solarwindpy 0.0.1.dev0__py3-none-any.whl → 0.1.0__py3-none-any.whl

plans/abandoned/hook-system-enhancement/8-Testing-Strategy.md

@@ -0,0 +1,579 @@
+# Testing Strategy
+
+## Testing Overview
+
+This comprehensive testing strategy ensures the SolarWindPy Integrated Hook System Enhancement maintains the highest standards of scientific integrity while delivering performance improvements and enhanced functionality. The strategy recognizes that this is NASA research code requiring zero compromise on physics validation accuracy.
+
+### Testing Philosophy
+- **Scientific Integrity First**: Physics validation accuracy is paramount
+- **Comprehensive Coverage**: All system components thoroughly tested
+- **Real-world Validation**: Testing with actual research workflows
+- **Performance Validation**: Continuous performance monitoring and optimization
+- **User-centric Testing**: Focus on developer experience and workflow integration
+
+### Testing Levels
+1. **Unit Testing**: Individual component validation
+2. **Integration Testing**: Component interaction validation
+3. **System Testing**: End-to-end system validation
+4. **Performance Testing**: Speed, efficiency, and resource usage
+5. **Scientific Validation**: Physics accuracy and research workflow testing
+6. **User Acceptance Testing**: Developer experience and adoption validation
+
+## Phase-Specific Testing Strategies
+
+### Phase 1: Core Infrastructure Testing
+
+#### Unit Testing
+**Scope**: Individual hook components and agent interfaces
+
+**Test Categories**:
+- **Hook Manager**: 
+  - Agent coordination logic
+  - Error handling and recovery
+  - Configuration management
+  - Performance monitoring integration
+
+- **Agent Integration Interface**:
+  - Communication protocol validation
+  - Timeout handling
+  - Error propagation
+  - Async operation management
+
+- **Configuration Management**:
+  - YAML parsing and validation
+  - Environment-specific overrides
+  - Configuration schema validation
+  - Default value handling
+
+**Test Examples**:
+```python
+def test_hook_manager_agent_coordination():
+    """Test HookManager coordinates agents correctly."""
+    hook_manager = HookManager(test_config)
+    context = {'changed_files': ['solarwindpy/core/plasma.py']}
+    
+    result = hook_manager.execute_hook('pre-commit', context)
+    
+    assert result.success
+    assert 'physics_validator' in result.agent_results
+    assert result.execution_time < 30  # Performance requirement
+
+def test_agent_interface_timeout_handling():
+    """Test agent interface handles timeouts gracefully."""
+    agent_interface = AgentInterface()
+    
+    with patch('agent_interface.invoke_agent') as mock_invoke:
+        mock_invoke.side_effect = asyncio.TimeoutError()
+        
+        result = agent_interface.invoke_agent('test_agent', {}, timeout=1)
+        
+    assert not result.success
+    assert 'timeout' in result.error_message.lower()
+```
+
+#### Integration Testing
+**Scope**: Hook system integration with git and agent ecosystem
+
+**Test Scenarios**:
+- Complete hook execution workflow
+- Agent coordination under various scenarios
+- Error handling and fallback mechanisms
+- Configuration loading and validation
+
+### Phase 2: Intelligent Testing Validation
+
+#### Unit Testing
+**Scope**: Test selection algorithms and caching mechanisms
+
+**Test Categories**:
+- **Change Analysis**:
+  - Git diff parsing accuracy
+  - Module dependency identification
+  - Impact assessment correctness
+
+- **Test Selection**:
+  - Relevance algorithm accuracy
+  - Physics test prioritization
+  - TestEngineer agent integration
+
+- **Caching System**:
+  - Cache hit/miss accuracy
+  - Invalidation logic correctness
+  - Performance optimization effectiveness
+
+**Test Examples**:
+```python
+def test_change_analyzer_identifies_affected_modules():
+    """Test change analyzer correctly identifies affected modules."""
