focus`                                                                                     |
+| 9   | 评估报告                         | 报告      | `PLAYABLE-*.md`；单文件 HTML 见 [references/single-html-bundle.md](references/single-html-bundle.md) |
+
+---
+
+## ② 后处理链（固定顺序）
+
+```
+gpt-image-2（prompt 必须引用 ① 约束文档 + 参考图）
+  → remove background
+  → slice / repack
+  → resize
+  → merge atlas + manifest
+  → assets/images/…
+```
+
+**FX 分支**：
+
+- ADD 光效/环/光柱 → `playable-fx-peak`（§ GPT 出图与 A/B）
+- 物体破碎 → `playable-fx-decompose`
+
+---
+
+## ③ Image Validator
+
+```bash
+cd testN
+npm run verify:ui    # → ../skills/playable-verify-ui/scripts/run_all.py
+```
+
+| 能拦                              | 不能拦                    |
+| --------------------------------- | ------------------------- |
+| 缺资源、尺寸、budget、layout 魔数 | 合成鬼影、halo、动画手感  |
+| atlas / profile 一致              | HOOK→ENDCARD 是否「好看」 |
+
+**FAIL 不得进入 ④。** test9：verify 全 PASS，录屏仍 FAIL — Image Validator 不能替代 Video Validator。
+
+---
+
+## ⑤ 一键通关
+
+`game/config/game-config.js`：`SHOW_DEBUG_BUTTON: true`，`SKIP_TRANSITIONS: false`（录屏前）。
+
+详见 [playable-debug](../playable-debug/SKILL.md)。
+
+---
+
+## ⑥ Video Validator
+
+```bash
+npm run record:mp4 -- --headed --fps=60
+```
+
+- 产出：`recordings/playable-YYYYMMDD-HHmmss.mp4`
+- 要求：1080×1920，`60/1`，完整局 ~25s
+- 禁止 Playwright 25fps `recordVideo`
+
+**Validate 清单**：[validation-rules.md §⑥](./validation-rules.md#⑥-video-validator整片) · 扩展 [references/checklist-detail.md](references/checklist-detail.md)
+
+| 时段           | 看什么         |
+| -------------- | -------------- |
+| HOOK 0–3s      | 入场、HUD      |
+| TUTORIAL 3–8s  | 引导           |
+| GAMEPLAY 8–22s | 输入、FX、连击 |
+| ENDCARD 22–25s | CTA、尾帧      |
+
+**必须与基线** `test(N-1)/recordings/*.mp4` **同 timestamp 对比**。
+
+透明/合成问题必须带修复路由：
+
+| 录屏现象             | recommendedSkill                    | alphaStrategy                               |
+| -------------------- | ----------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------- |
+| 白边 / 抗锯齿脏      | `playable-art`                      | `dual-bg-diff` 或 `rgb-alpha-split`         |
+| 绿边 / 蓝边 / 品红边 | `playable-art`                      | 换 `chroma` key 或 `rgb-alpha-split`        |
+| 黑块包住 glow        | `playable-fx-peak`                  | `black-add`                                 |
+| halo 截断            | `playable-fx-peak`                  | `black-add` + clean harness                 |
+| 双主体漂移           | `playable-art` / `playable-fx-peak` | 避免 `dual-bg-diff`，转 `rgb-alpha-split`   |
+| video matte 错位     | `playable-art`                      | `rgb-alpha-video` 重新对齐或 `opaque-video` |
+
+---
+
+## ⑧ L→G 螺旋（嵌在 ⑥⑦）
+
+```
+L1 局部 deep（唯一 Zone）→ G1 全局录屏定下一 L
+      → L2 局部 → G2 再整合
+```
+
+- 同一时刻只 deep 一个局部
+- **无 G 的 L 不算完成**
+- Focus scope：`docs/local-playground.md`
+
+---
+
+## 改动后的回流
+
+| 改动              | 回流              |
