agentvibes 2.13.7 → 2.13.8

package/docs/whatsapp-tts-plugin-feasibility.md

@@ -1,418 +0,0 @@
-# WhatsApp TTS Plugin - Feasibility Analysis
-
-## Executive Summary
-
-**Status**: ✅ **HIGHLY FEASIBLE** - All components exist and can be integrated with minimal code changes.
-
-The WhatsApp TTS plugin for AgentVibes is completely feasible and can be implemented as an **MCP server extension** that integrates the existing WhatsApp MCP server with AgentVibes TTS capabilities.
-
-## Project Overview
-
-Create an AgentVibes plugin that enables voice notifications for WhatsApp messages through MCP (Model Context Protocol). When activated, the plugin will:
-
-1. Monitor incoming WhatsApp messages via the WhatsApp MCP server
-2. Use voice differentiation (round-robin) for different contacts in group chats
-3. Provide MCP commands to enable/disable notifications per contact/channel
-4. Automatically read messages aloud using AgentVibes TTS
-
-## Architecture Analysis
-
-### Component 1: WhatsApp MCP Server (Existing)
-
-**Location**: `/home/fire/claude/whatsapp-mcp/`
-
-**Key Components**:
-- **Go Bridge** (`whatsapp-bridge/main.go`): Connects to WhatsApp API, stores messages in SQLite
-  - Message handler: `handleMessage()` at line 412
-  - Captures: sender, content, timestamp, chat JID, media type
-  - Outputs to console: `fmt.Printf("[%s] %s %s: %s\n", timestamp, direction, sender, content)` at line 468
-
-- **Python MCP Server** (`whatsapp-mcp-server/main.py`): Exposes tools via MCP protocol
-  - Existing tools: `search_contacts`, `list_messages`, `list_chats`, `send_message`, etc.
-  - Built on FastMCP framework
-
-**Database Structure**:
-```sql
-chats (jid, name, last_message_time)
-messages (id, chat_jid, sender, content, timestamp, is_from_me, media_type, ...)
-```
-
-### Component 2: AgentVibes TTS System (Existing)
-
-**Location**: `/home/fire/claude/AgentVibes/`
-
-**Key Components**:
-- **MCP Server** (`mcp-server/server.py`): Exposes TTS capabilities via MCP
-  - Tool: `text_to_speech(text, voice, personality, language)`
-  - Voice management: `list_voices()`, `set_voice(voice_name)`
-  - Supports: ElevenLabs (150+ voices), Piper TTS (50+ voices)
-
-- **Voice Manager** (`.claude/hooks/voice-manager.sh`): Controls voice selection
-- **Play TTS** (`.claude/hooks/play-tts.sh`): Core TTS execution script
-
-**Available Voices**: 27+ unique voices with multilingual support
-
-## Proposed Architecture
-
-### ✅ RECOMMENDED: Standalone Plugin (Independent Repository)
-
-**UPDATE**: After analysis, a **completely standalone plugin** is the superior approach.
-
-Create an independent repository that depends on AgentVibes as an external service:
-
-```
-┌─────────────────────────────────────┐
-│   whatsapp-agentvibes-plugin        │ ← New Standalone Repo
-│   (Independent MCP Server)          │
-└──────────────┬──────────────────────┘
-               │ depends on (subprocess calls)
-               │
-      ┌────────┴─────────┬────────────────┐
-      ▼                  ▼                ▼
-┌────────────┐   ┌──────────────┐   ┌─────────────┐
-│ WhatsApp   │   │ AgentVibes   │   │ FastMCP     │
-│ MCP Server │   │ (installed)  │   │ (Python)    │
-└────────────┘   └──────────────┘   └─────────────┘
-```
-
-**Key Architecture Points**:
-- **Standalone repo**: `whatsapp-agentvibes` (separate from AgentVibes codebase)
-- **AgentVibes integration**: Calls `play-tts.sh` via subprocess (no code imports)
-- **WhatsApp data**: Reads SQLite database directly (read-only)
-- **Distribution**: pip package on PyPI
-- **Configuration**: Separate `~/.config/whatsapp-agentvibes/config.json`
-
-### Why Standalone?
