empathy-framework 5.1.1__py3-none-any.whl → 5.3.0__py3-none-any.whl

empathy_os/workflows/progressive/orchestrator 2.py

@@ -1,701 +0,0 @@
-"""Meta-orchestrator for progressive tier escalation decisions.
-
-The MetaOrchestrator is responsible for:
-1. Analyzing tier execution results
-2. Making escalation decisions
-3. Creating specialized agent teams
-4. Building XML-enhanced prompts with failure context
-5. Detecting stagnation patterns
-"""
-
-import logging
-from typing import Any
-
-from empathy_os.workflows.progressive.core import (
-    EscalationConfig,
-    Tier,
-    TierResult,
-)
-
-logger = logging.getLogger(__name__)
-
-
-class MetaOrchestrator:
-    """Meta-agent that orchestrates progressive tier decisions.
-
-    The MetaOrchestrator acts as a higher-level intelligence that:
-    - Analyzes tier results objectively
-    - Decides when to escalate vs retry
-    - Detects stagnation patterns
-    - Creates specialized agent teams per tier
-    - Builds context-aware prompts
-
-    This separates escalation logic from workflow logic, allowing
-    workflows to focus on their domain-specific tasks.
-
-    Example:
-        >>> orchestrator = MetaOrchestrator()
-        >>> should_esc, reason = orchestrator.should_escalate(
-        ...     tier=Tier.CHEAP,
-        ...     result=cheap_result,
-        ...     attempt=2,
-        ...     config=config
-        ... )
-        >>> if should_esc:
-        ...     print(f"Escalating: {reason}")
-    """
-
-    def __init__(self) -> None:
-        """Initialize meta-orchestrator."""
-        self.tier_history: dict[Tier, list[float]] = {
-            Tier.CHEAP: [],
-            Tier.CAPABLE: [],
-            Tier.PREMIUM: []
-        }
-
-    def should_escalate(
-        self,
-        tier: Tier,
-        result: TierResult,
-        attempt: int,
-        config: EscalationConfig
-    ) -> tuple[bool, str]:
-        """Determine if tier should escalate to next tier.
-
-        Multi-criteria decision based on:
-        - Quality score vs thresholds
-        - Syntax errors
-        - Failure rate
-        - Attempt count
-        - Stagnation detection (for CAPABLE tier)
-
-        Args:
-            tier: Current tier
-            result: Execution result
-            attempt: Attempt number at this tier
-            config: Escalation configuration
-
-        Returns:
-            Tuple of (should_escalate, reason)
-
-        Example:
-            >>> should_esc, reason = orchestrator.should_escalate(
-            ...     Tier.CHEAP, result, 2, config
-            ... )
-            >>> # (True, "Quality score 65 below threshold 70")
-        """
-        cqs = result.quality_score
-
-        # Track CQS history for stagnation detection
-        self.tier_history[tier].append(cqs)
-
-        # Check if we've met minimum attempts
-        min_attempts = config.get_min_attempts(tier)
-        if attempt < min_attempts:
-            return False, f"Only {attempt}/{min_attempts} attempts completed"
-
-        # Tier-specific threshold checks
-        if tier == Tier.CHEAP:
-            return self._check_cheap_escalation(result, config)
-        elif tier == Tier.CAPABLE:
-            return self._check_capable_escalation(result, attempt, config)
-        else:  # PREMIUM
-            # Premium doesn't escalate (highest tier)
-            return False, "Premium tier is final"
-
-    def _check_cheap_escalation(
-        self,
-        result: TierResult,
-        config: EscalationConfig
-    ) -> tuple[bool, str]:
-        """Check if cheap tier should escalate to capable.
-
-        Args:
-            result: Cheap tier result
-            config: Escalation configuration
-
-        Returns:
-            Tuple of (should_escalate, reason)
-        """
-        cqs = result.quality_score
-        failure_rate = 1.0 - result.success_rate
-        syntax_error_count = len(result.failure_analysis.syntax_errors)
-
-        # Check severity first (critical failures)
-        if result.failure_analysis.failure_severity == "CRITICAL":
-            return True, "Critical failures detected (consider skipping to Premium)"
-
-        # Check syntax errors (prioritize over CQS)
-        if syntax_error_count > config.cheap_to_capable_max_syntax_errors:
-            return True, f"{syntax_error_count} syntax errors exceeds limit {config.cheap_to_capable_max_syntax_errors}"
-
-        # Check failure rate
-        if failure_rate > config.cheap_to_capable_failure_rate:
-            return True, f"Failure rate {failure_rate:.1%} exceeds threshold {config.cheap_to_capable_failure_rate:.1%}"
-
-        # Check CQS threshold
-        if cqs < config.cheap_to_capable_min_cqs:
-            return True, f"Quality score {cqs:.1f} below threshold {config.cheap_to_capable_min_cqs}"
-
-        # All checks passed, no escalation needed
-        return False, f"Quality acceptable (CQS={cqs:.1f})"
-
-    def _check_capable_escalation(
-        self,
-        result: TierResult,
-        attempt: int,
-        config: EscalationConfig
-    ) -> tuple[bool, str]:
-        """Check if capable tier should escalate to premium.
-
-        Includes stagnation detection: if improvement is <5% for 2 consecutive
-        attempts, escalate even if quality is borderline acceptable.
-
-        Args:
-            result: Capable tier result
-            attempt: Attempt number
-            config: Escalation configuration
-
-        Returns:
-            Tuple of (should_escalate, reason)
-        """
-        cqs = result.quality_score
-        failure_rate = 1.0 - result.success_rate
-        syntax_error_count = len(result.failure_analysis.syntax_errors)
-
-        # Check max attempts first
-        if attempt >= config.capable_max_attempts:
-            return True, f"Max attempts ({config.capable_max_attempts}) reached without achieving target quality"
-
-        # Check syntax errors (strict for capable tier)
-        if syntax_error_count > config.capable_to_premium_max_syntax_errors:
-            return True, f"{syntax_error_count} syntax errors exceeds limit {config.capable_to_premium_max_syntax_errors}"
-
-        # Check failure rate
-        if failure_rate > config.capable_to_premium_failure_rate:
-            return True, f"Failure rate {failure_rate:.1%} exceeds threshold {config.capable_to_premium_failure_rate:.1%}"
-
-        # Check stagnation (consecutive runs with <5% improvement)
-        # Only check if we have enough history
-        if len(self.tier_history[Tier.CAPABLE]) >= config.consecutive_stagnation_limit + 1:
-            is_stagnant, stagnation_reason = self._detect_stagnation(
-                self.tier_history[Tier.CAPABLE],
-                config.improvement_threshold,
-                config.consecutive_stagnation_limit
-            )
-
-            if is_stagnant:
-                return True, f"Stagnation detected: {stagnation_reason}"
-
-        # Check CQS threshold (after stagnation check)
-        if cqs < config.capable_to_premium_min_cqs and attempt >= config.capable_min_attempts:
-            return True, f"Quality score {cqs:.1f} below threshold {config.capable_to_premium_min_cqs}"
-
-        # No escalation needed
-        return False, f"Quality acceptable (CQS={cqs:.1f}), continuing improvement"
-
-    def _detect_stagnation(
-        self,
-        cqs_history: list[float],
-        improvement_threshold: float,
-        consecutive_limit: int
-    ) -> tuple[bool, str]:
-        """Detect if improvement has stagnated.
-
-        Stagnation is defined as N consecutive attempts with <X% improvement.
-
-        Args:
-            cqs_history: List of CQS scores (chronological)
-            improvement_threshold: Min improvement % to avoid stagnation
-            consecutive_limit: Number of consecutive stagnations before escalating
-
-        Returns:
-            Tuple of (is_stagnant, reason)
-
-        Example:
-            >>> history = [75, 76, 77, 77.5]
-            >>> is_stagnant, reason = orchestrator._detect_stagnation(
-            ...     history, improvement_threshold=5.0, consecutive_limit=2
-            ... )
-            >>> # (True, "2 consecutive runs with <5% improvement")
-        """
-        if len(cqs_history) < consecutive_limit + 1:
-            return False, "Insufficient history for stagnation detection"
-
-        # Check last N improvements
-        consecutive_stagnations = 0
-
-        for i in range(len(cqs_history) - 1, 0, -1):
-            current = cqs_history[i]
-            previous = cqs_history[i - 1]
-
-            improvement = current - previous
-
-            if improvement < improvement_threshold:
-                consecutive_stagnations += 1
-
-                if consecutive_stagnations >= consecutive_limit:
-                    return True, (
-                        f"{consecutive_stagnations} consecutive runs with "
-                        f"<{improvement_threshold}% improvement"
-                    )
-            else:
-                # Improvement above threshold, reset counter
-                break
-
-        return False, "No stagnation detected"
-
-    def build_tier_prompt(
-        self,
-        tier: Tier,
-        base_task: str,
-        failure_context: dict[str, Any] | None = None
-    ) -> str:
-        """Build XML-enhanced prompt with failure context.
-
-        Creates tier-appropriate prompts:
-        - CHEAP: Simple, focused prompt
-        - CAPABLE: Enhanced with failure analysis from cheap tier
-        - PREMIUM: Comprehensive with full escalation context
-
-        Args:
-            tier: Which tier this prompt is for
-            base_task: Base task description
-            failure_context: Context from previous tier (if escalating)
-
-        Returns:
-            XML-enhanced prompt string
-
-        Example:
-            >>> prompt = orchestrator.build_tier_prompt(
-            ...     Tier.CAPABLE,
-            ...     "Generate tests for module.py",
-            ...     failure_context={"previous_tier": Tier.CHEAP, ...}
-            ... )
-        """
-        if tier == Tier.CHEAP:
-            return self._build_cheap_prompt(base_task)
-        elif tier == Tier.CAPABLE:
-            return self._build_capable_prompt(base_task, failure_context)
-        else:  # PREMIUM
-            return self._build_premium_prompt(base_task, failure_context)
-
-    def _build_cheap_prompt(self, base_task: str) -> str:
-        """Build simple prompt for cheap tier.
-
-        Args:
-            base_task: Task description
-
-        Returns:
-            XML-enhanced prompt
-        """
-        return f"""<task>
-  <objective>{base_task}</objective>
-
-  <quality_requirements>
-    <pass_rate>70%+</pass_rate>
-    <coverage>60%+</coverage>
-    <syntax>No syntax errors</syntax>
-  </quality_requirements>
-
-  <instructions>
-    Generate high-quality output that meets the quality requirements.
-    Focus on correctness and completeness.
-  </instructions>
-</task>"""
-
-    def _build_capable_prompt(
-        self,
-        base_task: str,
-        failure_context: dict[str, Any] | None
-    ) -> str:
-        """Build enhanced prompt for capable tier with failure context.
-
-        Args:
-            base_task: Task description
-            failure_context: Context from cheap tier
-
-        Returns:
-            XML-enhanced prompt with failure analysis
-        """
-        if not failure_context:
-            # No context, use enhanced base prompt
-            return f"""<task>
-  <objective>{base_task}</objective>
-
-  <quality_requirements>
-    <pass_rate>80%+</pass_rate>
-    <coverage>70%+</coverage>
-    <quality_score>80+</quality_score>
-  </quality_requirements>
-
-  <instructions>
-    Generate high-quality output with comprehensive coverage.
-    Ensure all edge cases are handled correctly.
-  </instructions>
-</task>"""
-
-        # Extract detailed failure context
-        previous_cqs = failure_context.get("previous_cqs", 0)
-        reason = failure_context.get("reason", "Quality below threshold")
-        failures = failure_context.get("failures", [])
-        examples = failure_context.get("examples", [])
-
-        # Analyze failure patterns
-        failure_patterns = self.analyze_failure_patterns(failures) if failures else {}
-
-        # Build detailed prompt with failure analysis
-        prompt_parts = [
-            "<task>",
-            f"  <objective>{base_task}</objective>",
-            "",
-            "  <context_from_previous_tier>",
-            "    <tier>cheap</tier>",
-            f"    <quality_score>{previous_cqs:.1f}</quality_score>",
-            f"    <escalation_reason>{reason}</escalation_reason>",
-            "",
-        ]
-
-        # Add failure pattern analysis
-        if failure_patterns:
-            prompt_parts.append("    <failure_analysis>")
-            prompt_parts.append(f"      <total_failures>{failure_patterns.get('total_failures', 0)}</total_failures>")
-            prompt_parts.append("      <patterns>")
-
-            error_types = failure_patterns.get("error_types", {})
-            for error_type, count in sorted(error_types.items(), key=lambda x: -x[1]):
-                prompt_parts.append(f"        <pattern type=\"{error_type}\" count=\"{count}\" />")
-
-            prompt_parts.append("      </patterns>")
-
-            primary_issue = failure_patterns.get("primary_issue", "unknown")
-            prompt_parts.append(f"      <primary_issue>{primary_issue}</primary_issue>")
-            prompt_parts.append("    </failure_analysis>")
-            prompt_parts.append("")
-
-        # Add concrete failure examples (max 3)
-        if examples:
-            prompt_parts.append("    <failed_attempts>")
-            prompt_parts.append("      <!-- Examples of what the cheap tier produced -->")
-
-            for i, example in enumerate(examples[:3], 1):
-                error = example.get("error", "Unknown error")
-                code_snippet = example.get("code", "")[:200]  # Limit snippet length
-
-                prompt_parts.append(f"      <example number=\"{i}\">")
-                prompt_parts.append(f"        <error>{self._escape_xml(error)}</error>")
-                if code_snippet:
-                    prompt_parts.append(f"        <code_snippet>{self._escape_xml(code_snippet)}</code_snippet>")
-                prompt_parts.append("      </example>")
-
-            prompt_parts.append("    </failed_attempts>")
-            prompt_parts.append("")
-
-        prompt_parts.extend([
-            "    <improvement_needed>",
-            "      The cheap tier struggled with these items. Analyze the failure",
-            "      patterns above and generate improved solutions that specifically",
-            "      address these issues.",
-            "    </improvement_needed>",
-            "  </context_from_previous_tier>",
-            "",
-            "  <your_task>",
-            "    Generate improved output that avoids the specific failure patterns identified above.",
-            "",
-            "    <quality_requirements>",
-            "      <pass_rate>80%+</pass_rate>",
-            "      <coverage>70%+</coverage>",
-            "      <quality_score>80+</quality_score>",
-            "    </quality_requirements>",
-            "",
-            "    <focus_areas>",
-        ])
-
-        # Add targeted focus areas based on failure patterns
-        if failure_patterns:
-            error_types = failure_patterns.get("error_types", {})
-            if "async_errors" in error_types:
-                prompt_parts.append("      <focus area=\"async\">Proper async/await patterns and error handling</focus>")
-            if "mocking_errors" in error_types:
-                prompt_parts.append("      <focus area=\"mocking\">Correct mock setup and teardown</focus>")
-            if "syntax_errors" in error_types:
-                prompt_parts.append("      <focus area=\"syntax\">Valid Python syntax and imports</focus>")
-            if "other_errors" in error_types:
-                prompt_parts.append("      <focus area=\"general\">Edge cases and error handling</focus>")
-        else:
-            # Default focus areas
-            prompt_parts.extend([
-                "      <focus area=\"syntax\">Correct syntax and structure</focus>",
-                "      <focus area=\"coverage\">Comprehensive test coverage</focus>",
-                "      <focus area=\"errors\">Proper error handling</focus>",
-                "      <focus area=\"edge_cases\">Edge case coverage</focus>",
-            ])
-
-        prompt_parts.extend([
-            "    </focus_areas>",
-            "  </your_task>",
-            "</task>"
-        ])
-
-        return "\n".join(prompt_parts)
-
-    def _build_premium_prompt(
-        self,
-        base_task: str,
-        failure_context: dict[str, Any] | None
-    ) -> str:
-        """Build comprehensive prompt for premium tier.
-
-        Args:
-            base_task: Task description
-            failure_context: Context from previous tiers
-
-        Returns:
-            XML-enhanced prompt with full escalation context
-        """
-        if not failure_context:
-            return f"""<task>
-  <objective>{base_task}</objective>
-
-  <quality_requirements>
-    <pass_rate>95%+</pass_rate>
-    <coverage>85%+</coverage>
-    <quality_score>95+</quality_score>
-  </quality_requirements>
-
-  <expert_instructions>
-    Apply expert-level techniques to generate exceptional output.
-    This is the highest tier - excellence is expected.
-  </expert_instructions>
-</task>"""
-
-        # Extract comprehensive escalation context
-        previous_tier = failure_context.get("previous_tier", Tier.CAPABLE)
-        previous_cqs = failure_context.get("previous_cqs", 0)
-        reason = failure_context.get("reason", "Previous tier unsuccessful")
-        failures = failure_context.get("failures", [])
-        examples = failure_context.get("examples", [])
-
-        # Analyze persistent failure patterns
-        failure_patterns = self.analyze_failure_patterns(failures) if failures else {}
-
-        prompt_parts = [
-            "<task>",
-            f"  <objective>{base_task}</objective>",
-            "",
-            "  <escalation_context>",
-            f"    <previous_tier>{previous_tier.value}</previous_tier>",
-            f"    <quality_score>{previous_cqs:.1f}</quality_score>",
-            f"    <escalation_reason>{self._escape_xml(reason)}</escalation_reason>",
-            "",
-            "    <progression_analysis>",
-            "      This task has been escalated through multiple tiers:",
-            "      1. CHEAP tier: Initial attempt with basic models",
-            "      2. CAPABLE tier: Enhanced attempt with better models",
-            "      3. PREMIUM tier (current): Final expert-level attempt",
-            "",
-            "      The fact that this reached premium tier indicates a complex",
-            "      or difficult case requiring expert-level handling.",
-            "    </progression_analysis>",
-            "",
-        ]
-
-        # Add detailed failure analysis
-        if failure_patterns:
-            prompt_parts.append("    <persistent_issues>")
-            prompt_parts.append(f"      <total_failures>{failure_patterns.get('total_failures', 0)}</total_failures>")
-            prompt_parts.append("      <failure_patterns>")
-
-            error_types = failure_patterns.get("error_types", {})
-            for error_type, count in sorted(error_types.items(), key=lambda x: -x[1]):
-                prompt_parts.append(f"        <pattern type=\"{error_type}\" count=\"{count}\">")
-
-                # Add specific guidance per error type
-                if error_type == "async_errors":
-                    prompt_parts.append("          <guidance>Use proper async/await patterns, handle timeouts correctly</guidance>")
-                elif error_type == "mocking_errors":
-                    prompt_parts.append("          <guidance>Ensure mocks are properly configured and reset</guidance>")
-                elif error_type == "syntax_errors":
-                    prompt_parts.append("          <guidance>Double-check syntax, imports, and type annotations</guidance>")
-
-                prompt_parts.append("        </pattern>")
-
-            prompt_parts.append("      </failure_patterns>")
-            prompt_parts.append(f"      <primary_issue>{failure_patterns.get('primary_issue', 'unknown')}</primary_issue>")
-            prompt_parts.append("    </persistent_issues>")
-            prompt_parts.append("")
-
-        # Add concrete examples from capable tier
-        if examples:
-            prompt_parts.append("    <capable_tier_attempts>")
-            prompt_parts.append("      <!-- Examples from the capable tier's attempts -->")
-
-            for i, example in enumerate(examples[:3], 1):
-                error = example.get("error", "Unknown error")
-                code_snippet = example.get("code", "")[:300]  # More context for premium
-                quality_score = example.get("quality_score", 0)
-
-                prompt_parts.append(f"      <attempt number=\"{i}\" quality_score=\"{quality_score}\">")
-                prompt_parts.append(f"        <error>{self._escape_xml(error)}</error>")
-                if code_snippet:
-                    prompt_parts.append(f"        <code_snippet>{self._escape_xml(code_snippet)}</code_snippet>")
-                prompt_parts.append("      </attempt>")
-
-            prompt_parts.append("    </capable_tier_attempts>")
-            prompt_parts.append("")
-
-        prompt_parts.extend([
-            "  </escalation_context>",
-            "",
-            "  <expert_task>",
-            "    <critical_notice>",
-            "      You are the FINAL tier in the progressive escalation system.",
-            "      Previous tiers (cheap and capable) have attempted this task",
-            "      multiple times and could not achieve the required quality.",
-            "",
-            "      This is the last automated attempt before human review.",
-            "      Excellence is not optional - it is required.",
-            "    </critical_notice>",
-            "",
-            "    <expert_techniques>",
-            "      Apply sophisticated approaches:",
-            "      - Deep analysis of why previous attempts failed",
-            "      - Production-grade error handling and edge cases",
-            "      - Comprehensive documentation and clarity",
-            "      - Defensive programming against subtle bugs",
-        ])
-
-        # Add specific techniques based on failure patterns
-        if failure_patterns:
-            error_types = failure_patterns.get("error_types", {})
-            if "async_errors" in error_types:
-                prompt_parts.append("      - Advanced async patterns (asyncio.gather, proper timeouts)")
-            if "mocking_errors" in error_types:
-                prompt_parts.append("      - Sophisticated mocking (pytest fixtures, proper lifecycle)")
-            if "syntax_errors" in error_types:
-                prompt_parts.append("      - Rigorous syntax validation before submission")
-
-        prompt_parts.extend([
-            "    </expert_techniques>",
-            "",
-            "    <quality_requirements>",
-            "      <pass_rate>95%+</pass_rate>",
-            "      <coverage>85%+</coverage>",
-            "      <quality_score>95+</quality_score>",
-            "      <zero_syntax_errors>MANDATORY</zero_syntax_errors>",
-            "    </quality_requirements>",
-            "",
-            "    <success_criteria>",
-            "      Your implementation must:",
-            "      1. Address ALL failure patterns identified above",
-            "      2. Achieve exceptional quality scores (95+)",
-            "      3. Have zero syntax errors or runtime failures",
-            "      4. Include comprehensive edge case coverage",
-            "      5. Be production-ready with proper documentation",
-            "    </success_criteria>",
-            "  </expert_task>",
-            "</task>"
-        ])
-
-        return "\n".join(prompt_parts)
-
-    def _escape_xml(self, text: str) -> str:
-        """Escape special XML characters.
-
-        Args:
-            text: Text to escape
-
-        Returns:
-            XML-safe text
-
-        Example:
-            >>> orchestrator._escape_xml("Error: <missing>")
-            'Error: &lt;missing&gt;'
-        """
-        return (
-            text
-            .replace("&", "&amp;")
-            .replace("<", "&lt;")
-            .replace(">", "&gt;")
-            .replace('"', "&quot;")
-            .replace("'", "&apos;")
-        )
-
-    def create_agent_team(
-        self,
-        tier: Tier,
-        failure_context: dict[str, Any] | None = None
-    ) -> list[str]:
-        """Create specialized agent team for tier.
-
-        Different tiers get different agent compositions:
-        - CHEAP: Single generator agent
-        - CAPABLE: Generator + Analyzer
-        - PREMIUM: Generator + Analyzer + Reviewer
-
-        Args:
-            tier: Which tier
-            failure_context: Context from previous tier
-
-        Returns:
-            List of agent types to create
-
-        Note:
-            This returns agent type names. Actual agent creation
-            will be implemented when we integrate with the agent system.
-
-        Example:
-            >>> agents = orchestrator.create_agent_team(
-            ...     Tier.CAPABLE,
-            ...     failure_context={...}
-            ... )
-            >>> # ["generator", "analyzer"]
-        """
-        if tier == Tier.CHEAP:
-            return ["generator"]
-        elif tier == Tier.CAPABLE:
-            return ["generator", "analyzer"]
-        else:  # PREMIUM
-            return ["generator", "analyzer", "reviewer"]
-
-    def analyze_failure_patterns(
-        self,
-        failures: list[dict[str, Any]]
-    ) -> dict[str, Any]:
-        """Analyze failure patterns to inform next tier.
-
-        Groups failures by type and identifies common issues.
-
-        Args:
-            failures: List of failed items with error details
-
-        Returns:
-            Failure pattern analysis
-
-        Example:
-            >>> patterns = orchestrator.analyze_failure_patterns(
-            ...     [{"error": "SyntaxError: async"}, ...]
-            ... )
-            >>> # {"async_errors": 15, "mocking_errors": 10, ...}
-        """
-        # Group by error type
-        error_types: dict[str, int] = {}
-
-        for failure in failures:
-            error = failure.get("error", "unknown")
-
-            # Categorize error
-            if "async" in error.lower() or "await" in error.lower():
-                error_types["async_errors"] = error_types.get("async_errors", 0) + 1
-            elif "mock" in error.lower():
-                error_types["mocking_errors"] = error_types.get("mocking_errors", 0) + 1
-            elif "syntax" in error.lower():
-                error_types["syntax_errors"] = error_types.get("syntax_errors", 0) + 1
-            else:
-                error_types["other_errors"] = error_types.get("other_errors", 0) + 1
-
-        return {
-            "total_failures": len(failures),
-            "error_types": error_types,
-            "primary_issue": max(error_types.items(), key=lambda x: x[1])[0] if error_types else "unknown"
-        }