lazycodex-ai 5.1.44 → 5.1.46

package/packages/shared-skills/skills/ulw-research/scripts/delivery-barrier.test.ts

@@ -0,0 +1,245 @@
+import { describe, expect, onTestFinished, test } from "bun:test"
+import { mkdirSync, mkdtempSync, readFileSync, rmSync, unlinkSync, writeFileSync } from "node:fs"
+import { tmpdir } from "node:os"
+import { join } from "node:path"
+
+import { sha256Of } from "./cli-support.mjs"
+import { DEFECT_CODES } from "./contracts.mjs"
+import { FIDELITY_RECORDS, MEANING_RECORD, RECORD_ENVELOPE, writeFidelityRecord } from "./fidelity-records.mjs"
+import { blocksDelivery } from "./gates-fidelity.mjs"
+import { run } from "./report-tools.mjs"
+
+async function delivered(format = "html", codes: string[] | null = null) {
+	const root = mkdtempSync(join(tmpdir(), "delivery-barrier-"))
+	onTestFinished(() => rmSync(root, { recursive: true, force: true }))
+	const dir = join(root, "20260101-120000")
+	mkdirSync(dir)
+	const path = join(dir, `report.${format}`)
+	const record = join(dir, "fidelity-defects.json")
+	writeFileSync(path, "<p>Report</p>")
+	if (codes !== null) writeFidelityRecord(record, "fidelity", { artifact_sha256: sha256Of(readFileSync(path)), report: path, defects: codes.map((code) => ({ code, severity: "minor", message: code })) })
+	const invoke = (args: string[]) => run(["outcome", ...args, "--session-dir", dir])
+	await invoke(["init", "--promised", format])
+	expect((await invoke(["set", format, "delivered", "--path", path, ...(codes === null ? [] : ["--verified-by", record])])).exitCode).toBe(0)
+	return { dir, path, record, invoke }
+}
+
+// Enumerate the source registry, not a second list of today's fidelity codes.
+for (const [code, entry] of Object.entries(DEFECT_CODES)) {
+	if (!entry.integrity && entry.severity === "minor") continue
+	test(`#given registry blocker ${code} #when verified and finished #then delivery refuses despite a demoted row`, async () => {
+		const { dir, invoke } = await delivered("html", [code])
+		for (const command of ["verify", "finish"]) {
+			const result = await invoke([command])
+			expect(result.exitCode).toBe(1)
+			expect(result.json.problems).toContainEqual(expect.objectContaining({ code: "fidelity_unresolved", codes: [code] }))
+		}
+		expect(JSON.parse(readFileSync(join(dir, "outcome.json"), "utf8")).finishedAt).toBeNull()
+	})
+}
+
+test("#given an unknown defect code #when verified or finished #then delivery refuses with its reason", async () => {
+	const { invoke } = await delivered("html", ["future_fidelity_defect"])
+	for (const command of ["verify", "finish"]) {
+		const result = await invoke([command])
+		expect(result.exitCode).toBe(1)
+		expect(JSON.stringify(result.json.problems)).toContain("unknown defect code future_fidelity_defect")
+	}
+})
+
+test("#given a registry non-blocker #when verified and finished #then delivery passes", async () => {
+	const entry = Object.entries(DEFECT_CODES).find(([, value]) => !value.integrity && value.severity === "minor")
+	if (!entry) throw new Error("registry must have a non-blocking entry")
+	const { invoke } = await delivered("html", [entry[0]])
+	expect((await invoke(["verify"])).exitCode).toBe(0)
+	expect((await invoke(["finish"])).exitCode).toBe(0)
+})
+
+for (const format of ["html", "pdf", "docx"]) {
+	test(`#given delivered ${format} without any ledger or gate record #when verified and finished #then both refuse`, async () => {
+		const { invoke } = await delivered(format)
+		for (const command of ["verify", "finish"]) {
+			const result = await invoke([command])
+			expect(result.exitCode).toBe(1)
+			expect(JSON.stringify(result.json.problems)).toContain("fidelity gate not run")
+		}
+	})
+}
+
+test("#given a missing gate #when explicitly skipped with a reason #then the logged choice permits delivery", async () => {
+	const { dir, invoke } = await delivered()
+	const now = "2026-01-01T12:01:00.000Z"
+	await invoke(["gate", "fidelity", "not_run", "--reason", "No factual content in this edition", "--now", now])
+	const manifest = JSON.parse(readFileSync(join(dir, "outcome.json"), "utf8"))
+	expect(manifest.gateHistory).toContainEqual({ gate: "fidelity", status: "not_run", reason: "No factual content in this edition", at: now })
