mindstudio-probe 1.0.3__py3-none-any.whl → 1.1.0__py3-none-any.whl

msprobe/pytorch/api_accuracy_checker/compare/compare.py

@@ -1,381 +1,416 @@
-# 进行比对及结果展示
-import os
-from collections import namedtuple
-
-import numpy as np
-from msprobe.core.common.utils import write_csv, get_json_contents, CompareException
-import torch
-from msprobe.core.common.const import Const, CompareConst
-from msprobe.pytorch.api_accuracy_checker.compare.algorithm import get_rmse, get_error_balance, get_max_rel_err, \
-    get_mean_rel_err, get_rel_err, get_abs_err, get_max_abs_err, get_rel_err_ratio, cosine_sim, get_rel_err_origin, \
-    get_small_value_err_ratio, get_finite_and_infinite_mask, get_small_value_mask, check_inf_nan_value, \
-    check_small_value, check_norm_value, get_abs_bench_with_eps, get_ulp_err
-from msprobe.pytorch.api_accuracy_checker.common.config import msCheckerConfig
-from msprobe.pytorch.api_accuracy_checker.compare.compare_column import CompareColumn
-from msprobe.pytorch.api_accuracy_checker.compare.compare_utils import check_dtype_comparable, \
-    DETAIL_TEST_ROWS, precision_configs, BENCHMARK_COMPARE_SUPPORT_LIST, absolute_standard_api, binary_standard_api, \
-    ulp_standard_api, thousandth_standard_api, apis_threshold
-from msprobe.pytorch.common.log import logger
-
-
-ResultInfo = namedtuple('ResultInfo', ['full_api_name', 'fwd_success_status', 'bwd_success_status',
-                                       'fwd_compare_alg_results', 'bwd_compare_alg_results', 'rank'])
-
-
-INDEX_TEST_RESULT_GROUP = 3
-INDEX_FIRST_GROUP = 0
-INDEX_MESSAGE = -1
-
-
-class Comparator:
-    # consts for result csv
-    COLUMN_API_NAME = "API name"
-    COLUMN_FORWARD_SUCCESS = "Forward Test Success"
-    COLUMN_BACKWARD_SUCCESS = "Backward Test Success"
-    COLUMN_STACK_INFO = "Traceback callstack info"
-
-    def __init__(self, result_csv_path, details_csv_path, is_continue_run_ut, stack_info_json_path=None, config=None):
-        self.save_path_str = result_csv_path
-        self.detail_save_path_str = details_csv_path
-        self.save_path_list = [result_csv_path]
-        self.detail_save_path_list = [details_csv_path]
-
-        if config and config.online_config.is_online:
-            self.save_path_str = result_csv_path.replace(".csv", "_rank{}.csv")
-            self.detail_save_path_str = details_csv_path.replace(".csv", "_rank{}.csv")
-            self.save_path_list = [self.save_path_str.format(rank) for rank in config.online_config.rank_list]
-            self.detail_save_path_list = \
-                [self.detail_save_path_str.format(rank) for rank in config.online_config.rank_list]
-
-        if not is_continue_run_ut:
-            self.write_csv_title()
-        if stack_info_json_path:
-            self.stack_info = get_json_contents(stack_info_json_path)
-        else:
-            self.stack_info = None
-
-    @staticmethod
-    def get_path_from_rank(rank, path_list, path_pattern):
-        return path_list[-1] if len(path_list) == 1 else path_pattern.format(rank)
-
-    @staticmethod
-    def print_pretest_result():
-        logger.info("Successfully completed run_ut/multi_run_ut.")
-
-    @staticmethod
-    def _compare_dropout(bench_output, device_output):
-        tensor_num = bench_output.numel()
-        if tensor_num >= 100:
-            if abs((bench_output == 0).sum() - (device_output == 0).cpu().sum()) / tensor_num < 0.1:
-                return CompareConst.PASS, 1
-            else:
-                return CompareConst.ERROR, 0
-        else:
-            return CompareConst.PASS, 1
-
-    @staticmethod
-    def _compare_builtin_type(bench_output, device_output, compare_column):
-        if not isinstance(bench_output, (bool, int, float, str)):
-            return CompareConst.PASS, compare_column, ""
-        if bench_output != device_output:
-            return CompareConst.ERROR, compare_column, ""
-        compare_column.error_rate = 0
-        return CompareConst.PASS, compare_column, ""
-
-    @staticmethod
-    def _compare_bool_tensor(bench_output, device_output):
-        error_nums = (bench_output != device_output).sum()
-        if bench_output.size == 0:
-            return CompareConst.NAN, CompareConst.ERROR, "There is not bench calculation result."
-        error_rate = float(error_nums / bench_output.size)
-        result = CompareConst.PASS if error_rate == 0 else CompareConst.ERROR
-        return error_rate, result, ""
-
-    @staticmethod
-    def _get_absolute_threshold_attribute(api_name, dtype):
-        small_value_threshold = apis_threshold.get(api_name).get(dtype).get('small_value')
-        small_value_atol = apis_threshold.get(api_name).get(dtype).get('small_value_atol')
-        rtol = apis_threshold.get(api_name).get(dtype).get('rtol')
-        return small_value_threshold, small_value_atol, rtol
-
-    @staticmethod
-    def _get_run_ut_detail(test_result):
-        """get run_ut detail before write to csv, called by online run_ut"""
-        test_rows = []
-        try:
-            subject_prefix = test_result[0]
-            fwd_result = test_result[3]
-            bwd_result = test_result[4]
-        except IndexError as e:
-            logger.error("List index out of bounds when writing detail CSV.")
