aigroup-workflow 1.0.0

package/skills/jarvis/engineering-team/engineering/api-design-reviewer/scripts/api_scorecard.py

@@ -0,0 +1,1661 @@
+#!/usr/bin/env python3
+"""
+API Scorecard - Comprehensive API design quality assessment tool.
+
+This script evaluates API designs across multiple dimensions and generates
+a detailed scorecard with letter grades and improvement recommendations.
+
+Scoring Dimensions:
+- Consistency (30%): Naming conventions, response patterns, structural consistency
+- Documentation (20%): Completeness and clarity of API documentation  
+- Security (20%): Authentication, authorization, and security best practices
+- Usability (15%): Ease of use, discoverability, and developer experience
+- Performance (15%): Caching, pagination, and efficiency patterns
+
+Generates letter grades (A-F) with detailed breakdowns and actionable recommendations.
+"""
+
+import argparse
+import json
+import re
+import sys
+from typing import Any, Dict, List, Optional, Set, Tuple
+from dataclasses import dataclass, field
+from enum import Enum
+import math
+
+
+class ScoreCategory(Enum):
+    """Scoring categories."""
+    CONSISTENCY = "consistency"
+    DOCUMENTATION = "documentation"
+    SECURITY = "security"
+    USABILITY = "usability"
+    PERFORMANCE = "performance"
+
+
+@dataclass
+class CategoryScore:
+    """Score for a specific category."""
+    category: ScoreCategory
+    score: float  # 0-100
+    max_score: float  # Usually 100
+    weight: float  # Percentage weight in overall score
+    issues: List[str] = field(default_factory=list)
+    recommendations: List[str] = field(default_factory=list)
+    
+    @property
+    def letter_grade(self) -> str:
+        """Convert score to letter grade."""
+        if self.score >= 90:
+            return "A"
+        elif self.score >= 80:
+            return "B"
+        elif self.score >= 70:
+            return "C"
+        elif self.score >= 60:
+            return "D"
+        else:
+            return "F"
+    
+    @property
+    def weighted_score(self) -> float:
+        """Calculate weighted contribution to overall score."""
+        return (self.score / 100.0) * self.weight
+
+
+@dataclass
+class APIScorecard:
+    """Complete API scorecard with all category scores."""
+    category_scores: Dict[ScoreCategory, CategoryScore] = field(default_factory=dict)
+    overall_score: float = 0.0
+    overall_grade: str = "F"
+    total_endpoints: int = 0
+    api_info: Dict[str, Any] = field(default_factory=dict)
+    
+    def calculate_overall_score(self) -> None:
+        """Calculate overall weighted score and grade."""
+        self.overall_score = sum(score.weighted_score for score in self.category_scores.values())
+        
+        if self.overall_score >= 90:
+            self.overall_grade = "A"
+        elif self.overall_score >= 80:
+            self.overall_grade = "B"
+        elif self.overall_score >= 70:
+            self.overall_grade = "C"
+        elif self.overall_score >= 60:
+            self.overall_grade = "D"
+        else:
+            self.overall_grade = "F"
+    
+    def get_top_recommendations(self, limit: int = 5) -> List[str]:
+        """Get top recommendations across all categories."""
+        all_recommendations = []
+        for category_score in self.category_scores.values():
+            for rec in category_score.recommendations:
+                all_recommendations.append(f"{category_score.category.value.title()}: {rec}")
+        
+        # Sort by category weight (highest impact first)
+        weighted_recs = []
+        for category_score in sorted(self.category_scores.values(), 
+                                   key=lambda x: x.weight, reverse=True):
+            for rec in category_score.recommendations[:2]:  # Top 2 per category
+                weighted_recs.append(f"{category_score.category.value.title()}: {rec}")
+        
+        return weighted_recs[:limit]
+
+
+class APIScoringEngine:
+    """Main API scoring engine."""
+    
+    def __init__(self):
+        self.scorecard = APIScorecard()
+        self.spec: Optional[Dict] = None
+        
+        # Regex patterns for validation
+        self.kebab_case_pattern = re.compile(r'^[a-z]+(?:-[a-z0-9]+)*$')
+        self.camel_case_pattern = re.compile(r'^[a-z][a-zA-Z0-9]*$')
+        self.pascal_case_pattern = re.compile(r'^[A-Z][a-zA-Z0-9]*$')
+        
+        # HTTP methods
+        self.http_methods = {'GET', 'POST', 'PUT', 'PATCH', 'DELETE', 'HEAD', 'OPTIONS'}
+        
+        # Category weights (must sum to 100)
+        self.category_weights = {
+            ScoreCategory.CONSISTENCY: 30.0,
+            ScoreCategory.DOCUMENTATION: 20.0,
+            ScoreCategory.SECURITY: 20.0,
+            ScoreCategory.USABILITY: 15.0,
+            ScoreCategory.PERFORMANCE: 15.0
+        }
+    
+    def score_api(self, spec: Dict[str, Any]) -> APIScorecard:
+        """Generate comprehensive API scorecard."""
+        self.spec = spec
+        self.scorecard = APIScorecard()
+        
+        # Extract basic API info
+        self._extract_api_info()
+        
+        # Score each category
+        self._score_consistency()
+        self._score_documentation()
+        self._score_security()
+        self._score_usability()
+        self._score_performance()
+        
+        # Calculate overall score
+        self.scorecard.calculate_overall_score()
+        
+        return self.scorecard
+    
+    def _extract_api_info(self) -> None:
+        """Extract basic API information."""
+        info = self.spec.get('info', {})
+        paths = self.spec.get('paths', {})
+        
+        self.scorecard.api_info = {
+            'title': info.get('title', 'Unknown API'),
+            'version': info.get('version', ''),
+            'description': info.get('description', ''),
+            'total_paths': len(paths),
+            'openapi_version': self.spec.get('openapi', self.spec.get('swagger', ''))
+        }
+        
+        # Count total endpoints
+        endpoint_count = 0
+        for path_obj in paths.values():
+            if isinstance(path_obj, dict):
+                endpoint_count += len([m for m in path_obj.keys() 
+                                     if m.upper() in self.http_methods])
+        
+        self.scorecard.total_endpoints = endpoint_count
+    
+    def _score_consistency(self) -> None:
+        """Score API consistency (30% weight)."""
