aiox-core 5.0.3 → 5.0.4

package/pro/squads/design/data/brad-frost-analysis-qa-report.yaml

@@ -1,168 +1,168 @@
-qa_report:
-  generated: "2026-02-16"
-  component: "outputs/minds/brad-frost/agent/design-system-v5.md"
-  type: agent
-  pipeline: "QA After Creation v1"
-
-  summary:
-    result: PASS
-    score: 8.65
-    issues_found: 2
-    total_lines: ~1910
-    version: "v5.0.1"
-
-  # ═══════════════════════════════════════════
-  # PHASE 1: Quick Checks
-  # ═══════════════════════════════════════════
-  quick_checks:
-    file_exists: true
-    valid_markdown: true
-    valid_yaml_block: true
-    yaml_block_opens: "line 13 (```yaml)"
-    yaml_block_closes: "line 1910 (```)"
-    unclosed_code_blocks: 0
-    broken_headers: 0
-    required_metadata:
-      agent_name: "Design System (Brad Frost)"
-      agent_id: "design-system"
-      persona_present: true
-      customization_present: true
-      commands_section_present: true
-      commands_count: 50
-    activation_instructions_present: true
-    result: PASS
-
-  # ═══════════════════════════════════════════
-  # PHASE 2: Security Scan
-  # ═══════════════════════════════════════════
-  security_scan:
-    api_keys_found: 0
-    secrets_found: 0
-    passwords_found: 0
-    bearer_tokens_found: 0
-    jwt_tokens_found: 0
-    aws_credentials_found: 0
-    database_connection_strings_found: 0
-    private_keys_found: 0
-    sensitive_file_references_found: 0
-    env_file_references: 0
-    pem_file_references: 0
-    credentials_json_references: 0
-    result: PASS
-    notes: "No security issues detected. File contains only agent configuration, no credentials."
-
-  # ═══════════════════════════════════════════
-  # PHASE 3: Structure Validation
-  # ═══════════════════════════════════════════
-  structure_validation:
-    activation_instructions: true
-    commands_section: true
-    dependency_references:
-      tasks_declared: 39
-      tasks_existence_check: "WARNING - task files not found in outputs/minds/brad-frost/ directory (only agent/ analysis/ dna/ folders exist)"
-      note: "Dependencies are declared but use pack-relative paths (tasks/*, templates/*, etc.). The brad-frost mind folder only contains agent/, analysis/, dna/. Task files may reside elsewhere or be unresolved."
-    handoff_to_targets:
-      declared:
-        - "Frontend infrastructure specialist"
-        - "Change management consultant"
-        - "Accessibility specialist"
-        - "Backend architect"
-      status: "Generic role references, not agent IDs - acceptable for handoff guidance"
-    expert_routing_dna_paths:
-      val-head:
-        path: "outputs/minds/val-head/dna/val-head-dna.yaml"
-        exists: true
-      steve-kinney:
-        path: "outputs/minds/steve-kinney/dna/steve-kinney-dna.yaml"
-        exists: true
-      nathan-curtis:
-        path: "outputs/minds/nathan-curtis/dna/nathan-curtis-dna.yaml"
-        exists: true
-      dan-mall:
-        path: "outputs/minds/dan-mall/dna/dan-mall-dna.yaml"
-        exists: true
-      jina-anne:
-        path: "outputs/minds/jina-anne/dna/jina-anne-dna.yaml"
-        exists: true
-      kaelig-deloumeau-prigent:
-        path: "outputs/minds/kaelig-deloumeau-prigent/dna/kaelig-deloumeau-prigent-dna.yaml"
-        exists: true
-    expert_routing_paths_valid: "6/6 (100%)"
-    result: CONDITIONAL
-    note: "Task dependency files not verifiable in current directory structure. Expert routing paths all valid."
