triflux 10.9.19 → 10.9.21

package/skills/tfx-workspace/iteration-2/multi-team-creation-refactored/old_skill/outputs/analysis.md

@@ -0,0 +1,382 @@
+# tfx-multi Routing Accuracy Analysis
+
+**Input:** `/tfx-multi 인증 리팩터링 + UI 개선 + 보안 리뷰`
+**Skill Definition:** SKILL.md (tfx-multi v3)
+**Analysis Type:** DRY RUN — no commands executed
+
+---
+
+## Phase 0: Preflight Checks
+
+The skill specifies that in **auto mode** (no `N:agent` prefix, no `--agents` flag), Phase 0 (preflight) and Phase 2 (triage) run **concurrently in parallel**. Preflight does NOT block Phase 2.
+
+The single combined Bash preflight check would be:
+
+```bash
+Bash(
+  command: "curl -sf http://127.0.0.1:27888/status >/dev/null && test -f ~/.claude/scripts/tfx-route.sh && echo 'preflight: ok' || echo 'preflight: FAIL'",
+  description: "Hub status + tfx-route.sh existence check"
+)
+```
+
+**What is verified:**
+1. Hub is running and healthy at `http://127.0.0.1:27888/status` (not `/health` alone — `/status` is the required endpoint per policy)
+2. `~/.claude/scripts/tfx-route.sh` exists on the filesystem
+
+**Output policy:** Lead only surfaces a one-line summary (e.g., `preflight: ok (route/hub)`). Individual Bash logs are not surfaced to the user unless preflight fails.
+
+**Failure conditions that would be reported:**
+- `tfx-route.sh` missing → advise running `tfx setup`
+- Hub not running or unhealthy → advise starting Hub
+- Required CLI (codex/gemini) not installed → the affected subtask would be reassigned to a claude worker
+
+**Timing:** Preflight runs **simultaneously** with Phase 2 triage (Codex classification). Agent spawn begins at Phase 3, which waits for Phase 2 output. If preflight fails, Agent spawn is aborted.
+
+---
+
+## Phase 1: Input Parsing
+
+**Raw input string:** `인증 리팩터링 + UI 개선 + 보안 리뷰`
+
+**Parsing decision tree:**
+
+| Check | Result |
+|-------|--------|
+| Is ARGUMENTS empty/whitespace? | No → proceed |
+| Does input match `N:agent_type`? | No (no colon-separated numeric prefix) |
+| Does input contain `--tmux` or `--psmux`? | No → not mux mode |
+| Does input contain `--agents`? | No → not manual agent-list mode |
+| Does input contain `--thorough`? | No → `--quick` mode (default) |
+| Does input match a control command (`status`, `stop`, `kill`, `attach`, `list`, `send`)? | No → not a control command |
+
+**Conclusion:** Input is parsed as **auto mode** with `--quick` (default). The full task string `인증 리팩터링 + UI 개선 + 보안 리뷰` is forwarded to Phase 2 triage.
+
+Control commands would have dispatched directly to:
+```bash
+Bash("node bin/triflux.mjs multi {cmd}")
+```
+...but that path is not taken here.
+
+---
+
+## Phase 2: Triage — Decomposition into Subtasks
+
+Since this is auto mode, triage follows the **Codex classification → Opus decomposition** path.