+	expect((await invoke(["verify"])).exitCode).toBe(0)
+	expect((await invoke(["finish"])).exitCode).toBe(0)
+	await invoke(["gate", "fidelity", "pass"])
+	expect((await invoke(["verify"])).exitCode).toBe(1)
+})
+
+test("#given a missing gate #when skipped without a meaningful reason #then the command refuses", async () => {
+	const { invoke } = await delivered()
+	for (const reason of [[], ["--reason", "   "]]) {
+		await expect(invoke(["gate", "fidelity", "not_run", ...reason])).rejects.toThrow("reason")
+	}
+})
+
+test("#given a fact ledger and an unverified edition #when the gate is skipped with a reason #then delivery still refuses", async () => {
+	const { dir, invoke } = await delivered()
+	writeFileSync(join(dir, "fact-ledger.json"), JSON.stringify({ version: 1, facts: [] }))
+	await invoke(["gate", "fidelity", "not_run", "--reason", "This harness has no verifier"])
+	for (const command of ["verify", "finish"]) {
+		const result = await invoke([command])
+		expect(result.exitCode).toBe(1)
+		expect(JSON.stringify(result.json.problems)).toContain("fidelity gate not run")
+	}
+})
+
+test("#given a stale fidelity record nobody attached #when the gate is skipped with a reason #then delivery still refuses", async () => {
+	const { dir, path, invoke } = await delivered()
+	writeFidelityRecord(join(dir, "fidelity-defects.json"), "fidelity", { artifact_sha256: "0".repeat(64), report: path, defects: [] })
+	await invoke(["gate", "fidelity", "not_run", "--reason", "This harness has no verifier"])
+	for (const command of ["verify", "finish"]) {
+		const result = await invoke([command])
+		expect(result.exitCode).toBe(1)
+		expect(JSON.stringify(result.json.problems)).toContain("fidelity gate not run")
+	}
+})
+
+test("#given an explicit skip and an existing blocker #when verified #then the skip cannot release the blocker", async () => {
+	const { invoke } = await delivered("html", ["claim_status_invalid"])
+	await invoke(["gate", "fidelity", "not_run", "--reason", "Unsupported edition"])
+	expect((await invoke(["verify"])).exitCode).toBe(1)
+})
+
+const LOCKED_BRIEF = readFileSync(join(import.meta.dir, "tests", "fixtures", "fidelity-brief-locked.md"), "utf8")
+const BLOCKER = Object.keys(DEFECT_CODES).find((code) => blocksDelivery({ code })) as string
+
+/**
+ * A delivered html edition whose locked brief requires every table record, each present, fresh for
+ * the delivered bytes, and clean. recordPath is where the session keeps each row's record; a table
+ * row with no entry here fails the coverage test below, so a new row brings its own cases.
+ */
+async function fullyRecorded(brief = LOCKED_BRIEF) {
+	const session = await delivered("html", [])
+	writeFileSync(join(session.dir, "brief.md"), brief)
+	const recordPath: Record<string, string> = { fidelity: session.record, meaning: join(session.dir, MEANING_RECORD) }
+	const write = (kind: string, fields: Record<string, unknown> = {}) =>
+		writeFidelityRecord(recordPath[kind], kind, { artifact_sha256: sha256Of(readFileSync(session.path)), report: session.path, defects: [], ...fields })
+	write("meaning")
+	const outcomes = async () => Promise.all(["verify", "finish"].map((command) => session.invoke([command])))
+	return { ...session, recordPath, write, outcomes }
+}
+
+async function expectRefused(session: Awaited<ReturnType<typeof fullyRecorded>>, problem: Record<string, unknown>) {
+	for (const result of await session.outcomes()) {
+		expect(result.exitCode).toBe(1)
+		expect(result.json.problems).toContainEqual(expect.objectContaining(problem))
+	}
+}
+
+test("#given the record table #when every row is read #then each row has every rule column and an arranged session path", async () => {
+	const { recordPath } = await fullyRecorded()
+	expect(Object.keys(recordPath).sort()).toEqual(FIDELITY_RECORDS.map((entry) => entry.kind).sort())
+	for (const entry of FIDELITY_RECORDS) {
+		for (const column of ["targets", "requiredWhen", "remedy", "blocking"] as const) expect(typeof entry[column], `${entry.kind}.${column}`).toBe("function")
+		expect(RECORD_ENVELOPE).toContain(entry.bindsTo)
+	}
+})
+
+// The table is the barrier's spec: every row gets the same five cases.
