@zeyue0329/xiaoma-cli 1.0.48 → 6.0.0-alpha.13

package/xiaoma-core/workflows/enhanced-fullstack-with-qa-loop.yaml

@@ -1,766 +0,0 @@
-# <!-- Powered by XIAOMA™ Core -->
-# Enhanced Full-Stack Development with Closed-Loop Quality Assurance
-# 增强型全栈开发工作流 - 带闭环质量保证系统
-
-workflow:
-  id: enhanced-fullstack-with-qa-loop
-  name: Enhanced Full-Stack Development with Closed-Loop Quality Assurance
-  version: "3.0"
-  description: >-
-    世界级的全自动化软件开发工作流，采用严格串行执行模式，包含完整的闭环质量保证系统。
-    特色：全局需求审计、智能问题分发、自动化修复验证、持续质量改进。
-    核心原则：质量优先、串行执行、依赖验证、持续验证、零缺陷交付。
-    执行模式：每个任务必须100%完成并通过质量门控后才能开始下一个任务。
-  type: greenfield
-  project_types:
-    - web-app
-    - saas
-    - enterprise-app
-    - data-driven-app
-    - api-first
-    - mission-critical-system
-
-  # ========== 工作流主序列 ==========
-  sequence:
-    # ===== 阶段1：需求分析与设计 =====
-    - agent: analyst
-      creates: project-brief.md
-      optional_steps:
-        - brainstorming_session
-        - market_research_prompt
-      quality_gates:
-        - completeness_check
-        - feasibility_validation
-        - 100_percent_completion_validated
-      success_criteria:
-        - project_brief_quality_score: ">90"
-        - completeness_percentage: "100%"
-        - feasibility_confirmed: true
-      wait_for_completion: true
-      notes: "项目分析与概要设计 - 必须100%完成"
-
-    - agent: pm
-      creates: prd.md
-      requires: project-brief.md
-      wait_for_previous: true
-      quality_gates:
-        - requirement_completeness
-        - measurability_check
-        - priority_validation
-        - 100_percent_completion_validated
-      success_criteria:
-        - prd_quality_score: ">95"
-        - requirement_coverage: "100%"
-        - priority_alignment: "100%"
-      dependency_validation:
-        - verify_project_brief_completed
-        - validate_previous_quality_gates
-      notes: "创建详细产品需求文档 - 依赖project-brief.md完成"
-
-    # ===== 阶段2：数据库与架构设计 =====
-    - agent: database-architect
-      action: analyze_existing_database
-      creates: existing-database-analysis.md
-      condition: has_existing_database
-      notes: "分析现有数据库结构"
-
-    - agent: database-architect
-      creates: database-design.md
-      requires:
-        - prd.md
-        - existing-database-analysis.md (if exists)
-      wait_for_previous: true
-      quality_gates:
-        - normalization_check
-        - performance_optimization
-        - scalability_validation
-        - 100_percent_completion_validated
-      success_criteria:
-        - database_design_quality_score: ">90"
-        - normalization_compliance: "100%"
-        - performance_requirements_met: true
-      dependency_validation:
-        - verify_prd_completed
-        - validate_existing_analysis_if_required
-      notes: "设计数据库架构 - 依赖PRD完成"
-
-    - agent: database-architect
-      action: generate_ddl_dml
-      creates: database-scripts/
-      requires: database-design.md
-      validation: syntax_check
-      notes: "生成数据库脚本"
-
-    - agent: database-architect
-      action: generate_entities_and_mappers
-      creates: generated-code/
-      requires: database-design.md
-      quality_gates:
-        - code_generation_validation
-        - naming_convention_check
-      notes: "生成实体类和映射器"
-
-    - agent: ux-expert
-      creates: front-end-spec.md
-      requires:
-        - prd.md
-        - database-design.md
-      quality_gates:
-        - usability_validation
-        - accessibility_check
-      notes: "创建前端设计规范"
-
-    - agent: architect
-      creates: fullstack-architecture.md
-      requires:
-        - prd.md
-        - database-design.md
-        - front-end-spec.md
-      quality_gates:
-        - architecture_completeness
