role-os 2.3.1 → 2.5.0

package/src/artifacts.mjs

@@ -1,647 +1,693 @@
-/**
- * Artifact Spine — Phase Q (v1.6.0)
- *
- * Every important role produces a declared artifact with a known shape.
- * Downstream roles never guess what they received.
- *
- * 1. Per-role artifact contracts (required sections, evidence, references)
- * 2. Structural validation (completeness, not semantic perfection)
- * 3. Pack-level handoff contracts (expected artifact flow between steps)
- * 4. Composite artifact ledger integration
- */
-
-// ── Per-role artifact contracts ───────────────────────────────────────────────
-
-/**
- * Each contract defines what a role MUST produce for its handoff to be valid.
- * Not every role needs a contract — only chain-critical roles that hand off
- * to other roles.
- */
-export const ROLE_ARTIFACT_CONTRACTS = {
-  "Product Strategist": {
-    artifactType: "strategy-brief",
-    requiredSections: ["problem-framing", "scope", "non-goals", "tradeoffs"],
-    optionalSections: ["user-value", "risks", "success-criteria"],
-    requiredEvidence: [],
-    consumedBy: ["Spec Writer", "Orchestrator"],
-    completionRule: "All 4 required sections must be present and non-empty.",
-  },
-  "Spec Writer": {
-    artifactType: "implementation-spec",
-    requiredSections: ["acceptance-criteria", "edge-cases", "interface-spec"],
-    optionalSections: ["data-schema", "nfrs", "open-questions"],
-    requiredEvidence: ["strategy-brief"],
-    consumedBy: ["Backend Engineer", "Frontend Developer"],
-    completionRule: "At least 3 acceptance criteria. Edge cases identified. Interface shape defined.",
-  },
-  "Backend Engineer": {
-    artifactType: "change-plan",
-    requiredSections: ["files-to-change", "implementation-approach", "risk-notes"],
-    optionalSections: ["test-strategy", "migration-notes"],
-    requiredEvidence: ["implementation-spec"],
-    consumedBy: ["Test Engineer", "Critic Reviewer"],
-    completionRule: "Files named. Approach described. Risks surfaced.",
-  },
-  "Frontend Developer": {
-    artifactType: "change-plan",
-    requiredSections: ["files-to-change", "implementation-approach", "risk-notes"],
-    optionalSections: ["component-structure", "accessibility-notes"],
-    requiredEvidence: ["implementation-spec"],
-    consumedBy: ["Test Engineer", "Critic Reviewer"],
-    completionRule: "Files named. Approach described. Risks surfaced.",
-  },
-  "Test Engineer": {
-    artifactType: "test-package",
-    requiredSections: ["test-plan", "test-cases", "false-confidence-assessment"],
-    optionalSections: ["edge-case-coverage", "regression-defense"],
-    requiredEvidence: ["change-plan"],
-    consumedBy: ["Critic Reviewer"],
-    completionRule: "Test plan present. At least 3 test cases. False confidence assessment honest.",
-  },
-  "Security Reviewer": {
-    artifactType: "security-findings",
-    requiredSections: ["findings", "severity-assessment", "recommendations"],
-    optionalSections: ["threat-model", "exploitation-scenarios"],
-    requiredEvidence: ["change-plan"],
-    consumedBy: ["Backend Engineer", "Critic Reviewer"],
-    completionRule: "Each finding has severity + recommendation. No finding without remediation path.",
-  },
-  "Coverage Auditor": {
-    artifactType: "coverage-report",
-    requiredSections: ["well-defended", "poorly-defended", "false-confidence", "priority-recommendations"],
-    optionalSections: ["missing-defenses", "regression-vectors"],
-    requiredEvidence: [],
-    consumedBy: ["Test Engineer", "Critic Reviewer"],
-    completionRule: "Coverage honestly assessed. False confidence identified. Priorities ranked.",
-  },
-  "Docs Architect": {
-    artifactType: "doc-map",
-    requiredSections: ["page-structure", "content-gaps", "navigation-design"],
-    optionalSections: ["getting-started-flow", "search-requirements"],
-    requiredEvidence: [],
-    consumedBy: ["Metadata Curator", "Release Engineer"],
-    completionRule: "Pages listed. Gaps identified. Navigation designed.",
-  },
-  "Launch Strategist": {
-    artifactType: "launch-brief",
-    requiredSections: ["launch-sequence", "proof-packaging", "channel-selection", "success-criteria"],
-    optionalSections: ["risk-assessment", "what-not-to-say"],
-    requiredEvidence: [],
-    consumedBy: ["Launch Copywriter"],
-    completionRule: "Sequence defined. Proof mapped. Channels selected. Success measurable.",
-  },
-  "Launch Copywriter": {
-    artifactType: "copy-package",
-    requiredSections: ["release-notes", "short-announcement"],
-    optionalSections: ["npm-description", "social-variants", "messaging-angle"],
-    requiredEvidence: ["launch-brief"],
-    consumedBy: ["Critic Reviewer"],
-    completionRule: "Release notes present. At least one announcement variant.",
-  },
-  "Repo Researcher": {
-    artifactType: "repo-map",
-    requiredSections: ["entrypoints", "module-map", "build-test-commands"],
-    optionalSections: ["seams", "dependencies"],
-    requiredEvidence: [],
-    consumedBy: ["Backend Engineer", "Coverage Auditor", "Security Reviewer"],
-    completionRule: "Entrypoints listed. Module responsibilities described. Commands documented.",
-  },
-  "Dependency Auditor": {
-    artifactType: "dependency-audit",
-    requiredSections: ["vulnerability-summary", "outdated-inventory"],
-    optionalSections: ["supply-chain-risks", "update-recommendations", "license-audit"],
-    requiredEvidence: [],
-    consumedBy: ["Critic Reviewer", "Security Reviewer"],
-    completionRule: "Vulnerabilities triaged. Outdated deps inventoried with severity.",
-  },
-  "Metadata Curator": {
-    artifactType: "metadata-audit",
-    requiredSections: ["manifest-audit", "registry-alignment"],
-    optionalSections: ["badge-verification", "discovery-surface", "recommendations"],
-    requiredEvidence: [],
-    consumedBy: ["Release Engineer"],
-    completionRule: "Package.json audited. Registry alignment checked.",
-  },
-  "Release Engineer": {
-    artifactType: "release-plan",
-    requiredSections: ["version-decision", "changelog-draft", "pre-publish-checklist"],
-    optionalSections: ["packaging-check", "release-steps"],
-    requiredEvidence: [],
-    consumedBy: ["Deployment Verifier", "Critic Reviewer"],
-    completionRule: "Version decided with rationale. Changelog written. Checklist present.",
-  },
-  "Deployment Verifier": {
-    artifactType: "deployment-report",
-    requiredSections: ["live-state-assessment"],
-    optionalSections: ["npm-verification", "github-verification", "badge-verification", "translation-check"],
-    requiredEvidence: [],
-    consumedBy: ["Critic Reviewer"],
-    completionRule: "All deployed surfaces checked. Stale/mismatched items named.",
-  },
-  "Critic Reviewer": {
-    artifactType: "verdict",
-    requiredSections: ["verdict", "evidence", "required-corrections"],
-    optionalSections: ["notes", "next-owner", "chain-assessment"],
-    requiredEvidence: [],
-    consumedBy: [],
-    completionRule: "Verdict stated. Evidence cited. Corrections listed if not accept.",
-  },
-  "UX Researcher": {
-    artifactType: "ux-evaluation",
-    requiredSections: ["friction-inventory", "severity-ranking", "recommendations"],
-    optionalSections: ["flow-analysis", "heuristic-evaluation"],
-    requiredEvidence: [],
-    consumedBy: ["Product Strategist", "UI Designer"],
-    completionRule: "Friction points identified. Severity ranked. Evidence-based recommendations.",
-  },
-  "Competitive Analyst": {
-    artifactType: "landscape-analysis",
-    requiredSections: ["competitor-inventory", "differentiation", "honest-disadvantages"],
-    optionalSections: ["positioning-gaps", "recommendations"],
-    requiredEvidence: [],
-    consumedBy: ["Product Strategist"],
