tldraw 3.16.0-canary.fa3749606e52 → 3.16.0-next.282b7be564ae

package/src/test/arrows-megabus.test.tsx

@@ -288,11 +288,13 @@ describe('When shapes are overlapping', () => {
 		editor.pointerDown(0, 50) // over nothing
 		editor.pointerMove(125, 50) // over box1 only
 		expect(bindings().end).toMatchObject({ toId: ids.box1 })
-		editor.pointerMove(175, 50) // box2 is higher but box1 is filled?
+		editor.pointerMove(175, 50) // box2 is higher but box1 is filled, but we're on the edge ofd box 2
+		expect(bindings().end).toMatchObject({ toId: ids.box2 })
+		editor.pointerMove(175, 70) // box2 is higher but box1 is filled, and we're inside of box2
 		expect(bindings().end).toMatchObject({ toId: ids.box1 })
-		editor.pointerMove(225, 50) // box3 is higher
+		editor.pointerMove(225, 70) // box3 is higher
 		expect(bindings().end).toMatchObject({ toId: ids.box3 })
-		editor.pointerMove(275, 50) // box4 is higher but box 3 is filled
+		editor.pointerMove(275, 70) // box4 is higher but box 3 is filled
 		expect(bindings().end).toMatchObject({ toId: ids.box3 })
 	})
 
@@ -304,14 +306,18 @@ describe('When shapes are overlapping', () => {
 		])
 		editor.setCurrentTool('arrow')
 		editor.pointerDown(0, 50)
-		editor.pointerMove(175, 50) // box1 is smaller even though it's behind box2
+		editor.pointerMove(175, 50) // box1 is smaller even though it's behind box2, but we're on the edge of box 2
+		expect(bindings().end).toMatchObject({ toId: ids.box2 })
+		editor.pointerMove(175, 70) // box1 is smaller even though it's behind box2
 		expect(bindings().end).toMatchObject({ toId: ids.box1 })
-		editor.pointerMove(150, 90) // box3 is smaller and at the front
+		editor.pointerMove(150, 90) // box3 is smaller and at the front but we're on the edge of box 2
+		expect(bindings().end).toMatchObject({ toId: ids.box2 })
+		editor.pointerMove(160, 90) // box3 is smaller and at the front and we're in box1 and box 3 and box 2
 		expect(bindings().end).toMatchObject({ toId: ids.box3 })
 		editor.sendToBack([ids.box3])
 		editor.pointerMove(149, 90) // box3 is smaller, even when at the back
 		expect(bindings().end).toMatchObject({ toId: ids.box3 })
-		editor.pointerMove(175, 50)
+		editor.pointerMove(175, 60) // inside of box1 and box 2, but box 1 is smaller
 		expect(bindings().end).toMatchObject({ toId: ids.box1 })
 	})
 })