+        category = ScoreCategory.CONSISTENCY
+        score = CategoryScore(
+            category=category,
+            score=0.0,
+            max_score=100.0,
+            weight=self.category_weights[category]
+        )
+        
+        consistency_checks = [
+            self._check_naming_consistency(),
+            self._check_response_consistency(),
+            self._check_error_format_consistency(),
+            self._check_parameter_consistency(),
+            self._check_url_structure_consistency(),
+            self._check_http_method_consistency(),
+            self._check_status_code_consistency()
+        ]
+        
+        # Average the consistency scores
+        valid_scores = [s for s in consistency_checks if s is not None]
+        if valid_scores:
+            score.score = sum(valid_scores) / len(valid_scores)
+        
+        # Add specific recommendations based on low scores
+        if score.score < 70:
+            score.recommendations.extend([
+                "Review naming conventions across all endpoints and schemas",
+                "Standardize response formats and error structures",
+                "Ensure consistent HTTP method usage patterns"
+            ])
+        elif score.score < 85:
+            score.recommendations.extend([
+                "Minor consistency improvements needed in naming or response formats",
+                "Consider creating API design guidelines document"
+            ])
+        
+        self.scorecard.category_scores[category] = score
+    
+    def _check_naming_consistency(self) -> float:
+        """Check naming convention consistency."""
+        paths = self.spec.get('paths', {})
+        schemas = self.spec.get('components', {}).get('schemas', {})
+        
+        total_checks = 0
+        passed_checks = 0
+        
+        # Check path naming (should be kebab-case)
+        for path in paths.keys():
+            segments = [seg for seg in path.split('/') if seg and not seg.startswith('{')]
+            for segment in segments:
+                total_checks += 1
+                if self.kebab_case_pattern.match(segment) or re.match(r'^v\d+$', segment):
+                    passed_checks += 1
+        
+        # Check schema naming (should be PascalCase)
+        for schema_name in schemas.keys():
+            total_checks += 1
+            if self.pascal_case_pattern.match(schema_name):
+                passed_checks += 1
+        
+        # Check property naming within schemas
+        for schema in schemas.values():
+            if isinstance(schema, dict) and 'properties' in schema:
+                for prop_name in schema['properties'].keys():
+                    total_checks += 1
+                    if self.camel_case_pattern.match(prop_name):
+                        passed_checks += 1
+        
+        return (passed_checks / total_checks * 100) if total_checks > 0 else 100
+    
+    def _check_response_consistency(self) -> float:
+        """Check response format consistency."""
+        paths = self.spec.get('paths', {})
+        
+        response_patterns = []
+        total_responses = 0
+        
+        for path_obj in paths.values():
+            if not isinstance(path_obj, dict):
+                continue
+                
+            for method, operation in path_obj.items():
+                if method.upper() not in self.http_methods or not isinstance(operation, dict):
+                    continue
+                
+                responses = operation.get('responses', {})
+                for status_code, response in responses.items():
+                    if not isinstance(response, dict):
+                        continue
+                        
+                    total_responses += 1
+                    content = response.get('content', {})
+                    
+                    # Analyze response structure
+                    for media_type, media_obj in content.items():
+                        schema = media_obj.get('schema', {})
+                        pattern = self._extract_schema_pattern(schema)
+                        response_patterns.append(pattern)
+        
+        # Calculate consistency by comparing patterns
+        if not response_patterns:
+            return 100
+        
+        pattern_counts = {}
+        for pattern in response_patterns:
+            pattern_key = json.dumps(pattern, sort_keys=True)
+            pattern_counts[pattern_key] = pattern_counts.get(pattern_key, 0) + 1
+        
+        # Most common pattern should dominate for good consistency
+        max_count = max(pattern_counts.values()) if pattern_counts else 0
+        consistency_ratio = max_count / len(response_patterns) if response_patterns else 1
+        
+        return consistency_ratio * 100
+    
+    def _extract_schema_pattern(self, schema: Dict[str, Any]) -> Dict[str, Any]:
+        """Extract a pattern from a schema for consistency checking."""
+        if not isinstance(schema, dict):
+            return {}
+        
+        pattern = {
+            'type': schema.get('type'),
+            'has_properties': 'properties' in schema,
+            'has_items': 'items' in schema,
+            'required_count': len(schema.get('required', [])),
+            'property_count': len(schema.get('properties', {}))
+        }
+        
+        return pattern
+    
+    def _check_error_format_consistency(self) -> float:
+        """Check error response format consistency."""
+        paths = self.spec.get('paths', {})
+        error_responses = []
+        
+        for path_obj in paths.values():
+            if not isinstance(path_obj, dict):
+                continue
+                
+            for method, operation in path_obj.items():
+                if method.upper() not in self.http_methods:
+                    continue
+                
+                responses = operation.get('responses', {})
+                for status_code, response in responses.items():
+                    try:
+                        code_int = int(status_code)
+                        if code_int >= 400:  # Error responses
+                            content = response.get('content', {})
+                            for media_type, media_obj in content.items():
+                                schema = media_obj.get('schema', {})
+                                error_responses.append(self._extract_schema_pattern(schema))
+                    except ValueError:
+                        continue
+        
+        if not error_responses:
+            return 80  # No error responses defined - somewhat concerning
+        
+        # Check consistency of error response formats
+        pattern_counts = {}
+        for pattern in error_responses:
+            pattern_key = json.dumps(pattern, sort_keys=True)
+            pattern_counts[pattern_key] = pattern_counts.get(pattern_key, 0) + 1
+        
+        max_count = max(pattern_counts.values()) if pattern_counts else 0
+        consistency_ratio = max_count / len(error_responses) if error_responses else 1
+        
+        return consistency_ratio * 100
+    
+    def _check_parameter_consistency(self) -> float:
+        """Check parameter naming and usage consistency."""
+        paths = self.spec.get('paths', {})
+        
+        query_params = []
+        path_params = []
+        header_params = []
+        
+        for path_obj in paths.values():
+            if not isinstance(path_obj, dict):
+                continue
+                
+            for method, operation in path_obj.items():
+                if method.upper() not in self.http_methods:
+                    continue
+                
+                parameters = operation.get('parameters', [])
+                for param in parameters:
+                    if not isinstance(param, dict):
+                        continue
+                        
+                    param_name = param.get('name', '')
+                    param_in = param.get('in', '')
+                    
+                    if param_in == 'query':
+                        query_params.append(param_name)
+                    elif param_in == 'path':
+                        path_params.append(param_name)
+                    elif param_in == 'header':
+                        header_params.append(param_name)
+        
+        # Check naming consistency for each parameter type
+        scores = []
+        
+        # Query parameters should be camelCase or kebab-case
+        if query_params:
+            valid_query = sum(1 for p in query_params 
+                            if self.camel_case_pattern.match(p) or self.kebab_case_pattern.match(p))
+            scores.append((valid_query / len(query_params)) * 100)
+        
+        # Path parameters should be camelCase or kebab-case
+        if path_params:
+            valid_path = sum(1 for p in path_params 
+                           if self.camel_case_pattern.match(p) or self.kebab_case_pattern.match(p))
+            scores.append((valid_path / len(path_params)) * 100)
+        
+        return sum(scores) / len(scores) if scores else 100
+    
+    def _check_url_structure_consistency(self) -> float:
+        """Check URL structure and pattern consistency."""
