plan-governance-cli 0.3.5 → 1.0.0

package/scripts/check_plan_governance.py

@@ -48,10 +48,13 @@ def read_utf8(path, errors):
         fail(errors, f"{path}: not valid UTF-8")
     except FileNotFoundError:
         fail(errors, f"{path}: file not found")
+    except OSError as exc:
+        fail(errors, f"{path}: cannot read file: {exc}")
     return ""
 
 
 def table_rows(text, heading):
+    text = mask_fenced_code(text)
     pattern = re.compile(rf"^##\s+{re.escape(heading)}\s*$", re.MULTILINE)
     match = pattern.search(text)
     if not match:
@@ -59,28 +62,24 @@ def table_rows(text, heading):
     tail = text[match.end():]
     next_heading = re.search(r"^##\s+", tail, re.MULTILINE)
     section = tail[: next_heading.start()] if next_heading else tail
-    rows = []
-    for line in section.splitlines():
-        stripped = line.strip()
-        if not stripped.startswith("|") or "---" in stripped:
-            continue
-        cells = [cell.strip() for cell in stripped.strip("|").split("|")]
-        if cells and cells[0] not in {"计划", "问题"}:
-            rows.append(cells)
-    return rows
+    return [cells for cells in markdown_table_rows(section) if cells[0] not in {"计划", "问题"}]
 
 
 def mask_fenced_code(text):
     """用等长空格屏蔽 fenced code 中的伪 Markdown 标题，保留偏移量。"""
     masked = []
-    in_fence = False
+    fence = None
     for line in text.splitlines(keepends=True):
         stripped = line.lstrip()
-        if stripped.startswith("```"):
-            in_fence = not in_fence
-            masked.append("".join("\n" if char == "\n" else "\r" if char == "\r" else " " for char in line))
-            continue
-        if in_fence:
+        marker = re.match(r"(`{3,}|~{3,})", stripped)
+        was_in_fence = fence is not None
+        if marker:
+            value = marker.group(1)
+            if fence is None:
+                fence = value
+            elif value[0] == fence[0] and len(value) >= len(fence) and not stripped[len(value):].strip():
+                fence = None
+        if was_in_fence or fence is not None:
             masked.append("".join("\n" if char == "\n" else "\r" if char == "\r" else " " for char in line))
         else:
             masked.append(line)
@@ -96,7 +95,7 @@ def markdown_section(text, heading_names):
     if not match:
         return None
     tail = text[match.end():]
-    next_heading = re.search(r"^#+\s+", tail, re.MULTILINE)
+    next_heading = re.search(r"^#+\s+", mask_fenced_code(text)[match.end():], re.MULTILINE)
     return tail[: next_heading.start()] if next_heading else tail
 
 
@@ -104,12 +103,12 @@ def markdown_table_rows(section):
     if section is None:
         return []
     rows = []
-    for line in section.splitlines():
+    for line in mask_fenced_code(section).splitlines():
         stripped = line.strip()
-        if not stripped.startswith("|") or "---" in stripped:
+        if not stripped.startswith("|"):
             continue
         cells = [cell.strip() for cell in stripped.strip("|").split("|")]
-        if cells:
+        if cells and not all(re.fullmatch(r":?-+:?", cell) for cell in cells):
             rows.append(cells)
     return rows
 
@@ -123,6 +122,19 @@ def key_value_table(section):
     return values
 
 
+def fixed_section(text, heading):
+    """结构化事实只接受完整的固定标题；正文保留，表格解析另行屏蔽示例。"""
+    if not text:
+        return None
+    masked = mask_fenced_code(text)
+    match = re.search(rf"^#+\s+{re.escape(heading)}\s*$", masked, re.MULTILINE)
+    if not match:
+        return None
+    tail = text[match.end():]
+    end = re.search(r"^#+\s+", masked[match.end():], re.MULTILINE)
+    return tail[:end.start()] if end else tail
+
+
 def numbered_structural_heading(plan_text, heading_names):
     """查找误把阶段编号写入结构化章节标题的常见形式。"""
     phase_number = r"[0-9一二三四五六七八九十百]+"
@@ -150,19 +162,19 @@ def structural_heading_hint(plan_text, heading_name):
 
 
 def phase_roadmap_rows(plan_text):
-    section = markdown_section(plan_text, ["阶段路线图"])
+    section = fixed_section(plan_text, "阶段路线图")
     return [row for row in markdown_table_rows(section) if row and row[0] != "阶段"]
 
 
 def review_history_rows(plan_text):
-    section = markdown_section(plan_text, ["独立复核记录"])
+    section = fixed_section(plan_text, "独立复核记录")
     return [row for row in markdown_table_rows(section) if row and row[0] != "日期"]
 
 
 def is_placeholder(value, allow_empty=False):
     normalized = re.sub(r"\s+", "", value or "")
     if not normalized:
-        return allow_empty
+        return not allow_empty
     return normalized in {re.sub(r"\s+", "", item) for item in PLACEHOLDER_VALUES}
 
 
@@ -184,14 +196,210 @@ def readiness_issue(warnings, errors, strict, message):
         warn(warnings, message)
 
