natural-pdf 0.2.11__py3-none-any.whl → 0.2.12__py3-none-any.whl

temp/debug_exclusions_guides.py

@@ -0,0 +1,67 @@
+"""Debug why exclusions aren't working with guides.extract_table()"""
+from natural_pdf import PDF
+from natural_pdf.analyzers.guides import Guides
+
+pdf = PDF("pdfs/m27.pdf")
+page = pdf.pages[0]
+
+# Check initial text
+print("Initial text:")
+print(page.extract_text()[:200])
+print()
+
+# Add exclusions
+pdf.add_exclusion(lambda page: page.find(text="PREMISE").above())
+pdf.add_exclusion(lambda page: page.find("text:regex(Page \d+ of)").expand())
+
+# Check text after exclusions
+print("Text after exclusions:")
+print(page.extract_text()[:100])
+print()
+
+# Debug exclusion regions
+print("Checking exclusion regions:")
+exclusions = page._get_exclusion_regions(debug=True)
+print(f"\nTotal exclusions: {len(exclusions)}")
+for i, exc in enumerate(exclusions):
+    print(f"  {i}: {exc.bbox}")
+print()
+
+# Create guides
+headers = (
+    page
+    .find(text="NUMBER")
+    .right(include_source=True)
+    .expand(top=3, bottom=3)
+    .find_all('text')
+)
+
+guides = Guides(page)
+guides.vertical.from_content(headers, align='left')
+guides.horizontal.from_stripes()
+
+# Build grid to see what regions are created
+print("\nBuilding grid...")
+grid_result = guides.build_grid(include_outer_boundaries=True)
+table_region = grid_result["regions"]["table"]
+print(f"Table region: {table_region}")
+print(f"Table bbox: {table_region.bbox if table_region else 'None'}")
+
+# Check if table region respects exclusions
+if table_region:
+    print("\nExtracting text from table region directly:")
+    table_text = table_region.extract_text()[:200]
+    print(f"Table text: {table_text}")
+    
+    # Now extract table
+    print("\nExtracting table with apply_exclusions=True:")
+    result = guides.extract_table(include_outer_boundaries=True, apply_exclusions=True, header=False)
+    df = result.to_df()
+    print(df.head())
+    
+    # Check if excluded content is in the table
+    table_str = df.to_string()
+    has_feb = "FEBRUARY 2014" in table_str or "FEBR" in table_str
+    has_alphabetic = "ALPHABETIC LISTING" in table_str
+    print(f"\nContains 'FEBRUARY': {has_feb}")
+    print(f"Contains 'ALPHABETIC LISTING': {has_alphabetic}")

temp/debug_extra_guide.py

@@ -0,0 +1,41 @@
+"""Debug the extra guide issue."""
+from natural_pdf import PDF
+from natural_pdf.analyzers.guides import Guides
+
+pdf = PDF("pdfs/m27.pdf")
+page = pdf.pages[0]
+
+# Get headers
+headers = (
+    page
+    .find("text:contains(NUMBER)")
+    .right(include_source=True)
+    .expand(top=3, bottom=3)
+    .find_all('text')
+)
+
+print("Headers 3-5:")
+for i, h in enumerate(headers[3:5]):
+    print(f"  {i}: '{h.text}' bbox={h.bbox}")
+
+# Create guides with just these two headers
+guides = Guides(page)
+guides.vertical.from_content(headers[3:5], align='left', outer=False)
+
+print(f"\nResulting guides: {guides.vertical}")
+print(f"Expected: [328.32012, 539.63316]")
+
+# Let's also check what happens with each header individually
+print("\nTesting each header individually:")
+for i, h in enumerate(headers[3:5]):
+    g = Guides(page)
+    g.vertical.from_content([h], align='left', outer=False)
+    print(f"  Header {i} guides: {g.vertical}")
+
+# Check if it's related to the ElementCollection
+print("\nTesting with manual list of text:")
+text_list = [h.text for h in headers[3:5]]
+print(f"Text list: {text_list}")
+guides2 = Guides(page)
+guides2.vertical.from_content(text_list, align='left', outer=False)
+print(f"Guides from text list: {guides2.vertical}")

temp/debug_outer_boundaries.py

@@ -0,0 +1,46 @@
+"""Debug outer boundaries issue with exclusions"""
+from natural_pdf import PDF
+from natural_pdf.analyzers.guides import Guides
+
+pdf = PDF("pdfs/m27.pdf")
+page = pdf.pages[0]
+
+# Add exclusions
+pdf.add_exclusion(lambda page: page.find(text="PREMISE").above())
+
+# Create guides
+headers = (
+    page
+    .find(text="NUMBER")
+    .right(include_source=True)
+    .expand(top=3, bottom=3)
+    .find_all('text')
+)
+
+guides = Guides(page)
+guides.vertical.from_content(headers, align='left')
+guides.horizontal.from_stripes()
+
+print("Horizontal guides (sorted):")
+for i, h in enumerate(sorted(guides.horizontal)):
+    print(f"  {i}: {h:.2f}")
+
+print(f"\nFirst content guide: {sorted(guides.horizontal)[0]:.2f}")
+print(f"Page height: {page.height}")
+
+# Test without outer boundaries
+print("\n\nWithout outer boundaries:")
+result1 = guides.extract_table(include_outer_boundaries=False, apply_exclusions=True, header=False)
+df1 = result1.to_df()
+print(f"Shape: {df1.shape}")
+print("First row, first column:", df1.iloc[0, 0] if not df1.empty else "Empty")
+
+# Test with outer boundaries
+print("\n\nWith outer boundaries:")
+result2 = guides.extract_table(include_outer_boundaries=True, apply_exclusions=True, header=False)
+df2 = result2.to_df()
+print(f"Shape: {df2.shape}")
+print("First row, first column:", df2.iloc[0, 0] if not df2.empty else "Empty")
+
+# The issue: include_outer_boundaries adds guides at 0 and 612,
+# which creates cells that span into the exclusion zone

temp/debug_st_search.py

@@ -0,0 +1,33 @@
+"""Debug searching for 'ST' text."""
+from natural_pdf import PDF
+
+pdf = PDF("pdfs/m27.pdf")
+page = pdf.pages[0]
+
+# Get the original ST element
+headers = (
+    page
+    .find("text:contains(NUMBER)")
+    .right(include_source=True)
+    .expand(top=3, bottom=3)
+    .find_all('text')
+)
+original_st = headers[4]
+print(f"Original 'ST' element: '{original_st.text}' at {original_st.bbox}")
+
+# Search for 'ST' using find
+found_st = page.find('text:contains("ST")')
+print(f"\nFound 'ST' using find: '{found_st.text}' at {found_st.bbox}")
+
+# Find all elements containing 'ST'
+all_st = page.find_all('text:contains("ST")')
+print(f"\nAll elements containing 'ST':")
+for i, elem in enumerate(all_st[:10]):  # First 10
+    print(f"  {i}: '{elem.text}' at x={elem.x0:.2f}, bbox={elem.bbox}")
+
+# Check what's at position 332.88
+print(f"\nLooking for element at x≈332.88:")
+all_text = page.find_all('text')
+for elem in all_text:
+    if 332 < elem.x0 < 334:
+        print(f"  Found: '{elem.text}' at x={elem.x0:.5f}, bbox={elem.bbox}")

temp/fix_page_exclusions.py

@@ -0,0 +1,42 @@
+"""Script to fix the remaining exclusion bugs in page.py"""
+
+import re
+
+# Read the file
+with open('/Users/soma/Development/natural-pdf/natural_pdf/core/page.py', 'r') as f:
+    content = f.read()
+
+# Fix 1: Line 1132 in find() method
+# Change: if apply_exclusions and self._exclusions and results_collection:
+# To: if apply_exclusions and results_collection:
+content = re.sub(
+    r'(\s+)if apply_exclusions and self\._exclusions and results_collection:',
+    r'\1if apply_exclusions and results_collection:',
+    content
+)
+
+# Fix 2: Line 1227 in find_all() method
+# Same change pattern
+content = re.sub(
+    r'(\s+)if apply_exclusions and self\._exclusions and results_collection:',
+    r'\1if apply_exclusions and results_collection:',
+    content
+)
+
+# Fix 3: Line 1599 in get_elements() method
+# Change: if apply_exclusions and self._exclusions:
+# To: if apply_exclusions:
+content = re.sub(
+    r'(\s+)if apply_exclusions and self\._exclusions:',
+    r'\1if apply_exclusions:',
+    content
+)
+
+# Write the fixed content back
+with open('/Users/soma/Development/natural-pdf/natural_pdf/core/page.py', 'w') as f:
+    f.write(content)
+
+print("Fixed exclusion checks in page.py")
+print("- find() method: removed self._exclusions check")
+print("- find_all() method: removed self._exclusions check")
+print("- get_elements() method: removed self._exclusions check")

temp/test_exclusion_with_debug.py

@@ -0,0 +1,30 @@
+"""Test exclusion with detailed debugging"""
+from natural_pdf import PDF
+
+pdf = PDF("pdfs/m27.pdf")
+page = pdf.pages[0]
+
+# Add exclusion
+pdf.add_exclusion(lambda page: page.find(text="PREMISE").above(), label="header")
+
+# First, verify the exclusion works on the page itself
+print("Page-level text extraction:")
+print("Without exclusions:", page.extract_text(apply_exclusions=False)[:100])
+print("With exclusions:", page.extract_text(apply_exclusions=True)[:100])
+
+# Now test on a specific region that should be excluded
+print("\n\nRegion in excluded area (0, 0, 200, 50):")
+excluded_region = page.region(0, 0, 200, 50)
+print("Without exclusions:", repr(excluded_region.extract_text(apply_exclusions=False)))
+print("With exclusions:", repr(excluded_region.extract_text(apply_exclusions=True)))
+
+# Test the actual problematic cell region
+print("\n\nProblematic cell region (32.06, 0.5, 73.18, 79.54):")
+cell_region = page.region(32.06, 0.5, 73.18288, 79.54)
+print("Without exclusions:", repr(cell_region.extract_text(apply_exclusions=False)))
+print("With exclusions:", repr(cell_region.extract_text(apply_exclusions=True)))
+
+# Check if the region inherits the page
+print(f"\nCell region's page: {cell_region.page}")
+print(f"Cell region's _page: {getattr(cell_region, '_page', 'Not found')}")
+print(f"Same as original page: {cell_region.page is page if hasattr(cell_region, 'page') else 'N/A'}")

temp/test_find_exclusions_fix.py

@@ -0,0 +1,53 @@
+"""Test that the find methods now work with PDF-level exclusions."""
+
+from natural_pdf import PDF
+
+# Load a test PDF
+pdf = PDF("pdfs/m27.pdf")
+page = pdf.pages[0]
+
+# Add PDF-level exclusion for the header
+pdf.add_exclusion(lambda page: page.find(text="PREMISE").above())
+
+# Test 1: find() should now exclude the header text
+print("Test 1: find() with PDF-level exclusions")
+result = page.find("text:contains(FEBRUARY)", apply_exclusions=True)
+if result is None:
+    print("✅ SUCCESS: find() correctly excluded header text")
+else:
+    print(f"❌ FAILED: find() returned {result.text}")
+
+# Test 2: find_all() should exclude header elements
+print("\nTest 2: find_all() with PDF-level exclusions")
+all_text = page.find_all("text", apply_exclusions=False)
+filtered_text = page.find_all("text", apply_exclusions=True)
+print(f"Without exclusions: {len(all_text)} elements")
+print(f"With exclusions: {len(filtered_text)} elements")
+if len(filtered_text) < len(all_text):
+    print("✅ SUCCESS: find_all() excluded some elements")
+else:
+    print("❌ FAILED: find_all() didn't exclude any elements")
+
+# Test 3: get_elements() should exclude header elements
+print("\nTest 3: get_elements() with PDF-level exclusions")
+all_elements = page.get_elements(apply_exclusions=False)
+filtered_elements = page.get_elements(apply_exclusions=True)
+print(f"Without exclusions: {len(all_elements)} elements")
+print(f"With exclusions: {len(filtered_elements)} elements")
+if len(filtered_elements) < len(all_elements):
+    print("✅ SUCCESS: get_elements() excluded some elements")
+else:
+    print("❌ FAILED: get_elements() didn't exclude any elements")
+
+# Test that excluded text is not in the filtered results
+print("\nChecking excluded text...")
+excluded_texts = ["FEBRUARY", "ALPHABETIC LISTING", "M27"]
+for text in excluded_texts:
+    found_in_filtered = any(
+        text in str(el.text) if hasattr(el, 'text') else False 
+        for el in filtered_text
+    )
+    if not found_in_filtered:
+        print(f"✅ '{text}' correctly excluded")
+    else:
+        print(f"❌ '{text}' still present in filtered results")

temp/test_find_exclusions_fix_no_recursion.py

@@ -0,0 +1,97 @@
+"""Test that the find methods now work with PDF-level exclusions (without recursion)."""
+
+from natural_pdf import PDF
+
+# Load a test PDF
+pdf = PDF("pdfs/m27.pdf")
+page = pdf.pages[0]
+
+# Add PDF-level exclusion using a Region directly to avoid recursion
+# First, get the header region without exclusions
+header_element = page.find(text="PREMISE", apply_exclusions=False)
+if header_element:
+    header_region = header_element.above()
+    pdf.add_exclusion(header_region)
+else:
+    print("WARNING: Could not find PREMISE text for exclusion")
+
+# Test 1: find() should now exclude the header text
+print("Test 1: find() with PDF-level exclusions")
+result = page.find("text:contains(FEBRUARY)", apply_exclusions=True)
+if result is None:
+    print("✅ SUCCESS: find() correctly excluded header text")
+else:
+    print(f"❌ FAILED: find() returned {result.text}")
+
+# Test 2: find_all() should exclude header elements
+print("\nTest 2: find_all() with PDF-level exclusions")
+all_text = page.find_all("text", apply_exclusions=False)
+filtered_text = page.find_all("text", apply_exclusions=True)
+print(f"Without exclusions: {len(all_text)} elements")
+print(f"With exclusions: {len(filtered_text)} elements")
+if len(filtered_text) < len(all_text):
+    print("✅ SUCCESS: find_all() excluded some elements")
+else:
+    print("❌ FAILED: find_all() didn't exclude any elements")
+
+# Test 3: get_elements() should exclude header elements
+print("\nTest 3: get_elements() with PDF-level exclusions")
+all_elements = page.get_elements(apply_exclusions=False)
+filtered_elements = page.get_elements(apply_exclusions=True)
+print(f"Without exclusions: {len(all_elements)} elements")
+print(f"With exclusions: {len(filtered_elements)} elements")
+if len(filtered_elements) < len(all_elements):
+    print("✅ SUCCESS: get_elements() excluded some elements")
+else:
+    print("❌ FAILED: get_elements() didn't exclude any elements")
+
+# Test that excluded text is not in the filtered results
+print("\nChecking excluded text...")
+excluded_texts = ["FEBRUARY", "ALPHABETIC LISTING", "M27"]
+for text in excluded_texts:
+    found_in_filtered = any(
+        text in str(el.text) if hasattr(el, 'text') else False 
+        for el in filtered_text
+    )
+    if not found_in_filtered:
+        print(f"✅ '{text}' correctly excluded")
+    else:
+        print(f"❌ '{text}' still present in filtered results")
+
+# Also test that the original table extraction issue is fixed
+print("\n\nTesting original table extraction issue...")
+from natural_pdf.analyzers.guides import Guides
+
+# Add exclusion for footer too
+footer_element = page.find("text:regex(Page \\d+ of)", apply_exclusions=False)
+if footer_element:
+    pdf.add_exclusion(footer_element.expand())
+
+headers = (
+    page
+    .find(text="NUMBER", apply_exclusions=False)
+    .right(include_source=True)
+    .expand(top=3, bottom=3)
+    .find_all('text')
+)
+
+guides = Guides(page)
+guides.vertical.from_content(headers, align='left')
+guides.horizontal.from_stripes()
+
+result = guides.extract_table(include_outer_boundaries=True, apply_exclusions=True, header=False)
+df = result.to_df()
+
+# Check if excluded content is in the table
+table_str = df.to_string()
+has_feb = "FEBRUARY" in table_str
+has_alphabetic = "ALPHABETIC LISTING" in table_str
+
+print(f"\nTable extraction with exclusions:")
+print(f"Contains 'FEBRUARY': {has_feb}")
+print(f"Contains 'ALPHABETIC LISTING': {has_alphabetic}")
+
+if not has_feb and not has_alphabetic:
+    print("✅ SUCCESS: Table extraction correctly excludes header/footer!")
+else:
+    print("❌ FAILED: Exclusions not working in table extraction")

temp/test_fix_real_pdf.py

@@ -0,0 +1,48 @@
+"""Test the fix with the actual PDF from the user's example."""
+from natural_pdf import PDF
+from natural_pdf.analyzers.guides import Guides
+
+pdf = PDF("pdfs/m27.pdf")
+page = pdf.pages[0]
+
+# Get headers using the user's exact code
+headers = (
+    page
+    .find("text:contains(NUMBER)")
+    .right(include_source=True)
+    .expand(top=3, bottom=3)
+    .find_all('text')
+)
+
+print("Headers found:")
+for i, h in enumerate(headers):
+    print(f"  {i}: '{h.text}' at x={h.x0:.2f}")
+
+# Create guides using ElementCollection
+guides = Guides(page)
+guides.vertical.from_content(headers, align='left', outer=False)
+
+print(f"\nResulting vertical guides: {sorted(guides.vertical)}")
+
+# Check specific headers that were problematic
+print("\nChecking headers 3-5:")
+for i, h in enumerate(headers[3:5]):
+    print(f"  Header {i+3}: '{h.text}' at x={h.x0:.5f}")
+
+# Test with just headers 3-5
+guides2 = Guides(page)
+guides2.vertical.from_content(headers[3:5], align='left', outer=False) 
+
+print(f"\nGuides from headers[3:5]: {guides2.vertical}")
+print(f"Expected: [328.32012, 539.63316]")
+
+# Verify the fix
+if 332.88095999999996 in guides2.vertical:
+    print("\n❌ FAILED: Extra guide at 332.88 is still present")
+else:
+    print("\n✅ SUCCESS: Extra guide at 332.88 is not present")
+
+# Test that outer guides work correctly too
+guides3 = Guides(page)
+guides3.vertical.from_content(headers[3:5], align='left', outer=True)
+print(f"\nWith outer=True: {guides3.vertical}")

temp/test_fix_working.py

@@ -0,0 +1,55 @@
+"""Test that the fix for region exclusions works"""
+from natural_pdf import PDF
+from natural_pdf.analyzers.guides import Guides
+
+pdf = PDF("pdfs/m27.pdf")
+page = pdf.pages[0]
+
+# Check initial text
+print("Initial text:")
+print(page.extract_text()[:200])
+
+# Add exclusions
+pdf.add_exclusion(lambda page: page.find(text="PREMISE").above())
+pdf.add_exclusion(lambda page: page.find("text:regex(Page \d+ of)").expand())
+
+# Test region extraction with exclusions
+print("\n\nRegion in excluded area (0, 0, 200, 50):")
+excluded_region = page.region(0, 0, 200, 50)
+print("Without exclusions:", repr(excluded_region.extract_text(apply_exclusions=False)))
+print("With exclusions:", repr(excluded_region.extract_text(apply_exclusions=True)))
+
+# Now test the full table extraction
+print("\n\nFull table extraction:")
+headers = (
+    page
+    .find(text="NUMBER")
+    .right(include_source=True)
+    .expand(top=3, bottom=3)
+    .find_all('text')
+)
+
+guides = Guides(page)
+guides.vertical.from_content(headers, align='left')
+guides.horizontal.from_stripes()
+
+result = guides.extract_table(include_outer_boundaries=True, apply_exclusions=True, header=False)
+df = result.to_df()
+
+print(f"Shape: {df.shape}")
+print("\nFirst row:")
+for col, val in df.iloc[0].items():
+    print(f"  {repr(col)}: {repr(val)}")
+
+# Check if excluded content is in the table
+table_str = df.to_string()
+has_feb = "FEBRUARY" in table_str or "FEBR" in table_str and "RUARY" in table_str
+has_alphabetic = "ALPHABETIC LISTING" in table_str
+
+print(f"\nContains 'FEBRUARY': {has_feb}")
+print(f"Contains 'ALPHABETIC LISTING': {has_alphabetic}")
+
+if has_feb or has_alphabetic:
+    print("\n❌ FAILED: Exclusions not working properly")
+else:
+    print("\n✅ SUCCESS: Exclusions working correctly!")

temp/test_fixed_pdf_exclusions.py

@@ -0,0 +1,67 @@
+"""Test PDF-level exclusions with proper Region returns."""
+from natural_pdf import PDF
+from natural_pdf.analyzers.guides import Guides
+
+# Load the PDF
+pdf = PDF("pdfs/m27.pdf")
+
+# Add PDF-level exclusions that properly return Regions
+print("Adding fixed PDF-level exclusions...")
+pdf.add_exclusion(
+    lambda page: page.find("text:contains(PREMISE)").above() 
+    if page.find("text:contains(PREMISE)") else None,
+    label="header_exclusion"
+)
+pdf.add_exclusion(
+    lambda page: page.find("text:regex(Page \d+ of)").expand(10) 
+    if page.find("text:regex(Page \d+ of)") else None,
+    label="footer_exclusion"
+)
+
+page = pdf.pages[0]
+
+# Create guides and extract table
+print("\nCreating guides and extracting table...")
+headers = (
+    page
+    .find("text:contains(NUMBER)")
+    .right(include_source=True)
+    .expand(top=3, bottom=3)
+    .find_all('text')
+)
+
+guides = Guides(page)
+guides.vertical.from_content(headers, align='left')
+guides.horizontal.from_stripes()
+
+# Extract table with apply_exclusions=True (default)
+table_result = guides.extract_table(include_outer_boundaries=True)
+df = table_result.to_df()
+
+print(f"\nTable shape: {df.shape}")
+print("\nFirst few rows:")
+print(df.head())
+
+# Check if excluded content is present
+print("\nChecking for excluded content...")
+table_text = df.to_string()
+has_alphabetic = "ALPHABETIC LISTING" in table_text
+has_page_num = "Page 1 of" in table_text or "Page" in table_text and "of" in table_text
+
+print(f"Contains 'ALPHABETIC LISTING': {has_alphabetic}")
+print(f"Contains 'Page X of Y': {has_page_num}")
+
+if has_alphabetic or has_page_num:
+    print("\n❌ FAILED: Exclusions not properly applied")
+    # Show what's in the first row/column that should be excluded
+    print("\nFirst column values (should not have header text):")
+    print(df.iloc[:5, 0])
+else:
+    print("\n✅ SUCCESS: Exclusions properly applied")
+
+# Debug: Check exclusion regions
+print("\n\nDebug: Checking exclusion regions...")
+exclusions = page._get_exclusion_regions(debug=True)
+print(f"\nTotal exclusion regions: {len(exclusions)}")
+for i, exc in enumerate(exclusions):
+    print(f"  Exclusion {i}: {exc.bbox} (label: {exc.label})")

temp/test_horizontal_top_bottom.py

@@ -0,0 +1,53 @@
+"""Test horizontal guides with top/bottom alignment on real PDF."""
+from natural_pdf import PDF
+from natural_pdf.analyzers.guides import Guides
+
+# Load the PDF
+pdf = PDF("pdfs/m27.pdf")
+page = pdf.pages[0]
+
+# Find some row headers to use as markers
+# First, let's find what text elements exist
+all_text = page.find_all('text')[:20]
+print("First 20 text elements:")
+for t in all_text:
+    print(f"  '{t.text}' at y={t.top:.2f}")
+
+# Look for rows containing numbers in the first column
+rows = page.find_all('text[x0<100]')[:5]  # Get elements in left column
+
+print("Found rows:")
+for i, row in enumerate(rows):
+    print(f"  {i}: '{row.text}' at y={row.top:.2f}-{row.bottom:.2f}")
+
+# Test with align='top' (should use top edge of each row)
+guides_top = Guides(page)
+guides_top.horizontal.from_content(rows, align='top', outer=False)
+
+print(f"\nHorizontal guides with align='top': {sorted(guides_top.horizontal)}")
+print("Expected: top edges of each row")
+
+# Test with align='bottom' (should use bottom edge of each row)
+guides_bottom = Guides(page)
+guides_bottom.horizontal.from_content(rows, align='bottom', outer=False)
+
+print(f"\nHorizontal guides with align='bottom': {sorted(guides_bottom.horizontal)}")
+print("Expected: bottom edges of each row")
+
+# Verify they're different
+if guides_top.horizontal != guides_bottom.horizontal:
+    print("\n✅ SUCCESS: top and bottom alignment produce different guides")
+else:
+    print("\n❌ FAILED: top and bottom alignment produced the same guides")
+
+# Test the class method too
+guides_class_top = Guides.from_content(page, axis='horizontal', markers=rows, align='top', outer=False)
+guides_class_bottom = Guides.from_content(page, axis='horizontal', markers=rows, align='bottom', outer=False)
+
+print(f"\nClass method with top: {sorted(guides_class_top.horizontal)}")
+print(f"Class method with bottom: {sorted(guides_class_bottom.horizontal)}")
+
+if guides_class_top.horizontal == guides_top.horizontal and guides_class_bottom.horizontal == guides_bottom.horizontal:
+    print("\n✅ SUCCESS: Class method produces same results as instance method")
+else:
+    print("\n❌ FAILED: Class method produces different results")