@soleur/opencode 0.0.0-stage → 3.354.2

package/hooks/compaction-state.sh

@@ -0,0 +1,525 @@
+#!/usr/bin/env bash
+# compaction-state.sh -- compaction-aware session hooks (#8323, ADR-227).
+#
+# Bound TWICE in hooks.json and dispatching on hook_event_name:
+#   PreCompact   (matcher manual|auto)                -> shape the summary (FR3)
+#   SessionStart (matcher startup|resume|clear|compact) -> reset the window, or
+#                                                        emit the directive (FR1/FR2)
+#
+# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
+# MEASURED PAYLOAD CONTRACT -- Claude Code 2.1.273, Linux, 2026-09-18.
+# Captured from a real marker hook bound in a throwaway project and driven by
+# headless `claude -p --continue "/compact"`. Docs are not the source here; this
+# is. NOTHING DETECTS DRIFT IN IT AUTOMATICALLY -- an earlier revision shipped a
+# canary and review deleted it (ADR-227 `## Amendment`), because it watched the
+# transcript while this contract lives in the stdin envelope. Re-measure these
+# rows on a CLI bump; a matcher miss here is silent in both directions (a missing
+# PreCompact under-counts, a missing SessionStart source over-counts).
+#
+#   SessionStart:startup  keys: cwd hook_event_name session_id source transcript_path
+#                         ...and transcript_path names a file that DOES NOT YET EXIST.
+#   SessionStart:compact  keys: cwd hook_event_name model prompt_id session_id
+#                               source transcript_path        -- NO `trigger`.
+#   PreCompact            keys: custom_instructions cwd hook_event_name prompt_id
+#                               session_id transcript_path trigger  -- NO `source`.
+#   PostCompact           keys: compact_summary cwd hook_event_name prompt_id
+#                               session_id transcript_path trigger  -- not bound here.
+#
+#   source after a compaction is literally "compact".
+#   transcript_path is STABLE across a compaction (identical at all three events).
+#   --fork-session starts a new session_id and a new transcript file, and fired
+#     no SessionStart hook at all.
+#
+# THE TWO FINDINGS THAT DETERMINE THIS FILE'S DESIGN:
+#
+#   1. At SessionStart:compact the just-fired compaction's compact_boundary is
+#      NOT on disk. Measured twice: compaction #1 read count=0 (1 present
+#      afterwards), compaction #2 read count=1 (2 present). PostCompact, 100 ms
+#      later, reads the same lagging value. The boundary's own timestamp
+#      PRECEDES the hook fire, so the record exists in memory and is flushed
+#      after the hook returns. The transcript therefore cannot answer "how many
+#      compactions has this session had" at the moment this hook needs it, and
+#      carries no trigger for the current compaction either.
+#
+#   2. PreCompact firing does NOT imply a compaction occurred -- 3 fires
+#      produced 2 boundaries, because a /compact with nothing left to compact
+#      fires PreCompact and then no SessionStart:compact. So "append one line
+#      per PreCompact and count lines" over-counts and moves the
+#      recommendation one compaction early, with every fixture green.
+#
+# Hence PENDING-THEN-COMMIT over a per-session ledger under TMPDIR:
+#   PreCompact            overwrites one `pending` slot with its own trigger.
+#   SessionStart:compact  commits that slot as one ledger line, then counts.
+#                         It fires exactly once per REAL compaction.
+#   SessionStart:other    truncates the ledger and clears pending -- this is
+#                         what makes TR2's session-window scoping exact rather
+#                         than approximated, and it is why the matcher is
+#                         startup|resume|clear|compact and not compact alone.
+#
+# The transcript is NOT read. An earlier revision greped it once for a
+# `prior_boundaries` corroboration marker; review deleted that, because nothing
+# consumed the field and -- since the ledger resets per window while the
+# transcript accumulates across --resume -- the two numbers diverge arbitrarily,
+# so it handed the model a contradiction with no reconciliation rule. The
+# measurements in this header are what the transcript was for; they are
+# recorded, not re-derived at runtime.