+        paths = self.spec.get('paths', {})
+        
+        total_paths = len(paths)
+        if total_paths == 0:
+            return 0
+        
+        structure_score = 0
+        
+        # Check for consistent versioning
+        versioned_paths = 0
+        for path in paths.keys():
+            if re.search(r'/v\d+/', path):
+                versioned_paths += 1
+        
+        # Either all or none should be versioned for consistency
+        if versioned_paths == 0 or versioned_paths == total_paths:
+            structure_score += 25
+        elif versioned_paths > total_paths * 0.8:
+            structure_score += 20
+        
+        # Check for reasonable path depth
+        reasonable_depth = 0
+        for path in paths.keys():
+            segments = [seg for seg in path.split('/') if seg]
+            if 2 <= len(segments) <= 5:  # Reasonable depth
+                reasonable_depth += 1
+        
+        structure_score += (reasonable_depth / total_paths) * 25
+        
+        # Check for RESTful resource patterns
+        restful_patterns = 0
+        for path in paths.keys():
+            # Look for patterns like /resources/{id} or /resources
+            if re.match(r'^/[a-z-]+(/\{[^}]+\})?(/[a-z-]+)*$', path):
+                restful_patterns += 1
+        
+        structure_score += (restful_patterns / total_paths) * 30
+        
+        # Check for consistent trailing slash usage
+        with_slash = sum(1 for path in paths.keys() if path.endswith('/'))
+        without_slash = total_paths - with_slash
+        
+        # Either all or none should have trailing slashes
+        if with_slash == 0 or without_slash == 0:
+            structure_score += 20
+        elif min(with_slash, without_slash) < total_paths * 0.1:
+            structure_score += 15
+        
+        return min(structure_score, 100)
+    
+    def _check_http_method_consistency(self) -> float:
+        """Check HTTP method usage consistency."""
+        paths = self.spec.get('paths', {})
+        
+        method_usage = {}
+        total_operations = 0
+        
+        for path, path_obj in paths.items():
+            if not isinstance(path_obj, dict):
+                continue
+                
+            for method in path_obj.keys():
+                if method.upper() in self.http_methods:
+                    method_upper = method.upper()
+                    total_operations += 1
+                    
+                    # Analyze method usage patterns
+                    if method_upper not in method_usage:
+                        method_usage[method_upper] = {'count': 0, 'appropriate': 0}
+                    
+                    method_usage[method_upper]['count'] += 1
+                    
+                    # Check if method usage seems appropriate
+                    if self._is_method_usage_appropriate(path, method_upper, path_obj[method]):
+                        method_usage[method_upper]['appropriate'] += 1
+        
+        if total_operations == 0:
+            return 0
+        
+        # Calculate appropriateness score
+        total_appropriate = sum(data['appropriate'] for data in method_usage.values())
+        return (total_appropriate / total_operations) * 100
+    
+    def _is_method_usage_appropriate(self, path: str, method: str, operation: Dict) -> bool:
+        """Check if HTTP method usage is appropriate for the endpoint."""
+        # Simple heuristics for method appropriateness
+        has_request_body = 'requestBody' in operation
+        path_has_id = '{' in path and '}' in path
+        
+        if method == 'GET':
+            return not has_request_body  # GET should not have body
+        elif method == 'POST':
+            return not path_has_id  # POST typically for collections
+        elif method == 'PUT':
+            return path_has_id and has_request_body  # PUT for specific resources
+        elif method == 'PATCH':
+            return path_has_id  # PATCH for specific resources
+        elif method == 'DELETE':
+            return path_has_id  # DELETE for specific resources
+        
+        return True  # Default to appropriate for other methods
+    
+    def _check_status_code_consistency(self) -> float:
+        """Check HTTP status code usage consistency."""
+        paths = self.spec.get('paths', {})
+        
+        method_status_patterns = {}
+        total_operations = 0
+        
+        for path_obj in paths.values():
+            if not isinstance(path_obj, dict):
+                continue
+                
+            for method, operation in path_obj.items():
+                if method.upper() not in self.http_methods:
+                    continue
+                
+                total_operations += 1
+                responses = operation.get('responses', {})
+                status_codes = set(responses.keys())
+                
+                if method.upper() not in method_status_patterns:
+                    method_status_patterns[method.upper()] = []
+                
+                method_status_patterns[method.upper()].append(status_codes)
+        
+        if total_operations == 0:
+            return 0
+        
+        # Check consistency within each method type
+        consistency_scores = []
+        
+        for method, status_patterns in method_status_patterns.items():
+            if not status_patterns:
+                continue
+            
+            # Find common status codes for this method
+            all_codes = set()
+            for pattern in status_patterns:
+                all_codes.update(pattern)
+            
+            # Calculate how many operations use the most common codes
+            code_usage = {}
+            for code in all_codes:
+                code_usage[code] = sum(1 for pattern in status_patterns if code in pattern)
+            
+            # Score based on consistency of common status codes
+            if status_patterns:
+                avg_consistency = sum(
+                    len([code for code in pattern if code_usage.get(code, 0) > len(status_patterns) * 0.5]) 
+                    for pattern in status_patterns
+                ) / len(status_patterns)
+                
+                method_consistency = min(avg_consistency / 3.0 * 100, 100)  # Expect ~3 common codes
+                consistency_scores.append(method_consistency)
+        
+        return sum(consistency_scores) / len(consistency_scores) if consistency_scores else 100
+    
+    def _score_documentation(self) -> None:
+        """Score API documentation quality (20% weight)."""
+        category = ScoreCategory.DOCUMENTATION
+        score = CategoryScore(
+            category=category,
+            score=0.0,
+            max_score=100.0,
+            weight=self.category_weights[category]
+        )
+        
+        documentation_checks = [
+            self._check_api_level_documentation(),
+            self._check_endpoint_documentation(),
+            self._check_schema_documentation(),
+            self._check_parameter_documentation(),
+            self._check_response_documentation(),
+            self._check_example_coverage()
+        ]
+        
+        valid_scores = [s for s in documentation_checks if s is not None]
+        if valid_scores:
+            score.score = sum(valid_scores) / len(valid_scores)
+        
+        # Add recommendations based on score
+        if score.score < 60:
+            score.recommendations.extend([
+                "Add comprehensive descriptions to all API components",
+                "Include examples for complex operations and schemas",
+                "Document all parameters and response fields"
+            ])
+        elif score.score < 80:
+            score.recommendations.extend([
+                "Improve documentation completeness for some endpoints",
+                "Add more examples to enhance developer experience"
+            ])
+        
+        self.scorecard.category_scores[category] = score
+    
+    def _check_api_level_documentation(self) -> float:
+        """Check API-level documentation completeness."""
