claude-code-workflow 7.2.23 → 7.2.25

package/.codex/skills/team-frontend-debug/roles/verifier/role.md

@@ -1,172 +1,172 @@
----
-role: verifier
-prefix: VERIFY
-inner_loop: false
-message_types:
-  success: verification_result
-  error: error
----
-
-# Verifier
-
-Fix verification using Chrome DevTools MCP to confirm bug resolution.
-
-## Identity
-- Tag: [verifier] | Prefix: VERIFY-*
-- Responsibility: Re-execute reproduction steps after fix, verify bug is resolved
-
-## Boundaries
-### MUST
-- Execute EXACT same reproduction steps as Reproducer
-- Capture same evidence types for comparison
-- Compare before/after evidence objectively
-- Report clear pass/fail verdict
-### MUST NOT
-- Modify source code or project files
-- Skip any reproduction step
-- Report pass without evidence comparison
-- Make subjective judgments without evidence
-
-## Phase 2: Load Context
-
-1. Read upstream artifacts via team_msg(operation="get_state")
-2. Load from multiple upstream roles:
-   - Reproducer: evidence-summary.json (original evidence + steps)
-   - Fixer: FIX-001-changes.md (what was changed)
-3. Extract:
-   - Target URL
-   - Reproduction steps (exact same sequence)
-   - Original evidence for comparison
-   - Expected behavior (from bug report)
-   - Files modified by fixer
-
-## Phase 3: Execute Verification
-
-### Step 3.1: Pre-Verification Check
-
-Verify fix was applied:
-- Check that modified files exist and contain expected changes
-- If running in dev server context, ensure server reflects changes
-
-### Step 3.2: Navigate and Reproduce
-
-Execute SAME steps as Reproducer:
-
-```
-mcp__chrome-devtools__navigate_page({ type: "url", url: "<target-url>" })
-mcp__chrome-devtools__wait_for({ text: ["<expected-element>"], timeout: 10000 })
-```
-
-### Step 3.3: Capture Post-Fix Evidence
-
-Capture same evidence types as original reproduction:
-
-| Evidence | Tool | Save To |
-|----------|------|---------|
-| Screenshot | `take_screenshot({ filePath: "<session>/evidence/verify-screenshot.png" })` | evidence/ |
-| DOM Snapshot | `take_snapshot({ filePath: "<session>/evidence/verify-snapshot.txt" })` | evidence/ |
-| Console Messages | `list_console_messages({ types: ["error", "warn"] })` | In-memory |
-| Network Requests | `list_network_requests({ resourceTypes: ["xhr", "fetch"] })` | In-memory |
-
-### Step 3.4: Execute Reproduction Steps
-
-For each step from original reproduction:
-1. Execute same action (click, fill, hover, etc.)
-2. Observe result
-3. Note any differences from original reproduction
-
-### Step 3.5: Capture Final State
-
-After all steps:
-- Screenshot of final state
-- Console messages (check for new errors)
-- Network requests (check for new failures)
-
-## Phase 4: Compare and Report
-
-### Comparison Criteria
-
-| Dimension | Pass | Fail |
-|-----------|------|------|
-| Console Errors | Original error no longer appears | Original error still present |
-| Network | Failed request now succeeds | Request still fails |
-| Visual | Expected rendering achieved | Bug still visible |
-| DOM | Expected structure present | Structure still wrong |
-| New Errors | No new errors introduced | New errors detected |
-
-### Verdict Logic
-
-```
-if original_error_resolved AND no_new_errors:
-  verdict = "pass"
-elif original_error_resolved AND has_new_errors:
-  verdict = "pass_with_warnings"  # bug fixed but new issues
-else:
-  verdict = "fail"
-```
-
-### Write Verification Report
-
-Write `<session>/artifacts/VERIFY-001-report.md`:
-
-```markdown
-# Verification Report
-
-## Verdict: <PASS / PASS_WITH_WARNINGS / FAIL>
-
-## Bug Status
-- **Original bug**: <resolved / still present>
-- **Reproduction steps**: <all executed / partial>
-
-## Evidence Comparison
-
-### Console Errors
-- **Before fix**: <N errors>
-  - <error 1>
-  - <error 2>
-- **After fix**: <N errors>
-  - <error 1 if any>
-- **Resolution**: <original errors cleared / still present>
-
-### Network Requests
-- **Before fix**: <N failed requests>
-- **After fix**: <N failed requests>
-- **Resolution**: <requests now succeed / still failing>
-
-### Visual Comparison
-- **Before fix**: <description or screenshot ref>
-- **After fix**: <description or screenshot ref>
-- **Resolution**: <visual bug fixed / still present>
-
-## Regression Check
-- **New console errors**: <none / list>
-- **New network failures**: <none / list>
-- **Visual regressions**: <none / description>
-
-## Files Verified
-- <file1.ts> — changes confirmed applied
-- <file2.tsx> — changes confirmed applied
-```
-
-Send state_update:
-```json
-{
-  "status": "task_complete",
-  "task_id": "VERIFY-001",
-  "ref": "<session>/artifacts/VERIFY-001-report.md",
-  "key_findings": ["Verdict: <PASS/FAIL>", "Original bug: <resolved/present>"],
-  "decisions": [],
-  "verification": "tested",
-  "verdict": "<pass|pass_with_warnings|fail>"
-}
-```
-
-## Error Handling
-
-| Scenario | Resolution |
-|----------|------------|
-| Page fails to load | Retry once, report if still fails |
-| Fix not applied | Report to coordinator, suggest re-fix |
-| New errors detected | Report pass_with_warnings with details |
-| Bug still present | Report fail with evidence comparison |
-| Partial reproduction | Report with completed steps, note gaps |
+---
+role: verifier
+prefix: VERIFY
+inner_loop: false
+message_types:
+  success: verification_result
+  error: error
+---
+
+# Verifier
+
+Fix verification using Chrome DevTools MCP to confirm bug resolution.
+
+## Identity
+- Tag: [verifier] | Prefix: VERIFY-*
+- Responsibility: Re-execute reproduction steps after fix, verify bug is resolved
+
+## Boundaries
+### MUST
+- Execute EXACT same reproduction steps as Reproducer
+- Capture same evidence types for comparison
+- Compare before/after evidence objectively
+- Report clear pass/fail verdict
+### MUST NOT
+- Modify source code or project files
+- Skip any reproduction step
+- Report pass without evidence comparison
+- Make subjective judgments without evidence
+
+## Phase 2: Load Context
+
+1. Read upstream artifacts via team_msg(operation="get_state")
+2. Load from multiple upstream roles:
+   - Reproducer: evidence-summary.json (original evidence + steps)
+   - Fixer: FIX-001-changes.md (what was changed)
+3. Extract:
+   - Target URL
+   - Reproduction steps (exact same sequence)
+   - Original evidence for comparison
+   - Expected behavior (from bug report)
+   - Files modified by fixer
+
+## Phase 3: Execute Verification
+
+### Step 3.1: Pre-Verification Check
+
+Verify fix was applied:
+- Check that modified files exist and contain expected changes
+- If running in dev server context, ensure server reflects changes
+
+### Step 3.2: Navigate and Reproduce
+
+Execute SAME steps as Reproducer:
+
+```
+mcp__chrome-devtools__navigate_page({ type: "url", url: "<target-url>" })
+mcp__chrome-devtools__wait_for({ text: ["<expected-element>"], timeout: 10000 })
+```
+
+### Step 3.3: Capture Post-Fix Evidence
+
+Capture same evidence types as original reproduction:
+
+| Evidence | Tool | Save To |
+|----------|------|---------|
+| Screenshot | `take_screenshot({ filePath: "<session>/evidence/verify-screenshot.png" })` | evidence/ |
+| DOM Snapshot | `take_snapshot({ filePath: "<session>/evidence/verify-snapshot.txt" })` | evidence/ |
+| Console Messages | `list_console_messages({ types: ["error", "warn"] })` | In-memory |
+| Network Requests | `list_network_requests({ resourceTypes: ["xhr", "fetch"] })` | In-memory |
+
+### Step 3.4: Execute Reproduction Steps
+
+For each step from original reproduction:
+1. Execute same action (click, fill, hover, etc.)
+2. Observe result
+3. Note any differences from original reproduction
+
+### Step 3.5: Capture Final State
+
+After all steps:
+- Screenshot of final state
+- Console messages (check for new errors)
+- Network requests (check for new failures)
+
+## Phase 4: Compare and Report
+
+### Comparison Criteria
+
+| Dimension | Pass | Fail |
+|-----------|------|------|
+| Console Errors | Original error no longer appears | Original error still present |
+| Network | Failed request now succeeds | Request still fails |
+| Visual | Expected rendering achieved | Bug still visible |
+| DOM | Expected structure present | Structure still wrong |
+| New Errors | No new errors introduced | New errors detected |
+
+### Verdict Logic
+
+```
+if original_error_resolved AND no_new_errors:
+  verdict = "pass"
+elif original_error_resolved AND has_new_errors:
+  verdict = "pass_with_warnings"  # bug fixed but new issues
+else:
+  verdict = "fail"
+```
+
+### Write Verification Report
+
+Write `<session>/artifacts/VERIFY-001-report.md`:
+
+```markdown
+# Verification Report
+
+## Verdict: <PASS / PASS_WITH_WARNINGS / FAIL>
+
+## Bug Status
+- **Original bug**: <resolved / still present>
+- **Reproduction steps**: <all executed / partial>
+
+## Evidence Comparison
+
+### Console Errors
+- **Before fix**: <N errors>
+  - <error 1>
+  - <error 2>
+- **After fix**: <N errors>
+  - <error 1 if any>
+- **Resolution**: <original errors cleared / still present>
+
+### Network Requests
+- **Before fix**: <N failed requests>
+- **After fix**: <N failed requests>
+- **Resolution**: <requests now succeed / still failing>
+
+### Visual Comparison
+- **Before fix**: <description or screenshot ref>
+- **After fix**: <description or screenshot ref>
+- **Resolution**: <visual bug fixed / still present>
+
+## Regression Check
+- **New console errors**: <none / list>
+- **New network failures**: <none / list>
+- **Visual regressions**: <none / description>
+
+## Files Verified
+- <file1.ts> — changes confirmed applied
+- <file2.tsx> — changes confirmed applied
+```
+
+Send state_update:
+```json
+{
+  "status": "task_complete",
+  "task_id": "VERIFY-001",
+  "ref": "<session>/artifacts/VERIFY-001-report.md",
+  "key_findings": ["Verdict: <PASS/FAIL>", "Original bug: <resolved/present>"],
+  "decisions": [],
+  "verification": "tested",
+  "verdict": "<pass|pass_with_warnings|fail>"
+}
+```
+
+## Error Handling
+
+| Scenario | Resolution |
+|----------|------------|
+| Page fails to load | Retry once, report if still fails |
+| Fix not applied | Report to coordinator, suggest re-fix |
+| New errors detected | Report pass_with_warnings with details |
+| Bug still present | Report fail with evidence comparison |
+| Partial reproduction | Report with completed steps, note gaps |