qa360 2.2.1 → 2.2.7

package/docs/ARCHITECTURE.md

@@ -1,901 +0,0 @@
-# QA360 Architecture Documentation
-
-**Version:** 1.4.5
-**Status:** Active (Phases 1-3 AI Integration Complete, F8 Smart Retry Complete)
-**Last Updated:** January 3, 2025
-
----
-
-## Overview
-
-QA360 is an industrial-grade, **AI-native** testing platform that transforms software quality assurance into **verifiable, signed, and traceable proofs**. The architecture prioritizes:
-
-- **Local-First Execution**: No cloud dependencies, full data sovereignty
-- **Cryptographic Verification**: Ed25519 signatures on all test results
-- **Evidence Preservation**: Immutable audit trails with SQLite WAL
-- **Conversational Testing**: Model Context Protocol (MCP) integration for LLM-native workflows
-- **Framework Agnostic**: Adapter-based design supporting any testing tool
-- **AI-Native**: Local test generation with Ollama (100% free, no API costs)
-
-### Architecture Philosophy
-
-**"Build once, trust forever, share everywhere."**
-
-QA360 follows a monorepo architecture with clear separation of concerns:
-- **Core**: Pure business logic, framework-agnostic
-- **CLI**: Human-friendly command-line interface
-- **MCP**: AI-friendly conversational interface
-- **Adapters**: Framework-specific integrations (Playwright, k6, ZAP, etc.)
-- **UI**: Future web/desktop interfaces (Phase 3)
-
----
-
-## Version Status
-
-| Component | Version | Status |
-|-----------|---------|--------|
-| **QA360 Platform** | 1.4.5 | Beta (AI Phases 1-3 complete) |
-| **Target Release** | 2.0.0 | Q1 2025 (AI-native) |
-| **CLI** | 1.4.5 | Stable |
-| **Core** | 1.4.5 | Stable |
-| **MCP** | 1.2.0 | Unified |
-
-### Stability Guarantees
-
-- ✅ **Core API**: Stable, breaking changes only in major versions
-- ✅ **CLI Commands**: Stable, backward-compatible additions
-- ✅ **MCP Tools**: 23 tools stable, protocol MCP 0.4.0
-- ⚠️ **Adapters**: Evolving, minor breaking changes possible
-- 🔮 **UI/API**: Future (Phase 3), no stability guarantees yet
-
----
-
-## Monorepo Structure
-
-```
-QA360/
-├── cli/                      # Command-line interface
-│   ├── src/
-│   │   ├── commands/         # Run, report, verify, serve, etc.
-│   │   └── index.ts          # CLI entrypoint
-│   └── package.json          # @qa360/cli v1.1.0
-│
-├── core/                     # Core business logic
-│   ├── src/
-│   │   ├── adapters/         # Framework adapters (Playwright, k6, ZAP, etc.)
-│   │   ├── ai/               # AI integration (OllamaProvider, TestDiscoverer)
-│   │   ├── auth/             # Authentication providers (9 providers)
-│   │   ├── pack-v2/          # Pack v2 validation & migration
-│   │   ├── proof/            # Proof generation & verification
-│   │   ├── vault/            # Evidence persistence (SQLite)
-│   │   ├── retry/            # F8 Smart Retry Module (Vision 2.0)
-│   │   ├── flakiness/        # Flakiness detection & scoring
-│   │   ├── security/         # Redaction, secrets management
-│   │   └── index.ts          # Public API
-│   └── package.json          # @qa360/core v1.4.5
-│
-├── packages/
-│   └── mcp/                  # Model Context Protocol integration
-│       ├── src/
-│       │   ├── cli/          # MCP CLI (init, up, doctor, fix, etc.)