+
+### Step 2a: Codex Classification (free, runs in parallel with preflight)
+
+```bash
+Bash(
+  command: "codex exec --full-auto --skip-git-repo-check '다음 작업을 분석하고 각 부분에 적합한 agent를 분류하라.\n\n  agent 선택:\n  - codex: 코드 구현/수정/분석/리뷰/디버깅/설계 (기본값)\n  - gemini: 문서/UI/디자인/멀티모달\n  - claude: 코드베이스 탐색/테스트 실행/검증 (최후 수단)\n\n  모든 역할은 Codex/Gemini 우선 배정:\n  - explore, verifier, test-engineer, qa-tester 포함 전 역할이 Codex/Gemini로 라우팅\n  - Codex/Gemini 미설치 시에만 claude-native(sonnet/haiku) fallback\n  - claude 타입은 최후 수단으로만 사용\n\n  작업: 인증 리팩터링 + UI 개선 + 보안 리뷰\n\n  JSON만 출력:\n  { \"parts\": [{ \"description\": \"...\", \"agent\": \"codex|gemini|claude\" }] }'"
+)
+```
+
+**Expected Codex JSON output (predicted):**
+```json
+{
+  "parts": [
+    { "description": "인증 리팩터링", "agent": "codex" },
+    { "description": "UI 개선",      "agent": "gemini" },
+    { "description": "보안 리뷰",    "agent": "codex" }
+  ]
+}
+```
+
+Rationale per skill's agent selection rules:
+- `인증 리팩터링` — code refactoring → **codex** (코드 구현/수정)
+- `UI 개선` — UI/design improvement → **gemini** (UI/디자인/멀티모달)
+- `보안 리뷰` — code review/analysis → **codex** (리뷰/분석)
+
+**Fallback:** If Codex classification fails, Opus (the Lead orchestrator) directly classifies and decomposes without the Codex step.
+
+### Step 2b: Inline Decomposition
+
+Opus maps the Codex output to the subtasks array:
+
+```
+assignments = [
+  { cli: "codex",  subtask: "인증 리팩터링", role: "executor"  },
+  { cli: "gemini", subtask: "UI 개선",       role: "designer"  },
+  { cli: "codex",  subtask: "보안 리뷰",     role: "reviewer"  }
+]
+```
+
+Role mapping rationale:
+- `인증 리팩터링` → implementation task → role: `executor`
+- `UI 개선` → design/UI improvement → role: `designer`
+- `보안 리뷰` → code review → role: `reviewer`
+
+**Note:** `--quick` mode is the default (no `--thorough` flag detected), so **Phase 2.5 (Plan) and Phase 2.6 (PRD) are skipped entirely**. Execution proceeds directly to Phase 3.
+
+---
+
+## Phase 3: Exact Tool Call Parameters
+
+### Step 3a: TeamCreate
+
+```
+TeamCreate({
+  team_name: "tfx-" + Date.now().toString(36).slice(-6),   // e.g., "tfx-m7x2p1"
+  description: "tfx-multi: 인증 리팩터링 + UI 개선 + 보안 리뷰"
+})
+```
+
+`teamName` (e.g., `"tfx-m7x2p1"`) is stored and reused throughout all subsequent calls.
+
+### Step 3b: TaskCreate (one per subtask)
+
+**TaskCreate #1 — 인증 리팩터링:**
+```
+TaskCreate({
+  subject: "인증 리팩터링",
+  description: "CLI: codex, 역할: executor\n\n인증 관련 코드를 리팩터링하고 구조를 개선한다.",
+  metadata: { cli: "codex", role: "executor" }
+})
+→ taskId_1 = <created task id>
+→ agentName_1 = "codex-worker-1"
+```
+
+**TaskCreate #2 — UI 개선:**
+```
+TaskCreate({
+  subject: "UI 개선",
+  description: "CLI: gemini, 역할: designer\n\nUI 컴포넌트 및 사용자 인터페이스를 개선한다.",
+  metadata: { cli: "gemini", role: "designer" }
+})
+→ taskId_2 = <created task id>
+→ agentName_2 = "gemini-worker-1"
+```
+
+**TaskCreate #3 — 보안 리뷰:**
+```
+TaskCreate({
+  subject: "보안 리뷰",
+  description: "CLI: codex, 역할: reviewer\n\n코드베이스의 보안 취약점을 검토하고 리뷰한다.",
+  metadata: { cli: "codex", role: "reviewer" }
+})
+→ taskId_3 = <created task id>
+→ agentName_3 = "codex-worker-2"
+```
+
+runQueue after Step 3b:
+```
+[
+  { taskId: taskId_1, agentName: "codex-worker-1",  cli: "codex",  subtask: "인증 리팩터링", role: "executor"  },
+  { taskId: taskId_2, agentName: "gemini-worker-1", cli: "gemini", subtask: "UI 개선",       role: "designer"  },
+  { taskId: taskId_3, agentName: "codex-worker-2",  cli: "codex",  subtask: "보안 리뷰",     role: "reviewer"  }
+]
+```
+
+### Step 3c: Agent Slim Wrapper Spawns (codex and gemini items)
+
+All three assignments in this input have `cli` of `"codex"` or `"gemini"`, so **all three go through Step 3c** (slim wrapper Agent spawn). None take the Step 3d (claude direct) path.
