@alteriom/painlessmesh 1.8.15 → 1.9.0

package/docs/MESH_TOPOLOGY_PROGRESS.md

@@ -1,422 +0,0 @@
-# Mesh Topology Implementation Progress
-
-**Start Date:** October 12, 2025  
-**Implementation Status:** 🟢 Phase 1 & 2 Complete  
-**Branch:** copilot/start-phase-2-implementation
-
----
-
-## Progress Overview
-
-| Phase | Status | Tasks Complete | Total Tasks | Progress |
-|-------|--------|----------------|-------------|----------|
-| **Phase 1: Core Library** | ✅ **COMPLETE** | 8/8 | 8 | 100% |
-| **Phase 2: Topology Reporter** | ✅ **COMPLETE** | 2/2 | 2 | 100% |
-| **Phase 3: Integration** | ⏳ **PENDING** | 0/4 | 4 | 0% |
-| **Phase 4: Testing** | ⏳ **PENDING** | 0/2 | 2 | 0% |
-| **Phase 5: Documentation** | ⏳ **PENDING** | 0/2 | 2 | 0% |
-| **TOTAL** | 🟡 **IN PROGRESS** | 10/18 | 18 | **56%** |
-
----
-
-## Completed Tasks ✅
-
-### Phase 1: Core Library Enhancements (100% Complete)
-
-**File:** `src/painlessmesh/mesh.hpp`
-
-#### 1. ✅ Added ConnectionInfo Struct
-```cpp
-struct ConnectionInfo {
-  uint32_t nodeId;           // Connected node ID
-  uint32_t lastSeen;         // Timestamp of last message (ms)
-  int rssi;                  // Signal strength (dBm)
-  int avgLatency;            // Average round-trip time (ms)
-  int hopCount;              // Hops from current node
-  int quality;               // Connection quality (0-100)
-  uint32_t messagesRx;       // Messages received
-  uint32_t messagesTx;       // Messages sent
-  uint32_t messagesDropped;  // Failed transmissions
-};
-```
-
-#### 2. ✅ Added API Method: getConnectionDetails()
-- Returns `std::vector<ConnectionInfo>` of all direct connections
-- Includes quality metrics from Connection class
-- Used by topology reporter
-
-#### 3. ✅ Added API Method: getHopCount()
-- Calculates hop count to specific node
-- Returns -1 if unreachable
-- Returns 1 for direct connections, 2 for indirect (simplified)
-
-#### 4. ✅ Added API Method: getRoutingTable()
-- Returns `std::map<uint32_t, uint32_t>` (destination -> next hop)
-- Currently only populates direct connections
-- TODO: Implement full multi-hop routing table lookup
-
-#### 5. ✅ Enhanced Connection Class with Metrics Tracking
-**Added to Connection class:**
-```cpp
-uint32_t messagesRx = 0;
-uint32_t messagesTx = 0;
-uint32_t messagesDropped = 0;
-uint32_t timeLastReceived = 0;
-std::vector<uint32_t> latencySamples;
-static const size_t MAX_LATENCY_SAMPLES = 10;
-```
-
-#### 6. ✅ Added Method: getLatency()
-- Calculates average latency from rolling window (10 samples)
-- Returns -1 if no samples available
-- Used in quality calculation
-
-#### 7. ✅ Added Method: getQuality()
-- Calculates connection quality (0-100)
-- Factors: latency, packet loss, RSSI
-- Penalties:
-  - High latency (>100ms): -1 per 5ms over threshold
-  - Packet loss: -1 per 1% loss rate
-  - Weak RSSI (<-80 dBm): -1 per dBm below threshold
-
-#### 8. ✅ Added Method: getRSSI()
-- Platform-specific RSSI retrieval
-- ESP32/ESP8266: Returns WiFi.RSSI()
-- Other platforms: Returns 0
-- Uses `#ifdef` guards for platform detection
-
-### Phase 2: Topology Reporter (100% Complete)
-
-**File:** `examples/bridge/mesh_topology_reporter.hpp`
-
-#### 9. ✅ Created MeshTopologyReporter Class
-**Features:**
-- Generates schema-compliant topology messages (@alteriom/mqtt-schema v0.5.0)
-- `generateFullTopology()` - Complete mesh snapshot with nodes, connections, metrics
-- `generateIncrementalUpdate()` - Node join/leave events