+for (const entry of FIDELITY_RECORDS) {
+	describe(`record row ${entry.kind}`, () => {
+		test("#given the record is missing while required #when verified and finished #then delivery refuses", async () => {
+			const session = await fullyRecorded()
+			unlinkSync(session.recordPath[entry.kind])
+			await expectRefused(session, { code: "edition_unverified", path: session.recordPath[entry.kind] })
+		})
+
+		test("#given the record is for other bytes #when verified and finished #then delivery refuses: a different edition", async () => {
+			const session = await fullyRecorded()
+			session.write(entry.kind, { artifact_sha256: sha256Of("an earlier draft") })
+			await expectRefused(session, { code: "edition_unverified", path: session.recordPath[entry.kind], message: expect.stringContaining("is for a different edition") })
+		})
+
+		test("#given a fresh record with a blocking defect #when verified and finished #then delivery refuses", async () => {
+			const session = await fullyRecorded()
+			session.write(entry.kind, { defects: [{ code: BLOCKER, severity: "minor", message: BLOCKER }] })
+			await expectRefused(session, { code: "fidelity_unresolved", codes: [BLOCKER], path: session.recordPath[entry.kind] })
+		})
+
+		test("#given a fresh clean record #when verified and finished #then delivery passes", async () => {
+			const session = await fullyRecorded()
+			expect((await session.outcomes()).map((result) => result.exitCode)).toEqual([0, 0])
+		})
+
+		for (const [name, mutate] of [
+			["a missing envelope field", (record: Record<string, unknown>) => delete record.written_at],
+			["an unknown field", (record: Record<string, unknown>) => Object.assign(record, { verified_elsewhere: true })],
+			["another record kind", (record: Record<string, unknown>) => Object.assign(record, { record_kind: "not_a_record_kind" })],
+		] as const) {
+			test(`#given a record with ${name} #when verified and finished #then delivery refuses it as malformed`, async () => {
+				const session = await fullyRecorded()
+				const path = session.recordPath[entry.kind]
+				const record = JSON.parse(readFileSync(path, "utf8"))
+				mutate(record)
+				writeFileSync(path, JSON.stringify(record))
+				await expectRefused(session, { code: "edition_unverified", path, message: expect.stringContaining("is malformed") })
+			})
+		}
+	})
+}
+
+test("#given a record kind outside the table or a malformed envelope #when written #then the writer refuses", () => {
+	const dir = mkdtempSync(join(tmpdir(), "delivery-barrier-writer-"))
+	onTestFinished(() => rmSync(dir, { recursive: true, force: true }))
+	const fields = { artifact_sha256: sha256Of("x"), report: join(dir, "report.html"), defects: [] }
+	expect(() => writeFidelityRecord(join(dir, "a.json"), "not_a_record_kind", fields)).toThrow("unknown fidelity record kind")
+	expect(() => writeFidelityRecord(join(dir, "b.json"), "meaning", { ...fields, artifact_sha256: "draft" })).toThrow("malformed")
+	expect(() => writeFidelityRecord(join(dir, "c.json"), "meaning", { ...fields, gatesRun: [] })).toThrow("unknown field")
+})
+
+/** A delivered, fidelity-verified html edition in a session whose locked brief sets `meaning check`. */
+async function meaningSession(meaning: "on" | "off", codes: string[] | null) {
+	const session = await fullyRecorded(LOCKED_BRIEF.replace("meaning check: on", `meaning check: ${meaning}`))
+	if (codes === null) unlinkSync(session.recordPath.meaning)
+	else session.write("meaning", { defects: codes.map((code) => ({ code, severity: "major", message: code })) })
+	return session
+}
+
+for (const code of ["meaning_drift_confirmed", "meaning_unverified"]) {
+	test(`#given a meaning record with ${code} #when verified and finished #then delivery refuses`, async () => {
+		const session = await meaningSession("on", [code])
+		await expectRefused(session, { code: "fidelity_unresolved", codes: [code], path: join(session.dir, MEANING_RECORD) })
+	})
+}
+
+test("#given the brief says meaning check on and the meaning step was skipped #when verified and finished #then delivery refuses: meaning gate not run", async () => {
+	const session = await meaningSession("on", null)
+	await expectRefused(session, { message: expect.stringContaining("meaning gate not run") })
+})
+
+test("#given a malformed ## Fidelity block that tries to turn meaning check off #when no meaning record exists #then delivery refuses: meaning gate not run", async () => {
+	const malformed = LOCKED_BRIEF.replace("meaning check: on (answered_by: default)", "meaning check: on (answered_by: default)\nmeaning check: off (answered_by: user)")
+	const session = await fullyRecorded(malformed)
+	unlinkSync(session.recordPath.meaning)
+	await expectRefused(session, { message: expect.stringContaining("meaning gate not run") })
+})
+
+test("#given the brief says meaning check off and no meaning record #when verified and finished #then delivery passes", async () => {
+	const session = await meaningSession("off", null)
+	expect((await session.outcomes()).map((result) => result.exitCode)).toEqual([0, 0])
+})
+
+test("#given a clean meaning record (warn only) under meaning check on #when verified #then delivery passes", async () => {
+	const { invoke } = await meaningSession("on", ["meaning_drift_warn"])
+	expect((await invoke(["verify"])).exitCode).toBe(0)
+})
+
+test("#given meaning check on, no fidelity evidence, and an explicit fidelity not_run #when verified #then the logged exemption covers the meaning step too", async () => {
+	const { dir, invoke } = await delivered()
+	writeFileSync(join(dir, "brief.md"), LOCKED_BRIEF)
+	await invoke(["gate", "fidelity", "not_run", "--reason", "No factual content in this edition"])
+	expect((await invoke(["verify"])).exitCode).toBe(0)
+})

package/packages/shared-skills/skills/ulw-research/scripts/fact-commands-meaning.mjs

@@ -0,0 +1,191 @@
+// fact-commands-meaning.mjs - `fact pairs` and `fact meaning-check`, the script half of the
+// separate-session meaning verifier. fact pairs writes the (source, report sentence) pairs a
+// reader lane gets and nothing else; it honours the brief's `meaning check` field and writes
+// `{ skipped: true }` when it is off. fact meaning-check ingests the readers' verdict files
+// (meaning-check.mjs), writes fidelity-meaning-defects.json (a fidelity record bound to the pairs'
+// artifact_sha256 and report, through writeFidelityRecord), and records the run in
+// fidelity-calibration.jsonl: a header with the promotion criterion on first write, then per run
+// one run line plus one line per flagged pair. The run id hashes the inputs only, so a rerun or a
+// --dispute rerun of the same inputs replaces that run's lines in place (disputes carry forward)
+// instead of counting a second run. Neither command calls a model or the network.
