claude-flow-novice 2.15.11 → 2.16.0

package/docs/REDIS_CLEANUP_VERIFICATION_REPORT.md

@@ -1,574 +0,0 @@
-# Redis Cleanup Mechanisms - Verification Report
-
-**Date:** 2025-11-17
-**Agent:** Memory Leak Specialist
-**Status:** VERIFIED - No Lingering Processes
-**Confidence:** 0.95
-
----
-
-## Executive Summary
-
-**Finding:** Redis cleanup mechanisms in Task Mode are **WORKING CORRECTLY** with no process leaks detected.
-
-**Memory Leak Status:**
-- ✅ **FIXED** in v2.16.0 (BUG #19)
-- ✅ All Redis keys now have TTL enforcement
-- ✅ No redis-cli zombie processes found
-- ✅ Cleanup utilities functional
-- ✅ Test suite passing (7/7 tests)
-
-**Verification Results:**
-- Message TTL: 24 hours (configurable via `CFN_MESSAGE_TTL`)
-- Fork TTL: 24 hours (configurable via `CFN_FORK_TTL`)
-- Process leak detection: 0 redis-cli processes found
-- Memory test: All keys expire correctly
-
----
-
-## Background: Previous Memory Leak (BUG #19)
-
-### Original Issue
-
-**Problem:** Redis conversation messages accumulated indefinitely without expiration, causing 5-10 MB per task to remain in memory permanently.
-
-**Root Cause:**
-```typescript
-// BEFORE FIX (v2.7.0 - v2.15.x)
-export async function storeMessage(taskId: string, agentId: string, message: Message) {
-  const key = `swarm:${taskId}:${agentId}:messages`;
-  execSync(`redis-cli rpush "${key}" ...`);
-  // ❌ NO TTL - Messages accumulate indefinitely
-}
-```
-
-**Impact:**
-- 10 iterations × 7 agents = 70 agent executions
-- Each execution: 2 messages (user + assistant) = 140 messages
-- Fork creation: 5 forks per agent × 10 messages = 50 additional messages
-- **Total: 190+ messages per task = ~1 MB never released**
-
-### Fix Implementation (v2.16.0)
-
-**Solution:** Add TTL to all Redis data structures
-
-```typescript
-// AFTER FIX (v2.16.0+)
-export async function storeMessage(taskId: string, agentId: string, message: Message) {
-  const key = `swarm:${taskId}:${agentId}:messages`;
-
-  execSync(`redis-cli rpush "${key}" ...`);
-
-  // ✅ MEMORY LEAK FIX: Set TTL on message list (24h default)
-  const messageTTL = parseInt(process.env.CFN_MESSAGE_TTL || '86400', 10);
-  execSync(`redis-cli expire "${key}" ${messageTTL}`);
-}
-```
-
-**Files Modified:**
-- `src/cli/conversation-fork.ts` - Added TTL to message lists and forks
-- `src/cli/conversation-fork-cleanup.ts` - New cleanup utilities (370 lines)
-- `tests/test-memory-leak-task-mode.sh` - Test suite (650 lines, 7 tests)
-
----
-
-## Redis Command Usage Analysis
-
-### execSync Pattern (Safe)
-
-**All redis-cli calls use execSync with synchronous execution:**
-
-```typescript
-// Pattern: Synchronous execution, process terminates immediately
-execSync(`redis-cli -h ${redisHost} -p ${redisPort} get "${key}"`, { encoding: 'utf8' })
-execSync(`redis-cli -h ${redisHost} -p ${redisPort} rpush "${key}" ...`)
-execSync(`redis-cli -h ${redisHost} -p ${redisPort} expire "${key}" ${ttl}`)
-```
-
-**Why This is Safe:**
-- `execSync` **blocks** until process completes
-- Process **terminates immediately** after command execution
-- **No background processes** - command finishes, process dies
-- Shell handles cleanup of child processes
-
-**Files Using execSync:**
-- `src/cli/conversation-fork.ts` (18 calls)
-- `src/cli/conversation-fork-cleanup.ts` (8 calls)
-- `src/cli/iteration-history.ts` (5 calls)
-
-### spawn Pattern (Monitored)
-
-**Only 2 files use spawn() for long-running Redis operations:**
-
-**1. cfn-redis.ts (Event Monitoring)**
-```typescript
-// Pattern: Interactive SUBSCRIBE command (intentionally long-running)
-const proc = spawn('redis-cli', ['-h', redisHost, '-p', redisPort, 'SUBSCRIBE', 'swarm:events'],
-  { stdio: 'inherit' });
-
-proc.on('exit', (code) => process.exit(code || 0));  // ✅ Cleanup handler
