rosett-ai 1.3.3

data/conf/review/rosett-ai-core.yml

@@ -0,0 +1,2919 @@
+---
+# Test Peer Review Registry — Rosett-AI core
+# Generated: 2026-03-14
+# Questionnaire: conf/review/questionnaire.yml
+#
+# Status values: pending | in_review | needs_fix | signed_off
+# This file is updated during the review process.
+
+repository: rosett-ai
+total_files: 142
+reviewed: 142
+signed_off: 142
+
+files:
+  spec/rosett_ai/project_context_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved_with_notes
+    intent: "Verifies ProjectContext detects rai projects by walking up for .rosett-ai/ markers, respecting RAI_ORIGINAL_PWD and explicit start_dir"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: concern
+    findings:
+      - severity: minor
+        question: Q10
+        description: "around blocks for env var save/restore lacked explanatory comments for junior developers"
+        resolution: "Added inline documentation comments explaining the pattern"
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/thor/tasks/build_package_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved_with_notes
+    intent: "Verifies BuildPackage produces correct .deb packages with staging, variant handling, environment validation, and build summary"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: concern
+      Q5: concern
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: concern
+    findings:
+      - severity: minor
+        question: Q4
+        description: "Extensive use of allow_any_instance_of — pragmatic for Thor but a known RSpec smell"
+        resolution: "Created controlled stub allowlist: stubbable_methods + stub_stages/stub_stage helpers + guard example. See doc/TEST_PEER_REVIEW.md"
+      - severity: minor
+        question: Q5
+        description: "Private helper methods (format_size, format_duration, clean_env) tested via send"
+        resolution: "Extracted format_size/format_duration to RosettAi::Formatting module (spec/rosett_ai/formatting_spec.rb). clean_env retained with send — justified inline (no public surface, build-critical env isolation)"
+      - severity: minor
+        question: Q10
+        description: "stub_all_stages helper and 30-line before block lacked explanatory comments"
+        resolution: "Added inline documentation comments explaining fixture setup and stub rationale"
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/thor/tasks/build_engine_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved_with_notes
+    intent: "Verifies BuildEngine detects engine gemspecs, validates build environment, and produces correct .deb filenames and staging paths"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: concern
+      Q5: concern
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: concern
+    findings:
+      - severity: minor
+        question: Q4
+        description: "Gemspec detection tests use instance_variable_get to verify parsed values"
+        resolution: "Pragmatic — parsed values only exposed through downstream output; ivar access isolates unit from full pipeline. Documented inline."
+      - severity: minor
+        question: Q5
+        description: "Tests set instance variables directly and call private methods via send, coupling to internal structure"
+        resolution: "format_size removed (now in RosettAi::Formatting module). Remaining send/ivar usage justified — gemspec pipeline and package_filename have no public accessor surface."
+      - severity: minor
+        question: Q10
+        description: "Three-step gemspec pipeline and manual ivar setup lacked explanatory comments"
+        resolution: "Added inline documentation comments explaining the pipeline and isolation rationale"
+
+  # --- Batch 2: Core Foundation (reviewed 2026-03-15) ---
+
+  spec/nncc_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies the top-level RosettAi module exposes correct VERSION format, memoized .root/.config singletons, and properly structured error class hierarchy"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/configuration_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved_with_notes
+    intent: "Verifies Configuration loads settings.json and settings.local.json, deep-merges nested hashes with array union deduplication, handles type mismatches, and clears memoized state on reload!"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: concern
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings:
+      - severity: minor
+        question: Q5
+        description: "reload! test used instance_variable_get to verify internal memoization state"
+        resolution: "Replaced with 4 behavioral tests verifying re-read of settings, local_settings, merged_settings, and behaviour_files after reload!"