-
-✅ **Separation of Concerns**: Plugin development doesn't affect AgentVibes core
-✅ **Independent Versioning**: Plugin can release updates independently
-✅ **Easier Maintenance**: Different maintainers can own different repos
-✅ **Cleaner Dependencies**: Users only install what they need
-✅ **Community Contributions**: Easier for external contributors
-✅ **Plugin Ecosystem**: Opens path for Signal-TTS, Telegram-TTS, Slack-TTS, etc.
-
-### ❌ Rejected: Integrated Approach
-
-Building inside AgentVibes repo would:
-- Couple messaging features to TTS engine
-- Make AgentVibes responsible for messaging integrations
-- Complicate versioning and releases
-- Limit community contributions
-- Mix concerns (TTS vs messaging)
-
-## Feature Design
-
-### Round-Robin Voice Assignment
-
-**Strategy**: Hash-based voice assignment with persistent storage
-
-```python
-def assign_voice_to_contact(contact_jid: str, available_voices: list) -> str:
-    """Assigns a consistent voice to a contact using hash-based selection"""
-    # Generate stable hash from contact JID
-    contact_hash = hash(contact_jid) % len(available_voices)
-    return available_voices[contact_hash]
-```
-
-**Benefits**:
-- Same contact always gets same voice (consistency)
-- Automatic distribution across available voices
-- No manual voice assignment needed
-
-**Persistence**:
-```json
-{
-  "contact_voices": {
-    "1234567890@s.whatsapp.net": "Aria",
-    "0987654321@s.whatsapp.net": "Northern Terry",
-    "group123@g.us": {
-      "sender1@s.whatsapp.net": "Cowboy Bob",
-      "sender2@s.whatsapp.net": "Kristin"
-    }
-  }
-}
-```
-
-### MCP Commands (New Tools)
-
-1. **`whatsapp_enable_notifications(contact_or_chat: str)`**
-   - Enable TTS notifications for a specific contact or group
-   - Assigns voice automatically via round-robin
-   - Returns: "✅ Enabled notifications for {name} with voice {voice}"
-
-2. **`whatsapp_disable_notifications(contact_or_chat: str)`**
-   - Disable TTS notifications for a specific contact or group
-   - Returns: "❌ Disabled notifications for {name}"
-
-3. **`whatsapp_list_notification_channels()`**
-   - Shows all contacts/groups with notifications enabled
-   - Displays assigned voices
-   - Returns formatted list
-
-4. **`whatsapp_set_contact_voice(contact: str, voice: str)`**
-   - Override automatic voice assignment
-   - Manually set specific voice for a contact
-   - Returns: "✅ Set {contact} voice to {voice}"
-
-5. **`whatsapp_get_notification_status()`**
-   - Show global notification status
-   - List enabled contacts with their voices
-   - Show round-robin statistics
-
-### Message Monitoring Implementation
-
-**Approach**: Polling SQLite database with timestamp tracking
-
-```python
-class WhatsAppTTSMonitor:
-    def __init__(self):
-        self.last_checked = datetime.now()
-        self.enabled_contacts = self.load_config()
-
-    async def check_new_messages(self):
-        """Poll database for messages since last check"""
-        query = """
-            SELECT id, chat_jid, sender, content, timestamp, is_from_me
-            FROM messages
-            WHERE timestamp > ? AND is_from_me = 0
-            ORDER BY timestamp ASC
-        """
-        messages = await db.execute(query, (self.last_checked,))
-
-        for msg in messages:
-            await self.process_message(msg)
-
-        self.last_checked = datetime.now()
-
-    async def process_message(self, msg):
-        """Determine if message should trigger TTS"""
-        # Check if notifications enabled for this contact/chat
-        if msg.chat_jid in self.enabled_contacts:
-            voice = self.get_voice_for_sender(msg.chat_jid, msg.sender)
-            await self.speak_message(msg.content, voice, msg.sender)
-```
-
-**Alternative**: Event-based (requires modifying Go bridge)
-- More efficient but requires code changes to `handleMessage()` in Go
-- Can add webhook/callback after line 470 in main.go
-- Polling is simpler and doesn't modify existing systems
-
-## Implementation Plan