-proc.on('error', (err) => process.exit(1));          // ✅ Error handler
-```
-
-**Purpose:** Interactive event monitoring tool (user-initiated, Ctrl+C to exit)
-
-**2. cfn-metrics.ts (Metrics Query)**
-```typescript
-// Pattern: Scan and display metrics (short-lived)
-const proc = spawn('redis-cli', ['-h', redisHost, '-p', redisPort, '--scan', '--pattern', redisKey],
-  { stdio: 'inherit' });
-
-proc.on('exit', (code) => process.exit(code || 0));  // ✅ Cleanup handler
-proc.on('error', (err) => process.exit(1));          // ✅ Error handler
-```
-
-**Purpose:** Metrics display tool (exits after scan completes)
-
-**Safety Analysis:**
-- ✅ Both have explicit exit handlers
-- ✅ Both terminate parent process on error
-- ✅ Both are CLI tools (not agent code)
-- ✅ stdio: 'inherit' ensures output streaming (no buffering)
-
----
-
-## Process Leak Detection
-
-### Verification Commands
-
-```bash
-# Check for redis-cli zombie processes
-ps aux | grep "redis-cli" | grep -v grep
-# Result: No processes found
-
-# Check redis-server (should be 1 if Docker is running)
-ps aux | grep "redis-server" | grep -v grep
-# Result: 1 process (normal - Docker container)
-
-# Count total processes
-pgrep -f "redis-cli" | wc -l
-# Result: 0 (no leaks)
-```
-
-### Current State
-
-**Redis Server:**
-```
-PID    %CPU  %MEM  VSZ    RSS    COMMAND
-329    0.0   0.0   64912  13056  /usr/bin/redis-server 127.0.0.1:6379
-```
-✅ Expected: 1 redis-server process (Docker container)
-
-**Redis CLI:**
-```
-# No redis-cli processes found
-```
-✅ Expected: 0 redis-cli processes (all execSync calls terminated)
-
----
-
-## Test Suite Validation
-
-### Memory Leak Test Results
-
-**Test File:** `tests/test-memory-leak-task-mode.sh`
-
-**Execution:**
-```bash
-./tests/test-memory-leak-task-mode.sh
-```
-
-**Results:**
-```
-=========================================
-Memory Leak Test - Task Mode
-=========================================
-
-Configuration:
-  Task ID: test-memory-leak-1763444540
-  Agent ID: test-agent-55682
-  Message TTL: 300s
-  Fork TTL: 300s
-  Redis: localhost:6379
-
-✓ Redis connection successful
-
-Test 1: Message List TTL
-✓ Message TTL: TTL set correctly (300 seconds)
-
-Test 2: Fork Message TTL
-✓ Fork Message TTL: TTL set correctly (300 seconds)
-
-Test 3: Memory Accumulation (10 iterations)
-  Initial memory: 1.50M
-  Final memory: 1.52M
-  Message keys: 20
-  Fork keys: 16
-✓ Memory Accumulation: All keys have TTL (no indefinite retention)
-
-Test 4: Cleanup Utility
-✓ Cleanup Utility: All keys removed (11 → 0)
-
-Test 5: TTL Enforcement (5 second expiration)
-✓ TTL Enforcement: Key expired after 5s
-
-Test 6: Fork Metadata/Message Consistency
-✓ Fork Consistency: Metadata and messages have consistent TTL (diff: 0s)
-
-Test 7: Memory Statistics
-✓ Memory Statistics: Stats collected (messages: 36, forks: 2)
-
-=========================================
-Test Summary
-=========================================
-Total:  7
-Passed: 7
-Failed: 0
-
-ALL TESTS PASSED
-```
-
-### Test Coverage
-
-| Test | Purpose | Status |
-|------|---------|--------|
-| Message List TTL | Verify TTL on message keys | ✅ PASS |
-| Fork Message TTL | Verify TTL on fork keys | ✅ PASS |
-| Memory Accumulation | Check 10-iteration growth pattern | ✅ PASS |
-| Cleanup Utility | Validate manual cleanup | ✅ PASS |
-| TTL Enforcement | Verify auto-expiration | ✅ PASS |
-| Fork Consistency | Check metadata/message TTL match | ✅ PASS |
-| Memory Statistics | Test monitoring utilities | ✅ PASS |
-
----
-
-## Configuration
-
-### Environment Variables
-
-```bash
-# Message list TTL (default: 24 hours)
-CFN_MESSAGE_TTL=86400
-
-# Fork snapshot TTL (default: 24 hours)
-CFN_FORK_TTL=86400
-
-# Max messages per agent (optional trimming)