-        - scalability_design
-        - security_architecture
-      notes: "设计全栈架构"
-
-    # ===== 阶段3：初步验证与调整 =====
-    - agent: po
-      validates: all_artifacts
-      uses: po-master-checklist
-      quality_gates:
-        - layer_1_syntax_format_validation
-        - layer_2_content_completeness_validation
-        - layer_3_content_quality_validation
-        - layer_4_consistency_validation
-        - layer_5_implementation_feasibility_validation
-        - layer_6_business_value_validation
-      notes: "产品负责人验证所有文档"
-
-    - agent: various
-      updates: any_flagged_documents
-      condition: po_checklist_issues
-      notes: "修复标记的问题"
-
-    # ===== 阶段4：开发实施 =====
-    - agent: po
-      action: shard_documents
-      creates: sharded_docs
-      requires: all_artifacts_in_project
-      notes: "文档分片准备开发"
-
-    - agent: sm
-      action: create_enhanced_story_with_database
-      creates: story.md
-      requires:
-        - sharded_docs
-        - database-design.md
-        - generated-code/
-      execution_mode: sequential_per_epic
-      completion_requirement: 100%
-      template: enhanced-story-with-database-tmpl.yaml
-      quality_gates:
-        - template_compliance_100_percent
-        - content_structure_validation
-        - database_integration_validation
-        - story_completeness_validation
-      success_criteria:
-        - story_quality_score: ">95"
-        - template_compliance: "100%"
-        - zero_validation_errors: true
-      wait_for_previous_completion: true
-      timeout: 1800
-      retry: 3
-      notes: "串行创建增强用户故事 - 每个模块依次完成"
-
-    - agent: dev
-      action: implement_story
-      creates: implementation_files
-      requires:
-        - story.md
-        - generated-code/
-      execution_mode: sequential_per_story
-      completion_requirement: 100%
-      quality_gates:
-        - implementation_quality_check
-        - code_structure_validation
-        - api_integration_validation
-        - implementation_completeness_check
-      success_criteria:
-        - implementation_quality_score: ">90"
-        - code_coverage: ">85%"
-        - zero_critical_bugs: true
-      wait_for_previous_completion: true
-      auto_correction:
-        max_attempts: 3
-        correction_strategies:
-          - immediate_auto_correction
-          - iterative_quality_improvement
-      notes: "串行开发实现用户故事 - 每个故事依次完成"
-
-    - agent: qa
-      action: review_implementation
-      updates: implementation_files
-      requires: implementation_files
-      quality_gates:
-        - unit_test_validation
-        - integration_test_validation
-        - code_coverage_check
-      notes: "QA初步审查"
-
-    # ===== 阶段5：全局质量审计（新增核心阶段）=====
-    - agent: global-requirements-auditor
-      action: comprehensive_global_audit
-      creates: global-audit-report.md
-      requires:
-        - all_stories_completed
-        - all_implementations
-        - all_test_results
-      validation_dimensions:
-        - prd_to_story_completeness
-        - story_quality_assessment
-        - implementation_completeness
-        - test_coverage_validation
-        - integration_verification
-        - performance_benchmarks
-        - security_compliance
-      quality_thresholds:
-        critical_requirements_coverage: 100
-        high_priority_completeness: 95
-        overall_quality_score: 90
-        test_coverage: 85
-      outputs:
-        - requirements_coverage_matrix
-        - quality_assessment_report
-        - identified_issues_list
-        - improvement_recommendations
-      notes: |
-        全局深度审计 - 核心质量保证阶段
-        验证所有PRD需求是否完整实现
-        评估每个用户故事的质量
-        审计所有开发任务的完成度
-
-    # ===== 阶段6：问题分发与修复循环（新增）=====
