gentle-pi 2.1.2 → 2.2.0

package/tests/review-host-relay.test.ts

@@ -0,0 +1,520 @@
+import assert from "node:assert/strict";
+import { chmodSync, existsSync, mkdtempSync, readFileSync, rmSync, writeFileSync } from "node:fs";
+import { tmpdir } from "node:os";
+import { join } from "node:path";
+import test from "node:test";
+import { createNodeExecFileAdapter } from "../lib/native-review-cli.ts";
+import {
+	REVIEW_HOST_RELAY_FAILURE,
+	REVIEW_HOST_RELAY_PI_ARGV,
+	REVIEW_HOST_RELAY_SUBMISSION_MISSING_MESSAGE,
+	REVIEW_HOST_RELAY_UNAVAILABLE_MESSAGE,
+	ReviewHostRelayError,
+	classifyReviewHostRelayRefusal,
+	resolveReviewHostRelaySubmission,
+	reviewHostRelaySlots,
+	runReviewHostRelaySlot,
+} from "../lib/review-host-relay.ts";
+import { GENTLE_PI_REVIEW_RELAY_CONTRACT, GENTLE_PI_REVIEW_RELAY_CONTRACT_ENV } from "../lib/review-relay-contract.ts";
+import { decodeReviewNextTransitionV3, type ReviewCaptureSubmissionV1, type ReviewCollectInputV3 } from "../lib/review-integration-v2.ts";
+
+// ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
+// Fake binaries. Following the repo's fake-executable idiom (shell/git
+// wrappers in review-gate/git-commit-transaction tests), these are
+// shebang scripts written into a scratch directory; node scripts are used so
+// binary-unsafe bytes survive verbatim.
+// ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
+
+const FAKE_GENTLE_AI = `#!/usr/bin/env node
+const fs = require("node:fs");
+const argv = process.argv.slice(2);
+if (process.env.RELAY_FAKE_LOG) fs.appendFileSync(process.env.RELAY_FAKE_LOG, JSON.stringify({ argv, contract: process.env.${GENTLE_PI_REVIEW_RELAY_CONTRACT_ENV} ?? null }) + "\\n");
+if (argv.some((token) => token === "--materialize" || token.startsWith("--materialize="))) {
+	const mode = process.env.RELAY_FAKE_MATERIALIZE_MODE || "ok";
+	if (mode === "ok") { process.stdout.write(Buffer.from(process.env.RELAY_FAKE_PROMPT_B64 || "", "base64")); process.exit(0); }
+	if (mode === "empty") process.exit(0);
+	if (mode === "unknown-flag") { process.stderr.write("flag provided but not defined: -materialize\\nUsage of gentle-ai review capture-result:\\n"); process.exit(2); }
+	if (mode === "handshake") { process.stderr.write(process.env.RELAY_FAKE_HANDSHAKE_STDERR || "the active runtime is not eligible for immutable receipt review"); process.exit(1); }
+	process.stderr.write("materialize exploded\\n"); process.exit(3);
+}
+const inputToken = argv.find((token) => token === "--input" || token.startsWith("--input="));
+if (inputToken !== undefined) {
+	const mode = process.env.RELAY_FAKE_SUBMIT_MODE || "ok";
+	if (mode === "ok") {
+		const inputPath = inputToken.startsWith("--input=") ? inputToken.slice("--input=".length) : argv[argv.indexOf("--input") + 1];
+		const bytes = fs.readFileSync(inputPath);
+		if (process.env.RELAY_FAKE_SUBMIT_CAPTURE) fs.writeFileSync(process.env.RELAY_FAKE_SUBMIT_CAPTURE, bytes);
+		process.stdout.write(JSON.stringify({ schema: "gentle-ai.review-result-artifact/v2", admission_decision: "completed" }));
+		process.exit(0);
+	}
+	process.stderr.write("capture binding does not match the current reviewing authority\\n");
+	process.exit(1);
+}
+process.stderr.write("unexpected fake gentle-ai invocation\\n");
+process.exit(9);
+`;