-            raise CompareException(CompareException.INDEX_OUT_OF_BOUNDS_ERROR, "list index out of bounds") from e
-
-        if isinstance(fwd_result, list):
-            for i, test_subject in enumerate(fwd_result):
-                subject = subject_prefix + ".forward.output." + str(i)
-                test_subject = ["{:.{}f}".format(item, msCheckerConfig.precision)
-                                if isinstance(item, float) else item for item in test_subject]
-                test_rows.append([subject] + list(test_subject))
-        if isinstance(bwd_result, list):
-            for i, test_subject in enumerate(bwd_result):
-                subject = subject_prefix + ".backward.output." + str(i)
-                test_subject = ["{:.{}f}".format(item, msCheckerConfig.precision)
-                                if isinstance(item, float) else item for item in test_subject]
-                test_rows.append([subject] + list(test_subject))
-        return test_rows
-
-    def write_csv_title(self):
-        summary_test_rows = [[self.COLUMN_API_NAME, self.COLUMN_FORWARD_SUCCESS,
-                              self.COLUMN_BACKWARD_SUCCESS, "Message"]]
-        for save_path, detail_save_path in zip(self.save_path_list, self.detail_save_path_list):
-            if not os.path.exists(save_path):
-                write_csv(summary_test_rows, save_path)
-            if not os.path.exists(detail_save_path):
-                write_csv(DETAIL_TEST_ROWS, detail_save_path)
-
-    def write_summary_csv(self, test_result):
-        test_rows = []
-        try:
-            name = test_result[0]
-            df_row = list(test_result[:INDEX_TEST_RESULT_GROUP])
-            if test_result[1] == "SKIP":
-                df_row.append(test_result[INDEX_TEST_RESULT_GROUP][INDEX_FIRST_GROUP][INDEX_MESSAGE])
-            if self.stack_info:
-                stack_info = "\n".join(self.stack_info[name])
-                df_row.append(stack_info)
-            test_rows.append(df_row)
-            save_path = self.get_path_from_rank(test_result[-1], self.save_path_list, self.save_path_str)
-        except IndexError as e:
-            logger.error("List index out of bounds when writing summary CSV.")
-            raise CompareException(CompareException.INDEX_OUT_OF_BOUNDS_ERROR, "list index out of bounds") from e
-        write_csv(test_rows, save_path)
-
-    def write_detail_csv(self, test_result):
-        test_rows = self._get_run_ut_detail(test_result)
-        detail_save_path = self.get_path_from_rank(test_result[-1],
-                                                   self.detail_save_path_list,
-                                                   self.detail_save_path_str)
-        write_csv(test_rows, detail_save_path)
-
-    def record_results(self, args):
-        self.write_summary_csv(args)
-        self.write_detail_csv(args)
-
-    def compare_output(self, full_api_name, data_info, is_online=False):
-        """Get compare result and write to result and detail csv.
-        is_online: bool, default False. True: called by online api precision compare, only compare without write to csv.
-        """
-        _, api_name, _ = full_api_name.split(Const.SEP)
-        bench_output, device_output = data_info.bench_output, data_info.device_output
-        bench_grad, device_grad = data_info.bench_grad, data_info.device_grad
-        backward_message = data_info.backward_message
-        if "dropout" in full_api_name:
-            fwd_success_status, fwd_compare_alg_results = self._compare_dropout(bench_output, device_output)
-        else:
-            fwd_success_status, fwd_compare_alg_results = self._compare_core_wrapper(api_name, bench_output,
-                                                                                     device_output)
-        if not (bench_grad and device_grad):
-            bwd_success_status, bwd_compare_alg_results = (CompareConst.SPACE, [])
-        else:
-            if "dropout" in full_api_name:
-                bwd_success_status, bwd_compare_alg_results = self._compare_dropout(bench_grad[0], device_grad[0])
-            else:
-                bwd_success_status, bwd_compare_alg_results = self._compare_core_wrapper(api_name, bench_grad,
-                                                                                         device_grad)
-        if backward_message:
-            backward_column = CompareColumn()
-            bwd_compare_alg_results = [backward_column.to_column_value(CompareConst.SKIP, backward_message)]
-        else:
-            bwd_success_status = bwd_success_status if bwd_compare_alg_results is not None else CompareConst.SPACE
-        result_info = ResultInfo(full_api_name,
-                                 fwd_success_status,
-                                 bwd_success_status,
-                                 fwd_compare_alg_results,
-                                 bwd_compare_alg_results,
-                                 data_info.rank)
-        if is_online:
-            # get run_ut compare detail
-            return self._get_run_ut_detail(result_info)
-        self.record_results(result_info)
-        return fwd_success_status == CompareConst.PASS, bwd_success_status == CompareConst.PASS \
-               or bwd_success_status == CompareConst.SPACE
-
-    def _compare_core_wrapper(self, api_name, bench_output, device_output):
-        detailed_result_total = []
-        test_final_success = CompareConst.PASS
-        if isinstance(bench_output, (list, tuple)):
-            status, compare_result, message = [], [], []
-            if len(bench_output) > len(device_output):
-                status = [CompareConst.ERROR]
-                message = ["bench and npu output structure is different."]
