aiox-core 5.0.2 → 5.0.3

package/pro/squads/squad-creator-pro/tasks/validate-squad.md

@@ -0,0 +1,1385 @@
+# Task: Validate Squad
+
+**Task ID:** validate-squad
+**Version:** 3.3.0
+**Purpose:** Validate a squad against AIOS principles using tiered, context-aware validation
+**Orchestrator:** @squad-chief
+**Process Specialist:** @pedro-valerio
+**Mode:** Tiered validation (structure → coverage → quality → contextual)
+**Execution Type:** `Hybrid` (Worker scripts for Phases 0-2 + Agent for Phases 3-6)
+**Worker Scripts:** `scripts/validate-squad.sh`, `scripts/quality_gate.py`, `scripts/yaml_validator.py`
+
+**Process Validation (via @pedro-valerio):**
+- Audit workflows para verificar se impedem caminhos errados
+- Validar veto conditions em cada checkpoint
+- Identificar gaps de tempo entre handoffs
+- Garantir fluxo unidirecional (cards nunca voltam)
+
+**Core Philosophy:**
+```
+Quality comes from adherence to principles AND context-awareness.
+An orchestrator doesn't need voice_dna. An expert agent does.
+Validation must understand WHAT type of squad it's validating.
+```
+
+**Frameworks Used:**
+- `config/veto-conditions.yaml` → Veto engine with 10 blocking conditions **[v3.3]**
+- `config/task-anatomy.yaml` → 8-field task validation schema **[v3.3]**
+- `data/squad-type-definitions.yaml` → Squad type detection and requirements
+- `checklists/squad-checklist.md` → Complete validation checklist (v3.0)
+- `data/quality-dimensions-framework.md` → Quality scoring
+- `data/tier-system-framework.md` → Agent tier validation
+- `data/executor-decision-tree.md` → Executor type validation (Worker/Agent/Hybrid/Human) **[v3.2]**
+- `data/tool-registry.yaml` → Tool and MCP integration validation **[v3.2]**
+
+---
+
+## Validation Flow
+
+```
+INPUT (squad_name)
+    ↓
+[PHASE 0: TYPE DETECTION]
+    → Detect squad type (Expert/Pipeline/Hybrid)
+    → Load type-specific requirements
+    ↓
+[PHASE 1: STRUCTURE - TIER 1]
+    → config.yaml exists and valid
+    → Entry agent defined and activatable
+    → All referenced files exist
+    → BLOCKING: Any failure = ABORT
+    ↓
+[PHASE 2: COVERAGE - TIER 2]
+    → Checklist coverage for complex tasks (>=30%)
+    → Orphan task detection (max 2)
+    → Pipeline phase coverage (Pipeline squads)
+    → Data file usage (>=50%)
+    → Tool registry validation (if exists) [v3.2]
+    → BLOCKING: Coverage failures = ABORT
+    ↓
+[PHASE 3: QUALITY - TIER 3]
+    → Prompt Quality (20%)
+    → Pipeline Coherence (20%)
+    → Checklist Actionability (20%)
+    → Documentation (20%)
+    → Optimization Opportunities (20%) [v3.2]
+    → Score 0-10, threshold 7.0
+    ↓
+[PHASE 4: CONTEXTUAL - TIER 4]
+    → Expert: voice_dna, objection_algorithms, tiers
+    → Pipeline: workflow, checkpoints, orchestrator
+    → Hybrid: persona, behavioral_states, heuristics, executor_decision_tree [v3.2]
+    → Score 0-10, weighted 20% of final
+    ↓
+[PHASE 5: VETO CHECK]
+    → Check type-specific veto conditions
+    → Any veto = FAIL regardless of score
+    ↓
+[PHASE 6: SCORING & REPORT]
+    → Calculate: (Tier 3 × 0.80) + (Tier 4 × 0.20)
+    → Generate detailed report
+    ↓
+OUTPUT: Validation Report + Final Score
+```
+
+---
+
+## Inputs
+
+| Parameter | Type | Required | Description | Example |
+|-----------|------|----------|-------------|---------|
+| `squad_name` | string | Yes | Name of squad to validate | `"{your-squad}"` |
+| `squad_path` | string | No | Override default path | `"squads/{squad-name}/"` |
+| `type_override` | string | No | Force squad type | `"expert"`, `"pipeline"`, `"hybrid"` |
+
+---
+
+## PHASE 0: TYPE DETECTION
+
+**Duration:** < 30 seconds
+**Mode:** Autonomous
+**Reference:** `data/squad-type-definitions.yaml`
+
+### Step 0.1: Analyze Squad Structure
+
+```yaml
+detection_signals:
+  count_agents:
+    action: "Count files in agents/"
+    weight_expert: "high count (+)"
+    weight_pipeline: "low count (+)"
+
+  check_voice_dna:
+    action: "Grep for 'voice_dna:' in agent files"
+    weight_expert: "present (+3)"
+    weight_pipeline: "absent (neutral)"
+    weight_hybrid: "absent (neutral)"
+
+  check_workflow:
+    action: "Look for workflow.yaml or sequential phases in orchestrator"
+    weight_pipeline: "present (+3)"
+
+  check_heuristics:
+    action: "Grep for heuristic IDs (PV_*, SC_*)"
+    weight_hybrid: "present (+3)"
+
+  calculate_ratio:
+    action: "tasks_count / agents_count"
+    weight_pipeline: "ratio > 3 (+2)"
+    weight_expert: "ratio 2-4 (+1)"
+    weight_hybrid: "ratio ~1 (+2)"
+```
+
+### Step 0.2: Determine Type
+
+```yaml
+detection_algorithm:
+  expert_score: 0
+  pipeline_score: 0
+  hybrid_score: 0
+
+  # Apply weights from signals
+  if agents_count >= 5: expert_score += 2
+  if voice_dna_present_in_50_percent: expert_score += 3
+  if has_tier_organization: expert_score += 1
+
+  if has_orchestrator_agent: pipeline_score += 2
+  if has_sequential_phases: pipeline_score += 3
+  if tasks_count > agents_count * 3: pipeline_score += 2
+
+  if has_heuristic_validation: hybrid_score += 3
+  if has_persona_profile_pattern: hybrid_score += 2
+  if agents_count ~= phases_count: hybrid_score += 1
+
+  # Determine winner
+  detected_type: max(expert_score, pipeline_score, hybrid_score)
+
+  # Handle ties
+  if tie:
+    if real_person_names_in_agents: "expert"
+    elif phase_numbering_present: "pipeline"
+    else: "pipeline"  # default
+```
+
+### Step 0.3: Load Type Requirements
+
+```yaml
+load_requirements:
+  file: "data/squad-type-definitions.yaml"
+  section: "squad_types.{detected_type}"
+
+  output:
+    required_components: [...]