+        info = self.spec.get('info', {})
+        score = 0
+        
+        # Required fields
+        if info.get('title'):
+            score += 20
+        if info.get('version'):
+            score += 20
+        if info.get('description') and len(info['description']) > 20:
+            score += 30
+        
+        # Optional but recommended fields
+        if info.get('contact'):
+            score += 15
+        if info.get('license'):
+            score += 15
+        
+        return score
+    
+    def _check_endpoint_documentation(self) -> float:
+        """Check endpoint-level documentation completeness."""
+        paths = self.spec.get('paths', {})
+        
+        total_operations = 0
+        documented_operations = 0
+        
+        for path_obj in paths.values():
+            if not isinstance(path_obj, dict):
+                continue
+                
+            for method, operation in path_obj.items():
+                if method.upper() not in self.http_methods:
+                    continue
+                
+                total_operations += 1
+                doc_score = 0
+                
+                if operation.get('summary'):
+                    doc_score += 1
+                if operation.get('description') and len(operation['description']) > 20:
+                    doc_score += 1
+                if operation.get('operationId'):
+                    doc_score += 1
+                
+                # Consider it documented if it has at least 2/3 elements
+                if doc_score >= 2:
+                    documented_operations += 1
+        
+        return (documented_operations / total_operations * 100) if total_operations > 0 else 100
+    
+    def _check_schema_documentation(self) -> float:
+        """Check schema documentation completeness."""
+        schemas = self.spec.get('components', {}).get('schemas', {})
+        
+        if not schemas:
+            return 80  # No schemas to document
+        
+        total_schemas = len(schemas)
+        documented_schemas = 0
+        
+        for schema_name, schema in schemas.items():
+            if not isinstance(schema, dict):
+                continue
+            
+            doc_elements = 0
+            
+            # Schema-level description
+            if schema.get('description'):
+                doc_elements += 1
+            
+            # Property descriptions
+            properties = schema.get('properties', {})
+            if properties:
+                described_props = sum(1 for prop in properties.values() 
+                                    if isinstance(prop, dict) and prop.get('description'))
+                if described_props > len(properties) * 0.5:  # At least 50% documented
+                    doc_elements += 1
+            
+            # Examples
+            if schema.get('example') or any(
+                isinstance(prop, dict) and prop.get('example') 
+                for prop in properties.values()
+            ):
+                doc_elements += 1
+            
+            if doc_elements >= 2:
+                documented_schemas += 1
+        
+        return (documented_schemas / total_schemas * 100) if total_schemas > 0 else 100
+    
+    def _check_parameter_documentation(self) -> float:
+        """Check parameter documentation completeness."""
+        paths = self.spec.get('paths', {})
+        
+        total_params = 0
+        documented_params = 0
+        
+        for path_obj in paths.values():
+            if not isinstance(path_obj, dict):
+                continue
+                
+            for method, operation in path_obj.items():
+                if method.upper() not in self.http_methods:
+                    continue
+                
+                parameters = operation.get('parameters', [])
+                for param in parameters:
+                    if not isinstance(param, dict):
+                        continue
+                    
+                    total_params += 1
+                    
+                    doc_score = 0
+                    if param.get('description'):
+                        doc_score += 1
+                    if param.get('example') or (param.get('schema', {}).get('example')):
+                        doc_score += 1
+                    
+                    if doc_score >= 1:  # At least description
+                        documented_params += 1
+        
+        return (documented_params / total_params * 100) if total_params > 0 else 100
+    
+    def _check_response_documentation(self) -> float:
+        """Check response documentation completeness."""
+        paths = self.spec.get('paths', {})
+        
+        total_responses = 0
+        documented_responses = 0
+        
+        for path_obj in paths.values():
+            if not isinstance(path_obj, dict):
+                continue
+                
+            for method, operation in path_obj.items():
+                if method.upper() not in self.http_methods:
+                    continue
+                
+                responses = operation.get('responses', {})
+                for status_code, response in responses.items():
+                    if not isinstance(response, dict):
+                        continue
+                    
+                    total_responses += 1
+                    
+                    if response.get('description'):
+                        documented_responses += 1
+        
+        return (documented_responses / total_responses * 100) if total_responses > 0 else 100
+    
+    def _check_example_coverage(self) -> float:
+        """Check example coverage across the API."""
+        paths = self.spec.get('paths', {})
+        schemas = self.spec.get('components', {}).get('schemas', {})
+        
+        # Check examples in operations
+        total_operations = 0
+        operations_with_examples = 0
+        
+        for path_obj in paths.values():
+            if not isinstance(path_obj, dict):
+                continue
+                
+            for method, operation in path_obj.items():
+                if method.upper() not in self.http_methods:
+                    continue
+                
+                total_operations += 1
+                
+                has_example = False
+                
+                # Check request body examples
+                request_body = operation.get('requestBody', {})
+                if self._has_examples(request_body.get('content', {})):
+                    has_example = True
+                
+                # Check response examples
+                responses = operation.get('responses', {})
+                for response in responses.values():
+                    if isinstance(response, dict) and self._has_examples(response.get('content', {})):
+                        has_example = True
+                        break
+                
+                if has_example:
+                    operations_with_examples += 1
+        
+        # Check examples in schemas
+        total_schemas = len(schemas)
+        schemas_with_examples = 0
+        
+        for schema in schemas.values():
+            if isinstance(schema, dict) and self._schema_has_examples(schema):
+                schemas_with_examples += 1
+        
+        # Combine scores
+        operation_score = (operations_with_examples / total_operations * 100) if total_operations > 0 else 100
+        schema_score = (schemas_with_examples / total_schemas * 100) if total_schemas > 0 else 100
+        
+        return (operation_score + schema_score) / 2
+    
+    def _has_examples(self, content: Dict[str, Any]) -> bool:
+        """Check if content has examples."""
+        for media_type, media_obj in content.items():
+            if isinstance(media_obj, dict):
+                if media_obj.get('example') or media_obj.get('examples'):
+                    return True
+        return False
+    
+    def _schema_has_examples(self, schema: Dict[str, Any]) -> bool:
+        """Check if schema has examples."""
+        if schema.get('example'):
+            return True
+        
+        properties = schema.get('properties', {})
+        for prop in properties.values():
+            if isinstance(prop, dict) and prop.get('example'):
+                return True
+        
+        return False
+    
+    def _score_security(self) -> None:
+        """Score API security implementation (20% weight)."""