+
+import { existsSync, readFileSync } from "node:fs"
+import { dirname, join, resolve } from "node:path"
+
+import { CliError, parseArgs, readJsonFile, sha256Of, writeJsonAtomic, writeTextAtomic } from "./cli-support.mjs"
+import { countDefects } from "./contracts.mjs"
+import { markdownAsHtml, readEdition } from "./fact-commands-verify.mjs"
+import { readLedger } from "./fact-ledger.mjs"
+import { validateLedger } from "./fact-ledger-schema.mjs"
+import { extractPairs, PAIR_KINDS } from "./fact-pairs.mjs"
+import { FIDELITY_INCOMPLETE, meaningCheckEnabled, requireLockedBrief } from "./fidelity-brief.mjs"
+import { MEANING_RECORD, writeFidelityRecord } from "./fidelity-records.mjs"
+import { blocksDelivery } from "./gates-fidelity.mjs"
+import { ingestVerdicts, unverifiedDefects, VERDICT_SCHEMA } from "./meaning-check.mjs"
+
+export const PAIRS_FILE = "pairs.json"
+export const CALIBRATION_FILE = "fidelity-calibration.jsonl"
+/** Starting values, recorded in the calibration log header; changed only with evidence. */
+export const PROMOTION = Object.freeze({ code: "meaning_drift_confirmed", to: "integrity", min_runs: 20, max_disputed_to_confirmed: 0.1, false_block_window: 20, max_report_false_blocks_in_window: 2 })
+
+/** The command status: fail when any defect blocks delivery under the registry policy. */
+export const meaningStatus = (defects) => (defects.some(blocksDelivery) ? "fail" : "pass")
+
+const sessionOf = (flags) => {
+	const dir = flags["session-dir"] ?? process.env.SESSION_DIR
+	return dir && dir !== true ? resolve(dir) : null
+}
+const inSession = (session, name, flag) => {
+	if (session === null) throw new CliError(`${flag} is required without --session-dir (or SESSION_DIR)`)
+	return join(session, name)
+}
+
+function readLedgerFrom(flags, session) {
+	if (flags.ledger === undefined) {
+		if (session === null) throw new CliError("--ledger is required without --session-dir (or SESSION_DIR)")
+		return readLedger(session)
+	}
+	const ledger = readJsonFile(flags.ledger)
+	const errors = validateLedger(ledger)
+	if (errors.length > 0) throw new CliError(`${flags.ledger} is not a valid fact ledger: ${errors[0]}`)
+	return ledger
+}
+
+function briefState(flags, session) {
+	const path = flags.brief ?? inSession(session, "brief.md", "--brief")
+	const lock = requireLockedBrief(path)
+	if (lock.exitCode === 2) throw new CliError(`${path}: malformed ## Fidelity block: ${lock.errors.join("; ")}`)
+	return { path, locked: lock.locked, off: !meaningCheckEnabled(lock.parsed) }
+}
+
+function runPairs(args) {
+	const [report] = args.positionals
+	const { flags } = args
+	if (!report) throw new CliError("usage: fact pairs <report> [--format html|md] [--ledger F] [--claims claims.json] [--changed-since <fill-map.json>] [--brief brief.md] [--out pairs.json]")
+	const session = sessionOf(flags)
+	const out = resolve(flags.out ?? inSession(session, PAIRS_FILE, "--out"))
+	const brief = briefState(flags, session)
+	if (!brief.locked) {
+		const json = { command: "fact pairs", status: "fail", exitCode: 1, error: "fidelity_interview_incomplete", message: `${brief.path} has no locked ## Fidelity block` }
+		return { json, summary: `fact pairs: ${json.message}`, exitCode: 1 }
+	}
+	if (brief.off) {
+		const record = { schemaVersion: 1, skipped: true, reason: "meaning check: off", pairs: [] }
+		writeJsonAtomic(out, record)