-
-  # ═══════════════════════════════════════════
-  # PHASE 4: Quality Scoring
-  # ═══════════════════════════════════════════
-  quality_score:
-    criteria:
-      - name: "Persona completeness"
-        weight: 0.20
-        score: 10
-        weighted: 2.00
-        details: "role, style, identity, focus all present. Full voice_dna with identity_statement, vocabulary (14 power_words, 12 signature_phrases with sources, 4 metaphor categories), tone dimensions (7 axes + 4 context variations), anti_patterns, immune_system, voice_contradictions. Thinking_dna with primary + 3 secondary frameworks, diagnostic framework, heuristics, decision architecture, recognition patterns, objection handling, handoff triggers. Exceptionally thorough."
-
-      - name: "Commands functionality"
-        weight: 0.20
-        score: 9
-        weighted: 1.80
-        details: "*help exists. 50 commands mapped to capabilities across 20 phases. Each command has description and usage. COMMAND-TO-TASK MAPPING provides direct Read() paths for token optimization. Minor: some commands reference tasks that could not be verified."
-
-      - name: "Voice consistency"
-        weight: 0.15
-        score: 10
-        weighted: 1.50
-        details: "voice_dna present with full vocabulary, signature_phrases (12 with sources), metaphors (4 categories), storytelling patterns, writing_style, tone dimensions. 22 source citations. Research-grounded with 0.95 confidence. Anti-patterns and immune_system define voice boundaries."
-
-      - name: "Examples quality"
-        weight: 0.15
-        score: 8
-        weighted: 1.20
-        details: "4 output_examples covering brownfield (70%), greenfield (20%), audit-only (10%), and YOLO refactoring. Realistic session flows with user/Brad dialogue. Missing: no example for expert routing (*ask) or accessibility workflow."
-
-      - name: "Dependencies valid"
-        weight: 0.15
-        score: 7
-        weighted: 1.05
-        details: "39 tasks, 12 templates, 7 checklists, 14 data files, 4 refactoring templates declared. Expert DNA paths (6/6) verified. However, task/template/checklist/data files not found in brad-frost directory - they may use a different resolution mechanism (pack-relative paths)."
-
-      - name: "Documentation"
-        weight: 0.15
-        score: 8
-        weighted: 1.20
-        details: "whenToUse is clear and comprehensive. Description helpful. Workflow section documents brownfield, greenfield, refactoring, and accessibility flows with phases, commands, outputs, and success criteria. Status section has detailed changelog. Minor: no standalone README or quick-start section."
-
-    total_weighted_score: 8.75
-    final_score: 8.75
-
-  # ═══════════════════════════════════════════
-  # PHASE 5: Issues
-  # ═══════════════════════════════════════════
-  issues:
-    blocking: []
-    warnings:
-      - id: "W001"
-        severity: warning
-        category: dependencies
-        description: "39 task files, 12 templates, 7 checklists, and 14 data files declared in dependencies section but not found in outputs/minds/brad-frost/ directory. Only agent/, analysis/, and dna/ folders exist."
-        recommendation: "Verify task files exist at the expected pack-relative resolution path, or document where they should be located for IDE-FILE-RESOLUTION to work correctly."
-
-      - id: "W002"
-        severity: warning
-        category: examples
-        description: "No example session demonstrating expert routing (*ask {expert}) or the accessibility workflow, despite these being key v5.0 features."
-        recommendation: "Add example sessions for *ask nathan and *a11y-audit to showcase expert routing and accessibility flows."
-
-  # ═══════════════════════════════════════════
-  # Recommendation
-  # ═══════════════════════════════════════════
-  recommendation:
-    verdict: PASS
-    score: 8.75
-    summary: |
-      The Brad Frost Design System v5 agent is a comprehensive, well-structured agent definition
-      with exceptional persona depth. The research-grounded DNA fusion (voice_dna + thinking_dna)
-      with 22 source citations sets a high bar for agent authenticity. 50 commands across 20 phases
-      cover the full design system lifecycle. Expert routing to 6 specialist DNAs is fully functional
-      with all paths verified. Two minor warnings relate to unverifiable task file dependencies and
-      missing example coverage for new v5.0 features. No security issues detected.
