solarwindpy 0.0.1.dev0__py3-none-any.whl → 0.1.1__py3-none-any.whl

plans/completed/compaction-hook-enhancement/5-Testing-Strategy.md

@@ -0,0 +1,404 @@
+# Testing Strategy for Enhanced Compaction Hook System
+
+## Overview
+Comprehensive testing strategy to validate the enhanced compaction hook system, ensuring reliability, performance, and seamless integration with the existing 7-hook ecosystem and 7-agent system.
+
+## Testing Levels
+
+### 1. Unit Testing (Individual Components)
+**Target:** Each enhancement component functions correctly in isolation
+
+#### Token Estimation Testing
+```python
+# tests/test_compaction_enhancement.py
+def test_enhanced_token_estimation():
+    """Test enhanced token estimation accuracy."""
+    # Test with known content samples
+    test_cases = [
+        ('simple_prose.md', 'Simple prose content', 150, 10),  # file, content, expected_tokens, tolerance
+        ('code_heavy.md', 'Code-heavy content', 200, 15),
+        ('mixed_content.md', 'Mixed content types', 300, 20)
+    ]
+    
+    for filename, description, expected, tolerance in test_cases:
+        tokens, lines, breakdown = estimate_context_size_enhanced_for_file(filename)
+        assert abs(tokens - expected) <= tolerance, f"Token estimation for {description} outside tolerance"
+        assert breakdown is not None, "Content breakdown should be provided"
+
+def test_content_analysis_functions():
+    """Test content analysis utility functions."""
+    sample_content = '''
+# Header
+Some prose content here.
+
+```python
+def test_function():
+    return "test"
+```
+
+- List item 1
+- List item 2
+
+| Column 1 | Column 2 |
+|----------|----------|
+| Data 1   | Data 2   |
+'''
+    
+    chars, words, lines, breakdown = analyze_file_content_from_string(sample_content)
+    
+    assert chars > 0, "Character count should be positive"
+    assert words > 0, "Word count should be positive"
+    assert lines > 0, "Line count should be positive"
+    assert breakdown['code'] == 1, "Should detect 1 code block"
+    assert breakdown['tables'] > 0, "Should detect table content"
+    assert breakdown['lists'] == 2, "Should detect 2 list items"
+```
+
+#### Compression Intelligence Testing
+```python
+def test_compression_strategy_selection():
+    """Test intelligent compression strategy selection."""
+    # Test with different content profiles
+    content_profiles = [
+        {'code': 50, 'prose': 30, 'tables': 10, 'lists': 10},  # Code-heavy
+        {'code': 10, 'prose': 70, 'tables': 5, 'lists': 15},   # Prose-heavy
+        {'code': 20, 'prose': 20, 'tables': 40, 'lists': 20}   # Table-heavy
+    ]
+    
+    for profile in content_profiles:
+        strategy = CompactionStrategy(profile, 10000, 0.4)
+        plan = strategy.create_compression_plan()
+        
+        assert 'compression_methods' in plan, "Compression methods should be selected"
+        assert len(plan['compression_methods']) > 0, "At least one method should be selected"
+        
+        # Verify appropriate methods for content type
+        if profile['code'] > 30:
+            assert 'compress_code_examples' in plan['compression_methods']
+        if profile['prose'] > 50:
+            assert 'summarize_verbose_sections' in plan['compression_methods']
+
+def test_compression_functions():
+    """Test individual compression functions."""
+    # Test code compression
+    code_content = '''
+```python
+def complex_function():
+    """This is a complex function."""
+    # Implementation details
+    for i in range(100):
+        process_item(i)
+    return result
+```
+'''
+    
+    compressed = compress_code_examples(code_content)
+    assert 'def complex_function()' in compressed, "Function signature should be preserved"
+    assert 'compressed' in compressed, "Should indicate compression occurred"
+    
+    # Test prose summarization
+    verbose_content = '''
+## Long Section
+This is a very long section with lots of details that could be summarized.
+''' + '\n'.join([f'Line {i} with more details.' for i in range(50)])
+    
+    summarized = summarize_verbose_sections(verbose_content)
+    assert 'summarized for compaction' in summarized, "Should indicate summarization"
+    assert len(summarized) < len(verbose_content), "Should be shorter than original"
+```
+
+#### Git Integration Testing
+```python
+def test_enhanced_git_info_collection():
+    """Test enhanced git information collection."""
+    git_info = get_enhanced_git_info()
+    
+    required_keys = ['branch', 'commits', 'status', 'branch_info', 'recent_activity', 'metrics']
+    for key in required_keys:
+        assert key in git_info, f"Git info should contain {key}"
+    
+    # Test branch relationship detection
+    if git_info['branch'].startswith('plan/'):
+        assert git_info['branch_info']['type'] == 'plan'
+        assert 'plan_name' in git_info['branch_info']
+    elif git_info['branch'].startswith('feature/'):
+        assert git_info['branch_info']['type'] == 'feature'
+        assert 'feature_name' in git_info['branch_info']
+
+def test_git_tagging():
+    """Test git tag creation and cleanup."""
