@mmerterden/multi-agent-pipeline 20.7.0 → 20.8.0

package/pipeline/skills/shared/external/swift-architecture/evals/evals.json

@@ -3,42 +3,42 @@
   "evals": [
     {
       "id": 0,
-      "prompt": "A small SwiftUI travel app has three CRUD screens, async loading from a service, simple search, and one edit sheet. The team wants to start with TCA because it sounds more testable. Review the architecture choice for Swift 6.3 and recommend the smallest pattern that still keeps the code testable.",
-      "expected_output": "A scope-aware architecture review that recommends MV with @Observable as the default starting point, explains when MVVM or TCA would become justified, and keeps detailed SwiftUI state wiring out of scope except for handoff notes.",
+      "prompt": "We are starting a small SwiftUI app for logging house plants: a list, an add form, an edit sheet and a detail screen, backed by a REST API. One developer wants TCA from day one so it scales. What architecture should we use, and when would we change it? Also tell us how to hold state in the edit sheet and how to push the detail screen.",
+      "expected_output": "An MV recommendation with @Observable, clear escalation triggers, injected dependencies and main-actor observed state, with state-wrapper and navigation details routed to sibling skills.",
       "files": [],
       "expectations": [
-        "Recommends starting with MV and @Observable for the described small-to-medium SwiftUI app instead of defaulting to TCA.",
-        "Explains the upgrade triggers for MVVM or TCA in terms of transformed view state, deterministic state transitions, side effects, feature composition, or testing pressure.",
-        "Keeps dependencies injected rather than created inside views or stores.",
-        "Mentions @MainActor for UI-observed Observable state or otherwise preserves Swift 6 data-race safety.",
-        "Routes detailed SwiftUI state ownership and sheet/navigation implementation to swiftui-patterns or swiftui-navigation instead of expanding this skill's scope."
+        "Recommends MV with @Observable models for this CRUD scope instead of TCA",
+        "Names escalation triggers such as transformed view state, deterministic transitions, managed side effects, feature composition and testing pressure",
+        "Injects the API client or repository rather than creating it inside the model",
+        "Places UI-observed state on @MainActor",
+        "Routes edit-sheet state details to swiftui-patterns and detail navigation to swiftui-navigation"
       ]
     },
     {
       "id": 1,
-      "prompt": "We're migrating an iOS 16 UIKit-heavy app that uses Coordinators, ObservableObject view models, and a few VIPER modules. New features are SwiftUI, but the old modules are still shipping. Write a migration plan that modernizes Observation without forcing one architecture everywhere.",
-      "expected_output": "An incremental migration plan that replaces ObservableObject with @Observable where iOS 17+ is available, preserves Coordinator or VIPER boundaries for legacy UIKit modules, and allows different modules to adopt MV, MVVM, or TCA where justified.",
+      "prompt": "Our app mixes old UIKit VIPER modules, some SwiftUI screens with ObservableObject view models, and coordinators everywhere, including in pure SwiftUI flows. Plan a migration to a modern architecture. Can each module end up different, or must the whole app use one pattern?",
+      "expected_output": "A per-module migration plan covering Observation, VIPER, coordinators versus NavigationStack, per-module consistency and handoffs.",
       "files": [],
       "expectations": [
-        "Describes ObservableObject to @Observable migration using State for owned observable objects, plain properties for read-only injected objects, and Bindable only when bindings are needed.",
-        "Treats VIPER as a legacy or strict-boundary maintenance pattern rather than the default for new SwiftUI work.",
-        "Keeps Coordinators for UIKit or hybrid complex navigation but recommends NavigationStack/path routing for pure SwiftUI flows.",
-        "Allows architecture to vary by feature module while warning against mixing patterns inconsistently inside a single module.",
-        "Identifies sibling handoffs for detailed concurrency diagnostics, navigation routing, and Swift Testing implementation."
+        "Moves ObservableObject to @Observable, using @State for owned models, plain properties for read-only injected models and @Bindable only where bindings are needed",
+        "Treats VIPER as a legacy pattern to keep only where modules already depend on it",
+        "Keeps coordinators at UIKit and hybrid boundaries and uses NavigationStack path routing in pure SwiftUI flows",
+        "Allows different patterns across modules during migration while keeping each module internally consistent",
+        "Hands off concurrency diagnostics to swift-concurrency, navigation details to swiftui-navigation, and test mechanics to swift-testing"
       ]
     },
     {
       "id": 2,
-      "prompt": "A product lead asks for one architecture memo covering SwiftUI state ownership, deep links and tab routing, actor isolation errors, app-wide module boundaries, and test strategy. Split what belongs in swift-architecture versus adjacent skills, then give the architecture-level recommendations.",
-      "expected_output": "A boundary-routing memo that keeps architecture selection, module boundaries, dependency direction, and migration strategy in swift-architecture while routing detailed SwiftUI state, navigation, concurrency, and test harness mechanics to sibling skills.",
+      "prompt": "For our banking app's new transfers feature, answer all of this at once: which architecture, how the modules and dependencies should be laid out, which property wrappers the views use, how deep links, tabs and sheets reach the feature, how to fix the Sendable errors we are getting, and how to write parameterized tests with fixtures.",
+      "expected_output": "An architecture-level recommendation that owns selection, module boundaries, dependency direction and migration, and explicitly routes the rest to sibling skills.",
       "files": [],
       "expectations": [
-        "Keeps pattern selection, module boundaries, dependency direction, and migration strategy in swift-architecture scope.",
-        "Routes detailed SwiftUI @State/@Bindable/@Environment ownership and view composition to swiftui-patterns.",
-        "Routes deep links, tabs, sheets, NavigationStack, and route-model implementation to swiftui-navigation.",
-        "Routes actor isolation, Sendable, strict-concurrency diagnostics, and default MainActor isolation details to swift-concurrency.",
-        "Routes detailed Swift Testing syntax, fixtures, parameterized tests, and suite organization to swift-testing.",
-        "Still provides a concise architecture-level recommendation rather than only listing handoffs."
+        "Keeps pattern selection, module boundaries, dependency direction and migration strategy in scope",
+        "Routes property wrapper choices to swiftui-patterns",
+        "Routes deep links, tabs and sheets to swiftui-navigation",
+        "Routes isolation and Sendable diagnostics to swift-concurrency",
+        "Routes test syntax, fixtures and parameterized tests to swift-testing",
+        "Still gives a concrete architecture recommendation rather than only listing handoffs"
       ]
     }
   ]