 
-def check_phase_readiness(plan_map_text, plan_name, data, plan_text, strict, warnings, errors):
+def review_outcome(conclusion):
+    """新策略只识别明确结论；未进行、失败和不确定声明不能混为通过。"""
+    conclusion = conclusion.strip()
+    choice_separator = r"\s*(?:[/／]|或(?:者)?)\s*"
+    if re.match(
+        rf"^(?:通过{choice_separator}(?:未通过|不通过)|(?:未通过|不通过){choice_separator}通过)",
+        conclusion,
+    ):
+        # 开头候选始终不是结论，不能因尾标点/说明漏匹配后落入 passed。
+        return "unknown"
+    if conclusion.startswith(("未通过", "不通过", "失败", "不满足", "拒绝")):
+        return "failed"
+    if re.match(r"^通过(?:$|[。.!！：:，,；;（(\s])", conclusion):
+        return "passed"
+    if any(token in conclusion for token in ("不可用", "超时", "证据冲突", "证据失效")):
+        return "failed"
+    if conclusion in {"未进行", "尚未进行", "待复核", "待自验", "待独立复核", "待验证"}:
+        return "pending"
+    return "unknown"
+
+
+def risk_review_state(plan_text, phase):
+    """显式风险策略的共享事实判定；不评估风险真实性或自动检测证据漂移。"""
+    summary_section = fixed_section(top_level_section(plan_text, "当前阶段"), "阶段准入摘要")
+    policies = [row for row in markdown_table_rows(summary_section) if row[0] == "复核策略"]
+    result = {"enabled": bool(policies), "passed": False, "pending_action": None,
+              "issues": [], "blockers": []}
+    if not policies:
+        return result
+    issues, blockers = result["issues"], result["blockers"]
+    if len(policies) != 1 or len(policies[0]) != 2 or policies[0][1] != "风险分流":
+        issues.append("复核策略必须唯一且为 风险分流；空值、未知值或重复声明不能准入")
+    summary = key_value_table(summary_section)
+    if "最新独立准入复核" in summary:
+        issues.append("风险分流的阶段准入摘要应以 最新阶段复核 替代 最新独立准入复核")
+    if is_placeholder(summary.get("最新阶段复核")):
+        issues.append("阶段准入摘要缺少有效的 最新阶段复核 链接")
+
+    review = key_value_table(fixed_section(plan_text, "最新阶段复核"))
+    if any(len(row) != 2 for row in markdown_table_rows(fixed_section(plan_text, "最新阶段复核"))):
+        issues.append("最新阶段复核必须使用字段/内容两列表格")
+    fields = {"日期", "阶段", "方式", "风险", "风险依据", "结论", "证据", "复核者"}
+    for field in sorted(fields - set(review)):
+        issues.append(f"最新阶段复核缺少字段：{field}")
+    outcome = review_outcome(review.get("结论", ""))
+    if review.get("阶段") != phase:
+        issues.append(f"最新阶段复核阶段与 PLAN_MAP 当前阶段 {phase} 不一致")
+    if review.get("方式") not in {"自验", "独立"}:
+        issues.append("最新阶段复核方式必须为 自验/独立")
+    if review.get("风险") not in {"低风险", "高影响", "待判断"}:
+        issues.append("最新阶段复核风险必须为 低风险/高影响/待判断")
+    if review.get("风险") == "待判断":
+        issues.append("最新阶段复核风险待判断，不能准入")
+    if review.get("方式") == "自验" and review.get("风险") != "低风险":
+        issues.append("自验只适用于低风险，不能代替高影响独立复核")
+    if is_placeholder(review.get("风险依据")):
+        issues.append("最新阶段复核风险依据为空或占位")
+    if outcome == "unknown":
+        issues.append("最新阶段复核结论为空或未知")
+    if outcome == "failed" and review.get("阶段") == phase:
+        blockers.append("最新阶段复核：" + review["结论"])
+
+    def valid_date(value):
+        if not re.fullmatch(r"\d{4}-\d{2}-\d{2}", value):
+            return None
+        try:
+            return parse_plan_date(value)
+        except ValueError:
+            return None
+
+    def qualified(row, legacy=False):
+        # 仅完整的独立通过可以解除先前独立失败；失败记录即使材料残缺也保留。
+        return (len(row) == (6 if legacy else 8) and not any(is_placeholder(value) for value in row)
+                and valid_date(row[0]) is not None
+                and (legacy or (row[3] == "独立" and row[4] in {"低风险", "高影响"})))
+
+    known_phases = {row[0] for row in phase_roadmap_rows(plan_text)}
+
+    def known_other_phase(value):
+        return value != phase and (value in known_phases or re.fullmatch(r"阶段\s*\d+", value))
+
+    def current_history(title, width):
+        section = fixed_section(plan_text, title)
+        rows = markdown_table_rows(section)
+        expected = (["日期", "类型", "阶段", "方式", "风险", "结论", "证据", "复核者"]
+                    if width == 8 else ["日期", "类型", "阶段", "结论", "证据", "复核者"])
+        if rows and rows[0] != expected:
+            issues.append(f"{title} 必须使用固定的 {width} 列表头")
+        if rows.count(expected) > 1:
+            issues.append(f"{title} 存在重复表头，无法确认记录结构")
+        current = []
+        previous_date = None
+        for row in rows:
+            if row == expected:
+                continue
+            if len(row) > 2 and row[2] != phase:
+                if known_other_phase(row[2]):
+                    continue
+                issues.append(f"{title} 记录阶段为空或未知，不能忽略")
+                continue
+            if len(row) != width or len(row) < 3 or row[2] != phase:
+                issues.append(f"{title} 记录字段不足、列数不符或阶段不明")
+                continue
+            current.append(row)
+            if is_placeholder(row[1]):
+                issues.append(f"{title} 类型为空或占位")
+            parsed = valid_date(row[0])
+            if not is_placeholder(row[0]) and parsed is None:
+                issues.append(f"{title} 日期不合法：{row[0]}")
+            if parsed and previous_date and parsed < previous_date:
+                issues.append(f"{title} 当前阶段记录日期逆序，无法确认最新结果")
+            if parsed:
+                previous_date = parsed
+        return current
+
+    history = current_history("阶段复核记录", 8)
+    for row in history:
+        if row[3] not in {"自验", "独立"} or row[4] not in {"低风险", "高影响", "待判断"}:
+            issues.append("阶段复核记录方式或风险未知")
+        if row[3] == "自验" and row[4] != "低风险":
+            issues.append("阶段复核记录自验只适用于低风险")
+        if review_outcome(row[5]) == "unknown":
+            issues.append("阶段复核记录结论为空或未知")
+        if review_outcome(row[5]) == "passed" and (
+            any(is_placeholder(value) for value in row) or valid_date(row[0]) is None or row[4] == "待判断"
+        ):
+            issues.append("阶段复核记录通过缺少有效日期、类型、风险、证据或身份")
+    if history:
+        latest = history[-1]
+        for field, index in [("日期", 0), ("方式", 3), ("风险", 4), ("结论", 5), ("证据", 6), ("复核者", 7)]:
+            if review.get(field) != latest[index]:
+                issues.append(f"最新阶段复核与当前阶段历史记录最后一条 {field} 冲突")
+        if review_outcome(latest[5]) == "failed":
+            blockers.append("阶段复核记录最新结果：" + latest[5])
+    elif outcome != "pending":
+        issues.append(f"阶段复核记录缺少当前阶段 {phase} 的记录")
+    if outcome == "passed":
+        for field in sorted(fields & set(review)):
+            if is_placeholder(review[field]):
+                issues.append(f"最新阶段复核字段 {field} 为空或占位")
+    if (outcome == "passed" or not is_placeholder(review.get("日期"))) and valid_date(review.get("日期", "")) is None:
+        issues.append("最新阶段复核日期不合法")
+
+    independent = [row for row in history if row[3] == "独立"]
+    unresolved = None
+    for row in independent:
+        row_outcome = review_outcome(row[5])
+        if row_outcome == "failed":
+            unresolved = row[5]
+        elif row_outcome == "passed" and qualified(row):
+            unresolved = None
+    if unresolved:
+        blockers.append("阶段复核记录存在未解除的独立失败：" + unresolved)
+
+    # 旧独立记录仍是独立事实源；完成失败也不能被新自验覆盖。
+    legacy_history = current_history("独立复核记录", 6)
+    legacy_section = fixed_section(plan_text, "最新独立准入复核")
+    legacy = key_value_table(legacy_section)
+    legacy_current = legacy.get("阶段") == phase
+    if legacy_section is not None and not legacy_current and not known_other_phase(legacy.get("阶段", "")):
+        issues.append("旧最新独立准入复核阶段为空或未知，不能降级放行")
+    if legacy_history:
+        latest = legacy_history[-1]
+        if not legacy_current or any(legacy.get(field) != latest[index]
+                                    for field, index in [("日期", 0), ("证据", 4), ("复核者", 5)]) or (
+            latest[3] != legacy.get("结论") and not (
+                review_outcome(latest[3]) == review_outcome(legacy.get("结论", "")) == "passed"
+                and latest[3] in legacy.get("结论", "")
+            )
+        ):
+            issues.append("旧最新独立准入复核与当前阶段历史记录冲突，不能降级放行")
+    unresolved = None
+    for row in legacy_history:
+        row_outcome = review_outcome(row[3])
+        if row_outcome == "failed":
+            unresolved = row[3]
+        elif row_outcome == "passed" and qualified(row, legacy=True):
+            unresolved = None
+        elif row_outcome == "passed":
+            issues.append("旧独立通过记录缺少有效日期、类型、证据或身份")
+        elif row_outcome == "unknown":
+            issues.append("旧独立复核记录结论为空或未知")
+    if unresolved:
+        blockers.append("旧独立复核记录存在未解除的失败：" + unresolved)
+    if legacy_current:
+        if review_outcome(legacy.get("结论", "")) == "failed":
+            blockers.append("最新独立准入复核：" + legacy["结论"])
+        elif not legacy_history or any(is_placeholder(legacy.get(field))
+                                     for field in ["日期", "阶段", "结论", "证据", "复核者"]) or valid_date(legacy.get("日期", "")) is None:
+            issues.append("旧最新独立准入复核缺少有效字段或当前阶段历史，不能降级放行")
+    result["passed"] = outcome == "passed" and not issues and not blockers
+    if outcome == "pending" and not issues and not blockers:
+        result["pending_action"] = "verify" if review.get("方式") == "自验" else "independent_review"
+    return result
+
+
+def check_phase_structure(plan_name, data, plan_text, strict, warnings, errors, review_state=None):
     """检查待实施/实施中计划的阶段准入结构，不判断业务证据真实性。"""
     if data["status"] not in ACTIVE:
         return
 
     current_phase = data["phase"]
     current_section = top_level_section(plan_text, "当前阶段")
-    summary_section = markdown_section(current_section, ["阶段准入摘要"])
+    summary_section = fixed_section(current_section, "阶段准入摘要")
     summary = key_value_table(summary_section)
     roadmap = phase_roadmap_rows(plan_text)
     matching_rows = [row for row in roadmap if row and row[0] == current_phase]
@@ -207,7 +415,7 @@ def check_phase_readiness(plan_map_text, plan_name, data, plan_text, strict, war
         roadmap_status = matching_rows[-1][4] if len(matching_rows[-1]) > 4 else ""
         phase_status = summary.get("阶段状态", "").strip()
         expected_roadmap_status = phase_status or data["status"]
-        if roadmap_status and roadmap_status != expected_roadmap_status:
+        if roadmap_status != expected_roadmap_status:
             readiness_issue(
                 warnings,
                 errors,
@@ -219,7 +427,11 @@ def check_phase_readiness(plan_map_text, plan_name, data, plan_text, strict, war
         section_hint = structural_heading_hint(plan_text, "当前阶段")
         readiness_issue(warnings, errors, strict, f"{plan_name}: 缺少 `## 当前阶段` 章节{section_hint}")
 
