pi-plans 0.5.7 → 0.7.0

This diff represents the content of publicly available package versions that have been released to one of the supported registries. The information contained in this diff is provided for informational purposes only and reflects changes between package versions as they appear in their respective public registries.
Files changed (112) hide show
  1. package/CONTRIBUTING.md +126 -0
  2. package/README.md +49 -39
  3. package/agents/ref-analyst.md +7 -4
  4. package/agents/reviewer.md +12 -3
  5. package/index.ts +74 -40
  6. package/package.json +2 -1
  7. package/references/pi-planning-workflow.md +45 -58
  8. package/references/plan-artifact-template.md +71 -60
  9. package/references/state-and-config.md +63 -47
  10. package/scripts/bench/pi-adapter/pi_plans_bench.py +33 -22
  11. package/scripts/bench/pi-adapter/rpc_driver.mjs +4 -4
  12. package/scripts/run-tests.ts +12 -1
  13. package/scripts/validate.ts +22 -10
  14. package/skills/debug-and-plan/SKILL.md +4 -4
  15. package/skills/plan-big/SKILL.md +5 -5
  16. package/skills/plan-normal/SKILL.md +5 -5
  17. package/skills/plan-small/SKILL.md +5 -5
  18. package/skills/plan-with-refs/SKILL.md +8 -8
  19. package/skills/planning/SKILL.md +1 -1
  20. package/src/ask-form.ts +4 -4
  21. package/src/auditor.ts +126 -0
  22. package/src/auto-approve.ts +1 -1
  23. package/src/autocomplete.ts +19 -17
  24. package/src/code-graph/commands.ts +2 -2
  25. package/src/code-graph/community.ts +1 -1
  26. package/src/code-graph/paths.ts +1 -1
  27. package/src/code-graph/watch.ts +2 -2
  28. package/src/compaction.ts +3 -3
  29. package/src/config-command.ts +154 -76
  30. package/src/dashboard.ts +257 -0
  31. package/src/exec.ts +709 -705
  32. package/src/global-state.ts +304 -0
  33. package/src/guard.ts +16 -3
  34. package/src/messaging.ts +44 -0
  35. package/src/plan.ts +421 -112
  36. package/src/query-hook.ts +4 -4
  37. package/src/refine-prompts.ts +14 -72
  38. package/src/refine-ui-helpers.ts +24 -5
  39. package/src/refine-ui-state.ts +1 -1
  40. package/src/refine-ui.ts +1 -1
  41. package/src/resume-command.ts +40 -130
  42. package/src/resume.ts +15 -17
  43. package/src/role-panels.ts +542 -0
  44. package/src/run-context.ts +5 -4
  45. package/src/run-picker.ts +98 -0
  46. package/src/state.ts +380 -77
  47. package/src/subagent.ts +32 -1
  48. package/src/task-tool.ts +100 -0
  49. package/src/tasks.ts +189 -0
  50. package/src/thinking-levels.ts +67 -0
  51. package/src/ui-language.ts +3 -54
  52. package/src/workflow-state.ts +78 -57
  53. package/tests/analyze-refs.test.ts +35 -18
  54. package/tests/ask-choice-pros-cons.test.ts +147 -0
  55. package/tests/ask-choice-schema.test.ts +0 -12
  56. package/tests/ask-choice.test.ts +2 -49
  57. package/tests/ask-form-tool.test.ts +4 -5
  58. package/tests/ask-form.test.ts +2 -2
  59. package/tests/auditor.test.ts +111 -0
  60. package/tests/auto-approve.test.ts +7 -10
  61. package/tests/autocomplete.test.ts +8 -11
  62. package/tests/code-graph-apply-action.test.ts +2 -2
  63. package/tests/code-graph-commands.test.ts +2 -2
  64. package/tests/code-graph-index.test.ts +2 -2
  65. package/tests/code-graph-loop.e2e.test.ts +1 -1
  66. package/tests/code-graph-mutations.test.ts +1 -1
  67. package/tests/code-graph-rollback.test.ts +1 -1
  68. package/tests/code-graph-v05.test.ts +2 -2
  69. package/tests/compaction.test.ts +1 -1
  70. package/tests/config-command.test.ts +103 -100
  71. package/tests/dashboard.test.ts +268 -0
  72. package/tests/exec-lifecycle.test.ts +181 -115
  73. package/tests/exec-panel-lifecycle.test.ts +106 -251
  74. package/tests/exec.test.ts +617 -1706
  75. package/tests/execute-plan.test.ts +44 -19
  76. package/tests/extension-load.test.ts +48 -0
  77. package/tests/global-state.test.ts +371 -0
  78. package/tests/graph-aware-file-tools.test.ts +5 -5
  79. package/tests/guard.test.ts +1 -1
  80. package/tests/multi-run.test.ts +184 -0
  81. package/tests/plan.test.ts +139 -62
  82. package/tests/plans.test.ts +7 -79
  83. package/tests/refine-prompts.test.ts +20 -71
  84. package/tests/refine-resume.test.ts +27 -22
  85. package/tests/refine-ui.test.ts +6 -15
  86. package/tests/resume-lifecycle.test.ts +37 -22
  87. package/tests/resume.test.ts +43 -88
  88. package/tests/role-panels.test.ts +391 -0
  89. package/tests/run-context.test.ts +1 -1
  90. package/tests/run-ownership.test.ts +1 -1
  91. package/tests/stale-ctx.test.ts +218 -0
  92. package/tests/state.test.ts +151 -32
  93. package/tests/subagent-thinking.test.ts +65 -0
  94. package/tests/subagent-usage.test.ts +1 -1
  95. package/tests/task-tool.test.ts +61 -0
  96. package/tests/thinking-levels.test.ts +77 -0
  97. package/tests/ui-language.test.ts +2 -17
  98. package/tests/workflow-state.test.ts +17 -99
  99. package/tools/analyze-refs.ts +67 -32
  100. package/tools/ask-choice.ts +19 -49
  101. package/tools/code-graph.ts +2 -2
  102. package/tools/execute-plan.ts +63 -33
  103. package/tools/graph-aware-file-tools.ts +6 -4
  104. package/tools/plans.ts +40 -66
  105. package/tools/refine.ts +101 -164
  106. package/agents/criticizer.md +0 -18
  107. package/scripts/bench/pi-adapter/__pycache__/pi_plans_bench.cpython-312.pyc +0 -0
  108. package/src/panel.ts +0 -473
  109. package/src/termination-prompt.ts +0 -73
  110. package/tests/goal-wait.test.ts +0 -269
  111. package/tests/panel-i-zero.test.ts +0 -420
  112. package/tests/panel.test.ts +0 -355
package/index.ts CHANGED
@@ -1,16 +1,16 @@
1
1
  /**
2
2
  * pi-plans — human-in-the-loop planning for the Pi coding agent.
3
3
  *
4
- * Researched, refined Markdown plans before any code changes. The five
4
+ * Researched, refined Markdown plans before any code changes. The six
5
5
  * planning skills are contributed via resources_discover; the extension
6
6
  * provides the supporting machinery:
7
7
  *
8
- * - `plans` tool — workspace state (config, runs, ledgers) in .git/pi_plans/
8
+ * - `plans` tool — workspace state (config, runs, ledgers) in .git/pi-plans/
9
9
  * - `ask_choice` tool — the choice-prompt contract (Other / Auto-complete rules)
10
- * - `refine` tool — reviewer/criticizer rounds via read-only pi subagents
10
+ * - `refine` tool — reviewer rounds (findings + questions) via read-only pi subagents
11
11
  * - `execute_plan` — execution handoff into the tracked execution loop
12
12
  * - write guard — planning runs may only write planning artifacts
13
- * - execution loop — checklist injection, [DONE:VC-xxx] tracking, progress status
13
+ * - execution loop — task-tree injection, plans_update_task tracking, dashboard, audit
14
14
  */
15
15
 
