tickmarkr 2.6.5 → 2.6.6

package/dist/cli/commands/fleet.js

@@ -1,5 +1,6 @@
 import { existsSync, mkdirSync, readFileSync, renameSync, unlinkSync, writeFileSync } from "node:fs";
-import { dirname, join } from "node:path";
+import { homedir } from "node:os";
+import { dirname, join, relative } from "node:path";
 import { parseArgs } from "node:util";
 import { allAdapters, discoverChannels, doctorAgeMs, initDoctorReuse, modelAuthExclusions, PREFERENCE_ROLES } from "../../adapters/registry.js";
 import { catalogModelAdvisory, catalogTierRanking, declaredModelWindow, fleetUnclassifiedModels } from "../../adapters/model-lints.js";
@@ -7,6 +8,7 @@ import { CATALOG_REFRESH_TIMEOUT_MS, formatCatalogRefreshLegs, readCachedCatalog
 import { CLAUDE_ALIAS_IDENTITY_STAMPS, readClaudeAliasIdentity } from "../../adapters/claude-code.js";
 import { ConfigError, DEFAULT_CONFIG, fleetEditableFromConfig, fleetEditableEquals, formatFleetPrint, globalConfigDir, DENY_SCOPES, initialDenyPropOf, loadConfigWithMode, lowerLayerModelOverrides, overlayBytesLoadError, readOverlayFile, stagedDenyKeyOf, renderFleetOverlayWrite, repoOverlayPath, repoShadowedUserKeys, ROUTING_MODES, TIER_RANK, unifiedYamlDiff, universeEntryMatches, } from "../../config/config.js";
 import { exclusionReason, projectFleetWhy, renderFleetWhy } from "../../config/fleet-why.js";
+import { overlayHoldingLine, overlayHoldsMap } from "../../config/fleet-overlay.js";
 import { SHAPES, TIERS } from "../../graph/schema.js";
 import { doctor } from "./doctor.js";
 import { candidateRow, costSignal, shapeCandidates } from "./fleet-picker.js";
@@ -87,6 +89,9 @@ function formatFleetSteering(cfg) {
     return blocks.length ? `${blocks.join("\n")}\n` : "";
 }
 // v1.51 T4: one gloss per routing mode on the fleet mode screen — mirrors the preset compiler.
+// T10: what every review says about where its bytes land and when they take effect
+const REPO_DESTINATION_NOTE = (path) => `destination: the repository overlay ${path} holds this repository's routing.allow/deny membership, so the edit lands there — the file is tracked: Fleet never stages or commits it; commit it to share the change`;
+const FUTURE_LOADS_NOTE = "the save changes future config loads only — a tickmarkr run already in progress keeps the config it loaded";
 const MODE_GLOSS = {
     "partner-led": "every shape frontier · explore off",
     "risk-based": "risk-tiered default floors",
@@ -218,10 +223,15 @@ export async function fleet(argv, cwd = process.cwd(), adapters = allAdapters(),
  * overlay write. */
 export async function assembleFleetEditor(cwd, adapters, io, opts) {
     const globalDir = opts.globalDir;
-    // B2: the editor's choices are the operator's MACHINE choices — every save lands in the USER
-    // overlay, which every repository on this machine inherits. The repo overlay is read, never written.
+    // B2: the editor's choices are the operator's MACHINE choices — a save lands in the USER overlay,
+    // which every repository on this machine inherits. T10 (D-925/D-926): except a membership edit the
+    // repository overlay holds — it lands where it is effective (destinationEdits below).
     const userPath = join(globalDir, "config.yaml");
+    const repoPath = repoOverlayPath(cwd);
     const currentUserText = () => (existsSync(userPath) ? readFileSync(userPath, "utf8") : "");
+    const pathOf = (destination) => (destination === "repo" ? repoPath : userPath);
+    // the candidate bytes stand in for the destination layer in the one loader path
+    const layerOf = (destination, bytes) => (destination === "repo" ? { repoOverlayText: bytes } : { userOverlayText: bytes });
     const { reuse, health: cached } = initDoctorReuse(cwd, false);
     if (!reuse || !cached) {
         return {
@@ -363,8 +373,6 @@ export async function assembleFleetEditor(cwd, adapters, io, opts) {
     const channels = discoverChannels(cfg, adapters, health);
     const profile = loadRoutingProfile(cwd, cfg, { preview: true });
     const stagedDenyOf = (editable) => Object.fromEntries(DENY_SCOPES.map((scope) => [stagedDenyKeyOf(scope), editable[scope.key] ?? []]));
-    // T8: staged classifications and efforts as the editable tiers/efforts a review writes — one fold for
-    // the review and every preview, so the mode/shape/picker callbacks rank exactly what w would write.
     const stagedMetadataOf = (stage) => {
         const tiers = structuredClone(initial.tiers);
         const today = new Date().toISOString().slice(0, 10);
@@ -377,20 +385,21 @@ export async function assembleFleetEditor(cwd, adapters, io, opts) {
         }
         // OBS-1182: staged efforts replace the loaded ones; none staged anywhere ⇒ no key, as loaded
         const efforts = Object.fromEntries(Object.entries(stage.efforts ?? {}).filter(([, models]) => Object.keys(models).length));
-        return { tiers, ...(Object.keys(efforts).length ? { efforts } : {}) };
+        return { tiers, ...(Object.keys(efforts).length ? { efforts } : {}), seeds: stage.seededAllowOut ?? [] };
     };
     // B2: the classifications and efforts of the last reviewed state — what a preview called without a
     // stage (the browser's staged routing, --why) ranks; the editor passes its current stage (T8).
