wapiti 0.0.1

Sign up to get free protection for your applications and to get access to all the features.
Files changed (63) hide show
  1. data/.autotest +13 -0
  2. data/.gitignore +5 -0
  3. data/.rspec +3 -0
  4. data/Gemfile +6 -0
  5. data/LICENSE +30 -0
  6. data/README.md +153 -0
  7. data/Rakefile +33 -0
  8. data/ext/wapiti/bcd.c +392 -0
  9. data/ext/wapiti/decoder.c +535 -0
  10. data/ext/wapiti/decoder.h +46 -0
  11. data/ext/wapiti/extconf.rb +8 -0
  12. data/ext/wapiti/gradient.c +818 -0
  13. data/ext/wapiti/gradient.h +81 -0
  14. data/ext/wapiti/lbfgs.c +294 -0
  15. data/ext/wapiti/model.c +296 -0
  16. data/ext/wapiti/model.h +100 -0
  17. data/ext/wapiti/native.c +1238 -0
  18. data/ext/wapiti/native.h +15 -0
  19. data/ext/wapiti/options.c +278 -0
  20. data/ext/wapiti/options.h +91 -0
  21. data/ext/wapiti/pattern.c +395 -0
  22. data/ext/wapiti/pattern.h +56 -0
  23. data/ext/wapiti/progress.c +167 -0
  24. data/ext/wapiti/progress.h +43 -0
  25. data/ext/wapiti/quark.c +272 -0
  26. data/ext/wapiti/quark.h +46 -0
  27. data/ext/wapiti/reader.c +553 -0
  28. data/ext/wapiti/reader.h +73 -0
  29. data/ext/wapiti/rprop.c +191 -0
  30. data/ext/wapiti/sequence.h +148 -0
  31. data/ext/wapiti/sgdl1.c +218 -0
  32. data/ext/wapiti/thread.c +171 -0
  33. data/ext/wapiti/thread.h +42 -0
  34. data/ext/wapiti/tools.c +202 -0
  35. data/ext/wapiti/tools.h +54 -0
  36. data/ext/wapiti/trainers.h +39 -0
  37. data/ext/wapiti/vmath.c +372 -0
  38. data/ext/wapiti/vmath.h +51 -0
  39. data/ext/wapiti/wapiti.c +288 -0
  40. data/ext/wapiti/wapiti.h +45 -0
  41. data/lib/wapiti.rb +30 -0
  42. data/lib/wapiti/errors.rb +17 -0
  43. data/lib/wapiti/model.rb +49 -0
  44. data/lib/wapiti/options.rb +113 -0
  45. data/lib/wapiti/utility.rb +15 -0
  46. data/lib/wapiti/version.rb +3 -0
  47. data/spec/fixtures/ch.mod +18550 -0
  48. data/spec/fixtures/chpattern.txt +52 -0
  49. data/spec/fixtures/chtest.txt +1973 -0
  50. data/spec/fixtures/chtrain.txt +19995 -0
  51. data/spec/fixtures/nppattern.txt +52 -0
  52. data/spec/fixtures/nptest.txt +1973 -0
  53. data/spec/fixtures/nptrain.txt +19995 -0
  54. data/spec/fixtures/pattern.txt +14 -0
  55. data/spec/fixtures/test.txt +60000 -0
  56. data/spec/fixtures/train.txt +1200 -0
  57. data/spec/spec_helper.rb +21 -0
  58. data/spec/wapiti/model_spec.rb +173 -0
  59. data/spec/wapiti/native_spec.rb +12 -0
  60. data/spec/wapiti/options_spec.rb +175 -0
  61. data/spec/wapiti/utility_spec.rb +22 -0
  62. data/wapiti.gemspec +35 -0
  63. metadata +178 -0
@@ -0,0 +1,288 @@
1
+ /*
2
+ * Wapiti - A linear-chain CRF tool
3
+ *
4
+ * Copyright (c) 2009-2011 CNRS
5
+ * All rights reserved.
6
+ *
7
+ * Redistribution and use in source and binary forms, with or without
8
+ * modification, are permitted provided that the following conditions are met:
9
+ * * Redistributions of source code must retain the above copyright
10
+ * notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer.
