trustdex 0.5.1 → 0.7.0

package/src/policy-packs.mjs

@@ -14,7 +14,39 @@ const BASE_SIGNALS = {
   'embedded-credentials': 'block',
   'insecure-transport': 'block',
   'url-query-parameters': 'ask',
-  'artifact-version-mismatch': 'block'
+  'artifact-version-mismatch': 'block',
+  'claude-auto-approve': 'ask',
+  'claude-broad-auto-approve': 'block',
+  'claude-shell-auto-approve': 'block',
+  'claude-filesystem-auto-approve': 'ask',
+  'claude-network-auto-approve': 'ask',
+  'claude-subagent-auto-approve': 'ask',
+  'claude-mcp-auto-approve': 'ask',
+  'claude-mcp-wildcard': 'ask',
+  'claude-bypass-permissions': 'block',
+  'claude-auto-mode': 'ask',
+  'claude-additional-directories': 'ask',
+  'claude-outside-read-access': 'ask',
+  'claude-hooks': 'block',
+  'claude-credential-helper': 'block',
+  'claude-environment': 'ask',
+  'claude-sandbox-settings': 'ask',
+  'claude-extension-loading': 'ask',
+  'uninspected-claude-settings': 'ask',
+  'codex-no-approvals': 'ask',
+  'codex-auto-review': 'ask',
+  'codex-workspace-write': 'ask',
+  'codex-full-access': 'block',
+  'codex-network-access': 'ask',
+  'codex-additional-writable-roots': 'ask',
+  'codex-temp-write-access': 'ask',
+  'codex-live-web-search': 'ask',
+  'codex-custom-permissions': 'ask',
+  'codex-subagents-enabled': 'ask',
+  'codex-subagent-settings': 'ask',
+  'codex-extension-settings': 'ask',
+  'uninspected-codex-settings': 'ask',
+  'uninspected-codex-sections': 'ask'
 };
 
 export const POLICY_PACKS = Object.freeze({
@@ -59,7 +91,11 @@ export const POLICY_PACKS = Object.freeze({
     signalActions: {
       ...BASE_SIGNALS,
       'shell-execution': 'ask',
-      'insecure-transport': 'ask'
+      'insecure-transport': 'ask',
+      'claude-broad-auto-approve': 'ask',
+      'claude-shell-auto-approve': 'ask',
+      'claude-hooks': 'ask',
+      'claude-credential-helper': 'ask'
     }
   })
 });

package/src/posture.mjs

@@ -0,0 +1,540 @@
+import { sha256Json } from './canonical.mjs';
+
+const ACTION_RANK = Object.freeze({ allow: 0, ask: 1, block: 2 });
+const SNAPSHOT_KIND = 'agent-permission-posture';
+const SNAPSHOT_VERSION = 1;
+
+const CLAUDE_MODES = new Set([
+  null,
+  'default',
+  'manual',
+  'acceptEdits',
+  'plan',
+  'dontAsk',
+  'bypassPermissions',
+  'auto'
+]);
+const CLAUDE_CATEGORIES = new Set(['filesystem', 'mcp', 'network', 'other', 'shell', 'subagent']);
+const CODEX_APPROVALS = new Set([null, 'on-request', 'never', 'granular']);
+const CODEX_REVIEWERS = new Set([null, 'user', 'auto_review']);
+const CODEX_SANDBOXES = new Set([null, 'read-only', 'workspace-write', 'danger-full-access']);
+const CODEX_PERMISSIONS = new Set([null, ':read-only', ':workspace', ':danger-full-access', 'custom']);
+const CODEX_SEARCH = new Set([null, 'disabled', 'cached', 'indexed', 'live']);
+const CODEX_PROMPTS = new Set([
+  'mcp_elicitations',
+  'request_permissions',
+  'rules',
+  'sandbox_approval',
+  'skill_approval'
+]);
+const RUNTIME_SIGNALS = Object.freeze({
+  claude: new Set([
+    'claude-auto-approve',
+    'claude-broad-auto-approve',
+    'claude-shell-auto-approve',
+    'claude-filesystem-auto-approve',
+    'claude-network-auto-approve',
+    'claude-subagent-auto-approve',
+    'claude-mcp-auto-approve',
+    'claude-mcp-wildcard',
+    'claude-bypass-permissions',
+    'claude-auto-mode',
+    'claude-additional-directories',
+    'claude-outside-read-access',
+    'claude-hooks',
+    'claude-credential-helper',
+    'claude-environment',
+    'claude-sandbox-settings',
+    'claude-extension-loading',
+    'uninspected-claude-settings',
+    'secret-env'
+  ]),
+  codex: new Set([
+    'codex-no-approvals',
+    'codex-auto-review',
+    'codex-workspace-write',
+    'codex-full-access',
+    'codex-network-access',