+
+const FAKE_PI = `#!/usr/bin/env node
+const fs = require("node:fs");
+const argv = process.argv.slice(2);
+if (process.env.RELAY_FAKE_PI_LOG) fs.appendFileSync(process.env.RELAY_FAKE_PI_LOG, JSON.stringify({ argv, cwd: process.cwd(), entries: fs.readdirSync(process.cwd()), contract: process.env.${GENTLE_PI_REVIEW_RELAY_CONTRACT_ENV} ?? null }) + "\\n");
+const chunks = [];
+process.stdin.on("data", (chunk) => chunks.push(chunk));
+process.stdin.on("end", () => {
+	const stdin = Buffer.concat(chunks);
+	if (process.env.RELAY_FAKE_PI_STDIN_CAPTURE) fs.writeFileSync(process.env.RELAY_FAKE_PI_STDIN_CAPTURE, stdin);
+	const mode = process.env.RELAY_FAKE_PI_MODE || "ok";
+	if (mode === "ok") { process.stdout.write(Buffer.from(process.env.RELAY_FAKE_PI_OUTPUT_B64 || "", "base64")); process.exit(0); }
+	if (mode === "empty") process.exit(0);
+	if (mode === "hang") { setTimeout(() => process.exit(0), 10_000); return; }
+	process.stderr.write("pi exploded\\n");
+	process.exit(4);
+});
+`;
+
+interface RelayHarness {
+	directory: string;
+	gentleAi: string;
+	pi: string;
+	logPath: string;
+	piLogPath: string;
+	stdinCapturePath: string;
+	submitCapturePath: string;
+	environment: NodeJS.ProcessEnv;
+}
+
+function harness(t: test.TestContext, overrides: Record<string, string> = {}): RelayHarness {
+	const directory = mkdtempSync(join(tmpdir(), "gentle-pi-relay-harness-"));
+	t.after(() => rmSync(directory, { recursive: true, force: true }));
+	const gentleAi = join(directory, "gentle-ai");
+	const pi = join(directory, "pi");
+	writeFileSync(gentleAi, FAKE_GENTLE_AI);
+	chmodSync(gentleAi, 0o755);
+	writeFileSync(pi, FAKE_PI);
+	chmodSync(pi, 0o755);
+	const logPath = join(directory, "gentle-ai.log");
+	const piLogPath = join(directory, "pi.log");
+	const stdinCapturePath = join(directory, "pi-stdin.bin");
+	const submitCapturePath = join(directory, "submitted.bin");
+	const environment: NodeJS.ProcessEnv = {
+		...process.env,
+		RELAY_FAKE_LOG: logPath,
+		RELAY_FAKE_PI_LOG: piLogPath,
+		RELAY_FAKE_PI_STDIN_CAPTURE: stdinCapturePath,
+		RELAY_FAKE_SUBMIT_CAPTURE: submitCapturePath,
+		...overrides,
+	};
+	// The relay itself must add the handshake; the base environment never
+	// carries it, so the fake-binary log proves the injection.
+	delete environment[GENTLE_PI_REVIEW_RELAY_CONTRACT_ENV];
+	return { directory, gentleAi, pi, logPath, piLogPath, stdinCapturePath, submitCapturePath, environment };
+}
+
+function readLog(path: string): Array<{ argv: string[]; contract: string | null; cwd?: string; entries?: string[] }> {
+	if (!existsSync(path)) return [];
+	return readFileSync(path, "utf8").split("\n").filter((line) => line.length > 0).map((line) => JSON.parse(line));
+}
+
+const BINDING_TOKENS = Object.freeze([
+	"--lineage=review-1d5aadacc600e167",
+	`--expected-revision=sha256:${"c".repeat(64)}`,
+	`--target=sha256:${"d".repeat(64)}`,
+	`--repository-context=rctx1_${"e".repeat(64)}`,
+	"--lens=review-reliability",
+	"--order=0",
+	`--subject-hash=sha256:${"a".repeat(64)}`,
+]);
+const CAPTURE_TOKENS = Object.freeze([...BINDING_TOKENS, "--agent=pi", "--materialize=true"]);
+
+// The provider-owned completing form: exact operation and argument tokens
+// with one declared {{value}} substitution slot for the artifact path.