+		return { json: { command: "fact pairs", status: "skipped", exitCode: 0, data: { out, ...record } }, summary: "fact pairs: skipped (meaning check: off)", exitCode: 0 }
+	}
+	const edition = readEdition(report, flags)
+	const claimsPath = flags.claims ?? (session === null ? null : join(session, "claims.json"))
+	const claims = claimsPath !== null && (flags.claims !== undefined || existsSync(claimsPath)) ? readJsonFile(claimsPath) : null
+	const changed = flags["changed-since"] === undefined ? undefined : readJsonFile(flags["changed-since"]).entries
+	const ledger = readLedgerFrom(flags, session)
+	const html = edition.format === "md" ? markdownAsHtml(edition.text, edition.entries, ledger).html : edition.text
+	const pairs = extractPairs(html, ledger, claims, changed)
+	const counts = { total: pairs.length, force_strong: pairs.filter((pair) => pair.force_strong).length }
+	for (const kind of PAIR_KINDS) counts[kind] = pairs.filter((pair) => pair.kind === kind).length
+	const record = { schemaVersion: 1, skipped: false, report: resolve(report), format: edition.format, artifact_sha256: sha256Of(edition.text), pairs_sha256: sha256Of(JSON.stringify(pairs)), counts, verdict_schema: VERDICT_SCHEMA, pairs }
+	writeJsonAtomic(out, record)
+	const summary = `fact pairs: ${counts.total} pair(s), ${counts.force_strong} routed to the strong reader`
+	return { json: { command: "fact pairs", status: "pass", exitCode: 0, data: { out, ...record, pairs: undefined } }, summary, exitCode: 0 }
+}
+
+/** Every line of the log after the header, in file order; a corrupt line is a usage error naming path:line. */
+function calibrationRows(path) {
+	if (!existsSync(path)) return []
+	const rows = []
+	for (const [index, line] of readFileSync(path, "utf8").split("\n").entries()) {
+		if (line.trim() === "") continue
+		try {
+			rows.push(JSON.parse(line))
+		} catch (error) {
+			throw new CliError(`${path}:${index + 1}: corrupt calibration log line (${error.message}); repair or move the file`)
+		}
+	}
+	return rows.filter((row) => row.header !== true)
+}
+
+/** The promotion criterion evaluated over the log: runs, disputed-to-confirmed, report-level false blocks. */
+export function promotionEligibility(rows) {
+	const runs = [...new Set(rows.map((row) => row.run_id))]
+	const confirmed = rows.filter((row) => row.run !== true && row.confirmed)
+	const disputed = confirmed.filter((row) => row.disputed).length
+	const ratio = confirmed.length === 0 ? null : disputed / confirmed.length
+	const falseBlocks = runs.slice(-PROMOTION.false_block_window).filter((run) => {
+		const blocking = confirmed.filter((row) => row.run_id === run)
+		return blocking.length > 0 && blocking.every((row) => row.disputed)
+	}).length
+	const eligible = runs.length >= PROMOTION.min_runs && ratio !== null && ratio < PROMOTION.max_disputed_to_confirmed && falseBlocks <= PROMOTION.max_report_false_blocks_in_window
+	return { runs: runs.length, confirmed: confirmed.length, disputed_confirmed: disputed, disputed_to_confirmed: ratio, report_false_blocks_in_window: falseBlocks, eligible }
+}
+
+/**
+ * Writes this run's lines: one run line (so a run with no flagged pair still counts) and one line per
+ * flagged pair. A run id already in the log is replaced in place, keeping its position in the false
+ * block window and any earlier dispute on a pair the new lines do not dispute.
