decidim-participatory_processes 0.30.3 → 0.31.0.rc2

This diff represents the content of publicly available package versions that have been released to one of the supported registries. The information contained in this diff is provided for informational purposes only and reflects changes between package versions as they appear in their respective public registries.
Files changed (129) hide show
  1. checksums.yaml +4 -4
  2. data/app/cells/decidim/participatory_process_groups/content_blocks/main_data/content.erb +1 -1
  3. data/app/cells/decidim/participatory_process_groups/content_blocks/main_data_cell.rb +1 -15
  4. data/app/cells/decidim/participatory_processes/content_blocks/democratic_quality_stats/show.erb +74 -0
  5. data/app/cells/decidim/participatory_processes/content_blocks/democratic_quality_stats_cell.rb +29 -0
  6. data/app/cells/decidim/participatory_processes/content_blocks/democratic_quality_stats_settings_form/citizen_influence.erb +32 -0
  7. data/app/cells/decidim/participatory_processes/content_blocks/democratic_quality_stats_settings_form/inclusiveness.erb +69 -0
  8. data/app/cells/decidim/participatory_processes/content_blocks/democratic_quality_stats_settings_form/informativeness.erb +29 -0
  9. data/app/cells/decidim/participatory_processes/content_blocks/democratic_quality_stats_settings_form/show.erb +10 -0
  10. data/app/cells/decidim/participatory_processes/content_blocks/democratic_quality_stats_settings_form_cell.rb +81 -0
  11. data/app/cells/decidim/participatory_processes/content_blocks/highlighted_processes_settings_form/show.erb +3 -1
  12. data/app/cells/decidim/participatory_processes/content_blocks/main_data_cell.rb +10 -2
  13. data/app/cells/decidim/participatory_processes/indicator/show.erb +11 -0
  14. data/app/cells/decidim/participatory_processes/indicator_cell.rb +25 -0
  15. data/app/cells/decidim/participatory_processes/process_dropdown_metadata/metadata.erb +0 -7
  16. data/app/cells/decidim/participatory_processes/process_filters_cell.rb +2 -0
  17. data/app/cells/decidim/participatory_processes/process_step/show.erb +1 -1
  18. data/app/commands/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/create_participatory_process.rb +1 -1
  19. data/app/commands/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/create_participatory_process_group.rb +1 -1
  20. data/app/commands/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/{copy_participatory_process.rb → duplicate_participatory_process.rb} +25 -26
  21. data/app/commands/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/import_participatory_process.rb +1 -1
  22. data/app/commands/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/update_participatory_process.rb +16 -4
  23. data/app/commands/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/update_participatory_process_group.rb +1 -1
  24. data/app/commands/decidim/participatory_processes/create_democratic_quality_indicators_page.rb +40 -0
  25. data/app/controllers/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/{participatory_process_copies_controller.rb → participatory_process_duplicates_controller.rb} +7 -7
  26. data/app/controllers/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/participatory_process_group_landing_page_controller.rb +4 -0
  27. data/app/controllers/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/participatory_process_groups_controller.rb +3 -3
  28. data/app/controllers/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/participatory_process_imports_controller.rb +1 -1
  29. data/app/controllers/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/participatory_process_landing_page_controller.rb +4 -0
  30. data/app/controllers/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/participatory_process_steps_controller.rb +2 -2
  31. data/app/controllers/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/participatory_processes_controller.rb +3 -3
  32. data/app/controllers/decidim/participatory_processes/participatory_processes_controller.rb +0 -9
  33. data/app/forms/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/{participatory_process_copy_form.rb → participatory_process_duplicate_form.rb} +5 -5
