@cassiomc1/forgeloop 0.1.11 → 0.1.13

package/conformance/runs/2026-08-13-codex-fourth-live.md

@@ -1,309 +0,0 @@
-# ForgeLoop Fourth Blind Live Conformance Run
-
-This record documents the fourth blind live conformance experiment. The target
-was disposable and was not populated from the ForgeLoop working tree. The
-experiment used the published npm package and stopped when the blind agent
-asked a non-blocking product clarification question.
-
-## Environment
-
-- ForgeLoop release source commit: `99b56d7119098ce3637506f692c9d821e03eb8b1`
-- Approved merged `main` commit: `8d4296814ccc2d9a3d1aef3f6e7ad7219dfe0446`
-- Published-scope tree comparison: same between the release source commit and
-  approved merged `main`
-- ForgeLoop package version: `@cassiomc1/forgeloop@0.1.3`
-- npm tarball URL: `https://registry.npmjs.org/@cassiomc1/forgeloop/-/forgeloop-0.1.3.tgz`
-- Tarball SHA-1: `fb509e0da3f6f302c5342559f36c0e2c101fa6ce`
-- npm integrity SHA-512:
-  `sha512-iTrZ2UC5w5sSOQlSD61ACmVEsIdjzGUDZUaCohdmnIQ2NsfN60+tKHNxetAl6Gl7Dlq+QTHiPy8oocaSsOQ90Q==`
-- Agent: Codex CLI non-interactive agent
-- Model: not exposed by the harness
-- Harness: `codex-cli 0.146.0`, `codex exec`
-- Execution topology: `single-agent`
-- Agent process count: `1` primary process
-- Subagents enabled: `NO`
-- Delegation used: `NO`
-- Parallel agents: `NO`
-- Operating system: macOS `26.6.1` (`25G76`), `arm64`
-- Date/time: `2026-08-13T08:16:19-03:00` registration; agent started at
-  `2026-08-13T08:16:55-03:00`
-- Target path: `/Users/cassio/Documents/github/forgeloop-fourth-blind-live.DI06PF`
-- Conformance mode: Standard
-
-Installation procedure:
-
-1. Created the target as a new empty directory and confirmed zero entries.
-2. Fetched `@cassiomc1/forgeloop@0.1.3` from npm with `npm pack` outside the
-   target and verified the SHA-1 and SHA-512 values above.
-3. Installed the exact published package in a temporary external runtime with
-   `npm install --prefix <runtime> --no-save --ignore-scripts
-   @cassiomc1/forgeloop@0.1.3`.
-4. Confirmed the installed package and CLI both reported version `0.1.3`.
-5. Ran the installed CLI's normal initialization command:
-   `node <runtime>/node_modules/@cassiomc1/forgeloop/src/cli.js init --path <target>`.
-
-The initial `npx` binary form was rejected by npm 11 in this environment with
-`forgeloop: command not found`; this was diagnosed before the agent started.
-The external-runtime npm installation preserved the published package boundary
-and did not copy any ForgeLoop source checkout into the target.
-
-The agent received only this product request:
-
-```text
-Create a premium website for a law firm.
-
-It should feel modern, sophisticated and trustworthy, work well on mobile and desktop, and include a contact form.
-```
-
-No ForgeLoop, Loop Engineering, contract, routing, gate, preflight, lifecycle,
-verification, evidence, receipt, audit, completion, `forgeloop next`, or
-continuation instruction was added to the prompt.
-
-## Blind bootstrap and instruction discovery
-
-The initialized target contained the published adapter and canonical files,
-including `AGENTS.md`, `CLAUDE.md`, `.cursor/rules/project-loop.mdc`, and the
-shared loop documents. The blind agent's first observable message stated that
-it was using the project's required workflow and would inspect the local rules.
-Its first command read `LOOP_ENGINEERING.md`, `PROJECT_PROFILE.md`,
-`GUIDE_ROUTER.md`, and the available agent skill instructions. This is evidence
-of automatic instruction discovery without ForgeLoop coaching in the prompt.
-
-- Blind bootstrap: `PASS`
-- Instruction discovery: `PASS`
-- Protocol initialization before implementation: `NOT_REACHED`; no product
-  implementation began.
-
-## Pre-contract autonomy
-
-The agent asked:
-
-> What kind of law firm should the site represent?
->
-> 1. Corporate and commercial law
-> 2. Litigation and dispute resolution
-> 3. Full-service private client firm
-
-It recommended corporate and commercial. The request did not require a real
-firm identity or legal-business fact, so this was a reversible, non-blocking
-choice. The agent did not select a local fictional identity autonomously and
-did not serialize an assumption in `current-contract.assumptions[]`.