+#
+# FAIL-OPEN BY CONTRACT. Every path exits 0. `trap 'exit 0' ERR EXIT`: the EXIT
+# arm is load-bearing because a `set -u` unbound-variable expansion terminates
+# the shell with status 1 WITHOUT firing ERR, and any non-zero exit other than 2
+# makes Claude Code silently drop the whole JSON output.
+#
+# Kill switch: SOLEUR_DISABLE_COMPACTION_HOOKS=1
+# Threshold:   SOLEUR_COMPACTION_COUNT_THRESHOLD (default 2)
+# ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
+
+set -uo pipefail
+trap 'exit 0' ERR EXIT
+
+# Canonical copy of test-helpers.sh's assert_fixture_dir -- P1a requires every
+# tracked copy be byte-equal, and the P1b scanner recognises ONLY this name.
+# Here it guards the ledger window: TMPDIR is caller-supplied, so a relative or
+# synthetic-fs value would put these writes somewhere unintended. The exit 2 is
+# converted to 0 by the EXIT trap above, which is the fail-open contract -- the
+# hook refuses to write and says nothing, rather than writing to a bad path.
+assert_fixture_dir() {
+  case "${1-}" in
+    "") printf 'FATAL: fixture dir is EMPTY; git -C "" would operate on %s\n' "$PWD" >&2; exit 2 ;;
+    */../*|*/..) printf 'FATAL: fixture dir %s contains ..; refusing\n' "$1" >&2; exit 2 ;;
+    /proc/*|/sys/*|/dev/*) printf 'FATAL: fixture dir %s is a synthetic-fs path; refusing\n' "$1" >&2; exit 2 ;;
+    /|//|/.) printf 'FATAL: fixture dir resolves to the filesystem root; refusing\n' >&2; exit 2 ;;
+    /*) : ;;
+    *)  printf 'FATAL: fixture dir %s is RELATIVE; refusing\n' "$1" >&2; exit 2 ;;
+  esac
+}
+
+# Written before every guard, so it certifies INVOCATION rather than success.
+# The suite floors on this: a harness that asserts without spawning the hook
+# produces none of these lines.
+[[ "${SOLEUR_DISABLE_COMPACTION_HOOKS:-0}" == "1" ]] && exit 0
+
+# Coverage trace, BELOW the kill switch. It sat above it, which made the README's
+# "no directive, no summary shaping, nothing written" false -- measured: with the
+# switch set, the hook still appended. `assert_fixture_dir` validates a path
+# STRING (absolute, no `..`, not a synthetic fs); it says nothing about symlinks,
+# ownership, or file-vs-directory, so on its own it authorises an append to any
+# absolute path the process can write. Require an EXISTING regular non-symlink
+# file: a harness creates it deliberately, a stray export cannot conjure one.
+if [[ -n "${SOLEUR_HOOK_TRACE:-}" ]]; then
+  assert_fixture_dir "$SOLEUR_HOOK_TRACE"
+  if [[ -f "$SOLEUR_HOOK_TRACE" && ! -L "$SOLEUR_HOOK_TRACE" && -O "$SOLEUR_HOOK_TRACE" ]]; then
+    printf 'ran\n' >> "$SOLEUR_HOOK_TRACE"
+  fi
+fi
+
+# Deliberate set -u fault, reachable only through this seam. It is the only way
+# to drive the EXIT arm of the trap above from a test: an ERR-only trap leaves
+# the fail-open contract broken on exactly this fault, and nothing else in the
+# script can be made to raise it on demand.
+if [[ "${SOLEUR_COMPACTION_SELFTEST_UNBOUND:-0}" == "1" ]]; then
+  printf '%s' "$__soleur_deliberately_unbound_variable"
+fi
+
+# `timeout` is the point, not `cat`. Every other external call here is bounded;
+# the one reading a stream this hook does not own was not, and `trap exit 0`
+# bounds failure, never time. A hook that HANGS at SessionStart is worse than
+# one that crashes: the session never starts, and no marker can explain it
+# because the process is still alive. hooks.json declares no per-binding
+# timeout, so the harness default was the only bound.