+qa_report:
+  generated: "2026-02-16"
+  component: "outputs/minds/brad-frost/agent/design-system-v5.md"
+  type: agent
+  pipeline: "QA After Creation v1"
+
+  summary:
+    result: PASS
+    score: 8.65
+    issues_found: 2
+    total_lines: ~1910
+    version: "v5.0.1"
+
+  # ═══════════════════════════════════════════
+  # PHASE 1: Quick Checks
+  # ═══════════════════════════════════════════
+  quick_checks:
+    file_exists: true
+    valid_markdown: true
+    valid_yaml_block: true
+    yaml_block_opens: "line 13 (```yaml)"
+    yaml_block_closes: "line 1910 (```)"
+    unclosed_code_blocks: 0
+    broken_headers: 0
+    required_metadata:
+      agent_name: "Design System (Brad Frost)"
+      agent_id: "design-system"
+      persona_present: true
+      customization_present: true
+      commands_section_present: true
+      commands_count: 50
+    activation_instructions_present: true
+    result: PASS
+
+  # ═══════════════════════════════════════════
+  # PHASE 2: Security Scan
+  # ═══════════════════════════════════════════
+  security_scan:
+    api_keys_found: 0
+    secrets_found: 0
+    passwords_found: 0
+    bearer_tokens_found: 0
+    jwt_tokens_found: 0
+    aws_credentials_found: 0
+    database_connection_strings_found: 0
+    private_keys_found: 0
+    sensitive_file_references_found: 0
+    env_file_references: 0
+    pem_file_references: 0
+    credentials_json_references: 0
+    result: PASS
+    notes: "No security issues detected. File contains only agent configuration, no credentials."
+
+  # ═══════════════════════════════════════════
+  # PHASE 3: Structure Validation
+  # ═══════════════════════════════════════════
+  structure_validation:
+    activation_instructions: true
+    commands_section: true
+    dependency_references:
+      tasks_declared: 39
+      tasks_existence_check: "WARNING - task files not found in outputs/minds/brad-frost/ directory (only agent/ analysis/ dna/ folders exist)"
+      note: "Dependencies are declared but use pack-relative paths (tasks/*, templates/*, etc.). The brad-frost mind folder only contains agent/, analysis/, dna/. Task files may reside elsewhere or be unresolved."
+    handoff_to_targets:
+      declared:
+        - "Frontend infrastructure specialist"
+        - "Change management consultant"
+        - "Accessibility specialist"
+        - "Backend architect"
+      status: "Generic role references, not agent IDs - acceptable for handoff guidance"
+    expert_routing_dna_paths:
+      val-head:
+        path: "outputs/minds/val-head/dna/val-head-dna.yaml"
+        exists: true
+      steve-kinney:
+        path: "outputs/minds/steve-kinney/dna/steve-kinney-dna.yaml"
+        exists: true
+      nathan-curtis:
+        path: "outputs/minds/nathan-curtis/dna/nathan-curtis-dna.yaml"
+        exists: true
+      dan-mall:
+        path: "outputs/minds/dan-mall/dna/dan-mall-dna.yaml"
+        exists: true
+      jina-anne:
+        path: "outputs/minds/jina-anne/dna/jina-anne-dna.yaml"
+        exists: true
+      kaelig-deloumeau-prigent:
+        path: "outputs/minds/kaelig-deloumeau-prigent/dna/kaelig-deloumeau-prigent-dna.yaml"
+        exists: true
+    expert_routing_paths_valid: "6/6 (100%)"
+    result: CONDITIONAL
+    note: "Task dependency files not verifiable in current directory structure. Expert routing paths all valid."