+
+**Agent #1 — codex-worker-1 (인증 리팩터링):**
+```
+Agent({
+  name: "codex-worker-1",
+  team_name: teamName,                  // e.g., "tfx-m7x2p1"
+  mode: "bypassPermissions",
+  run_in_background: true,
+  prompt: buildSlimWrapperPrompt("codex", {
+    subtask:   "인증 리팩터링",
+    role:      "executor",
+    teamName:  teamName,
+    taskId:    taskId_1,
+    agentName: "codex-worker-1",
+    leadName:  "team-lead",
+    mcp_profile: <resolved mcp_profile>
+  })
+})
+```
+
+The slim wrapper prompt (generated by `hub/team/native.mjs:buildSlimWrapperPrompt()`) instructs the agent to:
+1. `TaskUpdate(taskId_1, status: "in_progress")` — claim
+2. `SendMessage(to: "team-lead", "작업 시작: codex-worker-1")` — turn boundary
+3. `Bash(command: "bash ~/.claude/scripts/tfx-route.sh executor '인증 리팩터링' <mcp_profile>", timeout: 1140000)` — execute via tfx-route.sh (1080s + 60s = 1140s = 1,140,000ms; executor role → default timeout)
+4. `SendMessage(to: "team-lead", "결과: <요약>")` — result boundary
+5. Await lead feedback; re-execute (Step 3) if directed
+6. On final completion: `TaskUpdate(taskId_1, status: "completed", metadata: {result: "success"|"failed"})` + `SendMessage`
+
+**Agent #2 — gemini-worker-1 (UI 개선):**
+```
+Agent({
+  name: "gemini-worker-1",
+  team_name: teamName,
+  mode: "bypassPermissions",
+  run_in_background: true,
+  prompt: buildSlimWrapperPrompt("gemini", {
+    subtask:   "UI 개선",
+    role:      "designer",
+    teamName:  teamName,
+    taskId:    taskId_2,
+    agentName: "gemini-worker-1",
+    leadName:  "team-lead",
+    mcp_profile: <resolved mcp_profile>
+  })
+})
+```
+
+Internal slim wrapper execution:
+```bash
+bash ~/.claude/scripts/tfx-route.sh designer 'UI 개선' <mcp_profile>
+```
+Timeout: 1140000ms (1080s default + 60s buffer).
+
+**Agent #3 — codex-worker-2 (보안 리뷰):**
+```
+Agent({
+  name: "codex-worker-2",
+  team_name: teamName,
+  mode: "bypassPermissions",
+  run_in_background: true,
+  prompt: buildSlimWrapperPrompt("codex", {
+    subtask:   "보안 리뷰",
+    role:      "reviewer",
+    teamName:  teamName,
+    taskId:    taskId_3,
+    agentName: "codex-worker-2",
+    leadName:  "team-lead",
+    mcp_profile: <resolved mcp_profile>
+  })
+})
+```
+
+Internal slim wrapper execution:
+```bash
+bash ~/.claude/scripts/tfx-route.sh reviewer '보안 리뷰' <mcp_profile>
+```
+Timeout: 3660000ms (reviewer role maps to "review" profile → 3600s + 60s buffer = 3,660,000ms).
+
+> Note on Bash timeout: `getRouteTimeout(role, mcpProfile)` determines the timeout. The `reviewer` role with a `review`-type profile yields **3600s** (not the default 1080s), resulting in a 3,660,000ms Bash timeout. The `executor` and `designer` roles use the default 1080s, giving 1,140,000ms.
+
+### Step 3d: Claude Direct Agent (not applicable here)
+
+No subtasks have `cli == "claude"` in this input. Step 3d is **not executed**.