+const SUBMISSION: ReviewCaptureSubmissionV1 = Object.freeze({
+	operationToken: "capture-result",
+	argumentTokens: Object.freeze([...BINDING_TOKENS, "--input={{value}}"]),
+	values: Object.freeze([{ slot: "reviewer_result", domain: "artifact_path_or_stdin", substitutionLocation: BINDING_TOKENS.length }]),
+});
+
+// Prompt and result bytes deliberately include binary-unsafe content: NUL,
+// control bytes, quotes, backslashes, CRLF, multi-byte UTF-8, and bytes that
+// are not valid UTF-8 at all. The relay must move them verbatim.
+const PROMPT_BYTES = Buffer.concat([
+	Buffer.from('GENTLE_AI_REVIEW_BINDING {"lineage":"review-1d5aadacc600e167"}\n"quotes" \\backslash\r\n\u00e9\u{1F3A9}\n', "utf8"),
+	Buffer.from([0x00, 0x01, 0x07, 0xff, 0xfe, 0x00]),
+]);
+const PI_OUTPUT_BYTES = Buffer.concat([
+	Buffer.from(`{"subject_hash":"sha256:${"a".repeat(64)}","findings":[]}\n`, "utf8"),
+	Buffer.from([0x00, 0xf0, 0x9f, 0x8e, 0xa9, 0xff, 0x0d, 0x0a]),
+]);
+
+function relayRequest(fixture: RelayHarness, overrides: Record<string, unknown> = {}) {
+	return {
+		captureArgumentTokens: CAPTURE_TOKENS,
+		submission: SUBMISSION,
+		gentleAiExecutable: fixture.gentleAi,
+		piExecutable: fixture.pi,
+		environment: {
+			...fixture.environment,
+			RELAY_FAKE_PROMPT_B64: PROMPT_BYTES.toString("base64"),
+			RELAY_FAKE_PI_OUTPUT_B64: PI_OUTPUT_BYTES.toString("base64"),
+		},
+		gentleAiTimeoutMs: 30_000,
+		piTimeoutMs: 30_000,
+		...overrides,
+	};
+}
+
+async function rejectsWithRelayError(promise: Promise<unknown>, kind: string, stage: string): Promise<ReviewHostRelayError> {
+	let caught: ReviewHostRelayError | undefined;
+	await assert.rejects(promise, (error: unknown) => {
+		assert.ok(error instanceof ReviewHostRelayError, `expected ReviewHostRelayError, received ${String(error)}`);
+		caught = error;
+		return error.name === "ReviewHostRelayError" && error.kind === kind && error.stage === stage;
+	});
+	return caught!;
+}
+
+// ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
+// Handshake — every gentle-ai CLI spawn carries the compiled declaration.
+// ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
+
+test("the central native CLI runner declares the relay contract on every gentle-ai spawn", async (t) => {
+	const fixture = harness(t);
+	const probe = join(fixture.directory, "env-probe");
+	writeFileSync(probe, `#!/usr/bin/env node\nprocess.stdout.write(JSON.stringify({ contract: process.env.${GENTLE_PI_REVIEW_RELAY_CONTRACT_ENV} ?? null }));\n`);
+	chmodSync(probe, 0o755);
+	const hadContract = Object.prototype.hasOwnProperty.call(process.env, GENTLE_PI_REVIEW_RELAY_CONTRACT_ENV);
+	const previous = process.env[GENTLE_PI_REVIEW_RELAY_CONTRACT_ENV];
+	delete process.env[GENTLE_PI_REVIEW_RELAY_CONTRACT_ENV];
+	t.after(() => {
+		if (hadContract) process.env[GENTLE_PI_REVIEW_RELAY_CONTRACT_ENV] = previous;
+	});
+	const adapter = createNodeExecFileAdapter();
+	for (const argv of [["version"], ["review", "status", "--cwd", fixture.directory]]) {
+		const result = await adapter({ file: probe, arguments: argv, cwd: fixture.directory, timeoutMs: 10_000, maxBufferBytes: 1024 * 1024 });
+		assert.equal(result.exitCode, 0);
+		assert.deepEqual(JSON.parse(result.stdout), { contract: GENTLE_PI_REVIEW_RELAY_CONTRACT });
+	}
+});
+
+test("relay contract constants are the compiled gentle-ai handshake values", () => {
+	assert.equal(GENTLE_PI_REVIEW_RELAY_CONTRACT_ENV, "GENTLE_PI_REVIEW_RELAY_CONTRACT");
+	assert.equal(GENTLE_PI_REVIEW_RELAY_CONTRACT, "gentle-pi.review-relay/v1");
+});
+
+// ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
+// Happy path
+// ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
+
+test("relay happy path moves prompt and result bytes verbatim through a fresh empty scratch pi subprocess", async (t) => {
+	const fixture = harness(t);
+	const result = await runReviewHostRelaySlot(relayRequest(fixture));
+
+	assert.equal(result.promptByteLength, PROMPT_BYTES.length);
+	assert.equal(result.resultByteLength, PI_OUTPUT_BYTES.length);
+	assert.equal(JSON.parse(result.submission).admission_decision, "completed");
+
+	// Prompt bytes reached pi stdin verbatim.
