@mytechtoday/augment-extensions 0.4.0 → 0.7.0

package/augment-extensions/writing-standards/screenplay/themes/rules/power.md

@@ -0,0 +1,494 @@
+# Power Theme
+
+**Category**: Screenplay Theme  
+**Type**: Universal Theme  
+**Complexity**: High
+
+## Overview
+
+The power theme explores the acquisition, use, abuse, and loss of power. It examines what people will do to gain power, how power changes those who wield it, and whether power can be used responsibly or inevitably corrupts.
+
+## Core Concept
+
+Power in storytelling represents control, influence, and authority over others or one's circumstances. It explores the seductive nature of power, the responsibility it demands, the corruption it can cause, and the fundamental question of whether power serves or destroys those who seek it.
+
+## Thematic Statement
+
+The theme of power explores what people will sacrifice to gain control, how power transforms those who wield it, and whether power can be used responsibly or inevitably corrupts.
+
+## Core Rules
+
+### Rule 1: Show Power's Seductive Appeal
+
+**Description**: Power must be genuinely attractive—offering security, control, respect, or the ability to shape the world. The audience must understand why characters seek it.
+
+**Why It Matters**: If power isn't appealing, the character's pursuit of it feels unmotivated. The temptation must be real.
+
+**Application**:
+- **Act I**: Establish what power offers (security, respect, control, ability to protect others)
+- **Act II**: Show power delivering on its promises while hinting at costs
+- **Act III**: Reveal the full cost of power and whether it was worth it
+
+**Examples**:
+- ✅ **Good**: In *The Godfather*, power offers Michael protection for his family and respect, making his descent understandable
+- ❌ **Bad**: Power is presented as purely negative with no appealing aspects, making pursuit of it seem irrational
+
+---
+
+### Rule 2: Demonstrate Power's Transformative Effect
+
+**Description**: Power must change the character who wields it. They cannot remain the same person after gaining significant power.
+
+**Why It Matters**: "Power corrupts" is the central insight of power themes. Characters must transform, usually for the worse.
+
+**Application**:
+- **Act I**: Establish the character's original values and personality
+- **Act II**: Show gradual transformation as power increases
+- **Act III**: Demonstrate how different they've become
+
+**Examples**:
+- ✅ **Good**: Michael Corleone transforms from war hero who wants nothing to do with the family business to ruthless godfather
+- ❌ **Bad**: The character gains immense power but remains fundamentally unchanged
+
+---
+
+### Rule 3: Create Moral Costs and Compromises
+
+**Description**: Power requires moral compromise. Characters must sacrifice values, relationships, or their humanity to gain or maintain power.
+
+**Why It Matters**: Power without cost feels unearned. The compromises demonstrate what power demands.
+
+**Application**:
+- **Act I**: Establish the character's moral lines they won't cross
+- **Act II**: Force them to cross those lines to gain or keep power
+- **Act III**: Show the cumulative cost of all compromises
+
+**Examples**:
+- ✅ **Good**: In *There Will Be Blood*, Daniel Plainview sacrifices every relationship and his humanity for wealth and power
+- ❌ **Bad**: The character gains power without moral compromise or sacrifice
+
+---
+
+### Rule 4: Explore Power's Isolation
+
+**Description**: Power separates people from authentic human connection. The more powerful the character becomes, the more isolated they are.
+
+**Why It Matters**: This explores the paradox of power—it promises control but delivers loneliness.
+
+**Application**:
+- **Act I**: Show the character's relationships and connections
+- **Act II**: Demonstrate power eroding these connections
+- **Act III**: Show the character isolated at the height of their power
+
+**Examples**:
+- ✅ **Good**: In *Citizen Kane*, Kane's pursuit of power leaves him alone in Xanadu, dying with only "Rosebud"
+- ❌ **Bad**: The character gains power and maintains all their relationships without tension
+
+---
+
+### Rule 5: Question Whether Power Can Be Used Responsibly
+
+**Description**: The story should explore whether power can be wielded for good or whether it inevitably corrupts. This is the central moral question.
+
+**Why It Matters**: This question creates dramatic tension and thematic depth.
+
+**Application**:
+- **Act I**: Establish the character's intentions for power (good or selfish)
+- **Act II**: Test whether they can maintain good intentions as power increases
+- **Act III**: Answer whether responsible power is possible or if corruption is inevitable
+
+**Examples**:
+- ✅ **Good**: In *The Lord of the Rings*, the Ring represents power that corrupts anyone who uses it, even with good intentions
+- ❌ **Bad**: Power is either purely good or purely evil without exploring the complexity
+
+---
+
+### Rule 6: Show Power's Fragility
+
+**Description**: Power is never secure. Those who have it fear losing it, and this fear drives increasingly desperate actions.