-    - agent: issue-dispatcher
-      action: analyze_and_route_issues
-      requires: global-audit-report.md
-      condition: issues_identified
-      routing_rules:
-        requirement_gaps:
-          target: sm
-          action: create_missing_stories
-          priority: HIGH
-        story_quality_issues:
-          target: sm
-          action: refine_stories
-          priority: MEDIUM
-        implementation_defects:
-          target: dev
-          action: fix_defects
-          priority: HIGH
-        test_coverage_gaps:
-          target: qa
-          action: enhance_tests
-          priority: MEDIUM
-        documentation_gaps:
-          target: doc
-          action: update_docs
-          priority: LOW
-      tracking:
-        - issue_id
-        - assigned_agent
-        - fix_deadline
-        - current_status
-      notes: "智能问题分发与任务指派"
-
-    # ===== 阶段7：串行修复执行（修改为串行）=====
-    - agent: sm
-      action: fix_story_issues
-      condition: story_issues_exist
-      auto_retry: 3
-      validation: story_quality_validator
-      quality_gates:
-        - story_fixes_complete
-        - story_quality_validated
-        - zero_story_defects
-      success_criteria:
-        - all_story_issues_resolved: 100%
-        - story_quality_score: ">95"
-      timeout: 2400 # 40分钟
-      notes: "串行修复用户故事问题 - 必须100%完成才能继续"
-
-    - agent: dev
-      action: fix_implementation_issues
-      condition: code_issues_exist
-      requires: story_fixes_completed
-      auto_retry: 3
-      validation: code_quality_validator
-      quality_gates:
-        - implementation_fixes_complete
-        - code_quality_validated
-        - zero_implementation_defects
-      success_criteria:
-        - all_code_issues_resolved: 100%
-        - code_quality_score: ">90"
-      timeout: 3600 # 60分钟
-      notes: "串行修复实现问题 - 依赖故事修复完成"
-
-    - agent: qa
-      action: fix_test_coverage
-      condition: test_issues_exist
-      requires: implementation_fixes_completed
-      auto_retry: 2
-      validation: coverage_validator
-      quality_gates:
-        - test_coverage_fixes_complete
-        - coverage_validated
-        - zero_test_gaps
-      success_criteria:
-        - all_test_issues_resolved: 100%
-        - test_coverage: ">90%"
-      timeout: 1800 # 30分钟
-      notes: "串行修复测试覆盖问题 - 依赖代码修复完成"
-
-    # ===== 阶段8：修复验证与回归（新增）=====
-    - agent: automated-fix-validator
-      action: validate_all_fixes
-      requires: all_fixes_completed
-      validation_layers:
-        - static_code_analysis
-        - unit_test_execution
-        - integration_testing
-        - e2e_testing
-        - business_logic_validation
-        - performance_validation
-        - security_scanning
-      regression_testing:
-        scope: affected_components_and_dependencies
-        depth: comprehensive
-      decision_outcomes:
-        - approve_fixes
-        - reject_and_rework
-        - conditional_approval
-        - escalate_for_review
-      notes: "验证所有修复的有效性"
-
-    # ===== 阶段9：循环验证直至通过（新增）=====
-    - loop: quality_assurance_loop
-      description: "质量保证循环 - 持续直到无问题"
-      max_iterations: 5
-      steps:
-        - agent: global-requirements-auditor
-          action: re_audit_after_fixes
-          creates: updated-audit-report.md
-
-        - condition: new_issues_found
-          agent: issue-dispatcher
-          action: route_new_issues
-
-        - condition: fixes_needed
-          serial_execution: sequential_fix_cycle
-
-        - agent: automated-fix-validator
-          action: validate_new_fixes
-
-      exit_condition:
-        - no_critical_issues
-        - no_high_priority_issues
-        - quality_score: ">90"
-        - all_requirements_covered