  34. data/app/forms/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/participatory_process_form.rb +2 -1
  35. data/app/forms/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/participatory_process_group_form.rb +0 -1
  36. data/app/helpers/decidim/participatory_processes/application_helper.rb +14 -0
  37. data/app/helpers/decidim/participatory_processes/participatory_process_helper.rb +1 -1
  38. data/app/models/decidim/participatory_process.rb +4 -4
  39. data/app/models/decidim/participatory_process_group.rb +9 -0
  40. data/app/permissions/decidim/participatory_processes/permissions.rb +4 -4
  41. data/app/presenters/decidim/participatory_processes/admin_log/participatory_process_group_presenter.rb +0 -1
  42. data/app/presenters/decidim/participatory_processes/admin_log/participatory_process_presenter.rb +0 -1
  43. data/app/presenters/decidim/participatory_processes/participatory_process_democratic_quality_stats_presenter.rb +312 -0
  44. data/app/presenters/decidim/participatory_processes/participatory_process_group_stats_presenter.rb +1 -11
  45. data/app/presenters/decidim/participatory_processes/participatory_process_presenter.rb +35 -1
  46. data/app/presenters/decidim/participatory_processes/participatory_process_stats_presenter.rb +1 -3
  47. data/app/queries/decidim/participatory_processes/participatory_processes_stats_followers_count.rb +31 -0
  48. data/app/queries/decidim/participatory_processes/participatory_processes_stats_participants_count.rb +27 -0
  49. data/app/serializers/decidim/participatory_processes/participatory_process_importer.rb +0 -1
  50. data/app/views/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/{participatory_process_copies → participatory_process_duplicates}/_form.html.erb +5 -5
  51. data/app/views/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/participatory_process_duplicates/new.html.erb +19 -0
  52. data/app/views/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/participatory_process_groups/_form.html.erb +3 -7
  53. data/app/views/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/participatory_process_groups/index.html.erb +31 -15
  54. data/app/views/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/participatory_process_steps/_form.html.erb +1 -1
  55. data/app/views/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/participatory_process_steps/index.html.erb +39 -21
  56. data/app/views/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/participatory_process_user_roles/index.html.erb +42 -24
  57. data/app/views/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/participatory_processes/_form.html.erb +10 -14
  58. data/app/views/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/participatory_processes/_process_row.html.erb +125 -53
  59. data/app/views/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/participatory_processes/edit.html.erb +0 -8
  60. data/app/views/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/participatory_processes/index.html.erb +2 -2
  61. data/app/views/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/participatory_processes/manage_trash.html.erb +2 -1
  62. data/app/views/layouts/decidim/admin/_manage_processes.html.erb +1 -1
  63. data/app/views/layouts/decidim/admin/participatory_process_group.html.erb +1 -1
  64. data/config/assets.rb +2 -2
  65. data/config/locales/ar.yml +0 -13
  66. data/config/locales/bg.yml +0 -24
  67. data/config/locales/bs-BA.yml +0 -4
  68. data/config/locales/ca-IT.yml +320 -26
  69. data/config/locales/ca.yml +320 -26
  70. data/config/locales/cs.yml +116 -25
  71. data/config/locales/de.yml +124 -26
  72. data/config/locales/el.yml +0 -21
  73. data/config/locales/en.yml +304 -25
  74. data/config/locales/es-MX.yml +320 -26
  75. data/config/locales/es-PY.yml +320 -26
  76. data/config/locales/es.yml +320 -26
  77. data/config/locales/eu.yml +305 -26
  78. data/config/locales/fi-plain.yml +304 -25
  79. data/config/locales/fi.yml +304 -25
  80. data/config/locales/fr-CA.yml +87 -25
  81. data/config/locales/fr.yml +87 -25
  82. data/config/locales/ga-IE.yml +0 -7
  83. data/config/locales/gl.yml +0 -19
