regscale-cli 6.25.1.0__py3-none-any.whl → 6.26.0.0__py3-none-any.whl

tests/regscale/integrations/test_control_matcher.py

@@ -0,0 +1,1314 @@
+#!/usr/bin/env python3
+# -*- coding: utf-8 -*-
+"""
+Unit and integration tests for control_matcher module
+
+This module provides comprehensive test coverage for the ControlMatcher class,
+including control ID parsing, catalog searches, implementation matching, and caching.
+"""
+
+import logging
+from typing import Dict, List, Optional, Tuple
+from unittest.mock import MagicMock, Mock, patch
+
+import pytest
+
+from regscale.core.app.api import Api
+from regscale.core.app.application import Application
+from regscale.integrations.control_matcher import ControlMatcher
+from regscale.models.regscale_models.control_implementation import ControlImplementation
+from regscale.models.regscale_models.security_control import SecurityControl
+
+
+class TestControlMatcherInit:
+    """Test cases for ControlMatcher initialization"""
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_init_with_no_app(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class):
+        """Test ControlMatcher initialization without providing an app"""
+        mock_app = MagicMock(spec=Application)
+        mock_app_class.return_value = mock_app
+        mock_api = MagicMock(spec=Api)
+        mock_api_class.return_value = mock_api
+
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        mock_app_class.assert_called_once()
+        mock_api_class.assert_called_once()
+        assert matcher.app == mock_app
+        assert matcher.api == mock_api
+        assert matcher._catalog_cache == {}
+        assert matcher._control_impl_cache == {}
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_init_with_app(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class):
+        """Test ControlMatcher initialization with an app instance"""
+        # Create a mock app that is truthy (has a return value)
+        mock_app = Mock(spec=Application)
+        # Set a non-None return value to make the mock truthy
+        mock_app.return_value = MagicMock()
+
+        mock_api = MagicMock(spec=Api)
+        mock_api_class.return_value = mock_api
+
+        matcher = ControlMatcher(app=mock_app)
+
+        # When app is provided and is truthy, it should be used
+        assert matcher.app == mock_app
+        assert matcher.api == mock_api
+        assert matcher._catalog_cache == {}
+        assert matcher._control_impl_cache == {}
+
+
+class TestControlMatcherParseControlId:
+    """Test cases for parse_control_id method"""
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_parse_control_id_none(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class):
+        """Test parsing None control ID returns None"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+        result = matcher.parse_control_id(None)
+        assert result is None
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_parse_control_id_empty_string(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class):
+        """Test parsing empty string returns None"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+        result = matcher.parse_control_id("")
+        assert result is None
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_parse_control_id_whitespace(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class):
+        """Test parsing whitespace-only string returns None"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+        result = matcher.parse_control_id("   ")
+        assert result is None
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_parse_control_id_basic_format(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class):
+        """Test parsing basic NIST control ID format"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+        test_cases = [
+            ("AC-1", "AC-1"),
+            ("ac-1", "AC-1"),
+            ("AC-10", "AC-10"),
+            ("SI-2", "SI-2"),
+            ("CM-6", "CM-6"),
+        ]
+
+        for input_id, expected in test_cases:
+            result = matcher.parse_control_id(input_id)
+            assert result == expected, f"Failed for input {input_id}"
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_parse_control_id_with_parentheses(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class):
+        """Test parsing control ID with parentheses converts to dots"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+        test_cases = [
+            ("AC-1(1)", "AC-1.1"),
+            ("ac-2(3)", "AC-2.3"),
+            ("SI-4(10)", "SI-4.10"),
+            ("CM-6(1)", "CM-6.1"),
+        ]
+
+        for input_id, expected in test_cases:
+            result = matcher.parse_control_id(input_id)
+            assert result == expected, f"Failed for input {input_id}"
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_parse_control_id_with_dots(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class):
+        """Test parsing control ID already with dot notation"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+        test_cases = [
+            ("AC-1.1", "AC-1.1"),
+            ("ac-2.5", "AC-2.5"),
+            ("SI-4.12", "SI-4.12"),
+        ]
+
+        for input_id, expected in test_cases:
+            result = matcher.parse_control_id(input_id)
+            assert result == expected, f"Failed for input {input_id}"
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_parse_control_id_with_text(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class):
+        """Test parsing control ID with descriptive text"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+        test_cases = [
+            ("Access Control AC-1", "AC-1"),
+            ("AC-1 Access Control Policy", "AC-1"),
+            ("NIST Control AC-2 Account Management", "AC-2"),
+            ("System Monitoring SI-4(5)", "SI-4.5"),
+        ]
+
+        for input_id, expected in test_cases:
+            result = matcher.parse_control_id(input_id)
+            assert result == expected, f"Failed for input {input_id}"
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_parse_control_id_multiple_controls_returns_first(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class):
+        """Test parsing string with multiple controls returns first one"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+        test_cases = [
+            ("AC-1, AC-2", "AC-1"),
+            ("SI-2, SI-4, CM-6", "SI-2"),
+            ("AC-1(1), AC-1(2)", "AC-1.1"),
+        ]
+
+        for input_id, expected in test_cases:
+            result = matcher.parse_control_id(input_id)
