sm-transcript 0.0.4 → 0.0.6

Sign up to get free protection for your applications and to get access to all the features.
Files changed (48) hide show
  1. data/README.txt +138 -118
  2. data/Rakefile +21 -10
  3. data/bin/sm-transcript +0 -0
  4. data/lib/sm_transcript/metadata.rb +25 -0
  5. data/lib/sm_transcript/options.rb +9 -3
  6. data/lib/sm_transcript/runner.rb +6 -0
  7. data/lib/sm_transcript/seg_reader.rb +1 -1
  8. data/lib/sm_transcript/transcript.rb +86 -39
  9. data/lib/sm_transcript/ttml_reader.rb +116 -0
  10. data/lib/sm_transcript/word.rb +6 -4
  11. data/lib/sm_transcript/wrd_reader.rb +5 -4
  12. data/test/results/18.03-2004-L01.align2.wrd +6441 -0
  13. data/test/results/8.01-1999-L01.wrd +5182 -0
  14. data/test/results/801-1stLecture.ttml.xml +757 -0
  15. data/test/results/801-lect01-4730.xml +757 -0
  16. data/test/results/801-lect02-4731.xml +886 -0
  17. data/test/results/801-lect03-4732.xml +818 -0
  18. data/test/results/801-lect04-4733.xml +831 -0
  19. data/test/results/801-lect05-4734.xml +879 -0
  20. data/test/results/801-lect06-4735.xml +822 -0
  21. data/test/results/801-lect07-4736.xml +893 -0
  22. data/test/results/801-lect08-4737.xml +809 -0
  23. data/test/results/801-lect09-4738.xml +807 -0
  24. data/test/results/Audio-Open-The_New_Deal_for_Education.xml +4301 -0
  25. data/test/test_metadatareader.rb +8 -3
  26. data/test/test_options.rb +8 -1
  27. data/test/test_runner.rb +34 -1
  28. data/test/test_transcript.rb +109 -12
  29. data/test/test_ttmlreader.rb +104 -0
  30. data/test/test_wrdreader.rb +24 -9
  31. metadata +47 -148
  32. data/lib/sm_transcript/optparseExample.rb +0 -113
  33. data/lib/sm_transcript/process_csv_files_to_html.rb +0 -58
  34. data/lib/sm_transcript/process_seg_files.rb +0 -21
  35. data/lib/sm_transcript/process_seg_files_to_csv.rb +0 -24
  36. data/lib/sm_transcript/process_seg_files_to_html.rb +0 -31
  37. data/lib/sm_transcript/require_relative.rb +0 -14
  38. data/test/transcripts/GardnerRileyInterview.t1.html +0 -247
  39. data/test/transcripts/IIHS_Diane_Davis_Nov2009-t1.html +0 -148
  40. data/test/transcripts/NERCOMP-SpokenMedia4.t1.html +0 -2178
  41. data/test/transcripts/data.js +0 -24
  42. data/test/transcripts/vijay_kumar-1.-t1.html +0 -557
  43. data/test/transcripts/vijay_kumar-1.t1.html +0 -558
  44. data/test/transcripts/vijay_kumar-t1.html +0 -558
  45. data/test/transcripts/vijay_kumar-t1.ttml +0 -570
  46. data/test/transcripts/vijay_kumar.data.js +0 -2
  47. data/test/transcripts/vijay_kumar.t1.html +0 -557
  48. data/test/transcripts/wirehair-beetle.data.js +0 -24
@@ -0,0 +1,4301 @@
1
+ <tt xml:lang="" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2006/04/ttaf1" xmlns:tts="http://www.w3.org/2006/04/ttaf1#styling">
2
+ <head>
3
+ <styling>
4
+ <style id="1" tts:textAlign="left"/>
5
+ <style id="2" tts:color="transparent"/>
6
+ <style id="3" style="2" tts:backgroundColor="white"/>
7
+ <style id="4" style="2 3" tts:fontSize="20"/>
8
+ </styling>
9
+ </head>
10
+
11
+ <body>
12
+ <div xml:lang="en">
13
+
14
+ <p begin="0:00:06.58" end="0:00:11.32">
15
+ Let me welcome all of you on<br/>
16
+ behalf of MIT, on behalf of the
17
+ </p>
18
+
19
+ <p begin="0:00:11.32" end="0:00:14.14">
20
+ Office of Educational<br/>
21
+ Innovation and Technology, and
22
+ </p>
23
+
24
+ <p begin="0:00:14.14" end="0:00:19.07">
25
+ on behalf of our partners here,<br/>
26
+ Apple, Scott's, I don't know,
27
+ </p>
28
+
29
+ <p begin="0:00:19.07" end="0:00:22.36">
30
+ it's not always good to extend<br/>
31
+ the family metaphor because
32
+ </p>
33
+
34
+ <p begin="0:00:22.36" end="0:00:25.11">
35
+ of all the intended<br/>
36
+ dysfunctionality, but, you
37
+ </p>
38
+
39
+ <p begin="0:00:25.11" end="0:00:28.86">
40
+ know, it's like a member of an<br/>
41
+ extended family over here.
42
+ </p>
43
+
44
+ <p begin="0:00:28.86" end="0:00:30.93">
45
+ <br/>
46
+
47
+ </p>
48
+
49
+ <p begin="0:00:30.93" end="0:00:35.87">
50
+ But, really, we welcome you<br/>
51
+ to MIT and to this event.
52
+ </p>
53
+
54
+ <p begin="0:00:35.87" end="0:00:38.42">
55
+ There is a lot of<br/>
56
+ planning, I know.
57
+ </p>
58
+
59
+ <p begin="0:00:38.42" end="0:00:42.33">
60
+ Not just what Scott was talking<br/>
61
+ about, I watched Andrew, who
62
+ </p>
63
+
64
+ <p begin="0:00:42.33" end="0:00:47.02">
65
+ works in our office, along with<br/>
66
+ Jeff and Judy go at it you
67
+ </p>
68
+
69
+ <p begin="0:00:47.02" end="0:00:48.9">
70
+ know, for quite some time.<br/>
71
+
72
+ </p>
73
+
74
+ <p begin="0:00:48.9" end="0:00:50.91">
75
+ So it's a treat to have<br/>
76
+ you over here and to have
77
+ </p>
78
+
79
+ <p begin="0:00:50.91" end="0:00:52.89">
80
+ this event over here.<br/>
81
+
82
+ </p>
83
+
84
+ <p begin="0:00:52.89" end="0:00:57.41">
85
+ I'm not going to be talking<br/>
86
+ about OEIT today, although the
87
+ </p>
88
+
89
+ <p begin="0:00:57.41" end="0:00:59.63">
90
+ Office of Educational<br/>
91
+ Innovation and Technology,
92
+ </p>
93
+
94
+ <p begin="0:00:59.63" end="0:01:03.179">
95
+ although, you know, I'm hoping<br/>
96
+ to touch on some examples,
97
+ </p>
98
+
99
+ <p begin="0:01:03.179" end="0:01:05.188">
100
+ as they are relevant<br/>
101
+ to my conversation.
102
+ </p>
103
+
104
+ <p begin="0:01:05.188" end="0:01:08.424">
105
+ I should also apologize to you<br/>
106
+ in advance, I'm not doing to
107
+ </p>
108
+
109
+ <p begin="0:01:08.424" end="0:01:14.299">
110
+ be singing for you today.<br/>
111
+ My voice is a little bit off,
112
+ </p>
113
+
114
+ <p begin="0:01:14.299" end="0:01:19.59">
115
+ but I do hope to talk about<br/>
116
+ some things open, and really
117
+ </p>
118
+
119
+ <p begin="0:01:19.59" end="0:01:25.42">
120
+ about this gathering storm, you<br/>
121
+ know, which I call the open
122
+ </p>
123
+
124
+ <p begin="0:01:25.42" end="0:01:30.86">
125
+ education movement, and the<br/>
126
+ potentially implications it has
127
+ </p>
128
+
129
+ <p begin="0:01:30.86" end="0:01:33.75">
130
+ for transforming education.<br/>
131
+
132
+ </p>
133
+
134
+ <p begin="0:01:33.75" end="0:01:36.97">
135
+ And you know, it was really<br/>
136
+ about, I don't know if it was
137
+ </p>
138
+
139
+ <p begin="0:01:36.97" end="0:01:39.93">
140
+ at 2:00 in the morning today<br/>
141
+ or 7:00 in the morning today.
142
+ </p>
143
+
144
+ <p begin="0:01:39.93" end="0:01:43.06">
145
+ You know I got onto MIT's<br/>
146
+ web page, and this was
147
+ </p>
148
+
149
+ <p begin="0:01:43.06" end="0:01:44.379">
150
+ the page, and I said wow!<br/>
151
+
152
+ </p>
153
+
154
+ <p begin="0:01:44.379" end="0:01:47.379">
155
+ You know, somebody paid<br/>
156
+ somebody to do this, because
157
+ </p>
158
+
159
+ <p begin="0:01:47.379" end="0:01:50.569">
160
+ it really epitomizes at least<br/>
161
+ certainly the institutional
162
+ </p>
163
+
164
+ <p begin="0:01:50.569" end="0:01:53.97">
165
+ commitment part of openness<br/>
166
+ that we want to talk about.
167
+ </p>
168
+
169
+ <p begin="0:01:53.97" end="0:01:57.489">
170
+ Last week at the faculty<br/>
171
+ meeting, not in this room, some
172
+ </p>
173
+
174
+ <p begin="0:01:57.489" end="0:01:59.61">
175
+ faculty meetings are held in<br/>
176
+ this room, but in another
177
+ </p>
178
+
179
+ <p begin="0:01:59.61" end="0:02:06.64">
180
+ renovated space in the main<br/>
181
+ drag, MIT faculty wanted to
182
+ </p>
183
+
184
+ <p begin="0:02:06.64" end="0:02:09.74">
185
+ provide, you know, to allow the<br/>
186
+ institute to provide open
187
+ </p>
188
+
189
+ <p begin="0:02:09.74" end="0:02:13.848">
190
+ access to all scholarly<br/>
191
+ articles, which sort of shows
192
+ </p>
193
+
194
+ <p begin="0:02:13.848" end="0:02:18.71">
195
+ the commitment and, of course,<br/>
196
+ most of you have heard about
197
+ </p>
198
+
199
+ <p begin="0:02:18.71" end="0:02:21.729">
200
+ OpenCourseWare, which was the<br/>
201
+ educational version of this.
202
+ </p>
203
+
204
+ <p begin="0:02:21.729" end="0:02:25.36">
205
+ So there's, you know, so<br/>
206
+ there's some institutional
207
+ </p>
208
+
209
+ <p begin="0:02:25.36" end="0:02:30.3">
210
+ teeth to this movement,<br/>
211
+ certainly as far as we are
212
+ </p>
213
+
214
+ <p begin="0:02:30.3" end="0:02:31.59">
215
+ concerned here at MIT.<br/>
216
+
217
+ </p>
218
+
219
+ <p begin="0:02:31.59" end="0:02:34.05">
220
+ <br/>
221
+
222
+ </p>
223
+
224
+ <p begin="0:02:34.05" end="0:02:45.78">
225
+ So, having -- let me pop it up<br/>
226
+ there and -- so, I chose an old
227
+ </p>
228
+
229
+ <p begin="0:02:45.78" end="0:02:49.5">
230
+ expression to describe a new<br/>
231
+ phenomenon, you know the new
232
+ </p>
233
+
234
+ <p begin="0:02:49.5" end="0:02:53.199">
235
+ deal, only to signify the<br/>
236
+ tremendous opportunity that I
237
+ </p>
238
+
239
+ <p begin="0:02:53.199" end="0:02:57.639">
240
+ see, this open education<br/>
241
+ movement has, and, you know,
242
+ </p>
243
+
244
+ <p begin="0:02:57.639" end="0:03:03.02">
245
+ it's characterized by open<br/>
246
+ content, open knowledge, open
247
+ </p>
248
+
249
+ <p begin="0:03:03.02" end="0:03:07.34">
250
+ technology and all these<br/>
251
+ dimensions sort of describe the
252
+ </p>
253
+
254
+ <p begin="0:03:07.34" end="0:03:09.58">
255
+ envelope of the open<br/>
256
+ education movement.
257
+ </p>
258
+
259
+ <p begin="0:03:09.58" end="0:03:13.65">
260
+ And the top part, you know, in<br/>
261
+ this world of borrowing and
262
+ </p>
263
+
264
+ <p begin="0:03:13.65" end="0:03:16.758">
265
+ collaboration euphemistically<br/>
266
+ called match ups, actually
267
+ </p>
268
+
269
+ <p begin="0:03:16.758" end="0:03:19.758">
270
+ borrowed the top part of that,<br/>
271
+ advancing the educational life
272
+ </p>
273
+
274
+ <p begin="0:03:19.758" end="0:03:23.65">
275
+ of information resources of<br/>
276
+ title from a guru of mine, John
277
+ </p>
278
+
279
+ <p begin="0:03:23.65" end="0:03:26.378">
280
+ Seely Brown, who many of you<br/>
281
+ know had this social
282
+ </p>
283
+
284
+ <p begin="0:03:26.378" end="0:03:27.68">
285
+ life of information.<br/>
286
+
287
+ </p>
288
+
289
+ <p begin="0:03:27.68" end="0:03:30.72">
290
+ The thesis there being that<br/>
291
+ the community really gives
292
+ </p>
293
+
294
+ <p begin="0:03:30.72" end="0:03:32.36">
295
+ meaning to information.<br/>
296
+
297
+ </p>
298
+
299
+ <p begin="0:03:32.36" end="0:03:39.91">
300
+ And here, my pitch is that a<br/>
301
+ lot of what openness is about
302
+ </p>
303
+
304
+ <p begin="0:03:39.91" end="0:03:43">
305
+ is breathing educational life<br/>
306
+ into information resources
307
+ </p>
308
+
309
+ <p begin="0:03:43" end="0:03:46.098">
310
+ which are becoming available<br/>
311
+ and plenty, through, you
312
+ </p>
313
+
314
+ <p begin="0:03:46.098" end="0:03:47.66">
315
+ know, through the kinds of<br/>
316
+ initiatives that I'm
317
+ </p>
318
+
319
+ <p begin="0:03:47.66" end="0:03:48.91">
320
+ going to talk about.<br/>
321
+
322
+ </p>
323
+
324
+ <p begin="0:03:48.91" end="0:03:50.19">
325
+ <br/>
326
+
327
+ </p>
328
+
329
+ <p begin="0:03:50.19" end="0:03:57.419">
330
+ So the promise was best<br/>
331
+ articulated by Chuck Vest, who
332
+ </p>
333
+
334
+ <p begin="0:03:57.419" end="0:04:01.55">
335
+ was President here at MIT, who<br/>
336
+ is now the President of the
337
+ </p>
338
+
339
+ <p begin="0:04:01.55" end="0:04:05.15">
340
+ National Academy, National<br/>
341
+ Academy for Engineering, and
342
+ </p>
343
+
344
+ <p begin="0:04:05.15" end="0:04:09.919">
345
+ it was under his championship,<br/>
346
+ actually, that OpenCourseWare
347
+ </p>
348
+
349
+ <p begin="0:04:09.919" end="0:04:11.968">
350
+ at MIT was launched.<br/>
351
+
352
+ </p>
353
+
354
+ <p begin="0:04:11.968" end="0:04:17.05">
355
+ And Fred painted this, you<br/>
356
+ know, this vision, if you will.
357
+ </p>
358
+
359
+ <p begin="0:04:17.05" end="0:04:21.18">
360
+ And he said we are talking<br/>
361
+ about OpenCourseWare and the
362
+ </p>
363
+
364
+ <p begin="0:04:21.18" end="0:04:24.72">
365
+ surrounding initiatives that<br/>
366
+ were sprouting at that time,
367
+ </p>
368
+
369
+ <p begin="0:04:24.72" end="0:04:27.329">
370
+ to say we are seeing the early<br/>
371
+ emergence of a Metaversity.
372
+ </p>
373
+
374
+ <p begin="0:04:27.329" end="0:04:28.36">
375
+ <br/>
376
+
377
+ </p>
378
+
379
+ <p begin="0:04:28.36" end="0:04:32.839">
380
+ A transcendent, accessible,<br/>
381
+ empowering, dynamic community
382
+ </p>
383
+
384
+ <p begin="0:04:32.839" end="0:04:36.009">
385
+ constructed framework of open<br/>
386
+ materials and platforms,
387
+ </p>
388
+
389
+ <p begin="0:04:36.009" end="0:04:39.24">
390
+ on which much of higher<br/>
391
+ education worldwide can be
392
+ </p>
393
+
394
+ <p begin="0:04:39.24" end="0:04:41.259">
395
+ constructed or enhanced.<br/>
396
+
397
+ </p>
398
+
399
+ <p begin="0:04:41.259" end="0:04:43.91">
400
+ And it's a tremendous vision.<br/>
401
+
402
+ </p>
403
+
404
+ <p begin="0:04:43.91" end="0:04:46.089">
405
+ It is a vision of<br/>
406
+ the Metaversity.
407
+ </p>
408
+
409
+ <p begin="0:04:46.089" end="0:04:46.43">
410
+ <br/>
411
+
412
+ </p>
413
+
414
+ <p begin="0:04:46.43" end="0:04:52.1">
415
+ And what I am contending today<br/>
416
+ is that much of what you have
417
+ </p>
418
+
419
+ <p begin="0:04:52.1" end="0:04:55.73">
420
+ seen, remarkable as it is, the<br/>
421
+ OpenCourseWare as a movement,
422
+ </p>
423
+
424
+ <p begin="0:04:55.73" end="0:04:58.74">
425
+ and I'll point to some of the<br/>
426
+ evidence, is the first
427
+ </p>
428
+
429
+ <p begin="0:04:58.74" end="0:05:00">
430
+ phase off that vision.<br/>
431
+
432
+ </p>
433
+
434
+ <p begin="0:05:00" end="0:05:03.095">
435
+ It is Metaversity part one, and<br/>
436
+ the kinds of things that we are
437
+ </p>
438
+
439
+ <p begin="0:05:03.095" end="0:05:08.699">
440
+ all engaged in really points to<br/>
441
+ a deeper vision of this second
442
+ </p>
443
+
444
+ <p begin="0:05:08.699" end="0:05:16.16">
445
+ phase, which is more akin to<br/>
446
+ what I think Chuck is trying to
447
+ </p>
448
+
449
+ <p begin="0:05:16.16" end="0:05:19.339">
450
+ describe over there, the<br/>
451
+ Metaversity part two.
452
+ </p>
453
+
454
+ <p begin="0:05:19.339" end="0:05:21.04">
455
+ <br/>
456
+
457
+ </p>
458
+
459
+ <p begin="0:05:21.04" end="0:05:26.769">
460
+ So, very quickly, some off the<br/>
461
+ artifacts some off the evidence
462
+ </p>
463
+
464
+ <p begin="0:05:26.769" end="0:05:30.879">
465
+ of this gathering storm that I<br/>
466
+ refer to are some of the
467
+ </p>
468
+
469
+ <p begin="0:05:30.879" end="0:05:34.56">
470
+ things that categorize<br/>
471
+ the Metaversity part one.
472
+ </p>
473
+
474
+ <p begin="0:05:34.56" end="0:05:37.899">
475
+ Of course, we like to<br/>
476
+ start with OpenCourseWare.