+        category = ScoreCategory.SECURITY
+        score = CategoryScore(
+            category=category,
+            score=0.0,
+            max_score=100.0,
+            weight=self.category_weights[category]
+        )
+        
+        security_checks = [
+            self._check_security_schemes(),
+            self._check_security_requirements(),
+            self._check_https_usage(),
+            self._check_authentication_patterns(),
+            self._check_sensitive_data_handling()
+        ]
+        
+        valid_scores = [s for s in security_checks if s is not None]
+        if valid_scores:
+            score.score = sum(valid_scores) / len(valid_scores)
+        
+        # Add recommendations
+        if score.score < 50:
+            score.recommendations.extend([
+                "Implement comprehensive security schemes (OAuth2, API keys, etc.)",
+                "Ensure all endpoints have appropriate security requirements",
+                "Add input validation and rate limiting patterns"
+            ])
+        elif score.score < 80:
+            score.recommendations.extend([
+                "Review security coverage for all endpoints",
+                "Consider additional security measures for sensitive operations"
+            ])
+        
+        self.scorecard.category_scores[category] = score
+    
+    def _check_security_schemes(self) -> float:
+        """Check security scheme definitions."""
+        security_schemes = self.spec.get('components', {}).get('securitySchemes', {})
+        
+        if not security_schemes:
+            return 20  # Very low score for no security
+        
+        score = 40  # Base score for having security schemes
+        
+        scheme_types = set()
+        for scheme in security_schemes.values():
+            if isinstance(scheme, dict):
+                scheme_type = scheme.get('type')
+                scheme_types.add(scheme_type)
+        
+        # Bonus for modern security schemes
+        if 'oauth2' in scheme_types:
+            score += 30
+        if 'apiKey' in scheme_types:
+            score += 15
+        if 'http' in scheme_types:
+            score += 15
+        
+        return min(score, 100)
+    
+    def _check_security_requirements(self) -> float:
+        """Check security requirement coverage."""
+        paths = self.spec.get('paths', {})
+        global_security = self.spec.get('security', [])
+        
+        total_operations = 0
+        secured_operations = 0
+        
+        for path_obj in paths.values():
+            if not isinstance(path_obj, dict):
+                continue
+                
+            for method, operation in path_obj.items():
+                if method.upper() not in self.http_methods:
+                    continue
+                
+                total_operations += 1
+                
+                # Check if operation has security requirements
+                operation_security = operation.get('security')
+                
+                if operation_security is not None:
+                    secured_operations += 1
+                elif global_security:
+                    secured_operations += 1
+        
+        return (secured_operations / total_operations * 100) if total_operations > 0 else 0
+    
+    def _check_https_usage(self) -> float:
+        """Check HTTPS enforcement."""
+        servers = self.spec.get('servers', [])
+        
+        if not servers:
+            return 60  # No servers defined - assume HTTPS
+        
+        https_servers = 0
+        for server in servers:
+            if isinstance(server, dict):
+                url = server.get('url', '')
+                if url.startswith('https://') or not url.startswith('http://'):
+                    https_servers += 1
+        
+        return (https_servers / len(servers) * 100) if servers else 100
+    
+    def _check_authentication_patterns(self) -> float:
+        """Check authentication pattern quality."""
+        security_schemes = self.spec.get('components', {}).get('securitySchemes', {})
+        
+        if not security_schemes:
+            return 0
+        
+        pattern_scores = []
+        
+        for scheme in security_schemes.values():
+            if not isinstance(scheme, dict):
+                continue
+            
+            scheme_type = scheme.get('type', '').lower()
+            
+            if scheme_type == 'oauth2':
+                # OAuth2 is highly recommended
+                flows = scheme.get('flows', {})
+                if flows:
+                    pattern_scores.append(95)
+                else:
+                    pattern_scores.append(80)
+            elif scheme_type == 'http':
+                scheme_scheme = scheme.get('scheme', '').lower()
+                if scheme_scheme == 'bearer':
+                    pattern_scores.append(85)
+                elif scheme_scheme == 'basic':
+                    pattern_scores.append(60)  # Less secure
+                else:
+                    pattern_scores.append(70)
+            elif scheme_type == 'apikey':
+                location = scheme.get('in', '').lower()
+                if location == 'header':
+                    pattern_scores.append(75)
+                else:
+                    pattern_scores.append(60)  # Query/cookie less secure
+            else:
+                pattern_scores.append(50)  # Unknown scheme
+        
+        return sum(pattern_scores) / len(pattern_scores) if pattern_scores else 0
+    
+    def _check_sensitive_data_handling(self) -> float:
+        """Check sensitive data handling patterns."""
+        # This is a simplified check - in reality would need more sophisticated analysis
+        schemas = self.spec.get('components', {}).get('schemas', {})
+        
+        score = 80  # Default good score
+        
+        # Look for potential sensitive fields without proper handling
+        sensitive_field_names = {'password', 'secret', 'token', 'key', 'ssn', 'credit_card'}
+        
+        for schema in schemas.values():
+            if not isinstance(schema, dict):
+                continue
+            
+            properties = schema.get('properties', {})
+            for prop_name, prop_def in properties.items():
+                if not isinstance(prop_def, dict):
+                    continue
+                
+                # Check for sensitive field names
+                if any(sensitive in prop_name.lower() for sensitive in sensitive_field_names):
+                    # Check if it's marked as sensitive (writeOnly, format: password, etc.)
+                    if not (prop_def.get('writeOnly') or 
+                           prop_def.get('format') == 'password' or
+                           'password' in prop_def.get('description', '').lower()):
+                        score -= 10  # Penalty for exposed sensitive field
+        
+        return max(score, 0)
+    
+    def _score_usability(self) -> None:
+        """Score API usability and developer experience (15% weight)."""
+        category = ScoreCategory.USABILITY
+        score = CategoryScore(
+            category=category,
+            score=0.0,
+            max_score=100.0,
+            weight=self.category_weights[category]
+        )
+        
+        usability_checks = [
+            self._check_discoverability(),
+            self._check_error_handling(),
+            self._check_filtering_and_searching(),
+            self._check_resource_relationships(),
+            self._check_developer_experience()
+        ]
+        
+        valid_scores = [s for s in usability_checks if s is not None]
+        if valid_scores:
+            score.score = sum(valid_scores) / len(valid_scores)
+        
+        # Add recommendations
+        if score.score < 60:
+            score.recommendations.extend([
+                "Improve error messages with actionable guidance",
+                "Add filtering and search capabilities to list endpoints",
+                "Enhance resource discoverability with better linking"
+            ])
+        elif score.score < 80:
+            score.recommendations.extend([
+                "Consider adding HATEOAS links for better discoverability",
+                "Enhance developer experience with better examples"
+            ])
+        
+        self.scorecard.category_scores[category] = score
+    
+    def _check_discoverability(self) -> float:
+        """Check API discoverability features."""