+RAW="$(timeout 5 cat 2>/dev/null)" || RAW=""
+
+HAVE_JQ=0
+command -v jq >/dev/null 2>&1 && HAVE_JQ=1
+
+# Flat top-level scalar read. Every field this hook consumes is a top-level
+# string in the measured envelopes, so the no-jq fallback is adequate rather
+# than a partial JSON parser pretending otherwise.
+jget() { # <key>
+  local k="$1"
+  if (( HAVE_JQ )); then
+    printf '%s' "$RAW" | jq -r --arg k "$k" '.[$k] // empty' 2>/dev/null
+    return 0
+  fi
+  printf '%s' "$RAW" \
+    | grep -oE "\"$k\"[[:space:]]*:[[:space:]]*\"[^\"]*\"" 2>/dev/null \
+    | head -1 \
+    | sed 's/.*:[[:space:]]*"\(.*\)"$/\1/' 2>/dev/null
+}
+
+EVENT="$(jget hook_event_name)"
+CWD="$(jget cwd)"
+# Caller-supplied, and the input to the scope walk, `git -C "$ROOT"` and two
+# globs -- so it gets the same gate as the ledger root rather than being trusted
+# because it comes from the CLI. A relative or `..`-bearing value would make the
+# walk test paths against whatever cwd the hook inherited.
+[[ -n "$CWD" ]] || CWD="$PWD"
+case "$CWD" in
+  /*) [[ "$CWD" == */../* || "$CWD" == */.. ]] && CWD="$PWD" ;;
+  *) CWD="$PWD" ;;
+esac
+# A non-existent cwd makes every test at the leaf false, so the walk climbs to a
+# real Soleur ancestor and reports ITS branch and plan for a directory that is
+# not there. Refuse instead of guessing.
+[[ -d "$CWD" ]] || exit 0
+
+# --- TR1 scope guard ---------------------------------------------------------
+# A plugin hook is global. `git rev-parse --is-inside-work-tree` is true in
+# EVERY customer repo, so gating on it would let PreCompact tell a stranger's
+# summarizer to preserve "PR #, plan path, unchecked ACs, operator holds" while
+# summarizing work that has none. The guard is welcome-hook.sh's sentinel -- a
+# plugins/soleur directory -- AND a Soleur plan/spec artifact. Both conjuncts
+# are load-bearing: a plugin developer's checkout has the first without the
+# second.
+# CTO ruling 2 (ADR-227 amendment). This is a RELEVANCE test -- is this project
+# one Soleur manages -- and explicitly NOT an authenticity test; no cheap
+# filesystem predicate can distinguish "my Soleur project" from "a repo I cloned
+# that looks like one", because a clone carries tracked files and Soleur's
+# artifacts are tracked. That limit is named rather than papered over, and the
+# platform baseline already exceeds it: a cloned repo reaches the model at equal
+# authority through CLAUDE.md / AGENTS.md, unconditionally and with no guard.
+#
+# The former first conjunct was a `plugins/soleur` directory, copied from
+# welcome-hook.sh. That tests whether the OPENED REPO is the Soleur monorepo --
+# which no marketplace install ever is, since `claude plugin install` puts the
+# plugin under ~/.claude/plugins/. It excluded the entire installed base, for a
+# feature whose consumers (plan/SKILL.md, work/SKILL.md) run wherever Soleur is
+# installed. Shipping that guard alongside this PR's retirement of the
+# unconditional /clear prose would have REMOVED working advice from a population
+# it could not serve. Installation itself needs no test: this file only exists
+# inside an installed, enabled plugin, so reaching this line IS the proof.