-    let reviewedStage = { tiers: initial.tiers, efforts: initial.efforts };
-    // OBS-1182: the layers under the written overlay — B2: the defaults alone under the USER overlay —
-    // read raw, so clearing an effort masks an inherited one. OBS-1188: re-read at every review and
-    // save, never an assembly-time snapshot; an unreadable read keeps the last good one for the
-    // preview only — the save guard below refuses it.
-    let lowerOverrides = {};
+    let reviewedStage = { tiers: initial.tiers, efforts: initial.efforts, seeds: [] };
+    // OBS-1182: the layers under the written overlay — B2: the defaults alone under the USER overlay;
+    // T10: defaults + user under the repository overlay — read raw, so clearing an effort masks an
+    // inherited one. OBS-1188: re-read at every review and save, never an assembly-time snapshot; an
+    // unreadable read keeps the last good one for the preview only — the save guard below refuses it.
+    const lowerOverrides = { user: {}, repo: {} };
     const stagedEditable = (map, deny, metadata) => ({
         ...structuredClone(initial),
-        efforts: undefined, // metadata carries efforts only when some are staged — as a review writes them
-        ...structuredClone(metadata),
+        // metadata carries efforts only when some are staged — as a review writes them
+        tiers: structuredClone(metadata.tiers),
+        efforts: metadata.efforts && structuredClone(metadata.efforts),
         ...Object.fromEntries(DENY_SCOPES.map((scope) => [scope.key, deny[stagedDenyKeyOf(scope)]])),
         // OBS-1046: the allow complement is staged beside the deny lists, never folded into them
         allowOut: deny.allowOut ?? initial.allowOut,
@@ -406,13 +415,17 @@ export async function assembleFleetEditor(cwd, adapters, io, opts) {
     // it in every other repository.
     const membershipKeys = [...DENY_SCOPES.filter((scope) => scope.path.length === 3).map((scope) => scope.key), "allowOut"];
     const sameSet = (a = [], b = []) => [...new Set(a)].sort().join() === [...new Set(b)].sort().join();
-    const destinationInitial = (base, edited, userText, target) => {
+    // T10: a repository destination diffs against the effective layers (defaults + user + repo).
+    const destinationInitial = (base, edited, destination, text, target) => {
         let userCfg;
         try {
-            userCfg = loadConfigWithMode(cwd, { globalDir, userOverlayText: userText, repoOverlayText: "" }).cfg;
+            userCfg = loadConfigWithMode(cwd, {
+                globalDir,
+                ...(destination === "repo" ? { repoOverlayText: text } : { userOverlayText: text, repoOverlayText: "" }),
+            }).cfg;
         }
         catch {
-            return base; // ponytail: user bytes that load only beside this repo — the reload guard refuses the write
+            return base; // ponytail: bytes that load only beside another layer — the reload guard refuses the write
         }
         const userLayer = userCfg.routing.map;
         const editedMap = edited.map;
@@ -429,11 +442,11 @@ export async function assembleFleetEditor(cwd, adapters, io, opts) {
             };
         }
         const membershipTouched = membershipKeys.some((key) => !sameSet(base[key], edited[key]));
-        const destination = membershipTouched ? fleetEditableFromConfig(userCfg, target) : undefined;
+        const layer = membershipTouched ? fleetEditableFromConfig(userCfg, target) : undefined;
         return {
             ...base,
             map,
-            ...(destination ? Object.fromEntries(membershipKeys.map((key) => [key, destination[key] ?? []])) : {}),
+            ...(layer ? Object.fromEntries(membershipKeys.map((key) => [key, layer[key] ?? []])) : {}),
         };
     };
     // B2: a changed slot staged with no declaration (auto, no prefer) where the defaults under the user
@@ -454,24 +467,207 @@ export async function assembleFleetEditor(cwd, adapters, io, opts) {
         }
         return { ...staged, map };
     };
-    // B2: the one user-layer write builder the previews and the review share, so a preview ranks the
-    // bytes y would land. A touched membership serializes against the universe the candidate itself
-    // serves (current layers plus staged classifications), rendered first with membership unchanged;
-    // a channel only that universe adds keeps the verdict the current layers' allow form gives it.
-    const userLayerWrite = (staged, userText, rest) => {
+    // T10 (D-939): ONE pure baseline — the session's initial allow complement plus the allow entry Ink
+    // seeded beside each classification it staged (FleetSeededAllow) — serves every preview, the review
+    // and the destination choice. `initial` is never mutated.