-    completionRule: "Competitors listed. Differentiation clear. Disadvantages honest.",
-  },
-  "Feedback Synthesizer": {
-    artifactType: "signal-synthesis",
-    requiredSections: ["theme-extraction", "theme-ranking", "confidence-assessment"],
-    optionalSections: ["contradictions", "complaint-to-action"],
-    requiredEvidence: [],
-    consumedBy: ["Product Strategist"],
-    completionRule: "Themes extracted. Ranking justified. Confidence assessed.",
-  },
-  "Refactor Engineer": {
-    artifactType: "refactor-plan",
-    requiredSections: ["structural-assessment", "module-boundaries", "migration-path"],
-    optionalSections: ["duplication-inventory", "proposed-structure"],
-    requiredEvidence: [],
-    consumedBy: ["Test Engineer", "Critic Reviewer"],
-    completionRule: "Current structure assessed. Target boundaries defined. Migration preserves tests.",
-  },
-  "Support Triage Lead": {
-    artifactType: "triage-report",
-    requiredSections: ["classification", "priority-assignment", "routing"],
-    optionalSections: ["recurring-patterns", "systemic-recommendations"],
-    requiredEvidence: [],
-    consumedBy: ["Feedback Synthesizer", "Docs Architect"],
-    completionRule: "Each item classified. Priority assigned. Route to owner named.",
-  },
-
-  // ── Brainstorm mission roles (v0.4) ─────────────────────────────────────────
-  //
-  // Layer 1: Truth — role-native schemas, provenance atoms, dispute graph
-  // Layer 2: Render — human-legible presentation (opt-in, never consumed by synthesis)
-  //
-  "Context Analyst": {
-    artifactType: "context-map",
-    requiredSections: ["terms", "category-map", "lineage-claims", "boundary-claims"],
-    optionalSections: [],
-    requiredEvidence: ["brainstorm-frame"],
-    consumedBy: ["Normalizer"],
-    completionRule: "3+ terms with adjacency. 2+ categories with examples. 1+ lineage claims with precedent. 1+ boundary claims. No forbidden phrases (blindspot enforced). Rendered as Boundary Memo (taxonomist voice).",
-  },
-  "User Value Analyst": {
-    artifactType: "user-value-map",
-    requiredSections: ["jobs", "frictions", "unmet-desires", "willingness-signals"],
-    optionalSections: [],
-    requiredEvidence: ["brainstorm-frame"],
-    consumedBy: ["Normalizer"],
-    completionRule: "2+ jobs (actor/situation/outcome). 2+ frictions with severity. 1+ unmet desires. 1+ willingness signals. No forbidden phrases (blindspot enforced). Rendered as Field Notes (ethnographer voice).",
-  },
-  "Mechanics Analyst": {
-    artifactType: "mechanics-map",
-    requiredSections: ["loops", "dependencies", "failure-points", "irreducible-mechanisms"],
-    optionalSections: [],
-    requiredEvidence: ["brainstorm-frame"],
-    consumedBy: ["Normalizer"],
-    completionRule: "1+ named loops (input/transform/output). 1+ dependencies. 1+ failure points. 1+ irreducible mechanisms. No forbidden phrases (blindspot enforced). Rendered as System Sketch (whiteboard voice).",
-  },
-  "Positioning Analyst": {
-    artifactType: "positioning-map",
-    requiredSections: ["substitutes", "wedge-candidates", "category-frame"],
-    optionalSections: ["forbidden-claims"],
-    requiredEvidence: ["brainstorm-frame"],
-    consumedBy: ["Normalizer"],
-    completionRule: "1+ substitutes (name/overlap/gap). 1+ wedge candidates (claim/timing/risk). Category frame as single declarative sentence. No forbidden phrases (blindspot enforced). Rendered as Claim Brief (strategist voice).",
-  },
-  "Contrarian Analyst": {
-    artifactType: "challenge-set",
-    requiredSections: ["challenges"],
-    optionalSections: [],
-    requiredEvidence: ["provenance-atoms"],
-    consumedBy: ["Normalizer"],
-    completionRule: "1+ challenges targeting specific atom IDs. Each has challenge_type, argument, evidence_grade, confidence. Only challenges permitted by cross-exam matrix accepted. Rendered as Cross-Exam Transcript (litigator voice).",
-  },
-  "Normalizer": {
-    artifactType: "provenance-atoms",
-    requiredSections: ["atoms", "conflicts", "stats"],
-    optionalSections: ["unsupported-high-confidence-flags", "rebuttal-set"],
-    requiredEvidence: ["context-map", "user-value-map", "mechanics-map", "positioning-map"],
-    consumedBy: ["Contrarian Analyst", "Synthesizer"],
-    completionRule: "Every atom carries source_role, source_artifact_type, claim_kind, allowed_challengers. No claim kinds overlap between roles. Rebuttal set: each original analyst defends/narrows/retracts challenged claims.",
-  },
-  "Synthesizer": {
-    artifactType: "synthesis-report",
-    requiredSections: ["topic-model", "major-themes", "advancing-directions", "archived-directions"],
-    optionalSections: ["tensions", "incubation-directions"],
-    requiredEvidence: ["provenance-atoms", "challenge-set", "rebuttal-set"],
-    consumedBy: ["Product Expander"],
-    completionRule: "Exactly breadth advancing directions. Each cites >= 2 truth-layer atoms (never rendered prose). Tensions reference dispute graph outcomes. Archived directions have reasons.",
-  },
-  "Product Expander": {
-    artifactType: "expanded-concept",
-    requiredSections: ["product-shape"],
-    optionalSections: ["scenarios", "moat"],
-    requiredEvidence: ["synthesis-report"],
-    consumedBy: ["Judge"],
-    completionRule: "Product shape has target_user, core_mechanism, features, core_loop, smallest_proof. Each concept maps to a synthesis direction.",
-  },
-  "Judge": {
-    artifactType: "judge-report",
-    requiredSections: ["disposition", "per-direction", "reasons"],
-    optionalSections: ["revision-targets", "revision-guidance"],
-    requiredEvidence: ["expanded-concept", "synthesis-report", "brainstorm-frame"],
-    consumedBy: [],
-    completionRule: "Disposition is accept/revise_expand/revise_synthesize/reject. Verdicts: ready_to_advance/needs_incubation/not_active_now. Actions: build_now/hold_for_followon/archive_but_retain. Revise requires targets.",
-  },
-
-  // ── Deep Audit ──
-  "Component Auditor": {
-    artifactType: "component-audit-report",
-    requiredSections: ["findings", "what-i-could-not-verify", "adjacent-parcel-risks", "parcel-statistics"],
-    optionalSections: [],
-    requiredEvidence: ["component-parcel-definition"],
-    consumedBy: ["Audit Synthesizer"],
-    completionRule: "Every file in owned paths read. Findings use standardized schema with severity, confidence, category, file, evidence, impact. Adjacent parcel risks are specific, not generic.",
-  },
-  "Seam Auditor": {
-    artifactType: "seam-audit-report",
-    requiredSections: ["findings", "false-independence-risks", "content-code-drift", "dependency-direction-assessment"],
-    optionalSections: [],
-    requiredEvidence: ["boundary-cluster-definition", "component-graph"],
-    consumedBy: ["Audit Synthesizer"],
-    completionRule: "Every declared boundary inspected. Findings reference both sides. Content-code drift quotes both content claim and code reality.",
-  },
-  "Test Truth Auditor": {
-    artifactType: "test-truth-report",
-    requiredSections: ["findings", "untested-but-risky", "ceremonial-tests", "integration-gaps", "test-suite-health-summary"],
-    optionalSections: [],
-    requiredEvidence: ["test-file-paths", "implementation-file-paths"],
-    consumedBy: ["Audit Synthesizer"],
-    completionRule: "Distinguishes 'line executed' from 'behavior verified'. Lists source files with no test. Estimates real coverage with reasoning.",
-  },
-  "Audit Synthesizer": {
-    artifactType: "audit-summary",
-    requiredSections: ["verdict", "posture", "by-the-numbers", "structurally-sound", "fragile", "dangerous", "dead-weight", "cross-cutting-findings", "contradictions", "audit-gaps"],
-    optionalSections: [],
-    requiredEvidence: ["component-audit-report", "seam-audit-report", "test-truth-report"],
