@su-record/vibe 2.9.23 → 2.9.24

package/skills/design-critique/templates/critique-report.md

@@ -1,86 +1,86 @@
-# Design Critique: {{TARGET}}
-
-**Date**: {{DATE}}
-**Scope**: {{SCOPE_DESCRIPTION}}
-**Design Context**: {{CONTEXT_SOURCE}} (design-context.json / defaults)
-**Audience**: {{AUDIENCE_PRIMARY}} — {{AUDIENCE_EXPERTISE}}
-
----
-
-## Heuristic Scores
-
-| # | Heuristic | Score | Key Issue |
-|---|-----------|-------|-----------|
-| H1 | Visibility of system status | {{H1_SCORE}}/4 | {{H1_ISSUE}} |
-| H2 | Match between system and real world | {{H2_SCORE}}/4 | {{H2_ISSUE}} |
-| H3 | User control and freedom | {{H3_SCORE}}/4 | {{H3_ISSUE}} |
-| H4 | Consistency and standards | {{H4_SCORE}}/4 | {{H4_ISSUE}} |
-| H5 | Error prevention | {{H5_SCORE}}/4 | {{H5_ISSUE}} |
-| H6 | Recognition rather than recall | {{H6_SCORE}}/4 | {{H6_ISSUE}} |
-| H7 | Flexibility and efficiency | {{H7_SCORE}}/4 | {{H7_ISSUE}} |
-| H8 | Aesthetic and minimalist design | {{H8_SCORE}}/4 | {{H8_ISSUE}} |
-| H9 | Help recognize and recover from errors | {{H9_SCORE}}/4 | {{H9_ISSUE}} |
-| H10 | Help and documentation | {{H10_SCORE}}/4 | {{H10_ISSUE}} |
-| **Total** | | **{{TOTAL_SCORE}}/40** | **{{TOTAL_PCT}}%** |
-
----
-
-## Persona Red Flags
-
-### Power User — {{POWER_STATUS}}
-{{#POWER_ISSUES}}
-- {{ISSUE}}
-{{/POWER_ISSUES}}
-{{#POWER_CLEAR}}
-- No red flags
-{{/POWER_CLEAR}}
-
-### First-Time User — {{FIRST_TIME_STATUS}}
-{{#FIRST_TIME_ISSUES}}
-- {{ISSUE}}
-{{/FIRST_TIME_ISSUES}}
-{{#FIRST_TIME_CLEAR}}
-- No red flags
-{{/FIRST_TIME_CLEAR}}
-
-### Accessibility-Dependent User — {{A11Y_STATUS}}
-{{#A11Y_ISSUES}}
-- {{ISSUE}}
-{{/A11Y_ISSUES}}
-{{#A11Y_CLEAR}}
-- No red flags
-{{/A11Y_CLEAR}}
-
-### Stressed / Distracted User — {{STRESSED_STATUS}}
-{{#STRESSED_ISSUES}}
-- {{ISSUE}}
-{{/STRESSED_ISSUES}}
-{{#STRESSED_CLEAR}}
-- No red flags
-{{/STRESSED_CLEAR}}
-
-### Mobile-Only User — {{MOBILE_STATUS}}
-{{#MOBILE_ISSUES}}
-- {{ISSUE}}
-{{/MOBILE_ISSUES}}
-{{#MOBILE_CLEAR}}
-- No red flags
-{{/MOBILE_CLEAR}}
-
----
-
-## Top Recommendations
-
-{{#RECOMMENDATIONS}}
-{{INDEX}}. **[{{HEURISTIC}}]** {{RECOMMENDATION}}
-{{/RECOMMENDATIONS}}
-
----
-
-## Next Steps
-
-| Condition | Recommended Skill |
-|-----------|-------------------|
-| Visual complexity / clutter noted | `/design-distill` |
-| Token inconsistencies noted | `/design-normalize` |
-| Good overall, minor polish needed | `/design-polish` |
+# Design Critique: {{TARGET}}
+
+**Date**: {{DATE}}
+**Scope**: {{SCOPE_DESCRIPTION}}
