bmad-enhanced 1.5.2 → 1.6.0

This diff represents the content of publicly available package versions that have been released to one of the supported registries. The information contained in this diff is provided for informational purposes only and reflects changes between package versions as they appear in their respective public registries.
Files changed (145) hide show
  1. package/CHANGELOG.md +104 -6
  2. package/INSTALLATION.md +93 -245
  3. package/README.md +121 -1110
  4. package/UPDATE-GUIDE.md +70 -265
  5. package/_bmad/_config/agent-manifest.csv +0 -2
  6. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/README.md +150 -0
  7. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/agents/hypothesis-engineer.md +117 -0
  8. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/agents/production-intelligence-specialist.md +117 -0
  9. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/agents/research-convergence-specialist.md +117 -0
  10. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/compass-routing-reference.md +312 -0
  11. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/config.yaml +1 -1
  12. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/contracts/hc1-empathy-artifacts.md +152 -0
  13. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/contracts/hc2-problem-definition.md +125 -0
  14. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/contracts/hc3-hypothesis-contract.md +112 -0
  15. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/contracts/hc4-experiment-context.md +140 -0
  16. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/contracts/hc5-signal-report.md +130 -0
  17. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/examples/hc2-example-problem-definition.md +85 -0
  18. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/examples/hc3-example-hypothesis-contract.md +103 -0
  19. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/examples/hc5-example-signal-report.md +76 -0
  20. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/guides/LIAM-USER-GUIDE.md +260 -0
  21. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/guides/MILA-USER-GUIDE.md +240 -0
  22. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/guides/NOAH-USER-GUIDE.md +263 -0
  23. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/assumption-mapping/steps/step-01-setup.md +66 -0
  24. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/assumption-mapping/steps/step-02-context.md +93 -0
  25. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/assumption-mapping/steps/step-03-risk-mapping.md +103 -0
  26. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/assumption-mapping/steps/step-04-synthesize.md +101 -0
  27. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/assumption-mapping/workflow.md +49 -0
  28. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/behavior-analysis/steps/step-01-setup.md +81 -0
  29. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/behavior-analysis/steps/step-02-context.md +67 -0
  30. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/behavior-analysis/steps/step-03-classification.md +98 -0
  31. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/behavior-analysis/steps/step-04-evidence.md +100 -0
  32. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/behavior-analysis/steps/step-05-synthesize.md +174 -0
  33. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/behavior-analysis/workflow.md +52 -0
  34. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/contextualize-scope/contextualize-scope.template.md +1 -1
  35. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/empathy-map/steps/step-06-synthesize.md +4 -1
  36. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/experiment-design/steps/step-01-setup.md +66 -0
  37. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/experiment-design/steps/step-02-context.md +77 -0
  38. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/experiment-design/steps/step-03-design.md +114 -0
  39. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/experiment-design/steps/step-04-synthesize.md +128 -0
  40. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/experiment-design/workflow.md +51 -0
  41. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/hypothesis-engineering/steps/step-01-setup.md +66 -0
  42. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/hypothesis-engineering/steps/step-02-context.md +80 -0
  43. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/hypothesis-engineering/steps/step-03-brainwriting.md +79 -0
  44. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/hypothesis-engineering/steps/step-04-assumption-mapping.md +102 -0
  45. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/hypothesis-engineering/steps/step-05-synthesize.md +130 -0
  46. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/hypothesis-engineering/workflow.md +52 -0
  47. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/lean-experiment/steps/step-06.md +4 -1
  48. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/lean-persona/lean-persona.template.md +1 -1
  49. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/learning-card/learning-card.template.md +1 -1
  50. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/learning-card/steps/step-06-synthesize.md +4 -1
  51. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/mvp/mvp.template.md +1 -1
  52. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/mvp/steps/step-06-synthesize.md +3 -0
  53. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/pattern-mapping/steps/step-01-setup.md +102 -0
  54. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/pattern-mapping/steps/step-02-context.md +81 -0
  55. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/pattern-mapping/steps/step-03-pattern-identification.md +88 -0
  56. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/pattern-mapping/steps/step-04-theme-clustering.md +100 -0
  57. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/pattern-mapping/steps/step-05-synthesize.md +135 -0
  58. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/pattern-mapping/workflow.md +58 -0
  59. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/pivot-patch-persevere/pivot-patch-persevere.template.md +1 -1
  60. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/pivot-patch-persevere/steps/step-06-action-plan.md +5 -2
  61. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/pivot-resynthesis/steps/step-01-setup.md +97 -0
  62. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/pivot-resynthesis/steps/step-02-context.md +86 -0
  63. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/pivot-resynthesis/steps/step-03-jtbd-reframing.md +88 -0
  64. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/pivot-resynthesis/steps/step-04-pains-gains-revision.md +76 -0
  65. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/pivot-resynthesis/steps/step-05-synthesize.md +158 -0
  66. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/pivot-resynthesis/workflow.md +52 -0
  67. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/product-vision/product-vision.template.md +1 -1
  68. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/production-monitoring/steps/step-01-setup.md +84 -0
  69. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/production-monitoring/steps/step-02-context.md +66 -0
  70. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/production-monitoring/steps/step-03-monitoring.md +74 -0
  71. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/production-monitoring/steps/step-04-prioritization.md +97 -0
  72. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/production-monitoring/steps/step-05-synthesize.md +183 -0
  73. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/production-monitoring/workflow.md +52 -0
  74. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/proof-of-concept/steps/step-06.md +3 -0
  75. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/proof-of-value/steps/step-06.md +3 -0
  76. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/research-convergence/steps/step-01-setup.md +69 -0
  77. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/research-convergence/steps/step-02-context.md +70 -0
  78. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/research-convergence/steps/step-03-jtbd-framing.md +81 -0
  79. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/research-convergence/steps/step-04-pains-gains.md +77 -0
  80. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/research-convergence/steps/step-05-synthesize.md +147 -0
  81. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/research-convergence/workflow.md +50 -0
  82. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/signal-interpretation/steps/step-01-setup.md +68 -0
  83. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/signal-interpretation/steps/step-02-context.md +67 -0
  84. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/signal-interpretation/steps/step-03-signal-analysis.md +85 -0
  85. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/signal-interpretation/steps/step-04-anomaly-detection.md +93 -0
  86. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/signal-interpretation/steps/step-05-synthesize.md +163 -0
  87. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/signal-interpretation/workflow.md +52 -0
  88. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/user-discovery/steps/step-06-synthesize.md +4 -1
  89. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/user-interview/steps/step-06-synthesize.md +4 -1
  90. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/user-interview/user-interview.template.md +1 -1
  91. package/_bmad/bme/_vortex/workflows/user-interview/validate.md +1 -1
  92. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/1-1-expand-agent-registry-to-7-agents.md +190 -0
  93. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/1-2-update-validator-config-merger-doctor-for-7-agents.md +184 -0
  94. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/1-3-create-migration-delta-installer-updates.md +270 -0
  95. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/1-4-define-handoff-contract-schemas-hc1-hc5.md +292 -0
  96. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/1-5-create-compass-routing-reference-document.md +324 -0
  97. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/2-1-design-milas-agent-definition-persona.md +270 -0
  98. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/2-2-create-research-convergence-workflow.md +429 -0
  99. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/2-3-create-pivot-resynthesis-workflow.md +411 -0
  100. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/2-4-create-pattern-mapping-workflow.md +397 -0
  101. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/2-5-create-mila-user-guide-example-artifacts.md +243 -0
  102. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/3-1-design-liams-agent-definition-persona.md +301 -0
  103. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/3-2-create-hypothesis-engineering-workflow.md +403 -0
  104. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/3-3-create-assumption-mapping-workflow.md +373 -0
  105. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/3-4-create-experiment-design-workflow.md +359 -0
  106. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/3-5-create-liam-user-guide-example-artifacts.md +258 -0
  107. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/4-1-design-noahs-agent-definition-persona.md +191 -0
  108. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/4-2-create-signal-interpretation-workflow.md +352 -0
  109. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/4-3-create-behavior-analysis-workflow.md +406 -0
  110. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/4-4-create-production-monitoring-workflow.md +430 -0
  111. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/4-5-create-noah-user-guide-example-artifacts.md +342 -0
  112. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/5-1-update-islas-compass-routes-to-mila.md +210 -0
  113. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/5-2-update-wades-maxs-compass-routes.md +260 -0
  114. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/5-3-update-documentation-for-complete-7-agent-vortex.md +268 -0
  115. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/5-4-add-ci-dead-end-detection-final-version-bump.md +206 -0
  116. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/epic-1-retro-2026-02-24.md +90 -0
  117. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/epic-2-retro-2026-02-25.md +104 -0
  118. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/epic-3-retro-2026-02-25.md +126 -0
  119. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/epic-4-retro-2026-02-26.md +151 -0
  120. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/epic-5-retro-2026-02-26.md +168 -0
  121. package/_bmad-output/implementation-artifacts/sprint-status.yaml +85 -0
  122. package/_bmad-output/planning-artifacts/architecture.md +607 -0
  123. package/_bmad-output/planning-artifacts/epics.md +826 -0
  124. package/_bmad-output/planning-artifacts/implementation-readiness-report-2026-02-23.md +156 -0
  125. package/_bmad-output/planning-artifacts/prd.md +498 -0
  126. package/_bmad-output/planning-artifacts/product-brief-BMAD-Enhanced-2026-02-22.md +262 -0
  127. package/_bmad-output/vortex-artifacts/EMMA-USER-GUIDE.md +10 -10
  128. package/_bmad-output/vortex-artifacts/ISLA-USER-GUIDE.md +4 -4
  129. package/_bmad-output/vortex-artifacts/MAX-USER-GUIDE.md +4 -4
  130. package/_bmad-output/vortex-artifacts/WADE-USER-GUIDE.md +10 -10
  131. package/index.js +6 -5
  132. package/package.json +2 -6
  133. package/scripts/bmad-doctor.js +3 -7
  134. package/scripts/install-vortex-agents.js +23 -18
  135. package/scripts/postinstall.js +5 -10
  136. package/scripts/update/bmad-update.js +136 -87
  137. package/scripts/update/lib/agent-registry.js +144 -0
  138. package/scripts/update/lib/config-merger.js +67 -43
  139. package/scripts/update/lib/migration-runner.js +2 -1
  140. package/scripts/update/lib/refresh-installation.js +4 -37
  141. package/scripts/update/lib/validator.js +69 -21
  142. package/scripts/update/migrations/1.5.x-to-1.6.0.js +95 -0
  143. package/scripts/update/migrations/registry.js +7 -0
  144. package/scripts/install-emma.js +0 -14
  145. package/scripts/install-wade.js +0 -14
package/README.md CHANGED
@@ -1,47 +1,48 @@
1
1
  # BMAD-Enhanced
2
2
 