-            else:
-                device_output = device_output[:len(bench_output)]
-                for b_out_i, n_out_i in zip(bench_output, device_output):
-                    status_i, compare_result_i, message_i = self._compare_core(api_name, b_out_i, n_out_i)
-                    status.append(status_i)
-                    compare_result.append(compare_result_i)
-                    message.append(message_i)
-        else:
-            status, compare_result, message = self._compare_core(api_name, bench_output, device_output)
-        if not isinstance(status, list):
-            detailed_result_total.append(compare_result.to_column_value(status, message))
-            if status == CompareConst.ERROR:
-                test_final_success = CompareConst.ERROR
-            elif status == CompareConst.WARNING:
-                test_final_success = CompareConst.WARNING
-        else:
-            for item, item_status in enumerate(status):
-                detailed_result_total.append(compare_result[item].to_column_value(item_status, message[item]))
-                if item_status == CompareConst.ERROR:
-                    test_final_success = CompareConst.ERROR
-                elif item_status == CompareConst.WARNING:
-                    test_final_success = CompareConst.WARNING
-        return test_final_success, detailed_result_total
-
-    def _compare_core(self, api_name, bench_output, device_output):
-        compare_column = CompareColumn()
-        if not isinstance(bench_output, type(device_output)):
-            return CompareConst.ERROR, compare_column, "bench and npu output type is different."
-        elif isinstance(bench_output, dict):
-            b_keys, n_keys = set(bench_output.keys()), set(device_output.keys())
-            if b_keys != n_keys:
-                return CompareConst.ERROR, compare_column, "bench and npu output dict keys are different."
-            else:
-                status, compare_result, message = self._compare_core(api_name, list(bench_output.values()),
-                                                                     list(device_output.values()))
-        elif isinstance(bench_output, torch.Tensor):
-            copy_bench_out = bench_output.detach().clone()
-            copy_device_output = device_output.detach().clone()
-            compare_column.bench_type = str(copy_bench_out.dtype)
-            compare_column.npu_type = str(copy_device_output.dtype)
-            compare_column.shape = tuple(device_output.shape)
-            status, compare_result, message = self._compare_torch_tensor(api_name, copy_bench_out, copy_device_output,
-                                                                         compare_column)
-        elif isinstance(bench_output, (bool, int, float, str)):
-            compare_column.bench_type = str(type(bench_output))
-            compare_column.npu_type = str(type(device_output))
-            status, compare_result, message = self._compare_builtin_type(bench_output, device_output, compare_column)
-        elif bench_output is None:
-            return CompareConst.SKIP, compare_column, "Bench output is None, skip this test."
-        else:
-            return CompareConst.PASS, compare_column,
-        "Unexpected output type in compare_core: {}".format(type(bench_output))
-
-        return status, compare_result, message
-
-    def _compare_torch_tensor(self, api_name, bench_output, device_output, compare_column):
-        cpu_shape = bench_output.shape
-        npu_shape = device_output.shape
-        npu_dtype = device_output.dtype
-        if npu_dtype == torch.bfloat16:
-            bench_output = bench_output.to(torch.float32)
-            device_output = device_output.to(torch.float32)
-        bench_output = bench_output.numpy()
-        device_output = device_output.cpu().numpy()
-        if cpu_shape != npu_shape:
-            return CompareConst.ERROR, compare_column, f"The shape of bench{str(cpu_shape)} " \
-                                                       f"and npu{str(npu_shape)} not equal."
-        if not check_dtype_comparable(bench_output, device_output):
-            return CompareConst.ERROR, compare_column, f"Bench out dtype is {bench_output.dtype} but " \
-                                                       f"npu output dtype is {device_output.dtype}, cannot compare."
-        message = ""
-        if bench_output.dtype in [bool, np.uint8, np.int8, np.int16, np.uint16, np.uint32, np.int32,
-                                  np.int64, np.uint64]:
-            message += f"Compare algorithm is not supported for {bench_output.dtype} data. " \
-                       f"Only judged by Error Rate."