-    consumedBy: ["Critic Reviewer"],
-    completionRule: "Reconciles findings across parcels. Cross-cutting findings reference source parcels. Contradictions adjudicated. Action plan groups by root cause and leverage.",
-  },
-
-  // ── Dogfood Swarm ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
-  "Swarm Coordinator": {
-    artifactType: "swarm-gate",
-    requiredSections: ["phase", "stage", "wave-count", "findings-summary", "severity-breakdown", "exit-condition-status", "decision"],
-    optionalSections: ["build-gate-results", "user-approval-status"],
-    requiredEvidence: ["wave-report"],
-    consumedBy: ["Swarm Backend Agent", "Swarm Bridge Agent", "Swarm Tests Agent", "Swarm Infra Agent", "Swarm Frontend Agent", "Swarm Synthesizer"],
-    completionRule: "Exit condition evaluated against accumulated findings. Decision is one of: loop (re-run wave), advance (next stage), or halt (max iterations or build gate failure).",
-  },
-  "Swarm Backend Agent": {
-    artifactType: "wave-report",
-    requiredSections: ["findings", "remediations", "files-touched", "build-status"],
-    optionalSections: ["architecture-notes"],
-    requiredEvidence: [],
-    consumedBy: ["Swarm Coordinator"],
-    completionRule: "Every file in assigned scope inspected. Findings severity-triaged. Remediations applied in severity order. Build passes after changes.",
-  },
-  "Swarm Bridge Agent": {
-    artifactType: "wave-report",
-    requiredSections: ["findings", "remediations", "files-touched", "build-status"],
-    optionalSections: ["integration-notes"],
-    requiredEvidence: [],
-    consumedBy: ["Swarm Coordinator"],
-    completionRule: "Every file in assigned scope inspected. Findings severity-triaged. Remediations applied in severity order. Build passes after changes.",
-  },
-  "Swarm Tests Agent": {
-    artifactType: "wave-report",
-    requiredSections: ["findings", "remediations", "files-touched", "build-status", "coverage-delta"],
-    optionalSections: ["test-health-notes"],
-    requiredEvidence: [],
-    consumedBy: ["Swarm Coordinator"],
-    completionRule: "Test suite audited for gaps, ceremonial tests, and fixture quality. Coverage delta reported. Build passes after changes.",
-  },
-  "Swarm Infra Agent": {
-    artifactType: "wave-report",
-    requiredSections: ["findings", "remediations", "files-touched", "build-status"],
-    optionalSections: ["ci-notes", "doc-freshness"],
-    requiredEvidence: [],
-    consumedBy: ["Swarm Coordinator"],
-    completionRule: "CI workflows, config files, and docs inspected. Findings severity-triaged. Build passes after changes.",
-  },
-  "Swarm Frontend Agent": {
-    artifactType: "wave-report",
-    requiredSections: ["findings", "remediations", "files-touched", "build-status", "accessibility-issues"],
-    optionalSections: ["ux-improvements", "responsive-notes"],
-    requiredEvidence: [],
-    consumedBy: ["Swarm Coordinator"],
-    completionRule: "UI layer audited for bugs, accessibility, and UX. Accessibility issues listed separately. Build passes after changes.",
-  },
-  "Swarm Synthesizer": {
-    artifactType: "swarm-final-report",
-    requiredSections: ["executive-summary", "stage-results", "total-findings-fixed", "remaining-items", "test-verification", "recommendation"],
-    optionalSections: ["metrics-comparison", "evidence-links"],
-    requiredEvidence: ["swarm-gate", "wave-report"],
-    consumedBy: ["Critic Reviewer"],
-    completionRule: "All stages summarized. Total findings fixed vs remaining tallied. Final test suite run. Recommendation is ship, hold, or re-swarm.",
-  },
-};
-
-// ── Artifact validation ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────
-
-/**
- * Validate an artifact against its role contract.
- * Checks structural completeness, not semantic quality.
- *
- * @param {string} roleName
- * @param {string} artifactContent - The artifact text
- * @returns {{ valid: boolean, missing: string[], warnings: string[], contract: object|null }}
- */
-export function validateArtifact(roleName, artifactContent) {
-  const contract = ROLE_ARTIFACT_CONTRACTS[roleName];
-  if (!contract) {
-    return { valid: true, missing: [], warnings: ["No artifact contract defined for this role."], contract: null };
-  }
-
-  const lower = artifactContent.toLowerCase();
-  const missing = [];
-  const warnings = [];
-
-  // Check required sections
-  for (const section of contract.requiredSections) {
-    // Look for the section as a heading or key phrase
-    const patterns = [
-      section.toLowerCase(),
-      section.replace(/-/g, " ").toLowerCase(),
-      `## ${section.replace(/-/g, " ")}`.toLowerCase(),
-      `### ${section.replace(/-/g, " ")}`.toLowerCase(),
-    ];
-    const found = patterns.some(p => lower.includes(p));
-    if (!found) {
-      missing.push(section);
-    }
-  }
-
-  // Check required evidence references
-  for (const evidence of contract.requiredEvidence) {
-    const patterns = [
-      evidence.toLowerCase(),
-      evidence.replace(/-/g, " ").toLowerCase(),
-    ];
-    const found = patterns.some(p => lower.includes(p));
-    if (!found) {
-      warnings.push(`Expected reference to "${evidence}" from upstream role.`);
-    }
-  }
-
-  // Check minimum content length (not just headers)
-  const contentLines = artifactContent.split("\n").filter(l => l.trim() && !l.trim().startsWith("#"));
-  if (contentLines.length < 5) {
-    warnings.push("Artifact appears thin — fewer than 5 content lines.");
-  }
-
-  return {
-    valid: missing.length === 0,
-    missing,
-    warnings,
-    contract,
-  };
-}
-
-// ── Pack-level handoff contracts ──────────────────────────────────────────────
-
-/**
- * Defines the expected artifact flow for each pack.
- * Each step produces an artifact that the next step consumes.
- */
-export const PACK_HANDOFF_CONTRACTS = {
-  feature: {
-    flow: [
-      { role: "Product Strategist", produces: "strategy-brief", consumedBy: "Spec Writer" },
-      { role: "Spec Writer", produces: "implementation-spec", consumedBy: "Backend Engineer" },
-      { role: "Backend Engineer", produces: "change-plan", consumedBy: "Test Engineer" },
-      { role: "Test Engineer", produces: "test-package", consumedBy: "Critic Reviewer" },
-      { role: "Critic Reviewer", produces: "verdict", consumedBy: null },
-    ],
-  },
-  bugfix: {
-    flow: [
-      { role: "Repo Researcher", produces: "repo-map", consumedBy: "Backend Engineer" },
-      { role: "Backend Engineer", produces: "change-plan", consumedBy: "Test Engineer" },
-      { role: "Test Engineer", produces: "test-package", consumedBy: "Critic Reviewer" },
-      { role: "Critic Reviewer", produces: "verdict", consumedBy: null },
-    ],
-  },
-  security: {
-    flow: [
-      { role: "Security Reviewer", produces: "security-findings", consumedBy: "Critic Reviewer" },
-      { role: "Dependency Auditor", produces: "dependency-audit", consumedBy: "Critic Reviewer" },
-      { role: "Critic Reviewer", produces: "verdict", consumedBy: null },
-    ],
-  },
-  docs: {
-    flow: [
-      { role: "Support Triage Lead", produces: "triage-report", consumedBy: "Feedback Synthesizer" },
-      { role: "Feedback Synthesizer", produces: "signal-synthesis", consumedBy: "Docs Architect" },
-      { role: "Docs Architect", produces: "doc-map", consumedBy: "Metadata Curator" },
-      { role: "Metadata Curator", produces: "metadata-audit", consumedBy: "Critic Reviewer" },
-      { role: "Critic Reviewer", produces: "verdict", consumedBy: null },
-    ],
-  },
-  launch: {
-    flow: [
-      { role: "Launch Strategist", produces: "launch-brief", consumedBy: "Launch Copywriter" },
-      { role: "Launch Copywriter", produces: "copy-package", consumedBy: "Critic Reviewer" },