  84. data/config/locales/hu.yml +0 -21
  85. data/config/locales/id-ID.yml +0 -13
  86. data/config/locales/is-IS.yml +0 -11
  87. data/config/locales/it.yml +0 -20
  88. data/config/locales/ja.yml +305 -26
  89. data/config/locales/lb.yml +0 -20
  90. data/config/locales/lt.yml +0 -21
  91. data/config/locales/lv.yml +0 -14
  92. data/config/locales/nl.yml +0 -20
  93. data/config/locales/no.yml +0 -21
  94. data/config/locales/pl.yml +16 -24
  95. data/config/locales/pt-BR.yml +0 -23
  96. data/config/locales/pt.yml +0 -20
  97. data/config/locales/ro-RO.yml +2 -21
  98. data/config/locales/ru.yml +0 -11
  99. data/config/locales/sk.yml +0 -14
  100. data/config/locales/sr-CS.yml +0 -4
  101. data/config/locales/sv.yml +87 -25
  102. data/config/locales/tr-TR.yml +0 -20
  103. data/config/locales/uk.yml +0 -11
  104. data/config/locales/zh-CN.yml +0 -17
  105. data/config/locales/zh-TW.yml +0 -21
  106. data/db/migrate/20250403110052_add_democratic_quality_static_page.rb +17 -0
  107. data/db/migrate/20250605114136_remove_hashtag_from_participatory_processes.rb +7 -0
  108. data/db/migrate/20250605114415_remove_hashtag_from_participatory_processes_groups.rb +7 -0
  109. data/decidim-participatory_processes.gemspec +3 -0
  110. data/lib/decidim/api/participatory_process_group_type.rb +9 -0
  111. data/lib/decidim/api/participatory_process_input_filter.rb +0 -1
  112. data/lib/decidim/api/participatory_process_step_type.rb +2 -0
  113. data/lib/decidim/api/participatory_process_type.rb +17 -11
  114. data/lib/decidim/participatory_processes/admin_engine.rb +1 -1
  115. data/lib/decidim/participatory_processes/content_blocks/registry_manager.rb +25 -5
  116. data/lib/decidim/participatory_processes/engine.rb +30 -25
  117. data/lib/decidim/participatory_processes/participatory_space.rb +1 -4
  118. data/lib/decidim/participatory_processes/seeds.rb +5 -5
  119. data/lib/decidim/participatory_processes/test/factories.rb +2 -3
  120. data/lib/decidim/participatory_processes/version.rb +1 -1
  121. metadata +72 -21
  122. data/app/cells/decidim/participatory_processes/content_blocks/metrics_cell.rb +0 -25
  123. data/app/presenters/decidim/participatory_processes/participatory_process_metric_charts_presenter.rb +0 -21
  124. data/app/queries/decidim/participatory_processes/metrics/participatory_process_followers_metric_measure.rb +0 -31
  125. data/app/queries/decidim/participatory_processes/metrics/participatory_processes_metric_manage.rb +0 -27
  126. data/app/queries/decidim/participatory_processes/stats_followers_count.rb +0 -60
  127. data/app/queries/decidim/participatory_processes/stats_participants_count.rb +0 -136
  128. data/app/views/decidim/participatory_processes/admin/participatory_process_copies/new.html.erb +0 -19
  129. data/app/views/decidim/participatory_processes/participatory_processes/all_metrics.html.erb +0 -25
@@ -5,17 +5,16 @@ en:
5
5
  participatory_process:
6
6
  announcement: Announcement
7
7
  area_id: Area
8
- copy_categories: Copy categories
9
- copy_components: Copy components
10
- copy_landing_page_blocks: Duplicate landing page blocks
11
- copy_steps: Copy steps
12
8
  decidim_area_id: Area
13
9
  description: Description
14
10
  developer_group: Promoter group
15
11
  document: Document
16
12
  domain: Domain
13
+ duplicate_categories: Duplicate categories
14
+ duplicate_components: Duplicate components
15
+ duplicate_landing_page_blocks: Duplicate landing page blocks
16
+ duplicate_steps: Duplicate steps
17
17
  end_date: End date
18
- hashtag: Hashtag
19
18
  hero_image: Home image
20
19
  import_attachments: Import attachments
21
20
  import_categories: Import categories
@@ -41,7 +40,6 @@ en:
41
40
  description: Description
42
41
  developer_group: Promoter group
43
42
  group_url: Website
44
- hashtag: Hashtag
45
43
  hero_image: Image
46
44
  local_area: Organization area
47
45
  meta_scope: Scope metadata
@@ -86,15 +84,12 @@ en:
86
84
  admin:
87
85
  actions:
88
86
  activate: Activate
89
- configure: Configure
90
87
  confirm_delete_process: Are you sure you want to delete this process? If you change your mind, you can restore it later.