+| ----------------- | ----------------- |
+| 仅 tween / scale  | ⑤ → ⑥             |
+| 新 PNG / manifest | ② → ③ → ④ → ⑤ → ⑥ |
+| 新 FX sheet       | ② → ③ → ⑦ → ⑥     |
+
+---
+
+## ⑨ 交付 Exit
+
+- [ ] ③ verify:ui PASS
+- [ ] ⑤ 一键通关 OK
+- [ ] ⑥ 最新 MP4 spec 正确
+- [ ] ⑧ 至少 L→G→L→G，无 P0 回归
+- [ ] `testN/validate/PLAYABLE-*.md` 已写
+- [ ] 相关 `skills/*/SKILL.md` § 实验记录已写
+
+---
+
+## Agent 约束
+
+1. 未看 MP4 不得声称 UI/FX 已修好
+2. 问题用 **效果** 描述（「halo 被切短」），不用类型标签
+3. 管线以 **录屏 A/B 赢家** 为准
+4. 每条 validate 问题 → **最小 diff** + recommendedSkill + alphaStrategy
+5. 经验写入根 `skills/`，不写 `testN/skills/`
+
+---
+
+## 实验记录模板
+
+```markdown
+## Pipeline testN — YYYY-MM-DD
+
+**步骤**: ⑥ Video / ⑦ 动效 / ⑧ L1 MATCH_BURST …
+**录屏**: recordings/playable-….mp4
+**基线**: test(N-1)/recordings/…
+
+### Validate
+
+1. [00:12] visible symptom → P0/P1/P2 → recommendedSkill → alphaStrategy
+
+### Fix
+
+-
+
+### vs 基线
+
+改善 / 仍存 / 回归
+
+### Skills
+
+- [ ] skills/playable-xxx — …
+```
+
+---
+
+完整 Gate 规则：[validation-rules.md](validation-rules.md) · Replay：[validate/REPLAY-CHECKLIST.md](../../validate/REPLAY-CHECKLIST.md)
+
+## Skills 脚本索引
+
+见 [skills/README.md](../../README.md)

package/project-template/skills/playable-validate/references/checklist-detail.md

@@ -0,0 +1,36 @@
+# Checklist Detail
+
+## verify:ui 四层
+
+| 脚本                     | 检查                                 |
+| ------------------------ | ------------------------------------ |
+| verify_game_config_load  | GAME_CONFIG 可加载，layout keys 存在 |
+| verify_layout_regions    | HUD/combo/CTA/playArea 区域规则      |
+| verify_hardcoded_layout  | 禁止散落魔数 Y/X                     |
+| verify_script_load_order | ui-layout / config 依赖顺序          |
+
+资源层另含：PNG 存在、atlas 帧尺寸、包体预算、placehold 反模式。
+
+## 浏览器截图位点
+
+必看三锚点：
+
+1. **Top HUD** — 计时 + 计数条
+2. **Board center** — 牌面与选中态
+3. **Bottom band** — CTA + 左右装饰 + 调试钮
+
+## 发布 vs 开发差异
+
+| 项                | 开发    | 发布       |
+| ----------------- | ------- | ---------- |
+| SHOW_DEBUG_BUTTON | true    | false      |
+| 一键通关          | 可见    | 必须不可见 |
+| SKIP_TRANSITIONS  | 可 true | false      |
+
+## 声称完成的前置条件
+
+满足 [verification-before-completion](https://cursor.com) 原则：
+
+1. 刚跑过 `npm run verify:ui` 且 PASS
+2. 浏览器目视过 bottom band（含 CTA）
+3. 对 CTA 类改动：确认 `scaleX === scaleY` 或未使用错误拼接

package/project-template/skills/playable-validate/references/single-html-bundle.md

@@ -0,0 +1,76 @@
+---
+name: playable-single-html-bundle
+description: Build self-contained single-file HTML playables for ad networks by inlining Phaser, game scripts, and atlas assets as base64 data URIs. Use when the user asks to pack, bundle, export, or ship one HTML file, single-file playable, offline playable, or playable ad delivery package.
+---
+
+# Playable Single HTML Bundle
+
+Package a Phaser/HTML5 playable into **one `.html` file** with no external asset requests (except optional store URLs on CTA).