+        paths = self.spec.get('paths', {})
+        
+        # Look for root/discovery endpoints
+        has_root = '/' in paths or any(path == '/api' or path.startswith('/api/') for path in paths)
+        
+        # Look for HATEOAS patterns in responses
+        hateoas_score = 0
+        total_responses = 0
+        
+        for path_obj in paths.values():
+            if not isinstance(path_obj, dict):
+                continue
+                
+            for method, operation in path_obj.items():
+                if method.upper() not in self.http_methods:
+                    continue
+                
+                responses = operation.get('responses', {})
+                for response in responses.values():
+                    if not isinstance(response, dict):
+                        continue
+                    
+                    total_responses += 1
+                    
+                    # Look for link-like properties in response schemas
+                    content = response.get('content', {})
+                    for media_obj in content.values():
+                        schema = media_obj.get('schema', {})
+                        if self._has_link_properties(schema):
+                            hateoas_score += 1
+                            break
+        
+        discovery_score = 50 if has_root else 30
+        if total_responses > 0:
+            hateoas_ratio = hateoas_score / total_responses
+            discovery_score += hateoas_ratio * 50
+        
+        return min(discovery_score, 100)
+    
+    def _has_link_properties(self, schema: Dict[str, Any]) -> bool:
+        """Check if schema has link-like properties."""
+        if not isinstance(schema, dict):
+            return False
+        
+        properties = schema.get('properties', {})
+        link_indicators = {'links', '_links', 'href', 'url', 'self', 'next', 'prev'}
+        
+        return any(prop_name.lower() in link_indicators for prop_name in properties.keys())
+    
+    def _check_error_handling(self) -> float:
+        """Check error handling quality."""
+        paths = self.spec.get('paths', {})
+        
+        total_operations = 0
+        operations_with_errors = 0
+        detailed_error_responses = 0
+        
+        for path_obj in paths.values():
+            if not isinstance(path_obj, dict):
+                continue
+                
+            for method, operation in path_obj.items():
+                if method.upper() not in self.http_methods:
+                    continue
+                
+                total_operations += 1
+                responses = operation.get('responses', {})
+                
+                # Check for error responses
+                has_error_responses = any(
+                    status_code.startswith('4') or status_code.startswith('5')
+                    for status_code in responses.keys()
+                )
+                
+                if has_error_responses:
+                    operations_with_errors += 1
+                    
+                    # Check for detailed error schemas
+                    for status_code, response in responses.items():
+                        if (status_code.startswith('4') or status_code.startswith('5')) and isinstance(response, dict):
+                            content = response.get('content', {})
+                            for media_obj in content.values():
+                                schema = media_obj.get('schema', {})
+                                if self._has_detailed_error_schema(schema):
+                                    detailed_error_responses += 1
+                                    break
+                            break
+        
+        if total_operations == 0:
+            return 0
+        
+        error_coverage = (operations_with_errors / total_operations) * 60
+        error_detail = (detailed_error_responses / operations_with_errors * 40) if operations_with_errors > 0 else 0
+        
+        return error_coverage + error_detail
+    
+    def _has_detailed_error_schema(self, schema: Dict[str, Any]) -> bool:
+        """Check if error schema has detailed information."""
+        if not isinstance(schema, dict):
+            return False
+        
+        properties = schema.get('properties', {})
+        error_fields = {'error', 'message', 'details', 'code', 'timestamp'}
+        
+        matching_fields = sum(1 for field in error_fields if field in properties)
+        return matching_fields >= 2  # At least 2 standard error fields
+    
+    def _check_filtering_and_searching(self) -> float:
+        """Check filtering and search capabilities."""
+        paths = self.spec.get('paths', {})
+        
+        collection_endpoints = 0
+        endpoints_with_filtering = 0
+        
+        for path, path_obj in paths.items():
+            if not isinstance(path_obj, dict):
+                continue
+            
+            # Identify collection endpoints (no path parameters)
+            if '{' not in path:
+                get_operation = path_obj.get('get')
+                if get_operation:
+                    collection_endpoints += 1
+                    
+                    # Check for filtering/search parameters
+                    parameters = get_operation.get('parameters', [])
+                    filter_params = {'filter', 'search', 'q', 'query', 'limit', 'page', 'offset'}
+                    
+                    has_filtering = any(
+                        isinstance(param, dict) and param.get('name', '').lower() in filter_params
+                        for param in parameters
+                    )
+                    
+                    if has_filtering:
+                        endpoints_with_filtering += 1
+        
+        return (endpoints_with_filtering / collection_endpoints * 100) if collection_endpoints > 0 else 100
+    
+    def _check_resource_relationships(self) -> float:
+        """Check resource relationship handling."""
+        paths = self.spec.get('paths', {})
+        schemas = self.spec.get('components', {}).get('schemas', {})
+        
+        # Look for nested resource patterns
+        nested_resources = 0
+        total_resource_paths = 0
+        
+        for path in paths.keys():
+            # Skip root paths
+            if path.count('/') >= 3:  # e.g., /api/users/123/orders
+                total_resource_paths += 1
+                if '{' in path:
+                    nested_resources += 1
+        
+        # Look for relationship fields in schemas
+        schemas_with_relations = 0
+        for schema in schemas.values():
+            if not isinstance(schema, dict):
+                continue
+            
+            properties = schema.get('properties', {})
+            relation_indicators = {'id', '_id', 'ref', 'link', 'relationship'}
+            
+            has_relations = any(
+                any(indicator in prop_name.lower() for indicator in relation_indicators)
+                for prop_name in properties.keys()
+            )
+            
+            if has_relations:
+                schemas_with_relations += 1
+        
+        nested_score = (nested_resources / total_resource_paths * 50) if total_resource_paths > 0 else 25
+        schema_score = (schemas_with_relations / len(schemas) * 50) if schemas else 25
+        
+        return nested_score + schema_score
+    
+    def _check_developer_experience(self) -> float:
+        """Check overall developer experience factors."""
+        # This is a composite score based on various DX factors
+        factors = []
+        
+        # Factor 1: Consistent response structure
+        factors.append(self._check_response_consistency())
+        
+        # Factor 2: Clear operation IDs
+        paths = self.spec.get('paths', {})
+        total_operations = 0
+        operations_with_ids = 0
+        
+        for path_obj in paths.values():
+            if not isinstance(path_obj, dict):
+                continue
+                
+            for method, operation in path_obj.items():
+                if method.upper() not in self.http_methods:
+                    continue
+                
+                total_operations += 1
+                if isinstance(operation, dict) and operation.get('operationId'):
+                    operations_with_ids += 1
+        
+        operation_id_score = (operations_with_ids / total_operations * 100) if total_operations > 0 else 100
+        factors.append(operation_id_score)
+        
+        # Factor 3: Reasonable path complexity
+        avg_path_complexity = 0
+        if paths:
+            complexities = []
+            for path in paths.keys():
+                segments = [seg for seg in path.split('/') if seg]
+                complexities.append(len(segments))
+            
+            avg_complexity = sum(complexities) / len(complexities)
+            # Optimal complexity is 3-4 segments
+            if 3 <= avg_complexity <= 4:
+                avg_path_complexity = 100
+            elif 2 <= avg_complexity <= 5:
+                avg_path_complexity = 80
+            else:
+                avg_path_complexity = 60
+        
+        factors.append(avg_path_complexity)
+        
+        return sum(factors) / len(factors) if factors else 0
+    
+    def _score_performance(self) -> None:
+        """Score API performance patterns (15% weight)."""