11
+ * * Redistributions in binary form must reproduce the above copyright
12
+ * notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer in the
13
+ * documentation and/or other materials provided with the distribution.
14
+ *
15
+ * THIS SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED BY THE COPYRIGHT HOLDERS AND CONTRIBUTORS "AS IS"
16
+ * AND ANY EXPRESS OR IMPLIED WARRANTIES, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, THE
17
+ * IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE
18
+ * ARE DISCLAIMED. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE COPYRIGHT OWNER OR CONTRIBUTORS BE
19
+ * LIABLE FOR ANY DIRECT, INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, SPECIAL, EXEMPLARY, OR
20
+ * CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES (INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, PROCUREMENT OF
21
+ * SUBSTITUTE GOODS OR SERVICES; LOSS OF USE, DATA, OR PROFITS; OR BUSINESS
22
+ * INTERRUPTION) HOWEVER CAUSED AND ON ANY THEORY OF LIABILITY, WHETHER IN
23
+ * CONTRACT, STRICT LIABILITY, OR TORT (INCLUDING NEGLIGENCE OR OTHERWISE)
24
+ * ARISING IN ANY WAY OUT OF THE USE OF THIS SOFTWARE, EVEN IF ADVISED OF THE
25
+ * POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGE.
26
+ */
27
+ #include <stdbool.h>
28
+ #include <stddef.h>
29
+ #include <stdlib.h>
30
+ #include <stdio.h>
31
+ #include <string.h>
32
+
33
+ #include "decoder.h"
34
+ #include "model.h"
35
+ #include "options.h"
36
+ #include "progress.h"
37
+ #include "quark.h"
38
+ #include "reader.h"
39
+ #include "sequence.h"
40
+ #include "tools.h"
41
+ #include "trainers.h"
42
+ #include "wapiti.h"
43
+
44
+ /*******************************************************************************
45
+ * Training
46
+ ******************************************************************************/
47
+ static void trn_auto(mdl_t *mdl) {
48
+ const int maxiter = mdl->opt->maxiter;
49
+ mdl->opt->maxiter = 3;
50
+ trn_sgdl1(mdl);
51
+ mdl->opt->maxiter = maxiter;
52
+ trn_lbfgs(mdl);
53
+ }
54
+
55
+ static const struct {
56
+ char *name;
57
+ void (* train)(mdl_t *mdl);
58
+ } trn_lst[] = {
59
+ {"l-bfgs", trn_lbfgs},
60
+ {"sgd-l1", trn_sgdl1},
61
+ {"bcd", trn_bcd },
62
+ {"rprop", trn_rprop},
63
+ {"rprop+", trn_rprop},
64
+ {"rprop-", trn_rprop},
65
+ {"auto", trn_auto }
66
+ };
67
+ static const int trn_cnt = sizeof(trn_lst) / sizeof(trn_lst[0]);
68
+
69
+ void dotrain(mdl_t *mdl) {
70
+ // Check if the user requested the trainer list. If this is not the
71
+ // case, search the trainer.
72
+ if (!strcmp(mdl->opt->algo, "list")) {
73
+ info("Available training algorithms:\n");
74
+ for (int i = 0; i < trn_cnt; i++)
75
+ info("\t%s\n", trn_lst[i].name);
76
+ exit(EXIT_SUCCESS);
77
+ }
78
+ int trn;
79
+ for (trn = 0; trn < trn_cnt; trn++)
80
+ if (!strcmp(mdl->opt->algo, trn_lst[trn].name))
81
+ break;
82
+ if (trn == trn_cnt)
83
+ fatal("unknown algorithm '%s'", mdl->opt->algo);
84
+ // Load a previous model to train again if specified by the user.
85
+ if (mdl->opt->model != NULL) {
86
+ info("* Load previous model\n");
87
+ FILE *file = fopen(mdl->opt->model, "r");
88
+ if (file == NULL)
89
+ pfatal("cannot open input model file");
90
+ mdl_load(mdl, file);
91
+ }
92
+ // Load the pattern file. This will unlock the database if previously
93
+ // locked by loading a model.