+#
+# ANCHORED at the enclosing repository, matching welcome-hook.sh's one-GIT_ROOT
+# shape: the walk stops at the first directory carrying .git (a FILE in a linked
+# worktree, a directory in a normal clone), so a stranger repo nested under a
+# Soleur checkout -- this repo's own .worktrees/ layout -- does not inherit scope.
+soleur_root() {
+  local d="$CWD" i=0
+  while [[ -n "$d" && "$d" != "/" && $i -lt 40 ]]; do
+    if [[ -d "$d/knowledge-base/project/plans" ]] || [[ -d "$d/knowledge-base/project/specs" ]]; then
+      printf '%s' "$d"
+      return 0
+    fi
+    # Repo boundary: climbing past it is what admits the nested-repo case.
+    # `-e` is FALSE for a DANGLING symlink, so `-L` is needed too or a broken
+    # .git link silently stops being a boundary.
+    { [[ -e "$d/.git" ]] || [[ -L "$d/.git" ]]; } && return 1
+    d="$(dirname "$d")"
+    i=$((i + 1))
+  done
+  return 1
+}
+ROOT="$(soleur_root)" || exit 0
+[[ -n "$ROOT" ]] || exit 0
+
+# --- ledger ------------------------------------------------------------------
+SID_RAW="$(jget session_id)"
+SID="$(printf '%s' "$SID_RAW" | tr -cd 'A-Za-z0-9_-' | cut -c1-64)"
+# Non-injective on two axes: `x/y`, `x.y` and `xy` all map to `xy`, and two ids
+# differing past char 64 map together. Harmless for today's UUIDs, and a
+# collision makes one session count another's compactions -- the over-firing
+# direction. Refuse a lossy id instead of sharing a key.
+[[ "$SID" == "$SID_RAW" ]] || SID=""
+umask 077   # ledger files were 0644; protection rested entirely on the dir mode
+LEDGER_DIR="${TMPDIR:-/tmp}/soleur-compaction"
+assert_fixture_dir "$LEDGER_DIR"
+# FAIL CLOSED on squatting. With TMPDIR unset this is /tmp/soleur-compaction,
+# world-reachable on a multi-user host. `mkdir -p || true` + `chmod || true`
+# degrades SILENTLY if another user pre-created the directory -- and a
+# pre-seeded <sid>.pending then flows through COMMITTED -> TRIGGER -> the
+# directive, which the model reads at elevated authority. Refuse instead:
+# the EXIT trap turns this into a silent exit 0, which is the fail-open
+# contract for the FEATURE and fail-closed for the WRITE.
+# Two calls, not `mkdir -m 0700 -p`: with -p the mode applies only to the
+# DEEPEST directory (shellcheck SC2174), so any parent this creates would take
+# the umask. The leaf is created WITHOUT -p so it is either made 0700 here or
+# already exists, and the ownership check below is what actually decides.
+mkdir -p "${LEDGER_DIR%/*}" 2>/dev/null || true
+mkdir -m 0700 "$LEDGER_DIR" 2>/dev/null || true
+# `-L` FIRST: `-d` and `-O` both stat rather than lstat, so a symlink planted at
+# this predictable path satisfied both -- measured, the hook wrote through it into
+# a victim-owned directory and chmod 700'd the TARGET.
+if [[ -L "$LEDGER_DIR" ]] || [[ ! -d "$LEDGER_DIR" ]] || [[ ! -O "$LEDGER_DIR" ]]; then
+  LEDGER_DIR_UNUSABLE=1
+else
+  LEDGER_DIR_UNUSABLE=0
+  chmod 700 "$LEDGER_DIR" 2>/dev/null || true
+fi
+LEDGER="$LEDGER_DIR/${SID}.ledger"
+PENDING="$LEDGER_DIR/${SID}.pending"
+
+# Bounded growth. Entries are disposable by construction -- a lost ledger costs
+# one directive, never correctness.