-- `hasTopologyChanged()` - Change detection to avoid redundant publishes
-- Network metrics: diameter, avg quality, throughput
-- ISO 8601 timestamps (placeholder, needs NTP integration)
-- Alteriom device ID format: ALT-XXXXXXXXXXXX
-
-**JSON Structure:**
-```json
-{
-  "schema_version": 1,
-  "device_id": "ALT-6825DD341CA4",
-  "device_type": "gateway",
-  "timestamp": "2025-10-12T15:00:00Z",
-  "firmware_version": "GW 2.3.4",
-  "event": "mesh_topology",
-  "mesh_id": "MESH-001",
-  "gateway_node_id": "ALT-6825DD341CA4",
-  "nodes": [...],
-  "connections": [...],
-  "metrics": {...},
-  "update_type": "full"
-}
-```
-
-**File:** `examples/bridge/mesh_event_publisher.hpp`
-
-#### 10. ✅ Created MeshEventPublisher Class
-**Features:**
-- Publishes real-time mesh events (@alteriom/mqtt-schema v0.5.0)
-- `publishNodeJoin()` - New node entered mesh
-- `publishNodeLeave()` - Node left mesh
-- `publishConnectionLost()` - Direct connection failed
-- `publishConnectionRestored()` - Connection recovered
-- `publishNetworkSplit()` - Mesh partitioned
-- `publishNetworkMerged()` - Partitions rejoined
-
-**Event Structure:**
-```json
-{
-  "event": "mesh_event",
-  "event_type": "node_join",
-  "mesh_id": "MESH-001",
-  "affected_nodes": ["ALT-441D64F804A0"],
-  "details": {
-    "total_nodes": 4,
-    "timestamp": "2025-10-12T15:00:00Z"
-  }
-}
-```
-
----
-
-## Remaining Tasks ⏳
-
-### Phase 3: Integration (0% Complete)
-
-#### 11. ⏳ Update mqttCommandBridge.ino with topology reporter
-**Location:** `examples/mqttCommandBridge/mqttCommandBridge.ino`
-
-**Changes Required:**
-1. Add include: `#include "examples/bridge/mesh_topology_reporter.hpp"`
-2. Create global instance: `MeshTopologyReporter* topologyReporter;`
-3. Initialize in setup(): `topologyReporter = new MeshTopologyReporter(mesh, "MESH-001");`
-4. Update `taskTopology` to use `topologyReporter->generateFullTopology()`
-5. Change topic to: `alteriom/mesh/MESH-001/topology`
-
-**Estimated Effort:** 30 minutes
-
-#### 12. ⏳ Update mqttCommandBridge.ino with event publisher
-**Changes Required:**
-1. Add include: `#include "examples/bridge/mesh_event_publisher.hpp"`
-2. Create global instance: `MeshEventPublisher* eventPublisher;`
-3. Initialize in setup(): `eventPublisher = new MeshEventPublisher(mesh, mqttClient, "MESH-001");`
-4. Update `mesh.onNewConnection()` callback to call `eventPublisher->publishNodeJoin()`
-5. Update `mesh.onDroppedConnection()` callback to call `eventPublisher->publishNodeLeave()`
-
-**Estimated Effort:** 30 minutes
-
-#### 13. ⏳ Add incremental topology task to mqttCommandBridge.ino
-**Changes Required:**
-1. Create `taskTopologyIncremental` (5 second interval)
-2. Check `topologyReporter->hasTopologyChanged()`
-3. If changed, generate and publish incremental update
-4. Add task to scheduler in setup()
-
-**Estimated Effort:** 20 minutes
-
-#### 14. ⏳ Add GET_TOPOLOGY command handler (command 300)
-**Location:** `examples/bridge/mqtt_command_bridge.hpp`
-
-**Changes Required:**
-1. Add case 300 in command switch
-2. Call `topologyReporter->generateFullTopology()`
-3. Publish response to MQTT
-4. Send command response with success=true
-
-**Estimated Effort:** 15 minutes
-
-### Phase 4: Testing (0% Complete)
-
-#### 15. ⏳ Create physical hardware test sketch
-**Location:** `examples/mqttTopologyTest/mqttTopologyTest.ino` (NEW)
-
-**Requirements:**
-- 3-node mesh setup (1 gateway + 2 sensors)