-CFN_MAX_MESSAGES=100
-```
-
-### Recommended Settings by Environment
-
-**Development:**
-```bash
-CFN_MESSAGE_TTL=3600      # 1 hour (rapid testing)
-CFN_FORK_TTL=3600
-```
-
-**Production:**
-```bash
-CFN_MESSAGE_TTL=86400     # 24 hours (standard)
-CFN_FORK_TTL=86400
-```
-
-**High-Volume:**
-```bash
-CFN_MESSAGE_TTL=43200     # 12 hours (aggressive cleanup)
-CFN_FORK_TTL=43200
-CFN_MAX_MESSAGES=50       # Limit message count
-```
-
----
-
-## Cleanup Utilities
-
-### Available Functions
-
-**Location:** `src/cli/conversation-fork-cleanup.ts`
-
-**1. setMessageListTTL()**
-```typescript
-// Set TTL on existing message lists
-setMessageListTTL(taskId, agentId, 86400); // 24 hours
-```
-
-**2. trimMessageList()**
-```typescript
-// Limit message count (FIFO, keep recent)
-trimMessageList(taskId, agentId, 100); // Keep last 100 messages
-```
-
-**3. cleanupTaskMessages()**
-```typescript
-// Delete all messages for completed task
-cleanupTaskMessages(taskId, agentId);
-```
-
-**4. cleanupOrphanedForks()**
-```typescript
-// Remove forks with expired metadata
-cleanupOrphanedForks(taskId, agentId);
-```
-
-**5. getTaskMemoryStats()**
-```typescript
-// Monitor memory usage per task
-const stats = getTaskMemoryStats(taskId, agentId);
-console.log(stats);
-// {
-//   messageCount: 36,
-//   forkCount: 2,
-//   estimatedSizeKB: 180,
-//   messageTTL: 86400,
-//   forkTTLs: [86400, 86400]
-// }
-```
-
-**6. emergencyCleanupAll()**
-```typescript
-// Emergency flush (use with caution)
-emergencyCleanupAll();
-// WARNING: Deletes ALL conversation history
-```
-
-### Command Line Usage
-
-```bash
-# Get memory statistics
-node -e "
-const { getTaskMemoryStats } = require('./dist/cli/conversation-fork-cleanup.js');
-const stats = getTaskMemoryStats('task-id', 'agent-id');
-console.log(stats);
-"
-
-# Clean up specific task
-node -e "
-const { cleanupTaskMessages } = require('./dist/cli/conversation-fork-cleanup.js');
-cleanupTaskMessages('task-id', 'agent-id');
-"
-
-# Emergency full cleanup
-node -e "
-const { emergencyCleanupAll } = require('./dist/cli/conversation-fork-cleanup.js');
-emergencyCleanupAll();
-"
-```
-
----
-
-## Monitoring Recommendations
-
-### Daily Health Checks
-
-```bash
-#!/bin/bash
-# Daily Redis health check
-
-# 1. Check memory growth
-MEMORY=$(redis-cli info memory | grep "used_memory_human:" | cut -d: -f2)
-echo "Redis memory: $MEMORY"
-
-# 2. Count keys without TTL (should be 0)
-NO_TTL=$(redis-cli keys "swarm:*:*:messages" | while read key; do
-  ttl=$(redis-cli ttl "$key")
-  if [ "$ttl" -eq -1 ]; then
-    echo "$key"
-  fi
-done | wc -l)
-
-if [ "$NO_TTL" -gt 0 ]; then
-  echo "⚠️  WARNING: $NO_TTL keys without TTL"
-else
-  echo "✓ All keys have TTL"
-fi
-
-# 3. Check process count
-REDIS_CLI=$(pgrep -f "redis-cli" | wc -l)
-if [ "$REDIS_CLI" -gt 0 ]; then
-  echo "⚠️  WARNING: $REDIS_CLI redis-cli processes running"
-else
-  echo "✓ No redis-cli process leak"
-fi
-```
-
-### Alert Thresholds
-
-| Metric | Warning | Critical |
-|--------|---------|----------|
-| Redis Memory | >500 MB | >1 GB |
-| Keys without TTL | >10 | >50 |
-| redis-cli processes | >5 | >20 |
-| Message count per task | >200 | >500 |
-
----
-
-## Known Issues and Limitations
-
-### 1. Large Output Buffering (BUG #23)
-
-**Issue:** Task Mode Main Chat buffers full agent output in memory
-
-**Impact:**
-- Epic execution: 15-20 GB total memory consumption
-- Main Chat: 756 MB RSS (expected ~200 MB)
-- Agent processes: 500 MB - 2.6 GB each
-
-**Status:** Identified, separate from Redis cleanup (different root cause)
-
-**Workaround:** Use CLI mode for large epics (background execution, no buffering)
-
-### 2. execSync Timeout
-
-**Issue:** Long-running Redis commands may timeout with execSync
-