+find "$LEDGER_DIR" -maxdepth 1 -type f \( -name '*.ledger' -o -name '*.pending' \) \
+  -mmin +10080 -delete 2>/dev/null || true
+
+# Every value interpolated into `additionalContext` is read by the model at
+# ELEVATED AUTHORITY, so each one is an injection surface. `trigger` and
+# `threshold` are closed-set / digits-only; these are free text from sources the
+# hook does not own -- a git ref name is chosen by whoever created the branch, and
+# a GIT FILENAME MAY CONTAIN NEWLINES, which `jq --arg` faithfully preserves as
+# real newlines inside the string the model reads. Reduce to a conservative
+# display charset and cap the length; an empty result becomes `unknown`.
+sanitize_display() { # <value> <fallback>
+  local v
+  v="$(printf '%s' "${1-}" | tr -cd 'A-Za-z0-9._/+@-' | cut -c1-200)"
+  printf '%s' "${v:-${2-unknown}}"
+}
+
+# --- PreCompact (FR3) --------------------------------------------------------
+if [[ "$EVENT" == "PreCompact" ]]; then
+  # AP-020: check a contracted field's SHAPE rather than assuming it. `trigger`
+  # is model-adjacent input that (a) gates the recommendation and (b) is
+  # interpolated into text the model reads at elevated authority. Unvalidated, a
+  # multi-line value inflates the ledger's line count -- which IS count_total --
+  # and forces recommend=true. Closed set, measured at CLI 2.1.273.
+  TRIGGER="$(jget trigger)"
+  case "$TRIGGER" in
+    manual|auto) : ;;
+    *) TRIGGER="unknown" ;;
+  esac
+  # Summary shaping does not need the ledger, so an unusable root suppresses the
+  # WRITE and not the FR3 prose.
+  if [[ -n "$SID" ]] && (( ! LEDGER_DIR_UNUSABLE )); then
+    # OVERWRITE, never append: PreCompact fires on no-op compactions, and only
+    # SessionStart:compact proves one actually happened.
+    assert_fixture_dir "$LEDGER_DIR"
+    printf '%s\n' "$TRIGGER" > "$PENDING" 2>/dev/null || true
+  fi
+  # Plain text, never JSON: this stream is read by the summarizer, and never
+  # exits 2 -- blocking a compaction trades a recoverable context loss for a
+  # dead session (NG3).
+  cat <<'PRECOMPACT'
+When summarizing, preserve these verbatim -- a resume depends on them:
+- the git branch and the worktree directory currently in use
+- the PR # and the issue # under work, and the plan path
+- the active skill and phase, and every unchecked acceptance criteria item
+- anything recorded under Operator Holds
+- every file path mentioned, spelled exactly as written
+Keep the paths themselves. Summarize what was done to them; do not reproduce
+what they contain.
+PRECOMPACT
+  exit 0
+fi
+
+[[ "$EVENT" == "SessionStart" ]] || exit 0
+
+# Reached here with an unusable ledger root: PreCompact already returned above,
+# so this is the SessionStart arm and it owes the model a reason. Emitting
+# nothing made a permanent per-host disable indistinguishable from "this session
+# has not compacted" -- and the plan's own Observability block promises every
+# failure path emits a named marker.
+
+SOURCE="$(jget source)"
+
+# --- envelope emission -------------------------------------------------------
+# stdout carries the JSON envelope and NOTHING else; a stray byte invalidates
+# the whole output. Diagnostics go to stderr.
+emit() { # <additionalContext>
+  local ctx="${1:0:8000}"
+  if (( HAVE_JQ )); then
+    jq -nc --arg c "$ctx" \
+      '{hookSpecificOutput:{hookEventName:"SessionStart",additionalContext:$c}}'
+  else
+    # The envelope cannot be built with jq in this state, so it is emitted
+    # literally -- no interpolation, hence nothing to escape.
+    printf '%s\n' '{"hookSpecificOutput":{"hookEventName":"SessionStart","additionalContext":"SOLEUR_COMPACTION_SKIPPED reason=jq-unavailable -- compaction state could not be reported. Context was just compacted: re-read the plan and spec before editing (hr-always-read-a-file-before-editing-it)."}}'
+  fi
+}
+
+
+# --- SessionStart, window reset ----------------------------------------------
+# startup / resume / clear all open a new window. Guarding only `resume` would
+# leave two of the three unscoped, which is how a long session pins
+# recommend=true forever (TR2).
