sm-transcript 0.0.4 → 0.0.6

This diff represents the content of publicly available package versions that have been released to one of the supported registries. The information contained in this diff is provided for informational purposes only and reflects changes between package versions as they appear in their respective public registries.
Files changed (48) hide show
  1. data/README.txt +138 -118
  2. data/Rakefile +21 -10
  3. data/bin/sm-transcript +0 -0
  4. data/lib/sm_transcript/metadata.rb +25 -0
  5. data/lib/sm_transcript/options.rb +9 -3
  6. data/lib/sm_transcript/runner.rb +6 -0
  7. data/lib/sm_transcript/seg_reader.rb +1 -1
  8. data/lib/sm_transcript/transcript.rb +86 -39
  9. data/lib/sm_transcript/ttml_reader.rb +116 -0
  10. data/lib/sm_transcript/word.rb +6 -4
  11. data/lib/sm_transcript/wrd_reader.rb +5 -4
  12. data/test/results/18.03-2004-L01.align2.wrd +6441 -0
  13. data/test/results/8.01-1999-L01.wrd +5182 -0
  14. data/test/results/801-1stLecture.ttml.xml +757 -0
  15. data/test/results/801-lect01-4730.xml +757 -0
  16. data/test/results/801-lect02-4731.xml +886 -0
  17. data/test/results/801-lect03-4732.xml +818 -0
  18. data/test/results/801-lect04-4733.xml +831 -0
  19. data/test/results/801-lect05-4734.xml +879 -0
  20. data/test/results/801-lect06-4735.xml +822 -0
  21. data/test/results/801-lect07-4736.xml +893 -0
  22. data/test/results/801-lect08-4737.xml +809 -0
  23. data/test/results/801-lect09-4738.xml +807 -0
  24. data/test/results/Audio-Open-The_New_Deal_for_Education.xml +4301 -0
  25. data/test/test_metadatareader.rb +8 -3
  26. data/test/test_options.rb +8 -1
  27. data/test/test_runner.rb +34 -1
  28. data/test/test_transcript.rb +109 -12
  29. data/test/test_ttmlreader.rb +104 -0
  30. data/test/test_wrdreader.rb +24 -9
  31. metadata +47 -148
  32. data/lib/sm_transcript/optparseExample.rb +0 -113
  33. data/lib/sm_transcript/process_csv_files_to_html.rb +0 -58
  34. data/lib/sm_transcript/process_seg_files.rb +0 -21
  35. data/lib/sm_transcript/process_seg_files_to_csv.rb +0 -24
  36. data/lib/sm_transcript/process_seg_files_to_html.rb +0 -31
  37. data/lib/sm_transcript/require_relative.rb +0 -14
  38. data/test/transcripts/GardnerRileyInterview.t1.html +0 -247
  39. data/test/transcripts/IIHS_Diane_Davis_Nov2009-t1.html +0 -148
  40. data/test/transcripts/NERCOMP-SpokenMedia4.t1.html +0 -2178
  41. data/test/transcripts/data.js +0 -24
  42. data/test/transcripts/vijay_kumar-1.-t1.html +0 -557
  43. data/test/transcripts/vijay_kumar-1.t1.html +0 -558
  44. data/test/transcripts/vijay_kumar-t1.html +0 -558
  45. data/test/transcripts/vijay_kumar-t1.ttml +0 -570
  46. data/test/transcripts/vijay_kumar.data.js +0 -2
  47. data/test/transcripts/vijay_kumar.t1.html +0 -557
  48. data/test/transcripts/wirehair-beetle.data.js +0 -24
@@ -0,0 +1,4301 @@
1
+ <tt xml:lang="" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2006/04/ttaf1" xmlns:tts="http://www.w3.org/2006/04/ttaf1#styling">
2
+ <head>
3
+ <styling>
4
+ <style id="1" tts:textAlign="left"/>
5
+ <style id="2" tts:color="transparent"/>
6
+ <style id="3" style="2" tts:backgroundColor="white"/>
7
+ <style id="4" style="2 3" tts:fontSize="20"/>
8
+ </styling>
9
+ </head>
10
+
11
+ <body>
12
+ <div xml:lang="en">
13
+
14
+ <p begin="0:00:06.58" end="0:00:11.32">
15
+ Let me welcome all of you on<br/>
16
+ behalf of MIT, on behalf of the
17
+ </p>
18
+
19
+ <p begin="0:00:11.32" end="0:00:14.14">
20
+ Office of Educational<br/>
21
+ Innovation and Technology, and
22
+ </p>
23
+
24
+ <p begin="0:00:14.14" end="0:00:19.07">
25
+ on behalf of our partners here,<br/>
26
+ Apple, Scott's, I don't know,
27
+ </p>
28
+
29
+ <p begin="0:00:19.07" end="0:00:22.36">
30
+ it's not always good to extend<br/>
31
+ the family metaphor because
32
+ </p>
33
+
34
+ <p begin="0:00:22.36" end="0:00:25.11">
35
+ of all the intended<br/>
36
+ dysfunctionality, but, you
37
+ </p>
38
+
39
+ <p begin="0:00:25.11" end="0:00:28.86">
40
+ know, it's like a member of an<br/>
41
+ extended family over here.
42
+ </p>
43
+
44
+ <p begin="0:00:28.86" end="0:00:30.93">
45
+ <br/>
46
+
47
+ </p>
48
+
49
+ <p begin="0:00:30.93" end="0:00:35.87">
50
+ But, really, we welcome you<br/>
51
+ to MIT and to this event.
52
+ </p>
53
+
54
+ <p begin="0:00:35.87" end="0:00:38.42">
55
+ There is a lot of<br/>
56
+ planning, I know.
57
+ </p>
58
+
59
+ <p begin="0:00:38.42" end="0:00:42.33">
60
+ Not just what Scott was talking<br/>
61
+ about, I watched Andrew, who
62
+ </p>
63
+
64
+ <p begin="0:00:42.33" end="0:00:47.02">
65
+ works in our office, along with<br/>
66
+ Jeff and Judy go at it you
67
+ </p>
68
+
69
+ <p begin="0:00:47.02" end="0:00:48.9">
70
+ know, for quite some time.<br/>
71
+
72
+ </p>
73
+
74
+ <p begin="0:00:48.9" end="0:00:50.91">
75
+ So it's a treat to have<br/>
76
+ you over here and to have
77
+ </p>
78
+
79
+ <p begin="0:00:50.91" end="0:00:52.89">
80
+ this event over here.<br/>
81
+
82
+ </p>
83
+
84
+ <p begin="0:00:52.89" end="0:00:57.41">
85
+ I'm not going to be talking<br/>
86
+ about OEIT today, although the
87
+ </p>
88
+
89
+ <p begin="0:00:57.41" end="0:00:59.63">
90
+ Office of Educational<br/>
91
+ Innovation and Technology,
92
+ </p>
93
+
94
+ <p begin="0:00:59.63" end="0:01:03.179">
95
+ although, you know, I'm hoping<br/>
96
+ to touch on some examples,
97
+ </p>
98
+
99
+ <p begin="0:01:03.179" end="0:01:05.188">
100
+ as they are relevant<br/>
101
+ to my conversation.
102
+ </p>
103
+
104
+ <p begin="0:01:05.188" end="0:01:08.424">
105
+ I should also apologize to you<br/>
106
+ in advance, I'm not doing to
107
+ </p>
108
+
109
+ <p begin="0:01:08.424" end="0:01:14.299">
110
+ be singing for you today.<br/>
111
+ My voice is a little bit off,
112
+ </p>
113
+
114
+ <p begin="0:01:14.299" end="0:01:19.59">
115
+ but I do hope to talk about<br/>
116
+ some things open, and really
117
+ </p>
118
+
119
+ <p begin="0:01:19.59" end="0:01:25.42">
120
+ about this gathering storm, you<br/>
121
+ know, which I call the open
122
+ </p>
123
+
124
+ <p begin="0:01:25.42" end="0:01:30.86">
125
+ education movement, and the<br/>
126
+ potentially implications it has
127
+ </p>
128
+
129
+ <p begin="0:01:30.86" end="0:01:33.75">
130
+ for transforming education.<br/>
131
+
132
+ </p>
133
+
134
+ <p begin="0:01:33.75" end="0:01:36.97">
135
+ And you know, it was really<br/>
136
+ about, I don't know if it was
137
+ </p>
138
+
139
+ <p begin="0:01:36.97" end="0:01:39.93">
140
+ at 2:00 in the morning today<br/>
141
+ or 7:00 in the morning today.
142
+ </p>
143
+
144
+ <p begin="0:01:39.93" end="0:01:43.06">
145
+ You know I got onto MIT's<br/>
146
+ web page, and this was
147
+ </p>
148
+
149
+ <p begin="0:01:43.06" end="0:01:44.379">
150
+ the page, and I said wow!<br/>
151
+
152
+ </p>
153
+
154
+ <p begin="0:01:44.379" end="0:01:47.379">
155
+ You know, somebody paid<br/>
156
+ somebody to do this, because
157
+ </p>
158
+
159
+ <p begin="0:01:47.379" end="0:01:50.569">
160
+ it really epitomizes at least<br/>
161
+ certainly the institutional
162
+ </p>
163
+
164
+ <p begin="0:01:50.569" end="0:01:53.97">
165
+ commitment part of openness<br/>
166
+ that we want to talk about.
167
+ </p>
168
+
169
+ <p begin="0:01:53.97" end="0:01:57.489">
170
+ Last week at the faculty<br/>
171
+ meeting, not in this room, some
172
+ </p>
173
+
174
+ <p begin="0:01:57.489" end="0:01:59.61">
175
+ faculty meetings are held in<br/>
176
+ this room, but in another
177
+ </p>
178
+
179
+ <p begin="0:01:59.61" end="0:02:06.64">
180
+ renovated space in the main<br/>
181
+ drag, MIT faculty wanted to
182
+ </p>
183
+
184
+ <p begin="0:02:06.64" end="0:02:09.74">
185
+ provide, you know, to allow the<br/>
186
+ institute to provide open
187
+ </p>
188
+
189
+ <p begin="0:02:09.74" end="0:02:13.848">
190
+ access to all scholarly<br/>
191
+ articles, which sort of shows
192
+ </p>
193
+
194
+ <p begin="0:02:13.848" end="0:02:18.71">
195
+ the commitment and, of course,<br/>
196
+ most of you have heard about
197
+ </p>
198
+
199
+ <p begin="0:02:18.71" end="0:02:21.729">
200
+ OpenCourseWare, which was the<br/>
201
+ educational version of this.
202
+ </p>
203
+
204
+ <p begin="0:02:21.729" end="0:02:25.36">
205
+ So there's, you know, so<br/>
206
+ there's some institutional
207
+ </p>
208
+
209
+ <p begin="0:02:25.36" end="0:02:30.3">
210
+ teeth to this movement,<br/>
211
+ certainly as far as we are
212
+ </p>
213
+
214
+ <p begin="0:02:30.3" end="0:02:31.59">
215
+ concerned here at MIT.<br/>
216
+
217
+ </p>
218
+
219
+ <p begin="0:02:31.59" end="0:02:34.05">
220
+ <br/>
221
+
222
+ </p>
223
+
224
+ <p begin="0:02:34.05" end="0:02:45.78">
225
+ So, having -- let me pop it up<br/>
226
+ there and -- so, I chose an old
227
+ </p>
228
+
229
+ <p begin="0:02:45.78" end="0:02:49.5">
230
+ expression to describe a new<br/>
231
+ phenomenon, you know the new
232
+ </p>
233
+
234
+ <p begin="0:02:49.5" end="0:02:53.199">
235
+ deal, only to signify the<br/>
236
+ tremendous opportunity that I
237
+ </p>
238
+
239
+ <p begin="0:02:53.199" end="0:02:57.639">
240
+ see, this open education<br/>
241
+ movement has, and, you know,
242
+ </p>
243
+
244
+ <p begin="0:02:57.639" end="0:03:03.02">
245
+ it's characterized by open<br/>
246
+ content, open knowledge, open
247
+ </p>
248
+
249
+ <p begin="0:03:03.02" end="0:03:07.34">
250
+ technology and all these<br/>
251
+ dimensions sort of describe the
252
+ </p>
253
+
254
+ <p begin="0:03:07.34" end="0:03:09.58">
255
+ envelope of the open<br/>
256
+ education movement.
257
+ </p>
258
+
259
+ <p begin="0:03:09.58" end="0:03:13.65">
260
+ And the top part, you know, in<br/>
261
+ this world of borrowing and
262
+ </p>
263
+
264
+ <p begin="0:03:13.65" end="0:03:16.758">
265
+ collaboration euphemistically<br/>
266
+ called match ups, actually
267
+ </p>
268
+
269
+ <p begin="0:03:16.758" end="0:03:19.758">
270
+ borrowed the top part of that,<br/>
271
+ advancing the educational life
272
+ </p>
273
+
274
+ <p begin="0:03:19.758" end="0:03:23.65">
275
+ of information resources of<br/>
276
+ title from a guru of mine, John
277
+ </p>
278
+
279
+ <p begin="0:03:23.65" end="0:03:26.378">
280
+ Seely Brown, who many of you<br/>
281
+ know had this social
282
+ </p>
283
+
284
+ <p begin="0:03:26.378" end="0:03:27.68">
285
+ life of information.<br/>
286
+
287
+ </p>
288
+
289
+ <p begin="0:03:27.68" end="0:03:30.72">
290
+ The thesis there being that<br/>
291
+ the community really gives
292
+ </p>
293
+
294
+ <p begin="0:03:30.72" end="0:03:32.36">
295
+ meaning to information.<br/>
296
+
297
+ </p>
298
+
299
+ <p begin="0:03:32.36" end="0:03:39.91">
300
+ And here, my pitch is that a<br/>
301
+ lot of what openness is about
302
+ </p>
303
+
304
+ <p begin="0:03:39.91" end="0:03:43">
305
+ is breathing educational life<br/>
306
+ into information resources
307
+ </p>
308
+
309
+ <p begin="0:03:43" end="0:03:46.098">
310
+ which are becoming available<br/>
311
+ and plenty, through, you
312
+ </p>
313
+
314
+ <p begin="0:03:46.098" end="0:03:47.66">
315
+ know, through the kinds of<br/>
316
+ initiatives that I'm
317
+ </p>
318
+
319
+ <p begin="0:03:47.66" end="0:03:48.91">
320
+ going to talk about.<br/>
321
+
322
+ </p>
323
+
324
+ <p begin="0:03:48.91" end="0:03:50.19">
325
+ <br/>
326
+
327
+ </p>
328
+
329
+ <p begin="0:03:50.19" end="0:03:57.419">
330
+ So the promise was best<br/>
331
+ articulated by Chuck Vest, who
332
+ </p>
333
+
334
+ <p begin="0:03:57.419" end="0:04:01.55">
335
+ was President here at MIT, who<br/>
336
+ is now the President of the
337
+ </p>
338
+
339
+ <p begin="0:04:01.55" end="0:04:05.15">
340
+ National Academy, National<br/>
341
+ Academy for Engineering, and
342
+ </p>
343
+
344
+ <p begin="0:04:05.15" end="0:04:09.919">
345
+ it was under his championship,<br/>
346
+ actually, that OpenCourseWare
347
+ </p>
348
+
349
+ <p begin="0:04:09.919" end="0:04:11.968">
350
+ at MIT was launched.<br/>
351
+
352
+ </p>
353
+
354
+ <p begin="0:04:11.968" end="0:04:17.05">
355
+ And Fred painted this, you<br/>
356
+ know, this vision, if you will.
357
+ </p>
358
+
359
+ <p begin="0:04:17.05" end="0:04:21.18">
360
+ And he said we are talking<br/>
361
+ about OpenCourseWare and the
362
+ </p>
363
+
364
+ <p begin="0:04:21.18" end="0:04:24.72">
365
+ surrounding initiatives that<br/>
366
+ were sprouting at that time,
367
+ </p>
368
+
369
+ <p begin="0:04:24.72" end="0:04:27.329">
370
+ to say we are seeing the early<br/>
371
+ emergence of a Metaversity.
372
+ </p>
373
+
374
+ <p begin="0:04:27.329" end="0:04:28.36">
375
+ <br/>
376
+
377
+ </p>
378
+
379
+ <p begin="0:04:28.36" end="0:04:32.839">
380
+ A transcendent, accessible,<br/>
381
+ empowering, dynamic community
382
+ </p>
383
+
384
+ <p begin="0:04:32.839" end="0:04:36.009">
385
+ constructed framework of open<br/>
386
+ materials and platforms,
387
+ </p>
388
+
389
+ <p begin="0:04:36.009" end="0:04:39.24">
390
+ on which much of higher<br/>
391
+ education worldwide can be
392
+ </p>
393
+
394
+ <p begin="0:04:39.24" end="0:04:41.259">
395
+ constructed or enhanced.<br/>
396
+
397
+ </p>
398
+
399
+ <p begin="0:04:41.259" end="0:04:43.91">
400
+ And it's a tremendous vision.<br/>
401
+
402
+ </p>
403
+
404
+ <p begin="0:04:43.91" end="0:04:46.089">
405
+ It is a vision of<br/>
406
+ the Metaversity.
407
+ </p>
408
+
409
+ <p begin="0:04:46.089" end="0:04:46.43">
410
+ <br/>
411
+
412
+ </p>
413
+
414
+ <p begin="0:04:46.43" end="0:04:52.1">
415
+ And what I am contending today<br/>
416
+ is that much of what you have
417
+ </p>
418
+
419
+ <p begin="0:04:52.1" end="0:04:55.73">
420
+ seen, remarkable as it is, the<br/>
421
+ OpenCourseWare as a movement,
422
+ </p>
423
+
424
+ <p begin="0:04:55.73" end="0:04:58.74">
425
+ and I'll point to some of the<br/>
426
+ evidence, is the first
427
+ </p>
428
+
429
+ <p begin="0:04:58.74" end="0:05:00">
430
+ phase off that vision.<br/>
431
+
432
+ </p>
433
+
434
+ <p begin="0:05:00" end="0:05:03.095">
435
+ It is Metaversity part one, and<br/>
436
+ the kinds of things that we are
437
+ </p>
438
+
439
+ <p begin="0:05:03.095" end="0:05:08.699">
440
+ all engaged in really points to<br/>
441
+ a deeper vision of this second
442
+ </p>
443
+
444
+ <p begin="0:05:08.699" end="0:05:16.16">
445
+ phase, which is more akin to<br/>
446
+ what I think Chuck is trying to
447
+ </p>
448
+
449
+ <p begin="0:05:16.16" end="0:05:19.339">
450
+ describe over there, the<br/>
451
+ Metaversity part two.
452
+ </p>
453
+
454
+ <p begin="0:05:19.339" end="0:05:21.04">
455
+ <br/>
456
+
457
+ </p>
458
+
459
+ <p begin="0:05:21.04" end="0:05:26.769">
460
+ So, very quickly, some off the<br/>
461
+ artifacts some off the evidence
462
+ </p>
463
+
464
+ <p begin="0:05:26.769" end="0:05:30.879">
465
+ of this gathering storm that I<br/>
466
+ refer to are some of the
467
+ </p>
468
+
469
+ <p begin="0:05:30.879" end="0:05:34.56">
470
+ things that categorize<br/>
471
+ the Metaversity part one.