-      { role: "Critic Reviewer", produces: "verdict", consumedBy: null },
-    ],
-  },
-  research: {
-    flow: [
-      { role: "Product Strategist", produces: "strategy-brief", consumedBy: "UX Researcher" },
-      { role: "UX Researcher", produces: "ux-evaluation", consumedBy: "Competitive Analyst" },
-      { role: "Competitive Analyst", produces: "landscape-analysis", consumedBy: "Feedback Synthesizer" },
-      { role: "Feedback Synthesizer", produces: "signal-synthesis", consumedBy: "Critic Reviewer" },
-      { role: "Critic Reviewer", produces: "verdict", consumedBy: null },
-    ],
-  },
-  brainstorm: {
-    flow: [
-      { role: "Context Scout",       produces: "scout-finding",          consumedBy: "Normalizer" },
-      { role: "User Value Scout",    produces: "scout-finding",          consumedBy: "Normalizer" },
-      { role: "Creative Leap Scout", produces: "scout-finding",          consumedBy: "Normalizer" },
-      { role: "Normalizer",          produces: "normalized-finding-set", consumedBy: "Synthesizer" },
-      { role: "Synthesizer",         produces: "synthesis-report",       consumedBy: "Product Expander" },
-      { role: "Product Expander",    produces: "expanded-concept",       consumedBy: "Judge" },
-      { role: "Judge",               produces: "judge-report",           consumedBy: null },
-    ],
-  },
-  treatment: {
-    flow: [
-      { role: "Repo Researcher", produces: "repo-map", consumedBy: "Security Reviewer" },
-      { role: "Security Reviewer", produces: "security-findings", consumedBy: "Coverage Auditor" },
-      { role: "Coverage Auditor", produces: "coverage-report", consumedBy: "Docs Architect" },
-      { role: "Docs Architect", produces: "doc-map", consumedBy: "Metadata Curator" },
-      { role: "Metadata Curator", produces: "metadata-audit", consumedBy: "Release Engineer" },
-      { role: "Release Engineer", produces: "release-plan", consumedBy: "Deployment Verifier" },
-      { role: "Deployment Verifier", produces: "deployment-report", consumedBy: "Critic Reviewer" },
-      { role: "Critic Reviewer", produces: "verdict", consumedBy: null },
-    ],
-  },
-  "deep-audit": {
-    flow: [
-      { role: "Component Auditor",  produces: "component-audit-report", consumedBy: "Audit Synthesizer" },
-      { role: "Test Truth Auditor", produces: "test-truth-report",      consumedBy: "Audit Synthesizer" },
-      { role: "Seam Auditor",       produces: "seam-audit-report",      consumedBy: "Audit Synthesizer" },
-      { role: "Audit Synthesizer",  produces: "audit-summary",          consumedBy: "Critic Reviewer" },
-      { role: "Critic Reviewer",    produces: "verdict",                consumedBy: null },
-    ],
-  },
-  swarm: {
-    flow: [
-      { role: "Swarm Coordinator",    produces: "swarm-gate",         consumedBy: "Swarm Backend Agent" },
-      { role: "Swarm Backend Agent",  produces: "wave-report",        consumedBy: "Swarm Coordinator" },
-      { role: "Swarm Bridge Agent",   produces: "wave-report",        consumedBy: "Swarm Coordinator" },
-      { role: "Swarm Tests Agent",    produces: "wave-report",        consumedBy: "Swarm Coordinator" },
-      { role: "Swarm Infra Agent",    produces: "wave-report",        consumedBy: "Swarm Coordinator" },
-      { role: "Swarm Frontend Agent", produces: "wave-report",        consumedBy: "Swarm Coordinator" },
-      { role: "Swarm Synthesizer",    produces: "swarm-final-report", consumedBy: "Critic Reviewer" },
-      { role: "Critic Reviewer",      produces: "verdict",            consumedBy: null },
-    ],
-  },
-};
-
-/**
- * Validate a pack's artifact chain — check that each step's output
- * matches what the next step expects.
- *
- * @param {string} packName
- * @param {Record<string, string>} artifacts - Map of role name → artifact content
- * @returns {{ valid: boolean, steps: object[] }}
- */
-export function validatePackChain(packName, artifacts) {
-  const contract = PACK_HANDOFF_CONTRACTS[packName];
-  if (!contract) {
-    return { valid: false, steps: [{ role: "unknown", status: "error", detail: `No handoff contract for pack "${packName}"` }] };
-  }
-
-  const steps = [];
-  let chainValid = true;
-
-  for (const step of contract.flow) {
-    const content = artifacts[step.role];
-    if (!content) {
-      steps.push({
-        role: step.role,
-        produces: step.produces,
-        status: "missing",
-        detail: `No artifact from ${step.role}.`,
-      });
-      chainValid = false;
-      continue;
-    }
-
-    const validation = validateArtifact(step.role, content);
-    steps.push({
-      role: step.role,
-      produces: step.produces,
-      status: validation.valid ? "valid" : "incomplete",
-      missing: validation.missing,
-      warnings: validation.warnings,
-      detail: validation.valid
-        ? `${step.produces} is structurally complete.`
-        : `Missing sections: ${validation.missing.join(", ")}`,
-    });
-
-    if (!validation.valid) chainValid = false;
-  }
-
-  return { valid: chainValid, steps };
-}
-
-/**
- * Get the artifact contract for a specific role.
- *
- * @param {string} roleName
- * @returns {object|null}
- */
-export function getArtifactContract(roleName) {
-  return ROLE_ARTIFACT_CONTRACTS[roleName] || null;
-}
-
-/**
- * Get the handoff contract for a specific pack.
- *
- * @param {string} packName
- * @returns {object|null}
- */
-export function getHandoffContract(packName) {
-  return PACK_HANDOFF_CONTRACTS[packName] || null;
-}
-
-/**
- * Format artifact validation result for display.
- *
- * @param {string} roleName
- * @param {object} validation
- * @returns {string}
- */
-export function formatArtifactValidation(roleName, validation) {
-  const lines = [`Artifact validation — ${roleName}`];
-
-  if (validation.valid) {
-    lines.push(`  ✓ Structurally complete`);
-  } else {
-    lines.push(`  ✗ Incomplete — missing: ${validation.missing.join(", ")}`);
-  }
-
-  if (validation.warnings.length > 0) {
-    for (const w of validation.warnings) {
-      lines.push(`  ! ${w}`);
-    }
-  }
-
-  if (validation.contract) {
-    lines.push(`  Contract: ${validation.contract.artifactType}`);
-    lines.push(`  Consumed by: ${validation.contract.consumedBy.join(", ") || "terminal"}`);
-  }
-
-  return lines.join("\n");
-}
-
-/**
- * Format pack chain validation for display.
- *
- * @param {string} packName
- * @param {object} chainValidation
- * @returns {string}
- */
-export function formatPackChain(packName, chainValidation) {
-  const lines = [
-    `\nPack Chain Validation — ${packName}`,
-    `─────────────────────────────────`,
-  ];
-
-  for (const step of chainValidation.steps) {
-    const icon = step.status === "valid" ? "✓" : step.status === "missing" ? "○" : "!";
-    lines.push(`  ${icon} ${step.role} → ${step.produces}: ${step.detail}`);
-  }
-
-  lines.push(``);
-  lines.push(chainValidation.valid
-    ? `Chain valid — all artifacts structurally complete.`
-    : `Chain incomplete — see above for missing artifacts.`
-  );
-
-  return lines.join("\n");
-}
+/**
+ * Artifact Spine — Phase Q (v1.6.0)
+ *
+ * Every important role produces a declared artifact with a known shape.
+ * Downstream roles never guess what they received.
+ *
+ * 1. Per-role artifact contracts (required sections, evidence, references)
+ * 2. Structural validation (completeness, not semantic perfection)
+ * 3. Pack-level handoff contracts (expected artifact flow between steps)
+ * 4. Composite artifact ledger integration
+ */
+
+// ── Per-role artifact contracts ───────────────────────────────────────────────
+
+/**
+ * Each contract defines what a role MUST produce for its handoff to be valid.
+ * Not every role needs a contract — only chain-critical roles that hand off
+ * to other roles.
