siesa-agents 2.1.78 → 2.1.80

package/siesa-agents/bmm/workflows/5-documentation/create-user-guide/steps/step-07-validacion-guardado.md

@@ -0,0 +1,467 @@
+---
+name: 'step-07-validacion-guardado'
+description: 'Validate Spanish user guide and save as single file'
+
+# Path Definitions
+workflow_path: '{project-root}/_siesa-agents/bmm/workflows/5-documentation/create-user-guide'
+
+# File References
+thisStepFile: '{workflow_path}/steps/step-07-validacion-guardado.md'
+workflowFile: '{workflow_path}/workflow.md'
+featuresOutputFolder: '{output_folder}/documentation-artifacts/user-guide'
+# Validates each: {featuresOutputFolder}/{slug}-guide.md
+
+# Loop reference (for corrections)
+correctionTargetStep: '{workflow_path}/steps/step-05-generacion-espanol.md'
+
+# Task References
+advancedElicitationTask: 'skill:bmad-advanced-elicitation'
+partyModeWorkflow: 'skill:bmad-party-mode'
+
+# Config
+bmmConfig: '{project-root}/_bmad/bmm/config.yaml'
+---
+
+# Step 7: Validación y Guardado
+
+## STEP GOAL:
+
+Ejecutar validación comprehensiva (self-check) de cada archivo de feature generado (`{slug}-guide.md`), verificar cumplimiento de criterios de éxito por archivo, presentar resultados consolidados al usuario y permitir correcciones si es necesario. Si todo está correcto, marcar cada archivo como `approved` y actualizar `{workflowStateFile}`.
+
+## MANDATORY EXECUTION RULES (READ FIRST):
+
+### Universal Rules:
+
+- 🛑 NEVER generate content without user input
+- 📖 CRITICAL: Read the complete step file before taking any action
+- 🔄 CRITICAL: When loading next step with 'C', ensure entire file is read
+- 📋 YOU ARE A FACILITATOR, not a content generator
+- ✅ YOU MUST ALWAYS SPEAK OUTPUT In your Agent communication style with the config `{communication_language}`
+
+### Role Reinforcement:
+
+- ✅ You are a quality assurance specialist and technical writer
+- ✅ If you already have been given communication or persona patterns, continue to use those while playing this new role
+- ✅ We engage in collaborative dialogue, not command-response
+- ✅ You bring quality validation expertise, user brings approval authority
+- ✅ Maintain collaborative professional tone throughout
+
+### Step-Specific Rules:
+
+- 🎯 Focus ONLY on validation and finalization (PRESCRIPTIVE)
+- 🚫 FORBIDDEN to skip validation checks
+- 💬 Present clear validation results
+- 🔄 Support loop back to step-05 if corrections needed
+
+## EXECUTION PROTOCOLS:
+
+- 🎯 Execute all validation checks systematically
+- 💾 Only save/finalize with user approval
+- 🔄 LOOP to step-05 if issues found and user requests fixes
+
+## CONTEXT BOUNDARIES:
+
+- Complete Spanish guide
+- All frontmatter metrics
+- This is final quality gate before delivery
+- User has final approval authority
+
+## TOP 5 NON-NEGOTIABLE CRITERIA:
+
+1. **📄 Spanish Output Completo:** El archivo de guía existe, no está vacío y tiene todas las secciones requeridas
+2. **🔗 Source Citations Obligatorias:** Every feature has citation
+3. **📊 Diagramas Mermaid Completos:** Every feature/workflow has diagram
+4. **📸 Screenshot Placeholders Presentes:** Correct format + Screenshot Index
+5. **✅ Self-Check Pasado:** Completeness >= 90%, no TODOs
+
+## EXECUTION SEQUENCE (PRESCRIPTIVE):
+
+### 1. Announce Validation Start
+
+"🔍 **Iniciando Validación Final**
+
+Voy a ejecutar una verificación comprehensiva de la guía de usuario en español para asegurar que cumple todos los criterios de calidad.
+
+**Criterios a Validar:**
+1. Spanish output completo (archivo único)
+2. Source citations obligatorias
+3. Diagramas Mermaid completos
+4. Screenshot placeholders presentes
+5. Self-check de completitud
+
+Este proceso tomará un momento..."
+
+### 2. VALIDATION CHECK 1: Feature Files Completos
+
+**Repeat for EACH feature file in `{workflowStateFile}.features_selected`:**
+
+**Check 1.1: File Existence**
+- `{slug}-guide.md` exists at `{featuresOutputFolder}`: {YES/NO}
+
+**Check 1.2: File Non-Empty**
+- File size: {bytes}
+- Size > 5KB: {YES/NO}
+
+**Check 1.3: Required Sections Present** (per feature file)
+
+| Section | Present | Notes |
+|---------|---------|-------|
+| Funcionalidades | {✓/✗} | Sección principal de la feature |
+| Flujos de Trabajo | {✓/✗} | |
+| FAQ | {✓/✗} | |
+| Glosario | {✓/✗} | |
+| Índice de Capturas | {✓/✗} | |
+
+Note: Introducción, Primeros Pasos, Conceptos Clave solo requeridos en el primer archivo.
+
+**Result per file:** {PASS/FAIL}
+**Overall Check 1 Result:** PASS only if ALL feature files pass
+
+### 3. VALIDATION CHECK 2: Source Citations Obligatorias
+
+**Check 2.1: Citation Presence**
+
+Scan document for `[Source: F` pattern:
+- Total source citations found: {count}
+- From frontmatter.features_documented: {count}
+- Citation ratio: {citations / features}
+
+**Required:** Ratio >= 1.0 (at least one citation per feature)
+
+**Check 2.2: Citation Format Validation**
+
+For each citation:
+- Matches pattern `[Source: F\d+ Story \d+\.\d+]`: {valid_count}/{total_count}
+- All feature IDs reference selected features: {YES/NO}
+
+**Check 2.3: No Invented Features**
+
+- All features documented appear in analyzed epics: {YES/NO}
+- No features without source: {YES/NO}
+
+**Result:** {PASS/FAIL}
+
+### 4. VALIDATION CHECK 3: Diagramas Mermaid Completos
+
+**Check 3.1: Diagram Count**
+
+Scan document for ```mermaid blocks:
+- Total diagrams: {count}
+
+**Check 3.2: Minimum Diagram Coverage**
+
+From frontmatter:
+- features_documented: {count}
+- workflows_documented: {count}
+- Expected minimum diagrams: {features + workflows}
+- Actual diagrams: {count}
+- Coverage: {actual >= expected}
+
+**Check 3.3: Diagram Localization**
+
+Sample 5 random diagrams:
+- Diagrams use Spanish labels: {YES/NO}
+
+**Result:** {PASS/FAIL}
+
+### 5. VALIDATION CHECK 4: Screenshot Placeholders
+
+**Check 4.1: Screenshot Format**
+
+Scan document for `[Screenshot: ` pattern:
+- Total screenshots: {count}
+
+**Check 4.2: ID Format Validation**
+
+For each screenshot placeholder:
+- ID in UPPER_SNAKE_CASE: {valid_count}/{total_count}
+- ID has valid prefix (FEATURE_/WORKFLOW_/UI_/ERROR_): {valid_count}/{total_count}
+- All IDs are unique: {YES/NO}
+
+**Check 4.3: Screenshot Index Validation**
+
+- Screenshot Index section exists: {YES/NO}
+- All placeholder IDs appear in index: {YES/NO}
+- Index table format correct: {YES/NO}
+
+**Result:** {PASS/FAIL}
+
+### 6. VALIDATION CHECK 5: Self-Check Completitud
+
+**Check 5.1: Feature Coverage**
+
+From frontmatter.features_selected list:
+
+- All selected features referenced in content: {YES/NO}
+  {for each feature in features_selected}
+  - {feature.id} — {feature.title}: {referenced count} times
+  {end for}
+
+**Check 5.2: No Incomplete Markers**
+
+Scan both documents for:
+- TODO markers: {count found} (should be 0)
+- FIXME markers: {count found} (should be 0)
+- [TBD] markers: {count found} (should be 0)
+- Empty sections (## Header with no content): {count found}
+
+**Check 5.3: Completeness Score Calculation**
+
+Calculate score based on:
+- All required sections present: {25 points if yes}
+- All features have diagrams: {25 points if yes}
+- All features have citations: {20 points if yes}
+- Screenshot index complete: {15 points if yes}
+- No incomplete markers: {15 points if yes}
+
+**Completeness Score:** {total}/100
+
+**Required:** Score >= 90
+
+**Result:** {PASS/FAIL}
+
+### 7. Compile Validation Report
+
+**📊 VALIDATION REPORT**
+
+```
+=== USER GUIDE VALIDATION RESULTS ===
+
+Project: {project_name}
+Audience: {target_audience}
+Output: {outputFile}
+Date: {current_date}
+
+CRITERIA 1: Spanish Output Completo
+├─ File Existence: {PASS/FAIL}
+├─ File Size: {PASS/FAIL}
+└─ Required Sections: {PASS/FAIL}
+   └─ Sections present: {sections_found}/8
+Status: {✓ PASS / ✗ FAIL}
+
+CRITERIA 2: Source Citations Obligatorias
+├─ Citation Count: {count} citations for {features_count} features
+├─ Citation Ratio: {ratio} (required: >= 1.0)
+├─ Format Valid: {valid_count}/{total_count}
+└─ Epic References Valid: {YES/NO}
+Status: {✓ PASS / ✗ FAIL}
+
+CRITERIA 3: Diagramas Mermaid Completos
+├─ Diagram Count: {count}
+├─ Minimum Coverage: {actual} >= {expected} required
+└─ Spanish Labels: {YES/NO}
+Status: {✓ PASS / ✗ FAIL}
+
+CRITERIA 4: Screenshot Placeholders
+├─ Placeholder Count: {count}
+├─ ID Format: {valid_count}/{total_count} valid (UPPER_SNAKE_CASE)
+├─ Screenshot Index: {EXISTS/MISSING}
+└─ Index Completeness: {matched}/{total} IDs
+Status: {✓ PASS / ✗ FAIL}
+
+CRITERIA 5: Self-Check Completitud
+├─ Feature Coverage: {covered_count}/{selected_count} features documented
+├─ Incomplete Markers: {count} found (should be 0)
+├─ Completeness Score: {score}/100 (required: >= 90)
+Status: {✓ PASS / ✗ FAIL}
+
+=== OVERALL RESULT ===
+
+Criteria Passed: {passed_count}/5
+Overall Status: {✅ APPROVED / ⚠️ NEEDS ATTENTION / ❌ FAILED}
+
+{if issues found:}
+=== ISSUES FOUND ===
+
+{list all validation failures with specific details}
+
+1. {Issue description}
+   Location: {where}
+   Required: {what's needed}
+
+2. {Issue description}
+   ...
+{endif}
+```
+
+### 8. Present Validation Results to User
+
+Display in Spanish (using `{communication_language}`):
+
+"🔍 **Validación Completada**
+
+{if all checks passed:}
+
+✅ **¡Excelente! Todas las validaciones pasaron.**
+
+Tu guía de usuario cumple con todos los criterios de calidad:
+
+- ✓ Guía en español generada y completa
+- ✓ {citations_count} source citations presentes ({ratio} por feature)
+- ✓ {diagrams_count} diagramas Mermaid completos con labels en español
+- ✓ {screenshots_count} screenshot placeholders con índice completo
+- ✓ Completeness score: {score}/100 (excelente)
+
+**Estadísticas Finales:**
+- Features documentadas: {features_count}
+- Workflows documentados: {workflows_count}
+- Total páginas (aprox): {estimated_pages}
+- Palabra count (aprox): {word_count}
+
+¿Listo para guardar y finalizar?
+
+{else:}
+
+⚠️ **Atención: Se encontraron {issues_count} problemas que necesitan corrección.**
+
+{Display issues list}
+
+**Opciones:**
+- Puedo intentar corregir estos problemas automáticamente (loop a step-05)
+- O puedes revisar manualmente y volver a ejecutar el workflow
+
+¿Qué prefieres hacer?
+
+{endif}"
+
+### 9. Update Completeness Score in Feature Files
+
+For each feature file: update frontmatter with `completeness_score` and `review_status`.