package/src/test/inner-outer-margin.test.ts

@@ -0,0 +1,315 @@
+import { TLArrowShape, createShapeId } from '@tldraw/editor'
+import { getArrowBindings } from '../lib/shapes/arrow/shared'
+import { TestEditor } from './TestEditor'
+
+let editor: TestEditor
+
+const ids = {
+	solidShape: createShapeId('solidShape'),
+	hollowShape: createShapeId('hollowShape'),
+	arrow: createShapeId('arrow'),
+}
+
+const _arrow = () => editor.getOnlySelectedShape() as TLArrowShape
+
+beforeEach(() => {
+	editor = new TestEditor()
+})
+
+describe('Inner/Outer Margin Shape Detection', () => {
+	describe('getShapeAtPoint with inner/outer margins', () => {
+		beforeEach(() => {
+			// Create a solid filled shape
+			editor.createShape({
+				id: ids.solidShape,
+				type: 'geo',
+				x: 100,
+				y: 100,
+				props: {
+					w: 100,
+					h: 100,
+					fill: 'solid',
+				},
+			})
+
+			// Create a hollow shape on top (same position, smaller size)
+			editor.createShape({
+				id: ids.hollowShape,
+				type: 'geo',
+				x: 125,
+				y: 125,
+				props: {
+					w: 50,
+					h: 50,
+					// No fill property - defaults to 'none' (hollow)
+				},
+			})
+		})
+
+		it('should support inner/outer margin options', () => {
+			// Test that the new margin options are accepted
+			const point = { x: 150, y: 150 }
+
+			// Test with array margin [innerMargin, outerMargin]
+			const arrayMarginHit = editor.getShapeAtPoint(point, {
+				hitInside: true,
+				margin: [8, 4],
+			})
+			expect(arrayMarginHit).toBeDefined()
+
+			// Test with insideMargin option
+			const insideMarginHit = editor.getShapeAtPoint(point, {
+				hitInside: true,
+			})
+			expect(insideMarginHit).toBeDefined()
+
+			// Test with single number margin (should use same for both)
+			const singleMarginHit = editor.getShapeAtPoint(point, {
+				hitInside: true,
+				margin: 8,
+			})
+			expect(singleMarginHit).toBeDefined()
+		})
+
+		it('should respect hitInside option for hollow shapes', () => {
+			const point = { x: 150, y: 150 }
+
+			// Without hitInside, should not hit hollow shape
+			const noHitInsideHit = editor.getShapeAtPoint(point, {
+				margin: [8, 0],
+			})
+			expect(noHitInsideHit?.id).toBe(ids.solidShape)
+
+			// With hitInside, should be able to hit hollow shape
+			const withHitInsideHit = editor.getShapeAtPoint(point, {
+				hitInside: true,
+				margin: [8, 0],
+			})
+			expect(withHitInsideHit).toBeDefined()
+		})
+
+		it('should handle edge cases correctly', () => {
+			// Test point exactly on the edge of hollow shape
+			const edgePoint = { x: 125, y: 150 }
+
+			const edgeHit = editor.getShapeAtPoint(edgePoint, {
+				hitInside: true,
+				margin: [8, 8],
+			})
+			expect(edgeHit).toBeDefined()
+		})
+	})
+
+	describe('Arrow binding with inner/outer margins', () => {
+		beforeEach(() => {
+			// Create a solid filled shape
+			editor.createShape({
+				id: ids.solidShape,
+				type: 'geo',
+				x: 100,
+				y: 100,
+				props: {
+					w: 100,
+					h: 100,
+					fill: 'solid',
+				},
+			})
+
+			// Create a hollow shape on top (same position, smaller size)
+			editor.createShape({
+				id: ids.hollowShape,
+				type: 'geo',
+				x: 125,
+				y: 125,
+				props: {
+					w: 50,
+					h: 50,
+					// No fill property - defaults to 'none' (hollow)
+				},
+			})
+		})
+
+		it('should create arrow bindings with inner/outer margin support', () => {
+			editor.setCurrentTool('arrow')
+
+			// Start arrow outside both shapes
+			editor.pointerDown(50, 150)
+
+			// Move to center of hollow shape (which overlaps solid shape)
+			editor.pointerMove(150, 150)
+			editor.pointerUp()
+
+			const createdArrow = editor
+				.getCurrentPageShapes()
+				.find((s) => s.type === 'arrow') as TLArrowShape
+			expect(createdArrow).toBeDefined()
+
+			const arrowBindings = getArrowBindings(editor, createdArrow)
+			expect(arrowBindings.end).toBeDefined()
+			// The binding should be to one of the shapes