472
+ </p>
473
+
474
+ <p begin="0:05:34.56" end="0:05:37.899">
475
+ Of course, we like to<br/>
476
+ start with OpenCourseWare.
477
+ </p>
478
+
479
+ <p begin="0:05:37.899" end="0:05:44.79">
480
+ Around 2000, when MIT very<br/>
481
+ boldly, and some of us
482
+ </p>
483
+
484
+ <p begin="0:05:44.79" end="0:05:48.22">
485
+ thought at that time thought<br/>
486
+ rationally, announced that it
487
+ </p>
488
+
489
+ <p begin="0:05:48.22" end="0:05:52.079">
490
+ would make the content of all<br/>
491
+ its courses available on the
492
+ </p>
493
+
494
+ <p begin="0:05:52.079" end="0:05:54.1">
495
+ web for free to the world.<br/>
496
+
497
+ </p>
498
+
499
+ <p begin="0:05:54.1" end="0:05:57.555">
500
+ And I remember being in the<br/>
501
+ room, as part of the Counsel in
502
+ </p>
503
+
504
+ <p begin="0:05:57.555" end="0:06:02.12">
505
+ Education Technology when the<br/>
506
+ sub-group came back and said,
507
+ </p>
508
+
509
+ <p begin="0:06:02.12" end="0:06:03.85">
510
+ you know, maybe we<br/>
511
+ should do this.
512
+ </p>
513
+
514
+ <p begin="0:06:03.85" end="0:06:07.189">
515
+ And there were two remarkable<br/>
516
+ things that happened,
517
+ </p>
518
+
519
+ <p begin="0:06:07.189" end="0:06:10.16">
520
+ that are true.<br/>
521
+ One was our emotional response.
522
+ </p>
523
+
524
+ <p begin="0:06:10.16" end="0:06:14.009">
525
+ We said, whoa -- this<br/>
526
+ is big, you know, and,
527
+ </p>
528
+
529
+ <p begin="0:06:14.009" end="0:06:15.509">
530
+ which was tremendous.<br/>
531
+ We all knew this was
532
+ </p>
533
+
534
+ <p begin="0:06:15.509" end="0:06:16.959">
535
+ something very important.<br/>
536
+
537
+ </p>
538
+
539
+ <p begin="0:06:16.959" end="0:06:20.389">
540
+ The second thing was none of us<br/>
541
+ knew what it meant, you know.
542
+ </p>
543
+
544
+ <p begin="0:06:20.389" end="0:06:25.11">
545
+ So, we said, well,<br/>
546
+ but it was powerful.
547
+ </p>
548
+
549
+ <p begin="0:06:25.11" end="0:06:28.8">
550
+ None of us really understood<br/>
551
+ the profound implications
552
+ </p>
553
+
554
+ <p begin="0:06:28.8" end="0:06:34.67">
555
+ that have subsequently emerged<br/>
556
+ from that announcement.
557
+ </p>
558
+
559
+ <p begin="0:06:34.67" end="0:06:36.81">
560
+ Of course, one of the side<br/>
561
+ benefits, and then since then
562
+ </p>
563
+
564
+ <p begin="0:06:36.81" end="0:06:38.24">
565
+ lots has happened, you know.<br/>
566
+
567
+ </p>
568
+
569
+ <p begin="0:06:38.24" end="0:06:39.68">
570
+ <br/>
571
+
572
+ </p>
573
+
574
+ <p begin="0:06:39.68" end="0:06:47.009">
575
+ A couple of Octobers ago MIT,<br/>
576
+ all of MIT's 1,800 courses were
577
+ </p>
578
+
579
+ <p begin="0:06:47.009" end="0:06:52.48">
580
+ actually made available through<br/>
581
+ OpenCourseWare, and -- which is
582
+ </p>
583
+
584
+ <p begin="0:06:52.48" end="0:06:55.889">
585
+ tremendous, which is sort of --<br/>
586
+ you know, the first item was
587
+ </p>
588
+
589
+ <p begin="0:06:55.889" end="0:06:59.94">
590
+ Daily Word, and the first part<br/>
591
+ of the promise was Daily Word.
592
+ </p>
593
+
594
+ <p begin="0:06:59.94" end="0:07:03.16">
595
+ Now, one side benefit that I<br/>
596
+ always like to point out from
597
+ </p>
598
+
599
+ <p begin="0:07:03.16" end="0:07:07.25">
600
+ OpenCourseWare is that we like<br/>
601
+ to say to MIT that we figured
602
+ </p>
603
+
604
+ <p begin="0:07:07.25" end="0:07:10.35">
605
+ out actually how many courses<br/>
606
+ there were, indeed, at MIT.
607
+ </p>
608
+
609
+ <p begin="0:07:10.35" end="0:07:15.61">
610
+ So we, you know, because we<br/>
611
+ said all the courses, like
612
+ </p>
613
+
614
+ <p begin="0:07:15.61" end="0:07:17.86">
615
+ in the old days we used<br/>
616
+ to talk about the Athena
617
+ </p>
618
+
619
+ <p begin="0:07:17.86" end="0:07:20.346">
620
+ computing environment.<br/>
621
+ It was sort of everything, but
622
+ </p>
623
+
624
+ <p begin="0:07:20.346" end="0:07:24.23">
625
+ we didn't exactly what it was,<br/>
626
+ and 1,800 was a good number,
627
+ </p>
628
+
629
+ <p begin="0:07:24.23" end="0:07:25.509">
630
+ so that's where it come.<br/>
631
+
632
+ </p>
633
+
634
+ <p begin="0:07:25.509" end="0:07:27.81">
635
+ So that was there, but the<br/>
636
+ interesting thing about the
637
+ </p>
638
+
639
+ <p begin="0:07:27.81" end="0:07:32.04">
640
+ open education movement that<br/>
641
+ I'm referring to was certainly,
642
+ </p>
643
+
644
+ <p begin="0:07:32.04" end="0:07:37.22">
645
+ motivated, led, catalyzed by<br/>
646
+ OpenCourseWare, but that's not
647
+ </p>
648
+
649
+ <p begin="0:07:37.22" end="0:07:43.259">
650
+ the movement, and it's not<br/>
651
+ even, when we announced
652
+ </p>
653
+
654
+ <p begin="0:07:43.259" end="0:07:48.1">
655
+ OpenCourseWare, it was<br/>
656
+ interesting because the kinds
657
+ </p>
658
+
659
+ <p begin="0:07:48.1" end="0:07:51.86">
660
+ of letters we'd get from all<br/>
661
+ over the world, MIT used to
662
+ </p>
663
+
664
+ <p begin="0:07:51.86" end="0:07:57.149">
665
+ get, and typically in<br/>
666
+ presentations, and in
667
+ </p>
668
+
669
+ <p begin="0:07:57.149" end="0:08:00.06">
670
+ fact, if you go to the MIT<br/>
671
+ OpenCourseWare site, you will
672
+ </p>
673
+
674
+ <p begin="0:08:00.06" end="0:08:04.899">
675
+ see stats on the millions off<br/>
676
+ hits and how much access, and
677
+ </p>
678
+
679
+ <p begin="0:08:04.899" end="0:08:07">
680
+ that's all wonderful.<br/>
681
+
682
+ </p>
683
+
684
+ <p begin="0:08:07" end="0:08:10.62">
685
+ That's great data.<br/>
686
+ That's great information, but
687
+ </p>
688
+
689
+ <p begin="0:08:10.62" end="0:08:16.019">
690
+ the impact data is really<br/>
691
+ vignette like this, when you
692
+ </p>
693
+
694
+ <p begin="0:08:16.019" end="0:08:18.939">
695
+ talk about the fact that when<br/>
696
+ you put out resources like
697
+ </p>
698
+
699
+ <p begin="0:08:18.939" end="0:08:21.49">
700
+ OpenCourseWare, people<br/>
701
+ can use it for curriculum
702
+ </p>
703
+
704
+ <p begin="0:08:21.49" end="0:08:26.12">
705
+ formulation elsewhere.<br/>
706
+ It serves as a model and so
707
+ </p>
708
+
709
+ <p begin="0:08:26.12" end="0:08:29.519">
710
+ it's not just about consuming<br/>
711
+ the content that is put over
712
+ </p>
713
+
714
+ <p begin="0:08:29.519" end="0:08:32.178">
715
+ there, but being able to learn<br/>
716
+ from it the way it is put
717
+ </p>
718
+
719
+ <p begin="0:08:32.178" end="0:08:34.889">
720
+ together, the way it is<br/>
721
+ structured in order that you
722
+ </p>
723
+
724
+ <p begin="0:08:34.889" end="0:08:38.44">
725
+ can do your own thing<br/>
726
+ more efficiently.
727
+ </p>
728
+
729
+ <p begin="0:08:38.44" end="0:08:41.95">
730
+ So this is, Richard Hall, who<br/>
731
+ says it saved him an enormous
732
+ </p>
733
+
734
+ <p begin="0:08:41.95" end="0:08:43.47">
735
+ amount of time and stress.<br/>
736
+
737
+ </p>
738
+
739
+ <p begin="0:08:43.47" end="0:08:45.07">
740
+ I could use some of that myself.<br/>
741
+
742
+ </p>
743
+
744
+ <p begin="0:08:45.07" end="0:08:50.558">
745
+ So, the other kind of vignette,<br/>
746
+ which I look at as evidence is
747
+ </p>
748
+
749
+ <p begin="0:08:50.558" end="0:08:53.21">
750
+ this one, where, you know,<br/>
751
+ you actually have students
752
+ </p>
753
+
754
+ <p begin="0:08:53.21" end="0:08:57.509">
755
+ elsewhere who are using this,<br/>
756
+ and who actually go and look at
757
+ </p>
758
+
759
+ <p begin="0:08:57.509" end="0:09:01.09">
760
+ the notes in OpenCourseWare and<br/>
761
+ then use them as supplements
762
+ </p>
763
+
764
+ <p begin="0:09:01.09" end="0:09:02.98">
765
+ to what they're learning.<br/>
766
+ And by the way, this is a
767
+ </p>
768
+
769
+ <p begin="0:09:02.98" end="0:09:05.87">
770
+ phenomenon that I experience<br/>
771
+ all the time when I'm giving
772
+ </p>
773
+
774
+ <p begin="0:09:05.87" end="0:09:09.36">
775
+ talks, for instance, in India,<br/>
776
+ I'd be there giving a talk to
777
+ </p>
778
+
779
+ <p begin="0:09:09.36" end="0:09:13.48">
780
+ you know, some 1,700 people in<br/>
781
+ a class like this, and I'll as
782
+ </p>
783
+
784
+ <p begin="0:09:13.48" end="0:09:17.45">
785
+ for a show of hands, how many<br/>
786
+ of you have heard of OCW, you
787
+ </p>
788
+
789
+ <p begin="0:09:17.45" end="0:09:19.558">
790
+ know, the hands will go up.<br/>
791
+
792
+ </p>
793
+
794
+ <p begin="0:09:19.558" end="0:09:22.129">
795
+ Then I'll ask, how<br/>
796
+ many of you use OCW?
797
+ </p>
798
+
799
+ <p begin="0:09:22.129" end="0:09:28.028">
800
+ And what is remarkable is that<br/>
801
+ there are classes where all
802
+ </p>
803
+
804
+ <p begin="0:09:28.028" end="0:09:30.389">
805
+ the students would have<br/>
806
+ their hands up, you know.
807
+ </p>
808
+
809
+ <p begin="0:09:30.389" end="0:09:35.308">
810
+ And unselfconsciously, with the<br/>
811
+ instructor over there, because
812
+ </p>
813
+
814
+ <p begin="0:09:35.308" end="0:09:36.69">
815
+ they using get the supplements.<br/>
816
+
817
+ </p>
818
+
819
+ <p begin="0:09:36.69" end="0:09:43.408">
820
+ Sometimes they're looking at it<br/>
821
+ as a benchmark, to ask an
822
+ </p>
823
+
824
+ <p begin="0:09:43.408" end="0:09:48.279">
825
+ instructor why isn't our course<br/>
826
+ looking like that, or why
827
+ </p>
828
+
829
+ <p begin="0:09:48.279" end="0:09:52.038">
830
+ aren't we covering those<br/>
831
+ aspects of the content?
832
+ </p>
833
+
834
+ <p begin="0:09:52.038" end="0:09:55.24">
835
+ So you can start to see<br/>
836
+ the kinds of implications
837
+ </p>
838
+
839
+ <p begin="0:09:55.24" end="0:09:56.72">
840
+ of things open.<br/>
841
+
842
+ </p>
843
+
844
+ <p begin="0:09:56.72" end="0:09:59.69">
845
+ It is not just about being able<br/>
846
+ to go and grab the contents.
847
+ </p>
848
+
849
+ <p begin="0:09:59.69" end="0:10:02.009">
850
+ It serves as a model.<br/>
851
+ It serves as a benchmark.
852
+ </p>
853
+
854
+ <p begin="0:10:02.009" end="0:10:05.74">
855
+ It serves as a mirror into your<br/>
856
+ quality, and this is, these are
857
+ </p>
858
+
859
+ <p begin="0:10:05.74" end="0:10:08.08">
860
+ the -- I'm trying to start<br/>
861
+ giving you hints of the
862
+ </p>
863
+
864
+ <p begin="0:10:08.08" end="0:10:10.86">
865
+ transubmitive impact<br/>
866
+ of things open.
867
+ </p>
868
+
869
+ <p begin="0:10:10.86" end="0:10:12.308">
870
+ <br/>
871
+
872
+ </p>
873
+
874
+ <p begin="0:10:12.308" end="0:10:14.09">
875
+ Again, but that's is<br/>
876
+ not the movement.
877
+ </p>
878
+
879
+ <p begin="0:10:14.09" end="0:10:16.7">
880
+ This was, so far I've<br/>
881
+ talked about OCW.
882
+ </p>
883
+
884
+ <p begin="0:10:16.7" end="0:10:21.6">
885
+ What characterized the movement<br/>
886
+ was, now actually hundreds
887
+ </p>
888
+
889
+ <p begin="0:10:21.6" end="0:10:23.918">
890
+ of OCWs that started.<br/>
891
+
892
+ </p>
893
+
894
+ <p begin="0:10:23.918" end="0:10:26.07">
895
+ There's a consortium<br/>
896
+ with 160 institutions.
897
+ </p>
898
+
899
+ <p begin="0:10:26.07" end="0:10:27.548">
900
+ <br/>
901
+
902
+ </p>
903
+
904
+ <p begin="0:10:27.548" end="0:10:29.6">
905
+ Brandon, sitting over there,<br/>
906
+ is actually involved in
907
+ </p>
908
+
909
+ <p begin="0:10:29.6" end="0:10:32.36">
910
+ the consortium, as I am.<br/>
911
+
912
+ </p>
913
+
914
+ <p begin="0:10:32.36" end="0:10:37.12">
915
+ So the number of universities<br/>
916
+ who started making there
917
+ </p>
918
+
919
+ <p begin="0:10:37.12" end="0:10:41.82">
920
+ materials available, and number<br/>
921
+ of initiatives that started
922
+ </p>
923
+
924
+ <p begin="0:10:41.82" end="0:10:44.918">
925
+ making their resources<br/>
926
+ available in one form or the
927
+ </p>
928
+
929
+ <p begin="0:10:44.918" end="0:10:48.47">
930
+ other, making them available<br/>
931
+ for consumption across
932
+ </p>
933
+
934
+ <p begin="0:10:48.47" end="0:10:49.83">
935
+ the world for free.<br/>
936
+
937
+ </p>
938
+
939
+ <p begin="0:10:49.83" end="0:10:55.529">
940
+ So that characterizes the scale<br/>
941
+ of the movement, and why I
942
+ </p>
943
+
944
+ <p begin="0:10:55.529" end="0:10:59.7">
945
+ use terms like a gatherings<br/>
946
+ storm, because this is big.
947
+ </p>
948
+
949
+ <p begin="0:10:59.7" end="0:11:04.98">
950
+ I go to the Commonwealth of<br/>
951
+ Learning meetings in London,
952
+ </p>
953
+
954
+ <p begin="0:11:04.98" end="0:11:08.35">
955
+ and they say, well you know, we<br/>
956
+ have to have OER as a strategy
957
+ </p>
958
+
959
+ <p begin="0:11:08.35" end="0:11:11.408">
960
+ for extensive access to<br/>
961
+ education in developing
962
+ </p>
963
+
964
+ <p begin="0:11:11.408" end="0:11:13.36">
965
+ countries, you know.<br/>
966
+ And why they are able to make
967
+ </p>
968
+
969
+ <p begin="0:11:13.36" end="0:11:17.009">
970
+ statements like that is because<br/>
971
+ they see the evidence of the
972
+ </p>
973
+
974
+ <p begin="0:11:17.009" end="0:11:19.61">
975
+ movement in pretty<br/>
976
+ dramatically ways.
977
+ </p>
978
+
979
+ <p begin="0:11:19.61" end="0:11:22.33">
980
+ So that's one part.<br/>
981
+
982
+ </p>
983
+
984
+ <p begin="0:11:22.33" end="0:11:24.158">
985
+ I mention the consortium.<br/>
986
+
987
+ </p>
988
+
989
+ <p begin="0:11:24.158" end="0:11:27.86">
990
+ Now, typically we think this<br/>
991
+ is all about higher education.
992
+ </p>
993
+
994
+ <p begin="0:11:27.86" end="0:11:29.2">
995
+ Not true, you know.<br/>
996
+
997
+ </p>
998
+
999
+ <p begin="0:11:29.2" end="0:11:31.509">
1000
+ There are very significant<br/>
1001
+ K through 12 initiatives,
1002
+ </p>
1003
+
1004
+ <p begin="0:11:31.509" end="0:11:34.21">
1005
+ some of which you see<br/>
1006
+ listed before you.
1007
+ </p>
1008
+
1009
+ <p begin="0:11:34.21" end="0:11:38.149">
1010
+ One that Scott mentioned<br/>
1011
+ in my introduction.
1012
+ </p>
1013
+
1014
+ <p begin="0:11:38.149" end="0:11:40.84">
1015
+ Curriki which I served as<br/>
1016
+ adviser to, which actually
1017
+ </p>
1018
+
1019
+ <p begin="0:11:40.84" end="0:11:46.158">
1020
+ came out of Scott McNealy's<br/>
1021
+ championship from Sun
1022
+ </p>
1023
+
1024
+ <p begin="0:11:46.158" end="0:11:49.6">
1025
+ Microsystems, but this is, the<br/>
1026
+ Curriki initiative is to make
1027
+ </p>
1028
+
1029
+ <p begin="0:11:49.6" end="0:11:52.45">
1030
+ sure that you can create a<br/>
1031
+ framework so that people can
1032
+ </p>
1033
+
1034
+ <p begin="0:11:52.45" end="0:11:56.59">
1035
+ contribute resources for K<br/>
1036
+ through 12, and then make it
1037
+ </p>
1038
+
1039
+ <p begin="0:11:56.59" end="0:11:59.24">
1040
+ widely available in an<br/>
1041
+ open-fashion and open-source
1042
+ </p>
1043
+
1044
+ <p begin="0:11:59.24" end="0:12:04.399">
1045
+ model, and mapping it<br/>
1046
+ to regional, local and
1047
+ </p>
1048
+
1049
+ <p begin="0:12:04.399" end="0:12:07.97">
1050
+ curricula, not just in this<br/>
1051
+ country, but elsewhere.