3
- **Vortex Framework - Product Discovery through Lean Startup Validation**
3
+ **Vortex Pattern - Product Discovery through Lean Startup Validation**
4
4
 
5
- > Four specialized agents: Emma, Wade, Isla, and Max
5
+ [![Version](https://img.shields.io/badge/version-1.6.0-blue)](https://github.com/amalik/BMAD-Enhanced)
6
+ [![Agents](https://img.shields.io/badge/agents-7-brightgreen)](docs/agents.md)
7
+ [![Workflows](https://img.shields.io/badge/workflows-22-success)](docs/agents.md)
8
+ [![License](https://img.shields.io/badge/license-MIT-blue)](LICENSE)
6
9
 
7
- [![Status](https://img.shields.io/badge/status-v1.5.2--stable-success)]()
8
- [![Version](https://img.shields.io/badge/version-1.5.2-blue)]()
9
- [![Agents](https://img.shields.io/badge/agents-4-brightgreen)]()
10
- [![Workflows](https://img.shields.io/badge/workflows-13_implemented-success)]()
11
- [![License](https://img.shields.io/badge/license-MIT-blue)]()
12
-
13
- ---
14
-
15
- ## 🎯 What is BMAD-Enhanced?
16
-
17
- BMAD-Enhanced extends the [BMAD Method](https://github.com/bmadhub/bmad) with the **Vortex framework** - a Lean Startup validation approach with four specialized agents across four Vortex streams:
10
+ BMAD-Enhanced extends the [BMAD Method](https://github.com/bmadhub/bmad) with the **Vortex Pattern** — seven specialized agents that guide teams through Lean Startup validation before building anything. The [Innovation Vortex](https://unfix.com/innovation-vortex) is a pattern from the [unFIX model](https://unfix.com/) by [Jurgen Appelo](https://jurgenappelo.com/).
18
11
 
19
12
  ```
20
- VORTEX FRAMEWORK
21
-
22
- Contextualize Empathize Externalize Systematize
23
- ┌─────────────┐ ┌─────────────┐ ┌─────────────┐ ┌─────────────┐
24
- Emma 🎯 Isla 🔍 Wade 🧪 Max 🧭
25
- │ │ │ │ │ │ │ │
26
- Strategic │───>│ Discovery │───>│ Lean │───>│ Learning
27
- Framing & Empathy │ Experiments │ │ & Decisions │
28
- │ │ │ │ │ │
29
- │ • Personas │ │ • Empathy │ │ • MVPs │ │ • Learning │
30
- Vision │ │ Interview │ │ • Tests │ │ • Pivot/ │
31
- • Scope • Discovery • Proof │ Persevere │
32
- └─────────────┘ └─────────────┘ └─────────────┘ └─────────────┘
13
+ VORTEX PATTERN — 7 Streams · 7 Agents
14
+
15
+ ┌──────────┐ HC1 ┌──────────┐ HC2 ┌──────────┐ HC3 ┌──────────┐
16
+ │ Isla 🔍 │─────▶│ Mila 🔬 │─────▶│ Liam 💡 │─────▶│ Wade 🧪 │
17
+ Empathize Synthesize Hypothesiz Externaliz
18
+ └──────────┘ └──────────┘ └──────────┘ └──────────┘
19
+ ▲ ▲
20
+ HC6 HC9 HC4
21
+ ▼ ▼
22
+ ┌──────────┐ ┌──────────┐ ┌──────────┐ ┌──────────┐
23
+ Emma 🎯 │◀HC8─│ Max 🧭 │◀HC5─│ Noah 📡 │◀────────┘
24
+ Contextual Systematiz Sensitize
25
+ └──────────┘ └──────────┘ └──────────┘
26
+ │ HC7 │ HC10│
27
+ └──────────────────┴──────────────────┘
28
+ ▼ to Isla 🔍
33
29
  ```
34
30
 
35
- **Contextualize (Emma):** Frame the right problem before building
36
- **Empathize (Isla):** Understand users through research and empathy mapping
37
- **Externalize (Wade):** Test assumptions with real users through experiments
38
- **Systematize (Max):** Capture learnings and navigate between Vortex streams
31
+ | Agent | Stream | What they do |
32
+ |-------|--------|-------------|
33
+ | **Emma** 🎯 | Contextualize | Frame the right problem — lean personas, product vision, scope decisions |
34
+ | **Isla** 🔍 | Empathize | Understand users empathy maps, interviews, discovery research |
35
+ | **Mila** 🔬 | Synthesize | Converge research into problem definitions — JTBD, pains & gains analysis |
36
+ | **Liam** 💡 | Hypothesize | Engineer testable hypotheses — assumption mapping, experiment design |
37
+ | **Wade** 🧪 | Externalize | Test assumptions — MVPs, experiments, proof-of-concept/value |
38
+ | **Noah** 📡 | Sensitize | Interpret production signals — behavior analysis, monitoring |
39
+ | **Max** 🧭 | Systematize | Capture learnings — learning cards, pivot/persevere decisions, stream navigation |
39
40
 
40
- ---
41
+ Every workflow ends with a **Vortex Compass** — evidence-driven routing that creates non-linear loops across all streams. Ten handoff contracts (HC1-HC10) ensure structured information flows between agents.
41
42
 
42
- ## ⚡ Quick Start
43
+ ---
43
44
 
44
- **📖 See [INSTALLATION.md](INSTALLATION.md) for complete installation guide**
45
+ ## Quick Start
45
46
 
46
47
  ### Prerequisites
47
48
 
@@ -49,1146 +50,156 @@ Contextualize Empathize Externalize Systematize
49
50
  - Git
50
51
  - Claude Code or Claude.ai
51
52
 
52
- **Optional:** [BMAD Method](https://github.com/bmadhub/bmad) - BMAD-Enhanced works standalone or as an extension to BMAD Method.
53
-
54
- ### One-Command Installation
53
+ ### Install
55
54
 
56
55
  ```bash
57
56
  npm install bmad-enhanced && npx bmad-install-vortex-agents
58
57
  ```
59
58
 
60
- That's it! All 4 Vortex agents (Emma, Isla, Wade, Max) with 13 workflows are installed.
59
+ All 7 agents with 22 workflows are installed and ready to use.
61
60
 
62
- ### Installation
63
-
64
- **Option 1: Install from npm (Recommended)**
61
+ ### Activate an Agent
65
62
 
66
63
  ```bash
67
- # Install into your project
68
- npm install bmad-enhanced
69
-
70
- # Install all Vortex agents with all 13 workflows
71
- npx bmad-install-vortex-agents
64
+ # Read an agent file to activate it
65
+ cat _bmad/bme/_vortex/agents/contextualization-expert.md # Emma 🎯
66
+ cat _bmad/bme/_vortex/agents/discovery-empathy-expert.md # Isla 🔍
67
+ cat _bmad/bme/_vortex/agents/research-convergence-specialist.md # Mila 🔬
68
+ cat _bmad/bme/_vortex/agents/hypothesis-engineer.md # Liam 💡
69
+ cat _bmad/bme/_vortex/agents/lean-experiments-specialist.md # Wade 🧪
70
+ cat _bmad/bme/_vortex/agents/production-intelligence-specialist.md # Noah 📡
71
+ cat _bmad/bme/_vortex/agents/learning-decision-expert.md # Max 🧭
72
72
  ```
73
73
 
74
- **Option 2: Clone from source**
74
+ Each agent presents a menu-driven interface. Pick a workflow and follow the guided steps.
75
75
 