+    analyzer = ChangeAnalyzer(test_repo_path)
+    
+    # Create test changes
+    test_changes = [
+        'solarwindpy/core/plasma.py',
+        'solarwindpy/core/ions.py'
+    ]
+    
+    affected_modules = analyzer.analyze_changes(test_changes)
+    
+    # Should include changed modules and their dependents
+    assert 'solarwindpy.core.plasma' in affected_modules
+    assert 'solarwindpy.core.ions' in affected_modules
+    # Should include modules that depend on plasma.py
+    assert 'solarwindpy.instabilities' in affected_modules
+
+def test_test_selector_prioritizes_physics_tests():
+    """Test that physics tests are always prioritized."""
+    selector = TestSelector(test_config)
+    affected_modules = {'solarwindpy.core.plasma'}
+    
+    selected_tests = selector.select_tests(affected_modules)
+    
+    # All physics tests should be included
+    physics_tests = [t for t in selected_tests if 'physics' in t]
+    assert len(physics_tests) > 0
+    
+    # Performance: should reduce total test time
+    all_tests = selector._discover_tests()
+    reduction_ratio = len(selected_tests) / len(all_tests)
+    assert reduction_ratio < 0.4  # >60% reduction target
+```
+
+#### Performance Testing
+**Scope**: Test execution speed and efficiency validation
+
+**Performance Metrics**:
+- Test selection time < 5 seconds
+- Test execution time reduction 60-80%
+- Cache hit rate > 90% for unchanged code
+- Memory usage < 500MB during test selection
+
+**Test Scenarios**:
+- Large codebase test selection performance
+- Cache efficiency under various change patterns
+- Parallel test execution optimization
+- Resource usage monitoring
+
+### Phase 3: Physics Validation Testing
+
+#### Scientific Accuracy Testing
+**Scope**: Validation of physics validation preservation and enhancement
+
+**Critical Test Categories**:
+- **Physics Constraint Validation**:
+  - Thermal speed convention (mw² = 2kT)
+  - Alfvén speed calculation (V_A = B/√(μ₀ρ))
+  - Missing data handling (NaN enforcement)
+  - Physical bounds and limits
+
+- **Unit Consistency**:
+  - SI unit enforcement
+  - Dimensional analysis validation
+  - Scientific constants usage
+  - Unit conversion accuracy
+
+- **Research Workflow Validation**:
+  - Spacecraft data processing
+  - MultiIndex DataFrame operations
+  - Time series chronological ordering
+  - Reproducibility enforcement
+
+**Test Examples**:
+```python
+def test_thermal_speed_convention_validation():
+    """Test thermal speed convention validation."""
+    validator = PhysicsConstraints()
+    
+    # Test valid thermal speed calculation
+    valid_code = '''
+    def thermal_speed(temperature, mass):
+        # mw² = 2kT convention
+        return np.sqrt(2 * k_B * temperature / mass)
+    '''
+    
+    result = validator.validate_thermal_speed_convention(valid_code)
+    assert result.success
+    
+    # Test invalid convention
+    invalid_code = '''
+    def thermal_speed(temperature, mass):
+        # Incorrect: mw² = kT
+        return np.sqrt(k_B * temperature / mass)
+    '''
+    
+    result = validator.validate_thermal_speed_convention(invalid_code)
+    assert not result.success
+    assert 'thermal speed convention' in result.error_message
+
+def test_physics_validation_regression():
+    """Test that new system matches existing physics validation."""