+	assert.deepEqual(readFileSync(fixture.stdinCapturePath), PROMPT_BYTES);
+	// Submission --input file bytes are EXACTLY the pi stdout bytes.
+	assert.deepEqual(readFileSync(fixture.submitCapturePath), PI_OUTPUT_BYTES);
+
+	const gentleAiCalls = readLog(fixture.logPath);
+	assert.equal(gentleAiCalls.length, 2);
+	// (a) exact provider tokens, verbatim, in provider order.
+	assert.deepEqual(gentleAiCalls[0]!.argv, ["review", "capture-result", ...CAPTURE_TOKENS]);
+	// (d) the provider-owned submission form, verbatim: its exact operation
+	// and argument tokens with only the artifact path substituted into the
+	// declared {{value}} slot. No agent/materialize, nothing synthesized.
+	assert.deepEqual(gentleAiCalls[1]!.argv.slice(0, 2 + BINDING_TOKENS.length), ["review", SUBMISSION.operationToken, ...BINDING_TOKENS]);
+	const substituted = gentleAiCalls[1]!.argv.at(-1)!;
+	assert.match(substituted, /^--input=\S+$/);
+	assert.equal(substituted.includes("{{value}}"), false);
+	assert.equal(gentleAiCalls[1]!.argv.length, 2 + SUBMISSION.argumentTokens.length);
+	assert.equal(gentleAiCalls[1]!.argv.some((token) => token.includes("--agent") || token.includes("--materialize")), false);
+	// Handshake declared on both gentle-ai invocations even though the base
+	// environment carried none.
+	assert.deepEqual(gentleAiCalls.map((call) => call.contract), [GENTLE_PI_REVIEW_RELAY_CONTRACT, GENTLE_PI_REVIEW_RELAY_CONTRACT]);
+
+	const piCalls = readLog(fixture.piLogPath);
+	assert.equal(piCalls.length, 1);
+	// The pi environment stays untouched: no relay handshake is injected.
+	assert.equal(piCalls[0]!.contract, null);
+	// Fresh EMPTY scratch cwd, removed after the run.
+	assert.deepEqual(piCalls[0]!.entries, []);
+	assert.notEqual(piCalls[0]!.cwd, process.cwd());
+	assert.equal(existsSync(piCalls[0]!.cwd!), false);
+});
+
+test("the pi lockdown argv is pinned exactly with no model or provider selection", async (t) => {
+	const fixture = harness(t);
+	await runReviewHostRelaySlot(relayRequest(fixture));
+	const piCalls = readLog(fixture.piLogPath);
+	const expected = [
+		"--print",
+		"--mode", "text",
+		"--no-session",
+		"--no-tools",
+		"--no-extensions",
+		"--no-skills",
+		"--no-prompt-templates",
+		"--no-themes",
+		"--no-context-files",
+		"--no-approve",
+	];
+	assert.deepEqual([...REVIEW_HOST_RELAY_PI_ARGV], expected);
+	assert.deepEqual(piCalls[0]!.argv, expected);
+	assert.equal(piCalls[0]!.argv.some((token) => token.startsWith("--model") || token.startsWith("--provider") || token.startsWith("--profile")), false);
+});
+
+// ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
+// Fail-closed legs — a typed transport error and NO submission.
+// ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
+
+test("materialize nonzero exit fails closed with a typed error and never launches pi or submits", async (t) => {
+	const fixture = harness(t, { RELAY_FAKE_MATERIALIZE_MODE: "fail" });
+	const error = await rejectsWithRelayError(runReviewHostRelaySlot(relayRequest(fixture)), REVIEW_HOST_RELAY_FAILURE.MATERIALIZE_FAILED, "materialize");
+	assert.equal(error.exitCode, 3);
+	assert.equal(error.mutationOutcome, "none");
+	assert.equal(readLog(fixture.logPath).length, 1);
+	assert.equal(readLog(fixture.piLogPath).length, 0);
+	assert.equal(existsSync(fixture.submitCapturePath), false);
+});
+
+test("an empty materialized prompt fails closed before pi launches", async (t) => {
+	const fixture = harness(t, { RELAY_FAKE_MATERIALIZE_MODE: "empty" });
+	await rejectsWithRelayError(runReviewHostRelaySlot(relayRequest(fixture)), REVIEW_HOST_RELAY_FAILURE.EMPTY_PROMPT, "materialize");
+	assert.equal(readLog(fixture.piLogPath).length, 0);
+	assert.equal(existsSync(fixture.submitCapturePath), false);
+});
+
+test("pi nonzero exit fails closed with a typed error and no submission", async (t) => {
+	const fixture = harness(t, { RELAY_FAKE_PI_MODE: "fail" });
+	const error = await rejectsWithRelayError(runReviewHostRelaySlot(relayRequest(fixture)), REVIEW_HOST_RELAY_FAILURE.PI_FAILED, "pi");
+	assert.equal(error.exitCode, 4);
+	assert.equal(error.mutationOutcome, "none");
+	assert.equal(readLog(fixture.logPath).length, 1, "no submission invocation after pi failure");
+	assert.equal(existsSync(fixture.submitCapturePath), false);
+});
+
+test("empty pi stdout fails closed with a typed error and no submission", async (t) => {
+	const fixture = harness(t, { RELAY_FAKE_PI_MODE: "empty" });
+	await rejectsWithRelayError(runReviewHostRelaySlot(relayRequest(fixture)), REVIEW_HOST_RELAY_FAILURE.PI_EMPTY_OUTPUT, "pi");
+	assert.equal(readLog(fixture.logPath).length, 1);
+	assert.equal(existsSync(fixture.submitCapturePath), false);
+});
+
+test("pi timeout fails closed with a typed error and no submission", async (t) => {
+	const fixture = harness(t, { RELAY_FAKE_PI_MODE: "hang" });
+	const error = await rejectsWithRelayError(runReviewHostRelaySlot(relayRequest(fixture, { piTimeoutMs: 300 })), REVIEW_HOST_RELAY_FAILURE.PI_FAILED, "pi");
+	assert.equal(error.timedOut, true);
+	assert.equal(readLog(fixture.logPath).length, 1);
+	assert.equal(existsSync(fixture.submitCapturePath), false);
+});
+
+test("submission refusal is a typed error whose outcome is unknown pending STATUS", async (t) => {
+	const fixture = harness(t, { RELAY_FAKE_SUBMIT_MODE: "refuse" });
+	const error = await rejectsWithRelayError(runReviewHostRelaySlot(relayRequest(fixture)), REVIEW_HOST_RELAY_FAILURE.SUBMISSION_REFUSED, "submit");
+	assert.equal(error.mutationOutcome, "unknown");
+	assert.match(error.stderr, /capture binding does not match/);
+	assert.equal(readLog(fixture.logPath).length, 2);
+});
+
+test("relay scratch and staging directories are removed after failures too", async (t) => {
+	const fixture = harness(t, { RELAY_FAKE_PI_MODE: "fail" });
+	await rejectsWithRelayError(runReviewHostRelaySlot(relayRequest(fixture)), REVIEW_HOST_RELAY_FAILURE.PI_FAILED, "pi");
+	const piCalls = readLog(fixture.piLogPath);
+	assert.equal(piCalls.length, 1);
+	assert.equal(existsSync(piCalls[0]!.cwd!), false);
+});
+
+// ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
+// Capability detection — typed refusal classes, no version sniffing.
+// ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
+
+test("an old binary's unknown-flag refusal classifies as relay-unavailable with the exact report", async (t) => {
+	const fixture = harness(t, { RELAY_FAKE_MATERIALIZE_MODE: "unknown-flag" });
+	const error = await rejectsWithRelayError(runReviewHostRelaySlot(relayRequest(fixture)), REVIEW_HOST_RELAY_FAILURE.RELAY_UNAVAILABLE, "materialize");
+	assert.equal(error.message, REVIEW_HOST_RELAY_UNAVAILABLE_MESSAGE);
+	assert.match(error.stderr, /flag provided but not defined: -materialize/);
+	assert.equal(readLog(fixture.piLogPath).length, 0);
+	assert.equal(existsSync(fixture.submitCapturePath), false);
+});
+
+test("a handshake refusal surfaces the provider refusal verbatim", async (t) => {
+	const refusal = "review capture-result --agent pi: the active runtime is not eligible for immutable receipt review; supported immutable review runtimes: claude-code, codex, opencode";
+	const fixture = harness(t, { RELAY_FAKE_MATERIALIZE_MODE: "handshake", RELAY_FAKE_HANDSHAKE_STDERR: refusal });
+	const error = await rejectsWithRelayError(runReviewHostRelaySlot(relayRequest(fixture)), REVIEW_HOST_RELAY_FAILURE.HANDSHAKE_REFUSED, "materialize");
+	assert.equal(error.message, refusal);
+	assert.equal(error.stderr, refusal);
+	assert.equal(readLog(fixture.piLogPath).length, 0);
+});
+
+test("refusal classification distinguishes unknown-flag, handshake, and other", () => {
+	assert.equal(classifyReviewHostRelayRefusal("flag provided but not defined: -materialize\nUsage:"), "unknown-flag");
+	assert.equal(classifyReviewHostRelayRefusal("flag provided but not defined: -agent"), "unknown-flag");
+	assert.equal(classifyReviewHostRelayRefusal("the active runtime is not eligible for immutable receipt review"), "handshake");
+	assert.equal(classifyReviewHostRelayRefusal("declare GENTLE_PI_REVIEW_RELAY_CONTRACT=gentle-pi.review-relay/v1"), "handshake");
+	assert.equal(classifyReviewHostRelayRefusal("some unrelated explosion"), "other");
+});
+
+// ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
+// Slot detection — the provider decides; nothing is inferred.
+// ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
+
+function collectInput(overrides: Partial<{ captureOperation: string; arguments: ReviewCollectInputV3["arguments"]; submission: ReviewCaptureSubmissionV1 | undefined }> = {}): ReviewCollectInputV3 {
+	const argumentsList: ReviewCollectInputV3["arguments"] = overrides.arguments ?? [
+		{ name: "lineage", value: "review-1d5aadacc600e167", token: "--lineage=review-1d5aadacc600e167" },
+		{ name: "expected-revision", value: `sha256:${"c".repeat(64)}`, token: `--expected-revision=sha256:${"c".repeat(64)}` },
+		{ name: "target", value: `sha256:${"d".repeat(64)}`, token: `--target=sha256:${"d".repeat(64)}` },
+		{ name: "repository-context", value: `rctx1_${"e".repeat(64)}`, token: `--repository-context=rctx1_${"e".repeat(64)}` },
+		{ name: "lens", value: "review-reliability", token: "--lens=review-reliability" },
+		{ name: "order", value: "0", token: "--order=0" },
+		{ name: "subject-hash", value: `sha256:${"a".repeat(64)}`, token: `--subject-hash=sha256:${"a".repeat(64)}` },
+		{ name: "agent", value: "pi", token: "--agent=pi" },
+		{ name: "materialize", value: "true", token: "--materialize=true" },
+	];
+	return {
+		name: "reviewer_result",
+		schema: "https://gentle-ai.dev/schema/review/reviewer/v1",
+		captureOperation: overrides.captureOperation ?? "review.capture-result",
+		arguments: argumentsList,
+		...("submission" in overrides ? (overrides.submission === undefined ? {} : { submission: overrides.submission }) : { submission: SUBMISSION }),
+	};
+}
+
+test("only provider-issued pi --materialize capture-result inputs become relay slots", () => {
+	const slots = reviewHostRelaySlots([collectInput()]);
+	assert.equal(slots.length, 1);
+	assert.deepEqual(slots[0]!.captureArgumentTokens, [...CAPTURE_TOKENS]);
+	// The provider-owned completing form passes through verbatim.