+
+  # ═══════════════════════════════════════════
+  # PHASE 4: Quality Scoring
+  # ═══════════════════════════════════════════
+  quality_score:
+    criteria:
+      - name: "Persona completeness"
+        weight: 0.20
+        score: 10
+        weighted: 2.00
+        details: "role, style, identity, focus all present. Full voice_dna with identity_statement, vocabulary (14 power_words, 12 signature_phrases with sources, 4 metaphor categories), tone dimensions (7 axes + 4 context variations), anti_patterns, immune_system, voice_contradictions. Thinking_dna with primary + 3 secondary frameworks, diagnostic framework, heuristics, decision architecture, recognition patterns, objection handling, handoff triggers. Exceptionally thorough."
+
+      - name: "Commands functionality"
+        weight: 0.20
+        score: 9
+        weighted: 1.80
+        details: "*help exists. 50 commands mapped to capabilities across 20 phases. Each command has description and usage. COMMAND-TO-TASK MAPPING provides direct Read() paths for token optimization. Minor: some commands reference tasks that could not be verified."
+
+      - name: "Voice consistency"
+        weight: 0.15
+        score: 10
+        weighted: 1.50
+        details: "voice_dna present with full vocabulary, signature_phrases (12 with sources), metaphors (4 categories), storytelling patterns, writing_style, tone dimensions. 22 source citations. Research-grounded with 0.95 confidence. Anti-patterns and immune_system define voice boundaries."
+
+      - name: "Examples quality"
+        weight: 0.15
+        score: 8
+        weighted: 1.20
+        details: "4 output_examples covering brownfield (70%), greenfield (20%), audit-only (10%), and YOLO refactoring. Realistic session flows with user/Brad dialogue. Missing: no example for expert routing (*ask) or accessibility workflow."
+
+      - name: "Dependencies valid"
+        weight: 0.15
+        score: 7
+        weighted: 1.05
+        details: "39 tasks, 12 templates, 7 checklists, 14 data files, 4 refactoring templates declared. Expert DNA paths (6/6) verified. However, task/template/checklist/data files not found in brad-frost directory - they may use a different resolution mechanism (pack-relative paths)."
+
+      - name: "Documentation"
+        weight: 0.15
+        score: 8
+        weighted: 1.20
+        details: "whenToUse is clear and comprehensive. Description helpful. Workflow section documents brownfield, greenfield, refactoring, and accessibility flows with phases, commands, outputs, and success criteria. Status section has detailed changelog. Minor: no standalone README or quick-start section."
+
+    total_weighted_score: 8.75
+    final_score: 8.75
+
+  # ═══════════════════════════════════════════
+  # PHASE 5: Issues
+  # ═══════════════════════════════════════════
+  issues:
+    blocking: []
+    warnings:
+      - id: "W001"
+        severity: warning
+        category: dependencies
+        description: "39 task files, 12 templates, 7 checklists, and 14 data files declared in dependencies section but not found in outputs/minds/brad-frost/ directory. Only agent/, analysis/, and dna/ folders exist."
+        recommendation: "Verify task files exist at the expected pack-relative resolution path, or document where they should be located for IDE-FILE-RESOLUTION to work correctly."
+
+      - id: "W002"
+        severity: warning
+        category: examples
+        description: "No example session demonstrating expert routing (*ask {expert}) or the accessibility workflow, despite these being key v5.0 features."
+        recommendation: "Add example sessions for *ask nathan and *a11y-audit to showcase expert routing and accessibility flows."
+
+  # ═══════════════════════════════════════════
+  # Recommendation
+  # ═══════════════════════════════════════════
+  recommendation:
+    verdict: PASS
+    score: 8.75
+    summary: |
+      The Brad Frost Design System v5 agent is a comprehensive, well-structured agent definition
+      with exceptional persona depth. The research-grounded DNA fusion (voice_dna + thinking_dna)
+      with 22 source citations sets a high bar for agent authenticity. 50 commands across 20 phases
+      cover the full design system lifecycle. Expert routing to 6 specialist DNAs is fully functional
+      with all paths verified. Two minor warnings relate to unverifiable task file dependencies and
+      missing example coverage for new v5.0 features. No security issues detected.