@mytechtoday/augment-extensions 0.4.0 → 0.7.0

package/augment-extensions/writing-standards/screenplay/themes/rules/identity.md

@@ -0,0 +1,490 @@
+# Identity Theme
+
+**Category**: Screenplay Theme  
+**Type**: Universal Theme  
+**Complexity**: High
+
+## Overview
+
+The identity theme explores who we are, who we think we are, and who we're meant to be. It examines the journey of self-discovery, the conflict between imposed and authentic identity, and the question of whether identity is fixed or fluid.
+
+## Core Concept
+
+Identity in storytelling represents the fundamental human quest to understand ourselves. It explores the masks we wear, the roles society assigns us, the conflict between who we are and who we want to be, and the transformative journey of discovering or creating our authentic self.
+
+## Thematic Statement
+
+The theme of identity explores who we truly are beneath social roles and expectations, examining whether identity is discovered or created, and what it costs to live authentically.
+
+## Core Rules
+
+### Rule 1: Establish the False or Incomplete Identity
+
+**Description**: The protagonist must begin with a false, imposed, or incomplete sense of self. They believe they know who they are, but this understanding is flawed or limiting.
+
+**Why It Matters**: Identity discovery has no meaning if the character already knows themselves. The journey requires starting from a place of misunderstanding or incompleteness.
+
+**Application**:
+- **Act I**: Show the character living according to an imposed identity (family expectations, social role, false belief about themselves)
+- **Act II**: Create situations that challenge this identity and reveal its inadequacy
+- **Act III**: Demonstrate the character's authentic identity emerging or being consciously created
+
+**Examples**:
+- ✅ **Good**: In *The Matrix*, Neo believes he's Thomas Anderson, an ordinary programmer, before discovering his true identity as The One
+- ❌ **Bad**: A character already knows exactly who they are and never questions or discovers anything new about themselves
+
+---
+
+### Rule 2: Create Identity Conflict
+
+**Description**: The character must face conflict between different aspects of their identity—who they were, who they are, who they're expected to be, and who they want to become.
+
+**Why It Matters**: Identity conflict creates internal drama and forces characters to make meaningful choices about who they will be.
+
+**Application**:
+- **Act I**: Establish multiple competing identities or expectations
+- **Act II**: Force the character to choose between these competing identities
+- **Act III**: Resolve the conflict by integrating, choosing, or transcending these identities
+
+**Examples**:
+- ✅ **Good**: In *Spider-Man 2*, Peter Parker struggles between his identity as Peter (student, friend, lover) and Spider-Man (hero, protector)
+- ❌ **Bad**: The character has only one identity with no internal conflict or competing expectations
+
+---
+
+### Rule 3: Use External Challenges to Reveal Internal Truth
+
+**Description**: External plot events should force the character to confront questions about their identity. Action reveals character.
+
+**Why It Matters**: Identity isn't discovered through introspection alone—it's revealed through choices and actions under pressure.
+
+**Application**:
+- **Act I**: Establish the character's assumed identity through their normal behavior
+- **Act II**: Create situations that force choices revealing their true nature
+- **Act III**: Present ultimate test that proves who they really are
+
+**Examples**:
+- ✅ **Good**: In *The Bourne Identity*, Jason Bourne discovers who he is through his actions and skills, not just recovered memories
+- ❌ **Bad**: The character simply thinks about who they are without their identity being tested through action
+
+---
+
+### Rule 4: Explore the Cost of Authenticity
+
+**Description**: Living authentically requires sacrifice—of comfort, acceptance, safety, or relationships. The character must choose between authentic identity and easier alternatives.
+
+**Why It Matters**: Identity without cost feels cheap. The sacrifice demonstrates the value of authentic self.
+
+**Application**:
+- **Act I**: Establish what the character would lose by being authentic (family approval, social status, safety)
+- **Act II**: Force choices between authenticity and comfort
+- **Act III**: Require ultimate sacrifice to live as authentic self
+
+**Examples**:
+- ✅ **Good**: In *Mulan*, the protagonist must risk death and dishonor to live authentically as both woman and warrior
+- ❌ **Bad**: The character discovers their true self and everyone immediately accepts it with no consequences
+
+---
+
+### Rule 5: Show Identity as Journey, Not Destination
+
+**Description**: Identity isn't a fixed state to be discovered—it's an ongoing process of becoming. The character's identity at the end should feel like a beginning, not a conclusion.
