jskelet 0.6.3 → 0.6.4

package/docs/en/02-architecture.md

@@ -1,329 +1,329 @@
-# 02 — Architecture and the reasoning behind the decisions
-
-This document does not explain how JSkelet works, but **why it works this way**.
-The path a request takes from the server to the browser, why the island model is
-tied to visibility, why the HTML is produced in full, why the cache lives in
-process memory and why the middleware order must not be shuffled — that is all
-here. Most of the reasoning comes from the measurement notes in the headers of
-the source files; for the APIs themselves see documents
-[03](./03-routing.md), [04](./04-rendering.md), [05](./05-islands.md) and
-[06](./06-caching.md).
-
-## The basic premise
-
-On a news or content site, almost everything the visitor sees is already ready
-on the server. Interaction, on the other hand, is scattered point by point: a
-search box, a drawer, a chart, a comment form. With that profile, rebuilding the
-whole page on the client (hydration) is the biggest cost you pay, and in return
-the visitor gains nothing.
-
-JSkelet puts this observation at the centre of the architecture:
-
-1. **The server HTML is complete.** Even if JS never runs, the page can be read,
-   navigated and indexed.
-2. **JS only adds behaviour.** Every interactive piece is attached as an
-   independent "island", with its own module, at its own time.
-3. **Page production is cached.** There is no point in producing the same HTML
-   again on every request; a memory cache with a TTL takes the place of ISR.
-4. **Templates are compiled at build time (`.jsk`).** No request-time parsing;
-   EJS remains as a legacy path. Features may co-locate under
-   `features/<name>/{server,views,client}` — route URLs stay explicit.
-
-## The path of a request
-
-```
-Request
- ├─ rewrites(beforeFiles)          config → proxy or a change to req.url
- ├─ compression                    brotli/gzip negotiation (quality 5)
- ├─ headers                        static cache + config headers()
- ├─ devGate                        if the gate is on, 404 without a token
- ├─ redirects                      config redirects(), first match wins
- ├─ trailingSlash                  308 when config trailingSlash is true
- ├─ robots.txt                     appends framework Disallow rules to the user's body
- ├─ staticPrecompressed            .br/.gz copies produced at build (quality 11)
- ├─ express.static                 files under public/
- ├─ (dev) devtools                 only when NODE_ENV=development
- ├─ admin (if enabled)             /_jskelet/admin
- ├─ image optimizer (remote)       /_jskelet/image — when allowHosts is set
- ├─ body parsers                   urlencoded 64kb + json 256kb
- ├─ rewrites(afterFiles)           after static has been tried
- ├─ routes
- │   └─ route(controller)
- │       └─ withHtmlCache          TTL + stale-while-revalidate
- │           └─ withUpstreamTracking
- │               └─ withRequestCache
- │                   └─ controller → renderPage → .jsk (or legacy EJS)
- ├─ 404 → hooks.notFound()
- └─ error handling                 redirect/notFound + 500 fallback
-```
-
-## Why the middleware order is this order
-
-The real value of the `src/server/create-app.js` file is the order; every
-position has a reason, and moving things around leads to silent breakage.
-
-- **`rewrites(beforeFiles)` comes even before static files.** Otherwise a rule
-  that moves the `/assets/x.js` path somewhere else would never take effect,
-  because `express.static` answers the request first.
-- **`compression` before static.** If it came after, static files would never be
-  compressed.
-- **`headers` → `devGate` → `redirects` → `trailingSlash`.** The gate's 404 must
-  come before the redirects: an environment that has not gone live should not
-  leak even its redirect rules to the outside. `trailingSlash` sits after config
-  redirects so explicit rules see the requested path first; the canonical slash
-  form is enforced as a second step.
-- **`robots.txt` before static, and inside compression.** The body the
-  application wrote is left intact; the framework appends `Disallow` rules
-  for its own endpoints. A response that already has `Content-Encoding` is
-  not rewritten — the block is added to plain text, and compression stays
-  outside.
