cool-workflow 0.1.98 → 0.2.0

package/dist/{multi-agent-operator-ux.js → shell/multi-agent-operator-ux.js}

@@ -1,25 +1,95 @@
 "use strict";
-var __importDefault = (this && this.__importDefault) || function (mod) {
-    return (mod && mod.__esModule) ? mod : { "default": mod };
-};
+// shell/multi-agent-operator-ux.ts — the "Multi-Agent Operator UX" family
+// (v0.1.21 + v0.1.27): the dependency / failure / evidence panels that the
+// `multi-agent status|dependencies|failures|evidence` surfaces render.
+//
+// GAP #17. Port of the old build's src/multi-agent-operator-ux.ts data layer
+// (summarizeMultiAgentOperator + deriveDependencies/deriveFailures/
+// deriveEvidence + the three text formatters + graph). Byte-behavior
+// preserved; adapted to v2's core/shell split:
+//   - StateEvidence lives in core/state/types;
+//   - CandidateScore lives in core/multi-agent/candidate-scoring;
+//   - scores are read from disk the same way candidate-scoring-io.ts's
+//     private readScores does (there is no validateCandidateScore in v2 —
+//     the on-disk record is trusted, matching the io reader).
+//
+// Evidence: SPEC/multi-agent.md "Multi-Agent Operator UX";
+// plugins/cool-workflow/src/multi-agent-operator-ux.ts (byte-exact source).
+var __createBinding = (this && this.__createBinding) || (Object.create ? (function(o, m, k, k2) {
+    if (k2 === undefined) k2 = k;
+    var desc = Object.getOwnPropertyDescriptor(m, k);
+    if (!desc || ("get" in desc ? !m.__esModule : desc.writable || desc.configurable)) {
+      desc = { enumerable: true, get: function() { return m[k]; } };
+    }
+    Object.defineProperty(o, k2, desc);
+}) : (function(o, m, k, k2) {
+    if (k2 === undefined) k2 = k;
+    o[k2] = m[k];
+}));
+var __setModuleDefault = (this && this.__setModuleDefault) || (Object.create ? (function(o, v) {
+    Object.defineProperty(o, "default", { enumerable: true, value: v });
+}) : function(o, v) {
+    o["default"] = v;
+});
+var __importStar = (this && this.__importStar) || (function () {
+    var ownKeys = function(o) {
+        ownKeys = Object.getOwnPropertyNames || function (o) {
+            var ar = [];
+            for (var k in o) if (Object.prototype.hasOwnProperty.call(o, k)) ar[ar.length] = k;
+            return ar;
+        };
+        return ownKeys(o);
+    };
+    return function (mod) {
+        if (mod && mod.__esModule) return mod;
+        var result = {};
+        if (mod != null) for (var k = ownKeys(mod), i = 0; i < k.length; i++) if (k[i] !== "default") __createBinding(result, mod, k[i]);
+        __setModuleDefault(result, mod);
+        return result;
+    };
+})();
 Object.defineProperty(exports, "__esModule", { value: true });
 exports.summarizeMultiAgentOperator = summarizeMultiAgentOperator;
+exports.operatorDigestInput = operatorDigestInput;
 exports.buildMultiAgentOperatorGraph = buildMultiAgentOperatorGraph;
 exports.formatMultiAgentOperatorStatus = formatMultiAgentOperatorStatus;
 exports.formatMultiAgentDependencies = formatMultiAgentDependencies;
 exports.formatMultiAgentFailures = formatMultiAgentFailures;
 exports.formatMultiAgentEvidence = formatMultiAgentEvidence;
-const node_fs_1 = __importDefault(require("node:fs"));
-const node_path_1 = __importDefault(require("node:path"));
-const coordinator_1 = require("./coordinator");
-const multi_agent_1 = require("./multi-agent");
-const topology_1 = require("./topology");
+const fs = __importStar(require("node:fs"));
+const path = __importStar(require("node:path"));
+const coordinator_io_1 = require("./coordinator-io");
+const multi_agent_io_1 = require("./multi-agent-io");
+const topology_io_1 = require("./topology-io");
 const trust_audit_1 = require("./trust-audit");
-const validation_1 = require("./validation");
+function maOf(run) {
+    return run.multiAgent || {};
+}
+function candidatesOf(run) {
+    return (run.candidates || []);
+}
+function selectionsOf(run) {
+    return (run.candidateSelections || []);
+}
+function commitsOf(run) {
+    return (run.commits || []);
+}
+function workersOf(run) {
+    return (run.workers || []);
+}
+function feedbackOf(run) {
+    return (run.feedback || []);
+}
+function topologyRunsOf(run) {
+    return (run.topologies?.runs || []);
+}
+function blackboardOf(run) {
+    return (run.blackboard || {});
+}
 function summarizeMultiAgentOperator(run) {
-    const topologies = (0, topology_1.summarizeTopologies)(run);
-    const multiAgent = (0, multi_agent_1.summarizeMultiAgent)(run);
-    const blackboard = (0, coordinator_1.summarizeBlackboard)(run);
+    const topologies = (0, topology_io_1.summarizeTopologies)(run);
+    const multiAgent = (0, multi_agent_io_1.summarizeMultiAgent)(run);
+    const blackboard = (0, coordinator_io_1.summarizeBlackboard)(run);
     const trust = (0, trust_audit_1.summarizeTrustAudit)(run);
     const dependencies = deriveDependencies(run);
     const failures = deriveFailures(run, dependencies);
@@ -29,7 +99,7 @@ function summarizeMultiAgentOperator(run) {
     const inspectableEvidence = missingEvidence.filter((entry) => entry.disposition === "inspectable");
     const activeTopologyIds = new Set(topologies.active.map((entry) => entry.id));
     const activeMultiAgentRunIds = new Set(topologies.active.map((entry) => entry.multiAgentRunId));
-    const state = run.multiAgent;
+    const state = maOf(run);
     const nextAction = failures[0]?.nextCommand ||
         topologies.nextAction ||
         multiAgent.nextAction ||
@@ -39,14 +109,14 @@ function summarizeMultiAgentOperator(run) {
     return {
         schemaVersion: 1,
         runId: run.id,
-        activeMultiAgentRunIds: [...activeMultiAgentRunIds, ...((state?.runs || []).filter((entry) => !isTerminal(entry.status)).map((entry) => entry.id))].filter(uniqueFilter),