+ */
+function recordCalibration(path, lines, runId, pairsSha) {
+	const before = calibrationRows(path)
+	const previous = before.filter((row) => row.run_id === runId)
+	const disputes = new Map(previous.filter((row) => row.disputed).map((row) => [row.pair_id, row.reason]))
+	const pairRows = lines.map((line) => {
+		const row = { ...JSON.parse(line), run_id: runId, pairs_sha256: pairsSha }
+		return !row.disputed && disputes.has(row.pair_id) ? { ...row, disputed: true, reason: disputes.get(row.pair_id) } : row
+	})
+	const rows = [{ run: true, run_id: runId, pairs_sha256: pairsSha, flagged: pairRows.length }, ...pairRows]
+	const at = previous.length === 0 ? before.length : before.indexOf(previous[0])
+	const after = [...before.slice(0, at).filter((row) => row.run_id !== runId), ...rows, ...before.slice(at).filter((row) => row.run_id !== runId)]
+	const header = { header: true, schemaVersion: 1, promotion: PROMOTION, note: "starting values; change them only with evidence" }
+	writeTextAtomic(path, `${[header, ...after].map((row) => JSON.stringify(row)).join("\n")}\n`)
+	return { written: pairRows.length, replaced: previous.length > 0, rows: after }
+}
+
+/** A `{ skipped: true }` pairs file is accepted only when the locked brief turns the meaning check off. */
+function skippedRefusal(flags, session) {
+	const brief = briefState(flags, session)
+	if (!brief.locked) return { error: FIDELITY_INCOMPLETE, message: `${brief.path} has no locked ## Fidelity block, so a skipped meaning check cannot be accepted` }
+	if (!brief.off) return { error: "meaning_check_required", message: `${flags.pairs} says skipped but ${brief.path} has meaning check on; rerun fact pairs` }
+	return null
+}
+
+function runMeaningCheck(args) {
+	const { flags } = args
+	const usage = "usage: fact meaning-check --pairs pairs.json --verdicts cheap.json [--verdicts strong.json] [--dispute P<n> --reason TEXT] [--run-id ID] [--calibration F] [--out F]"
+	if (flags.pairs === undefined || !Array.isArray(flags.verdicts)) throw new CliError(usage)
+	const session = sessionOf(flags)
+	const pairsText = readFileSync(flags.pairs, "utf8")
+	const pairsDoc = readJsonFile(flags.pairs)
+	if (pairsDoc?.skipped === true) {
+		const refusal = skippedRefusal(flags, session)
+		if (refusal !== null) return { json: { command: "fact meaning-check", status: "fail", exitCode: 1, ...refusal }, summary: `fact meaning-check: ${refusal.message}`, exitCode: 1 }
+		return { json: { command: "fact meaning-check", status: "skipped", exitCode: 0, defects: [] }, summary: JSON.stringify({ command: "fact meaning-check", status: "skipped" }), exitCode: 0 }
+	}
+	if (typeof pairsDoc?.artifact_sha256 !== "string" || typeof pairsDoc.report !== "string") throw new CliError(`${flags.pairs} names no artifact_sha256 and report, so the meaning record cannot be bound to an edition; rerun fact pairs`)
+	for (const file of flags.verdicts) readJsonFile(file)
+	const verdictTexts = flags.verdicts.map((file) => readFileSync(file, "utf8"))
+	const dispute = flags.dispute === undefined ? undefined : { pair_id: flags.dispute, reason: args.required("reason") }
+	let result
+	try {
+		result = ingestVerdicts(pairsDoc, flags.verdicts, dispute ? { dispute } : {})
+	} catch (error) {
+		throw new CliError(`invalid verdict input: ${error.message}`)
+	}
+	const out = resolve(flags.out ?? inSession(session, MEANING_RECORD, "--out"))
+	const calibration = resolve(flags.calibration ?? join(session ?? dirname(out), CALIBRATION_FILE))
+	const runId = flags["run-id"] ?? sha256Of([pairsText, ...verdictTexts].join("\0")).slice(0, 16)
+	const pairsSha = pairsDoc.pairs_sha256 ?? sha256Of(pairsText)
+	const log = recordCalibration(calibration, result.calibrationLines, runId, pairsSha)
+	const defects = [...result.defects, ...unverifiedDefects(result.unverified)]
+	const counts = countDefects(defects)
+	const status = meaningStatus(defects)
+	const exitCode = status === "fail" ? 1 : 0
+	const record = writeFidelityRecord(out, "meaning", { command: "fact meaning-check", status, exitCode, artifact_sha256: pairsDoc.artifact_sha256, report: pairsDoc.report, run_id: runId, pairs_sha256: pairsSha, defects, counts, dropped: result.dropped, unverified: result.unverified, calibration_path: calibration, calibration_written: log.written, calibration_replaced: log.replaced, promotion_eligibility: promotionEligibility(log.rows) })
+	const confirmed = result.defects.filter((defect) => defect.code === "meaning_drift_confirmed").length
+	const summary = JSON.stringify({ command: "fact meaning-check", status, defects: defects.length, confirmed, warn: result.defects.length - confirmed, dropped: result.dropped.length, unverified: result.unverified.length })
+	return { json: { ...record, out }, summary, exitCode }
+}
+
+/** @param {string[]} argv the arguments after `fact pairs` or `fact meaning-check` */
+export function runFactMeaning(sub, argv) {
+	const args = parseArgs(argv, { repeatable: ["verdicts"] })
+	return sub === "pairs" ? runPairs(args) : runMeaningCheck(args)
+}

package/packages/shared-skills/skills/ulw-research/scripts/fact-commands-verify.mjs

@@ -0,0 +1,164 @@
+// fact-commands-verify.mjs - `fact verify` and the Markdown projection it checks.
+//
+// fact verify runs the deterministic fidelity gate over one filled HTML or Markdown edition and
+// writes a fidelity record (default $SESSION_DIR/fidelity-defects.json, through
+// writeFidelityRecord) carrying the artifact's sha256. It
+// exits 1 on any blocker or major defect (the orchestrator then records `outcome gate fidelity
+// fail`); minors alone exit 0 and are listed. A Markdown edition is read through md-lite into an
+// escaped HTML projection (same line numbers) and checked with its fill map, which is the only
+// record of where its values sit; LaTeX is verified through its Markdown source.