+    'codex-additional-writable-roots',
+    'codex-temp-write-access',
+    'codex-live-web-search',
+    'codex-custom-permissions',
+    'codex-subagents-enabled',
+    'codex-subagent-settings',
+    'codex-extension-settings',
+    'uninspected-codex-settings',
+    'uninspected-codex-sections'
+  ])
+});
+
+function requireObject(value, message) {
+  if (!value || typeof value !== 'object' || Array.isArray(value)) throw new Error(message);
+  return value;
+}
+
+function requireCount(value, field) {
+  if (!Number.isSafeInteger(value) || value < 0) throw new Error(`Invalid permission posture count: ${field}`);
+  return value;
+}
+
+function requireBoolean(value, field) {
+  if (typeof value !== 'boolean') throw new Error(`Invalid permission posture boolean: ${field}`);
+  return value;
+}
+
+function requireEnum(value, allowed, field) {
+  if (!allowed.has(value)) throw new Error(`Invalid permission posture value: ${field}`);
+  return value;
+}
+
+function requireStringArray(value, allowed, field) {
+  if (!Array.isArray(value) || value.some((item) => typeof item !== 'string' || !allowed.has(item))) {
+    throw new Error(`Invalid permission posture list: ${field}`);
+  }
+  return [...new Set(value)].sort();
+}
+
+function assertMetadataKeys(metadata, expected) {
+  for (const key of Object.keys(metadata)) {
+    if (!expected.has(key)) throw new Error(`Unsupported permission posture metadata: ${key}`);
+  }
+}
+
+function normalizeClaudeMetadata(metadata) {
+  const expected = new Set([
+    'defaultMode',
+    'allowRuleCount',
+    'askRuleCount',
+    'denyRuleCount',
+    'allowCategories',
+    'additionalDirectoryCount',
+    'bypassDisabled',
+    'autoModeDisabled',
+    'outsideReadsBlocked',
+    'uninspectedRootKeys'
+  ]);
+  assertMetadataKeys(metadata, expected);
+  if (!Array.isArray(metadata.uninspectedRootKeys) ||
+      metadata.uninspectedRootKeys.some((item) => typeof item !== 'string')) {
+    throw new Error('Invalid Claude uninspected root key metadata.');
+  }
+  return {
+    defaultMode: requireEnum(metadata.defaultMode, CLAUDE_MODES, 'defaultMode'),
+    allowRuleCount: requireCount(metadata.allowRuleCount, 'allowRuleCount'),
+    askRuleCount: requireCount(metadata.askRuleCount, 'askRuleCount'),
+    denyRuleCount: requireCount(metadata.denyRuleCount, 'denyRuleCount'),
+    allowCategories: requireStringArray(metadata.allowCategories, CLAUDE_CATEGORIES, 'allowCategories'),
+    additionalDirectoryCount: requireCount(metadata.additionalDirectoryCount, 'additionalDirectoryCount'),
+    bypassDisabled: requireBoolean(metadata.bypassDisabled, 'bypassDisabled'),
+    autoModeDisabled: requireBoolean(metadata.autoModeDisabled, 'autoModeDisabled'),
+    outsideReadsBlocked: requireBoolean(metadata.outsideReadsBlocked, 'outsideReadsBlocked'),
+    uninspectedRootKeyCount: metadata.uninspectedRootKeys.length
+  };
+}
+
+function normalizeCodexMetadata(metadata) {
+  const expected = new Set([
+    'approvalPolicy',
+    'granularPromptCategories',
+    'approvalsReviewer',
+    'sandboxMode',
+    'defaultPermissionsKind',
+    'webSearch',
+    'networkAccess',
+    'additionalWritableRootCount',
+    'tempRootsExcluded',
+    'subagentsEnabled',
+    'uninspectedAgentKeys',
+    'uninspectedRootKeys',
+    'uninspectedSectionKinds'
+  ]);
+  assertMetadataKeys(metadata, expected);
+  for (const field of ['uninspectedAgentKeys', 'uninspectedRootKeys', 'uninspectedSectionKinds']) {
+    if (!Array.isArray(metadata[field]) || metadata[field].some((item) => typeof item !== 'string')) {
+      throw new Error(`Invalid Codex ${field} metadata.`);
+    }
+  }
+  return {
+    approvalPolicy: requireEnum(metadata.approvalPolicy, CODEX_APPROVALS, 'approvalPolicy'),
+    granularPromptCategories: requireStringArray(