+            assert result == expected, f"Failed for input {input_id}"
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_parse_control_id_three_letter_family(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class):
+        """Test parsing control IDs with three-letter family codes"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+        test_cases = [
+            ("PTA-1", "PTA-1"),
+            ("SAR-10", "SAR-10"),
+            ("PRM-3(2)", "PRM-3.2"),
+        ]
+
+        for input_id, expected in test_cases:
+            result = matcher.parse_control_id(input_id)
+            assert result == expected, f"Failed for input {input_id}"
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_parse_control_id_no_match(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class):
+        """Test parsing invalid control ID format returns None"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+        test_cases = [
+            "No control here",
+            "12345",
+            "A-1",  # Too short family code (single letter)
+            "AC",  # Missing number
+            "Control without ID",
+        ]
+
+        for input_id in test_cases:
+            result = matcher.parse_control_id(input_id)
+            assert result is None, f"Expected None for input {input_id}, got {result}"
+
+
+class TestControlMatcherFindControlInCatalog:
+    """Test cases for find_control_in_catalog method"""
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher._get_catalog_controls")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_find_control_exact_match(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_controls):
+        """Test finding control with exact match"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        # Create mock controls
+        mock_control1 = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_control1.controlId = "AC-1"
+        mock_control1.id = 100
+
+        mock_control2 = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_control2.controlId = "AC-2"
+        mock_control2.id = 101
+
+        mock_get_controls.return_value = [mock_control1, mock_control2]
+
+        result = matcher.find_control_in_catalog("AC-1", 1)
+
+        assert result == mock_control1
+        mock_get_controls.assert_called_once_with(1)
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher._get_catalog_controls")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_find_control_normalized_match(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_controls):
+        """Test finding control with normalized match when exact match fails"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        # Create mock controls with parentheses notation
+        mock_control1 = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_control1.controlId = "AC-1(1)"
+        mock_control1.id = 100
+
+        mock_control2 = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_control2.controlId = "AC-2"
+        mock_control2.id = 101
+
+        mock_get_controls.return_value = [mock_control1, mock_control2]
+
+        # Search using dot notation
+        result = matcher.find_control_in_catalog("AC-1.1", 1)
+
+        assert result == mock_control1
+        mock_get_controls.assert_called_once_with(1)
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher._get_catalog_controls")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_find_control_not_found(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_controls):
+        """Test finding control that doesn't exist returns None"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        mock_control1 = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_control1.controlId = "AC-1"
+        mock_control1.id = 100
+
+        mock_get_controls.return_value = [mock_control1]
+
+        result = matcher.find_control_in_catalog("SI-4", 1)
+
+        assert result is None
+        mock_get_controls.assert_called_once_with(1)
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher._get_catalog_controls")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_find_control_empty_catalog(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_controls):
+        """Test finding control in empty catalog returns None"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+        mock_get_controls.return_value = []
+
+        result = matcher.find_control_in_catalog("AC-1", 1)
+
+        assert result is None
+        mock_get_controls.assert_called_once_with(1)
+
+
+class TestControlMatcherFindControlImplementation:
+    """Test cases for find_control_implementation method"""
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher._get_control_implementations")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_find_implementation_by_label(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_impls):
+        """Test finding implementation by control label"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        # Create mock implementations
+        mock_impl1 = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+        mock_impl1.id = 200
+        mock_impl1.controlID = 100
+
+        mock_impl2 = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+        mock_impl2.id = 201
+        mock_impl2.controlID = 101
+
+        mock_get_impls.return_value = {
+            "AC-1": mock_impl1,
+            "AC-2": mock_impl2,
+        }
+
+        result = matcher.find_control_implementation("AC-1", 50, "securityplans")
+
+        assert result == mock_impl1
+        mock_get_impls.assert_called_once_with(50, "securityplans")
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher._get_control_implementations")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_find_implementation_case_insensitive(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_impls):
+        """Test finding implementation with case-insensitive matching"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        mock_impl1 = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+        mock_impl1.id = 200
+        mock_impl1.controlID = 100
+
+        mock_get_impls.return_value = {
+            "ac-1": mock_impl1,  # lowercase in dict
+        }
+
+        result = matcher.find_control_implementation("AC-1", 50)
+
+        assert result == mock_impl1
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher.find_control_in_catalog")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher._get_control_implementations")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_find_implementation_via_catalog(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_impls, mock_find_control):
