puppet-retrospec 1.5.0 → 1.6.0

data/vendor/pup410/lib/puppet/transaction/resource_harness.rb

@@ -0,0 +1,316 @@
+require 'puppet/resource/status'
+
+class Puppet::Transaction::ResourceHarness
+  NO_ACTION = Object.new
+
+  extend Forwardable
+  def_delegators :@transaction, :relationship_graph
+
+  attr_reader :transaction
+
+  def initialize(transaction)
+    @transaction = transaction
+    @persistence = transaction.persistence
+  end
+
+  def evaluate(resource)
+    status = Puppet::Resource::Status.new(resource)
+
+    begin
+      context = ResourceApplicationContext.from_resource(resource, status)
+      perform_changes(resource, context)
+
+      if status.changed? && ! resource.noop?
+        cache(resource, :synced, Time.now)
+        resource.flush if resource.respond_to?(:flush)
+      end
+    rescue => detail
+      status.failed_because(detail)
+    ensure
+      status.evaluation_time = Time.now - status.time
+    end
+
+    status
+  end
+
+  def scheduled?(resource)
+    return true if Puppet[:ignoreschedules]
+    return true unless schedule = schedule(resource)
+
+    # We use 'checked' here instead of 'synced' because otherwise we'll
+    # end up checking most resources most times, because they will generally
+    # have been synced a long time ago (e.g., a file only gets updated
+    # once a month on the server and its schedule is daily; the last sync time
+    # will have been a month ago, so we'd end up checking every run).
+    schedule.match?(cached(resource, :checked).to_i)
+  end
+
+  def schedule(resource)
+    unless resource.catalog
+      resource.warning "Cannot schedule without a schedule-containing catalog"
+      return nil
+    end
+
+    return nil unless name = resource[:schedule]
+    resource.catalog.resource(:schedule, name) || resource.fail("Could not find schedule #{name}")
+  end
+
+  # Used mostly for scheduling and auditing at this point.
+  def cached(resource, name)
+    Puppet::Util::Storage.cache(resource)[name]
+  end
+
+  # Used mostly for scheduling and auditing at this point.
+  def cache(resource, name, value)
+    Puppet::Util::Storage.cache(resource)[name] = value
+  end
+
+  private
+
+  def perform_changes(resource, context)
+    cache(resource, :checked, Time.now)
+
+    # Record the current state in state.yml.
+    context.audited_params.each do |param|
+      cache(resource, param, context.current_values[param])
+    end
+
+    ensure_param = resource.parameter(:ensure)
+    if ensure_param && ensure_param.should
+      ensure_event = sync_if_needed(ensure_param, context)
+    else
+      ensure_event = NO_ACTION
+    end
+
+    if ensure_event == NO_ACTION
+      if context.resource_present?
+        resource.properties.each do |param|
+          sync_if_needed(param, context)
+        end
+      else
+        resource.debug("Nothing to manage: no ensure and the resource doesn't exist")
+      end
+    end
+
+    capture_audit_events(resource, context)
+    persist_system_values(resource, context)
+  end
+
+  # We persist the last known values for the properties of a resource after resource
+  # application.
+  # @param [Puppet::Type] resource resource whose values we are to persist.
+  # @param [ResourceApplicationContent] context the application context to operate on.
+  def persist_system_values(resource, context)
+    param_to_event = {}
+    context.status.events.each do |ev|
+      param_to_event[ev.property] = ev
+    end
+
+    context.system_value_params.each do |pname, param|
+      @persistence.set_system_value(resource.ref, pname.to_s,
+                                    new_system_value(param,
+                                                     param_to_event[pname.to_s],
+                                                     @persistence.get_system_value(resource.ref, pname.to_s)))
+    end
+  end
+
+  def sync_if_needed(param, context)
+    historical_value = context.historical_values[param.name]
+    current_value = context.current_values[param.name]
+    do_audit = context.audited_params.include?(param.name)
+
+    begin
+      if param.should && !param.safe_insync?(current_value)
+        event = create_change_event(param, current_value, historical_value)
+        if do_audit
+          event = audit_event(event, param, context)
+        end
+
+        brief_audit_message = audit_message(param, do_audit, historical_value, current_value)
+
+        if param.noop
+          noop(event, param, current_value, brief_audit_message)
+        else
+          sync(event, param, current_value, brief_audit_message)
+        end
+
+        event
+      else
+        NO_ACTION
+      end
+    rescue => detail
+      # Execution will continue on StandardErrors, just store the event
+      Puppet.log_exception(detail)
+
+      event = create_change_event(param, current_value, historical_value)
+      event.status = "failure"
+      event.message = param.format("change from %s to %s failed: #{detail}",
+                                   param.is_to_s(current_value),
+                                   param.should_to_s(param.should))
+      event
+    rescue Exception => detail
+      # Execution will halt on Exceptions, they get raised to the application
+      event = create_change_event(param, current_value, historical_value)
+      event.status = "failure"
+      event.message = param.format("change from %s to %s failed: #{detail}",
+                                   param.is_to_s(current_value),
+                                   param.should_to_s(param.should))
+      raise
+    ensure
+      if event
+        event.calculate_corrective_change(@persistence.get_system_value(context.resource.ref, param.name.to_s))
+        context.record(event)
+        event.send_log
+        context.synced_params << param.name
+      end
+    end
+  end
+
+  def create_change_event(property, current_value, historical_value)
+    options = {}
+    should = property.should
+
+    if property.sensitive
+      options[:previous_value] = current_value.nil? ? nil : '[redacted]'
+      options[:desired_value] = should.nil? ? nil : '[redacted]'
+      options[:historical_value] = historical_value.nil? ? nil : '[redacted]'
+    else
+      options[:previous_value] = current_value
+      options[:desired_value] = should
+      options[:historical_value] = historical_value
+    end
+
+    property.event(options)
+  end
+
+  # This method is an ugly hack because, given a Time object with nanosecond
+  # resolution, roundtripped through YAML serialization, the Time object will
+  # be truncated to microseconds.
+  # For audit purposes, this code special cases this comparison, and compares
+  # the two objects by their second and microsecond components. tv_sec is the
+  # number of seconds since the epoch, and tv_usec is only the microsecond
+  # portion of time.
+  def are_audited_values_equal(a, b)
+    a == b || (a.is_a?(Time) && b.is_a?(Time) && a.tv_sec == b.tv_sec && a.tv_usec == b.tv_usec)
+  end
+  private :are_audited_values_equal
+
+  # Populate an existing event with audit information.
+  #
+  # @param event [Puppet::Transaction::Event] The event to be populated.
+  # @param property [Puppet::Property] The property being audited.
+  # @param context [ResourceApplicationContext]
+  #
+  # @return [Puppet::Transaction::Event] The given event, populated with the audit information.
+  def audit_event(event, property, context)
+    event.audited = true
+    event.status = "audit"
+
+    # The event we've been provided might have been redacted so we need to use the state stored within
+    # the resource application context to see if an event was actually generated.
+    if !are_audited_values_equal(context.historical_values[property.name], context.current_values[property.name])
+      event.message = property.format("audit change: previously recorded value %s has been changed to %s",
+                 property.is_to_s(event.historical_value),
+                 property.is_to_s(event.previous_value))
+    end
+
+    event
+  end
+
+  def audit_message(param, do_audit, historical_value, current_value)
+    if do_audit && historical_value && !are_audited_values_equal(historical_value, current_value)
+      param.format(" (previously recorded value was %s)", param.is_to_s(historical_value))
+    else
+      ""
+    end
+  end
+
+  def noop(event, param, current_value, audit_message)
+    event.message = param.format("current_value %s, should be %s (noop)#{audit_message}",
+                                 param.is_to_s(current_value),
+                                 param.should_to_s(param.should))
+    event.status = "noop"
+  end
+
+  def sync(event, param, current_value, audit_message)
+    param.sync
+    if param.sensitive
+      event.message = param.format("changed %s to %s#{audit_message}", param.is_to_s(current_value), param.should_to_s(param.should))
+    else
+      event.message = "#{param.change_to_s(current_value, param.should)}#{audit_message}"
+    end
+    event.status = "success"
+  end
+
+  def capture_audit_events(resource, context)
+    context.audited_params.each do |param_name|
+      if context.historical_values.include?(param_name)
+        if !are_audited_values_equal(context.historical_values[param_name], context.current_values[param_name]) && !context.synced_params.include?(param_name)
+          parameter = resource.parameter(param_name)
+          event = audit_event(create_change_event(parameter,
+                                                  context.current_values[param_name],
+                                                  context.historical_values[param_name]),
+                              parameter, context)
+          event.send_log
+          context.record(event)
+        end
+      else
+        property = resource.property(param_name)
+        property.notice(property.format("audit change: newly-recorded value %s", context.current_values[param_name]))
+      end
+    end
+  end
+
+  # Given an event and its property, calculate the system_value to persist
+  # for future calculations.
+  # @param [Puppet::Transaction::Event] event event to use for processing
+  # @param [Puppet::Property] property correlating property
+  # @param [Object] old_system_value system_value from last transaction
+  # @return [Object] system_value to be used for next transaction
+  def new_system_value(property, event, old_system_value)
+    if event && event.status != "success"
+      # For non-success events, we persist the old_system_value if it is defined,
+      # or use the event previous_value.
+      # If we're using the event previous_value, we ensure that it's
+      # an array. This is needed because properties assume that their
+      # `should` value is an array, and we will use this value later
+      # on in property insync? logic.
+      event_value = [event.previous_value] unless event.previous_value.is_a?(Array)
+      old_system_value.nil? ? event_value : old_system_value
+    else
+      # For non events, or for success cases, we just want to store
+      # the parameters agent value.
+      # We use instance_variable_get here because we want this process to bypass any
+      # munging/unmunging or validation that the property might try to do, since those
+      # operations may not be correctly implemented for custom types.
+      property.instance_variable_get(:@should)
+    end
+  end
+
+  # @api private
+  ResourceApplicationContext = Struct.new(:resource,
+                                          :current_values,
+                                          :historical_values,
+                                          :audited_params,
+                                          :synced_params,
+                                          :status,
+                                          :system_value_params) do
+    def self.from_resource(resource, status)
+      ResourceApplicationContext.new(resource,
+                                     resource.retrieve_resource.to_hash,
+                                     Puppet::Util::Storage.cache(resource).dup,
+                                     (resource[:audit] || []).map { |p| p.to_sym },
+                                     [],
+                                     status,
+                                     resource.parameters.select { |n,p| p.is_a?(Puppet::Property) && !p.sensitive })
+    end
+
+    def resource_present?
+      resource.present?(current_values)
+    end
+
+    def record(event)
+      status << event
+    end
+  end
+end

data/vendor/pup410/lib/puppet/type.rb

@@ -0,0 +1,2670 @@
+# -*- coding: utf-8 -*-
+require 'puppet'
+require 'puppet/util/log'
+require 'puppet/util/metric'
+require 'puppet/property'
+require 'puppet/parameter'
+require 'puppet/util'
+require 'puppet/util/autoload'
+require 'puppet/metatype/manager'
+require 'puppet/util/errors'
+require 'puppet/util/logging'
+require 'puppet/util/tagging'
+
+# see the bottom of the file for the rest of the inclusions
+
+
+module Puppet
+# The base class for all Puppet types.
+#
+# A type describes:
+#--
+# * **Attributes** - properties, parameters, and meta-parameters are different types of attributes of a type.
+#   * **Properties** - these are the properties of the managed resource (attributes of the entity being managed; like
+#     a file's owner, group and mode). A property describes two states; the 'is' (current state) and the 'should' (wanted
+#     state).
+#       * **Ensurable** - a set of traits that control the lifecycle (create, remove, etc.) of a managed entity.
+#         There is a default set of operations associated with being _ensurable_, but this can be changed.
+#       * **Name/Identity** - one property is the name/identity of a resource, the _namevar_ that uniquely identifies
+#         one instance of a type from all others.
+#   * **Parameters** - additional attributes of the type (that does not directly related to an instance of the managed
+#     resource; if an operation is recursive or not, where to look for things, etc.). A Parameter (in contrast to Property)
+#     has one current value where a Property has two (current-state and wanted-state).
+#   * **Meta-Parameters** - parameters that are available across all types. A meta-parameter typically has
+#     additional semantics; like the `require` meta-parameter. A new type typically does not add new meta-parameters,
+#     but you need to be aware of their existence so you do not inadvertently shadow an existing meta-parameters.
+# * **Parent** - a type can have a super type (that it inherits from).
+# * **Validation** - If not just a basic data type, or an enumeration of symbolic values, it is possible to provide
+#     validation logic for a type, properties and parameters.
+# * **Munging** - munging/unmunging is the process of turning a value in external representation (as used
+#     by a provider) into an internal representation and vice versa. A Type supports adding custom logic for these.
+# * **Auto Requirements** - a type can specify automatic relationships to resources to ensure that if they are being
+#     managed, they will be processed before this type.
+# * **Providers** - a provider is an implementation of a type's behavior - the management of a resource in the
+#     system being managed. A provider is often platform specific and is selected at runtime based on
+#     criteria/predicates specified in the configured providers. See {Puppet::Provider} for details.
+# * **Device Support** - A type has some support for being applied to a device; i.e. something that is managed
+#     by running logic external to the device itself. There are several methods that deals with type
+#     applicability for these special cases such as {apply_to_device}.
+#
+# Additional Concepts:
+# --
+# * **Resource-type** - A _resource type_ is a term used to denote the type of a resource; internally a resource
+#     is really an instance of a Ruby class i.e. {Puppet::Resource} which defines its behavior as "resource data".
+#     Conceptually however, a resource is an instance of a subclass of Type (e.g. File), where such a class describes
+#     its interface (what can be said/what is known about a resource of this type),
+# * **Managed Entity** - This is not a term in general use, but is used here when there is a need to make
+#     a distinction between a resource (a description of what/how something should be managed), and what it is
+#     managing (a file in the file system). The term _managed entity_ is a reference to the "file in the file system"
+# * **Isomorphism** - the quality of being _isomorphic_ means that two resource instances with the same name
+#     refers to the same managed entity. Or put differently; _an isomorphic name is the identity of a resource_.
+#     As an example, `exec` resources (that executes some command) have the command (i.e. the command line string) as
+#     their name, and these resources are said to be non-isomorphic.
+#
+# @note The Type class deals with multiple concerns; some methods provide an internal DSL for convenient definition
+#   of types, other methods deal with various aspects while running; wiring up a resource (expressed in Puppet DSL)
+#   with its _resource type_ (i.e. an instance of Type) to enable validation, transformation of values
+#   (munge/unmunge), etc. Lastly, Type is also responsible for dealing with Providers; the concrete implementations
+#   of the behavior that constitutes how a particular Type behaves on a particular type of system (e.g. how
+#   commands are executed on a flavor of Linux, on Windows, etc.). This means that as you are reading through the
+#   documentation of this class, you will be switching between these concepts, as well as switching between
+#   the conceptual level "a resource is an instance of a resource-type" and the actual implementation classes
+#   (Type, Resource, Provider, and various utility and helper classes).
+#
+# @api public
+#
+#
+class Type
+  extend Puppet::CompilableResourceType
+  include Puppet::Util
+  include Puppet::Util::Errors
+  include Puppet::Util::Logging
+  include Puppet::Util::Tagging
+
+  # Comparing type instances.
+  include Comparable
+
+  # Compares this type against the given _other_ (type) and returns -1, 0, or +1 depending on the order.
+  # @param other [Object] the object to compare against (produces nil, if not kind of Type}
+  # @return [-1, 0, +1, nil] produces -1 if this type is before the given _other_ type, 0 if equals, and 1 if after.
+  #   Returns nil, if the given _other_ is not a kind of Type.
+  # @see Comparable
+  #
+  def <=>(other)
+    # Order is only maintained against other types, not arbitrary objects.
+    # The natural order is based on the reference name used when comparing
+    return nil unless other.is_a?(Puppet::CompilableResourceType) || other.class.is_a?(Puppet::CompilableResourceType)
+    # against other type instances.
+    self.ref <=> other.ref
+  end
+
+  # Code related to resource type attributes.
+  class << self
+    include Puppet::Util::ClassGen
+    include Puppet::Util::Warnings
+
+    # @return [Array<Puppet::Property>] The list of declared properties for the resource type.
+    # The returned lists contains instances if Puppet::Property or its subclasses.
+    attr_reader :properties
+  end
+
+  # Allow declaring that a type is actually a capability
+  class << self
+    attr_accessor :is_capability
+
+    def is_capability?
+      c = is_capability
+      c.nil? ? false : c
+    end
+  end
+
+  # Returns whether this type represents an application instance; since
+  # only defined types, i.e., instances of Puppet::Resource::Type can
+  # represent application instances, this implementation always returns
+  # +false+. Having this method though makes code checking whether a
+  # resource is an application instance simpler
+  def self.application?
+      false
+  end
+
+  # Returns all the attribute names of the type in the appropriate order.
+  # The {key_attributes} come first, then the {provider}, then the {properties}, and finally
+  # the {parameters} and {metaparams},
+  # all in the order they were specified in the respective files.
+  # @return [Array<String>] all type attribute names in a defined order.
+  #
+  def self.allattrs
+    key_attributes | (parameters & [:provider]) | properties.collect { |property| property.name } | parameters | metaparams
+  end
+
+  # Returns the class associated with the given attribute name.
+  # @param name [String] the name of the attribute to obtain the class for
+  # @return [Class, nil] the class for the given attribute, or nil if the name does not refer to an existing attribute
+  #
+  def self.attrclass(name)
+    @attrclasses ||= {}
+
+    # We cache the value, since this method gets called such a huge number
+    # of times (as in, hundreds of thousands in a given run).
+    unless @attrclasses.include?(name)
+      @attrclasses[name] = case self.attrtype(name)
+      when :property; @validproperties[name]
+      when :meta; @@metaparamhash[name]
+      when :param; @paramhash[name]
+      end
+    end
+    @attrclasses[name]
+  end
+
+  # Returns the attribute type (`:property`, `;param`, `:meta`).
+  # @comment What type of parameter are we dealing with? Cache the results, because
+  #   this method gets called so many times.
+  # @return [Symbol] a symbol describing the type of attribute (`:property`, `;param`, `:meta`)
+  #
+  def self.attrtype(attr)
+    @attrtypes ||= {}
+    unless @attrtypes.include?(attr)
+      @attrtypes[attr] = case
+        when @validproperties.include?(attr); :property
+        when @paramhash.include?(attr); :param
+        when @@metaparamhash.include?(attr); :meta
+        end
+    end
+
+    @attrtypes[attr]
+  end
+
+  # Provides iteration over meta-parameters.
+  # @yieldparam p [Puppet::Parameter] each meta parameter
+  # @return [void]
+  #
+  def self.eachmetaparam
+    @@metaparams.each { |p| yield p.name }
+  end
+
+  # Creates a new `ensure` property with configured default values or with configuration by an optional block.
+  # This method is a convenience method for creating a property `ensure` with default accepted values.
+  # If no block is specified, the new `ensure` property will accept the default symbolic
+  # values `:present`, and `:absent` - see {Puppet::Property::Ensure}.
+  # If something else is wanted, pass a block and make calls to {Puppet::Property.newvalue} from this block
+  # to define each possible value. If a block is passed, the defaults are not automatically added to the set of
+  # valid values.
+  #
+  # @note This method will be automatically called without a block if the type implements the methods
+  #   specified by {ensurable?}. It is recommended to always call this method and not rely on this automatic
+  #   specification to clearly state that the type is ensurable.
+  #
+  # @overload ensurable()
+  # @overload ensurable({|| ... })
+  # @yield [ ] A block evaluated in scope of the new Parameter
+  # @yieldreturn [void]
+  # @return [void]
+  # @dsl type
+  # @api public
+  #
+  def self.ensurable(&block)
+    if block_given?
+      self.newproperty(:ensure, :parent => Puppet::Property::Ensure, &block)
+    else
+      self.newproperty(:ensure, :parent => Puppet::Property::Ensure) do
+        self.defaultvalues
+      end
+    end
+  end
+
+  # Returns true if the type implements the default behavior expected by being _ensurable_ "by default".
+  # A type is _ensurable_ by default if it responds to `:exists`, `:create`, and `:destroy`.
+  # If a type implements these methods and have not already specified that it is _ensurable_, it will be
+  # made so with the defaults specified in {ensurable}.
+  # @return [Boolean] whether the type is _ensurable_ or not.
+  #
+  def self.ensurable?
+    # If the class has all three of these methods defined, then it's
+    # ensurable.
+    [:exists?, :create, :destroy].all? { |method|
+      self.public_method_defined?(method)
+    }
+  end
+
+  # @comment These `apply_to` methods are horrible.  They should really be implemented
+  #   as part of the usual system of constraints that apply to a type and
+  #   provider pair, but were implemented as a separate shadow system.
+  #
+  # @comment We should rip them out in favour of a real constraint pattern around the
+  #   target device - whatever that looks like - and not have this additional
+  #   magic here. --daniel 2012-03-08
+  #
+  # Makes this type applicable to `:device`.
+  # @return [Symbol] Returns `:device`
+  # @api private
+  #
+  def self.apply_to_device
+    @apply_to = :device
+  end
+
+  # Makes this type applicable to `:host`.
+  # @return [Symbol] Returns `:host`
+  # @api private
+  #
+  def self.apply_to_host
+    @apply_to = :host
+  end
+
+  # Makes this type applicable to `:both` (i.e. `:host` and `:device`).
+  # @return [Symbol] Returns `:both`
+  # @api private
+  #
+  def self.apply_to_all
+    @apply_to = :both
+  end
+
+  # Makes this type apply to `:host` if not already applied to something else.
+  # @return [Symbol] a `:device`, `:host`, or `:both` enumeration
+  # @api private
+  def self.apply_to
+    @apply_to ||= :host
+  end
+
+  # Returns true if this type is applicable to the given target.
+  # @param target [Symbol] should be :device, :host or :target, if anything else, :host is enforced
+  # @return [Boolean] true
+  # @api private
+  #
+  def self.can_apply_to(target)
+    [ target == :device ? :device : :host, :both ].include?(apply_to)
+  end
+
+  # Processes the options for a named parameter.
+  # @param name [String] the name of a parameter
+  # @param options [Hash] a hash of options
+  # @option options [Boolean] :boolean if option set to true, an access method on the form _name_? is added for the param
+  # @return [void]
+  #
+  def self.handle_param_options(name, options)
+    # If it's a boolean parameter, create a method to test the value easily
+    if options[:boolean]
+      define_method(name.to_s + "?") do
+        val = self[name]
+        if val == :true or val == true
+          return true
+        end
+      end
+    end
+  end
+
+  # Is the given parameter a meta-parameter?
+  # @return [Boolean] true if the given parameter is a meta-parameter.
+  #
+  def self.metaparam?(param)
+    @@metaparamhash.include?(param.intern)
+  end
+
+  # Returns the meta-parameter class associated with the given meta-parameter name.
+  # Accepts a `nil` name, and return nil.
+  # @param name [String, nil] the name of a meta-parameter
+  # @return [Class,nil] the class for the given meta-parameter, or `nil` if no such meta-parameter exists, (or if
+  #   the given meta-parameter name is `nil`.
+  #
+  def self.metaparamclass(name)
+    return nil if name.nil?
+    @@metaparamhash[name.intern]
+  end
+
+  # Returns all meta-parameter names.
+  # @return [Array<String>] all meta-parameter names
+  #
+  def self.metaparams
+    @@metaparams.collect { |param| param.name }
+  end
+
+  # Returns the documentation for a given meta-parameter of this type.
+  # @param metaparam [Puppet::Parameter] the meta-parameter to get documentation for.
+  # @return [String] the documentation associated with the given meta-parameter, or nil of no such documentation
+  #   exists.
+  # @raise if the given metaparam is not a meta-parameter in this type
+  #
+  def self.metaparamdoc(metaparam)
+    @@metaparamhash[metaparam].doc
+  end
+
+  # Creates a new meta-parameter.
+  # This creates a new meta-parameter that is added to this and all inheriting types.
+  # @param name [Symbol] the name of the parameter
+  # @param options [Hash] a hash with options.
+  # @option options [Class<inherits Puppet::Parameter>] :parent (Puppet::Parameter) the super class of this parameter
+  # @option options [Hash{String => Object}] :attributes a hash that is applied to the generated class
+  #   by calling setter methods corresponding to this hash's keys/value pairs. This is done before the given
+  #   block is evaluated.
+  # @option options [Boolean] :boolean (false) specifies if this is a boolean parameter
+  # @option options [Boolean] :namevar  (false) specifies if this parameter is the namevar
+  # @option options [Symbol, Array<Symbol>] :required_features  specifies required provider features by name
+  # @return [Class<inherits Puppet::Parameter>] the created parameter
+  # @yield [ ] a required block that is evaluated in the scope of the new meta-parameter
+  # @api public
+  # @dsl type
+  # @todo Verify that this description is ok
+  #
+  def self.newmetaparam(name, options = {}, &block)
+    @@metaparams ||= []
+    @@metaparamhash ||= {}
+    name = name.intern
+
+    param = genclass(
+      name,
+      :parent => options[:parent] || Puppet::Parameter,
+      :prefix => "MetaParam",
+      :hash => @@metaparamhash,
+      :array => @@metaparams,
+      :attributes => options[:attributes],
+      &block
+    )
+
+    # Grr.
+    param.required_features = options[:required_features] if options[:required_features]
+
+    handle_param_options(name, options)
+
+    param.metaparam = true
+
+    param
+  end
+
+  # Returns the list of parameters that comprise the composite key / "uniqueness key".
+  # All parameters that return true from #isnamevar? or is named `:name` are included in the returned result.
+  # @see uniqueness_key
+  # @return [Array<Puppet::Parameter>] WARNING: this return type is uncertain
+  def self.key_attribute_parameters
+    @key_attribute_parameters ||= (
+      @parameters.find_all { |param|
+        param.isnamevar? or param.name == :name
+      }
+    )
+  end
+
+  # Returns cached {key_attribute_parameters} names.
+  # Key attributes are properties and parameters that comprise a composite key
+  # or "uniqueness key".
+  # @return [Array<String>] cached key_attribute names
+  #
+  def self.key_attributes
+    # This is a cache miss around 0.05 percent of the time. --daniel 2012-07-17
+    @key_attributes_cache ||= key_attribute_parameters.collect { |p| p.name }
+  end
+
+  # Returns a mapping from the title string to setting of attribute value(s).
+  # This default implementation provides a mapping of title to the one and only _namevar_ present
+  # in the type's definition.
+  # @note Advanced: some logic requires this mapping to be done differently, using a different
+  #   validation/pattern, breaking up the title
+  #   into several parts assigning each to an individual attribute, or even use a composite identity where
+  #   all namevars are seen as part of the unique identity (such computation is done by the {#uniqueness} method.
+  #   These advanced options are rarely used (only one of the built in puppet types use this, and then only
+  #   a small part of the available functionality), and the support for these advanced mappings is not
+  #   implemented in a straight forward way. For these reasons, this method has been marked as private).
+  #
+  # @raise [Puppet::DevError] if there is no title pattern and there are two or more key attributes
+  # @return [Array<Array<Regexp, Array<Array <Symbol, Proc>>>>, nil] a structure with a regexp and the first key_attribute ???
+  # @comment This wonderful piece of logic creates a structure used by Resource.parse_title which
+  #   has the capability to assign parts of the title to one or more attributes; It looks like an implementation
+  #   of a composite identity key (all parts of the key_attributes array are in the key). This can also
+  #   be seen in the method uniqueness_key.
+  #   The implementation in this method simply assigns the title to the one and only namevar (which is name
+  #   or a variable marked as namevar).
+  #   If there are multiple namevars (any in addition to :name?) then this method MUST be implemented
+  #   as it raises an exception if there is more than 1. Note that in puppet, it is only File that uses this
+  #   to create a different pattern for assigning to the :path attribute
+  #   This requires further digging.
+  #   The entire construct is somewhat strange, since resource checks if the method "title_patterns" is
+  #   implemented (it seems it always is) - why take this more expensive regexp mathching route for all
+  #   other types?
+  # @api private
+  #
+  def self.title_patterns
+    case key_attributes.length
+    when 0; []
+    when 1;
+      [ [ /(.*)/m, [ [key_attributes.first] ] ] ]
+    else
+      raise Puppet::DevError,"you must specify title patterns when there are two or more key attributes"
+    end
+  end
+
+  # Produces a resource's _uniqueness_key_ (or composite key).
+  # This key is an array of all key attributes' values. Each distinct tuple must be unique for each resource type.
+  # @see key_attributes
+  # @return [Object] an object that is a _uniqueness_key_ for this object
+  #
+  def uniqueness_key
+    self.class.key_attributes.sort_by { |attribute_name| attribute_name.to_s }.map{ |attribute_name| self[attribute_name] }
+  end
+
+  # Creates a new parameter.
+  # @param name [Symbol] the name of the parameter
+  # @param options [Hash] a hash with options.
+  # @option options [Class<inherits Puppet::Parameter>] :parent (Puppet::Parameter) the super class of this parameter
+  # @option options [Hash{String => Object}] :attributes a hash that is applied to the generated class
+  #   by calling setter methods corresponding to this hash's keys/value pairs. This is done before the given
+  #   block is evaluated.
+  # @option options [Boolean] :boolean (false) specifies if this is a boolean parameter
+  # @option options [Boolean] :namevar  (false) specifies if this parameter is the namevar
+  # @option options [Symbol, Array<Symbol>] :required_features  specifies required provider features by name
+  # @return [Class<inherits Puppet::Parameter>] the created parameter
+  # @yield [ ] a required block that is evaluated in the scope of the new parameter
+  # @api public
+  # @dsl type
+  #
+  def self.newparam(name, options = {}, &block)
+    options[:attributes] ||= {}
+
+    param = genclass(
+      name,
+      :parent     => options[:parent] || Puppet::Parameter,
+      :attributes => options[:attributes],
+      :block      => block,
+      :prefix     => "Parameter",
+      :array      => @parameters,
+      :hash       => @paramhash
+    )
+
+    handle_param_options(name, options)
+
+    # Grr.
+    param.required_features = options[:required_features] if options[:required_features]
+
+    param.isnamevar if options[:namevar]
+
+    param
+  end
+
+  # Creates a new property.
+  # @param name [Symbol] the name of the property
+  # @param options [Hash] a hash with options.
+  # @option options [Symbol] :array_matching (:first) specifies how the current state is matched against
+  #   the wanted state. Use `:first` if the property is single valued, and (`:all`) otherwise.
+  # @option options [Class<inherits Puppet::Property>] :parent (Puppet::Property) the super class of this property
+  # @option options [Hash{String => Object}] :attributes a hash that is applied to the generated class
+  #   by calling setter methods corresponding to this hash's keys/value pairs. This is done before the given
+  #   block is evaluated.
+  # @option options [Boolean] :boolean (false) specifies if this is a boolean parameter
+  # @option options [Symbol] :retrieve the method to call on the provider (or `parent` if `provider` is not set)
+  #   to retrieve the current value of this property.
+  # @option options [Symbol, Array<Symbol>] :required_features  specifies required provider features by name
+  # @return [Class<inherits Puppet::Property>] the created property
+  # @yield [ ] a required block that is evaluated in the scope of the new property
+  # @api public
+  # @dsl type
+  #
+  def self.newproperty(name, options = {}, &block)
+    name = name.intern
+
+    # This is here for types that might still have the old method of defining
+    # a parent class.
+    unless options.is_a? Hash
+      raise Puppet::DevError,
+        "Options must be a hash, not #{options.inspect}"
+    end
+
+    raise Puppet::DevError, "Class #{self.name} already has a property named #{name}" if @validproperties.include?(name)
+
+    if parent = options[:parent]
+      options.delete(:parent)
+    else
+      parent = Puppet::Property
+    end
+
+    # We have to create our own, new block here because we want to define
+    # an initial :retrieve method, if told to, and then eval the passed
+    # block if available.
+    prop = genclass(name, :parent => parent, :hash => @validproperties, :attributes => options) do
+      # If they've passed a retrieve method, then override the retrieve
+      # method on the class.
+      if options[:retrieve]
+        define_method(:retrieve) do
+          provider.send(options[:retrieve])
+        end
+      end
+
+      class_eval(&block) if block
+    end
+
+    # If it's the 'ensure' property, always put it first.
+    if name == :ensure
+      @properties.unshift prop
+    else
+      @properties << prop
+    end
+
+    prop
+  end
+
+  def self.paramdoc(param)
+    @paramhash[param].doc
+  end
+
+  # @return [Array<String>] Returns the parameter names
+  def self.parameters
+    return [] unless defined?(@parameters)
+    @parameters.collect { |klass| klass.name }
+  end
+
+  # @return [Puppet::Parameter] Returns the parameter class associated with the given parameter name.
+  def self.paramclass(name)
+    @paramhash[name]
+  end
+
+  # @return [Puppet::Property] Returns the property class ??? associated with the given property name
+  def self.propertybyname(name)
+    @validproperties[name]
+  end
+
+  # Returns whether or not the given name is the name of a property, parameter or meta-parameter
+  # @return [Boolean] true if the given attribute name is the name of an existing property, parameter or meta-parameter
+  #
+  def self.validattr?(name)
+    name = name.intern
+    return true if name == :name
+    @validattrs ||= {}
+
+    unless @validattrs.include?(name)
+      @validattrs[name] = !!(self.validproperty?(name) or self.validparameter?(name) or self.metaparam?(name))
+    end
+
+    @validattrs[name]
+  end
+
+  # @return [Boolean] Returns true if the given name is the name of an existing property
+  def self.validproperty?(name)
+    name = name.intern
+    @validproperties.include?(name) && @validproperties[name]
+  end
+
+  # @return [Array<Symbol>, {}] Returns a list of valid property names, or an empty hash if there are none.
+  # @todo An empty hash is returned if there are no defined parameters (not an empty array). This looks like
+  #   a bug.
+  #
+  def self.validproperties
+    return {} unless defined?(@parameters)
+
+    @validproperties.keys
+  end
+
+  # @return [Boolean] Returns true if the given name is the name of an existing parameter
+  def self.validparameter?(name)
+    raise Puppet::DevError, "Class #{self} has not defined parameters" unless defined?(@parameters)
+    !!(@paramhash.include?(name) or @@metaparamhash.include?(name))
+  end
+
+  # (see validattr?)
+  # @note see comment in code - how should this be documented? Are some of the other query methods deprecated?
+  #   (or should be).
+  # @comment This is a forward-compatibility method - it's the validity interface we'll use in Puppet::Resource.
+  def self.valid_parameter?(name)
+    validattr?(name)
+  end
+
+  # @return [Boolean] Returns true if the wanted state of the resource is that it should be absent (i.e. to be deleted).
+  def deleting?
+    obj = @parameters[:ensure] and obj.should == :absent
+  end
+
+  # Creates a new property value holder for the resource if it is valid and does not already exist
+  # @return [Boolean] true if a new parameter was added, false otherwise
+  def add_property_parameter(prop_name)
+    if self.class.validproperty?(prop_name) && !@parameters[prop_name]
+      self.newattr(prop_name)
+      return true
+    end
+    false
+  end
+
+  # @return [Symbol, Boolean] Returns the name of the namevar if there is only one or false otherwise.
+  # @comment This is really convoluted and part of the support for multiple namevars (?).
+  #   If there is only one namevar, the produced value is naturally this namevar, but if there are several?
+  #   The logic caches the name of the namevar if it is a single name, but otherwise always
+  #   calls key_attributes, and then caches the first if there was only one, otherwise it returns
+  #   false and caches this (which is then subsequently returned as a cache hit).
+  #
+  def name_var
+    return @name_var_cache unless @name_var_cache.nil?
+    key_attributes = self.class.key_attributes
+    @name_var_cache = (key_attributes.length == 1) && key_attributes.first
+  end
+
+  # Gets the 'should' (wanted state) value of a parameter or property by name.
+  # To explicitly get the 'is' (current state) value use `o.is(:name)`, and to explicitly get the 'should' value
+  # use `o.should(:name)`
+  # @param name [String] the name of the attribute to obtain the 'should' value for.
+  # @return [Object] 'should'/wanted value of the given attribute
+  def [](name)
+    name = name.intern
+    fail("Invalid parameter #{name}(#{name.inspect})") unless self.class.validattr?(name)
+
+    if name == :name && nv = name_var
+      name = nv
+    end
+
+    if obj = @parameters[name]
+      # Note that if this is a property, then the value is the "should" value,
+      # not the current value.
+      obj.value
+    else
+      return nil
+    end
+  end
+
+  # Sets the 'should' (wanted state) value of a property, or the value of a parameter.
+  # @return
+  # @raise [Puppet::Error] if the setting of the value fails, or if the given name is nil.
+  # @raise [Puppet::ResourceError] when the parameter validation raises Puppet::Error or
+  #   ArgumentError
+  def []=(name,value)
+    name = name.intern
+
+    fail("no parameter named '#{name}'") unless self.class.validattr?(name)
+
+    if name == :name && nv = name_var
+      name = nv
+    end
+    raise Puppet::Error.new("Got nil value for #{name}") if value.nil?
+
+    property = self.newattr(name)
+
+    if property
+      begin
+        # make sure the parameter doesn't have any errors
+        property.value = value
+      rescue Puppet::Error, ArgumentError => detail
+        error = Puppet::ResourceError.new("Parameter #{name} failed on #{ref}: #{detail}")
+        adderrorcontext(error, detail)
+        raise error
+      end
+    end
+
+    nil
+  end
+
+  # Removes an attribute from the object; useful in testing or in cleanup
+  # when an error has been encountered
+  # @todo Don't know what the attr is (name or Property/Parameter?). Guessing it is a String name...
+  # @todo Is it possible to delete a meta-parameter?
+  # @todo What does delete mean? Is it deleted from the type or is its value state 'is'/'should' deleted?
+  # @param attr [String] the attribute to delete from this object. WHAT IS THE TYPE?
+  # @raise [Puppet::DecError] when an attempt is made to delete an attribute that does not exists.
+  #
+  def delete(attr)
+    attr = attr.intern
+    if @parameters.has_key?(attr)
+      @parameters.delete(attr)
+    else
+      raise Puppet::DevError.new("Undefined attribute '#{attr}' in #{self}")
+    end
+  end
+
+  # Iterates over the properties that were set on this resource.
+  # @yieldparam property [Puppet::Property] each property
+  # @return [void]
+  def eachproperty
+    # properties is a private method
+    properties.each { |property|
+      yield property
+    }
+  end
+
+  # Return the parameters, metaparams, and properties that have a value or were set by a default. Properties are
+  # included since they are a subclass of parameter.
+  # @return [Array<Puppet::Parameter>] Array of parameter objects ( or subclass thereof )
+  def parameters_with_value
+    self.class.allattrs.collect { |attr| parameter(attr) }.compact
+  end
+
+  # Iterates over all parameters with value currently set.
+  # @yieldparam parameter [Puppet::Parameter] or a subclass thereof
+  # @return [void]
+  def eachparameter
+    parameters_with_value.each { |parameter| yield parameter }
+  end
+
+  # Creates a transaction event.
+  # Called by Transaction or by a property.
+  # Merges the given options with the options `:resource`, `:file`, `:line`, and `:tags`, initialized from
+  # values in this object. For possible options to pass (if any ????) see {Puppet::Transaction::Event}.
+  # @todo Needs a better explanation "Why should I care who is calling this method?", What do I need to know
+  #   about events and how they work? Where can I read about them?
+  # @param options [Hash] options merged with a fixed set of options defined by this method, passed on to {Puppet::Transaction::Event}.
+  # @return [Puppet::Transaction::Event] the created event
+  def event(options = {})
+    Puppet::Transaction::Event.new({:resource => self, :file => file, :line => line, :tags => tags}.merge(options))
+  end
+
+  # @return [Object, nil] Returns the 'should' (wanted state) value for a specified property, or nil if the
+  #   given attribute name is not a property (i.e. if it is a parameter, meta-parameter, or does not exist).
+  def should(name)
+    name = name.intern
+    (prop = @parameters[name] and prop.is_a?(Puppet::Property)) ? prop.should : nil
+  end
+
+  # Registers an attribute to this resource type instance.
+  # Requires either the attribute name or class as its argument.
+  # This is a noop if the named property/parameter is not supported
+  # by this resource. Otherwise, an attribute instance is created
+  # and kept in this resource's parameters hash.
+  # @overload newattr(name)
+  #   @param name [Symbol] symbolic name of the attribute
+  # @overload newattr(klass)
+  #   @param klass [Class] a class supported as an attribute class, i.e. a subclass of
+  #     Parameter or Property
+  # @return [Object] An instance of the named Parameter or Property class associated
+  #   to this resource type instance, or nil if the attribute is not supported
+  #
+  def newattr(name)
+    if name.is_a?(Class)
+      klass = name
+      name = klass.name
+    end
+
+    unless klass = self.class.attrclass(name)
+      raise Puppet::Error, "Resource type #{self.class.name} does not support parameter #{name}"
+    end
+
+    if provider and ! provider.class.supports_parameter?(klass)
+      missing = klass.required_features.find_all { |f| ! provider.class.feature?(f) }
+      debug "Provider %s does not support features %s; not managing attribute %s" % [provider.class.name, missing.join(", "), name]
+      return nil
+    end
+
+    return @parameters[name] if @parameters.include?(name)
+
+    @parameters[name] = klass.new(:resource => self)
+  end
+
+  # Returns a string representation of the resource's containment path in
+  # the catalog.
+  # @return [String]
+  def path
+    @path ||= '/' + pathbuilder.join('/')
+  end
+
+  # Returns the value of this object's parameter given by name
+  # @param name [String] the name of the parameter
+  # @return [Object] the value
+  def parameter(name)
+    @parameters[name.to_sym]
+  end
+
+  # Returns a shallow copy of this object's hash of attributes by name.
+  # Note that his not only comprises parameters, but also properties and metaparameters.
+  # Changes to the contained parameters will have an effect on the parameters of this type, but changes to
+  # the returned hash does not.
+  # @return [Hash{String => Object}] a new hash being a shallow copy of the parameters map name to parameter
+  def parameters
+    @parameters.dup
+  end
+
+  # @return [Boolean] Returns whether the attribute given by name has been added
+  #   to this resource or not.
+  def propertydefined?(name)
+    name = name.intern unless name.is_a? Symbol
+    @parameters.include?(name)
+  end
+
+  # Returns a {Puppet::Property} instance by name.
+  # To return the value, use 'resource[param]'
+  # @todo LAK:NOTE(20081028) Since the 'parameter' method is now a superset of this method,
+  #   this one should probably go away at some point. - Does this mean it should be deprecated ?
+  # @return [Puppet::Property] the property with the given name, or nil if not a property or does not exist.
+  def property(name)
+    (obj = @parameters[name.intern] and obj.is_a?(Puppet::Property)) ? obj : nil
+  end
+
+  # @todo comment says "For any parameters or properties that have defaults and have not yet been
+  #   set, set them now.  This method can be handed a list of attributes,
+  #   and if so it will only set defaults for those attributes."
+  # @todo Needs a better explanation, and investigation about the claim an array can be passed (it is passed
+  #   to self.class.attrclass to produce a class on which a check is made if it has a method class :default (does
+  #   not seem to support an array...
+  # @return [void]
+  #
+  def set_default(attr)
+    return unless klass = self.class.attrclass(attr)
+    return unless klass.method_defined?(:default)
+    return if @parameters.include?(klass.name)
+
+    return unless parameter = newattr(klass.name)
+
+    if value = parameter.default and ! value.nil?
+      parameter.value = value
+    else
+      @parameters.delete(parameter.name)
+    end
+  end
+
+  # @todo the comment says: "Convert our object to a hash.  This just includes properties."
+  # @todo this is confused, again it is the @parameters instance variable that is consulted, and
+  #   each value is copied - does it contain "properties" and "parameters" or both? Does it contain
+  #   meta-parameters?
+  #
+  # @return [Hash{ ??? => ??? }] a hash of WHAT?. The hash is a shallow copy, any changes to the
+  #  objects returned in this hash will be reflected in the original resource having these attributes.
+  #
+  def to_hash
+    rethash = {}
+
+    @parameters.each do |name, obj|
+      rethash[name] = obj.value
+    end
+
+    rethash
+  end
+
+  # @return [String] the name of this object's class
+  # @todo Would that be "file" for the "File" resource type? of "File" or something else?
+  #
+  def type
+    self.class.name
+  end
+
+  # @todo Comment says "Return a specific value for an attribute.", as opposed to what "An unspecific value"???
+  # @todo is this the 'is' or the 'should' value?
+  # @todo why is the return restricted to things that respond to :value? (Only non structural basic data types
+  #   supported?
+  #
+  # @return [Object, nil] the value of the attribute having the given name, or nil if the given name is not
+  #   an attribute, or the referenced attribute does not respond to `:value`.
+  def value(name)
+    name = name.intern
+
+    (obj = @parameters[name] and obj.respond_to?(:value)) ? obj.value : nil
+  end
+
+  # @todo What is this used for? Needs a better explanation.
+  # @return [???] the version of the catalog or 0 if there is no catalog.
+  def version
+    return 0 unless catalog
+    catalog.version
+  end
+
+  # @return [Array<Puppet::Property>] Returns all of the property objects, in the order specified in the
+  #   class.
+  # @todo "what does the 'order specified in the class' mean? The order the properties where added in the
+  #   ruby file adding a new type with new properties?
+  #
+  def properties
+    self.class.properties.collect { |prop| @parameters[prop.name] }.compact
+  end
+
+  # Returns true if the type's notion of name is the identity of a resource.
+  # See the overview of this class for a longer explanation of the concept _isomorphism_.
+  # Defaults to true.
+  #
+  # @return [Boolean] true, if this type's name is isomorphic with the object
+  def self.isomorphic?
+    if defined?(@isomorphic)
+      return @isomorphic
+    else
+      return true
+    end
+  end
+
+  # @todo check that this gets documentation (it is at the class level as well as instance).
+  # (see isomorphic?)
+  def isomorphic?
+    self.class.isomorphic?
+  end
+
+  # Returns true if the instance is a managed instance.
+  # A 'yes' here means that the instance was created from the language, vs. being created
+  # in order resolve other questions, such as finding a package in a list.
+  # @note An object that is managed always stays managed, but an object that is not managed
+  #   may become managed later in its lifecycle.
+  # @return [Boolean] true if the object is managed
+  def managed?
+    # Once an object is managed, it always stays managed; but an object
+    # that is listed as unmanaged might become managed later in the process,
+    # so we have to check that every time
+    if @managed
+      return @managed
+    else
+      @managed = false
+      properties.each { |property|
+        s = property.should
+        if s and ! property.class.unmanaged
+          @managed = true
+          break
+        end
+      }
+      return @managed
+    end
+  end
+
+  ###############################
+  # Code related to the container behaviour.
+
+  # Returns true if the search should be done in depth-first order.
+  # This implementation always returns false.
+  # @todo What is this used for?
+  #
+  # @return [Boolean] true if the search should be done in depth first order.
+  #
+  def depthfirst?
+    false
+  end
+
+  # Removes this object (FROM WHERE?)
+  # @todo removes if from where?
+  # @return [void]
+  def remove()
+    # This is hackish (mmm, cut and paste), but it works for now, and it's
+    # better than warnings.
+    @parameters.each do |name, obj|
+      obj.remove
+    end
+    @parameters.clear
+
+    @parent = nil
+
+    # Remove the reference to the provider.
+    if self.provider
+      @provider.clear
+      @provider = nil
+    end
+  end
+
+  ###############################
+  # Code related to evaluating the resources.
+
+  # Returns the ancestors - WHAT?
+  # This implementation always returns an empty list.
+  # @todo WHAT IS THIS ?
+  # @return [Array<???>] returns a list of ancestors.
+  def ancestors
+    []
+  end
+
+  # Lifecycle method for a resource. This is called during graph creation.
+  # It should perform any consistency checking of the catalog and raise a
+  # Puppet::Error if the transaction should be aborted.
+  #
+  # It differs from the validate method, since it is called later during
+  # initialization and can rely on self.catalog to have references to all
+  # resources that comprise the catalog.
+  #
+  # @see Puppet::Transaction#add_vertex
+  # @raise [Puppet::Error] If the pre-run check failed.
+  # @return [void]
+  # @abstract a resource type may implement this method to perform
+  #   validation checks that can query the complete catalog
+  def pre_run_check
+  end
+
+  # Flushes the provider if supported by the provider, else no action.
+  # This is called by the transaction.
+  # @todo What does Flushing the provider mean? Why is it interesting to know that this is
+  #   called by the transaction? (It is not explained anywhere what a transaction is).
+  #
+  # @return [???, nil] WHAT DOES IT RETURN? GUESS IS VOID
+  def flush
+    self.provider.flush if self.provider and self.provider.respond_to?(:flush)
+  end
+
+  # Returns true if all contained objects are in sync.
+  # @todo "contained in what?" in the given "in" parameter?
+  #
+  # @todo deal with the comment _"FIXME I don't think this is used on the type instances any more,
+  #   it's really only used for testing"_
+  # @return [Boolean] true if in sync, false otherwise.
+  #
+  def insync?(is)
+    insync = true
+
+    if property = @parameters[:ensure]
+      unless is.include? property
+        raise Puppet::DevError,
+          "The is value is not in the is array for '#{property.name}'"
+      end
+      ensureis = is[property]
+      if property.safe_insync?(ensureis) and property.should == :absent
+        return true
+      end
+    end
+
+    properties.each { |prop|
+      unless is.include? prop
+        raise Puppet::DevError,
+          "The is value is not in the is array for '#{prop.name}'"
+      end
+
+      propis = is[prop]
+      unless prop.safe_insync?(propis)
+        prop.debug("Not in sync: #{propis.inspect} vs #{prop.should.inspect}")
+        insync = false
+      #else
+      #    property.debug("In sync")
+      end
+    }
+
+    #self.debug("#{self} sync status is #{insync}")
+    insync
+  end
+
+  # Says if the ensure property should be retrieved if the resource is ensurable
+  # Defaults to true. Some resource type classes can override it
+  def self.needs_ensure_retrieved
+    true
+  end
+
+  # Retrieves the current value of all contained properties.
+  # Parameters and meta-parameters are not included in the result.
+  # @todo As opposed to all non contained properties? How is this different than any of the other
+  #   methods that also "gets" properties/parameters/etc. ?
+  # @return [Puppet::Resource] array of all property values (mix of types)
+  # @raise [fail???] if there is a provider and it is not suitable for the host this is evaluated for.
+  def retrieve
+    fail "Provider #{provider.class.name} is not functional on this host" if self.provider.is_a?(Puppet::Provider) and ! provider.class.suitable?
+
+    result = Puppet::Resource.new(self.class, title)
+
+    # Provide the name, so we know we'll always refer to a real thing
+    result[:name] = self[:name] unless self[:name] == title
+
+    if ensure_prop = property(:ensure) or (self.class.needs_ensure_retrieved and self.class.validattr?(:ensure) and ensure_prop = newattr(:ensure))
+      result[:ensure] = ensure_state = ensure_prop.retrieve
+    else
+      ensure_state = nil
+    end
+
+    properties.each do |property|
+      next if property.name == :ensure
+      if ensure_state == :absent
+        result[property] = :absent
+      else
+        result[property] = property.retrieve
+      end
+    end
+
+    result
+  end
+
+  # Retrieve the current state of the system as a Puppet::Resource. For
+  # the base Puppet::Type this does the same thing as #retrieve, but
+  # specific types are free to implement #retrieve as returning a hash,
+  # and this will call #retrieve and convert the hash to a resource.
+  # This is used when determining when syncing a resource.
+  #
+  # @return [Puppet::Resource] A resource representing the current state
+  #   of the system.
+  #
+  # @api private
+  def retrieve_resource
+    resource = retrieve
+    resource = Resource.new(self.class, title, :parameters => resource) if resource.is_a? Hash
+    resource
+  end
+
+  # Given the hash of current properties, should this resource be treated as if it
+  # currently exists on the system. May need to be overridden by types that offer up
+  # more than just :absent and :present.
+  def present?(current_values)
+    current_values[:ensure] != :absent
+  end
+
+  # Returns a hash of the current properties and their values.
+  # If a resource is absent, its value is the symbol `:absent`
+  # @return [Hash{Puppet::Property => Object}] mapping of property instance to its value
+  #
+  def currentpropvalues
+    # It's important to use the 'properties' method here, as it follows the order
+    # in which they're defined in the class.  It also guarantees that 'ensure'
+    # is the first property, which is important for skipping 'retrieve' on
+    # all the properties if the resource is absent.
+    ensure_state = false
+    return properties.inject({}) do | prophash, property|
+      if property.name == :ensure
+        ensure_state = property.retrieve
+        prophash[property] = ensure_state
+      else
+        if ensure_state == :absent
+          prophash[property] = :absent
+        else
+          prophash[property] = property.retrieve
+        end
+      end
+      prophash
+    end
+  end
+
+  # Returns the `noop` run mode status of this.
+  # @return [Boolean] true if running in noop mode.
+  def noop?
+    # If we're not a host_config, we're almost certainly part of
+    # Settings, and we want to ignore 'noop'
+    return false if catalog and ! catalog.host_config?
+
+    if defined?(@noop)
+      @noop
+    else
+      Puppet[:noop]
+    end
+  end
+
+  # (see #noop?)
+  def noop
+    noop?
+  end
+
+  # Retrieves all known instances.
+  # @todo Retrieves them from where? Known to whom?
+  # Either requires providers or must be overridden.
+  # @raise [Puppet::DevError] when there are no providers and the implementation has not overridden this method.
+  def self.instances
+    raise Puppet::DevError, "#{self.name} has no providers and has not overridden 'instances'" if provider_hash.empty?
+
+    # Put the default provider first, then the rest of the suitable providers.
+    provider_instances = {}
+    providers_by_source.collect do |provider|
+      self.properties.find_all do |property|
+        provider.supports_parameter?(property)
+      end.collect do |property|
+        property.name
+      end
+
+      provider.instances.collect do |instance|
+        # We always want to use the "first" provider instance we find, unless the resource
+        # is already managed and has a different provider set
+        if other = provider_instances[instance.name]
+          Puppet.debug "%s %s found in both %s and %s; skipping the %s version" %
+            [self.name.to_s.capitalize, instance.name, other.class.name, instance.class.name, instance.class.name]
+          next
+        end
+        provider_instances[instance.name] = instance
+
+        result = new(:name => instance.name, :provider => instance)
+        properties.each { |name| result.newattr(name) }
+        result
+      end
+    end.flatten.compact
+  end
+
+  # Returns a list of one suitable provider per source, with the default provider first.
+  # @todo Needs better explanation; what does "source" mean in this context?
+  # @return [Array<Puppet::Provider>] list of providers
+  #
+  def self.providers_by_source
+    # Put the default provider first (can be nil), then the rest of the suitable providers.
+    sources = []
+    [defaultprovider, suitableprovider].flatten.uniq.collect do |provider|
+      next if provider.nil?
+      next if sources.include?(provider.source)
+
+      sources << provider.source
+      provider
+    end.compact
+  end
+
+  # Converts a simple hash into a Resource instance.
+  # @todo as opposed to a complex hash? Other raised exceptions?
+  # @param [Hash{Symbol, String => Object}] hash resource attribute to value map to initialize the created resource from
+  # @return [Puppet::Resource] the resource created from the hash
+  # @raise [Puppet::Error] if a title is missing in the given hash
+  def self.hash2resource(hash)
+    hash = hash.inject({}) { |result, ary| result[ary[0].to_sym] = ary[1]; result }
+
+    title = hash.delete(:title)
+    title ||= hash[:name]
+    title ||= hash[key_attributes.first] if key_attributes.length == 1
+
+    raise Puppet::Error, "Title or name must be provided" unless title
+
+    # Now create our resource.
+    resource = Puppet::Resource.new(self, title)
+    resource.catalog = hash.delete(:catalog)
+
+    if sensitive = hash.delete(:sensitive_parameters)
+      resource.sensitive_parameters = sensitive
+    end
+
+    hash.each do |param, value|
+      resource[param] = value
+    end
+    resource
+  end
+
+
+  # Returns an array of strings representing the containment hierarchy
+  # (types/classes) that make up the path to the resource from the root
+  # of the catalog.  This is mostly used for logging purposes.
+  #
+  # @api private
+  def pathbuilder
+    if p = parent
+      [p.pathbuilder, self.ref].flatten
+    else
+      [self.ref]
+    end
+  end
+
+  ###############################
+  # Add all of the meta-parameters.
+  newmetaparam(:noop) do
+    desc "Whether to apply this resource in noop mode.
+
+      When applying a resource in noop mode, Puppet will check whether it is in sync,
+      like it does when running normally. However, if a resource attribute is not in
+      the desired state (as declared in the catalog), Puppet will take no
+      action, and will instead report the changes it _would_ have made. These
+      simulated changes will appear in the report sent to the puppet master, or
+      be shown on the console if running puppet agent or puppet apply in the
+      foreground. The simulated changes will not send refresh events to any
+      subscribing or notified resources, although Puppet will log that a refresh
+      event _would_ have been sent.
+
+      **Important note:**
+      [The `noop` setting](https://docs.puppetlabs.com/puppet/latest/reference/configuration.html#noop)
+      allows you to globally enable or disable noop mode, but it will _not_ override
+      the `noop` metaparameter on individual resources. That is, the value of the
+      global `noop` setting will _only_ affect resources that do not have an explicit
+      value set for their `noop` attribute."
+
+    newvalues(:true, :false)
+    munge do |value|
+      case value
+      when true, :true, "true"; @resource.noop = true
+      when false, :false, "false"; @resource.noop = false
+      end
+    end
+  end
+
+  newmetaparam(:schedule) do
+    desc "A schedule to govern when Puppet is allowed to manage this resource.
+      The value of this metaparameter must be the `name` of a `schedule`
+      resource. This means you must declare a schedule resource, then
+      refer to it by name; see
+      [the docs for the `schedule` type](https://docs.puppetlabs.com/puppet/latest/reference/type.html#schedule)
+      for more info.
+
+          schedule { 'everyday':
+            period => daily,
+            range  => \"2-4\"
+          }
+
+          exec { \"/usr/bin/apt-get update\":
+            schedule => 'everyday'
+          }
+
+      Note that you can declare the schedule resource anywhere in your
+      manifests, as long as it ends up in the final compiled catalog."
+  end
+
+  newmetaparam(:audit) do
+    desc "(This metaparameter is deprecated and will be ignored in a future release.)
+
+      Marks a subset of this resource's unmanaged attributes for auditing. Accepts an
+      attribute name, an array of attribute names, or `all`.
+
+      Auditing a resource attribute has two effects: First, whenever a catalog
+      is applied with puppet apply or puppet agent, Puppet will check whether
+      that attribute of the resource has been modified, comparing its current
+      value to the previous run; any change will be logged alongside any actions
+      performed by Puppet while applying the catalog.
+
+      Secondly, marking a resource attribute for auditing will include that
+      attribute in inspection reports generated by puppet inspect; see the
+      puppet inspect documentation for more details.
+
+      Managed attributes for a resource can also be audited, but note that
+      changes made by Puppet will be logged as additional modifications. (I.e.
+      if a user manually edits a file whose contents are audited and managed,
+      puppet agent's next two runs will both log an audit notice: the first run
+      will log the user's edit and then revert the file to the desired state,
+      and the second run will log the edit made by Puppet.)"
+
+    validate do |list|
+      if Puppet.settings[:strict] != :off
+        # Only warn if `audit` metaparam came from a manifest
+        if file && line
+          puppet_deprecation_warning(_("The `audit` metaparameter is deprecated and will be ignored in a future release."), { :line => line, :file => file })
+        end
+      end
+      list = Array(list).collect {|p| p.to_sym}
+      unless list == [:all]
+        list.each do |param|
+          next if @resource.class.validattr?(param)
+          fail "Cannot audit #{param}: not a valid attribute for #{resource}"
+        end
+      end
+    end
+
+    munge do |args|
+      properties_to_audit(args).each do |param|
+        next unless resource.class.validproperty?(param)
+        resource.newattr(param)
+      end
+    end
+
+    def all_properties
+      resource.class.properties.find_all do |property|
+        resource.provider.nil? or resource.provider.class.supports_parameter?(property)
+      end.collect do |property|
+        property.name
+      end
+    end
+
+    def properties_to_audit(list)
+      if !list.kind_of?(Array) && list.to_sym == :all
+        list = all_properties
+      else
+        list = Array(list).collect { |p| p.to_sym }
+      end
+    end
+  end
+
+  newmetaparam(:loglevel) do
+    desc "Sets the level that information will be logged.
+      The log levels have the biggest impact when logs are sent to
+      syslog (which is currently the default).
+
+      The order of the log levels, in decreasing priority, is:
+
+      * `crit`
+      * `emerg`
+      * `alert`
+      * `err`
+      * `warning`
+      * `notice`
+      * `info` / `verbose`
+      * `debug`
+      "
+    defaultto :notice
+
+    newvalues(*Puppet::Util::Log.levels)
+    newvalues(:verbose)
+
+    munge do |loglevel|
+      val = super(loglevel)
+      if val == :verbose
+        val = :info
+      end
+      val
+    end
+  end
+
+  newmetaparam(:alias) do
+    desc %q{Creates an alias for the resource.  Puppet uses this internally when you
+      provide a symbolic title and an explicit namevar value:
+
+          file { 'sshdconfig':
+            path => $operatingsystem ? {
+              solaris => '/usr/local/etc/ssh/sshd_config',
+              default => '/etc/ssh/sshd_config',
+            },
+            source => '...'
+          }
+
+          service { 'sshd':
+            subscribe => File['sshdconfig'],
+          }
+
+      When you use this feature, the parser sets `sshdconfig` as the title,
+      and the library sets that as an alias for the file so the dependency
+      lookup in `Service['sshd']` works.  You can use this metaparameter yourself,
+      but note that aliases generally only work for creating relationships; anything
+      else that refers to an existing resource (such as amending or overriding
+      resource attributes in an inherited class) must use the resource's exact
+      title. For example, the following code will not work:
+
+          file { '/etc/ssh/sshd_config':
+            owner => root,
+            group => root,
+            alias => 'sshdconfig',
+          }
+
+          File['sshdconfig'] {
+            mode => '0644',
+          }
+
+      There's no way here for the Puppet parser to know that these two stanzas
+      should be affecting the same file.
+
+      }
+
+    munge do |aliases|
+      aliases = [aliases] unless aliases.is_a?(Array)
+
+      raise(ArgumentError, "Cannot add aliases without a catalog") unless @resource.catalog
+
+      aliases.each do |other|
+        if obj = @resource.catalog.resource(@resource.class.name, other)
+          unless obj.object_id == @resource.object_id
+            self.fail("#{@resource.title} can not create alias #{other}: object already exists")
+          end
+          next
+        end
+
+        # Newschool, add it to the catalog.
+        @resource.catalog.alias(@resource, other)
+      end
+    end
+  end
+
+  newmetaparam(:tag) do
+    desc "Add the specified tags to the associated resource.  While all resources
+      are automatically tagged with as much information as possible
+      (e.g., each class and definition containing the resource), it can
+      be useful to add your own tags to a given resource.
+
+      Multiple tags can be specified as an array:
+
+          file {'/etc/hosts':
+            ensure => file,
+            source => 'puppet:///modules/site/hosts',
+            mode   => '0644',
+            tag    => ['bootstrap', 'minimumrun', 'mediumrun'],
+          }
+
+      Tags are useful for things like applying a subset of a host's configuration
+      with [the `tags` setting](/puppet/latest/reference/configuration.html#tags)
+      (e.g. `puppet agent --test --tags bootstrap`)."
+
+    munge do |tags|
+      tags = [tags] unless tags.is_a? Array
+
+      tags.each do |tag|
+        @resource.tag(tag)
+      end
+    end
+  end
+
+  # RelationshipMetaparam is an implementation supporting the meta-parameters `:require`, `:subscribe`,
+  # `:notify`, and `:before`.
+  #
+  #
+  class RelationshipMetaparam < Puppet::Parameter
+    class << self
+      attr_accessor :direction, :events, :callback, :subclasses
+    end
+
+    @subclasses = []
+
+    def self.inherited(sub)
+      @subclasses << sub
+    end
+
+    # @return [Array<Puppet::Resource>] turns attribute value(s) into list of resources
+    def munge(references)
+      references = [references] unless references.is_a?(Array)
+      references.collect do |ref|
+        if ref.is_a?(Puppet::Resource)
+          ref
+        else
+          Puppet::Resource.new(ref)
+        end
+      end
+    end
+
+    # Checks each reference to assert that what it references exists in the catalog.
+    #
+    # @raise [???fail] if the referenced resource can not be found
+    # @return [void]
+    def validate_relationship
+      @value.each do |ref|
+        unless @resource.catalog.resource(ref.to_s)
+          description = self.class.direction == :in ? "dependency" : "dependent"
+          fail ResourceError, "Could not find #{description} #{ref} for #{resource.ref}"
+        end
+      end
+    end
+
+    # Creates edges for all relationships.
+    # The `:in` relationships are specified by the event-receivers, and `:out`
+    # relationships are specified by the event generator.
+    # @todo references to "event-receivers" and "event generator" means in this context - are those just
+    #   the resources at the two ends of the relationship?
+    # This way 'source' and 'target' are consistent terms in both edges
+    # and events, i.e. an event targets edges whose source matches
+    # the event's source. The direction of the relationship determines
+    # which resource is applied first and which resource is considered
+    # to be the event generator.
+    # @return [Array<Puppet::Relationship>]
+    # @raise [???fail] when a reference can not be resolved
+    #
+    def to_edges
+      @value.collect do |reference|
+        reference.catalog = resource.catalog
+
+        # Either of the two retrieval attempts could have returned
+        # nil.
+        unless related_resource = reference.resolve
+          self.fail "Could not retrieve dependency '#{reference}' of #{@resource.ref}"
+        end
+
+        # Are we requiring them, or vice versa?  See the method docs
+        # for further info on this.
+        if self.class.direction == :in
+          source = related_resource
+          target = @resource
+        else
+          source = @resource
+          target = related_resource
+        end
+
+        if method = self.class.callback
+          subargs = {
+            :event => self.class.events,
+            :callback => method
+          }
+          self.debug { "subscribes to #{related_resource.ref}" }
+        else
+          # If there's no callback, there's no point in even adding
+          # a label.
+          subargs = nil
+          self.debug { "subscribes to #{related_resource.ref}" }
+        end
+
+        Puppet::Relationship.new(source, target, subargs)
+      end
+    end
+  end
+
+  # @todo document this, have no clue what this does... it returns "RelationshipMetaparam.subclasses"
+  #
+  def self.relationship_params
+    RelationshipMetaparam.subclasses
+  end
+
+
+  # Note that the order in which the relationships params is defined
+  # matters.  The labeled params (notify and subscribe) must be later,
+  # so that if both params are used, those ones win.  It's a hackish
+  # solution, but it works.
+
+  newmetaparam(:require, :parent => RelationshipMetaparam, :attributes => {:direction => :in, :events => :NONE}) do
+    desc "One or more resources that this resource depends on, expressed as
+      [resource references](https://docs.puppetlabs.com/puppet/latest/reference/lang_data_resource_reference.html).
+      Multiple resources can be specified as an array of references. When this
+      attribute is present:
+
+      * The required resource(s) will be applied **before** this resource.
+
+      This is one of the four relationship metaparameters, along with
+      `before`, `notify`, and `subscribe`. For more context, including the
+      alternate chaining arrow (`->` and `~>`) syntax, see
+      [the language page on relationships](https://docs.puppetlabs.com/puppet/latest/reference/lang_relationships.html)."
+  end
+
+  newmetaparam(:subscribe, :parent => RelationshipMetaparam, :attributes => {:direction => :in, :events => :ALL_EVENTS, :callback => :refresh}) do
+    desc "One or more resources that this resource depends on, expressed as
+      [resource references](https://docs.puppetlabs.com/puppet/latest/reference/lang_data_resource_reference.html).
+      Multiple resources can be specified as an array of references. When this
+      attribute is present:
+
+      * The subscribed resource(s) will be applied _before_ this resource.
+      * If Puppet makes changes to any of the subscribed resources, it will cause
+        this resource to _refresh._ (Refresh behavior varies by resource
+        type: services will restart, mounts will unmount and re-mount, etc. Not
+        all types can refresh.)
+
+      This is one of the four relationship metaparameters, along with
+      `before`, `require`, and `notify`. For more context, including the
+      alternate chaining arrow (`->` and `~>`) syntax, see
+      [the language page on relationships](https://docs.puppetlabs.com/puppet/latest/reference/lang_relationships.html)."
+  end
+
+  newmetaparam(:before, :parent => RelationshipMetaparam, :attributes => {:direction => :out, :events => :NONE}) do
+    desc "One or more resources that depend on this resource, expressed as
+      [resource references](https://docs.puppetlabs.com/puppet/latest/reference/lang_data_resource_reference.html).
+      Multiple resources can be specified as an array of references. When this
+      attribute is present:
+
+      * This resource will be applied _before_ the dependent resource(s).
+
+      This is one of the four relationship metaparameters, along with
+      `require`, `notify`, and `subscribe`. For more context, including the
+      alternate chaining arrow (`->` and `~>`) syntax, see
+      [the language page on relationships](https://docs.puppetlabs.com/puppet/latest/reference/lang_relationships.html)."
+  end
+
+  newmetaparam(:notify, :parent => RelationshipMetaparam, :attributes => {:direction => :out, :events => :ALL_EVENTS, :callback => :refresh}) do
+    desc "One or more resources that depend on this resource, expressed as
+      [resource references](https://docs.puppetlabs.com/puppet/latest/reference/lang_data_resource_reference.html).
+      Multiple resources can be specified as an array of references. When this
+      attribute is present:
+
+      * This resource will be applied _before_ the notified resource(s).
+      * If Puppet makes changes to this resource, it will cause all of the
+        notified resources to _refresh._ (Refresh behavior varies by resource
+        type: services will restart, mounts will unmount and re-mount, etc. Not
+        all types can refresh.)
+
+      This is one of the four relationship metaparameters, along with
+      `before`, `require`, and `subscribe`. For more context, including the
+      alternate chaining arrow (`->` and `~>`) syntax, see
+      [the language page on relationships](https://docs.puppetlabs.com/puppet/latest/reference/lang_relationships.html)."
+  end
+
+  newmetaparam(:stage) do
+    desc %{Which run stage this class should reside in.
+
+      **Note: This metaparameter can only be used on classes,** and only when
+      declaring them with the resource-like syntax. It cannot be used on normal
+      resources or on classes declared with `include`.
+
+      By default, all classes are declared in the `main` stage. To assign a class
+      to a different stage, you must:
+
+      * Declare the new stage as a [`stage` resource](https://docs.puppetlabs.com/puppet/latest/reference/type.html#stage).
+      * Declare an order relationship between the new stage and the `main` stage.
+      * Use the resource-like syntax to declare the class, and set the `stage`
+        metaparameter to the name of the desired stage.
+
+      For example:
+
+          stage { 'pre':
+            before => Stage['main'],
+          }
+
+          class { 'apt-updates':
+            stage => 'pre',
+          }
+    }
+  end
+
+  newmetaparam(:export, :parent => RelationshipMetaparam, :attributes => {:direction => :out, :events => :NONE}) do
+          desc <<EOS
+Export a capability resource.
+
+The value of this parameter must be a reference to a capability resource,
+or an array of such references. Each capability resource referenced here
+will be instantiated in the node catalog and exported to consumers of this
+resource. The title of the capability resource will be the title given in
+the reference, and all other attributes of the resource will be filled
+according to the corresponding produces statement.
+
+It is an error if this metaparameter references resources whose type is not
+a capability type, or of there is no produces clause for the type of the
+current resource and the capability resource mentioned in this parameter.
+
+For example:
+
+define web(..) { .. }
+Web produces Http { .. }
+web { server:
+  export => Http[main_server]
+}
+EOS
+  end
+
+  newmetaparam(:consume, :parent => RelationshipMetaparam, :attributes => {:direction => :in, :events => :NONE}) do
+          desc <<EOS
+Consume a capability resource.
+
+The value of this parameter must be a reference to a capability resource,
+or an array of such references. Each capability resource referenced here
+must have been exported by another resource in the same environment.
+
+The referenced capability resource(s) will be looked up, added to the
+current node catalog, and processed following the underlying consumes
+clause.
+
+It is an error if this metaparameter references resources whose type is not
+a capability type, or of there is no consumes clause for the type of the
+current resource and the capability resource mentioned in this parameter.
+
+For example:
+
+define web(..) { .. }
+Web consumes Sql { .. }
+web { server:
+  consume => Sql[my_db]
+}
+EOS
+end
+
+  ###############################
+  # All of the provider plumbing for the resource types.
+  require 'puppet/provider'
+  require 'puppet/util/provider_features'
+
+  # Add the feature handling module.
+  extend Puppet::Util::ProviderFeatures
+
+  # The provider that has been selected for the instance of the resource type.
+  # @return [Puppet::Provider,nil] the selected provider or nil, if none has been selected
+  #
+  attr_reader :provider
+
+  # the Type class attribute accessors
+  class << self
+    # The loader of providers to use when loading providers from disk.
+    # Although it looks like this attribute provides a way to operate with different loaders of
+    # providers that is not the case; the attribute is written when a new type is created,
+    # and should not be changed thereafter.
+    # @api private
+    #
+    attr_accessor :providerloader
+
+    # @todo Don't know if this is a name, or a reference to a Provider instance (now marked up as an instance
+    #   of Provider.
+    # @return [Puppet::Provider, nil] The default provider for this type, or nil if non is defines
+    #
+    attr_writer :defaultprovider
+  end
+
+  # The default provider, or the most suitable provider if no default provider was set.
+  # @note a warning will be issued if no default provider has been configured and a search for the most
+  #   suitable provider returns more than one equally suitable provider.
+  # @return [Puppet::Provider, nil] the default or most suitable provider, or nil if no provider was found
+  #
+  def self.defaultprovider
+    return @defaultprovider if @defaultprovider
+
+    suitable = suitableprovider
+
+    # Find which providers are a default for this system.
+    defaults = suitable.find_all { |provider| provider.default? }
+
+    # If we don't have any default we use suitable providers
+    defaults = suitable if defaults.empty?
+    max = defaults.collect { |provider| provider.specificity }.max
+    defaults = defaults.find_all { |provider| provider.specificity == max }
+
+    if defaults.length > 1
+      Puppet.warning(
+        "Found multiple default providers for #{self.name}: #{defaults.collect { |i| i.name.to_s }.join(", ")}; using #{defaults[0].name}"
+      )
+    end
+
+    @defaultprovider = defaults.shift unless defaults.empty?
+  end
+
+  # @return [Hash{??? => Puppet::Provider}] Returns a hash of WHAT EXACTLY for the given type
+  # @todo what goes into this hash?
+  def self.provider_hash_by_type(type)
+    @provider_hashes ||= {}
+    @provider_hashes[type] ||= {}
+  end
+
+  # @return [Hash{ ??? => Puppet::Provider}] Returns a hash of WHAT EXACTLY for this type.
+  # @see provider_hash_by_type method to get the same for some other type
+  def self.provider_hash
+    Puppet::Type.provider_hash_by_type(self.name)
+  end
+
+  # Returns the provider having the given name.
+  # This will load a provider if it is not already loaded. The returned provider is the first found provider
+  # having the given name, where "first found" semantics is defined by the {providerloader} in use.
+  #
+  # @param name [String] the name of the provider to get
+  # @return [Puppet::Provider, nil] the found provider, or nil if no provider of the given name was found
+  #
+  def self.provider(name)
+    name = name.intern
+
+    # If we don't have it yet, try loading it.
+    @providerloader.load(name) unless provider_hash.has_key?(name)
+    provider_hash[name]
+  end
+
+  # Returns a list of loaded providers by name.
+  # This method will not load/search for available providers.
+  # @return [Array<String>] list of loaded provider names
+  #
+  def self.providers
+    provider_hash.keys
+  end
+
+  # Returns true if the given name is a reference to a provider and if this is a suitable provider for
+  # this type.
+  # @todo How does the provider know if it is suitable for the type? Is it just suitable for the platform/
+  #   environment where this method is executing?
+  # @param name [String] the name of the provider for which validity is checked
+  # @return [Boolean] true if the given name references a provider that is suitable
+  #
+  def self.validprovider?(name)
+    name = name.intern
+
+    (provider_hash.has_key?(name) && provider_hash[name].suitable?)
+  end
+
+  # Creates a new provider of a type.
+  # This method must be called directly on the type that it's implementing.
+  # @todo Fix Confusing Explanations!
+  #   Is this a new provider of a Type (metatype), or a provider of an instance of Type (a resource), or
+  #   a Provider (the implementation of a Type's behavior). CONFUSED. It calls magically named methods like
+  #   "providify" ...
+  # @param name [String, Symbol] the name of the WHAT? provider? type?
+  # @param options [Hash{Symbol => Object}] a hash of options, used by this method, and passed on to {#genclass}, (see
+  #   it for additional options to pass).
+  # @option options [Puppet::Provider] :parent the parent provider (what is this?)
+  # @option options [Puppet::Type] :resource_type the resource type, defaults to this type if unspecified
+  # @return [Puppet::Provider] a provider ???
+  # @raise [Puppet::DevError] when the parent provider could not be found.
+  #
+  def self.provide(name, options = {}, &block)
+    name = name.intern
+
+    if unprovide(name)
+      Puppet.debug "Reloading #{name} #{self.name} provider"
+    end
+
+    parent = if pname = options[:parent]
+      options.delete(:parent)
+      if pname.is_a? Class
+        pname
+      else
+        if provider = self.provider(pname)
+          provider
+        else
+          raise Puppet::DevError,
+            "Could not find parent provider #{pname} of #{name}"
+        end
+      end
+    else
+      Puppet::Provider
+    end
+
+    options[:resource_type] ||= self
+
+    self.providify
+
+    provider = genclass(
+      name,
+      :parent     => parent,
+      :hash       => provider_hash,
+      :prefix     => "Provider",
+      :block      => block,
+      :include    => feature_module,
+      :extend     => feature_module,
+      :attributes => options
+    )
+
+    provider
+  end
+
+  # Ensures there is a `:provider` parameter defined.
+  # Should only be called if there are providers.
+  # @return [void]
+  def self.providify
+    return if @paramhash.has_key? :provider
+
+    param = newparam(:provider) do
+      # We're using a hacky way to get the name of our type, since there doesn't
+      # seem to be a correct way to introspect this at the time this code is run.
+      # We expect that the class in which this code is executed will be something
+      # like Puppet::Type::Ssh_authorized_key::ParameterProvider.
+      desc <<-EOT
+        The specific backend to use for this `#{self.to_s.split('::')[2].downcase}`
+        resource. You will seldom need to specify this --- Puppet will usually
+        discover the appropriate provider for your platform.
+      EOT
+
+      # This is so we can refer back to the type to get a list of
+      # providers for documentation.
+      class << self
+        # The reference to a parent type for the parameter `:provider` used to get a list of
+        # providers for documentation purposes.
+        #
+        attr_accessor :parenttype
+      end
+
+      # Provides the ability to add documentation to a provider.
+      #
+      def self.doc
+        # Since we're mixing @doc with text from other sources, we must normalize
+        # its indentation with scrub. But we don't need to manually scrub the
+        # provider's doc string, since markdown_definitionlist sanitizes its inputs.
+        scrub(@doc) + "Available providers are:\n\n" + parenttype.providers.sort { |a,b|
+          a.to_s <=> b.to_s
+        }.collect { |i|
+          markdown_definitionlist( i, scrub(parenttype().provider(i).doc) )
+        }.join
+      end
+
+      # For each resource, the provider param defaults to
+      # the type's default provider
+      defaultto {
+        prov = @resource.class.defaultprovider
+        prov.name if prov
+      }
+
+      validate do |provider_class|
+        provider_class = provider_class[0] if provider_class.is_a? Array
+        provider_class = provider_class.class.name if provider_class.is_a?(Puppet::Provider)
+
+        unless @resource.class.provider(provider_class)
+          raise ArgumentError, "Invalid #{@resource.class.name} provider '#{provider_class}'"
+        end
+      end
+
+      munge do |provider|
+        provider = provider[0] if provider.is_a? Array
+        provider = provider.intern if provider.is_a? String
+        @resource.provider = provider
+
+        if provider.is_a?(Puppet::Provider)
+          provider.class.name
+        else
+          provider
+        end
+      end
+    end
+    param.parenttype = self
+  end
+
+  # @todo this needs a better explanation
+  # Removes the implementation class of a given provider.
+  # @return [Object] returns what {Puppet::Util::ClassGen#rmclass} returns
+  def self.unprovide(name)
+    if @defaultprovider and @defaultprovider.name == name
+      @defaultprovider = nil
+    end
+
+    rmclass(name, :hash => provider_hash, :prefix => "Provider")
+  end
+
+  # Returns a list of suitable providers for the given type.
+  # A call to this method will load all providers if not already loaded and ask each if it is
+  # suitable - those that are are included in the result.
+  # @note This method also does some special processing which rejects a provider named `:fake` (for testing purposes).
+  # @return [Array<Puppet::Provider>] Returns an array of all suitable providers.
+  #
+  def self.suitableprovider
+    providerloader.loadall if provider_hash.empty?
+    provider_hash.find_all { |name, provider|
+      provider.suitable?
+    }.collect { |name, provider|
+      provider
+    }.reject { |p| p.name == :fake } # For testing
+  end
+
+  # @return [Boolean] Returns true if this is something else than a `:provider`, or if it
+  #   is a provider and it is suitable, or if there is a default provider. Otherwise, false is returned.
+  #
+  def suitable?
+    # If we don't use providers, then we consider it suitable.
+    return true unless self.class.paramclass(:provider)
+
+    # We have a provider and it is suitable.
+    return true if provider && provider.class.suitable?
+
+    # We're using the default provider and there is one.
+    if !provider and self.class.defaultprovider
+      self.provider = self.class.defaultprovider.name
+      return true
+    end
+
+    # We specified an unsuitable provider, or there isn't any suitable
+    # provider.
+    false
+  end
+
+  # Sets the provider to the given provider/name.
+  # @overload provider=(name)
+  #   Sets the provider to the result of resolving the name to an instance of Provider.
+  #   @param name [String] the name of the provider
+  # @overload provider=(provider)
+  #   Sets the provider to the given instances of Provider.
+  #   @param provider [Puppet::Provider] the provider to set
+  # @return [Puppet::Provider] the provider set
+  # @raise [ArgumentError] if the provider could not be found/resolved.
+  #
+  def provider=(name)
+    if name.is_a?(Puppet::Provider)
+      @provider = name
+      @provider.resource = self
+    elsif klass = self.class.provider(name)
+      @provider = klass.new(self)
+    else
+      raise ArgumentError, "Could not find #{name} provider of #{self.class.name}"
+    end
+  end
+
+  ###############################
+  # All of the relationship code.
+
+  # Adds a block producing a single name (or list of names) of the given
+  # resource type name to autorelate.
+  #
+  # The four relationship types require, before, notify, and subscribe are all
+  # supported.
+  #
+  # Be *careful* with notify and subscribe as they may have unintended
+  # consequences.
+  #
+  # Resources in the catalog that have the named type and a title that is
+  # included in the result will be linked to the calling resource as a
+  # requirement.
+  #
+  # @example Autorequire the files File['foo', 'bar']
+  #   autorequire( 'file', {|| ['foo', 'bar'] })
+  #
+  # @example Autobefore the files File['foo', 'bar']
+  #   autobefore( 'file', {|| ['foo', 'bar'] })
+  #
+  # @example Autosubscribe the files File['foo', 'bar']
+  #   autosubscribe( 'file', {|| ['foo', 'bar'] })
+  #
+  # @example Autonotify the files File['foo', 'bar']
+  #   autonotify( 'file', {|| ['foo', 'bar'] })
+  #
+  # @param name [String] the name of a type of which one or several resources should be autorelated e.g. "file"
+  # @yield [ ] a block returning list of names of given type to auto require
+  # @yieldreturn [String, Array<String>] one or several resource names for the named type
+  # @return [void]
+  # @dsl type
+  # @api public
+  #
+  def self.autorequire(name, &block)
+    @autorequires ||= {}
+    @autorequires[name] = block
+  end
+
+  def self.autobefore(name, &block)
+    @autobefores ||= {}
+    @autobefores[name] = block
+  end
+
+  def self.autosubscribe(name, &block)
+    @autosubscribes ||= {}
+    @autosubscribes[name] = block
+  end
+
+  def self.autonotify(name, &block)
+    @autonotifies ||= {}
+    @autonotifies[name] = block
+  end
+
+  # Provides iteration over added auto-requirements (see {autorequire}).
+  # @yieldparam type [String] the name of the type to autorequire an instance of
+  # @yieldparam block [Proc] a block producing one or several dependencies to auto require (see {autorequire}).
+  # @yieldreturn [void]
+  # @return [void]
+  def self.eachautorequire
+    @autorequires ||= {}
+    @autorequires.each { |type, block|
+      yield(type, block)
+    }
+  end
+
+  # Provides iteration over added auto-requirements (see {autobefore}).
+  # @yieldparam type [String] the name of the type to autorequire an instance of
+  # @yieldparam block [Proc] a block producing one or several dependencies to auto require (see {autobefore}).
+  # @yieldreturn [void]
+  # @return [void]
+  def self.eachautobefore
+    @autobefores ||= {}
+    @autobefores.each { |type,block|
+      yield(type, block)
+    }
+  end
+
+  # Provides iteration over added auto-requirements (see {autosubscribe}).
+  # @yieldparam type [String] the name of the type to autorequire an instance of
+  # @yieldparam block [Proc] a block producing one or several dependencies to auto require (see {autosubscribe}).
+  # @yieldreturn [void]
+  # @return [void]
+  def self.eachautosubscribe
+    @autosubscribes ||= {}
+    @autosubscribes.each { |type,block|
+      yield(type, block)
+    }
+  end
+
+  # Provides iteration over added auto-requirements (see {autonotify}).
+  # @yieldparam type [String] the name of the type to autorequire an instance of
+  # @yieldparam block [Proc] a block producing one or several dependencies to auto require (see {autonotify}).
+  # @yieldreturn [void]
+  # @return [void]
+  def self.eachautonotify
+    @autonotifies ||= {}
+    @autonotifies.each { |type,block|
+      yield(type, block)
+    }
+  end
+
+  # Adds dependencies to the catalog from added autorelations.
+  # See {autorequire} for how to add an auto-requirement.
+  # @todo needs details - see the param rel_catalog, and type of this param
+  # @param rel_catalog [Puppet::Resource::Catalog, nil] the catalog to
+  #   add dependencies to. Defaults to the current catalog (set when the
+  #   type instance was added to a catalog)
+  # @raise [Puppet::DevError] if there is no catalog
+  #
+  def autorelation(rel_type, rel_catalog = nil)
+    rel_catalog ||= catalog
+    raise(Puppet::DevError, "You cannot add relationships without a catalog") unless rel_catalog
+
+    reqs = []
+
+    auto_rel = "eachauto#{rel_type}".to_sym
+
+    self.class.send(auto_rel) { |type, block|
+      # Ignore any types we can't find, although that would be a bit odd.
+      next unless Puppet::Type.type(type)
+
+      # Retrieve the list of names from the block.
+      next unless list = self.instance_eval(&block)
+      list = [list] unless list.is_a?(Array)
+
+      # Collect the current prereqs
+      list.each { |dep|
+        next if dep.nil?
+
+        # Support them passing objects directly, to save some effort.
+        unless dep.is_a?(Puppet::Type)
+          # Skip autorelation that we aren't managing
+          unless dep = rel_catalog.resource(type, dep)
+            next
+          end
+        end
+
+        if [:require, :subscribe].include?(rel_type)
+          reqs << Puppet::Relationship.new(dep, self)
+        else
+          reqs << Puppet::Relationship.new(self, dep)
+        end
+      }
+    }
+
+    reqs
+  end
+
+  def autorequire(rel_catalog = nil)
+    autorelation(:require, rel_catalog)
+  end
+
+  def autobefore(rel_catalog = nil)
+    autorelation(:before, rel_catalog)
+  end
+
+  def autosubscribe(rel_catalog = nil)
+    autorelation(:subscribe, rel_catalog)
+  end
+
+  def autonotify(rel_catalog = nil)
+    autorelation(:notify, rel_catalog)
+  end
+
+  # Builds the dependencies associated with this resource.
+  #
+  # @return [Array<Puppet::Relationship>] list of relationships to other resources
+  def builddepends
+    # Handle the requires
+    self.class.relationship_params.collect do |klass|
+      if param = @parameters[klass.name]
+        param.to_edges
+      end
+    end.flatten.reject { |r| r.nil? }
+  end
+
+  # Sets the initial list of tags to associate to this resource.
+  #
+  # @return [void] ???
+  def tags=(list)
+    tag(self.class.name)
+    tag(*list)
+  end
+
+  # @comment - these two comments were floating around here, and turned up as documentation
+  #  for the attribute "title", much to my surprise and amusement. Clearly these comments
+  #  are orphaned ... I think they can just be removed as what they say should be covered
+  #  by the now added yardoc. <irony>(Yo! to quote some of the other actual awesome specific comments applicable
+  #  to objects called from elsewhere, or not. ;-)</irony>
+  #
+  # @comment Types (which map to resources in the languages) are entirely composed of
+  #   attribute value pairs.  Generally, Puppet calls any of these things an
+  #   'attribute', but these attributes always take one of three specific
+  #   forms:  parameters, metaparams, or properties.
+
+  # @comment In naming methods, I have tried to consistently name the method so
+  #   that it is clear whether it operates on all attributes (thus has 'attr' in
+  #   the method name, or whether it operates on a specific type of attributes.
+
+  # The title attribute of WHAT ???
+  # @todo Figure out what this is the title attribute of (it appears on line 1926 currently).
+  # @return [String] the title
+  attr_writer :title
+
+  # The noop attribute of WHAT ??? does WHAT???
+  # @todo Figure out what this is the noop attribute of (it appears on line 1931 currently).
+  # @return [???] the noop WHAT ??? (mode? if so of what, or noop for an instance of the type, or for all
+  #   instances of a type, or for what???
+  #
+  attr_writer :noop
+
+  include Enumerable
+
+  # class methods dealing with Type management
+
+  public
+
+  # The Type class attribute accessors
+  class << self
+    # @return [String] the name of the resource type; e.g., "File"
+    #
+    attr_reader :name
+
+    # @return [Boolean] true if the type should send itself a refresh event on change.
+    #
+    attr_accessor :self_refresh
+    include Enumerable, Puppet::Util::ClassGen
+    include Puppet::MetaType::Manager
+
+    include Puppet::Util
+    include Puppet::Util::Logging
+  end
+
+  # Initializes all of the variables that must be initialized for each subclass.
+  # @todo Does the explanation make sense?
+  # @return [void]
+  def self.initvars
+    # all of the instances of this class
+    @objects = Hash.new
+    @aliases = Hash.new
+
+    @defaults = {}
+
+    @parameters ||= []
+
+    @validproperties = {}
+    @properties = []
+    @parameters = []
+    @paramhash = {}
+
+    @paramdoc = Hash.new { |hash,key|
+      key = key.intern if key.is_a?(String)
+      if hash.include?(key)
+        hash[key]
+      else
+        "Param Documentation for #{key} not found"
+      end
+    }
+
+    @doc ||= ""
+
+  end
+
+  # Returns the name of this type (if specified) or the parent type #to_s.
+  # The returned name is on the form "Puppet::Type::<name>", where the first letter of name is
+  # capitalized.
+  # @return [String] the fully qualified name Puppet::Type::<name> where the first letter of name is capitalized
+  #
+  def self.to_s
+    if defined?(@name)
+      "Puppet::Type::#{@name.to_s.capitalize}"
+    else
+      super
+    end
+  end
+
+  # Creates a `validate` method that is used to validate a resource before it is operated on.
+  # The validation should raise exceptions if the validation finds errors. (It is not recommended to
+  # issue warnings as this typically just ends up in a logfile - you should fail if a validation fails).
+  # The easiest way to raise an appropriate exception is to call the method {Puppet::Util::Errors.fail} with
+  # the message as an argument.
+  #
+  # @yield [ ] a required block called with self set to the instance of a Type class representing a resource.
+  # @return [void]
+  # @dsl type
+  # @api public
+  #
+  def self.validate(&block)
+    define_method(:validate, &block)
+  end
+
+  # @return [String] The file from which this type originates from
+  attr_accessor :file
+
+  # @return [Integer] The line in {#file} from which this type originates from
+  attr_accessor :line
+
+  # @todo what does this mean "this resource" (sounds like this if for an instance of the type, not the meta Type),
+  #   but not sure if this is about the catalog where the meta Type is included)
+  # @return [??? TODO] The catalog that this resource is stored in.
+  attr_accessor :catalog
+
+  # @return [Boolean] Flag indicating if this type is exported
+  attr_accessor :exported
+
+  # @return [Boolean] Flag indicating if the type is virtual (it should not be).
+  attr_accessor :virtual
+
+  # Creates a log entry with the given message at the log level specified by the parameter `loglevel`
+  # @return [void]
+  #
+  def log(msg)
+
+    Puppet::Util::Log.create(
+
+      :level => @parameters[:loglevel].value,
+      :message => msg,
+
+      :source => self
+    )
+  end
+
+
+  # instance methods related to instance intrinsics
+  # e.g., initialize and name
+
+  public
+
+  # @return [Hash] hash of parameters originally defined
+  # @api private
+  attr_reader :original_parameters
+
+  # Creates an instance of Type from a hash or a {Puppet::Resource}.
+  # @todo Unclear if this is a new Type or a new instance of a given type (the initialization ends
+  #   with calling validate - which seems like validation of an instance of a given type, not a new
+  #   meta type.
+  #
+  # @todo Explain what the Hash and Resource are. There seems to be two different types of
+  #   resources; one that causes the title to be set to resource.title, and one that
+  #   causes the title to be resource.ref ("for components") - what is a component?
+  #
+  # @overload initialize(hash)
+  #   @param [Hash] hash
+  #   @raise [Puppet::ResourceError] when the type validation raises
+  #     Puppet::Error or ArgumentError
+  # @overload initialize(resource)
+  #   @param resource [Puppet:Resource]
+  #   @raise [Puppet::ResourceError] when the type validation raises
+  #     Puppet::Error or ArgumentError
+  #
+  def initialize(resource)
+    resource = self.class.hash2resource(resource) unless resource.is_a?(Puppet::Resource)
+
+    # The list of parameter/property instances.
+    @parameters = {}
+
+    # Set the title first, so any failures print correctly.
+    if resource.type.to_s.downcase.to_sym == self.class.name
+      self.title = resource.title
+    else
+      # This should only ever happen for components
+      self.title = resource.ref
+    end
+
+    [:file, :line, :catalog, :exported, :virtual].each do |getter|
+      setter = getter.to_s + "="
+      if val = resource.send(getter)
+        self.send(setter, val)
+      end
+    end
+
+    @tags = resource.tags
+
+    @original_parameters = resource.to_hash
+
+    set_name(@original_parameters)
+
+    set_default(:provider)
+
+    set_parameters(@original_parameters)
+
+    begin
+      self.validate if self.respond_to?(:validate)
+    rescue Puppet::Error, ArgumentError => detail
+      error = Puppet::ResourceError.new("Validation of #{ref} failed: #{detail}")
+      adderrorcontext(error, detail)
+      raise error
+    end
+
+    set_sensitive_parameters(resource.sensitive_parameters)
+  end
+
+  protected
+
+  # Mark parameters associated with this type as sensitive, based on the associated resource.
+  #
+  # Currently, only instances of `Puppet::Property` can be easily marked for sensitive data handling
+  # and information redaction is limited to redacting events generated while synchronizing
+  # properties. While support for redaction will be broadened in the future we can't automatically
+  # deduce how to redact arbitrary parameters, so if a parameter is marked for redaction the best
+  # we can do is warn that we can't handle treating that parameter as sensitive and move on.
+  #
+  # In some unusual cases a given parameter will be marked as sensitive but that sensitive context
+  # needs to be transferred to another parameter. In this case resource types may need to override
+  # this method in order to copy the sensitive context from one parameter to another (and in the
+  # process force the early generation of a parameter that might otherwise be lazily generated.)
+  # See `Puppet::Type.type(:file)#set_sensitive_parameters` for an example of this.
+  #
+  # @note This method visibility is protected since it should only be called by #initialize, but is
+  #   marked as public as subclasses may need to override this method.
+  #
+  # @api public
+  #
+  # @param sensitive_parameters [Array<Symbol>] A list of parameters to mark as sensitive.
+  #
+  # @return [void]
+  def set_sensitive_parameters(sensitive_parameters)
+    sensitive_parameters.each do |name|
+      p = parameter(name)
+      if p.is_a?(Puppet::Property)
+        p.sensitive = true
+      elsif p.is_a?(Puppet::Parameter)
+        warning("Unable to mark '#{name}' as sensitive: #{name} is a parameter and not a property, and cannot be automatically redacted.")
+      elsif self.class.attrclass(name)
+        warning("Unable to mark '#{name}' as sensitive: the property itself was not assigned a value.")
+      else
+        err("Unable to mark '#{name}' as sensitive: the property itself is not defined on #{type}.")
+      end
+    end
+  end
+
+  private
+
+  # Sets the name of the resource from a hash containing a mapping of `name_var` to value.
+  # Sets the value of the property/parameter appointed by the `name_var` (if it is defined). The value set is
+  # given by the corresponding entry in the given hash - e.g. if name_var appoints the name `:path` the value
+  # of `:path` is set to the value at the key `:path` in the given hash. As a side effect this key/value is then
+  # removed from the given hash.
+  #
+  # @note This method mutates the given hash by removing the entry with a key equal to the value
+  #   returned from name_var!
+  # @param hash [Hash] a hash of what
+  # @return [void]
+  def set_name(hash)
+    self[name_var] = hash.delete(name_var) if name_var
+  end
+
+  # Sets parameters from the given hash.
+  # Values are set in _attribute order_ i.e. higher priority attributes before others, otherwise in
+  # the order they were specified (as opposed to just setting them in the order they happen to appear in
+  # when iterating over the given hash).
+  #
+  # Attributes that are not included in the given hash are set to their default value.
+  #
+  # @todo Is this description accurate? Is "ensure" an example of such a higher priority attribute?
+  # @return [void]
+  # @raise [Puppet::DevError] when impossible to set the value due to some problem
+  # @raise [ArgumentError, TypeError, Puppet::Error] when faulty arguments have been passed
+  #
+  def set_parameters(hash)
+    # Use the order provided by allattrs, but add in any
+    # extra attributes from the resource so we get failures
+    # on invalid attributes.
+    no_values = []
+    (self.class.allattrs + hash.keys).uniq.each do |attr|
+      begin
+        # Set any defaults immediately.  This is mostly done so
+        # that the default provider is available for any other
+        # property validation.
+        if hash.has_key?(attr)
+          self[attr] = hash[attr]
+        else
+          no_values << attr
+        end
+      rescue ArgumentError, Puppet::Error, TypeError
+        raise
+      rescue => detail
+        error = Puppet::DevError.new( "Could not set #{attr} on #{self.class.name}: #{detail}")
+        error.set_backtrace(detail.backtrace)
+        raise error
+      end
+    end
+    no_values.each do |attr|
+      set_default(attr)
+    end
+  end
+
+  public
+
+  # Finishes any outstanding processing.
+  # This method should be called as a final step in setup,
+  # to allow the parameters that have associated auto-require needs to be processed.
+  #
+  # @todo what is the expected sequence here - who is responsible for calling this? When?
+  #   Is the returned type correct?
+  # @return [Array<Puppet::Parameter>] the validated list/set of attributes
+  #
+  def finish
+    # Call post_compile hook on every parameter that implements it. This includes all subclasses
+    # of parameter including, but not limited to, regular parameters, metaparameters, relationship
+    # parameters, and properties.
+    eachparameter do |parameter|
+      parameter.post_compile if parameter.respond_to? :post_compile
+    end
+
+    # Make sure all of our relationships are valid.  Again, must be done
+    # when the entire catalog is instantiated.
+    self.class.relationship_params.collect do |klass|
+      if param = @parameters[klass.name]
+        param.validate_relationship
+      end
+    end.flatten.reject { |r| r.nil? }
+  end
+
+  # @comment For now, leave the 'name' method functioning like it used to.  Once 'title'
+  #   works everywhere, I'll switch it.
+  # Returns the resource's name
+  # @todo There is a comment in source that this is not quite the same as ':title' and that a switch should
+  #   be made...
+  # @return [String] the name of a resource
+  def name
+    self[:name]
+  end
+
+  # Returns the parent of this in the catalog.  In case of an erroneous catalog
+  # where multiple parents have been produced, the first found (non
+  # deterministic) parent is returned.
+  # @return [Puppet::Type, nil] the
+  #   containing resource or nil if there is no catalog or no containing
+  #   resource.
+  def parent
+    return nil unless catalog
+
+    @parent ||=
+      if parents = catalog.adjacent(self, :direction => :in)
+        parents.shift
+      else
+        nil
+      end
+  end
+
+  # Returns a reference to this as a string in "Type[name]" format.
+  # @return [String] a reference to this object on the form 'Type[name]'
+  #
+  def ref
+    # memoizing this is worthwhile ~ 3 percent of calls are the "first time
+    # around" in an average run of Puppet. --daniel 2012-07-17
+    @ref ||= "#{self.class.name.to_s.capitalize}[#{self.title}]"
+  end
+
+  # (see self_refresh)
+  # @todo check that meaningful yardoc is produced - this method delegates to "self.class.self_refresh"
+  # @return [Boolean] - ??? returns true when ... what?
+  #
+  def self_refresh?
+    self.class.self_refresh
+  end
+
+  # Marks the object as "being purged".
+  # This method is used by transactions to forbid deletion when there are dependencies.
+  # @todo what does this mean; "mark that we are purging" (purging what from where). How to use/when?
+  #   Is this internal API in transactions?
+  # @see purging?
+  def purging
+    @purging = true
+  end
+
+  # Returns whether this resource is being purged or not.
+  # This method is used by transactions to forbid deletion when there are dependencies.
+  # @return [Boolean] the current "purging" state
+  #
+  def purging?
+    if defined?(@purging)
+      @purging
+    else
+      false
+    end
+  end
+
+  # Returns the title of this object, or its name if title was not explicitly set.
+  # If the title is not already set, it will be computed by looking up the {#name_var} and using
+  # that value as the title.
+  # @todo it is somewhat confusing that if the name_var is a valid parameter, it is assumed to
+  #  be the name_var called :name, but if it is a property, it uses the name_var.
+  #  It is further confusing as Type in some respects supports multiple namevars.
+  #
+  # @return [String] Returns the title of this object, or its name if title was not explicitly set.
+  # @raise [??? devfail] if title is not set, and name_var can not be found.
+  def title
+    unless @title
+      if self.class.validparameter?(name_var)
+        @title = self[:name]
+      elsif self.class.validproperty?(name_var)
+        @title = self.should(name_var)
+      else
+        self.devfail "Could not find namevar #{name_var} for #{self.class.name}"
+      end
+    end
+
+    @title
+  end
+
+  # Produces a reference to this in reference format.
+  # @see #ref
+  #
+  def to_s
+    self.ref
+  end
+
+  # Convert this resource type instance to a Puppet::Resource.
+  # @return [Puppet::Resource] Returns a serializable representation of this resource
+  #
+  def to_resource
+    resource = self.retrieve_resource
+    resource.tag(*self.tags)
+
+    @parameters.each do |name, param|
+      # Avoid adding each instance name twice
+      next if param.class.isnamevar? and param.value == self.title
+
+      # We've already got property values
+      next if param.is_a?(Puppet::Property)
+      resource[name] = param.value
+    end
+
+    resource
+  end
+
+  # @return [Boolean] Returns whether the resource is virtual or not
+  def virtual?;  !!@virtual;  end
+  # @return [Boolean] Returns whether the resource is exported or not
+  def exported?; !!@exported; end
+
+  # @return [Boolean] Returns whether the resource is applicable to `:device`
+  # Returns true if a resource of this type can be evaluated on a 'network device' kind
+  # of hosts.
+  # @api private
+  def appliable_to_device?
+    self.class.can_apply_to(:device)
+  end
+
+  # @return [Boolean] Returns whether the resource is applicable to `:host`
+  # Returns true if a resource of this type can be evaluated on a regular generalized computer (ie not an appliance like a network device)
+  # @api private
+  def appliable_to_host?
+    self.class.can_apply_to(:host)
+  end
+end
+end