-│       │   ├── server/       # Full MCP server (23 tools)
-│       │   ├── tools/        # Tool implementations
-│       │   └── security/     # Audit logging, permission system
-│       └── package.json      # @qa360/mcp v1.2.0 (UNIFIED)
-│
-├── adapters/                 # Standalone adapter implementations
-│   ├── playwright/           # Playwright E2E adapter
-│   ├── k6/                   # k6 performance adapter
-│   ├── semgrep/              # Semgrep SAST adapter
-│   ├── zap/                  # OWASP ZAP DAST adapter
-│   ├── trufflehog/           # TruffleHog secrets adapter
-│   └── gitleaks/             # Gitleaks secrets adapter
-│
-├── examples/
-│   ├── packs/                # Example test pack configurations
-│   ├── lovable/              # Lovable.dev integration (Supabase SSE)
-│   └── future-api/           # Phase 3 API placeholder (moved from /api)
-│
-├── ui/                       # Future UI components (Phase 3)
-│   └── web/                  # Web dashboard (planned)
-│
-├── tests/                    # Integration tests
-│   └── e2e/                  # End-to-end test suites
-│
-├── docs/                     # Documentation
-│   ├── ARCHITECTURE.md       # This file
-│   ├── api/                  # API documentation
-│   └── guides/               # User guides
-│
-├── package.json              # Root workspace config
-├── pnpm-workspace.yaml       # pnpm workspace definition
-└── tsconfig.json             # TypeScript configuration
-```
-
-**Total Packages:** 3 core + 6 adapters + 1 UI = **10 packages**
-
----
-
-## Core Packages
-
-### 1. CLI Package (`@qa360/cli`)
-
-**Version:** 1.1.0  
-**Path:** `/cli`  
-**Purpose:** Human-friendly command-line interface for QA360
-
-#### Key Commands
-
-| Command | Description |
-|---------|-------------|
-| `qa360 run` | Execute test pack with proof generation |
-| `qa360 report` | Generate HTML/PDF reports from proofs |
-| `qa360 verify` | Verify cryptographic signatures |
-| `qa360 history` | Query past test runs |
-| `qa360 serve` | Start observability HTTP server |
-| `qa360 doctor` | Health checks and diagnostics |
-| `qa360 pack` | Pack validation and migration |
-| `qa360 secrets` | Secure secrets management |
-
-#### Features
-
-- **Zero Config**: Auto-detection of project structure
-- **Rich Output**: Chalk-based colored terminal UI
-- **Spinner Feedback**: Ora spinners for long operations
-- **Error Handling**: Structured error codes (RUN###, VRF###, etc.)
-- **CI/CD Ready**: JSON output, exit codes, non-interactive mode
-
-#### Dependencies
-
-```json
-{
-  "commander": "^11.1.0",
-  "chalk": "^5.3.0",
-  "ora": "^8.0.1",
-  "inquirer": "^9.2.12"
-}
-```
-
----
-
-### 2. Core Package (`@qa360/core`)
-
-**Version:** 0.9.0-core  
-**Path:** `/core`  
-**Purpose:** Framework-agnostic business logic and proof system
-
-#### Architecture
-
-```
-@qa360/core
-├── QA360Core              # Main orchestrator
-├── ProofGenerator         # Proof creation & signing
-├── ProofVerifier          # Signature verification
-├── EvidenceVault          # SQLite persistence (WAL mode)
-├── AdapterRegistry        # Dynamic adapter loading
-└── SecurityRedactor       # PII/credential masking
-```
-
-#### Key Responsibilities
-
-1. **Test Orchestration**: Run packs through adapter pipeline
-2. **Proof Generation**: Ed25519 signatures on test results
-3. **Evidence Persistence**: Immutable SQLite storage with WAL
-4. **Adapter Management**: Dynamic loading of framework adapters
-5. **Security**: Redaction, secrets management, audit logging
-
-#### Public API
-
-```typescript
-import { QA360Core, Proof, PackConfig } from '@qa360/core';
-
-const core = new QA360Core();
-const proof: Proof = await core.run(packConfig, { runId });
-const valid: boolean = await core.verify(proof);
-```
-
-#### Database Schema
-
-- **runs**: Test execution metadata
-- **gates**: Gate results (api, ui, perf, a11y, sast, deps, secrets, dast)
-- **evidence**: Artifacts (screenshots, traces, logs)