477
+ </p>
478
+
479
+ <p begin="0:05:37.899" end="0:05:44.79">
480
+ Around 2000, when MIT very<br/>
481
+ boldly, and some of us
482
+ </p>
483
+
484
+ <p begin="0:05:44.79" end="0:05:48.22">
485
+ thought at that time thought<br/>
486
+ rationally, announced that it
487
+ </p>
488
+
489
+ <p begin="0:05:48.22" end="0:05:52.079">
490
+ would make the content of all<br/>
491
+ its courses available on the
492
+ </p>
493
+
494
+ <p begin="0:05:52.079" end="0:05:54.1">
495
+ web for free to the world.<br/>
496
+
497
+ </p>
498
+
499
+ <p begin="0:05:54.1" end="0:05:57.555">
500
+ And I remember being in the<br/>
501
+ room, as part of the Counsel in
502
+ </p>
503
+
504
+ <p begin="0:05:57.555" end="0:06:02.12">
505
+ Education Technology when the<br/>
506
+ sub-group came back and said,
507
+ </p>
508
+
509
+ <p begin="0:06:02.12" end="0:06:03.85">
510
+ you know, maybe we<br/>
511
+ should do this.
512
+ </p>
513
+
514
+ <p begin="0:06:03.85" end="0:06:07.189">
515
+ And there were two remarkable<br/>
516
+ things that happened,
517
+ </p>
518
+
519
+ <p begin="0:06:07.189" end="0:06:10.16">
520
+ that are true.<br/>
521
+ One was our emotional response.
522
+ </p>
523
+
524
+ <p begin="0:06:10.16" end="0:06:14.009">
525
+ We said, whoa -- this<br/>
526
+ is big, you know, and,
527
+ </p>
528
+
529
+ <p begin="0:06:14.009" end="0:06:15.509">
530
+ which was tremendous.<br/>
531
+ We all knew this was
532
+ </p>
533
+
534
+ <p begin="0:06:15.509" end="0:06:16.959">
535
+ something very important.<br/>
536
+
537
+ </p>
538
+
539
+ <p begin="0:06:16.959" end="0:06:20.389">
540
+ The second thing was none of us<br/>
541
+ knew what it meant, you know.
542
+ </p>
543
+
544
+ <p begin="0:06:20.389" end="0:06:25.11">
545
+ So, we said, well,<br/>
546
+ but it was powerful.
547
+ </p>
548
+
549
+ <p begin="0:06:25.11" end="0:06:28.8">
550
+ None of us really understood<br/>
551
+ the profound implications
552
+ </p>
553
+
554
+ <p begin="0:06:28.8" end="0:06:34.67">
555
+ that have subsequently emerged<br/>
556
+ from that announcement.
557
+ </p>
558
+
559
+ <p begin="0:06:34.67" end="0:06:36.81">
560
+ Of course, one of the side<br/>
561
+ benefits, and then since then
562
+ </p>
563
+
564
+ <p begin="0:06:36.81" end="0:06:38.24">
565
+ lots has happened, you know.<br/>
566
+
567
+ </p>
568
+
569
+ <p begin="0:06:38.24" end="0:06:39.68">
570
+ <br/>
571
+
572
+ </p>
573
+
574
+ <p begin="0:06:39.68" end="0:06:47.009">
575
+ A couple of Octobers ago MIT,<br/>
576
+ all of MIT's 1,800 courses were
577
+ </p>
578
+
579
+ <p begin="0:06:47.009" end="0:06:52.48">
580
+ actually made available through<br/>
581
+ OpenCourseWare, and -- which is
582
+ </p>
583
+
584
+ <p begin="0:06:52.48" end="0:06:55.889">
585
+ tremendous, which is sort of --<br/>
586
+ you know, the first item was
587
+ </p>
588
+
589
+ <p begin="0:06:55.889" end="0:06:59.94">
590
+ Daily Word, and the first part<br/>
591
+ of the promise was Daily Word.
592
+ </p>
593
+
594
+ <p begin="0:06:59.94" end="0:07:03.16">
595
+ Now, one side benefit that I<br/>
596
+ always like to point out from
597
+ </p>
598
+
599
+ <p begin="0:07:03.16" end="0:07:07.25">
600
+ OpenCourseWare is that we like<br/>
601
+ to say to MIT that we figured
602
+ </p>
603
+
604
+ <p begin="0:07:07.25" end="0:07:10.35">
605
+ out actually how many courses<br/>
606
+ there were, indeed, at MIT.
607
+ </p>
608
+
609
+ <p begin="0:07:10.35" end="0:07:15.61">
610
+ So we, you know, because we<br/>
611
+ said all the courses, like
612
+ </p>
613
+
614
+ <p begin="0:07:15.61" end="0:07:17.86">
615
+ in the old days we used<br/>
616
+ to talk about the Athena
617
+ </p>
618
+
619
+ <p begin="0:07:17.86" end="0:07:20.346">
620
+ computing environment.<br/>
621
+ It was sort of everything, but
622
+ </p>
623
+
624
+ <p begin="0:07:20.346" end="0:07:24.23">
625
+ we didn't exactly what it was,<br/>
626
+ and 1,800 was a good number,
627
+ </p>
628
+
629
+ <p begin="0:07:24.23" end="0:07:25.509">
630
+ so that's where it come.<br/>
631
+
632
+ </p>
633
+
634
+ <p begin="0:07:25.509" end="0:07:27.81">
635
+ So that was there, but the<br/>
636
+ interesting thing about the
637
+ </p>
638
+
639
+ <p begin="0:07:27.81" end="0:07:32.04">
640
+ open education movement that<br/>
641
+ I'm referring to was certainly,
642
+ </p>
643
+
644
+ <p begin="0:07:32.04" end="0:07:37.22">
645
+ motivated, led, catalyzed by<br/>
646
+ OpenCourseWare, but that's not
647
+ </p>
648
+
649
+ <p begin="0:07:37.22" end="0:07:43.259">
650
+ the movement, and it's not<br/>
651
+ even, when we announced
652
+ </p>
653
+
654
+ <p begin="0:07:43.259" end="0:07:48.1">
655
+ OpenCourseWare, it was<br/>
656
+ interesting because the kinds
657
+ </p>
658
+
659
+ <p begin="0:07:48.1" end="0:07:51.86">
660
+ of letters we'd get from all<br/>
661
+ over the world, MIT used to
662
+ </p>
663
+
664
+ <p begin="0:07:51.86" end="0:07:57.149">
665
+ get, and typically in<br/>
666
+ presentations, and in
667
+ </p>
668
+
669
+ <p begin="0:07:57.149" end="0:08:00.06">
670
+ fact, if you go to the MIT<br/>
671
+ OpenCourseWare site, you will
672
+ </p>
673
+
674
+ <p begin="0:08:00.06" end="0:08:04.899">
675
+ see stats on the millions off<br/>
676
+ hits and how much access, and
677
+ </p>
678
+
679
+ <p begin="0:08:04.899" end="0:08:07">
680
+ that's all wonderful.<br/>
681
+
682
+ </p>
683
+
684
+ <p begin="0:08:07" end="0:08:10.62">
685
+ That's great data.<br/>
686
+ That's great information, but
687
+ </p>
688
+
689
+ <p begin="0:08:10.62" end="0:08:16.019">
690
+ the impact data is really<br/>
691
+ vignette like this, when you
692
+ </p>
693
+
694
+ <p begin="0:08:16.019" end="0:08:18.939">
695
+ talk about the fact that when<br/>
696
+ you put out resources like
697
+ </p>
698
+
699
+ <p begin="0:08:18.939" end="0:08:21.49">
700
+ OpenCourseWare, people<br/>
701
+ can use it for curriculum
702
+ </p>
703
+
704
+ <p begin="0:08:21.49" end="0:08:26.12">
705
+ formulation elsewhere.<br/>
706
+ It serves as a model and so
707
+ </p>
708
+
709
+ <p begin="0:08:26.12" end="0:08:29.519">
710
+ it's not just about consuming<br/>
711
+ the content that is put over
712
+ </p>
713
+
714
+ <p begin="0:08:29.519" end="0:08:32.178">
715
+ there, but being able to learn<br/>
716
+ from it the way it is put
717
+ </p>
718
+
719
+ <p begin="0:08:32.178" end="0:08:34.889">
720
+ together, the way it is<br/>
721
+ structured in order that you
722
+ </p>
723
+
724
+ <p begin="0:08:34.889" end="0:08:38.44">
725
+ can do your own thing<br/>
726
+ more efficiently.
727
+ </p>
728
+
729
+ <p begin="0:08:38.44" end="0:08:41.95">
730
+ So this is, Richard Hall, who<br/>
731
+ says it saved him an enormous
732
+ </p>
733
+
734
+ <p begin="0:08:41.95" end="0:08:43.47">
735
+ amount of time and stress.<br/>
736
+
737
+ </p>
738
+
739
+ <p begin="0:08:43.47" end="0:08:45.07">
740
+ I could use some of that myself.<br/>
741
+
742
+ </p>
743
+
744
+ <p begin="0:08:45.07" end="0:08:50.558">
745
+ So, the other kind of vignette,<br/>
746
+ which I look at as evidence is
747
+ </p>
748
+
749
+ <p begin="0:08:50.558" end="0:08:53.21">
750
+ this one, where, you know,<br/>
751
+ you actually have students
752
+ </p>
753
+
754
+ <p begin="0:08:53.21" end="0:08:57.509">
755
+ elsewhere who are using this,<br/>
756
+ and who actually go and look at
757
+ </p>
758
+
759
+ <p begin="0:08:57.509" end="0:09:01.09">
760
+ the notes in OpenCourseWare and<br/>
761
+ then use them as supplements
762
+ </p>
763
+
764
+ <p begin="0:09:01.09" end="0:09:02.98">
765
+ to what they're learning.<br/>
766
+ And by the way, this is a
767
+ </p>
768
+
769
+ <p begin="0:09:02.98" end="0:09:05.87">
770
+ phenomenon that I experience<br/>
771
+ all the time when I'm giving
772
+ </p>
773
+
774
+ <p begin="0:09:05.87" end="0:09:09.36">
775
+ talks, for instance, in India,<br/>
776
+ I'd be there giving a talk to
777
+ </p>
778
+
779
+ <p begin="0:09:09.36" end="0:09:13.48">
780
+ you know, some 1,700 people in<br/>
781
+ a class like this, and I'll as
782
+ </p>
783
+
784
+ <p begin="0:09:13.48" end="0:09:17.45">
785
+ for a show of hands, how many<br/>
786
+ of you have heard of OCW, you
787
+ </p>
788
+
789
+ <p begin="0:09:17.45" end="0:09:19.558">
790
+ know, the hands will go up.<br/>
791
+
792
+ </p>
793
+
794
+ <p begin="0:09:19.558" end="0:09:22.129">
795
+ Then I'll ask, how<br/>
796
+ many of you use OCW?
797
+ </p>
798
+
799
+ <p begin="0:09:22.129" end="0:09:28.028">
800
+ And what is remarkable is that<br/>
801
+ there are classes where all
802
+ </p>
803
+
804
+ <p begin="0:09:28.028" end="0:09:30.389">
805
+ the students would have<br/>
806
+ their hands up, you know.
807
+ </p>
808
+
809
+ <p begin="0:09:30.389" end="0:09:35.308">
810
+ And unselfconsciously, with the<br/>
811
+ instructor over there, because
812
+ </p>
813
+
814
+ <p begin="0:09:35.308" end="0:09:36.69">
815
+ they using get the supplements.<br/>
816
+
817
+ </p>
818
+
819
+ <p begin="0:09:36.69" end="0:09:43.408">
820
+ Sometimes they're looking at it<br/>
821
+ as a benchmark, to ask an
822
+ </p>
823
+
824
+ <p begin="0:09:43.408" end="0:09:48.279">
825
+ instructor why isn't our course<br/>
826
+ looking like that, or why
827
+ </p>
828
+
829
+ <p begin="0:09:48.279" end="0:09:52.038">
830
+ aren't we covering those<br/>
831
+ aspects of the content?
832
+ </p>
833
+
834
+ <p begin="0:09:52.038" end="0:09:55.24">
835
+ So you can start to see<br/>
836
+ the kinds of implications
837
+ </p>
838
+
839
+ <p begin="0:09:55.24" end="0:09:56.72">
840
+ of things open.<br/>
841
+
842
+ </p>
843
+
844
+ <p begin="0:09:56.72" end="0:09:59.69">
845
+ It is not just about being able<br/>
846
+ to go and grab the contents.
847
+ </p>
848
+
849
+ <p begin="0:09:59.69" end="0:10:02.009">
850
+ It serves as a model.<br/>
851
+ It serves as a benchmark.
852
+ </p>
853
+
854
+ <p begin="0:10:02.009" end="0:10:05.74">
855
+ It serves as a mirror into your<br/>
856
+ quality, and this is, these are
857
+ </p>
858
+
859
+ <p begin="0:10:05.74" end="0:10:08.08">
860
+ the -- I'm trying to start<br/>
861
+ giving you hints of the
862
+ </p>
863
+
864
+ <p begin="0:10:08.08" end="0:10:10.86">
865
+ transubmitive impact<br/>
866
+ of things open.
867
+ </p>
868
+
869
+ <p begin="0:10:10.86" end="0:10:12.308">
870
+ <br/>
871
+
872
+ </p>
873
+
874
+ <p begin="0:10:12.308" end="0:10:14.09">
875
+ Again, but that's is<br/>
876
+ not the movement.
877
+ </p>
878
+
879
+ <p begin="0:10:14.09" end="0:10:16.7">
880
+ This was, so far I've<br/>
881
+ talked about OCW.
882
+ </p>
883
+
884
+ <p begin="0:10:16.7" end="0:10:21.6">
885
+ What characterized the movement<br/>
886
+ was, now actually hundreds
887
+ </p>
888
+
889
+ <p begin="0:10:21.6" end="0:10:23.918">
890
+ of OCWs that started.<br/>
891
+
892
+ </p>
893
+
894
+ <p begin="0:10:23.918" end="0:10:26.07">
895
+ There's a consortium<br/>
896
+ with 160 institutions.
897
+ </p>
898
+
899
+ <p begin="0:10:26.07" end="0:10:27.548">
900
+ <br/>
901
+
902
+ </p>
903
+
904
+ <p begin="0:10:27.548" end="0:10:29.6">
905
+ Brandon, sitting over there,<br/>
906
+ is actually involved in
907
+ </p>
908
+
909
+ <p begin="0:10:29.6" end="0:10:32.36">
910
+ the consortium, as I am.<br/>
911
+
912
+ </p>
913
+
914
+ <p begin="0:10:32.36" end="0:10:37.12">
915
+ So the number of universities<br/>
916
+ who started making there
917
+ </p>
918
+
919
+ <p begin="0:10:37.12" end="0:10:41.82">
920
+ materials available, and number<br/>
921
+ of initiatives that started
922
+ </p>
923
+
924
+ <p begin="0:10:41.82" end="0:10:44.918">
925
+ making their resources<br/>
926
+ available in one form or the
927
+ </p>
928
+
929
+ <p begin="0:10:44.918" end="0:10:48.47">
930
+ other, making them available<br/>
931
+ for consumption across
932
+ </p>
933
+
934
+ <p begin="0:10:48.47" end="0:10:49.83">
935
+ the world for free.<br/>
936
+
937
+ </p>
938
+
939
+ <p begin="0:10:49.83" end="0:10:55.529">
940
+ So that characterizes the scale<br/>
941
+ of the movement, and why I
942
+ </p>
943
+
944
+ <p begin="0:10:55.529" end="0:10:59.7">
945
+ use terms like a gatherings<br/>
946
+ storm, because this is big.
947
+ </p>
948
+
949
+ <p begin="0:10:59.7" end="0:11:04.98">
950
+ I go to the Commonwealth of<br/>
951
+ Learning meetings in London,
952
+ </p>
953
+
954
+ <p begin="0:11:04.98" end="0:11:08.35">
955
+ and they say, well you know, we<br/>
956
+ have to have OER as a strategy
957
+ </p>
958
+
959
+ <p begin="0:11:08.35" end="0:11:11.408">
960
+ for extensive access to<br/>
961
+ education in developing
962
+ </p>
963
+
964
+ <p begin="0:11:11.408" end="0:11:13.36">
965
+ countries, you know.<br/>
966
+ And why they are able to make
967
+ </p>
968
+
969
+ <p begin="0:11:13.36" end="0:11:17.009">
970
+ statements like that is because<br/>
971
+ they see the evidence of the
972
+ </p>
973
+
974
+ <p begin="0:11:17.009" end="0:11:19.61">
975
+ movement in pretty<br/>
976
+ dramatically ways.
977
+ </p>
978
+
979
+ <p begin="0:11:19.61" end="0:11:22.33">
980
+ So that's one part.<br/>
981
+
982
+ </p>
983
+
984
+ <p begin="0:11:22.33" end="0:11:24.158">
985
+ I mention the consortium.<br/>
986
+
987
+ </p>
988
+
989
+ <p begin="0:11:24.158" end="0:11:27.86">
990
+ Now, typically we think this<br/>
991
+ is all about higher education.
992
+ </p>
993
+
994
+ <p begin="0:11:27.86" end="0:11:29.2">
995
+ Not true, you know.<br/>
996
+
997
+ </p>
998
+
999
+ <p begin="0:11:29.2" end="0:11:31.509">
1000
+ There are very significant<br/>
1001
+ K through 12 initiatives,
1002
+ </p>
1003
+
1004
+ <p begin="0:11:31.509" end="0:11:34.21">
1005
+ some of which you see<br/>
1006
+ listed before you.
1007
+ </p>
1008
+
1009
+ <p begin="0:11:34.21" end="0:11:38.149">
1010
+ One that Scott mentioned<br/>
1011
+ in my introduction.
1012
+ </p>
1013
+
1014
+ <p begin="0:11:38.149" end="0:11:40.84">
1015
+ Curriki which I served as<br/>
1016
+ adviser to, which actually
1017
+ </p>
1018
+
1019
+ <p begin="0:11:40.84" end="0:11:46.158">
1020
+ came out of Scott McNealy's<br/>
1021
+ championship from Sun
1022
+ </p>
1023
+
1024
+ <p begin="0:11:46.158" end="0:11:49.6">
1025
+ Microsystems, but this is, the<br/>
1026
+ Curriki initiative is to make
1027
+ </p>
1028
+
1029
+ <p begin="0:11:49.6" end="0:11:52.45">
1030
+ sure that you can create a<br/>
1031
+ framework so that people can
1032
+ </p>
1033
+
1034
+ <p begin="0:11:52.45" end="0:11:56.59">
1035
+ contribute resources for K<br/>
1036
+ through 12, and then make it
1037
+ </p>
1038
+
1039
+ <p begin="0:11:56.59" end="0:11:59.24">
1040
+ widely available in an<br/>
1041
+ open-fashion and open-source
1042
+ </p>
1043
+
1044
+ <p begin="0:11:59.24" end="0:12:04.399">
1045
+ model, and mapping it<br/>
1046
+ to regional, local and
1047
+ </p>
1048
+
1049
+ <p begin="0:12:04.399" end="0:12:07.97">
1050
+ curricula, not just in this<br/>
1051
+ country, but elsewhere.