-- **`staticPrecompressed` before `express.static`.** If there are `.br`/`.gz`
-  copies produced at build time, those are served (brotli quality 11);
-  otherwise the request falls through to the `static` below it and the
-  middleware compresses on the fly (quality 5). Recompressing a hashed,
-  `immutable` file on every request is wasted CPU. In production the `stat`
-  result (present or missing) stays in process memory; in development it does not.
-- **Admin panel** (when `admin().enabled` / `JSKELET_ADMIN`): after static,
-  before body parsers and routes. Carries its own body parsers so the app
-  cannot shadow the path. When off, the module is never loaded.
-- **Body parsers after static.** Image requests should not pay the cost of body
-  parsing.
-- **`rewrites(afterFiles)` after static has been tried and before pages.** The
-  equivalent of Next.js's two-phase rewrite semantics.
-- **404 and error handling last.** The error handler also catches the
-  `notFound`/`redirect` control flow, because those can be thrown outside a
-  controller as well (e.g. inside a middleware).
-
-The framework turns off `x-powered-by` and writes a brandable header in its
-place, sets `etag` to `strong` and enables `trust proxy`. `trust proxy` is
-required for the correct protocol and client IP behind a reverse proxy
-([10-deployment.md](./10-deployment.md)).
-
-## The island model: why visibility-based hydration
-
-`src/client/registry.js` hands every `[data-island]` element to an
-`IntersectionObserver` (`rootMargin: "200px 0px"`). Elements on screen are
-triggered on the very first observation; those off screen are **never
-downloaded** until they are scrolled to. Heavy modules like the chart library on
-the home page thus drop out of the initial load entirely.
-
-There are three behaviours, all controlled from the HTML:
-
-- **Default:** tied to visibility.
-- **`data-island-eager`:** independent of visibility, attaches immediately. For
-  global behaviours like the header or the cookie banner.
-- **`data-island-idle`:** even if it is visible, it waits until `load` has
-  completed and the main thread is free. So that heavy modules that are visible
-  in the first viewport but not critical (e.g. a mini chart that pulls in a
-  chart library) do not compete with LCP.
-
-Two further details came out of measurement:
-
-- **The attaching work is deferred to idle time** (`requestIdleCallback`,
-  `timeout: 500`). If many islands that become visible at once turn into a
-  single long task, TBT and INP suffer.
-- **Elements with no layout box are attached directly.** A `hidden`
-  drawer/dialog has no layout box and `IntersectionObserver` will never report
-  it; that is why `hydrate()` reads the measurements in one pass
-  (`getClientRects().length`) and, instead of handing boxless elements to the
-  observer, attaches them immediately.
-
-One consequence of this: **image error handling is not an island.** An
-image-heavy page can have 80+ `<img>` elements, and attaching a separate island
-to each one (observer + dynamic import + mount) is a serious hydration cost just
-for the possibility of an error. `startSafeImages()` instead installs a single
-capture-phase listener on the document ([05-islands.md](./05-islands.md)).
-
-## Why the server HTML is complete
-
-The layout and the page template produce the entirety of the content the visitor
-will see. There is no "show a skeleton, then fill it in" pattern on the client
-side. This buys three things:
-
-1. **SEO:** the crawler does not have to wait for JS.
-2. **LCP:** the largest contentful element arrives in the first HTML response;
-   downloading, parsing and executing JS is not on the LCP path.
-3. **CLS:** because content is not injected later, the layout does not shift.
-
-The same principle is applied on the `<head>` side too. The layout prints
-resource hints (`preconnect`, LCP `preload`) at the **very beginning** of the
-`<head>`; delaying those writes straight to LCP.
-
-### Why a single, render-blocking stylesheet
-
-No separate "critical CSS" is produced. In measurement, because the inline
-critical CSS did not fully cover the first viewport, the page reflowed once the
-sheet arrived (CLS 0.307 on a list page) and the same ~27 KB was repeated in
-every HTML response. Leaving the compressed global `app.css` render-blocking is
-both faster and free of CLS; on the second visit it already comes from the
-`immutable` cache.