91
88
  confirm_destroy: Confirm delete
92
89
  destroy: Delete
93
90
  duplicate: Duplicate
94
91
  edit: Edit
95
92
  import_process: Import
96
- menu_hidden: Hide
97
- moderate: Moderate
98
93
  new_process: New process
99
94
  new_process_group: New process group
100
95
  new_process_step: New phase
@@ -112,7 +107,7 @@ en:
112
107
  participatory_process_groups: Process groups
113
108
  participatory_process_groups_submenu:
114
109
  info: Info
115
- landing_page: Landing page
110
+ landing_page: Landing page layout
116
111
  participatory_processes: Processes
117
112
  participatory_processes_submenu:
118
113
  attachment_collections: Folders
@@ -120,7 +115,7 @@ en:
120
115
  attachments: Attachments
121
116
  components: Components
122
117
  info: About this process
123
- landing_page: Landing page
118
+ landing_page: Landing page layout
124
119
  moderations: Moderations
125
120
  private_users: Members
126
121
  process_admins: Process admins
@@ -136,16 +131,19 @@ en:
136
131
  name: Participatory process
137
132
  participatory_process_group:
138
133
  fields:
134
+ actions: Actions
139
135
  title: Title
140
136
  name: Process group
141
137
  participatory_process_step:
142
138
  fields:
139
+ actions: Actions
143
140
  end_date: End date
144
141
  start_date: Start date
145
142
  title: Title
146
143
  name: Participatory process phase
147
144
  participatory_process_user_role:
148
145
  fields:
146
+ actions: Actions
149
147
  email: Email
150
148
  name: Name
151
149
  role: Role
@@ -153,16 +151,16 @@ en:
153
151
  roles:
154
152
  admin: Administrator
155
153
  collaborator: Collaborator
154
+ evaluator: Evaluator
156
155
  moderator: Moderator
157
- valuator: Valuator
158
156
  user:
159
157
  fields:
160
158
  invitation_accepted_at: Invitation accepted at
161
159
  invitation_sent_at: Invitation sent at
162
160
  published: Published
163
- participatory_process_copies:
161
+ participatory_process_duplicates:
164
162
  new:
165
- copy: Copy
163
+ duplicate: Duplicate
166
164
  select: Select which data you would like to duplicate
167
165
  title: Duplicate participatory process
168
166
  participatory_process_groups:
@@ -263,7 +261,7 @@ en:
263
261
  update:
264
262
  error: There was a problem updating this participatory process.
265
263
  success: Participatory process successfully updated.
266
- participatory_processes_copies:
264
+ participatory_processes_duplicates:
267
265
  create:
268
266
  error: There was a problem duplicating this participatory process.
269
267
  success: Participatory process successfully duplicated.
@@ -345,11 +343,6 @@ en:
345
343
  not_found: 'The process type was not found on the database (ID: %{id}).'
346
344
  menu:
347
345
  processes: Processes
348
- metrics:
349
- participatory_processes:
350
- description: Number of participatory processes in this organization
351
- object: participatory processes
352
- title: Participatory processes
353
346
  open_data:
354
347
  help:
355
348
  participatory_processes:
@@ -360,7 +353,6 @@ en:
360
353
  developer_group: The developer group of the process. This is the organization that is promoting the process.
361
354
  end_date: The end date of the process
362
355
  follows_count: The number of users following this space
363
- hashtag: The process hashtag, used for Twitter/X
364
356
  id: The unique identifier of this process
365
357
  local_area: The local area of the process. This is the organization area where the process is taking place.