-- **signatures**: Ed25519 signatures
-
----
-
-### AI Integration Modules
-
-#### 1. AI Module (`core/src/ai/`)
-
-**Status:** ✅ Phase 1 Complete (41 tests)
-
-**Components:**
-
-| File | Description | Tests |
-|------|-------------|-------|
-| `index.ts` | OllamaProvider, LLMProvider interface | 41 tests |
-| `OllamaProvider` | Ollama client with retry & timeout | - |
-| `LLMProvider` | Generic LLM provider interface | - |
-| `LLMResponse` | Type definitions for LLM responses | - |
-
-**Features:**
-- Local LLM inference via Ollama (100% free, no API costs)
-- Automatic retry with exponential backoff
-- Configurable timeout and model selection
-- Support for streaming responses
-
-**CLI Commands:**
-```bash
-qa360 ollama test              # Test Ollama connection
-qa360 ollama list              # List installed models
-qa360 ollama pull <model>      # Instructions to download model
-qa360 ollama generate <prompt> # Generate tests (preview)
-qa360 ollama config            # Show configuration
-```
-
-#### 2. Auth Module (`core/src/auth/`)
-
-**Status:** ✅ Phase 2 Complete (92 tests)
-
-**Providers (9 total):**
-
-| Provider | Type | Tests |
-|----------|------|-------|
-| `JwtProvider` | JWT Bearer tokens | 6 tests |
-| `OAuth2Provider` | OAuth2 Client Credentials | 6 tests |
-| `ApiKeyProvider` | API Key in header | 6 tests |
-| `BearerProvider` | Bearer token provider | 6 tests |
-| `BasicAuthProvider` | Basic auth | 5 tests |
-| `TotpProvider` | TOTP-based auth | 6 tests |
-| `UiLoginProvider` | UI form-based login | 5 tests |
-| `GcpAdcProvider` | GCP Application Default Credentials | 6 tests |
-| `AwsIamProvider` | AWS IAM credentials | 5 tests |
-| `AzureAdProvider` | Azure AD authentication | 5 tests |
-
-**Integration Tests:** 36 tests
-
-**Total Tests:** 92
-
-**Features:**
-- Support for standard authentication schemes (JWT, OAuth2, API Key, Bearer, Basic)
-- Support for cloud provider auth (GCP ADC, AWS IAM, Azure AD)
-- TOTP support for two-factor authentication
-- UI login provider for browser-based tests
-
-#### 3. Pack v2 Module (`core/src/pack-v2/`)
-
-**Status:** ✅ Phase 3 Complete (210+ tests)
-
-**Components:**
-
-| File | Description | Tests |
-|------|-------------|-------|
-| `validator.ts` | PackValidatorV2 with 36 error codes | 100+ tests |
-| `migrator.ts` | Migration v1 → v2 | 50+ tests |
-| `loader.ts` | Load with auto-detection | 60+ tests |
-
-**CLI Commands:**
-```bash
-qa360 pack validate [pack] --check-files   # Validate pack
-qa360 pack migrate [pack] --output <file>  # Migrate v1 → v2
-qa360 pack lint [pack]                     # Auto-fix
-```
-
-**Features:**
-- Auto-detection of v1 vs v2 pack format
-- 36 validation error codes with detailed messages
-- Migration of gates array → gates object with adapters
-- Migration of environment → auth profiles + variables
-- Migration of hooks string → typed hook objects
-
-**Total AI Integration Tests:** 343 (41 + 92 + 210)
-
-#### 5. F8 Smart Retry Module (`core/src/retry/`)
-
-**Status:** ✅ Phase 2 Complete (48 tests)
-
-**Components:**
-
-| File | Description | Tests |
-|------|-------------|-------|
-| `types.ts` | RetryStrategy enum, RetryConfig, RetryResult types | - |
-| `retry-engine.ts` | SmartRetryEngine with 6 strategies | 30 tests |
-| `flakiness-integration.ts` | FlakinessAwareRetryEngine for intelligent retry | 18 tests |
-| `vault.ts` | SQLite persistence for retry history | - |
-
-**Retry Strategies:**
-- `NONE` - No retry, fail immediately
-- `FIXED` - Fixed delay between retries
-- `LINEAR` - Linear backoff (delay increases linearly)
-- `EXPONENTIAL` - Exponential backoff (delay doubles each retry)
-- `ADAPTIVE` - Adaptive retry based on flakiness score
-- `INTELLIGENT` - Pattern-based retry (timing, race conditions, selectors)
-
-**Features:**
-- Flakiness-aware retry decisions based on historical test data
-- Non-retriable error detection (OutOfMemoryError, PermissionDenied, SyntaxError, etc.)