-            err_rate, status, msg = self._compare_bool_tensor(bench_output, device_output)
-            message += msg + "\n"
-            compare_column.error_rate = err_rate
-            return status, compare_column, message
-        else:
-            status, compare_column, message = self._compare_float_tensor(api_name, bench_output, device_output,
-                                                                         compare_column, npu_dtype)
-            return status, compare_column, message
-
-    def _compare_float_tensor(self, api_name, bench_output, device_output, compare_column, dtype):
-        message = ""
-        abs_bench, abs_bench_with_eps = get_abs_bench_with_eps(bench_output, dtype)
-        abs_err = get_abs_err(bench_output, device_output)
-        rel_err_orign = get_rel_err_origin(abs_err, abs_bench_with_eps)
-        if api_name in thousandth_standard_api:
-            thousand_res, thousand_status = get_rel_err_ratio(rel_err_orign, CompareConst.THOUSAND_RATIO_THRESHOLD)
-            compare_column.rel_err_thousandth = thousand_res
-        if str(dtype) in BENCHMARK_COMPARE_SUPPORT_LIST:
-            both_finite_mask, inf_nan_mask = get_finite_and_infinite_mask(bench_output, device_output)
-            if api_name in binary_standard_api:
-                err_rate, _, _ = self._compare_bool_tensor(bench_output, device_output)
-                compare_column.error_rate = err_rate
-            elif api_name in absolute_standard_api:
-                small_value_threshold, small_value_atol, rtol = self._get_absolute_threshold_attribute(
-                    api_name, str(dtype))
-                rel_err = abs_err / abs_bench_with_eps
-                small_value_mask = get_small_value_mask(abs_bench, both_finite_mask, small_value_threshold)
-                normal_value_mask = np.logical_and(both_finite_mask, np.logical_not(small_value_mask))
-                compare_column.inf_nan_error_ratio = check_inf_nan_value(inf_nan_mask, bench_output, device_output,
-                                                                         dtype, rtol)
-                compare_column.rel_err_ratio = check_norm_value(normal_value_mask, rel_err, rtol)
-                compare_column.abs_err_ratio = check_small_value(abs_err, small_value_mask, small_value_atol)
-            elif api_name in ulp_standard_api:
-                if bench_output.size == 0:
-                    compare_column.max_ulp_error = 0
-                    compare_column.mean_ulp_error = 0
-                    compare_column.ulp_error_proportion = 0
-                else:
-                    ulp_err = get_ulp_err(bench_output, device_output, dtype)
-                    compare_column.max_ulp_error = np.max(ulp_err)
-                    compare_column.mean_ulp_error = np.mean(ulp_err)
-                    if dtype == torch.float32:
-                        compare_column.ulp_error_proportion = np.sum(ulp_err > CompareConst.ULP_FLOAT32_THRESHOLD) / bench_output.size
-                    else:
-                        compare_column.ulp_error_proportion = np.sum(ulp_err > CompareConst.ULP_FLOAT16_THRESHOLD) / bench_output.size
-            else:
-                dtype_config = precision_configs.get(dtype)
-                small_value_mask = get_small_value_mask(abs_bench, both_finite_mask, dtype_config['small_value'][0])
-                abs_err_greater_mask = np.greater(abs_err, dtype_config['small_value_atol'][0])
-                compare_column.small_value_err_ratio = get_small_value_err_ratio(small_value_mask, abs_err_greater_mask)
-                rel_err = get_rel_err(abs_err, abs_bench_with_eps, small_value_mask, inf_nan_mask)
-                compare_column.RMSE = get_rmse(abs_err, np.logical_or(inf_nan_mask, small_value_mask))
-                compare_column.EB = get_error_balance(bench_output, device_output)
-                if rel_err.size == 0:
-                    return CompareConst.ERROR, compare_column, "Relative error result list is empty."
-                compare_column.Max_rel_error = get_max_rel_err(rel_err)
-                compare_column.Mean_rel_error = get_mean_rel_err(rel_err)
-
-        cos_res, cos_status, msg = cosine_sim(bench_output, device_output)
-        compare_column.cosine_sim = cos_res
-        message += msg + "\n"
-        if not cos_status:
-            message += "Cosine similarity is less than 0.99, consider as error, skip other check and set to SPACE.\n"
-            return CompareConst.ERROR, compare_column, message
-
-        max_abs_res, max_abs_status = get_max_abs_err(abs_err)
-        compare_column.max_abs_err = max_abs_res
-        if max_abs_status:
-            message += "Max abs error is less than 0.001, consider as pass, skip other check and set to SPACE.\n"
-            return CompareConst.PASS, compare_column, message
-
-        if dtype in [torch.float16, torch.bfloat16]:
-            hundred_res, hundred_status = get_rel_err_ratio(rel_err_orign, CompareConst.HUNDRED_RATIO_THRESHOLD)
-            compare_column.rel_err_hundredth = hundred_res
-            if not hundred_status:
-                message += "Relative error is greater than 0.01, consider as error, skip other check and set to SPACE.\n"
-                return CompareConst.ERROR, compare_column, message
-        thousand_res, thousand_status = get_rel_err_ratio(rel_err_orign, CompareConst.THOUSAND_RATIO_THRESHOLD)
-        compare_column.rel_err_thousandth = thousand_res
-        if dtype in [torch.float16, torch.bfloat16]:
-            if thousand_status:
-                message += "Relative error is less than 0.001, consider as pass, skip other check and set to SPACE.\n"
-                return CompareConst.PASS, compare_column, message
-            message += "Relative error is greater than 0.001, consider as warning, skip other check and set to SPACE.\n"
-            return CompareConst.WARNING, compare_column, message
-        ten_thousand_res, ten_thousand_status = get_rel_err_ratio(rel_err_orign, CompareConst.TEN_THOUSAND_RATIO_THRESHOLD)
-        compare_column.rel_err_ten_thousandth = ten_thousand_res
-        if dtype in [torch.float32, torch.float64]:
-            if not thousand_status:
-                message += "Relative error is greater than 0.001, consider as error, skip other check and set to SPACE.\n"
-                return CompareConst.ERROR, compare_column, message
-            if not ten_thousand_status:
-                message += "Relative error is greater than 0.0001, consider as warning, skip other check and set to SPACE.\n"
-                return CompareConst.WARNING, compare_column, message
-            message += "Relative error is less than 0.0001, consider as pass.\n"
-        return CompareConst.PASS, compare_column, message
+#!/usr/bin/env python3
+# -*- coding: utf-8 -*-
+# Copyright (c) 2024-2024, Huawei Technologies Co., Ltd.
+# All rights reserved.
+#
+# Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0  (the "License");
+# you may not use this file except in compliance with the License.