-
-Page-specific rules can use `styles/pages/*.css` plus controller
-`styles: [...]` ([08-build.md](./08-build.md)); those are also render-blocking
-but only on the pages that ask for them. Keep Tailwind utilities in the global
-sheet — a full `@import "tailwindcss"` in a page sheet duplicates utility
-output.
-
-The same logic applies to icons: instead of a separate request per icon, an SVG
-sprite is produced at build time from only the symbols actually used in the
-source. Shipping the whole Phosphor set is 1500+ icons, that is several
-megabytes; the scan typically keeps the sprite at 10-30 symbols
-([08-build.md](./08-build.md)).
-
-## Cache strategy: in-memory TTL instead of ISR
-
-`src/server/html-cache.js` keeps an LRU HTML cache with a TTL, keyed by route +
-query (at most 500 entries). When the TTL expires the entry is not thrown away
-immediately: within the `stale` window the old HTML returns instantly and the
-refresh runs in the background (stale-while-revalidate, `STALE_FACTOR = 1`, i.e.
-the stale window is as long as the TTL).
-
-The gain: after the first warm-up no request ever waits for a render. The price:
-the data in the HTML can be at most `revalidate + one refresh round` behind.
-That price is acceptable, because live fields such as prices are updated on the
-client from a WebSocket and the lag is not visible on screen.
-
-The decision not to write to disk is deliberate. The equivalent of Next's
-build-time prerender is prewarm, but the output is not written to disk: because
-the cache lives in process memory, the warm-up is done when the process comes
-up. The gain is the same — the first visitor does not wait for a cold render —
-but the data is not frozen; every entry ages with the route's `revalidate`
-duration ([06-caching.md](./06-caching.md)).
-
-### Keeping the compressed body in the cache
-
-Every cached entry stores the brotli/gzip output alongside the HTML (the
-`encoded` map shares its lifetime with the HTML). The same page is not
-re-brotli'd on every request. Because `Content-Encoding` is set inside `route()`
-on this path, the compression middleware does not kick in.
-
-### Why transient and permanent upstream errors are handled differently
-
-If an upstream went down during the render, the output contains incomplete data,
-and such HTML is **not** written to the cache: the next request tries again.
-
-But this only applies to *transient* errors (network errors, 408, 425, 429 and
-all 5xx). Deterministic answers like 400/403/404 do not get better by retrying;
-turning off the cache because of them would mean rendering the page from scratch
-on every visit — the content comes back in the same incomplete state anyway, the
-visitor merely pays the render time. That is why permanent errors are only
-logged and do not block the cache.
-
-The direction in which this information reaches the framework is also
-deliberately inverted: the framework does not know the data layer, the data
-layer notifies the framework (`reportUpstreamFailure()`). If nobody ever calls
-it, the cost is an empty array.
-
-### The nesting order of the three scopes
-
-`route()` sets up this order:
-
-```
-withHtmlCache( withUpstreamTracking( withRequestCache( controller ) ) )
-```
-
-The order matters: **the per-request cache must be innermost** so that two calls
-within the same render collapse into a single upstream request; **upstream
-tracking must be inside the HTML cache** so that output produced with incomplete
-data is not written to the cache.
-
-## Fault tolerance: no single gap takes the site down
-
-There is a principle repeated throughout the framework: missing configuration or
-missing build output produces a degraded but working page instead of an error.
-
-- **If the config file is missing or unreadable**, a warning is printed and the
-  server comes up with the defaults. A broken edit must not make the site
-  impossible to open. In the same way, if one of the
-  `headers()`/`redirects()`/`rewrites()`/`cache()` sections throws, only that
-  section is ignored.
-- **If hooks throw**, the framework falls back to its own default and warns.
-- **If the build did not run**, `asset()` returns `/assets/<name>`, `hasAsset()`
-  is false and the layout does not print the stylesheet/script tags at all. When
-  `jskelet build` is forgotten you see an unstyled but working page instead of
-  an error.
-- **A broken route module in dev** prints a warning and is skipped; **in
-  production it throws.** Going live with a half-built route table means pages
-  that silently return 404.