+
+**Why It Matters**: Treating identity as a simple answer reduces complexity. Identity is fluid and evolving.
+
+**Application**:
+- **Act I**: Show the character's current understanding of themselves
+- **Act II**: Demonstrate identity shifting and evolving through experience
+- **Act III**: End with new understanding that opens future possibilities rather than closing them
+
+**Examples**:
+- ✅ **Good**: In *Moonlight*, Chiron's identity evolves through three distinct phases, with the ending suggesting ongoing evolution
+- ❌ **Bad**: The character discovers "the answer" to who they are and their identity is now fixed forever
+
+---
+
+### Rule 6: Differentiate Between Social and Authentic Identity
+
+**Description**: Explore the gap between the identity society assigns (or the character performs) and their authentic self. The tension between these creates drama.
+
+**Why It Matters**: Most identity struggles involve the conflict between social expectations and authentic self.
+
+**Application**:
+- **Act I**: Establish the social identity the character performs
+- **Act II**: Reveal the authentic self that conflicts with this performance
+- **Act III**: Resolve whether the character can integrate these or must choose
+
+**Examples**:
+- ✅ **Good**: In *Birdman*, Riggan Thomson struggles between his identity as a serious actor and his public identity as Birdman
+- ❌ **Bad**: The character's social and authentic identities are identical with no tension
+
+---
+
+### Rule 7: Make Identity Specific, Not Generic
+
+**Description**: Identity questions must be specific to the character—not just "who am I?" but "am I a good father?" or "am I defined by my trauma?" or "can I be both warrior and woman?"
+
+**Why It Matters**: Generic identity questions lack dramatic focus. Specific questions create clear dramatic goals.
+
+**Application**:
+- **Act I**: Establish specific identity questions unique to this character
+- **Act II**: Explore these specific questions through action and choice
+- **Act III**: Answer the specific questions, not just vague self-discovery
+
+**Examples**:
+- ✅ **Good**: In *The Wrestler*, Randy asks "Am I only valuable as a wrestler?" not just "who am I?"
+- ❌ **Bad**: The character vaguely wonders "who am I?" without specific identity questions
+
+---
+
+### Rule 8: Consider Multiple Identity Dimensions
+
+**Description**: Identity isn't singular—it includes cultural, gender, professional, familial, and personal dimensions. Explore how these intersect and sometimes conflict.
+
+**Why It Matters**: Real identity is multifaceted. Exploring multiple dimensions creates richer, more authentic stories.
+
+**Application**:
+- **Act I**: Establish multiple dimensions of the character's identity
+- **Act II**: Show how these dimensions conflict or support each other
+- **Act III**: Demonstrate integration or prioritization of identity dimensions
+
+**Examples**:
+- ✅ **Good**: In *Moonlight*, Chiron's identity encompasses race, sexuality, masculinity, and personal trauma
+- ❌ **Bad**: Identity is treated as one-dimensional (just their job, just their relationship, etc.)
+
+---
+
+## Integration Guidelines
+
+### Act I: Setup
+
+**Thematic Introduction**:
+- Introduce the character living according to their assumed or imposed identity
+- Show the masks they wear and roles they perform
+- Establish the gap between who they appear to be and hints of who they really are
+- Plant seeds of identity questions or conflicts
+
+**Character Connection**:
+- Demonstrate the character's current self-understanding
+- Show how they define themselves (by job, relationships, past, etc.)