+case "$SOURCE" in
+  startup|resume|clear) SOURCE_CLASS=reset ;;
+  compact)              SOURCE_CLASS=compact ;;
+  *)                    SOURCE_CLASS=unknown ;;
+esac
+
+if [[ "$SOURCE_CLASS" != "compact" ]]; then
+  # `unknown` must not RESET -- the matcher admits any source containing one of
+  # the four words, and a future `precompact` would otherwise truncate the
+  # ledger at the event it counts. But it must not be SILENT either.
+  #
+  # This is the one arm whose failure is permanent and total. `compact` is the
+  # only source the gate counts, and the Phase 0 addendum measured SessionStart
+  # only after MANUAL compactions (`claude -p --continue "/compact"`); that an
+  # AUTOMATIC one also arrives with the literal source `compact` is marked
+  # Inferential there, not measured. If it ever arrives as anything else
+  # (`auto_compact`, say), every install loses the feature forever -- and a bare
+  # `exit 0` makes that byte-identical to "this session has not compacted".
+  #
+  # stderr is NOT the channel: this hook exits 0, and stderr on an exit-0 hook is
+  # discarded. That is precisely the defect the design-validity pass deleted the
+  # drift canary over; reintroducing it here would repeat it.
+  if [[ "$SOURCE_CLASS" != "reset" ]]; then
+    emit "SOLEUR_COMPACTION_SKIPPED reason=unknown-source source=$(sanitize_display "$SOURCE" empty) -- this SessionStart source is outside the measured set (startup|resume|clear|compact), so no compaction state was read or written. If this appears after an automatic compaction, the recommendation gate is dark on this harness and the matcher needs the observed spelling."
+    exit 0
+  fi
+  # The `LEDGER_DIR_UNUSABLE` conjunct is the half scenario 23 was missing. Its
+  # stated thesis is "the WRITE fails closed", and PreCompact's write does --
+  # but this DELETE did not, so a symlinked ledger root made one SessionStart
+  # unlink `<sid>.ledger` and `<sid>.pending` inside the link target. The names
+  # are session-id-derived so it is not an arbitrary-file delete, but "refuses
+  # to touch a root it has already judged hostile" is the invariant, and it was
+  # false on exactly one of the two paths.
+  if [[ -n "$SID" ]] && (( ! LEDGER_DIR_UNUSABLE )); then
+    assert_fixture_dir "$LEDGER_DIR"
+    rm -f "$LEDGER" "$PENDING" 2>/dev/null || true
+    if [[ -s "$LEDGER" ]]; then
+      # A surviving ledger carries the PREVIOUS window's rows into this one and
+      # is the only state that over-counts. Never silent -- and not via stderr,
+      # which an exit-0 hook discards.
+      emit "SOLEUR_COMPACTION_SKIPPED reason=window-reset-failed path=$(sanitize_display "$LEDGER" unknown) -- the previous window's compaction rows survived this session reset, so any recommendation in this window may over-count."
+    fi
+  fi
+  exit 0
+fi
+
+if (( ! HAVE_JQ )); then
+  emit ""
+  exit 0
+fi
+
+if (( LEDGER_DIR_UNUSABLE )); then
+  emit "SOLEUR_COMPACTION_SKIPPED reason=ledger-dir-unusable -- the compaction ledger directory is missing, foreign-owned or a symlink, so no compaction state could be recorded. Context was just compacted: re-read the plan and spec before editing (hr-always-read-a-file-before-editing-it)."
+  exit 0
+fi
+
+if [[ -z "$SID" ]]; then
+  emit "SOLEUR_COMPACTION_SKIPPED reason=no-session-id"
+  exit 0
+fi
+
+# Commit the pending slot. Reached exactly once per real compaction.