-- Configurable jitter to avoid thundering herd problem
-- Pattern-based retry adjustments (timing, external_dependency, race_condition, selector_issue)
-- Retry history tracking in SQLite vault
-
-**Public API:**
-```typescript
-import { SmartRetryEngine, RetryStrategy, createSmartRetryEngine } from '@qa360/core/retry';
-
-const engine = createSmartRetryEngine({
-  maxRetries: 3,
-  initialDelayMs: 1000,
-  strategy: RetryStrategy.ADAPTIVE,
-  jitterFactor: 0.1
-});
-
-const result = await engine.executeWithRetry('test-1', async () => {
-  // Test execution
-});
-// → { success: true, totalAttempts: 2, stopReason: 'success', ... }
-
-// Get retry recommendation based on flakiness
-const rec = engine.getRetryRecommendation({ flakinessScore: 60 });
-// → { shouldRetry: true, strategy: RetryStrategy.ADAPTIVE, maxRetries: 3, ... }
-```
-
-**Total Tests:** 48 (30 + 18)
-
----
-
-### 4. MCP Package (`@qa360/mcp`)
-
-**Version:** 1.2.0 (Unified)  
-**Path:** `/packages/mcp`  
-**Purpose:** AI-friendly conversational testing interface
-
-#### History & Merge
-
-**December 23, 2024**: Merged two separate packages into one unified package:
-- ❌ `@qa360/mcp-server` (0.9.0-mcp) - Full MCP server, 23 tools
-- ❌ `@qa360/mcp-cli` (1.1.0) - Zero-friction CLI
-- ✅ `@qa360/mcp` (1.2.0) - **Unified package** combining both
-
-**Merge Impact:**
-- Eliminated package conflicts
-- Single binary: `qa360-mcp` (CLI + Server)
-- Reduced complexity: -10,503 lines of duplicate code
-- Improved build speed: +50%
-
-#### MCP Tools (23 Total)
-
-**Core Execution (3 tools):**
-- `qa360.run` - Execute test packs
-- `qa360.verify` - Verify signatures
-- `qa360.report.sign` - Sign reports
-
-**History & Analytics (8 tools):**
-- `qa360.history.list|get|diff|trend|export|gc|pin|unpin`
-
-**Pack Management (4 tools):**
-- `qa360.pack.ask|validate|lint|migrate`
-
-**Secrets Management (2 tools):**
-- `qa360.secrets.add|list` (requires `--allow-secrets`)
-
-**Server & Diagnostics (6 tools):**
-- `qa360.serve.health|diag|metrics`
-- `qa360.vault.get_run|get_artifacts`
-- `qa360.triage.explain_code`
-
-#### CLI Commands (9 Total)
-
-| Command | Description |
-|---------|-------------|
-| `qa360-mcp init` | Auto-configure VS Code +  |
-| `qa360-mcp up` | Start MCP server with auto-recovery |
-| `qa360-mcp doctor` | Health checks (Node, VS Code, Claude) |
-| `qa360-mcp fix` | Auto-repair configuration |
-| `qa360-mcp reset` | Clean slate restart |
-| `qa360-mcp uninstall` | Complete removal |
-| `qa360-mcp test:dx` | DX compliance tests (CI/CD) |
-| `qa360-mcp telemetry` | Opt-in telemetry management |
-
-#### Security Features
-
-- **Permission System**: `--allow-run`, `--allow-secrets` opt-in flags
-- **Rate Limiting**: Configurable requests/second
-- **Audit Logging**: Full trail in `~/.qa360/mcp-audit.log`
-- **Data Redaction**: Automatic PII/credential masking
-- **Concurrency Control**: Limit parallel operations
-
-#### Integration
-
-**Claude Desktop:**
-```json
-{
-  "mcpServers": {
-    "qa360": {
-      "command": "qa360-mcp-server",
-      "args": ["--allow-run", "--allow-secrets"]
-    }
-  }
-}
-```
-
-**VS Code MCP Extension:**
-Auto-configured via `qa360-mcp init` command.
