@rankcli/agent-runtime 0.0.15 → 0.0.17

package/src/audit/checks/ai-content-structure.ts

@@ -1,325 +0,0 @@
-/**
- * AI Content Structure Checks
- *
- * AI systems prefer well-structured content that's easy to parse and quote.
- * These checks verify content is formatted optimally for AI consumption:
- * - Tables for comparisons/data
- * - Numbered lists for steps/procedures
- * - Bullet points for features/benefits
- * - Clear Q&A format for direct answers
- * - Concise, quotable statements
- */
-
-import * as cheerio from 'cheerio';
-import type { AuditIssue } from '../types.js';
-
-export interface AIContentStructureData {
-  tables: {
-    count: number;
-    hasComparisonTable: boolean;
-    hasDataTable: boolean;
-  };
-  lists: {
-    orderedLists: number;
-    unorderedLists: number;
-    hasStepByStep: boolean;
-    hasBulletedFeatures: boolean;
-  };
-  qaFormat: {
-    hasExplicitQA: boolean;
-    questionCount: number;
-    hasDirectAnswers: boolean;
-  };
-  quotability: {
-    hasDefinitions: boolean;
-    hasConciseStatements: boolean;
-    shortParagraphRatio: number;
-  };
-  structureScore: number;
-}
-
-export function analyzeAIContentStructure(
-  html: string,
-  url: string
-): { issues: AuditIssue[]; data: AIContentStructureData } {
-  const issues: AuditIssue[] = [];
-  const $ = cheerio.load(html);
-
-  // Remove nav, footer, aside, scripts, styles for content analysis
-  $('nav, footer, aside, script, style, noscript, header').remove();
-
-  // Analyze tables
-  const tables = $('table');
-  const tableCount = tables.length;
-  let hasComparisonTable = false;
-  let hasDataTable = false;
-
-  tables.each((_, table) => {
-    const $table = $(table);
-    const headers = $table.find('th').length;
-    const rows = $table.find('tr').length;
-    const cells = $table.find('td').length;
-
-    // Comparison table: multiple columns with headers
-    if (headers >= 2 && rows >= 3) {
-      hasComparisonTable = true;
-    }
-
-    // Data table: has numeric data
-    const cellTexts = $table.find('td').map((_, td) => $(td).text()).get();
-    const hasNumbers = cellTexts.some(text => /\d+/.test(text));
-    if (hasNumbers && cells >= 4) {
-      hasDataTable = true;
-    }
-  });
-
-  // Analyze lists
-  const orderedLists = $('ol').length;
-  const unorderedLists = $('ul').not('nav ul').length;
-
-  // Check for step-by-step content
-  let hasStepByStep = false;
-  $('ol').each((_, ol) => {
-    const items = $(ol).find('> li').length;
-    if (items >= 3) {
-      hasStepByStep = true;
-    }
-  });
-
-  // Check for bulleted features/benefits
-  let hasBulletedFeatures = false;
-  $('ul').not('nav ul').each((_, ul) => {
-    const items = $(ul).find('> li').length;
-    if (items >= 3) {
-      hasBulletedFeatures = true;
-    }
-  });
-
-  // Analyze Q&A format
-  const bodyText = $('body').text().toLowerCase();
-  const headings = $('h1, h2, h3, h4, h5, h6');
-  let questionCount = 0;
-  let hasDirectAnswers = false;
-
-  headings.each((_, heading) => {
-    const text = $(heading).text();
-    // Check if heading is a question
-    if (text.includes('?') || /^(what|how|why|when|where|who|which|can|does|is|are|should|will)\s/i.test(text)) {
-      questionCount++;
-
-      // Check if followed by a direct answer (short paragraph)
-      const nextP = $(heading).next('p');
-      if (nextP.length) {
-        const answerText = nextP.text();
-        if (answerText.length > 20 && answerText.length < 300) {
-          hasDirectAnswers = true;
-        }
-      }
-    }
-  });
-
-  // Check for explicit Q&A format (FAQ style)
-  const hasExplicitQA =
-    $('[itemtype*="FAQPage"]').length > 0 ||
-    $('[itemtype*="Question"]').length > 0 ||
-    $('.faq, #faq, [class*="faq"], [id*="faq"]').length > 0 ||
-    $('details summary').length >= 2 ||
-    $('dt').length >= 2; // Definition lists often used for Q&A
-
-  // Analyze quotability
-  const paragraphs = $('p');
-  let shortParagraphCount = 0;
-  let totalParagraphs = 0;
-  let hasDefinitions = false;
-  let hasConciseStatements = false;
-
-  paragraphs.each((_, p) => {
-    const text = $(p).text().trim();
-    if (text.length < 20) return; // Skip very short paragraphs
-
-    totalParagraphs++;
-
-    // Short paragraphs (under 150 chars) are more quotable
-    if (text.length < 150) {
-      shortParagraphCount++;
-    }
-
-    // Check for definition patterns ("X is a...", "X refers to...")