-- **If the 404 render blows up too**, a minimal, template-free HTML is returned;
-  the visitor should not see an empty response.
-- **A single request error does not take the process down:**
-  `unhandledRejection` and `uncaughtException` are logged and the process stays
-  up. On a news site, an error on a single page must not take the whole site
-  down.
-
-## Why there is no file-system-based routing
-
-Order matters. If a single-segment catch-all such as `/:slug` is registered
-before the `/about` route, "about" is mistaken for a slug. Making the order
-visible instead of hiding it in file names makes diagnosis easier: either you
-give an explicit list via `jskelet.config.mjs` → `routes`, or you have the
-`routes/` directory scanned alphabetically and put a numeric prefix on the file
-names (`10-pages.js`, `50-blog.js`, `99-catch-all.js`). Details:
-[03-routing.md](./03-routing.md).
-
-## Why a single source of truth for config
-
-`src/config/index.js` normalizes the project root, the directory paths, the
-branding, the hooks and the rules. Other modules do not compute paths, they call
-`getConfig()`. The reason is concrete: once the framework lives inside
-`node_modules/`, every file that tries to find the root by counting `../..`
-breaks. For the same reason there is a single mutation point on the build side
-too (`initBuildPaths()`).
-
-If `getConfig()` is used without `loadConfig()` having been called, it throws
-instead of assuming an empty project root: a silently wrong path turns into
-hard-to-diagnose problems like "why is there no stylesheet".
-
-## Why this dependency list
-
-There are three runtime dependencies: `express`, `esbuild`, `tailwind-merge`.
-`ejs` is an optional peer only for legacy `.ejs` templates. Everything else
-(Tailwind, PostCSS, lightningcss, sharp, the Phosphor icons) is an **optional
-peer dependency**, and if it is absent the corresponding build step is skipped.
-
-Two decisions deserve a separate explanation:
-
-- **`node:zlib` instead of the `compression` package.** The package does not
-  support brotli and brings a seven-deep dependency tree; doing the brotli +
-  gzip negotiation by hand is enough. Brotli is preferred: on the home page HTML
-  it is ~35% smaller than gzip.
-- **`tailwind-merge` stays at runtime.** Class computation is done only on the
-  server, it never enters the client bundle, so it has no effect on page weight.
-  A hand-written group table, on the other hand, produced visual regressions
-  because it mixed up width/colour pairs like `border-2` +
-  `border-transparent` and dropped classes.
-
-Optional packages are resolved from the **application's** `node_modules`, not
-from the framework's own. If the framework is installed via a `file:` or
-workspace link, a plain `import "postcss"` looks in the framework's tree — not
-in the application's.
-
-## Why alias and extension hooks
-
-`node --import jskelet/register` does two things:
-
-1. It resolves the `compilerOptions.paths` aliases in `jsconfig.json` /
-   `tsconfig.json` (`@/lib/x` → `<root>/lib/x`). Because the editor and the
-   runtime are fed from the same file, the two do not drift apart.
-2. It adds extensions to extensionless relative imports (`./cache` →
-   `./cache.js`). Node ESM does not do this, and it is the most common breaking
-   point in code migrated from a bundler.
-
-The `@/` resolution on the esbuild side mimics the same behaviour, so that
-modules under `lib/` can use the same import style both on the server and in the
-browser.
-
-`--import` expects a module **specifier**, not a file path. On Windows an
-absolute path like `H:\...` is mistaken for a URL with the `h:` scheme and
-rejected; that is why the framework uses `pathToFileURL(...).href` everywhere.
-For the same reason the config, the route modules and the components are
-imported with a `file://` URL too.
-
-## What's next
-
-- The route and controller contract: [03-routing.md](./03-routing.md)
-- The template layer and metadata: [04-rendering.md](./04-rendering.md)
-- The island runtime API: [05-islands.md](./05-islands.md)
-- Cache settings and prewarm: [06-caching.md](./06-caching.md)
-- The inner workings of the dev flow: [09-dev-tools.md](./09-dev-tools.md)
+# 02 — Architecture and the reasoning behind the decisions
+
+This document does not explain how JSkelet works, but **why it works this way**.