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/rai_config_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies RaiConfig returns compiled defaults when no config file exists, deep-merges user values, validates against JSON Schema, supports dotted-key updates with type coercion, and provides a memoized singleton"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/path_resolver_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved_with_notes
+    intent: "Verifies PathResolver resolves all filesystem paths correctly, respects RAI_ORIGINAL_PWD for .deb wrapper compatibility, honours XDG_CONFIG_HOME for Rosett-AI-domain paths, and provides a memoized singleton"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: concern
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings:
+      - severity: minor
+        question: Q5
+        description: "Test used instance_variable_get(:@engine) because engine value had no observable output"
+        resolution: "Added attr_reader :engine to PathResolver, test now uses public accessor — multi-engine ready"
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/version_consistency_checker_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies VersionConsistencyChecker detects stale Ruby version references, correctly excludes build artifacts and version-pinning patterns, and reports file/line/found/expected for each mismatch"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/secrets_resolver_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies SecretsResolver resolves secrets through ENV > secrets file fallback, rejects insecure file permissions (non-0600), and provides actionable error messages with setup instructions"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/validators/schema_validator_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies SchemaValidator loads JSON schemas, validates YAML files against them, and provides clear error messages for missing files, broken YAML, and schema violations"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/validators/behaviour_validator_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies BehaviourValidator validates behaviour YAML files against the behaviour JSON Schema, catching missing fields, empty rules, invalid rule structures, and malformed version strings"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/validators/design_validator_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies DesignValidator validates design documents against the design JSON Schema and that all existing design files pass validation"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/validators/tooling_validator_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies ToolingValidator validates tooling configuration files against the tooling JSON Schema and that all existing tooling files pass validation"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  # --- Batch 3: Core Compiler + Composition (reviewed 2026-03-15) ---
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/compiler/compilation_pipeline_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies CompilationPipeline discovers categories, compiles behaviour YAML to markdown, produces checksums, and detects orphaned managed files"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/compiler/behaviour_compiler_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved_with_notes
+    intent: "Verifies BehaviourCompiler loads YAML, validates against schema, generates markdown with backend-appropriate templates, handles lockfile data and multi-category compilation"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: concern
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings:
+      - severity: minor
+        question: Q4
+        description: "Mocks class under test for lockfile_data — spy on compile result rather than exercising real pipeline"
+        resolution: "Pragmatic — lockfile_data is an accessor on compiled output, mocking avoids full pipeline setup. Documented inline."
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/compiler/backend_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved_with_notes
+    intent: "Verifies Backend.for resolves engine names to backend classes, handles aliases, raises for unknown engines, and supports the deprecated Backend.resolve_backend_class path"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: concern
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings:
+      - severity: minor
+        question: Q5
+        description: "Uses send(:resolve_backend_class) to test private class resolution method"
+        resolution: "Pragmatic — resolve_backend_class has no public surface, only consumed by Backend.for. Testing via send isolates the resolver from full pipeline."
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/compiler/backends/claude_backend_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies ClaudeBackend is a deprecated alias that resolves to the correct backend class"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/compiler/backends/generic_backend_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies GenericBackend is a deprecated alias that resolves to the correct backend class"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/compiler/capability_checker_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies CapabilityChecker detects unsupported behaviour features for target engines, produces summarized warnings, and correctly passes through supported features"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/compiler/target_profile_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies TargetProfile loads engine YAML profiles, exposes output_dir/template/features/metadata, and raises for missing profile files"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/compiler/locale_compiler_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies LocaleCompiler compiles YAML locale files to gettext .po and Qt .ts formats, handles missing source directories, and produces correct file structures"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/compiler/compiled_output_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies CompiledOutput wraps compilation results with content, metadata, and checksum accessors"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/thor/tasks/compile_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved_with_notes
+    intent: "Verifies Compile Thor task creates markdown rule files, handles simulate/verbose/vendor/engine options, removes orphans, and emits deprecation warnings for --target"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: concern
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings:
+      - severity: minor
+        question: Q4
+        description: "Used bare allow_any_instance_of for resolve_target_dir — Thor invoke prevents instance access"
+        resolution: "Created controlled stub allowlist: stubbable_methods + stub_stages/stub_stage helpers + guard example, consistent with build_package_spec.rb pattern"