-
----
-
-## Adapters
-
-QA360 uses an **adapter pattern** to integrate with various testing frameworks. Each adapter implements the `TestAdapter` interface.
-
-### Adapter List
-
-| Adapter | Framework | Gate | Status |
-|---------|-----------|------|--------|
-| **playwright** | Playwright | UI | ✅ Stable |
-| **k6** | k6 | Performance | ✅ Stable |
-| **semgrep** | Semgrep | SAST | ✅ Stable |
-| **zap** | OWASP ZAP | DAST | ⚠️ Beta |
-| **trufflehog** | TruffleHog | Secrets | ✅ Stable |
-| **gitleaks** | Gitleaks | Secrets | ✅ Stable |
-
-### Adapter Interface
-
-```typescript
-interface TestAdapter {
-  name: string;
-  version: string;
-  isAvailable(): Promise<boolean>;
-  run(config: AdapterConfig): Promise<AdapterResult>;
-  cleanup(): Promise<void>;
-}
-```
-
-### Adding Custom Adapters
-
-1. Implement `TestAdapter` interface
-2. Register in `AdapterRegistry`
-3. Configure in pack YAML:
-   ```yaml
-   gates:
-     custom:
-       adapter: my-custom-adapter
-       config: { ... }
-   ```
-
----
-
-## Architecture Decisions (Week 1 Cleanup)
-
-### Context: December 18-23, 2024
-
-Week 1 focused on **monorepo cleanup and MCP unification** to eliminate technical debt and simplify the architecture.
-
-### Major Changes
-
-#### 1. Empty Package Deletion ✅
-
-**Removed 4 empty/stub packages:**
-- `packages/shared/` - Empty placeholder
-- `packages/types/` - Unused type definitions
-- `packages/utils/` - Duplicate utilities
-- `packages/config/` - Empty config package
-
-**Rationale:**
-- Reduced cognitive overhead (fewer directories to navigate)
-- Eliminated confusion about package responsibilities
-- Simplified dependency graph
-
-**Impact:**
-- -2,156 lines of boilerplate
-- Faster `pnpm install` (fewer workspace links)
-- Clearer project structure
-
----
-
-#### 2. MCP Package Merge ✅
-
-**Unified 2 MCP packages into 1:**
-
-| Before | After |
-|--------|-------|
-| `@qa360/mcp-server` (0.9.0-mcp) | ✅ `@qa360/mcp` (1.2.0) |
-| `@qa360/mcp-cli` (1.1.0) | ❌ Merged |
-| **2 packages, 1 binary conflict** | **1 package, 1 unified binary** |
-
-**Problem Solved:**
-- Binary name conflict (`qa360-mcp` in both packages)
-- Duplicate code (tools, security, types duplicated)
-- Confusion about which package to use
-- Maintenance burden (updating 2 packages)
-
-**Merge Details:**
-- Copied `tools/` (23 production tools vs 3 stubs)
-- Copied `security/` (audit + manager)
-- Replaced minimal server with full server
-- Merged dependencies (`@qa360/core`, `ajv`)
-- Updated bin entries to point to full server
-
-**Result:**
-- Single source of truth for MCP functionality
-- Eliminated 10,503 lines of duplicate code
-- Unified documentation and examples
-- +50% faster build (no duplicate TypeScript compilation)
-
-**Git History:**
-```bash
-d65d8a1c - refactor(mcp): merge core functionality from mcp-server
-d2ba795e - chore(architecture): finalize monorepo cleanup
-```
-
----
-
-#### 3. API Directory Relocation ✅
-
-**Moved `/api` to `examples/future-api`**
-
-**Rationale:**
-- `/api` contained placeholder code for Phase 3 REST API
-- Having it at root implied it was production-ready
-- Caused confusion ("Is QA360 a REST API?")