+The path a request takes from the server to the browser, why the island model is
+tied to visibility, why the HTML is produced in full, why the cache lives in
+process memory and why the middleware order must not be shuffled — that is all
+here. Most of the reasoning comes from the measurement notes in the headers of
+the source files; for the APIs themselves see documents
+[03](./03-routing.md), [04](./04-rendering.md), [05](./05-islands.md) and
+[06](./06-caching.md).
+
+## The basic premise
+
+On a news or content site, almost everything the visitor sees is already ready
+on the server. Interaction, on the other hand, is scattered point by point: a
+search box, a drawer, a chart, a comment form. With that profile, rebuilding the
+whole page on the client (hydration) is the biggest cost you pay, and in return
+the visitor gains nothing.
+
+JSkelet puts this observation at the centre of the architecture:
+
+1. **The server HTML is complete.** Even if JS never runs, the page can be read,
+   navigated and indexed.
+2. **JS only adds behaviour.** Every interactive piece is attached as an
+   independent "island", with its own module, at its own time.
+3. **Page production is cached.** There is no point in producing the same HTML
+   again on every request; a memory cache with a TTL takes the place of ISR.
+4. **Templates are compiled at build time (`.jsk`).** No request-time parsing;
+   EJS remains as a legacy path. Features may co-locate under
+   `features/<name>/{server,views,client}` — route URLs stay explicit.
+
+## The path of a request
+
+```
+Request
+ ├─ rewrites(beforeFiles)          config → proxy or a change to req.url
+ ├─ compression                    brotli/gzip negotiation (quality 5)
+ ├─ headers                        static cache + config headers()
+ ├─ devGate                        if the gate is on, 404 without a token
+ ├─ redirects                      config redirects(), first match wins
+ ├─ trailingSlash                  308 when config trailingSlash is true
+ ├─ robots.txt                     appends framework Disallow rules to the user's body
+ ├─ staticPrecompressed            .br/.gz copies produced at build (quality 11)
+ ├─ express.static                 files under public/
+ ├─ (dev) devtools                 only when NODE_ENV=development
+ ├─ admin (if enabled)             /_jskelet/admin
+ ├─ image optimizer (remote)       /_jskelet/image — when allowHosts is set
+ ├─ body parsers                   urlencoded 64kb + json 256kb
+ ├─ rewrites(afterFiles)           after static has been tried
+ ├─ routes
+ │   └─ route(controller)
+ │       └─ withHtmlCache          TTL + stale-while-revalidate
+ │           └─ withUpstreamTracking
+ │               └─ withRequestCache
+ │                   └─ controller → renderPage → .jsk (or legacy EJS)
+ ├─ 404 → hooks.notFound()
+ └─ error handling                 redirect/notFound + 500 fallback
+```
+
+## Why the middleware order is this order
+
+The real value of the `src/server/create-app.js` file is the order; every
+position has a reason, and moving things around leads to silent breakage.
+
+- **`rewrites(beforeFiles)` comes even before static files.** Otherwise a rule
+  that moves the `/assets/x.js` path somewhere else would never take effect,
+  because `express.static` answers the request first.
+- **`compression` before static.** If it came after, static files would never be
+  compressed.
+- **`headers` → `devGate` → `redirects` → `trailingSlash`.** The gate's 404 must
+  come before the redirects: an environment that has not gone live should not
+  leak even its redirect rules to the outside. `trailingSlash` sits after config
+  redirects so explicit rules see the requested path first; the canonical slash
+  form is enforced as a second step.
+- **`robots.txt` before static, and inside compression.** The body the
+  application wrote is left intact; the framework appends `Disallow` rules
+  for its own endpoints. A response that already has `Content-Encoding` is
+  not rewritten — the block is added to plain text, and compression stays
+  outside.