+- Establish what they believe about their nature and capabilities
+- Reveal discomfort or questions about their identity
+
+**Visual/Symbolic Introduction**:
+- Use visual motifs representing identity (mirrors, masks, photographs, names)
+- Establish symbolic objects that represent different identities
+- Create visual language for authentic vs. performed self
+
+### Act II: Development
+
+**Thematic Exploration**:
+- Challenge the character's assumed identity through events and relationships
+- Force choices that reveal their true nature
+- Show the character trying on different identities or roles
+- Create crisis points where identity questions become urgent
+
+**Subtext Techniques**:
+- Use dialogue where characters discuss who they are indirectly
+- Show behavioral changes as identity shifts
+- Create visual progression showing transformation
+- Use other characters as mirrors reflecting different aspects of identity
+
+**Thematic Complications**:
+- The character's assumed identity fails them in crucial moments
+- Others challenge or reject the character's self-definition
+- The character discovers uncomfortable truths about themselves
+- Multiple identity dimensions come into conflict
+
+### Act III: Resolution
+
+**Thematic Payoff**:
+- Present ultimate test that reveals or proves authentic identity
+- Require choice between competing identities or integration of them
+- Show the character living authentically despite cost
+- Demonstrate new self-understanding that opens future possibilities
+
+**Avoiding Preachiness**:
+- Let actions demonstrate identity rather than speeches about it
+- Avoid characters explicitly stating "now I know who I am"
+- Make identity discovery feel earned through struggle and choice
+- Allow for complexity—identity isn't fully resolved
+
+## Character Connection
+
+### Protagonist
+
+**Thematic Relationship**: The protagonist's journey IS the identity journey. Every choice, every action, every relationship reveals or shapes who they are.
+
+**Arc Integration**: The character arc should move from false/incomplete identity to authentic/integrated identity.
+
+**Key Moments**:
+- **Thematic Introduction**: The moment we see the gap between performed and authentic self
+- **Thematic Challenge**: The crisis where their assumed identity fails them
+- **Thematic Resolution**: The moment they choose or embrace their authentic identity
+
+### Antagonist
+
+**Thematic Opposition**: The antagonist often represents the forces that impose false identity—society, family, the character's own fear, or an alternative identity path.
+
+**Thematic Function**: The antagonist tests whether the protagonist will accept imposed identity or fight for authentic self.
+
+### Supporting Characters
+
+**Thematic Mirrors**: Supporting characters represent different approaches to identity:
+- The character who lives authentically despite cost
+- The character who accepts imposed identity for comfort
+- The character who shows what the protagonist could become
+- The mentor who helps the protagonist discover themselves
+
+**Thematic Perspectives**: Different characters embody different beliefs about identity—whether it's fixed or fluid, discovered or created, individual or social.
+
+## Subtext Techniques
+
+### Dialogue
+
+- Characters discuss identity indirectly through metaphor and subtext
+- Use questions like "who are you?" or "what do you want?" to probe identity
+- Create conversations where characters define themselves and others
+- Include moments where characters are called by different names representing different identities
+
+### Visual Storytelling
+
+- **Visual motifs**: Mirrors, reflections, photographs, masks, costumes
+- **Color palette**: Different colors for different identity states
+- **Symbolic imagery**: Objects representing different identities (uniforms, heirlooms, etc.)
+- **Physical transformation**: Appearance changes reflecting identity shifts
+
+### Action and Behavior
+
+- Show the character behaving differently in different contexts
+- Demonstrate moments where authentic self breaks through performed identity
+- Create situations where the character must choose which identity to embody
+- Show physical changes (posture, voice, mannerisms) with identity shifts
+
+## Film Examples
+
+### Example 1: The Matrix (1999)
+
+**Director**: The Wachowskis
+
+**Thematic Exploration**: Explores identity as both discovery (Neo is The One) and choice (choosing the red pill, choosing to believe), questioning whether identity is predetermined or self-created.
+
+**Key Thematic Moments**:
+- **"You're living two lives"**: Establishes Neo's dual identity as Thomas Anderson and hacker
+- **The red pill**: Choice that begins identity transformation
+- **"There is no spoon"**: Realization that identity and reality are malleable
+- **Death and resurrection**: Ultimate transformation into The One
+- **"My name is Neo"**: Claiming authentic identity
+
+**Thematic Resolution**: Identity is both discovered (Neo was always The One) and chosen (he had to believe and choose to become it).