1052
+ </p>
1053
+
1054
+ <p begin="0:12:07.97" end="0:12:11.99">
1055
+ So in the K through 12 domain<br/>
1056
+ also there is a palpable
1057
+ </p>
1058
+
1059
+ <p begin="0:12:11.99" end="0:12:16.21">
1060
+ movement, open movement, and<br/>
1061
+ you know, with some good
1062
+ </p>
1063
+
1064
+ <p begin="0:12:16.21" end="0:12:18.399">
1065
+ materials, people say, well<br/>
1066
+ you know, if it's open,
1067
+ </p>
1068
+
1069
+ <p begin="0:12:18.399" end="0:12:21.558">
1070
+ it won't be good.<br/>
1071
+ It's all bitter medicine thing.
1072
+ </p>
1073
+
1074
+ <p begin="0:12:21.558" end="0:12:26.72">
1075
+ And there are some very, very<br/>
1076
+ good pieces off educational
1077
+ </p>
1078
+
1079
+ <p begin="0:12:26.72" end="0:12:32.2">
1080
+ courseware, you know, applets<br/>
1081
+ if you will, to teach
1082
+ </p>
1083
+
1084
+ <p begin="0:12:32.2" end="0:12:33.75">
1085
+ different concepts.<br/>
1086
+
1087
+ </p>
1088
+
1089
+ <p begin="0:12:33.75" end="0:12:37.779">
1090
+ And this contribution from<br/>
1091
+ around the world, there are
1092
+ </p>
1093
+
1094
+ <p begin="0:12:37.779" end="0:12:40.84">
1095
+ initiatives that have been<br/>
1096
+ launched, to filter, to
1097
+ </p>
1098
+
1099
+ <p begin="0:12:40.84" end="0:12:44.029">
1100
+ make sure there is good,<br/>
1101
+ appropriate content.
1102
+ </p>
1103
+
1104
+ <p begin="0:12:44.029" end="0:12:46.918">
1105
+ <br/>
1106
+
1107
+ </p>
1108
+
1109
+ <p begin="0:12:46.918" end="0:12:51.62">
1110
+ MIT itself has provided a<br/>
1111
+ channel to its OpenCourseWare
1112
+ </p>
1113
+
1114
+ <p begin="0:12:51.62" end="0:12:53.408">
1115
+ for, you know, for<br/>
1116
+ higher education.
1117
+ </p>
1118
+
1119
+ <p begin="0:12:53.408" end="0:12:58.558">
1120
+ We call it highlights for high<br/>
1121
+ school, where you provide
1122
+ </p>
1123
+
1124
+ <p begin="0:12:58.558" end="0:13:02.23">
1125
+ particular channels into<br/>
1126
+ courses and content which might
1127
+ </p>
1128
+
1129
+ <p begin="0:13:02.23" end="0:13:05.73">
1130
+ be relevant for high school<br/>
1131
+ consumption, for advanced
1132
+ </p>
1133
+
1134
+ <p begin="0:13:05.73" end="0:13:08.129">
1135
+ placement of, you know,<br/>
1136
+ of advanced preparation.
1137
+ </p>
1138
+
1139
+ <p begin="0:13:08.129" end="0:13:10.6">
1140
+ <br/>
1141
+
1142
+ </p>
1143
+
1144
+ <p begin="0:13:10.6" end="0:13:13.24">
1145
+ This is a resource that I<br/>
1146
+ like to point to in the
1147
+ </p>
1148
+
1149
+ <p begin="0:13:13.24" end="0:13:14.61">
1150
+ K through 12 domain.<br/>
1151
+
1152
+ </p>
1153
+
1154
+ <p begin="0:13:14.61" end="0:13:17.778">
1155
+ This was an initiative that was<br/>
1156
+ launch by Carl Wyman, no less,
1157
+ </p>
1158
+
1159
+ <p begin="0:13:17.778" end="0:13:20.96">
1160
+ who was the year before last,<br/>
1161
+ Novel Laureate in physics, and
1162
+ </p>
1163
+
1164
+ <p begin="0:13:20.96" end="0:13:22.59">
1165
+ he had launched this when he<br/>
1166
+ was at the University
1167
+ </p>
1168
+
1169
+ <p begin="0:13:22.59" end="0:13:26.09">
1170
+ of Colorado.<br/>
1171
+ And, where, if you go to this
1172
+ </p>
1173
+
1174
+ <p begin="0:13:26.09" end="0:13:29.72">
1175
+ site, and now of course, Carl<br/>
1176
+ has moved on to University of
1177
+ </p>
1178
+
1179
+ <p begin="0:13:29.72" end="0:13:33.798">
1180
+ British Columbia, and<br/>
1181
+ this site is there.
1182
+ </p>
1183
+
1184
+ <p begin="0:13:33.798" end="0:13:35.058">
1185
+ It is maintained by his group.<br/>
1186
+
1187
+ </p>
1188
+
1189
+ <p begin="0:13:35.058" end="0:13:37.57">
1190
+ It is openly, maid<br/>
1191
+ openly available.
1192
+ </p>
1193
+
1194
+ <p begin="0:13:37.57" end="0:13:42.658">
1195
+ And if you go to the site, you<br/>
1196
+ will find that there is very,
1197
+ </p>
1198
+
1199
+ <p begin="0:13:42.658" end="0:13:46.58">
1200
+ you know, there'll be<br/>
1201
+ statements about how the
1202
+ </p>
1203
+
1204
+ <p begin="0:13:46.58" end="0:13:49.139">
1205
+ resources over there<br/>
1206
+ have been evaluated.
1207
+ </p>
1208
+
1209
+ <p begin="0:13:49.139" end="0:13:53.22">
1210
+ There has been very, very good,<br/>
1211
+ you know, they have founded,
1212
+ </p>
1213
+
1214
+ <p begin="0:13:53.22" end="0:13:55.029">
1215
+ they have been developed<br/>
1216
+ on very, very good
1217
+ </p>
1218
+
1219
+ <p begin="0:13:55.029" end="0:13:56.928">
1220
+ educational principles.<br/>
1221
+
1222
+ </p>
1223
+
1224
+ <p begin="0:13:56.928" end="0:13:59.87">
1225
+ There has been some amount<br/>
1226
+ of vigorous evaluation done.
1227
+ </p>
1228
+
1229
+ <p begin="0:13:59.87" end="0:14:05.32">
1230
+ All this to tell you that there<br/>
1231
+ is open stuff there, good stuff
1232
+ </p>
1233
+
1234
+ <p begin="0:14:05.32" end="0:14:11.61">
1235
+ that, there is quality stuff<br/>
1236
+ there, capable off making great
1237
+ </p>
1238
+
1239
+ <p begin="0:14:11.61" end="0:14:14.908">
1240
+ transformative contribution<br/>
1241
+ to education as we know it.
1242
+ </p>
1243
+
1244
+ <p begin="0:14:14.908" end="0:14:17.44">
1245
+ And what happens is, over time,<br/>
1246
+ when you start doing these
1247
+ </p>
1248
+
1249
+ <p begin="0:14:17.44" end="0:14:21.509">
1250
+ things, the kind of sort of<br/>
1251
+ vision that Scott was alluding
1252
+ </p>
1253
+
1254
+ <p begin="0:14:21.509" end="0:14:23.07">
1255
+ to, you start seeing pieces of.<br/>
1256
+
1257
+ </p>
1258
+
1259
+ <p begin="0:14:23.07" end="0:14:26.389">
1260
+ <br/>
1261
+
1262
+ </p>
1263
+
1264
+ <p begin="0:14:26.389" end="0:14:31.778">
1265
+ But like I said, that's all<br/>
1266
+ fantastic, but it's still
1267
+ </p>
1268
+
1269
+ <p begin="0:14:31.778" end="0:14:35.11">
1270
+ -- I characterize all<br/>
1271
+ that as F part one.
1272
+ </p>
1273
+
1274
+ <p begin="0:14:35.11" end="0:14:41.37">
1275
+ Part two, I think, is when, and<br/>
1276
+ if you've noticed, many of
1277
+ </p>
1278
+
1279
+ <p begin="0:14:41.37" end="0:14:46.21">
1280
+ those are about fantastic<br/>
1281
+ resources, largely about
1282
+ </p>
1283
+
1284
+ <p begin="0:14:46.21" end="0:14:51.808">
1285
+ content, and they are<br/>
1286
+ stand-alone, they are
1287
+ </p>
1288
+
1289
+ <p begin="0:14:51.808" end="0:14:56.428">
1290
+ disparitary resources, but<br/>
1291
+ transformative impact or
1292
+ </p>
1293
+
1294
+ <p begin="0:14:56.428" end="0:15:00.1">
1295
+ systemic change, I think, for<br/>
1296
+ education, happens when we can
1297
+ </p>
1298
+
1299
+ <p begin="0:15:00.1" end="0:15:07.058">
1300
+ move from there to another kind<br/>
1301
+ of place where we can actually
1302
+ </p>
1303
+
1304
+ <p begin="0:15:07.058" end="0:15:10.019">
1305
+ provide quality end to an<br/>
1306
+ educational experience
1307
+ </p>
1308
+
1309
+ <p begin="0:15:10.019" end="0:15:11.298">
1310
+ through things open.<br/>
1311
+
1312
+ </p>
1313
+
1314
+ <p begin="0:15:11.298" end="0:15:13.129">
1315
+ So when we think about<br/>
1316
+ end-to-end educational
1317
+ </p>
1318
+
1319
+ <p begin="0:15:13.129" end="0:15:16.259">
1320
+ experiences, we think not<br/>
1321
+ only about content, but how we
1322
+ </p>
1323
+
1324
+ <p begin="0:15:16.259" end="0:15:19.57">
1325
+ might be able to do, provide<br/>
1326
+ first-hand experiences,
1327
+ </p>
1328
+
1329
+ <p begin="0:15:19.57" end="0:15:25.288">
1330
+ laboratory experiences, as,<br/>
1331
+ you know, to complement
1332
+ </p>
1333
+
1334
+ <p begin="0:15:25.288" end="0:15:26.71">
1335
+ good content out there.<br/>
1336
+
1337
+ </p>
1338
+
1339
+ <p begin="0:15:26.71" end="0:15:29.798">
1340
+ How might we provide good<br/>
1341
+ interactive experiences for
1342
+ </p>
1343
+
1344
+ <p begin="0:15:29.798" end="0:15:38.49">
1345
+ people learning and how we<br/>
1346
+ might actually harvest
1347
+ </p>
1348
+
1349
+ <p begin="0:15:38.49" end="0:15:41.69">
1350
+ resources that might be<br/>
1351
+ available anywhere and
1352
+ </p>
1353
+
1354
+ <p begin="0:15:41.69" end="0:15:44.808">
1355
+ productivity combine them to<br/>
1356
+ deliver different kinds of
1357
+ </p>
1358
+
1359
+ <p begin="0:15:44.808" end="0:15:48.149">
1360
+ learning experiences to<br/>
1361
+ suit different audiences.
1362
+ </p>
1363
+
1364
+ <p begin="0:15:48.149" end="0:15:54.538">
1365
+ And, really keep the focus<br/>
1366
+ on quality, the fact that
1367
+ </p>
1368
+
1369
+ <p begin="0:15:54.538" end="0:15:58.94">
1370
+ you can generate new kinds<br/>
1371
+ of experiences, new
1372
+ </p>
1373
+
1374
+ <p begin="0:15:58.94" end="0:16:00.389">
1375
+ kinds of material.<br/>
1376
+
1377
+ </p>
1378
+
1379
+ <p begin="0:16:00.389" end="0:16:04.72">
1380
+ So what I'd like to do now is<br/>
1381
+ just point to some off the
1382
+ </p>
1383
+
1384
+ <p begin="0:16:04.72" end="0:16:08.399">
1385
+ kinds of initiatives, and I<br/>
1386
+ will apologize, many of the
1387
+ </p>
1388
+
1389
+ <p begin="0:16:08.399" end="0:16:13.528">
1390
+ initiatives that I'm pointing<br/>
1391
+ to are MIT based, but
1392
+ </p>
1393
+
1394
+ <p begin="0:16:13.528" end="0:16:16.08">
1395
+ you know, I talk about<br/>
1396
+ what I know better.
1397
+ </p>
1398
+
1399
+ <p begin="0:16:16.08" end="0:16:19.278">
1400
+ So I'll point to them,<br/>
1401
+ but they're done.
1402
+ </p>
1403
+
1404
+ <p begin="0:16:19.278" end="0:16:22.72">
1405
+ And I'll also point out that<br/>
1406
+ they might have been launched
1407
+ </p>
1408
+
1409
+ <p begin="0:16:22.72" end="0:16:28.278">
1410
+ at MIT, but right from the<br/>
1411
+ get-go they involved other
1412
+ </p>
1413
+
1414
+ <p begin="0:16:28.278" end="0:16:30.889">
1415
+ institutions, other players.<br/>
1416
+
1417
+ </p>
1418
+
1419
+ <p begin="0:16:30.889" end="0:16:35.389">
1420
+ But they speak to the kinds of,<br/>
1421
+ the value proposition elements
1422
+ </p>
1423
+
1424
+ <p begin="0:16:35.389" end="0:16:38.35">
1425
+ that I think will take us to to<br/>
1426
+ this vision of a Metaversity II.
1427
+ </p>
1428
+
1429
+ <p begin="0:16:38.35" end="0:16:46.08">
1430
+ So, this is an initiative that<br/>
1431
+ I like to talk about a lot.
1432
+ </p>
1433
+
1434
+ <p begin="0:16:46.08" end="0:16:47.61">
1435
+ <br/>
1436
+
1437
+ </p>
1438
+
1439
+ <p begin="0:16:47.61" end="0:16:50.95">
1440
+ On the left is Jesus del<br/>
1441
+ Alamo he is a professor right
1442
+ </p>
1443
+
1444
+ <p begin="0:16:50.95" end="0:16:55.408">
1445
+ here, upstairs, teaches in<br/>
1446
+ electrical engineering.
1447
+ </p>
1448
+
1449
+ <p begin="0:16:55.408" end="0:16:56.95">
1450
+ <br/>
1451
+
1452
+ </p>
1453
+
1454
+ <p begin="0:16:56.95" end="0:17:00.96">
1455
+ So some years ago, he started<br/>
1456
+ this thing called iLab and the
1457
+ </p>
1458
+
1459
+ <p begin="0:17:00.96" end="0:17:04.759">
1460
+ intent of iLab is to provide<br/>
1461
+ access to real laboratories
1462
+ </p>
1463
+
1464
+ <p begin="0:17:04.759" end="0:17:07.96">
1465
+ over the internet, not<br/>
1466
+ simulations, actually labs.
1467
+ </p>
1468
+
1469
+ <p begin="0:17:07.96" end="0:17:13.22">
1470
+ So, initially it started off<br/>
1471
+ with some, you know, network
1472
+ </p>
1473
+
1474
+ <p begin="0:17:13.22" end="0:17:17.96">
1475
+ signal analyzer and for digital<br/>
1476
+ signal processing courses.
1477
+ </p>
1478
+
1479
+ <p begin="0:17:17.96" end="0:17:20.68">
1480
+ And then there were some<br/>
1481
+ other labs that actually got
1482
+ </p>
1483
+
1484
+ <p begin="0:17:20.68" end="0:17:23.96">
1485
+ launched, and we had students<br/>
1486
+ from Singapore, from Sweden
1487
+ </p>
1488
+
1489
+ <p begin="0:17:23.96" end="0:17:28.588">
1490
+ sort of places who were<br/>
1491
+ actually conducting
1492
+ </p>
1493
+
1494
+ <p begin="0:17:28.588" end="0:17:29.836">
1495
+ labs over here.<br/>
1496
+
1497
+ </p>
1498
+
1499
+ <p begin="0:17:29.836" end="0:17:31.99">
1500
+ <br/>
1501
+
1502
+ </p>
1503
+
1504
+ <p begin="0:17:31.99" end="0:17:34.848">
1505
+ And, you know, then we had<br/>
1506
+ some of our Cambridge students
1507
+ </p>
1508
+
1509
+ <p begin="0:17:34.848" end="0:17:37.259">
1510
+ actually looking at, you know,<br/>
1511
+ we had a partnership with the
1512
+ </p>
1513
+
1514
+ <p begin="0:17:37.259" end="0:17:39.618">
1515
+ University of Cambridge,<br/>
1516
+ who was looking at
1517
+ </p>
1518
+
1519
+ <p begin="0:17:39.618" end="0:17:40.9">
1520
+ chemical reactors.<br/>
1521
+
1522
+ </p>
1523
+
1524
+ <p begin="0:17:40.9" end="0:17:44.328">
1525
+ There was a civil engineering,<br/>
1526
+ a shake table experiment to do
1527
+ </p>
1528
+
1529
+ <p begin="0:17:44.328" end="0:17:51.298">
1530
+ seismic measurements, and these<br/>
1531
+ work controlled, accessed,
1532
+ </p>
1533
+
1534
+ <p begin="0:17:51.298" end="0:17:54.328">
1535
+ through browsers, and people<br/>
1536
+ actually adjusted the
1537
+ </p>
1538
+
1539
+ <p begin="0:17:54.328" end="0:17:57.17">
1540
+ parameters, saw the results,<br/>
1541
+ and not only that, there were
1542
+ </p>
1543
+
1544
+ <p begin="0:17:57.17" end="0:17:59.99">
1545
+ communities swarming which<br/>
1546
+ would discuss the results.
1547
+ </p>
1548
+
1549
+ <p begin="0:17:59.99" end="0:18:05.73">
1550
+ And in fact, we have one that<br/>
1551
+ is going on right now, an NSF
1552
+ </p>
1553
+
1554
+ <p begin="0:18:05.73" end="0:18:08.74">
1555
+ supported project where K<br/>
1556
+ through 12 students have
1557
+ </p>
1558
+
1559
+ <p begin="0:18:08.74" end="0:18:11.828">
1560
+ browser-based access.<br/>
1561
+ MIT has a benign,
1562
+ </p>
1563
+
1564
+ <p begin="0:18:11.828" end="0:18:13.368">
1565
+ friendly, nuclear reactor.<br/>
1566
+
1567
+ </p>
1568
+
1569
+ <p begin="0:18:13.368" end="0:18:18.24">
1570
+ I have to put all these<br/>
1571
+ qualifiers over there, but
1572
+ </p>
1573
+
1574
+ <p begin="0:18:18.24" end="0:18:22.278">
1575
+ you know, it's provides<br/>
1576
+ access to those.
1577
+ </p>
1578
+
1579
+ <p begin="0:18:22.278" end="0:18:23.43">
1580
+ <br/>
1581
+
1582
+ </p>
1583
+
1584
+ <p begin="0:18:23.43" end="0:18:26.39">
1585
+ And you can see, I mean you can<br/>
1586
+ imagine the empowerment when K
1587
+ </p>
1588
+
1589
+ <p begin="0:18:26.39" end="0:18:28.163">
1590
+ through 12 students are<br/>
1591
+ watching these neutrons go,
1592
+ </p>
1593
+
1594
+ <p begin="0:18:28.163" end="0:18:30.64">
1595
+ and by the way, the same<br/>
1596
+ browser-based access that is
1597
+ </p>
1598
+
1599
+ <p begin="0:18:30.64" end="0:18:35.779">
1600
+ providing data for spectrometry<br/>
1601
+ experiments to a nuclear
1602
+ </p>
1603
+
1604
+ <p begin="0:18:35.779" end="0:18:43.66">
1605
+ engineering program, but the<br/>
1606
+ fact is that iLabs, the
1607
+ </p>
1608
+
1609
+ <p begin="0:18:43.66" end="0:18:49.769">
1610
+ technical architecture, the<br/>
1611
+ framework iLabs, makes labs
1612
+ </p>
1613
+
1614
+ <p begin="0:18:49.769" end="0:18:54.858">
1615
+ available, labs accessible<br/>
1616
+ openly over the internet.