+    const baselineOf = (seeds) => (seeds.length
+        ? { ...initial, allowOut: [...new Set([...(initial.allowOut ?? []), ...seeds.map((seed) => seed.entry)])].sort() }
+        : initial);
+    const FLAT_SCOPES = DENY_SCOPES.filter((scope) => scope.path.length === 3);
+    const seedChannel = (seed) => ({ adapter: seed.adapter, model: seed.displayModel, ...(seed.identity !== undefined ? { identity: seed.identity } : {}) });
+    // an allow-complement entry excludes a seeded channel by the allow form's own matching (adapter id,
+    // model, adapter:model, recorded identity) — the seed's spelling is one such entry, never the only one
+    const seedRow = (seed) => ({
+        adapter: seed.adapter,
+        models: [seed.displayModel],
+        ...(seed.identity !== undefined ? { identities: { [seed.displayModel]: seed.identity } } : {}),
+    });
+    const allowExcludes = (staged, seed) => (staged.allowOut ?? []).some((entry) => universeEntryMatches(seedRow(seed), seed.displayModel, entry));
+    // membership keeps the channel out: its allow complement or a flat (all-seats) deny entry
+    const excludedIn = (staged, seed) => allowExcludes(staged, seed)
+        || FLAT_SCOPES.some((scope) => (staged[scope.key] ?? []).some((entry) => entryMatchesChannel(entry, seedChannel(seed), true)));
+    // a seed cleared while another staged complement entry (its adapter's, say) still excludes its
+    // channel admitted nothing: the press is a no-op, so the seed stays staged and the shared exclusion
+    // is no membership edit — its classification stays a lone tier
+    const settled = (staged, seeds) => {
+        const kept = seeds.filter((seed) => !(staged.allowOut ?? []).includes(seed.entry) && allowExcludes(staged, seed));
+        return kept.length
+            ? { ...staged, allowOut: [...new Set([...(staged.allowOut ?? []), ...kept.map((seed) => seed.entry)])].sort() }
+            : staged;
+    };
+    // an END state, re-derived per call: no staged complement entry and no flat deny excludes the seed's
+    // channel any more — an admission undone by out · all is no admission
+    const admittedSeeds = (staged, seeds) => seeds.filter((seed) => !excludedIn(staged, seed));
+    // ponytail: rows re-render per key press, each naming its scopes' holders — memoized per (bytes, path),
+    // cleared wholesale past 256 entries; a keyed LRU if a fleet ever outgrows it
+    const holdingMemo = new Map();
+    const holdingLine = (text, path) => {
+        const key = `${path.join(".")}\0${text}`;
+        if (!holdingMemo.has(key)) {
+            if (holdingMemo.size > 256)
+                holdingMemo.clear();
+            holdingMemo.set(key, overlayHoldingLine(text, path));
+        }
+        return holdingMemo.get(key);
+    };
+    // routing.allow is held through its leaves: a bare `allow: {}` declares none, so the merge keeps the
+    // lower layer's leaves effective; a null mask at a leaf or above still holds it
+    const heldLine = (text, path) => path.join(".") === "routing.allow" && ["adapters", "models"].every((leaf) => holdingLine(text, [...path, leaf]) === undefined)
+        ? undefined
+        : holdingLine(text, path);
+    // T10: the repository holds a path when it declares it ([] included) or masks it with null at it or above
+    const repoHolds = (path) => heldLine(currentRepoOverlayText(cwd), path) !== undefined;
+    // T10: where a scope lives in this repository's merge — `path:line` of the repository overlay when it
+    // holds it, else of the user overlay when that one does; undefined = the defaults alone. Paths are
+    // short (repo-relative, ~ for home) so the row's detail line keeps them on screen.
+    const home = homedir();
+    const shown = (path) => (path.startsWith(`${home}/`) ? `~${path.slice(home.length)}` : path);
+    const holderOf = (dotted) => {
+        const path = dotted.split(".");
+        const repoLine = heldLine(currentRepoOverlayText(cwd), path);
+        if (repoLine !== undefined)
+            return `${relative(cwd, repoPath)}:${repoLine}`;
+        const userLine = heldLine(currentUserText(), path);
+        return userLine === undefined ? undefined : `${shown(userPath)}:${userLine}`;
+    };
+    // the allow + flat-deny family is ONE coupled write (the allow form is
+    // regenerated from the whole staged fleet), so it has one holder: the repository when it holds any of
+    // its leaves, else the user. A bare repository `allow: {}` holds no leaf, yet its presence alone keeps
+    // the allowlist on: a user save that drops the user allow form would fail-close this repository, so
+    // only the repository (which masks it) can take that save. Whether the user form goes away is read off
+    // the one writer's user bytes — a staged flat deny, an allow exclusion, or a retained authored entry
+    // for a channel this probe never served each keep it, and with it the save, in the user overlay.
