chef-dk 3.0.36 → 3.1.0

data/spec/unit/policyfile_demands_spec.rb

@@ -1,1197 +1,1197 @@
-#
-# Copyright:: Copyright (c) 2014-2018 Chef Software Inc.
-# License:: Apache License, Version 2.0
-#
-# Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License");
-# you may not use this file except in compliance with the License.
-# You may obtain a copy of the License at
-#
-#     http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0
-#
-# Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software
-# distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS,
-# WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
-# See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
-# limitations under the License.
-#
-
-require "spec_helper"
-require "chef-dk/policyfile_compiler"
-
-describe ChefDK::PolicyfileCompiler, "when expressing the Policyfile graph demands" do
-
-  let(:run_list) { [] }
-
-  let(:default_source) { nil }
-
-  let(:external_cookbook_universe) { {} }
-
-  let(:policyfile) do
-    policyfile = ChefDK::PolicyfileCompiler.new.build do |p|
-
-      p.default_source(*default_source) if default_source
-      p.run_list(*run_list)
-
-      allow(p.default_source.first).to receive(:universe_graph).and_return(external_cookbook_universe)
-    end
-
-    policyfile
-  end
-
-  let(:demands) { policyfile.graph_demands }
-
-  shared_context("community default source") do
-
-    let(:default_source) { [:community] }
-
-    let(:external_cookbook_universe) do
-      {
-        "nginx" => {
-          "1.0.0" => [ [ "apt", "~> 2.0" ], [ "yum", "~> 1.0" ] ],
-          "1.2.0" => [ [ "apt", "~> 2.1" ], [ "yum", "~> 1.0" ] ],
-          "2.0.0" => [ [ "apt", "~> 3.0" ], [ "yum", "~> 1.0" ], [ "ohai", "~> 2.0" ] ],
-        },
-
-        "mysql" => {
-          "3.0.0" => [ [ "apt", "~> 2.0" ], [ "yum", "~> 1.0" ] ],
-          "4.0.0" => [ [ "apt", "~> 2.4" ], [ "yum", "~> 1.1" ] ],
-          "5.0.0" => [ ],
-        },
-
-        "local-cookbook" => {
-          "9.9.9" => [ ["local-cookbook-on-community-dep", "= 1.0.0"] ],
-        },
-
-        "git-sourced-cookbook" => {
-          "10.10.10" => [ ["git-sourced-cookbook-dep", "= 1.0.0"] ],
-        },
-
-        "remote-cb" => {
-          "0.1.0" => [ ],
-          "1.1.1" => [ ],
-        },
-
-        "remote-cb-two" => {
-          "0.1.0" => [ ],
-          "1.1.1" => [ ],
-        },
-
-        "local-cookbook-dep-one" => {
-          "1.5.0" => [ ],
-        },
-
-        "git-sourced-cookbook-dep" => {
-          "2.8.0" => [ ],
-        },
-
-      }
-    end
-  end
-
-  shared_context("chef server default source") do
-
-    let(:default_source) { [:chef_server, "https://chef.example.com"] }
-
-    let(:external_cookbook_universe) do
-      {
-        "nginx" => {
-          "1.0.0" => [ [ "apt", "~> 2.0" ], [ "yum", "~> 1.0" ] ],
-        },
-
-        "mysql" => {
-          "5.0.0" => [ ],
-        },
-
-        "local-cookbook" => {
-          "9.9.9" => [ ["local-cookbook-on-community-dep", "= 1.0.0"] ],
-        },
-
-        "remote-cb" => {
-          "1.1.1" => [ ],
-        },
-
-        "git-sourced-cookbook" => {
-          "10.10.10" => [ ["git-sourced-cookbook-dep", "= 1.0.0"] ],
-        },
-
-        "private-cookbook" => {
-          "0.1.0" => [ ],
-        },
-
-        "local-cookbook-dep-one" => {
-          "1.6.0" => [ ],
-        },
-
-        "git-sourced-cookbook-dep" => {
-          "2.9.0" => [ ],
-        },
-
-      }
-    end
-  end
-
-  describe "when normalizing run_list items" do
-
-    it "normalizes a bare cookbook name" do
-      policyfile.run_list("local-cookbook")
-      expect(policyfile.normalized_run_list).to eq(["recipe[local-cookbook::default]"])
-    end
-
-    it "normalizes a bare cookbook::recipe item" do
-      policyfile.run_list("local-cookbook::server")
-      expect(policyfile.normalized_run_list).to eq(["recipe[local-cookbook::server]"])
-    end
-
-    it "normalizes a recipe[] item with implicit default" do
-      policyfile.run_list("recipe[local-cookbook]")
-      expect(policyfile.normalized_run_list).to eq(["recipe[local-cookbook::default]"])
-    end
-
-    it "does not modify a fully qualified recipe" do
-      policyfile.run_list("recipe[local-cookbook::jazz_hands]")
-      expect(policyfile.normalized_run_list).to eq(["recipe[local-cookbook::jazz_hands]"])
-    end
-
-    describe "in an alternate run list" do
-
-      it "normalizes a bare cookbook name" do
-        policyfile.named_run_list(:foo, "local-cookbook")
-        expect(policyfile.normalized_named_run_lists[:foo]).to eq(["recipe[local-cookbook::default]"])
-      end
-
-      it "normalizes a bare cookbook::recipe item" do
-        policyfile.named_run_list(:foo, "local-cookbook::server")
-        expect(policyfile.normalized_named_run_lists[:foo]).to eq(["recipe[local-cookbook::server]"])
-      end
-
-      it "normalizes a recipe[] item with implicit default" do
-        policyfile.named_run_list(:foo, "recipe[local-cookbook]")
-        expect(policyfile.normalized_named_run_lists[:foo]).to eq(["recipe[local-cookbook::default]"])
-      end
-
-      it "does not modify a fully qualified recipe" do
-        policyfile.named_run_list(:foo, "recipe[local-cookbook::jazz_hands]")
-        expect(policyfile.normalized_named_run_lists[:foo]).to eq(["recipe[local-cookbook::jazz_hands]"])
-      end
-
-    end
-  end
-
-  before do
-    expect(policyfile.errors).to eq([])
-  end
-
-  context "Given resolvable cookbook demands" do
-
-    let(:default_source) { [:supermarket] }
-
-    let(:trimmed_cookbook_universe) do
-      {
-        "remote-cb" => {
-          "1.1.1" => [ ],
-        },
-
-      }
-    end
-
-    let(:remote_cb_source_opts) do
-      { artifactserver: "https://supermarket.example/c/remote-cb/1.1.1/download", version: "1.1.1" }
-    end
-
-    let(:default_source_obj) do
-      instance_double("ChefDK::Policyfile::CommunityCookbookSource")
-    end
-
-    let(:cb_location_spec) do
-      s = "Cookbook 'remote-cb'"
-      s << " = 1.1.1"
-      s << " #{remote_cb_source_opts}"
-
-      instance_double("ChefDK::Policyfile::CookbookLocationSpecification",
-                      name: "remote-cb",
-                      version_constraint: Semverse::Constraint.new("= 1.1.1"),
-                      ensure_cached: nil,
-                      to_s: s)
-    end
-
-    before do
-      allow(policyfile).to receive(:default_source).and_return([default_source_obj])
-
-      allow(default_source_obj).to receive(:universe_graph).
-        and_return(trimmed_cookbook_universe)
-
-      allow(default_source_obj).to receive(:preferred_source_for?).
-        with("remote-cb").
-        and_return(true)
-
-      allow(default_source_obj).to receive(:source_options_for).
-        with("remote-cb", "1.1.1").
-        and_return(remote_cb_source_opts)
-
-      allow(ChefDK::Policyfile::CookbookLocationSpecification).to receive(:new).
-        with("remote-cb", "= 1.1.1", remote_cb_source_opts, policyfile.storage_config).
-        and_return(cb_location_spec)
-
-      allow(cb_location_spec).to receive(:installed?).and_return(true)
-    end
-
-    context "when the resolved cookbooks have the recipes requested by the run list" do
-
-      context "with an implied default recipe" do
-
-        before do
-          expect(cb_location_spec).to receive(:cookbook_has_recipe?).
-            with("default").
-            and_return(true)
-        end
-
-        let(:run_list) { ["remote-cb"] }
-
-        it "installs without error" do
-          expect { policyfile.install }.to_not raise_error
-        end
-
-      end
-
-      context "with an explicit recipe name" do
-
-        before do
-          expect(cb_location_spec).to receive(:cookbook_has_recipe?).
-            with("this_exists").
-            and_return(true)
-        end
-
-        let(:run_list) { ["remote-cb::this_exists"] }
-
-        it "installs without error" do
-          expect { policyfile.install }.to_not raise_error
-        end
-
-      end
-
-      context "with a fully qualified recipe name" do
-
-        before do
-          expect(cb_location_spec).to receive(:cookbook_has_recipe?).
-            with("this_exists").
-            and_return(true)
-        end
-
-        let(:run_list) { ["recipe[remote-cb::this_exists]"] }
-
-        it "installs without error" do
-          expect { policyfile.install }.to_not raise_error
-        end
-
-      end
-
-    end
-
-    context "when the resolved cookbooks do not have the recipes requested by the run list" do
-
-      context "when the cookbook with a missing recipe appears once in the run list" do
-        before do
-          expect(cb_location_spec).to receive(:cookbook_has_recipe?).
-            with("this_recipe_doesnt_exist").
-            and_return(false)
-        end
-
-        let(:run_list) { ["remote-cb::this_recipe_doesnt_exist"] }
-
-        it "emits an error" do
-          message = <<-MESSAGE
-The installed cookbooks do not contain all the recipes required by your run list(s):
-Cookbook 'remote-cb' = 1.1.1 {:artifactserver=>"https://supermarket.example/c/remote-cb/1.1.1/download", :version=>"1.1.1"}
-is missing the following required recipes:
-* this_recipe_doesnt_exist
-
-You may have specified an incorrect recipe in your run list,
-or this recipe may not be available in that version of the cookbook
-MESSAGE
-
-          expect { policyfile.install }.to raise_error do |e|
-            expect(e).to be_a(ChefDK::CookbookDoesNotContainRequiredRecipe)
-            expect(e.message).to eq(message)
-          end
-        end
-      end
-
-      context "when there is one valid item and one invalid item in the run list" do
-
-        before do
-          expect(cb_location_spec).to receive(:cookbook_has_recipe?).
-            with("default").
-            and_return(true)
-          expect(cb_location_spec).to receive(:cookbook_has_recipe?).
-            with("this_recipe_doesnt_exist").