+**Design Context**: {{CONTEXT_SOURCE}} (design-context.json / defaults)
+**Audience**: {{AUDIENCE_PRIMARY}} — {{AUDIENCE_EXPERTISE}}
+
+---
+
+## Heuristic Scores
+
+| # | Heuristic | Score | Key Issue |
+|---|-----------|-------|-----------|
+| H1 | Visibility of system status | {{H1_SCORE}}/4 | {{H1_ISSUE}} |
+| H2 | Match between system and real world | {{H2_SCORE}}/4 | {{H2_ISSUE}} |
+| H3 | User control and freedom | {{H3_SCORE}}/4 | {{H3_ISSUE}} |
+| H4 | Consistency and standards | {{H4_SCORE}}/4 | {{H4_ISSUE}} |
+| H5 | Error prevention | {{H5_SCORE}}/4 | {{H5_ISSUE}} |
+| H6 | Recognition rather than recall | {{H6_SCORE}}/4 | {{H6_ISSUE}} |
+| H7 | Flexibility and efficiency | {{H7_SCORE}}/4 | {{H7_ISSUE}} |
+| H8 | Aesthetic and minimalist design | {{H8_SCORE}}/4 | {{H8_ISSUE}} |
+| H9 | Help recognize and recover from errors | {{H9_SCORE}}/4 | {{H9_ISSUE}} |
+| H10 | Help and documentation | {{H10_SCORE}}/4 | {{H10_ISSUE}} |
+| **Total** | | **{{TOTAL_SCORE}}/40** | **{{TOTAL_PCT}}%** |
+
+---
+
+## Persona Red Flags
+
+### Power User — {{POWER_STATUS}}
+{{#POWER_ISSUES}}
+- {{ISSUE}}
+{{/POWER_ISSUES}}
+{{#POWER_CLEAR}}
+- No red flags
+{{/POWER_CLEAR}}
+
+### First-Time User — {{FIRST_TIME_STATUS}}
+{{#FIRST_TIME_ISSUES}}
+- {{ISSUE}}
+{{/FIRST_TIME_ISSUES}}
+{{#FIRST_TIME_CLEAR}}
+- No red flags
+{{/FIRST_TIME_CLEAR}}
+
+### Accessibility-Dependent User — {{A11Y_STATUS}}
+{{#A11Y_ISSUES}}
+- {{ISSUE}}
+{{/A11Y_ISSUES}}
+{{#A11Y_CLEAR}}
+- No red flags
+{{/A11Y_CLEAR}}
+
+### Stressed / Distracted User — {{STRESSED_STATUS}}
+{{#STRESSED_ISSUES}}
+- {{ISSUE}}
+{{/STRESSED_ISSUES}}
+{{#STRESSED_CLEAR}}
+- No red flags
+{{/STRESSED_CLEAR}}
+
+### Mobile-Only User — {{MOBILE_STATUS}}
+{{#MOBILE_ISSUES}}
+- {{ISSUE}}
+{{/MOBILE_ISSUES}}
+{{#MOBILE_CLEAR}}
+- No red flags
+{{/MOBILE_CLEAR}}
+
+---
+
+## Top Recommendations
+
+{{#RECOMMENDATIONS}}
+{{INDEX}}. **[{{HEURISTIC}}]** {{RECOMMENDATION}}
+{{/RECOMMENDATIONS}}
+
+---
+
+## Next Steps
+
+| Condition | Recommended Skill |
+|-----------|-------------------|
+| Visual complexity / clutter noted | `/design-distill` |
+| Token inconsistencies noted | `/design-normalize` |
+| Good overall, minor polish needed | `/design-polish` |

package/skills/design-distill/SKILL.md

@@ -1,130 +1,130 @@
----
-name: design-distill
-tier: standard
-description: "Remove unnecessary visual complexity — strip decorative clutter, apply progressive disclosure, simplify UI to essentials. Use when design-distill, simplify-ui, ui-simplify, strip-ui."