+    const userFormDropped = (staged, seeds) => {
+        const text = currentUserText();
+        try {
+            const bytes = renderFleetOverlayWrite(text, layerWrite(staged, seeds, "user", text, { lowerOverrides: lowerOverrides.user }));
+            return !overlayHoldsMap(bytes, ["routing", "allow"]);
+        }
+        catch {
+            return false; // the review renders the same write and names its refusal
+        }
+    };
+    const familyHolder = (staged, seeds) => [["routing", "allow"], ...FLAT_SCOPES.map((scope) => scope.path)].some(repoHolds)
+        || (holdingLine(currentRepoOverlayText(cwd), ["routing", "allow"]) !== undefined && userFormDropped(staged, seeds))
+        ? "repo" : "user";
+    const destinationEdits = (pressed, seeds, controls) => {
+        const staged = settled(pressed, seeds);
+        const baseline = baselineOf(seeds);
+        const admitted = admittedSeeds(staged, seeds);
+        let held;
+        const family = () => (held ??= familyHolder(staged, seeds));
+        const edits = [];
+        if (admitted.length || membershipKeys.some((key) => !sameSet(baseline[key], staged[key]))) {
+            edits.push({ name: "routing.allow/routing.deny membership", destination: family() });
+        }
+        // a worker leaf follows the layer that holds it
+        for (const scope of DENY_SCOPES.filter((candidate) => candidate.path.length > 3)) {
+            if (!sameSet(initial[scope.key], staged[scope.key]))
+                edits.push({ name: scope.dotted, destination: repoHolds(scope.path) ? "repo" : "user" });
+        }
+        for (const [adapter, models] of Object.entries(staged.tiers)) {
+            for (const [model, value] of Object.entries(models)) {
+                if (JSON.stringify(value) === JSON.stringify(initial.tiers[adapter]?.[model]))
+                    continue;
+                // a classification co-locates only with its own admission — its seed cleared, or (T10 review) its
+                // own flat-deny lift: a row the baseline membership kept out that the staged one admits; a lone or
+                // unrelated tier stays user
+                const own = admitted.some((seed) => seed.adapter === adapter && seed.model === model)
+                    || (modelGroups.find((group) => group.adapter === adapter)?.rows ?? [])
+                        .filter((row) => row.model === model || ("classifyModel" in row && row.classifyModel === model))
+                        .some((row) => {
+                        const channel = { adapter, displayModel: row.model, ...(row.evidence?.identity !== undefined ? { identity: row.evidence.identity } : {}) };
+                        return excludedIn(baseline, channel) && !excludedIn(staged, channel);
+                    });
+                edits.push({ name: `tiers.${adapter}.models.${model}`, destination: own ? family() : "user" });
+            }
+        }
+        // {} ≡ absent: pin-then-auto leaves an empty entry that writes nothing (fleet-app stagedCount)
+        if ([...new Set([...Object.keys(initial.map), ...Object.keys(staged.map)])]
+            .some((shape) => JSON.stringify(initial.map[shape] ?? {}) !== JSON.stringify(staged.map[shape] ?? {}))) {
+            edits.push({ name: "routing.map", destination: "user" });
+        }
+        if (JSON.stringify(initial.efforts ?? {}) !== JSON.stringify(staged.efforts ?? {}))
+            edits.push({ name: "model efforts", destination: "user" });
+        return [...edits, ...controls.map((name) => ({ name, destination: "user" }))];
+    };
+    // ONE review confirms ONE destination; a batch needing both is refused before any write (no
+    // multi-file transaction) and names what to save in separate sessions
+    const chooseDestination = (edits) => {
+        if (new Set(edits.map((edit) => edit.destination)).size <= 1)
+            return { ok: true, destination: edits[0]?.destination ?? "user" };
+        const side = (destination) => `${edits.filter((edit) => edit.destination === destination).map((edit) => edit.name).join(", ")} → ${pathOf(destination)}`;
+        return {
+            ok: false,
+            reason: `mixed destinations — one review writes one overlay: ${side("repo")}; ${side("user")} — save them in separate sessions (stage one side, w, y; then the other)`,
+        };
+    };
+    // T10: the universe a write edits — the candidate's own discovery plus every seeded channel, so an
+    // unprobed classified model can still be admitted (membership ≠ routability). A seed whose channel
+    // the browser never showed, or whose spelling names no channel, is refused.
+    const editingUniverse = (candidate, seeds) => {
+        const target = universeOf(candidateChannels(candidate));
+        const covers = (seed) => target.some((row) => row.adapter === seed.adapter
+            && row.models.some((model) => universeEntryMatches(row, model, seed.entry)));
+        for (const seed of seeds) {
+            if (covers(seed))
+                continue;
+            const shown = modelGroups.some((group) => group.adapter === seed.adapter && group.rows.some((row) => row.model === seed.displayModel));
+            const row = target.find((candidateRow) => candidateRow.adapter === seed.adapter);
+            if (shown && row) {
+                row.models = [...row.models, seed.displayModel];
+                if (seed.identity !== undefined)
+                    row.identities = { ...row.identities, [seed.displayModel]: seed.identity };
+            }
+            if (!covers(seed))
+                throw new ConfigError(`the seeded allow entry ${seed.entry} names no channel of the discovered fleet — re-probe with tickmarkr doctor, then classify it again`);
+        }
+        return target;
+    };
+    // T10: the routing.allow the layers BELOW the destination declare (the defaults declare none; under
+    // the repository, the user overlay's, read now). "Whole fleet in" masks it, never resurrects it, and
+    // while the repository declares no allow of its own, that inherited form's unserved entries are
+    // effective here, so the regenerated repository form keeps them.