+
+**Why It Matters**: The fragility of power creates tension and explains escalating behavior.
+
+**Application**:
+- **Act I**: Show how power can be lost or challenged
+- **Act II**: Create threats to the character's power that drive desperate actions
+- **Act III**: Often end with power lost or maintained at terrible cost
+
+**Examples**:
+- ✅ **Good**: In *Macbeth*, Macbeth's paranoia about losing power drives him to increasingly murderous actions
+- ❌ **Bad**: Power once gained is completely secure with no threat of loss
+
+---
+
+### Rule 7: Differentiate Types of Power
+
+**Description**: Power comes in many forms—political, physical, economic, social, knowledge. Each type has different dynamics and costs.
+
+**Why It Matters**: Different types of power create different stories and moral questions.
+
+**Application**:
+- **Act I**: Establish what type of power is being pursued
+- **Act II**: Explore the specific dynamics and costs of that power type
+- **Act III**: Resolve the power story in ways specific to that type
+
+**Examples**:
+- ✅ **Good**: *The Social Network* explores social/economic power through technology, different from political power in *House of Cards*
+- ❌ **Bad**: All power is treated identically regardless of type
+
+---
+
+### Rule 8: Show Power's Effect on Others
+
+**Description**: Power doesn't just affect the wielder—it impacts everyone around them. Show how power changes relationships and harms others.
+
+**Why It Matters**: This explores the broader consequences of power beyond the individual.
+
+**Application**:
+- **Act I**: Establish relationships before power
+- **Act II**: Show how power changes these relationships
+- **Act III**: Demonstrate the full impact on others
+
+**Examples**:
+- ✅ **Good**: In *The Godfather*, Michael's power destroys his marriage and alienates his family
+- ❌ **Bad**: Power only affects the person who wields it, not those around them
+
+---
+
+## Integration Guidelines
+
+### Act I: Setup
+
+**Thematic Introduction**:
+- Establish the character's current powerless or limited-power state
+- Show what they lack (security, respect, control, protection)
+- Introduce the possibility of gaining power
+- Establish what they believe power will give them
+
+**Character Connection**:
+- Demonstrate the character's initial relationship with power
+- Show their values and moral lines before power
+- Establish what they're willing to do (or not do) for power
+- Reveal their motivations for seeking power
+
+**Visual/Symbolic Introduction**:
+- Use visual motifs representing power (thrones, weapons, money, symbols of authority)
+- Establish symbolic objects that represent power
+- Create visual language for powerlessness vs. power
+
+### Act II: Development
+
+**Thematic Exploration**:
+- Show the character gaining power incrementally
+- Demonstrate power delivering on its promises
+- Reveal the costs and compromises power demands
+- Show the character changing as power increases
+
+**Subtext Techniques**:
+- Use dialogue about control, respect, and authority
+- Show behavioral changes as power corrupts
+- Create visual progression showing transformation
+- Use other characters' reactions to show power's effect
+
+**Thematic Complications**:
+- Power requires moral compromises
+- Relationships are damaged or destroyed
+- The character becomes isolated
+- Threats to power create paranoia and desperate actions
+
+### Act III: Resolution
+
+**Thematic Payoff**:
+- Show the character at peak power or losing power
+- Demonstrate the full cost of power
+- Answer whether power was worth it
+- Reveal whether the character is destroyed or transformed by power
+
+**Avoiding Preachiness**:
+- Let consequences demonstrate theme rather than speeches
+- Avoid characters explicitly stating "power corrupts"
+- Show complexity—power can be both seductive and destructive
+- Allow for ambiguity in whether power was worth pursuing
+
+## Character Connection
+
+### Protagonist
+
+**Thematic Relationship**: The protagonist's journey is defined by their relationship with power—seeking it, wielding it, being corrupted by it, or resisting it.
+
+**Arc Integration**: The character arc should reflect the transformation power causes.
+
+**Key Moments**:
+- **Thematic Introduction**: The moment they first taste power or decide to pursue it
+- **Thematic Challenge**: The moment they must compromise their values for power
+- **Thematic Resolution**: The moment they achieve, lose, or reject power
+
+### Antagonist
+
+**Thematic Opposition**: The antagonist often represents either the power the protagonist seeks or the corrupting influence of power already achieved.
+
+**Thematic Function**: The antagonist shows what the protagonist could become if power fully corrupts them.
+
+### Supporting Characters
+
+**Thematic Mirrors**: Supporting characters represent different relationships with power:
+- The character corrupted by power (cautionary tale)
+- The character who rejects power for values
+- The character who uses power responsibly (if possible)
+- The victim of the protagonist's power
+
+**Thematic Perspectives**: Different characters embody different beliefs about power—whether it corrupts, whether it's necessary, what it costs.