+# You may obtain a copy of the License at
+#
+# http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0
+#
+# Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software
+# distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS,
+# WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
+# See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
+# limitations under the License.
+
+# 进行比对及结果展示
+import os
+from collections import namedtuple
+
+import numpy as np
+from msprobe.core.common.utils import CompareException
+from msprobe.core.common.file_utils import get_json_contents, write_csv
+import torch
+from msprobe.core.common.const import CompareConst
+from msprobe.pytorch.api_accuracy_checker.compare.algorithm import get_rmse, get_error_balance, get_max_rel_err, \
+    get_mean_rel_err, get_rel_err, get_abs_err, get_max_abs_err, get_rel_err_ratio, cosine_sim, get_rel_err_origin, \
+    get_small_value_err_ratio, get_finite_and_infinite_mask, get_small_value_mask, check_inf_nan_value, \
+    check_small_value, check_norm_value, get_abs_bench_with_eps, get_ulp_err
+from msprobe.pytorch.api_accuracy_checker.common.config import msCheckerConfig
+from msprobe.pytorch.api_accuracy_checker.compare.compare_column import CompareColumn
+from msprobe.pytorch.api_accuracy_checker.compare.compare_utils import check_dtype_comparable, \
+    DETAIL_TEST_ROWS, precision_configs, BENCHMARK_COMPARE_SUPPORT_LIST, absolute_standard_api, binary_standard_api, \
+    ulp_standard_api, thousandth_standard_api, apis_threshold
+from msprobe.pytorch.api_accuracy_checker.common.utils import extract_basic_api_segments
+from msprobe.pytorch.common.log import logger
+
+
+ResultInfo = namedtuple('ResultInfo', ['full_api_name', 'fwd_success_status', 'bwd_success_status',
+                                       'fwd_compare_alg_results', 'bwd_compare_alg_results', 'rank'])
+
+
+INDEX_TEST_RESULT_GROUP = 3
+INDEX_FIRST_GROUP = 0
+INDEX_MESSAGE = -1
+
+
+class Comparator:
+    # consts for result csv
+    COLUMN_API_NAME = "API name"
+    COLUMN_FORWARD_SUCCESS = "Forward Test Success"
+    COLUMN_BACKWARD_SUCCESS = "Backward Test Success"
+    COLUMN_STACK_INFO = "Traceback callstack info"
+
+    def __init__(self, result_csv_path, details_csv_path, is_continue_run_ut, stack_info_json_path=None, config=None):
+        self.save_path_str = result_csv_path
+        self.detail_save_path_str = details_csv_path
+        self.save_path_list = [result_csv_path]
+        self.detail_save_path_list = [details_csv_path]
+
+        if config and config.online_config.is_online:
+            self.save_path_str = result_csv_path.replace(".csv", "_rank{}.csv")
+            self.detail_save_path_str = details_csv_path.replace(".csv", "_rank{}.csv")
+            self.save_path_list = [self.save_path_str.format(rank) for rank in config.online_config.rank_list]
+            self.detail_save_path_list = \
+                [self.detail_save_path_str.format(rank) for rank in config.online_config.rank_list]
+
+        if not is_continue_run_ut:
+            self.write_csv_title()
+        if stack_info_json_path:
+            self.stack_info = get_json_contents(stack_info_json_path)
+        else:
+            self.stack_info = None
+
+    @staticmethod
+    def get_path_from_rank(rank, path_list, path_pattern):
+        return path_list[-1] if len(path_list) == 1 else path_pattern.format(rank)
+
+    @staticmethod
+    def print_pretest_result():
+        logger.info("Successfully completed run_ut/multi_run_ut.")
+
+    @staticmethod
+    def _compare_dropout(bench_output, device_output):
+        tensor_num = bench_output.numel()
+        if tensor_num >= 100:
+            if abs((bench_output == 0).sum() - (device_output == 0).cpu().sum()) / tensor_num < 0.1:
+                return CompareConst.PASS, 1
+            else:
+                return CompareConst.ERROR, 0
+        else:
+            return CompareConst.PASS, 1
+
+    @staticmethod
+    def _compare_builtin_type(bench_output, device_output, compare_column):
+        if not isinstance(bench_output, (bool, int, float, str)):
+            return CompareConst.PASS, compare_column, ""
+        if bench_output != device_output:
+            return CompareConst.ERROR, compare_column, ""
+        compare_column.error_rate = 0
+        return CompareConst.PASS, compare_column, ""
+
+    @staticmethod
+    def _compare_bool_tensor(bench_output, device_output):
+        error_nums = (bench_output != device_output).sum()
+        if bench_output.size == 0:
+            return CompareConst.NAN, CompareConst.ERROR, "There is not bench calculation result."
+        error_rate = float(error_nums / bench_output.size)
+        result = CompareConst.PASS if error_rate == 0 else CompareConst.ERROR
+        return error_rate, result, ""
+
+    @staticmethod
+    def _get_absolute_threshold_attribute(api_name, dtype):
+        small_value_threshold = apis_threshold.get(api_name).get(dtype).get('small_value')
+        small_value_atol = apis_threshold.get(api_name).get(dtype).get('small_value_atol')
+        rtol = apis_threshold.get(api_name).get(dtype).get('rtol')
+        return small_value_threshold, small_value_atol, rtol
+
+    @staticmethod
+    def _get_run_ut_detail(test_result):
+        """get run_ut detail before write to csv, called by online run_ut"""
+        test_rows = []
+        try:
+            subject_prefix = test_result[0]
+            fwd_result = test_result[3]
+            bwd_result = test_result[4]
+        except IndexError as e:
+            logger.error("List index out of bounds when writing detail CSV.")