+        activeMultiAgentRunIds: [...activeMultiAgentRunIds, ...((state.runs || []).filter((entry) => !isTerminal(entry.status)).map((entry) => entry.id))].filter(uniqueFilter),
         topologyRunIds: [...activeTopologyIds],
         topologyIds: topologies.active.map((entry) => entry.topologyId).filter(uniqueFilter),
-        groups: (state?.groups || []).map((entry) => entry.id).sort(),
-        roles: (state?.roles || []).map((entry) => entry.id).sort(),
-        memberships: (state?.memberships || []).map((entry) => entry.id).sort(),
-        fanouts: (state?.fanouts || []).map((entry) => entry.id).sort(),
-        fanins: (state?.fanins || []).map((entry) => entry.id).sort(),
+        groups: (state.groups || []).map((entry) => entry.id).sort(),
+        roles: (state.roles || []).map((entry) => entry.id).sort(),
+        memberships: (state.memberships || []).map((entry) => entry.id).sort(),
+        fanouts: (state.fanouts || []).map((entry) => entry.id).sort(),
+        fanins: (state.fanins || []).map((entry) => entry.id).sort(),
         blocked: failures.length > 0,
         dependencies,
         failures,
@@ -55,87 +125,60 @@ function summarizeMultiAgentOperator(run) {
         adoptedEvidence,
         inspectableEvidence,
         nextAction,
-        summaries: { topologies, multiAgent, blackboard, trust }
+        summaries: { topologies, multiAgent, blackboard, trust },
+    };
+}
+/** Adapt the operator status into the structural input `buildOperatorDigest`
+ *  (core) folds into the state-explosion digest — the shell-side bridge that
+ *  lets core stay free of `summarizeMultiAgentOperator`. */
+function operatorDigestInput(run) {
+    const status = summarizeMultiAgentOperator(run);
+    return {
+        failures: status.failures.map((f) => ({ id: f.id, kind: f.kind, status: f.status, reason: f.reason, nextCommand: f.nextCommand })),
+        evidence: status.evidence.map((e) => ({ id: e.id, ref: e.ref, status: e.status, sourceId: e.sourceId })),
+        nextAction: status.nextAction,
+        trustEvents: status.summaries.trust?.eventCount || 0,
     };
 }
 function buildMultiAgentOperatorGraph(run) {
     const nodes = new Map();
     const edges = [];
-    const addNode = (id, kind, status, label, pathValue) => {
+    const addNode = (id, kind, status, label, filePath) => {
         if (!id)
             return;
-        nodes.set(id, { id, kind, status, label, path: pathValue });
-    };
-    const addEdge = (from, to, label) => {
-        if (!from || !to)
-            return;
-        edges.push({ from, to, label });
-    };
-    addNode(`${run.id}:run`, "multi-agent-run-root", run.loopStage, run.id, run.paths.state);
-    for (const graph of [(0, topology_1.buildTopologyGraph)(run), (0, multi_agent_1.buildMultiAgentGraph)(run), (0, coordinator_1.buildBlackboardGraph)(run)]) {
-        for (const node of graph.nodes)
-            addNode(node.id, node.kind, node.status, node.label, node.path);
-        for (const edge of graph.edges)
-            addEdge(edge.from, edge.to, relabel(edge.label));
-    }
-    for (const task of run.tasks || []) {
-        addNode(`${run.id}:task:${task.id}`, "task", task.status, task.id, task.taskPath);
-        addEdge(`${run.id}:run`, `${run.id}:task:${task.id}`, "owns");
-        addEdge(`${run.id}:task:${task.id}`, task.dispatchId ? `${run.id}:dispatch:${task.dispatchId}` : undefined, "dispatches");
-        addEdge(`${run.id}:task:${task.id}`, task.resultNodeId, "reports");
-        addEdge(`${run.id}:task:${task.id}`, task.verifierNodeId, "gates");
-    }
-    for (const dispatch of run.dispatches || []) {
-        addNode(`${run.id}:dispatch:${dispatch.id}`, "dispatch", "completed", dispatch.id, dispatch.manifestPath);
-        for (const workerId of dispatch.workerIds || [])
-            addEdge(`${run.id}:dispatch:${dispatch.id}`, `${run.id}:worker:${workerId}`, "dispatches");
-    }
-    for (const worker of run.workers || []) {
-        addNode(`${run.id}:worker:${worker.id}`, "worker", worker.status, worker.id, worker.inputPath);
-        addEdge(`${run.id}:worker:${worker.id}`, worker.resultNodeId, "reports");
-        addEdge(`${run.id}:worker:${worker.id}`, worker.output?.verifierNodeId, "gates");
-        for (const feedbackId of worker.feedbackIds || [])
-            addEdge(`${run.id}:worker:${worker.id}`, `${run.id}:feedback:${feedbackId}`, "blocks");
-    }
-    for (const candidate of run.candidates || []) {
-        const candidateId = `${run.id}:candidate:${candidate.id}`;
-        addNode(candidateId, "candidate", candidate.status, candidate.id, candidate.resultPath);
-        addEdge(candidate.workerId ? `${run.id}:worker:${candidate.workerId}` : candidate.resultNodeId, candidateId, "reports");
-        addEdge(candidate.verifierNodeId, candidateId, "gates");
-        for (const scoreId of candidate.scores || []) {
-            const nodeId = `${run.id}:score:${scoreId}`;
-            addNode(nodeId, "score", "completed", scoreId, scorePath(run, candidate.id, scoreId));
-            addEdge(candidateId, nodeId, "scores");
-        }
-        for (const feedbackId of candidate.feedbackIds || [])
-            addEdge(candidateId, `${run.id}:feedback:${feedbackId}`, "blocks");
-    }
-    for (const selection of run.candidateSelections || []) {
-        const nodeId = `${run.id}:selection:${selection.id}`;
-        addNode(nodeId, "selection", "accepted", selection.id, selection.rankingPath);
-        addEdge(`${run.id}:candidate:${selection.candidateId}`, nodeId, "selects");
-        if (selection.scoreId)
-            addEdge(`${run.id}:score:${selection.scoreId}`, nodeId, "selects");
-        addEdge(selection.verifierNodeId, nodeId, "gates");
-    }
-    for (const commit of run.commits || []) {