+	assert.deepEqual(slots[0]!.submission, SUBMISSION);
+	assert.equal(slots[0]!.lens, "review-reliability");
+	assert.equal(slots[0]!.order, "0");
+
+	// A materialize slot whose provider omitted the submission still becomes
+	// a slot (the provider decided the route); the relay then fails closed.
+	const missingSubmission = reviewHostRelaySlots([collectInput({ submission: undefined })]);
+	assert.equal(missingSubmission.length, 1);
+	assert.equal(missingSubmission[0]!.submission, undefined);
+
+	const withoutMaterialize = collectInput({ arguments: collectInput().arguments.filter((argument) => argument.name !== "materialize") });
+	assert.deepEqual(reviewHostRelaySlots([withoutMaterialize]), []);
+
+	const withoutAgent = collectInput({ arguments: collectInput().arguments.filter((argument) => argument.name !== "agent") });
+	assert.deepEqual(reviewHostRelaySlots([withoutAgent]), []);
+
+	const foreignAgent = collectInput({ arguments: collectInput().arguments.map((argument) => argument.name === "agent" ? { ...argument, value: "codex", token: "--agent=codex" } : argument) });
+	assert.deepEqual(reviewHostRelaySlots([foreignAgent]), []);
+
+	const evidence = collectInput({ captureOperation: "review.capture-evidence" });
+	assert.deepEqual(reviewHostRelaySlots([evidence]), []);
+});
+
+test("relay input validation rejects empty or malformed inputs before any process launches", async () => {
+	await assert.rejects(runReviewHostRelaySlot({ captureArgumentTokens: [], submission: SUBMISSION }), TypeError);
+	await assert.rejects(runReviewHostRelaySlot({ captureArgumentTokens: [""], submission: SUBMISSION }), TypeError);
+	await assert.rejects(runReviewHostRelaySlot({ captureArgumentTokens: CAPTURE_TOKENS, submission: SUBMISSION, gentleAiExecutable: "gentle-ai" }), TypeError);
+});
+
+// ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
+// Provider-owned submission form — consumed verbatim, never synthesized.
+// ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
+
+test("a materialize slot without a provider submission fails closed before any process launches", async (t) => {
+	const fixture = harness(t);
+	const error = await rejectsWithRelayError(
+		runReviewHostRelaySlot(relayRequest(fixture, { submission: undefined })),
+		REVIEW_HOST_RELAY_FAILURE.SUBMISSION_CONTRACT_MISMATCH,
+		"binding",
+	);
+	assert.equal(error.message, REVIEW_HOST_RELAY_SUBMISSION_MISSING_MESSAGE);
+	assert.equal(error.mutationOutcome, "none");
+	assert.equal(readLog(fixture.logPath).length, 0, "no gentle-ai invocation was launched");
+	assert.equal(readLog(fixture.piLogPath).length, 0, "no pi subprocess was launched");
+	assert.equal(existsSync(fixture.submitCapturePath), false);
+});
+
+test("a submission form the relay cannot bind is a typed contract mismatch, never a repaired invocation", async (t) => {
+	const fixture = harness(t);
+	const twoValues: ReviewCaptureSubmissionV1 = {
+		...SUBMISSION,
+		values: [...SUBMISSION.values, { slot: "extra", domain: "artifact_path_or_stdin", substitutionLocation: 0 }],
+	};
+	await rejectsWithRelayError(runReviewHostRelaySlot(relayRequest(fixture, { submission: twoValues })), REVIEW_HOST_RELAY_FAILURE.SUBMISSION_CONTRACT_MISMATCH, "binding");
+	const noSlot: ReviewCaptureSubmissionV1 = {
+		...SUBMISSION,
+		argumentTokens: [...BINDING_TOKENS, "--input=/etc/somewhere"],
+	};
+	await rejectsWithRelayError(runReviewHostRelaySlot(relayRequest(fixture, { submission: noSlot })), REVIEW_HOST_RELAY_FAILURE.SUBMISSION_CONTRACT_MISMATCH, "binding");
+	const outOfBounds: ReviewCaptureSubmissionV1 = {
+		...SUBMISSION,
+		values: [{ slot: "reviewer_result", domain: "artifact_path_or_stdin", substitutionLocation: SUBMISSION.argumentTokens.length }],
+	};
+	await rejectsWithRelayError(runReviewHostRelaySlot(relayRequest(fixture, { submission: outOfBounds })), REVIEW_HOST_RELAY_FAILURE.SUBMISSION_CONTRACT_MISMATCH, "binding");
+	assert.equal(readLog(fixture.logPath).length, 0);
+	assert.equal(readLog(fixture.piLogPath).length, 0);
+});
+
+test("resolveReviewHostRelaySubmission returns the provider binding untouched", () => {
+	const binding = resolveReviewHostRelaySubmission(SUBMISSION);
+	assert.equal(binding.operationToken, "capture-result");
+	assert.deepEqual(binding.argumentTokens, SUBMISSION.argumentTokens);
+	assert.equal(binding.substitutionLocation, BINDING_TOKENS.length);
+	assert.throws(() => resolveReviewHostRelaySubmission(undefined), (error: unknown) =>
+		error instanceof ReviewHostRelayError && error.kind === REVIEW_HOST_RELAY_FAILURE.SUBMISSION_CONTRACT_MISMATCH && error.message === REVIEW_HOST_RELAY_SUBMISSION_MISSING_MESSAGE);
+});
+
+test("the negotiated decoder carries the provider submission through the capture-result collect input", () => {
+	const lineageId = "review-1d5aadacc600e167";
+	const sha = `sha256:${"c".repeat(64)}`;
+	const tree = "3".repeat(40);
+	const rawSubmission = {
+		operation_token: "capture-result",
+		argument_tokens: [...BINDING_TOKENS, "--input={{value}}"],
+		values: [{ slot: "reviewer_result", domain: "artifact_path_or_stdin", substitution_location: BINDING_TOKENS.length }],
+	};
+	const rawInput = {
+		name: "reviewer_result",
+		schema: "https://gentle-ai.dev/schema/review/reviewer/v1",
+		capture_operation: "review.capture-result",
+		arguments: [
+			{ name: "lineage", value: lineageId, token: `--lineage=${lineageId}` },
+			{ name: "agent", value: "pi", token: "--agent=pi" },
+			{ name: "materialize", value: "true", token: "--materialize=true" },
+		],
+		artifact_subject: {
+			schema: "gentle-ai.review-artifact-subject/v2",
+			subject_hash: sha,
+			lineage_id: lineageId,
+			authority_revision: sha,
+			target_identity: sha,
+			base_tree: tree,
+			candidate_tree: tree,
+			changed_path_manifest_sha256: sha,
+			lens: "review-reliability",
+			selected_order: 0,
+		},
+		base_tree: tree,
+		candidate_tree: tree,
+		changed_path_manifest: [{ path: "app.ts", status: "M", old_mode: "100644", new_mode: "100644", deleted: false, type_changed: false, mode_only: false, intended_untracked: false }],
+		submission: rawSubmission,
+	};
+	const decoded = decodeReviewNextTransitionV3({ kind: "collect", reason_code: "reviewer_results_required", collect: { inputs: [rawInput] } });
+	assert.equal(decoded.collect!.inputs[0]!.submission!.operationToken, "capture-result");
+	assert.deepEqual(decoded.collect!.inputs[0]!.submission!.argumentTokens, rawSubmission.argument_tokens);
+	assert.deepEqual(decoded.collect!.inputs[0]!.submission!.values, [{ slot: "reviewer_result", domain: "artifact_path_or_stdin", substitutionLocation: BINDING_TOKENS.length }]);
+
+	// Strict rejections: submission outside capture-result, and a
+	// substitution location outside its own argument tokens.
+	assert.throws(() => decodeReviewNextTransitionV3({ kind: "collect", reason_code: "verification_evidence_required", collect: { inputs: [{
+		name: "verification_evidence",
+		schema: "gentle-ai.review-verification-evidence/v2",
+		capture_operation: "review.capture-evidence",
+		arguments: [{ name: "lineage", value: lineageId }],
+		submission: rawSubmission,
+	}] } }), /submission is only valid for review\.capture-result/);
+	assert.throws(() => decodeReviewNextTransitionV3({ kind: "collect", reason_code: "reviewer_results_required", collect: { inputs: [{
+		...rawInput,
+		submission: { ...rawSubmission, values: [{ slot: "reviewer_result", domain: "artifact_path_or_stdin", substitution_location: rawSubmission.argument_tokens.length }] },
+	}] } }), /substitution_location/);
+});