366
358
  meta_scope: The scope metadata of the process
@@ -420,6 +412,82 @@ en:
420
412
  participatory_processes:
421
413
  admin:
422
414
  content_blocks:
415
+ democratic_quality_stats_settings_form:
416
+ announcement:
417
+ body_html: |-
418
+ <ul>
419
+ <li>These are calculated automatically from Decidim data. They will become visible once you publish the content block.</li>
420
+ <li>These are based on your responses in the following form. They will be visible once you have answered all the questions.</li>
421
+ </ul>
422
+ title: 'This content block includes two types of metrics:'
423
+ citizen_influence:
424
+ citizen_decisional_intervention:
425
+ legend: Out of all phases in the process (from selecting issues to supervising execution), in how many does the public have the ability to make decisions or take executive action?
426
+ options:
427
+ five: 80 - 100%
428
+ four: 60 - 80%
429
+ one: 0 - 20%
430
+ three: 40 - 60%
431
+ two: 20 - 40%
432
+ citizen_influence_level:
433
+ legend: To what extent do citizens hold decisional authority in this process, ranging from simply receiving information to decisively influencing decisions and managing resources?
434
+ options:
435
+ five: Participants were involved in the decision-making and the management of resources or the implementation
436
+ four: Participants were involved decisively in the decision-making
437
+ one: Participants received information from the organisation
438
+ three: Participants were involved to share decision-making power
439
+ two: Participants were asked in a consultative manner or gave feedback to the organisation
440
+ name: Citizen influence
441
+ inclusiveness:
442
+ description: Inclusivity according to cultural origin and functional diversity.
443
+ digital_support_offered:
444
+ legend: Has digital support been offered to the participants?
445
+ options:
446
+ five: 'Yes'
447
+ two_five: Partially
448
+ zero: 'No'
449
+ functional_diversity_invited:
450
+ legend: How is the degree of diversity of the agents and participants assessed with respect to the population of reference in the process?
451
+ options:
452
+ five: Good
453
+ one: Low
454
+ two_five: Sufficient
455
+ zero: None
456
+ languages_communicated:
457
+ legend: How many languages have been used within the process?
458
+ options:
459
+ five: More than half of the languages spoken in the community
460
+ one: One language
461
+ two_five: Less than half of the languages spoken in the community
462
+ mobility_meeting_access:
463
+ legend: Were the venues of the face-to-face meetings accessible to people with reduced mobility?
464
+ options:
465
+ five: 'Yes'
466
+ two_five: Partially
467
+ zero: 'No'
468
+ name: Inclusiveness
469
+ participation_scheduling_times:
470
+ legend: The participation sessions have been scheduled at varied times (morning, midday, afternoon, evening, and weekends).
471
+ options:
472
+ five: 'Yes'
473
+ two_five: Partially
474
+ zero: 'No'
475
+ informativeness:
476
+ information_provided:
477
+ legend: Has information been provided regarding the participants capacity to influence the topic under discussion? (both in the communication of the process and invitations, as well as at the beginning of each debate session)
478
+ options:
479
+ five: Always
480
+ one: Almost never
481
+ two_five: Usually
482
+ zero: Never
483
+ name: Informativeness
484
+ published_information_clarity:
485
+ legend: Does the published information provide clarity on the decision-making mechanisms? (e.g. voting, consensus, direct negotiations)
486
+ options:
487
+ five: Full clarity
488
+ one: Low clarity
489
+ two_five: Suficient clarity
490
+ zero: No clarity
423
491
  highlighted_processes:
424
492
  active: Active
425
493
  all: All
@@ -428,7 +496,7 @@ en:
428
496
  new_import:
429
497
  accepted_types:
430
498
  json: JSON
431
- participatory_process_copies:
499
+ participatory_process_duplicates:
432
500
  form:
433
501
  slug_help_html: 'URL slugs are used to generate the URLs that point to this process. Only accepts letters, numbers and dashes, and must start with a letter. Example: %{url}'
434
502
  participatory_process_groups:
@@ -460,6 +528,35 @@ en:
460
528
  title: General Information
461
529
  visibility: Visibility
462
530
  content_blocks:
531
+ democratic_quality_stats:
532
+ automatic_metrics:
533
+ description: These indicators are obtained automatically from the platform data.