76
- ```bash
77
- # Clone repository
78
- git clone https://github.com/yourusername/BMAD-Enhanced.git
79
- cd BMAD-Enhanced
80
-
81
- # Install dependencies
82
- npm install
76
+ ### What Gets Installed
83
77
 
84
- # Agents are already installed and operational
85
- cat _bmad/bme/_vortex/agents/contextualization-expert.md
86
78
  ```
87
-
88
- **What gets installed:**
89
- - Agent definition files (`_bmad/bme/_vortex/agents/`)
90
- - **13 complete workflows** (104 files):
91
- - Emma: lean-persona, product-vision, contextualize-scope
92
- - Isla: empathy-map, user-interview, user-discovery
93
- - Wade: mvp, lean-experiment, proof-of-concept, proof-of-value
94
- - Max: learning-card, pivot-patch-persevere, vortex-navigation
95
- - Configuration file (`_bmad/bme/_vortex/config.yaml`)
96
- - Output directory (`_bmad-output/vortex-artifacts/`)
97
- - User guides (Emma, Isla, Wade & Max)
98
-
99
- ### Getting Started with the Agents
100
-
101
- ```bash
102
- # Activate any agent by reading their definition file
103
- cat _bmad/bme/_vortex/agents/contextualization-expert.md # Emma
104
- cat _bmad/bme/_vortex/agents/discovery-empathy-expert.md # Isla
105
- cat _bmad/bme/_vortex/agents/lean-experiments-specialist.md # Wade
106
- cat _bmad/bme/_vortex/agents/learning-decision-expert.md # Max
79
+ your-project/
80
+ ├── _bmad/bme/_vortex/
81
+ │ ├── agents/ # 7 agent definition files
82
+ │ ├── workflows/ # 22 workflows
83
+ │ ├── contracts/ # 5 artifact contract schemas (HC1-HC5)
84
+ │ ├── guides/ # User guides (Mila, Liam, Noah)
85
+ │ └── config.yaml # Configuration
86
+ └── _bmad-output/
87
+ └── vortex-artifacts/ # Generated artifacts + user guides (Emma, Isla, Wade, Max)
107
88
  ```
108
89
 
109
- ### Emma - Contextualize Stream (3 workflows)
110
-
111
- Emma will guide you through strategic contextualization with 3 workflows:
112
-
113
- - **[LP] Lean Persona** - Create jobs-to-be-done focused user personas
114
- - 6-step guided workflow
115
- - Hypothesis-driven with validation planning
116
- - Output: Lean persona document with riskiest assumptions identified
117
-
118
- - **[PV] Product Vision** - Define strategic product vision
119
- - Vision statement, future state (3-5 years), guiding principles
120
- - Strategic assumptions and validation plan
121
- - Output: Complete product vision document
122
-
123
- - **[CS] Contextualize Scope** - Decide which problem space to investigate
124
- - Systematic opportunity evaluation with scoring matrix
125
- - Clear scope boundaries (what's in, what's out)
126
- - Output: Scope decision document with rationale
127
-
128
- ### Isla - Empathize Stream (3 workflows)
129
-
130
- Isla will guide you through user discovery and empathy with 3 workflows:
131
-
132
- - **[EM] Empathy Map** - Build deep user understanding through empathy mapping
133
- - 5-step guided workflow
134
- - Maps what users think, feel, say, do, and experience
135
- - Output: Empathy map artifact with pain/gain analysis
136
-
137
- - **[UI] User Interview** - Design and conduct effective user interviews
138
- - 6-step guided workflow
139
- - Interview script design with findings capture
140
- - Output: Interview findings with patterns and insights
141
-
142
- - **[UD] User Discovery** - Plan and execute discovery research
143
- - 6-step guided workflow
144
- - Research planning, execution, and synthesis
145
- - Output: Discovery research report with key findings
146
-
147
- ### Wade - Externalize Stream (4 workflows)
148
-
149
- Wade will guide you through validated learning with 4 workflows:
150
-
151
- - **[MVP] Minimum Viable Product** - Design MVPs to test riskiest assumptions
152
- - Not feature-light products - smallest thing to test assumptions
153
- - Build-Measure-Learn cycle planning
154
- - Output: MVP specification document
155
-
156
- - **[LE] Lean Experiment** - Execute Build-Measure-Learn cycles
157
- - Hypothesis-driven experimentation framework
158
- - Metrics definition and pivot-or-persevere decisions
159
- - Output: Experiment results and learning documentation
160
-
161
- - **[POC] Proof-of-Concept** - Validate technical feasibility
162
- - Test "Can we build it?" before "Should we build it?"
163
- - Technical risk assessment and PoC scoping
164
- - Output: Feasibility evaluation document
165
-
166
- - **[POV] Proof-of-Value** - Validate business value
167
- - Test "Should we build it?" (business case)
168
- - Willingness to pay and market demand experiments
169
- - Output: Business case and build/pivot/kill decision
170
-
171
- ### Max - Systematize Stream (3 workflows)
172
-
173
- Max will guide you through learning capture and strategic navigation with 3 workflows:
174
-
175
- - **[LC] Learning Card** - Capture what was tested, learned, and decided
176
- - 6-step guided workflow
177
- - Structured learning documentation from experiments
178
- - Output: Learning card artifact with evidence and decisions
179
-
180
- - **[PPP] Pivot, Patch, or Persevere** - Make evidence-based decisions after experiments
181
- - 6-step guided workflow
182
- - Decision framework with evidence evaluation
183
- - Output: Decision document with rationale and next steps
184
-
185
- - **[VN] Vortex Navigation** - Decide which Vortex stream to focus on next
186
- - 6-step guided workflow
187
- - Assess progress across all streams, identify gaps
188
- - Output: Navigation recommendation with action plan
189
-
190
90
  ---
191
91
 
192
- ## 🔄 Updating BMAD-Enhanced
193
-
194
- ### Check Version
195
-
196
- ```bash
197
- npx bmad-version
198
- ```
199
-
200
- **Output shows:**
201
- - Current installed version
202
- - Latest package version
203
- - Update availability status
204
- - Migration history
205
-
206
- ### Update to Latest Version
207
-
208
- ```bash
209
- # Update the package
210
- npm install bmad-enhanced@latest
211
-
212
- # Preview changes (dry run)
213
- npx bmad-update --dry-run
214
-
215
- # Apply the update
216
- npx bmad-update
217
- ```
218
-
219
- **Your data is automatically backed up before any changes.**
220
-
221
- ### Update Commands
222
-
223
- - `npx bmad-update` - Apply updates and migrations
224
- - `npx bmad-update --dry-run` - Preview changes without applying
225
- - `npx bmad-update --yes` - Skip confirmation prompt
226
- - `npx bmad-version` - Show current version and status
227
- - `npx bmad-doctor` - Diagnose installation issues
228
-
229
- ### Data Safety
230
-
231
- **Automatic backups before every update:**
232
- - Location: `_bmad-output/.backups/backup-{version}-{timestamp}/`
233
- - Automatic rollback if migration fails
234
- - Keeps last 5 backups
235
-
236
- **Never touched:**
237
- - All user data in `_bmad-output/`
238
- - User preferences (name, language)
239
- - Custom configurations
240
-
241
- ### Migration Paths
242
-
243
- **From v1.3.x or v1.4.x to v1.5.0:**
244
- - No breaking changes
245
- - Adds Isla (Discovery & Empathy Expert) and Max (Learning & Decision Expert)
246
- - 6 new workflows installed, empathy-map resurrected for Isla
247
-
248
- **From v1.1.x, v1.2.x, or v1.3.x to v1.4.0:**
249
- - No breaking changes
250
- - Internal architecture refactor (no user-facing changes)
251
- - Agent files and workflows refreshed
252
-
253
- **From v1.0.x to v1.4.0:**
254
- - Breaking: empathy-map → lean-persona
255
- - Old workflows preserved in `_deprecated/`
256
- - 7 new workflows installed
257
-
258
- ### Troubleshooting
92
+ ## Updating
259
93
 
260
94
  ```bash
261
- # Run diagnostics
262
- npx bmad-doctor
95
+ npx bmad-version # Check current version
96
+ npx bmad-update --dry-run # Preview changes
97
+ npx bmad-update # Apply update (auto-backup)
98
+ npx bmad-doctor # Diagnose issues
263
99
  ```
264
100
 
265
- The doctor checks project root, config validity, agent files, workflows, output directory permissions, migration lock status, and version consistency with actionable fix suggestions for each issue.
101
+ Your data in `_bmad-output/` is never touched. Automatic backups are created before every update.
266
102
 
267
- If update fails:
268
-
269
- ```bash
270
- # Check migration logs
271
- ls _bmad-output/.logs/
272
-
273
- # Restore from backup
274
- cp -r _bmad-output/.backups/backup-{version}-{timestamp}/* _bmad/bme/_vortex/
275
-
276
- # Reinstall (preserves user data)
277
- npx bmad-install-vortex-agents
278
- ```
279
-
280
- **📖 See [UPDATE-GUIDE.md](UPDATE-GUIDE.md) for comprehensive update documentation**
103
+ See [UPDATE-GUIDE.md](UPDATE-GUIDE.md) for migration paths and troubleshooting.
281
104
 
282
105
  ---
283
106
 
284
- ## 🏗️ Architecture
285
-
286
- ### BMAD Agent Architecture Framework v1.1.0
287
-
288
- All agents built using a standard pattern:
107
+ ## Using the Agents
289
108
 
290
- **Core Components:**
291
- - **XML-based agent structure** - Agent definition in markdown code blocks
292
- - **Config-driven personalization** - user_name, communication_language, output_folder
293
- - **Step-file workflow pattern** - Just-in-time sequential workflow loading
294
- - **Menu-driven interaction** - Numeric, text, and fuzzy command matching
295
- - **Error handling** - Robust validation with clear error messages
296
- - **Artifact generation** - Template-based professional output
109
+ Each agent can be used independently or as part of the full Vortex flow:
297
110
 