1617
+ </p>
1618
+
1619
+ <p begin="0:18:54.858" end="0:18:58.44">
1620
+ So that's brings a first-time,<br/>
1621
+ hands-on experience to
1622
+ </p>
1623
+
1624
+ <p begin="0:18:58.44" end="0:19:02.588">
1625
+ complement open resources that<br/>
1626
+ might be available in a course.
1627
+ </p>
1628
+
1629
+ <p begin="0:19:02.588" end="0:19:07.24">
1630
+ Now, so you can see, and I<br/>
1631
+ normally talk about this more
1632
+ </p>
1633
+
1634
+ <p begin="0:19:07.24" end="0:19:09.769">
1635
+ than I should, but I'm really<br/>
1636
+ passionate about this.
1637
+ </p>
1638
+
1639
+ <p begin="0:19:09.769" end="0:19:14.24">
1640
+ Because, one of the things that<br/>
1641
+ you find that happens, and this
1642
+ </p>
1643
+
1644
+ <p begin="0:19:14.24" end="0:19:18.99">
1645
+ is a transformative dimension<br/>
1646
+ of this, is that iLabs is not
1647
+ </p>
1648
+
1649
+ <p begin="0:19:18.99" end="0:19:23.058">
1650
+ just about making expensive<br/>
1651
+ equipment, you know, a radio
1652
+ </p>
1653
+
1654
+ <p begin="0:19:23.058" end="0:19:29.38">
1655
+ telescope accessible to people,<br/>
1656
+ you know, but it really alters
1657
+ </p>
1658
+
1659
+ <p begin="0:19:29.38" end="0:19:31.868">
1660
+ the economics of<br/>
1661
+ lab instruction.
1662
+ </p>
1663
+
1664
+ <p begin="0:19:31.868" end="0:19:35.578">
1665
+ Labs are expensive, whether<br/>
1666
+ they're small labs or big labs.
1667
+ </p>
1668
+
1669
+ <p begin="0:19:35.578" end="0:19:38.588">
1670
+ You configure them.<br/>
1671
+ They take time to be configured.
1672
+ </p>
1673
+
1674
+ <p begin="0:19:38.588" end="0:19:40.029">
1675
+ They are one-time installation.<br/>
1676
+
1677
+ </p>
1678
+
1679
+ <p begin="0:19:40.029" end="0:19:41.558">
1680
+ You set it up. You do it.<br/>
1681
+
1682
+ </p>
1683
+
1684
+ <p begin="0:19:41.558" end="0:19:44.308">
1685
+ Then you've got to wait long<br/>
1686
+ time before you set up again.
1687
+ </p>
1688
+
1689
+ <p begin="0:19:44.308" end="0:19:45.7">
1690
+ There's always latency.<br/>
1691
+
1692
+ </p>
1693
+
1694
+ <p begin="0:19:45.7" end="0:19:48.5">
1695
+ I do not know about your<br/>
1696
+ education, but you know,
1697
+ </p>
1698
+
1699
+ <p begin="0:19:48.5" end="0:19:51.16">
1700
+ Monday you got the lecture.<br/>
1701
+
1702
+ </p>
1703
+
1704
+ <p begin="0:19:51.16" end="0:19:53.078">
1705
+ And a couple of weeks<br/>
1706
+ later you did the lab
1707
+ </p>
1708
+
1709
+ <p begin="0:19:53.078" end="0:19:55.75">
1710
+ work or didn't do it.<br/>
1711
+ Solid latency between when you
1712
+ </p>
1713
+
1714
+ <p begin="0:19:55.75" end="0:19:57.868">
1715
+ learned the concept and you<br/>
1716
+ would actually be able
1717
+ </p>
1718
+
1719
+ <p begin="0:19:57.868" end="0:19:59.69">
1720
+ to learn from it.<br/>
1721
+
1722
+ </p>
1723
+
1724
+ <p begin="0:19:59.69" end="0:20:03.769">
1725
+ So it was expensive, you<br/>
1726
+ know, what IT affrays, it
1727
+ </p>
1728
+
1729
+ <p begin="0:20:03.769" end="0:20:06.259">
1730
+ was expensive in terms<br/>
1731
+ of the learner's time.
1732
+ </p>
1733
+
1734
+ <p begin="0:20:06.259" end="0:20:08.259">
1735
+ It was expensive in terms of<br/>
1736
+ the fact that there were
1737
+ </p>
1738
+
1739
+ <p begin="0:20:08.259" end="0:20:14.548">
1740
+ one-time installation, and<br/>
1741
+ suddenly this iLab project
1742
+ </p>
1743
+
1744
+ <p begin="0:20:14.548" end="0:20:18.22">
1745
+ provides the potential to say,<br/>
1746
+ you know, this 24 by 7 access
1747
+ </p>
1748
+
1749
+ <p begin="0:20:18.22" end="0:20:22.48">
1750
+ for this, being able to<br/>
1751
+ leverage a setup much more
1752
+ </p>
1753
+
1754
+ <p begin="0:20:22.48" end="0:20:26.13">
1755
+ extensively, can dramatically<br/>
1756
+ alter the economics of
1757
+ </p>
1758
+
1759
+ <p begin="0:20:26.13" end="0:20:27.798">
1760
+ laboratory instruction.<br/>
1761
+
1762
+ </p>
1763
+
1764
+ <p begin="0:20:27.798" end="0:20:31.098">
1765
+ That is, of course, if you<br/>
1766
+ believe as we do, that
1767
+ </p>
1768
+
1769
+ <p begin="0:20:31.098" end="0:20:34.618">
1770
+ laboratory instruction,<br/>
1771
+ first-hand experiences are a
1772
+ </p>
1773
+
1774
+ <p begin="0:20:34.618" end="0:20:38.45">
1775
+ very important part off the<br/>
1776
+ educational experience.
1777
+ </p>
1778
+
1779
+ <p begin="0:20:38.45" end="0:20:41.4">
1780
+ And you know, there are things<br/>
1781
+ that, we had students here for
1782
+ </p>
1783
+
1784
+ <p begin="0:20:41.4" end="0:20:45.73">
1785
+ one time, I remember, who<br/>
1786
+ wanted to do some experiments
1787
+ </p>
1788
+
1789
+ <p begin="0:20:45.73" end="0:20:47.298">
1790
+ with Compaq's clean labs.<br/>
1791
+
1792
+ </p>
1793
+
1794
+ <p begin="0:20:47.298" end="0:20:50.24">
1795
+ We, Compaq didn't want our<br/>
1796
+ student traipsing all over the
1797
+ </p>
1798
+
1799
+ <p begin="0:20:50.24" end="0:20:53.048">
1800
+ clean labs over there, but the<br/>
1801
+ setup allowed us to do
1802
+ </p>
1803
+
1804
+ <p begin="0:20:53.048" end="0:20:54.95">
1805
+ controlled experiments<br/>
1806
+ in the clean labs.
1807
+ </p>
1808
+
1809
+ <p begin="0:20:54.95" end="0:20:58.048">
1810
+ So you can start imagining<br/>
1811
+ the implications, not only for
1812
+ </p>
1813
+
1814
+ <p begin="0:20:58.048" end="0:21:00.63">
1815
+ formal education, but things<br/>
1816
+ like vocational education,
1817
+ </p>
1818
+
1819
+ <p begin="0:21:00.63" end="0:21:04.38">
1820
+ cannot connect up with<br/>
1821
+ equipment that might
1822
+ </p>
1823
+
1824
+ <p begin="0:21:04.38" end="0:21:05.68">
1825
+ be available industry.<br/>
1826
+
1827
+ </p>
1828
+
1829
+ <p begin="0:21:05.68" end="0:21:10.278">
1830
+ So it has the potential<br/>
1831
+ to dramatically
1832
+ </p>
1833
+
1834
+ <p begin="0:21:10.278" end="0:21:12.74">
1835
+ alter the economics.<br/>
1836
+ Now, again, the interesting
1837
+ </p>
1838
+
1839
+ <p begin="0:21:12.74" end="0:21:17.42">
1840
+ things about iLab and open<br/>
1841
+ iLabs is not the five or six or
1842
+ </p>
1843
+
1844
+ <p begin="0:21:17.42" end="0:21:21.16">
1845
+ seven labs that have been set<br/>
1846
+ up at MIT and being made
1847
+ </p>
1848
+
1849
+ <p begin="0:21:21.16" end="0:21:24.568">
1850
+ accessible, but the fact that<br/>
1851
+ there are labs elsewhere, in
1852
+ </p>
1853
+
1854
+ <p begin="0:21:24.568" end="0:21:28.118">
1855
+ fact, both at the University of<br/>
1856
+ Queensland our colleague,
1857
+ </p>
1858
+
1859
+ <p begin="0:21:28.118" end="0:21:30.99">
1860
+ Phil Hong, who's there.<br/>
1861
+ University of Queensland,
1862
+ </p>
1863
+
1864
+ <p begin="0:21:30.99" end="0:21:35.598">
1865
+ China, they have more labs<br/>
1866
+ in the iLab framework
1867
+ </p>
1868
+
1869
+ <p begin="0:21:35.598" end="0:21:37.529">
1870
+ than actually MIT has.<br/>
1871
+
1872
+ </p>
1873
+
1874
+ <p begin="0:21:37.529" end="0:21:41.588">
1875
+ And so the architecture allows<br/>
1876
+ lab anywhere to be set up.
1877
+ </p>
1878
+
1879
+ <p begin="0:21:41.588" end="0:21:44.68">
1880
+ In fact, for us, the value<br/>
1881
+ proposition is that we might
1882
+ </p>
1883
+
1884
+ <p begin="0:21:44.68" end="0:21:47.65">
1885
+ want our students to access<br/>
1886
+ labs that have been
1887
+ </p>
1888
+
1889
+ <p begin="0:21:47.65" end="0:21:49.308">
1890
+ set up elsewhere.<br/>
1891
+
1892
+ </p>
1893
+
1894
+ <p begin="0:21:49.308" end="0:21:53.4">
1895
+ So that's the value<br/>
1896
+ proposition, and that's where
1897
+ </p>
1898
+
1899
+ <p begin="0:21:53.4" end="0:21:56.608">
1900
+ the openness dimension comes<br/>
1901
+ the open architecture, allows
1902
+ </p>
1903
+
1904
+ <p begin="0:21:56.608" end="0:22:00.45">
1905
+ people to set up labs, big or<br/>
1906
+ small, and make it accessible
1907
+ </p>
1908
+
1909
+ <p begin="0:22:00.45" end="0:22:02.63">
1910
+ to students all over the world.<br/>
1911
+
1912
+ </p>
1913
+
1914
+ <p begin="0:22:02.63" end="0:22:05.2">
1915
+ So, I'm pointing to<br/>
1916
+ a couple of things.
1917
+ </p>
1918
+
1919
+ <p begin="0:22:05.2" end="0:22:07.75">
1920
+ This is done at our office,<br/>
1921
+ at the Office of Educational
1922
+ </p>
1923
+
1924
+ <p begin="0:22:07.75" end="0:22:10.74">
1925
+ Innovation and Technology.<br/>
1926
+ The day before yesterday, Chuck
1927
+ </p>
1928
+
1929
+ <p begin="0:22:10.74" end="0:22:14.89">
1930
+ Schubert, who heads this group<br/>
1931
+ called the Star Group, at, oh
1932
+ </p>
1933
+
1934
+ <p begin="0:22:14.89" end="0:22:17.94">
1935
+ yes, he came and you know, had<br/>
1936
+ me sign a few forms, a whole
1937
+ </p>
1938
+
1939
+ <p begin="0:22:17.94" end="0:22:23.108">
1940
+ bunch of the Star tools for<br/>
1941
+ visualization in biology, in
1942
+ </p>
1943
+
1944
+ <p begin="0:22:23.108" end="0:22:26.22">
1945
+ genetic modeling for genetic<br/>
1946
+ modeling for hydrology, that
1947
+ </p>
1948
+
1949
+ <p begin="0:22:26.22" end="0:22:33.23">
1950
+ had been set up, are now an<br/>
1951
+ open source and made available.
1952
+ </p>
1953
+
1954
+ <p begin="0:22:33.23" end="0:22:34.779">
1955
+ So these are<br/>
1956
+ fantastic simulations.
1957
+ </p>
1958
+
1959
+ <p begin="0:22:34.779" end="0:22:38.65">
1960
+ And why I'm pointing to these<br/>
1961
+ particular ones, because there
1962
+ </p>
1963
+
1964
+ <p begin="0:22:38.65" end="0:22:46.47">
1965
+ is educational, because they<br/>
1966
+ are tied to some very good deep
1967
+ </p>
1968
+
1969
+ <p begin="0:22:46.47" end="0:22:52.029">
1970
+ thinking about tools that are<br/>
1971
+ available openly, and you know,
1972
+ </p>
1973
+
1974
+ <p begin="0:22:52.029" end="0:22:53.838">
1975
+ there are great visualization<br/>
1976
+ tools tools, and
1977
+ </p>
1978
+
1979
+ <p begin="0:22:53.838" end="0:22:55.308">
1980
+ we've all seen them.<br/>
1981
+ They are common.
1982
+ </p>
1983
+
1984
+ <p begin="0:22:55.308" end="0:22:58.759">
1985
+ This is part of a program that<br/>
1986
+ we have at OEIT to bridge
1987
+ </p>
1988
+
1989
+ <p begin="0:22:58.759" end="0:23:01.64">
1990
+ research and learning, to<br/>
1991
+ bring, to provide our
1992
+ </p>
1993
+
1994
+ <p begin="0:23:01.64" end="0:23:04.65">
1995
+ undergraduate students,<br/>
1996
+ first-year students, with early
1997
+ </p>
1998
+
1999
+ <p begin="0:23:04.65" end="0:23:08.338">
2000
+ exposure to research tools, and<br/>
2001
+ the kinds of applications
2002
+ </p>
2003
+
2004
+ <p begin="0:23:08.338" end="0:23:10.92">
2005
+ that typically are only<br/>
2006
+ available to researchers.
2007
+ </p>
2008
+
2009
+ <p begin="0:23:10.92" end="0:23:14.568">
2010
+ And how can we remove the<br/>
2011
+ operational fog from these, so
2012
+ </p>
2013
+
2014
+ <p begin="0:23:14.568" end="0:23:18.519">
2015
+ that first-year students, again<br/>
2016
+ in this case even K through 12
2017
+ </p>
2018
+
2019
+ <p begin="0:23:18.519" end="0:23:21.598">
2020
+ students, can actually<br/>
2021
+ use these tools.
2022
+ </p>
2023
+
2024
+ <p begin="0:23:21.598" end="0:23:25.94">
2025
+ This visualization that is seen<br/>
2026
+ which looks like Justin, who
2027
+ </p>
2028
+
2029
+ <p begin="0:23:25.94" end="0:23:30.4">
2030
+ also works with us, twirling,<br/>
2031
+ you know, when they are
2032
+ </p>
2033
+
2034
+ <p begin="0:23:30.4" end="0:23:33.41">
2035
+ visualizing DNA molecules,<br/>
2036
+ students look at it, They make
2037
+ </p>
2038
+
2039
+ <p begin="0:23:33.41" end="0:23:37.7">
2040
+ conjectures about<br/>
2041
+ it's properties.
2042
+ </p>
2043
+
2044
+ <p begin="0:23:37.7" end="0:23:40.868">
2045
+ They can reach into Cornell's<br/>
2046
+ protein database, make
2047
+ </p>
2048
+
2049
+ <p begin="0:23:40.868" end="0:23:46.23">
2050
+ comparisons now, and so you<br/>
2051
+ provide some very empowering
2052
+ </p>
2053
+
2054
+ <p begin="0:23:46.23" end="0:23:49.97">
2055
+ experiences and exposure to<br/>
2056
+ very big professional tools
2057
+ </p>
2058
+
2059
+ <p begin="0:23:49.97" end="0:23:52.98">
2060
+ and profession thinking, and<br/>
2061
+ provide them the confidence by
2062
+ </p>
2063
+
2064
+ <p begin="0:23:52.98" end="0:23:57.788">
2065
+ creating visualizations like<br/>
2066
+ this, with students can control.
2067
+ </p>
2068
+
2069
+ <p begin="0:23:57.788" end="0:24:02.7">
2070
+ Now these kinds of simulations<br/>
2071
+ of tools are available in the
2072
+ </p>
2073
+
2074
+ <p begin="0:24:02.7" end="0:24:08.068">
2075
+ open, and what lies under them<br/>
2076
+ is a lot of good thinking, hard
2077
+ </p>
2078
+
2079
+ <p begin="0:24:08.068" end="0:24:12.338">
2080
+ problems that certainly are a<br/>
2081
+ faculty of experience, in
2082
+ </p>
2083
+
2084
+ <p begin="0:24:12.338" end="0:24:15.17">
2085
+ bringing research concepts into<br/>
2086
+ learning, because it's all nice
2087
+ </p>
2088
+
2089
+ <p begin="0:24:15.17" end="0:24:18.65">
2090
+ to say, you know, we want to<br/>
2091
+ have lots of proximity between
2092
+ </p>
2093
+
2094
+ <p begin="0:24:18.65" end="0:24:22.38">
2095
+ research and teaching, but to<br/>
2096
+ create tangible, manageable
2097
+ </p>
2098
+
2099
+ <p begin="0:24:22.38" end="0:24:26.97">
2100
+ crosswalks is not easy, and you<br/>
2101
+ do it through these tools, and
2102
+ </p>
2103
+
2104
+ <p begin="0:24:26.97" end="0:24:29.25">
2105
+ then you make these tools<br/>
2106
+ widely available so
2107
+ </p>
2108
+
2109
+ <p begin="0:24:29.25" end="0:24:31.788">
2110
+ that students all over<br/>
2111
+ can benefit from it.
2112
+ </p>
2113
+
2114
+ <p begin="0:24:31.788" end="0:24:32.848">
2115
+ <br/>
2116
+
2117
+ </p>
2118
+
2119
+ <p begin="0:24:32.848" end="0:24:37.91">
2120
+ So, I'm trying to give you a<br/>
2121
+ sense of the kinds of
2122
+ </p>
2123
+
2124
+ <p begin="0:24:37.91" end="0:24:48.328">
2125
+ possibilities, the enablements<br/>
2126
+ that lead to this vision, this
2127
+ </p>
2128
+
2129
+ <p begin="0:24:48.328" end="0:24:52.048">
2130
+ vision that is more advanced<br/>
2131
+ than the current capabilities
2132
+ </p>
2133
+
2134
+ <p begin="0:24:52.048" end="0:24:53.788">
2135
+ that open resources<br/>
2136
+ have created.