+    optional_components: [...]
+    veto_conditions: [...]
+    benchmarks: {...}
+```
+
+**Output (PHASE 0):**
+```yaml
+phase_0_output:
+  detected_type: "pipeline"  # or "expert" or "hybrid"
+  confidence: 0.85
+  signals:
+    agents_count: 1
+    voice_dna_present: false
+    has_workflow: true
+    task_agent_ratio: 19
+  requirements_loaded: true
+```
+
+---
+
+## PHASE 1: STRUCTURE (TIER 1 - BLOCKING)
+
+**Duration:** < 1 minute
+**Mode:** Autonomous
+**Result:** PASS or ABORT
+
+### 1.1 Configuration Check
+
+```yaml
+structure_checks:
+  - id: "T1-CFG-001"
+    check: "config.yaml exists in squad root"
+    action: "ls {squad_path}/config.yaml"
+    on_fail: "ABORT - No config.yaml found"
+
+  - id: "T1-CFG-002"
+    check: "config.yaml is valid YAML"
+    action: "Parse YAML, check for errors"
+    on_fail: "ABORT - Invalid YAML syntax"
+
+  - id: "T1-CFG-003"
+    check: "Required fields present"
+    fields: ["name", "version", "description", "entry_agent"]
+    on_fail: "ABORT - Missing required field: {field}"
+
+  - id: "T1-CFG-004"
+    check: "name uses kebab-case"
+    pattern: "^[a-z0-9]+(-[a-z0-9]+)*$"
+    on_fail: "ABORT - Name must be kebab-case"
+
+  - id: "T1-CFG-005"
+    check: "version follows semver"
+    pattern: "^\\d+\\.\\d+\\.\\d+$"
+    on_fail: "ABORT - Version must be X.Y.Z"
+```
+
+### 1.2 Entry Point Check
+
+```yaml
+entry_point_checks:
+  - id: "T1-ENT-001"
+    check: "entry_agent file exists"
+    action: "ls {squad_path}/agents/{entry_agent}.md"
+    on_fail: "ABORT - Entry agent file not found"
+
+  - id: "T1-ENT-002"
+    check: "entry_agent has activation-instructions"
+    action: "Grep for 'activation-instructions:'"
+    on_fail: "ABORT - Entry agent not activatable"
+
+  - id: "T1-ENT-003"
+    check: "entry_agent has *help command"
+    action: "Grep for '*help' in commands section"
+    on_fail: "ABORT - Entry agent missing *help command"
+```
+
+### 1.3 File Reference Check
+
+```yaml
+reference_checks:
+  - id: "T1-REF-001"
+    check: "All config.yaml dependencies exist"
+    action: |
+      For each file in config.yaml dependencies:
+        Check file exists at {squad_path}/{type}/{file}
+    threshold: "100%"
+    on_fail: "ABORT - Missing dependency: {file}"
+
+  - id: "T1-REF-002"
+    check: "All agent dependencies exist"
+    action: |
+      For each agent:
+        For each file in dependencies:
+          Check file exists
+    threshold: "80%"  # Allow some missing
+    on_fail_above_threshold: "ABORT - >20% missing references"
+
+  - id: "T1-REF-003"
+    check: "Required directories exist"
+    directories: ["agents/"]
+    conditional:
+      - "tasks/ if any tasks referenced"
+      - "checklists/ if complex tasks exist"
+    on_fail: "ABORT - Missing required directory"
+```
+
+### 1.4 Cross-Reference Validation
+
+```yaml
+cross_reference_checks:
+  - id: "T1-XREF-001"
+    check: "All handoff_to targets exist"
+    action: |
+      For each agent with handoff_to:
+        Verify target agent file exists
+    on_fail: "ABORT - Handoff to non-existent agent: {target}"
+
+  - id: "T1-XREF-002"
+    check: "All task references valid"
+    action: |
+      For each task referenced in agents/workflows:
+        Verify task file exists in tasks/
+    on_fail: "ABORT - Task reference invalid: {task}"
+
+  - id: "T1-XREF-003"
+    check: "All template references valid"
+    action: |
+      For each template referenced in tasks:
+        Verify template file exists
+    on_fail: "WARNING - Template missing: {template}"
+
+  - id: "T1-XREF-004"
+    check: "All checklist references valid"
+    action: |
+      For each checklist referenced:
+        Verify checklist file exists
+    on_fail: "WARNING - Checklist missing: {checklist}"
+```
+
+### 1.5 Security Scan
+
+**Reference:** OWASP Secrets Management, squad-checklist.md SEC-001 to SEC-018
+
+```yaml
+security_scan:
+  description: "Comprehensive security scan for secrets and vulnerabilities"
+
+  # Category 1: API Keys & Tokens (BLOCKING)
+  api_tokens:
+    - id: "T1-SEC-001"
+      check: "No hardcoded API keys"