-        const nodeId = commit.stateNodeId || `${run.id}:commit:${commit.id}`;
-        addNode(nodeId, "commit", commit.verifierGated ? "committed" : "checkpoint", commit.id, commit.snapshotPath);
-        addEdge(commit.selectionId ? `${run.id}:selection:${commit.selectionId}` : undefined, nodeId, "commits");
-        addEdge(commit.verifierNodeId, nodeId, "gates");
-    }
-    for (const feedback of run.feedback || []) {
-        addNode(`${run.id}:feedback:${feedback.id}`, "feedback", feedback.status, `${feedback.severity} ${feedback.classification}`);
-        addEdge(feedback.nodeId, `${run.id}:feedback:${feedback.id}`, "blocks");
-        addEdge(feedback.taskId ? `${run.id}:task:${feedback.taskId}` : undefined, `${run.id}:feedback:${feedback.id}`, "blocks");
-    }
-    for (const dep of deriveDependencies(run))
-        addEdge(dep.from, dep.to, dep.label);
-    return {
-        runId: run.id,
-        nodes: [...nodes.values()].sort((left, right) => left.kind.localeCompare(right.kind) || left.id.localeCompare(right.id)),
-        edges: uniqueEdges(edges).sort((left, right) => left.from.localeCompare(right.from) || left.to.localeCompare(right.to) || (left.label || "").localeCompare(right.label || ""))
+        if (!nodes.has(id))
+            nodes.set(id, { id, kind, status, label, path: filePath });
     };
+    const state = maOf(run);
+    for (const topology of topologyRunsOf(run)) {
+        const id = String(topology.id);
+        addNode(`${run.id}:topology:${id}`, "topology-run", String(topology.status), `topology ${topology.topologyId}`);
+    }
+    for (const group of state.groups || [])
+        addNode(`${run.id}:multi-agent:group:${group.id}`, "agent-group", "running", `group ${group.id}`);
+    for (const role of state.roles || [])
+        addNode(`${run.id}:multi-agent:role:${role.id}`, "agent-role", role.status, `role ${role.id}`);
+    for (const membership of state.memberships || [])
+        addNode(`${run.id}:multi-agent:membership:${membership.id}`, "agent-membership", membership.status, `membership ${membership.id}`);
+    for (const fanout of state.fanouts || [])
+        addNode(`${run.id}:multi-agent:fanout:${fanout.id}`, "agent-fanout", "running", `fanout ${fanout.id}`);
+    for (const fanin of state.fanins || [])
+        addNode(`${run.id}:multi-agent:fanin:${fanin.id}`, "agent-fanin", fanin.status, `fanin ${fanin.id}`);
+    for (const candidate of candidatesOf(run))
+        addNode(`${run.id}:candidate:${candidate.id}`, "candidate", String(candidate.status), `candidate ${candidate.id}`);
+    for (const candidate of candidatesOf(run))
+        for (const scoreId of candidate.scores || [])
+            addNode(`${run.id}:score:${scoreId}`, "score", "completed", `score ${scoreId}`);
+    for (const selection of selectionsOf(run))
+        addNode(`${run.id}:selection:${selection.id}`, "selection", "accepted", `selection ${selection.id}`);
+    for (const commit of commitsOf(run))
+        addNode(String(commit.stateNodeId || `${run.id}:commit:${commit.id}`), "commit", commit.verifierGated ? "committed" : "checkpoint", `commit ${commit.id}`);
+    for (const artifact of blackboardOf(run).artifacts || [])
+        addNode(`${run.id}:blackboard:artifact:${artifact.id}`, "blackboard-artifact", String(artifact.status || "pending"), `artifact ${artifact.id}`, artifact.path);
+    for (const dependency of deriveDependencies(run)) {
+        edges.push({ from: dependency.from, to: dependency.to, label: relabel(dependency.label) });
+    }
+    return { runId: run.id, nodes: [...nodes.values()], edges: uniqueEdges(edges) };
 }
 function formatMultiAgentOperatorStatus(status) {
     return [
@@ -158,7 +201,7 @@ function formatMultiAgentOperatorStatus(status) {
             : "Missing Evidence", status.missingEvidence),
         "",
         "Next Action",
-        `  ${status.nextAction}`
+        `  ${status.nextAction}`,
     ].join("\n");
 }
 function formatMultiAgentDependencies(rows) {
@@ -177,32 +220,33 @@ function deriveDependencies(run) {
             return;
         rows.push({ id: `${from}->${to}:${label}`, from, to, label, status, reason, nextCommand });
     };
-    const state = run.multiAgent;
-    for (const topology of run.topologies?.runs || []) {
-        add(`${run.id}:topology:${topology.id}`, `${run.id}:multi-agent:${topology.multiAgentRunId}`, "owns");
-        add(`${run.id}:topology:${topology.id}`, `${run.id}:blackboard:${topology.blackboardId}`, "owns");
-        for (const fanoutId of topology.fanoutIds)
-            add(`${run.id}:topology:${topology.id}`, `${run.id}:multi-agent:fanout:${fanoutId}`, "fanout");
-        for (const faninId of topology.faninIds)
-            add(`${run.id}:multi-agent:fanin:${faninId}`, `${run.id}:topology:${topology.id}`, "reports");
-        for (const candidateId of topology.candidateIds)
-            add(`${run.id}:topology:${topology.id}`, `${run.id}:candidate:${candidateId}`, "candidate");
-        for (const selectionId of topology.selectionIds)
-            add(`${run.id}:selection:${selectionId}`, `${run.id}:topology:${topology.id}`, "selects");
-    }
-    for (const group of state?.groups || []) {
+    const state = maOf(run);
+    for (const topology of topologyRunsOf(run)) {
+        const id = String(topology.id);
+        add(`${run.id}:topology:${id}`, `${run.id}:multi-agent:${topology.multiAgentRunId}`, "owns");
+        add(`${run.id}:topology:${id}`, `${run.id}:blackboard:${topology.blackboardId}`, "owns");
+        for (const fanoutId of topology.fanoutIds || [])
+            add(`${run.id}:topology:${id}`, `${run.id}:multi-agent:fanout:${fanoutId}`, "fanout");
+        for (const faninId of topology.faninIds || [])
+            add(`${run.id}:multi-agent:fanin:${faninId}`, `${run.id}:topology:${id}`, "reports");