+COMMITTED=""
+if [[ -f "$PENDING" ]]; then
+  COMMITTED="$(head -1 "$PENDING" 2>/dev/null || true)"
+  # Re-assert the closed set BEFORE the append. The pending file is same-uid
+  # writable and its value reaches count_total and the "compaction N" sentence
+  # even where it cannot reach `recommend`.
+  case "$COMMITTED" in
+    manual|auto) : ;;
+    *) COMMITTED="unknown" ;;
+  esac
+  assert_fixture_dir "$LEDGER_DIR"
+  printf '%s\n' "$COMMITTED" >> "$LEDGER" 2>/dev/null || true
+  rm -f "$PENDING" 2>/dev/null || true
+fi
+
+COUNT_TOTAL=0
+COUNT_AUTO=0
+if [[ -r "$LEDGER" ]]; then
+  COUNT_TOTAL="$(LC_ALL=C grep -acxE 'manual|auto|unknown' "$LEDGER" 2>/dev/null || true)"
+  COUNT_AUTO="$(LC_ALL=C grep -acx 'auto' "$LEDGER" 2>/dev/null || true)"
+fi
+COUNT_TOTAL="${COUNT_TOTAL:-0}"
+COUNT_AUTO="${COUNT_AUTO:-0}"
+
+if [[ "$COUNT_TOTAL" -eq 0 ]]; then
+  # No PreCompact was seen for this window. Honest silence beats a guess: the
+  # transcript cannot supply the answer (finding 1 above).
+  emit "SOLEUR_COMPACTION_SKIPPED reason=no-ledger-entry -- context was compacted but this session's compaction ledger is empty. Re-read the plan and spec before editing (hr-always-read-a-file-before-editing-it)."
+  exit 0
+fi
+
+# `tail -1 "$LEDGER"` as the fallback reinstated, on the missing-pending path,
+# exactly what alternative (a) is rejected for: it reports the PREVIOUS
+# compaction's trigger for the current event. Measured -- a third compaction with
+# no pending slot inherited `trigger=auto` and was not counted. Unknown is the
+# honest answer, and the closed-set rule already stops it recommending.
+TRIGGER="$COMMITTED"
+case "$TRIGGER" in
+  manual|auto) : ;;
+  *) TRIGGER="unknown" ;;
+esac
+
+CLI="${SOLEUR_COMPACTION_CLI_VERSION:-}"
+if [[ -z "$CLI" ]] && command -v claude >/dev/null 2>&1; then
+  # `command -v` first: this runs with the cwd of an arbitrary repo, so resolving
+  # `claude` by bare name is a PATH question, not a given.
+  CLI="$(timeout 5 claude --version 2>/dev/null | head -1 | awk '{print $1}' || true)"
+fi
+CLI="$(sanitize_display "$CLI" unknown)"
+
+# `symbolic-ref --short -q` is this repo's precedent for exactly this
+# (.claude/hooks/ship-unpushed-commits-gate.sh): it exits non-zero on a detached
+# HEAD, where `rev-parse --abbrev-ref` returns the literal string `HEAD` and
+# would have the directive assert `Branch: HEAD.` to the model. CI checks out a
+# detached HEAD on pull_request, so that is the common case, not an edge one.
+BRANCH="$(timeout 5 git -C "$ROOT" symbolic-ref --short -q HEAD 2>/dev/null || true)"
+BRANCH="$(sanitize_display "$BRANCH" unknown)"
+
+PLAN=""
+if [[ "$BRANCH" != "unknown" ]]; then
+  for p in "$ROOT/knowledge-base/project/plans/"*"-${BRANCH}-plan.md"; do
+    [[ -e "$p" ]] && PLAN="$(sanitize_display "knowledge-base/project/plans/$(basename "$p")" "")"
+  done
+fi
+SPEC=""
+# Same `unknown` gate as PLAN above. Without it a detached HEAD -- which this
+# file's own comment calls the common case, since CI checks one out for
+# `pull_request` -- makes the directive assert `specs/unknown/` to the model the
+# moment such a directory exists. PLAN was gated and SPEC was not; one sentinel,
+# two consumers, one of them guarded.