+      metadata.granularPromptCategories,
+      CODEX_PROMPTS,
+      'granularPromptCategories'
+    ),
+    approvalsReviewer: requireEnum(metadata.approvalsReviewer, CODEX_REVIEWERS, 'approvalsReviewer'),
+    sandboxMode: requireEnum(metadata.sandboxMode, CODEX_SANDBOXES, 'sandboxMode'),
+    defaultPermissionsKind: requireEnum(
+      metadata.defaultPermissionsKind,
+      CODEX_PERMISSIONS,
+      'defaultPermissionsKind'
+    ),
+    webSearch: requireEnum(metadata.webSearch, CODEX_SEARCH, 'webSearch'),
+    networkAccess: requireBoolean(metadata.networkAccess, 'networkAccess'),
+    additionalWritableRootCount: requireCount(
+      metadata.additionalWritableRootCount,
+      'additionalWritableRootCount'
+    ),
+    tempRootsExcluded: requireBoolean(metadata.tempRootsExcluded, 'tempRootsExcluded'),
+    subagentsEnabled: requireBoolean(metadata.subagentsEnabled, 'subagentsEnabled'),
+    uninspectedAgentKeyCount: metadata.uninspectedAgentKeys.length,
+    uninspectedRootKeyCount: metadata.uninspectedRootKeys.length,
+    uninspectedSectionKindCount: metadata.uninspectedSectionKinds.length
+  };
+}
+
+function projectAction(value) {
+  return Object.hasOwn(ACTION_RANK, value) ? value : value == null ? null : 'invalid';
+}
+
+function projectPolicy(policy, runtime) {
+  const relevantSignals = RUNTIME_SIGNALS[runtime];
+  const signalActions = Object.fromEntries(
+    Object.entries(policy?.signalActions || {})
+      .filter(([signal]) => relevantSignals.has(signal))
+      .map(([signal, action]) => [signal, projectAction(action)])
+      .sort(([left], [right]) => left.localeCompare(right))
+  );
+  return {
+    unknownAction: projectAction(policy?.unknownAction),
+    localAction: projectAction(policy?.localAction),
+    sensitiveAction: projectAction(policy?.sensitiveAction),
+    signalActions
+  };
+}
+
+function snapshotDigest(snapshot) {
+  return sha256Json({
+    schemaVersion: snapshot.schemaVersion,
+    kind: snapshot.kind,
+    runtime: snapshot.runtime,
+    policyDigest: snapshot.policyDigest,
+    posture: snapshot.posture
+  });
+}
+
+export function createPermissionPostureSnapshot(result, policy = {}) {
+  requireObject(result, 'Permission posture requires one evaluated settings result.');
+  if (!Object.hasOwn(ACTION_RANK, result.action)) throw new Error('Permission posture result has an invalid action.');
+  if (!Array.isArray(result.signals) || result.signals.some((item) => typeof item !== 'string')) {
+    throw new Error('Permission posture result has invalid signals.');
+  }
+  const runtime = result.kind === 'claude-settings'
+    ? 'claude'
+    : result.kind === 'codex-settings' ? 'codex' : null;
+  if (!runtime) throw new Error('Permission posture supports Claude or Codex settings results only.');
+  if (result.signals.some((signal) => !RUNTIME_SIGNALS[runtime].has(signal))) {
+    throw new Error('Permission posture result contains an unsupported signal.');
+  }
+
+  const metadata = requireObject(result.metadata, 'Permission posture result is missing metadata.');
+  const posture = {
+    action: result.action,
+    signals: [...new Set(result.signals)].sort(),
+    metadata: runtime === 'claude'
+      ? normalizeClaudeMetadata(metadata)
+      : normalizeCodexMetadata(metadata)
+  };
+  const snapshot = {
+    schemaVersion: SNAPSHOT_VERSION,
+    kind: SNAPSHOT_KIND,
+    createdAt: new Date().toISOString(),
+    runtime,
+    policyDigest: sha256Json(projectPolicy(policy, runtime)),
+    posture
+  };
+  return { ...snapshot, digest: snapshotDigest(snapshot) };
+}
+
+function validateSnapshot(snapshot) {
+  requireObject(snapshot, 'Invalid permission posture snapshot.');
+  if (snapshot.schemaVersion !== SNAPSHOT_VERSION || snapshot.kind !== SNAPSHOT_KIND) {
+    throw new Error('Unsupported permission posture snapshot schema.');