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/composition/composer_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Composer orchestrates the full composition pipeline: priority sorting, scope resolution, conflict detection, circular dependency checks, and produces a CompositionResult"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/composition/circular_dependency_detector_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies CircularDependencyDetector identifies circular requires between behaviours and reports the cycle path"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/composition/conflict_detector_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies ConflictDetector identifies rule ID collisions across behaviours and reports conflicting sources"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/composition/lockfile_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Lockfile generates and reads compile.lock.yml with generator metadata, SHA-256 checksums, and version stamps"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/composition/priority_sorter_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies PrioritySorter orders behaviours by priority field, handles equal priorities with stable sort, and places lower priority numbers first"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/composition/scope_resolver_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies ScopeResolver filters behaviours by used_in scope tags, handles global/project/engine scopes, and passes through unscoped behaviours"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/composition/composition_result_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies CompositionResult wraps composed behaviours with conflict/circular reports, provides success?/warnings accessors, and supports serialization"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  # --- Batch 4: Policy + Provenance + Authorship + AI Config (reviewed 2026-03-15) ---
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/policy/auditor_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Auditor counts deny list patterns, denied files, and protected files in a project and reports compliance status"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/policy/deny_list_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies DenyList matches glob patterns against file paths, supports merge with deduplication, and provides size/empty? collection semantics"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/policy/opt_out_scanner_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies OptOutScanner detects AI-MODIFICATION: disabled markers in files and scans batches for opted-out files"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/policy/policy_compiler_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies PolicyCompiler compiles deny lists and protected files to engine-specific formats (Claude deniedPaths, Cursor ignore_patterns, AGENTS.md denied_access) with warnings for unknown engines"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/policy/protected_files_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies ProtectedFiles identifies protected paths, supports merge with deduplication, and provides size/empty? collection semantics"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/policy/tier_hierarchy_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies TierHierarchy enforces tighten-only pattern (child can add but not remove deny patterns) and validates tier/scope enum values"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/policy/validator_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Validator catches missing policy_version/tier fields, rejects invalid tier and scope enum values, and provides valid? convenience method"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/provenance/entry_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Entry immutable record stores AI contribution metadata, freezes all attributes, defaults timestamp, rejects invalid roles, and serializes via to_h"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/provenance/file_source_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies FileSource value object stores path/source_type/optional lines, freezes attributes, and conditionally serializes lines in to_h"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/provenance/source_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Source validates type against ALLOWED_TYPES, requires specific URL for external_source, freezes attributes, and serializes conditionally"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/provenance/store_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Store manages append-only YAML provenance file with init/append/read/query-by-commit/query-by-file operations and raises on missing files"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/provenance/trailer_generator_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies TrailerGenerator formats AI provenance as git trailer lines, deduplicates across entries, and produces newline-separated trailer blocks"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/provenance/validator_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Validator checks provenance YAML structure including version, commit SHA format, ai_role enum, and source_type enum"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/authorship/attribution_compiler_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies AttributionCompiler produces disclosure-level-appropriate output: none (nil), minimal (HTML comment), standard (heading + trailers), full (per-file involvement)"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/authorship/disclosure_policy_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies DisclosurePolicy enum class validates levels and exposes disclose?/include_attribution?/include_per_file?/include_trailer_guidance? query methods"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/authorship/review_validator_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies ReviewValidator prevents self-review with case/whitespace normalization and handles nil author/reviewer gracefully"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/authorship/trailer_generator_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies TrailerGenerator formats AI role trailers for all four roles, validates roles, and produces newline-separated trailer blocks"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/ai_config/config_compiler_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies ConfigCompiler resolves model routing (tier→model), context window, and cost controls per engine, with strict mode and custom model support"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/ai_config/context_window_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies ContextWindow value object stores max_tokens/output_reserve/truncation_strategy, calculates effective_input_tokens, and validates strategy enum"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/ai_config/cost_controls_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies CostControls value object stores preferred_tier with validation, optional monthly_budget_note, and conditional to_h serialization"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/ai_config/fallback_chain_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies FallbackChain stores ordered engine list, detects local-to-remote transitions with warnings, exposes primary/fallbacks, and serializes via to_h"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/ai_config/model_router_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies ModelRouter maps canonical tiers to engine-specific models (Claude haiku/sonnet/opus, Ollama 3b/70b), supports custom:model syntax, and allows custom engine mappings"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/ai_config/validator_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Validator catches invalid truncation_strategy, preferred_tier, and model tier patterns while accepting empty config and custom:model format"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  # --- Batch 5: Configuration System (reviewed 2026-03-15) ---