+ */
+export const ROLE_ARTIFACT_CONTRACTS = {
+  "Product Strategist": {
+    artifactType: "strategy-brief",
+    requiredSections: ["problem-framing", "scope", "non-goals", "tradeoffs"],
+    optionalSections: ["user-value", "risks", "success-criteria"],
+    requiredEvidence: [],
+    consumedBy: ["Spec Writer", "Orchestrator"],
+    completionRule: "All 4 required sections must be present and non-empty.",
+  },
+  "Spec Writer": {
+    artifactType: "implementation-spec",
+    requiredSections: ["acceptance-criteria", "edge-cases", "interface-spec"],
+    optionalSections: ["data-schema", "nfrs", "open-questions"],
+    requiredEvidence: ["strategy-brief"],
+    consumedBy: ["Backend Engineer", "Frontend Developer"],
+    completionRule: "At least 3 acceptance criteria. Edge cases identified. Interface shape defined.",
+  },
+  "Backend Engineer": {
+    artifactType: "change-plan",
+    requiredSections: ["files-to-change", "implementation-approach", "risk-notes"],
+    optionalSections: ["test-strategy", "migration-notes"],
+    requiredEvidence: ["implementation-spec"],
+    consumedBy: ["Test Engineer", "Critic Reviewer"],
+    completionRule: "Files named. Approach described. Risks surfaced.",
+  },
+  "Frontend Developer": {
+    artifactType: "change-plan",
+    requiredSections: ["files-to-change", "implementation-approach", "risk-notes"],
+    optionalSections: ["component-structure", "accessibility-notes"],
+    requiredEvidence: ["implementation-spec"],
+    consumedBy: ["Test Engineer", "Critic Reviewer"],
+    completionRule: "Files named. Approach described. Risks surfaced.",
+  },
+  "Test Engineer": {
+    artifactType: "test-package",
+    requiredSections: ["test-plan", "test-cases", "false-confidence-assessment"],
+    optionalSections: ["edge-case-coverage", "regression-defense"],
+    requiredEvidence: ["change-plan"],
+    consumedBy: ["Critic Reviewer"],
+    completionRule: "Test plan present. At least 3 test cases. False confidence assessment honest.",
+  },
+  "Security Reviewer": {
+    artifactType: "security-findings",
+    requiredSections: ["findings", "severity-assessment", "recommendations"],
+    optionalSections: ["threat-model", "exploitation-scenarios"],
+    requiredEvidence: ["change-plan"],
+    consumedBy: ["Backend Engineer", "Critic Reviewer"],
+    completionRule: "Each finding has severity + recommendation. No finding without remediation path.",
+  },
+  "Coverage Auditor": {
+    artifactType: "coverage-report",
+    requiredSections: ["well-defended", "poorly-defended", "false-confidence", "priority-recommendations"],
+    optionalSections: ["missing-defenses", "regression-vectors"],
+    requiredEvidence: [],
+    consumedBy: ["Test Engineer", "Critic Reviewer"],
+    completionRule: "Coverage honestly assessed. False confidence identified. Priorities ranked.",
+  },
+  "Docs Architect": {
+    artifactType: "doc-map",
+    requiredSections: ["page-structure", "content-gaps", "navigation-design"],
+    optionalSections: ["getting-started-flow", "search-requirements"],
+    requiredEvidence: [],
+    consumedBy: ["Metadata Curator", "Release Engineer"],
+    completionRule: "Pages listed. Gaps identified. Navigation designed.",
+  },
+  "Launch Strategist": {
+    artifactType: "launch-brief",
+    requiredSections: ["launch-sequence", "proof-packaging", "channel-selection", "success-criteria"],
+    optionalSections: ["risk-assessment", "what-not-to-say"],
+    requiredEvidence: [],
+    consumedBy: ["Launch Copywriter"],
+    completionRule: "Sequence defined. Proof mapped. Channels selected. Success measurable.",
+  },
+  "Launch Copywriter": {
+    artifactType: "copy-package",
+    requiredSections: ["release-notes", "short-announcement"],
+    optionalSections: ["npm-description", "social-variants", "messaging-angle"],
+    requiredEvidence: ["launch-brief"],
+    consumedBy: ["Critic Reviewer"],
+    completionRule: "Release notes present. At least one announcement variant.",
+  },
+  "Repo Researcher": {
+    artifactType: "repo-map",
+    requiredSections: ["entrypoints", "module-map", "build-test-commands"],
+    optionalSections: ["seams", "dependencies"],
+    requiredEvidence: [],
+    consumedBy: ["Backend Engineer", "Coverage Auditor", "Security Reviewer"],
+    completionRule: "Entrypoints listed. Module responsibilities described. Commands documented.",
+  },
+  "Dependency Auditor": {
+    artifactType: "dependency-audit",
+    requiredSections: ["vulnerability-summary", "outdated-inventory"],
+    optionalSections: ["supply-chain-risks", "update-recommendations", "license-audit"],
+    requiredEvidence: [],
+    consumedBy: ["Critic Reviewer", "Security Reviewer"],
+    completionRule: "Vulnerabilities triaged. Outdated deps inventoried with severity.",
+  },
+  "Metadata Curator": {
+    artifactType: "metadata-audit",
+    requiredSections: ["manifest-audit", "registry-alignment"],
+    optionalSections: ["badge-verification", "discovery-surface", "recommendations"],
+    requiredEvidence: [],
+    consumedBy: ["Release Engineer"],
+    completionRule: "Package.json audited. Registry alignment checked.",
+  },
+  "Release Engineer": {
+    artifactType: "release-plan",
+    requiredSections: ["version-decision", "changelog-draft", "pre-publish-checklist"],
+    optionalSections: ["packaging-check", "release-steps"],
+    requiredEvidence: [],
+    consumedBy: ["Deployment Verifier", "Critic Reviewer"],
+    completionRule: "Version decided with rationale. Changelog written. Checklist present.",
+  },
+  "Deployment Verifier": {
+    artifactType: "deployment-report",
+    requiredSections: ["live-state-assessment"],
+    optionalSections: ["npm-verification", "github-verification", "badge-verification", "translation-check"],
+    requiredEvidence: [],
+    consumedBy: ["Critic Reviewer"],
+    completionRule: "All deployed surfaces checked. Stale/mismatched items named.",
+  },
+  "Critic Reviewer": {
+    artifactType: "verdict",
+    requiredSections: ["verdict", "evidence", "required-corrections"],
+    optionalSections: ["notes", "next-owner", "chain-assessment"],
+    requiredEvidence: [],
+    consumedBy: [],
+    completionRule: "Verdict stated. Evidence cited. Corrections listed if not accept.",
+  },
+  "UX Researcher": {
+    artifactType: "ux-evaluation",
+    requiredSections: ["friction-inventory", "severity-ranking", "recommendations"],
+    optionalSections: ["flow-analysis", "heuristic-evaluation"],
+    requiredEvidence: [],
+    consumedBy: ["Product Strategist", "UI Designer"],
+    completionRule: "Friction points identified. Severity ranked. Evidence-based recommendations.",
+  },
+  "Competitive Analyst": {
+    artifactType: "landscape-analysis",
+    requiredSections: ["competitor-inventory", "differentiation", "honest-disadvantages"],
+    optionalSections: ["positioning-gaps", "recommendations"],
+    requiredEvidence: [],
+    consumedBy: ["Product Strategist"],
+    completionRule: "Competitors listed. Differentiation clear. Disadvantages honest.",
+  },
+  "Feedback Synthesizer": {
+    artifactType: "signal-synthesis",
+    requiredSections: ["theme-extraction", "theme-ranking", "confidence-assessment"],
+    optionalSections: ["contradictions", "complaint-to-action"],
+    requiredEvidence: [],
+    consumedBy: ["Product Strategist"],
+    completionRule: "Themes extracted. Ranking justified. Confidence assessed.",
+  },
+  "Refactor Engineer": {
+    artifactType: "refactor-plan",
+    requiredSections: ["structural-assessment", "module-boundaries", "migration-path"],
+    optionalSections: ["duplication-inventory", "proposed-structure"],