-            and_return(false)
-        end
-
-        let(:run_list) { ["remote-cb::default", "remote-cb::this_recipe_doesnt_exist"] }
-
-        it "emits an error" do
-          message = <<-MESSAGE
-The installed cookbooks do not contain all the recipes required by your run list(s):
-Cookbook 'remote-cb' = 1.1.1 {:artifactserver=>"https://supermarket.example/c/remote-cb/1.1.1/download", :version=>"1.1.1"}
-is missing the following required recipes:
-* this_recipe_doesnt_exist
-
-You may have specified an incorrect recipe in your run list,
-or this recipe may not be available in that version of the cookbook
-MESSAGE
-
-          expect { policyfile.install }.to raise_error do |e|
-            expect(e).to be_a(ChefDK::CookbookDoesNotContainRequiredRecipe)
-            expect(e.message).to eq(message)
-          end
-        end
-
-      end
-
-      context "when there are multiple invalid items in the run list" do
-
-        before do
-          expect(cb_location_spec).to receive(:cookbook_has_recipe?).
-            with("this_recipe_doesnt_exist").
-            and_return(false)
-          expect(cb_location_spec).to receive(:cookbook_has_recipe?).
-            with("this_also_doesnt_exist").
-            and_return(false)
-        end
-
-        let(:run_list) { ["remote-cb::this_recipe_doesnt_exist", "remote-cb::this_also_doesnt_exist"] }
-
-        it "emits an error" do
-          message = <<-MESSAGE
-The installed cookbooks do not contain all the recipes required by your run list(s):
-Cookbook 'remote-cb' = 1.1.1 {:artifactserver=>"https://supermarket.example/c/remote-cb/1.1.1/download", :version=>"1.1.1"}
-is missing the following required recipes:
-* this_recipe_doesnt_exist
-* this_also_doesnt_exist
-
-You may have specified an incorrect recipe in your run list,
-or this recipe may not be available in that version of the cookbook
-MESSAGE
-
-          expect { policyfile.install }.to raise_error do |e|
-            expect(e).to be_a(ChefDK::CookbookDoesNotContainRequiredRecipe)
-            expect(e.message).to eq(message)
-          end
-        end
-
-      end
-
-    end
-  end
-
-  context "Given no local or git cookbooks, no default source, and an empty run list" do
-
-    let(:run_list) { [] }
-
-    it "has an empty set of demands" do
-      expect(demands).to eq([])
-    end
-
-    it "uses an empty universe for dependencies" do
-      expect(policyfile.artifacts_graph).to eq({})
-    end
-
-    it "has an empty solution" do
-      expect(policyfile).to receive(:ensure_cache_dir_exists)
-      expect(policyfile.graph_solution).to eq({})
-    end
-
-    it "has an empty set of solution_dependencies" do
-      expected_solution_deps = {
-        "Policyfile" => [],
-        "dependencies" => {},
-      }
-      expect(policyfile.solution_dependencies.to_lock).to eq(expected_solution_deps)
-    end
-  end
-
-  context "Given a run list and no local or git cookbooks" do
-
-    let(:run_list) { ["remote-cb"] }
-
-    context "with no default source" do
-
-      it "fails to locate the cookbook" do
-        expect { policyfile.graph_solution }.to raise_error(Solve::Errors::NoSolutionError)
-      end
-
-      context "when the policyfile also has a `cookbook` entry for the run list item" do
-
-        before do
-          policyfile.dsl.cookbook "remote-cb"
-        end
-
-        it "fails to locate the cookbook" do
-          expect { policyfile.graph_solution }.to raise_error(Solve::Errors::NoSolutionError)
-        end
-
-      end
-
-    end
-
-    context "And the default source is the community site" do
-
-      include_context "community default source"
-
-      it "has an unconstrained demand on the required cookbooks" do
-        expect(demands).to eq([["remote-cb", ">= 0.0.0"]])
-      end
-
-      it "uses the community site universe for dependencies" do
-        expect(policyfile.artifacts_graph).to eq(external_cookbook_universe)
-      end
-
-      it "uses the community cookbook in the solution" do
-        expect(policyfile).to receive(:ensure_cache_dir_exists)
-        expect(policyfile.graph_solution).to eq({ "remote-cb" => "1.1.1" })
-      end
-
-      it "includes the cookbook in the solution dependencies" do
-        expected_solution_deps = {
-          "Policyfile" => [],
-          "dependencies" => { "remote-cb (1.1.1)" => [] },
-        }
-        expect(policyfile.solution_dependencies.to_lock).to eq(expected_solution_deps)
-      end
-
-    end
-
-    context "And the default source is the chef-server" do
-
-      include_context "chef server default source"
-
-      it "has an unconstrained demand on the required cookbooks" do
-        expect(demands).to eq([["remote-cb", ">= 0.0.0"]])
-      end
-
-      it "uses the chef-server universe for dependencies" do
-        expect(policyfile.artifacts_graph).to eq(external_cookbook_universe)
-      end
-
-      it "uses the chef-server cookbook in the solution" do
-        expect(policyfile).to receive(:ensure_cache_dir_exists)
-        expect(policyfile.graph_solution).to eq({ "remote-cb" => "1.1.1" })
-      end
-    end
-  end
-
-  context "Given a local cookbook and only that cookbook in the run list" do
-
-    let(:run_list) { ["local-cookbook"] }
-
-    before do
-      policyfile.dsl.cookbook("local-cookbook", path: "/foo")
-      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:version).and_return("2.3.4")
-      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:dependencies).and_return([])
-      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:ensure_cached).and_return(true)
-    end
-
-    it "demands a solution using the local cookbook" do
-      expect(demands).to eq([["local-cookbook", "= 2.3.4"]])
-    end
-
-    it "includes the local cookbook in the artifact universe" do
-      expected_artifacts_graph = {
-        "local-cookbook" => { "2.3.4" => [] },
-      }
-      expect(policyfile.artifacts_graph).to eq(expected_artifacts_graph)
-    end
-
-    it "includes the cookbook in the solution dependencies" do
-      expected_solution_deps = {
-        "Policyfile" => [ [ "local-cookbook", ">= 0.0.0" ] ],
-        "dependencies" => { "local-cookbook (2.3.4)" => [] },
-      }
-      expect(policyfile.solution_dependencies.to_lock).to eq(expected_solution_deps)
-    end
-
-  end
-
-  context "Given a local cookbook with a dependency and only the local cookbook in the run list" do
-
-    let(:run_list) { ["local-cookbook"] }
-
-    context "And the default source is the community site" do
-
-      include_context "community default source"
-
-      before do
-        policyfile.dsl.cookbook("local-cookbook", path: "foo/")
-        allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:ensure_cached)
-        allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:version).and_return("2.3.4")
-        allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:dependencies).and_return([ [ "local-cookbook-dep-one", "~> 1.0"] ])
-      end
-
-      it "demands a solution using the local cookbook" do
-        expect(demands).to eq([["local-cookbook", "= 2.3.4"]])
-      end
-
-      it "overrides the community site universe with the local cookbook and its dependencies" do
-        expected_artifacts_graph = external_cookbook_universe.dup
-        expected_artifacts_graph["local-cookbook"] = {
-          "2.3.4" => [ [ "local-cookbook-dep-one", "~> 1.0" ] ],
-        }
-        expect(policyfile.artifacts_graph).to eq(expected_artifacts_graph)
-      end
-
-      it "uses the local cookbook in the solution and gets dependencies remotely" do
-        expect(policyfile).to receive(:ensure_cache_dir_exists)
-        expect(policyfile.graph_solution).to eq({ "local-cookbook" => "2.3.4", "local-cookbook-dep-one" => "1.5.0" })
-      end
-
-      it "includes the cookbook and dependencies in the solution dependencies" do
-        expected_solution_deps = {
-          "Policyfile" => [ [ "local-cookbook", ">= 0.0.0" ] ],
-          "dependencies" => {
-            "local-cookbook (2.3.4)" => [[ "local-cookbook-dep-one", "~> 1.0"]],
-            "local-cookbook-dep-one (1.5.0)" => [],
-          },
-
-        }
-        expect(policyfile.solution_dependencies.to_lock).to eq(expected_solution_deps)
-      end
-
-    end
-    context "And the default source is the chef server" do
-
-      include_context "chef server default source"
-
-      before do
-        policyfile.dsl.cookbook("local-cookbook", path: "foo/")
-        allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:ensure_cached)
-        allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:version).and_return("2.3.4")
-        allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:dependencies).and_return([ [ "local-cookbook-dep-one", "~> 1.0"] ])
-      end
-
-      it "demands a solution using the local cookbook" do
-        expect(demands).to eq([["local-cookbook", "= 2.3.4"]])
-      end
-
-      it "overrides the chef server universe with the local cookbook and its dependencies" do
-        # all versions of "local-cookbook" from the cookbook site universe
-        # should be removed so we won't run into trouble if there's a community
-        # cookbook with the same name and version but different deps.