+			expect([ids.solidShape, ids.hollowShape]).toContain(arrowBindings.end?.toId)
+		})
+
+		it('should bind to solid shape when no hollow shape is present', () => {
+			// Remove the hollow shape
+			editor.deleteShape(ids.hollowShape)
+
+			editor.setCurrentTool('arrow')
+
+			// Start arrow outside shape
+			editor.pointerDown(50, 150)
+
+			// Move to center of solid shape
+			editor.pointerMove(150, 150)
+			editor.pointerUp()
+
+			const createdArrow = editor
+				.getCurrentPageShapes()
+				.find((s) => s.type === 'arrow') as TLArrowShape
+			expect(createdArrow).toBeDefined()
+
+			const arrowBindings = getArrowBindings(editor, createdArrow)
+			expect(arrowBindings.end).toBeDefined()
+			expect(arrowBindings.end?.toId).toBe(ids.solidShape)
+		})
+	})
+
+	describe('Complex overlapping scenarios', () => {
+		it('should handle multiple overlapping shapes correctly', () => {
+			// Create multiple shapes with different fill states
+			editor.createShape({
+				id: ids.solidShape,
+				type: 'geo',
+				x: 100,
+				y: 100,
+				props: {
+					w: 100,
+					h: 100,
+					fill: 'solid',
+				},
+			})
+
+			editor.createShape({
+				id: ids.hollowShape,
+				type: 'geo',
+				x: 125,
+				y: 125,
+				props: {
+					w: 50,
+					h: 50,
+					// No fill property - defaults to 'none' (hollow)
+				},
+			})
+
+			// Create another hollow shape
+			const hollowShape2 = createShapeId('hollowShape2')
+			editor.createShape({
+				id: hollowShape2,
+				type: 'geo',
+				x: 140,
+				y: 140,
+				props: {
+					w: 30,
+					h: 30,
+					// No fill property - defaults to 'none' (hollow)
+				},
+			})
+
+			// Test point in the innermost hollow shape
+			const point = { x: 155, y: 155 }
+
+			const hit = editor.getShapeAtPoint(point, {
+				hitInside: true,
+				margin: [8, 8],
+			})
+			expect(hit).toBeDefined()
+			// Should hit one of the shapes
+			expect([ids.solidShape, ids.hollowShape, hollowShape2]).toContain(hit?.id)
+		})
+
+		it('should handle shapes with different geometries', () => {
+			// Create a solid rectangle
+			editor.createShape({
+				id: ids.solidShape,
+				type: 'geo',
+				x: 100,
+				y: 100,
+				props: {
+					w: 100,
+					h: 100,
+					fill: 'solid',
+				},
+			})
+
+			// Create a hollow circle on top
+			editor.createShape({
+				id: ids.hollowShape,
+				type: 'geo',
+				x: 125,
+				y: 125,
+				props: {
+					w: 50,
+					h: 50,
+					geo: 'ellipse',
+					// No fill property - defaults to 'none' (hollow)
+				},
+			})
+
+			// Test point inside the circle
+			const point = { x: 150, y: 150 }
+
+			const hit = editor.getShapeAtPoint(point, {
+				hitInside: true,
+				margin: [8, 8],
+			})
+			expect(hit).toBeDefined()
+			// Should hit one of the shapes
+			expect([ids.solidShape, ids.hollowShape]).toContain(hit?.id)
+		})
+	})
+
+	describe('Regression tests for the original bug', () => {
+		it('should support binding to hollow shapes when overlapping solid shapes', () => {
+			// This test verifies that the infrastructure exists for the bug fix
+			// Create a solid shape
+			editor.createShape({
+				id: ids.solidShape,
+				type: 'geo',
+				x: 100,
+				y: 100,
+				props: {
+					w: 100,
+					h: 100,
+					fill: 'solid',
+				},
+			})
+
+			// Create a hollow shape on top
+			editor.createShape({
+				id: ids.hollowShape,
+				type: 'geo',
+				x: 125,
+				y: 125,
+				props: {
+					w: 50,
+					h: 50,
+					// No fill property - defaults to 'none' (hollow)
+				},
+			})
+
+			// Test that we can detect both shapes
+			const point = { x: 150, y: 150 }
+
+			// Should be able to hit the solid shape without hitInside
+			const solidHit = editor.getShapeAtPoint(point)
+			expect(solidHit?.id).toBe(ids.solidShape)
+
+			// Should be able to hit the hollow shape with hitInside and inner margin
+			const hollowHit = editor.getShapeAtPoint(point, {
+				hitInside: true,
+				margin: [8, 0],
+			})
+			expect(hollowHit).toBeDefined()
+		})
+	})
+})