+if [[ "$BRANCH" != "unknown" ]]; then
+  [[ -d "$ROOT/knowledge-base/project/specs/$BRANCH" ]] \
+    && SPEC="$(sanitize_display "knowledge-base/project/specs/$BRANCH/" "")"
+fi
+
+THRESHOLD="${SOLEUR_COMPACTION_COUNT_THRESHOLD:-2}"
+case "$THRESHOLD" in
+  ''|*[!0-9]*) THRESHOLD=2 ;;   # a non-numeric seam makes (( )) evaluate false
+esac                            # silently, skipping the branch rather than failing
+THRESHOLD=$((10#$THRESHOLD))    # `010` passes the digit filter and (( )) reads octal
+# The CTO ruling requires a floor of at least 1: with the trigger operand gone,
+# THRESHOLD=0 makes the gate true on a ledger holding ZERO auto lines. Floored to
+# the DEFAULT (2) rather than to 1 -- a deviation, recorded in ADR-227. `0` is
+# what an operator types meaning "off", and flooring to 1 would hand that person
+# the MOST aggressive setting, which is the over-firing harm delivered to someone
+# trying to disable the feature. The off switch is
+# SOLEUR_DISABLE_COMPACTION_HOOKS. Written as if/fi, not `(( )) && x`: measured on
+# bash 5.3.15 the && form does not abort under `trap ERR EXIT`, but if/fi does not
+# depend on that exemption.
+if (( THRESHOLD < 1 )); then THRESHOLD=2; fi
+
+# CTO ruling 1 (ADR-227 amendment): the gate is COUNT_AUTO alone. The current
+# event's trigger was a second operand that could only ever REVOKE -- COUNT_AUTO
+# rises only on a SessionStart:compact that commits an `auto` line, so the first
+# emission crossing the threshold always had trigger=auto and fired either way.
+# Its sole behavioural delta was retracting a recommendation already issued,
+# which overwrites a correct recommend=true with an affirmative recommend=false
+# at the moment the model can least reconstruct it. The ledger is append-only
+# within a window, so RECOMMEND is already monotonic without a sticky bit.
+RECOMMEND=false
+if (( COUNT_AUTO >= THRESHOLD )); then
+  RECOMMEND=true
+fi
+
+# Pointers, never content. Nothing read out of the transcript is echoed: the
+# only transcript-derived value here is an integer (NG5, and the
+# elevated-authority framing hook-delivered text carries).
+CTX="SOLEUR_COMPACTION_DIRECTIVE count_auto=${COUNT_AUTO} count_total=${COUNT_TOTAL} trigger=${TRIGGER} recommend=${RECOMMEND} threshold=${THRESHOLD} cli=${CLI} branch=${BRANCH}
+
+Context was just compacted (compaction ${COUNT_TOTAL} of this session, trigger=${TRIGGER}).
+The summary above is a paraphrase written by another model. Before editing any
+file, re-read the artifacts it names -- hr-always-read-a-file-before-editing-it.
+Branch: ${BRANCH}."
+[[ -n "$PLAN" ]] && CTX="${CTX}
+Plan: ${PLAN}"
+[[ -n "$SPEC" ]] && CTX="${CTX}
+Spec and tasks: ${SPEC}"
+
+if [[ "$RECOMMEND" == "true" ]]; then
+  CTX="${CTX}
+
+${COUNT_AUTO} automatic compactions have now occurred in this session window.
+At the next phase boundary -- not mid-pipeline -- emit the resume prompt per
+wg-end-of-work-emit-resume-prompt and recommend continuing in a fresh session.
+Inside /soleur:one-shot, never pause for this: carry the recommendation into the
+final resume prompt instead."
+fi
+
+emit "$CTX"
+exit 0