+- **`staticPrecompressed` before `express.static`.** If there are `.br`/`.gz`
+  copies produced at build time, those are served (brotli quality 11);
+  otherwise the request falls through to the `static` below it and the
+  middleware compresses on the fly (quality 5). Recompressing a hashed,
+  `immutable` file on every request is wasted CPU. In production the `stat`
+  result (present or missing) stays in process memory; in development it does not.
+- **Admin panel** (when `admin().enabled` / `JSKELET_ADMIN`): after static,
+  before body parsers and routes. Carries its own body parsers so the app
+  cannot shadow the path. When off, the module is never loaded.
+- **Body parsers after static.** Image requests should not pay the cost of body
+  parsing.
+- **`rewrites(afterFiles)` after static has been tried and before pages.** The
+  equivalent of Next.js's two-phase rewrite semantics.
+- **404 and error handling last.** The error handler also catches the
+  `notFound`/`redirect` control flow, because those can be thrown outside a
+  controller as well (e.g. inside a middleware).
+
+The framework turns off `x-powered-by` and writes a brandable header in its
+place, sets `etag` to `strong` and enables `trust proxy`. `trust proxy` is
+required for the correct protocol and client IP behind a reverse proxy
+([10-deployment.md](./10-deployment.md)).
+
+## The island model: why visibility-based hydration
+
+`src/client/registry.js` hands every `[data-island]` element to an
+`IntersectionObserver` (`rootMargin: "200px 0px"`). Elements on screen are
+triggered on the very first observation; those off screen are **never
+downloaded** until they are scrolled to. Heavy modules like the chart library on
+the home page thus drop out of the initial load entirely.
+
+There are three behaviours, all controlled from the HTML:
+
+- **Default:** tied to visibility.
+- **`data-island-eager`:** independent of visibility, attaches immediately. For
+  global behaviours like the header or the cookie banner.
+- **`data-island-idle`:** even if it is visible, it waits until `load` has
+  completed and the main thread is free. So that heavy modules that are visible
+  in the first viewport but not critical (e.g. a mini chart that pulls in a
+  chart library) do not compete with LCP.
+
+Two further details came out of measurement:
+
+- **The attaching work is deferred to idle time** (`requestIdleCallback`,
+  `timeout: 500`). If many islands that become visible at once turn into a
+  single long task, TBT and INP suffer.
+- **Elements with no layout box are attached directly.** A `hidden`
+  drawer/dialog has no layout box and `IntersectionObserver` will never report
+  it; that is why `hydrate()` reads the measurements in one pass
+  (`getClientRects().length`) and, instead of handing boxless elements to the
+  observer, attaches them immediately.
+
+One consequence of this: **image error handling is not an island.** An
+image-heavy page can have 80+ `<img>` elements, and attaching a separate island
+to each one (observer + dynamic import + mount) is a serious hydration cost just
+for the possibility of an error. `startSafeImages()` instead installs a single
+capture-phase listener on the document ([05-islands.md](./05-islands.md)).
+
+## Why the server HTML is complete
+
+The layout and the page template produce the entirety of the content the visitor
+will see. There is no "show a skeleton, then fill it in" pattern on the client
+side. This buys three things:
+
+1. **SEO:** the crawler does not have to wait for JS.
+2. **LCP:** the largest contentful element arrives in the first HTML response;
+   downloading, parsing and executing JS is not on the LCP path.
+3. **CLS:** because content is not injected later, the layout does not shift.
+
+The same principle is applied on the `<head>` side too. The layout prints
+resource hints (`preconnect`, LCP `preload`) at the **very beginning** of the
+`<head>`; delaying those writes straight to LCP.
+
+### Why a single, render-blocking stylesheet
+
+No separate "critical CSS" is produced. In measurement, because the inline
+critical CSS did not fully cover the first viewport, the page reflowed once the
+sheet arrived (CLS 0.307 on a list page) and the same ~27 KB was repeated in
+every HTML response. Leaving the compressed global `app.css` render-blocking is
+both faster and free of CLS; on the second visit it already comes from the
+`immutable` cache.