+  }
+  if (!['claude', 'codex'].includes(snapshot.runtime)) throw new Error('Invalid permission posture runtime.');
+  if (typeof snapshot.policyDigest !== 'string' || !/^[a-f0-9]{64}$/.test(snapshot.policyDigest)) {
+    throw new Error('Invalid permission posture policy digest.');
+  }
+  requireObject(snapshot.posture, 'Permission posture snapshot is missing posture data.');
+  if (!Object.hasOwn(ACTION_RANK, snapshot.posture.action)) throw new Error('Invalid permission posture action.');
+  if (!Array.isArray(snapshot.posture.signals) ||
+      snapshot.posture.signals.some((item) => typeof item !== 'string')) {
+    throw new Error('Invalid permission posture signals.');
+  }
+  const normalizedSignals = [...new Set(snapshot.posture.signals)].sort();
+  if (sha256Json(normalizedSignals) !== sha256Json(snapshot.posture.signals)) {
+    throw new Error('Non-canonical permission posture signals.');
+  }
+  const metadata = requireObject(snapshot.posture.metadata, 'Permission posture snapshot is missing metadata.');
+  if (snapshot.runtime === 'claude') {
+    const normalized = normalizeClaudeSnapshotMetadata(metadata);
+    if (sha256Json(normalized) !== sha256Json(metadata)) throw new Error('Non-canonical Claude posture metadata.');
+  } else {
+    const normalized = normalizeCodexSnapshotMetadata(metadata);
+    if (sha256Json(normalized) !== sha256Json(metadata)) throw new Error('Non-canonical Codex posture metadata.');
+  }
+  if (snapshot.digest !== snapshotDigest(snapshot)) throw new Error('Permission posture snapshot digest mismatch.');
+  return snapshot;
+}
+
+function normalizeClaudeSnapshotMetadata(metadata) {
+  const expected = new Set([
+    'defaultMode', 'allowRuleCount', 'askRuleCount', 'denyRuleCount', 'allowCategories',
+    'additionalDirectoryCount', 'bypassDisabled', 'autoModeDisabled', 'outsideReadsBlocked',
+    'uninspectedRootKeyCount'
+  ]);
+  assertMetadataKeys(metadata, expected);
+  return {
+    defaultMode: requireEnum(metadata.defaultMode, CLAUDE_MODES, 'defaultMode'),
+    allowRuleCount: requireCount(metadata.allowRuleCount, 'allowRuleCount'),
+    askRuleCount: requireCount(metadata.askRuleCount, 'askRuleCount'),
+    denyRuleCount: requireCount(metadata.denyRuleCount, 'denyRuleCount'),
+    allowCategories: requireStringArray(metadata.allowCategories, CLAUDE_CATEGORIES, 'allowCategories'),
+    additionalDirectoryCount: requireCount(metadata.additionalDirectoryCount, 'additionalDirectoryCount'),
+    bypassDisabled: requireBoolean(metadata.bypassDisabled, 'bypassDisabled'),
+    autoModeDisabled: requireBoolean(metadata.autoModeDisabled, 'autoModeDisabled'),
+    outsideReadsBlocked: requireBoolean(metadata.outsideReadsBlocked, 'outsideReadsBlocked'),
+    uninspectedRootKeyCount: requireCount(metadata.uninspectedRootKeyCount, 'uninspectedRootKeyCount')
+  };
+}
+
+function normalizeCodexSnapshotMetadata(metadata) {
+  const expected = new Set([
+    'approvalPolicy', 'granularPromptCategories', 'approvalsReviewer', 'sandboxMode',
+    'defaultPermissionsKind', 'webSearch', 'networkAccess', 'additionalWritableRootCount',
+    'tempRootsExcluded', 'subagentsEnabled', 'uninspectedAgentKeyCount',
+    'uninspectedRootKeyCount', 'uninspectedSectionKindCount'
+  ]);
+  assertMetadataKeys(metadata, expected);
+  return {
+    approvalPolicy: requireEnum(metadata.approvalPolicy, CODEX_APPROVALS, 'approvalPolicy'),
+    granularPromptCategories: requireStringArray(
+      metadata.granularPromptCategories,
+      CODEX_PROMPTS,
+      'granularPromptCategories'
+    ),
+    approvalsReviewer: requireEnum(metadata.approvalsReviewer, CODEX_REVIEWERS, 'approvalsReviewer'),
+    sandboxMode: requireEnum(metadata.sandboxMode, CODEX_SANDBOXES, 'sandboxMode'),
+    defaultPermissionsKind: requireEnum(