16
16
  import type { ExtensionAPI } from "@earendil-works/pi-coding-agent";
@@ -44,6 +44,7 @@ import {
44
44
  requestPlanningCompaction,
45
45
  restoreFromSession,
46
46
  stopExecution,
47
+ toggleDashboardExpanded,
47
48
  updateStatusWidget,
48
49
  shouldTriggerPlanningCompaction,
49
50
  } from "./src/exec.ts";
@@ -75,14 +76,18 @@ import { restartWatcherIfEnabled, stopGraphWatcher, disableWatcher } from "./src
75
76
  import { latestPlanVersion, nextPlanVersionPath } from "./src/plan.ts";
76
77
  import { configPiPlansCommand } from "./src/config-command.ts";
77
78
  import { resumePlansCommand } from "./src/resume-command.ts";
78
- import { getRun, loadConfig, readActive, recordDecision, resolveStateRootOrNull, setRunStatus } from "./src/state.ts";
79
+ import { getRun, listRuns, loadConfig, readActive, recordDecision, resolveStateRootOrNull, setRunStatus } from "./src/state.ts";
79
80
  import { boundRunId, resolveActiveRun, restoreRunBindingFromSession } from "./src/run-context.ts";
81
+ import { abandonCandidates, resolveCommandRun } from "./src/run-picker.ts";
80
82
  import { applyPlanWritten, mutateCheckpoint, planIdentityOf } from "./src/workflow-state.ts";
81
83
  import { registerAskChoiceTool } from "./tools/ask-choice.ts";
82
84
  import { executeCommand, registerExecutePlanTool } from "./tools/execute-plan.ts";
85
+ import { registerTaskStatusTool } from "./src/task-tool.ts";
86
+ import { flattenTaskViews, taskIsTerminal, taskProgress } from "./src/tasks.ts";
83
87
  import { registerPlansTool } from "./tools/plans.ts";
84
88
  import { registerRefineTool } from "./tools/refine.ts";
85
89
  import { registerAnalyzeRefsTool } from "./tools/analyze-refs.ts";
90
+ import { messaging, setMessagingApi } from "./src/messaging.ts";
86
91
 
87
92
  const baseDir = dirname(fileURLToPath(import.meta.url));
88
93
 
@@ -125,11 +130,17 @@ function hasActivePlanningWorkflow(ctx: Parameters<typeof updateStatusWidget>[0]
125
130
  }
126
131
 
127
132
  export default function piPlansExtension(pi: ExtensionAPI): void {
133
+ setMessagingApi(pi);
128
134
  registerPlansTool(pi);
129
135
  registerAskChoiceTool(pi);
130
136
  registerRefineTool(pi, baseDir);
131
137
  registerAnalyzeRefsTool(pi, baseDir);
132
138
  registerExecutePlanTool(pi);
139
+ registerTaskStatusTool(pi);
140
+ pi.registerShortcut("ctrl+shift+t", {
141
+ description: "Expand/collapse the pi-plans task dashboard",
142
+ handler: (ctx) => toggleDashboardExpanded(ctx),
143
+ });
133
144
  registerQueryInterviewHooks(pi, hasActivePlanningWorkflow);
134
145
  registerCodeGraphTool(pi);
135
146
  registerGraphAwareFileTools(pi);
@@ -176,7 +187,7 @@ export default function piPlansExtension(pi: ExtensionAPI): void {
176
187
  handler: async (args, ctx) => {
177
188
  const invocation = args.trim() ? `/skill:${name} ${args.trim()}` : `/skill:${name}`;
178
189
  try {
179
- pi.sendUserMessage(invocation, { expandPromptTemplates: true });
190
+ messaging().sendUserMessage(invocation, { expandPromptTemplates: true });
180
191
  } catch {
181
192
  ctx.ui.notify("Agent is busy; try again once the current turn finishes.", "error");
182
193
  }
@@ -206,7 +217,7 @@ export default function piPlansExtension(pi: ExtensionAPI): void {
206
217
  if (active) {
207
218
  const latest = latestPlanVersion(active.artifact_dir);
208
219
  if (latest && path.resolve(ctx.cwd, rawPath) === path.resolve(ctx.cwd, latest.path)) {
209
- pi.appendEntry(PLANNING_PLAN_WRITTEN_CUSTOM_TYPE, {
220
+ messaging().appendEntry(PLANNING_PLAN_WRITTEN_CUSTOM_TYPE, {
210
221
  runId: active.run_id,
211
222
  planPath: latest.path,
212
223
  });
@@ -252,14 +263,14 @@ export default function piPlansExtension(pi: ExtensionAPI): void {
252
263
  if (event.toolName !== "plans") return;
253
264
  if (!consumePrePlanCompactPending(ctx)) return;
254
265
  if (typeof ctx.compact !== "function") {
255
- sendPrePlanCompactResume(pi);
266
+ sendPrePlanCompactResume(ctx);
256
267
  return;
257
268
  }
258
269
  let resumed = false;
259
270
  const resumeOnce = () => {
260
271
  if (resumed) return;
261
272
  resumed = true;
262
- sendPrePlanCompactResume(pi);
273
+ sendPrePlanCompactResume(ctx);
263
274
  };
264
275
  ctx.compact({
265
276
  customInstructions: PLANNING_PREPLAN_COMPACT_HINT,
@@ -311,18 +322,18 @@ export default function piPlansExtension(pi: ExtensionAPI): void {
311
322
 
312
323
  pi.on("session_before_compact", async (event, ctx) => {
313
324
  noteCompactionStarted(ctx, event.customInstructions);
314
- const executionResult = await handleExecutionBeforeCompact(pi, ctx, event);
325
+ const executionResult = await handleExecutionBeforeCompact(ctx, event);
315
326
  if (executionResult) return executionResult;
316
- return handlePlanningBeforeCompact(pi, ctx, event);
327
+ return handlePlanningBeforeCompact(ctx, event);
317
328
  });
318
329
  pi.on("session_compact", async (event, ctx) => {
319
- await handleExecutionCompact(pi, ctx, event);
320
- await handlePlanningCompact(pi, ctx, event);
330
+ await handleExecutionCompact(ctx, event);
331
+ await handlePlanningCompact(ctx, event);
321
332
  noteCompactionEnded(ctx, event.customInstructions);
322
333
  });
323
334
  pi.on("session_compact_failed", async (event, ctx) => {
324
- handleExecutionCompactFailed(pi, ctx, event);
325
- handlePlanningCompactFailed(pi, ctx, event);
335
+ handleExecutionCompactFailed(ctx, event);
336
+ handlePlanningCompactFailed(ctx, event);
326
337
  noteCompactionEnded(ctx, event.customInstructions);
327
338
  });
328
339
 