534
+ indicators:
535
+ hybridization: Hybridization
536
+ hybridization_tooltip: This indicator measures the level of combination between online and offline spaces during the process
537
+ influence: Citizen influence
538
+ influence_tooltip: This indicator measures the level of citizen influence on the accepted proposals and the outcomes of the process.
539
+ traceability: Traceability
540
+ traceability_tooltip: This indicator measures the transparency and traceability of the participatory process. It reflects how easily participants can follow the evolution of proposals and verify institutional actions through published records.
541
+ transparency: Responsiveness
542
+ transparency_tooltip: This indicator measures the level of responsiveness of the organization to participant input. It reflects their engagement through official responses and implemented decisions.
543
+ name: Automatic metrics
544
+ global_score:
545
+ description_html: Below is a set of indicators used to assess the democratic quality of this participatory process. For more details on how they are calculated, see the <a href="%{info_url}">information page on democratic quality indicators</a>.
546
+ name: Global score
547
+ note: "*The indicative values are measured on a scale from 1 to 5, where 1 represents the lowest and 5 the highest quality indicator."
548
+ tooltip: Calculated as the average of all the dimensions
549
+ name: Quality indicator
550
+ qualitative_metrics:
551
+ description: These indicators are obtained from the answers to a self-assessment survey filled in by the platform's administrators.
552
+ indicators:
553
+ citizen_influence: Citizen influence
554
+ citizen_influence_tooltip: Measures the level of participant impact on decision-making.
555
+ inclusiveness: Inclusiveness
556
+ inclusiveness_tooltip: Assesses whether diverse interested parties are fairly represented.
557
+ informativeness: Informativeness
558
+ informativeness_tooltip: Measures the level of clarity and information provided within the process.
559
+ name: Self-assessment metrics
463
560
  extra_data:
464
561
  name: Phase & duration
465
562
  hero:
@@ -477,9 +574,6 @@ en:
477
574
  highlighted_processes:
478
575
  active_spaces: Active processes
479
576
  see_all_spaces: See all processes
480
- participatory_process_steps:
481
- index:
482
- back_to_process: Back to the process page
483
577
  participatory_processes:
484
578
  description:
485
579
  area_name: Area
@@ -528,8 +622,193 @@ en:
528
622
  belongs_to_group: This process belongs to
529
623
  private_space: This is a private process
530
624
  related_processes: Related processes
625
+ static_pages:
626
+ democratic_quality_indicators:
627
+ content: |-
628
+ <h2>Indicator system to measure quality indicator in Decidim.</h2>
629
+
630
+ <h3>Introduction</h3>
631
+ <p>Democratic quality is a core principle of Decidim. To uphold this, we have developed a system of indicators that help evaluate the quality of participatory processes on the platform. This article explains how these indicators are calculated.</p>
632
+
633
+ <h3>How Are Indicators Calculated?</h3>
634
+ <p>We have defined two methods for collecting quality indicators:</p>
635
+
636
+ <ol>
637
+ <li><strong>Automatic Metrics:</strong> These are calculated directly from Decidim platform data.</li>
638
+ <li><strong>Self-Assessment Questions:</strong> These are based on a form filled out by an administrator.</li>
639
+ </ol>
640
+
641
+ <p>Each indicator is expressed as a percentage (n/total). This percentage is then converted to a score on a 1-to-5 scale:</p>
642
+
643
+ <ul>
644
+ <li>1 = 0–20%</li>
645
+ <li>2 = 20–40%</li>
646
+ <li>3 = 40–60%</li>
647
+ <li>4 = 60–80%</li>
648
+ <li>5 = 80–100%</li>
649
+ </ul>
650
+
651
+ <br><br>
652
+ <h3>Automatic Metrics</h3>
653