1052
+ </p>
1053
+
1054
+ <p begin="0:12:07.97" end="0:12:11.99">
1055
+ So in the K through 12 domain<br/>
1056
+ also there is a palpable
1057
+ </p>
1058
+
1059
+ <p begin="0:12:11.99" end="0:12:16.21">
1060
+ movement, open movement, and<br/>
1061
+ you know, with some good
1062
+ </p>
1063
+
1064
+ <p begin="0:12:16.21" end="0:12:18.399">
1065
+ materials, people say, well<br/>
1066
+ you know, if it's open,
1067
+ </p>
1068
+
1069
+ <p begin="0:12:18.399" end="0:12:21.558">
1070
+ it won't be good.<br/>
1071
+ It's all bitter medicine thing.
1072
+ </p>
1073
+
1074
+ <p begin="0:12:21.558" end="0:12:26.72">
1075
+ And there are some very, very<br/>
1076
+ good pieces off educational
1077
+ </p>
1078
+
1079
+ <p begin="0:12:26.72" end="0:12:32.2">
1080
+ courseware, you know, applets<br/>
1081
+ if you will, to teach
1082
+ </p>
1083
+
1084
+ <p begin="0:12:32.2" end="0:12:33.75">
1085
+ different concepts.<br/>
1086
+
1087
+ </p>
1088
+
1089
+ <p begin="0:12:33.75" end="0:12:37.779">
1090
+ And this contribution from<br/>
1091
+ around the world, there are
1092
+ </p>
1093
+
1094
+ <p begin="0:12:37.779" end="0:12:40.84">
1095
+ initiatives that have been<br/>
1096
+ launched, to filter, to
1097
+ </p>
1098
+
1099
+ <p begin="0:12:40.84" end="0:12:44.029">
1100
+ make sure there is good,<br/>
1101
+ appropriate content.
1102
+ </p>
1103
+
1104
+ <p begin="0:12:44.029" end="0:12:46.918">
1105
+ <br/>
1106
+
1107
+ </p>
1108
+
1109
+ <p begin="0:12:46.918" end="0:12:51.62">
1110
+ MIT itself has provided a<br/>
1111
+ channel to its OpenCourseWare
1112
+ </p>
1113
+
1114
+ <p begin="0:12:51.62" end="0:12:53.408">
1115
+ for, you know, for<br/>
1116
+ higher education.
1117
+ </p>
1118
+
1119
+ <p begin="0:12:53.408" end="0:12:58.558">
1120
+ We call it highlights for high<br/>
1121
+ school, where you provide
1122
+ </p>
1123
+
1124
+ <p begin="0:12:58.558" end="0:13:02.23">
1125
+ particular channels into<br/>
1126
+ courses and content which might
1127
+ </p>
1128
+
1129
+ <p begin="0:13:02.23" end="0:13:05.73">
1130
+ be relevant for high school<br/>
1131
+ consumption, for advanced
1132
+ </p>
1133
+
1134
+ <p begin="0:13:05.73" end="0:13:08.129">
1135
+ placement of, you know,<br/>
1136
+ of advanced preparation.
1137
+ </p>
1138
+
1139
+ <p begin="0:13:08.129" end="0:13:10.6">
1140
+ <br/>
1141
+
1142
+ </p>
1143
+
1144
+ <p begin="0:13:10.6" end="0:13:13.24">
1145
+ This is a resource that I<br/>
1146
+ like to point to in the
1147
+ </p>
1148
+
1149
+ <p begin="0:13:13.24" end="0:13:14.61">
1150
+ K through 12 domain.<br/>
1151
+
1152
+ </p>
1153
+
1154
+ <p begin="0:13:14.61" end="0:13:17.778">
1155
+ This was an initiative that was<br/>
1156
+ launch by Carl Wyman, no less,
1157
+ </p>
1158
+
1159
+ <p begin="0:13:17.778" end="0:13:20.96">
1160
+ who was the year before last,<br/>
1161
+ Novel Laureate in physics, and
1162
+ </p>
1163
+
1164
+ <p begin="0:13:20.96" end="0:13:22.59">
1165
+ he had launched this when he<br/>
1166
+ was at the University
1167
+ </p>
1168
+
1169
+ <p begin="0:13:22.59" end="0:13:26.09">
1170
+ of Colorado.<br/>
1171
+ And, where, if you go to this
1172
+ </p>
1173
+
1174
+ <p begin="0:13:26.09" end="0:13:29.72">
1175
+ site, and now of course, Carl<br/>
1176
+ has moved on to University of
1177
+ </p>
1178
+
1179
+ <p begin="0:13:29.72" end="0:13:33.798">
1180
+ British Columbia, and<br/>
1181
+ this site is there.
1182
+ </p>
1183
+
1184
+ <p begin="0:13:33.798" end="0:13:35.058">
1185
+ It is maintained by his group.<br/>
1186
+
1187
+ </p>
1188
+
1189
+ <p begin="0:13:35.058" end="0:13:37.57">
1190
+ It is openly, maid<br/>
1191
+ openly available.
1192
+ </p>
1193
+
1194
+ <p begin="0:13:37.57" end="0:13:42.658">
1195
+ And if you go to the site, you<br/>
1196
+ will find that there is very,
1197
+ </p>
1198
+
1199
+ <p begin="0:13:42.658" end="0:13:46.58">
1200
+ you know, there'll be<br/>
1201
+ statements about how the
1202
+ </p>
1203
+
1204
+ <p begin="0:13:46.58" end="0:13:49.139">
1205
+ resources over there<br/>
1206
+ have been evaluated.
1207
+ </p>
1208
+
1209
+ <p begin="0:13:49.139" end="0:13:53.22">
1210
+ There has been very, very good,<br/>
1211
+ you know, they have founded,
1212
+ </p>
1213
+
1214
+ <p begin="0:13:53.22" end="0:13:55.029">
1215
+ they have been developed<br/>
1216
+ on very, very good
1217
+ </p>
1218
+
1219
+ <p begin="0:13:55.029" end="0:13:56.928">
1220
+ educational principles.<br/>
1221
+
1222
+ </p>
1223
+
1224
+ <p begin="0:13:56.928" end="0:13:59.87">
1225
+ There has been some amount<br/>
1226
+ of vigorous evaluation done.
1227
+ </p>
1228
+
1229
+ <p begin="0:13:59.87" end="0:14:05.32">
1230
+ All this to tell you that there<br/>
1231
+ is open stuff there, good stuff
1232
+ </p>
1233
+
1234
+ <p begin="0:14:05.32" end="0:14:11.61">
1235
+ that, there is quality stuff<br/>
1236
+ there, capable off making great
1237
+ </p>
1238
+
1239
+ <p begin="0:14:11.61" end="0:14:14.908">
1240
+ transformative contribution<br/>
1241
+ to education as we know it.
1242
+ </p>
1243
+
1244
+ <p begin="0:14:14.908" end="0:14:17.44">
1245
+ And what happens is, over time,<br/>
1246
+ when you start doing these
1247
+ </p>
1248
+
1249
+ <p begin="0:14:17.44" end="0:14:21.509">
1250
+ things, the kind of sort of<br/>
1251
+ vision that Scott was alluding
1252
+ </p>
1253
+
1254
+ <p begin="0:14:21.509" end="0:14:23.07">
1255
+ to, you start seeing pieces of.<br/>
1256
+
1257
+ </p>
1258
+
1259
+ <p begin="0:14:23.07" end="0:14:26.389">
1260
+ <br/>
1261
+
1262
+ </p>
1263
+
1264
+ <p begin="0:14:26.389" end="0:14:31.778">
1265
+ But like I said, that's all<br/>
1266
+ fantastic, but it's still
1267
+ </p>
1268
+
1269
+ <p begin="0:14:31.778" end="0:14:35.11">
1270
+ -- I characterize all<br/>
1271
+ that as F part one.
1272
+ </p>
1273
+
1274
+ <p begin="0:14:35.11" end="0:14:41.37">
1275
+ Part two, I think, is when, and<br/>
1276
+ if you've noticed, many of
1277
+ </p>
1278
+
1279
+ <p begin="0:14:41.37" end="0:14:46.21">
1280
+ those are about fantastic<br/>
1281
+ resources, largely about
1282
+ </p>
1283
+
1284
+ <p begin="0:14:46.21" end="0:14:51.808">
1285
+ content, and they are<br/>
1286
+ stand-alone, they are
1287
+ </p>
1288
+
1289
+ <p begin="0:14:51.808" end="0:14:56.428">
1290
+ disparitary resources, but<br/>
1291
+ transformative impact or
1292
+ </p>
1293
+
1294
+ <p begin="0:14:56.428" end="0:15:00.1">
1295
+ systemic change, I think, for<br/>
1296
+ education, happens when we can
1297
+ </p>
1298
+
1299
+ <p begin="0:15:00.1" end="0:15:07.058">
1300
+ move from there to another kind<br/>
1301
+ of place where we can actually
1302
+ </p>
1303
+
1304
+ <p begin="0:15:07.058" end="0:15:10.019">
1305
+ provide quality end to an<br/>
1306
+ educational experience
1307
+ </p>
1308
+
1309
+ <p begin="0:15:10.019" end="0:15:11.298">
1310
+ through things open.<br/>
1311
+
1312
+ </p>
1313
+
1314
+ <p begin="0:15:11.298" end="0:15:13.129">
1315
+ So when we think about<br/>
1316
+ end-to-end educational
1317
+ </p>
1318
+
1319
+ <p begin="0:15:13.129" end="0:15:16.259">
1320
+ experiences, we think not<br/>
1321
+ only about content, but how we
1322
+ </p>
1323
+
1324
+ <p begin="0:15:16.259" end="0:15:19.57">
1325
+ might be able to do, provide<br/>
1326
+ first-hand experiences,
1327
+ </p>
1328
+
1329
+ <p begin="0:15:19.57" end="0:15:25.288">
1330
+ laboratory experiences, as,<br/>
1331
+ you know, to complement
1332
+ </p>
1333
+
1334
+ <p begin="0:15:25.288" end="0:15:26.71">
1335
+ good content out there.<br/>
1336
+
1337
+ </p>
1338
+
1339
+ <p begin="0:15:26.71" end="0:15:29.798">
1340
+ How might we provide good<br/>
1341
+ interactive experiences for
1342
+ </p>
1343
+
1344
+ <p begin="0:15:29.798" end="0:15:38.49">
1345
+ people learning and how we<br/>
1346
+ might actually harvest
1347
+ </p>
1348
+
1349
+ <p begin="0:15:38.49" end="0:15:41.69">
1350
+ resources that might be<br/>
1351
+ available anywhere and
1352
+ </p>
1353
+
1354
+ <p begin="0:15:41.69" end="0:15:44.808">
1355
+ productivity combine them to<br/>
1356
+ deliver different kinds of
1357
+ </p>
1358
+
1359
+ <p begin="0:15:44.808" end="0:15:48.149">
1360
+ learning experiences to<br/>
1361
+ suit different audiences.
1362
+ </p>
1363
+
1364
+ <p begin="0:15:48.149" end="0:15:54.538">
1365
+ And, really keep the focus<br/>
1366
+ on quality, the fact that
1367
+ </p>
1368
+
1369
+ <p begin="0:15:54.538" end="0:15:58.94">
1370
+ you can generate new kinds<br/>
1371
+ of experiences, new
1372
+ </p>
1373
+
1374
+ <p begin="0:15:58.94" end="0:16:00.389">
1375
+ kinds of material.<br/>
1376
+
1377
+ </p>
1378
+
1379
+ <p begin="0:16:00.389" end="0:16:04.72">
1380
+ So what I'd like to do now is<br/>
1381
+ just point to some off the
1382
+ </p>
1383
+
1384
+ <p begin="0:16:04.72" end="0:16:08.399">
1385
+ kinds of initiatives, and I<br/>
1386
+ will apologize, many of the
1387
+ </p>
1388
+
1389
+ <p begin="0:16:08.399" end="0:16:13.528">
1390
+ initiatives that I'm pointing<br/>
1391
+ to are MIT based, but
1392
+ </p>
1393
+
1394
+ <p begin="0:16:13.528" end="0:16:16.08">
1395
+ you know, I talk about<br/>
1396
+ what I know better.
1397
+ </p>
1398
+
1399
+ <p begin="0:16:16.08" end="0:16:19.278">
1400
+ So I'll point to them,<br/>
1401
+ but they're done.
1402
+ </p>
1403
+
1404
+ <p begin="0:16:19.278" end="0:16:22.72">
1405
+ And I'll also point out that<br/>
1406
+ they might have been launched
1407
+ </p>
1408
+
1409
+ <p begin="0:16:22.72" end="0:16:28.278">
1410
+ at MIT, but right from the<br/>
1411
+ get-go they involved other
1412
+ </p>
1413
+
1414
+ <p begin="0:16:28.278" end="0:16:30.889">
1415
+ institutions, other players.<br/>
1416
+
1417
+ </p>
1418
+
1419
+ <p begin="0:16:30.889" end="0:16:35.389">
1420
+ But they speak to the kinds of,<br/>
1421
+ the value proposition elements
1422
+ </p>
1423
+
1424
+ <p begin="0:16:35.389" end="0:16:38.35">
1425
+ that I think will take us to to<br/>
1426
+ this vision of a Metaversity II.
1427
+ </p>
1428
+
1429
+ <p begin="0:16:38.35" end="0:16:46.08">
1430
+ So, this is an initiative that<br/>
1431
+ I like to talk about a lot.
1432
+ </p>
1433
+
1434
+ <p begin="0:16:46.08" end="0:16:47.61">
1435
+ <br/>
1436
+
1437
+ </p>
1438
+
1439
+ <p begin="0:16:47.61" end="0:16:50.95">
1440
+ On the left is Jesus del<br/>
1441
+ Alamo he is a professor right
1442
+ </p>
1443
+
1444
+ <p begin="0:16:50.95" end="0:16:55.408">
1445
+ here, upstairs, teaches in<br/>
1446
+ electrical engineering.
1447
+ </p>
1448
+
1449
+ <p begin="0:16:55.408" end="0:16:56.95">
1450
+ <br/>
1451
+
1452
+ </p>
1453
+
1454
+ <p begin="0:16:56.95" end="0:17:00.96">
1455
+ So some years ago, he started<br/>
1456
+ this thing called iLab and the
1457
+ </p>
1458
+
1459
+ <p begin="0:17:00.96" end="0:17:04.759">
1460
+ intent of iLab is to provide<br/>
1461
+ access to real laboratories
1462
+ </p>
1463
+
1464
+ <p begin="0:17:04.759" end="0:17:07.96">
1465
+ over the internet, not<br/>
1466
+ simulations, actually labs.
1467
+ </p>
1468
+
1469
+ <p begin="0:17:07.96" end="0:17:13.22">
1470
+ So, initially it started off<br/>
1471
+ with some, you know, network
1472
+ </p>
1473
+
1474
+ <p begin="0:17:13.22" end="0:17:17.96">
1475
+ signal analyzer and for digital<br/>
1476
+ signal processing courses.
1477
+ </p>
1478
+
1479
+ <p begin="0:17:17.96" end="0:17:20.68">
1480
+ And then there were some<br/>
1481
+ other labs that actually got
1482
+ </p>
1483
+
1484
+ <p begin="0:17:20.68" end="0:17:23.96">
1485
+ launched, and we had students<br/>
1486
+ from Singapore, from Sweden
1487
+ </p>
1488
+
1489
+ <p begin="0:17:23.96" end="0:17:28.588">
1490
+ sort of places who were<br/>
1491
+ actually conducting
1492
+ </p>
1493
+
1494
+ <p begin="0:17:28.588" end="0:17:29.836">
1495
+ labs over here.<br/>
1496
+
1497
+ </p>
1498
+
1499
+ <p begin="0:17:29.836" end="0:17:31.99">
1500
+ <br/>
1501
+
1502
+ </p>
1503
+
1504
+ <p begin="0:17:31.99" end="0:17:34.848">
1505
+ And, you know, then we had<br/>
1506
+ some of our Cambridge students
1507
+ </p>
1508
+
1509
+ <p begin="0:17:34.848" end="0:17:37.259">
1510
+ actually looking at, you know,<br/>
1511
+ we had a partnership with the
1512
+ </p>
1513
+
1514
+ <p begin="0:17:37.259" end="0:17:39.618">
1515
+ University of Cambridge,<br/>
1516
+ who was looking at
1517
+ </p>
1518
+
1519
+ <p begin="0:17:39.618" end="0:17:40.9">
1520
+ chemical reactors.<br/>
1521
+
1522
+ </p>
1523
+
1524
+ <p begin="0:17:40.9" end="0:17:44.328">
1525
+ There was a civil engineering,<br/>
1526
+ a shake table experiment to do
1527
+ </p>
1528
+
1529
+ <p begin="0:17:44.328" end="0:17:51.298">
1530
+ seismic measurements, and these<br/>
1531
+ work controlled, accessed,
1532
+ </p>
1533
+
1534
+ <p begin="0:17:51.298" end="0:17:54.328">
1535
+ through browsers, and people<br/>
1536
+ actually adjusted the
1537
+ </p>
1538
+
1539
+ <p begin="0:17:54.328" end="0:17:57.17">
1540
+ parameters, saw the results,<br/>
1541
+ and not only that, there were
1542
+ </p>
1543
+
1544
+ <p begin="0:17:57.17" end="0:17:59.99">
1545
+ communities swarming which<br/>
1546
+ would discuss the results.
1547
+ </p>
1548
+
1549
+ <p begin="0:17:59.99" end="0:18:05.73">
1550
+ And in fact, we have one that<br/>
1551
+ is going on right now, an NSF
1552
+ </p>
1553
+
1554
+ <p begin="0:18:05.73" end="0:18:08.74">
1555
+ supported project where K<br/>
1556
+ through 12 students have
1557
+ </p>
1558
+
1559
+ <p begin="0:18:08.74" end="0:18:11.828">
1560
+ browser-based access.<br/>
1561
+ MIT has a benign,
1562
+ </p>
1563
+
1564
+ <p begin="0:18:11.828" end="0:18:13.368">
1565
+ friendly, nuclear reactor.<br/>
1566
+
1567
+ </p>
1568
+
1569
+ <p begin="0:18:13.368" end="0:18:18.24">
1570
+ I have to put all these<br/>
1571
+ qualifiers over there, but
1572
+ </p>
1573
+
1574
+ <p begin="0:18:18.24" end="0:18:22.278">
1575
+ you know, it's provides<br/>
1576
+ access to those.
1577
+ </p>
1578
+
1579
+ <p begin="0:18:22.278" end="0:18:23.43">
1580
+ <br/>
1581
+
1582
+ </p>
1583
+
1584
+ <p begin="0:18:23.43" end="0:18:26.39">
1585
+ And you can see, I mean you can<br/>
1586
+ imagine the empowerment when K
1587
+ </p>
1588
+
1589
+ <p begin="0:18:26.39" end="0:18:28.163">
1590
+ through 12 students are<br/>
1591
+ watching these neutrons go,
1592
+ </p>
1593
+
1594
+ <p begin="0:18:28.163" end="0:18:30.64">
1595
+ and by the way, the same<br/>
1596
+ browser-based access that is
1597
+ </p>
1598
+
1599
+ <p begin="0:18:30.64" end="0:18:35.779">
1600
+ providing data for spectrometry<br/>
1601
+ experiments to a nuclear
1602
+ </p>
1603
+
1604
+ <p begin="0:18:35.779" end="0:18:43.66">
1605
+ engineering program, but the<br/>
1606
+ fact is that iLabs, the
1607
+ </p>
1608
+
1609
+ <p begin="0:18:43.66" end="0:18:49.769">
1610
+ technical architecture, the<br/>
1611
+ framework iLabs, makes labs
1612
+ </p>
1613
+
1614
+ <p begin="0:18:49.769" end="0:18:54.858">
1615
+ available, labs accessible<br/>
1616
+ openly over the internet.