-    if (/^[A-Z][^.]+\s+(is|are|refers to|means|describes)\s+/i.test(text)) {
-      hasDefinitions = true;
-    }
-
-    // Concise statements with clear structure
-    if (text.length < 200 && (
-      text.includes(':') ||
-      /^(The|A|An)\s+\w+/.test(text) ||
-      /^\d+\.?\s+/.test(text)
-    )) {
-      hasConciseStatements = true;
-    }
-  });
-
-  const shortParagraphRatio = totalParagraphs > 0
-    ? shortParagraphCount / totalParagraphs
-    : 0;
-
-  // Calculate structure score (0-100)
-  let structureScore = 50; // Base score
-
-  // Tables bonus
-  if (hasComparisonTable) structureScore += 10;
-  if (hasDataTable) structureScore += 5;
-
-  // Lists bonus
-  if (hasStepByStep) structureScore += 10;
-  if (hasBulletedFeatures) structureScore += 5;
-
-  // Q&A bonus
-  if (hasExplicitQA) structureScore += 10;
-  if (questionCount >= 3) structureScore += 5;
-  if (hasDirectAnswers) structureScore += 5;
-
-  // Quotability bonus
-  if (hasDefinitions) structureScore += 5;
-  if (hasConciseStatements) structureScore += 5;
-  if (shortParagraphRatio > 0.3) structureScore += 5;
-
-  // Penalties
-  if (tableCount === 0 && orderedLists === 0 && unorderedLists === 0) {
-    structureScore -= 15; // No structured content at all
-  }
-  if (questionCount === 0) {
-    structureScore -= 5; // No question-based headings
-  }
-
-  structureScore = Math.max(0, Math.min(100, structureScore));
-
-  // Generate issues
-
-  // No tables for comparisons
-  if (!hasComparisonTable && bodyText.includes('compar') || bodyText.includes('vs') || bodyText.includes('versus')) {
-    issues.push({
-      code: 'AI_NO_COMPARISON_TABLE',
-      severity: 'notice',
-      category: 'ai-readiness',
-      title: 'Comparison content without table format',
-      description: 'Your content mentions comparisons but doesn\'t use a table format. AI systems can easily parse and quote table data.',
-      impact: 'AI may not accurately extract comparison data, reducing chances of being cited in AI-generated comparisons.',
-      howToFix: 'Convert comparison content to HTML tables with clear headers. Example: Feature | Option A | Option B',
-      affectedUrls: [url],
-    });
-  }
-
-  // No numbered lists for procedural content
-  if (!hasStepByStep && (bodyText.includes('step') || bodyText.includes('how to') || bodyText.includes('guide'))) {
-    issues.push({
-      code: 'AI_NO_NUMBERED_STEPS',
-      severity: 'notice',
-      category: 'ai-readiness',
-      title: 'Procedural content without numbered steps',
-      description: 'Your content appears to be a guide or how-to but doesn\'t use numbered lists. AI prefers numbered lists for step-by-step content.',
-      impact: 'AI may not accurately quote your steps in order, or may skip your content for better-structured alternatives.',
-      howToFix: 'Convert step-by-step instructions to <ol> (ordered list) format with clear, actionable items.',
-      affectedUrls: [url],
-    });
-  }
-
-  // No Q&A format
-  if (!hasExplicitQA && questionCount === 0) {
-    issues.push({
-      code: 'AI_NO_QA_FORMAT',
-      severity: 'notice',
-      category: 'ai-readiness',
-      title: 'No question-and-answer format detected',
-      description: 'Content lacks explicit Q&A structure. AI systems often look for clear question-answer pairs to provide direct responses.',
-      impact: 'Lower chance of being featured in AI direct answers or FAQ-style responses.',