-        expected_artifacts_graph = external_cookbook_universe.dup
-        expected_artifacts_graph["local-cookbook"] = {
-          "2.3.4" => [ [ "local-cookbook-dep-one", "~> 1.0" ] ],
-        }
-        expect(policyfile.artifacts_graph).to eq(expected_artifacts_graph)
-      end
-
-      it "uses the local cookbook in the solution and gets dependencies remotely" do
-        expect(policyfile).to receive(:ensure_cache_dir_exists)
-        expect(policyfile.graph_solution).to eq({ "local-cookbook" => "2.3.4", "local-cookbook-dep-one" => "1.6.0" })
-      end
-
-      it "includes the cookbook and dependencies in the solution dependencies" do
-        expected_solution_deps = {
-          "Policyfile" => [ [ "local-cookbook", ">= 0.0.0" ] ],
-          "dependencies" => {
-            "local-cookbook (2.3.4)" => [[ "local-cookbook-dep-one", "~> 1.0"]],
-            "local-cookbook-dep-one (1.6.0)" => [],
-          },
-
-        }
-        expect(policyfile.solution_dependencies.to_lock).to eq(expected_solution_deps)
-      end
-
-    end
-  end
-
-  context "Given a git-sourced cookbook with no dependencies and only the git cookbook in the run list" do
-
-    let(:run_list) { ["git-sourced-cookbook"] }
-
-    before do
-      policyfile.dsl.cookbook("git-sourced-cookbook", git: "git://git.example.org:user/a-cookbook.git")
-      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("git-sourced-cookbook")).to receive(:ensure_cached)
-      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("git-sourced-cookbook")).to receive(:version).and_return("8.6.7")
-      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("git-sourced-cookbook")).to receive(:dependencies).and_return([ ])
-    end
-
-    it "demands a solution using the git sourced cookbook" do
-      expect(demands).to eq([["git-sourced-cookbook", "= 8.6.7"]])
-    end
-
-    it "includes the git-sourced cookbook in the universe graph" do
-      expected_artifacts_graph = {
-        "git-sourced-cookbook" => { "8.6.7" => [ ] },
-      }
-      expect(policyfile.artifacts_graph).to eq(expected_artifacts_graph)
-    end
-
-    it "uses the git sourced cookbook in the solution" do
-      expect(policyfile).to receive(:ensure_cache_dir_exists)
-      expect(policyfile.graph_solution).to eq({ "git-sourced-cookbook" => "8.6.7" })
-    end
-
-    it "includes the cookbook and dependencies in the solution dependencies" do
-      expected_solution_deps = {
-        "Policyfile" => [ [ "git-sourced-cookbook", ">= 0.0.0" ] ],
-        "dependencies" => {
-          "git-sourced-cookbook (8.6.7)" => [],
-        },
-
-      }
-      expect(policyfile.solution_dependencies.to_lock).to eq(expected_solution_deps)
-    end
-
-  end
-
-  context "Given a git-sourced cookbook with a dependency and only the git cookbook in the run list" do
-
-    let(:run_list) { ["git-sourced-cookbook"] }
-
-    before do
-      policyfile.dsl.cookbook("git-sourced-cookbook", git: "git://git.example.org:user/a-cookbook.git")
-      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("git-sourced-cookbook")).to receive(:ensure_cached)
-      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("git-sourced-cookbook")).to receive(:version).and_return("8.6.7")
-      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("git-sourced-cookbook")).to receive(:dependencies).and_return([ ["git-sourced-cookbook-dep", "~> 2.2" ] ])
-    end
-
-    context "And the default source is the community site" do
-
-      include_context "community default source"
-
-      it "demands a solution using the git sourced cookbook" do
-        expect(demands).to eq([["git-sourced-cookbook", "= 8.6.7"]])
-      end
-
-      it "overrides the community site universe with the git-sourced cookbook and deps" do
-        expected_artifacts_graph = external_cookbook_universe.dup
-        expected_artifacts_graph["git-sourced-cookbook"] = {
-          "8.6.7" => [ ["git-sourced-cookbook-dep", "~> 2.2" ] ],
-        }
-        expect(policyfile.artifacts_graph).to eq(expected_artifacts_graph)
-      end
-
-      it "uses the git sourced cookbook with remote dependencies in the solution" do
-        expect(policyfile).to receive(:ensure_cache_dir_exists)
-        expect(policyfile.graph_solution).to eq({ "git-sourced-cookbook" => "8.6.7", "git-sourced-cookbook-dep" => "2.8.0" })
-      end
-
-      it "includes the cookbook and dependencies in the solution dependencies" do
-        expected_solution_deps = {
-          "Policyfile" => [ [ "git-sourced-cookbook", ">= 0.0.0" ] ],
-          "dependencies" => {
-            "git-sourced-cookbook (8.6.7)" => [ [ "git-sourced-cookbook-dep", "~> 2.2" ] ],
-            "git-sourced-cookbook-dep (2.8.0)" => [],
-          },
-
-        }
-        expect(policyfile.solution_dependencies.to_lock).to eq(expected_solution_deps)
-      end
-
-    end
-
-    context "And the default source is the chef server" do
-
-      include_context "chef server default source"
-
-      it "demands a solution using the git sourced cookbook" do
-        expect(demands).to eq([["git-sourced-cookbook", "= 8.6.7"]])
-      end
-
-      it "overrides the chef server universe with the git-sourced cookbook and deps" do
-        expected_artifacts_graph = external_cookbook_universe.dup
-        expected_artifacts_graph["git-sourced-cookbook"] = {
-          "8.6.7" => [ ["git-sourced-cookbook-dep", "~> 2.2" ] ],
-        }
-        expect(policyfile.artifacts_graph).to eq(expected_artifacts_graph)
-      end
-
-      it "uses the git sourced cookbook with remote dependencies in the solution" do
-        expect(policyfile).to receive(:ensure_cache_dir_exists)
-        expect(policyfile.graph_solution).to eq({ "git-sourced-cookbook" => "8.6.7", "git-sourced-cookbook-dep" => "2.9.0" })
-      end
-
-      it "includes the cookbook and dependencies in the solution dependencies" do
-        expected_solution_deps = {
-          "Policyfile" => [ [ "git-sourced-cookbook", ">= 0.0.0" ] ],
-          "dependencies" => {
-            "git-sourced-cookbook (8.6.7)" => [ [ "git-sourced-cookbook-dep", "~> 2.2" ] ],
-            "git-sourced-cookbook-dep (2.9.0)" => [],
-          },
-
-        }
-        expect(policyfile.solution_dependencies.to_lock).to eq(expected_solution_deps)
-      end
-
-    end
-  end
-
-  context "Given a local cookbook with a run list containing the local cookbook and another cookbook" do
-
-    let(:run_list) { ["local-cookbook", "remote-cb"] }
-
-    before do
-      policyfile.dsl.cookbook("local-cookbook", path: "foo/")
-      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:ensure_cached)
-      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:version).and_return("2.3.4")
-      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:dependencies).and_return([])
-    end
-
-    context "And the default source is the community site" do
-
-      include_context "community default source"
-
-      it "demands a solution with the local cookbook and any version of the other cookbook" do
-        expect(demands).to eq([["local-cookbook", "= 2.3.4"], ["remote-cb", ">= 0.0.0"]])
-      end
-
-      it "overrides the community universe with the local cookbook and deps" do
-        expected_artifacts_graph = external_cookbook_universe.dup
-        expected_artifacts_graph["local-cookbook"] = { "2.3.4" => [ ] }
-        expect(policyfile.artifacts_graph).to eq(expected_artifacts_graph)
-      end
-
-      it "uses the locally specified cookbook and remote cookbooks in the solution" do
-        expect(policyfile).to receive(:ensure_cache_dir_exists)
-        expect(policyfile.graph_solution).to eq({ "local-cookbook" => "2.3.4", "remote-cb" => "1.1.1" })
-      end
-
-      it "includes the cookbook and dependencies in the solution dependencies" do
-        expected_solution_deps = {
-          "Policyfile" => [ [ "local-cookbook", ">= 0.0.0" ] ],
-          "dependencies" => {
-            "local-cookbook (2.3.4)" => [],
-            "remote-cb (1.1.1)" => [],
-          },
-
-        }
-        expect(policyfile.solution_dependencies.to_lock).to eq(expected_solution_deps)
-      end
-
-    end
-
-    context "And the default source is the chef server" do
-
-      include_context "chef server default source"
-
-      it "demands a solution with the local cookbook and any version of the other cookbook" do
-        expect(demands).to eq([["local-cookbook", "= 2.3.4"], ["remote-cb", ">= 0.0.0"]])
-      end
-
-      it "overrides the chef-server universe with the local cookbook and deps" do
-        expected_artifacts_graph = external_cookbook_universe.dup
-        expected_artifacts_graph["local-cookbook"] = { "2.3.4" => [ ] }
-        expect(policyfile.artifacts_graph).to eq(expected_artifacts_graph)
-      end
-
-      it "uses the locally specified cookbook and remote cookbooks in the solution" do
-        expect(policyfile).to receive(:ensure_cache_dir_exists)
-        expect(policyfile.graph_solution).to eq({ "local-cookbook" => "2.3.4", "remote-cb" => "1.1.1" })
-      end
-
-      it "includes the cookbook and dependencies in the solution dependencies" do
-        expected_solution_deps = {
-          "Policyfile" => [ [ "local-cookbook", ">= 0.0.0" ] ],
-          "dependencies" => {
-            "local-cookbook (2.3.4)" => [],
-            "remote-cb (1.1.1)" => [],
-          },
-
-        }
-        expect(policyfile.solution_dependencies.to_lock).to eq(expected_solution_deps)
-      end
-
-    end
-  end
-
-  context "given a cookbook with a version constraint in the policyfile" do
-
-    include_context "community default source"
-
-    let(:run_list) { ["remote-cb"] }
-
-    before do
-      policyfile.dsl.cookbook("remote-cb", "~> 0.1")
-    end
-
-    it "demands a solution that matches the version constraint in the policyfile" do
-      expect(demands).to eq([["remote-cb", "~> 0.1"]])
-    end
-
-    it "emits a solution that satisfies the policyfile constraint" do
-      expect(policyfile).to receive(:ensure_cache_dir_exists)
-      expect(policyfile.graph_solution).to eq({ "remote-cb" => "0.1.0" })
-    end
-
-    it "includes the policyfile constraint in the solution dependencies" do
-      expected_solution_deps = {
-        "Policyfile" => [ [ "remote-cb", "~> 0.1" ] ],
-        "dependencies" => {
-          "remote-cb (0.1.0)" => [],
-        },
-
-      }
-      expect(policyfile.solution_dependencies.to_lock).to eq(expected_solution_deps)
-    end
-  end
-
-  context "given a cookbook that isn't in the run list is specified with a version constraint in the policyfile" do
-
-    include_context "community default source"
-
-    let(:run_list) { ["local-cookbook"] }
-
-    before do
-      policyfile.dsl.cookbook("remote-cb", "~> 0.1")
-
-      policyfile.dsl.cookbook("local-cookbook", path: "foo/")
-
-      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:ensure_cached)
-      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:version).and_return("2.3.4")
-      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:dependencies).and_return([])
-    end
-
-    it "demands a solution that matches the version constraint in the policyfile" do
-      expect(demands).to eq([["local-cookbook", "= 2.3.4"], ["remote-cb", "~> 0.1"]])
-    end
-
-    it "emits a solution that satisfies the policyfile constraint" do
-      expect(policyfile).to receive(:ensure_cache_dir_exists)
-      expect(policyfile.graph_solution).to eq({ "local-cookbook" => "2.3.4", "remote-cb" => "0.1.0" })
-    end
-
-    it "includes the policyfile constraint in the solution dependencies" do
-      expected_solution_deps = {
-        "Policyfile" => [ [ "local-cookbook", ">= 0.0.0" ], [ "remote-cb", "~> 0.1" ] ],
-        "dependencies" => {
-          "local-cookbook (2.3.4)" => [],
-          "remote-cb (0.1.0)" => [],
-        },
-
-      }
-      expect(policyfile.solution_dependencies.to_lock).to eq(expected_solution_deps)
-    end
-  end
-
-  context "Given a run_list and named run_lists" do
-
-    before do
-      policyfile.dsl.named_run_list(:foo, "local-cookbook", "nginx")
-      policyfile.dsl.named_run_list(:bar, "remote-cb", "nginx")
-      policyfile.dsl.run_list("private-cookbook", "nginx")
-    end
-
-    it "demands a solution that satisfies all of the run lists, with no duplicates" do
-      expect(policyfile.graph_demands).to include(["private-cookbook", ">= 0.0.0"])
-      expect(policyfile.graph_demands).to include(["nginx", ">= 0.0.0"])
-      expect(policyfile.graph_demands).to include(["remote-cb", ">= 0.0.0"])
-      expect(policyfile.graph_demands).to include(["local-cookbook", ">= 0.0.0"])
-
-      # ensure there are no duplicates:
-      expected_demands = [["private-cookbook", ">= 0.0.0"],
-                          ["nginx", ">= 0.0.0"],
-                          ["local-cookbook", ">= 0.0.0"],
-                          ["remote-cb", ">= 0.0.0"]]
-      expect(policyfile.graph_demands).to eq(expected_demands)
-    end
-
-  end
-
-  context "when using multiple default sources" do
-
-    include_context "community default source"
-
-    let(:run_list) { [ "repo-cookbook-one", "remote-cb", "remote-cb-two" ] }
-
-    before do
-      policyfile.default_source(:chef_repo, "path/to/repo")
-      allow(policyfile.default_source.last).to receive(:universe_graph).and_return(repo_cookbook_universe)
-    end
-
-    context "when the graphs don't conflict" do
-
-      before do
-        # This is on the community site
-        policyfile.dsl.cookbook("remote-cb")
-      end
-
-      let(:repo_cookbook_universe) do
-        {
-          "repo-cookbook-one" => {
-            "1.0.0" => [ ],
-          },
-
-          "repo-cookbook-two" => {
-            "9.9.9" => [ ["repo-cookbook-on-community-dep", "= 1.0.0"] ],
-          },
-
-          "private-cookbook" => {
-            "0.1.0" => [ ],
-          },
-        }
-      end
-
-      it "merges the graphs" do
-        merged = policyfile.remote_artifacts_graph
-        expected = external_cookbook_universe.merge(repo_cookbook_universe)
-
-        expect(merged).to eq(expected)
-      end
-
-      it "solves the graph demands using cookbooks from both sources" do
-        expected = { "repo-cookbook-one" => "1.0.0", "remote-cb" => "1.1.1", "remote-cb-two" => "1.1.1" }
-        expect(policyfile.graph_solution).to eq(expected)
-      end
-
-      it "finds the location of a cookbook declared via explicit `cookbook` with no source options" do
-        community_source = policyfile.default_source.first
-
-        expected_source_options = { artifactserver: "https://chef.example/url", version: "1.1.1" }
-
-        expect(community_source).to be_a(ChefDK::Policyfile::CommunityCookbookSource)
-        expect(community_source).to receive(:source_options_for).