+
+Page-specific rules can use `styles/pages/*.css` plus controller
+`styles: [...]` ([08-build.md](./08-build.md)); those are also render-blocking
+but only on the pages that ask for them. Keep Tailwind utilities in the global
+sheet — a full `@import "tailwindcss"` in a page sheet duplicates utility
+output.
+
+The same logic applies to icons: instead of a separate request per icon, an SVG
+sprite is produced at build time from only the symbols actually used in the
+source. Shipping the whole Phosphor set is 1500+ icons, that is several
+megabytes; the scan typically keeps the sprite at 10-30 symbols
+([08-build.md](./08-build.md)).
+
+## Cache strategy: in-memory TTL instead of ISR
+
+`src/server/html-cache.js` keeps an LRU HTML cache with a TTL, keyed by route +
+query (at most 500 entries). When the TTL expires the entry is not thrown away
+immediately: within the `stale` window the old HTML returns instantly and the
+refresh runs in the background (stale-while-revalidate, `STALE_FACTOR = 1`, i.e.
+the stale window is as long as the TTL).
+
+The gain: after the first warm-up no request ever waits for a render. The price:
+the data in the HTML can be at most `revalidate + one refresh round` behind.
+That price is acceptable, because live fields such as prices are updated on the
+client from a WebSocket and the lag is not visible on screen.
+
+The decision not to write to disk is deliberate. The equivalent of Next's
+build-time prerender is prewarm, but the output is not written to disk: because
+the cache lives in process memory, the warm-up is done when the process comes
+up. The gain is the same — the first visitor does not wait for a cold render —
+but the data is not frozen; every entry ages with the route's `revalidate`
+duration ([06-caching.md](./06-caching.md)).
+
+### Keeping the compressed body in the cache
+
+Every cached entry stores the brotli/gzip output alongside the HTML (the
+`encoded` map shares its lifetime with the HTML). The same page is not
+re-brotli'd on every request. Because `Content-Encoding` is set inside `route()`
+on this path, the compression middleware does not kick in.
+
+### Why transient and permanent upstream errors are handled differently
+
+If an upstream went down during the render, the output contains incomplete data,
+and such HTML is **not** written to the cache: the next request tries again.
+
+But this only applies to *transient* errors (network errors, 408, 425, 429 and
+all 5xx). Deterministic answers like 400/403/404 do not get better by retrying;
+turning off the cache because of them would mean rendering the page from scratch
+on every visit — the content comes back in the same incomplete state anyway, the
+visitor merely pays the render time. That is why permanent errors are only
+logged and do not block the cache.
+
+The direction in which this information reaches the framework is also
+deliberately inverted: the framework does not know the data layer, the data
+layer notifies the framework (`reportUpstreamFailure()`). If nobody ever calls
+it, the cost is an empty array.
+
+### The nesting order of the three scopes
+
+`route()` sets up this order:
+
+```
+withHtmlCache( withUpstreamTracking( withRequestCache( controller ) ) )
+```
+
+The order matters: **the per-request cache must be innermost** so that two calls
+within the same render collapse into a single upstream request; **upstream
+tracking must be inside the HTML cache** so that output produced with incomplete
+data is not written to the cache.
+
+## Fault tolerance: no single gap takes the site down
+
+There is a principle repeated throughout the framework: missing configuration or
+missing build output produces a degraded but working page instead of an error.
+
+- **If the config file is missing or unreadable**, a warning is printed and the
+  server comes up with the defaults. A broken edit must not make the site
+  impossible to open. In the same way, if one of the
+  `headers()`/`redirects()`/`rewrites()`/`cache()` sections throws, only that
+  section is ignored.
+- **If hooks throw**, the framework falls back to its own default and warns.
+- **If the build did not run**, `asset()` returns `/assets/<name>`, `hasAsset()`
+  is false and the layout does not print the stylesheet/script tags at all. When
+  `jskelet build` is forgotten you see an unstyled but working page instead of
+  an error.
+- **A broken route module in dev** prints a warning and is skipped; **in
+  production it throws.** Going live with a half-built route table means pages
+  that silently return 404.