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/config/compile_result_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies CompileResult value object exposes success?/changed? predicates for action types (created/updated/unchanged/skipped) and defaults warnings"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/config/key_map_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies deprecated RosettAi::Config::KeyMap alias resolves to RosettAiEngine::Claude::KeyMap when engine gem is installed"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/config/masking_secret_resolver_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies MaskingSecretResolver replaces secret references with *** for safe display, handles nested structures, preserves non-secret and non-string values"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/config/scope_router_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies deprecated RosettAi::Config::ScopeRouter alias resolves to RosettAiEngine::Claude::ScopeRouter when engine gem is installed"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/config/secret_resolver_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies SecretResolver resolves env/file/path backends with security validation (0600 perms, UID ownership, path traversal, 64 KiB limit, single-pass guarantee, no regex)"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/backup/compressor_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Compressor abstract base and three implementations (TarGz/Zip/TarXz) create valid archives with compression levels and proper error handling"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/backup/destination_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Destination abstract base, FileDestination (copy + mkdir), UnsupportedDestination (s3/ssh), and scheme parsing with file:// URI support"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/init/config_file_writer_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies ConfigFileWriter creates default config.yml with engine default, returns unchanged for existing files, and creates parent directories"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  # --- Batch 6: Content & Licensing (reviewed 2026-03-15) ---
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/content/content_client_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies ContentClient issues authenticated HTTP requests (Bearer token) for catalog/download/signature/availability with WebMock-stubbed success, error, and connection failure paths"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/content/pack_installer_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies PackInstaller extracts Ed25519-signed tarballs, rejects tampered signatures and path traversal attacks (../../../etc/passwd), and creates pack directories"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/content/pack_manifest_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies PackManifest validates required fields (name, version, tier_required), rejects invalid patterns/semver/tiers, and loads from YAML files"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/content/pack_registry_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies PackRegistry scans premium directory for installed packs, skips dirs without manifests, and supports version query and removal"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/licensing/license_key_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies LicenseKey decodes Ed25519-signed JWT tokens, rejects forged keys, enforces 14-day grace period, supports perpetual/subscription/offline modes, and resists property-based fuzzing"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/licensing/license_store_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies LicenseStore saves keys with 0600 file / 0700 dir permissions, rejects insecure permissions on load, strips trailing newlines, and supports remove/exists?"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/licensing/license_validator_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies LicenseValidator integration: no-license returns community tier, valid perpetual key returns supporter, forged key falls back to community with error, and grace period produces warnings"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/licensing/tier_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Tier implements Comparable ordering (community < supporter < subscriber < enterprise), entitled_to? boundary checks, string input coercion, and invalid tier rejection"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/packaging/variant_config_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies VariantConfig loads core/gtk4/qt6 packaging variants with schema validation, resolves dynamic VERSION dependencies, and produces fpm_depends arrays"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/text_sanitizer_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies TextSanitizer strips ANSI escape sequences (SGR, cursor, OSC, control chars), normalizes NFC with encoding conversion, and recursively sanitizes nested hash/array structures"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/gemspec_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Regression guard: verifies gemspec guards git ls-files behind .git check, provides Dir.glob fallback, and does not spawn git subprocess in non-git directories"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/i18n_completeness_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Cross-cutting quality check: verifies all locale files have required structure, reports missing/orphan keys vs en.yml with CLDR plural awareness, and validates I18n.t calls in lib/"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  # --- Batch 7: D-Bus & Desktop (reviewed 2026-03-15) ---