-
-### Phase 1: Core Integration (Week 1)
-
-1. Create new MCP server: `agentvibes-whatsapp-mcp/`
-   - Merge WhatsApp MCP tools
-   - Add AgentVibes TTS integration
-   - Implement configuration storage (JSON file)
-
-2. Implement voice assignment logic
-   - Hash-based round-robin
-   - Persistent voice-to-contact mapping
-   - Configuration save/load
-
-3. Add basic MCP tools
-   - `whatsapp_enable_notifications`
-   - `whatsapp_disable_notifications`
-   - `whatsapp_list_notification_channels`
-
-### Phase 2: Message Monitoring (Week 2)
-
-1. Implement SQLite polling
-   - Connect to WhatsApp messages.db
-   - Track last checked timestamp
-   - Query new messages periodically
-
-2. Message filtering
-   - Filter by enabled contacts
-   - Skip messages from self (is_from_me = true)
-   - Handle group vs direct messages
-
-3. TTS integration
-   - Call AgentVibes play-tts.sh script
-   - Pass contact name + message content
-   - Handle voice selection
-
-### Phase 3: Advanced Features (Week 3)
-
-1. Voice management tools
-   - `whatsapp_set_contact_voice` (manual override)
-   - `whatsapp_get_notification_status` (statistics)
-
-2. Group chat handling
-   - Per-sender voice assignment within groups
-   - Optional: Prefix speaker name ("John says: Hello")
-
-3. Configuration UI enhancements
-   - Natural language commands
-   - Bulk enable/disable operations
-
-### Phase 4: Testing & Documentation (Week 4)
-
-1. End-to-end testing
-2. Documentation
-3. Example usage scenarios
-4. Error handling and edge cases
-
-## Technical Considerations
-
-### Pros
-✅ **Zero modification to existing systems** - WhatsApp bridge and AgentVibes remain unchanged
-✅ **Leverages MCP protocol** - Native Claude Desktop/Code integration
-✅ **Reuses existing infrastructure** - Both message storage and TTS already work
-✅ **Natural language control** - "Enable notifications for Mom's chat"
-✅ **Voice variety** - 27+ voices available for round-robin
-
-### Challenges
-⚠️ **Database polling latency** - 1-5 second delay before TTS (acceptable for notifications)
-⚠️ **Voice assignment persistence** - Need to store contact-voice mappings
-⚠️ **Group chat complexity** - Multiple senders require per-sender voice tracking
-⚠️ **Media messages** - How to announce images/videos/voice notes?
-
-### Solutions
-- **Polling**: Use 2-second intervals for responsive notifications
-- **Persistence**: JSON config file in `.claude/whatsapp-notifications.json`
-- **Groups**: Extend mapping to `{group_jid: {sender_jid: voice}}`
-- **Media**: Speak "[Name] sent a photo" or "[Name] sent a voice message"
-
-## Resource Requirements
-
-### Development Time
-- **Phase 1**: 8-12 hours (core integration)
-- **Phase 2**: 6-8 hours (monitoring)
-- **Phase 3**: 4-6 hours (advanced features)
-- **Phase 4**: 4-6 hours (testing/docs)
-- **Total**: ~25-35 hours
-
-### Runtime Resources
-- **Memory**: +50-100 MB (Python process with polling)
-- **CPU**: Negligible (2-second polls, TTS on demand)
-- **Storage**: ~10 KB (configuration file)
-
-### Dependencies
-- Existing: WhatsApp MCP server, AgentVibes
-- New: None (uses existing FastMCP framework)
-
-## Example Usage Scenarios
-
-### Scenario 1: Enable notifications for a contact
-```
-User: "Enable WhatsApp notifications for my mom"
-Claude: [Calls whatsapp_search_contacts("mom")]
-        [Finds: Jane Smith, +1234567890]
-        [Calls whatsapp_enable_notifications("+1234567890@s.whatsapp.net")]
-        ✅ Enabled notifications for Jane Smith with voice "Aria"
-
-[Later, message arrives from Jane]
-TTS: "Message from Jane Smith: Don't forget to call me tonight"
-```
-
-### Scenario 2: Group chat with multiple voices
-```
-User: "Enable notifications for the Family group"
-Claude: [Calls whatsapp_list_chats("Family")]
-        [Calls whatsapp_enable_notifications("group123@g.us")]
-        ✅ Enabled notifications for Family group
-        Voices will be assigned per sender automatically
-
-[Later, messages arrive]
-TTS (Aria voice): "Dad: Can someone pick up milk?"