@@ -330,7 +341,7 @@ export default function piPlansExtension(pi: ExtensionAPI): void {
330
341
  // Execution loop: inject remaining checklist each turn, track markers.
331
342
  // -----------------------------------------------------------------------
332
343
  pi.on("before_agent_start", async (_event, ctx) => {
333
- drainExecutionFlush(pi, ctx);
344
+ drainExecutionFlush(ctx);
334
345
  const content = executionContextMessage(ctx);
335
346
  if (!content) {
336
347
  if (!getExecution() && shouldTriggerPlanningCompaction(ctx)) {
@@ -370,7 +381,7 @@ export default function piPlansExtension(pi: ExtensionAPI): void {
370
381
  // -----------------------------------------------------------------------
371
382
 
372
383
  pi.registerCommand("init-graph", {
373
- description: "Index the worktree into .git/pi_plans/code_graph.db. If a graph DB already exists, prompt to rebuild or sync changed paths via /update-graph; `--reindex` and non-interactive runs stay on the rebuild path.",
384
+ description: "Index the worktree into .git/pi-plans/code_graph.db. If a graph DB already exists, prompt to rebuild or sync changed paths via /update-graph; `--reindex` and non-interactive runs stay on the rebuild path.",
374
385
  handler: async (args, ctx) => {
375
386
  await initGraphCommand(args, ctx);
376
387
  },
@@ -436,23 +447,38 @@ export default function piPlansExtension(pi: ExtensionAPI): void {
436
447
  description: "Show pi-plans state: config, active run, and execution progress",
437
448
  handler: async (_args, ctx) => {
438
449
  const lines: string[] = [];
450
+ // v0.6.0: list ALL runs (newest first, bound marked, cap 50) instead of
451
+ // only the shared active one — multi-run workdirs stay legible.
452
+ const runs = listRuns(ctx.cwd).slice(0, 50);
453
+ const bound = boundRunId(ctx.sessionManager, ctx.cwd);
454
+ if (runs.length === 0) {
455
+ lines.push("No planning runs recorded in this workdir.");
456
+ } else {
457
+ lines.push(`Runs (${runs.length} shown, newest first):`);
458
+ for (const run of runs) {
459
+ lines.push(` ${run.run_id === bound ? "★" : " "} ${run.topic} · ${run.status} · ${run.skill} · ${run.updated_at}`);
460
+ }
461
+ }
439
462
  const active = resolveActiveRun(ctx.sessionManager, ctx.cwd);
440
463
  const run = active ? getRun(ctx.cwd, active.run_id) : null;
441
- if (!run) {
442
- lines.push("No active planning run.");
443
- } else {
444
- lines.push(`Active run: ${run.run_id}`);
464
+ if (run) {
465
+ lines.push(`Session run: ${run.run_id}`);
445
466
  lines.push(`Skill: ${run.skill} Status: ${run.status}`);
446
467
  lines.push(`Artifacts: ${run.artifact_dir}`);
447
468
  lines.push(`Language: ${run.language_tag ?? "(unset)"}`);
448
469
  lines.push(`State: ${resolveStateRootOrNull(ctx.cwd) ?? "(no repo)"}`);
449
470
  }
471
+ // One-time active.json deprecation note (v0.6.0 registry migration).
472
+ if (fs.existsSync(path.join(resolveStateRootOrNull(ctx.cwd) ?? ".git/pi-plans", "active.json"))) {
473
+ lines.push("Note: active.json is deprecated — the run registry now derives from runs/*/run.json; the legacy file is ignored.");
474
+ }
450
475
  const execution = getExecution();
451
476
  if (execution) {
452
- const done = execution.items.filter((item) => item.done).length;
453
- lines.push(`Execution: ${execution.planPath} — ${done}/${execution.items.length} verifier items done`);
454
- for (const item of execution.items) {
455
- lines.push(` ${item.done ? "☑" : "☐"} ${item.id}`);
477
+ const progress = taskProgress(execution.tasks);
478
+ const vcDone = execution.items.filter((item) => item.done).length;
479
+ lines.push(`Execution: ${execution.planPath} — tasks ${progress.done}/${progress.total} · VC ${vcDone}/${execution.items.length}`);
480
+ for (const task of flattenTaskViews(execution.tasks)) {
481
+ lines.push(` ${taskIsTerminal(task) ? (task.status === "skipped" ? "~" : "☑") : "☐"} ${task.id}`);
456
482
  }
457
483
  }
458
484
  lines.push(`Auto-complete: ${autoCompleteStatus(ctx)}`);
@@ -462,7 +488,7 @@ export default function piPlansExtension(pi: ExtensionAPI): void {
462
488
  });
463
489
 
464
490
  pi.registerCommand("config-pi-plans", {
465
- description: "Re-ask and update pi-plans workspace config: language, artifact root, graph, reviewer, and criticizer defaults",
491
+ description: "Re-ask and update pi-plans workspace config: language, artifact root, graph, and reviewer defaults",
466
492
  handler: async (args, ctx) => {
467
493
  await configPiPlansCommand(args, ctx);
468
494
  },
@@ -538,7 +564,7 @@ export default function piPlansExtension(pi: ExtensionAPI): void {
538
564
  `${doneIds.length}/${execution.items.length} verifier item(s) already verified; their work stays. Remaining items return to planning.`,
539
565
  );
540
566
  if (!ok) return;
541
- await stopExecution(pi, ctx, "interrupted by /update-plan");
567
+ await stopExecution(ctx, "interrupted by /update-plan");
542
568
  }
543
569
 
544
570
  // Return the run to planning so refinement rules and guards apply again.
@@ -586,7 +612,7 @@ export default function piPlansExtension(pi: ExtensionAPI): void {
586
612
  "Follow the original planning-skill contract for revisions: collect needed clarifications via ask_choice (one question at a time, recorded), apply evidence-based revisions only, then ask the next merged accept/execute question (autoComplete: false — ✓ Accept & execute now / Accept, don't execute yet / another round) and call execute_plan pointing at the new version on accept.",
587
613
  );
588
614
 
589
- await pi.sendUserMessage(lines.join("\n"));
615
+ await messaging().sendUserMessage(lines.join("\n"));
590
616
  },
591
617
  });
592
618
 
@@ -597,9 +623,9 @@ export default function piPlansExtension(pi: ExtensionAPI): void {
597
623
  ctx.ui.notify("No execution in progress.", "info");
598
624
  return;
599
625
  }
600
- const ok = await ctx.ui.confirm("Stop execution?", "Remaining verifier items will be left unfinished.");
626
+ const ok = await ctx.ui.confirm("Stop execution?", "Open tasks will be left unfinished.");
601
627
  if (!ok) return;
602
- await stopExecution(pi, ctx, "stopped by user via /plans-stop");
628
+ await stopExecution(ctx, "stopped by user via /plans-stop");
603
629
  ctx.ui.notify("Execution stopped.", "info");
604
630
  },
605
631
  });
@@ -608,31 +634,38 @@ export default function piPlansExtension(pi: ExtensionAPI): void {
608
634
  description:
609
635
  "Resume the working plan in this repository: unfinished planning / reviewing / execution / implementation review, across sessions and linked worktrees, in the current session.",
610
636
  handler: async (_args, ctx) => {
611
- await resumePlansCommand(pi, ctx, baseDir);
637
+ await resumePlansCommand(ctx, baseDir);
612
638
  },
613
639
  });
614
640
 