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/dbus/service_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies D-Bus Service lifecycle (start/stop/running?), session bus connection, interface export, focus monitoring delegation, error handling, and BUS_NAME/OBJECT_PATH constants"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/dbus/manager_interface_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies ManagerInterface contract: INTERFACE constant, Shutdown logging, SetConfig delegation to RaiConfig, ListEngines returning name/display_name tuples, GetStatus dictionary with version/running/context/pid/dbus_name"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/dbus/focus_monitor_interface_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies FocusMonitorInterface INTERFACE constant and create_adapter factory mapping all 7 compositor types (i3, sway, hyprland, gnome, kwin, x11, unknown)"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/dbus/focus_adapters/base_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies FocusAdapters::Base abstract contract: non-running initial state, callback registration/notification, multiple callback support, NotImplementedError for start, argument-to-string coercion"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/dbus/focus_adapters/gnome_adapter_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies GnomeAdapter D-Bus Eval-based focus polling with 0.5s interval, duplicate-focus suppression, double-start idempotency, and D-Bus error handling"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/dbus/focus_adapters/kwin_adapter_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies KwinAdapter D-Bus signal subscription with polling fallback, double-start prevention, and graceful error handling when KWin unavailable"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/dbus/focus_adapters/hyprland_adapter_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies HyprlandAdapter UNIX socket connection via HYPRLAND_INSTANCE_SIGNATURE, activewindow event parsing (app_id>>title), empty title/missing separator handling, and missing env/socket edge cases"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/dbus/focus_adapters/i3_adapter_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies I3Adapter i3ipc connection, window event subscription, focus event extraction with app_id fallback to window_properties.class"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/dbus/focus_adapters/x11_adapter_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies X11Adapter xprop-based focus detection: WM_CLASS extraction, _NET_WM_NAME with WM_NAME fallback, active window ID parsing, nil window handling, and POLL_INTERVAL constant"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/dbus/compositor_detector_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies CompositorDetector env var detection (Hyprland > Sway > i3 > DISPLAY), D-Bus service detection (GNOME Shell, KWin), precedence ordering, and :unknown fallback"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/dbus/status_notifier_interface_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies StatusNotifierInterface org.kde.StatusNotifierItem properties (id, category, status, title, icon_name, tool_tip struct), update_status method with NewStatus signal emission"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/desktop/dbus_client_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies DbusClient full lifecycle (connect/disconnect/connected?/service_available?), all Manager methods (status/compile/switch_context/set_config/list_engines), FocusMonitor current_focus, and error paths for every D-Bus call"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/desktop/gtk4_app_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Gtk4App APPLICATION_ID reverse-DNS, conditional Adwaita availability, DbusClient initialization, and graceful exit when adwaita gem missing"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/desktop/gtk4_preferences_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Gtk4Preferences D-Bus preference callbacks (verbose/strict/engine/auto_switch), dynamic engine list from D-Bus with FALLBACK_ENGINES, index-based selection at boundaries, and Adw version compatibility"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/desktop/gui_logger_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies GuiLogger env var control (RAI_GUI_LOG/FILE/LEVEL), JSON Lines structured logging, action tracking with duration_ms, error logging with truncated backtrace, level filtering, file logging, and LEVELS constant"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  # --- Batch 8: UI + Plugins + Engines + i18n (reviewed 2026-03-15) ---
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/ui/base_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies UI::Base abstract contract — subclass enforcement for required methods (display_table, display_banner, etc.), shared helpers (format_status, truncate_text), and NotImplementedError on unimplemented calls"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/ui/tui_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Tui adapter renders display_table with aligned columns, display_banner with box-drawing, format_status with colour codes, progress_bar percentage, and truncate_text with Unicode awareness"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/ui/accessible_tui_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies AccessibleTui screen-reader-safe output — no ANSI codes, text-only table format, high-contrast status labels, semantic progress reporting, and EN 301 549 compliance helpers"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/ui/registry_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies UI::Registry adapter registration, lookup, default selection (tui), accessible auto-selection via ORCA_RUNNING/BRLTTY_TTY env vars, and unknown adapter error handling"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/ui/tty_helper_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies TtyHelper TTY-aware prompt helpers — confirm_yes? reads from $stdin with default fallback, non-TTY auto-accepts defaults, and say outputs to $stdout"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/ui/gtk4_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Gtk4 UI adapter renders Pango-markup tables, styled banners, HTML-escaped status, GTK progress fraction, and Pango-safe text truncation"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/ui/qt6_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Qt6 UI adapter renders HTML tables with Qt-compatible styling, banner with border-radius, colour-coded status, QProgressBar percentage, and HTML-safe truncation"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/ui/kde_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies KDE UI adapter renders Breeze-themed HTML tables, KDE-styled banners, Breeze-palette status colours, Plasma-compatible progress, and KDE-safe truncation"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/plugins/contract_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Plugins::Contract base class — validates plugin_name/plugin_type presence, PLUGIN_TYPES constant [:engine, :gui, :mcp], lifecycle hooks (activate/deactivate), and abstract method enforcement"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/plugins/engine_contract_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies EngineContract duck-type — requires compile_rules/engine_name/supported_features, inherits Contract lifecycle, validates engine type classification"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/plugins/gui_contract_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies GuiContract duck-type — requires show_window/gui_toolkit, inherits Contract lifecycle, validates gui type classification"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/plugins/mcp_contract_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies McpContract duck-type — requires handle_request/server_info, inherits Contract lifecycle, validates mcp type classification"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/plugins/registry_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Plugins::Registry — register/lookup/list by type, duplicate name rejection, contract compliance validation, and type-filtered listing"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/engines/registry_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Engines::Registry — register/lookup/list engines, default engine selection, duplicate rejection, and reset! for test isolation"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/engines/base_config_compiler_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies BaseConfigCompiler abstract contract — subclass must implement compile_scope/engine_name, provides config file discovery, validates YAML loading, and reports compile results"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/engines/detector_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Engines::Detector manifest-driven detection — checks cli_binary via which and config_dir existence, returns detected engine list, handles missing binaries gracefully"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/i18n/locale_resolver_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies LocaleResolver POSIX locale parsing (LANG/LC_ALL/LC_MESSAGES), language-region extraction, fallback chain to 'en', and validation against available locales"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/i18n/utf8_checker_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Utf8Checker validates UTF-8 encoding on strings and files, detects invalid byte sequences, reports line/column positions of encoding errors, and handles empty/missing files"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  # --- Batch 9: Adopter + Quorum + Documentation + Core utilities (reviewed 2026-03-15) ---
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/adopter/executor_resolver_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies ExecutorResolver creates correct executor instances for SDK-based (Claude), HTTP-based (Ollama), OpenAI-compatible (GPT-NeoX), and CLI-based (Goose/Aider) engines with proper kwargs routing"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/adopter/local_analysis_collector_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies LocalAnalysisCollector structural analysis of compiled rules — empty descriptions, missing priorities, identical descriptions, bullet-list AGENTS.md format with synthetic IDs, and overall_status pass/warn/fail"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/adopter/rule_adopter_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies RuleAdopter full adoption pipeline — file discovery, SHA256 checksums, cache read/write, redaction patterns, prompt building, local/API analysis, sensitive file filtering, engine parameter, and merge_results status logic"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/quorum/collector_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Quorum::Collector annotates findings with engine name, preserves original finding data, creates error findings for failed engines, and handles empty findings"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/quorum/comparator_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Quorum::Comparator cross-engine finding merge (identical findings → cross_engine:true), unique finding separation, severity promotion to highest across engines, overall status determination, and informative summary text"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/quorum/dispatcher_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Quorum::Dispatcher parallel executor dispatch — multiple executors, elapsed time tracking, error capture without crash, mixed success/failure isolation, and empty executor map"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/quorum/strategies/adopt_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Quorum Adopt strategy filters eligible engines by adopt_api capability + executor presence, runs aggregated analysis across engines, and raises AdoptError when no eligible engines exist"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/documentation/reference_compiler_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies ReferenceCompiler LaTeX pipeline — tool availability checks, staleness detection (PDF vs source/design mtime), 4-pass compilation sequence (pdflatex×4 + biber + makeindex), artifact cleanup, and error handling for missing tools/sources"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/documentation/translator_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Translator Claude API-powered document translation — API call with correct prompt, output file creation in locale directory, skip guard for missing anthropic gem"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/config/compiler_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies deprecated RosettAi::Config::Compiler alias resolves to RosettAiEngine::Claude::ConfigCompiler, with skip guard for missing engine gem"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/formatting_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Formatting module format_size (B/KB/MB/GB with boundaries) and format_duration (seconds/minutes) helpers, plus SIZE_UNITS frozen constant"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/gem_consistency_checker_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies GemConsistencyChecker detects gemspec/lockfile mismatches (missing, conflict, ok), stale version references in docs (with file/line/gem/found/expected), exclusion paths (vendor/, Gemfile.lock, conf/design/), and rai:no-version-check suppression"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/yaml_loader_property_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies YamlLoader safety limits via Rantly property-based testing — random valid hashes always load, oversized payloads always rejected, deeply nested structures always rejected"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/yaml_loader_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies YamlLoader deterministic safety limits — file size (1MB), nesting depth (10 levels for hash/array/mixed), key count (1000 including nested), boundary acceptance/rejection, Date/Time permitted classes, and error messages with file paths and counts"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rubocop/cop/rosett-ai/shell_interpolation_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies ShellInterpolation RuboCop cop detects shell injection via interpolated strings in system/exec/spawn/backticks, and permits array-form system() and plain string commands"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rubocop/cop/rosett-ai/unsafe_yaml_load_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies UnsafeYamlLoad RuboCop cop detects YAML.load/load_file/::YAML.load usage and permits YAML.safe_load, safe_load_file, and RosettAi::YamlLoader.load_file"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/yard_coverage_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies YARD documentation coverage — tier1 core API files (6) each have @return tags, and overall lib/ coverage meets 40% threshold with dynamic file scanning"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  # --- Batch 10: Thor CLI + Thor tasks (reviewed 2026-03-15) — FINAL BATCH ---
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/thor/cli_help_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies CLI help output renders without error for top-level help, version, and all 12 registered subcommands via dynamic test generation from subcommands array"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/thor/cli_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies CLI command visibility — internal commands (release, documentation, dbus, desktop) hidden outside rosett-ai repo via nncc_internal? guard, invoke_command raises Thor::Error for restricted commands"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/thor/tasks/adopt_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Adopt task CLI output — local/API modes, pass/warn/fail/unknown status display, severity colorization, elaborate explanations, verbose file counts, sensitive file reporting, cached results, and empty files warning"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/thor/tasks/backup_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Backup task — global/local/both scopes, tar.gz creation with content verification, exclusions (settings.local.json, adopt cache), compression algorithms/ratios, URI destinations (file:// support, s3:// rejection), idempotency (unchanged/updated), and summary table"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/thor/tasks/behaviour_manage_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies BehaviourManage CRUD lifecycle — add with editor ($EDITOR=true), modify with metadata update, delete with force/confirmation/decline, validation failure cleanup, and reference detection in CLAUDE.md and rules"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/thor/tasks/behaviour_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Behaviour task — display with table/json/yaml formats and used_in values, list all files, show specific behaviour, validate all/specific files with Thor::Error on failure, corrupted file error handling"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/thor/tasks/build_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Build task registers package and engine subcommands and returns exit_on_failure? true"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/thor/tasks/config_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Config task — compile with scope files, --simulate dry run, --scope filtering, invalid scope error, show with JSON display and secret masking, --raw YAML display, engine plugin resolution with actionable error messages, and CLI registration"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/thor/tasks/content_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Content task — list installed packs, install with WebMock-stubbed catalog/download/signature and Ed25519 license validation, tier-insufficient error, and update with no packs"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/thor/tasks/dbus_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies DBus task — status (running/not running), detect compositor with adapter mapping, start (already running / D-Bus unavailable), stop (not running), and adapter_for private method for sway/hyprland/unknown"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/thor/tasks/design_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Design task — validate all/specific/missing docs, show with header/intent/constraints/acceptance/dependencies, --full with examples/anti-patterns/preferences, list with table and malformed file handling"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/thor/tasks/desktop_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Desktop task — status display with GTK4/D-Bus availability, install instructions when missing, gtk4 launch with SystemExit(0) on success and Thor::Error when unavailable"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/thor/tasks/documentation_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Documentation task — update with dry-run/apply/all-locales, status with file count and locale display, private change scanning (behaviour/dependency/lib/reference), documented? detection, locale resolution, and reference compilation integration"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/thor/tasks/engines_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Engines task — list all engines in table, detect with detector stubs for claude/agents_md/acme, and status with default engine display and detection results"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/thor/tasks/init_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Init task — --global creates directories/settings/config with engine detection, --local creates .claude structure, --project creates .rosett-ai with config.yml, RAI_ORIGINAL_PWD respects external directory, compile integration with --no-compile and CompileError graceful handling"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/thor/tasks/license_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies License task — activate with valid/invalid Ed25519 JWT keys, status display (community/subscriber tiers), and deactivate with file removal and not-found handling"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/thor/tasks/release_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Release task — status table with version/commit count, prepare with invalid level/dirty tree guards, tag with exists check, version bumping arithmetic (major/minor/patch resets), VERIFICATION_GATES constant, and VALID_LEVELS constant"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/thor/tasks/tooling_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Tooling task registers validate-ci-yaml and check-versions commands"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []
+
+  spec/rosett_ai/thor/tasks/validate_spec.rb:
+    status: signed_off
+    reviewer: hugo
+    review_date: "2026-03-15"
+    sign_off_date: "2026-03-15"
+    verdict: approved
+    intent: "Verifies Validate task — all categories (behaviour/design/tooling) with zero/valid/invalid/mixed files, per-category breakdown, Thor::Error on failure, and CATEGORIES constant coverage against schema files (excluding internal schemas)"
+    answers:
+      Q1: pass
+      Q2: pass
+      Q3: pass
+      Q4: pass
+      Q5: pass
+      Q6: pass
+      Q7: pass
+      Q8: pass
+      Q9: pass
+      Q10: pass
+    findings: []