+    requiredEvidence: [],
+    consumedBy: ["Test Engineer", "Critic Reviewer"],
+    completionRule: "Current structure assessed. Target boundaries defined. Migration preserves tests.",
+  },
+  "Support Triage Lead": {
+    artifactType: "triage-report",
+    requiredSections: ["classification", "priority-assignment", "routing"],
+    optionalSections: ["recurring-patterns", "systemic-recommendations"],
+    requiredEvidence: [],
+    consumedBy: ["Feedback Synthesizer", "Docs Architect"],
+    completionRule: "Each item classified. Priority assigned. Route to owner named.",
+  },
+  "Red-Teamer": {
+    artifactType: "red-team-report",
+    requiredSections: [
+      "subject-under-test",
+      "attack-vectors",
+      "attempted-violations",
+      "catch-rate",
+      "uncaught-breaks",
+      "recommendations",
+    ],
+    optionalSections: ["attack-taxonomy", "severity-ranking", "diff-from-prior-run"],
+    requiredEvidence: [],
+    consumedBy: ["Critic Reviewer"],
+    completionRule:
+      "Subject under test named. At least 5 attack vectors across 4+ categories. Catch rate computed (caught/attempted). Uncaught breaks itemized with severity and minimal reproduction. Pipelines rejecting 0/N attacks flagged as suspect (probably untested rather than hardened).",
+  },
+  "Caption Auditor": {
+    artifactType: "caption-audit",
+    requiredSections: [
+      "dataset-scope",
+      "rule-compliance-summary",
+      "violations",
+      "sampling-strategy",
+      "recommendations",
+    ],
+    optionalSections: ["strategy-distribution", "trigger-inventory", "duplicate-inventory"],
+    requiredEvidence: [],
+    consumedBy: ["Critic Reviewer"],
+    completionRule:
+      "Dataset scope named with manifest/path + record count + caption strategy in force. Per-rule compliance rate computed across declared sample. Each violation cites rule, record id, and minimal caption evidence. Sampling strategy declared (full | N-sampled | stratified) for reproducibility. Recommendations tied to specific rule violations and priority-ranked. Refuses to PASS if 100% compliance with sample size < 5.",
+  },
+  "Monster Taxonomy Verifier": {
+    artifactType: "taxonomy-audit",
+    requiredSections: [
+      "entries-audited",
+      "schema-compliance",
+      "missing-fields",
+      "lora-separability-assessment",
+      "recommendations",
+    ],
+    optionalSections: ["lineage-coverage", "palette-consistency", "scale-distribution"],
+    requiredEvidence: [],
+    consumedBy: ["Critic Reviewer"],
+    completionRule:
+      "At least 5 entries audited (or all if fewer in scope). Schema compliance computed per required field with absolute counts and percentages. Missing fields enumerated per entry. LoRA-separability assessment declared explicitly (YES | NO | CONDITIONAL) with blockers named. Recommendations actionable. Entries declaring human_element: true in pure-monster scope are flagged as contamination risk.",
+  },
+
+  // ── Brainstorm mission roles (v0.4) ─────────────────────────────────────────
+  //
+  // Layer 1: Truth — role-native schemas, provenance atoms, dispute graph
+  // Layer 2: Render — human-legible presentation (opt-in, never consumed by synthesis)
+  //
+  "Context Analyst": {
+    artifactType: "context-map",
+    requiredSections: ["terms", "category-map", "lineage-claims", "boundary-claims"],
+    optionalSections: [],
+    requiredEvidence: ["brainstorm-frame"],
+    consumedBy: ["Normalizer"],
+    completionRule: "3+ terms with adjacency. 2+ categories with examples. 1+ lineage claims with precedent. 1+ boundary claims. No forbidden phrases (blindspot enforced). Rendered as Boundary Memo (taxonomist voice).",
+  },
+  "User Value Analyst": {
+    artifactType: "user-value-map",
+    requiredSections: ["jobs", "frictions", "unmet-desires", "willingness-signals"],
+    optionalSections: [],
+    requiredEvidence: ["brainstorm-frame"],
+    consumedBy: ["Normalizer"],
+    completionRule: "2+ jobs (actor/situation/outcome). 2+ frictions with severity. 1+ unmet desires. 1+ willingness signals. No forbidden phrases (blindspot enforced). Rendered as Field Notes (ethnographer voice).",
+  },
+  "Mechanics Analyst": {
+    artifactType: "mechanics-map",
+    requiredSections: ["loops", "dependencies", "failure-points", "irreducible-mechanisms"],
+    optionalSections: [],
+    requiredEvidence: ["brainstorm-frame"],
+    consumedBy: ["Normalizer"],
+    completionRule: "1+ named loops (input/transform/output). 1+ dependencies. 1+ failure points. 1+ irreducible mechanisms. No forbidden phrases (blindspot enforced). Rendered as System Sketch (whiteboard voice).",
+  },
+  "Positioning Analyst": {
+    artifactType: "positioning-map",
+    requiredSections: ["substitutes", "wedge-candidates", "category-frame"],
+    optionalSections: ["forbidden-claims"],
+    requiredEvidence: ["brainstorm-frame"],
+    consumedBy: ["Normalizer"],
+    completionRule: "1+ substitutes (name/overlap/gap). 1+ wedge candidates (claim/timing/risk). Category frame as single declarative sentence. No forbidden phrases (blindspot enforced). Rendered as Claim Brief (strategist voice).",
+  },
+  "Contrarian Analyst": {
+    artifactType: "challenge-set",
+    requiredSections: ["challenges"],
+    optionalSections: [],
+    requiredEvidence: ["provenance-atoms"],
+    consumedBy: ["Normalizer"],
+    completionRule: "1+ challenges targeting specific atom IDs. Each has challenge_type, argument, evidence_grade, confidence. Only challenges permitted by cross-exam matrix accepted. Rendered as Cross-Exam Transcript (litigator voice).",
+  },
+  "Normalizer": {
+    artifactType: "provenance-atoms",
+    requiredSections: ["atoms", "conflicts", "stats"],
+    optionalSections: ["unsupported-high-confidence-flags", "rebuttal-set"],
+    requiredEvidence: ["context-map", "user-value-map", "mechanics-map", "positioning-map"],
+    consumedBy: ["Contrarian Analyst", "Synthesizer"],
+    completionRule: "Every atom carries source_role, source_artifact_type, claim_kind, allowed_challengers. No claim kinds overlap between roles. Rebuttal set: each original analyst defends/narrows/retracts challenged claims.",
+  },
+  "Synthesizer": {
+    artifactType: "synthesis-report",
+    requiredSections: ["topic-model", "major-themes", "advancing-directions", "archived-directions"],
+    optionalSections: ["tensions", "incubation-directions"],
+    requiredEvidence: ["provenance-atoms", "challenge-set", "rebuttal-set"],
+    consumedBy: ["Product Expander"],
+    completionRule: "Exactly breadth advancing directions. Each cites >= 2 truth-layer atoms (never rendered prose). Tensions reference dispute graph outcomes. Archived directions have reasons.",
+  },
+  "Product Expander": {
+    artifactType: "expanded-concept",
+    requiredSections: ["product-shape"],
+    optionalSections: ["scenarios", "moat"],
+    requiredEvidence: ["synthesis-report"],
+    consumedBy: ["Judge"],
+    completionRule: "Product shape has target_user, core_mechanism, features, core_loop, smallest_proof. Each concept maps to a synthesis direction.",
+  },
+  "Judge": {
+    artifactType: "judge-report",
+    requiredSections: ["disposition", "per-direction", "reasons"],
+    optionalSections: ["revision-targets", "revision-guidance"],
+    requiredEvidence: ["expanded-concept", "synthesis-report", "brainstorm-frame"],
+    consumedBy: [],
+    completionRule: "Disposition is accept/revise_expand/revise_synthesize/reject. Verdicts: ready_to_advance/needs_incubation/not_active_now. Actions: build_now/hold_for_followon/archive_but_retain. Revise requires targets.",
+  },
+
+  // ── Deep Audit ──