615
641
  pi.registerCommand("plans-abandon", {
616
642
  description: "Abandon the active planning run (lifts the read-only guard; artifacts are kept)",
617
643
  handler: async (_args, ctx) => {
618
- const active = resolveActiveRun(ctx.sessionManager, ctx.cwd);
619
- if (!active) {
644
+ // v0.6.0 (R-3): pick the run to abandon when several candidates exist;
645
+ // binding-first, single candidate stays direct (0.5.7 parity).
646
+ const chosen = await resolveCommandRun(
647
+ { cwd: ctx.cwd, sessionManager: ctx.sessionManager, ui: ctx.ui },
648
+ { candidates: abandonCandidates(ctx.cwd), title: "Abandon which run?" },
649
+ );
650
+ if (!chosen) {
620
651
  ctx.ui.notify("No active planning run.", "info");
621
652
  return;
622
653
  }
654
+ const active = resolveActiveRun(ctx.sessionManager, ctx.cwd);
655
+ const abandoningBound = active?.run_id === chosen.run_id;
623
656
  const ok = await ctx.ui.confirm(
624
657
  "Abandon planning run?",
625
- `${active.run_id}\nThe read-only guard lifts; committed artifacts stay in place.`,
658
+ `${chosen.run_id} (${chosen.topic} · ${chosen.status})\nThe read-only guard lifts; committed artifacts stay in place.`,
626
659
  );
627
660
  if (!ok) return;
628
661
  // Abandon must end execution first so the planning model is restored.
629
662
  disableAutoComplete(ctx, "run abandoned");
630
- if (getExecution()) {
631
- await stopExecution(pi, ctx, "run abandoned via /plans-abandon");
663
+ if (abandoningBound && getExecution()) {
664
+ await stopExecution(ctx, "run abandoned via /plans-abandon");
632
665
  }
633
666
  try {
634
- setRunStatus(ctx.cwd, active.run_id, "abandoned");
635
- ctx.ui.notify(`Run ${active.run_id} abandoned.`, "info");
667
+ setRunStatus(ctx.cwd, chosen.run_id, "abandoned");
668
+ ctx.ui.notify(`Run ${chosen.run_id} abandoned.`, "info");
636
669
  } catch (error) {
637
670
  ctx.ui.notify(`Failed: ${(error as Error).message}`, "error");
638
671
  }
@@ -644,7 +677,7 @@ export default function piPlansExtension(pi: ExtensionAPI): void {
644
677
  // Session lifecycle
645
678
  // -----------------------------------------------------------------------
646
679
  pi.on("session_tree", async (_event, ctx) => {
647
- await restoreFromSession(pi, ctx, ctx.sessionManager.getBranch() as unknown as Parameters<typeof restoreFromSession>[2]);
680
+ await restoreFromSession(ctx, ctx.sessionManager.getBranch() as unknown as Parameters<typeof restoreFromSession>[1]);
648
681
  restoreRunBindingFromSession(
649
682
  ctx.sessionManager,
650
683
  ctx.cwd,
@@ -652,7 +685,7 @@ export default function piPlansExtension(pi: ExtensionAPI): void {
652
685
  );
653
686
  });
654
687
  pi.on("session_start", async (_event, ctx) => {
655
- await restoreFromSession(pi, ctx, ctx.sessionManager.getBranch() as unknown as Parameters<typeof restoreFromSession>[2]);
688
+ await restoreFromSession(ctx, ctx.sessionManager.getBranch() as unknown as Parameters<typeof restoreFromSession>[1]);
656
689
  restoreAutoCompleteFromSession(ctx, ctx.sessionManager.getEntries() as unknown as Parameters<typeof restoreAutoCompleteFromSession>[1]);
657
690
  restoreRunBindingFromSession(
658
691
  ctx.sessionManager,
@@ -661,3 +694,4 @@ export default function piPlansExtension(pi: ExtensionAPI): void {
661
694
  );
662
695
  });
663
696
  }
697
+
package/package.json CHANGED
@@ -1,6 +1,6 @@
1
1
  {
2
2
  "name": "pi-plans",
3
- "version": "0.5.7",
3
+ "version": "0.7.0",
4
4
  "description": "Human-in-the-loop planning extension for the Pi coding agent: researched, refined Markdown plans before any code changes.",
5
5
  "license": "MIT",
6
6
  "type": "module",
@@ -40,6 +40,7 @@
40
40
  "files": [
41
41
  "README.md",
42
42
  "LICENSE",
43
+ "CONTRIBUTING.md",
43
44
  "index.ts",
44
45
  "agents/",
45
46
  "docs/assets",
@@ -9,17 +9,17 @@ This skill set is written for the Pi coding agent's documented behavior:
9
9
  - the five skills are contributed by the pi-plans extension and loaded as Pi skills (also invokable as `/skill:<name>`);
10
10
  - skill references and helper sources are resolved relative to the directory containing `SKILL.md`;
11
11
  - Planning and reference analysis run with the extension tools `plans`, `ask_choice`, `refine`, `analyze_refs`, and `execute_plan`;
12
- - `refine` spawns read-only Pi subagents (`pi --mode json -p --no-session --tools read,grep,find,ls`, plus `code_graph` for both roles when workspace `graph_enabled` is true) with isolated context; delegated Reviewer/Criticizer runs show a standalone aggregate overlay titled `Reviewer` or `Criticizer` (78% × 78% top-center, ≥72 cols, no input row), stream assistant/thinking/tool events into per-lane transcripts with follow-bottom scroll, dismiss on `Esc` (close-only — the refiner child keeps running and its result still flows back as tool output), replace any retained finished overlay when a new round begins, and return conclusions to the main session as tool output; `analyze_refs` spawns one read-only subagent per downloaded reference (cwd = that ref's directory) reusing the reviewer role gates, shows the same overlay titled `Refs` in batches of at most 3 lanes, and returns structured per-reference sections for `REF_ANALYSIS.md`;
12
+ - `refine` spawns read-only Pi subagents (`pi --mode json -p --no-session --tools read,grep,find,ls`, plus `code_graph` when workspace `graph_enabled` is true) with isolated context; delegated reviewer runs show a standalone aggregate overlay titled `Reviewer` (78% × 78% top-center, ≥72 cols, no input row), stream assistant/thinking/tool events into per-lane transcripts with follow-bottom scroll, dismiss on `Esc` (close-only — the refiner child keeps running and its result still flows back as tool output), replace any retained finished overlay when a new round begins, and return conclusions to the main session as tool output; `analyze_refs` spawns one read-only subagent per downloaded reference (cwd = that ref's directory) reusing the reviewer role gates, shows the same overlay titled `Refs` in batches of at most 3 lanes, and returns structured per-reference sections for `REF_ANALYSIS.md`;
13
13
  - when graph mode is enabled, graph-aware `read`/`edit` overrides are active for indexed source files: `read` returns a capped function digest (≤50 lines, synthetic anonymous entries folded) by default — drill in via `offset/limit` or `code_graph get-function`, and `full: true` is the only whole-file exit (small/zero-function files return full text; safety truncation matches native read); `write`/`edit` stage DB-first mutations until materialized via the `code_graph` tool's `apply` action (same planning/accepted gate as /apply-graph; refused for read-only refiner subagents via the PI_PLANS_REFINER marker; returns a per-file report with counts and a post-apply drift summary, and never changes run status); unexpected fallbacks (`not indexed` / `runtime unavailable` / `config read failed`) are marked at the top of the result while flag-off fallbacks stay unmarked;
14
- - the execution loop is extension-managed: remaining verifier items are injected each turn, implementation items emit `[I-###:current]`/`[I-###:implemented|validating]`, and `[DONE:VC-xxx]` markers are tracked with a bottom status bar;
14
+ - the execution loop is extension-managed and task-tree driven: the current wave and remaining tasks are injected each turn, progress is reported exclusively through the `plans_update_task` tool (status + evidence / skipReason), the task dashboard tracks every task (compact widget; Ctrl+Shift+T expands the tree), and an independent completion auditor verifies the verification checks before the run completes;
15
15
  - execution and planning compaction keep Pi's SessionManager as the history owner; during active pi-plans runs, `session_before_compact` uses a deterministic no-LLM VCC-style summary with `[Session Goal]`, `[Files And Changes]`, `[Commits]`, `[Outstanding Context]`, `[User Preferences]`, and a ranked brief transcript; Pi core owns manual `/compact`, threshold, and overflow scheduling, while pi-plans handles smart tail keep, `keep:N`, stats, and phase-specific run/plan/current-I/checklist context; in addition, creating a new planning run (`plans start-run`) proactively requests one pre-plan VCC compaction before the first planning question and resumes the planning turn with a hidden message (default on, `prePlanCompact` in `pi-vcc-config.json`);
16
16
 