-
-      fallback:
-        condition: max_iterations_reached
-        action: escalate_to_human_review
-
-      notes: "闭环质量保证 - 自动循环直至质量达标"
-
-    # ===== 阶段10：最终验证与发布准备 =====
-    - agent: po
-      action: final_acceptance
-      requires:
-        - quality_loop_completed
-        - all_validations_passed
-      creates: release-readiness-report.md
-      sign_off_criteria:
-        - all_requirements_implemented
-        - zero_critical_defects
-        - performance_benchmarks_met
-        - security_clearance_obtained
-        - documentation_complete
-      notes: "最终验收与发布批准"
-
-    - agent: devops
-      action: prepare_deployment
-      creates: deployment-package/
-      requires: release-readiness-report.md
-      includes:
-        - validated_code
-        - database_migrations
-        - configuration_files
-        - rollback_plan
-        - monitoring_setup
-      notes: "准备部署包"
-
-  # ========== 工作流状态机（新增）==========
-  state_machine:
-    states:
-      - INITIALIZED: "工作流初始化"
-      - REQUIREMENTS_ANALYSIS: "需求分析中"
-      - DESIGN_PHASE: "设计阶段"
-      - DEVELOPMENT_PHASE: "开发阶段"
-      - INITIAL_QA: "初步QA"
-      - GLOBAL_AUDIT: "全局审计中"
-      - ISSUE_IDENTIFIED: "发现问题"
-      - FIX_IN_PROGRESS: "修复进行中"
-      - FIX_VALIDATION: "修复验证中"
-      - QUALITY_LOOP: "质量循环中"
-      - FINAL_VALIDATION: "最终验证"
-      - RELEASE_READY: "准备发布"
-      - COMPLETED: "已完成"
-      - FAILED: "失败"
-      - ESCALATED: "已升级"
-
-    transitions:
-      - from: INITIALIZED
-        to: REQUIREMENTS_ANALYSIS
-        trigger: workflow_start
-
-      - from: REQUIREMENTS_ANALYSIS
-        to: DESIGN_PHASE
-        trigger: requirements_complete
-
-      - from: DESIGN_PHASE
-        to: DEVELOPMENT_PHASE
-        trigger: design_approved
-
-      - from: DEVELOPMENT_PHASE
-        to: INITIAL_QA
-        trigger: development_complete
-
-      - from: INITIAL_QA
-        to: GLOBAL_AUDIT
-        trigger: initial_qa_passed
-
-      - from: GLOBAL_AUDIT
-        to: [ISSUE_IDENTIFIED, FINAL_VALIDATION]
-        trigger: audit_complete
-        condition: "issues_found ? ISSUE_IDENTIFIED : FINAL_VALIDATION"
-
-      - from: ISSUE_IDENTIFIED
-        to: FIX_IN_PROGRESS
-        trigger: issues_routed
-
-      - from: FIX_IN_PROGRESS
-        to: FIX_VALIDATION
-        trigger: fixes_complete
-
-      - from: FIX_VALIDATION
-        to: [QUALITY_LOOP, FAILED]
-        trigger: validation_complete
-        condition: "validation_passed ? QUALITY_LOOP : FAILED"
-
-      - from: QUALITY_LOOP
-        to: [GLOBAL_AUDIT, ESCALATED]
-        trigger: loop_iteration
-        condition: "max_iterations ? ESCALATED : GLOBAL_AUDIT"
-
-      - from: FINAL_VALIDATION
-        to: [RELEASE_READY, FAILED]
-        trigger: final_check
-        condition: "approved ? RELEASE_READY : FAILED"
-
-      - from: RELEASE_READY
-        to: COMPLETED
-        trigger: deployment_ready
-
-      - from: [FAILED, ESCALATED]
-        to: COMPLETED
-        trigger: manual_intervention
-
-  # ========== 质量保证配置（增强）==========
-  quality_assurance:
-    # 多层质量门控
-    quality_gates:
-      critical_gates:
-        - system_health_check
-        - requirement_coverage_100
-        - zero_critical_defects
-        - security_clearance
-        - performance_benchmarks
-
-      mandatory_gates:
-        - template_compliance
-        - code_quality_standards
-        - test_coverage_minimum
-        - documentation_completeness
-        - integration_validation
-
-      recommended_gates:
-        - user_experience_score
-        - maintainability_index
-        - technical_debt_ratio
-
-    # 质量标准（提高阈值）
-    quality_standards:
-      overall_quality_score: 95 # 提高到95