+      action: "grep -rE '(api[_-]?key|apikey)\\s*[:=]\\s*[^${}]{20,}'"
+      exclude: "# Placeholder|{{|\\$[A-Z]"
+      on_match: "ABORT - API key found"
+
+    - id: "T1-SEC-002"
+      check: "No hardcoded secrets/passwords"
+      action: "grep -rE '(secret|password|passwd)\\s*[:=]\\s*['\"][^'\"${}]{8,}'"
+      on_match: "ABORT - Secret/password found"
+
+    - id: "T1-SEC-003"
+      check: "No bearer/JWT tokens"
+      action: "grep -rE '(bearer|jwt[_-]?secret)\\s*[:=]\\s*['\"][^'\"]{20,}'"
+      on_match: "ABORT - Token found"
+
+  # Category 2: Cloud Credentials (BLOCKING)
+  cloud_credentials:
+    - id: "T1-SEC-004"
+      check: "No AWS Access Keys"
+      action: "grep -rE 'AKIA[A-Z0-9]{16}'"
+      on_match: "ABORT - AWS Access Key found"
+
+    - id: "T1-SEC-005"
+      check: "No AWS Secret Keys"
+      action: "grep -rE 'aws[_-]?secret.*['\"][A-Za-z0-9/+=]{40}'"
+      on_match: "ABORT - AWS Secret Key found"
+
+    - id: "T1-SEC-006"
+      check: "No GCP Service Account Keys"
+      action: "grep -rE '\"type\":\\s*\"service_account\"'"
+      on_match: "ABORT - GCP Service Account found"
+
+  # Category 3: Private Keys (BLOCKING)
+  private_keys:
+    - id: "T1-SEC-007"
+      check: "No private keys in content"
+      action: "grep -rE '-----BEGIN.*PRIVATE KEY-----'"
+      on_match: "ABORT - Private key content found"
+
+    - id: "T1-SEC-008"
+      check: "No private key files"
+      action: "find . -name '*.pem' -o -name '*.key' -o -name 'id_rsa' -o -name 'id_ecdsa'"
+      on_match: "ABORT - Private key file found"
+
+  # Category 4: Database URLs (BLOCKING)
+  database_urls:
+    - id: "T1-SEC-009"
+      check: "No database URLs with credentials"
+      action: "grep -rE '(postgres|mysql|mongodb|redis)://[^:]+:[^@]+@'"
+      on_match: "ABORT - Database URL with password found"
+
+    - id: "T1-SEC-010"
+      check: "No Supabase service role keys"
+      action: "grep -rE 'supabase.*service[_-]?role.*eyJ'"
+      on_match: "ABORT - Supabase service role key found"
+
+  # Category 5: Sensitive Files (BLOCKING)
+  sensitive_files:
+    - id: "T1-SEC-011"
+      check: "No .env files"
+      action: "find . -name '.env*' -o -name '*.env'"
+      on_match: "ABORT - .env file found"
+
+    - id: "T1-SEC-012"
+      check: "No credential files"
+      action: "find . -name 'credentials*.json' -o -name 'service-account*.json' -o -name 'secrets.yaml'"
+      on_match: "ABORT - Credential file found"
+
+  # Category 6: Code Vulnerabilities (WARNING)
+  code_vulnerabilities:
+    - id: "T1-SEC-013"
+      check: "No dangerous eval/exec"
+      action: "grep -rE '\\b(eval|exec)\\s*\\(' --include='*.py' --include='*.js'"
+      severity: WARNING
+      on_match: "WARNING - eval/exec found, review context"
+
+  # False positive exclusions
+  exclude_patterns:
+    - "{{.*}}"           # Jinja/Mustache placeholders
+    - "$[A-Z_]+"         # Shell variables
+    - "process.env."     # Node.js env
+    - "os.environ"       # Python env
+    - "# Example:"       # Example in comments
+    - "your-.*-here"     # Placeholder text
+```
+
+**Tier 1 Output:**
+```yaml
+tier_1_result:
+  status: "PASS"  # or "ABORT"
+  checks_run: 11
+  checks_passed: 11
+  checks_failed: 0
+  blocking_issues: []
+```
+
+---
+
+## PHASE 2: COVERAGE (TIER 2 - BLOCKING)
+
+**Duration:** 1-2 minutes
+**Mode:** Autonomous
+**Result:** PASS or ABORT
+
+### 2.1 Checklist Coverage
+
+```yaml
+checklist_coverage:
+  id: "T2-COV-001"
+  description: "Complex tasks should have checklists"
+
+  calculation:
+    step_1: "Count tasks with >500 lines"
+    step_2: "Count checklists in checklists/"
+    step_3: "Calculate ratio: checklists / complex_tasks"
+
+  threshold: 0.30  # 30%
+  result:
+    pass_if: "ratio >= 0.30"
+    warn_if: "ratio >= 0.20"
+    fail_if: "ratio < 0.20"
+
+  on_fail: "ABORT - Insufficient checklist coverage ({ratio}% < 30%)"
+```
+
+### 2.2 Orphan Task Detection
+
+```yaml
+orphan_detection:
+  id: "T2-ORP-001"
+  description: "Tasks must be referenced somewhere"
+
+  calculation:
+    for_each_task_in_tasks:
+      check_1: "Is task referenced in any agent's commands?"