+        """Test finding implementation via catalog when label match fails"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        # No label match
+        mock_impl1 = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+        mock_impl1.id = 200
+        mock_impl1.controlID = 100
+
+        mock_get_impls.return_value = {
+            "SI-2": mock_impl1,  # Different control
+        }
+
+        # But catalog returns a control
+        mock_control = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_control.id = 100
+        mock_control.controlId = "AC-1"
+        mock_find_control.return_value = mock_control
+
+        result = matcher.find_control_implementation("AC-1", 50, "securityplans", catalog_id=1)
+
+        assert result == mock_impl1
+        mock_find_control.assert_called_once_with("AC-1", 1)
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher._get_control_implementations")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_find_implementation_invalid_control_id(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_impls):
+        """Test finding implementation with invalid control ID returns None"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+        mock_get_impls.return_value = {}
+
+        with patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.logger") as mock_logger:
+            result = matcher.find_control_implementation("Invalid", 50)
+
+            assert result is None
+            mock_logger.warning.assert_called_once()
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher._get_control_implementations")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_find_implementation_not_found(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_impls):
+        """Test finding implementation that doesn't exist returns None"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+        mock_get_impls.return_value = {
+            "SI-2": MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation),
+        }
+
+        result = matcher.find_control_implementation("AC-1", 50)
+
+        assert result is None
+
+
+class TestControlMatcherMatchControlsToImplementations:
+    """Test cases for match_controls_to_implementations method"""
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher.find_control_implementation")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_match_multiple_controls(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_find_impl):
+        """Test matching multiple control IDs to implementations"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        mock_impl1 = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+        mock_impl1.id = 200
+
+        mock_impl2 = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+        mock_impl2.id = 201
+
+        def find_impl_side_effect(control_id, parent_id, parent_module="securityplans", catalog_id=None):
+            if control_id == "AC-1":
+                return mock_impl1
+            elif control_id == "AC-2":
+                return mock_impl2
+            return None
+
+        mock_find_impl.side_effect = find_impl_side_effect
+
+        control_ids = ["AC-1", "AC-2", "SI-4"]
+        result = matcher.match_controls_to_implementations(control_ids, 50)
+
+        assert len(result) == 3
+        assert result["AC-1"] == mock_impl1
+        assert result["AC-2"] == mock_impl2
+        assert result["SI-4"] is None
+        assert mock_find_impl.call_count == 3
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher.find_control_implementation")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_match_empty_list(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_find_impl):
+        """Test matching empty list returns empty dict"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+        result = matcher.match_controls_to_implementations([], 50)
+
+        assert result == {}
+        mock_find_impl.assert_not_called()
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher.find_control_implementation")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_match_with_catalog_id(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_find_impl):
+        """Test matching controls with catalog ID provided"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+        mock_impl = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+        mock_find_impl.return_value = mock_impl
+
+        control_ids = ["AC-1"]
+        result = matcher.match_controls_to_implementations(control_ids, 50, "securityplans", catalog_id=1)
+
+        assert result["AC-1"] == mock_impl
+        mock_find_impl.assert_called_once_with("AC-1", 50, "securityplans", 1)
+
+
+class TestControlMatcherGetSecurityPlanControls:
+    """Test cases for get_security_plan_controls method"""
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher._get_control_implementations")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_get_security_plan_controls(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_impls):
+        """Test getting all control implementations for a security plan"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        mock_impl1 = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+        mock_impl2 = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+
+        expected_dict = {
+            "AC-1": mock_impl1,
+            "AC-2": mock_impl2,
+        }
+        mock_get_impls.return_value = expected_dict
+
+        result = matcher.get_security_plan_controls(50)
+
+        assert result == expected_dict
+        mock_get_impls.assert_called_once_with(50, "securityplans")
+
+
+class TestControlMatcherFindControlsByPattern:
+    """Test cases for find_controls_by_pattern method"""
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher._get_catalog_controls")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_find_by_control_id_pattern(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_controls):
+        """Test finding controls by control ID pattern"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        mock_control1 = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_control1.controlId = "AC-1"
+        mock_control1.title = "Access Control Policy"
+
+        mock_control2 = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_control2.controlId = "AC-2"
+        mock_control2.title = "Account Management"
+
+        mock_control3 = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_control3.controlId = "SI-2"
+        mock_control3.title = "Flaw Remediation"
+