17
17
  ## Planning Boundary
18
18
 
19
19
  - Treat the user's request as a planning target, not as write authorization.
20
- - Before the execution handoff, do not edit target source files, docs, configs, package metadata, generated assets, or tests outside the planning artifact directory and the pi-plans state under `.git/pi_plans/`. The extension enforces this for `edit` and `write` while a run is active: only `.git/pi_plans/`, the run's artifact directory, `~/.cache/pi-plans/`, and the configured refs root are writable. Bash is not machine-guarded — keep it read-only by discipline (inspection, `git init`, downloads into the cache).
21
- - The normal pre-handoff writes are `.git/pi_plans/` state plus planning artifacts under the configured artifact root (default `./docs/pi-plans/...`).
22
- - Downloaded references go to the workspace's configured refs root (`refs_root` in `.git/pi_plans/config.json`; unset → ask once via `ask_choice`, recommended `.git/pi-plans/refs/`, second `./refs/`, third `~/.cache/pi-plans/refs/`; persist with the `plans` tool, `set-refs-root`) and their paths and evidence are recorded in `REF_ANALYSIS.md`.
20
+ - Before the execution handoff, do not edit target source files, docs, configs, package metadata, generated assets, or tests outside the planning artifact directory and the pi-plans state under `.git/pi-plans/`. The extension enforces this for `edit` and `write` while a run is active: only `.git/pi-plans/`, the run's artifact directory, `~/.cache/pi-plans/`, and the configured refs root are writable. Bash is not machine-guarded — keep it read-only by discipline (inspection, `git init`, downloads into the cache).
21
+ - The normal pre-handoff writes are `.git/pi-plans/` state plus planning artifacts under the configured artifact root (default `./.git/pi-plans/plans/...`).
22
+ - Downloaded references go to the workspace's configured refs root (`refs_root` in `.git/pi-plans/config.json`; unset → ask once via `ask_choice`, recommended `.git/pi-plans/refs/`, second `./refs/`, third `~/.cache/pi-plans/refs/`; persist with the `plans` tool, `set-refs-root`) and their paths and evidence are recorded in `REF_ANALYSIS.md`. References are not limited to GitHub repositories: papers (arXiv etc.), engineering blogs, and documentation sites are first-class, with per-medium qualified downloads (repo = clone; paper = full text — abstracts never qualify; blog/docs = full-article markdown) and one directory per reference; theoretical references count exactly as much as implementation references. plan-normal and plan-big may optionally cite 1–2 search-found references (URLs in the plan's Evidence section) without downloading them.
23
23
  - After the user explicitly approves the execution handoff, leave this planning workflow and execute in the extension-managed loop (see Execution Handoff).
24
24
 
25
25
  ## State And Settings
@@ -30,13 +30,13 @@ Before the first planning question, read `references/state-and-config.md` and in
30
30
  { "action": "init", "workdir": "<target-workdir>" }
31
31
  ```
32
32
 
33
- State lives under the workspace's resolved git common dir as `.git/pi_plans/` (auto-ignored, no `.gitignore` entries; the tool auto-runs `git init` when the workdir safely has no repository). The target workspace is the current working directory unless the user explicitly names another repository.
33
+ State lives under the workspace's resolved git common dir as `.git/pi-plans/` (auto-ignored, no `.gitignore` entries; the tool auto-runs `git init` when the workdir safely has no repository). The target workspace is the current working directory unless the user explicitly names another repository.
34
34
 
35
- If `language.tag` is missing from `.git/pi_plans/config.json`, ask the language setting question (via `ask_choice`) before any product question. Persist it with `plans` (`set-language`); this question does not count against the planning-question limit.
35
+ If `language.tag` is missing from `.git/pi-plans/config.json`, ask the language setting question (via `ask_choice`) before any product question. Persist it with `plans` (`set-language`); this question does not count against the planning-question limit.
36
36
 
37
- If `artifact_root_source` is missing from `.git/pi_plans/config.json` or is `unset`, ask the planning docs location question (via `ask_choice`) before any product question. Persist it with `plans` (`set-artifact-root`); this question does not count against the planning-question limit.
37
+ If `artifact_root_source` is missing from `.git/pi-plans/config.json` or is `unset`, ask the planning docs location question (via `ask_choice`) before any product question. Persist it with `plans` (`set-artifact-root`); this question does not count against the planning-question limit.
38
38
 
39
- Reviewer and criticizer settings also live in `config.json`. If a role's mode is missing/invalid or its `confirmed_at` is `null` when the role is about to run, ask the matching role-setting or model-confirmation question (via `ask_choice`), persist with `plans` (`set-role`), and then run the `refine` tool. The `refine` tool refuses to spawn until the gates pass.
39
+ The reviewer role lives in the GLOBAL config (`~/.pi/pi-plans/config.json`, `PI_PLANS_GLOBAL_DIR` override — one confirmation for every workspace). If its mode is missing/invalid when a round is about to run, ask the role-setting question via `ask_choice` and persist with `plans` (`set-role`). The model + thinking level are confirmed at first use through NATIVE panels, not ask_choice: in TUI the `refine` gate itself pops a searchable model panel followed by an effort panel (Default row = no `--thinking` flag; other rows follow the chosen model's `thinkingLevelMap`) and continues the same invocation on completion; hasUI non-TUI sessions get native menus; UI-less sessions get text guidance embedding the available selectors. Esc cancels the whole gate (nothing persisted; do NOT re-ask via ask_choice — suggest `/config-pi-plans`). The `refine` tool refuses to spawn until `reviewerReady` passes (current-session, or delegated with a confirmed concrete `provider/model`). (v0.6.1: the criticizer role is gone — the reviewer emits findings AND questions in one round.)
40
40
 
41
41
  ## First-Turn Contract
42
42
 
@@ -59,7 +59,7 @@ When the recommended option depends on a web-verifiable claim, search first (web
59
59
 
60
60
  Every user-facing planning or refinement question goes through the `ask_choice` tool:
61
61
 
62
- - `options`: ordered options, recommended option first with `recommended: true` (exactly one), each with the tradeoff that matters in `description`;
62
+ - `options`: ordered options, recommended option first with `recommended: true` (exactly one), each with a `description` of the form `✓ <advantage> / ✗ <drawback>` — **every option you author states both what it gains and what it costs**, in the configured language, tersely (≈8 words per half; write `—` when a side is genuinely absent). Both halves live in the single `description` string; there are no separate `pros`/`cons` fields. This rule covers every AI-written option, including the scope confirmation and the merged accept/execute handoff; only the tool-appended `Other…` / `Auto-complete` rows are exempt;
63
63
  - do not add `Other` or `Auto-complete` yourself — the tool appends `Other…` second-last and `Auto-complete` last;
64
64
  - pass `autoComplete: false` for the merged accept/execute question — it contains the execution approval, so Auto-complete never appears there — and for any install waiver, publishing, deployment, merge, push, credential, or external-state question. Auto-complete may choose the recommended planning or refinement option only.
65
65
  - When the user selects Auto-complete, it remains active for the current planning run: later eligible questions use their recommended options automatically, and the extension queues one deduplicated follow-up if the model stops after an auto-completed answer. `/plans-autocomplete-stop` disables it; session restore may reactivate it only for the same active run while its status is `planning`.
@@ -74,9 +74,9 @@ Create a run only after initial read-only inspection makes the topic clear:
74
74
  { "action": "start-run", "workdir": "<target-workdir>", "topic": "<short topic>", "skill": "<skill-name>", "requestText": "<original request>" }
75
75
  ```
76
76
 