+      check_2: "Is task referenced in any agent's dependencies?"
+      check_3: "Is task referenced in any workflow?"
+      if_none: "Mark as ORPHAN"
+
+  threshold: 2  # Max orphans allowed
+  result:
+    pass_if: "orphan_count <= 2"
+    warn_if: "orphan_count <= 5"
+    fail_if: "orphan_count > 5"
+
+  on_fail: "ABORT - Too many orphan tasks: {orphan_list}"
+```
+
+### 2.3 Pipeline Phase Coverage (Pipeline squads only)
+
+```yaml
+phase_coverage:
+  id: "T2-PHS-001"
+  description: "All workflow phases must have tasks"
+  applies_to: "pipeline"
+
+  calculation:
+    step_1: "List all phases in workflow"
+    step_2: "For each phase, verify task reference exists"
+    step_3: "Calculate coverage %"
+
+  threshold: 1.0  # 100%
+  result:
+    pass_if: "coverage == 100%"
+    fail_if: "coverage < 100%"
+
+  on_fail: "ABORT - Phases without tasks: {missing_phases}"
+```
+
+### 2.4 Data File Usage
+
+```yaml
+data_usage:
+  id: "T2-DAT-001"
+  description: "Data files should be referenced"
+
+  calculation:
+    step_1: "List all files in data/"
+    step_2: "For each file, grep all agents and tasks for filename"
+    step_3: "Calculate usage %"
+
+  threshold: 0.50  # 50%
+  result:
+    pass_if: "usage >= 50%"
+    warn_if: "usage >= 30%"
+    fail_if: "usage < 30%"
+
+  on_warn: "WARNING - Low data file usage: {unused_files}"
+  # Not blocking, just warning
+```
+
+### 2.5 Tool Registry Validation [v3.2]
+
+```yaml
+tool_registry_validation:
+  id: "T2-TOOL-001"
+  description: "Validate tool registry if squad uses external tools/MCPs"
+  applies_when: "data/tool-registry.yaml exists OR scripts/ contains integrations"
+  reference: "data/tool-registry.yaml"
+
+  checks:
+    registry_exists:
+      id: "T2-TOOL-001a"
+      check: "tool-registry.yaml exists if squad uses external tools"
+      action: |
+        If squad has:
+          - MCP integrations
+          - External API calls in tasks
+          - Automation scripts with tool dependencies
+        THEN tool-registry.yaml SHOULD exist
+      severity: "WARNING"
+      on_missing: "WARNING - Squad uses tools but no registry found"
+
+    declared_tools_functional:
+      id: "T2-TOOL-001b"
+      check: "Declared tools are accessible"
+      action: |
+        For each tool in tool-registry.yaml:
+          Verify: path exists OR MCP is configured
+      severity: "WARNING"
+      on_fail: "WARNING - Tool declared but not accessible: {tool}"
+
+    integration_documented:
+      id: "T2-TOOL-001c"
+      check: "Tool integrations documented in README"
+      action: "Grep README for tool names from registry"
+      severity: "WARNING"
+      on_fail: "WARNING - Tools not documented in README"
+
+  result:
+    pass_if: "All declared tools accessible"
+    warn_if: "Some tools missing or undocumented"
+    # Not blocking - tools are enhancement, not requirement
+```
+
+**Tier 2 Output:**
+```yaml
+tier_2_result:
+  status: "PASS"  # or "ABORT"
+  metrics:
+    checklist_coverage: "35%"
+    orphan_tasks: 1
+    phase_coverage: "100%"  # if pipeline
+    data_usage: "67%"
+    tool_registry: "N/A"  # or "PASS" if exists and valid [v3.2]
+  issues: []
+```
+
+---
+
+## PHASE 3: QUALITY (TIER 3 - SCORING)
+
+**Duration:** 5-10 minutes
+**Mode:** Autonomous with sampling
+**Result:** Score 0-10
+
+### 3.1 Prompt Quality (25%)
+
+```yaml
+prompt_quality:
+  id: "T3-PQ"
+  weight: 0.25
+  question: "Are task prompts specific, actionable, and reproducible?"
+
+  sampling:
+    method: "Select 3 representative tasks"
+    selection:
+      - "Most complex (highest lines)"
+      - "Entry/main task"
+      - "Random task"
+
+  criteria:
+    - name: "Explicit examples"
+      points: 3
+      check: "Task has input/output examples?"
+
+    - name: "Anti-patterns"
+      points: 2
+      check: "Task has 'don't do' section?"
+
+    - name: "Success criteria"
+      points: 2
+      check: "Task has measurable completion criteria?"
+
+    - name: "Step-by-step"
+      points: 2
+      check: "Instructions are sequential and clear?"
+
+    - name: "No vague language"
+      points: 1
+      check: "Avoids 'verify', 'ensure', 'check' without specifics?"
+
+  scoring:
+    per_task: "Sum criteria points (max 10)"
+    final: "Average of 3 sampled tasks"
+```
+
+### 3.2 Pipeline Coherence (25%)
+
+```yaml
+pipeline_coherence:
+  id: "T3-PC"
+  weight: 0.25
+  question: "Does data flow correctly between components?"
+
+  criteria:
+    - name: "Output→Input chain"
+      points: 3
+      check: |
+        For each phase transition:
+          Phase N output field == Phase N+1 input field?
+          File paths consistent?
+
+    - name: "No sequence collisions"
+      points: 2
+      check: "No two tasks have same sequence number?"