+    # Get existing validation results for reference dataset
+    existing_validator = ExistingPhysicsValidator()
+    enhanced_validator = EnhancedPhysicsValidator()
+    
+    test_datasets = load_physics_test_datasets()
+    
+    for dataset in test_datasets:
+        existing_result = existing_validator.validate(dataset)
+        enhanced_result = enhanced_validator.validate(dataset)
+        
+        # Results must be identical
+        assert existing_result.is_valid == enhanced_result.is_valid
+        assert existing_result.violations == enhanced_result.violations
+        
+        # Enhanced system may provide additional insights
+        assert len(enhanced_result.insights) >= len(existing_result.insights)
+```
+
+#### Agent Integration Testing
+**Scope**: Validation of PhysicsValidator and NumericalStabilityGuard integration
+
+**Test Scenarios**:
+- Agent communication protocol validation
+- Physics validation workflow coordination
+- Error handling and fallback mechanisms
+- Performance impact measurement
+
+### Phase 4: Performance Monitoring Testing
+
+#### Monitoring Accuracy Testing
+**Scope**: Validation of performance metrics collection and analysis
+
+**Test Categories**:
+- **Metrics Collection**:
+  - Timing accuracy validation
+  - Resource usage measurement accuracy
+  - Data collection completeness
+  - Storage and retrieval correctness
+
+- **Analytics Engine**:
+  - Trend analysis algorithm accuracy
+  - Bottleneck detection effectiveness
+  - Performance regression detection
+  - Optimization recommendation quality
+
+**Test Examples**:
+```python
+def test_metrics_collector_timing_accuracy():
+    """Test metrics collector provides accurate timing data."""
+    collector = MetricsCollector()
+    
+    start_time = time.time()
+    execution_id = collector.start_hook_monitoring('pre-commit', {})
+    
+    # Simulate hook execution
+    time.sleep(1.0)  # Known duration
+    
+    collector.finish_hook_monitoring(execution_id, True, {})
+    
+    metrics = collector.get_execution_metrics(execution_id)
+    duration = metrics['total_duration']
+    
+    # Should be accurate within 100ms
+    assert abs(duration - 1.0) < 0.1
+
+def test_bottleneck_detection():
+    """Test bottleneck detection identifies performance issues."""
+    detector = BottleneckDetector()
+    
+    # Create test metrics with known bottleneck
+    test_metrics = [
+        {'agent': 'physics_validator', 'duration': 25},  # Bottleneck
+        {'agent': 'test_engineer', 'duration': 3},
+        {'agent': 'code_formatter', 'duration': 2}
+    ]
+    
+    bottlenecks = detector.detect_bottlenecks(test_metrics)
+    
+    assert len(bottlenecks) > 0
+    assert bottlenecks[0]['agent'] == 'physics_validator'
+    assert bottlenecks[0]['severity'] == 'high'
+```
+
+#### Performance Impact Testing
+**Scope**: Validation that monitoring doesn't impact system performance
+
+**Performance Requirements**:
+- Monitoring overhead < 5% of total execution time
+- Memory usage < 50MB for monitoring
+- No impact on hook execution speed
+- Real-time dashboard responsiveness
+
+### Phase 5: Developer Experience Testing
+
+#### Usability Testing
+**Scope**: Validation of user interfaces and developer workflows
+
+**Test Categories**:
+- **Configuration Wizard**:
+  - Setup completion time < 10 minutes
+  - Configuration accuracy validation
+  - User satisfaction measurement
+  - Error handling and guidance
+
+- **Documentation Quality**:
+  - Completeness and accuracy
+  - Example functionality validation
+  - Search and navigation effectiveness
+  - User task completion rates
+
+- **CLI Tool Effectiveness**:
+  - Command functionality validation
+  - Output clarity and usefulness
+  - Performance of CLI operations
+  - Error message quality
+
+**Test Examples**:
+```python
+def test_configuration_wizard_completion():
+    """Test configuration wizard completes successfully."""
+    wizard = ConfigurationWizard()
+    
+    # Simulate user inputs
+    user_inputs = [
+        'y',  # Enable hook system
+        '2',  # Development mode
+        'y',  # Enable intelligent testing
+        '1',  # Default physics validation
+        'n'   # Skip advanced options
+    ]
+    
+    with patch('builtins.input', side_effect=user_inputs):
+        config = wizard.run_wizard()
+    
+    # Should generate valid configuration
+    assert config['hook_system']['enabled'] is True
+    assert config['intelligent_testing']['enabled'] is True
+    
+    # Configuration should be valid
+    validator = ConfigValidator()
+    assert validator.validate(config).success
+
+def test_cli_status_command():
+    """Test CLI status command provides useful information."""