-
-**Action:**
-- Moved 4 placeholder files to `examples/future-api/`
-- Created `README.md` documenting Phase 3 timeline
-- Updated workspace configuration
-
-**Benefit:**
-- Clear signal: API is future work, not current feature
-- Cleaner root directory structure
-- Examples directory as home for future integrations
-
----
-
-#### 4. Node Requirement Adjustment ✅
-
-**Changed:** `node: ">=20.18.1"` → `">=18.20.0"`
-
-**Rationale:**
-- Original requirement too strict (20.18.1 very recent)
-- Build system works fine on Node 18.x
-- `undici` dependency had strict requirement, downgraded to v6
-- Improves compatibility with existing CI/CD pipelines
-
-**Impact:**
-- Broader Node.js version support
-- Better developer experience (no forced Node upgrade)
-- Still modern (18.20.0 is LTS)
-
----
-
-### Overall Impact
-
-| Metric | Before | After | Change |
-|--------|--------|-------|--------|
-| **Packages** | 13 | 10 | -23% |
-| **Empty Packages** | 4 | 0 | -100% |
-| **MCP Packages** | 2 | 1 | -50% |
-| **Lines of Code** | ~45,000 | ~34,500 | **-10,503** |
-| **Build Time** | ~12s | ~6s | **+50% faster** |
-| **Workspace Links** | 15 | 10 | -33% |
-| **Binary Conflicts** | 1 | 0 | Resolved |
-
-### Decision Log
-
-All architectural decisions are tracked in:
-- `ARCH-01_MCP_MERGE_ANALYSIS.md` - Detailed merge analysis
-- Git commit messages - Rationale and implementation details
-- This document - High-level summaries
-
----
-
-## Build System
-
-### Package Manager
-
-**pnpm 9.12.2** - Fast, efficient, strict workspace management
-
-```yaml
-# pnpm-workspace.yaml
-packages:
-  - cli
-  - core
-  - adapters/*
-  - ui/*
-  - examples/*
-  - packages/*
-  - tests
-```
-
-### TypeScript Configuration
-
-**Version:** TypeScript 5.0+
-
-**tsconfig.json (root):**
-```json
-{
-  "compilerOptions": {
-    "target": "ES2022",
-    "module": "ESNext",
-    "moduleResolution": "node",
-    "strict": true,
-    "esModuleInterop": true,
-    "skipLibCheck": true
-  }
-}
-```
-
-**Build Commands:**
-```bash
-pnpm install           # Install all workspace dependencies
-pnpm run build         # Compile all TypeScript packages
-pnpm run test          # Run Jest tests
-pnpm run lint          # ESLint checks
-pnpm run type-check    # TypeScript type checking
-```
-
-### CI/CD
-
-**GitHub Actions:**
-- Multi-OS testing (Ubuntu, macOS, Windows)
-- Multi-Node testing (18.x, 20.x, 22.x)
-- Automated build + test + lint
-- Playwright browser installation
-- Artifact collection
-
-**Workflow:** `.github/workflows/qa360-ci.yml`
-
----
-
-## Security
-
-QA360 implements defense-in-depth security:
-
-### 1. Cryptographic Signatures
-
-**Algorithm:** Ed25519 (Curve25519-based)
-
-- **Key Generation**: Automatic on first run
-- **Storage**: `~/.qa360/keys/` (0600 permissions)
-- **Signing**: All test results signed with private key
-- **Verification**: Public key included in proof for validation
-
-**Proof Structure:**
-```json
-{
-  "proof_version": "1.0.0",
-  "run_id": "uuid-v4",
-  "timestamp": "ISO-8601",
-  "gates": [...],
-  "signature": {
-    "algorithm": "ed25519",
-    "public_key": "base64",
-    "signature": "base64"
-  }
-}
-```
-
-### 2. Evidence Vault
-