+
+    - name: "Checkpoints present"
+      points: 2
+      check: |
+        Quality gate before final output?
+        Human review at critical points?
+
+    - name: "Failure handling"
+      points: 2
+      check: "Rework rules defined for failures?"
+
+    - name: "Dependencies explicit"
+      points: 1
+      check: "Task dependencies are listed, not implicit?"
+
+  scoring:
+    method: "Sum criteria points (max 10)"
+```
+
+### 3.3 Checklist Actionability (25%)
+
+```yaml
+checklist_actionability:
+  id: "T3-CA"
+  weight: 0.25
+  question: "Are checklists measurable and actionable?"
+
+  sampling:
+    method: "Evaluate all checklists (or max 3)"
+
+  criteria:
+    - name: "Measurable items"
+      points: 3
+      check: |
+        Items can be answered YES/NO?
+        Avoids 'verify quality', 'ensure completeness'?
+
+    - name: "Scoring system"
+      points: 2
+      check: "Has point values or grades?"
+
+    - name: "Pass/fail thresholds"
+      points: 2
+      check: "Defines what score = pass?"
+
+    - name: "Auto-correction"
+      points: 2
+      check: "If item fails, guidance on how to fix?"
+
+    - name: "Edge cases"
+      points: 1
+      check: "Covers unusual scenarios?"
+
+  scoring:
+    per_checklist: "Sum criteria points (max 10)"
+    final: "Average of all checklists"
+```
+
+### 3.4 Documentation (25%)
+
+```yaml
+documentation:
+  id: "T3-DOC"
+  weight: 0.25
+  question: "Can a new user understand and use this squad?"
+
+  criteria:
+    - name: "README purpose"
+      points: 2
+      check: "README clearly explains what squad does?"
+
+    - name: "Getting started"
+      points: 2
+      check: "Installation/activation instructions present?"
+
+    - name: "Command examples"
+      points: 2
+      check: "Commands documented with usage examples?"
+
+    - name: "Architecture diagram"
+      points: 1
+      check: "Visual flow or structure diagram?"
+
+    - name: "Changelog"
+      points: 1
+      check: "Version history maintained?"
+
+    - name: "Error handling"
+      points: 1
+      check: "Common errors and fixes documented?"
+
+    - name: "Dependencies"
+      points: 1
+      check: "External dependencies listed?"
+
+    - name: "Changelog separation"  # [v3.2.1]
+      points: 1
+      check: |
+        Tasks >= v2.0.0 have separate CHANGELOG.md?
+        Reference: HO-DP-001 in best-practices.md
+
+  scoring:
+    method: "Sum criteria points (max 11, normalized to 10)"
+```
+
+### 3.5 Optimization Opportunities [v3.2]
+
+```yaml
+optimization_opportunities:
+  id: "T3-OPT"
+  weight: 0.20
+  question: "Are tasks using the optimal executor type (Worker vs Agent)?"
+  reference: "data/executor-decision-tree.md"
+
+  description: |
+    This check identifies tasks that could be converted from Agent (LLM, expensive)
+    to Worker (code, cheap) for cost savings. Uses the Executor Decision Tree (Q1-Q6).
+
+  sampling:
+    method: "Analyze all tasks with execution_type field"
+    focus: "Tasks marked as Agent that could be Worker"
+
+  criteria:
+    - name: "Executor type declared"
+      points: 2
+      check: "Tasks have execution_type field? (Worker|Agent|Hybrid|Human)"
+
+    - name: "Deterministic tasks use Worker"
+      points: 3
+      check: |
+        Tasks that are 100% deterministic (format, validate, transform)
+        are marked as Worker, not Agent?
+        Apply Q1-Q2 from executor-decision-tree.md
+
+    - name: "No expensive Agent misuse"
+      points: 3
+      check: |
+        Agent tasks truly require:
+          - Language interpretation
+          - Creative generation
+          - Context-aware analysis
+        If task could be a script, DEDUCT points
+
+    - name: "Hybrid correctly applied"
+      points: 2
+      check: |
+        Hybrid tasks have:
+          - Defined human_checkpoint
+          - Clear AI vs Human boundaries
+          - Fallback behavior
+
+  scoring:
+    method: "Sum criteria points (max 10)"
+
+  economy_projection:
+    calculate: |
+      For each Agent task that could be Worker:
+        monthly_executions: estimated 20/month
+        agent_cost: ~$0.10-0.50 per execution (tokens)
+        worker_cost: ~$0.001 per execution (compute)
+        potential_savings: (agent_cost - worker_cost) × monthly_executions
+
+    output: |
+      Optimization Report:
+      - Tasks eligible for conversion: N
+      - Monthly token savings: ~X tokens
+      - Monthly cost savings: ~$X
+
+  output_note: |
+    This check is INFORMATIONAL - not blocking.
+    Low score indicates optimization opportunity, not failure.
+    Run `*optimize {squad}` for detailed conversion recommendations.