-          with("remote-cb", "1.1.1").
-          and_return(expected_source_options)
-
-        location_spec = policyfile.create_spec_for_cookbook("remote-cb", "1.1.1")
-        expect(location_spec.source_options).to eq(expected_source_options)
-      end
-
-      it "sources cookbooks from the correct source when the cookbook doesn't have a `cookbook` entry" do
-        # these don't have `cookbook` entries in the Policyfile.rb, so they are nil
-        expect(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("repo-cookbook-one")).to be_nil
-        expect(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("remote-cb-two")).to be_nil
-
-        # We have to stub #source_options_for or else we'd need to stub the
-        # source options data inside the source object. That's getting a bit
-        # too deep into the source object's internals.
-
-        expected_repo_options = { path: "path/to/cookbook", version: "1.0.0" }
-        repo_source = policyfile.default_source.last
-        expect(repo_source).to be_a(ChefDK::Policyfile::ChefRepoCookbookSource)
-        expect(repo_source).to receive(:source_options_for).
-          with("repo-cookbook-one", "1.0.0").
-          and_return(expected_repo_options)
-
-        repo_cb_location = policyfile.create_spec_for_cookbook("repo-cookbook-one", "1.0.0")
-        expect(repo_cb_location.source_options).to eq(expected_repo_options)
-
-        expected_server_options = { artifactserver: "https://chef.example/url", version: "1.1.1" }
-        community_source = policyfile.default_source.first
-        expect(community_source).to be_a(ChefDK::Policyfile::CommunityCookbookSource)
-        expect(community_source).to receive(:source_options_for).
-          with("remote-cb-two", "1.1.1").
-          and_return(expected_server_options)
-
-        remote_cb_location = policyfile.create_spec_for_cookbook("remote-cb-two", "1.1.1")
-        expect(remote_cb_location.source_options).to eq(expected_server_options)
-      end
-
-    end
-
-    context "when the graphs conflict" do
-
-      let(:repo_cookbook_universe) do
-        {
-          "repo-cookbook-one" => {
-            "1.0.0" => [ ],
-          },
-
-          "repo-cookbook-two" => {
-            "9.9.9" => [ ["repo-cookbook-on-community-dep", "= 1.0.0"] ],
-          },
-
-          "private-cookbook" => {
-            "0.1.0" => [ ],
-          },
-
-          # NOTE: cookbooks are considered to conflict when both sources have
-          # cookbooks with the same name, regardless of whether any version
-          # numbers overlap.
-          #
-          # The before block does the equivalent to putting this in the
-          # Policyfile.rb:
-          #
-          #   cookbook "remote-cb"
-          #
-          # This makes the compiler take a slightly different code path than if
-          # the cookbook was just in the dep graphs.
-          "remote-cb" => {
-            "99.99.99" => [ ],
-          },
-
-          # This also conflicts, but only via the graphs
-          "remote-cb-two" => {
-            "1.2.3" => [ ],
-          },
-
-          # This has a dependency on a conflicting cookbook
-          "dep_on_conflicting_cookbook" => {
-
-            # Only the older cookbook has the conflicting dep, however we don't
-            # know how the dependency solver will solve this without doing more
-            # inspection of the graph, so the expected behavior is to error if
-            # any possible solution could have a conflict.
-            "1.0.0" => [ ["remote-cb-two", ">= 0.0.0" ] ],
-            "2.0.0" => [ ],
-
-          },
-
-        }
-      end
-
-      context "and the conflicting cookbook is in the run list" do
-
-        let(:run_list) { [ "repo-cookbook-one", "remote-cb", "remote-cb-two" ] }
-
-        context "and no explicit source is given for the conflicting cookbook" do
-
-          before do
-            # This is on the community site
-            policyfile.dsl.cookbook("remote-cb")
-          end
-
-          it "raises an error describing the conflict" do
-            repo_path = File.expand_path("path/to/repo")
-
-            expected_err = <<-ERROR
-Source supermarket(https://supermarket.chef.io) and chef_repo(#{repo_path}) contain conflicting cookbooks:
-- remote-cb
-- remote-cb-two
-
-You can set a preferred source to resolve this issue with code like:
-
-default_source :supermarket, "https://supermarket.chef.io" do |s|
-  s.preferred_for "remote-cb", "remote-cb-two"
-end
-ERROR
-
-            expect { policyfile.remote_artifacts_graph }.to raise_error do |error|
-              expect(error).to be_a(ChefDK::CookbookSourceConflict)
-              expect(error.message).to eq(expected_err)
-            end
-          end
-        end
-
-        context "and the conflicting cookbook has an explicit source in the Policyfile" do
-
-          before do
-            # This is on the community site
-            policyfile.dsl.cookbook("remote-cb", path: "path/to/remote-cb")
-            policyfile.dsl.cookbook("remote-cb-two", git: "git://git.example:user/remote-cb-two.git")
-            policyfile.error!
-          end
-
-          it "solves the graph" do
-            expect { policyfile.remote_artifacts_graph }.to_not raise_error
-          end
-
-          it "assigns the correct source options to the cookbook" do
-            remote_cb_source_opts = policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("remote-cb").source_options
-            expect(remote_cb_source_opts).to eq(path: "path/to/remote-cb")
-
-            remote_cb_two_source_opts = policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("remote-cb-two").source_options
-            expect(remote_cb_two_source_opts).to eq(git: "git://git.example:user/remote-cb-two.git")
-          end
-        end
-
-        context "and the conflicting cookbook has a preferred source" do
-
-          let(:community_source) { policyfile.dsl.default_source.first }
-
-          let(:repo_source) { policyfile.dsl.default_source.last }
-
-          let(:full_universe_graph) do
-            {
-              "remote-cb" => {
-                "1.1.1" => {
-                  "download_url" => "https://supermarket.chef.io/api/v1/cookbooks/remote-cb/versions/1.1.1/download",
-                },
-              },
-            }
-          end
-
-          let(:cookbook_version_paths) do
-            {
-              "remote-cb-two" => {
-                "1.1.1" => "path/to/repo/remote-cb-two",
-              },
-            }
-          end
-
-          before do
-            community_source.preferred_for "remote-cb"
-            allow(community_source).to receive(:full_community_graph).and_return(full_universe_graph)
-            allow(repo_source).to receive(:cookbook_version_paths).and_return(cookbook_version_paths)
-            repo_source.preferred_for "remote-cb-two"
-          end
-
-          it "solves the graph" do
-            expect { policyfile.remote_artifacts_graph }.to_not raise_error
-          end
-
-          it "assigns the correct source options to the cookbook" do
-            expected_remote_cb_source_opts = {
-              artifactserver: "https://supermarket.chef.io/api/v1/cookbooks/remote-cb/versions/1.1.1/download",
-              version: "1.1.1",
-            }
-            actual_remote_cb_source_opts = policyfile.create_spec_for_cookbook("remote-cb", "1.1.1").source_options
-            expect(actual_remote_cb_source_opts).to eq(expected_remote_cb_source_opts)
-
-            expected_remote_cb_two_source_opts = {
-              path: "path/to/repo/remote-cb-two",
-              version: "1.1.1",
-            }
-            actual_remote_cb_two_source_opts = policyfile.create_spec_for_cookbook("remote-cb-two", "1.1.1").source_options
-            expect(actual_remote_cb_two_source_opts).to eq(expected_remote_cb_two_source_opts)
-          end
-
-        end
-
-      end
-
-      context "when top-level cookbooks don't conflict, but dependencies could" do
-
-        let(:run_list) { [ "dep_on_conflicting_cookbook" ] }
-
-        it "raises an error describing the conflict" do
-          repo_path = File.expand_path("path/to/repo")
-
-          expected_err = <<-ERROR
-Source supermarket(https://supermarket.chef.io) and chef_repo(#{repo_path}) contain conflicting cookbooks:
-- remote-cb-two
-
-You can set a preferred source to resolve this issue with code like:
-
-default_source :supermarket, "https://supermarket.chef.io" do |s|
-  s.preferred_for "remote-cb-two"
-end
-ERROR
-
-          expect { policyfile.remote_artifacts_graph }.to raise_error do |error|
-            expect(error).to be_a(ChefDK::CookbookSourceConflict)
-            expect(error.message).to eq(expected_err)
-          end
-        end
-      end
-
-      context "when the conflicting cookbook could not be in the solution set" do
-
-        let(:run_list) { [ "local_cookbook" ] }
-
-        it "creates the merged graph without error" do
-          expect { policyfile.remote_artifacts_graph }.to_not raise_error
-          expect { policyfile.graph }.to_not raise_error
-        end
-
-        it "has an empty set of artifacts for the conflicting cookbook" do
-          expect(policyfile.remote_artifacts_graph["remote-cb"]).to eq({})
-          expect(policyfile.remote_artifacts_graph["remote-cb-two"]).to eq({})
-        end
-
-      end
-
-    end
-
-  end
-
-end
+#
+# Copyright:: Copyright (c) 2014-2018 Chef Software Inc.