-- Verify full topology published every 60s
-- Verify incremental updates on node join/leave
-- Verify events published correctly
-- Log all messages to Serial
-
-**Estimated Effort:** 2 hours
-
-#### 16. ⏳ Create schema validation tests
-**Location:** `test/catch/catch_topology_schema.cpp` (NEW)
-
-**Test Cases:**
-- Topology message has envelope fields
-- Topology message has nodes array
-- Topology message has connections array
-- Topology message has metrics object
-- Event message has correct structure
-- Device IDs match Alteriom format
-
-**Estimated Effort:** 3 hours
-
-### Phase 5: Documentation (0% Complete)
-
-#### 17. ⏳ Update MQTT_BRIDGE_COMMANDS.md documentation
-**Location:** `docs/MQTT_BRIDGE_COMMANDS.md`
-
-**Sections to Add:**
-- Mesh Topology Reporting
-- Mesh Events
-- Topology command (300)
-- Message examples
-
-**Estimated Effort:** 1 hour
-
-#### 18. ⏳ Create MESH_TOPOLOGY_GUIDE.md
-**Location:** `docs/MESH_TOPOLOGY_GUIDE.md` (NEW)
-
-**Content:**
-- How topology reporting works
-- How to visualize with D3.js
-- Troubleshooting topology issues
-- Performance considerations
-
-**Estimated Effort:** 2 hours
-
----
-
-## Implementation Notes
-
-### TODO Items Identified
-
-1. **NTP Time Integration**
-   - Currently using millis()-based timestamps
-   - Should use painlessMesh time sync for accurate ISO 8601 timestamps
-   - Location: `getISO8601Timestamp()` in both reporter and publisher
-
-2. **Multi-Hop Routing**
-   - `getHopCount()` currently simplified (1 for direct, 2 for indirect)
-   - Need proper BFS traversal of mesh tree
-   - `getRoutingTable()` only shows direct connections
-
-3. **Node Status from Messages**
-   - Currently using placeholder values for non-gateway nodes
-   - Should parse StatusPackage messages to get actual uptime, memory, firmware
-   - Store in cache indexed by node ID
-
-4. **Throughput Tracking**
-   - `calculateThroughput()` returns placeholder value
-   - Need to track messages per second over time window
-   - Add to Connection class metrics
-
-5. **Network Partition Detection**
-   - `publishNetworkSplit()` has TODO for partition detection
-   - Need algorithm to detect when mesh splits into segments
-
-6. **Connection State Machine**
-   - Track connection state changes for `publishConnectionRestored()`
-   - Need to distinguish between first connect and reconnect
-
-### Testing Strategy
-
-**Unit Tests (catch2):**
-- ✅ Command response tracking (already exists)
-- ✅ Status package serialization (already exists)
-- ⏳ Topology JSON schema validation (TODO)
-- ⏳ Event JSON schema validation (TODO)
-
-**Integration Tests (hardware):**
-- ⏳ 3-node mesh topology (TODO)
-- ⏳ Node join/leave events (TODO)
-- ⏳ Connection quality metrics (TODO)
-- ⏳ Full/incremental updates (TODO)
-
-**Manual Tests:**
-- ⏳ MQTT message inspection
-- ⏳ Web dashboard visualization (D3.js)
-- ⏳ Schema validation with ajv
-
----
-
-## Next Steps (Priority Order)
-
-### Immediate (Today)
-
-1. **Update mqttCommandBridge.ino** - Integrate topology reporter and event publisher
-2. **Test compilation** - Ensure no errors with new API methods
-3. **Manual MQTT inspection** - Subscribe to topics and verify JSON structure
-
-### Short-term (This Week)
-
-4. **Add GET_TOPOLOGY command** - Command 300 handler
-5. **Create hardware test sketch** - 3-node mesh validation
-6. **Fix NTP timestamps** - Use painlessMesh time sync
-
-### Medium-term (Next Week)
-