+    const lowerAllow = (destination) => {
+        if (destination === "user")
+            return DEFAULT_CONFIG.routing.allow;
+        const user = readOverlayFile(userPath);
+        return user.routing?.allow ?? undefined;
+    };
+    // B2: the one write builder the previews and the review share, so a preview ranks the bytes y would
+    // land. A touched membership serializes against the universe the candidate itself serves (current
+    // layers plus staged classifications), rendered first with membership unchanged; a channel only that
+    // universe adds keeps the verdict the current layers' allow form gives it — T10: unless it is an
+    // admitted seed, which the operator just let in.
+    const layerWrite = (pressed, seeds, destination, text, rest) => {
+        const staged = settled(pressed, seeds);
+        const baseline = baselineOf(seeds);
+        const admitted = admittedSeeds(staged, seeds);
+        const lower = lowerAllow(destination);
+        // per leaf: an inherited allow leaf the repository neither declares nor masks (at it or above) is
+        // effective here, so its unserved entries ride the regenerated form even beside a declared sibling
+        const inherited = lower && Object.fromEntries(["adapters", "models"]
+            .filter((leaf) => lower[leaf] != null && !repoHolds(["routing", "allow", leaf]))
+            .map((leaf) => [leaf, lower[leaf]]));
+        const fixed = {
+            lowerMap: DEFAULT_CONFIG.routing.map,
+            ...(lower !== undefined ? { lowerAllow: lower } : {}),
+            ...(inherited && Object.keys(inherited).length ? { preservedAllow: inherited } : {}),
+        };
         let edited = maskClearedSlots(initial, staged);
-        let target = universe;
-        if (membershipKeys.some((key) => !sameSet(initial[key], edited[key]))) {
-            const unchanged = { ...edited, ...Object.fromEntries(membershipKeys.map((key) => [key, initial[key]])) };
+        let target = editingUniverse(cfg, seeds);
+        if (membershipKeys.some((key) => !sameSet(baseline[key], edited[key]))) {
+            const unchanged = { ...edited, ...Object.fromEntries(membershipKeys.map((key) => [key, baseline[key]])) };
             try {
-                const bytes = renderFleetOverlayWrite(userText, {
-                    ...rest, initial: destinationInitial(initial, unchanged, userText, universe), edited: unchanged, universe,
-                    lowerMap: DEFAULT_CONFIG.routing.map,
+                const bytes = renderFleetOverlayWrite(text, {
+                    ...rest, ...fixed, initial: destinationInitial(baseline, unchanged, destination, text, target), edited: unchanged, universe: target,
                 });
-                const candidate = loadConfigWithMode(cwd, { globalDir, userOverlayText: bytes }).cfg;
-                target = universeOf(candidateChannels(candidate));
+                const candidate = loadConfigWithMode(cwd, { globalDir, ...layerOf(destination, bytes) }).cfg;
+                target = editingUniverse(candidate, seeds);
                 const known = (entry) => universe.some((row) => entry === row.adapter || row.models.some((model) => universeEntryMatches(row, model, entry)));
-                const grown = (fleetEditableFromConfig(candidate, target).allowOut ?? []).filter((entry) => !known(entry));
+                const admits = (entry) => admitted.some((seed) => target.some((row) => row.adapter === seed.adapter
+                    && row.models.some((model) => universeEntryMatches(row, model, seed.entry) && universeEntryMatches(row, model, entry))));
+                const grown = (fleetEditableFromConfig(candidate, target).allowOut ?? []).filter((entry) => !known(entry) && !admits(entry));
                 if (grown.length)
                     edited = { ...edited, allowOut: [...new Set([...(edited.allowOut ?? []), ...grown])].sort() };
             }
@@ -479,8 +675,7 @@ export async function assembleFleetEditor(cwd, adapters, io, opts) {
                 // the full render below (or the reload guard) names the refusal
             }
         }
-        // T8: the user overlay's lower layer is the defaults alone (B2) — a pin cleared over one is tombstoned
-        return { ...rest, initial: destinationInitial(initial, edited, userText, target), edited, universe: target, lowerMap: DEFAULT_CONFIG.routing.map };
+        return { ...rest, ...fixed, initial: destinationInitial(baseline, edited, destination, text, target), edited, universe: target };
     };
     const candidateMemo = new Map();
     const previewCfg = (mode, map, deny, stage) => {
@@ -489,17 +684,24 @@ export async function assembleFleetEditor(cwd, adapters, io, opts) {
         // T8: so are the staged tiers/efforts — a metadata edit never serves the preview cached before it
         const metadata = stage ? stagedMetadataOf(stage) : reviewedStage;
         const userText = currentUserText();
-        const key = JSON.stringify([mode, map, deny, metadata, userText, currentRepoOverlayText(cwd)]);
+        const repoText = currentRepoOverlayText(cwd);
+        const key = JSON.stringify([mode, map, deny, metadata, userText, repoText]);
         const hit = candidateMemo.get(key);
         if (hit)
             return hit;
         let preview;
         try {
-            const bytes = renderFleetOverlayWrite(userText, userLayerWrite(stagedEditable(map, deny, metadata), userText, {
-                lowerOverrides,
+            const staged = stagedEditable(map, deny, metadata);
+            // T10: a preview loads the bytes the chosen destination would hold; a mixed batch (refused at w)
+            // previews with the repository side, so a row's reach never turns unknown mid-session