+ <p>These metrics are automatically calculated from data available in Decidim. They are evaluated per participatory process and can be made public by administrators, so all participants can access it.</p>
654
+
655
+ <p>We have defined four main indicators: Citizen Influence, Hybridization, Responsiveness and Traceability:</p>
656
+
657
+ <h3>Citizen Influence</h3>
658
+
659
+ <p>This indicator measures the level of citizen influence on the accepted proposals and the outcomes of the process.</p>
660
+
661
+ <ul>
662
+ <li>
663
+ Citizen influence on proposals
664
+ <ul>
665
+ <li>Percentage of proposals accepted (n/total)</li>
666
+ <li>Percentage of approved <em>citizen</em> proposals over total of citizen proposals (total citizen influence on proposals approved)</li>
667
+ <li>Percentage of approved citizen proposals over total of approved proposals (relative citizen influence on approved proposal)</li>
668
+ </ul>
669
+ </li>
670
+ <li>
671
+ Citizen influence on outputs/results
672
+ <ul>
673
+ <li>Percentage of results linked to citizen proposals out of the total of results (total citizen influence on outputs)</li>
674
+ </ul>
675
+ </li>
676
+ </ul>
677
+
678
+ <h3>Hybridization</h3>
679
+
680
+ <p>This indicator measures the level of combination between online and offline spaces during the process.</p>
681
+
682
+ <ul>
683
+ <li>Is a meeting component active? (Yes=5, No=0)</li>
684
+ <li>Are there face to face meetings? (Yes=5, No=0)</li>
685
+ <li>Are there online meetings ? (Yes=5, No=0)</li>
686
+ <li>Are there hybrid meetings? (Yes=5, No=0)</li>
687
+ <li>Are there proposals created from meetings? (Yes=5, No=0)</li>
688
+ </ul>
689
+
690
+ <h3>Responsiveness</h3>
691
+
692
+ <p>This indicator measures the level of responsiveness of the organization to participant input. It reflects their engagement through official responses and implemented decisions.</p>
693
+
694
+ <ul>
695
+ <li>Percentage of proposals with answers (n/total) – Proposal institutional responsiveness</li>
696
+ <li>Percentage of results completed at 100% (n/total)</li>
697
+ </ul>
698
+
699
+ <h3>Traceability</h3>
700
+
701
+ <p>This indicator measures the transparency and traceability of the participatory process. It reflects how easily participants can follow the evolution of proposals and verify institutional actions through published records.</p>
702
+
703
+ <ul>
704
+ <li>Number of Proposals with history (n/total)</li>
705
+ <li>Percentage of results linked to proposals (n/total)</li>
706
+ <li>Percentage of meetings closed with minutes published (n/total)</li>
707
+ <li>Activation of the open data module (dichotomic: 0 or 5)</li>
708
+ <li>Percentage of proposals related to budgets (n/total)</li>
709
+ </ul>
710
+
711
+ <br><br>
712
+ <h3>Self-Assessment Metrics</h3>
713
+
714
+ <p>In addition to automatic metrics, we propose the use of a <strong>self-evaluation form</strong> to assess the qualitative dimensions of each participatory process. This form will be completed by platform administrators at the end of each process, and the responses will be publicly displayed in the indicators content block.</p>
715
+
716
+ <p>These questions aim to capture aspects of democratic quality that cannot be assessed through quantitative data alone. It is important to note that the responses to this survey are biased by the opinion of the platform administrators.</p>
717
+
718
+ <br><br>
719
+ <h3>Self-assessment questions</h3>
720
+
721
+ <p>The questions that make up the self-assessment form answered by the administrators, as well as the values associated with each answer, are set out below.</p>
722
+
723
+ <h4>Informativeness</h4>
724
+
725
+ <ol>
726
+ <li>Does the published information provide clarity on the decision-making mechanisms (e.g., voting, consensus, direct negotiations)?