77
- The tool creates the configured artifact directory root (default `./docs/pi-plans/YYYY-MM-DD-<topic>/`) and the private run state `.git/pi_plans/runs/<run-id>/`, and stores the active run pointer. Use a short lowercase slug for the topic. Keep paths stable once written.
77
+ The tool creates the configured artifact directory root (default `./.git/pi-plans/plans/YYYY-MM-DD-<topic>/`) and the private run state `.git/pi-plans/runs/<run-id>/`, and stores the active run pointer. Use a short lowercase slug for the topic. Keep paths stable once written.
78
78
 
79
- `DECISIONS.md` records: original request; repository evidence inspected; each question, options, selected answer, and whether it came from the user or Auto-complete; assumptions still open; external sources consulted; language, reviewer, and criticizer settings used.
79
+ `DECISIONS.md` records: original request; repository evidence inspected; each question, options, selected answer, and whether it came from the user or Auto-complete; assumptions still open; external sources consulted; language and reviewer settings used.
80
80
 
81
81
  ## Final Scope Confirmation
82
82
 
@@ -91,93 +91,80 @@ If the user adds requirements, resolve only the necessary follow-up questions, t
91
91
 
92
92
  ## Plan Artifact Requirements
93
93
 
94
- Every `PLAN_vN.md` must include stable IDs that are never recycled across revisions: goals and non-goals; requirements and constraints; implementation items; affected paths; dependencies and sequencing; risks and mitigations; acceptance criteria; verification steps; repo and external evidence; resolved decisions; revision ledger.
94
+ Every `PLAN_vN.md` must include stable IDs that are never recycled across revisions: `Task-N` tasks (with deps/files/wave and one subtask level), `VC-###` verification checks, and the revision ledger. Everything else the workflow needs lives in the run state (decisions ledger, review rounds, refs), not in the plan file.
95
95
 
96
- Every plan version must include a dedicated `## Verifier Checklist` section. Each item is a Markdown checkbox of the exact shape:
96
+ Every plan version's body is exactly two sections — `## Tasks` and `## Verification Checks` — plus the metadata header (see `references/plan-artifact-template.md` for the full microsyntax: `Task-N` ids, one subtask level, inline `deps:`/`files:`/`wave:` fields, the `### Execution Waves` subsection, and lint rules). Each verification check is a Markdown checkbox of the exact shape:
97
97
 
98
98
  ```markdown
99
- - [ ] `VC-001` covers `I-001`; pass condition: ...; evidence: ...; metric: <threshold or reason not quantified>.
99
+ - [ ] `VC-001` covers `Task-1`; pass condition: ...; evidence: ...; metric: <threshold or reason not quantified>.
100
100
  ```
101
101
 
102
- The execution loop parses `- [ ] \`VC-###\`` items and tracks `[DONE:VC-###]` markers, so keep IDs on the checkbox line. Use `references/plan-artifact-template.md` when drafting.
102
+ The execution loop parses `- [ ] \`VC-###\`` checks and the task tree, so keep IDs on the checkbox line and the task grammar exact; task progress flows through `plans_update_task` and the completion auditor reads these checks. Use `references/plan-artifact-template.md` when drafting.
103
103
 
104
104
  ## Refinement
105
105
 
106
- After each plan version, ask one merged accept/execute question via `ask_choice` with `autoComplete: false` — it contains the execution approval, so Auto-complete never appears. Options:
106
+ After each plan version, ask one merged accept/execute question via `ask_choice` with `autoComplete: false` — it contains the execution approval, so Auto-complete never appears. Each of the three options below carries the usual `✓ <advantage> / ✗ <drawback>` description (executing now versus deferring versus another refine round are real trade-offs — say what each wins and costs). Options:
107
107
 
108
108
  1. `✓ Accept PLAN_vN and execute it now` — mark the plan accepted (`plans set-status accepted`), then call the `execute_plan` tool.
109
109
  2. `Accept PLAN_vN, don't execute yet` — mark accepted; resume later via `/plans-execute`.
110
110
  3. `Run another round: <the level's default next refine mode>` — only while the level's default sequence is unfinished.
111
111
 
112
- The recommended option follows the skill level's default sequence: while the default rounds are unfinished it is option 3's default next mode (`plan-small`: `Criticizer`; `plan-normal`: `Reviewer` then `Criticizer`; `plan-big`: three concurrent reviewers (`refine` with `reviewers: 3`) then `Criticizer`); once the default sequence is complete it is option 1.
112
+ The recommended option follows the skill level's default sequence: while the default round is unfinished it is option 3 (`plan-small` / `plan-normal`: one reviewer round; `plan-big` / `plan-with-refs`: three concurrent reviewers via `refine` with `reviewers: 3`); once the default round is complete it is option 1. Every round returns findings (`F-###`) and up to five questions (`Q-1..Q-5`) in the same output.
113
113
 