+        mock_get_controls.return_value = [mock_control1, mock_control2, mock_control3]
+
+        result = matcher.find_controls_by_pattern("^AC-", 1)
+
+        assert len(result) == 2
+        assert mock_control1 in result
+        assert mock_control2 in result
+        assert mock_control3 not in result
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher._get_catalog_controls")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_find_by_title_pattern(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_controls):
+        """Test finding controls by title pattern"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        mock_control1 = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_control1.controlId = "AC-1"
+        mock_control1.title = "Access Control Policy"
+
+        mock_control2 = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_control2.controlId = "AC-2"
+        mock_control2.title = "Account Management"
+
+        mock_control3 = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_control3.controlId = "SI-2"
+        mock_control3.title = "Access Review"
+
+        mock_get_controls.return_value = [mock_control1, mock_control2, mock_control3]
+
+        result = matcher.find_controls_by_pattern("Access", 1)
+
+        assert len(result) == 2
+        assert mock_control1 in result
+        assert mock_control3 in result
+        assert mock_control2 not in result
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher._get_catalog_controls")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_find_by_pattern_case_insensitive(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_controls):
+        """Test finding controls with case-insensitive pattern"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        mock_control1 = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_control1.controlId = "ac-1"
+        mock_control1.title = "access control"
+
+        mock_get_controls.return_value = [mock_control1]
+
+        result = matcher.find_controls_by_pattern("ACCESS", 1)
+
+        assert len(result) == 1
+        assert mock_control1 in result
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher._get_catalog_controls")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_find_by_pattern_no_matches(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_controls):
+        """Test finding controls with pattern that has no matches"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        mock_control1 = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_control1.controlId = "AC-1"
+        mock_control1.title = "Access Control"
+
+        mock_get_controls.return_value = [mock_control1]
+
+        result = matcher.find_controls_by_pattern("NOMATCH", 1)
+
+        assert len(result) == 0
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher._get_catalog_controls")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_find_by_pattern_none_title(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_controls):
+        """Test finding controls when title is None"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        mock_control1 = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_control1.controlId = "AC-1"
+        mock_control1.title = None
+
+        mock_control2 = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_control2.controlId = "AC-2"
+        mock_control2.title = "Account Management"
+
+        mock_get_controls.return_value = [mock_control1, mock_control2]
+
+        result = matcher.find_controls_by_pattern("AC-1", 1)
+
+        assert len(result) == 1
+        assert mock_control1 in result
+
+
+class TestControlMatcherBulkMatchControls:
+    """Test cases for bulk_match_controls method"""
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher.find_control_implementation")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_bulk_match_controls(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_find_impl):
+        """Test bulk matching external IDs to control implementations"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        mock_impl1 = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+        mock_impl1.id = 200
+
+        mock_impl2 = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+        mock_impl2.id = 201
+
+        def find_impl_side_effect(control_id, parent_id, parent_module="securityplans", catalog_id=None):
+            if control_id == "AC-1":
+                return mock_impl1
+            elif control_id == "AC-2":
+                return mock_impl2
+            return None
+
+        mock_find_impl.side_effect = find_impl_side_effect
+
+        control_mappings = {
+            "ext-001": "AC-1",
+            "ext-002": "AC-2",
+            "ext-003": "SI-4",
+        }
+
+        result = matcher.bulk_match_controls(control_mappings, 50)
+
+        assert len(result) == 3
+        assert result["ext-001"] == mock_impl1
+        assert result["ext-002"] == mock_impl2
+        assert result["ext-003"] is None
+        assert mock_find_impl.call_count == 3
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher.find_control_implementation")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_bulk_match_empty_dict(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_find_impl):
+        """Test bulk matching with empty dict returns empty dict"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+        result = matcher.bulk_match_controls({}, 50)
+
+        assert result == {}
+        mock_find_impl.assert_not_called()
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher.find_control_implementation")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_bulk_match_with_catalog(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_find_impl):
+        """Test bulk matching with catalog ID"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+        mock_impl = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+        mock_find_impl.return_value = mock_impl
+
+        control_mappings = {"ext-001": "AC-1"}
+        result = matcher.bulk_match_controls(control_mappings, 50, "securityplans", catalog_id=1)
+
+        assert result["ext-001"] == mock_impl
+        mock_find_impl.assert_called_once_with("AC-1", 50, "securityplans", 1)
+
+
+class TestControlMatcherGetCatalogControls:
+    """Test cases for _get_catalog_controls method"""
+
+    @patch("regscale.models.regscale_models.security_control.SecurityControl.get_list_by_catalog")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_get_catalog_controls_first_call(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_list):