+  "Component Auditor": {
+    artifactType: "component-audit-report",
+    requiredSections: ["findings", "what-i-could-not-verify", "adjacent-parcel-risks", "parcel-statistics"],
+    optionalSections: [],
+    requiredEvidence: ["component-parcel-definition"],
+    consumedBy: ["Audit Synthesizer"],
+    completionRule: "Every file in owned paths read. Findings use standardized schema with severity, confidence, category, file, evidence, impact. Adjacent parcel risks are specific, not generic.",
+  },
+  "Seam Auditor": {
+    artifactType: "seam-audit-report",
+    requiredSections: ["findings", "false-independence-risks", "content-code-drift", "dependency-direction-assessment"],
+    optionalSections: [],
+    requiredEvidence: ["boundary-cluster-definition", "component-graph"],
+    consumedBy: ["Audit Synthesizer"],
+    completionRule: "Every declared boundary inspected. Findings reference both sides. Content-code drift quotes both content claim and code reality.",
+  },
+  "Test Truth Auditor": {
+    artifactType: "test-truth-report",
+    requiredSections: ["findings", "untested-but-risky", "ceremonial-tests", "integration-gaps", "test-suite-health-summary"],
+    optionalSections: [],
+    requiredEvidence: ["test-file-paths", "implementation-file-paths"],
+    consumedBy: ["Audit Synthesizer"],
+    completionRule: "Distinguishes 'line executed' from 'behavior verified'. Lists source files with no test. Estimates real coverage with reasoning.",
+  },
+  "Audit Synthesizer": {
+    artifactType: "audit-summary",
+    requiredSections: ["verdict", "posture", "by-the-numbers", "structurally-sound", "fragile", "dangerous", "dead-weight", "cross-cutting-findings", "contradictions", "audit-gaps"],
+    optionalSections: [],
+    requiredEvidence: ["component-audit-report", "seam-audit-report", "test-truth-report"],
+    consumedBy: ["Critic Reviewer"],
+    completionRule: "Reconciles findings across parcels. Cross-cutting findings reference source parcels. Contradictions adjudicated. Action plan groups by root cause and leverage.",
+  },
+
+  // ── Dogfood Swarm ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────────
+  "Swarm Coordinator": {
+    artifactType: "swarm-gate",
+    requiredSections: ["phase", "stage", "wave-count", "findings-summary", "severity-breakdown", "exit-condition-status", "decision"],
+    optionalSections: ["build-gate-results", "user-approval-status"],
+    requiredEvidence: ["wave-report"],
+    consumedBy: ["Swarm Backend Agent", "Swarm Bridge Agent", "Swarm Tests Agent", "Swarm Infra Agent", "Swarm Frontend Agent", "Swarm Synthesizer"],
+    completionRule: "Exit condition evaluated against accumulated findings. Decision is one of: loop (re-run wave), advance (next stage), or halt (max iterations or build gate failure).",
+  },
+  "Swarm Backend Agent": {
+    artifactType: "wave-report",
+    requiredSections: ["findings", "remediations", "files-touched", "build-status"],
+    optionalSections: ["architecture-notes"],
+    requiredEvidence: [],
+    consumedBy: ["Swarm Coordinator"],
+    completionRule: "Every file in assigned scope inspected. Findings severity-triaged. Remediations applied in severity order. Build passes after changes.",
+  },
+  "Swarm Bridge Agent": {
+    artifactType: "wave-report",
+    requiredSections: ["findings", "remediations", "files-touched", "build-status"],
+    optionalSections: ["integration-notes"],
+    requiredEvidence: [],
+    consumedBy: ["Swarm Coordinator"],
+    completionRule: "Every file in assigned scope inspected. Findings severity-triaged. Remediations applied in severity order. Build passes after changes.",
+  },
+  "Swarm Tests Agent": {
+    artifactType: "wave-report",
+    requiredSections: ["findings", "remediations", "files-touched", "build-status", "coverage-delta"],
+    optionalSections: ["test-health-notes"],
+    requiredEvidence: [],
+    consumedBy: ["Swarm Coordinator"],
+    completionRule: "Test suite audited for gaps, ceremonial tests, and fixture quality. Coverage delta reported. Build passes after changes.",
+  },
+  "Swarm Infra Agent": {
+    artifactType: "wave-report",
+    requiredSections: ["findings", "remediations", "files-touched", "build-status"],
+    optionalSections: ["ci-notes", "doc-freshness"],
+    requiredEvidence: [],
+    consumedBy: ["Swarm Coordinator"],
+    completionRule: "CI workflows, config files, and docs inspected. Findings severity-triaged. Build passes after changes.",
+  },
+  "Swarm Frontend Agent": {
+    artifactType: "wave-report",
+    requiredSections: ["findings", "remediations", "files-touched", "build-status", "accessibility-issues"],
+    optionalSections: ["ux-improvements", "responsive-notes"],
+    requiredEvidence: [],
+    consumedBy: ["Swarm Coordinator"],
+    completionRule: "UI layer audited for bugs, accessibility, and UX. Accessibility issues listed separately. Build passes after changes.",
+  },
+  "Swarm Synthesizer": {
+    artifactType: "swarm-final-report",
+    requiredSections: ["executive-summary", "stage-results", "total-findings-fixed", "remaining-items", "test-verification", "recommendation"],
+    optionalSections: ["metrics-comparison", "evidence-links"],
+    requiredEvidence: ["swarm-gate", "wave-report"],
+    consumedBy: ["Critic Reviewer"],
+    completionRule: "All stages summarized. Total findings fixed vs remaining tallied. Final test suite run. Recommendation is ship, hold, or re-swarm.",
+  },
+};
+
+// ── Artifact validation ───────────────────────────────────────────────────────
+
+/**
+ * Validate an artifact against its role contract.
+ * Checks structural completeness, not semantic quality.
+ *
+ * @param {string} roleName
+ * @param {string} artifactContent - The artifact text
+ * @returns {{ valid: boolean, missing: string[], warnings: string[], contract: object|null }}
+ */
+export function validateArtifact(roleName, artifactContent) {
+  const contract = ROLE_ARTIFACT_CONTRACTS[roleName];
+  if (!contract) {
+    return { valid: true, missing: [], warnings: ["No artifact contract defined for this role."], contract: null };
+  }
+
+  const lower = artifactContent.toLowerCase();
+  const missing = [];
+  const warnings = [];
+
+  // Check required sections
+  for (const section of contract.requiredSections) {
+    // Look for the section as a heading or key phrase
+    const patterns = [
+      section.toLowerCase(),
+      section.replace(/-/g, " ").toLowerCase(),
+      `## ${section.replace(/-/g, " ")}`.toLowerCase(),
+      `### ${section.replace(/-/g, " ")}`.toLowerCase(),
+    ];
+    const found = patterns.some(p => lower.includes(p));
+    if (!found) {
+      missing.push(section);
+    }
+  }
+
+  // Check required evidence references
+  for (const evidence of contract.requiredEvidence) {
+    const patterns = [
+      evidence.toLowerCase(),
+      evidence.replace(/-/g, " ").toLowerCase(),
+    ];
+    const found = patterns.some(p => lower.includes(p));
+    if (!found) {
+      warnings.push(`Expected reference to "${evidence}" from upstream role.`);
+    }
+  }
+
+  // Check minimum content length (not just headers)
+  const contentLines = artifactContent.split("\n").filter(l => l.trim() && !l.trim().startsWith("#"));
+  if (contentLines.length < 5) {
+    warnings.push("Artifact appears thin — fewer than 5 content lines.");
+  }
+
+  return {
+    valid: missing.length === 0,
+    missing,
+    warnings,
+    contract,
+  };
+}
+
+// ── Pack-level handoff contracts ──────────────────────────────────────────────
+
+/**
+ * Defines the expected artifact flow for each pack.
+ * Each step produces an artifact that the next step consumes.