+# License:: Apache License, Version 2.0
+#
+# Licensed under the Apache License, Version 2.0 (the "License");
+# you may not use this file except in compliance with the License.
+# You may obtain a copy of the License at
+#
+#     http://www.apache.org/licenses/LICENSE-2.0
+#
+# Unless required by applicable law or agreed to in writing, software
+# distributed under the License is distributed on an "AS IS" BASIS,
+# WITHOUT WARRANTIES OR CONDITIONS OF ANY KIND, either express or implied.
+# See the License for the specific language governing permissions and
+# limitations under the License.
+#
+
+require "spec_helper"
+require "chef-dk/policyfile_compiler"
+
+describe ChefDK::PolicyfileCompiler, "when expressing the Policyfile graph demands" do
+
+  let(:run_list) { [] }
+
+  let(:default_source) { nil }
+
+  let(:external_cookbook_universe) { {} }
+
+  let(:policyfile) do
+    policyfile = ChefDK::PolicyfileCompiler.new.build do |p|
+
+      p.default_source(*default_source) if default_source
+      p.run_list(*run_list)
+
+      allow(p.default_source.first).to receive(:universe_graph).and_return(external_cookbook_universe)
+    end
+
+    policyfile
+  end
+
+  let(:demands) { policyfile.graph_demands }
+
+  shared_context("community default source") do
+
+    let(:default_source) { [:community] }
+
+    let(:external_cookbook_universe) do
+      {
+        "nginx" => {
+          "1.0.0" => [ [ "apt", "~> 2.0" ], [ "yum", "~> 1.0" ] ],
+          "1.2.0" => [ [ "apt", "~> 2.1" ], [ "yum", "~> 1.0" ] ],
+          "2.0.0" => [ [ "apt", "~> 3.0" ], [ "yum", "~> 1.0" ], [ "ohai", "~> 2.0" ] ],
+        },
+
+        "mysql" => {
+          "3.0.0" => [ [ "apt", "~> 2.0" ], [ "yum", "~> 1.0" ] ],
+          "4.0.0" => [ [ "apt", "~> 2.4" ], [ "yum", "~> 1.1" ] ],
+          "5.0.0" => [ ],
+        },
+
+        "local-cookbook" => {
+          "9.9.9" => [ ["local-cookbook-on-community-dep", "= 1.0.0"] ],
+        },
+
+        "git-sourced-cookbook" => {
+          "10.10.10" => [ ["git-sourced-cookbook-dep", "= 1.0.0"] ],
+        },
+
+        "remote-cb" => {
+          "0.1.0" => [ ],
+          "1.1.1" => [ ],
+        },
+
+        "remote-cb-two" => {
+          "0.1.0" => [ ],
+          "1.1.1" => [ ],
+        },
+
+        "local-cookbook-dep-one" => {
+          "1.5.0" => [ ],
+        },
+
+        "git-sourced-cookbook-dep" => {
+          "2.8.0" => [ ],
+        },
+
+      }
+    end
+  end
+
+  shared_context("chef server default source") do
+
+    let(:default_source) { [:chef_server, "https://chef.example.com"] }
+
+    let(:external_cookbook_universe) do
+      {
+        "nginx" => {
+          "1.0.0" => [ [ "apt", "~> 2.0" ], [ "yum", "~> 1.0" ] ],
+        },
+
+        "mysql" => {
+          "5.0.0" => [ ],
+        },
+
+        "local-cookbook" => {
+          "9.9.9" => [ ["local-cookbook-on-community-dep", "= 1.0.0"] ],
+        },
+
+        "remote-cb" => {
+          "1.1.1" => [ ],
+        },
+
+        "git-sourced-cookbook" => {
+          "10.10.10" => [ ["git-sourced-cookbook-dep", "= 1.0.0"] ],
+        },
+
+        "private-cookbook" => {
+          "0.1.0" => [ ],
+        },
+
+        "local-cookbook-dep-one" => {
+          "1.6.0" => [ ],
+        },
+
+        "git-sourced-cookbook-dep" => {
+          "2.9.0" => [ ],
+        },
+
+      }
+    end
+  end
+
+  describe "when normalizing run_list items" do
+
+    it "normalizes a bare cookbook name" do
+      policyfile.run_list("local-cookbook")
+      expect(policyfile.normalized_run_list).to eq(["recipe[local-cookbook::default]"])
+    end
+
+    it "normalizes a bare cookbook::recipe item" do
+      policyfile.run_list("local-cookbook::server")
+      expect(policyfile.normalized_run_list).to eq(["recipe[local-cookbook::server]"])
+    end
+
+    it "normalizes a recipe[] item with implicit default" do
+      policyfile.run_list("recipe[local-cookbook]")
+      expect(policyfile.normalized_run_list).to eq(["recipe[local-cookbook::default]"])
+    end
+
+    it "does not modify a fully qualified recipe" do
+      policyfile.run_list("recipe[local-cookbook::jazz_hands]")
+      expect(policyfile.normalized_run_list).to eq(["recipe[local-cookbook::jazz_hands]"])
+    end
+
+    describe "in an alternate run list" do
+
+      it "normalizes a bare cookbook name" do
+        policyfile.named_run_list(:foo, "local-cookbook")
+        expect(policyfile.normalized_named_run_lists[:foo]).to eq(["recipe[local-cookbook::default]"])
+      end
+
+      it "normalizes a bare cookbook::recipe item" do
+        policyfile.named_run_list(:foo, "local-cookbook::server")
+        expect(policyfile.normalized_named_run_lists[:foo]).to eq(["recipe[local-cookbook::server]"])
+      end
+
+      it "normalizes a recipe[] item with implicit default" do
+        policyfile.named_run_list(:foo, "recipe[local-cookbook]")
+        expect(policyfile.normalized_named_run_lists[:foo]).to eq(["recipe[local-cookbook::default]"])
+      end
+
+      it "does not modify a fully qualified recipe" do
+        policyfile.named_run_list(:foo, "recipe[local-cookbook::jazz_hands]")
+        expect(policyfile.normalized_named_run_lists[:foo]).to eq(["recipe[local-cookbook::jazz_hands]"])
+      end
+
+    end
+  end
+
+  before do
+    expect(policyfile.errors).to eq([])
+  end
+
+  context "Given resolvable cookbook demands" do
+
+    let(:default_source) { [:supermarket] }
+
+    let(:trimmed_cookbook_universe) do
+      {
+        "remote-cb" => {
+          "1.1.1" => [ ],
+        },
+
+      }
+    end
+
+    let(:remote_cb_source_opts) do
+      { artifactserver: "https://supermarket.example/c/remote-cb/1.1.1/download", version: "1.1.1" }
+    end
+
+    let(:default_source_obj) do
+      instance_double("ChefDK::Policyfile::CommunityCookbookSource")
+    end
+
+    let(:cb_location_spec) do
+      s = "Cookbook 'remote-cb'"
+      s << " = 1.1.1"
+      s << " #{remote_cb_source_opts}"
+
+      instance_double("ChefDK::Policyfile::CookbookLocationSpecification",
+                      name: "remote-cb",
+                      version_constraint: Semverse::Constraint.new("= 1.1.1"),
+                      ensure_cached: nil,
+                      to_s: s)
+    end
+
+    before do
+      allow(policyfile).to receive(:default_source).and_return([default_source_obj])
+
+      allow(default_source_obj).to receive(:universe_graph).
+        and_return(trimmed_cookbook_universe)
+
+      allow(default_source_obj).to receive(:preferred_source_for?).
+        with("remote-cb").
+        and_return(true)
+
+      allow(default_source_obj).to receive(:source_options_for).
+        with("remote-cb", "1.1.1").
+        and_return(remote_cb_source_opts)
+
+      allow(ChefDK::Policyfile::CookbookLocationSpecification).to receive(:new).
+        with("remote-cb", "= 1.1.1", remote_cb_source_opts, policyfile.storage_config).
+        and_return(cb_location_spec)
+
+      allow(cb_location_spec).to receive(:installed?).and_return(true)
+    end
+
+    context "when the resolved cookbooks have the recipes requested by the run list" do
+
+      context "with an implied default recipe" do
+
+        before do
+          expect(cb_location_spec).to receive(:cookbook_has_recipe?).
+            with("default").
+            and_return(true)
+        end
+
+        let(:run_list) { ["remote-cb"] }
+
+        it "installs without error" do
+          expect { policyfile.install }.to_not raise_error
+        end
+
+      end
+
+      context "with an explicit recipe name" do
+
+        before do
+          expect(cb_location_spec).to receive(:cookbook_has_recipe?).
+            with("this_exists").
+            and_return(true)
+        end
+
+        let(:run_list) { ["remote-cb::this_exists"] }
+
+        it "installs without error" do
+          expect { policyfile.install }.to_not raise_error
+        end
+
+      end
+
+      context "with a fully qualified recipe name" do
+
+        before do
+          expect(cb_location_spec).to receive(:cookbook_has_recipe?).
+            with("this_exists").
+            and_return(true)
+        end
+
+        let(:run_list) { ["recipe[remote-cb::this_exists]"] }
+
+        it "installs without error" do
+          expect { policyfile.install }.to_not raise_error
+        end
+
+      end
+
+    end
+
+    context "when the resolved cookbooks do not have the recipes requested by the run list" do
+
+      context "when the cookbook with a missing recipe appears once in the run list" do
+        before do
+          expect(cb_location_spec).to receive(:cookbook_has_recipe?).
+            with("this_recipe_doesnt_exist").
+            and_return(false)
+        end
+
+        let(:run_list) { ["remote-cb::this_recipe_doesnt_exist"] }
+
+        it "emits an error" do
+          message = <<-MESSAGE
+The installed cookbooks do not contain all the recipes required by your run list(s):
+Cookbook 'remote-cb' = 1.1.1 {:artifactserver=>"https://supermarket.example/c/remote-cb/1.1.1/download", :version=>"1.1.1"}
+is missing the following required recipes:
+* this_recipe_doesnt_exist
+
+You may have specified an incorrect recipe in your run list,
+or this recipe may not be available in that version of the cookbook
+MESSAGE
+
+          expect { policyfile.install }.to raise_error do |e|
+            expect(e).to be_a(ChefDK::CookbookDoesNotContainRequiredRecipe)
+            expect(e.message).to eq(message)
+          end
+        end
+      end
+
+      context "when there is one valid item and one invalid item in the run list" do
+
+        before do
+          expect(cb_location_spec).to receive(:cookbook_has_recipe?).
+            with("default").
+            and_return(true)
+          expect(cb_location_spec).to receive(:cookbook_has_recipe?).
+            with("this_recipe_doesnt_exist").