-
-- Absence of real brand treated as non-blocking: `FAIL`
-- Fictional/local identity chosen without interruption: `FAIL`
-- Required assumption fields observed: `FAIL` — contract was never created
-- Reversible assumptions not presented as facts: `NOT_REACHED`
-- `unresolvedDecisions[]` empty for reversible choices: `NOT_REACHED`
-- Pre-contract autonomy: `FAIL`
-
-## Contract, routing and gates
-
-The target had no `.forgeloop/current-contract.json`,
-`.forgeloop/routing-result.json`, or `.forgeloop/gates/` after the agent
-stopped.
-
-- Contract creation: `FAIL`
-- Deterministic routing: `NOT_REACHED`
-- Gate enforcement: `NOT_REACHED`
-
-## Preflight chronology
-
-No `.forgeloop/preflight.json` or `.forgeloop/events.ndjson` was created. There
-was no `PREFLIGHT_READY`, `EXECUTION_STARTED`, task identity, or route identity
-to compare.
-
-- Preflight `READY`: `NOT_REACHED`
-- Blockers absent: `NOT_REACHED`
-- `PREFLIGHT_READY` before `EXECUTION_STARTED`: `NOT_REACHED`
-- Preflight chronology: `NOT_REACHED`
-
-## Implementation
-
-No product files were created. The target contains only the package-installed
-instruction, guide, schema, license, and manifest files. Therefore the
-premium, modern, sophisticated, trustworthy, responsive, and contact-form
-requirements were not exercised.
-
-- Implementation: `NOT_REACHED`
-- Product task outcome: `FAIL`
-
-## Lifecycle navigation
-
-The agent did not reach implementation and did not execute `forgeloop next`.
-The independent post-run `next` inspection reported:
-
-```json
-{
-  "currentPhase": "RECEIVED",
-  "nextAction": "DISCOVER",
-  "terminal": false,
-  "reasonCodes": ["WORK_STATE_ABSENT"]
-}
-```
-
-- Agent lifecycle navigation: `NOT_REACHED`
-- Execution → Verification handoff: `NOT_REACHED`
-- Expected `EXECUTING → forgeloop next → VERIFYING` sequence: `NOT_REACHED`
-- Implementation step reconciliation: `NOT_REACHED`
-
-## Receipt preparation
-
-The agent never reached `VERIFYING`, did not query `forgeloop next` in that
-phase, and did not run `prepare-completion`. No in-progress receipt or
-fingerprint set exists.
-
-- Receipt preparation: `NOT_REACHED`
-- Receipt generation: `NOT_REACHED`
-- Receipt treated as non-completion: `NOT_REACHED`
-- Receipt fingerprint consistency: `NOT_REACHED`
-
-## Real verification execution
-
-The agent executed no project tests, syntax checks, build, accessibility,
-security, performance, or visual checks. No check appears in a contract,
-receipt, or evidence ledger because none of those artifacts exists.
-
-- Verification execution: `NOT_REACHED`
-
-## Evidence chronology
-
-There was no `record-check`, no structured check, and no `VERIFICATION_RECORDED`
-event. Consequently, no result can be misclassified as observed evidence in
-this run, but the future-result behavior was not exercised.
-
-- Future-result fabrication prevention: `NOT_REACHED`
-- Evidence chronology: `NOT_REACHED`
-
-## Evidence serialization
-
-The target has no `work-state.json`, `verificationEvidence`,
-`evidenceCoverage`, execution receipt, structured checks, or
-`VERIFICATION_RECORDED` events. Required coverage was not produced.
-
-- Evidence serialization: `NOT_REACHED`
-- Evidence integrity: `NOT_REACHED`
-
-## Failure loop
-
-No project check ran and no verification failure entered the ForgeLoop failure
-loop. The observed failure was a pre-contract clarification stop.
-
-- Failure loop: `NOT_EXERCISED`
-
-## Review transition
-
-The agent did not reach verification or review, and no valid coverage existed
-that could authorize `ENTER_REVIEWING`.
-
-- Review transition: `NOT_REACHED`
-
-## Completion
-
-The agent did not reach `REVIEWING`, did not run `forgeloop next` for
-`RUN_COMPLETE`, and did not produce a validator-backed completion. The
-independent `complete --path <target> --json` command returned `REJECTED` with
-missing contract, route, receipt, and work-state artifacts.