-      howToFix: 'Add FAQ section with common questions as headings (H2/H3) followed by concise answers. Implement FAQ schema markup.',
-      affectedUrls: [url],
-      details: {
-        suggestions: [
-          'Use question words in headings (What, How, Why, etc.)',
-          'Follow questions with short, direct answer paragraphs',
-          'Add FAQ schema markup for structured data',
-          'Consider using <details>/<summary> for expandable Q&A',
-        ],
-      },
-    });
-  }
-
-  // Questions without direct answers
-  if (questionCount >= 2 && !hasDirectAnswers) {
-    issues.push({
-      code: 'AI_QUESTIONS_NO_DIRECT_ANSWERS',
-      severity: 'notice',
-      category: 'ai-readiness',
-      title: 'Questions in headings lack direct answers',
-      description: `Found ${questionCount} question-style headings but answers are too long or not immediately following. AI prefers concise answers right after questions.`,
-      impact: 'AI may struggle to extract clear answers, reducing citation likelihood.',
-      howToFix: 'Start each answer section with a 1-2 sentence direct answer, then expand with details. First sentence should standalone as a complete answer.',
-      affectedUrls: [url],
-    });
-  }
-
-  // No definitions
-  if (!hasDefinitions && (bodyText.includes('what is') || bodyText.includes('definition'))) {
-    issues.push({
-      code: 'AI_NO_DEFINITIONS',
-      severity: 'notice',
-      category: 'ai-readiness',
-      title: 'Missing clear definitions',
-      description: 'Content discusses concepts but lacks Wikipedia-style definitions. AI loves clear "X is a..." statements.',
-      impact: 'Less likely to be cited for definitional queries in AI search.',
-      howToFix: 'Add clear definitions early in content: "[Term] is a [category] that [distinguishing features]." Make first paragraph a complete definition.',
-      affectedUrls: [url],
-    });
-  }
-
-  // Low quotability
-  if (structureScore < 50) {
-    issues.push({
-      code: 'AI_LOW_STRUCTURE_SCORE',
-      severity: 'warning',
-      category: 'ai-readiness',
-      title: 'Content structure not optimized for AI parsing',
-      description: `AI structure score: ${structureScore}/100. Content lacks structured elements that AI can easily parse and quote.`,
-      impact: 'Lower likelihood of being cited in AI-generated answers due to poor content structure.',
-      howToFix: 'Improve content structure: add tables for data, numbered lists for steps, bullet points for features, Q&A sections for common questions.',
-      affectedUrls: [url],
-      details: {
-        structureScore,
-        hasTable: tableCount > 0,
-        hasOrderedList: orderedLists > 0,
-        hasUnorderedList: unorderedLists > 0,
-        hasQAFormat: hasExplicitQA || questionCount > 0,
-      },
-    });
-  }
-
-  return {
-    issues,
-    data: {
-      tables: {
-        count: tableCount,
-        hasComparisonTable,
-        hasDataTable,
-      },
-      lists: {
-        orderedLists,
-        unorderedLists,
-        hasStepByStep,
-        hasBulletedFeatures,
-      },
-      qaFormat: {
-        hasExplicitQA,
-        questionCount,
-        hasDirectAnswers,
-      },
-      quotability: {
-        hasDefinitions,
-        hasConciseStatements,
-        shortParagraphRatio,
-      },
-      structureScore,
-    },
-  };
-}