114
- If the user selects `Reviewer` or `Criticizer`, run the `refine` tool with the plan path and any focus. Reviewer output consolidates into `PLAN_vN_reviewer_comments.md` with findings IDs, severity, affected plan IDs, evidence, impact, recommended fix, and disposition. Revise the next plan only for findings accepted on evidence.
114
+ If the user selects another round, run the `refine` tool with the plan path and any focus. Reviewer output consolidates into `PLAN_vN_reviewer_comments.md` with findings IDs, severity, affected plan IDs, evidence, impact, recommended fix, and disposition. Revise the next plan only for findings accepted on evidence.
115
115
 
116
116
  ### Concurrent Reviewers (big plans)
117
117
 
118
118
  A big-plan reviewer round runs three independent reviewer subagents (`reviewers: 3`); each gets its own emphasis lens but forms its own priorities. After they return, merge and dedupe their findings into one consolidated `PLAN_vN_reviewer_comments.md`, keeping each finding's source reviewer, severity, evidence, and disposition, and surface at most five high-priority comments to the user. Treat agreement between independent reviewers as stronger evidence, not as authority; every accepted finding still needs repo or reference evidence.
119
119
 
120
- ### Criticizer Rounds
120
+ ### Reviewer Questions
121
121
 
122
- Present each criticizer question with `ask_choice` (one call per question, in the configured language). Before each question, summarize the original criticism in at most three sentences and highlight the most important point. Do not revise the plan until every criticizer question has a recorded answer.
122
+ Merge the rounds' `Questions` sections into one deduped list and ask EVERY question with `ask_choice` (one batched `questions: [...]` form or one call per question, in the configured language, stable questionIds). Do not revise the plan until every reviewer question has a recorded answer.
123
123
 
124
124
  ### Round Lifecycle
125
125
 
126
- A refinement round is complete when all reviewer outputs have returned or all criticizer questions have answers. In the same turn: consolidate, accept or reject each finding on evidence (the user may override any disposition), revise to `PLAN_v(N+1).md` when accepted items require it (copy, edit only the new version, update the revision ledger and verifier checklist), then immediately ask the next merged accept/execute question. Never end a turn merely because a round completed.
126
+ A refinement round is complete when all reviewer lanes have returned; each lane's output carries findings (`F-###`) and up to five questions (`Q-1..Q-5`). In the same turn: consolidate, accept or reject each finding on evidence (the user may override any disposition), revise to `PLAN_v(N+1).md` when accepted items require it (copy, edit only the new version, update the revision ledger and verifier checklist), then immediately ask the next merged accept/execute question. Never end a turn merely because a round completed.
127
127
 
128
128
  ## Execution Handoff
129
129
 
130
- When the user picks `✓ Accept PLAN_vN and execute it now` in the merged question, mark the plan accepted and call the `execute_plan` tool (or the user runs `/plans-execute`). It re-confirms with the user, then the extension enters execution mode:
130
+ When the user picks `✓ Accept PLAN_vN and execute it now` in the merged question, mark the plan accepted and call the `execute_plan` tool (or the user runs `/plans-execute`). It re-confirms with the user (never auto-completed), then the extension enters task-tree execution mode:
131
131
 
132
- - every agent turn is injected with the remaining verifier checklist and execution rules (layered simplest implementation, waiting for subprocess-backed verification with backoff 5s -> 10s -> 20s -> 40s -> 80s, then keep polling at 80s and restart at 5s for each new subprocess, no stopgaps, dependency and library discipline, minimum tests);
133
- - execution-phase compaction is handled only when Pi core emits manual `/compact`, threshold, or overflow events; summaries are deterministic VCC-style summaries, include session-derived plan/current-I/checklist context, use smart tail keep and `keep:N`, and never call a model or request proactive current-I compaction;
132
+ - every agent turn is injected with the current wave's open tasks, the remaining task list, verification-check summary, and execution rules (wave order, `plans_update_task` reporting with status + evidence / skipReason, subprocess polling backoff 5s -> 10s -> 20s -> 40s -> 80s then keep polling at 80s, no stopgaps, dependency and library discipline, minimum tests);
133
+ - task progress flows exclusively through the `plans_update_task` tool: one call per task closing it as `complete` (with evidence) or `skipped` (with skipReason); closed statuses are immutable outside the audit-authorized rollback channel; subtasks close before their parent;
134
+ - the task dashboard tracks the whole tree live: a compact aboveEditor widget (current task ▸, progress bar, ✓/· counts, VC pass count, wave indicator, pause state, audit-failure line) and the Ctrl+Shift+T expanded tree view (✓/▸/~/· markers, current-task anchor, VC list with audit state, width-adaptive layout);
135
+ - a stall watchdog pauses execution after three consecutive settled rounds without any task-status change (genuine user input or `/plans-execute` resumes without losing progress);
136
+ - when every task reaches a terminal state, an independent read-only completion auditor verifies each check against the worktree: failed checks roll their covered tasks (children cascade, skipped tasks reopen) back to pending and inject the audit report; the audit re-runs as tasks re-close; after three failed rounds the run pauses for the user — under auto-approve/headless it terminates as `stopped` with the audit report so pipelines never hang; checks whose covered tasks are all skipped pass as skipped-pass; checks covering no task never enter the audit;
137
+ - execution-phase compaction is handled only when Pi core emits manual `/compact`, threshold, or overflow events; summaries are deterministic VCC-style summaries, include session-derived plan/current-task/checklist context, use smart tail keep and `keep:N`, and never call a model;
134
138
  - the read-only guard lifts: full write access returns;
135
- - the run status moves to `executing`, then `done` when the last `[DONE:VC-xxx]` marker lands;
139
+ - the run status moves to `executing`, then `done` when the completion audit passes;
136
140
  - `/plans-stop` stops execution; `/plans` shows progress.
137
141
 
138
142
  If the user declines, stay in planning (or stop, per their choice). Never start implementation without the approved handoff.
139
143
 
140
- ### Execution Goal-Wait
144
+ ### Continuation Between Turns
141
145
 
142
- In TUI/RPC, automatic goal-wait is evaluated only at `agent_settled`, after
146
+ In TUI/RPC, automatic continuation is evaluated only at `agent_settled`, after
143
147
  Pi has finished natural tool continuation, retries, and compaction. The
144
- extension rechecks that the same execution is active and incomplete, the
148
+ extension rechecks that the same execution is active with open tasks, the
145
149
  session is idle, and neither pending input nor compaction owns continuation.
146
150
  Each eligible settled cycle can send at most one hidden custom message with
147
- the current execution rules and remaining VC checklist. Tool `turn_end`
148
- events only update progress; they never prequeue goal-wait reminders.
149
-
150
- No-progress and literal `waiting for` counters advance only on eligible
151
- settled cycles. Real marker progress resets both; thresholds remain 3 and 6.
152
- User interruption and final model errors also pause continuation. Genuine
153
- interactive/RPC user input or `/plans-execute` can resume a paused active
154
- execution without losing verified VCs; extension input cannot unpause it.
155
- New-plan handoffs and the `execute_plan` tool still require explicit approval.
156
- Completion, stop, and session replacement invalidate the extension's wake
157
- identity without clearing user or other-extension queues. Print/JSON
158
- single-shot sessions keep VC tracking and completion but never auto-wake;
151
+ the current execution rules. Tool `turn_end` events only update usage; they
152
+ never prequeue continuation reminders. The stall watchdog counts settled
153
+ cycles without task-state change (threshold 3) and pauses instead of waking;
154
+ user interruption and final model errors pause too. Genuine interactive/RPC
155
+ user input or `/plans-execute` resumes a paused active execution without
156
+ losing task progress; extension input cannot unpause it. New-plan handoffs
157
+ and the `execute_plan` tool still require explicit approval. Print/JSON
158
+ single-shot sessions keep task tracking and completion but never auto-wake;
159
159
  use RPC for persistent headless execution.
160
160
 