-    missing_fields = sorted(READINESS_FIELDS - set(summary))
+    review_state = review_state if review_state is not None else risk_review_state(plan_text, current_phase)
+    required_fields = READINESS_FIELDS
+    if review_state["enabled"]:
+        required_fields = (READINESS_FIELDS - {"最新独立准入复核"}) | {"最新阶段复核"}
+    missing_fields = sorted(required_fields - set(summary))
     if missing_fields:
         title_hint = ""
         if summary_section is None:
@@ -230,7 +442,7 @@ def check_phase_readiness(plan_map_text, plan_name, data, plan_text, strict, war
             strict,
             f"{plan_name}: 阶段准入摘要缺少字段：{', '.join(missing_fields)}{title_hint}",
         )
-    for field in sorted(READINESS_FIELDS - {"当前阻塞项"}):
+    for field in sorted(required_fields - {"当前阻塞项"}):
         if field in summary and is_placeholder(summary[field]):
             readiness_issue(
                 warnings,
@@ -238,7 +450,7 @@ def check_phase_readiness(plan_map_text, plan_name, data, plan_text, strict, war
                 strict,
                 f"{plan_name}: 阶段准入摘要字段 {field} 仍是占位内容",
             )
-    if summary.get("当前阻塞项") and is_placeholder(summary["当前阻塞项"]) and summary["当前阻塞项"].strip() != "无":
+    if "当前阻塞项" in summary and is_placeholder(summary["当前阻塞项"]) and summary["当前阻塞项"].strip() != "无":
         readiness_issue(
             warnings,
             errors,
@@ -253,7 +465,14 @@ def check_phase_readiness(plan_map_text, plan_name, data, plan_text, strict, war
             f"{plan_name}: 阶段准入摘要状态 {summary['准入状态']} 与 PLAN_MAP 状态 {data['status']} 不一致",
         )
 
-    review = key_value_table(markdown_section(plan_text, ["最新独立准入复核"]))
+    if review_state["enabled"]:
+        for issue in review_state["issues"] + review_state["blockers"]:
+            readiness_issue(warnings, errors, strict, f"{plan_name}: {issue}")
+        if review_state["pending_action"]:
+            readiness_issue(warnings, errors, strict, f"{plan_name}: 最新阶段复核尚未通过")
+        return
+
+    review = key_value_table(fixed_section(plan_text, "最新独立准入复核"))
     review_fields = {"日期", "阶段", "结论", "证据", "复核者"}
     missing_review = sorted(review_fields - set(review))
     if missing_review:
@@ -264,6 +483,10 @@ def check_phase_readiness(plan_map_text, plan_name, data, plan_text, strict, war
             strict,
             f"{plan_name}: 最新独立准入复核缺少字段：{', '.join(missing_review)}{review_hint}",
         )
+    for field in sorted(review_fields & set(review)):
+        if is_placeholder(review[field]):
+            readiness_issue(warnings, errors, strict,
+                            f"{plan_name}: 最新独立准入复核字段 {field} 仍是占位内容")
     if review.get("日期"):
         try:
             parse_plan_date(review["日期"])
@@ -474,9 +697,11 @@ def has_coverage_evidence(plan_text):
 
 
 def has_current_blocker(plan_text):
+    """保留默认 check 对已有开放问题的硬错误，不扩大到新增来源。"""
     for row in table_rows(plan_text, "未决问题"):
-        joined = "|".join(row)
-        if re.search(r"\b(Yes|是)\b", joined) and re.search(r"(Open|待确认|未解决|待处理|未决定)", joined, re.IGNORECASE):
+        if (len(row) >= 4 and row[2].strip().lower() in {"是", "yes"}
+                and row[3].strip().lower() not in CLOSED_BLOCKER_STATES
+                and re.search(r"Open|待确认|未解决|待处理|未决定", row[3], re.IGNORECASE)):
             return True
     return False
 
@@ -696,6 +921,271 @@ def safe_relative_path(value):
     return normalized if normalized not in {"", ".", "/"} else None
 