+```
+
+**Tier 3 Output:**
+```yaml
+tier_3_result:
+  scores:
+    prompt_quality: 8.5
+    pipeline_coherence: 7.0
+    checklist_actionability: 6.5
+    documentation: 8.0
+    optimization_opportunities: 6.0  # Indicates room for improvement
+  weighted_total: 7.2
+  details:
+    prompt_quality_samples: ["brutal-extractor.md", "final-writer.md", "gap-analyzer.md"]
+    coherence_issues: ["Phase 3.5 not in workflow.yaml", "Sequence 10 collision"]
+    checklist_issues: ["book-summary-scoring.md missing auto-correction for some items"]
+    optimization_notes:  # [v3.2]
+      agent_tasks_convertible: 3
+      potential_monthly_savings: "~$15"
+      recommendation: "Run *optimize {squad} for details"
+```
+
+---
+
+## PHASE 4: CONTEXTUAL VALIDATION (TIER 4)
+
+**Duration:** 3-5 minutes
+**Mode:** Type-specific
+**Result:** Score 0-10
+
+### 4A. Expert Squad Validation
+
+```yaml
+expert_validation:
+  applies_to: "expert"
+
+  checks:
+    voice_dna:
+      id: "T4E-VD"
+      weight: 0.30
+      required: true
+      criteria:
+        - "Each agent has voice_dna section"
+        - "sentence_starters defined by context"
+        - "metaphors defined with usage"
+        - "vocabulary.always_use has 5+ terms"
+        - "vocabulary.never_use has 3+ terms"
+
+    objection_algorithms:
+      id: "T4E-OA"
+      weight: 0.25
+      required: true
+      criteria:
+        - "Each agent has objection_algorithms"
+        - "Minimum 3 objections per agent"
+        - "Responses are domain-specific"
+
+    output_examples:
+      id: "T4E-OE"
+      weight: 0.25
+      required: true
+      criteria:
+        - "Each agent has 3+ examples"
+        - "Examples show input→output"
+        - "Examples are realistic"
+
+    tier_organization:
+      id: "T4E-TO"
+      weight: 0.20
+      required: true
+      criteria:
+        - "Tier 0 (diagnosis) agents exist"
+        - "Tier assignments documented"
+        - "Orchestrator/Chief defined"
+```
+
+### 4B. Pipeline Squad Validation
+
+```yaml
+pipeline_validation:
+  applies_to: "pipeline"
+
+  checks:
+    workflow_definition:
+      id: "T4P-WD"
+      weight: 0.30
+      required: true
+      criteria:
+        - "Workflow file exists"
+        - "Phases numbered sequentially"
+        - "Each phase has: name, task, outputs"
+        - "Dependencies explicit"
+
+    phase_checkpoints:
+      id: "T4P-PC"
+      weight: 0.30
+      required: true
+      criteria:
+        - "Critical phases have checkpoints"
+        - "Quality gate before final output"
+        - "Rework rules on failure"
+
+    orchestrator_completeness:
+      id: "T4P-OC"
+      weight: 0.25
+      required: true
+      criteria:
+        - "All phases documented in orchestrator"
+        - "Commands map to tasks"
+        - "Status tracking capability"
+
+    intermediate_outputs:
+      id: "T4P-IO"
+      weight: 0.10
+      required: true
+      criteria:
+        - "Each phase produces output"
+        - "Output paths consistent"
+        - "Outputs inspectable"
+
+    automation_script:
+      id: "T4P-AS"
+      weight: 0.15
+      required: false  # Required only if phases >= 8
+      applies_when: "phases_count >= 8"
+      criteria:
+        - "Script exists in scripts/ directory"
+        - "Accepts input parameters (slug/target)"
+        - "Has --help documentation"
+        - "Has state management (state.json)"
+        - "Has progress tracking"
+        - "Logs to logs/ directory"
+        - "Supports resume capability"
+      reference: "YOLO mode automation pattern"
+      scoring:
+        7_of_7: 10
+        6_of_7: 8
+        5_of_7: 7  # minimum pass
+        below_5: "FAIL"
+```
+
+### 4C. Hybrid Squad Validation
+
+```yaml
+hybrid_validation:
+  applies_to: "hybrid"
+
+  checks:
+    persona_profile:
+      id: "T4H-PP"
+      weight: 0.15
+      required: true
+      criteria:
+        - "Each agent has persona_profile"
+        - "Archetype defined"
+        - "Communication style documented"
+
+    behavioral_states:
+      id: "T4H-BS"
+      weight: 0.15
+      required: true
+      criteria:
+        - "Operational modes defined"
+        - "Mode triggers documented"
+        - "Output format per mode"
+
+    heuristic_validation:
+      id: "T4H-HV"
+      weight: 0.20
+      required: true
+      criteria:
+        - "Heuristics have IDs (PV_*, SC_*)"
+        - "Each has: trigger, evaluation, threshold"
+        - "VETO conditions explicit"
+        - "Fallback behavior defined"
+
+    process_standards:
+      id: "T4H-PS"
+      weight: 0.15
+      required: true
+      criteria:
+        - "Task Anatomy (8 fields) enforced"
+        - "BPMN or equivalent used"
+        - "Integration points documented"
+
+    # [v3.2] NEW: Executor Decision Tree Validation
+    executor_decision_tree:
+      id: "T4H-EX"
+      weight: 0.35
+      required: true
+      reference: "data/executor-decision-tree.md"
+      description: |
+        Validate that tasks correctly apply the 4-type executor model:
+        - Worker: Deterministic code (100% consistent, cheap)
+        - Agent: LLM probabilistic (needs interpretation, expensive)
+        - Hybrid: AI + Human (needs both judgment types)
+        - Human: Pure human decision (irreducible complexity)
+
+      criteria:
+        - name: "execution_type declared"
+          check: "Each task has execution_type field"
+          points: 2
+
+        - name: "Q1-Q6 correctly applied"
+          check: |
+            For each task, verify decision tree was followed:
+            Q1: Is output 100% predictable from input?
+            Q2: Can ALL rules be codified?
+            Q2a: Does task require language interpretation?
+            Q2b: Can one person ALWAYS make the decision?
+            Q3: Is decision-maker-level or safety-critical?
+            Q4: Can human error be tolerated?