+//
+// The delivery barrier that reads these records (and every other fidelity record) is
+// fidelity-records.mjs.
+
+import { existsSync, readFileSync } from "node:fs"
+import { dirname, join, resolve } from "node:path"
+
+import { CliError, readJsonFile, sha256Of } from "./cli-support.mjs"
+import { countDefects } from "./contracts.mjs"
+import { recompute } from "./fact-derive.mjs"
+import { readLedger } from "./fact-ledger.mjs"
+import { FIDELITY_RECORD, writeFidelityRecord } from "./fidelity-records.mjs"
+import { blocksDelivery, checkFidelity } from "./gates-fidelity.mjs"
+import { parseMarkdown } from "./md-lite.mjs"
+import { escapeHtml, parseRenderedQuote, renderQuote, renderValueHtml } from "./placeholder.mjs"
+import { sessionDirOf } from "./source-commands.mjs"
+
+function readText(path) {
+	try {
+		return readFileSync(path, "utf8")
+	} catch (error) {
+		throw new CliError(`cannot read ${path}: ${error.code ?? error.message}`)
+	}
+}
+
+/**
+ * md-lite block kind -> its projection: the element tag (null = h<level>) and, for a run of one kind,
+ * the container that wraps the run. Code and table rows also take the specialized bodies below.
+ */
+export const MD_HTML_BLOCK_RULES = Object.freeze({
+	heading: Object.freeze({ tag: null }),
+	paragraph: Object.freeze({ tag: "p" }),
+	list_item: Object.freeze({ tag: "li", group: Object.freeze(["<ul>", "</ul>"]) }),
+	blockquote: Object.freeze({ tag: "blockquote" }),
+	code: Object.freeze({ tag: "code" }),
+	table_row: Object.freeze({ tag: "tr", group: Object.freeze(["<table>", "</table>"]) }),
+})
+
+/** Escaped text with inline links and code spans kept as elements, so a URL is never read as prose. */
+export const projectMarkdownInline = (text) =>
+	escapeHtml(text)
+		.replace(/\[([^\]]+)\]\(([^)\s]+)\)/gu, '<a href="$2">$1</a>')
+		.replace(/`([^`]+)`/gu, "<code>$1</code>")
+
+/** The element the HTML fill writes for one fill-map entry, or null when its bytes were edited since. */
+function entryHtml(text, entry, rows) {
+	const body = text.slice(entry.start, entry.end)
+	if (body !== entry.rendered) return null
+	const row = rows.get(entry.fact_id)
+	if (entry.translates) return `<span data-translates="${escapeHtml(entry.translates)}">${projectMarkdownInline(body.replace(/^<!--[\s\S]*?-->\s*/u, ""))}</span>`
+	if (!row) return `<data data-fact="${escapeHtml(entry.fact_id)}">${escapeHtml(body)}</data>`
+	const quoted = row.kind === "quote" ? parseRenderedQuote(body) : null
+	if (quoted) return renderQuote(row, entry.selector ?? "full", quoted.text, "html")
+	return row.kind === "quote" ? null : renderValueHtml(row, body)
+}
+
+/** [from, to) of the filled text as HTML, each intact fill-map entry rebuilt as its fill element. */
+function spanHtml(text, from, to, entries, rows, stale) {
+	let html = ""
+	let cursor = from
+	for (const entry of entries) {
+		if (entry.start < cursor || entry.end > to || entry.start < from || entry.replaced !== undefined) continue
+		const element = entryHtml(text, entry, rows)
+		if (element === null) continue
+		stale.delete(entry)
+		html += projectMarkdownInline(text.slice(cursor, entry.start)) + element
+		cursor = entry.end
+	}
+	return html + projectMarkdownInline(text.slice(cursor, to))
+}
+
+/**
+ * An escaped HTML projection of a filled Markdown edition: one element per md-lite block, each on
+ * the source line it starts on, lists and table rows grouped. Never a rendering for readers.