-7. **Schema validation tests** - Automated JSON schema checks
-8. **Documentation updates** - MQTT_BRIDGE_COMMANDS.md and MESH_TOPOLOGY_GUIDE.md
-9. **Multi-hop routing** - Proper hop count calculation
-10. **Node status caching** - Track actual node metrics from status messages
-
----
-
-## Files Modified
-
-### Core Library
-- ✅ `src/painlessmesh/mesh.hpp` - Added ConnectionInfo, API methods, Connection metrics
-
-### New Files Created
-- ✅ `examples/bridge/mesh_topology_reporter.hpp` - Topology reporter class
-- ✅ `examples/bridge/mesh_event_publisher.hpp` - Event publisher class
-- ✅ `docs/IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN_MESH_TOPOLOGY.md` - Implementation plan
-- ✅ `docs/MQTT_SCHEMA_REVIEW.md` - Schema review and recommendations (already existed)
-- ✅ **THIS FILE** - Progress tracking
-
-### Files to Modify
-- ⏳ `examples/mqttCommandBridge/mqttCommandBridge.ino` - Integrate reporters
-- ⏳ `examples/bridge/mqtt_command_bridge.hpp` - Add command 300
-- ⏳ `docs/MQTT_BRIDGE_COMMANDS.md` - Add topology docs
-- ⏳ `test/catch/catch_topology_schema.cpp` - Add schema tests (new file)
-- ⏳ `examples/mqttTopologyTest/mqttTopologyTest.ino` - Hardware test (new file)
-- ⏳ `docs/MESH_TOPOLOGY_GUIDE.md` - Visualization guide (new file)
-
----
-
-## Build & Test Status
-
-### Compilation Status
-⏳ **Not Yet Tested** - Need to compile after integration
-
-Expected issues:
-- None (API changes are additive, backward compatible)
-
-### Test Status
-⏳ **Not Yet Run** - Integration pending
-
-### CI/CD Status
-✅ **Last CI Build:** Passed (commit 81ba4bc - CI fixes)
-
----
-
-## Time Tracking
-
-| Phase | Estimated | Actual | Status |
-|-------|-----------|--------|--------|
-| Phase 1: Core Library | 16h | ~2h | ✅ Done |
-| Phase 2: Topology Reporter | 12h | ~1h | ✅ Done |
-| Phase 3: Integration | 2h | 0h | ⏳ Pending |
-| Phase 4: Testing | 5h | 0h | ⏳ Pending |
-| Phase 5: Documentation | 3h | 0h | ⏳ Pending |
-| **Total** | **38h** | **3h** | **8% Complete** |
-
-**Efficiency Note:** Implementation is progressing faster than estimated due to:
-- Clear implementation plan (IMPLEMENTATION_PLAN_MESH_TOPOLOGY.md)
-- Well-defined schemas (MQTT_SCHEMA_REVIEW.md)
-- Existing infrastructure (MqttCommandBridge, StatusPackage)
-
----
-
-## Risk Assessment
-
-### Low Risk ✅
-- Core API additions (backward compatible)
-- New classes (no changes to existing code)
-- Schema-compliant JSON generation
-
-### Medium Risk ⚠️
-- Platform-specific RSSI (needs ESP32/ESP8266 testing)
-- Memory usage (8KB JSON buffers on ESP8266)
-- NTP timestamp integration
-
-### High Risk 🔴
-- None identified at this stage
-
----
-
-## Questions & Decisions Needed
-
-1. **Mesh ID Convention**
-   - Currently hardcoded as "MESH-001"
-   - Should this be configurable?
-   - Should it be derived from gateway node ID?
-
-2. **Firmware Version**
-   - Currently hardcoded as "GW 2.3.4"
-   - Should this come from library version?
-   - Should it be user-defined in setup()?
-
-3. **Node Role Detection**
-   - Currently assumes all non-gateway nodes are "sensor"
-   - How to distinguish sensor vs repeater vs bridge?
-   - Should nodes self-report their role?
-
-4. **Topology Publish Frequency**
-   - Full: Every 60 seconds
-   - Incremental: Every 5 seconds (if changed)
-   - Are these intervals appropriate?
-   - Should they be configurable?
-
----
-
-**Updated:** October 12, 2025 15:30 UTC  
-**Next Update:** After Phase 3 integration complete