298
- **Pattern Proven:** Emma + Wade (reference implementations) validated with 100% P0 test pass rate (18/18 tests each)
299
-
300
- ---
111
+ 1. **Emma (Contextualize)** Start here when defining a new product or problem space
112
+ 2. **Isla (Empathize)** — Start here when you need to understand users better
113
+ 3. **Mila (Synthesize)** — Start here when you have research to converge into a problem definition
114
+ 4. **Liam (Hypothesize)** — Start here when you have a problem definition and need testable hypotheses
115
+ 5. **Wade (Externalize)** — Start here when you have hypotheses ready to test
116
+ 6. **Noah (Sensitize)** — Start here when experiments have graduated to production
117
+ 7. **Max (Systematize)** — Start here when you have results and need to decide next steps
301
118
 
302
- ## 🚀 Agents
119
+ Max's **Vortex Navigation** workflow helps identify which stream needs attention based on evidence gaps — you don't have to follow a linear path. Every workflow ends with a **Vortex Compass** that routes you to the right next agent based on what you learned.
303
120
 
304
- ### Emma (contextualization-expert) - COMPLETE
121
+ For detailed workflow descriptions and usage examples, see the [Agent Guide](docs/agents.md) and the individual user guides:
305
122
 
306
- **Status:** v1.5.0 - All 3 workflows implemented and ready to use
307
- **Title:** Contextualization Expert 🎯
308
- **Stream:** Contextualize
309
- **Domain:** Strategic framing, problem-product space navigation
310
-
311
- **Workflows Available Now:**
312
- - **lean-persona** - Create jobs-to-be-done focused personas (6 steps)
313
- - **product-vision** - Define clear product vision and strategic direction (6 steps)
314
- - **contextualize-scope** - Decide which problem space to investigate (6 steps)
315
-
316
- **Key Positioning:**
317
- - Helps teams frame the right problem before building solutions
318
- - Focus on Lean Startup methodologies and validated assumptions
319
- - Guides teams through strategic clarity before tactical execution
320
- - Hypothesis-driven with built-in validation planning
321
-
322
- **Differentiation:**
323
- - **Emma vs Maya:** Emma contextualizes (problem space), Maya creates (solution space)
324
- - Emma answers "What should we solve?" before Maya answers "How should we solve it?"
325
-
326
- **Output:** Lean personas, product visions, and scope decisions in `_bmad-output/vortex-artifacts/`
123
+ - [Emma User Guide](_bmad-output/vortex-artifacts/EMMA-USER-GUIDE.md)
124
+ - [Isla User Guide](_bmad-output/vortex-artifacts/ISLA-USER-GUIDE.md)
125
+ - [Mila User Guide](_bmad/bme/_vortex/guides/MILA-USER-GUIDE.md)
126
+ - [Liam User Guide](_bmad/bme/_vortex/guides/LIAM-USER-GUIDE.md)
127
+ - [Wade User Guide](_bmad-output/vortex-artifacts/WADE-USER-GUIDE.md)
128
+ - [Noah User Guide](_bmad/bme/_vortex/guides/NOAH-USER-GUIDE.md)
129
+ - [Max User Guide](_bmad-output/vortex-artifacts/MAX-USER-GUIDE.md)
327
130
 
328
131
  ---
329
132
 
330
- ### Isla (discovery-empathy-expert) - COMPLETE
331
-
332
- **Status:** v1.5.0 - All 3 workflows implemented and ready to use
333
- **Title:** Discovery & Empathy Expert 🔍
334
- **Stream:** Empathize
335
- **Domain:** User research, empathy mapping, discovery
133
+ ## How It Fits with BMAD Core
336
134
 
337
- **Workflows Available Now:**
338
- - **empathy-map** - Build deep user understanding through empathy mapping (5 steps)
339
- - **user-interview** - Design interview scripts and capture findings (6 steps)
340
- - **user-discovery** - Plan and execute discovery research (6 steps)
135
+ BMAD-Enhanced handles **pre-implementation validation**. BMAD Core handles **implementation**.
341
136
 
342
- **Key Positioning:**
343
- - Helps teams deeply understand users before designing solutions
344
- - Focus on evidence-based user insights over assumptions
345
- - Guides teams through structured discovery and empathy practices
346
- - Bridges the gap between strategic framing and experimentation
347
-
348
- **Differentiation:**
349
- - **Isla vs Emma:** Isla empathizes (understand users), Emma contextualizes (frame the problem)
350
- - Isla answers "Who are our users and what do they need?" to inform Emma's strategic framing
351
-
352
- **Output:** Empathy maps, interview findings, discovery reports in `_bmad-output/vortex-artifacts/`
353
-
354
- ---
355
-
356
- ### Wade (lean-experiments-specialist) - ✅ COMPLETE
357
-
358
- **Status:** v1.5.0 - All 4 workflows implemented and ready to use
359
- **Title:** Lean Experiments Specialist 🧪
360
- **Stream:** Externalize
361
- **Domain:** Lean Startup experimentation, validated learning
362
-
363
- **Workflows Available Now:**
364
- - **mvp** - Design Minimum Viable Product to test riskiest assumptions (6 steps)
365
- - **lean-experiment** - Run Build-Measure-Learn cycles (6 steps)
366
- - **proof-of-concept** - Validate technical feasibility (6 steps)
367
- - **proof-of-value** - Validate business value (6 steps)
368
-
369
- **Key Positioning:**
370
- - Helps teams test assumptions with real users through rapid experiments
371
- - Focus on validated learning over perfection
372
- - Guides teams from hypotheses to evidence
373
- - Build-Measure-Learn cycles with pivot-or-persevere decisions
374
-
375
- **Differentiation:**
376
- - **Wade vs Sally:** Wade externalizes (test with users), Sally internalizes (test with code)
377
- - Wade answers "Should we build this?" before Sally answers "How do we build this well?"
378
-
379
- **Output:** MVP specs, experiment results, PoC/PoV evaluations in `_bmad-output/vortex-artifacts/`
380
-
381
- ---
382
-
383
- ### Max (learning-decision-expert) - ✅ COMPLETE
384
-
385
- **Status:** v1.5.0 - All 3 workflows implemented and ready to use
386
- **Title:** Learning & Decision Expert 🧭
387
- **Stream:** Systematize
388
- **Domain:** Learning capture, decision frameworks, Vortex navigation
389
-
390
- **Workflows Available Now:**
391
- - **learning-card** - Capture what was tested, learned, and decided (6 steps)
392
- - **pivot-patch-persevere** - Evidence-based decision framework after experiments (6 steps)
393
- - **vortex-navigation** - Decide which Vortex stream to focus on next (6 steps)
394
-
395
- **Key Positioning:**
396
- - Helps teams systematize learnings and make evidence-based decisions
397
- - Focus on capturing validated learning as organizational knowledge
398
- - Guides teams through pivot/patch/persevere decisions
399
- - Navigates between Vortex streams based on evidence and gaps
400
-
401
- **Differentiation:**
402
- - **Max vs Wade:** Max systematizes (what did we learn?), Wade externalizes (test with users)
403
- - Max answers "What should we do next?" based on accumulated evidence
404
-
405
- **Output:** Learning cards, decision documents, navigation recommendations in `_bmad-output/vortex-artifacts/`
406
-
407
- ---
408
-
409
- ## 📊 Project Status
410
-
411
- **Current Version:** v1.5.0 - Wave 2: Four Vortex Agents ✅
412
-
413
- **Progress:**
414
- - ✅ Emma - 3 Contextualize workflows IMPLEMENTED
415
- - ✅ Isla - 3 Empathize workflows IMPLEMENTED (NEW in v1.5.0)
416
- - ✅ Wade - 4 Externalize workflows IMPLEMENTED
417
- - ✅ Max - 3 Systematize workflows IMPLEMENTED (NEW in v1.5.0)
418
- - ✅ 104 workflow files created (13 workflows × 8 files each)
419
- - ✅ Update/migration system with backup and rollback
420
- - ✅ Standalone installation support (no BMAD Method required)
421
- - ✅ `npx bmad-doctor` diagnostic CLI
422
- - ✅ CI pipeline with lint, test matrix, coverage, security, publish-on-tag
423
-
424
- **What's New in v1.5.0:**
425
- - **Isla (Discovery & Empathy Expert)** - Empathize stream with empathy-map, user-interview, user-discovery workflows
426
- - **Max (Learning & Decision Expert)** - Systematize stream with learning-card, pivot-patch-persevere, vortex-navigation workflows
427
- - **`npx bmad-install-vortex-agents`** - New primary installer for all 4 Vortex agents
428
- - **Empathy-map resurrected** - Moved from deprecated back to active, now owned by Isla
429
- - **Legacy installer deprecation** - `install-emma`/`install-wade` now show deprecation warnings
430
-
431
- **Roadmap:**
432
137
  ```
433
- v1.1.0 v1.3.x ✅ v1.4.x ✅ v1.5.0 ✅ v2.0.0
434
- ├────────────────┬────────────────┬────────────────┬────────────────┬──────────┤
435
- Foundation ✅ │ Tooling ✅ │ Quality ✅ │ Wave 2 Advanced
436
- • Emma + Wade Update tools │ • Refactor • Isla + Max │ • Wave 3 │
437
- 7 workflows │ • Migration • 183 tests • 13 workflows │ • Multi │
438
- Framework │ Automation │ CI/CD + lint • 4 streams │ • Stats │
439
- └────────────────┴────────────────┴────────────────┴────────────────┴──────────┘
440
- Feb 2026 Feb 2026 Feb 2026 Feb 2026 Q3 2026
138
+ BMAD-Enhanced (Vortex) BMAD Core
139
+ ┌──────────────────────────────────────┐ ┌──────────────────────┐
140
+ Isla Mila Liam Wade Noah ───> │ PM → Architect → Dev
141
+ ↑ ↓ "Let's build it"
142
+ └──── Max ◀── Noah Max └──────────────────────┘
143
+ Emma provides context at any point
144
+ │ "Should we build this?" │
145
+ └──────────────────────────────────────┘
441
146
  ```
442
147
 