+            raise CompareException(CompareException.INDEX_OUT_OF_BOUNDS_ERROR, "list index out of bounds") from e
+
+        if isinstance(fwd_result, list):
+            for i, test_subject in enumerate(fwd_result):
+                subject = subject_prefix + ".forward.output." + str(i)
+                test_subject = ["{:.{}f}".format(item, msCheckerConfig.precision)
+                                if isinstance(item, float) else item for item in test_subject]
+                test_rows.append([subject] + list(test_subject))
+        if isinstance(bwd_result, list):
+            for i, test_subject in enumerate(bwd_result):
+                subject = subject_prefix + ".backward.output." + str(i)
+                test_subject = ["{:.{}f}".format(item, msCheckerConfig.precision)
+                                if isinstance(item, float) else item for item in test_subject]
+                test_rows.append([subject] + list(test_subject))
+        return test_rows
+
+    def write_csv_title(self):
+        summary_test_rows = [
+            [self.COLUMN_API_NAME, 
+             self.COLUMN_FORWARD_SUCCESS,
+             self.COLUMN_BACKWARD_SUCCESS,
+             "Message"]
+            ]
+        for save_path, detail_save_path in zip(self.save_path_list, self.detail_save_path_list):
+            if not os.path.exists(save_path):
+                write_csv(summary_test_rows, save_path)
+            if not os.path.exists(detail_save_path):
+                write_csv(DETAIL_TEST_ROWS, detail_save_path)
+
+    def write_summary_csv(self, test_result):
+        test_rows = []
+        try:
+            name = test_result[0]
+            df_row = list(test_result[:INDEX_TEST_RESULT_GROUP])
+            if test_result[1] == CompareConst.SKIP:
+                df_row.append(test_result[INDEX_TEST_RESULT_GROUP][INDEX_FIRST_GROUP][INDEX_MESSAGE])
+            if self.stack_info:
+                stack_info = "\n".join(self.stack_info[name])
+                df_row.append(stack_info)
+            test_rows.append(df_row)
+            save_path = self.get_path_from_rank(test_result[-1], self.save_path_list, self.save_path_str)
+        except IndexError as e:
+            logger.error("List index out of bounds when writing summary CSV.")
+            raise CompareException(CompareException.INDEX_OUT_OF_BOUNDS_ERROR, "list index out of bounds") from e
+        write_csv(test_rows, save_path)
+
+    def write_detail_csv(self, test_result):
+        test_rows = self._get_run_ut_detail(test_result)
+        detail_save_path = self.get_path_from_rank(test_result[-1],
+                                                   self.detail_save_path_list,
+                                                   self.detail_save_path_str)
+        write_csv(test_rows, detail_save_path)
+
+    def record_results(self, args):
+        self.write_summary_csv(args)
+        self.write_detail_csv(args)
+
+
+    def compare_output(self, full_api_name, data_info, is_online=False):
+        """Get compare result and write to result and detail csv.
+        is_online: bool, default False. True: called by online api precision compare, only compare without write to csv.
+        """
+        _, api_name = extract_basic_api_segments(full_api_name)
+        if not api_name:
+            raise ValueError(f"API name {full_api_name} has not been adapted.")
+        bench_output, device_output = data_info.bench_output, data_info.device_output
+        bench_grad, device_grad = data_info.bench_grad, data_info.device_grad
+        backward_message = data_info.backward_message
+        if "dropout" in full_api_name:
+            fwd_success_status, fwd_compare_alg_results = self._compare_dropout(bench_output, device_output)
+        else:
+            fwd_success_status, fwd_compare_alg_results = self._compare_core_wrapper(api_name, bench_output,
+                                                                                     device_output)
+        if not (bench_grad and device_grad):
+            bwd_success_status, bwd_compare_alg_results = (CompareConst.SPACE, [])
+        else:
+            if "dropout" in full_api_name:
+                bwd_success_status, bwd_compare_alg_results = self._compare_dropout(bench_grad[0], device_grad[0])
+            else:
+                bwd_success_status, bwd_compare_alg_results = self._compare_core_wrapper(api_name, bench_grad,
+                                                                                         device_grad)
+        if backward_message:
+            backward_column = CompareColumn()
+            bwd_compare_alg_results = [backward_column.to_column_value(CompareConst.SKIP, backward_message)]
+        else:
+            bwd_success_status = bwd_success_status if bwd_compare_alg_results is not None else CompareConst.SPACE
+        result_info = ResultInfo(full_api_name,
+                                 fwd_success_status,
+                                 bwd_success_status,
+                                 fwd_compare_alg_results,
+                                 bwd_compare_alg_results,
+                                 data_info.rank)
+        if is_online:
+            # get run_ut compare detail
+            return self._get_run_ut_detail(result_info)
+        self.record_results(result_info)
+        return fwd_success_status == CompareConst.PASS, bwd_success_status == CompareConst.PASS \
+               or bwd_success_status == CompareConst.SPACE
+
+    def _compare_core_wrapper(self, api_name, bench_output, device_output):
+        detailed_result_total = []
+        test_final_success = CompareConst.PASS
+        if isinstance(bench_output, (list, tuple)):
+            status, compare_result, message = [], [], []
+            if len(bench_output) > len(device_output):
+                status = [CompareConst.ERROR]
+                message = ["bench and npu output structure is different."]
+            else:
+                device_output = device_output[:len(bench_output)]
+                for b_out_i, n_out_i in zip(bench_output, device_output):
+                    status_i, compare_result_i, message_i = self._compare_core(api_name, b_out_i, n_out_i)
+                    status.append(status_i)
+                    compare_result.append(compare_result_i)
+                    message.append(message_i)
+        else:
+            status, compare_result, message = self._compare_core(api_name, bench_output, device_output)
+        if not isinstance(status, list):
+            detailed_result_total.append(compare_result.to_column_value(status, message))
+            if status == CompareConst.ERROR:
+                test_final_success = CompareConst.ERROR
+            elif status == CompareConst.WARNING:
+                test_final_success = CompareConst.WARNING
+        else:
+            for item, item_status in enumerate(status):
+                detailed_result_total.append(compare_result[item].to_column_value(item_status, message[item]))
+                if item_status == CompareConst.ERROR:
+                    test_final_success = CompareConst.ERROR
+                elif item_status == CompareConst.WARNING:
+                    test_final_success = CompareConst.WARNING
+        return test_final_success, detailed_result_total
+
+    def _compare_core(self, api_name, bench_output, device_output):
+        compare_column = CompareColumn()
+        if not isinstance(bench_output, type(device_output)):
+            status = CompareConst.ERROR
+            message = "bench and npu output type is different."
+        elif isinstance(bench_output, dict):
+            b_keys, n_keys = set(bench_output.keys()), set(device_output.keys())
+            if b_keys != n_keys:
+                status = CompareConst.ERROR
+                message = "bench and npu output dict keys are different."
+            else:
+                status, compare_column, message = self._compare_core(api_name, list(bench_output.values()),
+                                                                     list(device_output.values()))
+        elif isinstance(bench_output, torch.Tensor):
+            copy_bench_out = bench_output.detach().clone()
+            copy_device_output = device_output.detach().clone()
+            compare_column.bench_type = str(copy_bench_out.dtype)
+            compare_column.npu_type = str(copy_device_output.dtype)
+            compare_column.shape = tuple(device_output.shape)
+            status, compare_column, message = self._compare_torch_tensor(api_name, copy_bench_out, copy_device_output,
+                                                                         compare_column)
+        elif isinstance(bench_output, (bool, int, float, str)):
+            compare_column.bench_type = str(type(bench_output))
+            compare_column.npu_type = str(type(device_output))
+            status, compare_column, message = self._compare_builtin_type(bench_output, device_output, compare_column)
+        elif bench_output is None:
+            status = CompareConst.SKIP
+            message = "Bench output is None, skip this test."
+        else:
+            status = CompareConst.ERROR
+            message = "Unexpected output type in compare_core: {}".format(type(bench_output))
+
+        return status, compare_column, message
+
+    def _compare_torch_tensor(self, api_name, bench_output, device_output, compare_column):
+        cpu_shape = bench_output.shape
+        npu_shape = device_output.shape
+        npu_dtype = device_output.dtype
+        if npu_dtype == torch.bfloat16:
+            bench_output = bench_output.to(torch.float32)
+            device_output = device_output.to(torch.float32)
+        bench_output = bench_output.cpu().numpy()
+        device_output = device_output.cpu().numpy()
+        if cpu_shape != npu_shape:
+            return CompareConst.ERROR, compare_column, f"The shape of bench{str(cpu_shape)} " \
+                                                       f"and npu{str(npu_shape)} not equal."
+        if not check_dtype_comparable(bench_output, device_output):
+            return CompareConst.ERROR, compare_column, f"Bench out dtype is {bench_output.dtype} but " \
+                                                       f"npu output dtype is {device_output.dtype}, cannot compare."
+        message = ""
+        if bench_output.dtype in [bool, np.uint8, np.int8, np.int16, np.uint16, np.uint32, np.int32,
+                                  np.int64, np.uint64]:
+            message += f"Compare algorithm is not supported for {bench_output.dtype} data. " \
+                       f"Only judged by Error Rate."