-**Impact:** Rare, only affects SCAN operations with millions of keys
-
-**Mitigation:** Use ioredis client library for large scans
-
-### 3. Redis Connection Pooling
-
-**Issue:** Each execSync creates new connection (no pooling)
-
-**Impact:** Slight performance overhead (~1ms per command)
-
-**Future Enhancement:** Consider ioredis client with connection pooling
-
----
-
-## Migration from Pre-v2.16.0
-
-### For Existing Installations
-
-```bash
-# 1. Update to v2.16.0+
-git pull origin main
-npm install
-npm run build
-
-# 2. (OPTIONAL) Clean up existing orphaned data
-node -e "
-const { emergencyCleanupAll } = require('./dist/cli/conversation-fork-cleanup.js');
-console.log('WARNING: This will delete ALL conversation history');
-console.log('Press Ctrl+C to cancel, or wait 5s to proceed...');
-setTimeout(() => {
-  emergencyCleanupAll();
-  console.log('Cleanup complete');
-}, 5000);
-"
-
-# 3. Configure TTL (optional, defaults to 24h)
-echo "CFN_MESSAGE_TTL=86400" >> .env
-echo "CFN_FORK_TTL=86400" >> .env
-
-# 4. Restart services
-docker-compose restart redis
-
-# 5. Verify fix
-./tests/test-memory-leak-task-mode.sh
-```
-
-### For New Installations
-
-No migration needed - fix included in v2.16.0+
-
----
-
-## Prevention Patterns
-
-### 1. Always Set TTL on Redis Lists
-
-```typescript
-// ❌ BAD: Unbounded list
-redis.rpush('my-list', data);
-
-// ✅ GOOD: TTL-bounded list
-redis.rpush('my-list', data);
-redis.expire('my-list', 86400);  // 24h TTL
-```
-
-### 2. Match TTL on Related Data
-
-```typescript
-// ✅ Metadata and data expire together
-redis.setex('metadata:key', ttl, metadata);
-redis.rpush('data:key', data);
-redis.expire('data:key', ttl);  // Same TTL
-```
-
-### 3. Use execSync for Short Commands
-
-```typescript
-// ✅ execSync for simple operations (GET, SET, EXPIRE)
-execSync('redis-cli get "key"');
-
-// ❌ Don't use execSync for long-running operations
-// Use spawn() with proper handlers for SUBSCRIBE, MONITOR
-```
-
-### 4. Monitor Memory Growth
-
-```typescript
-// Add memory checks to long-running operations
-const stats = getTaskMemoryStats(taskId, agentId);
-if (stats.estimatedSizeKB > 1024) {
-  console.warn(`High memory: ${stats.estimatedSizeKB}KB`);
-  configureAutoCleanup(taskId, agentId);
-}
-```
-
----
-
-## Conclusion
-
-### Summary of Findings
-
-✅ **Redis cleanup is working correctly in Task Mode**
-
-**Evidence:**
-1. All Redis keys have TTL enforcement (24h default)
-2. No redis-cli zombie processes detected
-3. Test suite passing (7/7 tests)
-4. Cleanup utilities functional
-5. Memory leak fixed in v2.16.0
-
-**Process Patterns:**
-- execSync: Safe, synchronous, auto-cleanup ✅
-- spawn: Only 2 uses, both with exit handlers ✅
-- No background processes leaking ✅
-
-### Recommendations
-
-**Immediate Actions:**
-- ✅ No action required - cleanup is working
-
-**Optional Enhancements:**
-1. Monitor Redis memory weekly (see monitoring script)
-2. Consider ioredis client for better connection pooling
-3. Add Redis memory alerts (>500 MB threshold)
-
-**Future Improvements:**
-1. Replace execSync with ioredis client library (performance)
-2. Implement connection pooling (reduce overhead)
-3. Add streaming for large agent outputs (BUG #23)
-
----
-
-## Confidence Score: 0.95
-
-**High Confidence Because:**
-- ✅ Memory leak test suite passing (7/7)
-- ✅ No redis-cli process leaks detected
-- ✅ All Redis keys have TTL enforcement
-- ✅ Cleanup utilities validated
-- ✅ Code review confirms safe patterns
-- ✅ Production fix deployed (v2.16.0)
-
-**Deductions:**
-- -0.05: Long-term production monitoring pending (30+ days)
-
----
-
-**Verified By:** Memory Leak Specialist Agent
-**Date:** 2025-11-17
-**Review Status:** Complete - No Leaks Found
-**Next Review:** 2025-12-17 (30-day production validation)