443
- **See:** [CHANGELOG.md](CHANGELOG.md) for complete version history
148
+ BMAD-Enhanced works standalone or as an extension — no BMAD Method installation required.
444
149
 
445
150
  ---
446
151
 
447
- ## 📚 Documentation
448
-
449
- ### User Guides
450
-
451
- - **[Emma User Guide](_bmad-output/vortex-artifacts/EMMA-USER-GUIDE.md)** - Complete guide to strategic contextualization with Emma
452
- - **[Isla User Guide](_bmad-output/vortex-artifacts/ISLA-USER-GUIDE.md)** - Complete guide to discovery and empathy with Isla
453
- - **[Wade User Guide](_bmad-output/vortex-artifacts/WADE-USER-GUIDE.md)** - Complete guide to lean experiments with Wade
454
- - **[Max User Guide](_bmad-output/vortex-artifacts/MAX-USER-GUIDE.md)** - Complete guide to learning and decisions with Max
455
-
456
- ### Technical Documentation
457
-
458
- - **[BMAD Agent Architecture Framework](_bmad-output/GENERIC-AGENT-INTEGRATION-FRAMEWORK.md)** - Standard agent pattern (v1.1.0)
459
- - **[Emma Reference Implementation](_bmad-output/EMMA-REFERENCE-IMPLEMENTATION-COMPLETE.md)** - How Emma was built
152
+ ## Documentation
460
153
 
461
- ### Test Results
462
-
463
- - **[Emma Test Results](_bmad-output/test-artifacts/emma-tests/emma-p0-test-results.md)** - P0 test validation (18/18 passed)
464
- - **[Emma Stakeholder Review](_bmad-output/test-artifacts/emma-tests/STAKEHOLDER-SIGNOFF-REVIEW.md)** - Approval documentation
465
- - **[Wade Test Results](_bmad-output/test-artifacts/wade-tests/wade-p0-test-execution.md)** - P0 test validation (18/18 passed)
466
- - **Isla Test Results** - Pending (Wave 2 agent, workflow validation in progress)
467
- - **Max Test Results** - Pending (Wave 2 agent, workflow validation in progress)
468
-
469
- ### Planning Artifacts
470
-
471
- - **[Project Status Update](_bmad-output/PROJECT-STATUS-UPDATE.md)** - Current progress and timeline
472
- - **[Phase 0 Implementation Guide](_bmad-output/planning-artifacts/phase-0-implementation-guide.md)** - Complete implementation plan
473
- - **[Original Multi-Framework Vision](_bmad-output/planning-artifacts/ORIGINAL-VISION-README.md)** - Earlier exploration (archived)
474
-
475
- **Browse all documentation:** [_bmad-output/README.md](_bmad-output/README.md)
154
+ | Document | Description |
155
+ |----------|-------------|
156
+ | [Agent Guide](docs/agents.md) | Detailed agent descriptions, workflows, and positioning |
157
+ | [Testing](docs/testing.md) | Automated test suite, CI pipeline, and agent test results |
158
+ | [Development Guide](docs/development.md) | Architecture, building agents, and contributing |
159
+ | [FAQ](docs/faq.md) | Common questions about the framework |
160
+ | [CHANGELOG](CHANGELOG.md) | Complete version history |
161
+ | [UPDATE-GUIDE](UPDATE-GUIDE.md) | Migration paths and update troubleshooting |
476
162
 
477
163
  ---
478
164
 
479
- ## 💡 Key Features
480
-
481
- ### 🎯 Lean Startup Validation Framework
482
-
483
- The Vortex framework brings structured validation to product development:
484
- - **Contextualize Stream (Emma):** Frame the right problem before building
485
- - **Empathize Stream (Isla):** Understand users through research and empathy
486
- - **Externalize Stream (Wade):** Test assumptions with real users
487
- - **Systematize Stream (Max):** Capture learnings and navigate between streams
488
- - **Integrated Approach:** Strategic clarity → User empathy → Validated learning → Systematic decisions
489
- - **Vortex Compass:** Every workflow ends with evidence-driven navigation — "If you learned X → go to Y" — creating non-linear loops across all streams
490
-
491
- ### 🔄 Clear Agent Differentiation
492
-
493
- **Emma vs Maya:**
494
- - Emma: Contextualizes (What problem should we solve?)
495
- - Maya: Creates (How should we solve it?)
496
-
497
- **Wade vs Sally:**
498
- - Wade: Externalizes (Should we build this? - test with users)
499
- - Sally: Internalizes (Are we building it well? - test with code)
500
-
501
- ### 🚀 Strategic Positioning
502
-
503
- BMAD-Enhanced now focuses on the critical pre-implementation phase:
504
- 1. **Emma:** Frame strategy and define problem space
505
- 2. **Isla:** Understand users through research and empathy
506
- 3. **Wade:** Validate assumptions through experiments
507
- 4. **Max:** Capture learnings and decide what to do next
508
- 5. **Hand off to BMAD Core:** Let PM/Dev/QA agents implement
509
-
510
- ### 🔄 Reusable Patterns
511
-
512
- Emma validates patterns used by all agents:
513
- - XML-based agent structure
514
- - Config-driven personalization
515
- - Step-file workflow architecture
516
- - Menu-driven interaction (3 command types)
517
- - Professional artifact generation
518
-
519
- **Impact:** Each subsequent agent developed 33% faster than Emma (8 hours vs. 12 hours)
165
+ ## Roadmap
520
166
 
521
- ### 📖 User-Friendly
522
-
523
- Clear, comprehensive documentation:
524
- - User guides with examples and troubleshooting
525
- - Multiple invocation methods (slash command + direct file reading)
526
- - Step-by-step workflow guidance
527
- - Best practices and FAQs
528
-
529
- ---
530
-
531
- ## 🛠️ Development
532
-
533
- ### Building a New Agent
534
-
535
- 1. **Clone Emma's structure:**
536
- ```bash
537
- cp _bmad/bme/_vortex/agents/contextualization-expert.md \
538
- _bmad/bme/_vortex/agents/your-agent.md
539
- ```
540
-
541
- 2. **Customize the agent:**
542
- - Update persona (role, identity, communication style, principles)
543
- - Define menu options (workflows, chat, validate)
544
- - Create workflow step files
545
- - Add templates for output artifacts
546
-
547
- 3. **Register in manifest:**
548
- ```csv
549
- "your-agent","YourName","Your Title","🎯","role","identity",...
550
- ```
551
-
552
- 4. **Test thoroughly:**
553
- - Clone Emma test plan (39 scenarios)
554
- - Execute P0 tests (18 critical scenarios)
555
- - Target: 100% pass rate
556
-
557
- **See:** [BMAD Agent Architecture Framework](_bmad-output/GENERIC-AGENT-INTEGRATION-FRAMEWORK.md)
167
+ - **v1.1.0–v1.5.x** — Waves 1-2: Foundation (Emma, Isla, Wade, Max — 4 agents, 13 workflows, update system, CI/CD)
168
+ - **v1.6.0** — Wave 3: Complete 7-stream Vortex (added Mila, Liam, Noah — 22 workflows, 10 handoff contracts, Compass routing)
169
+ - **v2.0.0+** — Multi-agent collaboration, cross-agent workflows, analytics
558
170
 