+            const chosen = chooseDestination(destinationEdits(staged, metadata.seeds, mode !== rm.mode.mode ? ["routing.mode"] : []));
+            const destination = chosen.ok ? chosen.destination : "repo";
+            const text = destination === "repo" ? repoText : userText;
+            const bytes = renderFleetOverlayWrite(text, layerWrite(staged, metadata.seeds, destination, text, {
+                lowerOverrides: lowerOverrides[destination],
                 ...(mode !== rm.mode.mode ? { mode } : {}),
             }));
-            preview = { ok: true, ...loadConfigWithMode(cwd, { globalDir, userOverlayText: bytes }) };
+            preview = { ok: true, ...loadConfigWithMode(cwd, { globalDir, ...layerOf(destination, bytes) }) };
         }
         catch (error) {
             preview = { ok: false, error: error.message.replace(/\s+/g, " ").trim() };
@@ -510,8 +712,9 @@ export async function assembleFleetEditor(cwd, adapters, io, opts) {
         return preview;
     };
     const previewUnavailable = (error) => `preview unavailable (${error}) — the staged overlay does not load, so w would be refused`;
-    const stagedRouting = (deny) => {
-        const preview = previewCfg(rm.mode.mode, editable.map, deny);
+    // T10: the staged metadata rides along, so a seeded classification's admission reads `in` before w
+    const stagedRouting = (deny, stage) => {
+        const preview = previewCfg(rm.mode.mode, editable.map, deny, stage);
         return preview.ok ? { ok: true, routing: preview.cfg.routing } : preview;
     };
     // B2: the candidate config's own discovery, blind to both membership scopes — classifications and
@@ -866,35 +1069,39 @@ export async function assembleFleetEditor(cwd, adapters, io, opts) {
     // discovered seats universe plus a keep-default row, and a write is staged only on a real change.
     const initialJudge = `${cfg.judge.adapter}:${cfg.judge.model}`;
     let pendingWrite = null;
-    const lowerLayers = () => lowerLayerModelOverrides({ globalDir, below: "user" });
+    const lowerLayers = (destination) => lowerLayerModelOverrides({ globalDir, below: destination });
     // OBS-1188: the reviewed bytes are the only bytes that may land. Any byte of the user or repo overlay
     // that moved since the review is a stale preview — a re-render alone would overwrite a same-key edit
     // with the staged value and still match — then the lower layers are re-rendered as they are NOW.
-    // Null = still current.
-    const stalePreview = (pending, reviewed, prior = currentUserText()) => {
-        if (currentRepoOverlayText(cwd) !== pending.repo) {
-            return `stale preview — the repository overlay ${repoOverlayPath(cwd)} changed after the review diff was rendered; press w to review what would be written now`;
+    // T10: both overlays are guarded whichever one is written, so a holder that moved after the review
+    // (the destination itself) refuses instead of retargeting. Null = still current.
+    const stalePreview = (pending, reviewed, prior) => {
+        const destinationNow = prior ?? (pending.destination === "repo" ? currentRepoOverlayText(cwd) : currentUserText());
+        const repoNow = pending.destination === "repo" ? destinationNow : currentRepoOverlayText(cwd);
+        const userNow = pending.destination === "user" ? destinationNow : currentUserText();
+        if (repoNow !== pending.repo) {
+            return `stale preview — the repository overlay ${repoPath} changed after the review diff was rendered; press w to review what would be written now`;
         }
-        if (prior !== pending.user) {
+        if (userNow !== pending.user) {
             return `stale preview — the user overlay ${userPath} changed after the review diff was rendered; press w to review what would be written now`;
         }
-        const lower = lowerLayers();
+        const lower = lowerLayers(pending.destination);
         if (!lower.ok)
             return lower.error;
         try {
-            if (renderFleetOverlayWrite(prior, { ...pending.write, lowerOverrides: lower.overrides }) === reviewed)
+            if (renderFleetOverlayWrite(destinationNow, { ...pending.write, lowerOverrides: lower.overrides }) === reviewed)
                 return null;
         }
         catch (error) {
             return error.message;
         }
-        return `stale preview — the user overlay ${userPath} or a lower config layer changed after the review diff was rendered; press w to review what would be written now`;
+        return `stale preview — the overlay ${pending.path} or a lower config layer changed after the review diff was rendered; press w to review what would be written now`;
     };
     // B2: a saved user key the repository overlay also decides does not apply in THIS repository —
     // each is named with the value that still applies here, never reported as applied.
     const repoShadowNotes = (before, after) => repoShadowedUserKeys(cwd, before, after, { globalDir }).map(({ path, value }) => {
         const shown = value === undefined ? "absent" : typeof value === "string" ? value : JSON.stringify(value);
-        return `repo-shadowed: ${path} stays ${shown} in this repository — ${repoOverlayPath(cwd)} sets it above the user overlay`;
+        return `repo-shadowed: ${path} stays ${shown} in this repository — ${repoPath} sets it above the user overlay`;
     });
     const reviewOverlay = (state) => {
         // B2: a review re-reads every layer, so no preview rendered before it is served after it
@@ -914,10 +1121,7 @@ export async function assembleFleetEditor(cwd, adapters, io, opts) {
         reviewedStage = metadata;
         // This callback is the sole candidate-overlay builder. The Ink component renders
         // the diff and asks for confirmation, but owns neither filesystem access nor a writer.