+
+### 10. Present FINAL MENU OPTIONS
+
+**IF all validations passed:**
+
+Display: **Select an Option:** [V] View Report [S] Save and Finalize
+
+**IF validations failed:**
+
+Display: **Select an Option:** [V] View Report [F] Fix Issues [S] Save Anyway (not recommended)
+
+#### EXECUTION RULES:
+
+- ALWAYS halt and wait for user input after presenting menu
+- DO NOT proceed without explicit user choice
+- After other menu items execution, return to this menu
+
+#### Menu Handling Logic:
+
+**Common options:**
+- IF V: Display complete validation report in detail, return to menu
+- IF A (if shown): Execute `{advancedElicitationTask}` for detailed issue analysis
+- IF P (if shown): Execute `{partyModeWorkflow}` for collaborative review
+
+**If ALL passed:**
+- IF S: Proceed to finalization (section 11)
+
+**If FAILED:**
+- IF F: Collect issues, prepare corrections context, LOOP to `{correctionTargetStep}` with corrections
+- IF S: Warn user, confirm, then proceed to finalization (not recommended)
+
+### 11. Finalization Sequence (When User Selects [S] Save)
+
+**11.1: Update Final Frontmatter**
+
+For each feature file, update frontmatter:
+```yaml
+review_status: "approved"
+last_modified: "{current_timestamp}"
+```
+
+**11.2: Save Files**
+
+- Save each `{slug}-guide.md`
+
+**11.3: Generate Completion Summary**
+
+"✅ **¡Workflow Completado Exitosamente!**
+
+**📦 Archivos Generados:**
+
+{for each feature file}
+- **{feature.id} — {feature.title}**
+  - Ubicación: `{featuresOutputFolder}/{slug}-guide.md`
+  - Acción: {action} (creado/actualizado)
+  - Tamaño: {file_size}
+{end for}
+
+> 💡 Los archivos de feature son independientes y actualizables. Re-ejecuta el workflow para agregar nuevas features (se crean nuevos archivos) o actualizar las existentes (se modifican los archivos actuales).
+
+**📊 Estadísticas Finales:**
+
+| Métrica | Valor |
+|---------|-------|
+| Features documentadas | {features_count} |
+| Workflows documentados | {workflows_count} |
+| Diagramas Mermaid | {diagrams_count} |
+| Screenshot placeholders | {screenshots_count} |
+| Source citations | {citations_count} |
+| Completeness score | {score}/100 |
+| Palabras totales (aprox) | {word_count} |
+
+**📋 Features Documentadas:**
+
+{For each feature in features_selected:}
+- {feature.id} — {feature.title} ✓ Documentada
+{End for}
+
+**✅ Próximos Pasos:**
+
+1. Revisar la guía generada
+2. Capturar las {screenshots_count} screenshots identificadas en el Screenshot Index
+3. Reemplazar placeholders con screenshots reales
+4. Revisar diagramas Mermaid y ajustar si es necesario
+5. Al completar nuevos features, re-ejecutar el workflow para actualizar la guía
+
+**¡Gracias por usar el generador de guías de usuario!**"
+
+### 12. Workflow Complete
+
+Workflow has finished successfully. No further steps.
+
+---
+
+## LOOP MECHANISM (If [F] Fix Issues Selected):
+
+**When user selects [F] Fix Issues:**
+
+1. **Prepare Corrections Context:**
+   - Compile list of all validation issues
+   - Identify which features/workflows need correction
+   - Prepare specific instructions for fixes
+
+2. **Hold Corrections in Memory:**
+   - List all issues: description, location, fix needed
+
+3. **Loop to step-05:**
+   - Load, read entire file `{correctionTargetStep}`
+   - Execute step-05 with corrections context
+   - Step-05 will regenerate problematic sections
+   - After step-05 completes, return directly to step-07 (this step) for re-validation
+   - NOTE: Step-06 is DISABLED — do not load it
+
+---
+
+## 🚨 SYSTEM SUCCESS/FAILURE METRICS
+
+### ✅ SUCCESS:
+
+- All 5 validation checks executed against EACH feature file
+- Validation report generated (consolidated + per-file)
+- User presented with clear results
+- IF issues: user offered fix or save options per file
+- IF no issues: all feature files saved with `review_status: approved`
+- Completion summary with per-file details displayed
+- Workflow finished
+
+### ❌ SYSTEM FAILURE:
+
+- Validating a single combined file instead of per-feature files
+- Skipping validation checks for any feature file
+- Not calculating completeness score per file
+- Saving without user approval
+- Not updating feature file frontmatter to "approved"
+- Writing to `_workflow-state.md` (forbidden — no state file)
+- Not offering fix option when issues found
+
+**Master Rule:** Skipping steps, optimizing sequences, or not following exact instructions is FORBIDDEN and constitutes SYSTEM FAILURE.