+        """Test getting catalog controls on first call (not cached)"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        mock_control1 = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_control2 = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_get_list.return_value = [mock_control1, mock_control2]
+
+        result = matcher._get_catalog_controls(1)
+
+        assert len(result) == 2
+        assert mock_control1 in result
+        assert mock_control2 in result
+        mock_get_list.assert_called_once_with(1)
+        assert 1 in matcher._catalog_cache
+
+    @patch("regscale.models.regscale_models.security_control.SecurityControl.get_list_by_catalog")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_get_catalog_controls_cached(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_list):
+        """Test getting catalog controls from cache on subsequent calls"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        mock_control1 = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_control2 = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        cached_controls = [mock_control1, mock_control2]
+
+        # Pre-populate cache
+        matcher._catalog_cache[1] = cached_controls
+
+        result = matcher._get_catalog_controls(1)
+
+        assert result == cached_controls
+        mock_get_list.assert_not_called()
+
+    @patch("regscale.models.regscale_models.security_control.SecurityControl.get_list_by_catalog")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_get_catalog_controls_error(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_list):
+        """Test getting catalog controls handles exception"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+        mock_get_list.side_effect = Exception("API Error")
+
+        with patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.logger") as mock_logger:
+            result = matcher._get_catalog_controls(1)
+
+            assert result == []
+            mock_logger.error.assert_called_once()
+            assert 1 not in matcher._catalog_cache
+
+
+class TestControlMatcherGetControlImplementations:
+    """Test cases for _get_control_implementations method"""
+
+    @patch("regscale.models.regscale_models.control_implementation.ControlImplementation.get_object")
+    @patch(
+        "regscale.models.regscale_models.control_implementation.ControlImplementation.get_control_label_map_by_parent"
+    )
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_get_control_implementations_first_call(
+        self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_label_map, mock_get_object
+    ):
+        """Test getting control implementations on first call (not cached)"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        mock_impl1 = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+        mock_impl1.id = 200
+
+        mock_impl2 = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+        mock_impl2.id = 201
+
+        mock_get_label_map.return_value = {
+            "AC-1": 200,
+            "AC-2": 201,
+        }
+
+        def get_object_side_effect(impl_id):
+            if impl_id == 200:
+                return mock_impl1
+            elif impl_id == 201:
+                return mock_impl2
+            return None
+
+        mock_get_object.side_effect = get_object_side_effect
+
+        result = matcher._get_control_implementations(50, "securityplans")
+
+        assert len(result) == 2
+        assert result["AC-1"] == mock_impl1
+        assert result["AC-2"] == mock_impl2
+        mock_get_label_map.assert_called_once_with(50, "securityplans")
+        assert (50, "securityplans") in matcher._control_impl_cache
+
+    @patch(
+        "regscale.models.regscale_models.control_implementation.ControlImplementation.get_control_label_map_by_parent"
+    )
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_get_control_implementations_cached(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_label_map):
+        """Test getting control implementations from cache"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        mock_impl = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+        cached_impls = {"AC-1": mock_impl}
+
+        # Pre-populate cache
+        matcher._control_impl_cache[(50, "securityplans")] = cached_impls
+
+        result = matcher._get_control_implementations(50, "securityplans")
+
+        assert result == cached_impls
+        mock_get_label_map.assert_not_called()
+
+    @patch("regscale.models.regscale_models.control_implementation.ControlImplementation.get_object")
+    @patch(
+        "regscale.models.regscale_models.control_implementation.ControlImplementation.get_control_label_map_by_parent"
+    )
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_get_control_implementations_with_none(
+        self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_label_map, mock_get_object
+    ):
+        """Test getting control implementations when some objects return None"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        mock_impl1 = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+        mock_impl1.id = 200
+
+        mock_get_label_map.return_value = {
+            "AC-1": 200,
+            "AC-2": 201,  # This will return None
+        }
+
+        def get_object_side_effect(impl_id):
+            if impl_id == 200:
+                return mock_impl1
+            return None
+
+        mock_get_object.side_effect = get_object_side_effect
+
+        result = matcher._get_control_implementations(50, "securityplans")
+
+        # Should only include the valid implementation
+        assert len(result) == 1
+        assert result["AC-1"] == mock_impl1
+        assert "AC-2" not in result
+
+    @patch(
+        "regscale.models.regscale_models.control_implementation.ControlImplementation.get_control_label_map_by_parent"
+    )
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_get_control_implementations_error(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_label_map):
+        """Test getting control implementations handles exception"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+        mock_get_label_map.side_effect = Exception("API Error")
+
+        with patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.logger") as mock_logger:
+            result = matcher._get_control_implementations(50, "securityplans")
+
+            assert result == {}
+            mock_logger.error.assert_called_once()
+            assert (50, "securityplans") not in matcher._control_impl_cache
+
+