 
+def binding_path(value):
+    """范围绑定只接受明确文件路径；不改变旧路径解析的兼容行为。"""
+    if not isinstance(value, str) or re.search(r"[\x00*?\[\]]", value) or re.match(r"^[A-Za-z]:", value):
+        raise ValueError(f"binding 路径非法：{value!r}")
+    normalized = safe_relative_path(value)
+    if normalized is None:
+        raise ValueError(f"binding 路径必须是仓库内相对文件：{value!r}")
+    return normalized
+
+
+def binding_file(root, value, require_file=True):
+    relative = binding_path(value)
+    path = root
+    if path.is_symlink():
+        raise ValueError("binding 仓库根目录不能是 symlink")
+    parts = relative.split("/")
+    for index, part in enumerate(parts):
+        path = path / part
+        if path.is_symlink():
+            raise ValueError(f"binding 路径不能包含 symlink：{relative}")
+        if index < len(parts) - 1 and path.exists() and not path.is_dir():
+            raise ValueError(f"binding 父路径不是目录：{relative}")
+    if require_file and not path.is_file():
+        raise ValueError(f"binding 文件不存在或不是普通文件：{relative}")
+    return path
+
+
+def canonical_sha256(value):
+    content = json.dumps(value, ensure_ascii=False, sort_keys=True, separators=(",", ":"))
+    return hashlib.sha256(content.encode("utf-8")).hexdigest()
+
+
+def binding_table(text, heading, columns, repeated_header=False):
+    count = len(re.findall(rf"^##\s+{re.escape(heading)}\s*$", mask_fenced_code(text), re.MULTILINE))
+    if count > 1:
+        raise ValueError(f"binding PLAN_MAP 重复结构章节：{heading}")
+    section = top_level_section(text, heading)
+    if section is None or not section.strip():
+        return []
+    rows = markdown_table_rows(section)
+    if not rows or rows[0] != columns:
+        raise ValueError(f"binding PLAN_MAP {heading} 表头非法")
+    result = []
+    for row in rows[1:]:
+        if row == columns and repeated_header:
+            continue
+        if len(row) != len(columns) or row == columns:
+            raise ValueError(f"binding PLAN_MAP {heading} 列数或重复表头非法")
+        if row in result:
+            raise ValueError(f"binding PLAN_MAP {heading} 重复行")
+        result.append(row)
+    return sorted(result)
+
+
+def binding_plan_id(cell):
+    link = extract_plan_link(cell)
+    return Path(link).stem if link else clean_relation_value(cell)
+
+
+def binding_metadata(root, plan_map_relative, plan_name):
+    text = binding_file(root, plan_map_relative).read_text(encoding="utf-8")
+    index = binding_table(text, "计划索引", ["计划", "状态", "当前阶段", "最后更新", "依赖", "证据"], True)
+    dependency = binding_table(text, "依赖关系", ["计划", "依赖", "原因"])
+    relations = binding_table(text, "阶段关系", RELATION_COLUMNS)
+    shared = binding_table(text, "机器可检查共享写入约束", SHARED_WRITE_COLUMNS)
+    blockers = binding_table(text, "当前阻塞项", ["问题", "推荐方案", "影响范围", "是否阻塞当前阶段", "状态"])
+    by_name = {}
+    dependencies = {}
+    for row in index:
+        link = extract_plan_link(row[0])
+        name = binding_plan_id(row[0])
+        if not link or name in by_name:
+            raise ValueError(f"binding PLAN_MAP 计划链接非法或重复 ID：{name}")
+        binding_path("docs/" + link)
+        if clean_relation_value(row[1]) not in VALID_STATUSES or not valid_phase_name(row[2]):
+            raise ValueError(f"binding PLAN_MAP 计划状态或阶段非法：{name}")
+        parse_plan_date(clean_relation_value(row[3]))
+        by_name[name] = row
+        deps = extract_declared_dependencies(row[4])
+        if len(set(deps)) != len(deps):
+            raise ValueError(f"binding PLAN_MAP 重复依赖：{name}")
+        dependencies[name] = set(deps)
+    if plan_name not in by_name:
+        raise ValueError(f"binding 未登记计划：{plan_name}")
+    for name, deps in dependencies.items():
+        if deps - by_name.keys():
+            raise ValueError(f"binding PLAN_MAP 未知依赖：{name}")
+    if detect_dependency_cycles(dependencies):
+        raise ValueError("binding PLAN_MAP 索引依赖存在环")
+    seen = set()
+    for row in dependency:
+        name = binding_plan_id(row[0])
+        if name not in by_name or name in seen:
+            raise ValueError(f"binding PLAN_MAP 依赖详情未知或重复计划：{name}")
+        deps = extract_declared_dependencies(row[1])
+        if len(set(deps)) != len(deps) or set(deps) != dependencies[name]:
+            raise ValueError(f"binding PLAN_MAP 依赖详情与索引不一致：{name}")
+        seen.add(name)
+    for rows, label in [(relations, "阶段关系"), (shared, "共享写入约束")]:
+        for row in rows:
+            source, source_phase, target, target_phase, kind = map(clean_relation_value, row[:5])
+            if source not in by_name or target not in by_name:
+                raise ValueError(f"binding PLAN_MAP {label} 未知关系端点")
+            kinds = RELATION_TYPES if rows is relations else {"shared_write_risk"}
+            if kind not in kinds or not valid_phase_name(source_phase) or not valid_phase_name(target_phase):
+                raise ValueError(f"binding PLAN_MAP {label} 类型或阶段非法")
+    scopes = []
+    for row in blockers:
+        if all(cell in {"", "-"} for cell in row[:3]) and row[3].lower() in {"否", "no"}:
+            continue
+        scope = re.sub(r"\[[^\]]+\]\((?:\./)?plans/([^/)]+)\.md(?:#[^)]*)?\)", r"\1", row[2]).replace("`", "")
+        targets = set(filter(None, re.split(r"[,，、/;；\s]+", scope.strip())))
+        if not targets or targets - by_name.keys():
+            raise ValueError(f"binding PLAN_MAP 阻塞影响范围无法归属：{row[2]}")
+        scopes.append((row, targets))
+    members = {plan_name}
+    while True:
+        expanded = members | set().union(*(dependencies[name] for name in members))
+        expanded.update(clean_relation_value(row[0]) for row in relations
+                        if clean_relation_value(row[2]) in members and clean_relation_value(row[4]) in {"hard_gate", "evidence"})
+        if expanded == members:
+            break
+        members = expanded
+    projection = {
+        "version": 1,
+        "members": sorted(members),
+        "index_rows": sorted(by_name[name] for name in members),
+        "dependency_rows": [row for row in dependency if binding_plan_id(row[0]) in members],
+        "relation_rows": [row for row in relations if clean_relation_value(row[0]) in members or clean_relation_value(row[2]) in members],
+        "shared_write_rows": [row for row in shared if clean_relation_value(row[0]) in members or clean_relation_value(row[2]) in members],
+        "blocker_rows": [row for row, targets in scopes if targets & members],
+    }
+    related = []
+    for name in sorted(members):
+        relative = binding_path("docs/" + extract_plan_link(by_name[name][0]))
+        path = binding_file(root, relative)
+        related.append({"plan": name, "path": relative, "sha256": sha256_file(path)})
+    return projection, related
+
+
+def make_attestation_binding(root, plan_map_relative, plan_name, files):
+    if not files:
+        raise ValueError("binding files 不能为空")
+    entries = []
+    seen = set()
+    for value in files:
+        relative = binding_path(value)
+        if relative in seen:
+            raise ValueError(f"binding 文件重复：{relative}")
+        seen.add(relative)
+        entries.append({"path": relative, "sha256": sha256_file(binding_file(root, relative))})
+    projection, related = binding_metadata(root, plan_map_relative, plan_name)
+    head = None
+    try:
+        result = subprocess.run(["git", "rev-parse", "--verify", "HEAD"], cwd=root, capture_output=True, text=True, check=False)
+        value = result.stdout.strip()
+        if result.returncode == 0 and re.fullmatch(r"[0-9a-f]{40}|[0-9a-f]{64}", value):
+            head = value
+    except OSError:
+        pass
+    return {"version": 1, "files": sorted(entries, key=lambda entry: entry["path"]),
+            "related_plans": related, "plan_map_projection": projection,
+            "plan_map_projection_sha256": canonical_sha256(projection),
+            "revision": {"source": "working_tree", "head": head}}
+
+
+def validate_attestation_binding(attestation):
+    """验证保存的结构，不访问已可能变化/删除的文件。"""
+    binding = attestation["binding"]
+    if not isinstance(binding, dict) or type(binding.get("version")) is not int or binding["version"] != 1:
+        raise ValueError("binding version 必须为 1")
+    projection = binding.get("plan_map_projection")
+    columns = {"index_rows": 6, "dependency_rows": 3, "relation_rows": 7, "shared_write_rows": 9, "blocker_rows": 5}
+    if not isinstance(projection, dict) or set(projection) != {"version", "members", *columns}:
+        raise ValueError("binding plan_map_projection 结构非法")
+    if type(projection["version"]) is not int or projection["version"] != 1:
+        raise ValueError("binding projection version 必须为 1")
+    members = projection["members"]
+    if (not isinstance(members, list) or not members or any(not isinstance(name, str) or not name for name in members)
+            or members != sorted(set(members)) or attestation.get("plan") not in members):
+        raise ValueError("binding projection members 非法")
+    for field, width in columns.items():
+        rows = projection[field]
+        if (not isinstance(rows, list) or any(not isinstance(row, list) or len(row) != width
+                or any(not isinstance(cell, str) for cell in row) for row in rows)):
+            raise ValueError(f"binding {field} 必须为固定列数的字符串二维数组")
+        if rows != sorted(rows) or len({tuple(row) for row in rows}) != len(rows):
+            raise ValueError(f"binding {field} 未排序或重复")
+    if binding.get("plan_map_projection_sha256") != canonical_sha256(projection):
+        raise ValueError("binding projection hash 不匹配")
+    for field, key in [("files", "path"), ("related_plans", "plan")]:
+        entries = binding.get(field)
+        if not isinstance(entries, list) or not entries:
+            raise ValueError(f"binding {field} 不能为空")
+        keys = []
+        for entry in entries:
+            if not isinstance(entry, dict) or not isinstance(entry.get(key), str) or not entry[key]:
+                raise ValueError(f"binding {field} 条目非法")
+            if binding_path(entry.get("path")) != entry["path"]:
+                raise ValueError(f"binding {field} 路径未规范化")
+            if not isinstance(entry.get("sha256"), str) or not re.fullmatch(r"[0-9a-f]{64}", entry["sha256"]):
+                raise ValueError(f"binding {field} sha256 非法")
+            keys.append(entry[key])
+        if keys != sorted(set(keys)):
+            raise ValueError(f"binding {field} 未排序或重复")
+    related = binding["related_plans"]
+    if [entry["plan"] for entry in related] != members:
+        raise ValueError("binding related_plans 与 members 不一致")
+    index_names = [binding_plan_id(row[0]) for row in projection["index_rows"]]
+    if sorted(index_names) != members:
+        raise ValueError("binding index_rows 与 members 不一致")
+    for entry in related:
+        row = next(row for row in projection["index_rows"] if binding_plan_id(row[0]) == entry["plan"])
+        link = extract_plan_link(row[0])
+        if not link or entry["path"] != binding_path("docs/" + link):
+            raise ValueError("binding related_plans 与索引路径不一致")
+    target = next(entry for entry in related if entry["plan"] == attestation["plan"])
+    if target["path"] != attestation.get("plan_path") or target["sha256"] != attestation.get("plan_sha256"):
+        raise ValueError("binding 目标计划与原快照字段不一致")
+    binding_path(attestation.get("plan_map_path"))
+    revision = binding.get("revision")
+    if not isinstance(revision, dict) or revision.get("source") != "working_tree" or "head" not in revision:
+        raise ValueError("binding revision 非法")
+    head = revision["head"]
+    if head is not None and (not isinstance(head, str) or not re.fullmatch(r"[0-9a-f]{40}|[0-9a-f]{64}", head)):
+        raise ValueError("binding HEAD 非法")
+    if "purpose" not in attestation:
+        raise ValueError("binding 必须使用 purpose 快照")
+
+
+def attestation_binding_drift(root, attestation):
+    binding = attestation["binding"]
+    changed = []
+    for entry in binding["files"]:
+        if sha256_file(binding_file(root, entry["path"])) != entry["sha256"]:
+            changed.append(entry["path"])
+    projection, related = binding_metadata(root, attestation["plan_map_path"], attestation["plan"])
+    if projection != binding["plan_map_projection"] or related != binding["related_plans"]:
+        changed.append("相关计划或 PLAN_MAP 投影")
+    return changed
+
+
+def attestation_paths(root):
+    directory = binding_file(root, "docs/attestations", require_file=False)
+    try:
+        directory.stat()
+    except FileNotFoundError:
+        return []
+    # glob 会把 PermissionError 当作空结果；证据清单必须显式枚举。
+    return sorted(path for path in directory.iterdir() if path.name.endswith(".json"))
+
+
+def has_attestation_binding(root):
+    for path in attestation_paths(root):
+        if path.is_symlink():
+            return True
+        try:
+            data = json.loads(path.read_text(encoding="utf-8"))
+        except (UnicodeError, json.JSONDecodeError):
+            continue
+        if isinstance(data, dict) and "binding" in data:
+            return True
+    return False
+
+
 def create_attestation(
     root,
     plan_map,
@@ -705,7 +1195,20 @@ def create_attestation(
     purpose=None,
     supersedes="",
     review_status="current",
+    attest_files=None,
 ):
+    binding = None
+    if attest_files is not None:
+        if errors:
+            return None
+        try:
+            if purpose not in ATTESTATION_PURPOSES:
+                raise ValueError("--attest-file 必须与 --attest 和 --attest-purpose 一起使用")
+            binding_file(root, relative_to_root(plan_map, root))
+            binding = make_attestation_binding(root, relative_to_root(plan_map, root), plan_name, attest_files)
+        except (ValueError, OSError, UnicodeError) as exc:
+            fail(errors, f"{plan_name}: 无法创建 binding 快照：{exc}")
+            return None
     data = plans.get(plan_name)
     if data is None:
         fail(errors, f"{plan_name}: 未登记计划，无法创建完成快照")
@@ -714,14 +1217,22 @@ def create_attestation(
         fail(errors, f"{plan_name}: 计划文件不存在，无法创建完成快照")
         return None
 
+    try:
+        plan_hash = sha256_file(data["path"])
+        map_hash = sha256_file(plan_map)
+    except OSError as exc:
+        if binding is None:
+            raise
+        fail(errors, f"{plan_name}: binding 快照读取失败：{exc}")
+        return None
     attestation = {
         "plan": plan_name,
         "phase": data["phase"],
         "status": data["status"],
         "plan_path": relative_to_root(data["path"], root),
         "plan_map_path": relative_to_root(plan_map, root),
-        "plan_sha256": sha256_file(data["path"]),
-        "plan_map_sha256": sha256_file(plan_map),
+        "plan_sha256": plan_hash,
+        "plan_map_sha256": map_hash,
         "created_at": datetime.now(timezone.utc).replace(microsecond=0).isoformat().replace("+00:00", "Z"),
         "created_by": "plan-governance",
         "reason": "阶段完成快照",
@@ -752,6 +1263,43 @@ def create_attestation(
     else:
         filename = f"{plan_name}.json"
     target = root / "docs" / "attestations" / filename
+    if binding is not None:
+        attestation["binding"] = binding
+        try:
+            relative = relative_to_root(target, root)
+            binding_file(root, relative, require_file=False)
+            if target.exists() or relative in {entry["path"] for entry in binding["files"]}:
+                raise ValueError("binding 快照目标已存在或引用自身")
+            validate_attestation_binding(attestation)
+            preflight_errors = []
+            warn_attestation_drift([], root, plans, errors=preflight_errors, strict=True,
+                                   pending=(target, attestation), enforce_binding_review=False)
+            if preflight_errors:
+                errors.extend(preflight_errors)
+                return None
+        except (ValueError, OSError, UnicodeError) as exc:
+            fail(errors, f"{plan_name}: binding 创建预检失败：{exc}")
+            return None
+        created_directory = False
+        created_file = False
+        try:
+            if not target.parent.exists():
+                target.parent.mkdir()
+                created_directory = True
+            with target.open("x", encoding="utf-8") as stream:
+                created_file = True
+                stream.write(json.dumps(attestation, ensure_ascii=False, indent=2) + "\n")
+        except OSError as exc:
+            fail(errors, f"{plan_name}: binding 快照写入失败：{exc}")
+            for artifact, created in [(target, created_file), (target.parent, created_directory)]:
+                if not created:
+                    continue
+                try:
+                    artifact.unlink() if artifact == target else artifact.rmdir()
+                except OSError as cleanup_error:
+                    fail(errors, f"binding 清理失败，残留路径 {artifact}：{cleanup_error}")
+            return None
+        return target
     target.parent.mkdir(parents=True, exist_ok=True)
     target.write_text(json.dumps(attestation, ensure_ascii=False, indent=2) + "\n", encoding="utf-8")
     return target
@@ -764,34 +1312,57 @@ def attestation_issue(warnings, errors, strict, message):
         warn(warnings, message)
 
 
-def warn_attestation_drift(warnings, root, plans, errors=None, strict=False, reports=None):
+def warn_attestation_drift(warnings, root, plans, errors=None, strict=False, reports=None,
+                           pending=None, enforce_binding_review=True):
     errors = errors if errors is not None else []
     attestations_dir = root / "docs" / "attestations"
-    if not attestations_dir.exists():
+    try:
+        paths = attestation_paths(root)
+        scoped_checks = pending is not None or has_attestation_binding(root)
+    except (ValueError, OSError) as exc:
+        attestation_issue(warnings, errors, strict, f"{attestations_dir}: 快照清单无法读取：{exc}")
         return
 
     records = []
-    for path in sorted(attestations_dir.glob("*.json")):
+    if pending is not None:
+        paths.append(pending[0])
+    for path in sorted(paths):
+        if path.is_symlink():
+            attestation_issue(warnings, errors, strict, f"{path}: 快照不能是 symlink")
+            continue
         try:
-            attestation = json.loads(path.read_text(encoding="utf-8"))
+            attestation = pending[1] if pending is not None and path == pending[0] else json.loads(path.read_text(encoding="utf-8"))
+        except OSError as exc:
+            attestation_issue(warnings, errors, strict, f"{path}: attestation 无法读取：{exc}")
+            continue
         except (UnicodeDecodeError, json.JSONDecodeError) as exc:
             warn(warnings, f"{path}: attestation JSON 无法解析：{exc}")
             continue
+        if not isinstance(attestation, dict):
+            warn(warnings, f"{path}: attestation JSON 必须为对象")
+            continue
 
+        bound = "binding" in attestation
+        invalid_structure = False
         plan_name = str(attestation.get("plan", "")).strip()
         if not plan_name or plan_name not in plans:
-            warn(warnings, f"{path}: 快照引用了未登记计划：{plan_name or '<missing>'}")
-            continue
+            message = f"{path}: 快照引用了未登记计划：{plan_name or '<missing>'}"
+            if not bound:
+                warn(warnings, message)
+                continue
+            # 删除计划也是可被后继替代的内容变化，记录不能消失。
+            warn(warnings, message)
 
         legacy = "purpose" not in attestation
         purpose = str(attestation.get("purpose", "phase_completion")).strip()
         if purpose not in ATTESTATION_PURPOSES:
             attestation_issue(warnings, errors, strict, f"{path}: attestation purpose 非法：{purpose or '<missing>'}")
-            continue
+            if not bound:
+                continue
+            invalid_structure = True
         snapshot_id = str(attestation.get("snapshot_id", "")).strip()
         review_status = str(attestation.get("review_status", "current")).strip()
         supersedes = attestation.get("supersedes", "")
-        invalid_structure = False
         if not legacy:
             for field in ["snapshot_id", "supersedes", "review_status"]:
                 if field not in attestation:
@@ -817,6 +1388,27 @@ def warn_attestation_drift(warnings, root, plans, errors=None, strict=False, rep
             normalized_supersedes = ""
             invalid_structure = True
 