1617
+ </p>
1618
+
1619
+ <p begin="0:18:54.858" end="0:18:58.44">
1620
+ So that's brings a first-time,<br/>
1621
+ hands-on experience to
1622
+ </p>
1623
+
1624
+ <p begin="0:18:58.44" end="0:19:02.588">
1625
+ complement open resources that<br/>
1626
+ might be available in a course.
1627
+ </p>
1628
+
1629
+ <p begin="0:19:02.588" end="0:19:07.24">
1630
+ Now, so you can see, and I<br/>
1631
+ normally talk about this more
1632
+ </p>
1633
+
1634
+ <p begin="0:19:07.24" end="0:19:09.769">
1635
+ than I should, but I'm really<br/>
1636
+ passionate about this.
1637
+ </p>
1638
+
1639
+ <p begin="0:19:09.769" end="0:19:14.24">
1640
+ Because, one of the things that<br/>
1641
+ you find that happens, and this
1642
+ </p>
1643
+
1644
+ <p begin="0:19:14.24" end="0:19:18.99">
1645
+ is a transformative dimension<br/>
1646
+ of this, is that iLabs is not
1647
+ </p>
1648
+
1649
+ <p begin="0:19:18.99" end="0:19:23.058">
1650
+ just about making expensive<br/>
1651
+ equipment, you know, a radio
1652
+ </p>
1653
+
1654
+ <p begin="0:19:23.058" end="0:19:29.38">
1655
+ telescope accessible to people,<br/>
1656
+ you know, but it really alters
1657
+ </p>
1658
+
1659
+ <p begin="0:19:29.38" end="0:19:31.868">
1660
+ the economics of<br/>
1661
+ lab instruction.
1662
+ </p>
1663
+
1664
+ <p begin="0:19:31.868" end="0:19:35.578">
1665
+ Labs are expensive, whether<br/>
1666
+ they're small labs or big labs.
1667
+ </p>
1668
+
1669
+ <p begin="0:19:35.578" end="0:19:38.588">
1670
+ You configure them.<br/>
1671
+ They take time to be configured.
1672
+ </p>
1673
+
1674
+ <p begin="0:19:38.588" end="0:19:40.029">
1675
+ They are one-time installation.<br/>
1676
+
1677
+ </p>
1678
+
1679
+ <p begin="0:19:40.029" end="0:19:41.558">
1680
+ You set it up. You do it.<br/>
1681
+
1682
+ </p>
1683
+
1684
+ <p begin="0:19:41.558" end="0:19:44.308">
1685
+ Then you've got to wait long<br/>
1686
+ time before you set up again.
1687
+ </p>
1688
+
1689
+ <p begin="0:19:44.308" end="0:19:45.7">
1690
+ There's always latency.<br/>
1691
+
1692
+ </p>
1693
+
1694
+ <p begin="0:19:45.7" end="0:19:48.5">
1695
+ I do not know about your<br/>
1696
+ education, but you know,
1697
+ </p>
1698
+
1699
+ <p begin="0:19:48.5" end="0:19:51.16">
1700
+ Monday you got the lecture.<br/>
1701
+
1702
+ </p>
1703
+
1704
+ <p begin="0:19:51.16" end="0:19:53.078">
1705
+ And a couple of weeks<br/>
1706
+ later you did the lab
1707
+ </p>
1708
+
1709
+ <p begin="0:19:53.078" end="0:19:55.75">
1710
+ work or didn't do it.<br/>
1711
+ Solid latency between when you
1712
+ </p>
1713
+
1714
+ <p begin="0:19:55.75" end="0:19:57.868">
1715
+ learned the concept and you<br/>
1716
+ would actually be able
1717
+ </p>
1718
+
1719
+ <p begin="0:19:57.868" end="0:19:59.69">
1720
+ to learn from it.<br/>
1721
+
1722
+ </p>
1723
+
1724
+ <p begin="0:19:59.69" end="0:20:03.769">
1725
+ So it was expensive, you<br/>
1726
+ know, what IT affrays, it
1727
+ </p>
1728
+
1729
+ <p begin="0:20:03.769" end="0:20:06.259">
1730
+ was expensive in terms<br/>
1731
+ of the learner's time.
1732
+ </p>
1733
+
1734
+ <p begin="0:20:06.259" end="0:20:08.259">
1735
+ It was expensive in terms of<br/>
1736
+ the fact that there were
1737
+ </p>
1738
+
1739
+ <p begin="0:20:08.259" end="0:20:14.548">
1740
+ one-time installation, and<br/>
1741
+ suddenly this iLab project
1742
+ </p>
1743
+
1744
+ <p begin="0:20:14.548" end="0:20:18.22">
1745
+ provides the potential to say,<br/>
1746
+ you know, this 24 by 7 access
1747
+ </p>
1748
+
1749
+ <p begin="0:20:18.22" end="0:20:22.48">
1750
+ for this, being able to<br/>
1751
+ leverage a setup much more
1752
+ </p>
1753
+
1754
+ <p begin="0:20:22.48" end="0:20:26.13">
1755
+ extensively, can dramatically<br/>
1756
+ alter the economics of
1757
+ </p>
1758
+
1759
+ <p begin="0:20:26.13" end="0:20:27.798">
1760
+ laboratory instruction.<br/>
1761
+
1762
+ </p>
1763
+
1764
+ <p begin="0:20:27.798" end="0:20:31.098">
1765
+ That is, of course, if you<br/>
1766
+ believe as we do, that
1767
+ </p>
1768
+
1769
+ <p begin="0:20:31.098" end="0:20:34.618">
1770
+ laboratory instruction,<br/>
1771
+ first-hand experiences are a
1772
+ </p>
1773
+
1774
+ <p begin="0:20:34.618" end="0:20:38.45">
1775
+ very important part off the<br/>
1776
+ educational experience.
1777
+ </p>
1778
+
1779
+ <p begin="0:20:38.45" end="0:20:41.4">
1780
+ And you know, there are things<br/>
1781
+ that, we had students here for
1782
+ </p>
1783
+
1784
+ <p begin="0:20:41.4" end="0:20:45.73">
1785
+ one time, I remember, who<br/>
1786
+ wanted to do some experiments
1787
+ </p>
1788
+
1789
+ <p begin="0:20:45.73" end="0:20:47.298">
1790
+ with Compaq's clean labs.<br/>
1791
+
1792
+ </p>
1793
+
1794
+ <p begin="0:20:47.298" end="0:20:50.24">
1795
+ We, Compaq didn't want our<br/>
1796
+ student traipsing all over the
1797
+ </p>
1798
+
1799
+ <p begin="0:20:50.24" end="0:20:53.048">
1800
+ clean labs over there, but the<br/>
1801
+ setup allowed us to do
1802
+ </p>
1803
+
1804
+ <p begin="0:20:53.048" end="0:20:54.95">
1805
+ controlled experiments<br/>
1806
+ in the clean labs.
1807
+ </p>
1808
+
1809
+ <p begin="0:20:54.95" end="0:20:58.048">
1810
+ So you can start imagining<br/>
1811
+ the implications, not only for
1812
+ </p>
1813
+
1814
+ <p begin="0:20:58.048" end="0:21:00.63">
1815
+ formal education, but things<br/>
1816
+ like vocational education,
1817
+ </p>
1818
+
1819
+ <p begin="0:21:00.63" end="0:21:04.38">
1820
+ cannot connect up with<br/>
1821
+ equipment that might
1822
+ </p>
1823
+
1824
+ <p begin="0:21:04.38" end="0:21:05.68">
1825
+ be available industry.<br/>
1826
+
1827
+ </p>
1828
+
1829
+ <p begin="0:21:05.68" end="0:21:10.278">
1830
+ So it has the potential<br/>
1831
+ to dramatically
1832
+ </p>
1833
+
1834
+ <p begin="0:21:10.278" end="0:21:12.74">
1835
+ alter the economics.<br/>
1836
+ Now, again, the interesting
1837
+ </p>
1838
+
1839
+ <p begin="0:21:12.74" end="0:21:17.42">
1840
+ things about iLab and open<br/>
1841
+ iLabs is not the five or six or
1842
+ </p>
1843
+
1844
+ <p begin="0:21:17.42" end="0:21:21.16">
1845
+ seven labs that have been set<br/>
1846
+ up at MIT and being made
1847
+ </p>
1848
+
1849
+ <p begin="0:21:21.16" end="0:21:24.568">
1850
+ accessible, but the fact that<br/>
1851
+ there are labs elsewhere, in
1852
+ </p>
1853
+
1854
+ <p begin="0:21:24.568" end="0:21:28.118">
1855
+ fact, both at the University of<br/>
1856
+ Queensland our colleague,
1857
+ </p>
1858
+
1859
+ <p begin="0:21:28.118" end="0:21:30.99">
1860
+ Phil Hong, who's there.<br/>
1861
+ University of Queensland,
1862
+ </p>
1863
+
1864
+ <p begin="0:21:30.99" end="0:21:35.598">
1865
+ China, they have more labs<br/>
1866
+ in the iLab framework
1867
+ </p>
1868
+
1869
+ <p begin="0:21:35.598" end="0:21:37.529">
1870
+ than actually MIT has.<br/>
1871
+
1872
+ </p>
1873
+
1874
+ <p begin="0:21:37.529" end="0:21:41.588">
1875
+ And so the architecture allows<br/>
1876
+ lab anywhere to be set up.
1877
+ </p>
1878
+
1879
+ <p begin="0:21:41.588" end="0:21:44.68">
1880
+ In fact, for us, the value<br/>
1881
+ proposition is that we might
1882
+ </p>
1883
+
1884
+ <p begin="0:21:44.68" end="0:21:47.65">
1885
+ want our students to access<br/>
1886
+ labs that have been
1887
+ </p>
1888
+
1889
+ <p begin="0:21:47.65" end="0:21:49.308">
1890
+ set up elsewhere.<br/>
1891
+
1892
+ </p>
1893
+
1894
+ <p begin="0:21:49.308" end="0:21:53.4">
1895
+ So that's the value<br/>
1896
+ proposition, and that's where
1897
+ </p>
1898
+
1899
+ <p begin="0:21:53.4" end="0:21:56.608">
1900
+ the openness dimension comes<br/>
1901
+ the open architecture, allows
1902
+ </p>
1903
+
1904
+ <p begin="0:21:56.608" end="0:22:00.45">
1905
+ people to set up labs, big or<br/>
1906
+ small, and make it accessible
1907
+ </p>
1908
+
1909
+ <p begin="0:22:00.45" end="0:22:02.63">
1910
+ to students all over the world.<br/>
1911
+
1912
+ </p>
1913
+
1914
+ <p begin="0:22:02.63" end="0:22:05.2">
1915
+ So, I'm pointing to<br/>
1916
+ a couple of things.
1917
+ </p>
1918
+
1919
+ <p begin="0:22:05.2" end="0:22:07.75">
1920
+ This is done at our office,<br/>
1921
+ at the Office of Educational
1922
+ </p>
1923
+
1924
+ <p begin="0:22:07.75" end="0:22:10.74">
1925
+ Innovation and Technology.<br/>
1926
+ The day before yesterday, Chuck
1927
+ </p>
1928
+
1929
+ <p begin="0:22:10.74" end="0:22:14.89">
1930
+ Schubert, who heads this group<br/>
1931
+ called the Star Group, at, oh
1932
+ </p>
1933
+
1934
+ <p begin="0:22:14.89" end="0:22:17.94">
1935
+ yes, he came and you know, had<br/>
1936
+ me sign a few forms, a whole
1937
+ </p>
1938
+
1939
+ <p begin="0:22:17.94" end="0:22:23.108">
1940
+ bunch of the Star tools for<br/>
1941
+ visualization in biology, in
1942
+ </p>
1943
+
1944
+ <p begin="0:22:23.108" end="0:22:26.22">
1945
+ genetic modeling for genetic<br/>
1946
+ modeling for hydrology, that
1947
+ </p>
1948
+
1949
+ <p begin="0:22:26.22" end="0:22:33.23">
1950
+ had been set up, are now an<br/>
1951
+ open source and made available.
1952
+ </p>
1953
+
1954
+ <p begin="0:22:33.23" end="0:22:34.779">
1955
+ So these are<br/>
1956
+ fantastic simulations.
1957
+ </p>
1958
+
1959
+ <p begin="0:22:34.779" end="0:22:38.65">
1960
+ And why I'm pointing to these<br/>
1961
+ particular ones, because there
1962
+ </p>
1963
+
1964
+ <p begin="0:22:38.65" end="0:22:46.47">
1965
+ is educational, because they<br/>
1966
+ are tied to some very good deep
1967
+ </p>
1968
+
1969
+ <p begin="0:22:46.47" end="0:22:52.029">
1970
+ thinking about tools that are<br/>
1971
+ available openly, and you know,
1972
+ </p>
1973
+
1974
+ <p begin="0:22:52.029" end="0:22:53.838">
1975
+ there are great visualization<br/>
1976
+ tools tools, and
1977
+ </p>
1978
+
1979
+ <p begin="0:22:53.838" end="0:22:55.308">
1980
+ we've all seen them.<br/>
1981
+ They are common.
1982
+ </p>
1983
+
1984
+ <p begin="0:22:55.308" end="0:22:58.759">
1985
+ This is part of a program that<br/>
1986
+ we have at OEIT to bridge
1987
+ </p>
1988
+
1989
+ <p begin="0:22:58.759" end="0:23:01.64">
1990
+ research and learning, to<br/>
1991
+ bring, to provide our
1992
+ </p>
1993
+
1994
+ <p begin="0:23:01.64" end="0:23:04.65">
1995
+ undergraduate students,<br/>
1996
+ first-year students, with early
1997
+ </p>
1998
+
1999
+ <p begin="0:23:04.65" end="0:23:08.338">
2000
+ exposure to research tools, and<br/>
2001
+ the kinds of applications
2002
+ </p>
2003
+
2004
+ <p begin="0:23:08.338" end="0:23:10.92">
2005
+ that typically are only<br/>
2006
+ available to researchers.
2007
+ </p>
2008
+
2009
+ <p begin="0:23:10.92" end="0:23:14.568">
2010
+ And how can we remove the<br/>
2011
+ operational fog from these, so
2012
+ </p>
2013
+
2014
+ <p begin="0:23:14.568" end="0:23:18.519">
2015
+ that first-year students, again<br/>
2016
+ in this case even K through 12
2017
+ </p>
2018
+
2019
+ <p begin="0:23:18.519" end="0:23:21.598">
2020
+ students, can actually<br/>
2021
+ use these tools.
2022
+ </p>
2023
+
2024
+ <p begin="0:23:21.598" end="0:23:25.94">
2025
+ This visualization that is seen<br/>
2026
+ which looks like Justin, who
2027
+ </p>
2028
+
2029
+ <p begin="0:23:25.94" end="0:23:30.4">
2030
+ also works with us, twirling,<br/>
2031
+ you know, when they are
2032
+ </p>
2033
+
2034
+ <p begin="0:23:30.4" end="0:23:33.41">
2035
+ visualizing DNA molecules,<br/>
2036
+ students look at it, They make
2037
+ </p>
2038
+
2039
+ <p begin="0:23:33.41" end="0:23:37.7">
2040
+ conjectures about<br/>
2041
+ it's properties.
2042
+ </p>
2043
+
2044
+ <p begin="0:23:37.7" end="0:23:40.868">
2045
+ They can reach into Cornell's<br/>
2046
+ protein database, make
2047
+ </p>
2048
+
2049
+ <p begin="0:23:40.868" end="0:23:46.23">
2050
+ comparisons now, and so you<br/>
2051
+ provide some very empowering
2052
+ </p>
2053
+
2054
+ <p begin="0:23:46.23" end="0:23:49.97">
2055
+ experiences and exposure to<br/>
2056
+ very big professional tools
2057
+ </p>
2058
+
2059
+ <p begin="0:23:49.97" end="0:23:52.98">
2060
+ and profession thinking, and<br/>
2061
+ provide them the confidence by
2062
+ </p>
2063
+
2064
+ <p begin="0:23:52.98" end="0:23:57.788">
2065
+ creating visualizations like<br/>
2066
+ this, with students can control.
2067
+ </p>
2068
+
2069
+ <p begin="0:23:57.788" end="0:24:02.7">
2070
+ Now these kinds of simulations<br/>
2071
+ of tools are available in the
2072
+ </p>
2073
+
2074
+ <p begin="0:24:02.7" end="0:24:08.068">
2075
+ open, and what lies under them<br/>
2076
+ is a lot of good thinking, hard
2077
+ </p>
2078
+
2079
+ <p begin="0:24:08.068" end="0:24:12.338">
2080
+ problems that certainly are a<br/>
2081
+ faculty of experience, in
2082
+ </p>
2083
+
2084
+ <p begin="0:24:12.338" end="0:24:15.17">
2085
+ bringing research concepts into<br/>
2086
+ learning, because it's all nice
2087
+ </p>
2088
+
2089
+ <p begin="0:24:15.17" end="0:24:18.65">
2090
+ to say, you know, we want to<br/>
2091
+ have lots of proximity between
2092
+ </p>
2093
+
2094
+ <p begin="0:24:18.65" end="0:24:22.38">
2095
+ research and teaching, but to<br/>
2096
+ create tangible, manageable
2097
+ </p>
2098
+
2099
+ <p begin="0:24:22.38" end="0:24:26.97">
2100
+ crosswalks is not easy, and you<br/>
2101
+ do it through these tools, and
2102
+ </p>
2103
+
2104
+ <p begin="0:24:26.97" end="0:24:29.25">
2105
+ then you make these tools<br/>
2106
+ widely available so
2107
+ </p>
2108
+
2109
+ <p begin="0:24:29.25" end="0:24:31.788">
2110
+ that students all over<br/>
2111
+ can benefit from it.
2112
+ </p>
2113
+
2114
+ <p begin="0:24:31.788" end="0:24:32.848">
2115
+ <br/>
2116
+
2117
+ </p>
2118
+
2119
+ <p begin="0:24:32.848" end="0:24:37.91">
2120
+ So, I'm trying to give you a<br/>
2121
+ sense of the kinds of
2122
+ </p>
2123
+
2124
+ <p begin="0:24:37.91" end="0:24:48.328">
2125
+ possibilities, the enablements<br/>
2126
+ that lead to this vision, this
2127
+ </p>
2128
+
2129
+ <p begin="0:24:48.328" end="0:24:52.048">
2130
+ vision that is more advanced<br/>
2131
+ than the current capabilities
2132
+ </p>
2133
+
2134
+ <p begin="0:24:52.048" end="0:24:53.788">
2135
+ that open resources<br/>
2136
+ have created.