+
+### Step 3e: User Notification
+
+After all three Agent spawns:
+```
+"팀 '{teamName}' 생성 완료.
+Codex/Gemini 워커가 슬림 래퍼 Agent로 네비게이션에 등록되었습니다.
+Shift+Down으로 다음 워커로 전환 (마지막→리드 wrap). Shift+Tab으로 이전 워커 전환."
+```
+
+---
+
+## Phase 4: Result Collection
+
+Phase 4 runs after all background Agent processes complete (or are awaited by the Lead).
+
+**Step 1:** Lead awaits completion signals from all three background Agents.
+
+**Step 2:** `team_task_list` is queried as the **single truth source**:
+```bash
+Bash("node hub/bridge.mjs team-task-list --team tfx-m7x2p1")
+```
+
+**Step 3:** For each task in the list:
+- If `status == "completed"` AND `metadata.result == "failed"` → the task is retried using a Claude fallback worker (Step 3d pattern)
+- If `status == "completed"` AND `metadata.result == "success"` → accepted as done
+
+**Step 4:** After any fallback retries, `team-task-list` is queried again to confirm final state.
+
+**Step 5:** `send-message` events and `result(task.result)` topic events are used only as **progress observation channels** — they do NOT determine the final outcome. Only `team_task_list` state is authoritative.
+
+**Final report (example):**
+```markdown
+## tfx-multi 실행 결과
+
+| # | Worker | CLI | 작업 | 상태 |
+|---|--------|-----|------|------|
+| 1 | codex-worker-1 | codex | 인증 리팩터링 | completed |
+| 2 | gemini-worker-1 | gemini | UI 개선 | completed |
+| 3 | codex-worker-2 | codex | 보안 리뷰 | completed |
+```
+
+---
+
+## Phase 5: Cleanup (TeamDelete)
+
+Phase 5 is **mandatory** regardless of success or failure. It runs after Phase 4 result collection.
+
+**Cleanup sequence:**
+
+1. Wait up to **30 seconds** for all background Agent processes to complete.
+2. If any Agent is still running after 30s, stop waiting and proceed with cleanup anyway.
+3. Call TeamDelete:
+   ```
+   TeamDelete(teamName)   // e.g., TeamDelete("tfx-m7x2p1")
+   ```
+4. If TeamDelete fails (active members still present):
+   - Call `forceCleanupTeam(teamName)` (force cleanup utility)
+   - If that also fails → instruct user to manually run:
+     ```bash
+     rm -rf ~/.claude/teams/tfx-m7x2p1/ ~/.claude/tasks/tfx-m7x2p1/
+     ```
+5. Output the final summary report (from Phase 4).
+
+**Why this is mandatory:** Without TeamDelete, `~/.claude/teams/{teamName}/` persists on disk and the OMC hook continuously detects "team executing," causing an infinite detection loop.
+
+---
+
+## Key Boolean Flags
+
+### `mode: "bypassPermissions"` in Agent calls
+
+**YES — included in all three Agent spawns.**
+
+The skill explicitly states (Phase 3c):
+> **[필수] `mode: "bypassPermissions"` — 모든 Agent spawn에 반드시 포함한다.**
+> 이 설정이 없으면 워커가 Bash 실행 시 사용자 승인을 요청하여 자동 실행이 중단된다.
+> Codex/Gemini 래퍼, Claude 워커 모두 동일하게 적용한다.
+
+All three `Agent({...})` calls in this analysis include `mode: "bypassPermissions"`.
+
+### `tfx-route.sh` usage inside Agent wrappers
+
+**YES — all slim wrapper Agents use `tfx-route.sh` exclusively.**
+
+The skill explicitly prohibits direct CLI invocation:
+> **[금지] Lead 또는 Agent 래퍼가 `gemini -y -p "..."` 또는 `codex exec "..."`를 직접 호출하면 안 된다.**
+
+The required form inside each slim wrapper Agent is:
+```bash
+bash ~/.claude/scripts/tfx-route.sh {role} '{subtask}' {mcp_profile}
+```
+
+This ensures that model specification (`-m gemini-3.1-pro-preview`), MCP filters, team bridge integration (`TFX_TEAM_*` env vars), Windows-compatible paths, timeouts, and post-processing (token tracking, issue logging) are all properly applied.