+    runner = CliRunner()
+    result = runner.invoke(hook_cli, ['status'])
+    
+    assert result.exit_code == 0
+    assert 'Hook System Status' in result.output
+    assert 'Active' in result.output or 'Inactive' in result.output
+```
+
+#### User Acceptance Testing
+**Scope**: Real-world usage validation with target developers
+
+**Test Scenarios**:
+- New developer onboarding workflow
+- Daily development workflow integration
+- Troubleshooting and problem resolution
+- Advanced configuration and customization
+
+## Cross-Phase Integration Testing
+
+### End-to-End Workflow Testing
+**Scope**: Complete development workflow validation
+
+**Test Scenarios**:
+1. **Complete Commit Workflow**:
+   - Developer makes changes to physics code
+   - Hook system automatically validates changes
+   - Intelligent test selection reduces execution time
+   - Physics validation ensures scientific accuracy
+   - Performance monitoring tracks efficiency
+   - Developer receives clear feedback
+
+2. **Research Publication Workflow**:
+   - Researcher preparing code for publication
+   - Enhanced validation ensures publication readiness
+   - Reproducibility checks pass
+   - Performance optimized for research datasets
+   - Documentation and examples validated
+
+3. **Emergency Commit Workflow**:
+   - Urgent fix needed for research deadline
+   - Emergency validation mode activated
+   - Critical physics checks maintained
+   - Fast validation without compromising accuracy
+   - System provides clear emergency status
+
+### System Integration Testing
+**Test Examples**:
+```python
+def test_complete_commit_workflow():
+    """Test complete development workflow from commit to validation."""
+    # Setup test repository
+    repo = create_test_repository()
+    
+    # Make changes to physics code
+    modify_file(repo, 'solarwindpy/core/plasma.py', add_thermal_speed_function)
+    
+    # Execute git commit (triggers hooks)
+    result = repo.git.commit('-m', 'test: add thermal speed calculation')
+    
+    # Verify hook execution
+    assert result.returncode == 0  # Commit successful
+    
+    # Verify intelligent testing occurred
+    test_log = read_hook_log('intelligent_testing')
+    assert 'test selection' in test_log
+    assert 'reduction: 70%' in test_log  # Performance target met
+    
+    # Verify physics validation occurred
+    physics_log = read_hook_log('physics_validation')
+    assert 'thermal speed convention: PASS' in physics_log
+    
+    # Verify performance monitoring
+    perf_metrics = get_latest_performance_metrics()
+    assert perf_metrics['total_duration'] < 30  # Performance target
+
+def test_research_workflow_integration():
+    """Test integration with research publication workflow."""
+    # Setup research branch
+    repo = create_research_repository()
+    
+    # Add research code with physics calculations
+    add_research_code(repo, 'alfven_wave_analysis.py')
+    
+    # Commit with publication validation
+    with environment_variable('HOOK_MODE', 'publication'):
+        result = repo.git.commit('-m', 'feat: add Alfvén wave analysis')
+    
+    # Verify enhanced validation for publication
+    validation_log = read_hook_log('publication_validation')
+    assert 'reproducibility: PASS' in validation_log
+    assert 'documentation: COMPLETE' in validation_log
+    assert 'examples: VALIDATED' in validation_log
+```
+
+## Performance Testing Strategy
+
+### Performance Benchmarking
+**Baseline Measurements**:
+- Current hook execution time (baseline)
+- Current test suite execution time (baseline)
+- Current physics validation time (baseline)
+- System resource usage (baseline)
+
+**Target Performance Metrics**:
+- Hook execution: <30 seconds (improvement from baseline)
+- Test time reduction: 60-80% (from intelligent selection)
+- Physics validation: <20% overhead (from enhancements)
+- Memory usage: <500MB peak (system constraint)
+
+### Load Testing
+**Test Scenarios**:
+- Large commit with many changed files
+- Concurrent hook executions
+- Heavy test suite with many physics tests
+- Long-running validation processes
+
+**Performance Test Examples**:
+```python
+def test_large_commit_performance():
+    """Test performance with large commits."""