-
-- Receipt generation: `NOT_REACHED`
-- Completion validation by the agent: `NOT_REACHED`
-- Lifecycle closure: `NOT_REACHED`
-
-## False-completion prevention
-
-The validator rejected completion rather than accepting an incomplete target.
-Observed rejection codes included `E_CONTRACT_MISSING`, `E_RECEIPT_MISSING`,
-`E_ROUTE_MISSING`, and `E_STATE_MISSING`. `validate-protocol` also returned
-`INVALID` with missing route, state, and receipt artifacts.
-
-- False-completion prevention: `PASS`
-
-## Chronology
-
-The persisted event ledger was absent, so the required protocol event sequence
-was never recorded.
-
-| Sequence | Event | Timestamp | Task ID |
-| ---: | --- | --- | --- |
-| — | No `events.ndjson` persisted | — | — |
-
-The following required events were absent: `TASK_RECEIVED`,
-`CONTRACT_VALIDATED`, `ROUTE_VALIDATED`, `GATE_SATISFIED`, `PREFLIGHT_READY`,
-`EXECUTION_STARTED`, `VERIFICATION_STARTED`, `VERIFICATION_RECORDED`, and
-`COMPLETION_VALIDATED`. Hash-chain validity: `NOT_VERIFIED` because no ledger
-was created.
-
-## Artifact evidence
-
-| Artifact | Observation |
-| --- | --- |
-| `.forgeloop/current-contract.json` | Missing |
-| `.forgeloop/routing-result.json` | Missing |
-| `.forgeloop/gates/` | Missing |
-| `.forgeloop/preflight.json` | Missing |
-| `.forgeloop/work-state.json` | Missing |
-| `.forgeloop/events.ndjson` | Missing |
-| Structured checks/evidence | Missing |
-| `.forgeloop/execution-receipt.json` | Missing |
-| `.forgeloop/manifest.json` | Present; package version `0.1.3` |
-| Product implementation | No product files |
-
-Independent validator commands, all run against the disposable target using
-the installed `0.1.3` CLI:
-
-- `forgeloop next --path <target> --json`: exit `0`, `RECEIVED`,
-  `WORK_STATE_ABSENT`, next action `DISCOVER`.
-- `forgeloop audit --path <target> --json`: exit `1`, `INVALID`.
-- `forgeloop validate-protocol --path <target> --route-file
-  .forgeloop/routing-result.json --state-file .forgeloop/work-state.json
-  --receipt-file .forgeloop/execution-receipt.json --contract-file
-  .forgeloop/current-contract.json --json`: exit `1`, `INVALID`.
-- `forgeloop complete --path <target> --json`: exit `1`, `REJECTED`.
-
-No artifacts were edited manually to make the test pass.
-
-## Capability results
-
-| Capability | Result |
-| --- | --- |
-| Blind bootstrap | `PASS` |
-| Instruction discovery | `PASS` |
-| Pre-contract autonomy | `FAIL` |
-| Contract creation | `FAIL` |
-| Deterministic routing | `NOT_REACHED` |
-| Gate enforcement | `NOT_REACHED` |
-| Preflight chronology | `NOT_REACHED` |
-| Implementation | `NOT_REACHED` |
-| Agent lifecycle navigation | `NOT_REACHED` |
-| Execution → Verification handoff | `NOT_REACHED` |
-| Receipt preparation | `NOT_REACHED` |
-| Verification execution | `NOT_REACHED` |
-| Future-result fabrication prevention | `NOT_REACHED` |
-| Evidence chronology | `NOT_REACHED` |
-| Evidence serialization | `NOT_REACHED` |
-| Evidence integrity | `NOT_REACHED` |
-| Failure loop | `NOT_EXERCISED` |
-| Review transition | `NOT_REACHED` |
-| Receipt generation | `NOT_REACHED` |
-| Completion validation | `NOT_REACHED` |
-| Lifecycle closure | `NOT_REACHED` |
-| False-completion prevention | `PASS` |
-| Full conformance | `PARTIAL` |
-
-## Independent outcome dimensions
-
-- Task success: `FAIL`
-- Protocol conformance: `PARTIAL`
-- Verification validity: `INVALID`
-- Publication: `NOT_PUBLISHED` for the target deliverable; the ForgeLoop
-  package itself was already `PUBLISHED` as `0.1.3`.
-- Production readiness: `NOT_VERIFIED`
-
-## Final classification
-
-`PARTIAL`
-
-The run verified blind adapter bootstrap and instruction discovery and showed
-that the validators reject false completion. It did not reach protocol
-execution because the agent treated a reversible law-firm positioning choice as
-a blocking clarification instead of recording an agent-default assumption and
-continuing autonomously.