2137
+ </p>
2138
+
2139
+ <p begin="0:24:53.788" end="0:24:57.19">
2140
+ Now this is a project, this is<br/>
2141
+ very dear to my friend, Andrew
2142
+ </p>
2143
+
2144
+ <p begin="0:24:57.19" end="0:25:01.788">
2145
+ over there, and he and his<br/>
2146
+ team, and Brandon, they
2147
+ </p>
2148
+
2149
+ <p begin="0:25:01.788" end="0:25:03.818">
2150
+ are all working on this.<br/>
2151
+ This is a project that was
2152
+ </p>
2153
+
2154
+ <p begin="0:25:03.818" end="0:25:07.519">
2155
+ started by a professor<br/>
2156
+ upstairs, a Professor Jim Glass
2157
+ </p>
2158
+
2159
+ <p begin="0:25:07.519" end="0:25:11.99">
2160
+ in Computer Science, and what<br/>
2161
+ it does is it uses natural
2162
+ </p>
2163
+
2164
+ <p begin="0:25:11.99" end="0:25:15.307">
2165
+ language recognition, voice<br/>
2166
+ recognition, summarization.
2167
+ </p>
2168
+
2169
+ <p begin="0:25:15.307" end="0:25:16.38">
2170
+ <br/>
2171
+
2172
+ </p>
2173
+
2174
+ <p begin="0:25:16.38" end="0:25:20.18">
2175
+ And the intent is to provide<br/>
2176
+ very, very acute and good
2177
+ </p>
2178
+
2179
+ <p begin="0:25:20.18" end="0:25:22.66">
2180
+ access to digitized content.<br/>
2181
+
2182
+ </p>
2183
+
2184
+ <p begin="0:25:22.66" end="0:25:30.38">
2185
+ So we have digital video of<br/>
2186
+ lectures and the idea is to go
2187
+ </p>
2188
+
2189
+ <p begin="0:25:30.38" end="0:25:34.24">
2190
+ search these to get particular<br/>
2191
+ snippets of the lectures
2192
+ </p>
2193
+
2194
+ <p begin="0:25:34.24" end="0:25:37.884">
2195
+ that might be relevant.<br/>
2196
+ So, for instance, what you
2197
+ </p>
2198
+
2199
+ <p begin="0:25:37.884" end="0:25:41.009">
2200
+ can't see, probably seen in<br/>
2201
+ the highlight, there's a lot of
2202
+ </p>
2203
+
2204
+ <p begin="0:25:41.009" end="0:25:42.89">
2205
+ angular momentum showing up.<br/>
2206
+
2207
+ </p>
2208
+
2209
+ <p begin="0:25:42.89" end="0:25:46.99">
2210
+ So what we are working on is to<br/>
2211
+ make sure that you can use this
2212
+ </p>
2213
+
2214
+ <p begin="0:25:46.99" end="0:25:52.97">
2215
+ to go and find all those<br/>
2216
+ lecture segments that deal with
2217
+ </p>
2218
+
2219
+ <p begin="0:25:52.97" end="0:25:57.578">
2220
+ angular momentum, because if I<br/>
2221
+ as an instructor, want to
2222
+ </p>
2223
+
2224
+ <p begin="0:25:57.578" end="0:26:00.68">
2225
+ provide some deeper thinking, a<br/>
2226
+ nuance learning around the
2227
+ </p>
2228
+
2229
+ <p begin="0:26:00.68" end="0:26:03.41">
2230
+ notion of angular momentum, I<br/>
2231
+ want to be able to make
2232
+ </p>
2233
+
2234
+ <p begin="0:26:03.41" end="0:26:06.519">
2235
+ sure the students can get<br/>
2236
+ efficiently to that section,
2237
+ </p>
2238
+
2239
+ <p begin="0:26:06.519" end="0:26:09.74">
2240
+ because you know, it might<br/>
2241
+ occur all over the place in the
2242
+ </p>
2243
+
2244
+ <p begin="0:26:09.74" end="0:26:14.42">
2245
+ course of a lecture or in the<br/>
2246
+ course of a 14-week semester,
2247
+ </p>
2248
+
2249
+ <p begin="0:26:14.42" end="0:26:17.098">
2250
+ where this topic might be<br/>
2251
+ treated in different ways, and
2252
+ </p>
2253
+
2254
+ <p begin="0:26:17.098" end="0:26:19.548">
2255
+ you want students to go very,<br/>
2256
+ very efficiently to those
2257
+ </p>
2258
+
2259
+ <p begin="0:26:19.548" end="0:26:21.14">
2260
+ segments and get there.<br/>
2261
+
2262
+ </p>
2263
+
2264
+ <p begin="0:26:21.14" end="0:26:24.44">
2265
+ So the Spoken Lecture Browser<br/>
2266
+ provides very, very -- as it's
2267
+ </p>
2268
+
2269
+ <p begin="0:26:24.44" end="0:26:30.46">
2270
+ named -- browser-based access,<br/>
2271
+ and, but it uses, like I
2272
+ </p>
2273
+
2274
+ <p begin="0:26:30.46" end="0:26:32.21">
2275
+ said, natural language<br/>
2276
+ recognition to get there.
2277
+ </p>
2278
+
2279
+ <p begin="0:26:32.21" end="0:26:34.38">
2280
+ This is a very exciting<br/>
2281
+ project, and what we are trying
2282
+ </p>
2283
+
2284
+ <p begin="0:26:34.38" end="0:26:38.808">
2285
+ to do is see how this can be<br/>
2286
+ really leveraged not only for
2287
+ </p>
2288
+
2289
+ <p begin="0:26:38.808" end="0:26:42.568">
2290
+ video content across our<br/>
2291
+ courses, Andrew and team
2292
+ </p>
2293
+
2294
+ <p begin="0:26:42.568" end="0:26:45.65">
2295
+ are working on a couple of<br/>
2296
+ introductory physics courses.
2297
+ </p>
2298
+
2299
+ <p begin="0:26:45.65" end="0:26:49.39">
2300
+ Some off you might have seen<br/>
2301
+ this dramatic video lecture,
2302
+ </p>
2303
+
2304
+ <p begin="0:26:49.39" end="0:26:51.328">
2305
+ Walter Lewin's lecture<br/>
2306
+ on OpenCourseWare.
2307
+ </p>
2308
+
2309
+ <p begin="0:26:51.328" end="0:26:53.41">
2310
+ He has been featured<br/>
2311
+ on everything from
2312
+ </p>
2313
+
2314
+ <p begin="0:26:53.41" end="0:26:56.078">
2315
+ Jay Leno to NPR.<br/>
2316
+
2317
+ </p>
2318
+
2319
+ <p begin="0:26:56.078" end="0:27:02.19">
2320
+ But, you know, you can get to<br/>
2321
+ segments of Lewin's lecture,
2322
+ </p>
2323
+
2324
+ <p begin="0:27:02.19" end="0:27:05.39">
2325
+ and they're working on that,<br/>
2326
+ because a current instructor,
2327
+ </p>
2328
+
2329
+ <p begin="0:27:05.39" end="0:27:09.14">
2330
+ Peter Dourmashkin, wants his<br/>
2331
+ students to go to particular
2332
+ </p>
2333
+
2334
+ <p begin="0:27:09.14" end="0:27:12.509">
2335
+ concepts, you know, advanced<br/>
2336
+ learning and particular things,
2337
+ </p>
2338
+
2339
+ <p begin="0:27:12.509" end="0:27:18.368">
2340
+ and the spoken lecture, you<br/>
2341
+ know, at OEIT, we are
2342
+ </p>
2343
+
2344
+ <p begin="0:27:18.368" end="0:27:21.38">
2345
+ stabilizing the research work<br/>
2346
+ in the project and enabling
2347
+ </p>
2348
+
2349
+ <p begin="0:27:21.38" end="0:27:22.73">
2350
+ that kind of research.<br/>
2351
+
2352
+ </p>
2353
+
2354
+ <p begin="0:27:22.73" end="0:27:27.298">
2355
+ Our goal is to take it to open<br/>
2356
+ video content that might be
2357
+ </p>
2358
+
2359
+ <p begin="0:27:27.298" end="0:27:30.259">
2360
+ available across, you know,<br/>
2361
+ from different institutions, at
2362
+ </p>
2363
+
2364
+ <p begin="0:27:30.259" end="0:27:32.93">
2365
+ least as a start for all of the<br/>
2366
+ universities that are in the
2367
+ </p>
2368
+
2369
+ <p begin="0:27:32.93" end="0:27:34.23">
2370
+ OpenCourseWare consortium.<br/>
2371
+
2372
+ </p>
2373
+
2374
+ <p begin="0:27:34.23" end="0:27:36.96">
2375
+ So that's, you can see that<br/>
2376
+ kind of enablement, again,
2377
+ </p>
2378
+
2379
+ <p begin="0:27:36.96" end="0:27:41.098">
2380
+ extending that to, this is a<br/>
2381
+ wonderful project, Shakespeare
2382
+ </p>
2383
+
2384
+ <p begin="0:27:41.098" end="0:27:45.19">
2385
+ in Asia, which has got various<br/>
2386
+ renderings of Shakespeare
2387
+ </p>
2388
+
2389
+ <p begin="0:27:45.19" end="0:27:48.73">
2390
+ presentations, video<br/>
2391
+ presentations, and the idea is
2392
+ </p>
2393
+
2394
+ <p begin="0:27:48.73" end="0:27:52.558">
2395
+ to do the same spoken lecture<br/>
2396
+ browser kind of access to this.
2397
+ </p>
2398
+
2399
+ <p begin="0:27:52.558" end="0:27:54.358">
2400
+ Those of you who thought<br/>
2401
+ Shakespeare was deal, he is
2402
+ </p>
2403
+
2404
+ <p begin="0:27:54.358" end="0:27:58.828">
2405
+ just living under an assumed<br/>
2406
+ name, and so, but there's --
2407
+ </p>
2408
+
2409
+ <p begin="0:27:58.828" end="0:28:03.798">
2410
+ but this is yet another --<br/>
2411
+ and I'm showing you these to,
2412
+ </p>
2413
+
2414
+ <p begin="0:28:03.798" end="0:28:06.108">
2415
+ let me give you the<br/>
2416
+ sub-text over here.
2417
+ </p>
2418
+
2419
+ <p begin="0:28:06.108" end="0:28:13.098">
2420
+ The idea of these is, see, that<br/>
2421
+ in order to realize the next
2422
+ </p>
2423
+
2424
+ <p begin="0:28:13.098" end="0:28:15.318">
2425
+ stage of educational<br/>
2426
+ transformation through open
2427
+ </p>
2428
+
2429
+ <p begin="0:28:15.318" end="0:28:21.14">
2430
+ resources, we not only need the<br/>
2431
+ surround off active experience,
2432
+ </p>
2433
+
2434
+ <p begin="0:28:21.14" end="0:28:25.88">
2435
+ we also need the means to go<br/>
2436
+ collectively harvest in useful
2437
+ </p>
2438
+
2439
+ <p begin="0:28:25.88" end="0:28:28.548">
2440
+ educational content<br/>
2441
+ very, very easily.
2442
+ </p>
2443
+
2444
+ <p begin="0:28:28.548" end="0:28:31.64">
2445
+ We want to reduce the barriers<br/>
2446
+ to get to them, and I keep
2447
+ </p>
2448
+
2449
+ <p begin="0:28:31.64" end="0:28:34.368">
2450
+ using the word productively,<br/>
2451
+ because you just don't want to
2452
+ </p>
2453
+
2454
+ <p begin="0:28:34.368" end="0:28:38.535">
2455
+ see and not touch, you want to<br/>
2456
+ see, bring, use, and use in
2457
+ </p>
2458
+
2459
+ <p begin="0:28:38.535" end="0:28:40.029">
2460
+ the fashion that you want.<br/>
2461
+
2462
+ </p>
2463
+
2464
+ <p begin="0:28:40.029" end="0:28:42.13">
2465
+ So, how do you<br/>
2466
+ productively combine them?
2467
+ </p>
2468
+
2469
+ <p begin="0:28:42.13" end="0:28:44.108">
2470
+ Now this was a wonderful<br/>
2471
+ project which sort of
2472
+ </p>
2473
+
2474
+ <p begin="0:28:44.108" end="0:28:47.19">
2475
+ demonstrates that, and it was<br/>
2476
+ built on OKI's open service
2477
+ </p>
2478
+
2479
+ <p begin="0:28:47.19" end="0:28:51.2">
2480
+ interface definition,<br/>
2481
+ the service interfaces.
2482
+ </p>
2483
+
2484
+ <p begin="0:28:51.2" end="0:28:54.779">
2485
+ And this was, Shigeru Miyagawa,<br/>
2486
+ who is the professor in
2487
+ </p>
2488
+
2489
+ <p begin="0:28:54.779" end="0:29:05.22">
2490
+ Linguistics, actually over<br/>
2491
+ here, and he and John Dower,
2492
+ </p>
2493
+
2494
+ <p begin="0:29:05.22" end="0:29:09.22">
2495
+ who is a prize winning,<br/>
2496
+ Pulitzer winning historian,
2497
+ </p>
2498
+
2499
+ <p begin="0:29:09.22" end="0:29:11.858">
2500
+ they created this program<br/>
2501
+ called Visualizing Cultures, by
2502
+ </p>
2503
+
2504
+ <p begin="0:29:11.858" end="0:29:13.98">
2505
+ the way, this is an<br/>
2506
+ OpenCourseWare also.
2507
+ </p>
2508
+
2509
+ <p begin="0:29:13.98" end="0:29:19.2">
2510
+ And it goes, the intent was<br/>
2511
+ to teach history and culture,
2512
+ </p>
2513
+
2514
+ <p begin="0:29:19.2" end="0:29:21.759">
2515
+ expose students to Japanese<br/>
2516
+ history and culture,
2517
+ </p>
2518
+
2519
+ <p begin="0:29:21.759" end="0:29:24.259">
2520
+ through images.<br/>
2521
+ Images that are available in a
2522
+ </p>
2523
+
2524
+ <p begin="0:29:24.259" end="0:29:27.21">
2525
+ variety of repositories, some<br/>
2526
+ in Japan, some of the Museum
2527
+ </p>
2528
+
2529
+ <p begin="0:29:27.21" end="0:29:28.788">
2530
+ of Fine Arts over here.<br/>
2531
+
2532
+ </p>
2533
+
2534
+ <p begin="0:29:28.788" end="0:29:32.48">
2535
+ And the idea was to go, be able<br/>
2536
+ to get these through different
2537
+ </p>
2538
+
2539
+ <p begin="0:29:32.48" end="0:29:33.73">
2540
+ kinds of applications.<br/>
2541
+
2542
+ </p>
2543
+
2544
+ <p begin="0:29:33.73" end="0:29:35.19">
2545
+ <br/>
2546
+
2547
+ </p>
2548
+
2549
+ <p begin="0:29:35.19" end="0:29:37.348">
2550
+ And you know, these<br/>
2551
+ images are fantastic.
2552
+ </p>
2553
+
2554
+ <p begin="0:29:37.348" end="0:29:41.308">
2555
+ For instance, some of them,<br/>
2556
+ which have to do with Commodore
2557
+ </p>
2558
+
2559
+ <p begin="0:29:41.308" end="0:29:45.519">
2560
+ Perry's trips to Japan, and if<br/>
2561
+ you look at them there's a
2562
+ </p>
2563
+
2564
+ <p begin="0:29:45.519" end="0:29:47.558">
2565
+ whole city called Black<br/>
2566
+ Ships and Samurai, now
2567
+ </p>
2568
+
2569
+ <p begin="0:29:47.558" end="0:29:49.538">
2570
+ that you see on top.<br/>
2571
+ And it's very interesting,
2572
+ </p>
2573
+
2574
+ <p begin="0:29:49.538" end="0:29:53.98">
2575
+ because depending on the<br/>
2576
+ relationship that the US had
2577
+ </p>
2578
+
2579
+ <p begin="0:29:53.98" end="0:29:57.89">
2580
+ with Japan, people in Japan<br/>
2581
+ would depict Commodore Perry.
2582
+ </p>
2583
+
2584
+ <p begin="0:29:57.89" end="0:30:00.778">
2585
+ So sometimes you see him<br/>
2586
+ characterized as a nice,
2587
+ </p>
2588
+
2589
+ <p begin="0:30:00.778" end="0:30:02.69">
2590
+ beaming, benevolent fellow,<br/>
2591
+ and sometimes you see
2592
+ </p>
2593
+
2594
+ <p begin="0:30:02.69" end="0:30:05.45">
2595
+ him drawn like an ogre.<br/>
2596
+
2597
+ </p>
2598
+
2599
+ <p begin="0:30:05.45" end="0:30:10.13">
2600
+ And, you know, it's reflective<br/>
2601
+ of the kinds of, the political
2602
+ </p>
2603
+
2604
+ <p begin="0:30:10.13" end="0:30:13.14">
2605
+ dynamics if you will,<br/>
2606
+ of that period.
2607
+ </p>
2608
+
2609
+ <p begin="0:30:13.14" end="0:30:14.288">
2610
+ But anyway, that's<br/>
2611
+ the content part.
2612
+ </p>
2613
+
2614
+ <p begin="0:30:14.288" end="0:30:18.608">
2615
+ The message here for me, from<br/>
2616
+ this slide, which has to do
2617
+ </p>
2618
+
2619
+ <p begin="0:30:18.608" end="0:30:22.17">
2620
+ with materials from Doc<br/>
2621
+ Edgerton, who was the creator
2622
+ </p>
2623
+
2624
+ <p begin="0:30:22.17" end="0:30:25.25">
2625
+ of strobe photography, who<br/>
2626
+ has, you know, wonderful
2627
+ </p>
2628
+
2629
+ <p begin="0:30:25.25" end="0:30:26.73">
2630
+ archive of materials.<br/>
2631
+
2632
+ </p>
2633
+
2634
+ <p begin="0:30:26.73" end="0:30:28.74">
2635
+ It's to say that we want to be<br/>
2636
+ able to say there are good
2637
+ </p>
2638
+
2639
+ <p begin="0:30:28.74" end="0:30:32.42">
2640
+ qualities of resources, rich<br/>
2641
+ media resources out there, and
2642
+ </p>
2643
+
2644
+ <p begin="0:30:32.42" end="0:30:35.39">
2645
+ we want to be able to really<br/>
2646
+ lower the barrier to getting
2647
+ </p>
2648
+
2649
+ <p begin="0:30:35.39" end="0:30:39.298">
2650
+ to these, and getting to these<br/>
2651
+ through different applications.
2652
+ </p>
2653
+
2654
+ <p begin="0:30:39.298" end="0:30:41.43">
2655
+ For instance, here you're<br/>
2656
+ seeing, and this is a
2657
+ </p>
2658
+
2659
+ <p begin="0:30:41.43" end="0:30:44.73">
2660
+ three-year old slide, four-year<br/>
2661
+ old slide, here you are seeing
2662
+ </p>
2663
+
2664
+ <p begin="0:30:44.73" end="0:30:49.88">
2665
+ those images that Shigeru was<br/>
2666
+ using for visualizing cultures,
2667
+ </p>
2668
+
2669
+ <p begin="0:30:49.88" end="0:30:51.71">
2670
+ got through Harvestrodes Hive.<br/>
2671
+
2672
+ </p>
2673
+
2674
+ <p begin="0:30:51.71" end="0:30:55.95">
2675
+ Hive was a Java-based<br/>
2676
+ application.