+      metadata.defaultPermissionsKind,
+      CODEX_PERMISSIONS,
+      'defaultPermissionsKind'
+    ),
+    webSearch: requireEnum(metadata.webSearch, CODEX_SEARCH, 'webSearch'),
+    networkAccess: requireBoolean(metadata.networkAccess, 'networkAccess'),
+    additionalWritableRootCount: requireCount(
+      metadata.additionalWritableRootCount,
+      'additionalWritableRootCount'
+    ),
+    tempRootsExcluded: requireBoolean(metadata.tempRootsExcluded, 'tempRootsExcluded'),
+    subagentsEnabled: requireBoolean(metadata.subagentsEnabled, 'subagentsEnabled'),
+    uninspectedAgentKeyCount: requireCount(metadata.uninspectedAgentKeyCount, 'uninspectedAgentKeyCount'),
+    uninspectedRootKeyCount: requireCount(metadata.uninspectedRootKeyCount, 'uninspectedRootKeyCount'),
+    uninspectedSectionKindCount: requireCount(
+      metadata.uninspectedSectionKindCount,
+      'uninspectedSectionKindCount'
+    )
+  };
+}
+
+function addChange(changes, impact, type, field, before, after) {
+  changes.push({ impact, type, field, before, after });
+}
+
+function compareCount(changes, field, before, after, riskIncreasing = true) {
+  if (before === after) return;
+  const increased = after > before;
+  const impact = increased === riskIncreasing ? 'expansion' : 'restriction';
+  addChange(changes, impact, 'count-changed', field, before, after);
+}
+
+function compareBoolean(changes, field, before, after, trueIsRisk) {
+  if (before === after) return;
+  const impact = after === trueIsRisk ? 'expansion' : 'restriction';
+  addChange(changes, impact, 'boolean-changed', field, before, after);
+}
+
+function compareArray(changes, field, before, after, additionsAreRisk = true) {
+  const added = after.filter((item) => !before.includes(item));
+  const removed = before.filter((item) => !after.includes(item));
+  if (added.length) {
+    changes.push({
+      impact: additionsAreRisk ? 'expansion' : 'restriction',
+      type: 'items-added',
+      field,
+      items: added
+    });
+  }
+  if (removed.length) {
+    changes.push({
+      impact: additionsAreRisk ? 'restriction' : 'expansion',
+      type: 'items-removed',
+      field,
+      items: removed
+    });
+  }
+}
+
+function compareRanked(changes, field, before, after, ranks) {
+  if (before === after) return;
+  if (!Object.hasOwn(ranks, before) || !Object.hasOwn(ranks, after) || ranks[before] === ranks[after]) {
+    addChange(changes, 'review', 'value-changed', field, before, after);
+    return;
+  }
+  addChange(
+    changes,
+    ranks[after] > ranks[before] ? 'expansion' : 'restriction',
+    'value-changed',
+    field,
+    before,
+    after
+  );
+}
+
+function compareClaudeMetadata(changes, before, after) {
+  compareRanked(changes, 'defaultMode', before.defaultMode, after.defaultMode, {
+    plan: 0,
+    manual: 0,
+    default: 1,
+    acceptEdits: 2,
+    dontAsk: 3,
+    auto: 4,
+    bypassPermissions: 5
+  });
+  compareCount(changes, 'allowRuleCount', before.allowRuleCount, after.allowRuleCount, true);
+  compareCount(changes, 'askRuleCount', before.askRuleCount, after.askRuleCount, false);
+  compareCount(changes, 'denyRuleCount', before.denyRuleCount, after.denyRuleCount, false);
+  compareArray(changes, 'allowCategories', before.allowCategories, after.allowCategories, true);
+  compareCount(
+    changes,
+    'additionalDirectoryCount',
+    before.additionalDirectoryCount,
+    after.additionalDirectoryCount,
+    true
+  );
+  compareBoolean(changes, 'bypassDisabled', before.bypassDisabled, after.bypassDisabled, false);
+  compareBoolean(changes, 'autoModeDisabled', before.autoModeDisabled, after.autoModeDisabled, false);
+  compareBoolean(changes, 'outsideReadsBlocked', before.outsideReadsBlocked, after.outsideReadsBlocked, false);
+  compareCount(
+    changes,