-**Technology:** SQLite with WAL (Write-Ahead Logging)
-
-- **Immutability**: Append-only writes
-- **Atomicity**: WAL ensures crash recovery
-- **Performance**: Up to 100x faster than journal mode
-- **Location**: `~/.qa360/vault/evidence.db`
-
-**Integrity Checks:**
-- SHA256 hashes on all artifacts
-- Foreign key constraints
-- CHECK constraints on enums
-- Timestamp validation
-
-### 3. Secrets Management
-
-**Storage:** Encrypted with AES-256
-
-- **Master Key**: Derived from system entropy
-- **Per-Secret Encryption**: Unique IV per secret
-- **Audit Trail**: All access logged
-- **Redaction**: Automatic masking in logs/reports
-
-**Secret Operations:**
-```bash
-qa360 secrets add DB_PASSWORD
-qa360 secrets list --show-values  # Requires confirmation
-qa360 secrets remove DB_PASSWORD
-qa360 secrets doctor             # Audit check
-```
-
-### 4. MCP Security
-
-**Permission System:**
-- `--allow-run`: Explicit opt-in for test execution
-- `--allow-secrets`: Explicit opt-in for secrets access
-- **Default**: Read-only (history, diagnostics, vault queries)
-
-**Rate Limiting:**
-- Configurable requests/second (default: 5 req/s)
-- Per-tool limits
-- DDoS protection
-
-**Audit Logging:**
-- Every MCP tool call logged
-- Timestamp, tool name, arguments (redacted)
-- Success/failure status
-- Log file: `~/.qa360/mcp-audit.log`
-
-### 5. Data Redaction
-
-**Automatic Redaction Patterns:**
-- Bearer tokens
-- Basic auth credentials
-- API keys
-- Database connection strings
-- Private keys / certificates
-- Email addresses (optional)
-
-**Redaction API:**
-```typescript
-import { SecurityRedactor } from '@qa360/core';
-
-const redactor = new SecurityRedactor();
-const safe = redactor.redact(text);
-// "Bearer abc123" → "Bearer [REDACTED]"
-```
-
----
-
-## Future Phases
-
-QA360 follows a phased roadmap:
-
-### Core Platform Phases
-
-### Phase 1: Core Platform ✅ (Complete)
-- Local-first testing engine
-- Proof generation & verification
-- CLI interface
-- 7 adapters (Playwright, k6, Semgrep, ZAP, Gitleaks, OSV)
-- Evidence vault
-- **Status:** Done (1.4.5)
-
-### Phase 2: MCP Integration ✅ (Complete)
-- Model Context Protocol server
-- 23 conversational tools
-- Claude Desktop / VS Code integration
-- Zero-friction DX CLI
-- **Status:** Done (1.2.0 unified)
-
-### AI Integration Phases (Ollama)
-
-#### AI Phase 1: Ollama Provider ✅ (Complete - Dec 31, 2024)
-- OllamaProvider with retry & timeout
-- TestDiscoverer for auto-detection
-- PackConfigV2 types
-- CLI commands: `ollama test|list|pull|generate|config`
-- **Tests:** 96 passing
-
-#### AI Phase 2: Auth Module ✅ (Complete - Dec 31, 2024)
-- 9 authentication providers
-- JWT, OAuth2, API Key, Bearer, Basic, TOTP
-- Cloud providers: GCP ADC, AWS IAM, Azure AD
-- UI Login provider for browser tests
-- **Tests:** 92 passing
-
-#### AI Phase 3: Pack v2 Validation ✅ (Complete - Dec 31, 2024)
-- PackValidatorV2 (36 error codes)
-- PackMigrator (v1 → v2)
-- PackLoaderV2 (auto-detection)
-- CLI commands: `pack validate|migrate|lint`
-- **Tests:** 210+ passing
-
-#### AI Phase 4: AI Test Generation ⏳ (Planned)
-- CodeGenerator module
-- PromptBuilder for LLM prompts
-- Test generation from OpenAPI/Swagger
-- Interactive test generation CLI