+- **If the 404 render blows up too**, a minimal, template-free HTML is returned;
+  the visitor should not see an empty response.
+- **A single request error does not take the process down:**
+  `unhandledRejection` and `uncaughtException` are logged and the process stays
+  up. On a news site, an error on a single page must not take the whole site
+  down.
+
+## Why there is no file-system-based routing
+
+Order matters. If a single-segment catch-all such as `/:slug` is registered
+before the `/about` route, "about" is mistaken for a slug. Making the order
+visible instead of hiding it in file names makes diagnosis easier: either you
+give an explicit list via `jskelet.config.mjs` → `routes`, or you have the
+`routes/` directory scanned alphabetically and put a numeric prefix on the file
+names (`10-pages.js`, `50-blog.js`, `99-catch-all.js`). Details:
+[03-routing.md](./03-routing.md).
+
+## Why a single source of truth for config
+
+`src/config/index.js` normalizes the project root, the directory paths, the
+branding, the hooks and the rules. Other modules do not compute paths, they call
+`getConfig()`. The reason is concrete: once the framework lives inside
+`node_modules/`, every file that tries to find the root by counting `../..`
+breaks. For the same reason there is a single mutation point on the build side
+too (`initBuildPaths()`).
+
+If `getConfig()` is used without `loadConfig()` having been called, it throws
+instead of assuming an empty project root: a silently wrong path turns into
+hard-to-diagnose problems like "why is there no stylesheet".
+
+## Why this dependency list
+
+There are three runtime dependencies: `express`, `esbuild`, `tailwind-merge`.
+`ejs` is an optional peer only for legacy `.ejs` templates. Everything else
+(Tailwind, PostCSS, lightningcss, sharp, the Phosphor icons) is an **optional
+peer dependency**, and if it is absent the corresponding build step is skipped.
+
+Two decisions deserve a separate explanation:
+
+- **`node:zlib` instead of the `compression` package.** The package does not
+  support brotli and brings a seven-deep dependency tree; doing the brotli +
+  gzip negotiation by hand is enough. Brotli is preferred: on the home page HTML
+  it is ~35% smaller than gzip.
+- **`tailwind-merge` stays at runtime.** Class computation is done only on the
+  server, it never enters the client bundle, so it has no effect on page weight.
+  A hand-written group table, on the other hand, produced visual regressions
+  because it mixed up width/colour pairs like `border-2` +
+  `border-transparent` and dropped classes.
+
+Optional packages are resolved from the **application's** `node_modules`, not
+from the framework's own. If the framework is installed via a `file:` or
+workspace link, a plain `import "postcss"` looks in the framework's tree — not
+in the application's.
+
+## Why alias and extension hooks
+
+`node --import jskelet/register` does two things:
+
+1. It resolves the `compilerOptions.paths` aliases in `jsconfig.json` /
+   `tsconfig.json` (`@/lib/x` → `<root>/lib/x`). Because the editor and the
+   runtime are fed from the same file, the two do not drift apart.
+2. It adds extensions to extensionless relative imports (`./cache` →
+   `./cache.js`). Node ESM does not do this, and it is the most common breaking
+   point in code migrated from a bundler.
+
+The `@/` resolution on the esbuild side mimics the same behaviour, so that
+modules under `lib/` can use the same import style both on the server and in the
+browser.
+
+`--import` expects a module **specifier**, not a file path. On Windows an
+absolute path like `H:\...` is mistaken for a URL with the `h:` scheme and
+rejected; that is why the framework uses `pathToFileURL(...).href` everywhere.
+For the same reason the config, the route modules and the components are
+imported with a `file://` URL too.
+
+## What's next
+
+- The route and controller contract: [03-routing.md](./03-routing.md)
+- The template layer and metadata: [04-rendering.md](./04-rendering.md)
+- The island runtime API: [05-islands.md](./05-islands.md)
+- Cache settings and prewarm: [06-caching.md](./06-caching.md)
+- The inner workings of the dev flow: [09-dev-tools.md](./09-dev-tools.md)