+    # Create test compression plan
+    test_plan = {
+        'compression_methods': ['test_method'],
+        'token_reduction': '40%'
+    }
+    
+    git_info = get_enhanced_git_info()
+    tag_name = create_compaction_git_tag(git_info, test_plan)
+    
+    if tag_name:  # Only test if tagging succeeded
+        # Verify tag was created
+        result = subprocess.run(['git', 'tag', '-l', tag_name], capture_output=True, text=True)
+        assert tag_name in result.stdout, "Tag should be created"
+        
+        # Test cleanup (but don't actually remove tags in test)
+        # cleanup_old_compaction_tags()  # Would need mock for real testing
+```
+
+### 2. Integration Testing (Component Interaction)
+**Target:** Enhanced components work together correctly
+
+```python
+def test_end_to_end_compaction_creation():
+    """Test complete enhanced compaction creation flow."""
+    # Create test content files
+    setup_test_content_files()
+    
+    try:
+        # Run enhanced compaction
+        final_content, metadata = create_enhanced_compaction_final()
+        
+        # Verify structure
+        assert '## Enhanced Compaction Metadata' in final_content
+        assert '## Session Resumption Guide' in final_content
+        assert 'Quick Start' in final_content
+        assert 'Priority Actions' in final_content
+        
+        # Verify metadata
+        assert 'tokens_before' in metadata
+        assert 'tokens_after' in metadata
+        assert 'compression_ratio' in metadata
+        assert metadata['resumption_ready'] is True
+        
+        # Verify compression effectiveness
+        assert metadata['tokens_after'] < metadata['tokens_before']
+        assert 0.2 <= metadata['compression_ratio'] <= 0.6  # 20-60% reduction
+        
+    finally:
+        cleanup_test_content_files()
+
+def test_hook_ecosystem_integration():
+    """Test integration with existing hook ecosystem."""
+    # Test with validate-session-state.sh
+    compaction_file = Path('.claude/compacted_state.md')
+    if compaction_file.exists():
+        # Verify validate-session-state.sh can load compacted state
+        result = subprocess.run([
+            '.claude/hooks/validate-session-state.sh'
+        ], capture_output=True, text=True)
+        
+        assert result.returncode == 0, "Session state validation should succeed"
+        assert 'compacted state' in result.stdout.lower(), "Should recognize compacted state"
+    
+    # Test with git-workflow-validator.sh
+    # Mock git operations to test integration
+    test_git_workflow_integration()
+```
+
+### 3. Performance Testing
+**Target:** Enhanced system meets performance requirements
+
+```python
+def test_compaction_performance():
+    """Test compaction creation performance."""
+    import time
+    
+    # Create realistic test content
+    setup_large_test_content()
+    
+    try:
+        start_time = time.time()
+        final_content, metadata = create_enhanced_compaction_final()
+        end_time = time.time()
+        
+        execution_time = end_time - start_time
+        
+        # Performance requirements
+        assert execution_time < 5.0, f"Compaction should complete in <5s, took {execution_time:.2f}s"
+        
+        # Memory usage test (would need memory profiling)
+        # assert peak_memory_usage < 50_000_000  # 50MB
+        
+    finally:
+        cleanup_large_test_content()
+
+def test_token_estimation_accuracy():
+    """Test token estimation accuracy against known samples."""
+    # Test with files of known token counts (manually verified)
+    test_files = [
+        ('sample_plan.md', 2500),  # filename, expected_tokens
+        ('sample_code.py', 800),
+        ('sample_prose.md', 1200)
+    ]
+    
+    for filename, expected_tokens in test_files:
+        if Path(filename).exists():
+            estimated_tokens, _, _ = estimate_context_size_enhanced_for_file(filename)
+            accuracy = abs(estimated_tokens - expected_tokens) / expected_tokens
+            
+            assert accuracy <= 0.1, f"Token estimation accuracy should be within 10%, was {accuracy:.1%}"
+```
+
+### 4. Regression Testing
+**Target:** Existing functionality preserved
+
+```python
+def test_backward_compatibility():
+    """Test that existing compaction functionality still works."""
+    # Test original compaction creation still functions
+    original_content = create_original_compaction()
+    assert original_content is not None, "Original compaction should still work"
+    assert '# Compacted Context State' in original_content, "Original format preserved"
+    
+    # Test existing plan structure compatibility
+    test_plan_structure_compatibility()
+    
+    # Test existing hook compatibility
+    test_existing_hook_compatibility()
+
+def test_existing_hook_compatibility():
+    """Test compatibility with existing hooks."""