2677
+ </p>
2678
+
2679
+ <p begin="0:30:55.95" end="0:30:58.44">
2680
+ We had to get to content<br/>
2681
+ from repositories.
2682
+ </p>
2683
+
2684
+ <p begin="0:30:58.44" end="0:31:00.65">
2685
+ You're seeing it accessed<br/>
2686
+ through our course management
2687
+ </p>
2688
+
2689
+ <p begin="0:31:00.65" end="0:31:03.519">
2690
+ system, through a search tool<br/>
2691
+ for the images in our course
2692
+ </p>
2693
+
2694
+ <p begin="0:31:03.519" end="0:31:05.328">
2695
+ management system on the right.<br/>
2696
+
2697
+ </p>
2698
+
2699
+ <p begin="0:31:05.328" end="0:31:08.328">
2700
+ You're seeing it accessed<br/>
2701
+ through the visual
2702
+ </p>
2703
+
2704
+ <p begin="0:31:08.328" end="0:31:11.118">
2705
+ understanding editor, a<br/>
2706
+ concept tool the Tufts
2707
+ </p>
2708
+
2709
+ <p begin="0:31:11.118" end="0:31:12.89">
2710
+ University created.<br/>
2711
+
2712
+ </p>
2713
+
2714
+ <p begin="0:31:12.89" end="0:31:16">
2715
+ So here the idea is that you<br/>
2716
+ can have these, you know,
2717
+ </p>
2718
+
2719
+ <p begin="0:31:16" end="0:31:19.858">
2720
+ wonderful depositories of rich<br/>
2721
+ content to do good things
2722
+ </p>
2723
+
2724
+ <p begin="0:31:19.858" end="0:31:22.838">
2725
+ educationally, but you want to<br/>
2726
+ bring them together, make them
2727
+ </p>
2728
+
2729
+ <p begin="0:31:22.838" end="0:31:29.72">
2730
+ accessible through OEIT of open<br/>
2731
+ or proprietary applications.
2732
+ </p>
2733
+
2734
+ <p begin="0:31:29.72" end="0:31:33.93">
2735
+ And that's the kind of<br/>
2736
+ econological transformation
2737
+ </p>
2738
+
2739
+ <p begin="0:31:33.93" end="0:31:37.154">
2740
+ that we think will lead to the,<br/>
2741
+ at least I believe will lead to
2742
+ </p>
2743
+
2744
+ <p begin="0:31:37.154" end="0:31:38.808">
2745
+ this Metaversity vision.<br/>
2746
+
2747
+ </p>
2748
+
2749
+ <p begin="0:31:38.808" end="0:31:43.009">
2750
+ So, and you created, you know,<br/>
2751
+ you, so, the message that we
2752
+ </p>
2753
+
2754
+ <p begin="0:31:43.009" end="0:31:45.808">
2755
+ hear, it's not just about all<br/>
2756
+ the resources that are being
2757
+ </p>
2758
+
2759
+ <p begin="0:31:45.808" end="0:31:48.558">
2760
+ created openly, but the<br/>
2761
+ technological enablements, and
2762
+ </p>
2763
+
2764
+ <p begin="0:31:48.558" end="0:31:53.098">
2765
+ then as I will point out in a<br/>
2766
+ bit, the organizational
2767
+ </p>
2768
+
2769
+ <p begin="0:31:53.098" end="0:31:57.68">
2770
+ enablements that will allow us<br/>
2771
+ to approach that kind of vision.
2772
+ </p>
2773
+
2774
+ <p begin="0:31:57.68" end="0:32:01.019">
2775
+ So, a lot of the stuff that<br/>
2776
+ I showed you was about deep
2777
+ </p>
2778
+
2779
+ <p begin="0:32:01.019" end="0:32:03.318">
2780
+ learning, subjects and stuff.<br/>
2781
+
2782
+ </p>
2783
+
2784
+ <p begin="0:32:03.318" end="0:32:06.5">
2785
+ The message of open and<br/>
2786
+ transformation is much
2787
+ </p>
2788
+
2789
+ <p begin="0:32:06.5" end="0:32:09.48">
2790
+ bigger than that.<br/>
2791
+ This is also, this is not
2792
+ </p>
2793
+
2794
+ <p begin="0:32:09.48" end="0:32:14.298">
2795
+ just about innovation at a<br/>
2796
+ micro-level, and significant as
2797
+ </p>
2798
+
2799
+ <p begin="0:32:14.298" end="0:32:18.548">
2800
+ it is, it's not about changing<br/>
2801
+ courses or even changing
2802
+ </p>
2803
+
2804
+ <p begin="0:32:18.548" end="0:32:22.368">
2805
+ universities, it is also<br/>
2806
+ about national crusades.
2807
+ </p>
2808
+
2809
+ <p begin="0:32:22.368" end="0:32:27.118">
2810
+ Scott mention that I had the<br/>
2811
+ opportunity to serve as an
2812
+ </p>
2813
+
2814
+ <p begin="0:32:27.118" end="0:32:29.41">
2815
+ advisor to India's National<br/>
2816
+ Knowledge Commission.
2817
+ </p>
2818
+
2819
+ <p begin="0:32:29.41" end="0:32:31.66">
2820
+ India, as most of you know,<br/>
2821
+ is a country in a hurry, you
2822
+ </p>
2823
+
2824
+ <p begin="0:32:31.66" end="0:32:36.24">
2825
+ know, to play in the national,<br/>
2826
+ in the knowledge economy.
2827
+ </p>
2828
+
2829
+ <p begin="0:32:36.24" end="0:32:39.48">
2830
+ And some years ago, you know,<br/>
2831
+ the National Knowledge
2832
+ </p>
2833
+
2834
+ <p begin="0:32:39.48" end="0:32:42.19">
2835
+ Commission was formed by the<br/>
2836
+ Prime Minister to say, how can
2837
+ </p>
2838
+
2839
+ <p begin="0:32:42.19" end="0:32:46.43">
2840
+ we really scale excellence,<br/>
2841
+ provide quality it the scales.
2842
+ </p>
2843
+
2844
+ <p begin="0:32:46.43" end="0:32:50.788">
2845
+ To meet the needs off<br/>
2846
+ this explosive economy?
2847
+ </p>
2848
+
2849
+ <p begin="0:32:50.788" end="0:32:53.538">
2850
+ We need knowledge workers<br/>
2851
+ to build roads, to build
2852
+ </p>
2853
+
2854
+ <p begin="0:32:53.538" end="0:32:57.038">
2855
+ hospitals, to build up, you<br/>
2856
+ know, engineering institutions.
2857
+ </p>
2858
+
2859
+ <p begin="0:32:57.038" end="0:33:01.21">
2860
+ We need doctors, and how can we<br/>
2861
+ provide quality education at
2862
+ </p>
2863
+
2864
+ <p begin="0:33:01.21" end="0:33:04.98">
2865
+ scale, and knowing what I know<br/>
2866
+ about the numbers, you cannot
2867
+ </p>
2868
+
2869
+ <p begin="0:33:04.98" end="0:33:07.108">
2870
+ do it in the traditional way.<br/>
2871
+
2872
+ </p>
2873
+
2874
+ <p begin="0:33:07.108" end="0:33:09.778">
2875
+ Not, you can't do it in the<br/>
2876
+ traditional way you can't build
2877
+ </p>
2878
+
2879
+ <p begin="0:33:09.778" end="0:33:13.769">
2880
+ schools I mean I could give you<br/>
2881
+ statistics, 55 million kids
2882
+ </p>
2883
+
2884
+ <p begin="0:33:13.769" end="0:33:16.828">
2885
+ who come out of primary<br/>
2886
+ education, no place to go.
2887
+ </p>
2888
+
2889
+ <p begin="0:33:16.828" end="0:33:19.23">
2890
+ Even if you built a school<br/>
2891
+ a week, it would not be
2892
+ </p>
2893
+
2894
+ <p begin="0:33:19.23" end="0:33:20.568">
2895
+ able to meet the demand.<br/>
2896
+
2897
+ </p>
2898
+
2899
+ <p begin="0:33:20.568" end="0:33:23.528">
2900
+ There are about 11 institutions<br/>
2901
+ in the Institute of Technology
2902
+ </p>
2903
+
2904
+ <p begin="0:33:23.528" end="0:33:26.65">
2905
+ you could keep, and they<br/>
2906
+ are being added on.
2907
+ </p>
2908
+
2909
+ <p begin="0:33:26.65" end="0:33:31.858">
2910
+ The message is that what the<br/>
2911
+ open education movement offers
2912
+ </p>
2913
+
2914
+ <p begin="0:33:31.858" end="0:33:37.75">
2915
+ is a way of going and being<br/>
2916
+ able to provide that kind of
2917
+ </p>
2918
+
2919
+ <p begin="0:33:37.75" end="0:33:40.279">
2920
+ quality education at<br/>
2921
+ scale efficiently.
2922
+ </p>
2923
+
2924
+ <p begin="0:33:40.279" end="0:33:41.838">
2925
+ <br/>
2926
+
2927
+ </p>
2928
+
2929
+ <p begin="0:33:41.838" end="0:33:44.769">
2930
+ And, therefore, a whole set<br/>
2931
+ of recommendations were made
2932
+ </p>
2933
+
2934
+ <p begin="0:33:44.769" end="0:33:47.21">
2935
+ which are being acted upon,<br/>
2936
+ which have been accepted.
2937
+ </p>
2938
+
2939
+ <p begin="0:33:47.21" end="0:33:50.578">
2940
+ They are part of the Planning<br/>
2941
+ Commission team entirely based
2942
+ </p>
2943
+
2944
+ <p begin="0:33:50.578" end="0:33:58.17">
2945
+ on open education resources,<br/>
2946
+ and again, the model over here,
2947
+ </p>
2948
+
2949
+ <p begin="0:33:58.17" end="0:34:01.39">
2950
+ and this is a real, a very<br/>
2951
+ short-time caricature of
2952
+ </p>
2953
+
2954
+ <p begin="0:34:01.39" end="0:34:04.18">
2955
+ the recommendations that<br/>
2956
+ I'm presenting to you.
2957
+ </p>
2958
+
2959
+ <p begin="0:34:04.18" end="0:34:06.038">
2960
+ Essentially, to say that,<br/>
2961
+ you know, you can have
2962
+ </p>
2963
+
2964
+ <p begin="0:34:06.038" end="0:34:09.3">
2965
+ distributed depositories<br/>
2966
+ of fantastic content.
2967
+ </p>
2968
+
2969
+ <p begin="0:34:09.3" end="0:34:12.199">
2970
+ You can have a very good<br/>
2971
+ technical substrate, which
2972
+ </p>
2973
+
2974
+ <p begin="0:34:12.199" end="0:34:15.579">
2975
+ allows and good applications,<br/>
2976
+ which allows people to harvest
2977
+ </p>
2978
+
2979
+ <p begin="0:34:15.579" end="0:34:21.018">
2980
+ these, and be able to deliver<br/>
2981
+ education to meet the
2982
+ </p>
2983
+
2984
+ <p begin="0:34:21.018" end="0:34:23.099">
2985
+ needs of various sectors.<br/>
2986
+
2987
+ </p>
2988
+
2989
+ <p begin="0:34:23.099" end="0:34:29">
2990
+ Again, in a scalable<br/>
2991
+ and efficient fashion.
2992
+ </p>
2993
+
2994
+ <p begin="0:34:29" end="0:34:33.559">
2995
+ And actually, this particular<br/>
2996
+ slide is because in order to
2997
+ </p>
2998
+
2999
+ <p begin="0:34:33.559" end="0:34:36.539">
3000
+ show that this is not just a<br/>
3001
+ pipe dream, we actually
3002
+ </p>
3003
+
3004
+ <p begin="0:34:36.539" end="0:34:39.03">
3005
+ started building small<br/>
3006
+ applications to show it.
3007
+ </p>
3008
+
3009
+ <p begin="0:34:39.03" end="0:34:44.349">
3010
+ I saw Jeff had just walked in,<br/>
3011
+ Jeff Merrimen, he and I and
3012
+ </p>
3013
+
3014
+ <p begin="0:34:44.349" end="0:34:47.829">
3015
+ some off you might know Stuart<br/>
3016
+ Sim, we actually we're working
3017
+ </p>
3018
+
3019
+ <p begin="0:34:47.829" end="0:34:51.829">
3020
+ with this group called<br/>
3021
+ IUCE, there's an Indo-U.S.
3022
+ </p>
3023
+
3024
+ <p begin="0:34:51.829" end="0:34:54.63">
3025
+ collaboration on engineering<br/>
3026
+ education, and the model was
3027
+ </p>
3028
+
3029
+ <p begin="0:34:54.63" end="0:35:00.21">
3030
+ to see how faculty over here<br/>
3031
+ could, and there, could go
3032
+ </p>
3033
+
3034
+ <p begin="0:35:00.21" end="0:35:03.46">
3035
+ get content from radius<br/>
3036
+ open initiatives from
3037
+ </p>
3038
+
3039
+ <p begin="0:35:03.46" end="0:35:04.71">
3040
+ MIT's OpenCourseWare.<br/>
3041
+
3042
+ </p>
3043
+
3044
+ <p begin="0:35:04.71" end="0:35:05.34">
3045
+ <br/>
3046
+
3047
+ </p>
3048
+
3049
+ <p begin="0:35:05.34" end="0:35:08.489">
3050
+ India has put a lot of its<br/>
3051
+ engineering content, there's
3052
+ </p>
3053
+
3054
+ <p begin="0:35:08.489" end="0:35:13.01">
3055
+ an initiative called NPTEL, The<br/>
3056
+ National Program on Technology
3057
+ </p>
3058
+
3059
+ <p begin="0:35:13.01" end="0:35:19.518">
3060
+ Enabled Learning, which has<br/>
3061
+ put out about 120 -- I
3062
+ </p>
3063
+
3064
+ <p begin="0:35:19.518" end="0:35:22.139">
3065
+ mean it's significant.<br/>
3066
+ All the engineering courses
3067
+ </p>
3068
+
3069
+ <p begin="0:35:22.139" end="0:35:26.86">
3070
+ available through You Tube, and<br/>
3071
+ so what we worked on was trying
3072
+ </p>
3073
+
3074
+ <p begin="0:35:26.86" end="0:35:31.13">
3075
+ to develop a demonstration<br/>
3076
+ which would allow faculty to
3077
+ </p>
3078
+
3079
+ <p begin="0:35:31.13" end="0:35:35.38">
3080
+ get content from OCW, from<br/>
3081
+ NPTEL from Rice University's
3082
+ </p>
3083
+
3084
+ <p begin="0:35:35.38" end="0:35:38.809">
3085
+ connections, and create courses<br/>
3086
+ along with the collaborative
3087
+ </p>
3088
+
3089
+ <p begin="0:35:38.809" end="0:35:41.268">
3090
+ surround, you know we keep it<br/>
3091
+ surround, so that they actually
3092
+ </p>
3093
+
3094
+ <p begin="0:35:41.268" end="0:35:45.61">
3095
+ collaborate, construct the<br/>
3096
+ courses from various resources.
3097
+ </p>
3098
+
3099
+ <p begin="0:35:45.61" end="0:35:47.05">
3100
+ <br/>
3101
+
3102
+ </p>
3103
+
3104
+ <p begin="0:35:47.05" end="0:35:53.9">
3105
+ So that's the value proposition.<br/>
3106
+
3107
+ </p>
3108
+
3109
+ <p begin="0:35:53.9" end="0:35:56.539">
3110
+ If you look at what I have,<br/>
3111
+ when I talk about Metaversity
3112
+ </p>
3113
+
3114
+ <p begin="0:35:56.539" end="0:36:02.11">
3115
+ two, the elements of the open<br/>
3116
+ movement that it really draws
3117
+ </p>
3118
+
3119
+ <p begin="0:36:02.11" end="0:36:09.76">
3120
+ upon is aid that you can have<br/>
3121
+ large, sort of unprecedented
3122
+ </p>
3123
+
3124
+ <p begin="0:36:09.76" end="0:36:14.739">
3125
+ volume of quality resources,<br/>
3126
+ which are available anywhere,
3127
+ </p>
3128
+
3129
+ <p begin="0:36:14.739" end="0:36:18.15">
3130
+ anytime, you know, through<br/>
3131
+ the kinds of enablements
3132
+ </p>
3133
+
3134
+ <p begin="0:36:18.15" end="0:36:19.5">
3135
+ I described.<br/>
3136
+
3137
+ </p>
3138
+
3139
+ <p begin="0:36:19.5" end="0:36:23.949">
3140
+ What's more, because of the way<br/>
3141
+ they are constructed, because,
3142
+ </p>
3143
+
3144
+ <p begin="0:36:23.949" end="0:36:27.159">
3145
+ and the kinds of information<br/>
3146
+ that surrounds them, they
3147
+ </p>
3148
+
3149
+ <p begin="0:36:27.159" end="0:36:29.26">
3150
+ can actually be localized.<br/>
3151
+
3152
+ </p>
3153
+
3154
+ <p begin="0:36:29.26" end="0:36:33.69">
3155
+ And you know, I personally am a<br/>
3156
+ very big believer, you know, we
3157
+ </p>
3158
+
3159
+ <p begin="0:36:33.69" end="0:36:38.44">
3160
+ keep talking about education<br/>
3161
+ being a cottage industry,
3162
+ </p>
3163
+
3164
+ <p begin="0:36:38.44" end="0:36:39.8">
3165
+ as if it was something bad.<br/>
3166
+
3167
+ </p>
3168
+
3169
+ <p begin="0:36:39.8" end="0:36:42.51">
3170
+ I actually believe that it<br/>
3171
+ derives its value from being a
3172
+ </p>
3173
+
3174
+ <p begin="0:36:42.51" end="0:36:45.76">
3175
+ cottage industry, and part of<br/>
3176
+ the challenge that we face is
3177
+ </p>
3178
+
3179
+ <p begin="0:36:45.76" end="0:36:47.659">
3180
+ how can we really make<br/>
3181
+ that cottage industry
3182
+ </p>
3183
+
3184
+ <p begin="0:36:47.659" end="0:36:49.199">
3185
+ thrive efficiency?<br/>
3186
+
3187
+ </p>
3188
+
3189
+ <p begin="0:36:49.199" end="0:36:50.809">
3190
+ <br/>
3191
+
3192
+ </p>
3193
+
3194
+ <p begin="0:36:50.809" end="0:36:53.5">
3195
+ And when I say cottage<br/>
3196
+ industry, it means that a lot
3197
+ </p>
3198
+
3199
+ <p begin="0:36:53.5" end="0:37:01.018">
3200
+ of value is derived locally,<br/>
3201
+ and we need to -- the idea of,
3202
+ </p>
3203
+
3204
+ <p begin="0:37:01.018" end="0:37:03.329">
3205
+ one of the things that the open<br/>
3206
+ education resource movement
3207
+ </p>
3208
+
3209
+ <p begin="0:37:03.329" end="0:37:07.199">
3210
+ offers is that you can have<br/>
3211
+ large pools of shared
3212
+ </p>
3213
+
3214
+ <p begin="0:37:07.199" end="0:37:11.73">
3215
+ resources, without militating<br/>
3216
+ against the localization
3217
+ </p>
3218
+
3219
+ <p begin="0:37:11.73" end="0:37:16.38">
3220
+ that is very important for<br/>
3221
+ good education to happen.