-        // B2: defaults/user/repo are re-read here, at review — the destination is the user overlay.
-        const before = currentUserText();
-        const repo = currentRepoOverlayText(cwd);
-        const path = userPath;
+        // B2: defaults/user/repo are re-read here, at review. T10: so is the destination.
         const modeChanged = state.selectedMode !== rm.mode.mode;
         const steeringChanged = ["review", "consult"].some((key) => JSON.stringify(state.steering[key]) !== JSON.stringify(initialSteering[key]));
         const judgeSeat = state.judgeSeat;
@@ -927,54 +1131,87 @@ export async function assembleFleetEditor(cwd, adapters, io, opts) {
             pendingWrite = null;
             return { kind: "empty" };
         }
-        const lower = lowerLayers();
+        const chosen = chooseDestination(destinationEdits(staged, metadata.seeds, [
+            ...(modeChanged ? ["routing.mode"] : []),
+            ...(steeringChanged ? ["review/consult prefer"] : []),
+            ...(judgeChanged ? ["judge"] : []),
+        ]));
+        if (!chosen.ok) {
+            pendingWrite = null;
+            return { kind: "refused", reason: chosen.reason };
+        }
+        const destination = chosen.destination;
+        const user = currentUserText();
+        const repo = currentRepoOverlayText(cwd);
+        const before = destination === "repo" ? repo : user;
+        const path = pathOf(destination);
+        const lower = lowerLayers(destination);
         if (lower.ok)
-            lowerOverrides = lower.overrides;
-        const write = userLayerWrite(staged, before, {
-            lowerOverrides,
-            ...(modeChanged ? { mode: state.selectedMode } : {}),
-            ...(judgeChanged && judgeSeat ? { judge: judgeSeat } : {}),
-            steering: { initial: initialSteering, edited: state.steering },
-        });
-        const after = renderFleetOverlayWrite(before, write);
+            lowerOverrides[destination] = lower.overrides;
+        let write;
+        let after;
+        try {
+            write = layerWrite(staged, metadata.seeds, destination, before, {
+                lowerOverrides: lowerOverrides[destination],
+                ...(modeChanged ? { mode: state.selectedMode } : {}),
+                ...(judgeChanged && judgeSeat ? { judge: judgeSeat } : {}),
+                steering: { initial: initialSteering, edited: state.steering },
+            });
+            after = renderFleetOverlayWrite(before, write); // T10 (D-987): a merge-key path refuses here
+        }
+        catch (error) {
+            if (!(error instanceof ConfigError))
+                throw error;
+            pendingWrite = null;
+            return { kind: "refused", reason: error.message };
+        }
         if (before === after) {
             pendingWrite = null;
             return { kind: "empty" };
         }
-        pendingWrite = { write, repo, user: before };
+        pendingWrite = { write, repo, user, destination, path };
         // OBS-1144: the review names every dead pool entry the written config carries, with its reason and
         // what still routes — before y. Unloadable bytes carry no notes: the reload guard refuses them anyway.
         let poolNotes = [];
         try {
-            const written = loadConfigWithMode(cwd, { globalDir, userOverlayText: after }).cfg;
+            const written = loadConfigWithMode(cwd, { globalDir, ...layerOf(destination, after) }).cfg;
             poolNotes = deadPoolEntries(written, undefined, health).map(deadPoolEntryLine);
         }
         catch {
             poolNotes = [];
         }
-        const notes = [...repoShadowNotes(before, after), ...(lower.ok ? [] : [`${lower.error} — y will be refused`]), ...poolNotes];
+        const notes = [
+            // T10: the review names where the edit lands and what that file is
+            ...(destination === "repo" ? [REPO_DESTINATION_NOTE(repoPath)] : repoShadowNotes(before, after)),
+            FUTURE_LOADS_NOTE,
+            ...(lower.ok ? [] : [`${lower.error} — y will be refused`]),
+            ...poolNotes,
+        ];
         return {
             kind: "diff",
             before,
             after,
             diff: unifiedYamlDiff(before, after, path),
             path,
-            ...(notes.length ? { notes } : {}),
+            notes,
         };
     };
     // B2: every repository inherits the user overlay, so its bytes must load here AND on their own —
-    // a tiers entry whose vendor/channel only this repository declares would break every other one
-    const loaderGuard = io.reloadGuard
+    // a tiers entry whose vendor/channel only this repository declares would break every other one.
+    // T10: repository bytes load through the same loader in the repository layer.