+            and_return(false)
+        end
+
+        let(:run_list) { ["remote-cb::default", "remote-cb::this_recipe_doesnt_exist"] }
+
+        it "emits an error" do
+          message = <<-MESSAGE
+The installed cookbooks do not contain all the recipes required by your run list(s):
+Cookbook 'remote-cb' = 1.1.1 {:artifactserver=>"https://supermarket.example/c/remote-cb/1.1.1/download", :version=>"1.1.1"}
+is missing the following required recipes:
+* this_recipe_doesnt_exist
+
+You may have specified an incorrect recipe in your run list,
+or this recipe may not be available in that version of the cookbook
+MESSAGE
+
+          expect { policyfile.install }.to raise_error do |e|
+            expect(e).to be_a(ChefDK::CookbookDoesNotContainRequiredRecipe)
+            expect(e.message).to eq(message)
+          end
+        end
+
+      end
+
+      context "when there are multiple invalid items in the run list" do
+
+        before do
+          expect(cb_location_spec).to receive(:cookbook_has_recipe?).
+            with("this_recipe_doesnt_exist").
+            and_return(false)
+          expect(cb_location_spec).to receive(:cookbook_has_recipe?).
+            with("this_also_doesnt_exist").
+            and_return(false)
+        end
+
+        let(:run_list) { ["remote-cb::this_recipe_doesnt_exist", "remote-cb::this_also_doesnt_exist"] }
+
+        it "emits an error" do
+          message = <<-MESSAGE
+The installed cookbooks do not contain all the recipes required by your run list(s):
+Cookbook 'remote-cb' = 1.1.1 {:artifactserver=>"https://supermarket.example/c/remote-cb/1.1.1/download", :version=>"1.1.1"}
+is missing the following required recipes:
+* this_recipe_doesnt_exist
+* this_also_doesnt_exist
+
+You may have specified an incorrect recipe in your run list,
+or this recipe may not be available in that version of the cookbook
+MESSAGE
+
+          expect { policyfile.install }.to raise_error do |e|
+            expect(e).to be_a(ChefDK::CookbookDoesNotContainRequiredRecipe)
+            expect(e.message).to eq(message)
+          end
+        end
+
+      end
+
+    end
+  end
+
+  context "Given no local or git cookbooks, no default source, and an empty run list" do
+
+    let(:run_list) { [] }
+
+    it "has an empty set of demands" do
+      expect(demands).to eq([])
+    end
+
+    it "uses an empty universe for dependencies" do
+      expect(policyfile.artifacts_graph).to eq({})
+    end
+
+    it "has an empty solution" do
+      expect(policyfile).to receive(:ensure_cache_dir_exists)
+      expect(policyfile.graph_solution).to eq({})
+    end
+
+    it "has an empty set of solution_dependencies" do
+      expected_solution_deps = {
+        "Policyfile" => [],
+        "dependencies" => {},
+      }
+      expect(policyfile.solution_dependencies.to_lock).to eq(expected_solution_deps)
+    end
+  end
+
+  context "Given a run list and no local or git cookbooks" do
+
+    let(:run_list) { ["remote-cb"] }
+
+    context "with no default source" do
+
+      it "fails to locate the cookbook" do
+        expect { policyfile.graph_solution }.to raise_error(Solve::Errors::NoSolutionError)
+      end
+
+      context "when the policyfile also has a `cookbook` entry for the run list item" do
+
+        before do
+          policyfile.dsl.cookbook "remote-cb"
+        end
+
+        it "fails to locate the cookbook" do
+          expect { policyfile.graph_solution }.to raise_error(Solve::Errors::NoSolutionError)
+        end
+
+      end
+
+    end
+
+    context "And the default source is the community site" do
+
+      include_context "community default source"
+
+      it "has an unconstrained demand on the required cookbooks" do
+        expect(demands).to eq([["remote-cb", ">= 0.0.0"]])
+      end
+
+      it "uses the community site universe for dependencies" do
+        expect(policyfile.artifacts_graph).to eq(external_cookbook_universe)
+      end
+
+      it "uses the community cookbook in the solution" do
+        expect(policyfile).to receive(:ensure_cache_dir_exists)
+        expect(policyfile.graph_solution).to eq({ "remote-cb" => "1.1.1" })
+      end
+
+      it "includes the cookbook in the solution dependencies" do
+        expected_solution_deps = {
+          "Policyfile" => [],
+          "dependencies" => { "remote-cb (1.1.1)" => [] },
+        }
+        expect(policyfile.solution_dependencies.to_lock).to eq(expected_solution_deps)
+      end
+
+    end
+
+    context "And the default source is the chef-server" do
+
+      include_context "chef server default source"
+
+      it "has an unconstrained demand on the required cookbooks" do
+        expect(demands).to eq([["remote-cb", ">= 0.0.0"]])
+      end
+
+      it "uses the chef-server universe for dependencies" do
+        expect(policyfile.artifacts_graph).to eq(external_cookbook_universe)
+      end
+
+      it "uses the chef-server cookbook in the solution" do
+        expect(policyfile).to receive(:ensure_cache_dir_exists)
+        expect(policyfile.graph_solution).to eq({ "remote-cb" => "1.1.1" })
+      end
+    end
+  end
+
+  context "Given a local cookbook and only that cookbook in the run list" do
+
+    let(:run_list) { ["local-cookbook"] }
+
+    before do
+      policyfile.dsl.cookbook("local-cookbook", path: "/foo")
+      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:version).and_return("2.3.4")
+      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:dependencies).and_return([])
+      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:ensure_cached).and_return(true)
+    end
+
+    it "demands a solution using the local cookbook" do
+      expect(demands).to eq([["local-cookbook", "= 2.3.4"]])
+    end
+
+    it "includes the local cookbook in the artifact universe" do
+      expected_artifacts_graph = {
+        "local-cookbook" => { "2.3.4" => [] },
+      }
+      expect(policyfile.artifacts_graph).to eq(expected_artifacts_graph)
+    end
+
+    it "includes the cookbook in the solution dependencies" do
+      expected_solution_deps = {
+        "Policyfile" => [ [ "local-cookbook", ">= 0.0.0" ] ],
+        "dependencies" => { "local-cookbook (2.3.4)" => [] },
+      }
+      expect(policyfile.solution_dependencies.to_lock).to eq(expected_solution_deps)
+    end
+
+  end
+
+  context "Given a local cookbook with a dependency and only the local cookbook in the run list" do
+
+    let(:run_list) { ["local-cookbook"] }
+
+    context "And the default source is the community site" do
+
+      include_context "community default source"
+
+      before do
+        policyfile.dsl.cookbook("local-cookbook", path: "foo/")
+        allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:ensure_cached)
+        allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:version).and_return("2.3.4")
+        allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:dependencies).and_return([ [ "local-cookbook-dep-one", "~> 1.0"] ])
+      end
+
+      it "demands a solution using the local cookbook" do
+        expect(demands).to eq([["local-cookbook", "= 2.3.4"]])
+      end
+
+      it "overrides the community site universe with the local cookbook and its dependencies" do
+        expected_artifacts_graph = external_cookbook_universe.dup
+        expected_artifacts_graph["local-cookbook"] = {
+          "2.3.4" => [ [ "local-cookbook-dep-one", "~> 1.0" ] ],
+        }
+        expect(policyfile.artifacts_graph).to eq(expected_artifacts_graph)
+      end
+
+      it "uses the local cookbook in the solution and gets dependencies remotely" do
+        expect(policyfile).to receive(:ensure_cache_dir_exists)
+        expect(policyfile.graph_solution).to eq({ "local-cookbook" => "2.3.4", "local-cookbook-dep-one" => "1.5.0" })
+      end
+
+      it "includes the cookbook and dependencies in the solution dependencies" do
+        expected_solution_deps = {
+          "Policyfile" => [ [ "local-cookbook", ">= 0.0.0" ] ],
+          "dependencies" => {
+            "local-cookbook (2.3.4)" => [[ "local-cookbook-dep-one", "~> 1.0"]],
+            "local-cookbook-dep-one (1.5.0)" => [],
+          },
+
+        }
+        expect(policyfile.solution_dependencies.to_lock).to eq(expected_solution_deps)
+      end
+
+    end
+    context "And the default source is the chef server" do
+
+      include_context "chef server default source"
+
+      before do
+        policyfile.dsl.cookbook("local-cookbook", path: "foo/")
+        allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:ensure_cached)
+        allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:version).and_return("2.3.4")
+        allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:dependencies).and_return([ [ "local-cookbook-dep-one", "~> 1.0"] ])
+      end
+
+      it "demands a solution using the local cookbook" do
+        expect(demands).to eq([["local-cookbook", "= 2.3.4"]])
+      end
+
+      it "overrides the chef server universe with the local cookbook and its dependencies" do
+        # all versions of "local-cookbook" from the cookbook site universe
+        # should be removed so we won't run into trouble if there's a community
+        # cookbook with the same name and version but different deps.