+        binding_changes = []
+        if bound:
+            try:
+                validate_attestation_binding(attestation)
+                if path != (pending[0] if pending is not None else None):
+                    binding_file(root, path.relative_to(root).as_posix())
+            except (ValueError, OSError, UnicodeError) as exc:
+                attestation_issue(warnings, errors, strict, f"{path}: binding 结构非法：{exc}")
+                invalid_structure = True
+            if not invalid_structure:
+                try:
+                    binding_changes = attestation_binding_drift(root, attestation)
+                except (ValueError, OSError, UnicodeError) as exc:
+                    binding_changes = [str(exc)]
+            records.append({"path": path, "relative_path": path.relative_to(root).as_posix(),
+                            "plan": plan_name, "purpose": purpose, "review_status": review_status,
+                            "supersedes": normalized_supersedes, "drifted": bool(binding_changes),
+                            "legacy": legacy, "invalid_structure": invalid_structure,
+                            "bound": True, "binding_changes": binding_changes})
+            continue
+
         plan_path_value = attestation.get("plan_path", "")
         plan_map_path_value = attestation.get("plan_map_path", "docs/PLAN_MAP.md")
         plan_path_rel = safe_relative_path(plan_path_value)
@@ -829,6 +1421,13 @@ def warn_attestation_drift(warnings, root, plans, errors=None, strict=False, rep
             continue
         plan_path = root / plan_path_rel
         plan_map_path = root / plan_map_path_rel
+        if scoped_checks:
+            try:
+                binding_file(root, plan_path_rel)
+                binding_file(root, plan_map_path_rel)
+            except (ValueError, OSError) as exc:
+                attestation_issue(warnings, errors, strict, f"{path}: 混合快照路径读取预检失败：{exc}")
+                continue
         if not plan_path.exists():
             warn(warnings, f"{path}: 快照引用的计划文件不存在：{plan_path}")
             continue
@@ -837,11 +1436,18 @@ def warn_attestation_drift(warnings, root, plans, errors=None, strict=False, rep
             continue
 
         drifted = False
-        if sha256_file(plan_path) != attestation.get("plan_sha256"):
-            warn(warnings, f"{path}: {plan_name} 计划文件 hash 已变化，需要人工复核")
-            drifted = True
-        if sha256_file(plan_map_path) != attestation.get("plan_map_sha256"):
-            warn(warnings, f"{path}: PLAN_MAP.md hash 已变化，需要人工复核")
+        try:
+            if sha256_file(plan_path) != attestation.get("plan_sha256"):
+                warn(warnings, f"{path}: {plan_name} 计划文件 hash 已变化，需要人工复核")
+                drifted = True
+            if sha256_file(plan_map_path) != attestation.get("plan_map_sha256"):
+                warn(warnings, f"{path}: PLAN_MAP.md hash 已变化，需要人工复核")
+                drifted = True
+        except OSError as exc:
+            if not scoped_checks:
+                raise
+            # 内容不可读不使已存在的替代目标消失，也不阻止后续绑定报告。
+            attestation_issue(warnings, errors, strict, f"{path}: 混合快照内容读取失败：{exc}")
             drifted = True
         records.append(
             {
@@ -854,6 +1460,7 @@ def warn_attestation_drift(warnings, root, plans, errors=None, strict=False, rep
                 "drifted": drifted,
                 "legacy": legacy,
                 "invalid_structure": invalid_structure,
+                "bound": False,
             }
         )
 
@@ -882,6 +1489,10 @@ def warn_attestation_drift(warnings, root, plans, errors=None, strict=False, rep
             attestation_issue(warnings, errors, strict, f"{record['path']}: supersedes 不能指向自身")
             record["invalid_structure"] = True
             continue
+        if target_record["bound"] and not record["bound"]:
+            attestation_issue(warnings, errors, strict, f"{record['path']}: binding 前驱必须由带 binding 的后继替代")
+            record["invalid_structure"] = True
+            continue
         incoming.setdefault(target, []).append(record["relative_path"])
         edges.setdefault(record["relative_path"], []).append(target)
 
@@ -892,6 +1503,22 @@ def warn_attestation_drift(warnings, root, plans, errors=None, strict=False, rep
             if node in by_path:
                 by_path[node]["invalid_structure"] = True
 
+    # 新范围关系的结构错误向后继传播，不能通过损坏中间节点压掉前驱。
+    changed = True
+    while changed:
+        changed = False
+        for record in records:
+            target_record = by_path.get(record["supersedes"])
+            if (target_record and (record["bound"] or target_record["bound"])
+                    and target_record["invalid_structure"] and not record["invalid_structure"]):
+                attestation_issue(warnings, errors, strict, f"{record['path']}: supersedes 目标结构无效")
+                record["invalid_structure"] = True
+                changed = True
+    incoming = {target: [source for source in sources
+                        if not (by_path[target]["bound"] or by_path[source]["bound"])
+                        or not (by_path[target]["invalid_structure"] or by_path[source]["invalid_structure"])]
+                for target, sources in incoming.items()}
+
     current_by_key = {}
     for record in records:
         effective = record["review_status"]
@@ -918,6 +1545,18 @@ def warn_attestation_drift(warnings, root, plans, errors=None, strict=False, rep
                 if record["relative_path"] in paths:
                     record["effective_status"] = "needs_review"
 
+    if enforce_binding_review:
+        for record in records:
+            if not record["bound"]:
+                continue
+            pending_review = record["drifted"] or record["review_status"] == "needs_review"
+            if pending_review:
+                details = ", ".join(record["binding_changes"]) or "声明待复核"
+                # 有效替代仅免除历史内容漂移，存储结构错误在上面仍阻断。
+                retired = bool(incoming.get(record["relative_path"]))
+                label = "binding 历史内容已变化，已有有效替代" if retired else "binding 需要复核"
+                attestation_issue(warnings, errors, strict and not retired, f"{record['path']}: {label}：{details}")
+
     if reports is not None:
         for record in records:
             reports.append(
@@ -978,6 +1617,8 @@ def load_plan_records(root, errors):
 def plan_index_issues(plan_map_text):
     """检查工作集入口依赖的计划索引结构，不改变既有基础检查语义。"""
     issues = []
+    if len(re.findall(r"^##\s+计划索引\s*$", mask_fenced_code(plan_map_text), re.MULTILINE)) > 1:
+        issues.append("PLAN_MAP 存在重复计划索引章节，无法安全派生工作集")
     seen = set()
     for row_index, row in enumerate(table_rows(plan_map_text, "计划索引"), start=1):
         if len(row) < 6:
@@ -998,38 +1639,163 @@ def plan_index_issues(plan_map_text):
 