-triggers: [design-distill, simplify-ui, ui-simplify, strip-ui]
-priority: 50
----
-
-# Design Distill — Remove Visual Complexity
-
-Strip unnecessary visual elements. Every remaining element must justify its existence. Applies the principle: **if it doesn't help the user complete their task, remove it.**
-
-## Usage
-
-```
-/design-distill <target>      # Distill specific page/component
-/design-distill .              # Distill all changed UI files
-```
-
-## What Gets Distilled
-
-### 1. Decorative Clutter
-
-- Gradient backgrounds that don't convey hierarchy
-- Decorative dividers between already-spaced sections
-- Background patterns or textures without purpose
-- Ornamental icons (icons that don't aid comprehension)
-- Excessive border/shadow stacking on nested containers
-
-### 2. Redundant Information
-
-- Headings that repeat the page title or parent context
-- Labels that duplicate placeholder text
-- "Welcome to {App}" banners on authenticated pages
-- Empty state illustrations when a simple message suffices
-- Descriptions restating what the UI element obviously does
-
-### 3. Over-Wrapped Containers
-
-- Cards wrapping single elements (card containing only a button)
-- Nested cards (card inside card inside card)
-- Wrapper divs with only cosmetic purpose
-- Sections with only one child element
-
-### 4. Excessive Animation
-
-- Entry animations on every element (staggered fade-ins on list items)
-- Hover animations on non-interactive elements
-- Transitions > 300ms for feedback (feels sluggish)
-- Parallax effects on content pages
-- Decorative loading animations when a spinner suffices
-
-### 5. Progressive Disclosure Opportunities
-
-- Settings pages showing all options at once → group and collapse
-- Forms with 10+ fields visible → break into steps
-- Dashboards showing every metric → show top 3, expandable for rest
-- Navigation with 8+ top-level items → group into categories
-
-## Distillation Principles
-
-| Principle | Question to Ask |
-|-----------|----------------|
-| **Purpose** | Does this element help the user complete a task? |
-| **Duplication** | Is this information available elsewhere on screen? |
-| **Cognitive load** | Would removing this reduce decision fatigue? |
-| **Visual weight** | Does this element compete with more important content? |
-| **Progressive disclosure** | Can this be hidden until needed? |
-
-## Process
-
-1. Read target files fully
-2. Identify elements matching distillation categories
-3. For each candidate:
-   - Verify removal won't break functionality
-   - Check if element carries semantic meaning
-   - Confirm removal improves signal-to-noise ratio
-4. Apply removals and simplifications
-5. Report changes with before/after rationale
-
-## Output Format
-
-```markdown
-## Design Distill: {target}
-
-### Removed
-- ✂️ {file}:{line} — Decorative gradient background (no hierarchy purpose)
-- ✂️ {file}:{line} — Wrapper card around single button
-- ✂️ {file}:{line} — Heading repeating parent page title
-
-### Simplified
-- 🔄 {file}:{line} — Collapsed 3 nested divs into 1 flex container
-- 🔄 {file}:{line} — Replaced staggered animation with single fade-in
-
-### Progressive Disclosure Applied
-- 📦 {file}:{line} — Settings grouped into collapsible sections (was 15 flat options)
-
-### Preserved (Justified)
-- ✓ {file}:{line} — Decorative illustration on empty state (brand expression)
-
-### Summary
-- Elements reviewed: {N}
-- Removed: {N}
-- Simplified: {N}
-- Progressive disclosure: {N}
-- Net complexity reduction: {percentage}
-```
-
-## Preparation
-
-Before running distillation:
-
-1. **Read** `.claude/vibe/design-context.json`
-   - If missing → display: "Run `/design-teach` first for better results" → proceed with defaults
-   - If parse error → display warning → proceed with defaults → recommend `/design-teach`
-   - If present → preserve elements that match `brand.personality` (e.g., "playful" brand may justify decorative elements)
-2. Use `aesthetic.style` to calibrate aggressiveness (minimal → more aggressive, bold → more lenient)
-
-## Next Steps
-
-| If Result Shows | Recommended Next |
-|----------------|-----------------|
-| Elements removed/simplified | `/design-normalize` — align remaining tokens |
-| Already minimal | `/design-polish` — final pre-ship pass |
-
-## Important
-
-- **Modifying**: Directly removes and simplifies identified elements.
-- **Conservative**: Only removes elements that clearly don't serve user tasks. Brand-expressive elements preserved.
-- **Reversible**: All removals listed in report for easy review and revert if needed.
+---
+name: design-distill
+tier: standard
+description: "Remove unnecessary visual complexity — strip decorative clutter, apply progressive disclosure, simplify UI to essentials. Use when design-distill, simplify-ui, ui-simplify, strip-ui."
+triggers: [design-distill, simplify-ui, ui-simplify, strip-ui]
+priority: 50
+---
+
+# Design Distill — Remove Visual Complexity
+
+Strip unnecessary visual elements. Every remaining element must justify its existence. Applies the principle: **if it doesn't help the user complete their task, remove it.**
+
+## Usage
+
+```
+/design-distill <target>      # Distill specific page/component
+/design-distill .              # Distill all changed UI files
+```
+
+## What Gets Distilled
+
+### 1. Decorative Clutter
+
+- Gradient backgrounds that don't convey hierarchy
+- Decorative dividers between already-spaced sections
+- Background patterns or textures without purpose
+- Ornamental icons (icons that don't aid comprehension)
+- Excessive border/shadow stacking on nested containers
+
+### 2. Redundant Information
+
+- Headings that repeat the page title or parent context
+- Labels that duplicate placeholder text
+- "Welcome to {App}" banners on authenticated pages
+- Empty state illustrations when a simple message suffices
+- Descriptions restating what the UI element obviously does
+
+### 3. Over-Wrapped Containers
+
+- Cards wrapping single elements (card containing only a button)
+- Nested cards (card inside card inside card)
+- Wrapper divs with only cosmetic purpose
+- Sections with only one child element
+
+### 4. Excessive Animation
+
+- Entry animations on every element (staggered fade-ins on list items)
+- Hover animations on non-interactive elements
+- Transitions > 300ms for feedback (feels sluggish)
+- Parallax effects on content pages
+- Decorative loading animations when a spinner suffices
+
+### 5. Progressive Disclosure Opportunities
+
+- Settings pages showing all options at once → group and collapse
+- Forms with 10+ fields visible → break into steps
+- Dashboards showing every metric → show top 3, expandable for rest
+- Navigation with 8+ top-level items → group into categories
+
+## Distillation Principles
+
+| Principle | Question to Ask |
+|-----------|----------------|
+| **Purpose** | Does this element help the user complete a task? |
+| **Duplication** | Is this information available elsewhere on screen? |
+| **Cognitive load** | Would removing this reduce decision fatigue? |
+| **Visual weight** | Does this element compete with more important content? |
+| **Progressive disclosure** | Can this be hidden until needed? |
+
+## Process
+
+1. Read target files fully
+2. Identify elements matching distillation categories
+3. For each candidate:
+   - Verify removal won't break functionality
+   - Check if element carries semantic meaning
+   - Confirm removal improves signal-to-noise ratio
+4. Apply removals and simplifications
+5. Report changes with before/after rationale
+
+## Output Format
+
+```markdown
+## Design Distill: {target}
+
+### Removed
+- ✂️ {file}:{line} — Decorative gradient background (no hierarchy purpose)
+- ✂️ {file}:{line} — Wrapper card around single button
+- ✂️ {file}:{line} — Heading repeating parent page title
+
+### Simplified
+- 🔄 {file}:{line} — Collapsed 3 nested divs into 1 flex container
+- 🔄 {file}:{line} — Replaced staggered animation with single fade-in
+
+### Progressive Disclosure Applied
+- 📦 {file}:{line} — Settings grouped into collapsible sections (was 15 flat options)
+
+### Preserved (Justified)
+- ✓ {file}:{line} — Decorative illustration on empty state (brand expression)
+
+### Summary
+- Elements reviewed: {N}
+- Removed: {N}
+- Simplified: {N}
+- Progressive disclosure: {N}
+- Net complexity reduction: {percentage}
+```
+
+## Preparation
+
+Before running distillation:
+
+1. **Read** `.claude/vibe/design-context.json`
+   - If missing → display: "Run `/design-teach` first for better results" → proceed with defaults
+   - If parse error → display warning → proceed with defaults → recommend `/design-teach`
+   - If present → preserve elements that match `brand.personality` (e.g., "playful" brand may justify decorative elements)
+2. Use `aesthetic.style` to calibrate aggressiveness (minimal → more aggressive, bold → more lenient)
+
+## Next Steps
+
+| If Result Shows | Recommended Next |
+|----------------|-----------------|
+| Elements removed/simplified | `/design-normalize` — align remaining tokens |
+| Already minimal | `/design-polish` — final pre-ship pass |
+
+## Important
+
+- **Modifying**: Directly removes and simplifies identified elements.
+- **Conservative**: Only removes elements that clearly don't serve user tasks. Brand-expressive elements preserved.
+- **Reversible**: All removals listed in report for easy review and revert if needed.