+        expected_artifacts_graph = external_cookbook_universe.dup
+        expected_artifacts_graph["local-cookbook"] = {
+          "2.3.4" => [ [ "local-cookbook-dep-one", "~> 1.0" ] ],
+        }
+        expect(policyfile.artifacts_graph).to eq(expected_artifacts_graph)
+      end
+
+      it "uses the local cookbook in the solution and gets dependencies remotely" do
+        expect(policyfile).to receive(:ensure_cache_dir_exists)
+        expect(policyfile.graph_solution).to eq({ "local-cookbook" => "2.3.4", "local-cookbook-dep-one" => "1.6.0" })
+      end
+
+      it "includes the cookbook and dependencies in the solution dependencies" do
+        expected_solution_deps = {
+          "Policyfile" => [ [ "local-cookbook", ">= 0.0.0" ] ],
+          "dependencies" => {
+            "local-cookbook (2.3.4)" => [[ "local-cookbook-dep-one", "~> 1.0"]],
+            "local-cookbook-dep-one (1.6.0)" => [],
+          },
+
+        }
+        expect(policyfile.solution_dependencies.to_lock).to eq(expected_solution_deps)
+      end
+
+    end
+  end
+
+  context "Given a git-sourced cookbook with no dependencies and only the git cookbook in the run list" do
+
+    let(:run_list) { ["git-sourced-cookbook"] }
+
+    before do
+      policyfile.dsl.cookbook("git-sourced-cookbook", git: "git://git.example.org:user/a-cookbook.git")
+      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("git-sourced-cookbook")).to receive(:ensure_cached)
+      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("git-sourced-cookbook")).to receive(:version).and_return("8.6.7")
+      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("git-sourced-cookbook")).to receive(:dependencies).and_return([ ])
+    end
+
+    it "demands a solution using the git sourced cookbook" do
+      expect(demands).to eq([["git-sourced-cookbook", "= 8.6.7"]])
+    end
+
+    it "includes the git-sourced cookbook in the universe graph" do
+      expected_artifacts_graph = {
+        "git-sourced-cookbook" => { "8.6.7" => [ ] },
+      }
+      expect(policyfile.artifacts_graph).to eq(expected_artifacts_graph)
+    end
+
+    it "uses the git sourced cookbook in the solution" do
+      expect(policyfile).to receive(:ensure_cache_dir_exists)
+      expect(policyfile.graph_solution).to eq({ "git-sourced-cookbook" => "8.6.7" })
+    end
+
+    it "includes the cookbook and dependencies in the solution dependencies" do
+      expected_solution_deps = {
+        "Policyfile" => [ [ "git-sourced-cookbook", ">= 0.0.0" ] ],
+        "dependencies" => {
+          "git-sourced-cookbook (8.6.7)" => [],
+        },
+
+      }
+      expect(policyfile.solution_dependencies.to_lock).to eq(expected_solution_deps)
+    end
+
+  end
+
+  context "Given a git-sourced cookbook with a dependency and only the git cookbook in the run list" do
+
+    let(:run_list) { ["git-sourced-cookbook"] }
+
+    before do
+      policyfile.dsl.cookbook("git-sourced-cookbook", git: "git://git.example.org:user/a-cookbook.git")
+      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("git-sourced-cookbook")).to receive(:ensure_cached)
+      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("git-sourced-cookbook")).to receive(:version).and_return("8.6.7")
+      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("git-sourced-cookbook")).to receive(:dependencies).and_return([ ["git-sourced-cookbook-dep", "~> 2.2" ] ])
+    end
+
+    context "And the default source is the community site" do
+
+      include_context "community default source"
+
+      it "demands a solution using the git sourced cookbook" do
+        expect(demands).to eq([["git-sourced-cookbook", "= 8.6.7"]])
+      end
+
+      it "overrides the community site universe with the git-sourced cookbook and deps" do
+        expected_artifacts_graph = external_cookbook_universe.dup
+        expected_artifacts_graph["git-sourced-cookbook"] = {
+          "8.6.7" => [ ["git-sourced-cookbook-dep", "~> 2.2" ] ],
+        }
+        expect(policyfile.artifacts_graph).to eq(expected_artifacts_graph)
+      end
+
+      it "uses the git sourced cookbook with remote dependencies in the solution" do
+        expect(policyfile).to receive(:ensure_cache_dir_exists)
+        expect(policyfile.graph_solution).to eq({ "git-sourced-cookbook" => "8.6.7", "git-sourced-cookbook-dep" => "2.8.0" })
+      end
+
+      it "includes the cookbook and dependencies in the solution dependencies" do
+        expected_solution_deps = {
+          "Policyfile" => [ [ "git-sourced-cookbook", ">= 0.0.0" ] ],
+          "dependencies" => {
+            "git-sourced-cookbook (8.6.7)" => [ [ "git-sourced-cookbook-dep", "~> 2.2" ] ],
+            "git-sourced-cookbook-dep (2.8.0)" => [],
+          },
+
+        }
+        expect(policyfile.solution_dependencies.to_lock).to eq(expected_solution_deps)
+      end
+
+    end
+
+    context "And the default source is the chef server" do
+
+      include_context "chef server default source"
+
+      it "demands a solution using the git sourced cookbook" do
+        expect(demands).to eq([["git-sourced-cookbook", "= 8.6.7"]])
+      end
+
+      it "overrides the chef server universe with the git-sourced cookbook and deps" do
+        expected_artifacts_graph = external_cookbook_universe.dup
+        expected_artifacts_graph["git-sourced-cookbook"] = {
+          "8.6.7" => [ ["git-sourced-cookbook-dep", "~> 2.2" ] ],
+        }
+        expect(policyfile.artifacts_graph).to eq(expected_artifacts_graph)
+      end
+
+      it "uses the git sourced cookbook with remote dependencies in the solution" do
+        expect(policyfile).to receive(:ensure_cache_dir_exists)
+        expect(policyfile.graph_solution).to eq({ "git-sourced-cookbook" => "8.6.7", "git-sourced-cookbook-dep" => "2.9.0" })
+      end
+
+      it "includes the cookbook and dependencies in the solution dependencies" do
+        expected_solution_deps = {
+          "Policyfile" => [ [ "git-sourced-cookbook", ">= 0.0.0" ] ],
+          "dependencies" => {
+            "git-sourced-cookbook (8.6.7)" => [ [ "git-sourced-cookbook-dep", "~> 2.2" ] ],
+            "git-sourced-cookbook-dep (2.9.0)" => [],
+          },
+
+        }
+        expect(policyfile.solution_dependencies.to_lock).to eq(expected_solution_deps)
+      end
+
+    end
+  end
+
+  context "Given a local cookbook with a run list containing the local cookbook and another cookbook" do
+
+    let(:run_list) { ["local-cookbook", "remote-cb"] }
+
+    before do
+      policyfile.dsl.cookbook("local-cookbook", path: "foo/")
+      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:ensure_cached)
+      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:version).and_return("2.3.4")
+      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:dependencies).and_return([])
+    end
+
+    context "And the default source is the community site" do
+
+      include_context "community default source"
+
+      it "demands a solution with the local cookbook and any version of the other cookbook" do
+        expect(demands).to eq([["local-cookbook", "= 2.3.4"], ["remote-cb", ">= 0.0.0"]])
+      end
+
+      it "overrides the community universe with the local cookbook and deps" do
+        expected_artifacts_graph = external_cookbook_universe.dup
+        expected_artifacts_graph["local-cookbook"] = { "2.3.4" => [ ] }
+        expect(policyfile.artifacts_graph).to eq(expected_artifacts_graph)
+      end
+
+      it "uses the locally specified cookbook and remote cookbooks in the solution" do
+        expect(policyfile).to receive(:ensure_cache_dir_exists)
+        expect(policyfile.graph_solution).to eq({ "local-cookbook" => "2.3.4", "remote-cb" => "1.1.1" })
+      end
+
+      it "includes the cookbook and dependencies in the solution dependencies" do
+        expected_solution_deps = {
+          "Policyfile" => [ [ "local-cookbook", ">= 0.0.0" ] ],
+          "dependencies" => {
+            "local-cookbook (2.3.4)" => [],
+            "remote-cb (1.1.1)" => [],
+          },
+
+        }
+        expect(policyfile.solution_dependencies.to_lock).to eq(expected_solution_deps)
+      end
+
+    end
+
+    context "And the default source is the chef server" do
+
+      include_context "chef server default source"
+
+      it "demands a solution with the local cookbook and any version of the other cookbook" do
+        expect(demands).to eq([["local-cookbook", "= 2.3.4"], ["remote-cb", ">= 0.0.0"]])
+      end
+
+      it "overrides the chef-server universe with the local cookbook and deps" do
+        expected_artifacts_graph = external_cookbook_universe.dup
+        expected_artifacts_graph["local-cookbook"] = { "2.3.4" => [ ] }
+        expect(policyfile.artifacts_graph).to eq(expected_artifacts_graph)
+      end
+
+      it "uses the locally specified cookbook and remote cookbooks in the solution" do
+        expect(policyfile).to receive(:ensure_cache_dir_exists)
+        expect(policyfile.graph_solution).to eq({ "local-cookbook" => "2.3.4", "remote-cb" => "1.1.1" })
+      end
+
+      it "includes the cookbook and dependencies in the solution dependencies" do
+        expected_solution_deps = {
+          "Policyfile" => [ [ "local-cookbook", ">= 0.0.0" ] ],
+          "dependencies" => {
+            "local-cookbook (2.3.4)" => [],
+            "remote-cb (1.1.1)" => [],
+          },
+
+        }
+        expect(policyfile.solution_dependencies.to_lock).to eq(expected_solution_deps)
+      end
+
+    end
+  end
+
+  context "given a cookbook with a version constraint in the policyfile" do
+
+    include_context "community default source"
+
+    let(:run_list) { ["remote-cb"] }
+
+    before do
+      policyfile.dsl.cookbook("remote-cb", "~> 0.1")
+    end
+
+    it "demands a solution that matches the version constraint in the policyfile" do
+      expect(demands).to eq([["remote-cb", "~> 0.1"]])
+    end
+
+    it "emits a solution that satisfies the policyfile constraint" do
+      expect(policyfile).to receive(:ensure_cache_dir_exists)
+      expect(policyfile.graph_solution).to eq({ "remote-cb" => "0.1.0" })
+    end
+
+    it "includes the policyfile constraint in the solution dependencies" do
+      expected_solution_deps = {
+        "Policyfile" => [ [ "remote-cb", "~> 0.1" ] ],
+        "dependencies" => {
+          "remote-cb (0.1.0)" => [],
+        },
+
+      }
+      expect(policyfile.solution_dependencies.to_lock).to eq(expected_solution_deps)
+    end
+  end
+
+  context "given a cookbook that isn't in the run list is specified with a version constraint in the policyfile" do
+
+    include_context "community default source"
+
+    let(:run_list) { ["local-cookbook"] }
+
+    before do
+      policyfile.dsl.cookbook("remote-cb", "~> 0.1")
+
+      policyfile.dsl.cookbook("local-cookbook", path: "foo/")
+
+      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:ensure_cached)
+      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:version).and_return("2.3.4")
+      allow(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("local-cookbook")).to receive(:dependencies).and_return([])
+    end
+
+    it "demands a solution that matches the version constraint in the policyfile" do
+      expect(demands).to eq([["local-cookbook", "= 2.3.4"], ["remote-cb", "~> 0.1"]])
+    end
+
+    it "emits a solution that satisfies the policyfile constraint" do
+      expect(policyfile).to receive(:ensure_cache_dir_exists)
+      expect(policyfile.graph_solution).to eq({ "local-cookbook" => "2.3.4", "remote-cb" => "0.1.0" })
+    end
+
+    it "includes the policyfile constraint in the solution dependencies" do
+      expected_solution_deps = {
+        "Policyfile" => [ [ "local-cookbook", ">= 0.0.0" ], [ "remote-cb", "~> 0.1" ] ],
+        "dependencies" => {
+          "local-cookbook (2.3.4)" => [],
+          "remote-cb (0.1.0)" => [],
+        },
+
+      }
+      expect(policyfile.solution_dependencies.to_lock).to eq(expected_solution_deps)
+    end
+  end
+
+  context "Given a run_list and named run_lists" do
+
+    before do
+      policyfile.dsl.named_run_list(:foo, "local-cookbook", "nginx")
+      policyfile.dsl.named_run_list(:bar, "remote-cb", "nginx")
+      policyfile.dsl.run_list("private-cookbook", "nginx")
+    end
+
+    it "demands a solution that satisfies all of the run lists, with no duplicates" do
+      expect(policyfile.graph_demands).to include(["private-cookbook", ">= 0.0.0"])
+      expect(policyfile.graph_demands).to include(["nginx", ">= 0.0.0"])
+      expect(policyfile.graph_demands).to include(["remote-cb", ">= 0.0.0"])
+      expect(policyfile.graph_demands).to include(["local-cookbook", ">= 0.0.0"])
+
+      # ensure there are no duplicates:
+      expected_demands = [["private-cookbook", ">= 0.0.0"],
+                          ["nginx", ">= 0.0.0"],
+                          ["local-cookbook", ">= 0.0.0"],
+                          ["remote-cb", ">= 0.0.0"]]
+      expect(policyfile.graph_demands).to eq(expected_demands)
+    end
+
+  end
+
+  context "when using multiple default sources" do
+
+    include_context "community default source"
+
+    let(:run_list) { [ "repo-cookbook-one", "remote-cb", "remote-cb-two" ] }
+
+    before do
+      policyfile.default_source(:chef_repo, "path/to/repo")
+      allow(policyfile.default_source.last).to receive(:universe_graph).and_return(repo_cookbook_universe)
+    end
+
+    context "when the graphs don't conflict" do
+
+      before do
+        # This is on the community site
+        policyfile.dsl.cookbook("remote-cb")
+      end
+
+      let(:repo_cookbook_universe) do
+        {
+          "repo-cookbook-one" => {
+            "1.0.0" => [ ],
+          },
+
+          "repo-cookbook-two" => {
+            "9.9.9" => [ ["repo-cookbook-on-community-dep", "= 1.0.0"] ],
+          },
+
+          "private-cookbook" => {
+            "0.1.0" => [ ],
+          },
+        }
+      end
+
+      it "merges the graphs" do
+        merged = policyfile.remote_artifacts_graph
+        expected = external_cookbook_universe.merge(repo_cookbook_universe)
+
+        expect(merged).to eq(expected)
+      end
+
+      it "solves the graph demands using cookbooks from both sources" do
+        expected = { "repo-cookbook-one" => "1.0.0", "remote-cb" => "1.1.1", "remote-cb-two" => "1.1.1" }
+        expect(policyfile.graph_solution).to eq(expected)
+      end
+
+      it "finds the location of a cookbook declared via explicit `cookbook` with no source options" do
+        community_source = policyfile.default_source.first
+
+        expected_source_options = { artifactserver: "https://chef.example/url", version: "1.1.1" }
+
+        expect(community_source).to be_a(ChefDK::Policyfile::CommunityCookbookSource)
+        expect(community_source).to receive(:source_options_for).