-
-#### AI Phase 5: Integration & Polish ⏳ (Planned)
-- Phase3Runner integration for Pack v2
-- Adapters updated for Auth profiles
-- Complete documentation
-- Example packs v2
-- E2E tests
-
-**Total AI Integration Tests:** 398 (Phases 1-3)
-
-### Vision 2.0 - Flakiness Detection & Smart Retry
-
-#### F1-F7: Flakiness System ✅ (Complete - January 2025)
-- Flakiness Detection Engine
-- Flakiness Scoring (Legendary, Solid, Good, Shaky, Unstable)
-- Quarantine System
-- Self-Healing Module
-- Coverage Analytics
-- SLO/SLI Management
-- Regression Detection
-
-#### F8: Smart Retry Module ✅ (Complete - January 3, 2025)
-- Smart Retry Engine with 6 strategies (NONE, FIXED, LINEAR, EXPONENTIAL, ADAPTIVE, INTELLIGENT)
-- Flakiness-Aware Retry: Integrates with flakiness scoring for intelligent retry decisions
-- Pattern-Based Retry: Adjusts strategy based on failure patterns (timing, race conditions, selectors)
-- Non-Retriable Error Detection: Automatically identifies unrecoverable errors
-- Jitter Support: Avoids thundering herd problem with configurable jitter
-- **Tests:** 48 passing
-
-**Complete Flakiness System:** Detection → Scoring → Quarantine → Smart Retry
-
-### Future Platform Phases
-
-### Phase 3: Cloud & API 🔮 (Q1 2025)
-- REST API for remote execution
-- Web dashboard (real-time)
-- Multi-user authentication
-- Cloud pack registry
-- **Status:** Planned, code in `examples/future-api/`
-
-### Phase 4: Enterprise 🔮 (Q2 2025)
-- SAML/OIDC authentication
-- RBAC (Role-Based Access Control)
-- Compliance reports (SOC2, ISO27001)
-- On-premise deployment
-- **Status:** Planned
-
----
-
-## References
-
-### Documentation
-
-- **API Reference**: `/docs/api/`
-- **User Guides**: `/docs/guides/`
-- **MCP Server**: `/packages/mcp/README.md`
-- **Core Package**: `/core/README.md`
-- **CLI Package**: `/cli/README.md`
-
-### Key Documents
-
-- **ARCH-01 Analysis**: `ARCH-01_MCP_MERGE_ANALYSIS.md` - Detailed merge analysis
-- **Migration Guide**: `docs/MIGRATION.md` - Upgrade path from pre-1.2.0
-- **Week 1 Summary**: `docs/WEEK1_SUMMARY.md` - Cleanup accomplishments
-- **Ollama Roadmap**: `docs/OLLAMA_REFACTORING_ROADMAP.md` - AI integration roadmap
-- **Status**: `docs/STATUS.md` - Current project status
-
-### External Links
-
-- **Website**: https://qa360.ai
-- **GitHub**: https://github.com/xyqotech/qa360
-- **MCP Protocol**: https://modelcontextprotocol.io
-- **Playwright**: https://playwright.dev
-- **k6**: https://k6.io
-
----
-
-## Contributing
-
-QA360 follows trunk-based development:
-
-1. **Main Branch**: `develop` (stable, deployable)
-2. **Feature Branches**: Short-lived, merged via PR
-3. **Commit Convention**: Conventional Commits (feat, fix, chore, docs, refactor)
-4. **Testing**: All PRs require passing CI/CD
-
-**Pull Request Checklist:**
-- [ ] Tests pass (`pnpm test`)
-- [ ] Lint passes (`pnpm lint`)
-- [ ] Type check passes (`pnpm type-check`)
-- [ ] Build succeeds (`pnpm build`)
-- [ ] Documentation updated
-- [ ] Commit messages follow convention
-
----
-
-## License
-
-MIT License - See `LICENSE` file for details.
-
----
-
-**Architecture Document Version:** 1.1.0
-**Last Review:** January 3, 2025
-**Next Review:** January 2025 (AI Phase 4)