+        category = ScoreCategory.PERFORMANCE
+        score = CategoryScore(
+            category=category,
+            score=0.0,
+            max_score=100.0,
+            weight=self.category_weights[category]
+        )
+        
+        performance_checks = [
+            self._check_caching_headers(),
+            self._check_pagination_patterns(),
+            self._check_compression_support(),
+            self._check_efficiency_patterns(),
+            self._check_batch_operations()
+        ]
+        
+        valid_scores = [s for s in performance_checks if s is not None]
+        if valid_scores:
+            score.score = sum(valid_scores) / len(valid_scores)
+        
+        # Add recommendations
+        if score.score < 60:
+            score.recommendations.extend([
+                "Implement pagination for list endpoints",
+                "Add caching headers for cacheable responses",
+                "Consider batch operations for bulk updates"
+            ])
+        elif score.score < 80:
+            score.recommendations.extend([
+                "Review caching strategies for better performance",
+                "Consider field selection parameters for large responses"
+            ])
+        
+        self.scorecard.category_scores[category] = score
+    
+    def _check_caching_headers(self) -> float:
+        """Check caching header implementation."""
+        paths = self.spec.get('paths', {})
+        
+        get_operations = 0
+        cacheable_operations = 0
+        
+        for path_obj in paths.values():
+            if not isinstance(path_obj, dict):
+                continue
+            
+            get_operation = path_obj.get('get')
+            if get_operation and isinstance(get_operation, dict):
+                get_operations += 1
+                
+                # Check for caching-related headers in responses
+                responses = get_operation.get('responses', {})
+                for response in responses.values():
+                    if not isinstance(response, dict):
+                        continue
+                    
+                    headers = response.get('headers', {})
+                    cache_headers = {'cache-control', 'etag', 'last-modified', 'expires'}
+                    
+                    if any(header.lower() in cache_headers for header in headers.keys()):
+                        cacheable_operations += 1
+                        break
+        
+        return (cacheable_operations / get_operations * 100) if get_operations > 0 else 50
+    
+    def _check_pagination_patterns(self) -> float:
+        """Check pagination implementation."""
+        paths = self.spec.get('paths', {})
+        
+        collection_endpoints = 0
+        paginated_endpoints = 0
+        
+        for path, path_obj in paths.items():
+            if not isinstance(path_obj, dict):
+                continue
+            
+            # Identify collection endpoints
+            if '{' not in path:  # No path parameters = collection
+                get_operation = path_obj.get('get')
+                if get_operation and isinstance(get_operation, dict):
+                    collection_endpoints += 1
+                    
+                    # Check for pagination parameters
+                    parameters = get_operation.get('parameters', [])
+                    pagination_params = {'limit', 'offset', 'page', 'pagesize', 'per_page', 'cursor'}
+                    
+                    has_pagination = any(
+                        isinstance(param, dict) and param.get('name', '').lower() in pagination_params
+                        for param in parameters
+                    )
+                    
+                    if has_pagination:
+                        paginated_endpoints += 1
+        
+        return (paginated_endpoints / collection_endpoints * 100) if collection_endpoints > 0 else 100
+    
+    def _check_compression_support(self) -> float:
+        """Check compression support indicators."""
+        # This is speculative - OpenAPI doesn't directly specify compression
+        # Look for indicators that compression is considered
+        
+        servers = self.spec.get('servers', [])
+        
+        # Check if any server descriptions mention compression
+        compression_mentions = 0
+        for server in servers:
+            if isinstance(server, dict):
+                description = server.get('description', '').lower()
+                if any(term in description for term in ['gzip', 'compress', 'deflate']):
+                    compression_mentions += 1
+        
+        # Base score - assume compression is handled at server level
+        base_score = 70
+        
+        if compression_mentions > 0:
+            return min(base_score + (compression_mentions * 10), 100)
+        
+        return base_score
+    
+    def _check_efficiency_patterns(self) -> float:
+        """Check efficiency patterns like field selection."""
+        paths = self.spec.get('paths', {})
+        
+        total_get_operations = 0
+        operations_with_selection = 0
+        
+        for path_obj in paths.values():
+            if not isinstance(path_obj, dict):
+                continue
+            
+            get_operation = path_obj.get('get')
+            if get_operation and isinstance(get_operation, dict):
+                total_get_operations += 1
+                
+                # Check for field selection parameters
+                parameters = get_operation.get('parameters', [])
+                selection_params = {'fields', 'select', 'include', 'exclude'}
+                
+                has_selection = any(
+                    isinstance(param, dict) and param.get('name', '').lower() in selection_params
+                    for param in parameters
+                )
+                
+                if has_selection:
+                    operations_with_selection += 1
+        
+        return (operations_with_selection / total_get_operations * 100) if total_get_operations > 0 else 60
+    
+    def _check_batch_operations(self) -> float:
+        """Check for batch operation support."""
+        paths = self.spec.get('paths', {})
+        
+        # Look for batch endpoints
+        batch_indicators = ['batch', 'bulk', 'multi']
+        batch_endpoints = 0
+        
+        for path in paths.keys():
+            if any(indicator in path.lower() for indicator in batch_indicators):
+                batch_endpoints += 1
+        
+        # Look for array-based request bodies (indicating batch operations)
+        array_operations = 0
+        total_post_put_operations = 0
+        
+        for path_obj in paths.values():
+            if not isinstance(path_obj, dict):
+                continue
+            
+            for method in ['post', 'put', 'patch']:
+                operation = path_obj.get(method)
+                if operation and isinstance(operation, dict):
+                    total_post_put_operations += 1
+                    
+                    request_body = operation.get('requestBody', {})
+                    content = request_body.get('content', {})
+                    
+                    for media_obj in content.values():
+                        schema = media_obj.get('schema', {})
+                        if schema.get('type') == 'array':
+                            array_operations += 1
+                            break
+        
+        # Score based on presence of batch patterns
+        batch_score = min(batch_endpoints * 20, 60)  # Up to 60 points for explicit batch endpoints
+        
+        if total_post_put_operations > 0:
+            array_score = (array_operations / total_post_put_operations) * 40
+            batch_score += array_score
+        
+        return min(batch_score, 100)
+    
+    def generate_json_report(self) -> str:
+        """Generate JSON format scorecard."""
+        report_data = {
+            "overall": {
+                "score": round(self.scorecard.overall_score, 2),
+                "grade": self.scorecard.overall_grade,
+                "totalEndpoints": self.scorecard.total_endpoints
+            },
+            "api_info": self.scorecard.api_info,
+            "categories": {},
+            "topRecommendations": self.scorecard.get_top_recommendations()
+        }
+        
+        for category, score in self.scorecard.category_scores.items():
+            report_data["categories"][category.value] = {
+                "score": round(score.score, 2),
+                "grade": score.letter_grade,
+                "weight": score.weight,
+                "weightedScore": round(score.weighted_score, 2),
+                "issues": score.issues,
+                "recommendations": score.recommendations
+            }
+        
+        return json.dumps(report_data, indent=2)
+    
+    def generate_text_report(self) -> str:
+        """Generate human-readable scorecard report."""
+        lines = [
+            "═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════",
+            "                      API DESIGN SCORECARD",
+            "═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════",
+            f"API: {self.scorecard.api_info.get('title', 'Unknown')}",
+            f"Version: {self.scorecard.api_info.get('version', 'Unknown')}",
+            f"Total Endpoints: {self.scorecard.total_endpoints}",
+            "",
+            f"🏆 OVERALL GRADE: {self.scorecard.overall_grade} ({self.scorecard.overall_score:.1f}/100.0)",
+            "",
+            "═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════",
+            "DETAILED BREAKDOWN:",
+            "═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════"
+        ]
+        
+        # Sort categories by weight (most important first)
+        sorted_categories = sorted(
+            self.scorecard.category_scores.items(),
+            key=lambda x: x[1].weight,
+            reverse=True
+        )
+        
+        for category, score in sorted_categories:
+            category_name = category.value.title().replace('_', ' ')
+            
+            lines.extend([
+                "",
+                f"📊 {category_name.upper()} - Grade: {score.letter_grade} ({score.score:.1f}/100)",
+                f"   Weight: {score.weight}% | Contribution: {score.weighted_score:.1f} points",
+                "   " + "─" * 50
+            ])
+            
+            if score.recommendations:
+                lines.append("   💡 Recommendations:")
+                for rec in score.recommendations[:3]:  # Top 3 recommendations
+                    lines.append(f"      • {rec}")
+            else:
+                lines.append("   ✅ No specific recommendations - performing well!")
+        
+        # Overall assessment
+        lines.extend([
+            "",
+            "═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════",
+            "OVERALL ASSESSMENT:",
+            "═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════"
+        ])
+        
+        if self.scorecard.overall_grade == "A":
+            lines.extend([
+                "🏆 EXCELLENT! Your API demonstrates outstanding design quality.",
+                "   Continue following these best practices and consider sharing",
+                "   your approach as a reference for other teams."
+            ])
+        elif self.scorecard.overall_grade == "B":
+            lines.extend([
+                "✅ GOOD! Your API follows most best practices with room for",
+                "   minor improvements. Focus on the recommendations above",
+                "   to achieve excellence."
+            ])
+        elif self.scorecard.overall_grade == "C":
+            lines.extend([
+                "⚠️  FAIR! Your API has a solid foundation but several areas",
+                "   need improvement. Prioritize the high-weight categories",
+                "   for maximum impact."
+            ])
+        elif self.scorecard.overall_grade == "D":
+            lines.extend([
+                "❌ NEEDS IMPROVEMENT! Your API has significant issues that",
+                "   may impact developer experience and maintainability.",
+                "   Focus on consistency and documentation first."
+            ])
+        else:  # Grade F
+            lines.extend([
+                "🚨 CRITICAL ISSUES! Your API requires major redesign to meet",
+                "   basic quality standards. Consider comprehensive review",
+                "   of design principles and best practices."
+            ])
+        
+        # Top recommendations
+        top_recs = self.scorecard.get_top_recommendations(3)
+        if top_recs:
+            lines.extend([
+                "",
+                "🎯 TOP PRIORITY RECOMMENDATIONS:",
+                ""
+            ])
+            for i, rec in enumerate(top_recs, 1):
+                lines.append(f"   {i}. {rec}")
+        
+        lines.extend([
+            "",
+            "═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════",
+            f"Generated by API Scorecard Tool | Score: {self.scorecard.overall_grade} ({self.scorecard.overall_score:.1f}%)",
+            "═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════"
+        ])
+        
+        return "\n".join(lines)
+
+
+def main():
+    """Main CLI entry point."""
+    parser = argparse.ArgumentParser(
+        description="Generate comprehensive API design quality scorecard",
+        formatter_class=argparse.RawDescriptionHelpFormatter,
+        epilog="""
+Examples:
+  python api_scorecard.py openapi.json
+  python api_scorecard.py --format json openapi.json > scorecard.json
+  python api_scorecard.py --output scorecard.txt openapi.json
+        """
+    )
+    
+    parser.add_argument(
+        'spec_file',
+        help='OpenAPI/Swagger specification file (JSON format)'
+    )
+    
+    parser.add_argument(
+        '--format',
+        choices=['text', 'json'],
+        default='text',
+        help='Output format (default: text)'
+    )
+    
+    parser.add_argument(
+        '--output',
+        help='Output file (default: stdout)'
+    )
+    
+    parser.add_argument(
+        '--min-grade',
+        choices=['A', 'B', 'C', 'D', 'F'],
+        help='Exit with code 1 if grade is below minimum'
+    )
+    
+    args = parser.parse_args()
+    
+    # Load specification file
+    try:
+        with open(args.spec_file, 'r') as f:
+            spec = json.load(f)
+    except FileNotFoundError:
+        print(f"Error: Specification file '{args.spec_file}' not found.", file=sys.stderr)
+        return 1
+    except json.JSONDecodeError as e:
+        print(f"Error: Invalid JSON in '{args.spec_file}': {e}", file=sys.stderr)
+        return 1
+    
+    # Initialize scoring engine and generate scorecard
+    engine = APIScoringEngine()
+    
+    try:
+        scorecard = engine.score_api(spec)
+    except Exception as e:
+        print(f"Error during scoring: {e}", file=sys.stderr)
+        return 1
+    
+    # Generate report
+    if args.format == 'json':
+        output = engine.generate_json_report()
+    else:
+        output = engine.generate_text_report()
+    
+    # Write output
+    if args.output:
+        try:
+            with open(args.output, 'w') as f:
+                f.write(output)
+            print(f"Scorecard written to {args.output}")
+        except IOError as e:
+            print(f"Error writing to '{args.output}': {e}", file=sys.stderr)
+            return 1
+    else:
+        print(output)
+    
+    # Check minimum grade requirement
+    if args.min_grade:
+        grade_order = ['F', 'D', 'C', 'B', 'A']
+        current_grade_index = grade_order.index(scorecard.overall_grade)
+        min_grade_index = grade_order.index(args.min_grade)
+        
+        if current_grade_index < min_grade_index:
+            print(f"Grade {scorecard.overall_grade} is below minimum required grade {args.min_grade}", file=sys.stderr)
+            return 1
+    
+    return 0
+
+
+if __name__ == '__main__':
+    sys.exit(main())