3222
+ </p>
3223
+
3224
+ <p begin="0:37:16.38" end="0:37:19.349">
3225
+ It provides alternatives,<br/>
3226
+ you know, deeper learning,
3227
+ </p>
3228
+
3229
+ <p begin="0:37:19.349" end="0:37:21.8">
3230
+ and I will some examples.<br/>
3231
+
3232
+ </p>
3233
+
3234
+ <p begin="0:37:21.8" end="0:37:25.07">
3235
+ One of the things that it<br/>
3236
+ does allow, and this is not
3237
+ </p>
3238
+
3239
+ <p begin="0:37:25.07" end="0:37:27.8">
3240
+ in my slides, but I will<br/>
3241
+ make a quick mention.
3242
+ </p>
3243
+
3244
+ <p begin="0:37:27.8" end="0:37:30.51">
3245
+ It does allow a lot of feedback.<br/>
3246
+
3247
+ </p>
3248
+
3249
+ <p begin="0:37:30.51" end="0:37:33.639">
3250
+ When we talk about educational<br/>
3251
+ transformation, it's not just
3252
+ </p>
3253
+
3254
+ <p begin="0:37:33.639" end="0:37:38.099">
3255
+ about access and good tools,<br/>
3256
+ but what is the generated
3257
+ </p>
3258
+
3259
+ <p begin="0:37:38.099" end="0:37:42.329">
3260
+ mechanism that you have in<br/>
3261
+ order to improve on what you do?
3262
+ </p>
3263
+
3264
+ <p begin="0:37:42.329" end="0:37:46.03">
3265
+ Now, I remember when<br/>
3266
+ OpenCourseWare was launched,
3267
+ </p>
3268
+
3269
+ <p begin="0:37:46.03" end="0:37:49.739">
3270
+ Shigeru, whom I refer to, now<br/>
3271
+ it's visualizing cultures, he
3272
+ </p>
3273
+
3274
+ <p begin="0:37:49.739" end="0:37:53">
3275
+ had a wonderful statement out<br/>
3276
+ there on our website, the OCW
3277
+ </p>
3278
+
3279
+ <p begin="0:37:53" end="0:37:56.96">
3280
+ websites, which said that, you<br/>
3281
+ know, this is about we, as
3282
+ </p>
3283
+
3284
+ <p begin="0:37:56.96" end="0:37:59.989">
3285
+ educators, we know how to share<br/>
3286
+ our research, but we don't know
3287
+ </p>
3288
+
3289
+ <p begin="0:37:59.989" end="0:38:03.82">
3290
+ how to share our pedagogy<br/>
3291
+ for critical review.
3292
+ </p>
3293
+
3294
+ <p begin="0:38:03.82" end="0:38:07.17">
3295
+ Now, if you think about it for<br/>
3296
+ a second, what you really do
3297
+ </p>
3298
+
3299
+ <p begin="0:38:07.17" end="0:38:09.469">
3300
+ through OpenCourseWare is<br/>
3301
+ you say, look, this
3302
+ </p>
3303
+
3304
+ <p begin="0:38:09.469" end="0:38:11.829">
3305
+ is how we teach. Have at it.<br/>
3306
+
3307
+ </p>
3308
+
3309
+ <p begin="0:38:11.829" end="0:38:13.429">
3310
+ Tell us what you can do.<br/>
3311
+
3312
+ </p>
3313
+
3314
+ <p begin="0:38:13.429" end="0:38:19.449">
3315
+ So that's, and if you can have<br/>
3316
+ the means to incorporate that
3317
+ </p>
3318
+
3319
+ <p begin="0:38:19.449" end="0:38:23.96">
3320
+ feedback that people might give<br/>
3321
+ you into continuously improving
3322
+ </p>
3323
+
3324
+ <p begin="0:38:23.96" end="0:38:26.139">
3325
+ your courses, good<br/>
3326
+ things can happen.
3327
+ </p>
3328
+
3329
+ <p begin="0:38:26.139" end="0:38:28.55">
3330
+ And there's a very good<br/>
3331
+ demonstration of this.
3332
+ </p>
3333
+
3334
+ <p begin="0:38:28.55" end="0:38:31.4">
3335
+ Carnegie Mellon has set up this<br/>
3336
+ thing called, they have this
3337
+ </p>
3338
+
3339
+ <p begin="0:38:31.4" end="0:38:36.079">
3340
+ initiative called the Open<br/>
3341
+ Learning Initiative, OLI, and
3342
+ </p>
3343
+
3344
+ <p begin="0:38:36.079" end="0:38:40.239">
3345
+ there's a statistics course<br/>
3346
+ where they have created, which
3347
+ </p>
3348
+
3349
+ <p begin="0:38:40.239" end="0:38:42.699">
3350
+ allows the community to give<br/>
3351
+ feedback, and then that's
3352
+ </p>
3353
+
3354
+ <p begin="0:38:42.699" end="0:38:47.079">
3355
+ incorporated into the into the<br/>
3356
+ course segments themselves, and
3357
+ </p>
3358
+
3359
+ <p begin="0:38:47.079" end="0:38:51.739">
3360
+ what they've found was that<br/>
3361
+ they had a learning gain of
3362
+ </p>
3363
+
3364
+ <p begin="0:38:51.739" end="0:38:54.829">
3365
+ 50% in the delivery of the<br/>
3366
+ statistics course, and I'll
3367
+ </p>
3368
+
3369
+ <p begin="0:38:54.829" end="0:38:58.07">
3370
+ tell you what that means.<br/>
3371
+ What it means is that coverage,
3372
+ </p>
3373
+
3374
+ <p begin="0:38:58.07" end="0:39:02.789">
3375
+ which they would have had, and<br/>
3376
+ without sacrificing quality,
3377
+ </p>
3378
+
3379
+ <p begin="0:39:02.789" end="0:39:06.07">
3380
+ the time to deliver that course<br/>
3381
+ was, for the same learning
3382
+ </p>
3383
+
3384
+ <p begin="0:39:06.07" end="0:39:08.789">
3385
+ games, was decreased by 50%.<br/>
3386
+
3387
+ </p>
3388
+
3389
+ <p begin="0:39:08.789" end="0:39:10.268">
3390
+ Now that is significant.<br/>
3391
+
3392
+ </p>
3393
+
3394
+ <p begin="0:39:10.268" end="0:39:13.579">
3395
+ That is transubmitive,<br/>
3396
+ and we are not, and this
3397
+ </p>
3398
+
3399
+ <p begin="0:39:13.579" end="0:39:14.409">
3400
+ is well written about.<br/>
3401
+
3402
+ </p>
3403
+
3404
+ <p begin="0:39:14.409" end="0:39:15.869">
3405
+ In fact, Candice [? Till ?]<br/>
3406
+
3407
+ </p>
3408
+
3409
+ <p begin="0:39:15.869" end="0:39:17.989">
3410
+ still has written about<br/>
3411
+ this in the book, that
3412
+ </p>
3413
+
3414
+ <p begin="0:39:17.989" end="0:39:20.429">
3415
+ we, according to, that<br/>
3416
+ Scott was referring to.
3417
+ </p>
3418
+
3419
+ <p begin="0:39:20.429" end="0:39:24.385">
3420
+ So there's this dimension of<br/>
3421
+ collected improvement and
3422
+ </p>
3423
+
3424
+ <p begin="0:39:24.385" end="0:39:27.989">
3425
+ feedback, both at the micro<br/>
3426
+ level and at the macro level
3427
+ </p>
3428
+
3429
+ <p begin="0:39:27.989" end="0:39:30.17">
3430
+ that is really, really<br/>
3431
+ important when you think
3432
+ </p>
3433
+
3434
+ <p begin="0:39:30.17" end="0:39:34.84">
3435
+ about transformation that's<br/>
3436
+ afforded by open education.
3437
+ </p>
3438
+
3439
+ <p begin="0:39:34.84" end="0:39:36.92">
3440
+ So all that's fine.<br/>
3441
+
3442
+ </p>
3443
+
3444
+ <p begin="0:39:36.92" end="0:39:39.139">
3445
+ When I think about possibility<br/>
3446
+ as a signal, there are two
3447
+ </p>
3448
+
3449
+ <p begin="0:39:39.139" end="0:39:42.789">
3450
+ dimensions that are really<br/>
3451
+ important that we all talk
3452
+ </p>
3453
+
3454
+ <p begin="0:39:42.789" end="0:39:45.119">
3455
+ about, which are<br/>
3456
+ enabled by this.
3457
+ </p>
3458
+
3459
+ <p begin="0:39:45.119" end="0:39:49.159">
3460
+ One which I loosely call<br/>
3461
+ blended learning opportunities.
3462
+ </p>
3463
+
3464
+ <p begin="0:39:49.159" end="0:39:53.239">
3465
+ And what openness allows is<br/>
3466
+ really, and this again speaks
3467
+ </p>
3468
+
3469
+ <p begin="0:39:53.239" end="0:39:56.8">
3470
+ to the context of setting<br/>
3471
+ statements that Scott was
3472
+ </p>
3473
+
3474
+ <p begin="0:39:56.8" end="0:40:01.119">
3475
+ making allows us to really<br/>
3476
+ look at possibilities for
3477
+ </p>
3478
+
3479
+ <p begin="0:40:01.119" end="0:40:04.32">
3480
+ intelligently combining the<br/>
3481
+ physical and the virtual.
3482
+ </p>
3483
+
3484
+ <p begin="0:40:04.32" end="0:40:07.36">
3485
+ How we might, you know, the<br/>
3486
+ highlight example for this, how
3487
+ </p>
3488
+
3489
+ <p begin="0:40:07.36" end="0:40:14.219">
3490
+ might we combine what we know<br/>
3491
+ as good practices and situated
3492
+ </p>
3493
+
3494
+ <p begin="0:40:14.219" end="0:40:16.739">
3495
+ learning, the kinds of<br/>
3496
+ authentic learning experiences
3497
+ </p>
3498
+
3499
+ <p begin="0:40:16.739" end="0:40:18.219">
3500
+ that we provide in<br/>
3501
+ this situation.
3502
+ </p>
3503
+
3504
+ <p begin="0:40:18.219" end="0:40:21.92">
3505
+ The labs, with what might<br/>
3506
+ be digitally available,
3507
+ </p>
3508
+
3509
+ <p begin="0:40:21.92" end="0:40:24.059">
3510
+ online available.<br/>
3511
+ So it purely provides
3512
+ </p>
3513
+
3514
+ <p begin="0:40:24.059" end="0:40:31.05">
3515
+ opportunities to mix and melt<br/>
3516
+ the best of good worlds, and
3517
+ </p>
3518
+
3519
+ <p begin="0:40:31.05" end="0:40:34.989">
3520
+ to be able to localize it.<br/>
3521
+ And this is being done.
3522
+ </p>
3523
+
3524
+ <p begin="0:40:34.989" end="0:40:41.429">
3525
+ This is not something that came<br/>
3526
+ out of some lazy exercise in
3527
+ </p>
3528
+
3529
+ <p begin="0:40:41.429" end="0:40:45.469">
3530
+ -- what shall I say, on<br/>
3531
+ controlled substances.
3532
+ </p>
3533
+
3534
+ <p begin="0:40:45.469" end="0:40:49.809">
3535
+ This is the kind of stuff that<br/>
3536
+ has been practiced, developed,
3537
+ </p>
3538
+
3539
+ <p begin="0:40:49.809" end="0:40:53.13">
3540
+ and demonstrated you know,<br/>
3541
+ through things like iLabs that
3542
+ </p>
3543
+
3544
+ <p begin="0:40:53.13" end="0:40:56.889">
3545
+ I'm talking about, and we have<br/>
3546
+ to start looking at these
3547
+ </p>
3548
+
3549
+ <p begin="0:40:56.889" end="0:40:58.34">
3550
+ for transformation.<br/>
3551
+
3552
+ </p>
3553
+
3554
+ <p begin="0:40:58.34" end="0:41:01.73">
3555
+ You know, the combining the<br/>
3556
+ formal and the non-formal here,
3557
+ </p>
3558
+
3559
+ <p begin="0:41:01.73" end="0:41:04.719">
3560
+ for instance, we are thinking,<br/>
3561
+ how can we use co-curricular
3562
+ </p>
3563
+
3564
+ <p begin="0:41:04.719" end="0:41:09.92">
3565
+ experiences and combine them<br/>
3566
+ with, you know, as good
3567
+ </p>
3568
+
3569
+ <p begin="0:41:09.92" end="0:41:12.48">
3570
+ substitutes for authentic<br/>
3571
+ learning experiences.
3572
+ </p>
3573
+
3574
+ <p begin="0:41:12.48" end="0:41:17.739">
3575
+ These are the enablements of<br/>
3576
+ open, given the very generous
3577
+ </p>
3578
+
3579
+ <p begin="0:41:17.739" end="0:41:20.59">
3580
+ definition of open that I<br/>
3581
+ provided here, you know,
3582
+ </p>
3583
+
3584
+ <p begin="0:41:20.59" end="0:41:24.17">
3585
+ about open technology, open<br/>
3586
+ content, and open knowledge.
3587
+ </p>
3588
+
3589
+ <p begin="0:41:24.17" end="0:41:30.699">
3590
+ The other really value element,<br/>
3591
+ value vision element for me
3592
+ </p>
3593
+
3594
+ <p begin="0:41:30.699" end="0:41:32.73">
3595
+ is boundary-less education.<br/>
3596
+
3597
+ </p>
3598
+
3599
+ <p begin="0:41:32.73" end="0:41:35.98">
3600
+ And again, this is not about<br/>
3601
+ traditional boundaries,
3602
+ </p>
3603
+
3604
+ <p begin="0:41:35.98" end="0:41:39.139">
3605
+ geopolitical boundaries, some<br/>
3606
+ of which is true, like in the
3607
+ </p>
3608
+
3609
+ <p begin="0:41:39.139" end="0:41:43.75">
3610
+ IUCEE example I gave, but even<br/>
3611
+ boundaries between disciplines.
3612
+ </p>
3613
+
3614
+ <p begin="0:41:43.75" end="0:41:48.079">
3615
+ If you go to the OpenCourseWare<br/>
3616
+ site, you will see some new
3617
+ </p>
3618
+
3619
+ <p begin="0:41:48.079" end="0:41:51.449">
3620
+ programs that have been<br/>
3621
+ launched for energy
3622
+ </p>
3623
+
3624
+ <p begin="0:41:51.449" end="0:41:53.449">
3625
+ studies, right?<br/>
3626
+
3627
+ </p>
3628
+
3629
+ <p begin="0:41:53.449" end="0:41:57.53">
3630
+ And these are being possible,<br/>
3631
+ made possible, some of these
3632
+ </p>
3633
+
3634
+ <p begin="0:41:57.53" end="0:42:00.539">
3635
+ boundaries are diminishing our<br/>
3636
+ ability to leverage, content is
3637
+ </p>
3638
+
3639
+ <p begin="0:42:00.539" end="0:42:03.909">
3640
+ happening, because the<br/>
3641
+ substance of the component
3642
+ </p>
3643
+
3644
+ <p begin="0:42:03.909" end="0:42:06.57">
3645
+ courses are becoming visible,<br/>
3646
+ and people are being able to
3647
+ </p>
3648
+
3649
+ <p begin="0:42:06.57" end="0:42:09.57">
3650
+ see much more finely where<br/>
3651
+ there might be substitutions,
3652
+ </p>
3653
+
3654
+ <p begin="0:42:09.57" end="0:42:12.679">
3655
+ where there might be<br/>
3656
+ opportunities to have compounds
3657
+ </p>
3658
+
3659
+ <p begin="0:42:12.679" end="0:42:17.73">
3660
+ of these courses to lead to new<br/>
3661
+ programs that transcend
3662
+ </p>
3663
+
3664
+ <p begin="0:42:17.73" end="0:42:21.219">
3665
+ disciplinary boundaries or<br/>
3666
+ department boundaries.
3667
+ </p>
3668
+
3669
+ <p begin="0:42:21.219" end="0:42:24.11">
3670
+ I could give you other<br/>
3671
+ examples with there is
3672
+ </p>
3673
+
3674
+ <p begin="0:42:24.11" end="0:42:27.38">
3675
+ boundary-less-ness being<br/>
3676
+ experienced where the boundary
3677
+ </p>
3678
+
3679
+ <p begin="0:42:27.38" end="0:42:32.15">
3680
+ between research learnings and<br/>
3681
+ the lay person is
3682
+ </p>
3683
+
3684
+ <p begin="0:42:32.15" end="0:42:33.48">
3685
+ being diminished.<br/>
3686
+
3687
+ </p>
3688
+
3689
+ <p begin="0:42:33.48" end="0:42:35.929">
3690
+ Neeru Paharia, she's is of<br/>
3691
+ the Graduate Business School
3692
+ </p>
3693
+
3694
+ <p begin="0:42:35.929" end="0:42:37.59">
3695
+ over here at Harvard.<br/>
3696
+
3697
+ </p>
3698
+
3699
+ <p begin="0:42:37.59" end="0:42:42.94">
3700
+ She used to be Director of<br/>
3701
+ Creative Commons, so she has
3702
+ </p>
3703
+
3704
+ <p begin="0:42:42.94" end="0:42:47.239">
3705
+ worked on something called<br/>
3706
+ Acawiki, A C A W I K I, where
3707
+ </p>
3708
+
3709
+ <p begin="0:42:47.239" end="0:42:50.869">
3710
+ actually people go in and<br/>
3711
+ provide sense-making documents
3712
+ </p>
3713
+
3714
+ <p begin="0:42:50.869" end="0:42:55.71">
3715
+ for the lay people, you and I,<br/>
3716
+ who fund research, to have, to
3717
+ </p>
3718
+
3719
+ <p begin="0:42:55.71" end="0:42:59.768">
3720
+ understand research, again, to<br/>
3721
+ take away the divide between,
3722
+ </p>
3723
+
3724
+ <p begin="0:42:59.768" end="0:43:03.61">
3725
+ to diminish the divide between<br/>
3726
+ research and lay people.
3727
+ </p>
3728
+
3729
+ <p begin="0:43:03.61" end="0:43:06.989">
3730
+ So there's a lot of<br/>
3731
+ boundary-less-ness that can
3732
+ </p>
3733
+
3734
+ <p begin="0:43:06.989" end="0:43:10.34">
3735
+ being enabled through openness.<br/>
3736
+
3737
+ </p>
3738
+
3739
+ <p begin="0:43:10.34" end="0:43:11.86">
3740
+ <br/>
3741
+
3742
+ </p>
3743
+
3744
+ <p begin="0:43:11.86" end="0:43:16.5">
3745
+ So I'm going to start, this<br/>
3746
+ is my, sort of getting to my
3747
+ </p>
3748
+
3749
+ <p begin="0:43:16.5" end="0:43:18.98">
3750
+ closing statements over here.<br/>
3751
+
3752
+ </p>
3753
+
3754
+ <p begin="0:43:18.98" end="0:43:21.289">
3755
+ We have this movement, and you<br/>
3756
+ say, well, you know, here's
3757
+ </p>
3758
+
3759
+ <p begin="0:43:21.289" end="0:43:23.73">
3760
+ this guy, he's talking about<br/>
3761
+ all these wonderful
3762
+ </p>
3763
+
3764
+ <p begin="0:43:23.73" end="0:43:26.929">
3765
+ possibilities, and like I<br/>
3766
+ said, you know, this
3767
+ </p>
3768
+
3769
+ <p begin="0:43:26.929" end="0:43:28.21">
3770
+ is not a pipe dream.<br/>
3771
+
3772
+ </p>
3773
+
3774
+ <p begin="0:43:28.21" end="0:43:35.46">
3775
+ How do we interpret pipe, b but<br/>
3776
+ it's born out of really looking
3777
+ </p>
3778
+
3779
+ <p begin="0:43:35.46" end="0:43:39.88">
3780
+ at some markers, some of the<br/>
3781
+ significant influences that
3782
+ </p>
3783
+
3784
+ <p begin="0:43:39.88" end="0:43:43.69">
3785
+ are around us, that give me<br/>
3786
+ comfort, give me solid hope.