+    # Test each existing hook still functions
+    hooks_to_test = [
+        '.claude/hooks/validate-session-state.sh',
+        '.claude/hooks/git-workflow-validator.sh',
+        '.claude/hooks/test-runner.sh',
+        '.claude/hooks/pre-commit-tests.sh'
+    ]
+    
+    for hook in hooks_to_test:
+        if Path(hook).exists():
+            # Run hook with test parameters
+            result = subprocess.run([hook], capture_output=True, text=True)
+            # Should not fail due to compaction enhancements
+            assert result.returncode in [0, None], f"Hook {hook} should remain functional"
+```
+
+### 5. Agent Coordination Testing
+**Target:** Enhanced compaction works with all 7 agents
+
+```python
+def test_agent_context_preservation():
+    """Test that agent contexts are properly preserved."""
+    # Create test scenario with agent-specific content
+    agent_contexts = {
+        'UnifiedPlanCoordinator': 'plan coordination context',
+        'PhysicsValidator': 'physics validation context',
+        'DataFrameArchitect': 'dataframe structure context',
+        'NumericalStabilityGuard': 'numerical computation context',
+        'PlottingEngineer': 'visualization context',
+        'FitFunctionSpecialist': 'curve fitting context',
+        'TestEngineer': 'testing strategy context'
+    }
+    
+    # Create compaction with agent contexts
+    compaction_content = create_compaction_with_agent_contexts(agent_contexts)
+    
+    # Verify each agent context is preserved or properly compressed
+    for agent, context_type in agent_contexts.items():
+        # Check if critical elements are preserved
+        assert agent in compaction_content or 'agent coordination' in compaction_content.lower()
+
+def test_session_resumption_with_agents():
+    """Test that agents can resume effectively with compacted state."""
+    # This would be more of a simulation test
+    resumption_guide = create_test_resumption_guide()
+    
+    # Verify resumption guide contains agent coordination information
+    assert 'agent_preparation' in str(resumption_guide)
+    assert 'domain_agents' in str(resumption_guide)
+```
+
+## Test Execution Strategy
+
+### Automated Testing
+```bash
+# Run enhanced compaction tests
+pytest tests/test_compaction_enhancement.py -v
+
+# Run integration tests with existing system
+pytest tests/test_hook_integration.py -v
+
+# Run performance benchmarks
+pytest tests/test_compaction_performance.py -v --benchmark
+
+# Run regression tests
+pytest tests/test_compaction_regression.py -v
+```
+
+### Manual Testing Scenarios
+1. **Complete Development Session**: Create plan, implement features, create compaction, resume session
+2. **Multi-Hook Workflow**: Trigger multiple hooks in sequence with enhanced compaction
+3. **Agent Coordination**: Test with actual agent usage scenarios
+4. **Error Conditions**: Test with git errors, file permission issues, corrupt content
+5. **Performance Stress**: Test with very large context (>20k tokens)
+
+### Continuous Integration
+- Add enhanced compaction tests to existing CI pipeline
+- Include performance benchmarks in CI
+- Test against multiple git states and branch configurations
+- Validate with different plan structures and content types
+
+## Rollback Testing
+
+### Fallback Validation
+```python
+def test_fallback_mechanisms():
+    """Test that fallback mechanisms work correctly."""
+    # Test enhanced estimation fallback
+    with mock_function_failure('estimate_context_size_enhanced'):
+        tokens, lines = estimate_context_size()  # Should fall back to original
+        assert tokens > 0, "Fallback estimation should work"
+    
+    # Test compression failure fallback
+    with mock_function_failure('apply_intelligent_compression'):
+        content = create_compaction()  # Should fall back to original method
+        assert content is not None, "Fallback compaction should work"
+```
+
+### Recovery Testing
+```python
+def test_error_recovery():
+    """Test error recovery in enhanced compaction."""
+    error_scenarios = [
+        'git_command_failure',
+        'file_permission_denied',
+        'corrupted_plan_files',
+        'insufficient_disk_space',
+        'network_timeout'
+    ]
+    
+    for scenario in error_scenarios:
+        with simulate_error_condition(scenario):
+            # Enhanced compaction should handle errors gracefully
+            try:
+                result = create_enhanced_compaction_final()
+                # Should either succeed or fail gracefully
+                assert result is not None or "fallback was used"
+            except Exception as e:
+                # Should be handled exception, not crash
+                assert "fallback" in str(e).lower() or "graceful" in str(e).lower()
+```
+
+## Success Criteria
+
+### Functional Requirements
+- [ ] All unit tests pass with >95% coverage
+- [ ] Integration tests validate hook ecosystem compatibility
+- [ ] Agent coordination tests confirm seamless operation
+- [ ] Regression tests ensure existing functionality preserved
+
+### Performance Requirements
+- [ ] Compaction creation <5 seconds
+- [ ] Token estimation accuracy within ±10%
+- [ ] Memory usage <50MB during operation
+- [ ] Session resumption <2 seconds
+
+### Quality Requirements
+- [ ] Error handling robust and informative
+- [ ] Fallback mechanisms functional
+- [ ] Documentation complete and accurate
+- [ ] Code quality meets project standards (black, flake8)
+
+---
+**Testing Strategy ensures reliable, performant, and compatible enhanced compaction system**