161
- ### Post-Execution Continuation
162
-
163
- When execution completes in an interactive session, the completion message attaches a goal-running continuation block and triggers a new agent turn so the model can enter the implementation-review loop immediately. The interactive-only trigger keeps headless sessions silent (no unconsented subagent cost). The same behavior applies on both completion call sites (the normal `turn_end` completion and the `restoreFromSession` recovery path).
164
-
165
- The agent then asks two `ask_choice` questions (each single-question, `autoComplete: false`) to configure the implementation-review loop:
166
-
167
- 1. **Termination condition** (questionId `termination-condition`, recommended first: goal wait) — options: 1. goal wait: continue until no unpassed VCs remain (auto-continue each round) 2. until no high-severity finding (hard cap 5 rounds) 3. 1 round 4. 2 rounds 5. 3 rounds.
168
- 2. **Reviewer count** (questionId `impl-review-reviewer-count`, `allowOther: false`, pure digit labels `1`/`2`/`3`, recommended first): "How many concurrent reviewers should each implementation-review round use?" The recommended default follows the run's skill: `plan-big` / `plan-with-refs` → 3, others → 1.
169
-
170
- Both answers persist TOGETHER in one `plans record-checkpoint` (`transition: "implementation-review-configured"`, `terminationCondition` + `reviewerCount`). Each refinement round calls `refine` with `role: "reviewer", target: "implementation", reviewers: <configured reviewerCount>`; an omitted `reviewers` falls back to the run's configured `reviewerCount` from the checkpoint, so restarts and worktree migrations never silently revert 2/3 to 1. Each round accepts findings on evidence, applies fixes, re-runs relevant tests, and records progress. The hard cap is 5 rounds regardless of the chosen termination condition. Multi-reviewer rounds (2 or 3) consolidate like big-plan rounds: merge and dedupe findings into one `PLAN_vN_reviewer_comments.md`, keep each finding's source reviewer, severity, evidence, and disposition, and surface at most five high-priority findings. Crash recovery: if the process dies after one or both answers were recorded in `decisions.jsonl` but before the combined write, `/resume-plans` rebuilds the answered configuration from the ledger, asks only the missing question(s), and then performs the single combined write (the re-ask guard rejects duplicate configuration writes while the fields are already set).
171
- - Round audit trail: `decisions.jsonl`, `subagents.jsonl`, and `pi-plans-ameliorate` entries (one at goal start, then one per round) carry `currentRound` for post-hoc verification.
172
- - Headless sessions skip the prompt entirely; no `pi-plans-ameliorate` entry is appended.
173
-
174
161
  `refine` records each round and lane outcome durably (successful outputs are persisted to run-state files before the tool result returns) and accepts `resumeRoundId` to resume an interrupted round lane-by-lane: completed lanes are reused from their persisted outputs and never re-run; a round id is never reused across plan versions.
175
162
 
176
163
  ## Resuming (`/resume-plans`)
177
164
 
178
- After a restart or in a fresh session, `/resume-plans` (interactive only) restores the repository's working plan in the current session: the unfinished active run wins; otherwise a unique candidate resumes directly and multiple candidates get a chooser. It resumes unfinished planning (re-asks the pending question with the same `questionId`, never re-asks answered decisions), reviewing (resumes interrupted rounds via `refine resumeRoundId`, consolidates completed ones), execution (durable approval: unchanged plan digest keeps the authorization — a changed HEAD re-verifies old VCs first; legacy runs without checkpoints must re-approve), and the implementation-review loop (asks the termination condition and reviewer count only when they were never chosen — answered decisions are rebuilt from the ledger, never re-asked). While the loop is live, the pi-plans panel stays alive as a compact impl-review box (round count, reviewer count or "config pending", termination condition) and the status line mirrors it; once the checkpoint phase flips to `completed` the panel unregisters and the status line shows `(done)`. Linked worktrees share candidates; cross-worktree resumes confirm, copy artifacts without overwriting, reset approval and VC validity, and restart round counts. Record semantic boundaries with `plans record-checkpoint` (`plan-written`, `review-consolidated`, `implementation-review-configured`, `implementation-round-finished`, `completed` with evidence).
165
+ After a restart or in a fresh session, `/resume-plans` (interactive only) restores the repository's working plan in the current session: the unfinished active run wins; otherwise a unique candidate resumes directly and multiple candidates get a chooser. It resumes unfinished planning (re-asks the pending question with the same `questionId`, never re-asks answered decisions), reviewing (resumes interrupted rounds via `refine resumeRoundId`, consolidates completed ones), and execution (durable approval: unchanged plan digest keeps the authorization — a changed HEAD re-opens previously closed tasks for re-verification; an unverifiable approval HEAD behaves the same; legacy runs without checkpoints must re-approve; v0.6.0 delegated-executor orphans require a fresh handoff approval; a legacy `implementation-review` phase maps to done — its historical acceptance stands). Linked worktrees share candidates; cross-worktree resumes confirm, copy artifacts without overwriting, reset approval and VC validity, and restart round counts. Record semantic boundaries with `plans record-checkpoint` (`plan-written`, `review-consolidated`, `completed` with evidence).
179
166
 
180
- `refine` accepts a `target` parameter (`"plan"` default, `"implementation"` for the post-execution loop). The implementation brief anchors findings to the plan's goals and acceptance criteria, explicitly assesses delivery maturity (MVP-only vs. long-term refinement: stopgaps, missing tests, technical debt, production readiness), and tags out-of-scope improvements as low severity.
167
+ `refine` reviews the plan text (the v0.6.0 `target: "implementation"` post-execution loop is gone; the independent completion auditor now gates delivery).
181
168
 
182
169
  ## Red Flags
183
170
 
@@ -186,9 +173,9 @@ Stop and return to the workflow if any of these happen:
186
173
  - implementing before the approved execution handoff;
187
174
  - running `refine` without first asking the merged accept/execute question, or before the role gates pass;
188
175
  - ending a turn after a completed refinement round without asking the next merged accept/execute question;
189
- - storing planning settings outside the target workspace's `.git/pi_plans/` state directory;
176
+ - storing planning settings outside the target workspace's `.git/pi-plans/` state directory;
190
177
  - asking multiple planning questions in one message, or asking them outside `ask_choice`;
191
178
  - writing `PLAN_v1.md` before final scope confirmation;
192
179
  - accepting vague answers that contradict repo or reference evidence;
193
- - treating a reviewer or criticizer as authority instead of evidence;
180
+ - treating a reviewer as authority instead of evidence;
194
181
  - offering Auto-complete for execution, install, deploy, merge, push, or destructive cleanup approval.