2137
+ </p>
2138
+
2139
+ <p begin="0:24:53.788" end="0:24:57.19">
2140
+ Now this is a project, this is<br/>
2141
+ very dear to my friend, Andrew
2142
+ </p>
2143
+
2144
+ <p begin="0:24:57.19" end="0:25:01.788">
2145
+ over there, and he and his<br/>
2146
+ team, and Brandon, they
2147
+ </p>
2148
+
2149
+ <p begin="0:25:01.788" end="0:25:03.818">
2150
+ are all working on this.<br/>
2151
+ This is a project that was
2152
+ </p>
2153
+
2154
+ <p begin="0:25:03.818" end="0:25:07.519">
2155
+ started by a professor<br/>
2156
+ upstairs, a Professor Jim Glass
2157
+ </p>
2158
+
2159
+ <p begin="0:25:07.519" end="0:25:11.99">
2160
+ in Computer Science, and what<br/>
2161
+ it does is it uses natural
2162
+ </p>
2163
+
2164
+ <p begin="0:25:11.99" end="0:25:15.307">
2165
+ language recognition, voice<br/>
2166
+ recognition, summarization.
2167
+ </p>
2168
+
2169
+ <p begin="0:25:15.307" end="0:25:16.38">
2170
+ <br/>
2171
+
2172
+ </p>
2173
+
2174
+ <p begin="0:25:16.38" end="0:25:20.18">
2175
+ And the intent is to provide<br/>
2176
+ very, very acute and good
2177
+ </p>
2178
+
2179
+ <p begin="0:25:20.18" end="0:25:22.66">
2180
+ access to digitized content.<br/>
2181
+
2182
+ </p>
2183
+
2184
+ <p begin="0:25:22.66" end="0:25:30.38">
2185
+ So we have digital video of<br/>
2186
+ lectures and the idea is to go
2187
+ </p>
2188
+
2189
+ <p begin="0:25:30.38" end="0:25:34.24">
2190
+ search these to get particular<br/>
2191
+ snippets of the lectures
2192
+ </p>
2193
+
2194
+ <p begin="0:25:34.24" end="0:25:37.884">
2195
+ that might be relevant.<br/>
2196
+ So, for instance, what you
2197
+ </p>
2198
+
2199
+ <p begin="0:25:37.884" end="0:25:41.009">
2200
+ can't see, probably seen in<br/>
2201
+ the highlight, there's a lot of
2202
+ </p>
2203
+
2204
+ <p begin="0:25:41.009" end="0:25:42.89">
2205
+ angular momentum showing up.<br/>
2206
+
2207
+ </p>
2208
+
2209
+ <p begin="0:25:42.89" end="0:25:46.99">
2210
+ So what we are working on is to<br/>
2211
+ make sure that you can use this
2212
+ </p>
2213
+
2214
+ <p begin="0:25:46.99" end="0:25:52.97">
2215
+ to go and find all those<br/>
2216
+ lecture segments that deal with
2217
+ </p>
2218
+
2219
+ <p begin="0:25:52.97" end="0:25:57.578">
2220
+ angular momentum, because if I<br/>
2221
+ as an instructor, want to
2222
+ </p>
2223
+
2224
+ <p begin="0:25:57.578" end="0:26:00.68">
2225
+ provide some deeper thinking, a<br/>
2226
+ nuance learning around the
2227
+ </p>
2228
+
2229
+ <p begin="0:26:00.68" end="0:26:03.41">
2230
+ notion of angular momentum, I<br/>
2231
+ want to be able to make
2232
+ </p>
2233
+
2234
+ <p begin="0:26:03.41" end="0:26:06.519">
2235
+ sure the students can get<br/>
2236
+ efficiently to that section,
2237
+ </p>
2238
+
2239
+ <p begin="0:26:06.519" end="0:26:09.74">
2240
+ because you know, it might<br/>
2241
+ occur all over the place in the
2242
+ </p>
2243
+
2244
+ <p begin="0:26:09.74" end="0:26:14.42">
2245
+ course of a lecture or in the<br/>
2246
+ course of a 14-week semester,
2247
+ </p>
2248
+
2249
+ <p begin="0:26:14.42" end="0:26:17.098">
2250
+ where this topic might be<br/>
2251
+ treated in different ways, and
2252
+ </p>
2253
+
2254
+ <p begin="0:26:17.098" end="0:26:19.548">
2255
+ you want students to go very,<br/>
2256
+ very efficiently to those
2257
+ </p>
2258
+
2259
+ <p begin="0:26:19.548" end="0:26:21.14">
2260
+ segments and get there.<br/>
2261
+
2262
+ </p>
2263
+
2264
+ <p begin="0:26:21.14" end="0:26:24.44">
2265
+ So the Spoken Lecture Browser<br/>
2266
+ provides very, very -- as it's
2267
+ </p>
2268
+
2269
+ <p begin="0:26:24.44" end="0:26:30.46">
2270
+ named -- browser-based access,<br/>
2271
+ and, but it uses, like I
2272
+ </p>
2273
+
2274
+ <p begin="0:26:30.46" end="0:26:32.21">
2275
+ said, natural language<br/>
2276
+ recognition to get there.
2277
+ </p>
2278
+
2279
+ <p begin="0:26:32.21" end="0:26:34.38">
2280
+ This is a very exciting<br/>
2281
+ project, and what we are trying
2282
+ </p>
2283
+
2284
+ <p begin="0:26:34.38" end="0:26:38.808">
2285
+ to do is see how this can be<br/>
2286
+ really leveraged not only for
2287
+ </p>
2288
+
2289
+ <p begin="0:26:38.808" end="0:26:42.568">
2290
+ video content across our<br/>
2291
+ courses, Andrew and team
2292
+ </p>
2293
+
2294
+ <p begin="0:26:42.568" end="0:26:45.65">
2295
+ are working on a couple of<br/>
2296
+ introductory physics courses.
2297
+ </p>
2298
+
2299
+ <p begin="0:26:45.65" end="0:26:49.39">
2300
+ Some off you might have seen<br/>
2301
+ this dramatic video lecture,
2302
+ </p>
2303
+
2304
+ <p begin="0:26:49.39" end="0:26:51.328">
2305
+ Walter Lewin's lecture<br/>
2306
+ on OpenCourseWare.
2307
+ </p>
2308
+
2309
+ <p begin="0:26:51.328" end="0:26:53.41">
2310
+ He has been featured<br/>
2311
+ on everything from
2312
+ </p>
2313
+
2314
+ <p begin="0:26:53.41" end="0:26:56.078">
2315
+ Jay Leno to NPR.<br/>
2316
+
2317
+ </p>
2318
+
2319
+ <p begin="0:26:56.078" end="0:27:02.19">
2320
+ But, you know, you can get to<br/>
2321
+ segments of Lewin's lecture,
2322
+ </p>
2323
+
2324
+ <p begin="0:27:02.19" end="0:27:05.39">
2325
+ and they're working on that,<br/>
2326
+ because a current instructor,
2327
+ </p>
2328
+
2329
+ <p begin="0:27:05.39" end="0:27:09.14">
2330
+ Peter Dourmashkin, wants his<br/>
2331
+ students to go to particular
2332
+ </p>
2333
+
2334
+ <p begin="0:27:09.14" end="0:27:12.509">
2335
+ concepts, you know, advanced<br/>
2336
+ learning and particular things,
2337
+ </p>
2338
+
2339
+ <p begin="0:27:12.509" end="0:27:18.368">
2340
+ and the spoken lecture, you<br/>
2341
+ know, at OEIT, we are
2342
+ </p>
2343
+
2344
+ <p begin="0:27:18.368" end="0:27:21.38">
2345
+ stabilizing the research work<br/>
2346
+ in the project and enabling
2347
+ </p>
2348
+
2349
+ <p begin="0:27:21.38" end="0:27:22.73">
2350
+ that kind of research.<br/>
2351
+
2352
+ </p>
2353
+
2354
+ <p begin="0:27:22.73" end="0:27:27.298">
2355
+ Our goal is to take it to open<br/>
2356
+ video content that might be
2357
+ </p>
2358
+
2359
+ <p begin="0:27:27.298" end="0:27:30.259">
2360
+ available across, you know,<br/>
2361
+ from different institutions, at
2362
+ </p>
2363
+
2364
+ <p begin="0:27:30.259" end="0:27:32.93">
2365
+ least as a start for all of the<br/>
2366
+ universities that are in the
2367
+ </p>
2368
+
2369
+ <p begin="0:27:32.93" end="0:27:34.23">
2370
+ OpenCourseWare consortium.<br/>
2371
+
2372
+ </p>
2373
+
2374
+ <p begin="0:27:34.23" end="0:27:36.96">
2375
+ So that's, you can see that<br/>
2376
+ kind of enablement, again,
2377
+ </p>
2378
+
2379
+ <p begin="0:27:36.96" end="0:27:41.098">
2380
+ extending that to, this is a<br/>
2381
+ wonderful project, Shakespeare
2382
+ </p>
2383
+
2384
+ <p begin="0:27:41.098" end="0:27:45.19">
2385
+ in Asia, which has got various<br/>
2386
+ renderings of Shakespeare
2387
+ </p>
2388
+
2389
+ <p begin="0:27:45.19" end="0:27:48.73">
2390
+ presentations, video<br/>
2391
+ presentations, and the idea is
2392
+ </p>
2393
+
2394
+ <p begin="0:27:48.73" end="0:27:52.558">
2395
+ to do the same spoken lecture<br/>
2396
+ browser kind of access to this.
2397
+ </p>
2398
+
2399
+ <p begin="0:27:52.558" end="0:27:54.358">
2400
+ Those of you who thought<br/>
2401
+ Shakespeare was deal, he is
2402
+ </p>
2403
+
2404
+ <p begin="0:27:54.358" end="0:27:58.828">
2405
+ just living under an assumed<br/>
2406
+ name, and so, but there's --
2407
+ </p>
2408
+
2409
+ <p begin="0:27:58.828" end="0:28:03.798">
2410
+ but this is yet another --<br/>
2411
+ and I'm showing you these to,
2412
+ </p>
2413
+
2414
+ <p begin="0:28:03.798" end="0:28:06.108">
2415
+ let me give you the<br/>
2416
+ sub-text over here.
2417
+ </p>
2418
+
2419
+ <p begin="0:28:06.108" end="0:28:13.098">
2420
+ The idea of these is, see, that<br/>
2421
+ in order to realize the next
2422
+ </p>
2423
+
2424
+ <p begin="0:28:13.098" end="0:28:15.318">
2425
+ stage of educational<br/>
2426
+ transformation through open
2427
+ </p>
2428
+
2429
+ <p begin="0:28:15.318" end="0:28:21.14">
2430
+ resources, we not only need the<br/>
2431
+ surround off active experience,
2432
+ </p>
2433
+
2434
+ <p begin="0:28:21.14" end="0:28:25.88">
2435
+ we also need the means to go<br/>
2436
+ collectively harvest in useful
2437
+ </p>
2438
+
2439
+ <p begin="0:28:25.88" end="0:28:28.548">
2440
+ educational content<br/>
2441
+ very, very easily.
2442
+ </p>
2443
+
2444
+ <p begin="0:28:28.548" end="0:28:31.64">
2445
+ We want to reduce the barriers<br/>
2446
+ to get to them, and I keep
2447
+ </p>
2448
+
2449
+ <p begin="0:28:31.64" end="0:28:34.368">
2450
+ using the word productively,<br/>
2451
+ because you just don't want to
2452
+ </p>
2453
+
2454
+ <p begin="0:28:34.368" end="0:28:38.535">
2455
+ see and not touch, you want to<br/>
2456
+ see, bring, use, and use in
2457
+ </p>
2458
+
2459
+ <p begin="0:28:38.535" end="0:28:40.029">
2460
+ the fashion that you want.<br/>
2461
+
2462
+ </p>
2463
+
2464
+ <p begin="0:28:40.029" end="0:28:42.13">
2465
+ So, how do you<br/>
2466
+ productively combine them?
2467
+ </p>
2468
+
2469
+ <p begin="0:28:42.13" end="0:28:44.108">
2470
+ Now this was a wonderful<br/>
2471
+ project which sort of
2472
+ </p>
2473
+
2474
+ <p begin="0:28:44.108" end="0:28:47.19">
2475
+ demonstrates that, and it was<br/>
2476
+ built on OKI's open service
2477
+ </p>
2478
+
2479
+ <p begin="0:28:47.19" end="0:28:51.2">
2480
+ interface definition,<br/>
2481
+ the service interfaces.
2482
+ </p>
2483
+
2484
+ <p begin="0:28:51.2" end="0:28:54.779">
2485
+ And this was, Shigeru Miyagawa,<br/>
2486
+ who is the professor in
2487
+ </p>
2488
+
2489
+ <p begin="0:28:54.779" end="0:29:05.22">
2490
+ Linguistics, actually over<br/>
2491
+ here, and he and John Dower,
2492
+ </p>
2493
+
2494
+ <p begin="0:29:05.22" end="0:29:09.22">
2495
+ who is a prize winning,<br/>
2496
+ Pulitzer winning historian,
2497
+ </p>
2498
+
2499
+ <p begin="0:29:09.22" end="0:29:11.858">
2500
+ they created this program<br/>
2501
+ called Visualizing Cultures, by
2502
+ </p>
2503
+
2504
+ <p begin="0:29:11.858" end="0:29:13.98">
2505
+ the way, this is an<br/>
2506
+ OpenCourseWare also.
2507
+ </p>
2508
+
2509
+ <p begin="0:29:13.98" end="0:29:19.2">
2510
+ And it goes, the intent was<br/>
2511
+ to teach history and culture,
2512
+ </p>
2513
+
2514
+ <p begin="0:29:19.2" end="0:29:21.759">
2515
+ expose students to Japanese<br/>
2516
+ history and culture,
2517
+ </p>
2518
+
2519
+ <p begin="0:29:21.759" end="0:29:24.259">
2520
+ through images.<br/>
2521
+ Images that are available in a
2522
+ </p>
2523
+
2524
+ <p begin="0:29:24.259" end="0:29:27.21">
2525
+ variety of repositories, some<br/>
2526
+ in Japan, some of the Museum
2527
+ </p>
2528
+
2529
+ <p begin="0:29:27.21" end="0:29:28.788">
2530
+ of Fine Arts over here.<br/>
2531
+
2532
+ </p>
2533
+
2534
+ <p begin="0:29:28.788" end="0:29:32.48">
2535
+ And the idea was to go, be able<br/>
2536
+ to get these through different
2537
+ </p>
2538
+
2539
+ <p begin="0:29:32.48" end="0:29:33.73">
2540
+ kinds of applications.<br/>
2541
+
2542
+ </p>
2543
+
2544
+ <p begin="0:29:33.73" end="0:29:35.19">
2545
+ <br/>
2546
+
2547
+ </p>
2548
+
2549
+ <p begin="0:29:35.19" end="0:29:37.348">
2550
+ And you know, these<br/>
2551
+ images are fantastic.
2552
+ </p>
2553
+
2554
+ <p begin="0:29:37.348" end="0:29:41.308">
2555
+ For instance, some of them,<br/>
2556
+ which have to do with Commodore
2557
+ </p>
2558
+
2559
+ <p begin="0:29:41.308" end="0:29:45.519">
2560
+ Perry's trips to Japan, and if<br/>
2561
+ you look at them there's a
2562
+ </p>
2563
+
2564
+ <p begin="0:29:45.519" end="0:29:47.558">
2565
+ whole city called Black<br/>
2566
+ Ships and Samurai, now
2567
+ </p>
2568
+
2569
+ <p begin="0:29:47.558" end="0:29:49.538">
2570
+ that you see on top.<br/>
2571
+ And it's very interesting,
2572
+ </p>
2573
+
2574
+ <p begin="0:29:49.538" end="0:29:53.98">
2575
+ because depending on the<br/>
2576
+ relationship that the US had
2577
+ </p>
2578
+
2579
+ <p begin="0:29:53.98" end="0:29:57.89">
2580
+ with Japan, people in Japan<br/>
2581
+ would depict Commodore Perry.
2582
+ </p>
2583
+
2584
+ <p begin="0:29:57.89" end="0:30:00.778">
2585
+ So sometimes you see him<br/>
2586
+ characterized as a nice,
2587
+ </p>
2588
+
2589
+ <p begin="0:30:00.778" end="0:30:02.69">
2590
+ beaming, benevolent fellow,<br/>
2591
+ and sometimes you see
2592
+ </p>
2593
+
2594
+ <p begin="0:30:02.69" end="0:30:05.45">
2595
+ him drawn like an ogre.<br/>
2596
+
2597
+ </p>
2598
+
2599
+ <p begin="0:30:05.45" end="0:30:10.13">
2600
+ And, you know, it's reflective<br/>
2601
+ of the kinds of, the political
2602
+ </p>
2603
+
2604
+ <p begin="0:30:10.13" end="0:30:13.14">
2605
+ dynamics if you will,<br/>
2606
+ of that period.
2607
+ </p>
2608
+
2609
+ <p begin="0:30:13.14" end="0:30:14.288">
2610
+ But anyway, that's<br/>
2611
+ the content part.
2612
+ </p>
2613
+
2614
+ <p begin="0:30:14.288" end="0:30:18.608">
2615
+ The message here for me, from<br/>
2616
+ this slide, which has to do
2617
+ </p>
2618
+
2619
+ <p begin="0:30:18.608" end="0:30:22.17">
2620
+ with materials from Doc<br/>
2621
+ Edgerton, who was the creator
2622
+ </p>
2623
+
2624
+ <p begin="0:30:22.17" end="0:30:25.25">
2625
+ of strobe photography, who<br/>
2626
+ has, you know, wonderful
2627
+ </p>
2628
+
2629
+ <p begin="0:30:25.25" end="0:30:26.73">
2630
+ archive of materials.<br/>
2631
+
2632
+ </p>
2633
+
2634
+ <p begin="0:30:26.73" end="0:30:28.74">
2635
+ It's to say that we want to be<br/>
2636
+ able to say there are good
2637
+ </p>
2638
+
2639
+ <p begin="0:30:28.74" end="0:30:32.42">
2640
+ qualities of resources, rich<br/>
2641
+ media resources out there, and
2642
+ </p>
2643
+
2644
+ <p begin="0:30:32.42" end="0:30:35.39">
2645
+ we want to be able to really<br/>
2646
+ lower the barrier to getting
2647
+ </p>
2648
+
2649
+ <p begin="0:30:35.39" end="0:30:39.298">
2650
+ to these, and getting to these<br/>
2651
+ through different applications.
2652
+ </p>
2653
+
2654
+ <p begin="0:30:39.298" end="0:30:41.43">
2655
+ For instance, here you're<br/>
2656
+ seeing, and this is a
2657
+ </p>
2658
+
2659
+ <p begin="0:30:41.43" end="0:30:44.73">
2660
+ three-year old slide, four-year<br/>
2661
+ old slide, here you are seeing
2662
+ </p>
2663
+
2664
+ <p begin="0:30:44.73" end="0:30:49.88">
2665
+ those images that Shigeru was<br/>
2666
+ using for visualizing cultures,
2667
+ </p>
2668
+
2669
+ <p begin="0:30:49.88" end="0:30:51.71">
2670
+ got through Harvestrodes Hive.<br/>
2671
+
2672
+ </p>
2673
+
2674
+ <p begin="0:30:51.71" end="0:30:55.95">
2675
+ Hive was a Java-based<br/>
2676
+ application.