+        for (const candidateId of topology.candidateIds || [])
+            add(`${run.id}:topology:${id}`, `${run.id}:candidate:${candidateId}`, "candidate");
+        for (const selectionId of topology.selectionIds || [])
+            add(`${run.id}:selection:${selectionId}`, `${run.id}:topology:${id}`, "selects");
+    }
+    for (const group of state.groups || []) {
         add(`${run.id}:multi-agent:${group.multiAgentRunId}`, `${run.id}:multi-agent:group:${group.id}`, "owns");
-        for (const taskId of group.taskIds)
+        for (const taskId of group.taskIds || [])
             add(`${run.id}:multi-agent:group:${group.id}`, `${run.id}:task:${taskId}`, "depends-on");
     }
-    for (const fanout of state?.fanouts || []) {
+    for (const fanout of state.fanouts || []) {
         add(`${run.id}:multi-agent:group:${fanout.groupId}`, `${run.id}:multi-agent:fanout:${fanout.id}`, "fanout");
-        for (const roleId of fanout.roleIds)
+        for (const roleId of fanout.roleIds || [])
             add(`${run.id}:multi-agent:fanout:${fanout.id}`, `${run.id}:multi-agent:role:${roleId}`, "depends-on");
-        for (const dispatchId of fanout.dispatchIds)
+        for (const dispatchId of fanout.dispatchIds || [])
             add(`${run.id}:multi-agent:fanout:${fanout.id}`, `${run.id}:dispatch:${dispatchId}`, "dispatches");
     }
-    for (const membership of state?.memberships || []) {
+    for (const membership of state.memberships || []) {
         add(`${run.id}:multi-agent:role:${membership.roleId}`, `${run.id}:multi-agent:membership:${membership.id}`, "owns");
         add(`${run.id}:multi-agent:membership:${membership.id}`, `${run.id}:task:${membership.taskId}`, "depends-on");
         add(`${run.id}:multi-agent:membership:${membership.id}`, membership.workerId ? `${run.id}:worker:${membership.workerId}` : undefined, "dispatches");
@@ -213,23 +257,23 @@ function deriveDependencies(run) {
         for (const messageId of membership.blackboardMessageIds || [])
             add(`${run.id}:blackboard:message:${messageId}`, `${run.id}:multi-agent:membership:${membership.id}`, "cites");
     }
-    for (const fanin of state?.fanins || []) {
+    for (const fanin of state.fanins || []) {
         add(fanin.fanoutId ? `${run.id}:multi-agent:fanout:${fanin.fanoutId}` : `${run.id}:multi-agent:group:${fanin.groupId}`, `${run.id}:multi-agent:fanin:${fanin.id}`, "fanin");
-        for (const coverage of fanin.evidenceCoverage) {
+        for (const coverage of fanin.evidenceCoverage || []) {
             add(`${run.id}:multi-agent:membership:${coverage.membershipId}`, `${run.id}:multi-agent:fanin:${fanin.id}`, coverage.complete ? "adopted-by" : "blocks", coverage.complete ? "ready" : "blocked", coverage.complete ? undefined : "membership has not reported required evidence", `node scripts/cw.js worker manifest ${run.id} ${coverage.workerId || "<worker-id>"}`);
         }
     }
-    for (const candidate of run.candidates || []) {
-        add(candidate.workerId ? `${run.id}:worker:${candidate.workerId}` : candidate.resultNodeId, `${run.id}:candidate:${candidate.id}`, "reports", candidate.status);
+    for (const candidate of candidatesOf(run)) {
+        add(candidate.workerId ? `${run.id}:worker:${candidate.workerId}` : candidate.resultNodeId, `${run.id}:candidate:${candidate.id}`, "reports", String(candidate.status));
         for (const scoreId of candidate.scores || [])
             add(`${run.id}:candidate:${candidate.id}`, `${run.id}:score:${scoreId}`, "scores", "completed");
     }
-    for (const selection of run.candidateSelections || []) {
+    for (const selection of selectionsOf(run)) {
         add(`${run.id}:candidate:${selection.candidateId}`, `${run.id}:selection:${selection.id}`, "selects", "accepted");
         add(selection.scoreId ? `${run.id}:score:${selection.scoreId}` : undefined, `${run.id}:selection:${selection.id}`, "scores", "accepted");
     }
-    for (const commit of run.commits || []) {
-        add(commit.selectionId ? `${run.id}:selection:${commit.selectionId}` : undefined, commit.stateNodeId || `${run.id}:commit:${commit.id}`, "commits", commit.verifierGated ? "committed" : "checkpoint");
+    for (const commit of commitsOf(run)) {
+        add(commit.selectionId ? `${run.id}:selection:${commit.selectionId}` : undefined, String(commit.stateNodeId || `${run.id}:commit:${commit.id}`), "commits", commit.verifierGated ? "committed" : "checkpoint");
     }
     return rows.filter(uniqueById).sort((left, right) => left.from.localeCompare(right.from) || left.to.localeCompare(right.to));
 }
@@ -238,60 +282,61 @@ function deriveFailures(run, dependencies) {
     const add = (id, kind, status, reason, nextCommand, owner, linked) => {
         rows.push({ id, kind, status, owner, linked, reason, nextCommand });
     };
-    const state = run.multiAgent;
-    for (const role of state?.roles || []) {
-        const memberships = (state?.memberships || []).filter((entry) => entry.roleId === role.id);
+    const state = maOf(run);
+    for (const role of state.roles || []) {
+        const memberships = (state.memberships || []).filter((entry) => entry.roleId === role.id);
         if (!memberships.length && role.status !== "completed" && role.status !== "cancelled") {
             add(role.id, "missing-role-coverage", role.status, `role ${role.id} has no membership`, `node scripts/cw.js multi-agent step ${run.id}`, role.id);
         }
         if (role.status === "blocked" || role.status === "cancelled")
             add(role.id, "agent-role", role.status, `role ${role.id} is ${role.status}`, `node scripts/cw.js multi-agent status ${run.id} --json`, role.id);
     }
-    for (const membership of state?.memberships || []) {