 
 def unresolved_current_blockers(plan_text):
-    blockers = []
+    return problem_blockers(plan_text)[0]
+
+
+CLOSED_BLOCKER_STATES = {"已决定", "已收敛", "已完成", "已解决", "已关闭", "无", "resolved", "closed", "done"}
+OPEN_BLOCKER_STATES = {"open", "待确认", "未解决", "待处理", "未决定", "待补充"}
+
+
+def blocker_is_open(impact, state, label, issues):
+    impact, state = impact.strip().lower(), state.strip().lower()
+    if impact in {"否", "no"} or state in CLOSED_BLOCKER_STATES:
+        return False
+    if impact not in {"是", "yes"}:
+        issues.append(f"{label}: 是否阻塞当前阶段为空或未知：{impact or '(空)'}")
+        return False
+    if state not in OPEN_BLOCKER_STATES:
+        issues.append(f"{label}: 当前阻塞状态为空或未知：{state or '(空)'}")
+    return True
+
+
+def problem_blockers(plan_text):
+    blockers, issues = [], []
     for row in table_rows(plan_text, "未决问题"):
-        if len(row) < 4 or not re.search(r"\b(Yes|是)\b", row[2]):
+        if not any(row):
             continue
-        state = row[3].strip()
-        if state in {"已决定", "已收敛", "已完成", "无"}:
+        if len(row) < 4:
+            issues.append("未决问题表字段不足，无法确认当前阻塞")
             continue
-        blockers.append(row[0].strip() or "未命名阻塞项")
-    return blockers
+        label = row[0] or "未命名阻塞项"
+        if blocker_is_open(row[2], row[3], label, issues):
+            blockers.append(label)
+    return blockers, issues
+
+
+def map_blockers(plan_map_text):
+    """只按显式 ID/链接归属；无法归属的开放行保留为全局诊断。"""
+    names = {
+        Path(link).stem for row in table_rows(plan_map_text, "计划索引")
+        if row and (link := extract_plan_link(row[0]))
+    }
+    result, issues = {}, []
+    if len(re.findall(r"^##\s+当前阻塞项\s*$", mask_fenced_code(plan_map_text), re.MULTILINE)) > 1:
+        issues.append("PLAN_MAP 存在重复当前阻塞项章节，无法确认阻塞来源")
+    for row in table_rows(plan_map_text, "当前阻塞项"):
+        if not any(row):
+            continue
+        if len(row) < 5:
+            issues.append("PLAN_MAP 当前阻塞项字段不足，无法归属")
+            continue
+        label = row[0] or "未命名阻塞项"
+        if not blocker_is_open(row[3], row[4], f"PLAN_MAP {label}", issues):
+            continue
+        scope = re.sub(r"\[[^\]]+\]\((?:\./)?plans/([^/)]+)\.md(?:#[^)]*)?\)",
+                       r"\1", row[2]).replace("`", "")
+        targets = set(filter(None, re.split(r"[,，、/;；\s]+", scope.strip())))
+        if not targets or targets - names:
+            issues.append(f"PLAN_MAP 当前阻塞项 {label} 的影响范围无法归属：{row[2]}")
+            continue
+        for name in sorted(targets):
+            result.setdefault(name, []).append(label)
+    return result, issues
+
+
+def structural_ambiguities(plan_text, phase):
+    issues = []
+    current = top_level_section(plan_text, "当前阶段") or ""
+    sections = [(plan_text, "当前阶段"), (current, "阶段准入摘要"),
+                (plan_text, "最新独立准入复核"), (plan_text, "阶段路线图"),
+                (plan_text, "独立复核记录"), (plan_text, "未决问题")]
+    if "复核策略" in key_value_table(fixed_section(current, "阶段准入摘要")):
+        sections.extend([(plan_text, "最新阶段复核"), (plan_text, "阶段复核记录")])
+    for text, title in sections:
+        level = "##" if title in {"当前阶段", "未决问题"} else "#+"
+        if len(re.findall(rf"^{level}\s+{re.escape(title)}\s*$", mask_fenced_code(text), re.MULTILINE)) > 1:
+            issues.append(f"重复结构化章节：{title}")
+        if title in {"阶段准入摘要", "最新独立准入复核", "最新阶段复核"}:
+            seen = set()
+            for row in markdown_table_rows(fixed_section(text, title)):
+                if len(row) < 2 or row[0] == "字段":
+                    continue
+                if row[0] in seen:
+                    issues.append(f"{title} 存在重复字段：{row[0]}")
+                seen.add(row[0])
+    if len([r for r in phase_roadmap_rows(plan_text) if r[0] == phase]) > 1:
+        issues.append(f"阶段路线图重复当前阶段：{phase}")
+    return issues
+
+
+def phase_gate(plan_map_text, plan_name, data, plan_text):
+    """共享只读派生；严重级别由 check/workset/hook 的入口契约决定。"""
+    issues = structural_ambiguities(plan_text, data["phase"])
+    warnings = []
+    review_state = risk_review_state(plan_text, data["phase"])
+    check_phase_structure(plan_name, data, plan_text, True, warnings, issues, review_state)
+    if review_state["enabled"]:
+        issues.extend(review_state["issues"] + review_state["blockers"])
+    if data["status"] in ACTIVE and is_placeholder(data["phase"]):
+        issues.append("PLAN_MAP 当前阶段为空或占位")
+    details, detail_issues = problem_blockers(plan_text)
+    issues.extend(detail_issues)
+    mapped, _ = map_blockers(plan_map_text)
+    indexed = mapped.get(plan_name, [])
+    summary = current_summary(plan_text)
+    value = summary.get("当前阻塞项", "").strip()
+    declared = [value] if value and not is_placeholder(value) else []
+    blockers = list(dict.fromkeys(details + indexed + declared))
+    if blockers:
+        issues.append("当前阶段存在未解决阻塞项：" + "；".join(blockers))
+        if ((details or indexed) and value == "无") or ((details or declared) and not indexed):
+            issues.append("当前阻塞来源需同步：PLAN_MAP 索引、未决问题或阶段准入摘要缺失/冲突")
+    if review_state["enabled"]:
+        blockers.extend(review_state["blockers"])
+    else:
+        review = key_value_table(fixed_section(plan_text, "最新独立准入复核"))
+        conclusion = review.get("结论", "").strip()
+        if review.get("阶段") == data["phase"] and conclusion.startswith(("未通过", "不通过", "失败", "不满足", "拒绝")):
+            blockers.append("最新独立准入复核：" + conclusion)
+            if data["status"] not in ACTIVE:
+                issues.append(blockers[-1])
+    _, recent_warnings = current_recent_evidence(plan_text, data["phase"])
+    warnings.extend(recent_warnings)
+    issues = [message.removeprefix(f"{plan_name}: ") for message in issues]
+    return {"blockers": list(dict.fromkeys(blockers)), "issues": list(dict.fromkeys(issues)),
+            "warnings": warnings, "review": review_state}
+
+
+def check_phase_readiness(plan_map_text, plan_name, data, plan_text, strict, warnings, errors):
+    if data["status"] not in WARNING_ACTIVE:
+        return
+    gate = phase_gate(plan_map_text, plan_name, data, plan_text)
+    warnings.extend(f"{plan_name}: {message}" for message in gate["warnings"])
+    for message in gate["issues"]:
+        # 缺失材料的设计计划仍合法；其显式冲突和阻塞保持可见而不强制准入。
+        readiness_issue(warnings, errors, strict and data["status"] in ACTIVE, f"{plan_name}: {message}")
 
 
 def top_level_section(text, heading):
     pattern = re.compile(rf"^##\s+{re.escape(heading)}\s*$", re.MULTILINE)
-    match = pattern.search(text)
+    masked = mask_fenced_code(text)
+    match = pattern.search(masked)
     if not match:
         return None
     tail = text[match.end():]
-    next_heading = re.search(r"^##\s+", tail, re.MULTILINE)
+    next_heading = re.search(r"^##\s+", masked[match.end():], re.MULTILINE)
     return tail[: next_heading.start()] if next_heading else tail
 
 
 def current_summary(plan_text):
-    return key_value_table(markdown_section(top_level_section(plan_text, "当前阶段"), ["阶段准入摘要"]))
+    return key_value_table(fixed_section(top_level_section(plan_text, "当前阶段"), "阶段准入摘要"))
 
 
 def current_review_passes(plan_text, phase):
-    review = key_value_table(markdown_section(plan_text, ["最新独立准入复核"]))
+    review = key_value_table(fixed_section(plan_text, "最新独立准入复核"))
     return review.get("阶段") == phase and review.get("结论", "").startswith("通过")
 
 
 def structured_next_action(plan_text):
-    section = top_level_section(plan_text, "当前阶段") or ""
+    section = mask_fenced_code(top_level_section(plan_text, "当前阶段") or "")
     values = key_value_table(section)
     value = values.get("下一动作", "").strip()
     if not value:
@@ -1044,12 +1810,15 @@ def structured_next_action(plan_text):
         "implement": "implement",
         "无": "none",
         "none": "none",
+        "等待用户验收": "none",
     }
     if not value:
         return {"state": "unknown", "kind": "unknown", "reason": "缺少结构化下一动作"}
     kind = mapping.get(value.lower(), "unknown")
     if kind == "unknown":
         return {"state": "unknown", "kind": "unknown", "reason": f"下一动作值无法识别：{value}"}
+    if value == "等待用户验收":
+        return {"state": "known", "kind": "none", "reason": "等待用户验收；技术完成不自动关闭计划"}
     return {"state": "known", "kind": kind, "reason": "来自当前阶段结构化下一动作"}
 
 
@@ -1287,11 +2056,22 @@ def validate_relation_graph(plan_map_text, plans):
     return errors, warnings
 
 
-def recent_evidence(plan_text):
+def current_recent_evidence(plan_text, phase=None):
     current = top_level_section(plan_text, "当前阶段") or ""
-    section = markdown_section(current, ["最近实施/验证记录"])
+    section = fixed_section(current, "最近实施/验证记录")
+    warnings = []
+    if section is None and phase:
+        for title in [f"{phase} 最近验证记录", f"{phase} 最近实施/验证记录"]:
+            section = fixed_section(current, title)
+            if section is not None:
+                warnings.append(f"兼容记录标题 `{title}`，请使用固定标题 `最近实施/验证记录`")
+                break
     rows = markdown_table_rows(section)
-    return [row for row in rows if len(row) >= 2 and row[0] not in {"日期", "字段", "类型"}]
+    return [row for row in rows if len(row) >= 2 and row[0] not in {"日期", "字段", "类型"}], warnings
+
+
+def recent_evidence(plan_text, phase=None):
+    return current_recent_evidence(plan_text, phase)[0]
 
 
 def workset_payload(root, include_history=False, strict=False):
@@ -1309,6 +2089,9 @@ def workset_payload(root, include_history=False, strict=False):
         return output, 1
 
     index_issues = plan_index_issues(plan_map_text)
+    _, blocker_index_issues = map_blockers(plan_map_text)
+    output["warnings"].extend(blocker_index_issues)
+    strict_failures.extend(blocker_index_issues)
     relation_errors, relation_warnings = validate_relation_graph(plan_map_text, plans)
     output["warnings"].extend(relation_warnings)
     if relation_errors:
@@ -1326,7 +2109,12 @@ def workset_payload(root, include_history=False, strict=False):
             continue
         plan_text = read_utf8(path, errors)
         summary = current_summary(plan_text)
-        blockers = unresolved_current_blockers(plan_text)
+        gate = phase_gate(plan_map_text, name, data, plan_text)
+        blockers = gate["blockers"]
+        output["warnings"].extend(f"{name}: {message}" for message in gate["issues"] + gate["warnings"])
+        if data["status"] in ACTIVE:
+            strict_failures.extend(gate["issues"])
+        uncertain = gate["issues"] or blocker_index_issues or relation_errors
         if blockers:
             readiness = "blocked"
             action = {
@@ -1334,9 +2122,12 @@ def workset_payload(root, include_history=False, strict=False):
                 "kind": "resolve_blocker",
                 "reason": "当前阶段存在未解决阻塞项",
             }
+        elif uncertain and data["status"] in WARNING_ACTIVE:
+            readiness = "unknown"
+            action = {"state": "unknown", "kind": "unknown", "reason": "准入信息存在缺失或冲突，见 warnings"}
         elif data["status"] == "待实施":
             readiness = "ready"
-            action = {"state": "known", "kind": "implement", "reason": "计划状态为待实施"}
+            action = {"state": "known", "kind": "implement", "reason": "待实施计划的结构化准入检查通过"}
         elif data["status"] == "实施中":
             readiness = "in_progress"
             action = structured_next_action(plan_text)
@@ -1352,6 +2143,17 @@ def workset_payload(root, include_history=False, strict=False):
                     "kind": "complete_step0",
                     "reason": f"阶段准入摘要缺少或占位字段：{', '.join(missing)}",
                 }
+            elif gate["review"]["enabled"]:
+                readiness = "design"
+                kind = "sync" if gate["review"]["passed"] else gate["review"]["pending_action"]
+                action = {
+                    "state": "known" if kind else "unknown",
+                    "kind": kind or "unknown",
+                    "reason": ("当前阶段复核通过，待同步 PLAN_MAP 准入状态" if kind == "sync" else
+                               "低风险阶段待自验" if kind == "verify" else
+                               "当前阶段待独立复核" if kind == "independent_review" else
+                               "当前阶段复核声明无法确定"),
+                }
             elif not current_review_passes(plan_text, data["phase"]):
                 readiness = "design"
                 action = {
@@ -1375,7 +2177,7 @@ def workset_payload(root, include_history=False, strict=False):
                 "blockers": blockers,
                 "next_action": action,
                 "parallel": parallel_summary(plan_map_text, name, relation_valid=not relation_errors),
-                "recent_evidence": recent_evidence(plan_text),
+                "recent_evidence": recent_evidence(plan_text, data["phase"]),
             }
         )
 
@@ -1402,7 +2204,8 @@ def print_workset_text(payload, strict=False):
         if item["blockers"]:
             print(f"  blockers: {'；'.join(item['blockers'])}")
     for warning in payload["warnings"]:
-        print(f"{'ERROR' if strict else 'WARNING'}: {warning}")
+        level = "ERROR" if strict and "兼容记录标题" not in warning else "WARNING"
+        print(f"{level}: {warning}")
 
 
 def run_workset(root, as_json=False, include_history=False, strict=False):
@@ -1429,6 +2232,8 @@ def parse_args(argv):
         help="将待实施/实施中计划的阶段准入结构缺陷从 WARNING 提升为 ERROR。",
     )
     parser.add_argument("--attest", metavar="PLAN", help="为已登记计划创建或覆盖完成快照。")
+    parser.add_argument("--attest-file", action="append", metavar="PATH",
+                        help="可重复：与 --attest/--attest-purpose 显式绑定被审查的普通文件。")
     parser.add_argument(
         "--attest-purpose",
         choices=sorted(ATTESTATION_PURPOSES),
@@ -1455,6 +2260,9 @@ def parse_args(argv):
 
 def main(argv=None):
     args = parse_args(sys.argv[1:] if argv is None else argv)
+    if args.attest_file is not None and (not args.attest or not args.attest_purpose or args.workset):
+        print("ERROR: --attest-file 必须与 --attest/--attest-purpose 一起使用，不能用于 workset")
+        return 1
     if args.workset:
         return run_workset(
             Path(args.mode_root or args.root),
@@ -1468,16 +2276,56 @@ def main(argv=None):
     errors = []
     warnings = []
 
+    try:
+        bound_input = args.attest_file is not None or (args.check_attestations and has_attestation_binding(root))
+    except (ValueError, OSError) as exc:
+        level = "ERROR" if args.strict_readiness else "WARNING"
+        print(f"{level}: 快照清单无法读取：{exc}")
+        return 1 if args.strict_readiness else 0
+    unsafe_map = False
+    if bound_input:
+        try:
+            binding_file(root, "docs/PLAN_MAP.md")
+        except (ValueError, OSError) as exc:
+            if args.attest_file is not None:
+                print(f"ERROR: binding 创建预检失败：{exc}")
+                return 1
+            unsafe_map = True
+    if unsafe_map:
+        reports = []
+        warn_attestation_drift(warnings, root, {}, errors=errors, strict=args.strict_readiness, reports=reports)
+        for warning in warnings:
+            print(f"WARNING: {warning}")
+        for report in reports:
+            print(f"ATTESTATION: {report}")
+        for error in errors:
+            print(f"ERROR: {error}")
+        return 1 if errors else 0
     if not plan_map.exists():
+        if args.check_attestations:
+            reports = []
+            warn_attestation_drift(warnings, root, {}, errors=errors, strict=args.strict_readiness, reports=reports)
+            if reports or errors:
+                for warning in warnings:
+                    print(f"WARNING: {warning}")
+                for report in reports:
+                    print(f"ATTESTATION: {report}")
+                for error in errors:
+                    print(f"ERROR: {error}")
+                return 1 if errors else 0
         print("未找到 docs/PLAN_MAP.md；当前仓库尚未初始化计划治理。")
         return 0
 
     text = read_utf8(plan_map, errors)
+    _, blocker_index_issues = map_blockers(text)
+    for issue in plan_index_issues(text) + blocker_index_issues:
+        readiness_issue(warnings, errors, args.strict_readiness, issue)
     plan_rows = table_rows(text, "计划索引")
     if not plan_rows:
         fail(errors, "docs/PLAN_MAP.md: 缺少计划索引表")
 
     plans = {}
+    unsafe_plans = set()
     for row in plan_rows:
         if len(row) < 2:
             continue
@@ -1497,6 +2345,13 @@ def main(argv=None):
             last_updated_date = date.min
         if link:
             path = docs / link
+            if bound_input:
+                try:
+                    binding_file(root, "docs/" + link)
+                except (ValueError, OSError) as exc:
+                    attestation_issue(warnings, errors, args.attest_file is not None or args.strict_readiness,
+                                      f"{name}: binding 计划读取预检失败：{exc}")
+                    unsafe_plans.add(name)
             if not path.exists():
                 fail(errors, f"docs/PLAN_MAP.md: 引用的计划文件不存在：{link}")
             plans[name] = {
@@ -1509,7 +2364,8 @@ def main(argv=None):
         else:
             fail(errors, f"docs/PLAN_MAP.md: 计划行缺少 docs/plans 链接：{row[0]}")
 
-    relation_errors, relation_warnings = validate_relation_graph(text, plans)
+    readable_plans = {name: data for name, data in plans.items() if name not in unsafe_plans}
+    relation_errors, relation_warnings = validate_relation_graph(text, readable_plans)
     warnings.extend(relation_warnings)
     if args.strict_readiness:
         errors.extend(relation_errors)
@@ -1535,6 +2391,8 @@ def main(argv=None):
     active_plan_targets = {}
     plan_texts = {}
     for name, data in plans.items():
+        if name in unsafe_plans:
+            continue
         plan_text = read_utf8(data["path"], errors)
         plan_texts[name] = plan_text
         if data["status"] in COMPLETED and not has_completion_evidence(plan_text):
@@ -1650,6 +2508,7 @@ def main(argv=None):
             purpose=args.attest_purpose,
             supersedes=args.supersedes or "",
             review_status=args.review_status,
+            attest_files=args.attest_file,
         )
 
     for warning in warnings: