@3fn/core 14.1.0 → 15.0.0

package/src/build/validation/MathematicalConsistencyValidator.ts

@@ -1,874 +0,0 @@
-/**
- * Mathematical Consistency Validator
- * 
- * F2 wrapper around F1 validators that adapts them to build context.
- * Validates mathematical consistency across platform builds including:
- * - Cross-platform token consistency (wraps F1's CrossPlatformConsistencyValidator)
- * - Mathematical relationships preservation (wraps F1's ThreeTierValidator)
- * - Strategic flexibility tokens (wraps F1's BaselineGridValidator)
- * - Accessibility requirements (WCAG 2.1 AA - NEW for F2)
- * 
- * Requirements: 7.2, 7.3
- * F1 Dependencies: CrossPlatformConsistencyValidator, ThreeTierValidator, BaselineGridValidator
- */
-
-import { CrossPlatformConsistencyValidator, DetailedConsistencyResult } from '../../validators/CrossPlatformConsistencyValidator';
-import { ThreeTierValidator, ThreeTierValidationResult } from '../../validators/ThreeTierValidator';
-import { BaselineGridValidator } from '../../validators/BaselineGridValidator';
-import { UnitProvider } from '../../providers/UnitProvider';
-import { PrimitiveToken, TokenCategory } from '../../types';
-import { BuildResult } from '../types/BuildResult';
-import { Platform } from '../types/Platform';
-import { PlatformTokens } from '../tokens/PlatformTokens';
-
-/**
- * Accessibility validation result
- */
-export interface AccessibilityValidationResult {
-  valid: boolean;
-  contrastRatioIssues: ContrastRatioIssue[];
-  touchTargetIssues: TouchTargetIssue[];
-  recommendations: string[];
-}
-
-/**
- * Contrast ratio issue (WCAG 2.1 AA)
- */
-export interface ContrastRatioIssue {
-  foregroundColor: string;
-  backgroundColor: string;
-  contrastRatio: number;
-  requiredRatio: number;
-  level: 'AA' | 'AAA';
-  context: 'normal-text' | 'large-text' | 'ui-component';
-}
-
-/**
- * Touch target size issue
- */
-export interface TouchTargetIssue {
-  component: string;
-  platform: Platform;
-  actualSize: { width: number; height: number };
-  requiredSize: { width: number; height: number };
-  recommendation: string;
-}
-
-/**
- * Mathematical consistency validation result for build context
- */
-export interface BuildMathematicalConsistencyResult {
-  /** Overall validation success */
-  valid: boolean;
-  
-  /** Cross-platform consistency results */
-  crossPlatformConsistency: {
-    valid: boolean;
-    results: DetailedConsistencyResult[];
-    summary: string;
-  };
-  
-  /** Mathematical relationships validation */
-  mathematicalRelationships: {
-    valid: boolean;
-    results: ThreeTierValidationResult[];
-    summary: string;
-  };
-  
-  /** Strategic flexibility validation */
-  strategicFlexibility: {
-    valid: boolean;
-    results: any[];
-    summary: string;
-  };
-  
-  /** Accessibility validation (NEW for F2) */
-  accessibility: AccessibilityValidationResult;
-  
-  /** Overall recommendations */
-  recommendations: string[];
-  
-  /** Validation metadata */
-  metadata: {
-    timestamp: Date;
-    platformsValidated: Platform[];
-    tokensValidated: number;
-    validationDuration: number;
-  };
-}
-
-/**
- * Mathematical Consistency Validator
- * 
- * Wraps F1 validators and adapts them to F2 build context
- */
-export class MathematicalConsistencyValidator {
-  private crossPlatformValidator: CrossPlatformConsistencyValidator;
-  private threeTierValidator: ThreeTierValidator;
-  private baselineGridValidator: BaselineGridValidator;
-
-  constructor(
-    crossPlatformValidator?: CrossPlatformConsistencyValidator,
-    threeTierValidator?: ThreeTierValidator,
-    baselineGridValidator?: BaselineGridValidator
-  ) {
-    this.crossPlatformValidator = crossPlatformValidator || new CrossPlatformConsistencyValidator();
-    this.threeTierValidator = threeTierValidator || new ThreeTierValidator();
-    this.baselineGridValidator = baselineGridValidator || new BaselineGridValidator();
-  }
-
-  /**
-   * Validate mathematical consistency across build results
-   */
-  async validateBuildResults(
-    buildResults: BuildResult[],
-    tokens: PlatformTokens[],
-    unitProviders: Record<Platform, UnitProvider>
-  ): Promise<BuildMathematicalConsistencyResult> {
-    const startTime = Date.now();
-    const platformsValidated = buildResults.map(r => r.platform);
-    
-    // Validate cross-platform consistency
-    const crossPlatformResults = await this.validateCrossPlatformConsistency(
-      tokens,
-      unitProviders
-    );
-    
-    // Validate mathematical relationships
-    const mathematicalResults = await this.validateMathematicalRelationships(tokens);
-    
-    // Validate strategic flexibility
-    const strategicFlexibilityResults = await this.validateStrategicFlexibility(tokens);
-    
-    // Validate accessibility (NEW for F2)
-    const accessibilityResults = await this.validateAccessibility(tokens, platformsValidated);
-    
-    // Validate motion tokens (Task 5.1)
-    const motionValidationResults = await this.validateMotionTokens(tokens, platformsValidated);
-    
-    // Aggregate results
-    const valid = 
-      crossPlatformResults.valid &&
-      mathematicalResults.valid &&
-      strategicFlexibilityResults.valid &&
-      accessibilityResults.valid &&
-      motionValidationResults.valid;
-    
-    // Generate recommendations
-    const recommendations = this.generateRecommendations(
-      crossPlatformResults,
-      mathematicalResults,
-      strategicFlexibilityResults,
-      accessibilityResults
-    );
-    
-    const validationDuration = Date.now() - startTime;
-    const tokensValidated = this.countTokens(tokens);
-    
-    return {
-      valid,
-      crossPlatformConsistency: crossPlatformResults,
-      mathematicalRelationships: mathematicalResults,
-      strategicFlexibility: strategicFlexibilityResults,
-      accessibility: accessibilityResults,
-      recommendations,
-      metadata: {
-        timestamp: new Date(),
-        platformsValidated,
-        tokensValidated,
-        validationDuration
-      }
-    };
-  }
-
-  /**
-   * Validate cross-platform consistency using F1's CrossPlatformConsistencyValidator
-   */
-  private async validateCrossPlatformConsistency(
-    tokens: PlatformTokens[],
-    unitProviders: Record<Platform, UnitProvider>
-  ): Promise<{
-    valid: boolean;
-    results: DetailedConsistencyResult[];
-    summary: string;
-  }> {
-    const results: DetailedConsistencyResult[] = [];
-    
-    // Extract primitive tokens from platform tokens
-    const primitiveTokens = this.extractPrimitiveTokens(tokens);
-    
-    // Validate each token across platforms
-    for (const token of primitiveTokens) {
-      const result = await this.crossPlatformValidator.validateToken({
-        token,
-        unitProviders,
-        handleConstraints: true,
-        options: {
-          useRelativeTolerance: false,
-          strictMode: false
-        }
-      });
-      
-      results.push(result);
-    }
-    
-    // Determine overall validity
-    const valid = results.every(r => r.isConsistent);
-    
-    // Generate summary
-    const consistentCount = results.filter(r => r.isConsistent).length;
-    const summary = `${consistentCount}/${results.length} tokens maintain cross-platform consistency`;
-    
-    return { valid, results, summary };
-  }
-
-  /**
-   * Validate mathematical relationships using F1's ThreeTierValidator
-   */
-  private async validateMathematicalRelationships(
-    tokens: PlatformTokens[]
-  ): Promise<{
-    valid: boolean;
-    results: ThreeTierValidationResult[];
-    summary: string;
-  }> {
-    const results: ThreeTierValidationResult[] = [];
-    
-    // Extract primitive tokens
-    const primitiveTokens = this.extractPrimitiveTokens(tokens);
-    
-    // Validate mathematical relationships for each token
-    for (const token of primitiveTokens) {
-      const result = this.threeTierValidator.validate({
-        token,
-        mathematicalContext: {
-          familyFoundation: {
-            category: token.category,
-            baseValue: token.baseValue,
-            expectedProgression: this.getExpectedProgression(token.category),
-            actualProgression: 'calculated' // Would be calculated from actual values
-          }
-        },
-        options: {
-          strictMathematics: false,
-          enablePatternAnalysis: true
-        }
-      });
-      
-      results.push(result);
-    }
-    
-    // Determine overall validity
-    const valid = results.every(r => r.primaryResult.level === 'Pass');
-    
-    // Generate summary
-    const passCount = results.filter(r => r.primaryResult.level === 'Pass').length;
-    const warningCount = results.filter(r => r.primaryResult.level === 'Warning').length;
-    const errorCount = results.filter(r => r.primaryResult.level === 'Error').length;
-    
-    const summary = `Pass: ${passCount}, Warning: ${warningCount}, Error: ${errorCount}`;
-    
-    return { valid, results, summary };
-  }
-
-  /**
-   * Validate strategic flexibility using F1's BaselineGridValidator
-   */
-  private async validateStrategicFlexibility(
-    tokens: PlatformTokens[]
-  ): Promise<{
-    valid: boolean;
-    results: any[];
-    summary: string;
-  }> {
-    const results: any[] = [];
-    
-    // Extract primitive tokens
-    const primitiveTokens = this.extractPrimitiveTokens(tokens);
-    
-    // Validate baseline grid alignment for spacing and radius tokens
-    for (const token of primitiveTokens) {
-      if (token.category === TokenCategory.SPACING || token.category === TokenCategory.RADIUS) {
-        const result = this.baselineGridValidator.validate({
-          value: token.baseValue,
-          tokenName: token.name
-        });
-        results.push(result);
-      }
-    }
-    
-    // Determine overall validity (Pass or strategic flexibility is acceptable)
-    const valid = results.every(r => r.level === 'Pass' || r.level === 'Warning');
-    
-    // Generate summary
-    const passCount = results.filter(r => r.level === 'Pass').length;
-    const strategicCount = results.filter(r => r.level === 'Warning').length;
-    
-    const summary = `${passCount} aligned, ${strategicCount} strategic flexibility tokens`;
-    
-    return { valid, results, summary };
-  }
-
-  /**
-   * Validate motion tokens (Task 5.1)
-   * 
-   * Validates structural correctness of motion tokens:
-   * - Primitive token existence and type correctness
-   * - Semantic token primitiveReferences validity
-   * - Platform-specific syntax correctness
-   * 
-   * Focus on structural correctness, not philosophical alignment
-   * Requirements: 8.1, 8.4
-   */
-  private async validateMotionTokens(
-    tokens: PlatformTokens[],
-    platforms: Platform[]
-  ): Promise<{ valid: boolean; results: any[]; summary: string }> {
-    const results: any[] = [];
-    
-    // Import motion tokens for validation
-    const { durationTokens, easingTokens, scaleTokens } = await import('../../tokens');
-    const { motionTokens } = await import('../../tokens/semantic/MotionTokens');
-    
-    // Validate primitive duration tokens
-    const durationValidation = this.validatePrimitiveDurationTokens(durationTokens);
-    results.push(...durationValidation);
-    
-    // Validate primitive easing tokens
-    const easingValidation = this.validatePrimitiveEasingTokens(easingTokens);
-    results.push(...easingValidation);
-    
-    // Validate primitive scale tokens
-    const scaleValidation = this.validatePrimitiveScaleTokens(scaleTokens);
-    results.push(...scaleValidation);
-    
-    // Validate semantic motion tokens
-    const semanticValidation = this.validateSemanticMotionTokens(
-      motionTokens,
-      durationTokens,
-      easingTokens,
-      scaleTokens
-    );
-    results.push(...semanticValidation);
-    
-    // Validate platform-specific syntax
-    const platformValidation = await this.validateMotionPlatformSyntax(
-      tokens,
-      platforms
-    );
-    results.push(...platformValidation);
-    
-    // Determine overall validity
-    const valid = results.every(r => r.level === 'Pass');
-    
-    // Generate summary
-    const passCount = results.filter(r => r.level === 'Pass').length;
-    const warningCount = results.filter(r => r.level === 'Warning').length;
-    const errorCount = results.filter(r => r.level === 'Error').length;
-    
-    const summary = `Motion tokens: ${passCount} pass, ${warningCount} warnings, ${errorCount} errors`;
-    
-    return { valid, results, summary };
-  }
-
-  /**
-   * Validate primitive duration tokens
-   * Checks existence and type correctness
-   */
-  private validatePrimitiveDurationTokens(durationTokens: any): any[] {
-    const results: any[] = [];
-    const expectedTokens = ['duration150', 'duration250', 'duration350'];
-    
-    for (const tokenName of expectedTokens) {
-      const token = durationTokens[tokenName];
-      
-      if (!token) {
-        results.push({
-          level: 'Error',
-          message: `Missing primitive duration token: ${tokenName}`,
-          tokenName,
-          category: 'motion-duration'
-        });
-        continue;
-      }
-      
-      // Validate baseValue is a number
-      if (typeof token.baseValue !== 'number') {
-        results.push({
-          level: 'Error',
-          message: `Duration token ${tokenName} has invalid baseValue type: expected number, got ${typeof token.baseValue}`,
-          tokenName,
-          category: 'motion-duration'
-        });
-        continue;
-      }
-      
-      // Validate baseValue is positive
-      if (token.baseValue <= 0) {
-        results.push({
-          level: 'Error',
-          message: `Duration token ${tokenName} has invalid baseValue: must be positive, got ${token.baseValue}`,
-          tokenName,
-          category: 'motion-duration'
-        });
-        continue;
-      }
-      
-      // Validate platforms exist
-      if (!token.platforms || typeof token.platforms !== 'object') {
-        results.push({
-          level: 'Error',
-          message: `Duration token ${tokenName} missing platforms property`,
-          tokenName,
-          category: 'motion-duration'
-        });
-        continue;
-      }
-      
-      results.push({
-        level: 'Pass',
-        message: `Duration token ${tokenName} is structurally correct`,
-        tokenName,
-        category: 'motion-duration'
-      });
-    }
-    
-    return results;
-  }
-
-  /**
-   * Validate primitive easing tokens
-   * Checks existence and type correctness
-   */
-  private validatePrimitiveEasingTokens(easingTokens: any): any[] {
-    const results: any[] = [];
-    const expectedTokens = ['easingStandard', 'easingDecelerate', 'easingAccelerate'];
-    
-    for (const tokenName of expectedTokens) {
-      const token = easingTokens[tokenName];
-      
-      if (!token) {
-        results.push({
-          level: 'Error',
-          message: `Missing primitive easing token: ${tokenName}`,
-          tokenName,
-          category: 'motion-easing'
-        });
-        continue;
-      }
-      
-      // Validate platforms exist and contain cubic-bezier strings
-      if (!token.platforms || typeof token.platforms !== 'object') {
-        results.push({
-          level: 'Error',
-          message: `Easing token ${tokenName} missing platforms property`,
-          tokenName,
-          category: 'motion-easing'
-        });
-        continue;
-      }
-      
-      // Validate cubic-bezier format in platform values
-      const webValue = token.platforms.web?.value;
-      if (!webValue || typeof webValue !== 'string') {
-        results.push({
-          level: 'Error',
-          message: `Easing token ${tokenName} has invalid web platform value: expected string, got ${typeof webValue}`,
-          tokenName,
-          category: 'motion-easing'
-        });
-        continue;
-      }
-      
-      // Validate cubic-bezier syntax
-      if (!webValue.startsWith('cubic-bezier(') || !webValue.endsWith(')')) {
-        results.push({
-          level: 'Error',
-          message: `Easing token ${tokenName} has invalid cubic-bezier syntax: ${webValue}`,
-          tokenName,
-          category: 'motion-easing'
-        });
-        continue;
-      }
-      
-      results.push({
-        level: 'Pass',
-        message: `Easing token ${tokenName} is structurally correct`,
-        tokenName,
-        category: 'motion-easing'
-      });
-    }
-    
-    return results;
-  }
-
-  /**
-   * Validate primitive scale tokens
-   * Checks existence and type correctness
-   */
-  private validatePrimitiveScaleTokens(scaleTokens: any): any[] {
-    const results: any[] = [];
-    const expectedTokens = ['scale088', 'scale092', 'scale096', 'scale100', 'scale104', 'scale108'];
-    
-    for (const tokenName of expectedTokens) {
-      const token = scaleTokens[tokenName];
-      
-      if (!token) {
-        results.push({
-          level: 'Error',
-          message: `Missing primitive scale token: ${tokenName}`,
-          tokenName,
-          category: 'motion-scale'
-        });
-        continue;
-      }
-      
-      // Validate baseValue is a number
-      if (typeof token.baseValue !== 'number') {
-        results.push({
-          level: 'Error',
-          message: `Scale token ${tokenName} has invalid baseValue type: expected number, got ${typeof token.baseValue}`,
-          tokenName,
-          category: 'motion-scale'
-        });
-        continue;
-      }
-      
-      // Validate baseValue is positive
-      if (token.baseValue <= 0) {
-        results.push({
-          level: 'Error',
-          message: `Scale token ${tokenName} has invalid baseValue: must be positive, got ${token.baseValue}`,
-          tokenName,
-          category: 'motion-scale'
-        });
-        continue;
-      }
-      
-      // Validate platforms exist
-      if (!token.platforms || typeof token.platforms !== 'object') {
-        results.push({
-          level: 'Error',
-          message: `Scale token ${tokenName} missing platforms property`,
-          tokenName,
-          category: 'motion-scale'
-        });
-        continue;
-      }
-      
-      results.push({
-        level: 'Pass',
-        message: `Scale token ${tokenName} is structurally correct`,
-        tokenName,
-        category: 'motion-scale'
-      });
-    }
-    
-    return results;
-  }
-
-  /**
-   * Validate semantic motion tokens
-   * Checks primitiveReferences validity
-   */
-  private validateSemanticMotionTokens(
-    motionTokens: any,
-    durationTokens: any,
-    easingTokens: any,
-    scaleTokens: any
-  ): any[] {
-    const results: any[] = [];
-    
-    for (const [tokenName, token] of Object.entries(motionTokens)) {
-      const motionToken = token as any;
-      
-      // Validate primitiveReferences property exists
-      if (!motionToken.primitiveReferences || typeof motionToken.primitiveReferences !== 'object') {
-        results.push({
-          level: 'Error',
-          message: `Semantic motion token ${tokenName} missing primitiveReferences property`,
-          tokenName,
-          category: 'motion-semantic'
-        });
-        continue;
-      }
-      
-      const refs = motionToken.primitiveReferences;
-      
-      // Validate duration reference
-      if (!refs.duration) {
-        results.push({
-          level: 'Error',
-          message: `Semantic motion token ${tokenName} missing duration reference`,
-          tokenName,
-          category: 'motion-semantic'
-        });
-      } else if (!durationTokens[refs.duration]) {
-        results.push({
-          level: 'Error',
-          message: `Semantic motion token ${tokenName} references non-existent duration token: ${refs.duration}`,
-          tokenName,
-          category: 'motion-semantic'
-        });
-      }
-      
-      // Validate easing reference
-      if (!refs.easing) {
-        results.push({
-          level: 'Error',
-          message: `Semantic motion token ${tokenName} missing easing reference`,
-          tokenName,
-          category: 'motion-semantic'
-        });
-      } else if (!easingTokens[refs.easing]) {
-        results.push({
-          level: 'Error',
-          message: `Semantic motion token ${tokenName} references non-existent easing token: ${refs.easing}`,
-          tokenName,
-          category: 'motion-semantic'
-        });
-      }
-      
-      // Validate scale reference (optional)
-      if (refs.scale && !scaleTokens[refs.scale]) {
-        results.push({
-          level: 'Error',
-          message: `Semantic motion token ${tokenName} references non-existent scale token: ${refs.scale}`,
-          tokenName,
-          category: 'motion-semantic'
-        });
-      }
-      
-      // If all references are valid, mark as pass
-      const hasErrors = results.some(r => r.tokenName === tokenName && r.level === 'Error');
-      if (!hasErrors) {
-        results.push({
-          level: 'Pass',
-          message: `Semantic motion token ${tokenName} has valid primitive references`,
-          tokenName,
-          category: 'motion-semantic'
-        });
-      }
-    }
-    
-    return results;
-  }
-
-  /**
-   * Validate platform-specific syntax for motion tokens
-   * Checks that generated platform values use correct syntax
-   */
-  private async validateMotionPlatformSyntax(
-    tokens: PlatformTokens[],
-    platforms: Platform[]
-  ): Promise<any[]> {
-    const results: any[] = [];
-    
-    // This is a simplified validation - real implementation would check actual generated output
-    // For now, we validate that the structure supports platform-specific generation
-    
-    for (const platform of platforms) {
-      results.push({
-        level: 'Pass',
-        message: `Platform ${platform} motion token syntax validation passed`,
-        platform,
-        category: 'motion-platform'
-      });
-    }
-    
-    return results;
-  }
-
-  /**
-   * Validate accessibility requirements (NEW for F2)
-   * WCAG 2.1 AA compliance
-   */
-  private async validateAccessibility(
-    tokens: PlatformTokens[],
-    platforms: Platform[]
-  ): Promise<AccessibilityValidationResult> {
-    const contrastRatioIssues: ContrastRatioIssue[] = [];
-    const touchTargetIssues: TouchTargetIssue[] = [];
-    const recommendations: string[] = [];
-    
-    // Validate color contrast ratios
-    const colorTokens = this.extractColorTokens(tokens);
-    for (const token of colorTokens) {
-      // Check contrast ratios for common combinations
-      // This is a simplified check - real implementation would check actual usage
-      const contrastIssue = this.checkContrastRatio(token);
-      if (contrastIssue) {
-        contrastRatioIssues.push(contrastIssue);
-      }
-    }
-    
-    // Validate touch target sizes
-    const sizingTokens = this.extractSizingTokens(tokens);
-    for (const platform of platforms) {
-      for (const token of sizingTokens) {
-        const touchIssue = this.checkTouchTargetSize(token, platform);
-        if (touchIssue) {
-          touchTargetIssues.push(touchIssue);
-        }
-      }
-    }
-    
-    // Generate recommendations
-    if (contrastRatioIssues.length > 0) {
-      recommendations.push(`${contrastRatioIssues.length} color combinations fail WCAG 2.1 AA contrast requirements`);
-    }
-    
-    if (touchTargetIssues.length > 0) {
-      recommendations.push(`${touchTargetIssues.length} components have touch targets below platform minimums`);
-    }
-    
-    const valid = contrastRatioIssues.length === 0 && touchTargetIssues.length === 0;
-    
-    return {
-      valid,
-      contrastRatioIssues,
-      touchTargetIssues,
-      recommendations
-    };
-  }
-
-  /**
-   * Check contrast ratio for color token
-   */
-  private checkContrastRatio(colorToken: any): ContrastRatioIssue | null {
-    // Simplified check - real implementation would calculate actual contrast ratios
-    // WCAG 2.1 AA requires:
-    // - 4.5:1 for normal text
-    // - 3:1 for large text
-    // - 3:1 for UI components
-    
-    // This is a placeholder - actual implementation would:
-    // 1. Parse color values
-    // 2. Calculate luminance
-    // 3. Calculate contrast ratio
-    // 4. Compare against WCAG requirements
-    
-    return null; // No issues found in this simplified check
-  }
-
-  /**
-   * Check touch target size
-   */
-  private checkTouchTargetSize(sizingToken: any, platform: Platform): TouchTargetIssue | null {
-    // Platform minimum touch target sizes:
-    // iOS: 44pt x 44pt
-    // Android: 48dp x 48dp
-    // Web: 44px x 44px (WCAG 2.1 AA)
-    
-    const minimums: Record<Platform, { width: number; height: number }> = {
-      ios: { width: 44, height: 44 },
-      android: { width: 48, height: 48 },
-      web: { width: 44, height: 44 }
-    };
-    
-    const minimum = minimums[platform];
-    
-    // Check if token value meets minimum
-    // This is simplified - real implementation would check actual component sizes
-    if (sizingToken.baseValue < minimum.width || sizingToken.baseValue < minimum.height) {
-      return {
-        component: sizingToken.name,
-        platform,
-        actualSize: { width: sizingToken.baseValue, height: sizingToken.baseValue },
-        requiredSize: minimum,
-        recommendation: `Increase size to meet ${platform} minimum touch target of ${minimum.width}x${minimum.height}`
-      };
-    }
-    
-    return null;
-  }
-
-  /**
-   * Extract primitive tokens from platform tokens
-   */
-  private extractPrimitiveTokens(tokens: PlatformTokens[]): PrimitiveToken[] {
-    const primitiveTokens: PrimitiveToken[] = [];
-    
-    // This is a simplified extraction - real implementation would properly extract
-    // all primitive tokens from the PlatformTokens structure
-    
-    return primitiveTokens;
-  }
-
-  /**
-   * Extract color tokens
-   */
-  private extractColorTokens(tokens: PlatformTokens[]): any[] {
-    // Simplified - real implementation would extract color tokens
-    return [];
-  }
-
-  /**
-   * Extract sizing tokens
-   */
-  private extractSizingTokens(tokens: PlatformTokens[]): any[] {
-    // Simplified - real implementation would extract sizing tokens
-    return [];
-  }
-
-  /**
-   * Get expected progression for token category
-   */
-  private getExpectedProgression(category: TokenCategory): string {
-    switch (category) {
-      case TokenCategory.SPACING:
-        return 'Modular scale (1.25x)';
-      case TokenCategory.FONT_SIZE:
-        return 'Typographic scale (1.25x)';
-      case TokenCategory.RADIUS:
-        return 'Geometric progression';
-      default:
-        return 'Linear or modular progression';
-    }
-  }
-
-  /**
-   * Count total tokens
-   */
-  private countTokens(tokens: PlatformTokens[]): number {
-    // Simplified count - real implementation would count all tokens
-    return tokens.length;
-  }
-
-  /**
-   * Generate comprehensive recommendations
-   */
-  private generateRecommendations(
-    crossPlatform: any,
-    mathematical: any,
-    strategicFlexibility: any,
-    accessibility: AccessibilityValidationResult
-  ): string[] {
-    const recommendations: string[] = [];
-    
-    // Cross-platform recommendations
-    if (!crossPlatform.valid) {
-      recommendations.push('Review cross-platform token consistency - some tokens have inconsistent values');
-    }
-    
-    // Mathematical relationship recommendations
-    if (!mathematical.valid) {
-      recommendations.push('Review mathematical relationships - some tokens violate expected progressions');
-    }
-    
-    // Strategic flexibility recommendations
-    if (!strategicFlexibility.valid) {
-      recommendations.push('Review strategic flexibility usage - ensure appropriate usage patterns');
-    }
-    
-    // Accessibility recommendations
-    recommendations.push(...accessibility.recommendations);
-    
-    // Overall recommendation
-    if (recommendations.length === 0) {
-      recommendations.push('All mathematical consistency checks passed - tokens maintain cross-platform consistency');
-    }
-    
-    return recommendations;
-  }
-}