-        const worker = membership.workerId ? (run.workers || []).find((entry) => entry.id === membership.workerId) : undefined;
+    for (const membership of state.memberships || []) {
+        const worker = membership.workerId ? workersOf(run).find((entry) => entry.id === membership.workerId) : undefined;
         if (membership.status === "failed" || membership.status === "cancelled")
             add(membership.id, "agent-membership", membership.status, `membership ${membership.id} is ${membership.status}`, `node scripts/cw.js multi-agent membership ${run.id} ${membership.id}`, membership.roleId, membership.workerId);
         if (!membership.workerId)
             add(membership.id, "missing-worker", membership.status, `membership ${membership.id} has no worker`, `node scripts/cw.js multi-agent step ${run.id}`, membership.roleId, membership.taskId);
         if (worker && (worker.status === "failed" || worker.status === "rejected"))
-            add(worker.id, "worker", worker.status, worker.errors[0]?.message || `worker ${worker.id} is ${worker.status}`, `node scripts/cw.js worker show ${run.id} ${worker.id}`, membership.roleId, membership.id);
+            add(String(worker.id), "worker", String(worker.status), worker.errors?.[0]?.message || `worker ${worker.id} is ${worker.status}`, `node scripts/cw.js worker show ${run.id} ${worker.id}`, membership.roleId, membership.id);
         if (worker && (worker.status === "allocated" || worker.status === "running"))
-            add(worker.id, "worker-output", worker.status, `worker ${worker.id} has not reported output`, `node scripts/cw.js worker manifest ${run.id} ${worker.id}`, membership.roleId, membership.id);
+            add(String(worker.id), "worker-output", String(worker.status), `worker ${worker.id} has not reported output`, `node scripts/cw.js worker manifest ${run.id} ${worker.id}`, membership.roleId, membership.id);
     }
-    for (const fanin of state?.fanins || []) {
-        for (const reason of fanin.blockedReasons)
+    for (const fanin of state.fanins || []) {
+        for (const reason of fanin.blockedReasons || [])
             add(fanin.id, "fanin", fanin.status, reason, `node scripts/cw.js multi-agent failures ${run.id}`, fanin.groupId, fanin.fanoutId);
-        for (const roleId of fanin.missingRoleIds)
+        for (const roleId of fanin.missingRoleIds || [])
             add(`${fanin.id}:${roleId}`, "missing-role-evidence", "missing", `fanin ${fanin.id} is missing role ${roleId}`, `node scripts/cw.js multi-agent step ${run.id}`, roleId, fanin.id);
-        for (const membershipId of fanin.missingMembershipIds)
+        for (const membershipId of fanin.missingMembershipIds || [])
             add(`${fanin.id}:${membershipId}`, "missing-membership-evidence", "missing", `fanin ${fanin.id} is missing membership ${membershipId}`, `node scripts/cw.js multi-agent membership ${run.id} ${membershipId}`, membershipId, fanin.id);
     }
-    for (const topology of run.topologies?.runs || []) {
+    for (const topology of topologyRunsOf(run)) {
         for (const missing of topology.missingEvidence || [])
-            add(`${topology.id}:${missing}`, "missing-topology-evidence", "missing", missing, topology.nextActions[0] || `node scripts/cw.js topology summary ${run.id}`, topology.id);
+            add(`${topology.id}:${missing}`, "missing-topology-evidence", "missing", missing, topology.nextActions?.[0] || `node scripts/cw.js topology summary ${run.id}`, String(topology.id));
         if (topology.status === "blocked" || topology.status === "failed")
-            add(topology.id, "topology", topology.status, `topology ${topology.id} is ${topology.status}`, `node scripts/cw.js topology summary ${run.id}`, topology.id);
+            add(String(topology.id), "topology", String(topology.status), `topology ${topology.id} is ${topology.status}`, `node scripts/cw.js topology summary ${run.id}`, String(topology.id));
     }
-    for (const feedback of run.feedback || []) {
+    for (const feedback of feedbackOf(run)) {
         if (feedback.status === "open" || feedback.status === "tasked")
-            add(feedback.id, feedback.classification, feedback.status, feedback.message, `node scripts/cw.js feedback show ${run.id} ${feedback.id}`, feedback.taskId, feedback.nodeId);
+            add(String(feedback.id), String(feedback.classification), String(feedback.status), String(feedback.message), `node scripts/cw.js feedback show ${run.id} ${feedback.id}`, feedback.taskId, feedback.nodeId);
     }
-    for (const candidate of run.candidates || []) {
+    for (const candidate of candidatesOf(run)) {
+        const scores = candidate.scores || [];
         if (candidate.status === "rejected" || candidate.status === "failed")
-            add(candidate.id, "candidate", candidate.status, candidate.feedbackIds[0] || `candidate ${candidate.id} is ${candidate.status}`, `node scripts/cw.js candidate show ${run.id} ${candidate.id}`, candidate.workerId, candidate.taskId);
-        if (!candidate.scores.length && candidate.status !== "rejected" && candidate.status !== "failed")
-            add(candidate.id, "candidate-score-gap", candidate.status, `candidate ${candidate.id} has no score`, `node scripts/cw.js multi-agent score ${run.id} --candidate ${candidate.id} --evidence <path-or-ref>`, candidate.workerId, candidate.taskId);
+            add(String(candidate.id), "candidate", String(candidate.status), candidate.feedbackIds?.[0] || `candidate ${candidate.id} is ${candidate.status}`, `node scripts/cw.js candidate show ${run.id} ${candidate.id}`, candidate.workerId, candidate.taskId);
+        if (!scores.length && candidate.status !== "rejected" && candidate.status !== "failed")