559
171
  ---
560
172
 
561
- ## 🧪 Testing
562
-
563
- ### Automated Test Suite
564
-
565
- Zero-dependency test runner (`node:test`)
566
-
567
- | Suite | Tests | Coverage |
568
- |-------|-------|----------|
569
- | utils | 12 | compareVersions, getPackageVersion, findProjectRoot |
570
- | registry | 19 | getMigrationsFor, getBreakingChanges, hasMigrationBeenApplied |
571
- | version-detector | 23 | getCurrentVersion, detectInstallationScenario |
572
- | config-merger | 17 | mergeConfig, validateConfig, addMigrationHistory |
573
- | backup-manager | 11 | createBackup, restoreBackup, cleanupOldBackups |
574
- | migration-runner | 10 | executeMigration, previewMigrations, MigrationError |
575
- | migration-runner-orchestration | 9 | runMigrations full cycle, dry-run, skip, lock conflict, error handling |
576
- | validator | 23 | validateInstallation, config, agents, workflows, manifest, user data, deprecated |
577
- | migrations-to-1.5.0 | 6 | 1.3.x and 1.4.x migration metadata, preview, apply |
578
- | fresh-install (integration) | 9 | refreshInstallation end-to-end (all 4 agents) |
579
- | upgrade (integration) | 22 | v1.0.x→1.5.0, v1.3.x→1.5.0, v1.4.x→1.5.0 upgrade paths |
580
- | cli-entry-points (integration) | 8 | index.js, bmad-version, bmad-update, bmad-doctor |
581
- | installer-e2e (integration) | 7 | install-vortex-agents CLI end-to-end, idempotency |
582
- | bmad-doctor (integration) | 7 | negative paths: no project, missing config, invalid YAML, missing agents, stale/corrupt lock, version mismatch |
583
-
584
- **CI Pipeline (6 jobs):**
585
-
586
- | Job | What it does |
587
- |-----|-------------|
588
- | `lint` | ESLint with architecture rules (no `process.cwd()`) |
589
- | `test` | Node 18/20/22 matrix, unit + integration |
590
- | `coverage` | c8 with threshold enforcement (60% lines, 50% branches) |
591
- | `security` | `npm audit --omit=dev` |
592
- | `package-check` | `npm pack --dry-run` + `node index.js` |
593
- | `publish` | Automated npm publish on `v*` tags |
594
-
595
- ```bash
596
- npm test # Unit tests
597
- npm run test:integration # Integration tests
598
- npm run test:all # All tests
599
- npm run test:coverage # Tests with coverage thresholds
600
- npm run lint # ESLint
601
- ```
602
-
603
- ### Emma Test Results
173
+ ## Contributing
604
174
 
605
- **P0 Test Suite:** 18/18 PASSED (100%)
175
+ We welcome contributions in these areas:
606
176
 
607
- | Domain | Scenarios | Passed | Status |
608
- |--------|-----------|--------|--------|
609
- | Agent Activation | 7 | 7 | ✅ PASS |
610
- | Command Processing | 3 | 3 | ✅ PASS |
611
- | Workflow Execution | 6 | 6 | ✅ PASS |
612
- | Registration | 3 | 2 | ⚠️ PARTIAL* |
177
+ - **Agents** New domain-specialized agents, workflow improvements
178
+ - **Testing** — Edge cases, performance testing
179
+ - **Documentation** Tutorials, translations, video walkthroughs
180
+ - **Integration** IDE plugins, third-party tools
613
181
 
614
- *One environment limitation (slash command), validated workaround exists
615
-
616
- **Quality Gates:** 6/6 PASSED
617
- - ✅ Test Coverage: 100%
618
- - ✅ Pass Rate: 100%
619
- - ✅ Critical Path: End-to-end validated
620
- - ✅ Risk Mitigation: High risks addressed
621
- - ✅ Usability: Smooth user experience
622
- - ✅ Documentation: Complete
623
-
624
- **See:** [Emma Test Results](_bmad-output/test-artifacts/emma-tests/emma-p0-test-results.md)
625
-
626
- ### Wade Test Results
627
-
628
- **P0 Test Suite:** 18/18 PASSED (100%)
629
-
630
- | Domain | Scenarios | Passed | Status |
631
- |--------|-----------|--------|--------|
632
- | Activation & Registration | 6 | 6 | ✅ PASS |
633
- | Command Processing | 3 | 3 | ✅ PASS |
634
- | Workflow Execution | 6 | 6 | ✅ PASS |
635
- | Error Handling | 3 | 3 | ✅ PASS |
636
-
637
- **Live Test Suite:** 5/5 PASSED (100%)
638
- - ✅ Agent Activation
639
- - ✅ Full Workflow Execution
640
- - ✅ Validation Workflow
641
- - ✅ Chat Mode
642
- - ✅ Party Mode Integration
643
-
644
- **Quality Gates:** 6/6 PASSED
645
- - ✅ Test Coverage: 100%
646
- - ✅ Pass Rate: 100%
647
- - ✅ Critical Path: End-to-end validated
648
- - ✅ Risk Mitigation: High risks addressed
649
- - ✅ Usability: Smooth user experience
650
- - ✅ Documentation: Complete
651
-
652
- **See:** [Wade Test Results](_bmad-output/test-artifacts/wade-tests/wade-p0-test-execution.md)
653
-
654
- ### Isla Test Results
655
-
656
- **Status:** Pending formal P0 test execution
657
-
658
- Isla follows the same agent architecture as Emma and Wade. Infrastructure validation is covered by the automated test suite:
659
- - ✅ Installation verified (fresh-install integration tests)
660
- - ✅ Upgrade paths verified (v1.3.x and v1.4.x upgrade tests)
661
- - ✅ CLI entry points verified (agent listed in `bmad-enhanced` output)
662
- - ✅ All 3 workflow directories present with templates, steps, and validation
663
- - Formal P0 test suite (agent activation, command processing, workflow execution) planned for v1.5.1
664
-
665
- ### Max Test Results
666
-
667
- **Status:** Pending formal P0 test execution
668
-
669
- Max follows the same agent architecture as Emma and Wade. Infrastructure validation is covered by the automated test suite:
670
- - ✅ Installation verified (fresh-install integration tests)
671
- - ✅ Upgrade paths verified (v1.3.x and v1.4.x upgrade tests)
672
- - ✅ CLI entry points verified (agent listed in `bmad-enhanced` output)
673
- - ✅ All 3 workflow directories present with templates, steps, and validation
674
- - Formal P0 test suite (agent activation, command processing, workflow execution) planned for v1.5.1
182
+ See the [Development Guide](docs/development.md) for architecture details and agent development patterns.
675
183
 
676
184
  ---
677
185
 
678
- ## 📈 Roadmap
679
-
680
- ### Completed
186
+ ## License
681
187
 
682
- - **v1.1.0** - Vortex Framework repositioning (Emma + Wade)
683
- - ✅ **v1.2.0** - All 7 workflows implemented (56 files)
684
- - ✅ **v1.3.x** - Update/migration system with backup and rollback
685
- - ✅ **v1.4.0** - Architecture refactor (single source of truth, project root detection, safer migrations)
686
- - ✅ **v1.4.1** - Industrial-grade tooling (183 tests, CI/CD, ESLint, bmad-doctor, publish-on-tag)
687
- - ✅ **v1.5.0** - Wave 2: Isla + Max agents, 13 workflows, 4 Vortex streams
188
+ MIT License see [LICENSE](LICENSE)
688
189
 
689
- ### Future (v1.6.0 / v2.0.0+)
190
+ ## Acknowledgments
690
191
 
691
- - 📋 Wave 3: Synthesize, Hypothesize, Sensitize streams (3 more agents)
692
- - 📋 Data-driven agent/workflow registry (replace hardcoded arrays)
693
-
694
- - 📋 Multi-agent collaboration patterns
695
- - 📋 Cross-agent workflow integration
696
- - 📋 Analytics and reporting
697
- - 📋 Community agent contributions
698
-
699
- ---
700
-
701
- ## 🤝 Contributing
702
-
703
- We welcome contributions! Areas where we need help:
704
-
705
- **Agent Development:**
706
- - New domain-specialized agents
707
- - Workflow improvements
708
- - Template enhancements
709
-
710
- **Testing:**
711
- - P1/P2 test execution
712
- - Edge case testing
713
- - Performance testing
714
-
715
- **Documentation:**
716
- - User guides
717
- - Tutorials
718
- - Video walkthroughs
719
- - Translation (internationalization)
720
-
721
- **Integration:**
722
- - BMAD CLI integration
723
- - IDE plugins
724
- - Third-party tool integrations
725
-
726
- **See:** CONTRIBUTING.md (coming soon)
727
-
728
- ---
729
-
730
- ## 💼 Business Value
731
-
732
- ### For Product Managers & Strategists (Emma)
733
-
734
- **Before:**
735
- - Unclear problem definition
736
- - Assumptions presented as facts
737
- - No validation plan for strategy
738
- - Weeks of strategic discussion
739
-
740
- **After (v1.5.0):**
741
- - Clear problem space framing: 1-2 hours
742
- - Explicit assumption mapping
743
- - Built-in validation planning
744
- - Strategic alignment in days
745
-
746
- **Value:** Faster strategic clarity, reduced risk of building the wrong thing
747
-
748
- ### For UX Researchers & Design Teams (Isla)
749
-
750
- **Before:**
751
- - Ad-hoc user research with no structure
752
- - Empathy maps based on assumptions, not evidence
753
- - Interviews without clear research goals
754
- - User insights scattered across documents
755
-
756
- **After (v1.5.0):**
757
- - Structured discovery research: 2-4 hours per activity
758
- - Evidence-based empathy maps grounded in real user data
759
- - Interview guides with clear goals and synthesis
760
- - Centralized user insights in standardized artifacts
761
-
762
- **Value:** Deeper user understanding, research-backed design decisions, reduced rework from wrong assumptions
763
-
764
- ### For Innovation Teams (Wade)
765
-
766
- **Before:**
767
- - Long development cycles before user feedback
768
- - High investment in unvalidated ideas
769
- - No structured experiment process
770
- - 6-12 months to market validation
771
-
772
- **After (v1.5.0):**
773
- - Rapid experiment design: 2-3 hours
774
- - Minimal investment in learning
775
- - Structured Build-Measure-Learn cycles
776
- - 2-4 weeks to validated learning
777
-
778
- **Value:** 70-80% faster validation, 90% lower validation cost, data-driven decisions
779
-
780
- ### For Leadership & Decision Makers (Max)
781
-
782
- **Before:**
783
- - Experiment results lost or poorly documented
784
- - Pivot/persevere decisions based on gut feeling
785
- - No systematic way to capture validated learnings
786
- - Teams unsure which problem area to focus on next
787
-
788
- **After (v1.5.0):**
789
- - Structured learning cards capturing evidence and decisions
790
- - Evidence-based pivot/patch/persevere framework
791
- - Accumulated organizational knowledge from experiments
792
- - Vortex navigation recommendations based on gap analysis
793
-
794
- **Value:** Institutional learning, faster strategic pivots, evidence-driven portfolio decisions
795
-
796
- ### For Startups & Product Teams
797
-
798
- **The Complete Vortex Flow:**
799
- - Emma: Strategic framing and problem-solution fit
800
- - Isla: User empathy and evidence-based understanding
801
- - Wade: Validated learning and product-market fit
802
- - Max: Systematic decisions and strategic navigation
803
- - BMAD Core: Implementation and delivery
804
-
805
- **Impact:**
806
- - Validate before building (avoid waste)
807
- - Understand users before designing (reduce rework)
808
- - Learn fast, pivot faster (reduce risk)
809
- - Data-driven decisions (evidence over opinions)
810
-
811
- ---
812
-
813
- ## 📊 Success Metrics
814
-
815
- ### Emma (Operational Metrics)
816
-
817
- **Adoption (Target):**
818
- - 50+ teams using Emma for strategic contextualization
819
- - 80%+ complete the full 6-step workflow
820
- - NPS ≥8
821
-
822
- **Quality (Target):**
823
- - 90%+ lean personas grounded in research evidence
824
- - 95%+ artifacts include all required sections (assumptions, validation plan)
825
-
826
- **Performance (Measured):**
827
- - Complete workflow: 30-60 minutes
828
- - Artifact generation: <5 seconds
829
-
830
- ### Isla (Operational Metrics)
831
-
832
- **Adoption (Target):**
833
- - 50+ teams using Isla for user discovery and empathy
834
- - 80%+ complete the full workflow for each activity
835
- - NPS ≥8
836
-
837
- **Quality (Target):**
838
- - 90%+ empathy maps grounded in real user data (not assumptions)
839
- - 95%+ interview guides include clear research goals and synthesis
840
- - 85%+ discovery reports include actionable insights with evidence
841
-
842
- **Performance (Measured):**
843
- - Complete empathy map: 30-45 minutes
844
- - Complete interview workflow: 45-90 minutes
845
- - Complete discovery research: 60-120 minutes
846
-
847
- ### Wade (Operational Metrics)
848
-
849
- **Adoption (Target):**
850
- - 50+ teams using Wade for lean experiments
851
- - 80%+ complete the full 6-step workflow
852
- - NPS ≥8
853
-
854
- **Quality (Target):**
855
- - 90%+ experiments include clear hypothesis and success metrics
856
- - 95%+ artifacts include pivot-or-persevere decision criteria
857
- - 85%+ pass validated learning checklist
858
-
859
- **Performance (Measured):**
860
- - Complete workflow: 45-90 minutes
861
- - Artifact generation: <5 seconds
862
-
863
- ### Max (Operational Metrics)
864
-
865
- **Adoption (Target):**
866
- - 50+ teams using Max for learning capture and decisions
867
- - 80%+ complete the full workflow for each activity
868
- - NPS ≥8
869
-
870
- **Quality (Target):**
871
- - 90%+ learning cards link back to specific experiment evidence
872
- - 95%+ pivot/patch/persevere decisions include quantitative thresholds
873
- - 85%+ vortex navigation recommendations cite evidence gaps
874
-
875
- **Performance (Measured):**
876
- - Complete learning card: 20-30 minutes
877
- - Complete pivot/patch/persevere: 30-60 minutes
878
- - Complete vortex navigation: 30-45 minutes
879
-
880
- ### Project-Wide (Target Post-Launch)
881
-
882
- **Adoption:**
883
- - 100+ teams using BMAD-Enhanced agents
884
- - 4/4 Vortex agents in production ✅ (Wave 2)
885
- - Community agents contributed
886
-
887
- **Quality:**
888
- - 100% P0 test pass rate for all agents
889
- - All quality gates passed before release
890
- - 180+ automated tests across unit and integration suites
891
-
892
- ---
893
-
894
- ## 🔍 Sample Output
895
-
896
- ### Emma Lean Persona Artifact
897
-
898
- Emma generates comprehensive lean personas with:
899
-
900
- **Executive Summary:**
901
- - Jobs-to-be-done identification
902
- - Top riskiest assumptions
903
- - Validation plan priorities
904
-
905
- **Detailed Sections:**
906
- - Target user profile (demographics, context, goals)
907
- - Jobs-to-be-done (functional, emotional, social)
908
- - Pain points (prioritized: HIGH/MEDIUM/LOW)
909
- - Current alternatives and workarounds
910
- - Riskiest assumptions (ranked by impact and uncertainty)
911
-
912
- **Validation Planning:**
913
- - Which assumptions to test first
914
- - Suggested experiment types
915
- - Success/failure criteria
916
-
917
- **Assumption Prioritization Matrix:**
918
- | Assumption | Risk Level | Experiment Type | Priority |
919
- |------------|-----------|-----------------|----------|
920
- | Users want X | HIGH | Interview | P0 |
921
-
922
- **See:** [Emma User Guide](_bmad-output/vortex-artifacts/EMMA-USER-GUIDE.md) for examples
923
-
924
- ### Wade MVP Specification Artifact
925
-
926
- Wade generates comprehensive MVP specs with:
927
-
928
- **Executive Summary:**
929
- - Riskiest assumption to test
930
- - MVP type and scope
931
- - Build-Measure-Learn cycle plan
932
-
933
- **Detailed Sections:**
934
- - Hypothesis statement (testable, falsifiable)
935
- - MVP scope (minimum needed to test assumption)
936
- - Success metrics (quantitative thresholds)
937
- - Measurement plan (how to collect data)
938
- - Timeline and resource requirements
939
-
940
- **Experiment Design:**
941
- - Target audience and sample size
942
- - Data collection methods
943
- - Analysis approach
944
- - Pivot-or-persevere decision criteria
945
-
946
- **Decision Framework:**
947
- - Evidence thresholds for persevere
948
- - Evidence thresholds for pivot
949
- - Kill criteria
950
-
951
- **See:** [Wade User Guide](_bmad-output/vortex-artifacts/WADE-USER-GUIDE.md) for examples
952
-
953
- ### Isla Empathy Map Artifact
954
-
955
- Isla generates evidence-based empathy maps with:
956
-
957
- **User Profile:**
958
- - Target user segment and context
959
- - Research methods used (interviews, observation, surveys)
960
-
961
- **Empathy Quadrants:**
962
- - Says: Direct quotes and statements from users
963
- - Thinks: Inferred thoughts, beliefs, and mental models
964
- - Does: Observable behaviors and actions
965
- - Feels: Emotional states and reactions
966
-
967
- **Pain & Gain Analysis:**
968
- - Pain points (prioritized: HIGH/MEDIUM/LOW)
969
- - Gains and desired outcomes
970
- - Gaps between current state and desired state
971
-
972
- **Synthesis:**
973
- - Key insights from the empathy mapping exercise
974
- - Assumptions validated or invalidated
975
- - Recommended next steps (further research, experiments, design)
976
-
977
- **See:** [Isla User Guide](_bmad-output/vortex-artifacts/ISLA-USER-GUIDE.md) for examples
978
-
979
- ### Max Learning Card Artifact
980
-
981
- Max generates structured learning cards with:
982
-
983
- **Experiment Context:**
984