-      requirement_coverage: 100 # 100%覆盖
-      story_completeness: 95 # 95%完整性
-      code_quality_score: 90 # 90代码质量
-      test_coverage: 90 # 90%测试覆盖
-      documentation_quality: 85 # 85文档质量
-      performance_baseline: 95 # 95%性能基准
-      security_score: 95 # 95安全分数
-
-    # 自动修复策略（串行执行）
-    auto_correction:
-      enabled: true
-      execution_mode: sequential
-      max_attempts: 5 # 增加到5次
-      strategies:
-        - immediate_auto_correction
-        - guided_correction_with_ai
-        - template_based_correction
-        - incremental_improvement
-        - collaborative_refinement
-
-      sequential_validation:
-        - validate_previous_completion
-        - ensure_quality_gates_passed
-        - verify_dependencies_satisfied
-
-      rollback_on_failure: true
-      escalation_after_max_attempts: true
-      wait_for_completion: true
-
-  # ========== 监控和报告（增强 - 串行执行）==========
-  monitoring_and_reporting:
-    real_time_monitoring:
-      enabled: true
-      update_frequency: REAL_TIME
-      execution_mode: sequential
-      metrics:
-        - workflow_progress
-        - quality_scores
-        - issue_detection_rate
-        - fix_success_rate
-        - loop_iteration_count
-        - agent_performance
-        - resource_utilization
-        - sla_compliance
-        - sequential_completion_rate
-        - dependency_satisfaction_rate
-        - inter_task_quality_gates
-
-      alerting:
-        - quality_degradation
-        - sla_breach_risk
-        - loop_stuck_detection
-        - resource_exhaustion
-        - critical_failure
-        - sequential_execution_blocked
-        - dependency_validation_failed
-        - quality_gate_failure
-
-    reporting:
-      types:
-        - executive_dashboard
-        - technical_detail_report
-        - quality_audit_report
-        - issue_tracking_report
-        - performance_analysis
-        - improvement_recommendations
-
-      frequency:
-        real_time: [dashboard, alerts]
-        hourly: [progress_update]
-        daily: [quality_summary, issue_summary]
-        weekly: [trend_analysis, recommendations]
-        on_completion: [final_report, lessons_learned]
-
-    audit_trail:
-      enabled: true
-      retention: 90_days
-      tracks:
-        - all_decisions
-        - quality_gate_results
-        - issue_routing
-        - fix_attempts
-        - validation_results
-        - state_transitions
-
-  # ========== 串行处理配置（修改为串行）==========
-  serial_processing:
-    enabled: true
-    sequential_execution: true
-    optimization_strategies:
-      - dependency_aware_scheduling
-      - quality_gate_enforcement
-      - completion_validation
-      - progressive_improvement
-
-    sequential_configuration:
-      story_creation:
-        execution_mode: sequential
-        completion_requirement: 100%
-        quality_validation: mandatory
-        wait_for_previous: true
-
-      fix_execution:
-        execution_mode: sequential
-        completion_requirement: 100%
-        quality_validation: mandatory
-        dependency_enforcement: strict
-
-      validation_execution:
-        execution_mode: sequential
-        completion_requirement: 100%
-        comprehensive_validation: true
-        progressive_validation: false
-
-  # ========== 错误处理和恢复（增强）==========
-  error_handling:
-    detection_mechanisms:
-      - runtime_exception_monitoring
-      - validation_failure_detection
-      - timeout_detection
-      - resource_limit_detection
-      - quality_threshold_breach
-
-    recovery_strategies:
-      immediate_recovery:
-        - automatic_retry
-        - alternative_path
-        - graceful_degradation
-
-      checkpoint_recovery:
-        - rollback_to_checkpoint
-        - partial_state_recovery
-        - incremental_rebuild
-
-      escalation_recovery:
-        - supervisor_agent_intervention
-        - human_expert_consultation
-        - emergency_bypass
-
-    retry_policy:
-      max_retries: 5
-      backoff_strategy: exponential
-      retry_delay_base: 30 # seconds
-      max_retry_delay: 600 # 10 minutes
-
-    failure_analysis:
-      enabled: true
-      includes:
-        - root_cause_analysis
-        - impact_assessment
-        - prevention_recommendations
-        - process_improvement_suggestions
-
-  # ========== 成功标准（严格化 - 串行执行）==========
-  success_criteria:
-    mandatory_criteria:
-      - all_requirements_implemented: true
-      - zero_critical_defects: true
-      - quality_score_achieved: ">95"
-      - test_coverage_met: ">90"
-      - security_clearance: passed
-      - performance_benchmarks: met
-      - documentation_complete: true
-      - sequential_completion_verified: true
-      - inter_task_dependencies_validated: true
-
-    quality_loop_exit:
-      - no_critical_issues: true
-      - no_high_priority_issues: true
-      - medium_issues: "<5"
-      - quality_improvement_trend: positive
-      - loop_iterations: "<5"
-
-    business_criteria:
-      - user_acceptance: achieved
-      - business_value_delivered: true
-      - roi_projected: positive
-      - risk_assessment: acceptable
-
-    technical_criteria:
-      - scalability_validated: true
-      - maintainability_score: ">85"
-      - technical_debt_ratio: "<10%"
-      - architecture_compliance: 100
-
-  # ========== 决策指导 ==========
-  decision_guidance:
-    when_to_use:
-      - mission_critical_applications
-      - high_quality_requirements
-      - complex_enterprise_systems
-      - regulated_industries
-      - zero_defect_tolerance
-      - continuous_improvement_focus
-
-    benefits:
-      - guaranteed_quality_delivery
-      - automated_issue_resolution
-      - continuous_validation
-      - reduced_production_defects
-      - improved_team_efficiency
-      - comprehensive_audit_trail
-
-    considerations:
-      - longer_initial_cycle_time
-      - higher_computational_resources
-      - requires_mature_agent_ecosystem
-      - investment_in_automation_setup
-
-# ========== 工作流流程图 ==========
-flow_diagram: |
-  ```mermaid
-  graph TD
-    A[Start] --> B[Requirements Analysis]
-    B --> C[Design Phase]
-    C --> D[Development]
-    D --> E[Initial QA]
-    E --> F[Global Audit]
-    F --> G{Issues Found?}
-    G -->|Yes| H[Issue Dispatch]
-    H --> I[Sequential Fix Execution]
-    I --> J[Fix Validation]
-    J --> K{Validation Passed?}
-    K -->|No| L[Rework]
-    L --> I
-    K -->|Yes| M[Quality Loop Check]
-    M --> N{Quality Achieved?}
-    N -->|No| F
-    N -->|Yes| O[Final Validation]
-    O --> P{Approved?}
-    P -->|No| Q[Escalate]
-    P -->|Yes| R[Release Ready]
-    R --> S[Complete]
-    G -->|No| O
-    
-    style F fill:#FFE4B5
-    style H fill:#FFB6C1
-    style J fill:#ADD8E6
-    style M fill:#98FB98
-    style O fill:#DDA0DD
-    style R fill:#90EE90
-  ```
-
-# ========== 执行示例命令 ==========
-execution_examples:
-  start_workflow: |
-    xiaoma workflow start enhanced-fullstack-with-qa-loop \
-      --project-name "mission-critical-app" \
-      --quality-priority "maximum" \
-      --enable-sequential \
-      --monitor-realtime
-
-  monitor_progress: |
-    xiaoma workflow status \
-      --show-quality-metrics \
-      --show-issue-tracking \
-      --show-loop-iterations
-
-  manual_intervention: |
-    xiaoma workflow intervene \
-      --workflow-id {id} \
-      --action "approve_conditional" \
-      --justification "acceptable_risk"