2677
+ </p>
2678
+
2679
+ <p begin="0:30:55.95" end="0:30:58.44">
2680
+ We had to get to content<br/>
2681
+ from repositories.
2682
+ </p>
2683
+
2684
+ <p begin="0:30:58.44" end="0:31:00.65">
2685
+ You're seeing it accessed<br/>
2686
+ through our course management
2687
+ </p>
2688
+
2689
+ <p begin="0:31:00.65" end="0:31:03.519">
2690
+ system, through a search tool<br/>
2691
+ for the images in our course
2692
+ </p>
2693
+
2694
+ <p begin="0:31:03.519" end="0:31:05.328">
2695
+ management system on the right.<br/>
2696
+
2697
+ </p>
2698
+
2699
+ <p begin="0:31:05.328" end="0:31:08.328">
2700
+ You're seeing it accessed<br/>
2701
+ through the visual
2702
+ </p>
2703
+
2704
+ <p begin="0:31:08.328" end="0:31:11.118">
2705
+ understanding editor, a<br/>
2706
+ concept tool the Tufts
2707
+ </p>
2708
+
2709
+ <p begin="0:31:11.118" end="0:31:12.89">
2710
+ University created.<br/>
2711
+
2712
+ </p>
2713
+
2714
+ <p begin="0:31:12.89" end="0:31:16">
2715
+ So here the idea is that you<br/>
2716
+ can have these, you know,
2717
+ </p>
2718
+
2719
+ <p begin="0:31:16" end="0:31:19.858">
2720
+ wonderful depositories of rich<br/>
2721
+ content to do good things
2722
+ </p>
2723
+
2724
+ <p begin="0:31:19.858" end="0:31:22.838">
2725
+ educationally, but you want to<br/>
2726
+ bring them together, make them
2727
+ </p>
2728
+
2729
+ <p begin="0:31:22.838" end="0:31:29.72">
2730
+ accessible through OEIT of open<br/>
2731
+ or proprietary applications.
2732
+ </p>
2733
+
2734
+ <p begin="0:31:29.72" end="0:31:33.93">
2735
+ And that's the kind of<br/>
2736
+ econological transformation
2737
+ </p>
2738
+
2739
+ <p begin="0:31:33.93" end="0:31:37.154">
2740
+ that we think will lead to the,<br/>
2741
+ at least I believe will lead to
2742
+ </p>
2743
+
2744
+ <p begin="0:31:37.154" end="0:31:38.808">
2745
+ this Metaversity vision.<br/>
2746
+
2747
+ </p>
2748
+
2749
+ <p begin="0:31:38.808" end="0:31:43.009">
2750
+ So, and you created, you know,<br/>
2751
+ you, so, the message that we
2752
+ </p>
2753
+
2754
+ <p begin="0:31:43.009" end="0:31:45.808">
2755
+ hear, it's not just about all<br/>
2756
+ the resources that are being
2757
+ </p>
2758
+
2759
+ <p begin="0:31:45.808" end="0:31:48.558">
2760
+ created openly, but the<br/>
2761
+ technological enablements, and
2762
+ </p>
2763
+
2764
+ <p begin="0:31:48.558" end="0:31:53.098">
2765
+ then as I will point out in a<br/>
2766
+ bit, the organizational
2767
+ </p>
2768
+
2769
+ <p begin="0:31:53.098" end="0:31:57.68">
2770
+ enablements that will allow us<br/>
2771
+ to approach that kind of vision.
2772
+ </p>
2773
+
2774
+ <p begin="0:31:57.68" end="0:32:01.019">
2775
+ So, a lot of the stuff that<br/>
2776
+ I showed you was about deep
2777
+ </p>
2778
+
2779
+ <p begin="0:32:01.019" end="0:32:03.318">
2780
+ learning, subjects and stuff.<br/>
2781
+
2782
+ </p>
2783
+
2784
+ <p begin="0:32:03.318" end="0:32:06.5">
2785
+ The message of open and<br/>
2786
+ transformation is much
2787
+ </p>
2788
+
2789
+ <p begin="0:32:06.5" end="0:32:09.48">
2790
+ bigger than that.<br/>
2791
+ This is also, this is not
2792
+ </p>
2793
+
2794
+ <p begin="0:32:09.48" end="0:32:14.298">
2795
+ just about innovation at a<br/>
2796
+ micro-level, and significant as
2797
+ </p>
2798
+
2799
+ <p begin="0:32:14.298" end="0:32:18.548">
2800
+ it is, it's not about changing<br/>
2801
+ courses or even changing
2802
+ </p>
2803
+
2804
+ <p begin="0:32:18.548" end="0:32:22.368">
2805
+ universities, it is also<br/>
2806
+ about national crusades.
2807
+ </p>
2808
+
2809
+ <p begin="0:32:22.368" end="0:32:27.118">
2810
+ Scott mention that I had the<br/>
2811
+ opportunity to serve as an
2812
+ </p>
2813
+
2814
+ <p begin="0:32:27.118" end="0:32:29.41">
2815
+ advisor to India's National<br/>
2816
+ Knowledge Commission.
2817
+ </p>
2818
+
2819
+ <p begin="0:32:29.41" end="0:32:31.66">
2820
+ India, as most of you know,<br/>
2821
+ is a country in a hurry, you
2822
+ </p>
2823
+
2824
+ <p begin="0:32:31.66" end="0:32:36.24">
2825
+ know, to play in the national,<br/>
2826
+ in the knowledge economy.
2827
+ </p>
2828
+
2829
+ <p begin="0:32:36.24" end="0:32:39.48">
2830
+ And some years ago, you know,<br/>
2831
+ the National Knowledge
2832
+ </p>
2833
+
2834
+ <p begin="0:32:39.48" end="0:32:42.19">
2835
+ Commission was formed by the<br/>
2836
+ Prime Minister to say, how can
2837
+ </p>
2838
+
2839
+ <p begin="0:32:42.19" end="0:32:46.43">
2840
+ we really scale excellence,<br/>
2841
+ provide quality it the scales.
2842
+ </p>
2843
+
2844
+ <p begin="0:32:46.43" end="0:32:50.788">
2845
+ To meet the needs off<br/>
2846
+ this explosive economy?
2847
+ </p>
2848
+
2849
+ <p begin="0:32:50.788" end="0:32:53.538">
2850
+ We need knowledge workers<br/>
2851
+ to build roads, to build
2852
+ </p>
2853
+
2854
+ <p begin="0:32:53.538" end="0:32:57.038">
2855
+ hospitals, to build up, you<br/>
2856
+ know, engineering institutions.
2857
+ </p>
2858
+
2859
+ <p begin="0:32:57.038" end="0:33:01.21">
2860
+ We need doctors, and how can we<br/>
2861
+ provide quality education at
2862
+ </p>
2863
+
2864
+ <p begin="0:33:01.21" end="0:33:04.98">
2865
+ scale, and knowing what I know<br/>
2866
+ about the numbers, you cannot
2867
+ </p>
2868
+
2869
+ <p begin="0:33:04.98" end="0:33:07.108">
2870
+ do it in the traditional way.<br/>
2871
+
2872
+ </p>
2873
+
2874
+ <p begin="0:33:07.108" end="0:33:09.778">
2875
+ Not, you can't do it in the<br/>
2876
+ traditional way you can't build
2877
+ </p>
2878
+
2879
+ <p begin="0:33:09.778" end="0:33:13.769">
2880
+ schools I mean I could give you<br/>
2881
+ statistics, 55 million kids
2882
+ </p>
2883
+
2884
+ <p begin="0:33:13.769" end="0:33:16.828">
2885
+ who come out of primary<br/>
2886
+ education, no place to go.
2887
+ </p>
2888
+
2889
+ <p begin="0:33:16.828" end="0:33:19.23">
2890
+ Even if you built a school<br/>
2891
+ a week, it would not be
2892
+ </p>
2893
+
2894
+ <p begin="0:33:19.23" end="0:33:20.568">
2895
+ able to meet the demand.<br/>
2896
+
2897
+ </p>
2898
+
2899
+ <p begin="0:33:20.568" end="0:33:23.528">
2900
+ There are about 11 institutions<br/>
2901
+ in the Institute of Technology
2902
+ </p>
2903
+
2904
+ <p begin="0:33:23.528" end="0:33:26.65">
2905
+ you could keep, and they<br/>
2906
+ are being added on.
2907
+ </p>
2908
+
2909
+ <p begin="0:33:26.65" end="0:33:31.858">
2910
+ The message is that what the<br/>
2911
+ open education movement offers
2912
+ </p>
2913
+
2914
+ <p begin="0:33:31.858" end="0:33:37.75">
2915
+ is a way of going and being<br/>
2916
+ able to provide that kind of
2917
+ </p>
2918
+
2919
+ <p begin="0:33:37.75" end="0:33:40.279">
2920
+ quality education at<br/>
2921
+ scale efficiently.
2922
+ </p>
2923
+
2924
+ <p begin="0:33:40.279" end="0:33:41.838">
2925
+ <br/>
2926
+
2927
+ </p>
2928
+
2929
+ <p begin="0:33:41.838" end="0:33:44.769">
2930
+ And, therefore, a whole set<br/>
2931
+ of recommendations were made
2932
+ </p>
2933
+
2934
+ <p begin="0:33:44.769" end="0:33:47.21">
2935
+ which are being acted upon,<br/>
2936
+ which have been accepted.
2937
+ </p>
2938
+
2939
+ <p begin="0:33:47.21" end="0:33:50.578">
2940
+ They are part of the Planning<br/>
2941
+ Commission team entirely based
2942
+ </p>
2943
+
2944
+ <p begin="0:33:50.578" end="0:33:58.17">
2945
+ on open education resources,<br/>
2946
+ and again, the model over here,
2947
+ </p>
2948
+
2949
+ <p begin="0:33:58.17" end="0:34:01.39">
2950
+ and this is a real, a very<br/>
2951
+ short-time caricature of
2952
+ </p>
2953
+
2954
+ <p begin="0:34:01.39" end="0:34:04.18">
2955
+ the recommendations that<br/>
2956
+ I'm presenting to you.
2957
+ </p>
2958
+
2959
+ <p begin="0:34:04.18" end="0:34:06.038">
2960
+ Essentially, to say that,<br/>
2961
+ you know, you can have
2962
+ </p>
2963
+
2964
+ <p begin="0:34:06.038" end="0:34:09.3">
2965
+ distributed depositories<br/>
2966
+ of fantastic content.
2967
+ </p>
2968
+
2969
+ <p begin="0:34:09.3" end="0:34:12.199">
2970
+ You can have a very good<br/>
2971
+ technical substrate, which
2972
+ </p>
2973
+
2974
+ <p begin="0:34:12.199" end="0:34:15.579">
2975
+ allows and good applications,<br/>
2976
+ which allows people to harvest
2977
+ </p>
2978
+
2979
+ <p begin="0:34:15.579" end="0:34:21.018">
2980
+ these, and be able to deliver<br/>
2981
+ education to meet the
2982
+ </p>
2983
+
2984
+ <p begin="0:34:21.018" end="0:34:23.099">
2985
+ needs of various sectors.<br/>
2986
+
2987
+ </p>
2988
+
2989
+ <p begin="0:34:23.099" end="0:34:29">
2990
+ Again, in a scalable<br/>
2991
+ and efficient fashion.
2992
+ </p>
2993
+
2994
+ <p begin="0:34:29" end="0:34:33.559">
2995
+ And actually, this particular<br/>
2996
+ slide is because in order to
2997
+ </p>
2998
+
2999
+ <p begin="0:34:33.559" end="0:34:36.539">
3000
+ show that this is not just a<br/>
3001
+ pipe dream, we actually
3002
+ </p>
3003
+
3004
+ <p begin="0:34:36.539" end="0:34:39.03">
3005
+ started building small<br/>
3006
+ applications to show it.
3007
+ </p>
3008
+
3009
+ <p begin="0:34:39.03" end="0:34:44.349">
3010
+ I saw Jeff had just walked in,<br/>
3011
+ Jeff Merrimen, he and I and
3012
+ </p>
3013
+
3014
+ <p begin="0:34:44.349" end="0:34:47.829">
3015
+ some off you might know Stuart<br/>
3016
+ Sim, we actually we're working
3017
+ </p>
3018
+
3019
+ <p begin="0:34:47.829" end="0:34:51.829">
3020
+ with this group called<br/>
3021
+ IUCE, there's an Indo-U.S.
3022
+ </p>
3023
+
3024
+ <p begin="0:34:51.829" end="0:34:54.63">
3025
+ collaboration on engineering<br/>
3026
+ education, and the model was
3027
+ </p>
3028
+
3029
+ <p begin="0:34:54.63" end="0:35:00.21">
3030
+ to see how faculty over here<br/>
3031
+ could, and there, could go
3032
+ </p>
3033
+
3034
+ <p begin="0:35:00.21" end="0:35:03.46">
3035
+ get content from radius<br/>
3036
+ open initiatives from
3037
+ </p>
3038
+
3039
+ <p begin="0:35:03.46" end="0:35:04.71">
3040
+ MIT's OpenCourseWare.<br/>
3041
+
3042
+ </p>
3043
+
3044
+ <p begin="0:35:04.71" end="0:35:05.34">
3045
+ <br/>
3046
+
3047
+ </p>
3048
+
3049
+ <p begin="0:35:05.34" end="0:35:08.489">
3050
+ India has put a lot of its<br/>
3051
+ engineering content, there's
3052
+ </p>
3053
+
3054
+ <p begin="0:35:08.489" end="0:35:13.01">
3055
+ an initiative called NPTEL, The<br/>
3056
+ National Program on Technology
3057
+ </p>
3058
+
3059
+ <p begin="0:35:13.01" end="0:35:19.518">
3060
+ Enabled Learning, which has<br/>
3061
+ put out about 120 -- I
3062
+ </p>
3063
+
3064
+ <p begin="0:35:19.518" end="0:35:22.139">
3065
+ mean it's significant.<br/>
3066
+ All the engineering courses
3067
+ </p>
3068
+
3069
+ <p begin="0:35:22.139" end="0:35:26.86">
3070
+ available through You Tube, and<br/>
3071
+ so what we worked on was trying
3072
+ </p>
3073
+
3074
+ <p begin="0:35:26.86" end="0:35:31.13">
3075
+ to develop a demonstration<br/>
3076
+ which would allow faculty to
3077
+ </p>
3078
+
3079
+ <p begin="0:35:31.13" end="0:35:35.38">
3080
+ get content from OCW, from<br/>
3081
+ NPTEL from Rice University's
3082
+ </p>
3083
+
3084
+ <p begin="0:35:35.38" end="0:35:38.809">
3085
+ connections, and create courses<br/>
3086
+ along with the collaborative
3087
+ </p>
3088
+
3089
+ <p begin="0:35:38.809" end="0:35:41.268">
3090
+ surround, you know we keep it<br/>
3091
+ surround, so that they actually
3092
+ </p>
3093
+
3094
+ <p begin="0:35:41.268" end="0:35:45.61">
3095
+ collaborate, construct the<br/>
3096
+ courses from various resources.
3097
+ </p>
3098
+
3099
+ <p begin="0:35:45.61" end="0:35:47.05">
3100
+ <br/>
3101
+
3102
+ </p>
3103
+
3104
+ <p begin="0:35:47.05" end="0:35:53.9">
3105
+ So that's the value proposition.<br/>
3106
+
3107
+ </p>
3108
+
3109
+ <p begin="0:35:53.9" end="0:35:56.539">
3110
+ If you look at what I have,<br/>
3111
+ when I talk about Metaversity
3112
+ </p>
3113
+
3114
+ <p begin="0:35:56.539" end="0:36:02.11">
3115
+ two, the elements of the open<br/>
3116
+ movement that it really draws
3117
+ </p>
3118
+
3119
+ <p begin="0:36:02.11" end="0:36:09.76">
3120
+ upon is aid that you can have<br/>
3121
+ large, sort of unprecedented
3122
+ </p>
3123
+
3124
+ <p begin="0:36:09.76" end="0:36:14.739">
3125
+ volume of quality resources,<br/>
3126
+ which are available anywhere,
3127
+ </p>
3128
+
3129
+ <p begin="0:36:14.739" end="0:36:18.15">
3130
+ anytime, you know, through<br/>
3131
+ the kinds of enablements
3132
+ </p>
3133
+
3134
+ <p begin="0:36:18.15" end="0:36:19.5">
3135
+ I described.<br/>
3136
+
3137
+ </p>
3138
+
3139
+ <p begin="0:36:19.5" end="0:36:23.949">
3140
+ What's more, because of the way<br/>
3141
+ they are constructed, because,
3142
+ </p>
3143
+
3144
+ <p begin="0:36:23.949" end="0:36:27.159">
3145
+ and the kinds of information<br/>
3146
+ that surrounds them, they
3147
+ </p>
3148
+
3149
+ <p begin="0:36:27.159" end="0:36:29.26">
3150
+ can actually be localized.<br/>
3151
+
3152
+ </p>
3153
+
3154
+ <p begin="0:36:29.26" end="0:36:33.69">
3155
+ And you know, I personally am a<br/>
3156
+ very big believer, you know, we
3157
+ </p>
3158
+
3159
+ <p begin="0:36:33.69" end="0:36:38.44">
3160
+ keep talking about education<br/>
3161
+ being a cottage industry,
3162
+ </p>
3163
+
3164
+ <p begin="0:36:38.44" end="0:36:39.8">
3165
+ as if it was something bad.<br/>
3166
+
3167
+ </p>
3168
+
3169
+ <p begin="0:36:39.8" end="0:36:42.51">
3170
+ I actually believe that it<br/>
3171
+ derives its value from being a
3172
+ </p>
3173
+
3174
+ <p begin="0:36:42.51" end="0:36:45.76">
3175
+ cottage industry, and part of<br/>
3176
+ the challenge that we face is
3177
+ </p>
3178
+
3179
+ <p begin="0:36:45.76" end="0:36:47.659">
3180
+ how can we really make<br/>
3181
+ that cottage industry
3182
+ </p>
3183
+
3184
+ <p begin="0:36:47.659" end="0:36:49.199">
3185
+ thrive efficiency?<br/>
3186
+
3187
+ </p>
3188
+
3189
+ <p begin="0:36:49.199" end="0:36:50.809">
3190
+ <br/>
3191
+
3192
+ </p>
3193
+
3194
+ <p begin="0:36:50.809" end="0:36:53.5">
3195
+ And when I say cottage<br/>
3196
+ industry, it means that a lot
3197
+ </p>
3198
+
3199
+ <p begin="0:36:53.5" end="0:37:01.018">
3200
+ of value is derived locally,<br/>
3201
+ and we need to -- the idea of,
3202
+ </p>
3203
+
3204
+ <p begin="0:37:01.018" end="0:37:03.329">
3205
+ one of the things that the open<br/>
3206
+ education resource movement
3207
+ </p>
3208
+
3209
+ <p begin="0:37:03.329" end="0:37:07.199">
3210
+ offers is that you can have<br/>
3211
+ large pools of shared
3212
+ </p>
3213
+
3214
+ <p begin="0:37:07.199" end="0:37:11.73">
3215
+ resources, without militating<br/>
3216
+ against the localization
3217
+ </p>
3218
+
3219
+ <p begin="0:37:11.73" end="0:37:16.38">
3220
+ that is very important for<br/>
3221
+ good education to happen.
3222
+ </p>
3223
+
3224
+ <p begin="0:37:16.38" end="0:37:19.349">
3225
+ It provides alternatives,<br/>
3226
+ you know, deeper learning,
3227
+ </p>
3228
+
3229
+ <p begin="0:37:19.349" end="0:37:21.8">
3230
+ and I will some examples.<br/>
3231
+
3232
+ </p>
3233
+
3234
+ <p begin="0:37:21.8" end="0:37:25.07">
3235
+ One of the things that it<br/>
3236
+ does allow, and this is not
3237
+ </p>
3238
+
3239
+ <p begin="0:37:25.07" end="0:37:27.8">
3240
+ in my slides, but I will<br/>
3241
+ make a quick mention.
3242
+ </p>
3243
+
3244
+ <p begin="0:37:27.8" end="0:37:30.51">
3245
+ It does allow a lot of feedback.<br/>
3246
+
3247
+ </p>
3248
+
3249
+ <p begin="0:37:30.51" end="0:37:33.639">
3250
+ When we talk about educational<br/>
3251
+ transformation, it's not just
3252
+ </p>
3253
+
3254
+ <p begin="0:37:33.639" end="0:37:38.099">
3255
+ about access and good tools,<br/>
3256
+ but what is the generated
3257
+ </p>
3258
+
3259
+ <p begin="0:37:38.099" end="0:37:42.329">
3260
+ mechanism that you have in<br/>
3261
+ order to improve on what you do?
3262
+ </p>
3263
+
3264
+ <p begin="0:37:42.329" end="0:37:46.03">
3265
+ Now, I remember when<br/>
3266
+ OpenCourseWare was launched,
3267
+ </p>
3268
+
3269
+ <p begin="0:37:46.03" end="0:37:49.739">
3270
+ Shigeru, whom I refer to, now<br/>
3271
+ it's visualizing cultures, he
3272
+ </p>
3273
+
3274
+ <p begin="0:37:49.739" end="0:37:53">
3275
+ had a wonderful statement out<br/>
3276
+ there on our website, the OCW
3277
+ </p>
3278
+
3279
+ <p begin="0:37:53" end="0:37:56.96">
3280
+ websites, which said that, you<br/>
3281
+ know, this is about we, as
3282
+ </p>
3283
+
3284
+ <p begin="0:37:56.96" end="0:37:59.989">
3285
+ educators, we know how to share<br/>
3286
+ our research, but we don't know
3287
+ </p>
3288
+
3289
+ <p begin="0:37:59.989" end="0:38:03.82">
3290
+ how to share our pedagogy<br/>
3291
+ for critical review.
3292
+ </p>
3293
+
3294
+ <p begin="0:38:03.82" end="0:38:07.17">
3295
+ Now, if you think about it for<br/>
3296
+ a second, what you really do
3297
+ </p>
3298
+
3299
+ <p begin="0:38:07.17" end="0:38:09.469">
3300
+ through OpenCourseWare is<br/>
3301
+ you say, look, this
3302
+ </p>
3303
+
3304
+ <p begin="0:38:09.469" end="0:38:11.829">
3305
+ is how we teach. Have at it.<br/>
3306
+
3307
+ </p>
3308
+
3309
+ <p begin="0:38:11.829" end="0:38:13.429">
3310
+ Tell us what you can do.<br/>
3311
+
3312
+ </p>
3313
+
3314
+ <p begin="0:38:13.429" end="0:38:19.449">
3315
+ So that's, and if you can have<br/>
3316
+ the means to incorporate that
3317
+ </p>
3318
+
3319
+ <p begin="0:38:19.449" end="0:38:23.96">
3320
+ feedback that people might give<br/>
3321
+ you into continuously improving
3322
+ </p>
3323
+
3324
+ <p begin="0:38:23.96" end="0:38:26.139">
3325
+ your courses, good<br/>
3326
+ things can happen.
3327
+ </p>
3328
+
3329
+ <p begin="0:38:26.139" end="0:38:28.55">
3330
+ And there's a very good<br/>
3331
+ demonstration of this.
3332
+ </p>
3333
+
3334
+ <p begin="0:38:28.55" end="0:38:31.4">
3335
+ Carnegie Mellon has set up this<br/>
3336
+ thing called, they have this
3337
+ </p>
3338
+
3339
+ <p begin="0:38:31.4" end="0:38:36.079">
3340
+ initiative called the Open<br/>
3341
+ Learning Initiative, OLI, and
3342
+ </p>
3343
+
3344
+ <p begin="0:38:36.079" end="0:38:40.239">
3345
+ there's a statistics course<br/>
3346
+ where they have created, which
3347
+ </p>
3348
+
3349
+ <p begin="0:38:40.239" end="0:38:42.699">
3350
+ allows the community to give<br/>
3351
+ feedback, and then that's
3352
+ </p>
3353
+
3354
+ <p begin="0:38:42.699" end="0:38:47.079">
3355
+ incorporated into the into the<br/>
3356
+ course segments themselves, and
3357
+ </p>
3358
+
3359
+ <p begin="0:38:47.079" end="0:38:51.739">
3360
+ what they've found was that<br/>
3361
+ they had a learning gain of
3362
+ </p>
3363
+
3364
+ <p begin="0:38:51.739" end="0:38:54.829">
3365
+ 50% in the delivery of the<br/>
3366
+ statistics course, and I'll
3367
+ </p>
3368
+
3369
+ <p begin="0:38:54.829" end="0:38:58.07">
3370
+ tell you what that means.<br/>
3371
+ What it means is that coverage,
3372
+ </p>
3373
+
3374
+ <p begin="0:38:58.07" end="0:39:02.789">
3375
+ which they would have had, and<br/>
3376
+ without sacrificing quality,
3377
+ </p>
3378
+
3379
+ <p begin="0:39:02.789" end="0:39:06.07">
3380
+ the time to deliver that course<br/>
3381
+ was, for the same learning
3382
+ </p>
3383
+
3384
+ <p begin="0:39:06.07" end="0:39:08.789">
3385
+ games, was decreased by 50%.<br/>
3386
+
3387
+ </p>
3388
+
3389
+ <p begin="0:39:08.789" end="0:39:10.268">
3390
+ Now that is significant.<br/>
3391
+
3392
+ </p>
3393
+
3394
+ <p begin="0:39:10.268" end="0:39:13.579">
3395
+ That is transubmitive,<br/>
3396
+ and we are not, and this
3397
+ </p>
3398
+
3399
+ <p begin="0:39:13.579" end="0:39:14.409">
3400
+ is well written about.<br/>
3401
+
3402
+ </p>
3403
+
3404
+ <p begin="0:39:14.409" end="0:39:15.869">
3405
+ In fact, Candice [? Till ?]<br/>
3406
+
3407
+ </p>
3408
+
3409
+ <p begin="0:39:15.869" end="0:39:17.989">
3410
+ still has written about<br/>
3411
+ this in the book, that
3412
+ </p>
3413
+
3414
+ <p begin="0:39:17.989" end="0:39:20.429">
3415
+ we, according to, that<br/>
3416
+ Scott was referring to.
3417
+ </p>
3418
+
3419
+ <p begin="0:39:20.429" end="0:39:24.385">
3420
+ So there's this dimension of<br/>
3421
+ collected improvement and
3422
+ </p>
3423
+
3424
+ <p begin="0:39:24.385" end="0:39:27.989">
3425
+ feedback, both at the micro<br/>
3426
+ level and at the macro level
3427
+ </p>
3428
+
3429
+ <p begin="0:39:27.989" end="0:39:30.17">
3430
+ that is really, really<br/>
3431
+ important when you think
3432
+ </p>
3433
+
3434
+ <p begin="0:39:30.17" end="0:39:34.84">
3435
+ about transformation that's<br/>
3436
+ afforded by open education.
3437
+ </p>
3438
+
3439
+ <p begin="0:39:34.84" end="0:39:36.92">
3440
+ So all that's fine.<br/>
3441
+
3442
+ </p>
3443
+
3444
+ <p begin="0:39:36.92" end="0:39:39.139">
3445
+ When I think about possibility<br/>
3446
+ as a signal, there are two
3447
+ </p>
3448
+
3449
+ <p begin="0:39:39.139" end="0:39:42.789">
3450
+ dimensions that are really<br/>
3451
+ important that we all talk
3452
+ </p>
3453
+
3454
+ <p begin="0:39:42.789" end="0:39:45.119">
3455
+ about, which are<br/>
3456
+ enabled by this.
3457
+ </p>
3458
+
3459
+ <p begin="0:39:45.119" end="0:39:49.159">
3460
+ One which I loosely call<br/>
3461
+ blended learning opportunities.
3462
+ </p>
3463
+
3464
+ <p begin="0:39:49.159" end="0:39:53.239">
3465
+ And what openness allows is<br/>
3466
+ really, and this again speaks
3467
+ </p>
3468
+
3469
+ <p begin="0:39:53.239" end="0:39:56.8">
3470
+ to the context of setting<br/>
3471
+ statements that Scott was
3472
+ </p>
3473
+
3474
+ <p begin="0:39:56.8" end="0:40:01.119">
3475
+ making allows us to really<br/>
3476
+ look at possibilities for
3477
+ </p>
3478
+
3479
+ <p begin="0:40:01.119" end="0:40:04.32">
3480
+ intelligently combining the<br/>
3481
+ physical and the virtual.
3482
+ </p>
3483
+
3484
+ <p begin="0:40:04.32" end="0:40:07.36">
3485
+ How we might, you know, the<br/>
3486
+ highlight example for this, how
3487
+ </p>
3488
+
3489
+ <p begin="0:40:07.36" end="0:40:14.219">
3490
+ might we combine what we know<br/>
3491
+ as good practices and situated
3492
+ </p>
3493
+
3494
+ <p begin="0:40:14.219" end="0:40:16.739">
3495
+ learning, the kinds of<br/>
3496
+ authentic learning experiences
3497
+ </p>
3498
+
3499
+ <p begin="0:40:16.739" end="0:40:18.219">
3500
+ that we provide in<br/>
3501
+ this situation.
3502
+ </p>
3503
+
3504
+ <p begin="0:40:18.219" end="0:40:21.92">
3505
+ The labs, with what might<br/>
3506
+ be digitally available,
3507
+ </p>
3508
+
3509
+ <p begin="0:40:21.92" end="0:40:24.059">
3510
+ online available.<br/>
3511
+ So it purely provides
3512
+ </p>
3513
+
3514
+ <p begin="0:40:24.059" end="0:40:31.05">
3515
+ opportunities to mix and melt<br/>
3516
+ the best of good worlds, and
3517
+ </p>
3518
+
3519
+ <p begin="0:40:31.05" end="0:40:34.989">
3520
+ to be able to localize it.<br/>
3521
+ And this is being done.
3522
+ </p>
3523
+
3524
+ <p begin="0:40:34.989" end="0:40:41.429">
3525
+ This is not something that came<br/>
3526
+ out of some lazy exercise in
3527
+ </p>
3528
+
3529
+ <p begin="0:40:41.429" end="0:40:45.469">
3530
+ -- what shall I say, on<br/>
3531
+ controlled substances.
3532
+ </p>
3533
+
3534
+ <p begin="0:40:45.469" end="0:40:49.809">
3535
+ This is the kind of stuff that<br/>
3536
+ has been practiced, developed,
3537
+ </p>
3538
+
3539
+ <p begin="0:40:49.809" end="0:40:53.13">
3540
+ and demonstrated you know,<br/>
3541
+ through things like iLabs that
3542
+ </p>
3543
+
3544
+ <p begin="0:40:53.13" end="0:40:56.889">
3545
+ I'm talking about, and we have<br/>
3546
+ to start looking at these
3547
+ </p>
3548
+
3549
+ <p begin="0:40:56.889" end="0:40:58.34">
3550
+ for transformation.<br/>
3551
+
3552
+ </p>
3553
+
3554
+ <p begin="0:40:58.34" end="0:41:01.73">
3555
+ You know, the combining the<br/>
3556
+ formal and the non-formal here,
3557
+ </p>
3558
+
3559
+ <p begin="0:41:01.73" end="0:41:04.719">
3560
+ for instance, we are thinking,<br/>
3561
+ how can we use co-curricular
3562
+ </p>
3563
+
3564
+ <p begin="0:41:04.719" end="0:41:09.92">
3565
+ experiences and combine them<br/>
3566
+ with, you know, as good
3567
+ </p>
3568
+
3569
+ <p begin="0:41:09.92" end="0:41:12.48">
3570
+ substitutes for authentic<br/>
3571
+ learning experiences.
3572
+ </p>
3573
+
3574
+ <p begin="0:41:12.48" end="0:41:17.739">
3575
+ These are the enablements of<br/>
3576
+ open, given the very generous
3577
+ </p>
3578
+
3579
+ <p begin="0:41:17.739" end="0:41:20.59">
3580
+ definition of open that I<br/>
3581
+ provided here, you know,
3582
+ </p>
3583
+
3584
+ <p begin="0:41:20.59" end="0:41:24.17">
3585
+ about open technology, open<br/>
3586
+ content, and open knowledge.
3587
+ </p>
3588
+
3589
+ <p begin="0:41:24.17" end="0:41:30.699">
3590
+ The other really value element,<br/>
3591
+ value vision element for me
3592
+ </p>
3593
+
3594
+ <p begin="0:41:30.699" end="0:41:32.73">
3595
+ is boundary-less education.<br/>
3596
+
3597
+ </p>
3598
+
3599
+ <p begin="0:41:32.73" end="0:41:35.98">
3600
+ And again, this is not about<br/>
3601
+ traditional boundaries,
3602
+ </p>
3603
+
3604
+ <p begin="0:41:35.98" end="0:41:39.139">
3605
+ geopolitical boundaries, some<br/>
3606
+ of which is true, like in the
3607
+ </p>
3608
+
3609
+ <p begin="0:41:39.139" end="0:41:43.75">
3610
+ IUCEE example I gave, but even<br/>
3611
+ boundaries between disciplines.
3612
+ </p>
3613
+
3614
+ <p begin="0:41:43.75" end="0:41:48.079">
3615
+ If you go to the OpenCourseWare<br/>
3616
+ site, you will see some new
3617
+ </p>
3618
+
3619
+ <p begin="0:41:48.079" end="0:41:51.449">
3620
+ programs that have been<br/>
3621
+ launched for energy
3622
+ </p>
3623
+
3624
+ <p begin="0:41:51.449" end="0:41:53.449">
3625
+ studies, right?<br/>
3626
+
3627
+ </p>
3628
+
3629
+ <p begin="0:41:53.449" end="0:41:57.53">
3630
+ And these are being possible,<br/>
3631
+ made possible, some of these
3632
+ </p>
3633
+
3634
+ <p begin="0:41:57.53" end="0:42:00.539">
3635
+ boundaries are diminishing our<br/>
3636
+ ability to leverage, content is
3637
+ </p>
3638
+
3639
+ <p begin="0:42:00.539" end="0:42:03.909">
3640
+ happening, because the<br/>
3641
+ substance of the component
3642
+ </p>
3643
+
3644
+ <p begin="0:42:03.909" end="0:42:06.57">
3645
+ courses are becoming visible,<br/>
3646
+ and people are being able to
3647
+ </p>
3648
+
3649
+ <p begin="0:42:06.57" end="0:42:09.57">
3650
+ see much more finely where<br/>
3651
+ there might be substitutions,
3652
+ </p>
3653
+
3654
+ <p begin="0:42:09.57" end="0:42:12.679">
3655
+ where there might be<br/>
3656
+ opportunities to have compounds
3657
+ </p>
3658
+
3659
+ <p begin="0:42:12.679" end="0:42:17.73">
3660
+ of these courses to lead to new<br/>
3661
+ programs that transcend
3662
+ </p>
3663
+
3664
+ <p begin="0:42:17.73" end="0:42:21.219">
3665
+ disciplinary boundaries or<br/>
3666
+ department boundaries.
3667
+ </p>
3668
+
3669
+ <p begin="0:42:21.219" end="0:42:24.11">
3670
+ I could give you other<br/>
3671
+ examples with there is
3672
+ </p>
3673
+
3674
+ <p begin="0:42:24.11" end="0:42:27.38">
3675
+ boundary-less-ness being<br/>
3676
+ experienced where the boundary
3677
+ </p>
3678
+
3679
+ <p begin="0:42:27.38" end="0:42:32.15">
3680
+ between research learnings and<br/>
3681
+ the lay person is
3682
+ </p>
3683
+
3684
+ <p begin="0:42:32.15" end="0:42:33.48">
3685
+ being diminished.<br/>
3686
+
3687
+ </p>
3688
+
3689
+ <p begin="0:42:33.48" end="0:42:35.929">
3690
+ Neeru Paharia, she's is of<br/>
3691
+ the Graduate Business School
3692
+ </p>
3693
+
3694
+ <p begin="0:42:35.929" end="0:42:37.59">
3695
+ over here at Harvard.<br/>
3696
+
3697
+ </p>
3698
+
3699
+ <p begin="0:42:37.59" end="0:42:42.94">
3700
+ She used to be Director of<br/>
3701
+ Creative Commons, so she has
3702
+ </p>
3703
+
3704
+ <p begin="0:42:42.94" end="0:42:47.239">
3705
+ worked on something called<br/>
3706
+ Acawiki, A C A W I K I, where
3707
+ </p>
3708
+
3709
+ <p begin="0:42:47.239" end="0:42:50.869">
3710
+ actually people go in and<br/>
3711
+ provide sense-making documents
3712
+ </p>
3713
+
3714
+ <p begin="0:42:50.869" end="0:42:55.71">
3715
+ for the lay people, you and I,<br/>
3716
+ who fund research, to have, to
3717
+ </p>
3718
+
3719
+ <p begin="0:42:55.71" end="0:42:59.768">
3720
+ understand research, again, to<br/>
3721
+ take away the divide between,
3722
+ </p>
3723
+
3724
+ <p begin="0:42:59.768" end="0:43:03.61">
3725
+ to diminish the divide between<br/>
3726
+ research and lay people.
3727
+ </p>
3728
+
3729
+ <p begin="0:43:03.61" end="0:43:06.989">
3730
+ So there's a lot of<br/>
3731
+ boundary-less-ness that can
3732
+ </p>
3733
+
3734
+ <p begin="0:43:06.989" end="0:43:10.34">
3735
+ being enabled through openness.<br/>
3736
+
3737
+ </p>
3738
+
3739
+ <p begin="0:43:10.34" end="0:43:11.86">
3740
+ <br/>
3741
+
3742
+ </p>
3743
+
3744
+ <p begin="0:43:11.86" end="0:43:16.5">
3745
+ So I'm going to start, this<br/>
3746
+ is my, sort of getting to my
3747
+ </p>
3748
+
3749
+ <p begin="0:43:16.5" end="0:43:18.98">
3750
+ closing statements over here.<br/>
3751
+
3752
+ </p>
3753
+
3754
+ <p begin="0:43:18.98" end="0:43:21.289">
3755
+ We have this movement, and you<br/>
3756
+ say, well, you know, here's
3757
+ </p>
3758
+
3759
+ <p begin="0:43:21.289" end="0:43:23.73">
3760
+ this guy, he's talking about<br/>
3761
+ all these wonderful
3762
+ </p>
3763
+
3764
+ <p begin="0:43:23.73" end="0:43:26.929">
3765
+ possibilities, and like I<br/>
3766
+ said, you know, this
3767
+ </p>
3768
+
3769
+ <p begin="0:43:26.929" end="0:43:28.21">
3770
+ is not a pipe dream.<br/>
3771
+
3772
+ </p>
3773
+
3774
+ <p begin="0:43:28.21" end="0:43:35.46">
3775
+ How do we interpret pipe, b but<br/>
3776
+ it's born out of really looking
3777
+ </p>
3778
+
3779
+ <p begin="0:43:35.46" end="0:43:39.88">
3780
+ at some markers, some of the<br/>
3781
+ significant influences that
3782
+ </p>
3783
+
3784
+ <p begin="0:43:39.88" end="0:43:43.69">
3785
+ are around us, that give me<br/>
3786
+ comfort, give me solid hope.
3787
+ </p>
3788
+
3789
+ <p begin="0:43:43.69" end="0:43:47.829">
3790
+ You know, and some of it is<br/>
3791
+ because many of us in this
3792
+ </p>
3793
+
3794
+ <p begin="0:43:47.829" end="0:43:52.21">
3795
+ room are invested and engaged<br/>
3796
+ in these initiatives.
3797
+ </p>
3798
+
3799
+ <p begin="0:43:52.21" end="0:43:55.949">
3800
+ So one significant category of<br/>
3801
+ significant influence I've
3802
+ </p>
3803
+
3804
+ <p begin="0:43:55.949" end="0:43:58.75">
3805
+ already talked a lot about, is<br/>
3806
+ the fact that there's a lot of
3807
+ </p>
3808
+
3809
+ <p begin="0:43:58.75" end="0:44:00.8">
3810
+ open content, there is<br/>
3811
+ good open technology
3812
+ </p>
3813
+
3814
+ <p begin="0:44:00.8" end="0:44:03.389">
3815
+ initiatives going on.<br/>
3816
+
3817
+ </p>
3818
+
3819
+ <p begin="0:44:03.389" end="0:44:08.159">
3820
+ Good design, and I mean<br/>
3821
+ this both in terms of
3822
+ </p>
3823
+
3824
+ <p begin="0:44:08.159" end="0:44:10.19">
3825
+ organization and technology.<br/>
3826
+
3827
+ </p>
3828
+
3829
+ <p begin="0:44:10.19" end="0:44:13.699">
3830
+ I particularly like to talk<br/>
3831
+ about my pet initiative, the
3832
+ </p>
3833
+
3834
+ <p begin="0:44:13.699" end="0:44:17.929">
3835
+ open knowledge initiative,<br/>
3836
+ which allows this kind of, you
3837
+ </p>
3838
+
3839
+ <p begin="0:44:17.929" end="0:44:21.73">
3840
+ know, Scott referred to it as<br/>
3841
+ disaggregation, which allows
3842
+ </p>
3843
+
3844
+ <p begin="0:44:21.73" end="0:44:23.835">
3845
+ different players, different<br/>
3846
+ qualities, different
3847
+ </p>
3848
+
3849
+ <p begin="0:44:23.835" end="0:44:25.739">
3850
+ strengths to play.<br/>
3851
+ So, there are design
3852
+ </p>
3853
+
3854
+ <p begin="0:44:25.739" end="0:44:30.03">
3855
+ enablers, and design is a<br/>
3856
+ very important consideration.
3857
+ </p>
3858
+
3859
+ <p begin="0:44:30.03" end="0:44:33.309">
3860
+ But there are legal enablers,<br/>
3861
+ creative commons, for instance,
3862
+ </p>
3863
+
3864
+ <p begin="0:44:33.309" end="0:44:39.969">
3865
+ which, you know, so which give<br/>
3866
+ me hope that this vision of
3867
+ </p>
3868
+
3869
+ <p begin="0:44:39.969" end="0:44:46.489">
3870
+ Metaversity II is, indeed,<br/>
3871
+ realizable and can be reaffied.
3872
+ </p>
3873
+
3874
+ <p begin="0:44:46.489" end="0:44:49.55">
3875
+ But there are two dimensions<br/>
3876
+ which I have not touch upon
3877
+ </p>
3878
+
3879
+ <p begin="0:44:49.55" end="0:44:52.67">
3880
+ which I'll quickly tell you.<br/>
3881
+ One is institutional
3882
+ </p>
3883
+
3884
+ <p begin="0:44:52.67" end="0:44:56.42">
3885
+ commitment.<br/>
3886
+ And some of the institutional
3887
+ </p>
3888
+
3889
+ <p begin="0:44:56.42" end="0:44:58.389">
3890
+ commitment is expressed<br/>
3891
+ through communities
3892
+ </p>
3893
+
3894
+ <p begin="0:44:58.389" end="0:44:59.969">
3895
+ that are being created.<br/>
3896
+
3897
+ </p>
3898
+
3899
+ <p begin="0:44:59.969" end="0:45:03.82">
3900
+ The Sakai community,<br/>
3901
+ consortia around iLabs
3902
+ </p>
3903
+
3904
+ <p begin="0:45:03.82" end="0:45:06.96">
3905
+ that are being built.<br/>
3906
+ The groups that meet around OKI.
3907
+ </p>
3908
+
3909
+ <p begin="0:45:06.96" end="0:45:11.32">
3910
+ So these are expressions of<br/>
3911
+ institutional commitment around
3912
+ </p>
3913
+
3914
+ <p begin="0:45:11.32" end="0:45:15.25">
3915
+ things open that are forming,<br/>
3916
+ which so which are really
3917
+ </p>
3918
+
3919
+ <p begin="0:45:15.25" end="0:45:18.789">
3920
+ becoming the building<br/>
3921
+ blocks for this open
3922
+ </p>
3923
+
3924
+ <p begin="0:45:18.789" end="0:45:21.405">
3925
+ education movement.<br/>
3926
+ There is another kind, which I
3927
+ </p>
3928
+
3929
+ <p begin="0:45:21.405" end="0:45:24.13">
3930
+ really pointed to, and I had a<br/>
3931
+ bunch of slides, and I think
3932
+ </p>
3933
+
3934
+ <p begin="0:45:24.13" end="0:45:27.768">
3935
+ they got finished by today's<br/>
3936
+ web page from MIT that I
3937
+ </p>
3938
+
3939
+ <p begin="0:45:27.768" end="0:45:31.05">
3940
+ showed you, which is a real<br/>
3941
+ expression of MIT commitment.
3942
+ </p>
3943
+
3944
+ <p begin="0:45:31.05" end="0:45:35.44">
3945
+ The slides I was going to show<br/>
3946
+ you, which are really, have to
3947
+ </p>
3948
+
3949
+ <p begin="0:45:35.44" end="0:45:40.139">
3950
+ do with the fact that MIT<br/>
3951
+ expressed its initial, its
3952
+ </p>
3953
+
3954
+ <p begin="0:45:40.139" end="0:45:43.51">
3955
+ institutional commitment to<br/>
3956
+ OpenCourseWare through a lot a
3957
+ </p>
3958
+
3959
+ <p begin="0:45:43.51" end="0:45:46.289">
3960
+ strategic thinking that<br/>
3961
+ preceded the launch of
3962
+ </p>
3963
+
3964
+ <p begin="0:45:46.289" end="0:45:49.849">
3965
+ OpenCourseWare, it's current<br/>
3966
+ commitment to it, right?
3967
+ </p>
3968
+
3969
+ <p begin="0:45:49.849" end="0:45:55.25">
3970
+ And to openness, as expressed<br/>
3971
+ wonderfully by, you know,
3972
+ </p>
3973
+
3974
+ <p begin="0:45:55.25" end="0:45:56.929">
3975
+ by today's web page.<br/>
3976
+
3977
+ </p>
3978
+
3979
+ <p begin="0:45:56.929" end="0:45:59.699">
3980
+ And there is a second dimension<br/>
3981
+ off this, there is another
3982
+ </p>
3983
+
3984
+ <p begin="0:45:59.699" end="0:46:03.699">
3985
+ aspect which is on the<br/>
3986
+ collectivity culture, and you
3987
+ </p>
3988
+
3989
+ <p begin="0:46:03.699" end="0:46:06.32">
3990
+ see that, you know, through the<br/>
3991
+ Wikis, the blogs, the
3992
+ </p>
3993
+
3994
+ <p begin="0:46:06.32" end="0:46:10.5">
3995
+ distributed culture, all the<br/>
3996
+ tools and artifacts of
3997
+ </p>
3998
+
3999
+ <p begin="0:46:10.5" end="0:46:14.61">
4000
+ the digital natives that<br/>
4001
+ Scott was talking about.
4002
+ </p>
4003
+
4004
+ <p begin="0:46:14.61" end="0:46:17.01">
4005
+ So very quickly, some things<br/>
4006
+ about MIT's institutional
4007
+ </p>
4008
+
4009
+ <p begin="0:46:17.01" end="0:46:19.289">
4010
+ commitments.<br/>
4011
+ Like I said, OpenCourseWare
4012
+ </p>
4013
+
4014
+ <p begin="0:46:19.289" end="0:46:21.88">
4015
+ was preceded by a lot<br/>
4016
+ of strategic thinking.
4017
+ </p>
4018
+
4019
+ <p begin="0:46:21.88" end="0:46:24.889">
4020
+ You know, we had this Counsel<br/>
4021
+ on Education Technology, and
4022
+ </p>
4023
+
4024
+ <p begin="0:46:24.889" end="0:46:27.579">
4025
+ there was a particular<br/>
4026
+ strategic thrust around
4027
+ </p>
4028
+
4029
+ <p begin="0:46:27.579" end="0:46:30.809">
4030
+ bolstering the commons<br/>
4031
+ off the mind, you know.
4032
+ </p>
4033
+
4034
+ <p begin="0:46:30.809" end="0:46:35.239">
4035
+ Nice words chosen by Hal<br/>
4036
+ Abelson, who was, you know,
4037
+ </p>
4038
+
4039
+ <p begin="0:46:35.239" end="0:46:38.26">
4040
+ who was a leader in education<br/>
4041
+ technology over here at MIT.
4042
+ </p>
4043
+
4044
+ <p begin="0:46:38.26" end="0:46:41.659">
4045
+ <br/>
4046
+
4047
+ </p>
4048
+
4049
+ <p begin="0:46:41.659" end="0:46:44.07">
4050
+ And we had a lot of strategies<br/>
4051
+ around active learning, which
4052
+ </p>
4053
+
4054
+ <p begin="0:46:44.07" end="0:46:48.01">
4055
+ led to all kinds of initiatives<br/>
4056
+ like, you know, TEAL
4057
+ </p>
4058
+
4059
+ <p begin="0:46:48.01" end="0:46:50.349">
4060
+ and iLab and so on.<br/>
4061
+
4062
+ </p>
4063
+
4064
+ <p begin="0:46:50.349" end="0:46:54.579">
4065
+ But the strategy around<br/>
4066
+ intellectual commons was what
4067
+ </p>
4068
+
4069
+ <p begin="0:46:54.579" end="0:46:58.09">
4070
+ was an expression of MIT's<br/>
4071
+ institutional commitment
4072
+ </p>
4073
+
4074
+ <p begin="0:46:58.09" end="0:46:59.739">
4075
+ to things open.<br/>
4076
+
4077
+ </p>
4078
+
4079
+ <p begin="0:46:59.739" end="0:47:04.48">
4080
+ In fact, at that time, and<br/>
4081
+ these slides are dated, you
4082
+ </p>
4083
+
4084
+ <p begin="0:47:04.48" end="0:47:09.909">
4085
+ know, they're circa 2004, but<br/>
4086
+ these initiatives that were
4087
+ </p>
4088
+
4089
+ <p begin="0:47:09.909" end="0:47:12.96">
4090
+ launched were part of an<br/>
4091
+ institutional strategy and
4092
+ </p>
4093
+
4094
+ <p begin="0:47:12.96" end="0:47:15.559">
4095
+ the present MIT's commitment.<br/>
4096
+
4097
+ </p>
4098
+
4099
+ <p begin="0:47:15.559" end="0:47:22.719">
4100
+ This base, which is a very,<br/>
4101
+ very big base, to the website
4102
+ </p>
4103
+
4104
+ <p begin="0:47:22.719" end="0:47:26.969">
4105
+ announcement that you saw about<br/>
4106
+ open access to research, OKI
4107
+ </p>
4108
+
4109
+ <p begin="0:47:26.969" end="0:47:28.789">
4110
+ that you've heard about,<br/>
4111
+ OpenCourseWare that I
4112
+ </p>
4113
+
4114
+ <p begin="0:47:28.789" end="0:47:31.5">
4115
+ need not speak about.<br/>
4116
+ So, the institutional
4117
+ </p>
4118
+
4119
+ <p begin="0:47:31.5" end="0:47:36.239">
4120
+ commitment was because it was<br/>
4121
+ seen as important elements of
4122
+ </p>
4123
+
4124
+ <p begin="0:47:36.239" end="0:47:38.889">
4125
+ educational strategy at MIT.<br/>
4126
+
4127
+ </p>
4128
+
4129
+ <p begin="0:47:38.889" end="0:47:44.579">
4130
+ Now, the second thing about the<br/>
4131
+ collectivity culture, and I'm
4132
+ </p>
4133
+
4134
+ <p begin="0:47:44.579" end="0:47:48.25">
4135
+ going to close over here,<br/>
4136
+ the collectivity culture is
4137
+ </p>
4138
+
4139
+ <p begin="0:47:48.25" end="0:47:54.5">
4140
+ really expressed through, you<br/>
4141
+ know, through what we see.
4142
+ </p>
4143
+
4144
+ <p begin="0:47:54.5" end="0:47:59.239">
4145
+ And my boss, Dan Hastings,<br/>
4146
+ who's the Dean of Undergraduate
4147
+ </p>
4148
+
4149
+ <p begin="0:47:59.239" end="0:48:02.789">
4150
+ Education over here, has sent<br/>
4151
+ us these slides sometime ago.
4152
+ </p>
4153
+
4154
+ <p begin="0:48:02.789" end="0:48:06.07">
4155
+ And for me, they tells the<br/>
4156
+ story about the digital
4157
+ </p>
4158
+
4159
+ <p begin="0:48:06.07" end="0:48:10.82">
4160
+ natives, and the collectivity<br/>
4161
+ culture, which I think gives
4162
+ </p>
4163
+
4164
+ <p begin="0:48:10.82" end="0:48:14.829">
4165
+ me comfort that -- well, on the<br/>
4166
+ one hand it makes it very
4167
+ </p>
4168
+
4169
+ <p begin="0:48:14.829" end="0:48:19.38">
4170
+ important that we continue to<br/>
4171
+ march on, on this road towards
4172
+ </p>
4173
+
4174
+ <p begin="0:48:19.38" end="0:48:22.92">
4175
+ Metaversity two, but at the<br/>
4176
+ same time it gives me comfort
4177
+ </p>
4178
+
4179
+ <p begin="0:48:22.92" end="0:48:27.289">
4180
+ that it's well on it's<br/>
4181
+ way to being reaffied.
4182
+ </p>
4183
+
4184
+ <p begin="0:48:27.289" end="0:48:30.012">
4185
+ So here are a set of<br/>
4186
+ slides that Dan gave that
4187
+ </p>
4188
+
4189
+ <p begin="0:48:30.012" end="0:48:32.71">
4190
+ I think speak to the<br/>
4191
+ collectivity culture.
4192
+ </p>
4193
+
4194
+ <p begin="0:48:32.71" end="0:48:37.03">
4195
+ This is by a group of students<br/>
4196
+ who fancy that they work at
4197
+ </p>
4198
+
4199
+ <p begin="0:48:37.03" end="0:48:40.469">
4200
+ NASA, and who also asking why<br/>
4201
+ aren't we working at NASA.
4202
+ </p>
4203
+
4204
+ <p begin="0:48:40.469" end="0:48:43.219">
4205
+ And they are -- I won't<br/>
4206
+ say much why it is being
4207
+ </p>
4208
+
4209
+ <p begin="0:48:43.219" end="0:48:45.289">
4210
+ played, they are from gen-Y.<br/>
4211
+
4212
+ </p>
4213
+
4214
+ <p begin="0:48:45.289" end="0:48:47.48">
4215
+ Gen-Y is, by the way, it is<br/>
4216
+ characterized by everyone
4217
+ </p>
4218
+
4219
+ <p begin="0:48:47.48" end="0:48:52.059">
4220
+ between 14 and they say 40,<br/>
4221
+ but I'm going to say 50s.
4222
+ </p>
4223
+
4224
+ <p begin="0:48:52.059" end="0:48:54.739">
4225
+ <br/>
4226
+
4227
+ </p>
4228
+
4229
+ <p begin="0:48:54.739" end="0:49:00.849">
4230
+ So and well, these are the, and<br/>
4231
+ you're seeing characteristics
4232
+ </p>
4233
+
4234
+ <p begin="0:49:00.849" end="0:49:06.59">
4235
+ of this collectivity<br/>
4236
+ generations, right?
4237
+ </p>
4238
+
4239
+ <p begin="0:49:06.59" end="0:49:09.07">
4240
+ <br/>
4241
+
4242
+ </p>
4243
+
4244
+ <p begin="0:49:09.07" end="0:49:12.75">
4245
+ So they're talking about why<br/>
4246
+ are -- it's self-explanatory.
4247
+ </p>
4248
+
4249
+ <p begin="0:49:12.75" end="0:49:43.82">
4250
+ <br/>
4251
+
4252
+ </p>
4253
+
4254
+ <p begin="0:49:43.82" end="0:49:49.746">
4255
+ Now, there are tools that they,<br/>
4256
+ and this speaks exactly to your
4257
+ </p>
4258
+
4259
+ <p begin="0:49:49.746" end="0:50:08.19">
4260
+ point, By the way, this is just<br/>
4261
+ a sort of disclaimer slide
4262
+ </p>
4263
+
4264
+ <p begin="0:50:08.19" end="0:50:10.619">
4265
+ to say that NASA actually<br/>
4266
+ uses a lot of these tools.
4267
+ </p>
4268
+
4269
+ <p begin="0:50:10.619" end="0:50:11.9">
4270
+ I think I have said enough.<br/>
4271
+
4272
+ </p>
4273
+
4274
+ <p begin="0:50:11.9" end="0:50:13.599">
4275
+ I hope I have given<br/>
4276
+ you a message.
4277
+ </p>
4278
+
4279
+ <p begin="0:50:13.599" end="0:50:16.69">
4280
+ Thank you very much, and<br/>
4281
+ I hope the message off
4282
+ </p>
4283
+
4284
+ <p begin="0:50:16.69" end="0:50:18.018">
4285
+ everything open is clear.<br/>
4286
+
4287
+ </p>
4288
+
4289
+ <p begin="0:50:18.018" end="0:50:21.84">
4290
+ And I don't know, Scott, if you<br/>
4291
+ wanted to take any questions,
4292
+ </p>
4293
+
4294
+ <p begin="0:50:21.84" end="0:50:33.75">
4295
+ or if -- what have you<br/>
4296
+ noticed, but thanks a lot.
4297
+ </p>
4298
+
4299
+ </div>
4300
+ </body>
4301
+ </tt>