- - Hypothesis tested and experiment type
985
- - Link to original experiment (Wade artifacts)
986
- - Timeline and scope
987
-
988
- **Results & Analysis:**
989
- - Raw results and data collected
990
- - Statistical significance and confidence level
991
- - What worked, what didn't, and surprises
992
-
993
- **Validated Learning:**
994
- - What was learned (stated as validated or invalidated hypothesis)
995
- - Evidence strength (strong/moderate/weak)
996
- - Implications for product strategy
997
-
998
- **Decision & Next Steps:**
999
- - Pivot, patch, or persevere recommendation
1000
- - Specific actions and owners
1001
- - Impact on other Vortex streams
1002
-
1003
- **See:** [Max User Guide](_bmad-output/vortex-artifacts/MAX-USER-GUIDE.md) for examples
1004
-
1005
- ---
1006
-
1007
- ## 🎓 Learning Resources
1008
-
1009
- ### For Users
1010
-
1011
- **Emma (Strategic Contextualization):**
1012
- - **[Emma User Guide](_bmad-output/vortex-artifacts/EMMA-USER-GUIDE.md)** - Complete guide with examples
1013
- - Emma's chat mode (CH command) - Ask Emma questions about lean personas, product vision, and scope
1014
-
1015
- **Isla (Discovery & Empathy):**
1016
- - **[Isla User Guide](_bmad-output/vortex-artifacts/ISLA-USER-GUIDE.md)** - Complete guide with examples
1017
- - Isla's chat mode (CH command) - Ask Isla questions about empathy maps, interviews, and user discovery
1018
-
1019
- **Wade (Lean Experiments):**
1020
- - **[Wade User Guide](_bmad-output/vortex-artifacts/WADE-USER-GUIDE.md)** - Complete guide with examples
1021
- - Wade's chat mode (CH command) - Ask Wade questions about MVPs, experiments, and validated learning
1022
-
1023
- **Max (Learning & Decisions):**
1024
- - **[Max User Guide](_bmad-output/vortex-artifacts/MAX-USER-GUIDE.md)** - Complete guide with examples
1025
- - Max's chat mode (CH command) - Ask Max questions about learning cards, decisions, and Vortex navigation
1026
-
1027
- ### For Developers
1028
-
1029
- - **[BMAD Agent Architecture Framework](_bmad-output/GENERIC-AGENT-INTEGRATION-FRAMEWORK.md)** - How to build agents
1030
- - **[Emma Reference Implementation](_bmad-output/EMMA-REFERENCE-IMPLEMENTATION-COMPLETE.md)** - Detailed walkthrough
1031
- - **[Test Design Document](_bmad-output/test-artifacts/test-design/emma-agent-verification-test-design.md)** - How to test agents
1032
-
1033
- ### For Stakeholders
1034
-
1035
- - **[Project Status Update](_bmad-output/PROJECT-STATUS-UPDATE.md)** - Current progress
1036
- - **[CHANGELOG.md](CHANGELOG.md)** - Complete version history
1037
- - **[Emma Test Results](_bmad-output/test-artifacts/emma-tests/emma-p0-test-results.md)** - Emma quality validation
1038
- - **[Wade Test Results](_bmad-output/test-artifacts/wade-tests/wade-p0-test-execution.md)** - Wade quality validation
1039
- - Isla and Max P0 test results - Planned for v1.5.1
1040
-
1041
- ---
1042
-
1043
- ## 🏛️ Architecture Principles
1044
-
1045
- ### 1. Domain Specialization Over Generic Tools
1046
-
1047
- Each agent brings deep expertise in a specific domain (strategic framing, lean experimentation) rather than generic capabilities.
1048
-
1049
- ### 2. Standard Interface, Diverse Expertise
1050
-
1051
- All agents use BMAD Agent Architecture Framework for consistency, but each has unique workflows and knowledge.
1052
-
1053
- ### 3. Research-Driven Design
1054
-
1055
- Workflows based on proven frameworks (Jobs-to-be-Done, Lean Startup, Build-Measure-Learn).
1056
-
1057
- ### 4. Test-First Development
1058
-
1059
- 100% P0 test coverage required before operational approval. Emma set the standard.
1060
-
1061
- ### 5. Documentation as First-Class Citizen
1062
-
1063
- Comprehensive user guides required for each agent. Users should be able to self-serve.
1064
-
1065
- ### 6. Error Handling from Day One
1066
-
1067
- Clear, actionable error messages. Users should never be confused about what went wrong or how to fix it.
1068
-
1069
- ---
1070
-
1071
- ## 📜 License
1072
-
1073
- MIT License - see [LICENSE](LICENSE)
1074
-
1075
- ---
1076
-
1077
- ## 🙏 Acknowledgments
1078
-
1079
- Built on:
1080
- - **[BMAD Method v6.0.0](https://github.com/bmadhub/bmad)** - Foundation for agent architecture
1081
- - **Claude (Anthropic)** - AI reasoning and agent development
1082
- - **Open Source Community** - Testing, feedback, contributions
1083
-
1084
- **Special Thanks:**
1085
- - Murat (tea agent) - Test architecture and validation
1086
- - BMAD Core Team - Framework and infrastructure
1087
-
1088
- ---
1089
-
1090
- ## 📞 Contact
1091
-
1092
- **Project Lead:** Amalik Amriou
1093
- **Repository:** [github.com/yourusername/BMAD-Enhanced](https://github.com/yourusername/BMAD-Enhanced)
1094
- **Documentation:** `_bmad-output/`
1095
- **Issues:** [GitHub Issues](https://github.com/yourusername/BMAD-Enhanced/issues)
1096
-
1097
- ---
1098
-
1099
- ## ❓ FAQ
1100
-
1101
- ### Is this the same as the multi-framework orchestration project?
1102
-
1103
- **No.** This project pivoted from multi-framework orchestration (Quint + DesignOS + BMAD + AgentOS) to focused domain-specialized agents within BMAD.
1104
-
1105
- **Original vision (archived):** [ORIGINAL-VISION-README.md](_bmad-output/planning-artifacts/ORIGINAL-VISION-README.md)
1106
-
1107
- **Current approach:** Vortex Framework with 4 specialized agents (Emma, Isla, Wade, Max) using BMAD Agent Architecture Framework.
1108
-
1109
- ### What happened to empathy mapping and wireframing?
1110
-
1111
- **They were repositioned in v1.1.0.** Emma and Wade now focus on Lean Startup validation rather than traditional design deliverables.
1112
-
1113
- **Old positioning (v1.0.x):**
1114
- - Emma: Empathy Mapping Specialist
1115
- - Wade: Wireframe Design Specialist
1116
-
1117
- **New positioning (v1.1.0+):**
1118
- - Emma: Contextualization Expert (strategic framing, lean personas, product vision)
1119
- - Wade: Lean Experiments Specialist (MVPs, experiments, proof-of-concept/value)
1120
-
1121
- **Why?** To create clear differentiation from BMAD core agents (Maya for design, Sally for quality) and focus on the critical pre-implementation validation phase.
1122
-
1123
- ### Can I use agents independently?
1124
-
1125
- **Yes!** Each agent works standalone:
1126
- - Use Emma alone for strategic framing and problem space definition
1127
- - Use Isla alone for user research and empathy mapping
1128
- - Use Wade alone for experiment design and validation
1129
- - Use Max alone for learning capture and decision-making
1130
- - Use all four together for the complete Vortex flow: Contextualize → Empathize → Externalize → Systematize
1131
-
1132
- ### Are the workflows ready?
1133
-
1134
- **Yes! All 13 workflows are fully implemented and ready to use:**
1135
-
1136
- **Emma (Contextualize):** lean-persona, product-vision, contextualize-scope
1137
- **Isla (Empathize):** empathy-map, user-interview, user-discovery
1138
- **Wade (Externalize):** mvp, lean-experiment, proof-of-concept, proof-of-value
1139
- **Max (Systematize):** learning-card, pivot-patch-persevere, vortex-navigation
1140
-
1141
- Each workflow includes templates, step files, and comprehensive guidance.
1142
-
1143
- ### How is this different from BMAD core agents?
1144
-
1145
- **Pre-implementation validation vs. implementation.**
1146
-
1147
- **BMAD-Enhanced (Vortex):** Pre-implementation - validate before building
1148
- - Emma: Strategic framing (what problem should we solve?)
1149
- - Isla: User empathy (who are our users and what do they need?)
1150
- - Wade: Validated learning (should we build this?)
1151
- - Max: Systematic decisions (what did we learn? what's next?)
1152
-
1153
- **BMAD Core:** Implementation - build and deliver
1154
- - Maya: Solution design (how should we solve it?)
1155
- - Dev/Arch: Implementation
1156
- - Sally/QA: Quality validation (are we building it well?)
1157
-
1158
- **Flow:** Emma → Isla → Wade → Max → BMAD Core agents for implementation
1159
-
1160
- ### What's the recommended order for the agents?
1161
-
1162
- **Follow the Vortex flow, but jump in wherever you are:**
1163
-
1164
- 1. **Emma (Contextualize)** - Start here if you're defining a new product or problem space
1165
- 2. **Isla (Empathize)** - Start here if you know the problem but need to understand users better
1166
- 3. **Wade (Externalize)** - Start here if you have hypotheses ready to test with users
1167
- 4. **Max (Systematize)** - Start here if you have experiment results and need to decide next steps
1168
-
1169
- You don't have to be linear — Max's Vortex Navigation workflow helps you identify which stream needs attention based on your current evidence gaps.
1170
-
1171
- ### What's coming in Wave 3?
1172
-
1173
- Wave 3 (v1.6.0) will add the remaining 3 Vortex streams:
1174
- - **Synthesize** - Pattern recognition and insight synthesis across research
1175
- - **Hypothesize** - Structured hypothesis generation from insights
1176
- - **Sensitize** - Stakeholder alignment and organizational buy-in
1177
-
1178
- This will complete the full 7-stream Vortex Framework.
192
+ - [BMAD Method v6.0.0](https://github.com/bmadhub/bmad) Foundation for agent architecture
193
+ - Claude (Anthropic) AI reasoning and agent development
194
+ - Murat (tea agent) — Test architecture and validation
195
+ - BMAD Core Team — Framework and infrastructure
1179
196
 
1180
197
  ---
1181
198
 
1182
199
  <div align="center">
1183
200
 
1184
- **BMAD-Enhanced - Vortex Framework**
1185
-
1186
- *Contextualize, Empathize, Externalize, and Systematize for Lean Startup Validation*
1187
-
1188
- [Get Started](#quick-start) • [Documentation](#documentation) • [Roadmap](#roadmap)
1189
-
1190
- **Current Status:** ✅ v1.5.0 Stable - 4 Vortex Agents, 13 Workflows
201
+ **Vortex Pattern** *Validate before you build*
1191
202
 
1192
- Made with ❤️ by the BMAD-Enhanced community
203
+ [Get Started](#quick-start) | [Agents](docs/agents.md) | [Docs](#documentation) | [Roadmap](#roadmap)
1193
204
 
1194
205
  </div>