+
+## When to Use
+
+- Ad network upload requires a single HTML (AppLovin, Unity, ironSource, etc.)
+- QA needs an offline artifact that works from `file://` or email attachment
+- Dev server is unavailable but the game must still run
+
+## Workflow
+
+```bash
+npm run build-atlas    # ensure atlases are current
+npm run build:html     # scripts/build-html.py → dist/playable.html
+```
+
+Open `dist/playable.html` in a browser or serve `dist/` locally. Confirm boot → main scene, HUD digits (timer colon), CTA, and tile match all load.
+
+## Bundle Architecture
+
+1. **Inline Phaser** — fetch `phaser.min.js` at build time and embed in `<script>`.
+2. **Inline game JS** — concatenate scripts in the same order as `game/index.html`.
+3. **Inline assets** — base64 data URIs for `bg.png` + each atlas `*.png` / `*.json`.
+4. **Runtime resolver** — `window.__BUNDLE_ASSETS__` map; `ASSET_MANIFEST.getFullPath` / `getAtlasFullPath` return bundled URIs when present.
+
+Dev mode unchanged: without `__BUNDLE_ASSETS__`, manifest still uses `../assets/...` paths.
+
+## Adding New Assets
+
+Update **both**:
+
+1. `scripts/build-html.py` → `ASSET_FILES` list (key, disk path, mime)
+2. `game/index.html` script list if a new `.js` file was added → `SCRIPT_ORDER` in build script
+
+Rebuild and verify the new asset appears in-game.
+
+## Size Expectations
+
+Typical Mahjong playable with 5 atlases + Phaser: **~3.5–5 MB**. If over network limit:
+
+- Run `npm run verify:ui:assets` for atlas budget warnings
+- Quantize large UI/reward atlases before rebuild
+- Pin Phaser to the version already used in `game/index.html`
+
+## CTA / MRAID
+
+Keep the inline bootstrap from `game/index.html` (`onCTAClick`, `mraid`, `FbPlayableAd`, etc.). Bundle script extracts this block verbatim — edit CTA handlers there, not in `build-html.py`.
+
+## Common Failures
+
+| Symptom                 | Fix                                                                                  |
+| ----------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ |
+| Black screen, no canvas | Check browser console; usually script order drift vs `index.html`                    |
+| Missing textures        | Asset not listed in `ASSET_FILES` or atlas not rebuilt                               |
+| Timer shows `x` not `:` | Wrong `digit_colon` frame — re-run `npm run import:gpt-art` (see art pipeline skill) |
+| File too large          | Shrink atlases; avoid duplicating individual PNGs when atlases already cover them    |
+
+## Validation Checklist
+
+- [ ] `dist/playable.html` loads without network (disable cache, hard refresh)
+- [ ] No 404s in Network tab (only document request)
+- [ ] Timer, pairs counter, board, CTA visible
+- [ ] CTA click logs or opens fallback URL
+- [ ] File size within target network cap
+
+## Additional Resources
+
+- Build script: `scripts/build-html.py`
+- Bundle resolver hooks: `game/config/asset-manifest.js` (`__BUNDLE_ASSETS__`)
+- Pre-ship： [validation-rules §⑥](../validation-rules.md#⑥-video-validator整片)