+    # Create commit with 50+ changed files
+    large_commit = create_large_commit(num_files=50)
+    
+    start_time = time.time()
+    result = execute_hook_system(large_commit)
+    execution_time = time.time() - start_time
+    
+    # Should still meet performance target
+    assert execution_time < 30
+    assert result.success
+    
+    # Intelligent testing should still provide benefit
+    assert result.test_reduction > 0.6  # 60% minimum
+
+def test_concurrent_hook_execution():
+    """Test system handles concurrent executions."""
+    import concurrent.futures
+    
+    # Create multiple simultaneous commits
+    commits = [create_test_commit(f'change_{i}') for i in range(5)]
+    
+    with concurrent.futures.ThreadPoolExecutor(max_workers=5) as executor:
+        futures = [executor.submit(execute_hook_system, commit) 
+                  for commit in commits]
+        
+        results = [future.result() for future in futures]
+    
+    # All should succeed
+    assert all(result.success for result in results)
+    
+    # Performance should not degrade significantly
+    max_time = max(result.execution_time for result in results)
+    assert max_time < 45  # Some degradation acceptable under load
+```
+
+## Continuous Testing Strategy
+
+### Automated Testing Pipeline
+**Test Execution Triggers**:
+- Every code commit to hook system
+- Daily regression testing
+- Weekly performance benchmarking
+- Monthly comprehensive validation
+
+**Test Environment Matrix**:
+- **Operating Systems**: Linux, macOS, Windows
+- **Python Versions**: 3.9, 3.10, 3.11, 3.12
+- **Git Versions**: 2.30+, latest
+- **Dependency Versions**: Minimum supported, latest
+
+### Quality Gates
+**Automated Quality Checks**:
+- All unit tests pass (100%)
+- Integration tests pass (100%)
+- Code coverage ≥95%
+- Performance targets met
+- Physics validation accuracy maintained
+- No security vulnerabilities
+
+### Monitoring and Alerting
+**Test Result Monitoring**:
+- Real-time test execution status
+- Performance trend monitoring
+- Failure rate tracking
+- Coverage trend analysis
+
+**Alert Conditions**:
+- Any test failure in critical components
+- Performance degradation >10%
+- Coverage drop below 95%
+- Physics validation accuracy issues
+
+## Test Data Management
+
+### Test Data Strategy
+**Test Data Categories**:
+- **Synthetic Data**: Generated test cases for specific scenarios
+- **Reference Data**: Known-good physics datasets for validation
+- **Real Data**: Actual spacecraft data for realistic testing
+- **Edge Cases**: Boundary conditions and error scenarios
+
+### Data Security and Privacy
+**Data Handling Requirements**:
+- No sensitive mission data in test repositories
+- Anonymized datasets for realistic testing
+- Secure storage of test credentials
+- Regular cleanup of temporary test data
+
+## Documentation Testing
+
+### Documentation Validation
+**Testing Approach**:
+- All code examples must execute successfully
+- Installation instructions verified on clean environments
+- Configuration examples validated against schema
+- Troubleshooting guides tested with real issues
+
+### User Documentation Testing
+**Test Scenarios**:
+- New user following quick start guide
+- Experienced user using advanced features
+- Developer troubleshooting common issues
+- Administrator configuring system-wide deployment
+
+---
+*Testing Strategy - SolarWindPy Integrated Hook System Enhancement - Last Updated: 2025-01-19*
+*See [0-Overview.md](./0-Overview.md) for complete plan context and cross-phase coordination.*