+ */
+export const PACK_HANDOFF_CONTRACTS = {
+  feature: {
+    flow: [
+      { role: "Product Strategist", produces: "strategy-brief", consumedBy: "Spec Writer" },
+      { role: "Spec Writer", produces: "implementation-spec", consumedBy: "Backend Engineer" },
+      { role: "Backend Engineer", produces: "change-plan", consumedBy: "Test Engineer" },
+      { role: "Test Engineer", produces: "test-package", consumedBy: "Critic Reviewer" },
+      { role: "Critic Reviewer", produces: "verdict", consumedBy: null },
+    ],
+  },
+  bugfix: {
+    flow: [
+      { role: "Repo Researcher", produces: "repo-map", consumedBy: "Backend Engineer" },
+      { role: "Backend Engineer", produces: "change-plan", consumedBy: "Test Engineer" },
+      { role: "Test Engineer", produces: "test-package", consumedBy: "Critic Reviewer" },
+      { role: "Critic Reviewer", produces: "verdict", consumedBy: null },
+    ],
+  },
+  security: {
+    flow: [
+      { role: "Security Reviewer", produces: "security-findings", consumedBy: "Critic Reviewer" },
+      { role: "Dependency Auditor", produces: "dependency-audit", consumedBy: "Critic Reviewer" },
+      { role: "Critic Reviewer", produces: "verdict", consumedBy: null },
+    ],
+  },
+  docs: {
+    flow: [
+      { role: "Support Triage Lead", produces: "triage-report", consumedBy: "Feedback Synthesizer" },
+      { role: "Feedback Synthesizer", produces: "signal-synthesis", consumedBy: "Docs Architect" },
+      { role: "Docs Architect", produces: "doc-map", consumedBy: "Metadata Curator" },
+      { role: "Metadata Curator", produces: "metadata-audit", consumedBy: "Critic Reviewer" },
+      { role: "Critic Reviewer", produces: "verdict", consumedBy: null },
+    ],
+  },
+  launch: {
+    flow: [
+      { role: "Launch Strategist", produces: "launch-brief", consumedBy: "Launch Copywriter" },
+      { role: "Launch Copywriter", produces: "copy-package", consumedBy: "Critic Reviewer" },
+      { role: "Critic Reviewer", produces: "verdict", consumedBy: null },
+    ],
+  },
+  research: {
+    flow: [
+      { role: "Product Strategist", produces: "strategy-brief", consumedBy: "UX Researcher" },
+      { role: "UX Researcher", produces: "ux-evaluation", consumedBy: "Competitive Analyst" },
+      { role: "Competitive Analyst", produces: "landscape-analysis", consumedBy: "Feedback Synthesizer" },
+      { role: "Feedback Synthesizer", produces: "signal-synthesis", consumedBy: "Critic Reviewer" },
+      { role: "Critic Reviewer", produces: "verdict", consumedBy: null },
+    ],
+  },
+  brainstorm: {
+    flow: [
+      { role: "Context Scout",       produces: "scout-finding",          consumedBy: "Normalizer" },
+      { role: "User Value Scout",    produces: "scout-finding",          consumedBy: "Normalizer" },
+      { role: "Creative Leap Scout", produces: "scout-finding",          consumedBy: "Normalizer" },
+      { role: "Normalizer",          produces: "normalized-finding-set", consumedBy: "Synthesizer" },
+      { role: "Synthesizer",         produces: "synthesis-report",       consumedBy: "Product Expander" },
+      { role: "Product Expander",    produces: "expanded-concept",       consumedBy: "Judge" },
+      { role: "Judge",               produces: "judge-report",           consumedBy: null },
+    ],
+  },
+  treatment: {
+    flow: [
+      { role: "Repo Researcher", produces: "repo-map", consumedBy: "Security Reviewer" },
+      { role: "Security Reviewer", produces: "security-findings", consumedBy: "Coverage Auditor" },
+      { role: "Coverage Auditor", produces: "coverage-report", consumedBy: "Docs Architect" },
+      { role: "Docs Architect", produces: "doc-map", consumedBy: "Metadata Curator" },
+      { role: "Metadata Curator", produces: "metadata-audit", consumedBy: "Release Engineer" },
+      { role: "Release Engineer", produces: "release-plan", consumedBy: "Deployment Verifier" },
+      { role: "Deployment Verifier", produces: "deployment-report", consumedBy: "Critic Reviewer" },
+      { role: "Critic Reviewer", produces: "verdict", consumedBy: null },
+    ],
+  },
+  "deep-audit": {
+    flow: [
+      { role: "Component Auditor",  produces: "component-audit-report", consumedBy: "Audit Synthesizer" },
+      { role: "Test Truth Auditor", produces: "test-truth-report",      consumedBy: "Audit Synthesizer" },
+      { role: "Seam Auditor",       produces: "seam-audit-report",      consumedBy: "Audit Synthesizer" },
+      { role: "Audit Synthesizer",  produces: "audit-summary",          consumedBy: "Critic Reviewer" },
+      { role: "Critic Reviewer",    produces: "verdict",                consumedBy: null },
+    ],
+  },
+  swarm: {
+    flow: [
+      { role: "Swarm Coordinator",    produces: "swarm-gate",         consumedBy: "Swarm Backend Agent" },
+      { role: "Swarm Backend Agent",  produces: "wave-report",        consumedBy: "Swarm Coordinator" },
+      { role: "Swarm Bridge Agent",   produces: "wave-report",        consumedBy: "Swarm Coordinator" },
+      { role: "Swarm Tests Agent",    produces: "wave-report",        consumedBy: "Swarm Coordinator" },
+      { role: "Swarm Infra Agent",    produces: "wave-report",        consumedBy: "Swarm Coordinator" },
+      { role: "Swarm Frontend Agent", produces: "wave-report",        consumedBy: "Swarm Coordinator" },
+      { role: "Swarm Synthesizer",    produces: "swarm-final-report", consumedBy: "Critic Reviewer" },
+      { role: "Critic Reviewer",      produces: "verdict",            consumedBy: null },
+    ],
+  },
+};
+
+/**
+ * Validate a pack's artifact chain — check that each step's output
+ * matches what the next step expects.
+ *
+ * @param {string} packName
+ * @param {Record<string, string>} artifacts - Map of role name → artifact content
+ * @returns {{ valid: boolean, steps: object[] }}
+ */
+export function validatePackChain(packName, artifacts) {
+  const contract = PACK_HANDOFF_CONTRACTS[packName];
+  if (!contract) {
+    return { valid: false, steps: [{ role: "unknown", status: "error", detail: `No handoff contract for pack "${packName}"` }] };
+  }
+
+  const steps = [];
+  let chainValid = true;
+
+  for (const step of contract.flow) {
+    const content = artifacts[step.role];
+    if (!content) {
+      steps.push({
+        role: step.role,
+        produces: step.produces,
+        status: "missing",
+        detail: `No artifact from ${step.role}.`,
+      });
+      chainValid = false;
+      continue;
+    }
+
+    const validation = validateArtifact(step.role, content);
+    steps.push({
+      role: step.role,
+      produces: step.produces,
+      status: validation.valid ? "valid" : "incomplete",
+      missing: validation.missing,
+      warnings: validation.warnings,
+      detail: validation.valid
+        ? `${step.produces} is structurally complete.`
+        : `Missing sections: ${validation.missing.join(", ")}`,
+    });
+
+    if (!validation.valid) chainValid = false;
+  }
+
+  return { valid: chainValid, steps };
+}
+
+/**
+ * Get the artifact contract for a specific role.
+ *
+ * @param {string} roleName
+ * @returns {object|null}
+ */
+export function getArtifactContract(roleName) {
+  return ROLE_ARTIFACT_CONTRACTS[roleName] || null;
+}
+
+/**
+ * Get the handoff contract for a specific pack.
+ *
+ * @param {string} packName
+ * @returns {object|null}
+ */
+export function getHandoffContract(packName) {
+  return PACK_HANDOFF_CONTRACTS[packName] || null;
+}
+
+/**
+ * Format artifact validation result for display.
+ *
+ * @param {string} roleName
+ * @param {object} validation
+ * @returns {string}
+ */
+export function formatArtifactValidation(roleName, validation) {
+  const lines = [`Artifact validation — ${roleName}`];
+
+  if (validation.valid) {
+    lines.push(`  ✓ Structurally complete`);
+  } else {
+    lines.push(`  ✗ Incomplete — missing: ${validation.missing.join(", ")}`);
+  }
+
+  if (validation.warnings.length > 0) {
+    for (const w of validation.warnings) {
+      lines.push(`  ! ${w}`);
+    }
+  }
+
+  if (validation.contract) {
+    lines.push(`  Contract: ${validation.contract.artifactType}`);
+    lines.push(`  Consumed by: ${validation.contract.consumedBy.join(", ") || "terminal"}`);
+  }
+
+  return lines.join("\n");
+}
+
+/**
+ * Format pack chain validation for display.
+ *
+ * @param {string} packName
+ * @param {object} chainValidation
+ * @returns {string}
+ */
+export function formatPackChain(packName, chainValidation) {
+  const lines = [
+    `\nPack Chain Validation — ${packName}`,
+    `─────────────────────────────────`,
+  ];
+
+  for (const step of chainValidation.steps) {
+    const icon = step.status === "valid" ? "✓" : step.status === "missing" ? "○" : "!";
+    lines.push(`  ${icon} ${step.role} → ${step.produces}: ${step.detail}`);
+  }
+
+  lines.push(``);
+  lines.push(chainValidation.valid
+    ? `Chain valid — all artifacts structurally complete.`
+    : `Chain incomplete — see above for missing artifacts.`
+  );
+
+  return lines.join("\n");
+}