package/project-template/skills/playable-validate/validation-rules.md

@@ -0,0 +1,200 @@
+# Validation Gates — 九步流水线校验规则
+
+> Agent 在 **任何 skill 之前** 运行 `npm run ensure:project`（见 [agent-prep.md](../_shared/agent-prep.md)）。
+
+---
+
+## Gate 总表
+
+| 步  | Gate 名称           | 工具                | 硬 FAIL 条件                              |
+| --- | ------------------- | ------------------- | ----------------------------------------- |
+| ①   | 约束就绪            | 文档                | 无 vds/vfx-spec/profile 中任一项          |
+| ②   | 后处理完成          | 脚本                | 缺 `_raw` 备份；manifest 未登记新帧       |
+| ③   | **Image Validator** | `npm run verify:ui` | 任何 FAIL；budget FAIL 无 P2 文档         |
+| ④   | 工程加载            | dev 控制台          | 缺资源；layout 魔数未走 profile           |
+| ⑤   | **Auto-clear**      | 一键通关            | 卡住；到不了 ENDCARD                      |
+| ⑥   | **Video Validator** | headed MP4          | spec 非 1080×1920@60；有 P0               |
+| ⑦   | 动效验收            | MP4 + L1            | frame 无 anchor gate；decompose 语义 FAIL |
+| ⑧   | L→G 螺旋            | playground sweep    | 无 G 步；并行多个 L                       |
+| ⑨   | 交付                | PLAYABLE-\*.md      | 无基线对比；无 skills 记录                |
+
+---
+
+## ③ Image Validator（`verify:ui`）
+
+```bash
+cd testN && npm run verify:ui
+```
+
+| 检查项           | PASS             | 备注               |
+| ---------------- | ---------------- | ------------------ |
+| profile schema   | 必须             |                    |
+| assets present   | 必须             |                    |
+| atlas frames     | 必须             |                    |
+| atlas budget     | 必须或 WARN+文档 | test11 2505KB 教训 |
+| layout regions   | 必须             |                    |
+| hardcoded layout | 必须无           |                    |
+
+**不能代替 ⑥**：合成、动画、鬼影。透明相关 FAIL/WARN 必须附带 `recommendedSkill` 和 `alphaStrategy`，例如 `playable-art + rgb-alpha-split`、`playable-fx-peak + black-add`。
+
+---
+
+## ⑥ Video Validator（整片）
+
+```bash
+npm run record:mp4 -- --headed --fps=60
+ffprobe recordings/*.mp4  # 1080×1920 60/1 ~25s
+```
+
+### 分段 P0 定义
+
+| 段       | 时间   | P0 示例                          |
+| -------- | ------ | -------------------------------- |
+| HOOK     | 0–3s   | 白块、HUD 错位、占位字牌         |
+| TUTORIAL | 3–8s   | 引导不可见                       |
+| GAMEPLAY | 8–22s  | 输入无效、FX 竖缝/鬼影、严重卡顿 |
+| ENDCARD  | 22–25s | CTA 不可读、HUD 抢戏、尾帧截断   |
+
+### 透明 / 合成 P0-P2 分类
+
+| 现象 | 严重度 | 推荐反馈 |
+| ---- | ------ | -------- |
+| 白边、绿边、品红边明显包住 UI / sprite | P1/P0 | `playable-art`, `alphaStrategy=rgb-alpha-split` 或换 `chroma` key |
+| 黑块包住 glow / 粒子 | P1/P0 | `playable-fx-peak`, `alphaStrategy=black-add` |
+| halo 被 remove-bg 吃掉 | P1 | `playable-fx-peak`, clean harness 后回全局 MP4 |
+| 双主体、邻帧串格、漂移 | P1/P0 | `playable-fx-peak` anchor gate；必要时禁用 `dual-bg-diff` |
+| video matte 错位 / 闪烁 | P1/P0 | `playable-art`, `videoAlphaStrategy=rgb-alpha-video` 或重出 opaque-video |
+
+### ⑥ 目视清单（并入原 regression-checklist）
+
+```
+自动化
+- [ ] npm run verify:ui — 全部 PASS
+- [ ] npm run record:mp4 — 1080×1920 @60fps
+
+配置
+- [ ] CTA 等比 scale，无独立压宽
+- [ ] SHOW_DEBUG_BUTTON：录屏 true / 发布 false