+            add(String(candidate.id), "candidate-score-gap", String(candidate.status), `candidate ${candidate.id} has no score`, `node scripts/cw.js multi-agent score ${run.id} --candidate ${candidate.id} --evidence <path-or-ref>`, candidate.workerId, candidate.taskId);
         if (!candidate.verifierNodeId)
-            add(`${candidate.id}:verifier`, "candidate-verifier-gap", candidate.status, `candidate ${candidate.id} has no verifier gate`, `node scripts/cw.js candidate show ${run.id} ${candidate.id}`, candidate.workerId, candidate.taskId);
+            add(`${candidate.id}:verifier`, "candidate-verifier-gap", String(candidate.status), `candidate ${candidate.id} has no verifier gate`, `node scripts/cw.js candidate show ${run.id} ${candidate.id}`, candidate.workerId, candidate.taskId);
     }
-    if ((run.candidates || []).some((candidate) => candidate.scores.length) && !(run.candidateSelections || []).length) {
+    if (candidatesOf(run).some((candidate) => (candidate.scores || []).length) && !selectionsOf(run).length) {
         add("selection-gap", "selection", "missing", "scored candidates exist but no selection is recorded", `node scripts/cw.js multi-agent select ${run.id} --candidate <candidate-id> --reason "<rationale>"`);
     }
     for (const dep of dependencies.filter((entry) => entry.status === "blocked"))
         add(dep.id, "ambiguous-dependency", dep.status, dep.reason || "dependency is blocked", dep.nextCommand || `node scripts/cw.js multi-agent status ${run.id} --json`);
-    const readySelection = (run.candidateSelections || []).find((selection) => !(run.commits || []).some((commit) => commit.selectionId === selection.id && commit.verifierGated));
+    const readySelection = selectionsOf(run).find((selection) => !commitsOf(run).some((commit) => commit.selectionId === selection.id && commit.verifierGated));
     if (readySelection)
-        add(readySelection.id, "commit-gate", "not-ready", `selection ${readySelection.id} has no verifier-gated commit`, `node scripts/cw.js commit ${run.id} --selection ${readySelection.id} --reason "<verified rationale>"`, readySelection.candidateId);
+        add(String(readySelection.id), "commit-gate", "not-ready", `selection ${readySelection.id} has no verifier-gated commit`, `node scripts/cw.js commit ${run.id} --selection ${readySelection.id} --reason "<verified rationale>"`, readySelection.candidateId);
     return rows.filter(uniqueByFailure).sort((left, right) => left.kind.localeCompare(right.kind) || left.id.localeCompare(right.id));
 }
 function deriveEvidence(run) {
@@ -308,7 +353,7 @@ function deriveEvidence(run) {
             scoreIds: [],
             selectionIds: [],
             commitIds: [],
-            status: "pending"
+            status: "pending",
         };
         Object.assign(next, patch);
         next.adoptedBy = unique([...(next.adoptedBy || []), ...(patch.adoptedBy || [])]);
@@ -329,17 +374,18 @@ function deriveEvidence(run) {
                 path: item.path,
                 locator: item.locator,
                 provenanceSource: item.provenance?.source,
-                sourceId: item.provenance?.workerId || item.provenance?.candidateId || item.provenance?.selectionId || item.provenance?.commitId || patch.sourceId,
+                sourceId: provenanceSourceId(item) || patch.sourceId,
                 sourceKind: sourceKindFromEvidence(item, patch.sourceKind),
-                ...patch
+                ...patch,
             });
         }
     };
-    for (const worker of run.workers || []) {
-        if (worker.output?.resultPath)
-            ensure(worker.output.resultPath, { path: worker.output.resultPath, sourceKind: "worker", sourceId: worker.id, status: worker.status === "verified" ? "adopted" : "pending", adoptedBy: worker.status === "verified" ? [worker.id] : [], pendingConsumers: worker.status === "verified" ? [] : [worker.id] });
+    for (const worker of workersOf(run)) {
+        const output = worker.output;
+        if (output?.resultPath)
+            ensure(output.resultPath, { path: output.resultPath, sourceKind: "worker", sourceId: String(worker.id), status: worker.status === "verified" ? "adopted" : "pending", adoptedBy: worker.status === "verified" ? [String(worker.id)] : [], pendingConsumers: worker.status === "verified" ? [] : [String(worker.id)] });
     }
-    for (const membership of run.multiAgent?.memberships || []) {
+    for (const membership of maOf(run).memberships || []) {
         for (const ref of membership.evidenceRefs || [])
             ensure(ref, { ref, sourceKind: "worker", sourceId: membership.workerId || membership.id, status: membership.status === "reported" || membership.status === "verified" ? "adopted" : "pending", adoptedBy: membership.status === "reported" || membership.status === "verified" ? [membership.id] : [], pendingConsumers: membership.status === "reported" || membership.status === "verified" ? [] : [membership.id] });
         for (const artifactId of membership.blackboardArtifactRefIds || [])
@@ -347,56 +393,51 @@ function deriveEvidence(run) {
         for (const messageId of membership.blackboardMessageIds || [])
             ensure(messageId, { ref: messageId, sourceKind: "blackboard", sourceId: membership.id, status: "adopted", adoptedBy: [membership.id] });
     }
-    for (const artifact of run.blackboard?.artifacts || []) {
-        ensure(artifact.id, { ref: artifact.locator || artifact.path || artifact.id, path: artifact.path, locator: artifact.locator, sourceKind: "blackboard", sourceId: artifact.source, provenanceSource: artifact.provenance.auditEventIds?.[0], status: artifact.status === "rejected" ? "rejected" : artifact.status === "superseded" ? "superseded" : artifact.status === "conflicting" ? "conflicting" : "pending" });
+    for (const artifact of blackboardOf(run).artifacts || []) {