+
+**Techniques Used**:
+- Dual names representing dual identities
+- Visual transformation (appearance, abilities)
+- Mentor figures helping identity discovery
+- Physical world vs. Matrix as metaphor for false vs. authentic identity
+- Resurrection as ultimate identity transformation
+
+---
+
+### Example 2: Moonlight (2016)
+
+**Director**: Barry Jenkins
+
+**Thematic Exploration**: Explores identity formation across three life stages, examining how race, sexuality, masculinity, and trauma shape who we become.
+
+**Key Thematic Moments**:
+- **"Little"**: Chiron's childhood identity shaped by vulnerability and Juan's mentorship
+- **"Who is you?"**: Central question of identity posed throughout
+- **The beach scene**: First expression of authentic sexual identity
+- **"Faggot"**: Violent rejection of identity leading to transformation
+- **"Black"**: Adult Chiron performing hypermasculine identity
+- **Final scene with Kevin**: Return to authentic self
+
+**Thematic Resolution**: Identity is fluid and multifaceted. Chiron integrates his past selves rather than rejecting them.
+
+**Techniques Used**:
+- Three-act structure with different names for each identity phase
+- Visual consistency (blue lighting) connecting all three identities
+- Minimal dialogue emphasizing action and behavior
+- Physical transformation showing identity performance
+- Circular structure (returning to Kevin) suggesting integration
+
+---
+
+### Example 3: The Bourne Identity (2002)
+
+**Director**: Doug Liman
+
+**Thematic Exploration**: Explores whether identity is defined by past actions or present choices, asking if we can escape who we were and become someone new.
+
+**Key Thematic Moments**:
+- **Waking with amnesia**: Complete loss of identity
+- **Discovering skills**: Identity revealed through action, not memory
+- **"I don't know who I am"**: Central identity crisis
+- **Discovering past as assassin**: Confronting uncomfortable truth about former self
+- **Choosing not to kill**: Defining new identity through different choices
+
+**Thematic Resolution**: Identity is defined by choices, not past. Jason Bourne chooses to be different from who he was.
+
+**Techniques Used**:
+- Amnesia as literal blank slate for identity exploration
+- Skills and instincts revealing past identity
+- Contrast between past actions (assassin) and present choices (protector)
+- Name as symbol (Jason Bourne vs. real name)
+- Action sequences revealing character through choices
+
+---
+
+### Example 4: Mulan (1998)
+
+**Director**: Tony Bancroft, Barry Cook
+
+**Thematic Exploration**: Explores gender identity, cultural expectations, and authentic self, asking whether we must choose between different aspects of identity or can integrate them.
+
+**Key Thematic Moments**:
+- **"Reflection"**: Song explicitly about identity and the gap between true self and social expectations
+- **Cutting hair**: Physical transformation representing identity shift
+- **Training montage**: Becoming competent in male identity
+- **"You don't belong here"**: Rejection of both identities (not proper woman, not real man)
+- **Final battle**: Integration of feminine and masculine strengths
+
+**Thematic Resolution**: Authentic identity integrates multiple dimensions. Mulan doesn't have to choose between being a woman and being a warrior.
+
+**Techniques Used**:
+- Visual transformation (appearance, clothing)
+- Dual names (Mulan vs. Ping)
+- Songs expressing internal identity struggle
+- Contrast between family expectations and authentic self
+- Integration rather than choice as resolution
+
+---
+
+### Example 5: Birdman (2014)
+
+**Director**: Alejandro González Iñárritu
+
+**Thematic Exploration**: Explores identity defined by past success, public perception vs. private self, and the question of whether we can escape who we were.
+
+**Key Thematic Moments**:
+- **Birdman voice**: Past identity haunting present
+- **The play**: Attempt to create new identity as serious artist
+- **Viral video**: Public identity beyond his control
+- **Flying fantasy**: Desire to reclaim past identity's power
+- **Final scene**: Ambiguous transcendence or delusion
+
+**Thematic Resolution**: Ambiguous—either Riggan transcends his identity crisis or is consumed by delusion. Identity remains unresolved.