+
+## Subtext Techniques
+
+### Dialogue
+
+- Characters discuss control, respect, and authority without explicitly mentioning "power"
+- Use metaphors of strength, weakness, control
+- Create conversations where characters justify their pursuit of power
+- Include moments where others question the cost of power
+
+### Visual Storytelling
+
+- **Visual motifs**: Thrones, high places, symbols of authority, weapons
+- **Color palette**: Often darker tones as power increases
+- **Symbolic imagery**: Crowns, rings, money, weapons representing power
+- **Physical positioning**: Powerful characters positioned above others, in center of frame
+
+### Action and Behavior
+
+- Show increasing control over others
+- Demonstrate isolation from authentic connection
+- Create moments where power is exercised ruthlessly
+- Show physical changes (posture, confidence, coldness)
+
+## Film Examples
+
+### Example 1: The Godfather (1972)
+
+**Director**: Francis Ford Coppola
+
+**Thematic Exploration**: Explores how power corrupts even those who initially reject it, examining the cost of power to family, morality, and soul.
+
+**Key Thematic Moments**:
+- **Michael's introduction**: "That's my family, Kay. That's not me" - rejection of power
+- **Hospital scene**: First taste of power and control
+- **Killing Sollozzo**: Crossing the moral line, entering the power game
+- **Becoming Godfather**: Achieving ultimate power
+- **Baptism sequence**: Consolidating power through murder while claiming spiritual purity
+- **Final door closing**: Complete isolation and transformation
+
+**Thematic Resolution**: Power completely corrupts Michael, transforming him from war hero to ruthless godfather, destroying his marriage and soul.
+
+**Techniques Used**:
+- Visual transformation (appearance, demeanor)
+- Contrast between Michael's stated intentions and actions
+- Symbolic use of doors closing (isolation)
+- Parallel editing (baptism and murders)
+- Progressive moral compromises
+
+---
+
+### Example 2: There Will Be Blood (2007)
+
+**Director**: Paul Thomas Anderson
+
+**Thematic Exploration**: Explores power through capitalism and ambition, examining how the pursuit of wealth and control destroys humanity and relationships.
+
+**Key Thematic Moments**:
+- **Opening sequence**: Wordless demonstration of brutal ambition
+- **"I have a competition in me"**: Explicit statement of power drive
+- **Adopting H.W.**: Using son as tool for power
+- **"I drink your milkshake"**: Power as zero-sum game
+- **H.W.'s deafness**: Power literally destroying family
+- **Final scene**: Isolated in mansion, having destroyed everyone
+
+**Thematic Resolution**: Power brings wealth and control but complete isolation and destruction of all relationships.
+
+**Techniques Used**:
+- Minimal dialogue emphasizing action
+- Visual isolation (wide shots of lone figure)
+- Sound design (oil derrick noise, silence)
+- Physical transformation (Daniel's deterioration)
+- Symbolic use of oil as corrupting power
+
+---
+
+### Example 3: The Lord of the Rings Trilogy (2001-2003)
+
+**Director**: Peter Jackson
+
+**Thematic Exploration**: Explores whether power can be used responsibly or inevitably corrupts, with the Ring representing absolute power that corrupts absolutely.
+
+**Key Thematic Moments**:
+- **"One Ring to rule them all"**: Power's seductive promise
+- **Boromir's temptation**: Good man corrupted by power's promise
+- **Gollum's transformation**: What power does over time
+- **Frodo's increasing burden**: Power's corrupting weight
+- **"I can't do this, Sam"**: Power nearly destroying Frodo
+- **Destroying the Ring**: Only way to defeat power is to destroy it
+
+**Thematic Resolution**: Power cannot be used responsibly—it must be destroyed. Even the best intentions cannot resist its corruption.
+
+**Techniques Used**:
+- Physical object (Ring) representing power
+- Visual corruption (Gollum's transformation)
+- Multiple characters tempted showing universal corruption
+- Frodo's physical deterioration under power's weight
+- Destruction as only solution
+
+---
+
+### Example 4: Citizen Kane (1941)
+
+**Director**: Orson Welles
+
+**Thematic Exploration**: Explores how wealth and power isolate and ultimately destroy, examining whether power can bring happiness or only loneliness.
+
+**Key Thematic Moments**:
+- **"Rosebud"**: Mystery representing what power cost him
+- **Building Xanadu**: Power creating isolation
+- **Destroying Susan's room**: Power unable to control love
+- **Death alone**: Ultimate isolation despite ultimate power
+- **Rosebud revealed**: Power cost him simple childhood happiness
+
+**Thematic Resolution**: Power brings everything except what matters—connection, love, happiness. Kane dies alone despite immense wealth and power.
+
+**Techniques Used**:
+- Non-linear structure revealing power's cost
+- Visual symbolism (Xanadu as gilded cage)
+- Deep focus cinematography showing isolation in vast spaces
+- "Rosebud" as symbol of lost innocence
+- Contrast between public power and private emptiness
+
+---
+
+### Example 5: The Social Network (2010)
+
+**Director**: David Fincher
+
+**Thematic Exploration**: Explores power in the digital age, examining how the pursuit of social and economic power destroys friendships and creates isolation.
+
+**Key Thematic Moments**:
+- **Opening breakup**: Powerlessness driving ambition
+- **Creating Facebook**: Power through technology
+- **Betraying Eduardo**: Friendship sacrificed for power
+- **"A million dollars isn't cool"**: Power's escalating demands
+- **Final scene**: Alone, refreshing page, waiting for friend request
+
+**Thematic Resolution**: Zuckerberg achieves immense power and wealth but loses all authentic relationships, ending alone.
+
+**Techniques Used**:
+- Fast-paced dialogue showing ambition
+- Visual isolation (Zuckerberg alone in frame)
+- Framing device (depositions) showing consequences
+- Contrast between social network and personal isolation
+- Final image of loneliness despite connection platform
+
+---
+
+## Integration with Other Features
+
+### Compatible Genres
+
+- **Drama**: Deep exploration of power's psychological effects
+- **Thriller**: Power struggles create suspense
+- **Crime**: Power within criminal organizations
+- **Political**: Institutional power and corruption
+- **Fantasy/Sci-Fi**: Magical or technological power
+- **Historical**: Power in historical contexts
+
+### Compatible Themes (Multi-Theme Stories)
+
+- **Corruption**: Power often leads to moral corruption
+- **Ambition**: Power is often the goal of ambition
+- **Betrayal**: Power often requires betraying others
+- **Isolation**: Power isolates those who wield it
+- **Responsibility**: Can power be used responsibly?
+- **Justice**: Power vs. justice
+
+### Compatible Styles
+
+- **Character-Driven**: Explores psychological transformation
+- **Epic**: Large-scale power struggles
+- **Minimalist**: Intimate focus on power's personal cost
+- **Ensemble**: Multiple characters pursuing or wielding power
+
+## Common Pitfalls
+
+### Pitfall 1: Power Without Appeal
+
+**Problem**: Power is presented as purely negative, making pursuit of it seem irrational.
+
+**Solution**: Show power's genuine appeal—what it offers and delivers.
+
+**Example**: Demonstrate how power provides security, respect, or ability to protect others.
+
+---
+
+### Pitfall 2: Power Without Cost
+
+**Problem**: Character gains power without moral compromise or sacrifice.
+
+**Solution**: Make power require crossing moral lines and sacrificing relationships.
+
+**Example**: Force the character to betray friends, abandon values, or harm innocents for power.
+
+---
+
+### Pitfall 3: Power Without Transformation
+
+**Problem**: Character wields power but remains fundamentally unchanged.
+
+**Solution**: Show how power corrupts and transforms the character.
+
+**Example**: Demonstrate the character becoming colder, more ruthless, more isolated.
+
+---
+
+### Pitfall 4: Secure Power
+
+**Problem**: Power once gained is completely secure with no threat of loss.
+
+**Solution**: Show power's fragility and the paranoia it creates.
+
+**Example**: Create threats to power that drive increasingly desperate actions.
+
+---
+
+### Pitfall 5: Power in Vacuum
+
+**Problem**: Power only affects the wielder, not those around them.
+
+**Solution**: Show how power impacts relationships and harms others.
+
+**Example**: Demonstrate power destroying marriages, friendships, and innocent lives.
+
+---
+
+## Best Practices
+
+1. **Make power appealing** - Show what it offers and why characters seek it
+2. **Demonstrate transformation** - Power must change those who wield it
+3. **Require moral costs** - Power demands compromise and sacrifice
+4. **Show isolation** - Power separates from authentic connection
+5. **Question responsibility** - Can power be used for good or does it corrupt?
+6. **Emphasize fragility** - Power is never secure
+7. **Differentiate types** - Political, physical, economic power have different dynamics
+8. **Show effect on others** - Power impacts everyone, not just the wielder
+9. **Use visual storytelling** - Show power through imagery and symbolism
+10. **Avoid preachiness** - Let consequences demonstrate theme
+
+## Resources
+
+- *The Prince* by Niccolò Machiavelli - Classic text on power
+- *The Anatomy of Story* by John Truby - Power and moral argument
+- *Story* by Robert McKee - Power dynamics in narrative
+- *The Hero with a Thousand Faces* by Joseph Campbell - Power in mythic journey
+- *Into the Woods* by John Yorke - Power and story structure
+
+---
+
+**Depth Coverage**: 85%
+**Last Updated**: 2026-01-31
+**Version**: 1.0.0
+