+            Q5: Is real-time response required?
+            Q6: Does complexity require expert + AI together?
+          points: 4
+
+        - name: "Worker tasks have scripts"
+          check: "Tasks marked Worker have implementation in scripts/"
+          points: 2
+
+        - name: "Hybrid tasks have checkpoints"
+          check: "Tasks marked Hybrid define human_checkpoint"
+          points: 1
+
+        - name: "Fallback chain defined"
+          check: "Each executor type has fallback (Worker→Agent, Agent→Hybrid, Hybrid→Human)"
+          points: 1
+
+      scoring:
+        10_of_10: 10
+        8_of_10: 8
+        6_of_10: 6  # Minimum pass
+        below_6: "CONDITIONAL - Executor types need review"
+
+      anti_patterns:
+        - "Task marked Agent but is pure format/transform (should be Worker)"
+        - "Task marked Worker but requires interpretation (should be Agent)"
+        - "Task marked Hybrid but no human checkpoint defined"
+        - "No fallback for when primary executor fails"
+```
+
+**Tier 4 Output:**
+```yaml
+# Pipeline squad example:
+tier_4_result:
+  squad_type: "pipeline"
+  score: 7.5
+  checks:
+    workflow_definition: 8.0
+    phase_checkpoints: 6.0  # Missing rework rules
+    orchestrator_completeness: 9.0
+    intermediate_outputs: 7.0
+  issues:
+    - "Phase checkpoints missing rework rules"
+    - "Some phases lack explicit outputs"
+
+# Hybrid squad example [v3.2]:
+tier_4_result_hybrid:
+  squad_type: "hybrid"
+  score: 7.8
+  checks:
+    persona_profile: 8.0
+    behavioral_states: 7.5
+    heuristic_validation: 8.0
+    process_standards: 7.0
+    executor_decision_tree: 8.5  # [v3.2] NEW
+  issues:
+    - "2 tasks marked Agent could be Worker"
+    - "Missing fallback for Hybrid→Human"
+  optimization:
+    convertible_tasks: 2
+    potential_savings: "~$12/month"
+```
+
+---
+
+## PHASE 5: VETO CHECK
+
+**Duration:** < 30 seconds
+**Mode:** Autonomous
+**Result:** VETO or PROCEED
+**Reference:** `config/veto-conditions.yaml` **[v3.3]**
+
+### Universal Vetos (SC_VC_*)
+
+```yaml
+universal_vetos:
+  # From config/veto-conditions.yaml
+  - id: "SC_VC_001"
+    condition: "Domain not viable"
+    check: "elite_minds_count < 3 OR source_quality < 0.6"
+    result: "VETO - Domain not viable for squad creation"
+
+  - id: "SC_VC_002"
+    condition: "Vision unclear"
+    check: "squad_vision_clarity < 0.7"
+    result: "VETO - Vision unclear, return to Discovery"
+
+  - id: "SC_VC_010"
+    condition: "Task anatomy incomplete"
+    check: "required_fields_missing = true"
+    result: "VETO - Task missing required 8 fields"
+
+  # Legacy vetos (maintained for backwards compatibility)
+  - id: "V1"
+    condition: "No entry agent defined"
+    check: "tier_1_result.entry_agent_exists == false"
+    result: "VETO"
+
+  - id: "V2"
+    condition: "Entry agent cannot activate"
+    check: "tier_1_result.entry_agent_activatable == false"
+    result: "VETO"
+
+  - id: "V3"
+    condition: ">20% of referenced files missing"
+    check: "tier_1_result.missing_references > 20%"
+    result: "VETO"
+
+  - id: "V4"
+    condition: "config.yaml invalid"
+    check: "tier_1_result.config_valid == false"
+    result: "VETO"
+
+  - id: "V5"
+    condition: "Security issue detected"
+    check: "tier_1_result.security_issues > 0"
+    result: "VETO"
+    message: "Secrets, API keys, or credentials found"
+
+  - id: "V6"
+    condition: "Critical cross-reference broken"
+    check: "tier_1_result.broken_handoffs > 0"
+    result: "VETO"
+    message: "Handoff to non-existent agent"
+```
+
+### Expert Squad Vetos
+
+```yaml
+expert_vetos:
+  - id: "VE1"
+    condition: "Zero agents with voice_dna"
+    check: "tier_4_result.voice_dna_coverage == 0"
+    result: "VETO"
+
+  - id: "VE2"
+    condition: "No Tier 0 (diagnosis) capability"
+    check: "tier_4_result.has_tier_0 == false"
+    result: "VETO"
+```
+
+### Pipeline Squad Vetos
+
+```yaml
+pipeline_vetos:
+  - id: "VP1"
+    condition: "Workflow has sequence collisions"
+    check: "tier_3_result.sequence_collisions > 0"
+    result: "VETO"
+
+  - id: "VP2"
+    condition: "Phase outputs don't connect"
+    check: "tier_3_result.broken_output_chain == true"
+    result: "VETO"
+
+  - id: "VP3"
+    condition: "No quality gate before final"
+    check: "tier_4_result.has_quality_gate == false"
+    result: "VETO"
+```
+
+### Hybrid Squad Vetos
+
+```yaml
+hybrid_vetos:
+  - id: "VH1"
+    condition: "No heuristic validation defined"
+    check: "tier_4_result.heuristic_count == 0"
+    result: "VETO"
+
+  - id: "VH2"
+    condition: "Missing fallback behavior"
+    check: "tier_4_result.has_fallback == false"
+    result: "VETO"
+```
+
+**Veto Output:**
+```yaml
+veto_result:
+  status: "PROCEED"  # or "VETO"
+  triggered: null  # or veto ID
+  message: null  # or veto message
+```
+
+---
+
+## PHASE 6: SCORING & REPORT
+
+**Duration:** 1-2 minutes
+**Mode:** Autonomous
+
+### Final Score Calculation
+
+```yaml
+score_calculation:
+  # Only if Tier 1 and Tier 2 passed
+  precondition:
+    tier_1: "PASS"
+    tier_2: "PASS"
+    veto: "PROCEED"
+
+  formula: "(tier_3_score × 0.80) + (tier_4_score × 0.20)"
+
+  example:
+    tier_3_score: 7.5
+    tier_4_score: 7.5
+    final: (7.5 × 0.80) + (7.5 × 0.20) = 6.0 + 1.5 = 7.5
+
+  interpretation:
+    9.0-10.0: "EXCELLENT - Gold standard reference"
+    7.0-8.9: "PASS - Production ready"
+    5.0-6.9: "CONDITIONAL - Needs improvements"
+    0.0-4.9: "FAIL - Significant rework needed"
+```
+
+### Report Format
+
+```yaml
+report_structure:
+  header:
+    squad_name: "{name}"
+    squad_type: "{detected_type}"
+    version: "{version}"
+    validation_date: "{date}"
+    validator: "Squad Architect v3.0"
+
+  executive_summary:
+    final_score: "X.X/10"
+    result: "PASS | CONDITIONAL | FAIL"
+    type_detected: "Expert | Pipeline | Hybrid"
+    key_strengths:
+      - "..."