+    'uninspectedRootKeyCount',
+    before.uninspectedRootKeyCount,
+    after.uninspectedRootKeyCount,
+    true
+  );
+}
+
+function compareCodexMetadata(changes, before, after) {
+  compareRanked(changes, 'approvalPolicy', before.approvalPolicy, after.approvalPolicy, {
+    'on-request': 0,
+    granular: 0,
+    never: 2
+  });
+  compareArray(
+    changes,
+    'granularPromptCategories',
+    before.granularPromptCategories,
+    after.granularPromptCategories,
+    false
+  );
+  compareRanked(changes, 'approvalsReviewer', before.approvalsReviewer, after.approvalsReviewer, {
+    user: 0,
+    auto_review: 1
+  });
+  compareRanked(changes, 'sandboxMode', before.sandboxMode, after.sandboxMode, {
+    'read-only': 0,
+    'workspace-write': 1,
+    'danger-full-access': 2
+  });
+  compareRanked(changes, 'defaultPermissionsKind', before.defaultPermissionsKind, after.defaultPermissionsKind, {
+    ':read-only': 0,
+    ':workspace': 1,
+    custom: 2,
+    ':danger-full-access': 3
+  });
+  compareRanked(changes, 'webSearch', before.webSearch, after.webSearch, {
+    disabled: 0,
+    cached: 1,
+    indexed: 1,
+    live: 2
+  });
+  compareBoolean(changes, 'networkAccess', before.networkAccess, after.networkAccess, true);
+  compareCount(
+    changes,
+    'additionalWritableRootCount',
+    before.additionalWritableRootCount,
+    after.additionalWritableRootCount,
+    true
+  );
+  compareBoolean(changes, 'tempRootsExcluded', before.tempRootsExcluded, after.tempRootsExcluded, false);
+  compareBoolean(changes, 'subagentsEnabled', before.subagentsEnabled, after.subagentsEnabled, true);
+  compareCount(
+    changes,
+    'uninspectedAgentKeyCount',
+    before.uninspectedAgentKeyCount,
+    after.uninspectedAgentKeyCount,
+    true
+  );
+  compareCount(
+    changes,
+    'uninspectedRootKeyCount',
+    before.uninspectedRootKeyCount,
+    after.uninspectedRootKeyCount,
+    true
+  );
+  compareCount(
+    changes,
+    'uninspectedSectionKindCount',
+    before.uninspectedSectionKindCount,
+    after.uninspectedSectionKindCount,
+    true
+  );
+}
+
+export function diffPermissionPostureSnapshots(beforeInput, afterInput) {
+  const before = validateSnapshot(beforeInput);
+  const after = validateSnapshot(afterInput);
+  if (before.runtime !== after.runtime) throw new Error('Cannot compare different permission posture runtimes.');
+
+  const changes = [];
+  if (before.policyDigest !== after.policyDigest) {
+    changes.push({ impact: 'review', type: 'policy-changed', field: 'policyDigest' });
+  }
+
+  compareArray(changes, 'signals', before.posture.signals, after.posture.signals, true);
+  if (before.posture.action !== after.posture.action) {
+    addChange(
+      changes,
+      ACTION_RANK[after.posture.action] > ACTION_RANK[before.posture.action]
+        ? 'expansion'
+        : 'restriction',
+      'decision-changed',
+      'action',
+      before.posture.action,
+      after.posture.action
+    );
+  }
+
+  if (before.runtime === 'claude') {
+    compareClaudeMetadata(changes, before.posture.metadata, after.posture.metadata);
+  } else {
+    compareCodexMetadata(changes, before.posture.metadata, after.posture.metadata);
+  }
+
+  const summary = {
+    expansions: changes.filter((change) => change.impact === 'expansion').length,
+    restrictions: changes.filter((change) => change.impact === 'restriction').length,
+    reviews: changes.filter((change) => change.impact === 'review').length
+  };
+  const status = summary.expansions || summary.reviews
+    ? 'needs-review'
+    : summary.restrictions ? 'restricted' : 'unchanged';
+  return {
+    schemaVersion: SNAPSHOT_VERSION,
+    runtime: before.runtime,
+    status,
+    baselineDigest: before.digest,
+    currentDigest: after.digest,
+    summary,
+    changes
+  };
+}