+
+浏览器 1080×1920
+- [ ] HUD/CTA 框不变形，数字在红区居中
+- [ ] 连击条与 CTA 间距 ≥ 40px
+- [ ] 一键通关可见且可达 ENDCARD（录屏配置）
+
+交互
+- [ ] 选牌/消除无永久 input lock
+- [ ] CTA 可点击
+
+FX（headed 录屏）
+- [ ] burst 无竖缝/鬼影；ring 晕开可读
+- [ ] 新 FX 已 A/B 且记录赢家（见 playable-fx-peak § GPT 出图与 A/B）
+- [ ] VFX 先走 playable-fx-peak clean harness，再回全局 MP4
+- [ ] 每条视频问题格式：timestamp → visible symptom → severity → recommended skill → recommended alphaStrategy
+```
+
+**Failure triage**
+
+| 现象                  | 查                                               |
+| --------------------- | ------------------------------------------------ |
+| verify:ui:layout FAIL | profile / `applySafeLayout`                      |
+| CTA 椭圆              | 非等比 scale → playable-verify-ui § Frame+Text   |
+| 一键通关无            | playable-debug                                   |
+| 图+字 inset           | `measure_frame_content.py`（playable-verify-ui） |
+| 白边 / 绿边 / alpha 脏 | playable-art § Alpha Postprocess Strategy        |
+| glow 黑块 / halo 截断 | playable-fx-peak clean harness + `black-add`     |
+| video matte 错位      | TA log `videoAlphaStrategy` + 重新生成 matte      |
+
+扩展项：[references/checklist-detail.md](references/checklist-detail.md)
+
+### 基线对比（必须）
+
+相对 `test(N-1)/recordings/*.mp4` 同 timestamp：
+
+- **改善** — 关闭了什么问题
+- **仍存** — 未关什么
+- **回归** — 新坏了什么（必须修或回滚）
+
+---
+
+## ⑦ 动效 Gate
+
+### Frame ADD（peak pipeline）
+
+```bash
+python3 skills/playable-fx-peak/scripts/repack-frame-sequence.py \
+  --raw assets/images/fx/<name>_raw.png --name <name> --cols 6 \
+  --report validate/focus/frame/<name>-repack.json
+
+python3 skills/playable-fx-peak/scripts/validate-frame-anchors.py \
+  'assets/images/fx/<name>_frame*.png' \
+  --json validate/focus/frame/<name>-anchor.json
+```
+
+| 阈值       | 默认   |
+| ---------- | ------ |
+| max drift  | ≤ 12px |
+| L/R ratio  | ≤ 1.6  |
+| edge_touch | 无     |
+| grey_px    | ≤ 500  |
+
+然后：
+
+```bash
+npm run playground -- record clean:frame:<id> --headed
+```
+
+### Decompose（破碎）
+
+- [ ] 状态行：同一物体 progressive damage
+- [ ] 模块行：无黑框；方向可预测
+- [ ] 可变牌面：**白板 crack overlay**，禁止错牌面 overlay
+- [ ] G1 `match-once` 合成无 P0
+
+详见 `playable-fx-decompose/examples.md`
+
+---
+
+## ⑧ L→G 规则
+
+```
+禁止：G→G→G 只全局审
+禁止：L→L→L 无全局整合
+禁止：一轮 parallel 多个 L
+正定：L1 → G1 → L2 → G2 → …
+```
+
+**L 步输入**：窄 — focus mp4、anchor json、单 spec  
+**G 步输入**：宽 — 整片或 integration 录屏
+
+Focus scope：`playground/registry.json`（`playable-focus`）
+
+---
+
+## ⑨ 交付报告模板
+
+`testN/validate/PLAYABLE-YYYYMMDD-HHmmss.md` 必含：
+
+1. 录屏路径 + ffprobe 规格
+2. 上一版基线路径
+3. ③ verify:ui 摘要
+4. ⑥ 分段观察 + P0/P1/P2 表（含 recommendedSkill + alphaStrategy）
+5. **相对基线** 改善/仍存/回归
+6. Loop 结论：通过 / 有条件通过 / 未通过
+7. skills 实验记录链接
+
+---
+
+## 回流规则
+
+| 改动               | 从哪步重来        |
+| ------------------ | ----------------- |
+| tween / scale only | ⑤ → ⑥             |
+| 新 PNG / manifest  | ② → ③ → ④ → ⑤ → ⑥ |
+| 新 FX sheet        | ② → ③ → ⑦ L1 → ⑥  |
+| 仅 playground spec | ⑧ L1 → G1 → ⑥     |
+
+---
+
+## 从 test3 重放的 Checkpoint
+
+见 [validate/REPLAY-CHECKLIST.md](../../validate/REPLAY-CHECKLIST.md)。