+    const loaderGuard = (destination) => io.reloadGuard
         ?? ((bytes) => {
+            if (destination === "repo")
+                return overlayBytesLoadError(cwd, bytes, { globalDir, layer: "repo" });
             const here = overlayBytesLoadError(cwd, bytes, { globalDir, layer: "user" });
             if (here !== null)
                 return here;
             const alone = overlayBytesLoadError(cwd, bytes, { globalDir, layer: "user", repoOverlayText: "" });
             return alone === null ? null
-                : `the user overlay ${userPath} loads only beside ${repoOverlayPath(cwd)} — every repository inherits it, and without that overlay it fails: ${alone}`;
+                : `the user overlay ${userPath} loads only beside ${repoPath} — every repository inherits it, and without that overlay it fails: ${alone}`;
         });
     // OBS-1188: a stale preview or an unreadable lower layer answers on the same error channel as the loader
-    const reloadGuard = (bytes) => (pendingWrite && stalePreview(pendingWrite, bytes)) || loaderGuard(bytes);
+    const reloadGuard = (bytes) => (pendingWrite && stalePreview(pendingWrite, bytes)) || loaderGuard(pendingWrite?.destination ?? "user")(bytes);
     const props = {
         ageMs: doctorAgeMs(cwd),
         adapters,
@@ -999,6 +1236,7 @@ export async function assembleFleetEditor(cwd, adapters, io, opts) {
         reviewOverlay,
         reloadGuard,
         stagedRouting,
+        holderOf,
         entry: opts.entry,
         initialJudge,
         judgeSeats: seats,
@@ -1024,12 +1262,12 @@ export async function assembleFleetEditor(cwd, adapters, io, opts) {
             throw new Error("fleet write reached confirmation without a staged overlay mutation");
         const write = pending.write;
         // OBS-1188: re-checked against the bytes on disk at write time; a refusal throws before the temp file exists.
-        // B2: the one destination is the user overlay, and bytes the loader refuses never land there either.
+        // T10: the one destination is the one the review confirmed, and bytes the loader refuses never land there.
         try {
-            writeFleetOverlay(userPath, (prior) => {
-                const refusal = result.review.path === userPath
-                    ? stalePreview(pending, result.review.after, prior) ?? loaderGuard(result.review.after)
-                    : `the reviewed destination ${result.review.path} is not the user overlay ${userPath}`;
+            writeFleetOverlay(pending.path, (prior) => {
+                const refusal = result.review.path === pending.path
+                    ? stalePreview(pending, result.review.after, prior) ?? loaderGuard(pending.destination)(result.review.after)
+                    : `the reviewed destination ${result.review.path} is not the staged destination ${pending.path}`;
                 if (refusal !== null)
                     throw new ConfigError(refusal);
                 return result.review.after;
@@ -1055,7 +1293,9 @@ export async function assembleFleetEditor(cwd, adapters, io, opts) {
             }
         }
         // B2: a repo-shadowed save says what still applies here — never claimed applied
-        const head = [`fleet: wrote ${userPath}`, ...repoShadowNotes(result.review.before, result.review.after).map((note) => `fleet: ${note}`)].join("\n");
+        const head = [`fleet: wrote ${pending.path}`, ...(pending.destination === "user"
+                ? repoShadowNotes(result.review.before, result.review.after).map((note) => `fleet: ${note}`)
+                : [])].join("\n");
         if (!unprobed.length)
             return head;
         const named = unprobed.slice(0, 3).join(", ") + (unprobed.length > 3 ? `, +${unprobed.length - 3} more` : "");

package/dist/cli/commands/init.js

@@ -639,7 +639,8 @@ export async function init(argv, cwd = process.cwd(), io = {}) {
     const interactive = input.isTTY === true && output.isTTY === true && !(values.yes ?? false);
     // Act 1 — preferences. Only when the repo config does not exist yet: init never rewrites an
     // operator's config; re-tuning is `tickmarkr fleet` (act 3 below still runs). Act 1 writes only
-    // project execution preferences; model choices are act 3's, saved to the USER overlay (B2).
+    // project execution preferences; model choices are act 3's, saved by Fleet's one destination rule:
+    // the USER overlay (B2), except a membership edit the repo overlay holds (T10).
     if (!repoConfigExists) {
         if (interactive) {
             emitBanner();
@@ -677,7 +678,9 @@ export async function init(argv, cwd = process.cwd(), io = {}) {
     // Act 3 — fleet. The compact discovery surface prints BETWEEN the acts so the operator reads
     // what the fleet browser (and its presets overlay, raised on the first Shapes entry) ranks
     // with; the final summary then carries a pointer, not a repeat. Its confirmation is the shared
-    // Fleet actuator's: the reviewed choices land in the user overlay (gdir), never the repo's.
+    // Fleet actuator's: a preset (routing.mode) lands in the user overlay (gdir), and so does every
+    // choice except a routing.allow/deny membership edit this repo overlay holds — T10 writes that one
+    // where it is effective, and the review names the destination before y.
     if (interactive) {
         output.write(`${doc}\n`);
         doc = "discovery shown above — full matrix any time with `tickmarkr doctor`";