727
+ <ul>
728
+ <li>No clarity = 0</li>
729
+ <li>Low clarity = 1</li>
730
+ <li>Sufficient clarity = 2,5</li>
731
+ <li>Full clarity = 5</li>
732
+ </ul>
733
+ </li>
734
+ <li>Has information been provided regarding the participants' capacity to influence the topic under discussion (both in the communication of the process and invitations, as well as at the beginning of each debate session)?
735
+ <ul>
736
+ <li>Never = 0</li>
737
+ <li>Almost never = 1</li>
738
+ <li>Usually = 2,5</li>
739
+ <li>Always = 5</li>
740
+ </ul>
741
+ </li>
742
+ </ol>
743
+
744
+ <h4>Citizens influence</h4>
745
+
746
+ <ol>
747
+ <li>Assessment of the degree of participation in the process
748
+ <ul>
749
+ <li>Participants received information from the organisation. = 1</li>
750
+ <li>Participants were asked in a consultative manner or gave feedback to the organisation. = 2</li>
751
+ <li>Participants were involved to share decision-making power. = 3</li>
752
+ <li>Participants were involved decisively in the decision-making. = 4</li>
753
+ <li>Participants were involved in the decision-making and the management of resources or the implementation. = 5</li>
754
+ </ul>
755
+ </li>
756
+ <li>Percentage of phases with 0-5 citizen decisional intervention.
757
+ <p>Out of all phases in the process (from selecting issues to supervising execution), in how many does the public have the ability to make decisions or take executive action?</p>
758
+ <ul>
759
+ <li>0-20% = 1</li>
760
+ <li>20-40% = 2</li>
761
+ <li>40-60% = 3</li>
762
+ <li>60-80% = 4</li>
763
+ <li>80-100% = 5</li>
764
+ </ul>
765
+ </li>
766
+ </ol>
767
+
768
+ <h4>Inclusiveness</h4>
769
+
770
+ <ol>
771
+ <li>How is the degree of diversity of the agents and participants assessed with respect to the population of reference in the process?
772
+ <ul>
773
+ <li>None = 0</li>
774
+ <li>Low = 1</li>
775
+ <li>Sufficient = 2,5</li>
776
+ <li>Good = 5</li>
777
+ </ul>
778
+ </li>
779
+ <li>In how many languages has the process been communicated?
780
+ <ul>
781
+ <li>One language = 1</li>
782
+ <li>Less than half of the languages spoken in the community = 2,5</li>
783
+ <li>More than half of the languages spoken in the community = 5</li>
784
+ </ul>
785
+ </li>
786
+ <li>Were the venues of the face-to-face meetings accessible to people with reduced mobility?
787
+ <ul>
788
+ <li>No = 0</li>
789
+ <li>Partially = 2,5</li>
790
+ <li>Yes = 5</li>
791
+ </ul>
792
+ </li>
793
+ <li>The participation sessions have been scheduled at varied times (morning, midday, afternoon, evening, and weekends).
794
+ <ul>
795
+ <li>No = 0</li>
796
+ <li>Partially = 2,5</li>
797
+ <li>Yes = 5</li>
798
+ </ul>
799
+ </li>
800
+ <li>Has digital support been offered to the participants?
801
+ <ul>
802
+ <li>No = 0</li>
803
+ <li>Partially = 2,5</li>
804
+ <li>Yes = 5</li>
805
+ </ul>
806
+ </li>
807
+ </ol>
808
+ title: Democratic quality indicators
531
809
  statistics:
532
810
  processes_count: Processes
811
+ processes_count_tooltip: The number of participatory processes that are publicly available.
533
812
  layouts:
534
813
  decidim:
535
814
  participatory_process_groups: