wdi-method 0.4.5 → 0.5.0

package/kit/.constitution/{scripts → method/scripts}/validate.py

@@ -1,1579 +1,1599 @@
-#!/usr/bin/env -S uv run --script
-# /// script
-# requires-python = ">=3.11"
-# dependencies = ["pyyaml>=6"]
-# ///
-"""validate — V1..V27 plus generator .control/generated/.
-
-Dua mode:
-    validate --check      keluar non-zero bila ada yang merah; tidak menulis apa pun
-    validate --generate   tulis ulang .control/generated/ (dan tetap menjalankan --check)
-
-Determinisme adalah kontraknya: dua run atas data yang sama MUST memberi hasil yang sama.
-Karena itu tidak ada iterasi tak berurut, dan satu-satunya masukan yang bergantung waktu
-(--asof, dipakai V14) dinyatakan eksplisit alih-alih diambil diam-diam dari jam dinding.
-
-Yang TIDAK dikerjakan di sini: dimensi waktu dari git. `generated/timeline` dan
-`generated/report` milik wdi-report. Lihat 08-project-management.md.
-"""
-
-from __future__ import annotations
-
-import argparse
-import datetime as dt
-import re
-import subprocess
-import sys
-from dataclasses import dataclass, field
-from pathlib import Path
-
-import yaml
-
-REGISTRY = "control/registry"  # dirapikan di resolve(); '.control' dipakai sebenarnya
-GENERATED_ORDER = ["components", "risks", "dag", "rtm", "status"]
-
-# Halaman yang dibaca MANUSIA, bukan mesin: ditulis sebagai tabel markdown sungguhan, bukan yaml
-# dalam fence. Ketiganya disebut §22 dan masing-masing punya satu pembaca yang jelas.
-GENERATED_PAGES = ["decisions", "blueprint", "estimate"]
-
-MODES = ("catalog", "outline", "guarded", "deep")
-
-# Keywords that make a component "sensitive" for V23. Matched against `risk_note`, which is PROSE in
-# whatever `policy.doc_language` the product chose — so the set is the UNION of both languages rather
-# than a translation. It leans toward disclosing more, which is what this check is for: it discloses,
-# it does not judge. Deliberately short.
-SENSITIVE_MARKERS = (
-    # English
-    "money", "payment", "personal data", "pii",
-    "irreversible", "cannot be undone", "contractual", "contract", "integration",
-    # Bahasa Indonesia
-    "uang", "pembayaran", "data pribadi",
-    "tak-terbalikkan", "tak terbalikkan", "tidak dapat dibatalkan",
-    "kontraktual", "kontrak", "integrasi",
-)
-
-
-# ---------------------------------------------------------------- infrastruktur
-
-
-@dataclass(frozen=True)
-class Finding:
-    vid: str
-    subject: str
-    message: str
-
-    @property
-    def sort_key(self) -> tuple[int, str, str]:
-        digits = "".join(ch for ch in self.vid if ch.isdigit())
-        return (int(digits or 0), self.subject, self.message)
-
-
-@dataclass
-class Result:
-    findings: list[Finding] = field(default_factory=list)
-    skipped: dict[str, str] = field(default_factory=dict)
-
-    def fail(self, vid: str, subject: str, message: str) -> None:
-        self.findings.append(Finding(vid, subject, message))
-
-    def skip(self, vid: str, why: str) -> None:
-        self.skipped[vid] = why
-
-    @property
-    def red(self) -> list[str]:
-        return sorted({f.vid for f in self.findings})
-
-
-def load_yaml(path: Path) -> dict:
-    if not path.exists():
-        return {}
-    data = yaml.safe_load(path.read_text(encoding="utf-8"))
-    return data if isinstance(data, dict) else {}
-
-
-def rows(data: dict, key: str) -> list[dict]:
-    """Registry list, selalu terurut menurut id supaya keluaran deterministik."""
-    value = data.get(key) or []
-    if not isinstance(value, list):
-        return []
-    items = [v for v in value if isinstance(v, dict)]
-    return sorted(items, key=lambda r: str(r.get("id", "")))
-
-
-FM = re.compile(r"\A---\s*\n(.*?)\n---\s*(\n|\Z)", re.S)
-
-
-class Dumper(yaml.SafeDumper):
-    """Tanpa anchor/alias: keluaran MUST bisa dibaca dan di-diff baris demi baris."""
-
-    def ignore_aliases(self, data) -> bool:  # noqa: ARG002
-        return True
-
-
-def dump(payload: dict) -> str:
-    return yaml.dump(payload, Dumper=Dumper, allow_unicode=True, sort_keys=False,
-                     default_flow_style=False, width=100)
-
-
-def frontmatter(path: Path) -> dict | None:
-    """None bila berkasnya tidak ada; {} bila ada tetapi tanpa frontmatter."""
-    if not path.exists():
-        return None
-    match = FM.match(path.read_text(encoding="utf-8", errors="replace"))
-    if not match:
-        return {}
-    data = yaml.safe_load(match.group(1))
-    return data if isinstance(data, dict) else {}
-
-
-def git(root: Path, *args: str) -> str | None:
-    try:
-        out = subprocess.run(
-            ["git", "-C", str(root), *args],
-            capture_output=True, text=True, timeout=30, check=False,
-        )
-    except (OSError, subprocess.SubprocessError):
-        return None
-    return out.stdout.strip() if out.returncode == 0 else None
-
-
-# ------------------------------------------------------------------- pemuatan
-
-
-@dataclass
-class Corpus:
-    root: Path
-    requirements: dict
-    usecases: dict
-    decisions: dict
-    risks: dict
-    components: dict
-    waves: dict
-    defects: dict
-    index: dict
-
-    @classmethod
-    def load(cls, root: Path) -> "Corpus":
-        reg = root / ".control" / "registry"
-        return cls(
-            root=root,
-            requirements=load_yaml(reg / "requirements.yaml"),
-            usecases=load_yaml(reg / "usecases.yaml"),
-            decisions=load_yaml(reg / "decisions.yaml"),
-            risks=load_yaml(reg / "risks.yaml"),
-            components=load_yaml(reg / "components.yaml"),
-            waves=load_yaml(reg / "waves.yaml"),
-            defects=load_yaml(reg / "defects.yaml"),
-            index=load_yaml(reg / "index.yaml"),
-        )
-
-    # --- pintasan yang dipakai berulang
-    @property
-    def goals(self) -> list[dict]:
-        return rows(self.requirements, "goals")
-
-    @property
-    def caps(self) -> list[dict]:
-        return rows(self.requirements, "capabilities")
-
-    @property
-    def frs(self) -> list[dict]:
-        return rows(self.requirements, "functional")
-
-    @property
-    def nfrs(self) -> list[dict]:
-        return rows(self.requirements, "nonfunctional")
-
-    @property
-    def ucs(self) -> list[dict]:
-        return rows(self.usecases, "usecases")
-
-    @property
-    def decs(self) -> list[dict]:
-        return rows(self.decisions, "decisions")
-
-    def mode_of(self, pc: dict) -> str:
-        """`mode` per komponen menang atas global; tanpa keduanya, default `catalog`."""
-        own = str(pc.get("mode") or "").strip()
-        if own:
-            return own
-        return str(self.index.get("mode") or "").strip() or "catalog"
-
-    @property
-    def lcs(self) -> list[dict]:
-        return rows(self.components, "logical_components")
-
-    @property
-    def pcs(self) -> list[dict]:
-        return rows(self.components, "product_components")
-
-    @property
-    def wave_list(self) -> list[dict]:
-        return rows(self.waves, "waves")
-
-    @property
-    def defect_list(self) -> list[dict]:
-        return rows(self.defects, "defects")
-
-    def stories(self) -> list[tuple[dict, dict, dict]]:
-        """(wave, epic, story) — urut menurut id di tiap tingkat."""
-        out = []
-        for wave in self.wave_list:
-            for epic in sorted(wave.get("epics") or [], key=lambda e: str(e.get("id", ""))):
-                if not isinstance(epic, dict):
-                    continue
-                for story in sorted(epic.get("stories") or [], key=lambda s: str(s.get("id", ""))):
-                    if isinstance(story, dict):
-                        out.append((wave, epic, story))
-        return out
-
-
-def listy(row: dict, key: str) -> list[str]:
-    value = row.get(key) or []
-    if isinstance(value, str):
-        return [value]
-    return [str(v) for v in value if v is not None]
-
-
-# ------------------------------------------------------------------ validator
-
-
-def v1(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
-    """Tiap BG punya >=1 FR lewat CAP-nya, ATAU menyatakan alasannya di `no_fr`.
-
-    Sebuah sasaran MAY dipenuhi oleh **invarian**, bukan oleh fitur. `BG-6` — fondasi data dan
-    deployment dapat dilanjutkan tanpa dibongkar — diukur oleh dua sifat arsitektural yang `measure`-nya
-    sendiri sebut, dan tidak ada `FR` yang dapat memikulnya tanpa dikarang. Menuntut satu `FR` di sana
-    menghasilkan janji palsu, dan janji palsu lebih mahal daripada temuan.
-
-    Escape-nya MUST membawa alasan, bukan boolean — bentuk yang sama dengan `no_uc` pada `FR` (V2).
-    """
-    cap_by_goal: dict[str, list[str]] = {}
-    for cap in c.caps:
-        cap_by_goal.setdefault(str(cap.get("goal", "")), []).append(str(cap.get("id")))
-    fr_caps = {str(fr.get("capability", "")) for fr in c.frs}
-    for goal in c.goals:
-        gid = str(goal.get("id"))
-        reachable = [cid for cid in cap_by_goal.get(gid, []) if cid in fr_caps]
-        if reachable:
-            continue
-        if str(goal.get("no_fr") or "").strip():
-            continue
-        r.fail("V1", gid, "tidak punya FR lewat CAP-nya dan tidak menyatakan alasan di `no_fr`")
-
-
-def v2(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
-    covered = {fr for uc in c.ucs for fr in listy(uc, "satisfies")}
-    for fr in c.frs:
-        fid = str(fr.get("id"))
-        if fid in covered:
-            continue
-        if str(fr.get("no_uc") or "").strip():
-            continue
-        r.fail("V2", fid, "tidak punya UC dan tidak menyatakan alasan di `no_uc`")
-
-
-def v3(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
-    """Sebuah UC pada komponen yang SUDAH disentuh sebuah wave MUST dijadwalkan story.
-
-    Bentuk lama menuntutnya atas SETIAP UC, kapan pun. Sebelum wave pertama itu berarti seluruh
-    katalog dilaporkan merah — 56 temuan dari 62, dan ke-56 itu keadaan yang benar, bukan drift:
-    story lahir di wave, dan belum ada wave. Sebuah validator yang menenggelamkan enam temuan nyata
-    di bawah lima puluh enam yang diharapkan berhenti dibaca, dan validator yang tidak dibaca tidak
-    menjaga apa pun.
-
-    Yang dijaga sekarang adalah kelalaian yang sebenarnya: sebuah wave menyentuh komponen, dan sebuah
-    UC komponen itu tertinggal tanpa story. Cakupan penuh atas seluruh katalog adalah pertanyaan G5,
-    dan `wdi-build` yang memilikinya — sama seperti V12 yang digeser ke penutupan wave.
-    """
-    scheduled = {uc for _, _, s in c.stories() for uc in listy(s, "satisfies")}
-    touched = {str(s.get("component")) for _, _, s in c.stories() if s.get("component")}
-    if not c.wave_list:
-        r.skip("V3", "belum ada wave, jadi belum ada story — tiap UC tak terjadwal adalah keadaan "
-                     "yang benar. Cakupan penuh katalog diperiksa di G5")
-        return
-    for uc in c.ucs:
-        uid = str(uc.get("id"))
-        if uid in scheduled or str(uc.get("component")) not in touched:
-            continue
-        r.fail("V3", uid, f"komponen `{uc.get('component')}` sudah disentuh sebuah wave, "
-                          f"tetapi UC ini tidak dijadwalkan story mana pun")
-
-
-def v4(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
-    for _, _, story in c.stories():
-        if not [t for t in listy(story, "tests") if t.strip()]:
-            r.fail("V4", str(story.get("id")), "tidak punya satu pun test bernama")
-
-
-def v5(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
-    """Tiap NFR punya penegak, ATAU menyatakan alasannya di `no_enforcer`.
-
-    Dua NFR di repo ini tidak dapat punya penegak, dan keduanya sah: satu sudah **dicabut**, dan satu
-    lagi menyatakan sendiri bahwa ia **ukuran perancangan, bukan pagar**. Menuntut test untuk keduanya
-    menghasilkan test yang tidak mungkin gagal, dan test yang tidak mungkin gagal adalah teater.
-    """
-    for nfr in c.nfrs:
-        if [e for e in listy(nfr, "enforced_by") if e.strip()]:
-            continue
-        if str(nfr.get("no_enforcer") or "").strip():
-            continue
-        r.fail("V5", str(nfr.get("id")),
-               "tidak punya penegak di `enforced_by` dan tidak menyatakan alasan di `no_enforcer`")
-
-
-def v6(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
-    defined: set[str] = set()
-    for group in (c.goals, c.caps, c.frs, c.nfrs, c.ucs, c.decs, c.lcs, c.pcs,
-                  rows(c.requirements, "journeys"), rows(c.risks, "risks"), c.defect_list):
-        defined |= {str(row.get("id")) for row in group if row.get("id") is not None}
-    for wave in c.wave_list:
-        defined.add(str(wave.get("id")))
-    for _, epic, story in c.stories():
-        defined.add(str(epic.get("id")))
-        defined.add(str(story.get("id")))
-
-    refs: list[tuple[str, str]] = []
-    for cap in c.caps:
-        refs.append((str(cap.get("id")), str(cap.get("goal", ""))))
-        refs += [(str(cap.get("id")), d) for d in listy(cap, "depends_on")]
-    for fr in c.frs:
-        refs.append((str(fr.get("id")), str(fr.get("capability", ""))))
-    for nfr in c.nfrs:
-        refs.append((str(nfr.get("id")), str(nfr.get("goal", ""))))
-    for uc in c.ucs:
-        refs += [(str(uc.get("id")), f) for f in listy(uc, "satisfies")]
-    for dec in c.decs:
-        refs += [(str(dec.get("id")), s) for s in listy(dec, "serves")]
-    for defect in c.defect_list:
-        refs += [(str(defect.get("id")), v) for v in listy(defect, "violates")]
-    for _, _, story in c.stories():
-        refs += [(str(story.get("id")), u) for u in listy(story, "satisfies")]
-        refs += [(str(story.get("id")), d) for d in listy(story, "depends_on")]
-
-    for owner, target in sorted(set(refs)):
-        if target and target not in defined:
-            r.fail("V6", owner, f"menunjuk `{target}` yang tidak ada di registry mana pun")
-
-
-def _cycles(graph: dict[str, list[str]]) -> list[str]:
-    state: dict[str, int] = {}
-    bad: list[str] = []
-
-    def walk(node: str) -> None:
-        state[node] = 1
-        for nxt in sorted(graph.get(node, [])):
-            if state.get(nxt) == 1:
-                bad.append(node)
-            elif state.get(nxt) is None and nxt in graph:
-                walk(nxt)
-        state[node] = 2
-
-    for node in sorted(graph):
-        if state.get(node) is None:
-            walk(node)
-    return sorted(set(bad))
-
-
-def v7(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
-    caps = {str(x.get("id")): listy(x, "depends_on") for x in c.caps}
-    for node in _cycles(caps):
-        r.fail("V7", node, "ikut dalam siklus `depends_on` antar-CAP")
-    stories = {str(s.get("id")): listy(s, "depends_on") for _, _, s in c.stories()}
-    for node in _cycles(stories):
-        r.fail("V7", node, "ikut dalam siklus `depends_on` antar-story")
-
-
-def v8(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
-    """Tiap keputusan `applied` menyebut `touches` yang tidak kosong.
-
-    Menggantikan bentuk lama "tiap keputusan accepted melayani >=1 FR/NFR". Keputusan seperti
-    "filter harus begini" tidak melayani FR mana pun, dan itu SAH — justru keputusan seperti itu
-    yang paling perlu diingat, dan aturan lama menyingkirkannya.
-    """
-    for dec in c.decs:
-        if str(dec.get("status")) != "applied":
-            continue
-        if not [x for x in listy(dec, "touches") if str(x).strip()]:
-            r.fail("V8", str(dec.get("id")),
-                   "berstatus applied tetapi `touches` kosong — penerapan tanpa jejak berkas")
-
-
-def v9(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
-    passed = {str(g) for g in (c.index.get("gates_passed") or [])}
-    for path in sorted(c.root.glob(".what/**/*.md")) + sorted(c.root.glob(".how/**/*.md")):
-        fm = frontmatter(path) or {}
-        if str(fm.get("status")) != "locked":
-            continue
-        gate = str(fm.get("locked_at_gate") or "")
-        if gate not in passed:
-            rel = path.relative_to(c.root).as_posix()
-            r.fail("V9", rel, f"berstatus locked tetapi gate `{gate or '?'}` tidak tercatat lulus")
-
-
-def v11(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
-    per_wave: dict[str, list[dict]] = {}
-    for wave, _, story in c.stories():
-        per_wave.setdefault(str(wave.get("id")), []).append(story)
-
-    for wid in sorted(per_wave):
-        items = per_wave[wid]
-        edges = {str(s.get("id")): set(listy(s, "depends_on")) for s in items}
-
-        def reaches(a: str, b: str, seen: set[str] | None = None) -> bool:
-            seen = seen or set()
-            if a in seen:
-                return False
-            seen.add(a)
-            if b in edges.get(a, set()):
-                return True
-            return any(reaches(n, b, seen) for n in sorted(edges.get(a, set())))
-
-        for i, left in enumerate(items):
-            for right in items[i + 1:]:
-                lid, rid = str(left.get("id")), str(right.get("id"))
-                shared = sorted(set(listy(left, "touches")) & set(listy(right, "touches")))
-                if not shared:
-                    continue
-                if reaches(lid, rid) or reaches(rid, lid):
-                    continue
-                r.fail("V11", f"{lid} + {rid}",
-                       f"berbagi touches {shared} tanpa relasi depends_on — MUST NOT paralel")
-
-
-def v12(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
-    """Pendaftaran LC diperiksa saat wave DITUTUP, bukan sebelum story `ready-for-dev`.
-
-    Bentuk lama menuntut jawabannya pada saat informasinya paling tipis. Di penutupan wave,
-    tiap `touches` sudah punya wilayah dan tiap boundary sudah punya nama.
-    """
-    areas = {str(lc.get("area")) for lc in c.lcs if lc.get("area")}
-    lcs_per_pc: dict[str, int] = {}
-    for lc in c.lcs:
-        lcs_per_pc[str(lc.get("component"))] = lcs_per_pc.get(str(lc.get("component")), 0) + 1
-    pc_by_id = {str(x.get("id")): x for x in c.pcs}
-
-    seen: set[tuple[str, str]] = set()
-    for wave, _, story in c.stories():
-        if str(wave.get("status")) != "closed":
-            continue
-        for area in listy(story, "touches"):
-            if area not in areas:
-                r.fail("V12", str(story.get("id")),
-                       f"wave-nya sudah ditutup, tetapi `{area}` tidak terdaftar sebagai `area` "
-                       f"di components.yaml")
-        pid = str(story.get("component") or "")
-        row = pc_by_id.get(pid)
-        if row is None or (str(wave.get("id")), pid) in seen:
-            continue
-        seen.add((str(wave.get("id")), pid))
-        if c.mode_of(row) in ("guarded", "deep") and not lcs_per_pc.get(pid):
-            r.fail("V12", f"{wave.get('id')} / {pid}",
-                   f"wave tertutup dan komponen ber-mode `{c.mode_of(row)}` belum punya satu pun "
-                   f"`LC` terdaftar")
-
-
-LENS_BY_RISK = {
-    "low": {"edge-case-hunter"},
-    "medium": {"edge-case-hunter"},
-    "high": set(),
-}
-FRONTMATTER_KEYS = ("reviewed:", "date:", "sha:", "lenses:", "updated:")
-
-
-def _reviewed_ok(r: Result, rel: str, block: object, need: set[str]) -> None:
-    if not isinstance(block, dict) or not block.get("sha") or not block.get("date"):
-        r.fail("V13", rel, "tidak membawa jejak `reviewed` berisi date dan sha")
-        return
-    lenses = {str(x) for x in (block.get("lenses") or [])}
-    if not lenses:
-        r.fail("V13", rel, "jejak `reviewed` tidak menyebut satu lensa pun")
-    missing = sorted(need - lenses)
-    if missing:
-        r.fail("V13", rel,
-               f"lensa {missing} MUST ikut — itu yang dituntut `risk_accepted` komponennya")
-
-
-def _only_reviewed_block(diff: str) -> bool:
-    """True bila diff sebuah commit atas satu berkas HANYA menyentuh blok `reviewed:`.
-
-    Inilah perbaikan OQ-146. V13 lama membandingkan `sha` dengan commit terakhir yang mengubah
-    berkasnya — tetapi commit yang MENULISKAN blok `reviewed:` selalu mengubah berkasnya, dan
-    menulis hash diri sendiri ke dalam sebuah commit git mustahil secara kriptografis. Akibatnya
-    setiap artefak yang baru distempel langsung terbaca "review basi", selamanya.
-    """
-    touched = [ln for ln in diff.splitlines()
-               if ln[:1] in "+-" and not ln.startswith("+++") and not ln.startswith("---")]
-    if not touched:
-        return True
-    for ln in touched:
-        body = ln[1:].strip()
-        if not body or body.startswith("#"):
-            continue
-        if not body.startswith(FRONTMATTER_KEYS):
-            return False
-    return True
-
-
-def _stale_since(c: Corpus, rel: str, sha: str) -> str | None:
-    """Commit pertama sesudah `sha` yang mengubah berkas ini karena alasan selain stempel review."""
-    log = git(c.root, "log", "--format=%H", f"{sha}..HEAD", "--", rel)
-    if not log:
-        return None
-    for head in log.splitlines():
-        head = head.strip()
-        if not head:
-            continue
-        diff = git(c.root, "show", "--format=", "--unified=0", head, "--", rel)
-        if diff is None:
-            return head
-        if _only_reviewed_block(diff):
-            continue
-        return head
-    return None
-
-
-def v13(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
-    """Jejak review mengikuti INTENSITAS review, bukan kedalaman dokumen.
-
-    Dipersempit ke komponen ber-`risk_accepted` `low` atau `medium`. Pada `high` pemilik sudah
-    menyatakan menerima risikonya, dan menuntut jejak di situ adalah pembukuan tanpa pembeli.
-    """
-    watched = [pc for pc in c.pcs
-               if str(pc.get("risk_accepted") or "").strip() in ("low", "medium")]
-    if not watched:
-        r.skip("V13", "tidak ada komponen ber-risk_accepted low atau medium — tidak ada yang dijaga")
-    targets: list[tuple[Path, set[str]]] = []
-    if watched:
-        targets.append((c.root / ".how/_platform/ARCHITECTURE-SPINE.md", set()))
-    for pc in watched:
-        pid = str(pc.get("id"))
-        need = LENS_BY_RISK.get(str(pc.get("risk_accepted")).strip(), set())
-        # SRS ada dan bermakna pada SETIAP mode: ia membawa Actor Register dan UC Catalogue, dan
-        # keduanya lahir di G3 yang tidak disentuh knob kedalaman.
-        targets.append((c.root / f".what/{pid}/SRS-{pid}.md", need))
-        # SDD hanya dijaga ketika ia PUNYA ISI untuk dijaga. Dua keadaan mengecualikannya, dan
-        # keduanya keadaan SELESAI bukan keadaan tertinggal:
-        #   mode: catalog        skeleton adalah bentuk akhirnya; G4 dilewati di situ
-        #   g4_passed belum ada  G4 belum dijalankan, jadi tidak ada satu bagian pun yang tertulis
-        # Menuntut jejak review atas berkas yang isinya 13 baris komentar template adalah teater —
-        # persis upacara yang rancang ulang ini cabut, dan review yang tidak mungkin gagal tidak
-        # membuktikan apa pun. Begitu G4 lewat, tuntutannya kembali dan ia bermakna.
-        passed = str(pc.get("g4_passed") or "").strip().lower()
-        if c.mode_of(pc) != "catalog" and passed not in ("", "false", "no", "belum"):
-            targets.append((c.root / f".how/{pid}/SDD-{pid}.md", need))
-
-    for path, need in targets:
-        fm = frontmatter(path)
-        if fm is None:
-            continue  # belum lahir — bukan urusan V13
-        rel = path.relative_to(c.root).as_posix()
-        _reviewed_ok(r, rel, fm.get("reviewed"), need)
-        block = fm.get("reviewed")
-        if isinstance(block, dict) and block.get("sha"):
-            stale = _stale_since(c, rel, str(block["sha"]))
-            if stale:
-                r.fail("V13", rel,
-                       f"berubah di {stale[:7]} sesudah direview di {str(block['sha'])[:7]} — "
-                       f"review basi")
-
-    for wave in c.wave_list:
-        if not wave.get("epics"):
-            continue
-        _reviewed_ok(r, f"waves.yaml:{wave.get('id')}", wave.get("spec_reviewed"),
-                     {"edge-case-hunter"})
-
-
-def cap_stories(c: Corpus) -> dict[str, list[dict]]:
-    """CAP -> story, ditelusuri CAP -> FR -> UC -> story. Tanpa git, tanpa timeline."""
-    frs_of: dict[str, list[str]] = {}
-    for fr in c.frs:
-        frs_of.setdefault(str(fr.get("capability", "")), []).append(str(fr.get("id")))
-    ucs_of: dict[str, list[str]] = {}
-    for uc in c.ucs:
-        for fid in listy(uc, "satisfies"):
-            ucs_of.setdefault(fid, []).append(str(uc.get("id")))
-    out: dict[str, list[dict]] = {}
-    for cap in c.caps:
-        cid = str(cap.get("id"))
-        wanted = {u for fid in frs_of.get(cid, []) for u in ucs_of.get(fid, [])}
-        out[cid] = [s for _, _, s in c.stories()
-                    if wanted & set(listy(s, "satisfies"))]
-    return out
-
-
-def v14(c: Corpus, r: Result, asof: dt.date) -> None:
-    """Keterlambatan dihitung dari registry sendiri — timeline hanya memperkuat, bukan syarat."""
-    by_cap = cap_stories(c)
-    timeline = load_yaml(c.root / ".control/generated/timeline.yaml")
-    listed = {str(row.get("id")) for row in rows(timeline, "capabilities")
-              if str(row.get("state")) == "overdue"} if timeline else None
-    if listed is None:
-        r.skip("V14", "generated/timeline.yaml belum ada — keterlambatan tetap dihitung "
-                      "dari registry, tetapi kehadirannya di generated/report tidak diperiksa")
-
-    for cap in c.caps:
-        cid = str(cap.get("id"))
-        end = str(cap.get("planned_end") or "")
-        if not end:
-            continue
-        try:
-            due = dt.date.fromisoformat(end)
-        except ValueError:
-            r.fail("V14", cid, f"`planned_end` `{end}` bukan tanggal ISO")
-            continue
-        items = by_cap.get(cid, [])
-        closed = bool(items) and all(_story_status(c, s) == "done" for s in items)
-        if closed or due >= asof:
-            continue
-        late = (asof - due).days
-        if listed is not None and cid not in listed:
-            r.fail("V14", cid, f"lewat {late} hari tanpa realisasi, dan tidak disebut "
-                               f"`overdue` di generated/timeline")
-        else:
-            r.fail("V14", cid, f"lewat {late} hari tanpa realisasi tertutup")
-
-
-def v15(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
-    for cap in c.caps:
-        if not str(cap.get("goal") or "").strip():
-            r.fail("V15", str(cap.get("id")), "tidak menunjuk `goal`")
-    for fr in c.frs:
-        if not str(fr.get("capability") or "").strip():
-            r.fail("V15", str(fr.get("id")), "tidak menunjuk `capability`")
-
-
-def v16(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
-    for path in sorted((c.root / ".control/memlog").glob("*.md")):
-        fm = frontmatter(path) or {}
-        rel = path.relative_to(c.root).as_posix()
-        artifact = str(fm.get("artifact") or "")
-        if not artifact:
-            r.fail("V16", rel, "tidak punya `artifact:` di frontmatter")
-        elif not (c.root / artifact).exists():
-            r.fail("V16", rel, f"`artifact:` menunjuk `{artifact}` yang tidak ada")
-    for layer in (".what", ".how"):
-        for stray in sorted(c.root.glob(f"{layer}/**/.memlog.md")):
-            r.fail("V16", stray.relative_to(c.root).as_posix(),
-                   "memlog MUST NOT tinggal di dalam korpus")
-
-
-def v17(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
-    for wave in c.wave_list:
-        wid = str(wave.get("id"))
-        if not str(wave.get("release") or "").strip():
-            r.fail("V17", wid, "tidak menyebut `release`")
-        slugs = listy(wave, "prd")
-        if not slugs:
-            r.fail("V17", wid, "tidak menyebut `prd`")
-        for slug in slugs:
-            if not (c.root / ".what/_prd" / slug).is_dir():
-                r.fail("V17", wid, f"`prd: {slug}` tidak punya folder .what/_prd/{slug}/")
-
-
-def v18(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
-    for _, _, story in c.stories():
-        sid = str(story.get("id"))
-        folder = str(story.get("spec_folder") or "").strip()
-        if not folder:
-            r.fail("V18", sid, "tidak menyebut `spec_folder`")
-            continue
-        matches = sorted((c.root / folder / "stories").glob(f"{sid}-*.md"))
-        if not matches:
-            r.fail("V18", sid, f"tidak punya story file di {folder}stories/")
-            continue
-        fm = frontmatter(matches[0]) or {}
-        if not str(fm.get("status") or "").strip():
-            r.fail("V18", sid, "story file tidak punya `status` di frontmatter")
-
-
-def v19(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
-    """Arsip retrospektif diikatkan ke UKURAN WAVE, bukan ke `mode`.
-
-    Wajib pada wave `L`; advisory pada `S` dan `M`. Kedalaman dokumen dan volume kerja adalah dua
-    hal berbeda, dan menuntut retrospektif atas wave tiga story adalah upacara.
-    """
-    names = [x.name for x in sorted((c.root / ".control/reports").glob("RTR-*"))]
-    advisory: list[str] = []
-    for wave in c.wave_list:
-        if str(wave.get("status")) != "closed":
-            continue
-        wid = str(wave.get("id"))
-        if any(wid in name for name in names):
-            continue
-        if str(wave.get("size")).upper() == "L":
-            r.fail("V19", wid, "wave `L` tertutup tanpa `RTR-` di .control/reports/")
-        else:
-            advisory.append(wid)
-    if advisory:
-        r.skip("V19", "advisory — wave S/M tertutup tanpa RTR-: " + ", ".join(sorted(advisory)))
-    else:
-        r.skip("V19", "hanya baris RTR- yang diperiksa mekanis; sisa distilasi dijaga wdi-build")
-
-
-PLATFORM = "_platform"
-CROSS_CUTTING = ".how/_platform/cross-cutting.md"
-PLATFORM_DATA_HEADING = "Milik platform"
-
-
-def v21(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
-    """Satu entitas domain punya TEPAT SATU pemilik yang berwenang menulisnya.
-
-    Pemiliknya sebuah Product Component, ATAU `_platform` untuk entitas yang tidak ada satu pun
-    janji komponen di belakangnya. Bentrokan semantik antar-PRD sudah pernah terjadi sungguhan: satu
-    komponen mengambil rentang penomoran business rule dari deret global milik bersama. Dua `FR`
-    yang mengklaim wewenang tulis atas entitas yang sama, tanpa salah satunya menunjuk yang lain,
-    adalah defect saat ditulis.
-
-    `_platform` BUKAN Product Component dan karena itu tidak punya `mode`, `risk_accepted`, SRS,
-    maupun G4. Ia rumah kepemilikan, bukan irisan domain — dan supaya ia tidak jadi tempat
-    pembuangan, tiap entitas yang ia klaim MUST dijelaskan di `cross-cutting.md`: kalau platform
-    memiliki data, platform yang mendokumentasikannya.
-    """
-    owner: dict[str, str] = {}
-    for pc in c.pcs:
-        pid = str(pc.get("id"))
-        for entity in listy(pc, "owns"):
-            if entity in owner and owner[entity] != pid:
-                r.fail("V21", entity,
-                       f"diklaim `owns` oleh `{owner[entity]}` dan `{pid}` — satu entitas MUST "
-                       f"punya tepat satu pemilik")
-            else:
-                owner.setdefault(entity, pid)
-
-    platform = listy(c.components, "platform_owns")
-    for entity in platform:
-        if entity in owner:
-            r.fail("V21", entity,
-                   f"diklaim `platform_owns` dan juga `owns` milik `{owner[entity]}` — "
-                   f"`{PLATFORM}` bukan jalan kedua bagi entitas yang sudah punya pemilik")
-        else:
-            owner[entity] = PLATFORM
-
-    _platform_documented(c, r, platform + _platform_inventory_rows(c))
-
-    cap_home = {str(x.get("id")): str(x.get("component") or "") for x in c.caps}
-    for fr in c.frs:
-        fid = str(fr.get("id"))
-        home = str(fr.get("component") or cap_home.get(str(fr.get("capability", "")), ""))
-        for entity in listy(fr, "writes"):
-            own = owner.get(entity)
-            if not own or not home or own == home:
-                continue
-            if own == PLATFORM:
-                # Platform tidak punya `FR`, jadi tidak ada yang bisa ditunjuk `defers_to`. Yang
-                # menggantikan "satu penulis" di sini adalah SATU BENTUK YANG TERDOKUMENTASI, dan
-                # itu diperiksa _platform_documented di atas.
-                continue
-            if not [d for d in listy(fr, "defers_to") if str(d).strip()]:
-                r.fail("V21", fid,
-                       f"menjanjikan penulisan `{entity}` yang dimiliki `{own}`, tanpa `defers_to` "
-                       f"menunjuk `FR` milik pemiliknya")
-
-
-def _platform_inventory_rows(c: Corpus) -> list[str]:
-    """Baris inventaris yang dimiliki `_platform`, dibaca dari `platform_rows:` tiap inventaris.
-
-    `_platform` adalah nilai sah di SETIAP posisi kepemilikan, jadi penjaganya berlaku di setiap
-    posisi juga: apa pun yang ia miliki MUST terdokumentasi di `cross-cutting.md`.
-    """
-    out: list[str] = []
-    for kind in ("db", "api", "screen"):
-        path = c.root / f".how/_platform/inventory-{kind}.md"
-        fm = frontmatter(path)
-        if not fm:
-            continue
-        out += [str(x) for x in (fm.get("platform_rows") or [])]
-    return out
-
-
-def _platform_documented(c: Corpus, r: Result, entities: list[str]) -> None:
-    """Tiap entitas ber-`platform_owns` MUST disebut di `cross-cutting.md`.
-
-    Dilewati selama berkasnya belum memuat bagian itu: `cross-cutting.md` adalah keluaran G3, dan
-    artefak yang gate berikutnya lahirkan MUST NOT dilaporkan hilang.
-    """
-    if not entities:
-        return
-    path = c.root / CROSS_CUTTING
-    text = path.read_text(encoding="utf-8", errors="replace") if path.exists() else ""
-    if PLATFORM_DATA_HEADING.lower() not in text.lower():
-        r.skip("V21", f"`{CROSS_CUTTING}` belum punya bagian `{PLATFORM_DATA_HEADING}` — "
-                      f"{len(entities)} entitas ber-platform_owns belum terdokumentasi: "
-                      + ", ".join(sorted(entities)))
-        return
-    for entity in sorted(entities):
-        if entity not in text:
-            r.fail("V21", entity,
-                   f"diklaim `platform_owns` tetapi tidak disebut di `{CROSS_CUTTING}` — "
-                   f"platform yang memiliki data MUST mendokumentasikannya")
-
-
-def v22(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
-    """Sebuah wave MUST NOT menyentuh komponen yang G4-nya belum lewat dan mode-nya bukan catalog.
-
-    `catalog` melewati G4 dengan sengaja, jadi ia bukan pengecualian — ia bagian aturannya.
-    """
-    pc_by_id = {str(x.get("id")): x for x in c.pcs}
-    seen: set[tuple[str, str]] = set()
-    for wave, _, story in c.stories():
-        pid = str(story.get("component") or "")
-        row = pc_by_id.get(pid)
-        if row is None:
-            continue
-        key = (str(wave.get("id")), pid)
-        if key in seen:
-            continue
-        seen.add(key)
-        mode = c.mode_of(row)
-        if mode == "catalog":
-            continue
-        if mode not in MODES:
-            r.fail("V22", pid, f"`mode: {mode}` bukan salah satu dari {list(MODES)}")
-            continue
-        passed = row.get("g4_passed")
-        if not passed or str(passed).strip().lower() in ("false", "no", "belum"):
-            r.fail("V22", f"{wave.get('id')} / {pid}",
-                   f"wave menyentuh komponen ber-mode `{mode}` yang `g4_passed`-nya belum diisi")
-
-
-def v23(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
-    """`risk_accepted: high` pada komponen sensitif menuntut sebuah `DEC-` di `risk_accepted_by`.
-
-    Pada komponen yang tidak menyentuh apa pun dari daftar itu, `high` GRATIS. Kontrolnya
-    pengungkapan, bukan veto — pemilik tetap boleh memilih cepat, tapi tidak tanpa tahu apa yang ia
-    taruhkan.
-    """
-    known = {str(x.get("id")) for x in c.decs}
-    for pc in c.pcs:
-        pid = str(pc.get("id"))
-        if str(pc.get("risk_accepted") or "").strip() != "high":
-            continue
-        note = str(pc.get("risk_note") or "").lower()
-        hits = sorted({m for m in SENSITIVE_MARKERS if m in note})
-        if not hits:
-            continue
-        ref = str(pc.get("risk_accepted_by") or "").strip()
-        if not ref:
-            r.fail("V23", pid,
-                   f"`risk_accepted: high` sementara `risk_note` menyebut {hits}, tanpa "
-                   f"`risk_accepted_by` menunjuk sebuah `DEC-` bertipe risk-acceptance")
-        elif ref not in known:
-            r.fail("V23", pid, f"`risk_accepted_by: {ref}` tidak ada di decisions.yaml")
-
-
-def v20(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
-    needs_link = {"requirement", "architecture"}
-    for defect in c.defect_list:
-        did = str(defect.get("id"))
-        cause = str(defect.get("root_cause") or "")
-        if cause not in needs_link:
-            continue
-        if not listy(defect, "violates"):
-            r.fail("V20", did, f"ber-root_cause `{cause}` tetapi `violates` kosong")
-        if str(defect.get("status")) == "fixed" and not str(defect.get("decision") or "").strip():
-            r.fail("V20", did,
-                   f"ditutup sebagai fixed dengan root_cause `{cause}` tanpa `DEC-` yang menyertainya")
-
-
-# Berkas yang MENGGAMBARKAN masa lalu, bukan MENYATAKAN apa yang berlaku. Kutipan menggantung di sini
-# bukan temuan — corpus-guide.md memiliki aturannya, dan menulisnya ulang akan memalsukan riwayat.
-PAST_RECORD = (
-    ".control/memlog/",
-    ".control/decisions/",
-    ".control/questions/answered.md",
-    ".control/reports/",
-)
-# Korpus yang §25 bekukan apa adanya. Kutipannya ke prototipe yang sudah dipensiunkan disahkan DEC-016.
-FROZEN = (".what/",)
-# Path yang sebuah run LAHIRKAN, bukan yang sebuah dokumen kutip. Aturan yang menyatakan "memlog pass
-# ini mendarat di X" menyebut TUJUAN; menuntut X sudah ada berarti menuntut run-nya sudah jalan.
-DESTINATION = (
-    ".control/memlog/",
-    ".control/meetings/",
-    ".control/reports/",
-    "_bmad-output/",
-)
-
-CITE_RE = re.compile(
-    r"`((?:\.constitution|\.control|\.what|\.how|_bmad-output|\.work|src|web|public|deploy)"
-    r"/[A-Za-z0-9_./-]+\.(?:md|yaml|yml|py|go|tsx|ts|js|mjs|sql|html|css|json))`")
-
-
-def v24(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
-    """Kutipan path di dalam dokumen yang MENYATAKAN apa yang berlaku MUST resolve.
-
-    Ini paruh mekanis dari Evidence check `wdi-reconcile`, dan ia satu-satunya cara mengetahui bahwa
-    sebuah migrasi tetap tuntas. Kelas kegagalannya khas: sebuah berkas dihapus atau dipindahkan,
-    sementara baris routing yang menunjuk ke arahnya tinggal — tidak ada satu pun validator lain yang
-    melihatnya, sebab tidak ada id yang bergerak.
-
-    Yang DILEWATI dengan sengaja: berkas yang menggambarkan masa lalu, dan korpus yang dibekukan.
-    Sebuah Trace `DEC-` yang menyebut bahan yang sudah dipensiunkan menggambarkan apa yang dibaca pada
-    tanggal itu; melaporkannya akan menuntut riwayat ditulis ulang agar cocok dengan masa kini.
-    """
-    scanned = 0
-    for path in sorted(c.root.rglob("*.md")) + sorted(c.root.rglob("*.yaml")):
-        rel = path.relative_to(c.root).as_posix()
-        if rel.startswith((".git/", "node_modules/", "_bmad-output/", ".claude/skills/bmad-")):
-            continue
-        if rel.startswith(PAST_RECORD) or rel.startswith(FROZEN):
-            continue
-        scanned += 1
-        text = path.read_text(encoding="utf-8", errors="replace")
-        for cited in sorted(set(CITE_RE.findall(text))):
-            if "<" in cited or "{" in cited:
-                continue  # placeholder, bukan path
-            if cited.startswith(DESTINATION):
-                continue
-            if not (c.root / cited).exists():
-                r.fail("V24", rel, f"mengutip `{cited}` yang tidak ada")
-    if not scanned:
-        r.skip("V24", "tidak ada berkas yang dipindai")
-
-
-CTR_HEADING = re.compile(r"^###\s+(.+?)\s*$", re.M)
-
-
-def map_container_headings(root: Path) -> list[str] | None:
-    """Heading `### x` di bawah `## Containers` pada peta kode. None bila petanya tidak ada."""
-    path = root / ".control" / "structure-codebase.md"
-    if not path.exists():
-        return None
-    text = path.read_text(encoding="utf-8", errors="replace")
-    start = text.find("\n## Containers")
-    if start < 0:
-        return []
-    rest = text[start + 1:]
-    nxt = re.search(r"^##\s+(?!#)", rest[len("## Containers"):], re.M)
-    if nxt:
-        rest = rest[:len("## Containers") + nxt.start()]
-    return [m.group(1).strip().strip("`") for m in CTR_HEADING.finditer(rest)]
-
-
-def v25(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
-    """`built` sebuah container dan keempat konsekuensinya, plus matriks PC x container.
-
-    Sebuah container ADA di dalam boundary entah kita yang menulis isinya atau bukan, dan itulah yang
-    dulu membuat aturannya tak bisa dipenuhi: `structure-guide.md` menuntut tiap heading peta kode cocok
-    dengan registry, sementara basis data dan web server MUST terdaftar dan MUST NOT punya heading.
-    `built` memisahkan keduanya, dan pemeriksaan ini yang membuat pemisahan itu berlaku alih-alih
-    diulang argumennya tiap proyek. `DEC-017` merekam definisinya.
-
-    Yang runtime-nya bukan kita yang deploy adalah external system: ia hidup di C4 L1 dan MUST NOT
-    terdaftar di sini sama sekali — ketiadaannya di registry itulah pemeriksaannya.
-    """
-    containers = rows(c.components, "containers")
-    if not containers:
-        r.skip("V25", "`containers:` belum terdaftar")
-        return
-
-    built: dict[str, bool] = {}
-    for ctr in containers:
-        cid = str(ctr.get("id") or "").strip()
-        if not cid:
-            r.fail("V25", "containers", "ada container tanpa `id`")
-            continue
-        flag = ctr.get("built")
-        if not isinstance(flag, bool):
-            r.fail("V25", cid, "`built` MUST bool — true bila isinya kita tulis, false bila implementasinya orang lain")
-            continue
-        built[cid] = flag
-
-    # (1) heading peta kode = TEPAT container `built: true`
-    headings = map_container_headings(c.root)
-    if headings is None:
-        r.fail("V25", ".control/structure-codebase.md", "peta kode tidak ada, jadi heading container tidak dapat diadu")
-    else:
-        for h in headings:
-            if h not in built:
-                r.fail("V25", f"peta kode §{h}", "heading bukan container terdaftar — daftarkan, atau ia bukan container")
-            elif not built[h]:
-                r.fail("V25", f"peta kode §{h}", "`built: false` MUST NOT punya heading — tidak ada kode kita di dalamnya")
-        for cid, flag in sorted(built.items()):
-            if flag and cid not in headings:
-                r.fail("V25", cid, "`built: true` MUST punya heading di peta kode")
-
-    # (2) `built: false` MUST NOT dipakai sebuah LC, dan (3) MUST NOT muncul di `containers:` sebuah PC
-    for lc in c.lcs:
-        ctr = str(lc.get("container") or "").strip()
-        if ctr and built.get(ctr) is False:
-            r.fail("V25", str(lc.get("id") or "LC-?"), f"menyebut container `{ctr}` yang `built: false`")
-        elif ctr and ctr not in built:
-            r.fail("V25", str(lc.get("id") or "LC-?"), f"menyebut container `{ctr}` yang tidak terdaftar")
-
-    # (4) matriks PC x container — SSOT-nya field ini, dan ia MUST lengkap di G3
-    for pc in c.pcs:
-        pid = str(pc.get("id") or "?")
-        listed = listy(pc, "containers")
-        if not listed:
-            r.fail("V25", pid, "`containers:` kosong — tiap PC MUST hidup di setidaknya satu container (utang G3)")
-            continue
-        for ctr in listed:
-            if ctr not in built:
-                r.fail("V25", pid, f"`containers:` menyebut `{ctr}` yang tidak terdaftar")
-            elif not built[ctr]:
-                r.fail("V25", pid, f"`containers:` menyebut `{ctr}` yang `built: false` — data hidup di sana menurut definisi, jadi barisnya tidak memberi tahu apa pun")
-
-    # (5) L3 — hanya untuk `built: true`, dan hanya yang memuat lebih dari satu PC
-    pcs_per: dict[str, list[str]] = {}
-    for pc in c.pcs:
-        for ctr in listy(pc, "containers"):
-            pcs_per.setdefault(ctr, []).append(str(pc.get("id") or "?"))
-    for path in sorted((c.root / ".how" / "_platform").glob("c4-l3-*.md")):
-        cid = path.name[len("c4-l3-"):-len(".md")]
-        if cid not in built:
-            r.fail("V25", path.relative_to(c.root).as_posix(),
-                   f"L3 untuk `{cid}` yang bukan container terdaftar")
-        elif not built[cid]:
-            r.fail("V25", path.relative_to(c.root).as_posix(),
-                   f"`{cid}` `built: false` MUST NOT punya L3 — tak satu kotak di dalamnya kita yang gambar")
-    for cid, pids in sorted(pcs_per.items()):
-        if built.get(cid) and len(pids) > 1:
-            l3 = c.root / ".how" / "_platform" / f"c4-l3-{cid}.md"
-            if not l3.exists():
-                r.fail("V25", cid, f"memuat {len(pids)} PC, jadi `c4-l3-{cid}.md` MUST ada")
-
-
-UC_ROW_RE = re.compile(r"^\|\s*(UC-\d+)\s*\|([^\n]*)$", re.M)
-
-# Nilai kolom `critical` dicocokkan mesin, jadi ia machine-facing dan bentuk kanoniknya English `yes`.
-# `ya` tetap diterima: sebuah korpus yang menulisnya sebelum aturan ini berlaku MUST NOT dipaksa migrasi
-# hanya supaya sebuah regex lebih rapi. Batas kata mencegah `ya` mencocoki kata lain.
-CRITICAL_YES = re.compile(r"\b(yes|ya)\b", re.I)
-
-
-def v26(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
-    """Katalog UC di tiap SRS MUST sepakat dengan `usecases.yaml` — id-nya DAN `critical`-nya.
-
-    Ini celah yang paling mahal dari semua yang ditutup lintasan ini, sebab ia satu-satunya yang
-    **sudah terjadi dan tidak satu pun validator melihatnya.** Step 16 menurunkan ulang `critical`
-    di registry dengan definisi yang dipersempit — uang, data pribadi, tindakan tak-terbalikkan — dan
-    ketujuh tabel katalog di SRS tidak ikut. Dua puluh enam baris berselisih, dan selisihnya baru
-    ketahuan ketika seorang manusia membaca kalimat "sembilan di antaranya critical" di SRS-admin
-    sementara registry menyimpan tiga.
-
-    Registry-nya SSOT. Tabel di SRS adalah rumah permanen katalog untuk seorang pembaca, dan dua rumah
-    untuk satu fakta hanya aman kalau ada yang mengadu keduanya. Ini yang mengadu.
-
-    Yang TIDAK diperiksa di sini: judul dan aktor. Keduanya prosa, dan prosa yang berbeda kata bukan
-    prosa yang berbeda arti — mengadunya akan melaporkan gaya sebagai cacat.
-    """
-    reg = {str(uc.get("id")): bool(uc.get("critical")) for uc in c.ucs}
-    reg_pc = {str(uc.get("id")): str(uc.get("component") or "") for uc in c.ucs}
-    checked = 0
-    for pc in c.pcs:
-        pid = str(pc.get("id"))
-        path = c.root / f".what/{pid}/SRS-{pid}.md"
-        if not path.exists():
-            continue
-        checked += 1
-        text = path.read_text(encoding="utf-8", errors="replace")
-        seen: set[str] = set()
-        for match in UC_ROW_RE.finditer(text):
-            uid = match.group(1)
-            cells = [x.strip() for x in match.group(2).split("|")]
-            if len(cells) < 4:
-                continue
-            seen.add(uid)
-            if uid not in reg:
-                r.fail("V26", f"{pid}/{uid}", "ada di katalog SRS tetapi tidak di `usecases.yaml`")
-                continue
-            if reg_pc[uid] != pid:
-                r.fail("V26", f"{pid}/{uid}",
-                       f"registry menaruhnya di `{reg_pc[uid]}`, bukan di komponen ini")
-            marked = CRITICAL_YES.search(cells[3]) is not None
-            if marked != reg[uid]:
-                r.fail("V26", f"{pid}/{uid}",
-                       f"`critical` in the SRS {'yes' if marked else 'no'}, "
-                       f"in the registry {'yes' if reg[uid] else 'no'}")
-        for uid, owner in sorted(reg_pc.items()):
-            if owner == pid and uid not in seen:
-                r.fail("V26", f"{pid}/{uid}", "ada di `usecases.yaml` tetapi tidak di katalog SRS")
-    if not checked:
-        r.skip("V26", "tidak ada SRS yang dapat dibaca")
-
-
-def v27(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
-    """Tiap berkas di kamar custom MUST menyatakan dirinya, dan pembantahan MUST punya keputusan.
-
-    Kamar `.constitution/project/` ada supaya aturan khusus produk punya rumah yang `update` tidak
-    timpa dan `promote` tidak terbitkan. Ongkos yang datang bersamanya: ia juga tempat paling mudah
-    untuk melanggar aturan generic tanpa jejak. Frontmatter-nya yang menahan itu.
-
-    Sebuah berkas di sini MAY mempersempit atau menambah tanpa menyebut apa pun. Untuk MEMBANTAH
-    aturan generic ia MUST menyebutnya di `overrides:` dan membawa `decision:` — sebab metode yang
-    boleh dibantah tanpa keputusan berhenti dapat dipercaya di repo berikutnya.
-
-    `README.md` kamar dilewati: ia dikarang di paket, bukan di produk.
-    """
-    room = c.root / ".constitution" / "project"
-    if not room.is_dir():
-        r.skip("V27", "kamar `.constitution/project/` belum ada — ia disemai saat install")
-        return
-    files = [p for p in sorted(room.rglob("*.md")) if p.name != "README.md"]
-    if not files:
-        r.skip("V27", "kamar `.constitution/project/` kosong, dan itu keadaan yang sah — "
-                      "aturan generic MUST NOT dipindahkan ke sini supaya kamarnya terpakai")
-        return
-    dec_ids = {str(d.get("id")) for d in c.decs}
-    for path in files:
-        rel = path.relative_to(c.root).as_posix()
-        fm = frontmatter(path)
-        if fm is None:
-            r.fail("V27", rel, "tidak punya frontmatter")
-            continue
-        if str(fm.get("scope") or "").strip() != "project":
-            r.fail("V27", rel, "`scope:` MUST berisi tepat `project`")
-        if not str(fm.get("purpose") or "").strip():
-            r.fail("V27", rel, "`purpose:` kosong — satu baris: aturan ini menjaga apa")
-        over = str(fm.get("overrides") or "").strip()
-        dec = str(fm.get("decision") or "").strip()
-        if over:
-            if not (c.root / over).exists():
-                r.fail("V27", rel, f"`overrides:` menunjuk `{over}` yang tidak ada — "
-                                   f"aturan yang dibantah mungkin sudah hilang")
-            if not dec:
-                r.fail("V27", rel, "membantah aturan generic tanpa `decision:` — "
-                                   "pembantahan MUST punya `DEC-` yang memutuskannya")
-            elif dec not in dec_ids:
-                r.fail("V27", rel, f"`decision: {dec}` tidak terdaftar di decisions.yaml")
-        elif dec:
-            r.fail("V27", rel, "`decision:` terisi tanpa `overrides:` — "
-                               "sebutkan aturan mana yang dibantah, atau cabut `decision:`")
-
-
-def run_checks(c: Corpus, asof: dt.date) -> Result:
-    r = Result()
-    for fn in (v1, v2, v3, v4, v5, v6, v7, v8, v9, v11, v12, v13, v15, v16, v17, v18, v19, v20,
-               v21, v22, v23, v24, v25, v26, v27):
-        fn(c, r)
-    v14(c, r, asof)
-    return r
-
-
-# ------------------------------------------------------------------ generator
-
-
-def _story_status(c: Corpus, story: dict) -> str:
-    folder = str(story.get("spec_folder") or "").strip()
-    if not folder:
-        return "unknown"
-    matches = sorted((c.root / folder / "stories").glob(f"{story.get('id')}-*.md"))
-    if not matches:
-        return "unknown"
-    return str((frontmatter(matches[0]) or {}).get("status") or "unknown")
-
-
-def gen_components(c: Corpus) -> dict:
-    return {
-        "product_components": [
-            {"id": pc.get("id"), "name": pc.get("name"),
-             "containers": listy(pc, "containers"),
-             "logical_components": sorted(
-                 str(lc.get("id")) for lc in c.lcs
-                 if str(lc.get("component")) == str(pc.get("id")))}
-            for pc in c.pcs
-        ],
-        "logical_components": [
-            {"id": lc.get("id"), "type": lc.get("type"), "component": lc.get("component"),
-             "area": lc.get("area"), "owner": lc.get("owner")}
-            for lc in c.lcs
-        ],
-    }
-
-
-def gen_risks(c: Corpus) -> dict:
-    return {"risks": [
-        {"id": x.get("id"), "impact": x.get("impact"), "likelihood": x.get("likelihood"),
-         "owner": x.get("owner"), "status": x.get("status"),
-         "pivot_trigger": x.get("pivot_trigger")}
-        for x in rows(c.risks, "risks") if str(x.get("status")) != "closed"
-    ]}
-
-
-def gen_dag(c: Corpus) -> dict:
-    out = []
-    per_wave: dict[str, list[dict]] = {}
-    for wave, _, story in c.stories():
-        per_wave.setdefault(str(wave.get("id")), []).append(story)
-    for wid in sorted(per_wave):
-        items = per_wave[wid]
-        done: set[str] = set()
-        pending = {str(s.get("id")): set(listy(s, "depends_on")) for s in items}
-        waves_out = []
-        while pending:
-            ready = sorted(k for k, deps in pending.items() if not (deps - done))
-            if not ready:  # siklus — V7 sudah melaporkannya
-                waves_out.append({"blocked": sorted(pending)})
-                break
-            waves_out.append({"parallel": ready})
-            done |= set(ready)
-            for k in ready:
-                pending.pop(k)
-        out.append({"wave": wid, "order": waves_out})
-    return {"dag": out}
-
-
-def gen_rtm(c: Corpus) -> dict:
-    cap_goal = {str(x.get("id")): str(x.get("goal", "")) for x in c.caps}
-    ucs_for_fr: dict[str, list[str]] = {}
-    for uc in c.ucs:
-        for fr in listy(uc, "satisfies"):
-            ucs_for_fr.setdefault(fr, []).append(str(uc.get("id")))
-    stories_for_uc: dict[str, list[tuple[dict, dict]]] = {}
-    for wave, _, story in c.stories():
-        for uc in listy(story, "satisfies"):
-            stories_for_uc.setdefault(uc, []).append((wave, story))
-    decs_for: dict[str, list[str]] = {}
-    for dec in c.decs:
-        for target in listy(dec, "serves"):
-            decs_for.setdefault(target, []).append(str(dec.get("id")))
-
-    lines = []
-    for fr in c.frs:
-        fid = str(fr.get("id"))
-        cap = str(fr.get("capability", ""))
-        base = {"BG": cap_goal.get(cap, ""), "CAP": cap, "FR": fid,
-                "DEC": sorted(decs_for.get(fid, []))}
-        ucs = sorted(ucs_for_fr.get(fid, []))
-        if not ucs:
-            exempt = bool(str(fr.get("no_uc") or "").strip())
-            lines.append({**base, "UC": "", "story": "", "wave": "", "release": "",
-                          "test": [], "status": "", "green": False,
-                          "exempt": exempt,
-                          "broken_at": "no_uc" if exempt else "UC"})
-            continue
-        for uid in ucs:
-            pairs = sorted(stories_for_uc.get(uid, []), key=lambda p: str(p[1].get("id")))
-            if not pairs:
-                lines.append({**base, "UC": uid, "story": "", "wave": "", "release": "",
-                              "test": [], "status": "", "green": False, "exempt": False,
-                              "broken_at": "story"})
-                continue
-            for wave, story in pairs:
-                status = _story_status(c, story)
-                tests = listy(story, "tests")
-                broken = ""
-                if not tests:
-                    broken = "test"
-                elif status != "done":
-                    broken = "status"
-                lines.append({**base, "UC": uid, "story": str(story.get("id")),
-                              "wave": str(wave.get("id")), "release": str(wave.get("release", "")),
-                              "test": tests, "status": status, "exempt": False,
-                              "green": broken == "", "broken_at": broken})
-    return {"rtm": lines}
-
-
-def gen_status(c: Corpus, rtm: dict, result: Result) -> dict:
-    lines = rtm.get("rtm") or []
-    counted = [line for line in lines if not line.get("exempt")]
-    exempt = len(lines) - len(counted)
-    green = sum(1 for line in counted if line.get("green"))
-    per_wave = []
-    for wave in c.wave_list:
-        wid = str(wave.get("id"))
-        items = [s for w, _, s in c.stories() if str(w.get("id")) == wid]
-        done = sum(1 for s in items if _story_status(c, s) == "done")
-        per_wave.append({"wave": wid, "status": wave.get("status"),
-                         "stories_done": done, "stories_total": len(items),
-                         "progres_kerja": _pct(done, len(items))})
-    applicable = 26  # V1..V27 tanpa V10 yang gugur
-    return {
-        "progres_janji": _pct(green, len(counted)),
-        "baris_rtm": {"hijau": green, "dihitung": len(counted),
-                      "dikecualikan_no_uc": exempt},
-        "progres_kerja": per_wave,
-        "kesiapan_gate": _pct(applicable - len(result.red), applicable),
-        "validator_merah": result.red,
-        "validator_dilewati": dict(sorted(result.skipped.items())),
-        "pertanyaan_terbuka": _question_budget(c),
-    }
-
-
-def _question_budget(c: Corpus) -> dict:
-    """Hitungan keempat daftar pertanyaan, diadu dengan jatah di index.yaml.
-
-    Jatahnya BUKAN pagar keras. Ia yang dilaporkan ketika sebuah batch melewatinya, karena batch
-    yang lebih besar adalah sinyal tentang lintasannya, bukan tentang korpus.
-    """
-    budget = c.index.get("question_budget") or {}
-    out: dict[str, object] = {}
-    for name in ("blocking", "assumptions", "external", "answered"):
-        path = c.root / ".control/questions" / f"{name}.md"
-        rows_n = 0
-        if path.exists():
-            rows_n = sum(1 for line in path.read_text(encoding="utf-8", errors="replace").splitlines()
-                         if line.startswith("| OQ-"))
-        out[name] = rows_n
-    cap_block = budget.get("blocking_per_component")
-    if cap_block and c.pcs:
-        allowed = int(cap_block) * len(c.pcs)
-        out["blocking_jatah"] = allowed
-        out["blocking_lewat_jatah"] = out["blocking"] > allowed
-    cap_assume = budget.get("assumptions_per_gate")
-    if cap_assume:
-        out["assumptions_jatah_per_gate"] = int(cap_assume)
-    return out
-
-
-def _pct(part: int, total: int) -> str:
-    return "n/a" if total == 0 else f"{round(100 * part / total)}%"
-
-
-def as_markdown(name: str, payload: dict) -> str:
-    body = dump(payload)
-    return (f"# {name}\n\n"
-            f"> Tergenerate oleh `.constitution/scripts/validate --generate`. "
-            f"MUST NOT diedit tangan.\n\n"
-            f"```yaml\n{body}```\n")
-
-
-# ------------------------------------------------------- halaman untuk manusia
-
-PAGE_HEADER = ("> Tergenerate oleh `.constitution/scripts/validate --generate`. "
-               "MUST NOT diedit tangan.\n")
-
-
-def _section(path: Path, heading: str) -> str:
-    """Ambil satu bagian `## <heading>` dari sebuah berkas markdown, apa adanya."""
-    if not path.exists():
-        return ""
-    lines = path.read_text(encoding="utf-8", errors="replace").splitlines()
-    out: list[str] = []
-    inside = False
-    for line in lines:
-        if line.startswith("## "):
-            if inside:
-                break
-            inside = line[3:].strip().lower().startswith(heading.lower())
-            continue
-        if inside:
-            out.append(line)
-    return "\n".join(out).strip("\n")
-
-
-def _body(path: Path) -> str:
-    """Isi berkas tanpa frontmatter dan tanpa komentar template."""
-    if not path.exists():
-        return ""
-    text = path.read_text(encoding="utf-8", errors="replace")
-    match = FM.match(text)
-    if match:
-        text = text[match.end():]
-    while "<!--" in text and "-->" in text:
-        head, _, rest = text.partition("<!--")
-        _, _, tail = rest.partition("-->")
-        text = head + tail
-    return text.strip("\n")
-
-
-def page_decisions(c: Corpus) -> str:
-    """Tabel rata seluruh `DEC-`. Ini yang menggantikan mencari keputusan lewat memlog."""
-    rows_out = ["| id | Judul | Status | Tipe | Menyentuh | Berkas |",
-                "| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |"]
-    for dec in c.decs:
-        touches = ", ".join(f"`{x}`" for x in listy(dec, "touches")) or "—"
-        rows_out.append(
-            f"| `{dec.get('id')}` | {_cell(dec.get('title'))} | `{dec.get('status', '')}` "
-            f"| {dec.get('type') or '—'} | {touches} | `{dec.get('file', '')}` |")
-    counts: dict[str, int] = {}
-    for dec in c.decs:
-        key = str(dec.get("status"))
-        counts[key] = counts.get(key, 0) + 1
-    tally = " · ".join(f"{k}: {v}" for k, v in sorted(counts.items())) or "belum ada keputusan"
-    return ("# decisions\n\n" + PAGE_HEADER +
-            "\nMencari keputusan tidak lagi lewat memlog — memlog kembali jadi log lintasan saja.\n"
-            f"\n**{len(c.decs)} keputusan** — {tally}.\n\n" + "\n".join(rows_out) + "\n")
-
-
-def page_blueprint(c: Corpus) -> str:
-    """Roll-up satu halaman yang di-review di G3. Tujuh berkas jadi satu bacaan.
-
-    Katalog UC, daftar aktor, dan model domain tetap tinggal di kernel komponennya masing-masing
-    sebagai rumah permanennya. Ini tampilannya. Satu fakta, satu rumah, satu tampilan.
-    """
-    parts = ["# blueprint\n", PAGE_HEADER,
-             "\nIni yang dibaca pemilik di **G3 Blueprint**, bukan tujuh berkas. Isinya tidak "
-             "dipengaruhi `mode` maupun `risk_accepted`.\n"]
-
-    crit = sum(1 for uc in c.ucs if uc.get("critical"))
-    parts.append(f"\n## Katalog use case\n\n**{len(c.ucs)} use case**, {crit} bertanda "
-                 f"`critical`.\n")
-    parts.append("| id | Use case | Komponen | Memenuhi | critical |")
-    parts.append("| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |")
-    for uc in c.ucs:
-        sat = ", ".join(f"`{x}`" for x in listy(uc, "satisfies")) or "—"
-        flag = "ya" if uc.get("critical") else "tidak"
-        parts.append(f"| `{uc.get('id')}` | {_cell(uc.get('title'))} | "
-                     f"`{uc.get('component', '')}` | {sat} | {flag} |")
-
-    parts.append("\n## Daftar aktor\n")
-    for pc in c.pcs:
-        pid = str(pc.get("id"))
-        block = _section(c.root / f".what/{pid}/SRS-{pid}.md", "Actor Register")
-        parts.append(f"\n### {pid} — {pc.get('name', '')}\n")
-        parts.append(_demote(block) if block
-                     else "_belum ada § Actor Register di SRS komponen ini._")
-
-    parts.append("\n## Model domain\n")
-    for pc in c.pcs:
-        pid = str(pc.get("id"))
-        block = _body(c.root / f".what/{pid}/03-domain/domain-model.md")
-        parts.append(f"\n### {pid}\n")
-        parts.append(_demote(block) if block else "_belum ada `03-domain/domain-model.md`._")
-
-    parts.append("\n## Tiga inventaris\n")
-    for kind, name in (("db", "tabel"), ("api", "endpoint"), ("screen", "layar")):
-        block = _body(c.root / f".how/_platform/inventory-{kind}.md")
-        parts.append(f"\n### Daftar {name} — `inventory-{kind}.md`\n")
-        parts.append(_demote(block) if block else f"_belum ada `inventory-{kind}.md`._")
-
-    return "\n".join(parts) + "\n"
-
-
-def _cell(value: object, limit: int = 110) -> str:
-    """Satu baris tabel, dipendekkan. Sumber panjangnya tetap di registry — ini tampilan."""
-    text = " ".join(str(value or "").split()).replace("|", "\\|")
-    return text if len(text) <= limit else text[: limit - 1].rstrip() + "…"
-
-
-def _demote(block: str, by: int = 2) -> str:
-    """Turunkan tingkat heading isi yang di-inline, supaya ia tidak menabrak kerangka roll-up."""
-    out = []
-    for line in block.splitlines():
-        stripped = line.lstrip()
-        if stripped.startswith("#"):
-            hashes = len(stripped) - len(stripped.lstrip("#"))
-            out.append("#" * min(6, hashes + by) + stripped[hashes:])
-        else:
-            out.append(line)
-    return "\n".join(out)
-
-
-def page_estimate(c: Corpus) -> str:
-    """Tabel task KANDIDAT. Satu baris per `FR`, karena itu bentuk ideal sebuah wave."""
-    mode_of = {str(pc.get("id")): c.mode_of(pc) for pc in c.pcs}
-    risk_of = {str(pc.get("id")): (str(pc.get("risk_accepted") or "—"),
-                                   str(pc.get("risk_note") or "—")) for pc in c.pcs}
-    cap_by_id = {str(x.get("id")): x for x in c.caps}
-    fr_per_cap: dict[str, int] = {}
-    for fr in c.frs:
-        key = str(fr.get("capability", ""))
-        fr_per_cap[key] = fr_per_cap.get(key, 0) + 1
-
-    have_mandays = any(x.get("estimate_mandays") for x in c.caps)
-    parts = ["# estimate\n", PAGE_HEADER,
-             "\n**INI ESTIMASI, MENGHADAP KE DEPAN.** Tiap baris di bawah adalah task "
-             "**kandidat**; wave di `waves.yaml` yang nyata. Satu baris MAY jadi satu wave, dan tiga "
-             "baris bertetangga MAY digabung jadi satu — penggabungan itu keputusan manusia saat wave "
-             "dibuka.\n"]
-    if not have_mandays:
-        parts.append("\n**Tanpa `estimate_mandays` pada satu pun `CAP`**, kolom Beban kosong dan "
-                     "keluaran ini setara ukuran kelas T-shirt. Ia MUST dilaporkan sebagai itu.\n")
-
-    parts.append("\n| Task | FR | Epic | mode | Paparan | Beban | Prioritas | Bergantung | Rilis |")
-    parts.append("| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |")
-    for fr in c.frs:
-        cap_id = str(fr.get("capability", ""))
-        cap = cap_by_id.get(cap_id, {})
-        pid = str(fr.get("component") or cap.get("component") or "")
-        risk, note = risk_of.get(pid, ("—", "—"))
-        exposure = "belum disetel" if risk == "—" else f"`{risk}` — {_cell(note, 60)}"
-        mandays = cap.get("estimate_mandays")
-        share = "—"
-        if mandays:
-            try:
-                share = f"{float(mandays) / max(1, fr_per_cap.get(cap_id, 1)):.1f}"
-            except (TypeError, ValueError):
-                share = "—"
-        deps = ", ".join(f"`{x}`" for x in listy(cap, "depends_on")) or "—"
-        parts.append(
-            f"| {_cell(fr.get('text') or fr.get('title'))} | `{fr.get('id')}` | `{pid or '—'}` "
-            f"| `{mode_of.get(pid, 'catalog')}` | {exposure} | {share} "
-            f"| {cap.get('priority', '—')} | {deps} | {cap.get('target_release', '—')} |")
-    return "\n".join(parts) + "\n"
-
-
-def generate(c: Corpus, result: Result) -> list[Path]:
-    out_dir = c.root / ".control" / "generated"
-    out_dir.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True)
-    rtm = gen_rtm(c)
-    payloads = {
-        "components": gen_components(c),
-        "risks": gen_risks(c),
-        "dag": gen_dag(c),
-        "rtm": rtm,
-        "status": gen_status(c, rtm, result),
-    }
-    written = []
-    for name in GENERATED_ORDER:
-        payload = payloads[name]
-        yaml_path = out_dir / f"{name}.yaml"
-        yaml_path.write_text(dump(payload), encoding="utf-8")
-        md_path = out_dir / f"{name}.md"
-        md_path.write_text(as_markdown(name, payload), encoding="utf-8")
-        written += [yaml_path, md_path]
-
-    # Tiga halaman untuk MANUSIA: tabel markdown sungguhan, tanpa kembar .yaml. Yang dibaca orang
-    # tidak dibungkus fence yaml, dan tidak ada pembaca mesin yang menuntut versi keduanya.
-    for name, render in (("decisions", page_decisions),
-                         ("blueprint", page_blueprint),
-                         ("estimate", page_estimate)):
-        page = out_dir / f"{name}.md"
-        page.write_text(render(c), encoding="utf-8")
-        written.append(page)
-    return written
-
-
-# ------------------------------------------------------------------------ CLI
-
-
-def main(argv: list[str] | None = None) -> int:
-    parser = argparse.ArgumentParser(
-        prog="validate", description="V1..V27 dan generator .control/generated/")
-    parser.add_argument("--check", action="store_true",
-                        help="periksa saja; keluar non-zero bila ada yang merah")
-    parser.add_argument("--generate", action="store_true",
-                        help="tulis ulang .control/generated/ (tetap memeriksa lebih dulu)")
-    parser.add_argument("--root", default=".", help="akar repo (default: direktori sekarang)")
-    parser.add_argument("--asof", default=None,
-                        help="tanggal acuan V14, format YYYY-MM-DD (default: hari ini). "
-                             "Dinyatakan eksplisit supaya run bisa diulang persis")
-    args = parser.parse_args(argv)
-
-    if not args.check and not args.generate:
-        args.check = True
-
-    root = Path(args.root).resolve()
-    if not (root / ".control" / "registry").is_dir():
-        print(f"validate: {root} tidak punya .control/registry/ — salah akar repo?", file=sys.stderr)
-        return 2
-
-    asof = dt.date.fromisoformat(args.asof) if args.asof else dt.date.today()
-    corpus = Corpus.load(root)
-    result = run_checks(corpus, asof)
-
-    if args.generate:
-        for path in generate(corpus, result):
-            print(f"  tulis {path.relative_to(root).as_posix()}")
-
-    if result.findings:
-        print(f"\nMERAH — {len(result.findings)} temuan di {len(result.red)} validator\n")
-        for finding in sorted(result.findings, key=lambda f: f.sort_key):
-            print(f"  {finding.vid:<4} {finding.subject}: {finding.message}")
-    else:
-        print("\nHIJAU — tidak ada temuan")
-
-    if result.skipped:
-        print("\nDilewati:")
-        for vid, why in sorted(result.skipped.items()):
-            print(f"  {vid:<4} {why}")
-
-    print(f"\nacuan waktu V14: {asof.isoformat()}")
-    return 1 if result.findings else 0
-
-
-if __name__ == "__main__":
-    raise SystemExit(main())
+#!/usr/bin/env -S uv run --script
+# /// script
+# requires-python = ">=3.11"
+# dependencies = ["pyyaml>=6"]
+# ///
+"""validate — V1..V27 plus the .control/generated/ generator.
+
+Two modes:
+    validate --check      exit non-zero if anything is red; writes nothing
+    validate --generate   rewrite .control/generated/ (and still runs --check)
+
+Determinism is the contract: two runs over the same data MUST produce the same result.
+That is why there is no unordered iteration, and the one time-dependent input
+(--asof, used by V14) is stated explicitly instead of being taken silently from the wall clock.
+
+What is NOT done here: the time dimension from git. `generated/timeline` and
+`generated/report` belong to wdi-report. See 08-project-management.md.
+"""
+
+from __future__ import annotations
+
+import argparse
+import datetime as dt
+import re
+import subprocess
+import sys
+from dataclasses import dataclass, field
+from pathlib import Path
+
+import yaml
+
+REGISTRY = "control/registry"  # tidied up in resolve(); '.control' is what is actually used
+GENERATED_ORDER = ["components", "risks", "dag", "rtm", "status"]
+
+# Pages read by HUMANS, not machines: written as real markdown tables, not yaml
+# in a fence. All three are named in §22 and each has one clear reader.
+GENERATED_PAGES = ["decisions", "blueprint", "estimate"]
+
+MODES = ("catalog", "outline", "guarded", "deep")
+
+# Keywords that make a component "sensitive" for V23. Matched against `risk_note`, which is PROSE in
+# whatever `policy.doc_language` the product chose — so the set is the UNION of both languages rather
+# than a translation. It leans toward disclosing more, which is what this check is for: it discloses,
+# it does not judge. Deliberately short.
+SENSITIVE_MARKERS = (
+    # English
+    "money", "payment", "personal data", "pii",
+    "irreversible", "cannot be undone", "contractual", "contract", "integration",
+    # Bahasa Indonesia
+    "uang", "pembayaran", "data pribadi",
+    "tak-terbalikkan", "tak terbalikkan", "tidak dapat dibatalkan",
+    "kontraktual", "kontrak", "integrasi",
+)
+
+
+# ---------------------------------------------------------------- infrastructure
+
+
+@dataclass(frozen=True)
+class Finding:
+    vid: str
+    subject: str
+    message: str
+
+    @property
+    def sort_key(self) -> tuple[int, str, str]:
+        digits = "".join(ch for ch in self.vid if ch.isdigit())
+        return (int(digits or 0), self.subject, self.message)
+
+
+@dataclass
+class Result:
+    findings: list[Finding] = field(default_factory=list)
+    skipped: dict[str, str] = field(default_factory=dict)
+
+    def fail(self, vid: str, subject: str, message: str) -> None:
+        self.findings.append(Finding(vid, subject, message))
+
+    def skip(self, vid: str, why: str) -> None:
+        self.skipped[vid] = why
+
+    @property
+    def red(self) -> list[str]:
+        return sorted({f.vid for f in self.findings})
+
+
+def load_yaml(path: Path) -> dict:
+    if not path.exists():
+        return {}
+    data = yaml.safe_load(path.read_text(encoding="utf-8"))
+    return data if isinstance(data, dict) else {}
+
+
+def rows(data: dict, key: str) -> list[dict]:
+    """Registry list, always sorted by id so the output is deterministic."""
+    value = data.get(key) or []
+    if not isinstance(value, list):
+        return []
+    items = [v for v in value if isinstance(v, dict)]
+    return sorted(items, key=lambda r: str(r.get("id", "")))
+
+
+FM = re.compile(r"\A---\s*\n(.*?)\n---\s*(\n|\Z)", re.S)
+
+
+class Dumper(yaml.SafeDumper):
+    """No anchors/aliases: output MUST be readable and diffable line by line."""
+
+    def ignore_aliases(self, data) -> bool:  # noqa: ARG002
+        return True
+
+
+def dump(payload: dict) -> str:
+    return yaml.dump(payload, Dumper=Dumper, allow_unicode=True, sort_keys=False,
+                     default_flow_style=False, width=100)
+
+
+def frontmatter(path: Path) -> dict | None:
+    """None if the file does not exist; {} if it exists but has no frontmatter."""
+    if not path.exists():
+        return None
+    match = FM.match(path.read_text(encoding="utf-8", errors="replace"))
+    if not match:
+        return {}
+    data = yaml.safe_load(match.group(1))
+    return data if isinstance(data, dict) else {}
+
+
+def git(root: Path, *args: str) -> str | None:
+    try:
+        out = subprocess.run(
+            ["git", "-C", str(root), *args],
+            capture_output=True, text=True, timeout=30, check=False,
+        )
+    except (OSError, subprocess.SubprocessError):
+        return None
+    return out.stdout.strip() if out.returncode == 0 else None
+
+
+# ------------------------------------------------------------------- loading
+
+
+@dataclass
+class Corpus:
+    root: Path
+    requirements: dict
+    usecases: dict
+    decisions: dict
+    risks: dict
+    components: dict
+    waves: dict
+    defects: dict
+    index: dict
+
+    @classmethod
+    def load(cls, root: Path) -> "Corpus":
+        reg = root / ".control" / "registry"
+        return cls(
+            root=root,
+            requirements=load_yaml(reg / "requirements.yaml"),
+            usecases=load_yaml(reg / "usecases.yaml"),
+            decisions=load_yaml(reg / "decisions.yaml"),
+            risks=load_yaml(reg / "risks.yaml"),
+            components=load_yaml(reg / "components.yaml"),
+            waves=load_yaml(reg / "waves.yaml"),
+            defects=load_yaml(reg / "defects.yaml"),
+            index=load_yaml(reg / "index.yaml"),
+        )
+
+    # --- shortcuts used repeatedly
+    @property
+    def goals(self) -> list[dict]:
+        return rows(self.requirements, "goals")
+
+    @property
+    def caps(self) -> list[dict]:
+        return rows(self.requirements, "capabilities")
+
+    @property
+    def frs(self) -> list[dict]:
+        return rows(self.requirements, "functional")
+
+    @property
+    def nfrs(self) -> list[dict]:
+        return rows(self.requirements, "nonfunctional")
+
+    @property
+    def ucs(self) -> list[dict]:
+        return rows(self.usecases, "usecases")
+
+    @property
+    def decs(self) -> list[dict]:
+        return rows(self.decisions, "decisions")
+
+    def mode_of(self, pc: dict) -> str:
+        """Per-component `mode` wins over the global one; with neither, default `catalog`."""
+        own = str(pc.get("mode") or "").strip()
+        if own:
+            return own
+        return str(self.index.get("mode") or "").strip() or "catalog"
+
+    @property
+    def lcs(self) -> list[dict]:
+        return rows(self.components, "logical_components")
+
+    @property
+    def pcs(self) -> list[dict]:
+        return rows(self.components, "product_components")
+
+    @property
+    def wave_list(self) -> list[dict]:
+        return rows(self.waves, "waves")
+
+    @property
+    def defect_list(self) -> list[dict]:
+        return rows(self.defects, "defects")
+
+    def stories(self) -> list[tuple[dict, dict, dict]]:
+        """(wave, epic, story) — sorted by id at each level."""
+        out = []
+        for wave in self.wave_list:
+            for epic in sorted(wave.get("epics") or [], key=lambda e: str(e.get("id", ""))):
+                if not isinstance(epic, dict):
+                    continue
+                for story in sorted(epic.get("stories") or [], key=lambda s: str(s.get("id", ""))):
+                    if isinstance(story, dict):
+                        out.append((wave, epic, story))
+        return out
+
+
+def listy(row: dict, key: str) -> list[str]:
+    value = row.get(key) or []
+    if isinstance(value, str):
+        return [value]
+    return [str(v) for v in value if v is not None]
+
+
+# ------------------------------------------------------------------ validators
+
+
+def v1(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
+    """Every BG has >=1 FR through its CAP, OR states its reason in `no_fr`.
+
+    A goal MAY be satisfied by an **invariant** rather than a feature. `BG-6` — the data and
+    deployment foundation can be extended without being torn down — is measured by two architectural
+    properties that its own `measure` names, and no `FR` can carry it without being invented. Demanding
+    one `FR` there produces a false promise, and a false promise is more expensive than a finding.
+
+    The escape MUST carry a reason, not a boolean — the same shape as `no_uc` on `FR` (V2).
+    """
+    cap_by_goal: dict[str, list[str]] = {}
+    for cap in c.caps:
+        cap_by_goal.setdefault(str(cap.get("goal", "")), []).append(str(cap.get("id")))
+    fr_caps = {str(fr.get("capability", "")) for fr in c.frs}
+    for goal in c.goals:
+        gid = str(goal.get("id"))
+        reachable = [cid for cid in cap_by_goal.get(gid, []) if cid in fr_caps]
+        if reachable:
+            continue
+        if str(goal.get("no_fr") or "").strip():
+            continue
+        r.fail("V1", gid, "has no FR through its CAP and states no reason in `no_fr`")
+
+
+def v2(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
+    covered = {fr for uc in c.ucs for fr in listy(uc, "satisfies")}
+    for fr in c.frs:
+        fid = str(fr.get("id"))
+        if fid in covered:
+            continue
+        if str(fr.get("no_uc") or "").strip():
+            continue
+        r.fail("V2", fid, "has no UC and states no reason in `no_uc`")
+
+
+def v3(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
+    """A UC on a component that a wave has ALREADY touched MUST be scheduled to a story.
+
+    The old shape demanded this of EVERY UC, at any time. Before the first wave that meant the
+    entire catalogue was reported red — 56 findings out of 62, and those 56 were the correct state,
+    not drift: a story is born in a wave, and there was no wave yet. A validator that drowns six real
+    findings under fifty-six expected ones stops being read, and a validator that is not read
+    guards nothing.
+
+    What is guarded now is the actual omission: a wave touches a component, and a UC of that
+    component is left behind without a story. Full coverage of the whole catalogue is a G5 question,
+    and `wdi-build` owns it — the same way V12 was shifted to wave closing.
+    """
+    scheduled = {uc for _, _, s in c.stories() for uc in listy(s, "satisfies")}
+    touched = {str(s.get("component")) for _, _, s in c.stories() if s.get("component")}
+    if not c.wave_list:
+        r.skip("V3", "no wave yet, so no story yet — every unscheduled UC is the correct "
+                     "state. Full catalogue coverage is checked at G5")
+        return
+    for uc in c.ucs:
+        uid = str(uc.get("id"))
+        if uid in scheduled or str(uc.get("component")) not in touched:
+            continue
+        r.fail("V3", uid, f"component `{uc.get('component')}` has already been touched by a wave, "
+                          f"but this UC is not scheduled to any story")
+
+
+def v4(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
+    for _, _, story in c.stories():
+        if not [t for t in listy(story, "tests") if t.strip()]:
+            r.fail("V4", str(story.get("id")), "has not one named test")
+
+
+def v5(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
+    """Every NFR has an enforcer, OR states its reason in `no_enforcer`.
+
+    Two NFRs in this repo cannot have an enforcer, and both are valid: one has already been
+    **retired**, and the other states of itself that it is a **design measure, not a gate**. Demanding
+    a test for both produces a test that cannot fail, and a test that cannot fail is theater.
+    """
+    for nfr in c.nfrs:
+        if [e for e in listy(nfr, "enforced_by") if e.strip()]:
+            continue
+        if str(nfr.get("no_enforcer") or "").strip():
+            continue
+        r.fail("V5", str(nfr.get("id")),
+               "has no enforcer in `enforced_by` and states no reason in `no_enforcer`")
+
+
+def v6(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
+    defined: set[str] = set()
+    for group in (c.goals, c.caps, c.frs, c.nfrs, c.ucs, c.decs, c.lcs, c.pcs,
+                  rows(c.requirements, "journeys"), rows(c.risks, "risks"), c.defect_list):
+        defined |= {str(row.get("id")) for row in group if row.get("id") is not None}
+    for wave in c.wave_list:
+        defined.add(str(wave.get("id")))
+    for _, epic, story in c.stories():
+        defined.add(str(epic.get("id")))
+        defined.add(str(story.get("id")))
+
+    refs: list[tuple[str, str]] = []
+    for cap in c.caps:
+        refs.append((str(cap.get("id")), str(cap.get("goal", ""))))
+        refs += [(str(cap.get("id")), d) for d in listy(cap, "depends_on")]
+    for fr in c.frs:
+        refs.append((str(fr.get("id")), str(fr.get("capability", ""))))
+    for nfr in c.nfrs:
+        refs.append((str(nfr.get("id")), str(nfr.get("goal", ""))))
+    for uc in c.ucs:
+        refs += [(str(uc.get("id")), f) for f in listy(uc, "satisfies")]
+    for dec in c.decs:
+        refs += [(str(dec.get("id")), s) for s in listy(dec, "serves")]
+    for defect in c.defect_list:
+        refs += [(str(defect.get("id")), v) for v in listy(defect, "violates")]
+    for _, _, story in c.stories():
+        refs += [(str(story.get("id")), u) for u in listy(story, "satisfies")]
+        refs += [(str(story.get("id")), d) for d in listy(story, "depends_on")]
+
+    for owner, target in sorted(set(refs)):
+        if target and target not in defined:
+            r.fail("V6", owner, f"points to `{target}` which does not exist in any registry")
+
+
+def _cycles(graph: dict[str, list[str]]) -> list[str]:
+    state: dict[str, int] = {}
+    bad: list[str] = []
+
+    def walk(node: str) -> None:
+        state[node] = 1
+        for nxt in sorted(graph.get(node, [])):
+            if state.get(nxt) == 1:
+                bad.append(node)
+            elif state.get(nxt) is None and nxt in graph:
+                walk(nxt)
+        state[node] = 2
+
+    for node in sorted(graph):
+        if state.get(node) is None:
+            walk(node)
+    return sorted(set(bad))
+
+
+def v7(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
+    caps = {str(x.get("id")): listy(x, "depends_on") for x in c.caps}
+    for node in _cycles(caps):
+        r.fail("V7", node, "is part of a `depends_on` cycle among CAPs")
+    stories = {str(s.get("id")): listy(s, "depends_on") for _, _, s in c.stories()}
+    for node in _cycles(stories):
+        r.fail("V7", node, "is part of a `depends_on` cycle among stories")
+
+
+def v8(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
+    """Every `applied` decision names a non-empty `touches`.
+
+    Replaces the old shape "every accepted decision serves >=1 FR/NFR". A decision like
+    "the filter MUST work like this" serves no FR at all, and that is VALID — it is exactly
+    decisions like that which most need remembering, and the old rule discarded them.
+    """
+    for dec in c.decs:
+        if str(dec.get("status")) != "applied":
+            continue
+        if not [x for x in listy(dec, "touches") if str(x).strip()]:
+            r.fail("V8", str(dec.get("id")),
+                   "is applied but `touches` is empty — an application with no file trace")
+
+
+def v9(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
+    passed = {str(g) for g in (c.index.get("gates_passed") or [])}
+    for path in sorted(c.root.glob(".what/**/*.md")) + sorted(c.root.glob(".how/**/*.md")):
+        fm = frontmatter(path) or {}
+        if str(fm.get("status")) != "locked":
+            continue
+        gate = str(fm.get("locked_at_gate") or "")
+        if gate not in passed:
+            rel = path.relative_to(c.root).as_posix()
+            r.fail("V9", rel, f"is locked but gate `{gate or '?'}` is not recorded as passed")
+
+
+def v11(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
+    per_wave: dict[str, list[dict]] = {}
+    for wave, _, story in c.stories():
+        per_wave.setdefault(str(wave.get("id")), []).append(story)
+
+    for wid in sorted(per_wave):
+        items = per_wave[wid]
+        edges = {str(s.get("id")): set(listy(s, "depends_on")) for s in items}
+
+        def reaches(a: str, b: str, seen: set[str] | None = None) -> bool:
+            seen = seen or set()
+            if a in seen:
+                return False
+            seen.add(a)
+            if b in edges.get(a, set()):
+                return True
+            return any(reaches(n, b, seen) for n in sorted(edges.get(a, set())))
+
+        for i, left in enumerate(items):
+            for right in items[i + 1:]:
+                lid, rid = str(left.get("id")), str(right.get("id"))
+                shared = sorted(set(listy(left, "touches")) & set(listy(right, "touches")))
+                if not shared:
+                    continue
+                if reaches(lid, rid) or reaches(rid, lid):
+                    continue
+                r.fail("V11", f"{lid} + {rid}",
+                       f"share touches {shared} with no depends_on relation — MUST NOT run in parallel")
+
+
+def v12(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
+    """LC registration is checked when a wave CLOSES, not before a story goes `ready-for-dev`.
+
+    The old shape demanded the answer when the information was thinnest. At wave closing,
+    every `touches` already has an area and every boundary already has a name.
+    """
+    areas = {str(lc.get("area")) for lc in c.lcs if lc.get("area")}
+    lcs_per_pc: dict[str, int] = {}
+    for lc in c.lcs:
+        lcs_per_pc[str(lc.get("component"))] = lcs_per_pc.get(str(lc.get("component")), 0) + 1
+    pc_by_id = {str(x.get("id")): x for x in c.pcs}
+
+    seen: set[tuple[str, str]] = set()
+    for wave, _, story in c.stories():
+        if str(wave.get("status")) != "closed":
+            continue
+        for area in listy(story, "touches"):
+            if area not in areas:
+                r.fail("V12", str(story.get("id")),
+                       f"its wave is already closed, but `{area}` is not registered as an `area` "
+                       f"in components.yaml")
+        pid = str(story.get("component") or "")
+        row = pc_by_id.get(pid)
+        if row is None or (str(wave.get("id")), pid) in seen:
+            continue
+        seen.add((str(wave.get("id")), pid))
+        if c.mode_of(row) in ("guarded", "deep") and not lcs_per_pc.get(pid):
+            r.fail("V12", f"{wave.get('id')} / {pid}",
+                   f"wave closed and component with mode `{c.mode_of(row)}` has not one "
+                   f"`LC` registered")
+
+
+LENS_BY_RISK = {
+    "low": {"edge-case-hunter"},
+    "medium": {"edge-case-hunter"},
+    "high": set(),
+}
+FRONTMATTER_KEYS = ("reviewed:", "date:", "sha:", "lenses:", "updated:")
+
+
+def _reviewed_ok(r: Result, rel: str, block: object, need: set[str]) -> None:
+    if not isinstance(block, dict) or not block.get("sha") or not block.get("date"):
+        r.fail("V13", rel, "carries no `reviewed` trace with a date and sha")
+        return
+    lenses = {str(x) for x in (block.get("lenses") or [])}
+    if not lenses:
+        r.fail("V13", rel, "the `reviewed` trace names not one lens")
+    missing = sorted(need - lenses)
+    if missing:
+        r.fail("V13", rel,
+               f"lenses {missing} MUST be included — that is what the component's `risk_accepted` demands")
+
+
+def _only_reviewed_block(diff: str) -> bool:
+    """True if a commit's diff on one file ONLY touches the `reviewed:` block.
+
+    This is the OQ-146 fix. The old V13 compared `sha` against the last commit that changed
+    the file — but the commit that WRITES the `reviewed:` block always changes the file, and
+    writing its own hash into a git commit is cryptographically impossible. As a result every
+    artifact that had just been stamped immediately read as "stale review", forever.
+    """
+    touched = [ln for ln in diff.splitlines()
+               if ln[:1] in "+-" and not ln.startswith("+++") and not ln.startswith("---")]
+    if not touched:
+        return True
+    for ln in touched:
+        body = ln[1:].strip()
+        if not body or body.startswith("#"):
+            continue
+        if not body.startswith(FRONTMATTER_KEYS):
+            return False
+    return True
+
+
+def _stale_since(c: Corpus, rel: str, sha: str) -> str | None:
+    """First commit after `sha` that changes this file for a reason other than a review stamp."""
+    log = git(c.root, "log", "--format=%H", f"{sha}..HEAD", "--", rel)
+    if not log:
+        return None
+    for head in log.splitlines():
+        head = head.strip()
+        if not head:
+            continue
+        diff = git(c.root, "show", "--format=", "--unified=0", head, "--", rel)
+        if diff is None:
+            return head
+        if _only_reviewed_block(diff):
+            continue
+        return head
+    return None
+
+
+def v13(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
+    """Review trace follows review INTENSITY, not document depth.
+
+    Narrowed to components with `risk_accepted` `low` or `medium`. At `high` the owner has already
+    stated they accept the risk, and demanding a trace there is bookkeeping with no buyer.
+    """
+    watched = [pc for pc in c.pcs
+               if str(pc.get("risk_accepted") or "").strip() in ("low", "medium")]
+    if not watched:
+        r.skip("V13", "no component with risk_accepted low or medium — nothing to guard")
+    targets: list[tuple[Path, set[str]]] = []
+    if watched:
+        targets.append((c.root / ".how/_platform/ARCHITECTURE-SPINE.md", set()))
+    for pc in watched:
+        pid = str(pc.get("id"))
+        need = LENS_BY_RISK.get(str(pc.get("risk_accepted")).strip(), set())
+        # The SRS exists and is meaningful at EVERY mode: it carries the Actor Register and UC
+        # Catalogue, and both are born at G3, which the depth knob does not touch.
+        targets.append((c.root / f".what/{pid}/SRS-{pid}.md", need))
+        # The SDD is guarded only when it HAS content worth guarding. Two states exempt it, and
+        # both are FINISHED states, not neglected ones:
+        #   mode: catalog        the skeleton is its final form; G4 is skipped there
+        #   g4_passed not set    G4 has not run yet, so not one section is written
+        # Demanding a review trace on a file whose content is 13 lines of template comments is
+        # theater — exactly the ceremony this redesign cut, and a review that cannot fail proves
+        # nothing. Once G4 passes, the demand comes back and it is meaningful.
+        passed = str(pc.get("g4_passed") or "").strip().lower()
+        if c.mode_of(pc) != "catalog" and passed not in ("", "false", "no", "belum"):
+            targets.append((c.root / f".how/{pid}/SDD-{pid}.md", need))
+
+    for path, need in targets:
+        fm = frontmatter(path)
+        if fm is None:
+            continue  # not born yet — not V13's business
+        rel = path.relative_to(c.root).as_posix()
+        _reviewed_ok(r, rel, fm.get("reviewed"), need)
+        block = fm.get("reviewed")
+        if isinstance(block, dict) and block.get("sha"):
+            stale = _stale_since(c, rel, str(block["sha"]))
+            if stale:
+                r.fail("V13", rel,
+                       f"changed at {stale[:7]} after being reviewed at {str(block['sha'])[:7]} — "
+                       f"stale review")
+
+    for wave in c.wave_list:
+        if not wave.get("epics"):
+            continue
+        _reviewed_ok(r, f"waves.yaml:{wave.get('id')}", wave.get("spec_reviewed"),
+                     {"edge-case-hunter"})
+
+
+def cap_stories(c: Corpus) -> dict[str, list[dict]]:
+    """CAP -> story, traced through CAP -> FR -> UC -> story. No git, no timeline."""
+    frs_of: dict[str, list[str]] = {}
+    for fr in c.frs:
+        frs_of.setdefault(str(fr.get("capability", "")), []).append(str(fr.get("id")))
+    ucs_of: dict[str, list[str]] = {}
+    for uc in c.ucs:
+        for fid in listy(uc, "satisfies"):
+            ucs_of.setdefault(fid, []).append(str(uc.get("id")))
+    out: dict[str, list[dict]] = {}
+    for cap in c.caps:
+        cid = str(cap.get("id"))
+        wanted = {u for fid in frs_of.get(cid, []) for u in ucs_of.get(fid, [])}
+        out[cid] = [s for _, _, s in c.stories()
+                    if wanted & set(listy(s, "satisfies"))]
+    return out
+
+
+def v14(c: Corpus, r: Result, asof: dt.date) -> None:
+    """Overdue-ness is computed from the registry itself — the timeline only reinforces, never gates."""
+    by_cap = cap_stories(c)
+    timeline = load_yaml(c.root / ".control/generated/timeline.yaml")
+    listed = {str(row.get("id")) for row in rows(timeline, "capabilities")
+              if str(row.get("state")) == "overdue"} if timeline else None
+    if listed is None:
+        r.skip("V14", "generated/timeline.yaml does not exist yet — overdue-ness is still computed "
+                      "from the registry, but its presence in generated/report is not checked")
+
+    for cap in c.caps:
+        cid = str(cap.get("id"))
+        end = str(cap.get("planned_end") or "")
+        if not end:
+            continue
+        try:
+            due = dt.date.fromisoformat(end)
+        except ValueError:
+            r.fail("V14", cid, f"`planned_end` `{end}` is not an ISO date")
+            continue
+        items = by_cap.get(cid, [])
+        closed = bool(items) and all(_story_status(c, s) == "done" for s in items)
+        if closed or due >= asof:
+            continue
+        late = (asof - due).days
+        if listed is not None and cid not in listed:
+            r.fail("V14", cid, f"{late} days overdue with nothing delivered, and not flagged "
+                               f"`overdue` in generated/timeline")
+        else:
+            r.fail("V14", cid, f"{late} days overdue with nothing closed")
+
+
+def v15(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
+    for cap in c.caps:
+        if not str(cap.get("goal") or "").strip():
+            r.fail("V15", str(cap.get("id")), "does not point to a `goal`")
+    for fr in c.frs:
+        if not str(fr.get("capability") or "").strip():
+            r.fail("V15", str(fr.get("id")), "does not point to a `capability`")
+
+
+def v16(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
+    for path in sorted((c.root / ".control/memlog").glob("*.md")):
+        fm = frontmatter(path) or {}
+        rel = path.relative_to(c.root).as_posix()
+        artifact = str(fm.get("artifact") or "")
+        if not artifact:
+            r.fail("V16", rel, "has no `artifact:` in frontmatter")
+        elif not (c.root / artifact).exists():
+            r.fail("V16", rel, f"`artifact:` points to `{artifact}` which does not exist")
+    for layer in (".what", ".how"):
+        for stray in sorted(c.root.glob(f"{layer}/**/.memlog.md")):
+            r.fail("V16", stray.relative_to(c.root).as_posix(),
+                   "a memlog MUST NOT live inside the corpus")
+
+
+def v17(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
+    for wave in c.wave_list:
+        wid = str(wave.get("id"))
+        if not str(wave.get("release") or "").strip():
+            r.fail("V17", wid, "does not name a `release`")
+        slugs = listy(wave, "prd")
+        if not slugs:
+            r.fail("V17", wid, "does not name a `prd`")
+        for slug in slugs:
+            if not (c.root / ".what/_prd" / slug).is_dir():
+                r.fail("V17", wid, f"`prd: {slug}` has no folder .what/_prd/{slug}/")
+
+
+def v18(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
+    for _, _, story in c.stories():
+        sid = str(story.get("id"))
+        folder = str(story.get("spec_folder") or "").strip()
+        if not folder:
+            r.fail("V18", sid, "does not name a `spec_folder`")
+            continue
+        matches = sorted((c.root / folder / "stories").glob(f"{sid}-*.md"))
+        if not matches:
+            r.fail("V18", sid, f"has no story file in {folder}stories/")
+            continue
+        fm = frontmatter(matches[0]) or {}
+        if not str(fm.get("status") or "").strip():
+            r.fail("V18", sid, "story file has no `status` in frontmatter")
+
+
+def v19(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
+    """The retrospective archive is tied to WAVE SIZE, not to `mode`.
+
+    Mandatory on wave `L`; advisory on `S` and `M`. Document depth and volume of work are two
+    different things, and demanding a retrospective for a three-story wave is ceremony.
+    """
+    names = [x.name for x in sorted((c.root / ".control/reports").glob("RTR-*"))]
+    advisory: list[str] = []
+    for wave in c.wave_list:
+        if str(wave.get("status")) != "closed":
+            continue
+        wid = str(wave.get("id"))
+        if any(wid in name for name in names):
+            continue
+        if str(wave.get("size")).upper() == "L":
+            r.fail("V19", wid, "wave `L` closed without an `RTR-` in .control/reports/")
+        else:
+            advisory.append(wid)
+    if advisory:
+        r.skip("V19", "advisory — wave S/M closed without an RTR-: " + ", ".join(sorted(advisory)))
+    else:
+        r.skip("V19", "only the RTR- line item is checked mechanically; the rest of the distillation is guarded by wdi-build")
+
+
+PLATFORM = "_platform"
+CROSS_CUTTING = ".how/_platform/cross-cutting.md"
+PLATFORM_DATA_HEADING = "Milik platform"
+
+
+def v21(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
+    """One domain entity has EXACTLY ONE owner authorized to write it.
+
+    The owner is a Product Component, OR `_platform` for an entity with no single component
+    promise behind it. Semantic collisions across PRDs have already happened for real: one
+    component took a business-rule numbering range from a shared global sequence. Two `FR`s
+    that both claim write authority over the same entity, with neither pointing at the other,
+    are a defect the moment they are written.
+
+    `_platform` is NOT a Product Component and therefore has no `mode`, `risk_accepted`, SRS,
+    or G4. It is a home for ownership, not a domain slice — and so it does not become a dumping
+    ground, every entity it claims MUST be explained in `cross-cutting.md`: if the platform
+    owns the data, the platform documents it.
+    """
+    owner: dict[str, str] = {}
+    for pc in c.pcs:
+        pid = str(pc.get("id"))
+        for entity in listy(pc, "owns"):
+            if entity in owner and owner[entity] != pid:
+                r.fail("V21", entity,
+                       f"claimed as `owns` by both `{owner[entity]}` and `{pid}` — one entity MUST "
+                       f"have exactly one owner")
+            else:
+                owner.setdefault(entity, pid)
+
+    platform = listy(c.components, "platform_owns")
+    for entity in platform:
+        if entity in owner:
+            r.fail("V21", entity,
+                   f"claimed as `platform_owns` and also as `owns` by `{owner[entity]}` — "
+                   f"`{PLATFORM}` is not a second path for an entity that already has an owner")
+        else:
+            owner[entity] = PLATFORM
+
+    _platform_documented(c, r, platform + _platform_inventory_rows(c))
+
+    cap_home = {str(x.get("id")): str(x.get("component") or "") for x in c.caps}
+    for fr in c.frs:
+        fid = str(fr.get("id"))
+        home = str(fr.get("component") or cap_home.get(str(fr.get("capability", "")), ""))
+        for entity in listy(fr, "writes"):
+            own = owner.get(entity)
+            if not own or not home or own == home:
+                continue
+            if own == PLATFORM:
+                # The platform has no `FR`, so there is nothing a `defers_to` could point to. What
+                # stands in for "one writer" here is ONE DOCUMENTED FORM, and that is what
+                # _platform_documented checks above.
+                continue
+            if not [d for d in listy(fr, "defers_to") if str(d).strip()]:
+                r.fail("V21", fid,
+                       f"promises to write `{entity}` which `{own}` owns, without `defers_to` "
+                       f"pointing to an `FR` owned by that owner")
+
+
+def _platform_inventory_rows(c: Corpus) -> list[str]:
+    """Inventory rows owned by `_platform`, read from `platform_rows:` in each inventory.
+
+    `_platform` is a valid value at EVERY ownership position, so the guard applies at every
+    position too: whatever it owns MUST be documented in `cross-cutting.md`.
+    """
+    out: list[str] = []
+    for kind in ("db", "api", "screen"):
+        path = c.root / f".how/_platform/inventory-{kind}.md"
+        fm = frontmatter(path)
+        if not fm:
+            continue
+        out += [str(x) for x in (fm.get("platform_rows") or [])]
+    return out
+
+
+def _platform_documented(c: Corpus, r: Result, entities: list[str]) -> None:
+    """Every entity with `platform_owns` MUST be named in `cross-cutting.md`.
+
+    Skipped while the file does not yet carry that section: `cross-cutting.md` is a G3 output, and
+    an artifact the next gate will produce MUST NOT be reported missing.
+    """
+    if not entities:
+        return
+    path = c.root / CROSS_CUTTING
+    text = path.read_text(encoding="utf-8", errors="replace") if path.exists() else ""
+    if PLATFORM_DATA_HEADING.lower() not in text.lower():
+        r.skip("V21", f"`{CROSS_CUTTING}` has no `{PLATFORM_DATA_HEADING}` section yet — "
+                      f"{len(entities)} entities with platform_owns are not documented yet: "
+                      + ", ".join(sorted(entities)))
+        return
+    for entity in sorted(entities):
+        if entity not in text:
+            r.fail("V21", entity,
+                   f"claimed as `platform_owns` but not named in `{CROSS_CUTTING}` — "
+                   f"a platform that owns data MUST document it")
+
+
+def v22(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
+    """A wave MUST NOT touch a component whose G4 has not passed and whose mode is not catalog.
+
+    `catalog` skips G4 on purpose, so it is not an exception — it is part of the rule.
+    """
+    pc_by_id = {str(x.get("id")): x for x in c.pcs}
+    seen: set[tuple[str, str]] = set()
+    for wave, _, story in c.stories():
+        pid = str(story.get("component") or "")
+        row = pc_by_id.get(pid)
+        if row is None:
+            continue
+        key = (str(wave.get("id")), pid)
+        if key in seen:
+            continue
+        seen.add(key)
+        mode = c.mode_of(row)
+        if mode == "catalog":
+            continue
+        if mode not in MODES:
+            r.fail("V22", pid, f"`mode: {mode}` is not one of {list(MODES)}")
+            continue
+        passed = row.get("g4_passed")
+        if not passed or str(passed).strip().lower() in ("false", "no", "belum"):
+            r.fail("V22", f"{wave.get('id')} / {pid}",
+                   f"wave touches a component with mode `{mode}` whose `g4_passed` has not been set")
+
+
+def v23(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
+    """`risk_accepted: high` on a sensitive component demands a `DEC-` in `risk_accepted_by`.
+
+    On a component that touches nothing on that list, `high` is FREE. The control is
+    disclosure, not veto — the owner may still choose quickly, just not without knowing what
+    they are wagering.
+    """
+    known = {str(x.get("id")) for x in c.decs}
+    for pc in c.pcs:
+        pid = str(pc.get("id"))
+        if str(pc.get("risk_accepted") or "").strip() != "high":
+            continue
+        note = str(pc.get("risk_note") or "").lower()
+        hits = sorted({m for m in SENSITIVE_MARKERS if m in note})
+        if not hits:
+            continue
+        ref = str(pc.get("risk_accepted_by") or "").strip()
+        if not ref:
+            r.fail("V23", pid,
+                   f"`risk_accepted: high` while `risk_note` mentions {hits}, without "
+                   f"`risk_accepted_by` pointing to a risk-acceptance `DEC-`")
+        elif ref not in known:
+            r.fail("V23", pid, f"`risk_accepted_by: {ref}` does not exist in decisions.yaml")
+
+
+def v20(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
+    needs_link = {"requirement", "architecture"}
+    for defect in c.defect_list:
+        did = str(defect.get("id"))
+        cause = str(defect.get("root_cause") or "")
+        if cause not in needs_link:
+            continue
+        if not listy(defect, "violates"):
+            r.fail("V20", did, f"has `root_cause` `{cause}` but `violates` is empty")
+        if str(defect.get("status")) == "fixed" and not str(defect.get("decision") or "").strip():
+            r.fail("V20", did,
+                   f"closed as fixed with root_cause `{cause}` without an accompanying `DEC-`")
+
+
+# Files that DESCRIBE the past, not STATE what currently holds. A dangling citation here is
+# not a finding — corpus-guide.md owns that rule, and rewriting it would falsify history.
+PAST_RECORD = (
+    ".control/memlog/",
+    ".control/decisions/",
+    ".control/questions/answered.md",
+    ".control/reports/",
+)
+# Corpus that §25 freezes as-is. Its citation of a now-retired prototype is authorized by DEC-016.
+FROZEN = (".what/",)
+# Derived output. A finding here is UNACTIONABLE by construction — the folder MUST NOT be written
+# by hand, so nobody may fix it where it is reported. It also renders registry values inside
+# backticks, which makes a frozen `DEC-` `touches:` entry look like a live citation: the 0.5.0
+# layout move surfaced three of those, all of them correct history. Fix the source or leave it.
+DERIVED = (".control/generated/",)
+# A path a run WILL PRODUCE, not one a document cites as existing. A rule stating "this pass's
+# memlog lands at X" names a DESTINATION; demanding X already exist would demand the run has already
+# happened.
+DESTINATION = (
+    ".control/memlog/",
+    ".control/meetings/",
+    ".control/reports/",
+    "_bmad-output/",
+)
+
+CITE_RE = re.compile(
+    r"`((?:\.constitution|\.control|\.what|\.how|_bmad-output|\.work|src|web|public|deploy)"
+    r"/[A-Za-z0-9_./-]+\.(?:md|yaml|yml|py|go|tsx|ts|js|mjs|sql|html|css|json))`")
+
+
+def v24(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
+    """A path citation inside a document that STATES what currently holds MUST resolve.
+
+    This is the mechanical half of `wdi-reconcile`'s Evidence check, and it is the only way to know
+    that a migration stayed complete. Its failure class is distinctive: a file gets deleted or moved,
+    while the routing line that points at it stays behind — no other validator sees it, because no
+    id moved.
+
+    Deliberately SKIPPED: files that describe the past, corpus that has been frozen, and derived
+    output. A `DEC-` Trace that names material that has since been retired describes what was read on
+    that date; reporting it would demand history be rewritten to match the present. Derived output is
+    skipped for a second reason on top of that: it MUST NOT be edited by hand, so a finding reported
+    there names a file nobody is allowed to fix.
+    """
+    scanned = 0
+    for path in sorted(c.root.rglob("*.md")) + sorted(c.root.rglob("*.yaml")):
+        rel = path.relative_to(c.root).as_posix()
+        if rel.startswith((".git/", "node_modules/", "_bmad-output/", ".claude/skills/bmad-")):
+            continue
+        if rel.startswith(PAST_RECORD) or rel.startswith(FROZEN) or rel.startswith(DERIVED):
+            continue
+        scanned += 1
+        text = path.read_text(encoding="utf-8", errors="replace")
+        for cited in sorted(set(CITE_RE.findall(text))):
+            if "<" in cited or "{" in cited:
+                continue  # placeholder, not a path
+            if cited.startswith(DESTINATION):
+                continue
+            if not (c.root / cited).exists():
+                r.fail("V24", rel, f"cites `{cited}` which does not exist")
+    if not scanned:
+        r.skip("V24", "no file was scanned")
+
+
+CTR_HEADING = re.compile(r"^###\s+(.+?)\s*$", re.M)
+
+
+def map_container_headings(root: Path) -> list[str] | None:
+    """Heading `### x` under `## Containers` in the code map. None if the map does not exist."""
+    path = root / ".control" / "structure-codebase.md"
+    if not path.exists():
+        return None
+    text = path.read_text(encoding="utf-8", errors="replace")
+    start = text.find("\n## Containers")
+    if start < 0:
+        return []
+    rest = text[start + 1:]
+    nxt = re.search(r"^##\s+(?!#)", rest[len("## Containers"):], re.M)
+    if nxt:
+        rest = rest[:len("## Containers") + nxt.start()]
+    return [m.group(1).strip().strip("`") for m in CTR_HEADING.finditer(rest)]
+
+
+def v25(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
+    """A container's `built` and its four consequences, plus the PC x container matrix.
+
+    A container EXISTS inside the boundary whether or not we write its content, and that is what
+    used to make the rule unsatisfiable: `structure-guide.md` demands every code-map heading match
+    the registry, while a database or web server MUST be registered and MUST NOT have a heading.
+    `built` separates the two, and this check is what makes that separation hold instead of the
+    argument being repeated on every project. `DEC-017` records its definition.
+
+    Anything whose runtime we do not deploy is an external system: it lives in C4 L1 and MUST NOT
+    be registered here at all — its absence from the registry is the check.
+    """
+    containers = rows(c.components, "containers")
+    if not containers:
+        r.skip("V25", "`containers:` is not registered yet")
+        return
+
+    built: dict[str, bool] = {}
+    for ctr in containers:
+        cid = str(ctr.get("id") or "").strip()
+        if not cid:
+            r.fail("V25", "containers", "a container has no `id`")
+            continue
+        flag = ctr.get("built")
+        if not isinstance(flag, bool):
+            r.fail("V25", cid, "`built` MUST be a bool — true if we write its content, false if someone else implements it")
+            continue
+        built[cid] = flag
+
+    # (1) code-map heading = EXACTLY a container with `built: true`
+    headings = map_container_headings(c.root)
+    if headings is None:
+        r.fail("V25", ".control/structure-codebase.md", "the code map does not exist, so container headings cannot be compared")
+    else:
+        for h in headings:
+            if h not in built:
+                r.fail("V25", f"code map §{h}", "heading is not a registered container — register it, or it is not a container")
+            elif not built[h]:
+                r.fail("V25", f"code map §{h}", "`built: false` MUST NOT have a heading — there is no code of ours inside it")
+        for cid, flag in sorted(built.items()):
+            if flag and cid not in headings:
+                r.fail("V25", cid, "`built: true` MUST have a heading in the code map")
+
+    # (2) `built: false` MUST NOT be used by an LC, and (3) MUST NOT appear in a PC's `containers:`
+    for lc in c.lcs:
+        ctr = str(lc.get("container") or "").strip()
+        if ctr and built.get(ctr) is False:
+            r.fail("V25", str(lc.get("id") or "LC-?"), f"names container `{ctr}` which is `built: false`")
+        elif ctr and ctr not in built:
+            r.fail("V25", str(lc.get("id") or "LC-?"), f"names container `{ctr}` which is not registered")
+
+    # (4) PC x container matrix — this field is its SSOT, and it MUST be complete at G3
+    for pc in c.pcs:
+        pid = str(pc.get("id") or "?")
+        listed = listy(pc, "containers")
+        if not listed:
+            r.fail("V25", pid, "`containers:` is empty — every PC MUST live in at least one container (a G3 debt)")
+            continue
+        for ctr in listed:
+            if ctr not in built:
+                r.fail("V25", pid, f"`containers:` names `{ctr}` which is not registered")
+            elif not built[ctr]:
+                r.fail("V25", pid, f"`containers:` names `{ctr}` which is `built: false` — the data lives there by definition, so the row tells us nothing")
+
+    # (5) L3 — only for `built: true`, and only ones that hold more than one PC
+    pcs_per: dict[str, list[str]] = {}
+    for pc in c.pcs:
+        for ctr in listy(pc, "containers"):
+            pcs_per.setdefault(ctr, []).append(str(pc.get("id") or "?"))
+    for path in sorted((c.root / ".how" / "_platform").glob("c4-l3-*.md")):
+        cid = path.name[len("c4-l3-"):-len(".md")]
+        if cid not in built:
+            r.fail("V25", path.relative_to(c.root).as_posix(),
+                   f"L3 for `{cid}` which is not a registered container")
+        elif not built[cid]:
+            r.fail("V25", path.relative_to(c.root).as_posix(),
+                   f"`{cid}` `built: false` MUST NOT have an L3 — not one box inside it is ours to draw")
+    for cid, pids in sorted(pcs_per.items()):
+        if built.get(cid) and len(pids) > 1:
+            l3 = c.root / ".how" / "_platform" / f"c4-l3-{cid}.md"
+            if not l3.exists():
+                r.fail("V25", cid, f"holds {len(pids)} PCs, so `c4-l3-{cid}.md` MUST exist")
+
+
+UC_ROW_RE = re.compile(r"^\|\s*(UC-\d+)\s*\|([^\n]*)$", re.M)
+
+# The `critical` column value is machine-matched, so it is machine-facing and its canonical form
+# is English `yes`. `ya` is still accepted: a corpus that wrote it before this rule took effect
+# MUST NOT be forced to migrate just so a regex can be tidier. The word boundary keeps `ya` from
+# matching inside other words.
+CRITICAL_YES = re.compile(r"\b(yes|ya)\b", re.I)
+
+
+def v26(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
+    """The UC catalogue in every SRS MUST agree with `usecases.yaml` — both its id AND its `critical`.
+
+    This is the most expensive gap this pass closes, because it is the only one that **had already
+    happened and no validator saw it.** Step 16 re-derived `critical` in the registry with a
+    narrowed definition — money, personal data, irreversible action — and the seven catalogue tables
+    in the SRS did not follow along. Twenty-six rows disagreed, and the disagreement was only
+    discovered when a human read the sentence "nine of these are critical" in SRS-admin while the
+    registry held three.
+
+    The registry is the SSOT. The table in the SRS is the catalogue's permanent home for a reader,
+    and two homes for one fact are only safe if something compares them. This is what compares them.
+
+    What is NOT checked here: title and actor. Both are prose, and prose with different words is
+    not prose with a different meaning — comparing them would report style as a defect.
+    """
+    reg = {str(uc.get("id")): bool(uc.get("critical")) for uc in c.ucs}
+    reg_pc = {str(uc.get("id")): str(uc.get("component") or "") for uc in c.ucs}
+    checked = 0
+    for pc in c.pcs:
+        pid = str(pc.get("id"))
+        path = c.root / f".what/{pid}/SRS-{pid}.md"
+        if not path.exists():
+            continue
+        checked += 1
+        text = path.read_text(encoding="utf-8", errors="replace")
+        seen: set[str] = set()
+        for match in UC_ROW_RE.finditer(text):
+            uid = match.group(1)
+            cells = [x.strip() for x in match.group(2).split("|")]
+            if len(cells) < 4:
+                continue
+            seen.add(uid)
+            if uid not in reg:
+                r.fail("V26", f"{pid}/{uid}", "is in the SRS catalogue but not in `usecases.yaml`")
+                continue
+            if reg_pc[uid] != pid:
+                r.fail("V26", f"{pid}/{uid}",
+                       f"the registry places it in `{reg_pc[uid]}`, not in this component")
+            marked = CRITICAL_YES.search(cells[3]) is not None
+            if marked != reg[uid]:
+                r.fail("V26", f"{pid}/{uid}",
+                       f"`critical` in the SRS {'yes' if marked else 'no'}, "
+                       f"in the registry {'yes' if reg[uid] else 'no'}")
+        for uid, owner in sorted(reg_pc.items()):
+            if owner == pid and uid not in seen:
+                r.fail("V26", f"{pid}/{uid}", "is in `usecases.yaml` but not in the SRS catalogue")
+    if not checked:
+        r.skip("V26", "no SRS could be read")
+
+
+def v27(c: Corpus, r: Result) -> None:
+    """Every file in the custom room MUST declare itself, and a rebuttal MUST have a decision.
+
+    The `.constitution/project/` room exists so product-specific rules have a home that `update`
+    does not overwrite and `promote` does not publish. The cost that comes with it: it is also the
+    easiest place to break a generic rule without a trace. Its frontmatter is what holds that back.
+
+    A file here MAY narrow or add without naming anything. To REBUT a generic rule it MUST name it
+    in `overrides:` and carry a `decision:` — because a method that can be rebutted without a
+    decision stops being trustworthy in the next repo.
+
+    Four files in the room are STRUCTURAL and are skipped, because they are not ad-hoc rules and
+    carry their own frontmatter conventions instead:
+
+        README.md               authored in the package, not in the product
+        constitution.md         Articles 1, 2, 5 — carries `status:`, and Article 4 governs it
+        codebase-*-guide.md     the stack, conventions, and brownfield guides — `status:` plus
+                                `ratified_by:`, and they are filled by a wave's distillation
+
+    Demanding `scope:` and `purpose:` of those would be demanding a declaration of files whose
+    role is already fixed by the layout. What V27 exists to guard is the file somebody ADDS.
+    """
+    room = c.root / ".constitution" / "project"
+    if not room.is_dir():
+        r.skip("V27", "the `.constitution/project/` room does not exist yet — it is seeded at install")
+        return
+    structural = {"README.md", "constitution.md"}
+    files = [p for p in sorted(room.rglob("*.md"))
+             if p.name not in structural and not p.name.startswith("codebase-")]
+    if not files:
+        r.skip("V27", "the `.constitution/project/` room is empty, and that is a valid state — "
+                      "a generic rule MUST NOT be moved here just to give the room content")
+        return
+    dec_ids = {str(d.get("id")) for d in c.decs}
+    for path in files:
+        rel = path.relative_to(c.root).as_posix()
+        fm = frontmatter(path)
+        if fm is None:
+            r.fail("V27", rel, "has no frontmatter")
+            continue
+        if str(fm.get("scope") or "").strip() != "project":
+            r.fail("V27", rel, "`scope:` MUST contain exactly `project`")
+        if not str(fm.get("purpose") or "").strip():
+            r.fail("V27", rel, "`purpose:` is empty — one line: what this rule guards")
+        over = str(fm.get("overrides") or "").strip()
+        dec = str(fm.get("decision") or "").strip()
+        if over:
+            if not (c.root / over).exists():
+                r.fail("V27", rel, f"`overrides:` points to `{over}` which does not exist — "
+                                   f"the rebutted rule may already be gone")
+            if not dec:
+                r.fail("V27", rel, "rebuts a generic rule without `decision:` — "
+                                   "a rebuttal MUST have a `DEC-` that decided it")
+            elif dec not in dec_ids:
+                r.fail("V27", rel, f"`decision: {dec}` is not registered in decisions.yaml")
+        elif dec:
+            r.fail("V27", rel, "`decision:` is set without `overrides:` — "
+                               "name which rule is rebutted, or drop `decision:`")
+
+
+def run_checks(c: Corpus, asof: dt.date) -> Result:
+    r = Result()
+    for fn in (v1, v2, v3, v4, v5, v6, v7, v8, v9, v11, v12, v13, v15, v16, v17, v18, v19, v20,
+               v21, v22, v23, v24, v25, v26, v27):
+        fn(c, r)
+    v14(c, r, asof)
+    return r
+
+
+# ------------------------------------------------------------------ generator
+
+
+def _story_status(c: Corpus, story: dict) -> str:
+    folder = str(story.get("spec_folder") or "").strip()
+    if not folder:
+        return "unknown"
+    matches = sorted((c.root / folder / "stories").glob(f"{story.get('id')}-*.md"))
+    if not matches:
+        return "unknown"
+    return str((frontmatter(matches[0]) or {}).get("status") or "unknown")
+
+
+def gen_components(c: Corpus) -> dict:
+    return {
+        "product_components": [
+            {"id": pc.get("id"), "name": pc.get("name"),
+             "containers": listy(pc, "containers"),
+             "logical_components": sorted(
+                 str(lc.get("id")) for lc in c.lcs
+                 if str(lc.get("component")) == str(pc.get("id")))}
+            for pc in c.pcs
+        ],
+        "logical_components": [
+            {"id": lc.get("id"), "type": lc.get("type"), "component": lc.get("component"),
+             "area": lc.get("area"), "owner": lc.get("owner")}
+            for lc in c.lcs
+        ],
+    }
+
+
+def gen_risks(c: Corpus) -> dict:
+    return {"risks": [
+        {"id": x.get("id"), "impact": x.get("impact"), "likelihood": x.get("likelihood"),
+         "owner": x.get("owner"), "status": x.get("status"),
+         "pivot_trigger": x.get("pivot_trigger")}
+        for x in rows(c.risks, "risks") if str(x.get("status")) != "closed"
+    ]}
+
+
+def gen_dag(c: Corpus) -> dict:
+    out = []
+    per_wave: dict[str, list[dict]] = {}
+    for wave, _, story in c.stories():
+        per_wave.setdefault(str(wave.get("id")), []).append(story)
+    for wid in sorted(per_wave):
+        items = per_wave[wid]
+        done: set[str] = set()
+        pending = {str(s.get("id")): set(listy(s, "depends_on")) for s in items}
+        waves_out = []
+        while pending:
+            ready = sorted(k for k, deps in pending.items() if not (deps - done))
+            if not ready:  # cycle — V7 has already reported it
+                waves_out.append({"blocked": sorted(pending)})
+                break
+            waves_out.append({"parallel": ready})
+            done |= set(ready)
+            for k in ready:
+                pending.pop(k)
+        out.append({"wave": wid, "order": waves_out})
+    return {"dag": out}
+
+
+def gen_rtm(c: Corpus) -> dict:
+    cap_goal = {str(x.get("id")): str(x.get("goal", "")) for x in c.caps}
+    ucs_for_fr: dict[str, list[str]] = {}
+    for uc in c.ucs:
+        for fr in listy(uc, "satisfies"):
+            ucs_for_fr.setdefault(fr, []).append(str(uc.get("id")))
+    stories_for_uc: dict[str, list[tuple[dict, dict]]] = {}
+    for wave, _, story in c.stories():
+        for uc in listy(story, "satisfies"):
+            stories_for_uc.setdefault(uc, []).append((wave, story))
+    decs_for: dict[str, list[str]] = {}
+    for dec in c.decs:
+        for target in listy(dec, "serves"):
+            decs_for.setdefault(target, []).append(str(dec.get("id")))
+
+    lines = []
+    for fr in c.frs:
+        fid = str(fr.get("id"))
+        cap = str(fr.get("capability", ""))
+        base = {"BG": cap_goal.get(cap, ""), "CAP": cap, "FR": fid,
+                "DEC": sorted(decs_for.get(fid, []))}
+        ucs = sorted(ucs_for_fr.get(fid, []))
+        if not ucs:
+            exempt = bool(str(fr.get("no_uc") or "").strip())
+            lines.append({**base, "UC": "", "story": "", "wave": "", "release": "",
+                          "test": [], "status": "", "green": False,
+                          "exempt": exempt,
+                          "broken_at": "no_uc" if exempt else "UC"})
+            continue
+        for uid in ucs:
+            pairs = sorted(stories_for_uc.get(uid, []), key=lambda p: str(p[1].get("id")))
+            if not pairs:
+                lines.append({**base, "UC": uid, "story": "", "wave": "", "release": "",
+                              "test": [], "status": "", "green": False, "exempt": False,
+                              "broken_at": "story"})
+                continue
+            for wave, story in pairs:
+                status = _story_status(c, story)
+                tests = listy(story, "tests")
+                broken = ""
+                if not tests:
+                    broken = "test"
+                elif status != "done":
+                    broken = "status"
+                lines.append({**base, "UC": uid, "story": str(story.get("id")),
+                              "wave": str(wave.get("id")), "release": str(wave.get("release", "")),
+                              "test": tests, "status": status, "exempt": False,
+                              "green": broken == "", "broken_at": broken})
+    return {"rtm": lines}
+
+
+def gen_status(c: Corpus, rtm: dict, result: Result) -> dict:
+    lines = rtm.get("rtm") or []
+    counted = [line for line in lines if not line.get("exempt")]
+    exempt = len(lines) - len(counted)
+    green = sum(1 for line in counted if line.get("green"))
+    per_wave = []
+    for wave in c.wave_list:
+        wid = str(wave.get("id"))
+        items = [s for w, _, s in c.stories() if str(w.get("id")) == wid]
+        done = sum(1 for s in items if _story_status(c, s) == "done")
+        per_wave.append({"wave": wid, "status": wave.get("status"),
+                         "stories_done": done, "stories_total": len(items),
+                         "work_progress": _pct(done, len(items))})
+    applicable = 26  # V1..V27 minus V10, which was retired
+    return {
+        "promise_progress": _pct(green, len(counted)),
+        "rtm_rows": {"green": green, "counted": len(counted),
+                      "excluded_no_uc": exempt},
+        "work_progress": per_wave,
+        "gate_readiness": _pct(applicable - len(result.red), applicable),
+        "validators_red": result.red,
+        "validators_skipped": dict(sorted(result.skipped.items())),
+        "open_questions": _question_budget(c),
+    }
+
+
+def _question_budget(c: Corpus) -> dict:
+    """Counts of all four question lists, compared against the budget in index.yaml.
+
+    The budget is NOT a hard gate. It is reported when a batch exceeds it, because a larger
+    batch is a signal about the pass, not about the corpus.
+    """
+    budget = c.index.get("question_budget") or {}
+    out: dict[str, object] = {}
+    for name in ("blocking", "assumptions", "external", "answered"):
+        path = c.root / ".control/questions" / f"{name}.md"
+        rows_n = 0
+        if path.exists():
+            rows_n = sum(1 for line in path.read_text(encoding="utf-8", errors="replace").splitlines()
+                         if line.startswith("| OQ-"))
+        out[name] = rows_n
+    cap_block = budget.get("blocking_per_component")
+    if cap_block and c.pcs:
+        allowed = int(cap_block) * len(c.pcs)
+        out["blocking_budget"] = allowed
+        out["blocking_over_budget"] = out["blocking"] > allowed
+    cap_assume = budget.get("assumptions_per_gate")
+    if cap_assume:
+        out["assumptions_budget_per_gate"] = int(cap_assume)
+    return out
+
+
+def _pct(part: int, total: int) -> str:
+    return "n/a" if total == 0 else f"{round(100 * part / total)}%"
+
+
+def as_markdown(name: str, payload: dict) -> str:
+    body = dump(payload)
+    return (f"# {name}\n\n"
+            f"> Generated by `.constitution/method/scripts/validate.py --generate`. "
+            f"MUST NOT be hand-edited.\n\n"
+            f"```yaml\n{body}```\n")
+
+
+# ------------------------------------------------------- pages for humans
+
+PAGE_HEADER = ("> Generated by `.constitution/method/scripts/validate.py --generate`. "
+               "MUST NOT be hand-edited.\n")
+
+
+def _section(path: Path, heading: str) -> str:
+    """Extract one `## <heading>` section from a markdown file, as-is."""
+    if not path.exists():
+        return ""
+    lines = path.read_text(encoding="utf-8", errors="replace").splitlines()
+    out: list[str] = []
+    inside = False
+    for line in lines:
+        if line.startswith("## "):
+            if inside:
+                break
+            inside = line[3:].strip().lower().startswith(heading.lower())
+            continue
+        if inside:
+            out.append(line)
+    return "\n".join(out).strip("\n")
+
+
+def _body(path: Path) -> str:
+    """File content without frontmatter and without template comments."""
+    if not path.exists():
+        return ""
+    text = path.read_text(encoding="utf-8", errors="replace")
+    match = FM.match(text)
+    if match:
+        text = text[match.end():]
+    while "<!--" in text and "-->" in text:
+        head, _, rest = text.partition("<!--")
+        _, _, tail = rest.partition("-->")
+        text = head + tail
+    return text.strip("\n")
+
+
+def page_decisions(c: Corpus) -> str:
+    """Flat table of every `DEC-`. This is what replaces looking up decisions through the memlog."""
+    rows_out = ["| id | Title | Status | Type | Touches | File |",
+                "| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |"]
+    for dec in c.decs:
+        touches = ", ".join(f"`{x}`" for x in listy(dec, "touches")) or "—"
+        rows_out.append(
+            f"| `{dec.get('id')}` | {_cell(dec.get('title'))} | `{dec.get('status', '')}` "
+            f"| {dec.get('type') or '—'} | {touches} | `{dec.get('file', '')}` |")
+    counts: dict[str, int] = {}
+    for dec in c.decs:
+        key = str(dec.get("status"))
+        counts[key] = counts.get(key, 0) + 1
+    tally = " · ".join(f"{k}: {v}" for k, v in sorted(counts.items())) or "no decisions yet"
+    return ("# decisions\n\n" + PAGE_HEADER +
+            "\nDecisions are no longer looked up through the memlog — the memlog goes back to being just a pass log.\n"
+            f"\n**{len(c.decs)} decisions** — {tally}.\n\n" + "\n".join(rows_out) + "\n")
+
+
+def page_blueprint(c: Corpus) -> str:
+    """One-page roll-up reviewed at G3. Seven files become one read.
+
+    The UC catalogue, actor list, and domain model stay put in their own component's kernel as
+    their permanent home. This is their view. One fact, one home, one view.
+    """
+    parts = ["# blueprint\n", PAGE_HEADER,
+             "\nThis is what the owner reads at **G3 Blueprint**, instead of seven files. Its "
+             "content is affected by neither `mode` nor `risk_accepted`.\n"]
+
+    crit = sum(1 for uc in c.ucs if uc.get("critical"))
+    parts.append(f"\n## Use case catalogue\n\n**{len(c.ucs)} use cases**, {crit} marked "
+                 f"`critical`.\n")
+    parts.append("| id | Use case | Component | Satisfies | critical |")
+    parts.append("| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |")
+    for uc in c.ucs:
+        sat = ", ".join(f"`{x}`" for x in listy(uc, "satisfies")) or "—"
+        flag = "yes" if uc.get("critical") else "no"
+        parts.append(f"| `{uc.get('id')}` | {_cell(uc.get('title'))} | "
+                     f"`{uc.get('component', '')}` | {sat} | {flag} |")
+
+    parts.append("\n## Actor list\n")
+    for pc in c.pcs:
+        pid = str(pc.get("id"))
+        block = _section(c.root / f".what/{pid}/SRS-{pid}.md", "Actor Register")
+        parts.append(f"\n### {pid} — {pc.get('name', '')}\n")
+        parts.append(_demote(block) if block
+                     else "_no § Actor Register in this component's SRS yet._")
+
+    parts.append("\n## Domain model\n")
+    for pc in c.pcs:
+        pid = str(pc.get("id"))
+        block = _body(c.root / f".what/{pid}/03-domain/domain-model.md")
+        parts.append(f"\n### {pid}\n")
+        parts.append(_demote(block) if block else "_no `03-domain/domain-model.md` yet._")
+
+    parts.append("\n## Three inventories\n")
+    for kind, name in (("db", "table"), ("api", "endpoint"), ("screen", "screen")):
+        block = _body(c.root / f".how/_platform/inventory-{kind}.md")
+        parts.append(f"\n### List of {name}s — `inventory-{kind}.md`\n")
+        parts.append(_demote(block) if block else f"_no `inventory-{kind}.md` yet._")
+
+    return "\n".join(parts) + "\n"
+
+
+def _cell(value: object, limit: int = 110) -> str:
+    """One table row, shortened. The full-length source stays in the registry — this is just a view."""
+    text = " ".join(str(value or "").split()).replace("|", "\\|")
+    return text if len(text) <= limit else text[: limit - 1].rstrip() + "…"
+
+
+def _demote(block: str, by: int = 2) -> str:
+    """Demote the heading level of inlined content, so it does not clash with the roll-up's own structure."""
+    out = []
+    for line in block.splitlines():
+        stripped = line.lstrip()
+        if stripped.startswith("#"):
+            hashes = len(stripped) - len(stripped.lstrip("#"))
+            out.append("#" * min(6, hashes + by) + stripped[hashes:])
+        else:
+            out.append(line)
+    return "\n".join(out)
+
+
+def page_estimate(c: Corpus) -> str:
+    """Table of CANDIDATE tasks. One row per `FR`, since that is a wave's ideal shape."""
+    mode_of = {str(pc.get("id")): c.mode_of(pc) for pc in c.pcs}
+    risk_of = {str(pc.get("id")): (str(pc.get("risk_accepted") or "—"),
+                                   str(pc.get("risk_note") or "—")) for pc in c.pcs}
+    cap_by_id = {str(x.get("id")): x for x in c.caps}
+    fr_per_cap: dict[str, int] = {}
+    for fr in c.frs:
+        key = str(fr.get("capability", ""))
+        fr_per_cap[key] = fr_per_cap.get(key, 0) + 1
+
+    have_mandays = any(x.get("estimate_mandays") for x in c.caps)
+    parts = ["# estimate\n", PAGE_HEADER,
+             "\n**THIS IS AN ESTIMATE, FORWARD-LOOKING.** Every row below is a **candidate** "
+             "task; the wave in `waves.yaml` is the real one. One row MAY become one wave, and three "
+             "neighboring rows MAY be merged into one — that merge is a human decision made when the "
+             "wave is opened.\n"]
+    if not have_mandays:
+        parts.append("\n**With no `estimate_mandays` on a single `CAP`**, the Load column is empty and "
+                     "this output is only as good as a T-shirt-size estimate. It MUST be reported as such.\n")
+
+    parts.append("\n| Task | FR | Epic | mode | Exposure | Load | Priority | Depends on | Release |")
+    parts.append("| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |")
+    for fr in c.frs:
+        cap_id = str(fr.get("capability", ""))
+        cap = cap_by_id.get(cap_id, {})
+        pid = str(fr.get("component") or cap.get("component") or "")
+        risk, note = risk_of.get(pid, ("—", "—"))
+        exposure = "not set yet" if risk == "—" else f"`{risk}` — {_cell(note, 60)}"
+        mandays = cap.get("estimate_mandays")
+        share = "—"
+        if mandays:
+            try:
+                share = f"{float(mandays) / max(1, fr_per_cap.get(cap_id, 1)):.1f}"
+            except (TypeError, ValueError):
+                share = "—"
+        deps = ", ".join(f"`{x}`" for x in listy(cap, "depends_on")) or "—"
+        parts.append(
+            f"| {_cell(fr.get('text') or fr.get('title'))} | `{fr.get('id')}` | `{pid or '—'}` "
+            f"| `{mode_of.get(pid, 'catalog')}` | {exposure} | {share} "
+            f"| {cap.get('priority', '—')} | {deps} | {cap.get('target_release', '—')} |")
+    return "\n".join(parts) + "\n"
+
+
+def generate(c: Corpus, result: Result) -> list[Path]:
+    out_dir = c.root / ".control" / "generated"
+    out_dir.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True)
+    rtm = gen_rtm(c)
+    payloads = {
+        "components": gen_components(c),
+        "risks": gen_risks(c),
+        "dag": gen_dag(c),
+        "rtm": rtm,
+        "status": gen_status(c, rtm, result),
+    }
+    written = []
+    for name in GENERATED_ORDER:
+        payload = payloads[name]
+        yaml_path = out_dir / f"{name}.yaml"
+        yaml_path.write_text(dump(payload), encoding="utf-8")
+        md_path = out_dir / f"{name}.md"
+        md_path.write_text(as_markdown(name, payload), encoding="utf-8")
+        written += [yaml_path, md_path]
+
+    # Three pages for HUMANS: real markdown tables, with no .yaml twin. What people read is
+    # not wrapped in a yaml fence, and no machine reader demands a second version of it.
+    for name, render in (("decisions", page_decisions),
+                         ("blueprint", page_blueprint),
+                         ("estimate", page_estimate)):
+        page = out_dir / f"{name}.md"
+        page.write_text(render(c), encoding="utf-8")
+        written.append(page)
+    return written
+
+
+# ------------------------------------------------------------------------ CLI
+
+
+def main(argv: list[str] | None = None) -> int:
+    parser = argparse.ArgumentParser(
+        prog="validate", description="V1..V27 and the .control/generated/ generator")
+    parser.add_argument("--check", action="store_true",
+                        help="check only; exit non-zero if anything is red")
+    parser.add_argument("--generate", action="store_true",
+                        help="rewrite .control/generated/ (still runs the check first)")
+    parser.add_argument("--root", default=".", help="repo root (default: current directory)")
+    parser.add_argument("--asof", default=None,
+                        help="reference date for V14, format YYYY-MM-DD (default: today). "
+                             "Stated explicitly so a run can be repeated exactly")
+    args = parser.parse_args(argv)
+
+    if not args.check and not args.generate:
+        args.check = True
+
+    root = Path(args.root).resolve()
+    if not (root / ".control" / "registry").is_dir():
+        print(f"validate: {root} has no .control/registry/ — wrong repo root?", file=sys.stderr)
+        return 2
+
+    asof = dt.date.fromisoformat(args.asof) if args.asof else dt.date.today()
+    corpus = Corpus.load(root)
+    result = run_checks(corpus, asof)
+
+    if args.generate:
+        for path in generate(corpus, result):
+            print(f"  wrote {path.relative_to(root).as_posix()}")
+
+    if result.findings:
+        print(f"\nRED — {len(result.findings)} findings across {len(result.red)} validators\n")
+        for finding in sorted(result.findings, key=lambda f: f.sort_key):
+            print(f"  {finding.vid:<4} {finding.subject}: {finding.message}")
+    else:
+        print("\nGREEN — no findings")
+
+    if result.skipped:
+        print("\nSkipped:")
+        for vid, why in sorted(result.skipped.items()):
+            print(f"  {vid:<4} {why}")
+
+    print(f"\nV14 reference date: {asof.isoformat()}")
+    return 1 if result.findings else 0
+
+
+if __name__ == "__main__":
+    raise SystemExit(main())