3787
+ </p>
3788
+
3789
+ <p begin="0:43:43.69" end="0:43:47.829">
3790
+ You know, and some of it is<br/>
3791
+ because many of us in this
3792
+ </p>
3793
+
3794
+ <p begin="0:43:47.829" end="0:43:52.21">
3795
+ room are invested and engaged<br/>
3796
+ in these initiatives.
3797
+ </p>
3798
+
3799
+ <p begin="0:43:52.21" end="0:43:55.949">
3800
+ So one significant category of<br/>
3801
+ significant influence I've
3802
+ </p>
3803
+
3804
+ <p begin="0:43:55.949" end="0:43:58.75">
3805
+ already talked a lot about, is<br/>
3806
+ the fact that there's a lot of
3807
+ </p>
3808
+
3809
+ <p begin="0:43:58.75" end="0:44:00.8">
3810
+ open content, there is<br/>
3811
+ good open technology
3812
+ </p>
3813
+
3814
+ <p begin="0:44:00.8" end="0:44:03.389">
3815
+ initiatives going on.<br/>
3816
+
3817
+ </p>
3818
+
3819
+ <p begin="0:44:03.389" end="0:44:08.159">
3820
+ Good design, and I mean<br/>
3821
+ this both in terms of
3822
+ </p>
3823
+
3824
+ <p begin="0:44:08.159" end="0:44:10.19">
3825
+ organization and technology.<br/>
3826
+
3827
+ </p>
3828
+
3829
+ <p begin="0:44:10.19" end="0:44:13.699">
3830
+ I particularly like to talk<br/>
3831
+ about my pet initiative, the
3832
+ </p>
3833
+
3834
+ <p begin="0:44:13.699" end="0:44:17.929">
3835
+ open knowledge initiative,<br/>
3836
+ which allows this kind of, you
3837
+ </p>
3838
+
3839
+ <p begin="0:44:17.929" end="0:44:21.73">
3840
+ know, Scott referred to it as<br/>
3841
+ disaggregation, which allows
3842
+ </p>
3843
+
3844
+ <p begin="0:44:21.73" end="0:44:23.835">
3845
+ different players, different<br/>
3846
+ qualities, different
3847
+ </p>
3848
+
3849
+ <p begin="0:44:23.835" end="0:44:25.739">
3850
+ strengths to play.<br/>
3851
+ So, there are design
3852
+ </p>
3853
+
3854
+ <p begin="0:44:25.739" end="0:44:30.03">
3855
+ enablers, and design is a<br/>
3856
+ very important consideration.
3857
+ </p>
3858
+
3859
+ <p begin="0:44:30.03" end="0:44:33.309">
3860
+ But there are legal enablers,<br/>
3861
+ creative commons, for instance,
3862
+ </p>
3863
+
3864
+ <p begin="0:44:33.309" end="0:44:39.969">
3865
+ which, you know, so which give<br/>
3866
+ me hope that this vision of
3867
+ </p>
3868
+
3869
+ <p begin="0:44:39.969" end="0:44:46.489">
3870
+ Metaversity II is, indeed,<br/>
3871
+ realizable and can be reaffied.
3872
+ </p>
3873
+
3874
+ <p begin="0:44:46.489" end="0:44:49.55">
3875
+ But there are two dimensions<br/>
3876
+ which I have not touch upon
3877
+ </p>
3878
+
3879
+ <p begin="0:44:49.55" end="0:44:52.67">
3880
+ which I'll quickly tell you.<br/>
3881
+ One is institutional
3882
+ </p>
3883
+
3884
+ <p begin="0:44:52.67" end="0:44:56.42">
3885
+ commitment.<br/>
3886
+ And some of the institutional
3887
+ </p>
3888
+
3889
+ <p begin="0:44:56.42" end="0:44:58.389">
3890
+ commitment is expressed<br/>
3891
+ through communities
3892
+ </p>
3893
+
3894
+ <p begin="0:44:58.389" end="0:44:59.969">
3895
+ that are being created.<br/>
3896
+
3897
+ </p>
3898
+
3899
+ <p begin="0:44:59.969" end="0:45:03.82">
3900
+ The Sakai community,<br/>
3901
+ consortia around iLabs
3902
+ </p>
3903
+
3904
+ <p begin="0:45:03.82" end="0:45:06.96">
3905
+ that are being built.<br/>
3906
+ The groups that meet around OKI.
3907
+ </p>
3908
+
3909
+ <p begin="0:45:06.96" end="0:45:11.32">
3910
+ So these are expressions of<br/>
3911
+ institutional commitment around
3912
+ </p>
3913
+
3914
+ <p begin="0:45:11.32" end="0:45:15.25">
3915
+ things open that are forming,<br/>
3916
+ which so which are really
3917
+ </p>
3918
+
3919
+ <p begin="0:45:15.25" end="0:45:18.789">
3920
+ becoming the building<br/>
3921
+ blocks for this open
3922
+ </p>
3923
+
3924
+ <p begin="0:45:18.789" end="0:45:21.405">
3925
+ education movement.<br/>
3926
+ There is another kind, which I
3927
+ </p>
3928
+
3929
+ <p begin="0:45:21.405" end="0:45:24.13">
3930
+ really pointed to, and I had a<br/>
3931
+ bunch of slides, and I think
3932
+ </p>
3933
+
3934
+ <p begin="0:45:24.13" end="0:45:27.768">
3935
+ they got finished by today's<br/>
3936
+ web page from MIT that I
3937
+ </p>
3938
+
3939
+ <p begin="0:45:27.768" end="0:45:31.05">
3940
+ showed you, which is a real<br/>
3941
+ expression of MIT commitment.
3942
+ </p>
3943
+
3944
+ <p begin="0:45:31.05" end="0:45:35.44">
3945
+ The slides I was going to show<br/>
3946
+ you, which are really, have to
3947
+ </p>
3948
+
3949
+ <p begin="0:45:35.44" end="0:45:40.139">
3950
+ do with the fact that MIT<br/>
3951
+ expressed its initial, its
3952
+ </p>
3953
+
3954
+ <p begin="0:45:40.139" end="0:45:43.51">
3955
+ institutional commitment to<br/>
3956
+ OpenCourseWare through a lot a
3957
+ </p>
3958
+
3959
+ <p begin="0:45:43.51" end="0:45:46.289">
3960
+ strategic thinking that<br/>
3961
+ preceded the launch of
3962
+ </p>
3963
+
3964
+ <p begin="0:45:46.289" end="0:45:49.849">
3965
+ OpenCourseWare, it's current<br/>
3966
+ commitment to it, right?
3967
+ </p>
3968
+
3969
+ <p begin="0:45:49.849" end="0:45:55.25">
3970
+ And to openness, as expressed<br/>
3971
+ wonderfully by, you know,
3972
+ </p>
3973
+
3974
+ <p begin="0:45:55.25" end="0:45:56.929">
3975
+ by today's web page.<br/>
3976
+
3977
+ </p>
3978
+
3979
+ <p begin="0:45:56.929" end="0:45:59.699">
3980
+ And there is a second dimension<br/>
3981
+ off this, there is another
3982
+ </p>
3983
+
3984
+ <p begin="0:45:59.699" end="0:46:03.699">
3985
+ aspect which is on the<br/>
3986
+ collectivity culture, and you
3987
+ </p>
3988
+
3989
+ <p begin="0:46:03.699" end="0:46:06.32">
3990
+ see that, you know, through the<br/>
3991
+ Wikis, the blogs, the
3992
+ </p>
3993
+
3994
+ <p begin="0:46:06.32" end="0:46:10.5">
3995
+ distributed culture, all the<br/>
3996
+ tools and artifacts of
3997
+ </p>
3998
+
3999
+ <p begin="0:46:10.5" end="0:46:14.61">
4000
+ the digital natives that<br/>
4001
+ Scott was talking about.
4002
+ </p>
4003
+
4004
+ <p begin="0:46:14.61" end="0:46:17.01">
4005
+ So very quickly, some things<br/>
4006
+ about MIT's institutional
4007
+ </p>
4008
+
4009
+ <p begin="0:46:17.01" end="0:46:19.289">
4010
+ commitments.<br/>
4011
+ Like I said, OpenCourseWare
4012
+ </p>
4013
+
4014
+ <p begin="0:46:19.289" end="0:46:21.88">
4015
+ was preceded by a lot<br/>
4016
+ of strategic thinking.
4017
+ </p>
4018
+
4019
+ <p begin="0:46:21.88" end="0:46:24.889">
4020
+ You know, we had this Counsel<br/>
4021
+ on Education Technology, and
4022
+ </p>
4023
+
4024
+ <p begin="0:46:24.889" end="0:46:27.579">
4025
+ there was a particular<br/>
4026
+ strategic thrust around
4027
+ </p>
4028
+
4029
+ <p begin="0:46:27.579" end="0:46:30.809">
4030
+ bolstering the commons<br/>
4031
+ off the mind, you know.
4032
+ </p>
4033
+
4034
+ <p begin="0:46:30.809" end="0:46:35.239">
4035
+ Nice words chosen by Hal<br/>
4036
+ Abelson, who was, you know,
4037
+ </p>
4038
+
4039
+ <p begin="0:46:35.239" end="0:46:38.26">
4040
+ who was a leader in education<br/>
4041
+ technology over here at MIT.
4042
+ </p>
4043
+
4044
+ <p begin="0:46:38.26" end="0:46:41.659">
4045
+ <br/>
4046
+
4047
+ </p>
4048
+
4049
+ <p begin="0:46:41.659" end="0:46:44.07">
4050
+ And we had a lot of strategies<br/>
4051
+ around active learning, which
4052
+ </p>
4053
+
4054
+ <p begin="0:46:44.07" end="0:46:48.01">
4055
+ led to all kinds of initiatives<br/>
4056
+ like, you know, TEAL
4057
+ </p>
4058
+
4059
+ <p begin="0:46:48.01" end="0:46:50.349">
4060
+ and iLab and so on.<br/>
4061
+
4062
+ </p>
4063
+
4064
+ <p begin="0:46:50.349" end="0:46:54.579">
4065
+ But the strategy around<br/>
4066
+ intellectual commons was what
4067
+ </p>
4068
+
4069
+ <p begin="0:46:54.579" end="0:46:58.09">
4070
+ was an expression of MIT's<br/>
4071
+ institutional commitment
4072
+ </p>
4073
+
4074
+ <p begin="0:46:58.09" end="0:46:59.739">
4075
+ to things open.<br/>
4076
+
4077
+ </p>
4078
+
4079
+ <p begin="0:46:59.739" end="0:47:04.48">
4080
+ In fact, at that time, and<br/>
4081
+ these slides are dated, you
4082
+ </p>
4083
+
4084
+ <p begin="0:47:04.48" end="0:47:09.909">
4085
+ know, they're circa 2004, but<br/>
4086
+ these initiatives that were
4087
+ </p>
4088
+
4089
+ <p begin="0:47:09.909" end="0:47:12.96">
4090
+ launched were part of an<br/>
4091
+ institutional strategy and
4092
+ </p>
4093
+
4094
+ <p begin="0:47:12.96" end="0:47:15.559">
4095
+ the present MIT's commitment.<br/>
4096
+
4097
+ </p>
4098
+
4099
+ <p begin="0:47:15.559" end="0:47:22.719">
4100
+ This base, which is a very,<br/>
4101
+ very big base, to the website
4102
+ </p>
4103
+
4104
+ <p begin="0:47:22.719" end="0:47:26.969">
4105
+ announcement that you saw about<br/>
4106
+ open access to research, OKI
4107
+ </p>
4108
+
4109
+ <p begin="0:47:26.969" end="0:47:28.789">
4110
+ that you've heard about,<br/>
4111
+ OpenCourseWare that I
4112
+ </p>
4113
+
4114
+ <p begin="0:47:28.789" end="0:47:31.5">
4115
+ need not speak about.<br/>
4116
+ So, the institutional
4117
+ </p>
4118
+
4119
+ <p begin="0:47:31.5" end="0:47:36.239">
4120
+ commitment was because it was<br/>
4121
+ seen as important elements of
4122
+ </p>
4123
+
4124
+ <p begin="0:47:36.239" end="0:47:38.889">
4125
+ educational strategy at MIT.<br/>
4126
+
4127
+ </p>
4128
+
4129
+ <p begin="0:47:38.889" end="0:47:44.579">
4130
+ Now, the second thing about the<br/>
4131
+ collectivity culture, and I'm
4132
+ </p>
4133
+
4134
+ <p begin="0:47:44.579" end="0:47:48.25">
4135
+ going to close over here,<br/>
4136
+ the collectivity culture is
4137
+ </p>
4138
+
4139
+ <p begin="0:47:48.25" end="0:47:54.5">
4140
+ really expressed through, you<br/>
4141
+ know, through what we see.
4142
+ </p>
4143
+
4144
+ <p begin="0:47:54.5" end="0:47:59.239">
4145
+ And my boss, Dan Hastings,<br/>
4146
+ who's the Dean of Undergraduate
4147
+ </p>
4148
+
4149
+ <p begin="0:47:59.239" end="0:48:02.789">
4150
+ Education over here, has sent<br/>
4151
+ us these slides sometime ago.
4152
+ </p>
4153
+
4154
+ <p begin="0:48:02.789" end="0:48:06.07">
4155
+ And for me, they tells the<br/>
4156
+ story about the digital
4157
+ </p>
4158
+
4159
+ <p begin="0:48:06.07" end="0:48:10.82">
4160
+ natives, and the collectivity<br/>
4161
+ culture, which I think gives
4162
+ </p>
4163
+
4164
+ <p begin="0:48:10.82" end="0:48:14.829">
4165
+ me comfort that -- well, on the<br/>
4166
+ one hand it makes it very
4167
+ </p>
4168
+
4169
+ <p begin="0:48:14.829" end="0:48:19.38">
4170
+ important that we continue to<br/>
4171
+ march on, on this road towards
4172
+ </p>
4173
+
4174
+ <p begin="0:48:19.38" end="0:48:22.92">
4175
+ Metaversity two, but at the<br/>
4176
+ same time it gives me comfort
4177
+ </p>
4178
+
4179
+ <p begin="0:48:22.92" end="0:48:27.289">
4180
+ that it's well on it's<br/>
4181
+ way to being reaffied.
4182
+ </p>
4183
+
4184
+ <p begin="0:48:27.289" end="0:48:30.012">
4185
+ So here are a set of<br/>
4186
+ slides that Dan gave that
4187
+ </p>
4188
+
4189
+ <p begin="0:48:30.012" end="0:48:32.71">
4190
+ I think speak to the<br/>
4191
+ collectivity culture.
4192
+ </p>
4193
+
4194
+ <p begin="0:48:32.71" end="0:48:37.03">
4195
+ This is by a group of students<br/>
4196
+ who fancy that they work at
4197
+ </p>
4198
+
4199
+ <p begin="0:48:37.03" end="0:48:40.469">
4200
+ NASA, and who also asking why<br/>
4201
+ aren't we working at NASA.
4202
+ </p>
4203
+
4204
+ <p begin="0:48:40.469" end="0:48:43.219">
4205
+ And they are -- I won't<br/>
4206
+ say much why it is being
4207
+ </p>
4208
+
4209
+ <p begin="0:48:43.219" end="0:48:45.289">
4210
+ played, they are from gen-Y.<br/>
4211
+
4212
+ </p>
4213
+
4214
+ <p begin="0:48:45.289" end="0:48:47.48">
4215
+ Gen-Y is, by the way, it is<br/>
4216
+ characterized by everyone
4217
+ </p>
4218
+
4219
+ <p begin="0:48:47.48" end="0:48:52.059">
4220
+ between 14 and they say 40,<br/>
4221
+ but I'm going to say 50s.
4222
+ </p>
4223
+
4224
+ <p begin="0:48:52.059" end="0:48:54.739">
4225
+ <br/>
4226
+
4227
+ </p>
4228
+
4229
+ <p begin="0:48:54.739" end="0:49:00.849">
4230
+ So and well, these are the, and<br/>
4231
+ you're seeing characteristics
4232
+ </p>
4233
+
4234
+ <p begin="0:49:00.849" end="0:49:06.59">
4235
+ of this collectivity<br/>
4236
+ generations, right?
4237
+ </p>
4238
+
4239
+ <p begin="0:49:06.59" end="0:49:09.07">
4240
+ <br/>
4241
+
4242
+ </p>
4243
+
4244
+ <p begin="0:49:09.07" end="0:49:12.75">
4245
+ So they're talking about why<br/>
4246
+ are -- it's self-explanatory.
4247
+ </p>
4248
+
4249
+ <p begin="0:49:12.75" end="0:49:43.82">
4250
+ <br/>
4251
+
4252
+ </p>
4253
+
4254
+ <p begin="0:49:43.82" end="0:49:49.746">
4255
+ Now, there are tools that they,<br/>
4256
+ and this speaks exactly to your
4257
+ </p>
4258
+
4259
+ <p begin="0:49:49.746" end="0:50:08.19">
4260
+ point, By the way, this is just<br/>
4261
+ a sort of disclaimer slide
4262
+ </p>
4263
+
4264
+ <p begin="0:50:08.19" end="0:50:10.619">
4265
+ to say that NASA actually<br/>
4266
+ uses a lot of these tools.
4267
+ </p>
4268
+
4269
+ <p begin="0:50:10.619" end="0:50:11.9">
4270
+ I think I have said enough.<br/>
4271
+
4272
+ </p>
4273
+
4274
+ <p begin="0:50:11.9" end="0:50:13.599">
4275
+ I hope I have given<br/>
4276
+ you a message.
4277
+ </p>
4278
+
4279
+ <p begin="0:50:13.599" end="0:50:16.69">
4280
+ Thank you very much, and<br/>
4281
+ I hope the message off
4282
+ </p>
4283
+
4284
+ <p begin="0:50:16.69" end="0:50:18.018">
4285
+ everything open is clear.<br/>
4286
+
4287
+ </p>
4288
+
4289
+ <p begin="0:50:18.018" end="0:50:21.84">
4290
+ And I don't know, Scott, if you<br/>
4291
+ wanted to take any questions,
4292
+ </p>
4293
+
4294
+ <p begin="0:50:21.84" end="0:50:33.75">
4295
+ or if -- what have you<br/>
4296
+ noticed, but thanks a lot.
4297
+ </p>
4298
+
4299
+ </div>
4300
+ </body>
4301
+ </tt>