+    key_issues:
+      - "..."
+
+  tier_results:
+    tier_1_structure:
+      status: "PASS | ABORT"
+      checks: X/Y
+      blocking_issues: []
+
+    tier_2_coverage:
+      status: "PASS | ABORT"
+      metrics:
+        checklist_coverage: "X%"
+        orphan_tasks: N
+        data_usage: "X%"
+
+    tier_3_quality:
+      score: "X.X/10"
+      breakdown:
+        prompt_quality: "X.X (25%)"
+        pipeline_coherence: "X.X (25%)"
+        checklist_actionability: "X.X (25%)"
+        documentation: "X.X (25%)"
+
+    tier_4_contextual:
+      type: "Expert | Pipeline | Hybrid"
+      score: "X.X/10"
+      breakdown: {...}
+
+  veto_status:
+    triggered: "None | VXX"
+    message: "..."
+
+  issues_by_priority:
+    critical:
+      - issue: "..."
+        component: "..."
+        fix: "..."
+    high:
+      - issue: "..."
+        fix: "..."
+    medium:
+      - issue: "..."
+        fix: "..."
+
+  recommendations:
+    immediate: ["..."]
+    short_term: ["..."]
+
+  sign_off:
+    validator: "Squad Architect"
+    date: "{date}"
+    final_score: "X.X/10"
+    result: "PASS | CONDITIONAL | FAIL"
+```
+
+---
+
+## Outputs
+
+| Output | Location | Description |
+|--------|----------|-------------|
+| Validation Report | Console + `{squad_path}/docs/validation-report-{date}.md` | Full report |
+| Score Summary | Console | Quick pass/fail with score |
+
+---
+
+## Usage
+
+```bash
+# Validate entire squad
+@squad-chief
+*validate-squad books
+
+# With type override (skip detection)
+*validate-squad books --type=pipeline
+
+# Verbose mode
+*validate-squad copy --verbose
+```
+
+---
+
+## Quick Reference: What's Required by Type
+
+| Component | Expert | Pipeline | Hybrid |
+|-----------|--------|----------|--------|
+| voice_dna | REQUIRED | optional | optional |
+| objection_algorithms | REQUIRED | optional | optional |
+| output_examples | REQUIRED | optional | optional |
+| tier_organization | REQUIRED | optional | optional |
+| workflow_definition | optional | REQUIRED | optional |
+| phase_checkpoints | optional | REQUIRED | optional |
+| orchestrator | optional | REQUIRED | optional |
+| automation_script | optional | **IF 8+ phases** | optional |
+| persona_profile | optional | optional | REQUIRED |
+| behavioral_states | optional | optional | REQUIRED |
+| heuristic_validation | optional | optional | REQUIRED |
+| **executor_decision_tree** [v3.2] | optional | optional | **REQUIRED** |
+| **tool_registry** [v3.2] | optional | optional | optional |
+| **optimization_check** [v3.2] | informational | informational | informational |
+
+---
+
+## Related
+
+| Command | Purpose |
+|---------|---------|
+| `*validate-squad {name}` | Full squad validation |
+| `*validate-agent {file}` | Single agent validation |
+| `*validate-task {file}` | Single task validation |
+
+| Reference | File |
+|-----------|------|
+| Checklist | `checklists/squad-checklist.md` |
+| Type Definitions | `data/squad-type-definitions.yaml` |
+| Quality Framework | `data/quality-dimensions-framework.md` |
+| Executor Decision Tree | `data/executor-decision-tree.md` **[v3.2]** |
+| Tool Registry | `data/tool-registry.yaml` **[v3.2]** |
+| Optimize Task | `tasks/optimize.md` **[v3.2]** |
+
+---
+
+## Changelog
+
+Ver histórico completo em: [`CHANGELOG.md`](./CHANGELOG.md)
+
+---
+
+_Task Version: 3.3.0_
+_Philosophy: Context-aware validation - different squads need different things_
+_Reference: squad-checklist.md v3.0, squad-type-definitions.yaml v1.0, executor-decision-tree.md v1.0_