+
+**Techniques Used**:
+- Continuous shot creating claustrophobic identity crisis
+- Birdman costume as symbol of past identity
+- Magical realism blurring reality and identity fantasy
+- Public vs. private spaces representing different identities
+- Ambiguous ending refusing simple resolution
+
+---
+
+## Integration with Other Features
+
+### Compatible Genres
+
+- **Drama**: Natural fit for deep identity exploration
+- **Science Fiction**: Can explore identity through clones, AI, memory manipulation
+- **Coming-of-Age**: Identity formation is central to the genre
+- **Thriller**: Identity can be literal mystery (amnesia, imposters)
+- **Fantasy**: Chosen one narratives often involve identity discovery
+
+### Compatible Themes (Multi-Theme Stories)
+
+- **Growth**: Identity discovery is a form of growth
+- **Belonging**: Identity often involves finding where/who you belong with
+- **Freedom**: Authentic identity often requires freedom from imposed roles
+- **Power**: Identity can involve claiming or rejecting power
+- **Love**: Relationships often catalyze identity discovery
+
+### Compatible Styles
+
+- **Character-Driven**: Focuses on internal identity journey
+- **Non-Linear**: Can show identity across different time periods
+- **Ensemble**: Multiple characters exploring different identity questions
+- **Minimalist**: Strips away everything but essential identity questions
+
+## Common Pitfalls
+
+### Pitfall 1: Identity Discovery Through Exposition
+
+**Problem**: Characters discover who they are through being told, not through action and choice.
+
+**Solution**: Reveal identity through behavior, choices, and actions under pressure.
+
+**Example**: Instead of someone telling the character "you're brave," show them making brave choices.
+
+---
+
+### Pitfall 2: Simple, One-Dimensional Identity
+
+**Problem**: Identity is treated as singular (just their job, just their trauma, etc.) rather than multifaceted.
+
+**Solution**: Explore multiple dimensions of identity and how they intersect.
+
+**Example**: Show how the character's cultural, professional, familial, and personal identities interact and sometimes conflict.
+
+---
+
+### Pitfall 3: Identity as Fixed Destination
+
+**Problem**: The character discovers "the answer" to who they are and their identity is now permanently fixed.
+
+**Solution**: Treat identity as ongoing journey, with the ending opening new possibilities.
+
+**Example**: End with new understanding that suggests continued evolution rather than final answer.
+
+---
+
+### Pitfall 4: No Cost to Authenticity
+
+**Problem**: The character lives authentically and everyone immediately accepts it with no consequences.
+
+**Solution**: Make authentic identity costly—require sacrifice of comfort, acceptance, or safety.
+
+**Example**: Show the character losing relationships, status, or security by choosing authentic self.
+
+---
+
+### Pitfall 5: Generic Identity Questions
+
+**Problem**: The character asks vague "who am I?" without specific identity questions.
+
+**Solution**: Make identity questions specific to this character's circumstances and conflicts.
+
+**Example**: Instead of "who am I?", ask "can I be both a good mother and pursue my career?" or "am I defined by my trauma?"
+
+---
+
+## Best Practices
+
+1. **Start with false/incomplete identity** - The character must begin with misunderstanding
+2. **Create identity conflict** - Multiple competing identities or expectations
+3. **Reveal through action** - Identity discovered through choices, not introspection alone
+4. **Make authenticity costly** - Require sacrifice to live as authentic self
+5. **Treat as journey** - Identity is ongoing process, not fixed destination
+6. **Differentiate social and authentic** - Explore gap between performed and true self
+7. **Be specific** - Particular identity questions, not generic "who am I?"
+8. **Explore multiple dimensions** - Cultural, gender, professional, familial, personal
+9. **Use visual storytelling** - Mirrors, masks, transformations showing identity shifts
+10. **Avoid simple answers** - Identity is complex and evolving
+
+## Resources
+
+- *The Hero with a Thousand Faces* by Joseph Campbell - Identity through mythic journey
+- *The Anatomy of Story* by John Truby - Character identity and moral argument
+- *Story* by Robert McKee - Character dimension and identity
+- *The Writer's Journey* by Christopher Vogler - Identity transformation through hero's journey
+- *Into the Woods* by John Yorke - Identity and the five-act structure
+
+---
+
+**Depth Coverage**: 85%
+**Last Updated**: 2026-01-31
+**Version**: 1.0.0
+