+        ensure(String(artifact.id), { ref: artifact.locator || artifact.path || String(artifact.id), path: artifact.path, locator: artifact.locator, sourceKind: "blackboard", sourceId: artifact.source, provenanceSource: artifact.provenance?.auditEventIds?.[0], status: artifact.status === "rejected" ? "rejected" : artifact.status === "superseded" ? "superseded" : artifact.status === "conflicting" ? "conflicting" : "pending" });
         for (const ref of artifact.evidenceRefs || [])
-            ensure(ref, { ref, sourceKind: "blackboard", sourceId: artifact.id, status: "pending", pendingConsumers: [artifact.id] });
+            ensure(ref, { ref, sourceKind: "blackboard", sourceId: String(artifact.id), status: "pending", pendingConsumers: [String(artifact.id)] });
     }
-    for (const message of run.blackboard?.messages || []) {
-        ensure(message.id, { ref: message.id, sourceKind: "blackboard", sourceId: message.author.id, status: message.status === "rejected" ? "rejected" : message.status === "superseded" ? "superseded" : "pending" });
+    for (const message of blackboardOf(run).messages || []) {
+        ensure(String(message.id), { ref: String(message.id), sourceKind: "blackboard", sourceId: message.author?.id, status: message.status === "rejected" ? "rejected" : message.status === "superseded" ? "superseded" : "pending" });
         for (const ref of message.linkedEvidenceRefs || [])
-            ensure(ref, { ref, sourceKind: "blackboard", sourceId: message.id, status: "pending", pendingConsumers: [message.id] });
+            ensure(ref, { ref, sourceKind: "blackboard", sourceId: String(message.id), status: "pending", pendingConsumers: [String(message.id)] });
     }
-    for (const decision of run.blackboard?.decisions || []) {
+    for (const decision of blackboardOf(run).decisions || []) {
         for (const ref of [...(decision.evidenceRefs || []), ...(decision.artifactRefIds || []), ...(decision.messageIds || [])]) {
-            ensure(ref, { ref, sourceKind: "coordinator", sourceId: decision.id, status: evidenceStatusForDecision(decision.outcome), adoptedBy: decision.outcome === "accepted" || decision.outcome === "ready" ? [decision.id] : [], rejectedBy: decision.outcome === "rejected" ? [decision.id] : [] });
+            ensure(ref, { ref, sourceKind: "coordinator", sourceId: String(decision.id), status: evidenceStatusForDecision(String(decision.outcome)), adoptedBy: decision.outcome === "accepted" || decision.outcome === "ready" ? [String(decision.id)] : [], rejectedBy: decision.outcome === "rejected" ? [String(decision.id)] : [] });
         }
     }
-    for (const fanin of run.multiAgent?.fanins || []) {
-        for (const coverage of fanin.evidenceCoverage) {
+    for (const fanin of maOf(run).fanins || []) {
+        for (const coverage of fanin.evidenceCoverage || []) {
             for (const ref of [...coverage.evidenceRefs, ...(coverage.blackboardArtifactRefIds || []), ...(coverage.blackboardMessageIds || [])])
                 ensure(ref, { ref, sourceKind: "worker", sourceId: coverage.workerId || coverage.membershipId, status: coverage.complete && fanin.verifierReady ? "adopted" : "pending", adoptedBy: coverage.complete ? [fanin.id] : [], pendingConsumers: coverage.complete ? [] : [fanin.id] });
         }
-        for (const roleId of fanin.missingRoleIds)
+        for (const roleId of fanin.missingRoleIds || [])
             ensure(`${fanin.id}:missing-role:${roleId}`, { ref: roleId, sourceKind: "runtime", sourceId: fanin.id, status: "missing", pendingConsumers: [fanin.id], reason: `fanin ${fanin.id} requires role ${roleId}` });
-        for (const membershipId of fanin.missingMembershipIds)
+        for (const membershipId of fanin.missingMembershipIds || [])
             ensure(`${fanin.id}:missing-membership:${membershipId}`, { ref: membershipId, sourceKind: "runtime", sourceId: fanin.id, status: "missing", pendingConsumers: [fanin.id], reason: `fanin ${fanin.id} requires membership ${membershipId}` });
     }
-    for (const candidate of run.candidates || []) {
-        addEvidence(candidate.evidence, { status: candidate.status === "rejected" || candidate.status === "failed" ? "rejected" : "pending", sourceKind: "worker", sourceId: candidate.workerId || candidate.id, candidateIds: [candidate.id], rejectedBy: candidate.status === "rejected" || candidate.status === "failed" ? [candidate.id] : [] });
-        for (const score of readScores(run, candidate.id))
-            addEvidence(score.evidence, { status: score.verdict === "fail" ? "rejected" : "adopted", sourceKind: "operator", sourceId: score.scorer, candidateIds: [candidate.id], scoreIds: [score.id], adoptedBy: score.verdict === "fail" ? [] : [score.id], rejectedBy: score.verdict === "fail" ? [score.id] : [] });
+    for (const candidate of candidatesOf(run)) {
+        addEvidence(candidate.evidence || [], { status: candidate.status === "rejected" || candidate.status === "failed" ? "rejected" : "pending", sourceKind: "worker", sourceId: candidate.workerId || String(candidate.id), candidateIds: [String(candidate.id)], rejectedBy: candidate.status === "rejected" || candidate.status === "failed" ? [String(candidate.id)] : [] });
+        for (const score of readScores(run, String(candidate.id)))
+            addEvidence(score.evidence, { status: score.verdict === "fail" ? "rejected" : "adopted", sourceKind: "operator", sourceId: score.scorer, candidateIds: [String(candidate.id)], scoreIds: [score.id], adoptedBy: score.verdict === "fail" ? [] : [score.id], rejectedBy: score.verdict === "fail" ? [score.id] : [] });
     }
-    for (const selection of run.candidateSelections || []) {
-        addEvidence(selection.evidence, { status: "adopted", sourceKind: "verifier", sourceId: selection.verifierNodeId || selection.id, candidateIds: [selection.candidateId], selectionIds: [selection.id], scoreIds: selection.scoreId ? [selection.scoreId] : [], adoptedBy: [selection.id] });
+    for (const selection of selectionsOf(run)) {
+        addEvidence(selection.evidence || [], { status: "adopted", sourceKind: "verifier", sourceId: selection.verifierNodeId || String(selection.id), candidateIds: [String(selection.candidateId)], selectionIds: [String(selection.id)], scoreIds: selection.scoreId ? [String(selection.scoreId)] : [], adoptedBy: [String(selection.id)] });
     }
-    for (const commit of run.commits || []) {
-        addEvidence(commit.evidence || [], { status: commit.verifierGated ? "adopted" : "pending", sourceKind: "runtime", sourceId: commit.id, selectionIds: commit.selectionId ? [commit.selectionId] : [], candidateIds: commit.candidateId ? [commit.candidateId] : [], commitIds: [commit.id], adoptedBy: commit.verifierGated ? [commit.id] : [], pendingConsumers: commit.verifierGated ? [] : [commit.id] });
+    for (const commit of commitsOf(run)) {
+        addEvidence(commit.evidence || [], { status: commit.verifierGated ? "adopted" : "pending", sourceKind: "runtime", sourceId: String(commit.id), selectionIds: commit.selectionId ? [String(commit.selectionId)] : [], candidateIds: commit.candidateId ? [String(commit.candidateId)] : [], commitIds: [String(commit.id)], adoptedBy: commit.verifierGated ? [String(commit.id)] : [], pendingConsumers: commit.verifierGated ? [] : [String(commit.id)] });
     }
-    for (const topology of run.topologies?.runs || []) {
+    for (const topology of topologyRunsOf(run)) {
         for (const missing of topology.missingEvidence || [])
-            ensure(`${topology.id}:missing:${missing}`, { ref: missing, sourceKind: "runtime", sourceId: topology.id, status: "missing", pendingConsumers: [topology.id], reason: missing });
+            ensure(`${topology.id}:missing:${missing}`, { ref: missing, sourceKind: "runtime", sourceId: String(topology.id), status: "missing", pendingConsumers: [String(topology.id)], reason: missing });
     }
-    // Once any verifier-gated commit exists the selected path is decided; rows
-    // that still read missing/pending/conflicting are then inspectable operator
-    // state (e.g. sibling judge-panel roles never driven as separate workers),
-    // not blocking failures. Before a verifier-gated commit, those same rows
-    // genuinely block. `disposition` is the operator-facing reading of `status`.
-    const committed = (run.commits || []).some((commit) => commit.verifierGated);
+    const committed = commitsOf(run).some((commit) => commit.verifierGated);
     const blocks = (status) => status === "missing" || status === "pending" || status === "conflicting";
     const withDisposition = (row) => ({
         ...row,
-        disposition: row.status === "adopted" ? "adopted" : blocks(row.status) && !committed ? "blocking" : "inspectable"
+        disposition: row.status === "adopted" ? "adopted" : blocks(row.status) && !committed ? "blocking" : "inspectable",
     });
     return [...rows.values()]
         .map(normalizeEvidenceStatus)
@@ -441,21 +482,18 @@ function formatEvidence(title, rows) {
     return lines.join("\n");
 }
 function readScores(run, candidateId) {
-    const dir = node_path_1.default.join(run.paths.candidatesDir || node_path_1.default.join(run.paths.runDir, "candidates"), safeFileName(candidateId), "scores");
-    if (!node_fs_1.default.existsSync(dir))
+    const candidatesDir = run.paths.candidatesDir || path.join(run.paths.runDir, "candidates");
+    const dir = path.join(candidatesDir, safeFileName(candidateId), "scores");
+    if (!fs.existsSync(dir))
         return [];
-    return node_fs_1.default
+    return fs
         .readdirSync(dir)
         .filter((file) => file.endsWith(".json"))
         .sort()
-        .map((file) => (0, validation_1.validateCandidateScore)(JSON.parse(node_fs_1.default.readFileSync(node_path_1.default.join(dir, file), "utf8"))));
-}
-function scorePath(run, candidateId, scoreId) {
-    const file = node_path_1.default.join(run.paths.candidatesDir || node_path_1.default.join(run.paths.runDir, "candidates"), safeFileName(candidateId), "scores", `${safeFileName(scoreId)}.json`);
-    return node_fs_1.default.existsSync(file) ? file : undefined;
+        .map((file) => JSON.parse(fs.readFileSync(path.join(dir, file), "utf8")));
 }
 function readyCommitCommand(run) {
-    const selection = (run.candidateSelections || []).find((entry) => !(run.commits || []).some((commit) => commit.selectionId === entry.id && commit.verifierGated));
+    const selection = selectionsOf(run).find((entry) => !commitsOf(run).some((commit) => commit.selectionId === entry.id && commit.verifierGated));
     return selection ? `node scripts/cw.js commit ${run.id} --selection ${selection.id} --reason "<verified rationale>"` : undefined;
 }
 function normalizeEvidenceStatus(row) {
@@ -470,14 +508,19 @@ function normalizeEvidenceStatus(row) {
 function evidenceKey(evidence) {
     return evidence.id || evidence.locator || evidence.path || evidence.summary || "evidence";
 }
+function provenanceSourceId(item) {
+    const provenance = item.provenance;
+    return provenance?.workerId || provenance?.candidateId || provenance?.selectionId || provenance?.commitId;
+}
 function sourceKindFromEvidence(evidence, fallback) {
     if (fallback)
         return fallback;
-    if (evidence.provenance?.workerId)
+    const provenance = evidence.provenance;
+    if (provenance?.workerId)
         return "worker";
-    if (evidence.provenance?.verifierNodeId)
+    if (provenance?.verifierNodeId)
         return "verifier";
-    if (evidence.provenance?.source === "operator-recorded")
+    if (provenance?.source === "operator-recorded")
         return "operator";
     return "runtime";
 }