-TTS (Terry voice): "Mom: I'll get it on the way home"
-TTS (Bob voice): "Sister: Thanks Mom!"
-```
-
-### Scenario 3: Managing notifications
-```
-User: "Show me all WhatsApp notification channels"
-Claude: [Calls whatsapp_list_notification_channels()]
-
-🔔 WhatsApp Notifications Active:
-━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
-  1. Jane Smith (+1234567890)
-     Voice: Aria
-     Last message: 2 minutes ago
-
-  2. Family Group
-     Voice assignments:
-       • Dad → Northern Terry
-       • Mom → Kristin
-       • Sister → Cowboy Bob
-     Last message: 5 minutes ago
-
-  3. Work Team
-     Voice: Jenny
-     Last message: 1 hour ago
-━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━━
-```
-
-## Security & Privacy
-
-### Data Access
-- **Read-only access** to WhatsApp SQLite database
-- **No message forwarding** - all processing local
-- **User-controlled** - notifications only for explicitly enabled contacts
-
-### Configuration Storage
-- Stored locally in `.claude/whatsapp-notifications.json`
-- Contains: JIDs (identifiers), voice assignments
-- No message content stored by plugin
-
-### Permissions
-- User must explicitly enable per-contact
-- Can disable anytime via MCP command
-- Respects WhatsApp MCP server's existing security
-
-## Alternatives Considered
-
-### Alternative 1: Direct Go Bridge Modification
-**Pros**: Real-time, no polling lag
-**Cons**: Modifies existing codebase, harder to maintain
-**Verdict**: ❌ Rejected - maintain separation of concerns
-
-### Alternative 2: Webhook-based System
-**Pros**: Event-driven, more efficient
-**Cons**: Requires network layer, authentication complexity
-**Verdict**: ❌ Rejected - overkill for local system
-
-### Alternative 3: Browser Extension
-**Pros**: Works with WhatsApp Web directly
-**Cons**: No access to MCP, can't use AgentVibes voices
-**Verdict**: ❌ Rejected - loses MCP integration benefits
-
-## Conclusion
-
-This plugin is **highly feasible** and should be implemented as a **standalone Python package** in an independent repository.
-
-**Key Success Factors**:
-1. ✅ No modifications to AgentVibes or WhatsApp MCP required
-2. ✅ Clean separation of concerns (TTS engine vs messaging integration)
-3. ✅ Independent versioning and release cycles
-4. ✅ Opens path for plugin ecosystem (Signal, Telegram, Slack, etc.)
-5. ✅ Subprocess-based AgentVibes integration (simple, reliable)
-6. ✅ Simple SQLite polling for message detection
-7. ✅ Hash-based voice assignment for consistency
-8. ✅ Natural language command interface via MCP
-
-**Repository Structure**:
-- **Name**: `whatsapp-agentvibes` or `agentvibes-whatsapp-plugin`
-- **Location**: New independent GitHub repository
-- **Distribution**: PyPI package (`pip install whatsapp-agentvibes`)
-- **Dependencies**: AgentVibes (subprocess), WhatsApp MCP (SQLite), FastMCP (Python)
-
-**Recommendation**: Proceed with **Standalone Plugin Architecture** using the phased implementation plan above.
-
-**See also**: `/docs/whatsapp-tts-standalone-plugin.md` for detailed standalone architecture design.
-
-## Next Steps
-
-1. Create GitHub issue with detailed implementation tasks
-2. Set up project structure: `agentvibes-whatsapp-plugin/`
-3. Implement Phase 1 (core integration)
-4. Create demo video showing the feature in action
-
----
-
-**Document Version**: 1.0
-**Date**: 2025-11-12
-**Author**: AgentVibes + Claude AI
-**Status**: Ready for Implementation