94
+ if (mdl->opt->pattern != NULL) {
95
+ info("* Load patterns\n");
96
+ FILE *file = fopen(mdl->opt->pattern, "r");
97
+ if (file == NULL)
98
+ pfatal("cannot open pattern file");
99
+ rdr_loadpat(mdl->reader, file);
100
+ fclose(file);
101
+ qrk_lock(mdl->reader->obs, false);
102
+ }
103
+ // Load the training data. When this is done we lock the quarks as we
104
+ // don't want to put in the model, informations present only in the
105
+ // devlopment set.
106
+ info("* Load training data\n");
107
+ FILE *file = stdin;
108
+ if (mdl->opt->input != NULL) {
109
+ file = fopen(mdl->opt->input, "r");
110
+ if (file == NULL)
111
+ pfatal("cannot open input data file");
112
+ }
113
+ mdl->train = rdr_readdat(mdl->reader, file, true);
114
+ if (mdl->opt->input != NULL)
115
+ fclose(file);
116
+ qrk_lock(mdl->reader->lbl, true);
117
+ qrk_lock(mdl->reader->obs, true);
118
+ if (mdl->train == NULL || mdl->train->nseq == 0)
119
+ fatal("no train data loaded");
120
+ // If present, load the development set in the model. If not specified,
121
+ // the training dataset will be used instead.
122
+ if (mdl->opt->devel != NULL) {
123
+ info("* Load development data\n");
124
+ FILE *file = fopen(mdl->opt->devel, "r");
125
+ if (file == NULL)
126
+ pfatal("cannot open development file");
127
+ mdl->devel = rdr_readdat(mdl->reader, file, true);
128
+ fclose(file);
129
+ }
130
+ // Initialize the model. If a previous model was loaded, this will be
131
+ // just a resync, else the model structure will be created.
132
+ if (mdl->theta == NULL)
133
+ info("* Initialize the model\n");
134
+ else
135
+ info("* Resync the model\n");
136
+ mdl_sync(mdl);
137
+ // Display some statistics as we all love this.
138
+ info("* Summary\n");
139
+ info(" nb train: %d\n", mdl->train->nseq);
140
+ if (mdl->devel != NULL)
141
+ info(" nb devel: %d\n", mdl->devel->nseq);
142
+ info(" nb labels: %zu\n", mdl->nlbl);
143
+ info(" nb blocks: %zu\n", mdl->nobs);
144
+ info(" nb features: %zu\n", mdl->nftr);
145
+ // And train the model...
146
+ info("* Train the model with %s\n", mdl->opt->algo);
147
+ uit_setup(mdl);
148
+ trn_lst[trn].train(mdl);
149
+ uit_cleanup(mdl);
150
+ // If requested compact the model.
151
+ if (mdl->opt->compact) {
152
+ const size_t O = mdl->nobs;
153
+ const size_t F = mdl->nftr;
154
+ info("* Compacting the model\n");
155
+ mdl_compact(mdl);
156
+ info(" %8zu observations removed\n", O - mdl->nobs);
157
+ info(" %8zu features removed\n", F - mdl->nftr);
158
+ }
159
+ // And save the trained model
160
+ info("* Save the model\n");
161
+ file = stdout;
162
+ if (mdl->opt->output != NULL) {
163
+ file = fopen(mdl->opt->output, "w");
164
+ if (file == NULL)
165
+ pfatal("cannot open output model");
166
+ }
167
+ mdl_save(mdl, file);
168
+ if (mdl->opt->output != NULL)
169
+ fclose(file);
170
+ info("* Done\n");
171
+ }
172
+
173
+ /*******************************************************************************
174
+ * Labeling
175
+ ******************************************************************************/
176
+ void dolabel(mdl_t *mdl) {
177
+ // First, load the model provided by the user. This is mandatory to
178
+ // label new datas ;-)
179
+ if (mdl->opt->model == NULL)
180
+ fatal("you must specify a model");
181
+ info("* Load model\n");
182
+ FILE *file = fopen(mdl->opt->model, "r");
183
+ if (file == NULL)
184
+ pfatal("cannot open input model file");
185
+ mdl_load(mdl, file);
186
+ // Open input and output files
187
+ FILE *fin = stdin, *fout = stdout;
188
+ if (mdl->opt->input != NULL) {
189
+ fin = fopen(mdl->opt->input, "r");
190
+ if (fin == NULL)
191
+ pfatal("cannot open input data file");
192
+ }
193
+ if (mdl->opt->output != NULL) {
194
+ fout = fopen(mdl->opt->output, "w");
195
+ if (fout == NULL)
196
+ pfatal("cannot open output data file");
197
+ }
198
+ // Do the labelling
199
+ info("* Label sequences\n");
200
+ tag_label(mdl, fin, fout);
201
+ info("* Done\n");
202
+ // And close files
203
+ if (mdl->opt->input != NULL)
204
+ fclose(fin);
205
+ if (mdl->opt->output != NULL)
206
+ fclose(fout);
207
+ }
208
+
209
+ /*******************************************************************************
210
+ * Dumping
211
+ ******************************************************************************/
212
+ void dodump(mdl_t *mdl) {
213
+ // Load input model file
214
+ info("* Load model\n");
215
+ FILE *fin = stdin;
216
+ if (mdl->opt->input != NULL) {
217
+ fin = fopen(mdl->opt->input, "r");
218
+ if (fin == NULL)
219
+ pfatal("cannot open input data file");
220
+ }
221
+ mdl_load(mdl, fin);
222
+ if (mdl->opt->input != NULL)
223
+ fclose(fin);
224
+ // Open output file
225
+ FILE *fout = stdout;
226
+ if (mdl->opt->output != NULL) {
227
+ fout = fopen(mdl->opt->output, "w");
228
+ if (fout == NULL)
229
+ pfatal("cannot open output data file");
230
+ }
231
+ // Dump model
232
+ info("* Dump model\n");
233
+ const size_t Y = mdl->nlbl;
234
+ const size_t O = mdl->nobs;
235
+ const qrk_t *Qlbl = mdl->reader->lbl;
236
+ const qrk_t *Qobs = mdl->reader->obs;
237
+ for (size_t o = 0; o < O; o++) {
238
+ const char *obs = qrk_id2str(Qobs, o);
239
+ bool empty = true;
240
+ if (mdl->kind[o] & 1) {
241
+ const double *w = mdl->theta + mdl->uoff[o];
242
+ for (size_t y = 0; y < Y; y++) {
243
+ if (w[y] == 0.0)
244
+ continue;
245
+ const char *ly = qrk_id2str(Qlbl, y);
246
+ fprintf(fout, "%s\t#\t%s\t%f\n", obs, ly, w[y]);
247
+ empty = false;
248
+ }
249
+ }
250
+ if (mdl->kind[o] & 2) {
251
+ const double *w = mdl->theta + mdl->boff[o];
252
+ for (size_t d = 0; d < Y * Y; d++) {
253
+ if (w[d] == 0.0)
254
+ continue;
255
+ const char *ly = qrk_id2str(Qlbl, d % Y);
256
+ const char *lyp = qrk_id2str(Qlbl, d / Y);
257
+ fprintf(fout, "%s\t%s\t%s\t%f\n", obs, lyp, ly,
258
+ w[d]);
259
+ empty = false;
260
+ }
261
+ }
262
+ if (!empty)
263
+ fprintf(fout, "\n");
264
+ }
265
+ if (mdl->opt->output != NULL)
266
+ fclose(fout);
267
+ }
268
+
269
+ /*******************************************************************************
270
+ * Entry point
271
+ ******************************************************************************/
272
+ int wapiti_main(int argc, char *argv[argc]) {
273
+ // We first parse command line switchs
274
+ opt_t opt = opt_defaults;
275
+ opt_parse(argc, argv, &opt);
276
+ // Next we prepare the model
277
+ mdl_t *mdl = mdl_new(rdr_new(opt.maxent));
278
+ mdl->opt = &opt;
279
+ // And switch to requested mode
280
+ switch (opt.mode) {
281
+ case 0: dotrain(mdl); break;
282
+ case 1: dolabel(mdl); break;
283
+ case 2: dodump(mdl); break;
284
+ }
285
+ // And cleanup
286
+ mdl_free(mdl);
287
+ return EXIT_SUCCESS;
288
+ }
@@ -0,0 +1,45 @@
1
+ /*
2
+ * Wapiti - A linear-chain CRF tool
3
+ *
4
+ * Copyright (c) 2009-2011 CNRS
5
+ * All rights reserved.
6
+ *
7
+ * Redistribution and use in source and binary forms, with or without
8
+ * modification, are permitted provided that the following conditions are met:
9
+ * * Redistributions of source code must retain the above copyright
10
+ * notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer.
11
+ * * Redistributions in binary form must reproduce the above copyright
12
+ * notice, this list of conditions and the following disclaimer in the
13
+ * documentation and/or other materials provided with the distribution.
14
+ *
15
+ * THIS SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED BY THE COPYRIGHT HOLDERS AND CONTRIBUTORS "AS IS"
16
+ * AND ANY EXPRESS OR IMPLIED WARRANTIES, INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, THE
17
+ * IMPLIED WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY AND FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE
18
+ * ARE DISCLAIMED. IN NO EVENT SHALL THE COPYRIGHT OWNER OR CONTRIBUTORS BE
19
+ * LIABLE FOR ANY DIRECT, INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, SPECIAL, EXEMPLARY, OR
20
+ * CONSEQUENTIAL DAMAGES (INCLUDING, BUT NOT LIMITED TO, PROCUREMENT OF
21
+ * SUBSTITUTE GOODS OR SERVICES; LOSS OF USE, DATA, OR PROFITS; OR BUSINESS
22
+ * INTERRUPTION) HOWEVER CAUSED AND ON ANY THEORY OF LIABILITY, WHETHER IN
23
+ * CONTRACT, STRICT LIABILITY, OR TORT (INCLUDING NEGLIGENCE OR OTHERWISE)
24
+ * ARISING IN ANY WAY OUT OF THE USE OF THIS SOFTWARE, EVEN IF ADVISED OF THE
25
+ * POSSIBILITY OF SUCH DAMAGE.
26
+ */
27
+ #ifndef wapiti_h
28
+ #define wapiti_h
29
+
30
+ #define VERSION "1.2.0"
31
+
32
+ /* XVM_ANSI:
33
+ * By uncomenting the following define, you can force wapiti to not use SSE2
34
+ * even if available.
35
+ */
36
+ //#define XVM_ANSI
37
+
38
+ /* MTH_ANSI:
39
+ * By uncomenting the following define, you can disable the use of POSIX
40
+ * threads in the multi-threading part of Wapiti, for non-POSIX systems.
41
+ */
42
+ //#define MTH_ANSI
43
+
44
+ #endif
45
+
@@ -0,0 +1,30 @@
1
+
2
+ require 'logger'
3
+ require 'tempfile'
4
+
5
+ require 'wapiti/version'
6
+
7
+ module Wapiti
8
+
9
+ Logger = ::Logger.new(STDOUT)
10
+ Logger.level = ::Logger::WARN
11
+
12
+ class << self
13
+ def log
14
+ Logger
15
+ end
16
+
17
+ def debug!
18
+ log.level == ::Logger::DEBUG
19
+ end
20
+ end
21
+
22
+ end
23
+
24
+ require 'wapiti/errors'
25
+ require 'wapiti/native'
26
+
27
+ require 'wapiti/options'
28
+ require 'wapiti/model'
29
+
30
+ require 'wapiti/utility'
@@ -0,0 +1,17 @@
1
+ module Wapiti
2
+
3
+ class Error < StandardError
4
+
5
+ attr_accessor :original
6
+
7
+ def initialize(message = '', original = $!)
8
+ super(message)
9
+ @original = original
10
+ end
11
+
12
+ end
13
+
14
+ class NativeError < Error; end
15
+ class ConfigurationError < Error; end
16
+
17
+ end
@@ -0,0 +1,49 @@
1
+ module Wapiti
2
+
3
+ class Model
4
+
5
+ class << self
6
+
7
+ def train(data, options, &block)
8
+ config = Options.new(options, &block)
9
+
10
+ # check configuration
11
+ if config.pattern.empty?
12
+ raise ConfigurationError, 'invalid options: no pattern specified'
13
+ end
14
+
15
+ unless config.valid?
16
+ raise ConfigurationError, "invalid options: #{ config.validate.join('; ') }"
17
+ end
18
+
19
+ new(config).train(data)
20
+ end
21
+
22
+ def load(filename)
23
+ m = new
24
+ m.path = filename
25
+ m.load
26
+ m
27
+ end
28
+
29
+ end
30
+
31
+ attr_accessor :path
32
+
33
+ def pattern
34
+ options.pattern
35
+ end
36
+
37
+ def pattern=(filename)
38
+ options.pattern = filename
39
+ end
40
+
41
+ private
42
+
43
+ def tokenize(input)
44
+ input
45
+ end
46
+
47
+ end
48
+
49
+ end
@@ -0,0 +1,113 @@
1
+ module Wapiti
2
+
3
+ class Options
4
+
5
+ include Comparable
6
+
7
+ class << self
8
+
9
+ # Returns a sorted list of available option attributes.
10
+ def attribute_names
11
+ @attribute_names ||= %w{ stop_window convergence_window posterior
12
+ max_iterations jobsize threads rho1 rho2 stop_epsilon score check
13
+ algorithm pattern development_data maxent compact sparse label
14
+ }.sort.map(&:to_sym).freeze
15
+ end
16
+
17
+ # Returns the default options.
18
+ def defaults
19
+ @defaults ||= new.attributes
20
+ end
21
+
22
+ # Returns the list of supported algorithm options.
23
+ def algorithms
24
+ @algorithms ||= %w{ l-bfgs sgd-l1 bcd rprop rprop+ rprop- auto }.freeze
25
+ end
26
+
27
+ end
28
+
29
+ # Returns the value of the attribute identified by +name+ or nil
30
+ # if there is no such attribute.
31
+ def [](name)
32
+ has_attribute?(name) ? send(name) : nil
33
+ end
34
+
35
+ # Updates the value of the attribute identified by +name+ with the
36
+ # passed-in +value+.
37
+ def []=(name, value)
38
+ raise ArgumentError, "bad attribute name: #{name}" unless has_attribute?(name)
39
+ send("#{name}=", value)
40
+ end
41
+
42
+ # Updates all the attributes from the passed-in hash.
43
+ def update(attributes = {})
44
+ attributes.each_pair do |k,v|
45
+ mid = "#{k}="
46
+ send(mid, v) if respond_to?(mid)
47
+ end
48
+ self
49
+ end
50
+
51
+ alias update_attributes update
52
+
53
+ def lbfgs
54
+ { :clip => clip, :histsz => histsz, :maxls => maxls }
55
+ end
56
+
57
+ def sgdl1
58
+ { :eta0 => eta0, :alpha => alpha }
59
+ end
60
+
61
+ def bcd
62
+ { :kappa => kappa }
63
+ end
64
+
65
+ def rprop
66
+ {
67
+ :stpmin => stpmin, :stpmax => stpmax, :stpinc => stpinc,
68
+ :stpdec => stpdec, :cutoff => cutoff
69
+ }
70
+ end
71
+
72
+ # Returns a hash of all the attributes with their names and values.
73
+ def attributes
74
+ Hash[*Options.attribute_names.map { |a| [a, send(a)] }.flatten]
75
+ end
76
+
77
+ alias to_hash attributes
78
+
79
+ def has_attribute?(attribute)
80
+ Options.attribute_names.include?(attribute)
81
+ end
82
+
83
+ def valid_algorithm?
84
+ self.class.algorithms.include?(algorithm)
85
+ end
86
+
87
+ def valid?
88
+ validate.empty?
89
+ end
90
+
91
+ def validate
92
+ e = []
93
+
94
+ %w{ threads jobsize alpha histsz maxls eta0 alpha nbest }.each do |name|
95
+ e << "invalid value for #{name}: #{send(name)}" unless send(name) > 0
96
+ end
97
+
98
+ %w{ rho1 rho2 }.each do |name|
99
+ e << "invalid value for #{name}: #{send(name)}" unless send(name) >= 0.0
100
+ end
101
+
102
+ e << "unknown algorithm: #{algorithm}" unless valid_algorithm?
103
+ e << "BCD not supported for training maxent models" if maxent && algorithm == 'bcd'
104
+ e
105
+ end
106
+
107
+ def <=>(other)
108
+ other.respond_to?(:attributes) ? attributes <=> other.attributes : nil
109
+ end
110
+
111
+ end
112
+
113
+ end