+ * @param {string} text the filled Markdown
+ * @param {{ fact_id: string, start: number, end: number, rendered: string, replaced?: string, translates?: string }[]} entries its fill map
+ * @param {{ rows: object[] }} ledger
+ * @returns {{ html: string, stale: object[] }} stale: entries whose bytes changed after fill (checked by text)
+ */
+export function markdownAsHtml(text, entries, ledger) {
+	const sorted = [...(entries ?? [])].sort((a, b) => a.start - b.start)
+	const rows = new Map((ledger?.rows ?? []).map((row) => [row.fact_id, row]))
+	const stale = new Set(sorted.filter((entry) => entry.replaced === undefined))
+	const lineAt = (offset) => text.slice(0, offset).split("\n").length
+	const parsed = parseMarkdown(text)
+	if (parsed.problems.length > 0) {
+		throw new CliError(`the Markdown edition is malformed: ${parsed.problems.map((problem) => `${problem.code} at line ${problem.line}`).join(", ")}; fix it before verifying`)
+	}
+	let html = "<!doctype html><html><head><title>md</title></head><body>"
+	let line = 1
+	let open = null
+	for (const block of parsed.blocks) {
+		const rule = MD_HTML_BLOCK_RULES[block.kind]
+		if (rule === undefined) throw new CliError(`md-lite block kind ${block.kind} has no projection rule`)
+		if (open && open !== block.kind) html += MD_HTML_BLOCK_RULES[open].group[1]
+		const target = lineAt(block.start)
+		if (target > line) html += "\n".repeat(target - line)
+		line = Math.max(line, target) + (text.slice(block.start, block.end).match(/\n/gu)?.length ?? 0)
+		if (rule.group && open !== block.kind) html += rule.group[0]
+		open = rule.group ? block.kind : null
+		const inner = (from, to) => spanHtml(text, from, to, sorted, rows, stale)
+		if (block.kind === "table_row") html += `<${rule.tag}>${block.cells.map((cell) => `<td>${inner(cell.start, cell.end)}</td>`).join("")}</${rule.tag}>`
+		else if (block.kind === "code") html += `<pre><${rule.tag}>${escapeHtml(block.text)}</${rule.tag}></pre>`
+		else {
+			const tag = rule.tag ?? `h${block.level}`
+			const replaced = block.kind === "blockquote" ? sorted.find((entry) => entry.replaced !== undefined && entry.start <= block.start && entry.end >= block.end) : undefined
+			const attrs = replaced ? ` data-fact="${escapeHtml(replaced.fact_id)}" data-replaced="${escapeHtml(replaced.replaced)}"` : ""
+			html += `<${tag}${attrs}>${inner(block.start, block.end)}</${tag}>`
+		}
+	}
+	return { html: `${html}${open ? MD_HTML_BLOCK_RULES[open].group[1] : ""}</body></html>\n`, stale: [...stale] }
+}
+
+const MARKDOWN_EXTENSION = /\.(md|markdown)$/iu
+/** The edition format: the explicit flag, else md for a .md or .markdown path (any case), else html. */
+export const editionFormatOf = (path, flag) => flag ?? (MARKDOWN_EXTENSION.test(path) ? "md" : "html")
+
+/** The report's format (from --format or its extension) and, for Markdown, its fill map entries. */
+export function readEdition(report, flags) {
+	const format = editionFormatOf(report, flags.format)
+	if (format !== "html" && format !== "md") throw new CliError(`--format ${format}: verify html or md (a LaTeX edition is verified through its Markdown source)`)
+	const text = readText(report)
+	if (format === "html") return { format, text, entries: flags["fill-map"] === undefined ? null : readJsonFile(flags["fill-map"]).entries }
+	const map = flags["fill-map"] ?? `${report}.fill-map.json`
+	if (!existsSync(map)) throw new CliError(`a Markdown edition needs its fill map: ${map} is missing (pass --fill-map)`)
+	return { format, text, entries: readJsonFile(map).entries }
+}
+
+/** @param {{ positionals: string[], flags: Record<string, any> }} args parsed by runFact */
+export function runFactVerify(args) {
+	const [report] = args.positionals
+	const { flags } = args
+	if (!report) throw new CliError("usage: fact verify <report> [--format html|md] [--sources D] [--claims claims.json] [--fill-map F] [--brief brief.md] [--out fidelity-defects.json]")
+	const edition = readEdition(report, flags)
+	const sessionDir = sessionDirOf(flags)
+	const claimsPath = flags.claims ?? join(sessionDir, "claims.json")
+	const briefPath = flags.brief ?? join(sessionDir, "brief.md")
+	const ledger = readLedger(sessionDir)
+	const projected = edition.format === "md" ? markdownAsHtml(edition.text, edition.entries, ledger) : null
+	const result = checkFidelity(projected?.html ?? edition.text, {
+		ledger,
+		sourcesDir: resolve(flags.sources ?? join(sessionDir, "sources")),
+		claims: flags.claims !== undefined || existsSync(claimsPath) ? readJsonFile(claimsPath) : null,
+		fillMap: projected?.stale ?? edition.entries,
+		brief: existsSync(briefPath) ? readText(briefPath) : "",
+		baseDir: dirname(resolve(report)),
+		recompute,
+	})
+	const counts = countDefects(result.defects)
+	const status = result.defects.some(blocksDelivery) ? "fail" : "pass"
+	const exitCode = status === "fail" ? 1 : 0
+	const out = resolve(flags.out ?? join(sessionDir, FIDELITY_RECORD))
+	const record = writeFidelityRecord(out, "fidelity", { command: "fact verify", status, exitCode, format: edition.format, report: resolve(report), artifact_sha256: sha256Of(edition.text), defects: result.defects, counts, gatesRun: result.gatesRun })
+	return { json: { ...record, out }, summary: `fact verify: ${status.toUpperCase()} - ${counts.blocker} blocker, ${counts.major} major, ${counts.minor} minor`, exitCode }
+}