+            err_rate, status, msg = self._compare_bool_tensor(bench_output, device_output)
+            message += msg + "\n"
+            compare_column.error_rate = err_rate
+            return status, compare_column, message
+        else:
+            status, compare_column, message = self._compare_float_tensor(api_name, bench_output, device_output,
+                                                                         compare_column, npu_dtype)
+            return status, compare_column, message
+
+    def _compare_float_tensor(self, api_name, bench_output, device_output, compare_column, dtype):
+        message = ""
+        abs_bench, abs_bench_with_eps = get_abs_bench_with_eps(bench_output, dtype)
+        abs_err = get_abs_err(bench_output, device_output)
+        rel_err_orign = get_rel_err_origin(abs_err, abs_bench_with_eps)
+        if api_name in thousandth_standard_api:
+            thousand_res, thousand_status = get_rel_err_ratio(rel_err_orign, CompareConst.THOUSAND_RATIO_THRESHOLD)
+            compare_column.rel_err_thousandth = thousand_res
+        if str(dtype) in BENCHMARK_COMPARE_SUPPORT_LIST:
+            both_finite_mask, inf_nan_mask = get_finite_and_infinite_mask(bench_output, device_output)
+            if api_name in binary_standard_api:
+                err_rate, _, _ = self._compare_bool_tensor(bench_output, device_output)
+                compare_column.error_rate = err_rate
+            elif api_name in absolute_standard_api:
+                small_value_threshold, small_value_atol, rtol = self._get_absolute_threshold_attribute(
+                    api_name, str(dtype))
+                rel_err = abs_err / abs_bench_with_eps
+                small_value_mask = get_small_value_mask(abs_bench, both_finite_mask, small_value_threshold)
+                normal_value_mask = np.logical_and(both_finite_mask, np.logical_not(small_value_mask))
+                compare_column.inf_nan_error_ratio = check_inf_nan_value(inf_nan_mask, bench_output, device_output,
+                                                                         dtype, rtol)
+                compare_column.rel_err_ratio = check_norm_value(normal_value_mask, rel_err, rtol)
+                compare_column.abs_err_ratio = check_small_value(abs_err, small_value_mask, small_value_atol)
+            elif api_name in ulp_standard_api:
+                if bench_output.size == 0:
+                    compare_column.max_ulp_error = 0
+                    compare_column.mean_ulp_error = 0
+                    compare_column.ulp_error_proportion = 0
+                else:
+                    ulp_err = get_ulp_err(bench_output, device_output, dtype)
+                    compare_column.max_ulp_error = np.max(ulp_err)
+                    compare_column.mean_ulp_error = np.mean(ulp_err)
+                    if dtype == torch.float32:
+                        compare_column.ulp_error_proportion = \
+                        np.sum(ulp_err > CompareConst.ULP_FLOAT32_THRESHOLD) / bench_output.size
+                    else:
+                        compare_column.ulp_error_proportion = \
+                            np.sum(ulp_err > CompareConst.ULP_FLOAT16_THRESHOLD) / bench_output.size
+            else:
+                dtype_config = precision_configs.get(dtype)
+                small_value_mask = get_small_value_mask(abs_bench, both_finite_mask, dtype_config['small_value'][0])
+                abs_err_greater_mask = np.greater(abs_err, dtype_config['small_value_atol'][0])
+                compare_column.small_value_err_ratio = get_small_value_err_ratio(small_value_mask, abs_err_greater_mask)
+                rel_err = get_rel_err(abs_err, abs_bench_with_eps, small_value_mask, inf_nan_mask)
+                compare_column.rmse = get_rmse(abs_err, np.logical_or(inf_nan_mask, small_value_mask))
+                compare_column.eb = get_error_balance(bench_output, device_output)
+                if rel_err.size == 0:
+                    return CompareConst.ERROR, compare_column, "Relative error result list is empty."
+                compare_column.max_rel_error = get_max_rel_err(rel_err)
+                compare_column.mean_rel_error = get_mean_rel_err(rel_err)
+
+        cos_res, cos_status, msg = cosine_sim(bench_output, device_output)
+        compare_column.cosine_sim = cos_res
+        message += msg + "\n"
+        if not cos_status:
+            message += "Cosine similarity is less than 0.99, consider as error, skip other check and set to SPACE.\n"
+            return CompareConst.ERROR, compare_column, message
+
+        max_abs_res, max_abs_status = get_max_abs_err(abs_err)
+        compare_column.max_abs_err = max_abs_res
+        if max_abs_status:
+            message += "Max abs error is less than 0.001, consider as pass, skip other check and set to SPACE.\n"
+            return CompareConst.PASS, compare_column, message
+
+        if dtype in [torch.float16, torch.bfloat16]:
+            hundred_res, hundred_status = get_rel_err_ratio(rel_err_orign, CompareConst.HUNDRED_RATIO_THRESHOLD)
+            compare_column.rel_err_hundredth = hundred_res
+            if not hundred_status:
+                message += "Relative error is greater than 0.01, consider as error, " \
+                           "skip other check and set to SPACE.\n"
+                return CompareConst.ERROR, compare_column, message
+        thousand_res, thousand_status = get_rel_err_ratio(rel_err_orign, CompareConst.THOUSAND_RATIO_THRESHOLD)
+        compare_column.rel_err_thousandth = thousand_res
+        if dtype in [torch.float16, torch.bfloat16]:
+            if thousand_status:
+                message += "Relative error is less than 0.001, consider as pass, skip other check and set to SPACE.\n"
+                return CompareConst.PASS, compare_column, message
+            message += "Relative error is greater than 0.001, consider as warning, skip other check and set to SPACE.\n"
+            return CompareConst.WARNING, compare_column, message
+        ten_thousand_res, ten_thousand_status = get_rel_err_ratio(
+                                                rel_err_orign, CompareConst.TEN_THOUSAND_RATIO_THRESHOLD)
+        compare_column.rel_err_ten_thousandth = ten_thousand_res
+        if dtype in [torch.float32, torch.float64]:
+            if not thousand_status:
+                message += "Relative error is greater than 0.001, consider as error, " \
+                           "skip other check and set to SPACE.\n"
+                return CompareConst.ERROR, compare_column, message
+            if not ten_thousand_status:
+                message += "Relative error is greater than 0.0001, consider as warning, " \
+                           "skip other check and set to SPACE.\n"
+                return CompareConst.WARNING, compare_column, message
+            message += "Relative error is less than 0.0001, consider as pass.\n"
+        return CompareConst.PASS, compare_column, message