+class TestControlMatcherClearCache:
+    """Test cases for clear_cache method"""
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_clear_cache_empty(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class):
+        """Test clearing cache when already empty"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        with patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.logger") as mock_logger:
+            matcher.clear_cache()
+
+            assert matcher._catalog_cache == {}
+            assert matcher._control_impl_cache == {}
+            mock_logger.info.assert_called_once_with("Cleared control matcher cache")
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_clear_cache_with_data(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class):
+        """Test clearing cache with data"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        # Add data to caches
+        matcher._catalog_cache[1] = [MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)]
+        matcher._control_impl_cache[(50, "securityplans")] = {"AC-1": MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)}
+
+        with patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.logger") as mock_logger:
+            matcher.clear_cache()
+
+            assert matcher._catalog_cache == {}
+            assert matcher._control_impl_cache == {}
+            mock_logger.info.assert_called_once_with("Cleared control matcher cache")
+
+
+class TestControlMatcherEdgeCases:
+    """Test cases for edge cases and error scenarios"""
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher._get_catalog_controls")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_find_control_with_special_characters(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_controls):
+        """Test finding control with special characters in ID"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        mock_control = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_control.controlId = "AC-1(1)"
+        mock_get_controls.return_value = [mock_control]
+
+        # Test with different variations
+        result1 = matcher.find_control_in_catalog("AC-1(1)", 1)
+        result2 = matcher.find_control_in_catalog("AC-1.1", 1)
+
+        assert result1 == mock_control
+        assert result2 == mock_control
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher.find_control_implementation")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_match_controls_with_duplicates(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_find_impl):
+        """Test matching controls when list contains duplicates"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        mock_impl1 = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+        mock_impl2 = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+
+        def find_impl_side_effect(control_id, parent_id, parent_module="securityplans", catalog_id=None):
+            if control_id == "AC-1":
+                return mock_impl1
+            elif control_id == "AC-2":
+                return mock_impl2
+            return None
+
+        mock_find_impl.side_effect = find_impl_side_effect
+
+        control_ids = ["AC-1", "AC-1", "AC-2"]
+        result = matcher.match_controls_to_implementations(control_ids, 50)
+
+        # Result is a dict, so duplicates are collapsed - should have 2 unique keys
+        assert len(result) == 2
+        assert result["AC-1"] == mock_impl1
+        assert result["AC-2"] == mock_impl2
+        # Should still call find_impl for each entry in the list, including duplicates
+        assert mock_find_impl.call_count == 3
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher._get_catalog_controls")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_find_by_pattern_with_empty_string(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_controls):
+        """Test finding controls with empty string pattern"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        mock_control = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_control.controlId = "AC-1"
+        mock_control.title = "Access Control"
+        mock_get_controls.return_value = [mock_control]
+
+        result = matcher.find_controls_by_pattern("", 1)
+
+        # Empty pattern should match everything
+        assert len(result) == 1
+        assert mock_control in result
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher._get_control_implementations")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_find_implementation_different_parent_modules(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_impls):
+        """Test finding implementations with different parent modules"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        mock_impl1 = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+        mock_impl2 = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+
+        def get_impls_side_effect(parent_id, parent_module):
+            if parent_module == "securityplans":
+                return {"AC-1": mock_impl1}
+            elif parent_module == "assessments":
+                return {"AC-1": mock_impl2}
+            return {}
+
+        mock_get_impls.side_effect = get_impls_side_effect
+
+        result1 = matcher.find_control_implementation("AC-1", 50, "securityplans")
+        result2 = matcher.find_control_implementation("AC-1", 51, "assessments")
+
+        assert result1 == mock_impl1
+        assert result2 == mock_impl2
+
+
+class TestControlMatcherLeadingZeros:
+    """Test cases for control IDs with leading zeros"""
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_normalize_control_id_with_leading_zeros(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class):
+        """Test normalizing control IDs with leading zeros"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        test_cases = [
+            ("AC-01", "AC-1"),
+            ("AC-17", "AC-17"),
+            ("AC-01.02", "AC-1.2"),
+            ("AC-17.02", "AC-17.2"),
+            ("AC-1.1", "AC-1.1"),
+        ]
+
+        for input_id, expected in test_cases:
+            result = matcher._normalize_control_id(input_id)
+            assert result == expected, f"Failed for input {input_id}"
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_get_control_id_variations_simple(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class):
+        """Test generating variations for simple control IDs"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        result = matcher._get_control_id_variations("AC-1")
+        expected = {"AC-1", "AC-01"}
+        assert result == expected
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_get_control_id_variations_with_enhancement(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class):
+        """Test generating variations for control IDs with enhancements"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        result = matcher._get_control_id_variations("AC-17.2")
+        expected = {
+            "AC-17.2",
+            "AC-17.02",
+            "AC-17(2)",
+            "AC-17(02)",
+        }
+        assert result == expected
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_get_control_id_variations_with_leading_zeros_input(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class):
+        """Test generating variations when input has leading zeros"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        result = matcher._get_control_id_variations("AC-01")
+        expected = {"AC-1", "AC-01"}
+        assert result == expected
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_get_control_id_variations_with_parentheses_input(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class):
+        """Test generating variations when input has parentheses"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        result = matcher._get_control_id_variations("AC-17(02)")
+        expected = {
+            "AC-17.2",
+            "AC-17.02",
+            "AC-17(2)",
+            "AC-17(02)",
+        }
+        assert result == expected
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher._get_catalog_controls")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_find_control_in_catalog_with_leading_zeros(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_controls):
+        """Test finding controls with leading zeros in catalog"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        # Catalog has control with leading zeros
+        mock_control = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_control.controlId = "AC-01"
+        mock_control.id = 100
+
+        mock_get_controls.return_value = [mock_control]
+
+        # Search without leading zero should find it
+        result = matcher.find_control_in_catalog("AC-1", 1)
+        assert result == mock_control
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher._get_catalog_controls")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_find_control_in_catalog_search_with_leading_zeros(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_controls):
+        """Test finding controls when search ID has leading zeros"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        # Catalog has control without leading zeros
+        mock_control = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_control.controlId = "AC-1"
+        mock_control.id = 100
+
+        mock_get_controls.return_value = [mock_control]
+
+        # Search with leading zero should find it
+        result = matcher.find_control_in_catalog("AC-01", 1)
+        assert result == mock_control
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher._get_catalog_controls")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_find_control_with_leading_zeros_enhancement(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_controls):
+        """Test finding controls with leading zeros in enhancement numbers"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        # Catalog has control with leading zeros in enhancement
+        mock_control = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_control.controlId = "AC-17(02)"
+        mock_control.id = 100
+
+        mock_get_controls.return_value = [mock_control]
+
+        # Search with different formats should all find it
+        result1 = matcher.find_control_in_catalog("AC-17.2", 1)
+        result2 = matcher.find_control_in_catalog("AC-17(2)", 1)
+        result3 = matcher.find_control_in_catalog("AC-17.02", 1)
+
+        assert result1 == mock_control
+        assert result2 == mock_control
+        assert result3 == mock_control
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher._get_control_implementations")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_find_implementation_with_leading_zeros(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_impls):
+        """Test finding implementation when control IDs have leading zeros"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        mock_impl = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+        mock_impl.id = 200
+        mock_impl.controlID = 100
+
+        # Implementation key has leading zero
+        mock_get_impls.return_value = {
+            "AC-01": mock_impl,
+        }
+
+        # Search without leading zero should find it
+        result = matcher.find_control_implementation("AC-1", 50)
+        assert result == mock_impl
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher._get_control_implementations")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_find_implementation_search_with_leading_zeros(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_impls):
+        """Test finding implementation when search ID has leading zeros"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        mock_impl = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+        mock_impl.id = 200
+        mock_impl.controlID = 100
+
+        # Implementation key has no leading zero
+        mock_get_impls.return_value = {
+            "AC-1": mock_impl,
+        }
+
+        # Search with leading zero should find it
+        result = matcher.find_control_implementation("AC-01", 50)
+        assert result == mock_impl
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher._get_control_implementations")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_find_implementation_with_leading_zeros_complex(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_impls):
+        """Test finding implementation with complex leading zero scenarios"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        mock_impl = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+        mock_impl.id = 200
+
+        # Implementation key has leading zeros in enhancement
+        mock_get_impls.return_value = {
+            "AC-17(02)": mock_impl,
+        }
+
+        # Search with different formats should find it
+        result1 = matcher.find_control_implementation("AC-17.2", 50)
+        result2 = matcher.find_control_implementation("AC-17(2)", 50)
+        result3 = matcher.find_control_implementation("AC-17.02", 50)
+
+        assert result1 == mock_impl
+        assert result2 == mock_impl
+        assert result3 == mock_impl
+
+
+class TestControlMatcherIntegrationScenarios:
+    """Integration test scenarios for complex workflows"""
+
+    @patch("regscale.models.regscale_models.control_implementation.ControlImplementation.get_object")
+    @patch(
+        "regscale.models.regscale_models.control_implementation.ControlImplementation.get_control_label_map_by_parent"
+    )
+    @patch("regscale.models.regscale_models.security_control.SecurityControl.get_list_by_catalog")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_full_workflow_with_caching(
+        self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_catalog, mock_get_label_map, mock_get_object
+    ):
+        """Test full workflow with multiple operations and caching"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        # Setup catalog controls
+        mock_control1 = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_control1.controlId = "AC-1"
+        mock_control1.id = 100
+        mock_control1.title = "Access Control Policy"
+
+        mock_control2 = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_control2.controlId = "AC-2"
+        mock_control2.id = 101
+        mock_control2.title = "Account Management"
+
+        mock_get_catalog.return_value = [mock_control1, mock_control2]
+
+        # Setup implementations
+        mock_impl1 = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+        mock_impl1.id = 200
+        mock_impl1.controlID = 100
+
+        mock_get_label_map.return_value = {"AC-1": 200}
+        mock_get_object.return_value = mock_impl1
+
+        # First operation: find control in catalog
+        control = matcher.find_control_in_catalog("AC-1", 1)
+        assert control == mock_control1
+        assert mock_get_catalog.call_count == 1
+
+        # Second operation: find same control (should use cache)
+        control2 = matcher.find_control_in_catalog("AC-2", 1)
+        assert control2 == mock_control2
+        assert mock_get_catalog.call_count == 1  # Should not increase
+
+        # Third operation: find implementation
+        impl = matcher.find_control_implementation("AC-1", 50)
+        assert impl == mock_impl1
+        assert mock_get_label_map.call_count == 1
+
+        # Fourth operation: find same implementation (should use cache)
+        impl2 = matcher.find_control_implementation("AC-1", 50)
+        assert impl2 == mock_impl1
+        assert mock_get_label_map.call_count == 1  # Should not increase
+
+        # Clear cache
+        matcher.clear_cache()
+
+        # Fifth operation: after cache clear, should fetch again
+        control3 = matcher.find_control_in_catalog("AC-1", 1)
+        assert control3 == mock_control1
+        assert mock_get_catalog.call_count == 2  # Should increase now
+
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.ControlMatcher.find_control_implementation")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_bulk_operations_with_mixed_results(self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_find_impl):
+        """Test bulk operations with some successes and some failures"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        mock_impl1 = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+        mock_impl2 = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+
+        def find_impl_side_effect(control_id, parent_id, parent_module="securityplans", catalog_id=None):
+            impl_map = {
+                "AC-1": mock_impl1,
+                "AC-2": mock_impl2,
+            }
+            return impl_map.get(control_id)
+
+        mock_find_impl.side_effect = find_impl_side_effect
+
+        # Bulk match with mixed results
+        mappings = {
+            "finding-001": "AC-1",  # Will find
+            "finding-002": "AC-2",  # Will find
+            "finding-003": "SI-4",  # Won't find
+            "finding-004": "CM-6",  # Won't find
+        }
+
+        result = matcher.bulk_match_controls(mappings, 50)
+
+        assert result["finding-001"] == mock_impl1
+        assert result["finding-002"] == mock_impl2
+        assert result["finding-003"] is None
+        assert result["finding-004"] is None
+        assert len(result) == 4
+
+    @patch("regscale.models.regscale_models.control_implementation.ControlImplementation.get_object")
+    @patch(
+        "regscale.models.regscale_models.control_implementation.ControlImplementation.get_control_label_map_by_parent"
+    )
+    @patch("regscale.models.regscale_models.security_control.SecurityControl.get_list_by_catalog")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Api")
+    @patch("regscale.integrations.control_matcher.Application")
+    def test_workflow_with_leading_zeros_catalog(
+        self, mock_app_class, mock_api_class, mock_get_catalog, mock_get_label_map, mock_get_object
+    ):
+        """Test workflow when catalog has control IDs with leading zeros"""
+        matcher = ControlMatcher()
+
+        # Catalog has controls with leading zeros
+        mock_control1 = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_control1.controlId = "AC-01"
+        mock_control1.id = 100
+
+        mock_control2 = MagicMock(spec=SecurityControl)
+        mock_control2.controlId = "AC-17(02)"
+        mock_control2.id = 101
+
+        mock_get_catalog.return_value = [mock_control1, mock_control2]
+
+        # Implementations have standard format
+        mock_impl1 = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+        mock_impl1.id = 200
+        mock_impl1.controlID = 100
+
+        mock_impl2 = MagicMock(spec=ControlImplementation)
+        mock_impl2.id = 201
+        mock_impl2.controlID = 101
+
+        mock_get_label_map.return_value = {
+            "AC-1": 200,
+            "AC-17.2": 201,
+        }
+
+        def get_object_side_effect(impl_id):
+            if impl_id == 200:
+                return mock_impl1
+            elif impl_id == 201:
+                return mock_impl2
+            return None
+
+        mock_get_object.side_effect = get_object_side_effect
+
+        # Search with standard format should find controls with leading zeros
+        control1 = matcher.find_control_in_catalog("AC-1", 1)
+        assert control1 == mock_control1
+
+        control2 = matcher.find_control_in_catalog("AC-17.2", 1)
+        assert control2 == mock_control2
+
+        # Find implementations should work with either format
+        impl1 = matcher.find_control_implementation("AC-01", 50)
+        assert impl1 == mock_impl1
+
+        impl2 = matcher.find_control_implementation("AC-17(02)", 50)
+        assert impl2 == mock_impl2