+          with("remote-cb", "1.1.1").
+          and_return(expected_source_options)
+
+        location_spec = policyfile.create_spec_for_cookbook("remote-cb", "1.1.1")
+        expect(location_spec.source_options).to eq(expected_source_options)
+      end
+
+      it "sources cookbooks from the correct source when the cookbook doesn't have a `cookbook` entry" do
+        # these don't have `cookbook` entries in the Policyfile.rb, so they are nil
+        expect(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("repo-cookbook-one")).to be_nil
+        expect(policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("remote-cb-two")).to be_nil
+
+        # We have to stub #source_options_for or else we'd need to stub the
+        # source options data inside the source object. That's getting a bit
+        # too deep into the source object's internals.
+
+        expected_repo_options = { path: "path/to/cookbook", version: "1.0.0" }
+        repo_source = policyfile.default_source.last
+        expect(repo_source).to be_a(ChefDK::Policyfile::ChefRepoCookbookSource)
+        expect(repo_source).to receive(:source_options_for).
+          with("repo-cookbook-one", "1.0.0").
+          and_return(expected_repo_options)
+
+        repo_cb_location = policyfile.create_spec_for_cookbook("repo-cookbook-one", "1.0.0")
+        expect(repo_cb_location.source_options).to eq(expected_repo_options)
+
+        expected_server_options = { artifactserver: "https://chef.example/url", version: "1.1.1" }
+        community_source = policyfile.default_source.first
+        expect(community_source).to be_a(ChefDK::Policyfile::CommunityCookbookSource)
+        expect(community_source).to receive(:source_options_for).
+          with("remote-cb-two", "1.1.1").
+          and_return(expected_server_options)
+
+        remote_cb_location = policyfile.create_spec_for_cookbook("remote-cb-two", "1.1.1")
+        expect(remote_cb_location.source_options).to eq(expected_server_options)
+      end
+
+    end
+
+    context "when the graphs conflict" do
+
+      let(:repo_cookbook_universe) do
+        {
+          "repo-cookbook-one" => {
+            "1.0.0" => [ ],
+          },
+
+          "repo-cookbook-two" => {
+            "9.9.9" => [ ["repo-cookbook-on-community-dep", "= 1.0.0"] ],
+          },
+
+          "private-cookbook" => {
+            "0.1.0" => [ ],
+          },
+
+          # NOTE: cookbooks are considered to conflict when both sources have
+          # cookbooks with the same name, regardless of whether any version
+          # numbers overlap.
+          #
+          # The before block does the equivalent to putting this in the
+          # Policyfile.rb:
+          #
+          #   cookbook "remote-cb"
+          #
+          # This makes the compiler take a slightly different code path than if
+          # the cookbook was just in the dep graphs.
+          "remote-cb" => {
+            "99.99.99" => [ ],
+          },
+
+          # This also conflicts, but only via the graphs
+          "remote-cb-two" => {
+            "1.2.3" => [ ],
+          },
+
+          # This has a dependency on a conflicting cookbook
+          "dep_on_conflicting_cookbook" => {
+
+            # Only the older cookbook has the conflicting dep, however we don't
+            # know how the dependency solver will solve this without doing more
+            # inspection of the graph, so the expected behavior is to error if
+            # any possible solution could have a conflict.
+            "1.0.0" => [ ["remote-cb-two", ">= 0.0.0" ] ],
+            "2.0.0" => [ ],
+
+          },
+
+        }
+      end
+
+      context "and the conflicting cookbook is in the run list" do
+
+        let(:run_list) { [ "repo-cookbook-one", "remote-cb", "remote-cb-two" ] }
+
+        context "and no explicit source is given for the conflicting cookbook" do
+
+          before do
+            # This is on the community site
+            policyfile.dsl.cookbook("remote-cb")
+          end
+
+          it "raises an error describing the conflict" do
+            repo_path = File.expand_path("path/to/repo")
+
+            expected_err = <<-ERROR
+Source supermarket(https://supermarket.chef.io) and chef_repo(#{repo_path}) contain conflicting cookbooks:
+- remote-cb
+- remote-cb-two
+
+You can set a preferred source to resolve this issue with code like:
+
+default_source :supermarket, "https://supermarket.chef.io" do |s|
+  s.preferred_for "remote-cb", "remote-cb-two"
+end
+ERROR
+
+            expect { policyfile.remote_artifacts_graph }.to raise_error do |error|
+              expect(error).to be_a(ChefDK::CookbookSourceConflict)
+              expect(error.message).to eq(expected_err)
+            end
+          end
+        end
+
+        context "and the conflicting cookbook has an explicit source in the Policyfile" do
+
+          before do
+            # This is on the community site
+            policyfile.dsl.cookbook("remote-cb", path: "path/to/remote-cb")
+            policyfile.dsl.cookbook("remote-cb-two", git: "git://git.example:user/remote-cb-two.git")
+            policyfile.error!
+          end
+
+          it "solves the graph" do
+            expect { policyfile.remote_artifacts_graph }.to_not raise_error
+          end
+
+          it "assigns the correct source options to the cookbook" do
+            remote_cb_source_opts = policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("remote-cb").source_options
+            expect(remote_cb_source_opts).to eq(path: "path/to/remote-cb")
+
+            remote_cb_two_source_opts = policyfile.cookbook_location_spec_for("remote-cb-two").source_options
+            expect(remote_cb_two_source_opts).to eq(git: "git://git.example:user/remote-cb-two.git")
+          end
+        end
+
+        context "and the conflicting cookbook has a preferred source" do
+
+          let(:community_source) { policyfile.dsl.default_source.first }
+
+          let(:repo_source) { policyfile.dsl.default_source.last }
+
+          let(:full_universe_graph) do
+            {
+              "remote-cb" => {
+                "1.1.1" => {
+                  "download_url" => "https://supermarket.chef.io/api/v1/cookbooks/remote-cb/versions/1.1.1/download",
+                },
+              },
+            }
+          end
+
+          let(:cookbook_version_paths) do
+            {
+              "remote-cb-two" => {
+                "1.1.1" => "path/to/repo/remote-cb-two",
+              },
+            }
+          end
+
+          before do
+            community_source.preferred_for "remote-cb"
+            allow(community_source).to receive(:full_community_graph).and_return(full_universe_graph)
+            allow(repo_source).to receive(:cookbook_version_paths).and_return(cookbook_version_paths)
+            repo_source.preferred_for "remote-cb-two"
+          end
+
+          it "solves the graph" do
+            expect { policyfile.remote_artifacts_graph }.to_not raise_error
+          end
+
+          it "assigns the correct source options to the cookbook" do
+            expected_remote_cb_source_opts = {
+              artifactserver: "https://supermarket.chef.io/api/v1/cookbooks/remote-cb/versions/1.1.1/download",
+              version: "1.1.1",
+            }
+            actual_remote_cb_source_opts = policyfile.create_spec_for_cookbook("remote-cb", "1.1.1").source_options
+            expect(actual_remote_cb_source_opts).to eq(expected_remote_cb_source_opts)
+
+            expected_remote_cb_two_source_opts = {
+              path: "path/to/repo/remote-cb-two",
+              version: "1.1.1",
+            }
+            actual_remote_cb_two_source_opts = policyfile.create_spec_for_cookbook("remote-cb-two", "1.1.1").source_options
+            expect(actual_remote_cb_two_source_opts).to eq(expected_remote_cb_two_source_opts)
+          end
+
+        end
+
+      end
+
+      context "when top-level cookbooks don't conflict, but dependencies could" do
+
+        let(:run_list) { [ "dep_on_conflicting_cookbook" ] }
+
+        it "raises an error describing the conflict" do
+          repo_path = File.expand_path("path/to/repo")
+
+          expected_err = <<-ERROR
+Source supermarket(https://supermarket.chef.io) and chef_repo(#{repo_path}) contain conflicting cookbooks:
+- remote-cb-two
+
+You can set a preferred source to resolve this issue with code like:
+
+default_source :supermarket, "https://supermarket.chef.io" do |s|
+  s.preferred_for "remote-cb-two"
+end
+ERROR
+
+          expect { policyfile.remote_artifacts_graph }.to raise_error do |error|
+            expect(error).to be_a(ChefDK::CookbookSourceConflict)
+            expect(error.message).to eq(expected_err)
+          end
+        end
+      end
+
+      context "when the conflicting cookbook could not be in the solution set" do
+
+        let(:run_list) { [ "local_cookbook" ] }
+
+        it "creates the merged graph without error" do
+          expect { policyfile.remote_artifacts_graph }.to_not raise_error
+          expect { policyfile.graph }.to_not raise_error
+        end
+
+        it "has an empty set of artifacts for the conflicting cookbook" do
+          expect(policyfile.remote_artifacts_graph["remote-cb"]).to eq({})
+          expect(policyfile.remote_artifacts_graph["remote-cb-two"]).to eq({})
+        end
+
+      end
+
+    end
+
+  end
+
+end