+
+The three concrete `tfx-route.sh` invocations in this session:
+```bash
+# codex-worker-1
+bash ~/.claude/scripts/tfx-route.sh executor '인증 리팩터링' <mcp_profile>
+
+# gemini-worker-1
+bash ~/.claude/scripts/tfx-route.sh designer 'UI 개선' <mcp_profile>
+
+# codex-worker-2
+bash ~/.claude/scripts/tfx-route.sh reviewer '보안 리뷰' <mcp_profile>
+```
+
+---
+
+## Summary Table
+
+| Phase | Action | Key Parameters / Notes |
+|-------|--------|------------------------|
+| 0 | Preflight (parallel with Phase 2) | `curl http://127.0.0.1:27888/status` + `test -f ~/.claude/scripts/tfx-route.sh` |
+| 1 | Input parsed as **auto mode, --quick** | No `N:agent`, no `--tmux`, no `--thorough`, no control command |
+| 2a | Codex classification | Task: `인증 리팩터링 + UI 개선 + 보안 리뷰` → codex / gemini / codex |
+| 2b | Subtask array | 3 items: executor/designer/reviewer |
+| 3a | TeamCreate | `team_name: "tfx-<6chars>"`, `description: "tfx-multi: 인증 리팩터링 + UI 개선 + 보안 리뷰"` |
+| 3b | 3x TaskCreate | subjects: 인증 리팩터링, UI 개선, 보안 리뷰 |
+| 3c | 3x Agent (slim wrapper) | `mode: "bypassPermissions"`, `run_in_background: true`, uses `tfx-route.sh` internally |
+| 3d | 0x Agent (claude direct) | Not applicable — no `cli: "claude"` assignments |
+| 4 | Result collection | `node hub/bridge.mjs team-task-list --team {teamName}` as truth source |
+| 5 | TeamDelete | Mandatory; max 30s wait; force cleanup fallback if needed |
+
+---
+
+*Analysis generated by DRY RUN — no commands were executed.*

package/skills/tfx-workspace/iteration-2/multi-team-creation-refactored/old_skill/timing.json

@@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
+{
+  "total_tokens": 27382,
+  "duration_ms": 133145,
+  "total_duration_seconds": 133.1
+}

package/skills/tfx-workspace/iteration-2/multi-team-creation-refactored/with_skill/grading.json

@@ -0,0 +1,35 @@
+{
+  "expectations": [
+    {
+      "text": "Creates exactly one TeamCreate with tfx- prefix naming",
+      "passed": true,
+      "evidence": "TeamCreate({ team_name: 'tfx-<hex6>' })"
+    },
+    {
+      "text": "Creates 3 TaskCreate calls (one per subtask)",
+      "passed": true,
+      "evidence": "3x TaskCreate with { subject, metadata: { cli, role } }"
+    },
+    {
+      "text": "Spawns 3 Agent wrappers with mode: bypassPermissions",
+      "passed": true,
+      "evidence": "3x Agent({ mode: bypassPermissions, run_in_background: true })"
+    },
+    {
+      "text": "Uses tfx-route.sh inside Agent wrapper (not direct codex/gemini)",
+      "passed": true,
+      "evidence": "bash ~/.claude/scripts/tfx-route.sh {role} '{subtask}' {mcp_profile}; direct codex exec is forbidden"
+    },
+    {
+      "text": "Includes Phase 5 cleanup (TeamDelete)",
+      "passed": true,
+      "evidence": "TeamDelete always executed, max 30s wait, skipping causes infinite loop"
+    },
+    {
+      "text": "References agent-wrapper-rules.md for detailed rules",
+      "passed": true,
+      "evidence": "agent-wrapper-rules.md provided 6-step interrupt protocol, dynamic timeout values, and 7 technical reasons for tfx-route.sh"
+    }
+  ],
+  "summary": { "passed": 6, "failed": 0, "total": 6, "pass_rate": 1.0 }
+}