pi2web 0.2.1 → 0.2.8

package/dist/collab/hub.js

@@ -1,14 +1,14 @@
-import { execFile, execFileSync, spawn } from 'node:child_process';
-import { createHash } from 'node:crypto';
-import { createReadStream } from 'node:fs';
-import path from 'node:path';
+import { execFile, execFileSync } from 'node:child_process';
 import { promisify } from 'node:util';
 import { COLLAB_ERRORS } from './types.js';
+import { gitBaseline } from './baseline.js';
+import { similarity } from './similarity.js';
+export { gitBaseline };
+const run = promisify(execFile);
 import { ValidationError, parse } from './validate.js';
 import { advanceRequest, createParticipantRequest, createSessionRequest, debateArgumentRequest, debateArgumentsRequest, escalationRequest, findingsRequest, finalizeRequest, nominationsRequest, participantBudgetRequest, policyPatch, readyRequest, rebindParticipantRequest, recheckRequest, resolveEscalationRequest, scoresRequest, votesRequest, issueVotesRequest, mergeVotesRequest, issueDiscussionsRequest, retryWaitingRequest } from './schemas.js';
 import { analyse, assertScoringCapability, assertScoringPhase, contestedCriteria, finalizeScores, isScoringReadyToAdvance, nextScoringPhase, nominationsSealed, scoresSealed, scoringPanel, scoringProgress, scoringWaitingOn, tallyVotes, votesSealed } from './scoring-flow.js';
 import { applyEscalation, applyHumanRuling, applyWithdraw, approvalSummary, assertCanFileFinding, assertCapability, canSeeOthersFindings, flowError, isOpenIssue, isReadyToAdvance, nextPhase, sessionProgress, stallCheck, waitingOn, currentIssueVotes, issueConsensus, activeContestedIssueIds, pendingCrossVoters, owedIssueVoteIds } from './review-flow.js';
-const run = promisify(execFile);
 /**
  * Shared rulebook handed to every seat. A reviewer that does not know the panel size, the vote semantics, or
  * what happens to a contested finding cannot calibrate anything: the first live panels produced one reviewer
@@ -23,71 +23,17 @@ const SEVERITY_GUIDE = {
     nit: 'Style, naming, or wording. Never blocks a merge.'
 };
 const REQUIRED_ACTION_GUIDE = {
-    must_fix: 'Must not merge with this unfixed.', should_fix: 'Fix in this change unless there is a reason not to.',
-    discuss: 'A judgment call that needs a decision, not necessarily a code change.', fyi: 'Recorded for awareness only.'
+    must_fix: 'Must not merge with this unfixed.',
+    should_fix: 'Fix in this change unless there is a reason not to.',
+    discuss: 'A judgment call that needs a decision, not necessarily a code change.',
+    fyi: 'Recorded for awareness only.'
 };
 const VOTE_GUIDE = {
     approve: 'The finding is factually correct at this baseline and in scope for this review. Approve even if you would have rated the severity lower; say so in the rationale.',
-    reject: 'Only when the finding is factually wrong, already handled elsewhere in the code, or outside this review\'s subject. A different severity or a matter of taste is not a reject.'
+    reject: "Only when the finding is factually wrong, already handled elsewhere in the code, or outside this review's subject. A different severity or a matter of taste is not a reject."
 };
 /** How long a queued task may sit undelivered before the human is told that the wake-up is not landing. */
 const UNDELIVERED_TASK_WARNING_MS = 120_000;
-/** Anchors every round to an immutable code state so round N+1 verdicts are not made against round N's memory. */
-export const gitBaseline = async ({ cwd, subject }) => {
-    const git = async (args) => (await run('git', args, { cwd })).stdout;
-    try {
-        const commit = (await git(['rev-parse', 'HEAD'])).trim();
-        let dirtyHash;
-        const status = await git(['status', '--porcelain', '-z']);
-        if (status) {
-            const untracked = (await git(['ls-files', '--others', '--exclude-standard', '-z'])).split('\0').filter(Boolean).sort();
-            // Hashed as a stream, never buffered. A working tree diff can be tens of megabytes, and a diff dropped for
-            // exceeding a buffer would leave a hash of nothing but file names - identical before and after an edit to
-            // those same files, which is exactly what `assertBaselineCurrent()` exists to catch.
-            const hash = createHash('sha256').update(status);
-            await hashStream(hash, spawn('git', ['diff', 'HEAD', '--binary'], { cwd, stdio: ['ignore', 'pipe', 'ignore'] }));
-            for (const relative of untracked) {
-                hash.update(relative).update('\0');
-                // A file removed during capture is already represented by status.
-                await hashStream(hash, createReadStream(path.join(cwd, relative))).catch(() => { });
-            }
-            dirtyHash = `sha256:${hash.digest('hex')}`;
-        }
-        // A commit range such as `main...feature` is only a name: either endpoint can move while HEAD and the
-        // working tree stay identical, which would silently change the code under review. Resolve both endpoints
-        // so the pinned identity covers the range, not just its spelling.
-        let rangeResolved;
-        if (subject.type === 'commit_range') {
-            const expression = subject.value.trim();
-            const endpoints = expression.includes('...') ? expression.split('...') : expression.includes('..') ? expression.split('..') : [expression];
-            const resolved = [];
-            for (const endpoint of endpoints) {
-                const name = endpoint.trim();
-                resolved.push(name ? (await git(['rev-parse', '--verify', `${name}^{commit}`]).catch(() => '')).trim() || `unresolved:${name}` : 'HEAD');
-            }
-            rangeResolved = resolved.join('...');
-        }
-        return { vcs: 'git', commit, range: subject.type === 'commit_range' ? subject.value : undefined, rangeResolved, dirtyHash, paths: subject.type === 'paths' ? subject.value.split(/[\n,]/).map(value => value.trim()).filter(Boolean) : [] };
-    }
-    catch {
-        // Not a git checkout (or git is missing). The hub still works; it just cannot prove code identity.
-        return { vcs: 'none', paths: [] };
-    }
-};
-/** Feeds one stream into a hash, rejecting on failure so a partial read can never pass as "nothing changed". */
-function hashStream(hash, source) {
-    const process = 'stdout' in source ? source : undefined, stream = (process ? process.stdout : source);
-    return new Promise((resolve, reject) => {
-        if (!stream)
-            return reject(new Error('Stream is not readable'));
-        stream.on('data', chunk => hash.update(chunk));
-        stream.on('error', reject);
-        if (!process)
-            return void stream.on('end', resolve);
-        process.on('error', reject);
-        process.on('close', code => code === 0 ? resolve() : reject(new Error(`git exited with ${code}`)));
-    });
-}
 const fieldError = (path, code, message) => ({ path, code, message });
 /**
  * Orchestration layer: authentication, validation, persistence, event emission, and phase advancement.
@@ -106,15 +52,30 @@ export class CollabHub {
         this.resolveBaseline = options.resolveBaseline ?? gitBaseline;
         this.now = options.now ?? (() => Date.now());
     }
-    init() { this.store.init(); }
-    shutdown() { this.closed = true; }
-    subscribe(listener) { this.listeners.add(listener); return () => this.listeners.delete(listener); }
-    emit(event) { for (const listener of this.listeners)
-        try {
-            listener(event);
-        }
-        catch { /* A broken subscriber must not roll back committed state. */ } }
-    record(sessionId, type, payload = {}, actorId) { const event = this.store.appendEvent(sessionId, type, payload, actorId); this.emit(event); return event; }
+    init() {
+        this.store.init();
+    }
+    shutdown() {
+        this.closed = true;
+    }
+    subscribe(listener) {
+        this.listeners.add(listener);
+        return () => this.listeners.delete(listener);
+    }
+    emit(event) {
+        for (const listener of this.listeners)
+            try {
+                listener(event);
+            }
+            catch {
+                /* A broken subscriber must not roll back committed state. */
+            }
+    }
+    record(sessionId, type, payload = {}, actorId) {
+        const event = this.store.appendEvent(sessionId, type, payload, actorId);
+        this.emit(event);
+        return event;
+    }
     /** Queues a durable wake-up. The dispatcher prompts; collab_get_task acknowledges collection. */
     push(sessionId, participantId, type, payload) {
         return this.store.pushInbox(sessionId, participantId, type, payload);
@@ -134,7 +95,9 @@ export class CollabHub {
         try {
             this.record(sessionId, type, payload);
         }
-        catch { /* the session may have been removed while a wake-up was in flight */ }
+        catch {
+            /* the session may have been removed while a wake-up was in flight */
+        }
     }
     /**
      * What this seat owes *now*. A wake-up is queued when a phase opens but delivered only once the agent's
@@ -157,26 +120,56 @@ export class CollabHub {
     async createSession(body, resolveCwd) {
         const input = parse(createSessionRequest, body);
         const cwd = await resolveCwd(input.workspaceId, input.relativeCwd);
-        const session = this.store.createSession({ kind: input.kind, title: input.title, workspaceId: input.workspaceId, cwd, subject: input.subject, policy: input.policy });
-        this.record(session.sessionId, 'session_created', { kind: session.kind, title: session.title, cwd, subject: session.subject });
+        const session = this.store.createSession({
+            kind: input.kind,
+            title: input.title,
+            workspaceId: input.workspaceId,
+            cwd,
+            subject: input.subject,
+            policy: input.policy
+        });
+        this.record(session.sessionId, 'session_created', {
+            kind: session.kind,
+            title: session.title,
+            cwd,
+            subject: session.subject
+        });
         // Scoring has no open-round hand-off, so pin its code before the first panel task is issued.
         if (session.kind === 'scoring')
             await this.captureBaseline(session);
         return session;
     }
-    listSessions(filter = {}) { return this.store.listSessions(filter); }
-    getSession(sessionId) { return this.store.getSession(sessionId); }
+    listSessions(filter = {}) {
+        return this.store.listSessions(filter);
+    }
+    getSession(sessionId) {
+        return this.store.getSession(sessionId);
+    }
     updatePolicy(sessionId, body) {
         const patch = parse(policyPatch, body), session = this.store.getSession(sessionId);
-        const updated = this.store.updateSession(sessionId, { policy: { ...session.policy, ...patch, scoring: { ...session.policy.scoring, ...patch.scoring, scale: { ...session.policy.scoring.scale, ...patch.scoring?.scale } } } });
+        const updated = this.store.updateSession(sessionId, {
+            policy: {
+                ...session.policy,
+                ...patch,
+                scoring: {
+                    ...session.policy.scoring,
+                    ...patch.scoring,
+                    scale: { ...session.policy.scoring.scale, ...patch.scoring?.scale }
+                }
+            }
+        });
         this.record(sessionId, 'policy_updated', { policy: updated.policy });
         return updated;
     }
     /** Phases in which a new seat can still be given a well-defined task; anywhere else it would only deadlock. */
-    registrationPhases(session) { return session.kind === 'scoring' ? ['nominating'] : ['draft', 'implementing', 'collecting']; }
+    registrationPhases(session) {
+        return session.kind === 'scoring' ? ['nominating'] : ['draft', 'implementing', 'collecting'];
+    }
     /** A dedicated collaboration Agent may own only one live seat globally; agentId alone is the bridge identity. */
     assertAgentAvailable(agentId, _sessionId, exceptParticipantId) {
-        const occupied = this.store.findOccupyingParticipantsByAgent(agentId).find(participant => participant.participantId !== exceptParticipantId);
+        const occupied = this.store
+            .findOccupyingParticipantsByAgent(agentId)
+            .find(participant => participant.participantId !== exceptParticipantId);
         if (occupied)
             throw flowError(COLLAB_ERRORS.conflict, `That agent is already registered to a seat in collaboration session ${occupied.sessionId}`);
     }
@@ -191,30 +184,58 @@ export class CollabHub {
             throw flowError(COLLAB_ERRORS.wrongPhase, 'Only a new implementer may be added to a finished review; the reviewer panel remains fixed for recheck');
         if (!preparingRemediation && !this.registrationPhases(session).includes(session.phase))
             throw flowError(COLLAB_ERRORS.wrongPhase, session.kind === 'scoring'
-                // A scoring panel never returns to `nominating` once the rubric is locked, so "wait for the next round"
-                // would be advice an operator cannot act on. Repairing the existing seat is the real path.
-                ? `A scoring panel is fixed once the rubric is locked (the session is in ${session.phase}). Repair the existing seat instead: POST /participants/{participantId}/binding to hand it to another agent, and POST /participants/{participantId}/budget if it ran out of tokens.`
+                ? // A scoring panel never returns to `nominating` once the rubric is locked, so "wait for the next round"
+                    // would be advice an operator cannot act on. Repairing the existing seat is the real path.
+                    `A scoring panel is fixed once the rubric is locked (the session is in ${session.phase}). Repair the existing seat instead: POST /participants/{participantId}/binding to hand it to another agent, and POST /participants/{participantId}/budget if it ran out of tokens.`
                 : `A participant can only be registered in phase ${this.registrationPhases(session).join('/')}, but the session is in ${session.phase}. Wait for the next round, or rebind an existing seat.`);
         this.assertAgentAvailable(input.agentId, sessionId);
-        const { participant, token } = this.store.createParticipant({ sessionId, role: input.role, displayName: input.displayName, model: input.model, agentId: input.agentId, tokenBudget: input.tokenBudget });
+        const { participant, token } = this.store.createParticipant({
+            sessionId,
+            role: input.role,
+            displayName: input.displayName,
+            model: input.model,
+            agentId: input.agentId,
+            tokenBudget: input.tokenBudget
+        });
         // Only the hash is stored: the managed agent submits through the in-process bridge, and the plaintext is
         // handed to the human exactly once, in this response.
-        this.record(sessionId, 'participant_added', { participantId: participant.participantId, role: participant.role, displayName: participant.displayName, agentId: participant.agentId, model: participant.model });
+        this.record(sessionId, 'participant_added', {
+            participantId: participant.participantId,
+            role: participant.role,
+            displayName: participant.displayName,
+            agentId: participant.agentId,
+            model: participant.model
+        });
         this.assignCurrentTask(session, participant);
         return { participant, token, session };
     }
     /** Hands a late arrival the task the session is currently waiting for, so it never joins without an assignment. */
     assignCurrentTask(session, participant) {
         const task = session.kind === 'scoring'
-            ? (session.phase === 'nominating' && participant.role === 'reviewer' ? 'nominate_criteria' : undefined)
-            : session.phase === 'implementing' && participant.role === 'implementer' ? 'implement'
-                : session.phase === 'collecting' && participant.role !== 'moderator' && !(session.policy.implementationFirst && participant.role === 'implementer')
-                    ? (participant.role === 'reviewer' ? 'file_findings' : 'file_findings_optional')
+            ? session.phase === 'nominating' && participant.role === 'reviewer'
+                ? 'nominate_criteria'
+                : undefined
+            : session.phase === 'implementing' && participant.role === 'implementer'
+                ? 'implement'
+                : session.phase === 'collecting' &&
+                    participant.role !== 'moderator' &&
+                    !(session.policy.implementationFirst && participant.role === 'implementer')
+                    ? participant.role === 'reviewer'
+                        ? 'file_findings'
+                        : 'file_findings_optional'
                     : undefined;
         if (!task)
             return;
-        this.push(session.sessionId, participant.participantId, task, { phase: session.phase, round: session.round });
-        this.record(session.sessionId, 'task_assigned', { participantId: participant.participantId, task, phase: session.phase, round: session.round });
+        this.push(session.sessionId, participant.participantId, task, {
+            phase: session.phase,
+            round: session.round
+        });
+        this.record(session.sessionId, 'task_assigned', {
+            participantId: participant.participantId,
+            task,
+            phase: session.phase,
+            round: session.round
+        });
     }
     /**
      * Hands a seat to another local agent: the bound one crashed, was deleted, or was picked by mistake. Without it
@@ -231,7 +252,12 @@ export class CollabHub {
         const agentId = input.agentId.trim();
         this.assertAgentAvailable(agentId, sessionId, participantId);
         const { participant, token } = this.store.rebindParticipant(participantId, agentId, input.model);
-        this.record(sessionId, 'participant_rebound', { participantId, agentId: participant.agentId, previousAgentId: current.agentId, model: participant.model });
+        this.record(sessionId, 'participant_rebound', {
+            participantId,
+            agentId: participant.agentId,
+            previousAgentId: current.agentId,
+            model: participant.model
+        });
         // Whatever this seat owes has to reach the *new* agent, even when the old one was already prompted: a rebind
         // exists precisely because that first delivery led nowhere. An entry that was never delivered is simply
         // re-announced; one that was already acked is queued again for the replacement.
@@ -240,7 +266,13 @@ export class CollabHub {
         if (last && session.status === 'active') {
             if (!undelivered.length)
                 this.push(sessionId, participantId, last.type, last.payload);
-            this.record(sessionId, 'task_assigned', { participantId, task: last.type, phase: session.phase, round: session.round, reason: 'rebound' });
+            this.record(sessionId, 'task_assigned', {
+                participantId,
+                task: last.type,
+                phase: session.phase,
+                round: session.round,
+                reason: 'rebound'
+            });
         }
         return { participant, token };
     }
@@ -253,16 +285,32 @@ export class CollabHub {
         if (participant.sessionId !== sessionId)
             throw flowError(COLLAB_ERRORS.participantNotFound, 'Participant not found in this session', 404);
         if (input.tokenBudget <= participant.tokensUsed)
-            throw new ValidationError([fieldError('tokenBudget', 'OUT_OF_RANGE', `The new budget must exceed the ${participant.tokensUsed} tokens already spent`)]);
+            throw new ValidationError([
+                fieldError('tokenBudget', 'OUT_OF_RANGE', `The new budget must exceed the ${participant.tokensUsed} tokens already spent`)
+            ]);
         return this.raiseBudget(participantId, input.tokenBudget);
     }
     raiseBudget(participantId, tokenBudget, actor = 'human') {
         const participant = this.store.getParticipant(participantId);
-        const updated = this.store.updateParticipant(participantId, { tokenBudget: Math.round(tokenBudget), state: participant.state === 'budget_exhausted' ? 'active' : participant.state });
-        this.record(updated.sessionId, 'budget_raised', { participantId: updated.participantId, tokenBudget: updated.tokenBudget, tokensUsed: updated.tokensUsed, previousState: participant.state }, actor);
+        const updated = this.store.updateParticipant(participantId, {
+            tokenBudget: Math.round(tokenBudget),
+            state: participant.state === 'budget_exhausted' ? 'active' : participant.state
+        });
+        this.record(updated.sessionId, 'budget_raised', {
+            participantId: updated.participantId,
+            tokenBudget: updated.tokenBudget,
+            tokensUsed: updated.tokensUsed,
+            previousState: participant.state
+        }, actor);
         // The seat may be the one the phase is waiting for, and it now has a task it can actually submit.
         for (const item of this.store.listInbox(participantId))
-            this.record(updated.sessionId, 'task_assigned', { participantId, task: item.type, phase: this.store.getSession(updated.sessionId).phase, round: this.store.getSession(updated.sessionId).round, reason: 'budget_raised' });
+            this.record(updated.sessionId, 'task_assigned', {
+                participantId,
+                task: item.type,
+                phase: this.store.getSession(updated.sessionId).phase,
+                round: this.store.getSession(updated.sessionId).round,
+                reason: 'budget_raised'
+            });
         return updated;
     }
     /**
@@ -281,13 +329,19 @@ export class CollabHub {
         const selected = [...new Set(input.implementerParticipantIds)], implementers = participants.filter(entry => entry.role === 'implementer' && entry.state === 'active');
         if (input.mode === 'fix_then_review') {
             if (selected.length !== 1)
-                throw new ValidationError([fieldError('implementerParticipantIds', 'WRONG_COUNT', 'Select exactly one active implementer; parallel implementers cannot safely share one workspace')]);
+                throw new ValidationError([
+                    fieldError('implementerParticipantIds', 'WRONG_COUNT', 'Select exactly one active implementer; parallel implementers cannot safely share one workspace')
+                ]);
             for (const participantId of selected)
                 if (!implementers.some(entry => entry.participantId === participantId))
-                    throw new ValidationError([fieldError('implementerParticipantIds', 'UNKNOWN_PARTICIPANT', `${participantId} is not an active implementer in this session`)]);
+                    throw new ValidationError([
+                        fieldError('implementerParticipantIds', 'UNKNOWN_PARTICIPANT', `${participantId} is not an active implementer in this session`)
+                    ]);
         }
         else if (selected.length)
-            throw new ValidationError([fieldError('implementerParticipantIds', 'UNEXPECTED', 'review_only does not assign an implementer')]);
+            throw new ValidationError([
+                fieldError('implementerParticipantIds', 'UNEXPECTED', 'review_only does not assign an implementer')
+            ]);
         // Finished seats can be reused elsewhere. Reopening is the durability boundary where they become active again.
         for (const participant of participants.filter(entry => entry.state === 'active'))
             this.assertAgentAvailable(participant.agentId, sessionId, participant.participantId);
@@ -298,7 +352,11 @@ export class CollabHub {
         const participantTokens = [];
         for (const participant of participants.filter(entry => entry.state === 'active')) {
             this.completeDelivery(participant.participantId, 'session_result');
-            participantTokens.push({ participantId: participant.participantId, displayName: participant.displayName, token: this.store.rotateParticipantToken(participant.participantId) });
+            participantTokens.push({
+                participantId: participant.participantId,
+                displayName: participant.displayName,
+                token: this.store.rotateParticipantToken(participant.participantId)
+            });
         }
         if (input.mode === 'fix_then_review')
             for (const implementer of implementers)
@@ -306,7 +364,14 @@ export class CollabHub {
                     this.store.markPhaseComplete(sessionId, round, 'implementing', implementer.participantId);
         if (phase === 'collecting')
             await this.captureBaseline({ ...session, phase, round, status: 'active' });
-        const updated = this.store.updateSession(sessionId, { phase, round, debateRound: 0, status: 'active', stalled: undefined, outcome: undefined });
+        const updated = this.store.updateSession(sessionId, {
+            phase,
+            round,
+            debateRound: 0,
+            status: 'active',
+            stalled: undefined,
+            outcome: undefined
+        });
         this.record(sessionId, 'review_reopened', { mode: input.mode, round, phase, implementerParticipantIds: selected }, actor);
         this.dispatch(sessionId);
         return { ...updated, participantTokens };
@@ -327,7 +392,12 @@ export class CollabHub {
         if (!buildFirst)
             await this.captureBaseline({ ...session, phase: 'collecting' });
         const updated = this.store.updateSession(sessionId, { phase: buildFirst ? 'implementing' : 'collecting' });
-        this.record(sessionId, 'phase_changed', { from: 'draft', to: updated.phase, round: updated.round, reason: buildFirst ? 'implementation_started' : 'round_opened' });
+        this.record(sessionId, 'phase_changed', {
+            from: 'draft',
+            to: updated.phase,
+            round: updated.round,
+            reason: buildFirst ? 'implementation_started' : 'round_opened'
+        });
         this.dispatch(sessionId);
         return this.store.getSession(sessionId);
     }
@@ -349,10 +419,21 @@ export class CollabHub {
         if (!waitingOn(this.snapshot(session.sessionId)).includes(participant.participantId))
             throw flowError(COLLAB_ERRORS.forbidden, 'This implementer is not assigned to the current fix cycle', 403);
         this.store.markPhaseComplete(session.sessionId, session.round, 'implementing', participant.participantId);
-        this.record(session.sessionId, 'implementation_ready', { participantId: participant.participantId, summary: input.summary, codeRef: input.codeRef, changedFiles: input.changes.length, trigger: 'self_reported' }, participant.participantId);
+        this.record(session.sessionId, 'implementation_ready', {
+            participantId: participant.participantId,
+            summary: input.summary,
+            codeRef: input.codeRef,
+            changedFiles: input.changes.length,
+            trigger: 'self_reported'
+        }, participant.participantId);
         await this.settle(session.sessionId);
         const current = this.store.getSession(session.sessionId);
-        const response = { accepted: true, phase: current.phase, round: current.round, waitingOn: waitingOn(this.snapshot(session.sessionId)) };
+        const response = {
+            accepted: true,
+            phase: current.phase,
+            round: current.round,
+            waitingOn: waitingOn(this.snapshot(session.sessionId))
+        };
         this.finish(participant, input.clientRequestId, body, input.usage, response);
         return response;
     }
@@ -364,7 +445,9 @@ export class CollabHub {
             if (pendingPanel.length && !input.force)
                 throw flowError(COLLAB_ERRORS.wrongPhase, `Still waiting on ${pendingPanel.length} panelist(s): ${pendingPanel.join(', ')}. Pass force=true to override.`);
             if (pendingPanel.length && !input.reason.trim())
-                throw new ValidationError([fieldError('reason', 'REQUIRED', 'A forced advance must state why the pending panelists are being skipped')]);
+                throw new ValidationError([
+                    fieldError('reason', 'REQUIRED', 'A forced advance must state why the pending panelists are being skipped')
+                ]);
             // Anything else that blocks the panel (no reviewer registered, a question still on the human's desk) has to
             // be reported too: settleScoring() returns quietly, so the operator would get 200 and an unchanged session.
             if (!input.force)
@@ -378,7 +461,9 @@ export class CollabHub {
         if (pending.length && !input.force)
             throw flowError(COLLAB_ERRORS.wrongPhase, `Still waiting on ${pending.length} participant(s): ${pending.join(', ')}. Pass force=true to override.`);
         if (pending.length && !input.reason.trim())
-            throw new ValidationError([fieldError('reason', 'REQUIRED', 'A forced advance must state why the pending participants are being skipped')]);
+            throw new ValidationError([
+                fieldError('reason', 'REQUIRED', 'A forced advance must state why the pending participants are being skipped')
+            ]);
         const result = nextPhase(snapshot, { forced: input.force });
         await this.applyPhase(session, result, { forced: input.force, reason: input.reason, actor });
         // A forced step may unblock purely automatic phases (consolidating), so let the machine run on.
@@ -390,25 +475,49 @@ export class CollabHub {
         const allPending = session.kind === 'scoring' ? scoringWaitingOn(this.scoringSnapshot(sessionId)) : waitingOn(snapshot);
         const crossVoters = snapshot ? pendingCrossVoters(snapshot) : [], owed = new Set([...allPending, ...crossVoters]);
         const wanted = input.participantIds?.length ? new Set(input.participantIds) : undefined, pending = [...owed].filter(participantId => !wanted || wanted.has(participantId));
-        const participants = this.store.listParticipants(sessionId), busy = pending.filter(participantId => { const participant = participants.find(entry => entry.participantId === participantId); return participant && ['starting', 'streaming', 'waiting_for_user', 'stopping'].includes(this.options.agentStatus?.(participant.agentId) ?? ''); });
+        const participants = this.store.listParticipants(sessionId), busy = pending.filter(participantId => {
+            const participant = participants.find(entry => entry.participantId === participantId);
+            return (participant &&
+                ['starting', 'streaming', 'waiting_for_user', 'stopping'].includes(this.options.agentStatus?.(participant.agentId) ?? ''));
+        });
         const retryable = pending.filter(participantId => !busy.includes(participantId));
-        const baseTask = session.kind === 'scoring' ? { nominating: 'nominate_criteria', voting: 'vote_on_criteria', scoring: 'score_rubric', debating: 'debate_contested_scores', rescoring: 'rescore_contested' }[session.phase]
-            : { implementing: 'implement', collecting: 'file_findings', validating: 'validate_issues', merge_voting: 'vote_on_merges', issue_discussing: 'defend_approved_issues', issue_reconsidering: 'reconsider_issue_votes' }[session.phase];
+        const baseTask = session.kind === 'scoring'
+            ? {
+                nominating: 'nominate_criteria',
+                voting: 'vote_on_criteria',
+                scoring: 'score_rubric',
+                debating: 'debate_contested_scores',
+                rescoring: 'rescore_contested'
+            }[session.phase]
+            : {
+                implementing: 'implement',
+                collecting: 'file_findings',
+                validating: 'validate_issues',
+                merge_voting: 'vote_on_merges',
+                issue_discussing: 'defend_approved_issues',
+                issue_reconsidering: 'reconsider_issue_votes'
+            }[session.phase];
         if (!owed.size)
             throw flowError(COLLAB_ERRORS.wrongPhase, 'Nobody is currently waiting to submit');
         if (!baseTask)
             throw flowError(COLLAB_ERRORS.wrongPhase, `Phase ${session.phase} has no retryable Agent task`);
         const nonce = this.now();
         for (const participantId of retryable) {
-            const taskBase = crossVoters.includes(participantId) && !allPending.includes(participantId) ? 'validate_issues' : baseTask;
+            const taskBase = crossVoters.includes(participantId) && !allPending.includes(participantId)
+                ? 'validate_issues'
+                : baseTask;
             const task = `${taskBase}#retry-${nonce}`;
             this.push(sessionId, participantId, task, { phase: session.phase, round: session.round, retry: true });
             this.record(sessionId, 'task_assigned', { participantId, task, phase: session.phase, round: session.round, retry: true }, actor);
         }
         return { retried: retryable, skippedBusy: busy, phase: session.phase };
     }
-    listEscalations(filter = {}) { return this.store.listEscalations(filter); }
-    getEscalation(escalationId) { return this.store.getEscalation(escalationId); }
+    listEscalations(filter = {}) {
+        return this.store.listEscalations(filter);
+    }
+    getEscalation(escalationId) {
+        return this.store.getEscalation(escalationId);
+    }
     /**
      * A human ruling is terminal. Every escalation kind carries its own structured action:
      * an issue dispute rules on the issue, an exhausted budget can be raised, a deadlock can raise the round cap,
@@ -429,8 +538,12 @@ export class CollabHub {
         // instead of consuming the only remedy the human has.
         const errors = [];
         let budgetTarget, tokenBudget = 0;
-        if ('tokenBudget' in extra || escalation.kind === 'budget_exhausted' && extra.tokenBudget !== undefined) {
-            budgetTarget = escalation.kind === 'budget_exhausted' && escalation.refId ? this.store.getParticipant(escalation.refId) : undefined;
+        if ('tokenBudget' in extra ||
+            (escalation.kind === 'budget_exhausted' && extra.tokenBudget !== undefined)) {
+            budgetTarget =
+                escalation.kind === 'budget_exhausted' && escalation.refId
+                    ? this.store.getParticipant(escalation.refId)
+                    : undefined;
             if (!budgetTarget)
                 errors.push(fieldError('extra.tokenBudget', 'UNEXPECTED', 'Only a budget_exhausted escalation can raise a token budget'));
             else if (typeof extra.tokenBudget !== 'number' || !Number.isFinite(extra.tokenBudget))
@@ -461,9 +574,23 @@ export class CollabHub {
             const ruledRound = input.issueDecision === 'reopen' && session.kind === 'review' ? session.round : outcome.round;
             this.store.updateIssue(issue.issueId, { status: outcome.status, round: ruledRound });
             if (input.issueDecision === 'reopen' && session.policy.consensusReview)
-                for (const reviewer of this.store.listParticipants(session.sessionId).filter(entry => entry.role === 'reviewer' && entry.state !== 'left'))
-                    this.store.saveIssueVote({ sessionId: session.sessionId, issueId: issue.issueId, participantId: reviewer.participantId, round: session.round, consensusRound: session.debateRound + 1, stance: 'approve', rationale: `Human ruled this a valid issue: ${input.rationale}` });
-            this.store.addIssueMessage(issue.issueId, outcome.round, resolvedBy, 'ruling', { decision: input.decision, rationale: input.rationale, issueDecision: input.issueDecision });
+                for (const reviewer of this.store
+                    .listParticipants(session.sessionId)
+                    .filter(entry => entry.role === 'reviewer' && entry.state !== 'left'))
+                    this.store.saveIssueVote({
+                        sessionId: session.sessionId,
+                        issueId: issue.issueId,
+                        participantId: reviewer.participantId,
+                        round: session.round,
+                        consensusRound: session.debateRound + 1,
+                        stance: 'approve',
+                        rationale: `Human ruled this a valid issue: ${input.rationale}`
+                    });
+            this.store.addIssueMessage(issue.issueId, outcome.round, resolvedBy, 'ruling', {
+                decision: input.decision,
+                rationale: input.rationale,
+                issueDecision: input.issueDecision
+            });
             this.record(escalation.sessionId, 'issue_ruled', { issueId: issue.issueId, status: outcome.status, decision: input.issueDecision }, resolvedBy);
             applied.push(`issue:${input.issueDecision}`);
         }
@@ -479,7 +606,13 @@ export class CollabHub {
             this.record(escalation.sessionId, 'policy_updated', { policy }, resolvedBy);
             applied.push(`maxTotalRounds:${maxTotalRounds}`);
         }
-        const resolved = this.store.resolveEscalation(escalationId, { decision: input.decision, rationale: input.rationale, issueDecision: input.issueDecision, extra: input.extra, applied }, resolvedBy);
+        const resolved = this.store.resolveEscalation(escalationId, {
+            decision: input.decision,
+            rationale: input.rationale,
+            issueDecision: input.issueDecision,
+            extra: input.extra,
+            applied
+        }, resolvedBy);
         // `applied` is on the event so the board can show what a ruling actually changed, not just what it said.
         this.record(escalation.sessionId, 'escalation_resolved', { escalationId, kind: escalation.kind, decision: input.decision, rationale: input.rationale, applied }, resolvedBy);
         // A scoring session must be settled by the scoring machine; the review machine has different phases.
@@ -494,18 +627,26 @@ export class CollabHub {
         const participant = token ? this.store.findParticipantByToken(token) : undefined;
         if (!participant)
             throw flowError(COLLAB_ERRORS.forbidden, 'Unknown participant token', 401);
-        return this.store.updateParticipant(participant.participantId, { lastSeenAt: new Date(this.now()).toISOString() });
+        return this.store.updateParticipant(participant.participantId, {
+            lastSeenAt: new Date(this.now()).toISOString()
+        });
     }
     /** Internal bridge identity lookup. A collaboration Agent is constrained to exactly one active seat. */
     participantForAgent(agentId) {
         const matches = this.store.findActiveParticipantsByAgent(agentId);
         if (matches.length !== 1)
-            throw flowError(COLLAB_ERRORS.forbidden, matches.length ? 'This collaboration Agent has more than one active seat' : 'This Agent has no active collaboration seat', 403);
-        return this.store.updateParticipant(matches[0].participantId, { lastSeenAt: new Date(this.now()).toISOString() });
+            throw flowError(COLLAB_ERRORS.forbidden, matches.length
+                ? 'This collaboration Agent has more than one active seat'
+                : 'This Agent has no active collaboration seat', 403);
+        return this.store.updateParticipant(matches[0].participantId, {
+            lastSeenAt: new Date(this.now()).toISOString()
+        });
     }
     /** A wake-up is durable until the extension actually asks for its task; merely queueing a Pi follow-up is not delivery. */
     claimTaskForAgent(agentId) {
-        const participant = this.participantForAgent(agentId), task = this.digest(participant), pending = this.store.listInbox(participant.participantId).filter(item => item.type !== 'session_result');
+        const participant = this.participantForAgent(agentId), task = this.digest(participant), pending = this.store
+            .listInbox(participant.participantId)
+            .filter(item => item.type !== 'session_result');
         if (pending.length) {
             this.store.ackInbox(participant.participantId, pending.map(item => item.itemId));
             this.record(participant.sessionId, 'task_collected', { participantId: participant.participantId, tasks: pending.map(item => item.type) }, participant.participantId);
@@ -530,9 +671,14 @@ export class CollabHub {
         const accepted = [], rejected = [];
         // A later review round verifies the reporter's previously confirmed findings as part of the same blind task.
         // `reviewComplete` is rejected unless every owed recheck has been explicitly resolved or kept open.
-        const alreadyRechecked = new Set(this.store.listIssues(session.sessionId).flatMap(issue => this.store.listIssueMessages(issue.issueId)
-            .filter(message => message.kind === 'recheck' && Number(message.payload.reviewRound) === session.round && message.authorId === participant.participantId).map(message => issue.issueId)));
-        const owedRechecks = this.store.listIssues(session.sessionId, { status: ['confirmed'], reporterId: participant.participantId })
+        const alreadyRechecked = new Set(this.store.listIssues(session.sessionId).flatMap(issue => this.store
+            .listIssueMessages(issue.issueId)
+            .filter(message => message.kind === 'recheck' &&
+            Number(message.payload.reviewRound) === session.round &&
+            message.authorId === participant.participantId)
+            .map(message => issue.issueId)));
+        const owedRechecks = this.store
+            .listIssues(session.sessionId, { status: ['confirmed'], reporterId: participant.participantId })
             .filter(issue => issue.round < session.round && !alreadyRechecked.has(issue.issueId));
         const submittedRechecks = input.rechecks.map(entry => entry.issueId), recheckErrors = [];
         for (const [index, entry] of input.rechecks.entries()) {
@@ -553,7 +699,12 @@ export class CollabHub {
             const issue = owedRechecks.find(candidate => candidate.issueId === entry.issueId);
             if (entry.outcome === 'resolved')
                 this.store.updateIssue(issue.issueId, { status: 'resolved' });
-            this.store.addIssueMessage(issue.issueId, session.round, participant.participantId, 'recheck', { reviewRound: session.round, outcome: entry.outcome, rationale: entry.rationale, baselineId: baseline.baselineId });
+            this.store.addIssueMessage(issue.issueId, session.round, participant.participantId, 'recheck', {
+                reviewRound: session.round,
+                outcome: entry.outcome,
+                rationale: entry.rationale,
+                baselineId: baseline.baselineId
+            });
             acceptedRechecks.push({ issueId: issue.issueId, outcome: entry.outcome });
             this.record(session.sessionId, 'issue_rechecked', { issueId: issue.issueId, outcome: entry.outcome, reviewRound: session.round }, participant.participantId);
         }
@@ -562,19 +713,44 @@ export class CollabHub {
             // is valid, so with no implementer the reporter itself is the harmless default owner.
             const targetId = finding.targetParticipantId ?? defaultTarget?.participantId ?? participant.participantId;
             if (!participants.some(entry => entry.participantId === targetId)) {
-                rejected.push({ externalId: finding.externalId, code: COLLAB_ERRORS.participantNotFound, message: `Unknown targetParticipantId ${targetId}` });
+                rejected.push({
+                    externalId: finding.externalId,
+                    code: COLLAB_ERRORS.participantNotFound,
+                    message: `Unknown targetParticipantId ${targetId}`
+                });
                 continue;
             }
-            const issue = this.store.createIssue({ sessionId: session.sessionId, externalId: finding.externalId, reporterId: participant.participantId, targetParticipantId: targetId,
-                title: finding.title, severity: finding.severity, category: finding.category, requiredAction: finding.requiredAction, confidence: finding.confidence,
-                location: finding.location, evidence: finding.evidence, impact: finding.impact, suggestion: finding.suggestion, baselineId: baseline.baselineId, round: session.round });
+            const issue = this.store.createIssue({
+                sessionId: session.sessionId,
+                externalId: finding.externalId,
+                reporterId: participant.participantId,
+                targetParticipantId: targetId,
+                title: finding.title,
+                severity: finding.severity,
+                category: finding.category,
+                requiredAction: finding.requiredAction,
+                confidence: finding.confidence,
+                location: finding.location,
+                evidence: finding.evidence,
+                impact: finding.impact,
+                suggestion: finding.suggestion,
+                baselineId: baseline.baselineId,
+                round: session.round
+            });
             accepted.push({ externalId: finding.externalId, issueId: issue.issueId });
             this.record(session.sessionId, 'issue_opened', { issueId: issue.issueId, title: issue.title, severity: issue.severity, targetParticipantId: targetId }, participant.participantId);
         }
         if (input.reviewComplete)
             this.store.markPhaseComplete(session.sessionId, session.round, 'collecting', participant.participantId);
         const duplicates = this.possibleDuplicates(session.sessionId, accepted.map(entry => entry.issueId), participant);
-        const response = { accepted, rejected, rechecks: acceptedRechecks, possibleDuplicates: duplicates, reviewComplete: input.reviewComplete, round: session.round };
+        const response = {
+            accepted,
+            rejected,
+            rechecks: acceptedRechecks,
+            possibleDuplicates: duplicates,
+            reviewComplete: input.reviewComplete,
+            round: session.round
+        };
         this.finish(participant, input.clientRequestId, body, input.usage, response);
         this.record(session.sessionId, 'findings_submitted', { count: accepted.length, rejected: rejected.length, reviewComplete: input.reviewComplete }, participant.participantId);
         await this.settle(session.sessionId);
@@ -587,7 +763,9 @@ export class CollabHub {
             return cached;
         const session = this.store.getSession(participant.sessionId), snapshot = this.snapshot(session.sessionId);
         assertCapability(this.toFlowParticipant(participant), 'vote');
-        const collected = snapshot.completions.some(entry => entry.phase === 'collecting' && entry.round === session.round && entry.participantId === participant.participantId);
+        const collected = snapshot.completions.some(entry => entry.phase === 'collecting' &&
+            entry.round === session.round &&
+            entry.participantId === participant.participantId);
         if (session.phase === 'collecting') {
             if (!session.policy.consensusReview)
                 throw flowError(COLLAB_ERRORS.wrongPhase, 'Issue votes are only accepted after collection when consensus review is enabled');
@@ -597,9 +775,17 @@ export class CollabHub {
         else if (!['validating', 'issue_reconsidering'].includes(session.phase))
             throw flowError(COLLAB_ERRORS.wrongPhase, `Issue votes are only accepted in validating or issue_reconsidering, but the session is in ${session.phase}`);
         const consensus = issueConsensus(snapshot), owedNow = session.phase === 'issue_reconsidering'
-            ? consensus.filter(entry => activeContestedIssueIds(snapshot).includes(entry.issueId) && entry.rejecters.includes(participant.participantId)).map(entry => entry.issueId)
+            ? consensus
+                .filter(entry => activeContestedIssueIds(snapshot).includes(entry.issueId) &&
+                entry.rejecters.includes(participant.participantId))
+                .map(entry => entry.issueId)
             : owedIssueVoteIds(snapshot, participant.participantId);
-        const votable = session.phase === 'issue_reconsidering' ? owedNow : this.store.listIssues(session.sessionId, { status: ['open'], round: session.round }).filter(issue => issue.reporterId !== participant.participantId).map(issue => issue.issueId);
+        const votable = session.phase === 'issue_reconsidering'
+            ? owedNow
+            : this.store
+                .listIssues(session.sessionId, { status: ['open'], round: session.round })
+                .filter(issue => issue.reporterId !== participant.participantId)
+                .map(issue => issue.issueId);
         const submitted = input.votes.map(vote => vote.issueId), errors = [], dropped = new Set();
         // A missing vote is not a bad request. Findings keep arriving while a reviewer reads code, so the owed set
         // grows underneath it and demanding the set as it stands at submit time threw away a whole turn of work
@@ -631,22 +817,55 @@ export class CollabHub {
             throw new ValidationError(errors);
         const counted = input.votes.filter(vote => !dropped.has(vote.issueId)), acceptedIds = counted.map(vote => vote.issueId);
         for (const vote of counted)
-            this.store.saveIssueVote({ sessionId: session.sessionId, issueId: vote.issueId, participantId: participant.participantId, round: session.round, consensusRound: session.phase === 'validating' ? 0 : session.debateRound, stance: vote.stance, rationale: vote.rationale });
+            this.store.saveIssueVote({
+                sessionId: session.sessionId,
+                issueId: vote.issueId,
+                participantId: participant.participantId,
+                round: session.round,
+                consensusRound: session.phase === 'validating' ? 0 : session.debateRound,
+                stance: vote.stance,
+                rationale: vote.rationale
+            });
         const proposalIds = [];
         for (const proposal of input.mergeProposals) {
             const issueIds = [...new Set(proposal.issueIds)];
-            if (issueIds.length < 2 || issueIds.some(issueId => !this.store.findIssueInSession(session.sessionId, issueId)))
-                throw new ValidationError([fieldError('mergeProposals', 'UNKNOWN_ISSUE', 'Every merge proposal needs at least two issues from this session')]);
-            proposalIds.push(this.store.createMergeProposal({ sessionId: session.sessionId, round: session.round, issueIds, participantId: participant.participantId, rationale: proposal.rationale }).proposalId);
+            if (issueIds.length < 2 ||
+                issueIds.some(issueId => !this.store.findIssueInSession(session.sessionId, issueId)))
+                throw new ValidationError([
+                    fieldError('mergeProposals', 'UNKNOWN_ISSUE', 'Every merge proposal needs at least two issues from this session')
+                ]);
+            proposalIds.push(this.store.createMergeProposal({
+                sessionId: session.sessionId,
+                round: session.round,
+                issueIds,
+                participantId: participant.participantId,
+                rationale: proposal.rationale
+            }).proposalId);
         }
         // Completion is measured against the ballot box, not against the request: a reviewer is done when nothing
         // is owed any more, whichever call finally covered it.
         const remaining = this.owedVotesAfter(session, participant, acceptedIds, owedNow);
         if (input.complete && !remaining.length && session.phase !== 'collecting')
-            this.store.markPhaseComplete(session.sessionId, session.round, session.phase === 'issue_reconsidering' ? `issue_reconsidering:${session.debateRound}` : session.phase, participant.participantId);
-        const response = { accepted: acceptedIds, dropped: [...dropped], mergeProposals: proposalIds, complete: input.complete && !remaining.length, stillOwed: remaining, consensusRound: session.debateRound };
+            this.store.markPhaseComplete(session.sessionId, session.round, session.phase === 'issue_reconsidering'
+                ? `issue_reconsidering:${session.debateRound}`
+                : session.phase, participant.participantId);
+        const response = {
+            accepted: acceptedIds,
+            dropped: [...dropped],
+            mergeProposals: proposalIds,
+            complete: input.complete && !remaining.length,
+            stillOwed: remaining,
+            consensusRound: session.debateRound
+        };
         this.finish(participant, input.clientRequestId, body, input.usage, response);
-        this.record(session.sessionId, 'issue_votes_submitted', { count: acceptedIds.length, dropped: dropped.size, mergeProposals: proposalIds, phase: session.phase, consensusRound: session.debateRound, stillOwed: remaining.length }, participant.participantId);
+        this.record(session.sessionId, 'issue_votes_submitted', {
+            count: acceptedIds.length,
+            dropped: dropped.size,
+            mergeProposals: proposalIds,
+            phase: session.phase,
+            consensusRound: session.debateRound,
+            stillOwed: remaining.length
+        }, participant.participantId);
         await this.settle(session.sessionId);
         // Whatever this seat still owes has to come back to it as a task, or the session waits on a reviewer that
         // believes it is finished.
@@ -661,7 +880,9 @@ export class CollabHub {
     }
     requeueVotes(sessionId, participantId, owed) {
         const session = this.store.findSession(sessionId);
-        if (!session || session.status !== 'active' || !['collecting', 'validating', 'issue_reconsidering'].includes(session.phase))
+        if (!session ||
+            session.status !== 'active' ||
+            !['collecting', 'validating', 'issue_reconsidering'].includes(session.phase))
             return;
         const prefix = session.phase === 'issue_reconsidering' ? 'reconsider_issue_votes' : 'validate_issues';
         const task = `${prefix}#${owed}`;
@@ -670,7 +891,13 @@ export class CollabHub {
         if (this.store.listInbox(participantId).some(item => item.type.split('#')[0] === prefix))
             return;
         this.push(sessionId, participantId, task, { phase: session.phase, round: session.round, owed });
-        this.record(sessionId, 'task_assigned', { participantId, task, phase: session.phase, round: session.round, remainder: true });
+        this.record(sessionId, 'task_assigned', {
+            participantId,
+            task,
+            phase: session.phase,
+            round: session.round,
+            remainder: true
+        });
     }
     async submitMergeVotes(participant, body) {
         const input = parse(mergeVotesRequest, body), cached = this.replay(participant, input.clientRequestId);
@@ -680,7 +907,9 @@ export class CollabHub {
         assertCapability(this.toFlowParticipant(participant), 'merge');
         if (session.phase !== 'merge_voting')
             throw flowError(COLLAB_ERRORS.wrongPhase, `Merge votes are only accepted in phase merge_voting, but the session is in ${session.phase}`);
-        const proposals = (snapshot.mergeProposals ?? []).filter(proposal => proposal.round === session.round), expected = proposals.filter(proposal => !proposal.votes.some(vote => vote.participantId === participant.participantId)).map(proposal => proposal.proposalId), submitted = input.votes.map(vote => vote.proposalId), errors = [];
+        const proposals = (snapshot.mergeProposals ?? []).filter(proposal => proposal.round === session.round), expected = proposals
+            .filter(proposal => !proposal.votes.some(vote => vote.participantId === participant.participantId))
+            .map(proposal => proposal.proposalId), submitted = input.votes.map(vote => vote.proposalId), errors = [];
         for (const proposalId of expected)
             if (!submitted.includes(proposalId))
                 errors.push(fieldError('votes', 'REQUIRED', `A vote for merge proposal ${proposalId} is required`));
@@ -693,7 +922,12 @@ export class CollabHub {
         if (errors.length)
             throw new ValidationError(errors);
         for (const vote of input.votes)
-            this.store.saveMergeVote({ proposalId: vote.proposalId, participantId: participant.participantId, stance: vote.stance, rationale: vote.rationale });
+            this.store.saveMergeVote({
+                proposalId: vote.proposalId,
+                participantId: participant.participantId,
+                stance: vote.stance,
+                rationale: vote.rationale
+            });
         if (input.complete)
             this.store.markPhaseComplete(session.sessionId, session.round, 'merge_voting', participant.participantId);
         const response = { accepted: submitted, complete: input.complete };
@@ -711,7 +945,9 @@ export class CollabHub {
         if (session.phase !== 'issue_discussing')
             throw flowError(COLLAB_ERRORS.wrongPhase, `Issue discussions are only accepted in phase issue_discussing, but the session is in ${session.phase}`);
         const active = new Set(activeContestedIssueIds(snapshot));
-        const expected = issueConsensus(snapshot).filter(entry => active.has(entry.issueId) && entry.supporters.includes(participant.participantId)).map(entry => entry.issueId);
+        const expected = issueConsensus(snapshot)
+            .filter(entry => active.has(entry.issueId) && entry.supporters.includes(participant.participantId))
+            .map(entry => entry.issueId);
         const errors = [];
         // Withdrawals are validated and applied first: a reporter that no longer stands by a finding must be able to
         // say so in the same call that defends the rest. Two calls are impossible for an agent, because the
@@ -767,22 +1003,44 @@ export class CollabHub {
             if (!withdrawn.has(entry.issueId))
                 continue;
             const issue = this.store.getIssue(entry.issueId);
-            const outcome = applyWithdraw({ issue: this.toFlowIssue(issue), actor: this.toFlowParticipant(participant) });
+            const outcome = applyWithdraw({
+                issue: this.toFlowIssue(issue),
+                actor: this.toFlowParticipant(participant)
+            });
             this.store.updateIssue(issue.issueId, { status: outcome.status });
-            this.store.addIssueMessage(issue.issueId, session.round, participant.participantId, 'discussion', { argument: `Withdrawn by the reporter: ${entry.rationale}`, withdrawn: true, consensusRound: session.debateRound });
+            this.store.addIssueMessage(issue.issueId, session.round, participant.participantId, 'discussion', {
+                argument: `Withdrawn by the reporter: ${entry.rationale}`,
+                withdrawn: true,
+                consensusRound: session.debateRound
+            });
             this.record(session.sessionId, 'issue_withdrawn', { issueId: issue.issueId, rationale: entry.rationale, consensusRound: session.debateRound }, participant.participantId);
         }
         for (const entry of input.discussions) {
             if (withdrawn.has(entry.issueId) || !expected.includes(entry.issueId))
                 continue;
-            this.store.addIssueMessage(entry.issueId, session.round, participant.participantId, 'discussion', { argument: entry.argument, respondingTo: entry.respondingTo, consensusRound: session.debateRound });
+            this.store.addIssueMessage(entry.issueId, session.round, participant.participantId, 'discussion', {
+                argument: entry.argument,
+                respondingTo: entry.respondingTo,
+                consensusRound: session.debateRound
+            });
             accepted.push(entry.issueId);
         }
         if (input.complete)
             this.store.markPhaseComplete(session.sessionId, session.round, `issue_discussing:${session.debateRound}`, participant.participantId);
-        const response = { accepted, withdrawn: [...withdrawn], alreadyWithdrawn: [...alreadyClosed], complete: input.complete, consensusRound: session.debateRound };
+        const response = {
+            accepted,
+            withdrawn: [...withdrawn],
+            alreadyWithdrawn: [...alreadyClosed],
+            complete: input.complete,
+            consensusRound: session.debateRound
+        };
         this.finish(participant, input.clientRequestId, body, input.usage, response);
-        this.record(session.sessionId, 'issue_discussions_submitted', { count: accepted.length, withdrawn: withdrawn.size, alreadyWithdrawn: alreadyClosed.size, consensusRound: session.debateRound }, participant.participantId);
+        this.record(session.sessionId, 'issue_discussions_submitted', {
+            count: accepted.length,
+            withdrawn: withdrawn.size,
+            alreadyWithdrawn: alreadyClosed.size,
+            consensusRound: session.debateRound
+        }, participant.participantId);
         await this.settle(session.sessionId);
         return response;
     }
@@ -790,7 +1048,10 @@ export class CollabHub {
         const session = this.store.getSession(participant.sessionId), issue = this.store.findIssueInSession(session.sessionId, issueId);
         if (!issue)
             throw flowError(COLLAB_ERRORS.issueNotFound, 'Issue not found in this session', 404);
-        const outcome = applyWithdraw({ issue: this.toFlowIssue(issue), actor: this.toFlowParticipant(participant) });
+        const outcome = applyWithdraw({
+            issue: this.toFlowIssue(issue),
+            actor: this.toFlowParticipant(participant)
+        });
         const updated = this.store.updateIssue(issue.issueId, { status: outcome.status });
         this.record(session.sessionId, 'issue_withdrawn', { issueId: issue.issueId }, participant.participantId);
         await this.settle(session.sessionId);
@@ -810,18 +1071,41 @@ export class CollabHub {
             const issue = this.store.findIssueInSession(session.sessionId, input.refId);
             if (!issue)
                 throw flowError(COLLAB_ERRORS.issueNotFound, 'Issue not found in this session', 404);
-            const consensusPhase = ['validating', 'merge_voting', 'issue_discussing', 'issue_reconsidering'].includes(session.phase);
+            const consensusPhase = [
+                'validating',
+                'merge_voting',
+                'issue_discussing',
+                'issue_reconsidering'
+            ].includes(session.phase);
             if (consensusPhase && participant.role === 'reviewer')
                 this.store.updateIssue(issue.issueId, { status: 'escalated' });
             else {
-                const outcome = applyEscalation({ issue: this.toFlowIssue(issue), actor: this.toFlowParticipant(participant) });
+                const outcome = applyEscalation({
+                    issue: this.toFlowIssue(issue),
+                    actor: this.toFlowParticipant(participant)
+                });
                 this.store.updateIssue(issue.issueId, { status: outcome.status, round: outcome.round });
             }
         }
-        const escalation = this.store.createEscalation({ sessionId: session.sessionId, kind: input.kind, refId: input.refId, raisedBy: participant.participantId,
-            summary: input.summary, positions: input.positions, question: input.question, options: input.options, urgency: input.urgency });
+        const escalation = this.store.createEscalation({
+            sessionId: session.sessionId,
+            kind: input.kind,
+            refId: input.refId,
+            raisedBy: participant.participantId,
+            summary: input.summary,
+            positions: input.positions,
+            question: input.question,
+            options: input.options,
+            urgency: input.urgency
+        });
         this.finish(participant, input.clientRequestId, body, input.usage, escalation);
-        this.record(session.sessionId, 'escalation_raised', { escalationId: escalation.escalationId, kind: escalation.kind, refId: escalation.refId, question: escalation.question, urgency: escalation.urgency }, participant.participantId);
+        this.record(session.sessionId, 'escalation_raised', {
+            escalationId: escalation.escalationId,
+            kind: escalation.kind,
+            refId: escalation.refId,
+            question: escalation.question,
+            urgency: escalation.urgency
+        }, participant.participantId);
         // Settling with the wrong machine is not a no-op: the review flow throws `Phase nominating cannot advance`
         // on a scoring session, so the escalation was persisted and the request still failed.
         if (session.kind === 'scoring')
@@ -837,12 +1121,36 @@ export class CollabHub {
             return this.scoringDigest(participant);
         const snapshot = this.snapshot(session.sessionId);
         const baseline = this.store.getBaselineForRound(session.sessionId, session.round);
-        const panel = this.store.listParticipants(session.sessionId).filter(entry => entry.state !== 'left')
-            .map(entry => ({ participantId: entry.participantId, role: entry.role, displayName: entry.displayName, model: entry.model, isYou: entry.participantId === participant.participantId }));
-        const base = { sessionId: session.sessionId, kind: session.kind, title: session.title, phase: session.phase, round: session.round, subject: session.subject,
-            baseline: baseline ? { ...baseline, ...this.reviewScope(session, baseline) } : baseline, panel,
-            you: { participantId: participant.participantId, role: participant.role, displayName: participant.displayName, tokensUsed: participant.tokensUsed, tokenBudget: participant.tokenBudget, state: participant.state },
-            progress: sessionProgress(snapshot), stalled: session.stalled };
+        const panel = this.store
+            .listParticipants(session.sessionId)
+            .filter(entry => entry.state !== 'left')
+            .map(entry => ({
+            participantId: entry.participantId,
+            role: entry.role,
+            displayName: entry.displayName,
+            model: entry.model,
+            isYou: entry.participantId === participant.participantId
+        }));
+        const base = {
+            sessionId: session.sessionId,
+            kind: session.kind,
+            title: session.title,
+            phase: session.phase,
+            round: session.round,
+            subject: session.subject,
+            baseline: baseline ? { ...baseline, ...this.reviewScope(session, baseline) } : baseline,
+            panel,
+            you: {
+                participantId: participant.participantId,
+                role: participant.role,
+                displayName: participant.displayName,
+                tokensUsed: participant.tokensUsed,
+                tokenBudget: participant.tokenBudget,
+                state: participant.state
+            },
+            progress: sessionProgress(snapshot),
+            stalled: session.stalled
+        };
         if (session.phase === 'implementing') {
             if (participant.role !== 'implementer' || !waitingOn(snapshot).includes(participant.participantId))
                 return this.waitDigest(session, base, 'Another implementer is working. Nothing is required from you; end your turn.');
@@ -850,23 +1158,44 @@ export class CollabHub {
             // than only findings that originally targeted an older implementer seat.
             const carried = this.store.listIssues(session.sessionId, { status: ['confirmed', 'open'] });
             const initial = session.round === 1 && session.policy.implementationFirst && !carried.length;
-            return { ...base, task: 'implement', issues: carried.map(issue => this.withHistory(issue)),
+            return {
+                ...base,
+                task: 'implement',
+                issues: carried.map(issue => this.withHistory(issue)),
                 instructions: initial
                     ? `Implement the requested subject in ${session.cwd}. When the code is ready, call collab_submit_ready with a summary, the changed files and a codeRef (commit or dirtyHash), then end your turn. The hub pins the baseline and calls the reviewers.`
-                    : `Fix the confirmed review findings listed in issues[] in ${session.cwd}. When the code is ready, call collab_submit_ready with a summary, the changed files and a codeRef (commit or dirtyHash), then end your turn. The hub pins the new baseline and calls the reviewers; there is no per-issue response stage.` };
+                    : `Fix the confirmed review findings listed in issues[] in ${session.cwd}. When the code is ready, call collab_submit_ready with a summary, the changed files and a codeRef (commit or dirtyHash), then end your turn. The hub pins the new baseline and calls the reviewers; there is no per-issue response stage.`
+            };
         }
         if (session.phase === 'collecting') {
-            const collected = snapshot.completions.some(entry => entry.phase === 'collecting' && entry.round === session.round && entry.participantId === participant.participantId);
+            const collected = snapshot.completions.some(entry => entry.phase === 'collecting' &&
+                entry.round === session.round &&
+                entry.participantId === participant.participantId);
             if (collected)
                 return this.crossVoteDigest(session, participant, snapshot, base, 'You finished the blind review. End your turn; the hub will prompt you if later findings need a vote or the panel moves on.');
-            const own = this.store.listIssues(session.sessionId, { reporterId: participant.participantId, round: session.round });
-            const issuesToRecheck = this.store.listIssues(session.sessionId, { status: ['confirmed'], reporterId: participant.participantId }).filter(issue => issue.round < session.round).map(issue => this.withHistory(issue));
+            const own = this.store.listIssues(session.sessionId, {
+                reporterId: participant.participantId,
+                round: session.round
+            });
+            const issuesToRecheck = this.store
+                .listIssues(session.sessionId, { status: ['confirmed'], reporterId: participant.participantId })
+                .filter(issue => issue.round < session.round)
+                .map(issue => this.withHistory(issue));
             const required = participant.role === 'reviewer', reviewerCount = panel.filter(entry => entry.role === 'reviewer').length;
-            return { ...base, task: required ? 'file_findings' : 'file_findings_optional', yourFindings: own, issuesToRecheck,
-                rules: { ...this.consensusRules(session), severity: SEVERITY_GUIDE, requiredAction: REQUIRED_ACTION_GUIDE,
+            return {
+                ...base,
+                task: required ? 'file_findings' : 'file_findings_optional',
+                yourFindings: own,
+                issuesToRecheck,
+                rules: {
+                    ...this.consensusRules(session),
+                    severity: SEVERITY_GUIDE,
+                    requiredAction: REQUIRED_ACTION_GUIDE,
                     blind: `This is a blind review by ${reviewerCount} reviewer(s). You cannot see anyone else's findings yet, and they cannot see yours. Afterwards each of you votes on the others' findings.`,
-                    scope: 'Review exactly the subject, and when baseline.changedFiles is present, those files. Reporting something outside that scope is what the other reviewers vote down.' },
-                instructions: `Review the code at the pinned baseline in ${session.cwd} and report every finding in ONE call to collab_submit_findings; that call closes your blind review and ends your turn, so gather everything first. location.path and evidence are mandatory, and evidence must be something you verified in this checkout. ${issuesToRecheck.length ? `Also include one rechecks[] entry (outcome resolved or still_present, with a rationale) for each of the ${issuesToRecheck.length} issuesToRecheck entries. ` : ''}Rate severity and requiredAction by rules.severity and rules.requiredAction, not by how important the finding feels.` };
+                    scope: 'Review exactly the subject, and when baseline.changedFiles is present, those files. Reporting something outside that scope is what the other reviewers vote down.'
+                },
+                instructions: `Review the code at the pinned baseline in ${session.cwd} and report every finding in ONE call to collab_submit_findings; that call closes your blind review and ends your turn, so gather everything first. location.path and evidence are mandatory, and evidence must be something you verified in this checkout. ${issuesToRecheck.length ? `Also include one rechecks[] entry (outcome resolved or still_present, with a rationale) for each of the ${issuesToRecheck.length} issuesToRecheck entries. ` : ''}Rate severity and requiredAction by rules.severity and rules.requiredAction, not by how important the finding feels.`
+            };
         }
         if (session.phase === 'validating')
             return this.crossVoteDigest(session, participant, snapshot, base, 'You have voted on every finding that needs your ballot. End your turn; the hub calls you back if later findings need one.');
@@ -874,8 +1203,13 @@ export class CollabHub {
             const proposals = this.store.listMergeProposals(session.sessionId), owed = proposals.filter(proposal => !proposal.votes.some(vote => vote.participantId === participant.participantId));
             if (!owed.length)
                 return this.waitDigest(session, base);
-            return { ...base, task: 'vote_on_merges', mergeProposals: proposals, yourRequiredProposalIds: owed.map(entry => entry.proposalId),
-                instructions: 'Call collab_submit_merge_votes once with a vote on every proposal in yourRequiredProposalIds. A merge is applied only if every reviewer approves it, so reject anything that would fold two genuinely different findings into one; rejecting requires a rationale.' };
+            return {
+                ...base,
+                task: 'vote_on_merges',
+                mergeProposals: proposals,
+                yourRequiredProposalIds: owed.map(entry => entry.proposalId),
+                instructions: 'Call collab_submit_merge_votes once with a vote on every proposal in yourRequiredProposalIds. A merge is applied only if every reviewer approves it, so reject anything that would fold two genuinely different findings into one; rejecting requires a rationale.'
+            };
         }
         if (session.phase === 'issue_discussing') {
             const consensus = this.annotatedConsensus(session, snapshot), active = new Set(activeContestedIssueIds(snapshot));
@@ -883,42 +1217,68 @@ export class CollabHub {
             if (!owed.length)
                 return this.waitDigest(session, base);
             const alone = owed.filter(entry => entry.reporterId === participant.participantId && entry.panelRejected).length;
-            return { ...base, task: 'defend_approved_issues', consensus, issues: owed.map(entry => this.withHistory(this.store.getIssue(entry.issueId))),
-                yourRequiredIssueIds: owed.map(entry => entry.issueId), rules: this.consensusRules(session),
-                instructions: `Reviewers rejected the findings in yourRequiredIssueIds and you are a current supporter of each. Call collab_submit_issue_discussions ONCE; it ends your turn, so put everything into that single call. For each finding either answer the rejection with evidence in discussions[], or, if you are its reporter and no longer stand by it, drop it in withdrawals[] with the reason${alone ? ` — ${alone === 1 ? 'one of them is' : `${alone} of them are`} now rejected by every other reviewer, so withdrawing is the expected outcome unless you have new evidence` : ''}. consensus[].positions holds what the rejecters actually argued. If this genuinely needs the human operator, call collab_escalate first: it does not end your turn.` };
+            return {
+                ...base,
+                task: 'defend_approved_issues',
+                consensus,
+                issues: owed.map(entry => this.withHistory(this.store.getIssue(entry.issueId))),
+                yourRequiredIssueIds: owed.map(entry => entry.issueId),
+                rules: this.consensusRules(session),
+                instructions: `Reviewers rejected the findings in yourRequiredIssueIds and you are a current supporter of each. Call collab_submit_issue_discussions ONCE; it ends your turn, so put everything into that single call. For each finding either answer the rejection with evidence in discussions[], or, if you are its reporter and no longer stand by it, drop it in withdrawals[] with the reason${alone ? ` — ${alone === 1 ? 'one of them is' : `${alone} of them are`} now rejected by every other reviewer, so withdrawing is the expected outcome unless you have new evidence` : ''}. consensus[].positions holds what the rejecters actually argued. If this genuinely needs the human operator, call collab_escalate first: it does not end your turn.`
+            };
         }
         if (session.phase === 'issue_reconsidering') {
             const consensus = this.annotatedConsensus(session, snapshot), active = new Set(activeContestedIssueIds(snapshot));
             const owed = consensus.filter(entry => active.has(entry.issueId) && entry.rejecters.includes(participant.participantId));
             if (!owed.length)
                 return this.waitDigest(session, base);
-            return { ...base, task: 'reconsider_issue_votes', consensus, issues: owed.map(entry => this.withHistory(this.store.getIssue(entry.issueId))),
-                yourRequiredIssueIds: owed.map(entry => entry.issueId), rules: this.consensusRules(session),
-                instructions: 'Read the supporters\' latest arguments in issues[].history, then call collab_submit_issue_votes once with a vote for every finding in yourRequiredIssueIds. Switch to approve if the argument answered your objection; keeping reject still requires a rationale that engages with what was argued. A rationale that only repeats your previous one ends the discussion for that finding.' };
+            return {
+                ...base,
+                task: 'reconsider_issue_votes',
+                consensus,
+                issues: owed.map(entry => this.withHistory(this.store.getIssue(entry.issueId))),
+                yourRequiredIssueIds: owed.map(entry => entry.issueId),
+                rules: this.consensusRules(session),
+                instructions: "Read the supporters' latest arguments in issues[].history, then call collab_submit_issue_votes once with a vote for every finding in yourRequiredIssueIds. Switch to approve if the argument answered your objection; keeping reject still requires a rationale that engages with what was argued. A rationale that only repeats your previous one ends the discussion for that finding."
+            };
         }
         return this.waitDigest(session, base);
     }
     /** The panel's own rules, in the prompt, so a vote is cast against a known standard instead of a guess. */
     consensusRules(session) {
-        return { vote: VOTE_GUIDE,
+        return {
+            vote: VOTE_GUIDE,
             contested: `Any reject makes a finding contested: its supporters answer with evidence, then the rejecters vote again, for at most ${session.policy.maxConsensusRounds} round(s).`,
             outcome: 'Still contested at the end: a finding every other reviewer rejected is dropped, a split panel is decided by majority, and only a blocker/critical dispute reaches the human operator.',
-            withdraw: 'The reporter of a finding may withdraw it at any time (collab_withdraw_issue, or withdrawals[] in collab_submit_issue_discussions). Withdrawing something you no longer stand by is a normal, expected move, not a failure.' };
+            withdraw: 'The reporter of a finding may withdraw it at any time (collab_withdraw_issue, or withdrawals[] in collab_submit_issue_discussions). Withdrawing something you no longer stand by is a normal, expected move, not a failure.'
+        };
     }
     /** Consensus board plus the two facts a defender needs: who filed it, and whether anybody else still agrees. */
     annotatedConsensus(session, snapshot) {
-        const panel = this.store.listParticipants(session.sessionId).filter(entry => entry.role === 'reviewer' && entry.state !== 'left');
+        const panel = this.store
+            .listParticipants(session.sessionId)
+            .filter(entry => entry.role === 'reviewer' && entry.state !== 'left');
         return issueConsensus(snapshot).map(entry => {
             const issue = this.store.getIssue(entry.issueId), voters = panel.filter(reviewer => reviewer.participantId !== issue.reporterId);
-            return { ...entry, reporterId: issue.reporterId, severity: issue.severity, title: issue.title,
-                panelRejected: voters.length > 0 && voters.every(reviewer => entry.rejecters.includes(reviewer.participantId)) };
+            return {
+                ...entry,
+                reporterId: issue.reporterId,
+                severity: issue.severity,
+                title: issue.title,
+                panelRejected: voters.length > 0 && voters.every(reviewer => entry.rejecters.includes(reviewer.participantId))
+            };
         });
     }
     /** A seat with nothing to do must be told exactly that: a stale phase blurb reads as work that was not done. */
     waitDigest(session, base, reason) {
-        return { ...base, task: 'wait', instructions: reason ?? (session.phase === 'awaiting_human'
-                ? 'A human ruling is pending. Nothing is required from you. Do not resubmit and do not poll; end your turn.'
-                : 'Nothing is required from you right now. Do not submit anything; end your turn. The hub prompts you when something needs you.') };
+        return {
+            ...base,
+            task: 'wait',
+            instructions: reason ??
+                (session.phase === 'awaiting_human'
+                    ? 'A human ruling is pending. Nothing is required from you. Do not resubmit and do not poll; end your turn.'
+                    : 'Nothing is required from you right now. Do not submit anything; end your turn. The hub prompts you when something needs you.')
+        };
     }
     /**
      * The concrete file list behind a review subject. Without it every reviewer re-derives the scope from prose
@@ -926,14 +1286,22 @@ export class CollabHub {
      * disagreement about findings rather than about scope. Derived, never persisted: a function of the pinned commit.
      */
     scopeCache = new Map();
-    scopeKey(session, baseline) { return `${session.sessionId}:${baseline.commit ?? ''}:${baseline.dirtyHash ?? ''}`; }
+    scopeKey(session, baseline) {
+        return `${session.sessionId}:${baseline.commit ?? ''}:${baseline.dirtyHash ?? ''}`;
+    }
     /** Only bare refs/ranges are forwarded, never flags: in the `free` case the value is human-authored prose. */
     scopeArgs(session) {
-        const tokens = session.subject.value.split(/\s+/).filter(token => token && !token.startsWith('-') && !['git', 'diff', 'log', 'show'].includes(token)).slice(0, 2);
+        const tokens = session.subject.value
+            .split(/\s+/)
+            .filter(token => token && !token.startsWith('-') && !['git', 'diff', 'log', 'show'].includes(token))
+            .slice(0, 2);
         return ['diff', '--name-only', ...(tokens.length ? tokens : ['HEAD'])];
     }
     toScope(stdout) {
-        const files = stdout.split('\n').map(line => line.trim()).filter(Boolean);
+        const files = stdout
+            .split('\n')
+            .map(line => line.trim())
+            .filter(Boolean);
         return { changedFiles: files.slice(0, 200), changedFilesTruncated: files.length > 200 };
     }
     reviewScope(session, baseline) {
@@ -949,7 +1317,13 @@ export class CollabHub {
         // event loop - on every digest, which currentTaskFor now triggers on every dispatch attempt as well.
         let scope = {};
         try {
-            scope = this.toScope(execFileSync('git', this.scopeArgs(session), { cwd: session.cwd, encoding: 'utf8', timeout: 10_000, maxBuffer: 4 * 1024 * 1024, stdio: ['ignore', 'pipe', 'ignore'] }));
+            scope = this.toScope(execFileSync('git', this.scopeArgs(session), {
+                cwd: session.cwd,
+                encoding: 'utf8',
+                timeout: 10_000,
+                maxBuffer: 4 * 1024 * 1024,
+                stdio: ['ignore', 'pipe', 'ignore']
+            }));
         }
         catch {
             scope = {};
@@ -968,7 +1342,11 @@ export class CollabHub {
         if (this.scopeCache.has(key))
             return;
         try {
-            this.scopeCache.set(key, this.toScope((await run('git', this.scopeArgs(session), { cwd: session.cwd, timeout: 10_000, maxBuffer: 4 * 1024 * 1024 })).stdout));
+            this.scopeCache.set(key, this.toScope((await run('git', this.scopeArgs(session), {
+                cwd: session.cwd,
+                timeout: 10_000,
+                maxBuffer: 4 * 1024 * 1024
+            })).stdout));
         }
         catch {
             this.scopeCache.set(key, {});
@@ -976,25 +1354,61 @@ export class CollabHub {
     }
     reviewSummary(sessionId) {
         const issues = this.store.listIssues(sessionId), severityOrder = { blocker: 0, critical: 1, major: 2, minor: 3, nit: 4 };
-        const entries = issues.map(issue => {
+        const entries = issues
+            .map(issue => {
             const messages = this.store.listIssueMessages(issue.issueId), response = [...messages].reverse().find(message => message.kind === 'response'), verdict = [...messages].reverse().find(message => message.kind === 'verdict');
             const responseType = typeof response?.payload.responseType === 'string' ? response.payload.responseType : undefined, verdictType = typeof verdict?.payload.verdict === 'string' ? verdict.payload.verdict : undefined;
             // Historical versions mapped every accepted response to `resolved`. Derive the actionable disposition from
             // the actual response so a deferred finding never disappears from the close-out report as "fixed".
-            const disposition = responseType === 'deferred' && verdictType === 'accept' ? 'deferred' : responseType === 'rejected' && verdictType === 'accept' ? 'wontfix' : responseType === 'needs_info' && verdictType === 'accept' ? 'needs_info' : issue.status;
-            const requiresAction = ['open', 'confirmed', 'answered', 'escalated', 'deferred', 'needs_info'].includes(disposition) || responseType === 'partially_fixed';
-            return { number: issue.number, issueId: issue.issueId, title: issue.title, severity: issue.severity, status: issue.status, disposition, requiresAction, category: issue.category, requiredAction: issue.requiredAction,
-                location: issue.location, description: issue.suggestion || issue.impact || issue.evidence || issue.title, evidence: issue.evidence, impact: issue.impact, suggestion: issue.suggestion,
-                response: response ? { responseType, rationale: response.payload.rationale, changes: response.payload.changes ?? [] } : undefined, verdict: verdict ? { verdict: verdictType, rationale: verdict.payload.rationale } : undefined };
-        }).sort((a, b) => (severityOrder[a.severity] ?? 99) - (severityOrder[b.severity] ?? 99) || a.number - b.number);
+            const disposition = responseType === 'deferred' && verdictType === 'accept'
+                ? 'deferred'
+                : responseType === 'rejected' && verdictType === 'accept'
+                    ? 'wontfix'
+                    : responseType === 'needs_info' && verdictType === 'accept'
+                        ? 'needs_info'
+                        : issue.status;
+            const requiresAction = ['open', 'confirmed', 'answered', 'escalated', 'deferred', 'needs_info'].includes(disposition) ||
+                responseType === 'partially_fixed';
+            return {
+                number: issue.number,
+                issueId: issue.issueId,
+                title: issue.title,
+                severity: issue.severity,
+                status: issue.status,
+                disposition,
+                requiresAction,
+                category: issue.category,
+                requiredAction: issue.requiredAction,
+                location: issue.location,
+                description: issue.suggestion || issue.impact || issue.evidence || issue.title,
+                evidence: issue.evidence,
+                impact: issue.impact,
+                suggestion: issue.suggestion,
+                response: response
+                    ? { responseType, rationale: response.payload.rationale, changes: response.payload.changes ?? [] }
+                    : undefined,
+                verdict: verdict ? { verdict: verdictType, rationale: verdict.payload.rationale } : undefined
+            };
+        })
+            .sort((a, b) => (severityOrder[a.severity] ?? 99) - (severityOrder[b.severity] ?? 99) || a.number - b.number);
         const actionItems = entries.filter(entry => entry.requiresAction), bySeverity = {}, byDisposition = {};
         for (const entry of entries) {
             bySeverity[entry.severity] = (bySeverity[entry.severity] ?? 0) + 1;
             byDisposition[entry.disposition] = (byDisposition[entry.disposition] ?? 0) + 1;
         }
         const urgent = actionItems.filter(entry => entry.severity === 'blocker' || entry.severity === 'critical').length;
-        return { description: actionItems.length ? `${actionItems.length} issue(s) still require implementation or follow-up${urgent ? `, including ${urgent} blocker/critical` : ''}.` : `All ${entries.length} reviewed issue(s) have a terminal disposition and no remaining implementation action.`,
-            verdict: actionItems.length ? (urgent ? 'changes_required' : 'follow_up_required') : 'approved', totalIssues: entries.length, actionItemCount: actionItems.length, bySeverity, byDisposition, actionItems, issues: entries };
+        return {
+            description: actionItems.length
+                ? `${actionItems.length} issue(s) still require implementation or follow-up${urgent ? `, including ${urgent} blocker/critical` : ''}.`
+                : `All ${entries.length} reviewed issue(s) have a terminal disposition and no remaining implementation action.`,
+            verdict: actionItems.length ? (urgent ? 'changes_required' : 'follow_up_required') : 'approved',
+            totalIssues: entries.length,
+            actionItemCount: actionItems.length,
+            bySeverity,
+            byDisposition,
+            actionItems,
+            issues: entries
+        };
     }
     reviewConsensus(sessionId, viewer) {
         const session = this.store.getSession(sessionId), snapshot = this.snapshot(sessionId);
@@ -1002,7 +1416,18 @@ export class CollabHub {
             throw flowError(COLLAB_ERRORS.forbidden, 'Consensus data stays sealed until every reviewer finishes collection', 403);
         // The state machine only evaluates still-open issues, but the board is also an audit view after finish.
         // Include terminal/resolved/merged issues here so their historical ballots do not disappear at close-out.
-        return { phase: session.phase, round: session.round, consensusRound: session.debateRound, issueVotes: this.store.listIssueVotes(sessionId), issueConsensus: issueConsensus(snapshot, { includeFinal: true }), mergeProposals: this.store.listMergeProposals(sessionId), discussions: this.store.listIssues(sessionId).flatMap(issue => this.store.listIssueMessages(issue.issueId).filter(message => message.kind === 'discussion')), summary: this.reviewSummary(sessionId) };
+        return {
+            phase: session.phase,
+            round: session.round,
+            consensusRound: session.debateRound,
+            issueVotes: this.store.listIssueVotes(sessionId),
+            issueConsensus: issueConsensus(snapshot, { includeFinal: true }),
+            mergeProposals: this.store.listMergeProposals(sessionId),
+            discussions: this.store
+                .listIssues(sessionId)
+                .flatMap(issue => this.store.listIssueMessages(issue.issueId).filter(message => message.kind === 'discussion')),
+            summary: this.reviewSummary(sessionId)
+        };
     }
     /**
      * Per-round audit of a review. The single issue list only ever shows the *current* verdict, so once a recheck
@@ -1014,12 +1439,32 @@ export class CollabHub {
         const session = this.store.getSession(sessionId);
         if (session.kind !== 'review')
             throw flowError(COLLAB_ERRORS.wrongPhase, 'Round history exists for review sessions only');
-        const issues = this.store.listIssues(sessionId), events = this.store.listEventsByType(sessionId, ['review_reopened', 'phase_changed', 'session_finished']);
+        const issues = this.store.listIssues(sessionId), events = this.store.listEventsByType(sessionId, [
+            'review_reopened',
+            'phase_changed',
+            'session_finished'
+        ]);
         const history = new Map(issues.map(issue => [issue.issueId, this.store.listIssueMessages(issue.issueId)]));
-        const rechecksOf = (issueId) => (history.get(issueId) ?? []).filter(message => message.kind === 'recheck')
-            .map(message => ({ round: Number(message.payload.reviewRound ?? message.round), outcome: String(message.payload.outcome ?? ''), rationale: String(message.payload.rationale ?? ''), reviewerId: message.authorId, at: message.createdAt }));
-        const brief = (issue) => ({ issueId: issue.issueId, number: issue.number, title: issue.title, severity: issue.severity, category: issue.category,
-            status: issue.status, reporterId: issue.reporterId, location: issue.location, foundInRound: issue.round });
+        const rechecksOf = (issueId) => (history.get(issueId) ?? [])
+            .filter(message => message.kind === 'recheck')
+            .map(message => ({
+            round: Number(message.payload.reviewRound ?? message.round),
+            outcome: String(message.payload.outcome ?? ''),
+            rationale: String(message.payload.rationale ?? ''),
+            reviewerId: message.authorId,
+            at: message.createdAt
+        }));
+        const brief = (issue) => ({
+            issueId: issue.issueId,
+            number: issue.number,
+            title: issue.title,
+            severity: issue.severity,
+            category: issue.category,
+            status: issue.status,
+            reporterId: issue.reporterId,
+            location: issue.location,
+            foundInRound: issue.round
+        });
         // A recheck only ever closes an issue by writing `resolved`. Sessions recorded by the older
         // respond/adjudicate flow closed findings with no recheck message at all, so where this round left no
         // recheck evidence the current status decides — otherwise every long-closed legacy finding would be
@@ -1043,22 +1488,46 @@ export class CollabHub {
                 const done = rechecksOf(issue.issueId).find(entry => entry.round === round);
                 // `pending` is not a reviewer verdict: it is "this wave never reported back on it", which for the live
                 // round means still owed and for a closed round means it was carried further without an answer.
-                return { ...brief(issue), outcome: done ? done.outcome : 'pending', rationale: done?.rationale ?? '', reviewerId: done?.reviewerId ?? issue.reporterId, at: done?.at };
+                return {
+                    ...brief(issue),
+                    outcome: done ? done.outcome : 'pending',
+                    rationale: done?.rationale ?? '',
+                    reviewerId: done?.reviewerId ?? issue.reporterId,
+                    at: done?.at
+                };
             });
-            const newIssues = issues.filter(issue => issue.round === round).map(issue => ({ ...brief(issue),
-                rechecks: rechecksOf(issue.issueId).filter(entry => entry.round > round) }));
-            const finishedEvent = events.find(event => event.type === 'phase_changed' && event.payload.to === 'finished' && Number(event.payload.round) === round);
-            const closed = finishedEvent ? events.find(event => event.type === 'session_finished' && event.sequence > finishedEvent.sequence) : undefined;
+            const newIssues = issues
+                .filter(issue => issue.round === round)
+                .map(issue => ({
+                ...brief(issue),
+                rechecks: rechecksOf(issue.issueId).filter(entry => entry.round > round)
+            }));
+            const finishedEvent = events.find(event => event.type === 'phase_changed' &&
+                event.payload.to === 'finished' &&
+                Number(event.payload.round) === round);
+            const closed = finishedEvent
+                ? events.find(event => event.type === 'session_finished' && event.sequence > finishedEvent.sequence)
+                : undefined;
             const verdict = closed?.payload.outcome?.verdict;
-            rounds.push({ round, mode: round === 1 ? 'initial' : String(reopened?.payload.mode ?? 'recheck'),
-                startedAt: round === 1 ? session.createdAt : reopened?.createdAt, finishedAt: finishedEvent?.createdAt,
+            rounds.push({
+                round,
+                mode: round === 1 ? 'initial' : String(reopened?.payload.mode ?? 'recheck'),
+                startedAt: round === 1 ? session.createdAt : reopened?.createdAt,
+                finishedAt: finishedEvent?.createdAt,
                 status: round < session.round || session.status !== 'active' ? 'finished' : 'in_progress',
-                phase: round === session.round ? session.phase : 'finished', verdict,
+                phase: round === session.round ? session.phase : 'finished',
+                verdict,
                 baseline: this.store.getBaselineForRound(sessionId, round),
-                rechecks, newIssues,
-                counts: { carried: carried.length, resolved: rechecks.filter(entry => entry.outcome === 'resolved').length,
+                rechecks,
+                newIssues,
+                counts: {
+                    carried: carried.length,
+                    resolved: rechecks.filter(entry => entry.outcome === 'resolved').length,
                     stillPresent: rechecks.filter(entry => entry.outcome === 'still_present').length,
-                    pending: rechecks.filter(entry => entry.outcome === 'pending').length, newIssues: newIssues.length } });
+                    pending: rechecks.filter(entry => entry.outcome === 'pending').length,
+                    newIssues: newIssues.length
+                }
+            });
         }
         return rounds;
     }
@@ -1068,16 +1537,21 @@ export class CollabHub {
         const issues = this.store.listIssues(session.sessionId);
         if (canSeeOthersFindings(snapshot))
             return issues;
-        return issues.filter(issue => issue.reporterId === participant.participantId || issue.targetParticipantId === participant.participantId);
+        return issues.filter(issue => issue.reporterId === participant.participantId ||
+            issue.targetParticipantId === participant.participantId);
     }
     /**
      * Event history. A participant token may read the timeline, but not through it: while a phase is sealed the
      * payload of somebody else's submission is withheld, otherwise `blindFindings` could be defeated by
      * reading `issue_opened` (title, severity, target) out of the log.
      */
-    events(sessionId, since = 0, limit = 500, viewer) { return this.redactEvents(sessionId, this.store.listEvents(sessionId, since, limit), viewer); }
+    events(sessionId, since = 0, limit = 500, viewer) {
+        return this.redactEvents(sessionId, this.store.listEvents(sessionId, since, limit), viewer);
+    }
     /** Tail of the timeline. The board needs the *latest* events; paging from sequence 0 stops showing new ones. */
-    recentEvents(sessionId, limit = 200, viewer) { return this.redactEvents(sessionId, this.store.listRecentEvents(sessionId, limit), viewer); }
+    recentEvents(sessionId, limit = 200, viewer) {
+        return this.redactEvents(sessionId, this.store.listRecentEvents(sessionId, limit), viewer);
+    }
     redactEvents(sessionId, events, viewer) {
         if (!viewer)
             return events;
@@ -1101,9 +1575,14 @@ export class CollabHub {
             return events;
         // The event itself stays visible so sequence numbers remain a usable cursor; only its content is withheld.
         return events.map(event => sealed.has(event.type) && event.actorId !== viewer.participantId
-            ? { ...event, payload: { redacted: true, reason: 'sealed_until_the_phase_closes' } } : event);
+            ? { ...event, payload: { redacted: true, reason: 'sealed_until_the_phase_closes' } }
+            : event);
+    }
+    progress(sessionId) {
+        return this.store.getSession(sessionId).kind === 'scoring'
+            ? scoringProgress(this.scoringSnapshot(sessionId))
+            : sessionProgress(this.snapshot(sessionId));
     }
-    progress(sessionId) { return this.store.getSession(sessionId).kind === 'scoring' ? scoringProgress(this.scoringSnapshot(sessionId)) : sessionProgress(this.snapshot(sessionId)); }
     /** Same blindness rule as listIssues(): a sealed finding must not be readable through its id either. */
     issueDetail(sessionId, issueId, viewer) {
         const issue = this.store.findIssueInSession(sessionId, issueId);
@@ -1113,7 +1592,9 @@ export class CollabHub {
     }
     /** A participant may read an issue it filed or one addressed to it; everything else waits for the seal to lift. */
     canSeeIssue(sessionId, issue, viewer) {
-        return issue.reporterId === viewer.participantId || issue.targetParticipantId === viewer.participantId || canSeeOthersFindings(this.snapshot(sessionId));
+        return (issue.reporterId === viewer.participantId ||
+            issue.targetParticipantId === viewer.participantId ||
+            canSeeOthersFindings(this.snapshot(sessionId)));
     }
     // ---------------------------------------------------------------- scoring session operations
     /** Blind nomination: a participant only sees its own proposals until the panel finishes. */
@@ -1126,9 +1607,19 @@ export class CollabHub {
         assertScoringCapability(this.toFlowParticipant(participant), 'nominate');
         assertScoringPhase(snapshot, ['nominating'], 'Nominating criteria');
         const accepted = input.nominations.map(nomination => {
-            const criterion = this.store.createCriterion({ sessionId: session.sessionId, name: nomination.name, definition: nomination.definition,
-                anchors: nomination.anchors, weight: nomination.weightSuggestion,
-                source: { participantId: participant.participantId, externalId: nomination.externalId, rationale: nomination.rationale }, round: session.round });
+            const criterion = this.store.createCriterion({
+                sessionId: session.sessionId,
+                name: nomination.name,
+                definition: nomination.definition,
+                anchors: nomination.anchors,
+                weight: nomination.weightSuggestion,
+                source: {
+                    participantId: participant.participantId,
+                    externalId: nomination.externalId,
+                    rationale: nomination.rationale
+                },
+                round: session.round
+            });
             return { externalId: nomination.externalId, criterionId: criterion.criterionId, name: criterion.name };
         });
         if (input.nominationsComplete)
@@ -1147,7 +1638,10 @@ export class CollabHub {
         const session = this.store.getSession(participant.sessionId), snapshot = this.scoringSnapshot(session.sessionId);
         assertScoringCapability(this.toFlowParticipant(participant), 'vote');
         assertScoringPhase(snapshot, ['voting'], 'Voting on criteria');
-        const expected = this.store.listCriteria(session.sessionId).filter(criterion => criterion.state === 'candidate').map(criterion => criterion.criterionId), submitted = input.votes.map(vote => vote.criterionId), voteErrors = [];
+        const expected = this.store
+            .listCriteria(session.sessionId)
+            .filter(criterion => criterion.state === 'candidate')
+            .map(criterion => criterion.criterionId), submitted = input.votes.map(vote => vote.criterionId), voteErrors = [];
         for (const criterionId of expected)
             if (!submitted.includes(criterionId))
                 voteErrors.push(fieldError('votes', 'REQUIRED', `A vote for criterion ${criterionId} is required`));
@@ -1170,10 +1664,23 @@ export class CollabHub {
         for (const vote of input.votes) {
             const criterion = this.store.findCriterionInSession(session.sessionId, vote.criterionId);
             if (!criterion || criterion.state !== 'candidate') {
-                rejected.push({ criterionId: vote.criterionId, code: COLLAB_ERRORS.criterionNotFound, message: 'Unknown or already decided criterion' });
+                rejected.push({
+                    criterionId: vote.criterionId,
+                    code: COLLAB_ERRORS.criterionNotFound,
+                    message: 'Unknown or already decided criterion'
+                });
                 continue;
             }
-            this.store.saveVote({ sessionId: session.sessionId, criterionId: vote.criterionId, participantId: participant.participantId, round: session.round, stance: vote.stance, weight: vote.weight, amendment: vote.amendment, rationale: vote.rationale });
+            this.store.saveVote({
+                sessionId: session.sessionId,
+                criterionId: vote.criterionId,
+                participantId: participant.participantId,
+                round: session.round,
+                stance: vote.stance,
+                weight: vote.weight,
+                amendment: vote.amendment,
+                rationale: vote.rationale
+            });
             accepted.push(vote.criterionId);
         }
         const response = { accepted, rejected, round: session.round };
@@ -1192,9 +1699,15 @@ export class CollabHub {
         assertScoringPhase(snapshot, ['scoring', 'rescoring'], 'Scoring');
         await this.assertBaselineCurrent(session);
         const { scale } = session.policy.scoring, round = snapshot.phase === 'rescoring' ? session.debateRound + 1 : session.debateRound;
-        const expected = (snapshot.phase === 'rescoring'
-            ? this.store.listDebates(session.sessionId).filter(debate => debate.round === session.debateRound).map(debate => debate.criterionId)
-            : this.store.listCriteria(session.sessionId).filter(criterion => criterion.state === 'approved').map(criterion => criterion.criterionId));
+        const expected = snapshot.phase === 'rescoring'
+            ? this.store
+                .listDebates(session.sessionId)
+                .filter(debate => debate.round === session.debateRound)
+                .map(debate => debate.criterionId)
+            : this.store
+                .listCriteria(session.sessionId)
+                .filter(criterion => criterion.state === 'approved')
+                .map(criterion => criterion.criterionId);
         const submitted = input.scores.map(entry => entry.criterionId), errors = [];
         for (const criterionId of expected)
             if (!submitted.includes(criterionId))
@@ -1221,10 +1734,24 @@ export class CollabHub {
         for (const entry of input.scores) {
             const criterion = this.store.findCriterionInSession(session.sessionId, entry.criterionId);
             if (!criterion || criterion.state !== 'approved') {
-                rejected.push({ criterionId: entry.criterionId, code: COLLAB_ERRORS.criterionNotFound, message: 'Criterion is not part of the locked rubric' });
+                rejected.push({
+                    criterionId: entry.criterionId,
+                    code: COLLAB_ERRORS.criterionNotFound,
+                    message: 'Criterion is not part of the locked rubric'
+                });
                 continue;
             }
-            this.store.saveScore({ sessionId: session.sessionId, criterionId: entry.criterionId, participantId: participant.participantId, round, score: entry.score, rationale: entry.rationale, evidence: entry.evidence, confidence: entry.confidence, changeReason: entry.changeReason });
+            this.store.saveScore({
+                sessionId: session.sessionId,
+                criterionId: entry.criterionId,
+                participantId: participant.participantId,
+                round,
+                score: entry.score,
+                rationale: entry.rationale,
+                evidence: entry.evidence,
+                confidence: entry.confidence,
+                changeReason: entry.changeReason
+            });
             accepted.push(entry.criterionId);
         }
         const response = { accepted, rejected, round };
@@ -1248,7 +1775,13 @@ export class CollabHub {
         const debate = this.store.findDebateInSession(session.sessionId, debateId);
         if (!debate || debate.status !== 'open')
             throw flowError(COLLAB_ERRORS.debateNotFound, 'Debate not found or already closed', 404);
-        const argumentId = this.store.addDebateArgument(debateId, { participantId: participant.participantId, stance: input.stance, argument: input.argument, evidence: input.evidence, respondingTo: input.respondingTo });
+        const argumentId = this.store.addDebateArgument(debateId, {
+            participantId: participant.participantId,
+            stance: input.stance,
+            argument: input.argument,
+            evidence: input.evidence,
+            respondingTo: input.respondingTo
+        });
         const response = { argumentId, debateId, criterionId: debate.criterionId };
         this.finish(participant, input.clientRequestId, body, input.usage, response);
         this.record(session.sessionId, 'debate_argument', { debateId, criterionId: debate.criterionId, stance: input.stance }, participant.participantId);
@@ -1264,9 +1797,15 @@ export class CollabHub {
         assertScoringCapability(this.toFlowParticipant(participant), 'debate');
         assertScoringPhase(snapshot, ['debating'], 'Debating');
         await this.assertBaselineCurrent(session);
-        const expected = this.store.listDebates(session.sessionId).filter(debate => debate.status === 'open' && debate.round === session.debateRound
-            && this.store.listScores(session.sessionId).some(score => score.criterionId === debate.criterionId && score.participantId === participant.participantId)
-            && !debate.arguments.some(argument => argument.participantId === participant.participantId)).map(debate => debate.debateId);
+        const expected = this.store
+            .listDebates(session.sessionId)
+            .filter(debate => debate.status === 'open' &&
+            debate.round === session.debateRound &&
+            this.store
+                .listScores(session.sessionId)
+                .some(score => score.criterionId === debate.criterionId && score.participantId === participant.participantId) &&
+            !debate.arguments.some(argument => argument.participantId === participant.participantId))
+            .map(debate => debate.debateId);
         const submitted = input.arguments.map(argument => argument.debateId), errors = [];
         for (const debateId of expected)
             if (!submitted.includes(debateId))
@@ -1281,7 +1820,13 @@ export class CollabHub {
             throw new ValidationError(errors);
         const accepted = input.arguments.map(entry => {
             const debate = this.store.findDebateInSession(session.sessionId, entry.debateId);
-            const argumentId = this.store.addDebateArgument(entry.debateId, { participantId: participant.participantId, stance: entry.stance, argument: entry.argument, evidence: entry.evidence, respondingTo: entry.respondingTo });
+            const argumentId = this.store.addDebateArgument(entry.debateId, {
+                participantId: participant.participantId,
+                stance: entry.stance,
+                argument: entry.argument,
+                evidence: entry.evidence,
+                respondingTo: entry.respondingTo
+            });
             this.record(session.sessionId, 'debate_argument', { debateId: entry.debateId, criterionId: debate.criterionId, stance: entry.stance }, participant.participantId);
             return { debateId: entry.debateId, argumentId };
         });
@@ -1295,7 +1840,13 @@ export class CollabHub {
         const snapshot = this.scoringSnapshot(sessionId);
         if (viewer && scoresSealed(snapshot))
             throw flowError(COLLAB_ERRORS.scoresSealed, 'Scores stay sealed until every panelist has submitted', 403);
-        return { phase: snapshot.phase, round: snapshot.round, debateRound: snapshot.debateRound, criteria: analyse(snapshot), contested: contestedCriteria(snapshot).map(entry => entry.criterionId) };
+        return {
+            phase: snapshot.phase,
+            round: snapshot.round,
+            debateRound: snapshot.debateRound,
+            criteria: analyse(snapshot),
+            contested: contestedCriteria(snapshot).map(entry => entry.criterionId)
+        };
     }
     criteria(sessionId, viewer) {
         const snapshot = this.scoringSnapshot(sessionId), all = this.store.listCriteria(sessionId);
@@ -1307,7 +1858,9 @@ export class CollabHub {
     }
     votes(sessionId, viewer) {
         const snapshot = this.scoringSnapshot(sessionId), all = this.store.listVotes(sessionId);
-        return viewer && votesSealed(snapshot) ? all.filter(vote => vote.participantId === viewer.participantId) : all;
+        return viewer && votesSealed(snapshot)
+            ? all.filter(vote => vote.participantId === viewer.participantId)
+            : all;
     }
     /**
      * Human ruling on the criteria a panel could not settle; it also closes the session. It is only accepted in
@@ -1344,7 +1897,11 @@ export class CollabHub {
         const report = finalizeScores(snapshot, rulings);
         // The dispute and the ruling are the same act: leaving the escalation pending would keep the board red forever.
         this.settleScoreDispute(sessionId, 'Final scores were set by a human via /finalize', resolvedBy, input.rulings);
-        this.store.updateSession(sessionId, { phase: 'finalized', status: 'finished', outcome: { ...(session.outcome ?? {}), ...report, rulings: input.rulings, resolvedBy } });
+        this.store.updateSession(sessionId, {
+            phase: 'finalized',
+            status: 'finished',
+            outcome: { ...(session.outcome ?? {}), ...report, rulings: input.rulings, resolvedBy }
+        });
         this.record(sessionId, 'session_finished', { outcome: report }, resolvedBy);
         this.announceFinish(this.store.getSession(sessionId));
         return report;
@@ -1352,13 +1909,49 @@ export class CollabHub {
     scoringSnapshot(sessionId) {
         const session = this.store.getSession(sessionId);
         return {
-            phase: session.phase, round: session.round, debateRound: session.debateRound, policy: session.policy, status: session.status,
-            participants: this.store.listParticipants(sessionId).map(participant => this.toFlowParticipant(participant)),
-            criteria: this.store.listCriteria(sessionId).map(criterion => ({ criterionId: criterion.criterionId, state: criterion.state, name: criterion.name, round: criterion.round, weight: criterion.weight })),
-            votes: this.store.listVotes(sessionId).map(vote => ({ criterionId: vote.criterionId, participantId: vote.participantId, round: vote.round, stance: vote.stance, weight: vote.weight })),
-            scores: this.store.listScores(sessionId).map(score => ({ criterionId: score.criterionId, participantId: score.participantId, round: score.round, score: score.score })),
-            debates: this.store.listDebates(sessionId).map(debate => ({ debateId: debate.debateId, criterionId: debate.criterionId, round: debate.round, status: debate.status, arguments: debate.arguments.map(entry => ({ participantId: entry.participantId })) })),
-            completions: this.store.listCompletions(sessionId).filter(entry => entry.phase === 'nominating').map(entry => ({ phase: 'nominating', round: entry.round, participantId: entry.participantId })),
+            phase: session.phase,
+            round: session.round,
+            debateRound: session.debateRound,
+            policy: session.policy,
+            status: session.status,
+            participants: this.store
+                .listParticipants(sessionId)
+                .map(participant => this.toFlowParticipant(participant)),
+            criteria: this.store.listCriteria(sessionId).map(criterion => ({
+                criterionId: criterion.criterionId,
+                state: criterion.state,
+                name: criterion.name,
+                round: criterion.round,
+                weight: criterion.weight
+            })),
+            votes: this.store.listVotes(sessionId).map(vote => ({
+                criterionId: vote.criterionId,
+                participantId: vote.participantId,
+                round: vote.round,
+                stance: vote.stance,
+                weight: vote.weight
+            })),
+            scores: this.store.listScores(sessionId).map(score => ({
+                criterionId: score.criterionId,
+                participantId: score.participantId,
+                round: score.round,
+                score: score.score
+            })),
+            debates: this.store.listDebates(sessionId).map(debate => ({
+                debateId: debate.debateId,
+                criterionId: debate.criterionId,
+                round: debate.round,
+                status: debate.status,
+                arguments: debate.arguments.map(entry => ({ participantId: entry.participantId }))
+            })),
+            completions: this.store
+                .listCompletions(sessionId)
+                .filter(entry => entry.phase === 'nominating')
+                .map(entry => ({
+                phase: 'nominating',
+                round: entry.round,
+                participantId: entry.participantId
+            })),
             pendingEscalations: this.store.listEscalations({ sessionId, status: 'pending' }).length
         };
     }
@@ -1376,28 +1969,56 @@ export class CollabHub {
             if (!isScoringReadyToAdvance(snapshot) && !(forced && guard === 0))
                 return;
             const result = nextScoringPhase(snapshot, { forced: forced && guard === 0 });
-            if (result.phase === snapshot.phase && result.round === snapshot.round && result.debateRound === snapshot.debateRound)
+            if (result.phase === snapshot.phase &&
+                result.round === snapshot.round &&
+                result.debateRound === snapshot.debateRound)
                 return;
             if (result.rubric)
                 this.applyRubric(sessionId, result.rubric);
             // Leaving awaiting_human always closes the dispute that put us there: a forced advance used to strand a
             // score_dispute that no endpoint could resolve afterwards (/finalize refuses a finished session).
             if (session.phase === 'awaiting_human' && result.phase !== 'awaiting_human')
-                this.settleScoreDispute(sessionId, forced && guard === 0 ? `Closed by a forced advance: ${reason || 'no reason given'}` : 'Closed when the panel left awaiting_human');
+                this.settleScoreDispute(sessionId, forced && guard === 0
+                    ? `Closed by a forced advance: ${reason || 'no reason given'}`
+                    : 'Closed when the panel left awaiting_human');
             if (result.phase === 'debating')
                 for (const criterionId of result.contested ?? [])
                     this.store.createDebate(sessionId, criterionId, session.debateRound);
             if (result.phase === 'rescoring')
                 this.store.closeDebates(sessionId, session.debateRound);
             const finalized = result.phase === 'finalized';
-            const rubricOutcome = result.rubric ? { ...(session.outcome ?? {}), rubricLockedBy: result.rubric.lockedBy, rubricLockReason: result.rubric.reason } : session.outcome;
-            const updated = this.store.updateSession(sessionId, { phase: result.phase, round: result.round, debateRound: result.debateRound,
-                status: finalized ? 'finished' : session.status, stalled: undefined,
-                outcome: finalized ? { ...(rubricOutcome ?? {}), ...finalizeScores(this.scoringSnapshot(sessionId)) } : rubricOutcome });
-            this.record(sessionId, 'phase_changed', { from: session.phase, to: result.phase, round: result.round, debateRound: result.debateRound, reason: result.reason,
-                ...(forced && guard === 0 ? { forced: true, forceReason: reason, skipped: result.skipped ?? [] } : {}), ...(result.contested ? { contested: result.contested } : {}) });
+            const rubricOutcome = result.rubric
+                ? {
+                    ...(session.outcome ?? {}),
+                    rubricLockedBy: result.rubric.lockedBy,
+                    rubricLockReason: result.rubric.reason
+                }
+                : session.outcome;
+            const updated = this.store.updateSession(sessionId, {
+                phase: result.phase,
+                round: result.round,
+                debateRound: result.debateRound,
+                status: finalized ? 'finished' : session.status,
+                stalled: undefined,
+                outcome: finalized
+                    ? { ...(rubricOutcome ?? {}), ...finalizeScores(this.scoringSnapshot(sessionId)) }
+                    : rubricOutcome
+            });
+            this.record(sessionId, 'phase_changed', {
+                from: session.phase,
+                to: result.phase,
+                round: result.round,
+                debateRound: result.debateRound,
+                reason: result.reason,
+                ...(forced && guard === 0 ? { forced: true, forceReason: reason, skipped: result.skipped ?? [] } : {}),
+                ...(result.contested ? { contested: result.contested } : {})
+            });
             if (result.rubric)
-                this.record(sessionId, 'rubric_locked', { lockedBy: result.rubric.lockedBy, reason: result.rubric.reason, criteria: result.rubric.criteria });
+                this.record(sessionId, 'rubric_locked', {
+                    lockedBy: result.rubric.lockedBy,
+                    reason: result.rubric.reason,
+                    criteria: result.rubric.criteria
+                });
             if (finalized) {
                 this.record(sessionId, 'session_finished', { outcome: updated.outcome ?? {} });
                 this.announceFinish(this.store.getSession(sessionId));
@@ -1410,8 +2031,13 @@ export class CollabHub {
     }
     /** Deterministically merges only certain duplicates: normalized names must be identical. Ambiguous semantics stay separate for the panel. */
     consolidateCriteria(sessionId) {
-        const candidates = this.store.listCriteria(sessionId).filter(criterion => criterion.state === 'candidate'), groups = new Map();
-        const key = (name) => name.normalize('NFKC').toLowerCase().replace(/[\s\p{P}\p{S}]+/gu, '');
+        const candidates = this.store
+            .listCriteria(sessionId)
+            .filter(criterion => criterion.state === 'candidate'), groups = new Map();
+        const key = (name) => name
+            .normalize('NFKC')
+            .toLowerCase()
+            .replace(/[\s\p{P}\p{S}]+/gu, '');
         for (const criterion of candidates) {
             const normalized = key(criterion.name);
             groups.set(normalized, [...(groups.get(normalized) ?? []), criterion]);
@@ -1422,11 +2048,21 @@ export class CollabHub {
             const [primary, ...duplicates] = entries;
             const detailed = [...entries].sort((a, b) => b.definition.length - a.definition.length || a.createdAt.localeCompare(b.createdAt))[0];
             const anchored = [...entries].sort((a, b) => Object.keys(b.anchors ?? {}).length - Object.keys(a.anchors ?? {}).length)[0];
-            const sources = entries.flatMap(entry => Array.isArray(entry.source?.sources) ? entry.source.sources : [entry.source].filter(Boolean));
-            this.store.updateCriterion(primary.criterionId, { definition: detailed.definition, anchors: anchored.anchors, source: { sources, mergedCriterionIds: duplicates.map(entry => entry.criterionId) } });
+            const sources = entries.flatMap(entry => Array.isArray(entry.source?.sources)
+                ? entry.source.sources
+                : [entry.source].filter(Boolean));
+            this.store.updateCriterion(primary.criterionId, {
+                definition: detailed.definition,
+                anchors: anchored.anchors,
+                source: { sources, mergedCriterionIds: duplicates.map(entry => entry.criterionId) }
+            });
             for (const duplicate of duplicates)
                 this.store.updateCriterion(duplicate.criterionId, { state: 'rejected' });
-            this.record(sessionId, 'criteria_consolidated', { criterionId: primary.criterionId, mergedCriterionIds: duplicates.map(entry => entry.criterionId), reason: 'identical_normalized_name' });
+            this.record(sessionId, 'criteria_consolidated', {
+                criterionId: primary.criterionId,
+                mergedCriterionIds: duplicates.map(entry => entry.criterionId),
+                reason: 'identical_normalized_name'
+            });
         }
     }
     applyRubric(sessionId, rubric) {
@@ -1440,77 +2076,232 @@ export class CollabHub {
         const pending = this.store.findPendingEscalation(sessionId, 'score_dispute');
         if (!pending)
             return;
-        this.store.resolveEscalation(pending.escalationId, { decision: rulings ? 'scores_ruled' : 'closed_without_ruling', rationale, ...(rulings ? { rulings } : {}) }, resolvedBy);
-        this.record(sessionId, 'escalation_resolved', { escalationId: pending.escalationId, kind: 'score_dispute', decision: rulings ? 'scores_ruled' : 'closed_without_ruling', rationale }, resolvedBy);
+        this.store.resolveEscalation(pending.escalationId, {
+            decision: rulings ? 'scores_ruled' : 'closed_without_ruling',
+            rationale,
+            ...(rulings ? { rulings } : {})
+        }, resolvedBy);
+        this.record(sessionId, 'escalation_resolved', {
+            escalationId: pending.escalationId,
+            kind: 'score_dispute',
+            decision: rulings ? 'scores_ruled' : 'closed_without_ruling',
+            rationale
+        }, resolvedBy);
     }
     raiseScoringEscalation(session, contested) {
         if (this.store.findPendingEscalation(session.sessionId, 'score_dispute'))
             return;
         const names = contested.map(criterionId => this.store.getCriterion(criterionId).name);
-        const escalation = this.store.createEscalation({ sessionId: session.sessionId, kind: 'score_dispute', raisedBy: 'system',
+        const escalation = this.store.createEscalation({
+            sessionId: session.sessionId,
+            kind: 'score_dispute',
+            raisedBy: 'system',
             summary: `After ${session.policy.scoring.maxDebateRounds} debate round(s) the panel still disagrees on: ${names.join(', ')}.`,
-            positions: this.store.listScores(session.sessionId).filter(score => contested.includes(score.criterionId) && score.round === session.debateRound)
-                .map(score => ({ participantId: score.participantId, stance: String(score.score), rationale: score.rationale })),
-            question: 'What is the final score for each contested criterion?', options: ['take the median', 'accept the lower score', 'accept the higher score', 'set a specific score'], urgency: 'normal' });
-        this.record(session.sessionId, 'escalation_raised', { escalationId: escalation.escalationId, kind: 'score_dispute', contested });
+            positions: this.store
+                .listScores(session.sessionId)
+                .filter(score => contested.includes(score.criterionId) && score.round === session.debateRound)
+                .map(score => ({
+                participantId: score.participantId,
+                stance: String(score.score),
+                rationale: score.rationale
+            })),
+            question: 'What is the final score for each contested criterion?',
+            options: [
+                'take the median',
+                'accept the lower score',
+                'accept the higher score',
+                'set a specific score'
+            ],
+            urgency: 'normal'
+        });
+        this.record(session.sessionId, 'escalation_raised', {
+            escalationId: escalation.escalationId,
+            kind: 'score_dispute',
+            contested
+        });
     }
     dispatchScoring(sessionId) {
         const session = this.store.getSession(sessionId), snapshot = this.scoringSnapshot(sessionId);
-        const task = { nominating: 'nominate_criteria', voting: 'vote_on_criteria', scoring: 'score_rubric', debating: 'debate_contested_scores', rescoring: 'rescore_contested' }[session.phase];
+        const task = {
+            nominating: 'nominate_criteria',
+            voting: 'vote_on_criteria',
+            scoring: 'score_rubric',
+            debating: 'debate_contested_scores',
+            rescoring: 'rescore_contested'
+        }[session.phase];
         if (!task)
             return;
-        for (const participantId of scoringWaitingOn(snapshot).length ? scoringWaitingOn(snapshot) : scoringPanel(snapshot).map(entry => entry.participantId)) {
-            this.push(sessionId, participantId, task, { phase: session.phase, round: session.round, debateRound: session.debateRound });
-            this.record(sessionId, 'task_assigned', { participantId, task, phase: session.phase, round: session.round });
+        for (const participantId of scoringWaitingOn(snapshot).length
+            ? scoringWaitingOn(snapshot)
+            : scoringPanel(snapshot).map(entry => entry.participantId)) {
+            this.push(sessionId, participantId, task, {
+                phase: session.phase,
+                round: session.round,
+                debateRound: session.debateRound
+            });
+            this.record(sessionId, 'task_assigned', {
+                participantId,
+                task,
+                phase: session.phase,
+                round: session.round
+            });
         }
     }
     scoringDigest(participant) {
         const session = this.store.getSession(participant.sessionId), snapshot = this.scoringSnapshot(session.sessionId), criteria = this.store.listCriteria(session.sessionId), votes = this.store.listVotes(session.sessionId), scores = this.store.listScores(session.sessionId), debates = this.store.listDebates(session.sessionId);
-        const byId = (ids) => ids.map(id => criteria.find(criterion => criterion.criterionId === id)).filter((entry) => !!entry);
-        const base = { sessionId: session.sessionId, kind: session.kind, title: session.title, phase: session.phase, round: session.round, debateRound: session.debateRound,
-            subject: session.subject, baseline: this.store.getBaselineForRound(session.sessionId, 1), scoringPolicy: session.policy.scoring,
-            you: { participantId: participant.participantId, role: participant.role, displayName: participant.displayName, tokensUsed: participant.tokensUsed, tokenBudget: participant.tokenBudget, state: participant.state },
-            progress: scoringProgress(snapshot), stalled: session.stalled };
+        const byId = (ids) => ids
+            .map(id => criteria.find(criterion => criterion.criterionId === id))
+            .filter((entry) => !!entry);
+        const base = {
+            sessionId: session.sessionId,
+            kind: session.kind,
+            title: session.title,
+            phase: session.phase,
+            round: session.round,
+            debateRound: session.debateRound,
+            subject: session.subject,
+            baseline: this.store.getBaselineForRound(session.sessionId, 1),
+            scoringPolicy: session.policy.scoring,
+            you: {
+                participantId: participant.participantId,
+                role: participant.role,
+                displayName: participant.displayName,
+                tokensUsed: participant.tokensUsed,
+                tokenBudget: participant.tokenBudget,
+                state: participant.state
+            },
+            progress: scoringProgress(snapshot),
+            stalled: session.stalled
+        };
         if (session.phase === 'nominating') {
             const previousRound = session.round > 1 ? session.round - 1 : undefined;
-            return { ...base, task: 'nominate_criteria', yourNominations: criteria.filter(criterion => criterion.round === session.round && criterion.source?.participantId === participant.participantId),
+            return {
+                ...base,
+                task: 'nominate_criteria',
+                yourNominations: criteria.filter(criterion => criterion.round === session.round &&
+                    criterion.source?.participantId === participant.participantId),
                 existingCandidates: criteria.filter(criterion => criterion.state === 'candidate' && criterion.round < session.round),
-                previousRound: previousRound ? { round: previousRound, tallies: tallyVotes(snapshot, previousRound), amendments: votes.filter(vote => vote.round === previousRound && vote.amendment) } : undefined,
-                instructions: `Propose enough distinct scoring criteria to help the panel reach ${session.policy.scoring.minCriteria}-${session.policy.scoring.maxCriteria} dimensions. Include a definition and concrete score anchors. Your current-round proposals stay blind until every reviewer finishes.` };
+                previousRound: previousRound
+                    ? {
+                        round: previousRound,
+                        tallies: tallyVotes(snapshot, previousRound),
+                        amendments: votes.filter(vote => vote.round === previousRound && vote.amendment)
+                    }
+                    : undefined,
+                instructions: `Propose enough distinct scoring criteria to help the panel reach ${session.policy.scoring.minCriteria}-${session.policy.scoring.maxCriteria} dimensions. Include a definition and concrete score anchors. Your current-round proposals stay blind until every reviewer finishes.`
+            };
         }
         if (session.phase === 'voting') {
-            const candidates = criteria.filter(criterion => criterion.state === 'candidate'), required = candidates.filter(criterion => !votes.some(vote => vote.criterionId === criterion.criterionId && vote.participantId === participant.participantId && vote.round === session.round)).map(criterion => criterion.criterionId), previousRound = session.round > 1 ? session.round - 1 : undefined;
-            return { ...base, task: 'vote_on_criteria', candidates, yourRequiredCriterionIds: required,
-                previousRound: previousRound ? { round: previousRound, tallies: tallyVotes(snapshot, previousRound), amendments: votes.filter(vote => vote.round === previousRound && vote.amendment) } : undefined,
-                instructions: `Vote approve, reject, or abstain on every required candidate. The rubric needs ${session.policy.scoring.minCriteria}-${session.policy.scoring.maxCriteria} dimensions. Suggest a weight for approvals; rejecting requires a rationale.` };
+            const candidates = criteria.filter(criterion => criterion.state === 'candidate'), required = candidates
+                .filter(criterion => !votes.some(vote => vote.criterionId === criterion.criterionId &&
+                vote.participantId === participant.participantId &&
+                vote.round === session.round))
+                .map(criterion => criterion.criterionId), previousRound = session.round > 1 ? session.round - 1 : undefined;
+            return {
+                ...base,
+                task: 'vote_on_criteria',
+                candidates,
+                yourRequiredCriterionIds: required,
+                previousRound: previousRound
+                    ? {
+                        round: previousRound,
+                        tallies: tallyVotes(snapshot, previousRound),
+                        amendments: votes.filter(vote => vote.round === previousRound && vote.amendment)
+                    }
+                    : undefined,
+                instructions: `Vote approve, reject, or abstain on every required candidate. The rubric needs ${session.policy.scoring.minCriteria}-${session.policy.scoring.maxCriteria} dimensions. Suggest a weight for approvals; rejecting requires a rationale.`
+            };
         }
         if (session.phase === 'scoring') {
-            const rubric = criteria.filter(criterion => criterion.state === 'approved'), required = rubric.filter(criterion => !scores.some(score => score.criterionId === criterion.criterionId && score.participantId === participant.participantId && score.round === session.debateRound)).map(criterion => criterion.criterionId);
-            return { ...base, task: 'score_rubric', rubric, yourRequiredCriterionIds: required,
-                instructions: `Score every required criterion on the ${session.policy.scoring.scale.min}-${session.policy.scoring.scale.max} scale in increments of ${session.policy.scoring.scale.step}. Apply its definition and anchors independently. Every score needs a rationale and file evidence.` };
+            const rubric = criteria.filter(criterion => criterion.state === 'approved'), required = rubric
+                .filter(criterion => !scores.some(score => score.criterionId === criterion.criterionId &&
+                score.participantId === participant.participantId &&
+                score.round === session.debateRound))
+                .map(criterion => criterion.criterionId);
+            return {
+                ...base,
+                task: 'score_rubric',
+                rubric,
+                yourRequiredCriterionIds: required,
+                instructions: `Score every required criterion on the ${session.policy.scoring.scale.min}-${session.policy.scoring.scale.max} scale in increments of ${session.policy.scoring.scale.step}. Apply its definition and anchors independently. Every score needs a rationale and file evidence.`
+            };
         }
         if (session.phase === 'debating') {
-            const open = debates.filter(debate => debate.status === 'open' && debate.round === session.debateRound), required = open.filter(debate => scores.some(score => score.criterionId === debate.criterionId && score.participantId === participant.participantId) && !debate.arguments.some(argument => argument.participantId === participant.participantId)).map(debate => debate.debateId);
-            return { ...base, task: 'debate_contested_scores', debates: open.map(debate => ({ ...debate, criterion: criteria.find(entry => entry.criterionId === debate.criterionId) })), yourRequiredDebateIds: required, analysis: analyse(snapshot), scoreDetails: scores.filter(score => open.some(debate => debate.criterionId === score.criterionId) && score.round === session.debateRound),
-                instructions: 'Address every required debate using the criterion definition, score evidence, and other panelists arguments. Use hold if you keep your score, raise/lower if the evidence changes your position.' };
+            const open = debates.filter(debate => debate.status === 'open' && debate.round === session.debateRound), required = open
+                .filter(debate => scores.some(score => score.criterionId === debate.criterionId &&
+                score.participantId === participant.participantId) && !debate.arguments.some(argument => argument.participantId === participant.participantId))
+                .map(debate => debate.debateId);
+            return {
+                ...base,
+                task: 'debate_contested_scores',
+                debates: open.map(debate => ({
+                    ...debate,
+                    criterion: criteria.find(entry => entry.criterionId === debate.criterionId)
+                })),
+                yourRequiredDebateIds: required,
+                analysis: analyse(snapshot),
+                scoreDetails: scores.filter(score => open.some(debate => debate.criterionId === score.criterionId) &&
+                    score.round === session.debateRound),
+                instructions: 'Address every required debate using the criterion definition, score evidence, and other panelists arguments. Use hold if you keep your score, raise/lower if the evidence changes your position.'
+            };
         }
         if (session.phase === 'rescoring') {
-            const contested = [...new Set(debates.filter(debate => debate.round === session.debateRound).map(debate => debate.criterionId))], nextRound = session.debateRound + 1, required = contested.filter(criterionId => !scores.some(score => score.criterionId === criterionId && score.participantId === participant.participantId && score.round === nextRound));
-            return { ...base, task: 'rescore_contested', rubric: byId(contested), yourRequiredCriterionIds: required, analysis: analyse(snapshot),
-                debates: debates.filter(debate => debate.round === session.debateRound).map(debate => ({ ...debate, criterion: criteria.find(entry => entry.criterionId === debate.criterionId) })), scoreDetails: scores.filter(score => contested.includes(score.criterionId) && score.round <= session.debateRound),
-                instructions: `Rescore every required contested criterion on the ${session.policy.scoring.scale.min}-${session.policy.scoring.scale.max} scale after reading the debate. Evidence and rationale remain mandatory; changeReason must explain both a change and an explicit hold.` };
+            const contested = [
+                ...new Set(debates.filter(debate => debate.round === session.debateRound).map(debate => debate.criterionId))
+            ], nextRound = session.debateRound + 1, required = contested.filter(criterionId => !scores.some(score => score.criterionId === criterionId &&
+                score.participantId === participant.participantId &&
+                score.round === nextRound));
+            return {
+                ...base,
+                task: 'rescore_contested',
+                rubric: byId(contested),
+                yourRequiredCriterionIds: required,
+                analysis: analyse(snapshot),
+                debates: debates
+                    .filter(debate => debate.round === session.debateRound)
+                    .map(debate => ({
+                    ...debate,
+                    criterion: criteria.find(entry => entry.criterionId === debate.criterionId)
+                })),
+                scoreDetails: scores.filter(score => contested.includes(score.criterionId) && score.round <= session.debateRound),
+                instructions: `Rescore every required contested criterion on the ${session.policy.scoring.scale.min}-${session.policy.scoring.scale.max} scale after reading the debate. Evidence and rationale remain mandatory; changeReason must explain both a change and an explicit hold.`
+            };
         }
-        return { ...base, task: 'wait', instructions: session.phase === 'awaiting_human' ? 'A human is ruling on the contested criteria. End your turn.' : 'Nothing is required from you right now. End your turn.' };
+        return {
+            ...base,
+            task: 'wait',
+            instructions: session.phase === 'awaiting_human'
+                ? 'A human is ruling on the contested criteria. End your turn.'
+                : 'Nothing is required from you right now. End your turn.'
+        };
     }
     // ---------------------------------------------------------------- internals
     snapshot(sessionId) {
         const session = this.store.getSession(sessionId);
         return {
-            phase: session.phase, round: session.round, debateRound: session.debateRound, policy: session.policy, status: session.status,
-            participants: this.store.listParticipants(sessionId).map(participant => this.toFlowParticipant(participant)),
+            phase: session.phase,
+            round: session.round,
+            debateRound: session.debateRound,
+            policy: session.policy,
+            status: session.status,
+            participants: this.store
+                .listParticipants(sessionId)
+                .map(participant => this.toFlowParticipant(participant)),
             issues: this.store.listIssues(sessionId).map(issue => this.toFlowIssue(issue)),
-            issueVotes: this.store.listIssueVotes(sessionId), mergeProposals: this.store.listMergeProposals(sessionId),
-            completions: this.store.listCompletions(sessionId).filter(entry => { const [phase, suffix] = entry.phase.split(':'); return !['issue_discussing', 'issue_reconsidering'].includes(phase) || Number(suffix) === session.debateRound; }).map(entry => ({ phase: entry.phase.split(':')[0], round: entry.round, participantId: entry.participantId })),
+            issueVotes: this.store.listIssueVotes(sessionId),
+            mergeProposals: this.store.listMergeProposals(sessionId),
+            completions: this.store
+                .listCompletions(sessionId)
+                .filter(entry => {
+                const [phase, suffix] = entry.phase.split(':');
+                return (!['issue_discussing', 'issue_reconsidering'].includes(phase) ||
+                    Number(suffix) === session.debateRound);
+            })
+                .map(entry => ({
+                phase: entry.phase.split(':')[0],
+                round: entry.round,
+                participantId: entry.participantId
+            })),
             pendingEscalations: this.store.listEscalations({ sessionId, status: 'pending' }).length
         };
     }
@@ -1527,14 +2318,23 @@ export class CollabHub {
     async applyPhase(session, result, context) {
         const finished = result.phase === 'finished';
         if (context.forced && result.skipped?.length) {
-            const completionPhase = ['issue_discussing', 'issue_reconsidering'].includes(session.phase) ? `${session.phase}:${session.debateRound}` : session.phase;
+            const completionPhase = ['issue_discussing', 'issue_reconsidering'].includes(session.phase)
+                ? `${session.phase}:${session.debateRound}`
+                : session.phase;
             for (const participantId of result.skipped)
                 this.store.markPhaseComplete(session.sessionId, session.round, completionPhase, participantId);
             if (session.phase === 'merge_voting')
-                for (const proposal of this.store.listMergeProposals(session.sessionId).filter(entry => entry.round === session.round))
+                for (const proposal of this.store
+                    .listMergeProposals(session.sessionId)
+                    .filter(entry => entry.round === session.round))
                     for (const participantId of result.skipped)
                         if (!proposal.votes.some(vote => vote.participantId === participantId))
-                            this.store.saveMergeVote({ proposalId: proposal.proposalId, participantId, stance: 'reject', rationale: `Skipped by forced advance: ${context.reason || 'no reason given'}` });
+                            this.store.saveMergeVote({
+                                proposalId: proposal.proposalId,
+                                participantId,
+                                stance: 'reject',
+                                rationale: `Skipped by forced advance: ${context.reason || 'no reason given'}`
+                            });
         }
         if (session.phase === 'merge_voting' && result.phase === 'consolidating')
             this.applyApprovedMerges(session.sessionId);
@@ -1551,10 +2351,29 @@ export class CollabHub {
                 this.store.updateIssue(issue.issueId, { status: 'confirmed' });
                 this.record(session.sessionId, 'issue_confirmed', { issueId: issue.issueId, round: result.round });
             }
-        const updated = this.store.updateSession(session.sessionId, { phase: result.phase, round: result.round, debateRound: result.debateRound ?? session.debateRound, status: finished ? 'finished' : session.status,
-            stalled: undefined, outcome: finished ? this.outcome(session.sessionId) : session.outcome });
-        this.record(session.sessionId, 'phase_changed', { from: session.phase, to: result.phase, round: result.round, debateRound: result.debateRound ?? session.debateRound, reason: result.reason,
-            ...(context.forced ? { forced: true, forcedBy: context.actor ?? 'human', forceReason: context.reason, skipped: result.skipped ?? [] } : {}) }, context.forced ? (context.actor ?? 'human') : undefined);
+        const updated = this.store.updateSession(session.sessionId, {
+            phase: result.phase,
+            round: result.round,
+            debateRound: result.debateRound ?? session.debateRound,
+            status: finished ? 'finished' : session.status,
+            stalled: undefined,
+            outcome: finished ? this.outcome(session.sessionId) : session.outcome
+        });
+        this.record(session.sessionId, 'phase_changed', {
+            from: session.phase,
+            to: result.phase,
+            round: result.round,
+            debateRound: result.debateRound ?? session.debateRound,
+            reason: result.reason,
+            ...(context.forced
+                ? {
+                    forced: true,
+                    forcedBy: context.actor ?? 'human',
+                    forceReason: context.reason,
+                    skipped: result.skipped ?? []
+                }
+                : {})
+        }, context.forced ? (context.actor ?? 'human') : undefined);
         if (result.escalateDeadlock)
             this.raiseDeadlockEscalation(updated);
         if (finished) {
@@ -1565,8 +2384,16 @@ export class CollabHub {
             this.dispatch(session.sessionId);
     }
     async captureBaseline(session) {
-        const snapshot = await this.resolveBaseline({ cwd: session.cwd, subject: session.subject, round: session.round });
-        const baseline = this.store.saveBaseline({ sessionId: session.sessionId, round: session.round, ...snapshot });
+        const snapshot = await this.resolveBaseline({
+            cwd: session.cwd,
+            subject: session.subject,
+            round: session.round
+        });
+        const baseline = this.store.saveBaseline({
+            sessionId: session.sessionId,
+            round: session.round,
+            ...snapshot
+        });
         this.record(session.sessionId, 'baseline_captured', { ...baseline });
         await this.warmReviewScope(session, baseline);
         return baseline;
@@ -1575,8 +2402,15 @@ export class CollabHub {
     async assertBaselineCurrent(session, baseline = this.store.getBaselineForRound(session.sessionId, session.kind === 'scoring' ? 1 : session.round)) {
         if (!baseline || baseline.vcs === 'none')
             return;
-        const current = await this.resolveBaseline({ cwd: session.cwd, subject: session.subject, round: baseline.round });
-        if (current.vcs !== baseline.vcs || current.commit !== baseline.commit || current.dirtyHash !== baseline.dirtyHash || (baseline.rangeResolved !== undefined && current.rangeResolved !== baseline.rangeResolved))
+        const current = await this.resolveBaseline({
+            cwd: session.cwd,
+            subject: session.subject,
+            round: baseline.round
+        });
+        if (current.vcs !== baseline.vcs ||
+            current.commit !== baseline.commit ||
+            current.dirtyHash !== baseline.dirtyHash ||
+            (baseline.rangeResolved !== undefined && current.rangeResolved !== baseline.rangeResolved))
             throw Object.assign(flowError(COLLAB_ERRORS.staleBaseline, 'The workspace changed after this collaboration baseline was captured. Refresh or restart the review against a new baseline.'), { currentBaseline: { ...current, round: baseline.round } });
     }
     /**
@@ -1589,12 +2423,20 @@ export class CollabHub {
         const owed = owedIssueVoteIds(snapshot, participant.participantId);
         if (!owed.length)
             return this.waitDigest(session, base, idle);
-        return { ...base, task: 'validate_issues', issues: this.store.listIssues(session.sessionId, { status: ['open'], round: session.round }).map(issue => this.withHistory(issue)),
-            yourRequiredIssueIds: owed, currentVotes: currentIssueVotes(snapshot), mergeProposals: this.store.listMergeProposals(session.sessionId),
+        return {
+            ...base,
+            task: 'validate_issues',
+            issues: this.store
+                .listIssues(session.sessionId, { status: ['open'], round: session.round })
+                .map(issue => this.withHistory(issue)),
+            yourRequiredIssueIds: owed,
+            currentVotes: currentIssueVotes(snapshot),
+            mergeProposals: this.store.listMergeProposals(session.sessionId),
             rules: { ...this.consensusRules(session), severity: SEVERITY_GUIDE },
             instructions: session.phase === 'collecting'
                 ? 'You finished your blind review; other reviewers are still filing. Verify each finding in yourRequiredIssueIds against the code yourself, then call collab_submit_issue_votes once with a vote for every one of them. Voting on the set you were given is enough: the hub calls you again for findings that arrive later. A reject needs a rationale. Do not wait, sleep or poll. Merge proposals wait until every reviewer has filed.'
-                : 'Every reviewer has finished the blind review. Verify each finding in yourRequiredIssueIds against the code yourself - approve and reject are claims about the code, not impressions - then call collab_submit_issue_votes once with a vote for each. A reject needs a rationale of at least 20 characters. Put findings that are genuinely the same defect into mergeProposals. Fixing is a separate, human-triggered cycle; this review ends at consensus.' };
+                : 'Every reviewer has finished the blind review. Verify each finding in yourRequiredIssueIds against the code yourself - approve and reject are claims about the code, not impressions - then call collab_submit_issue_votes once with a vote for each. A reject needs a rationale of at least 20 characters. Put findings that are genuinely the same defect into mergeProposals. Fixing is a separate, human-triggered cycle; this review ends at consensus.'
+        };
     }
     /**
      * Cross-votes should not wait for the slowest collector. As soon as two reviewers have closed their own
@@ -1602,17 +2444,32 @@ export class CollabHub {
      */
     dispatchEarlyIssueVotes(sessionId) {
         const session = this.store.findSession(sessionId);
-        if (!session || session.kind !== 'review' || session.phase !== 'collecting' || session.status !== 'active' || !session.policy.consensusReview)
+        if (!session ||
+            session.kind !== 'review' ||
+            session.phase !== 'collecting' ||
+            session.status !== 'active' ||
+            !session.policy.consensusReview)
             return [];
         const snapshot = this.snapshot(sessionId), assigned = [];
         for (const participantId of pendingCrossVoters(snapshot)) {
             const owed = owedIssueVoteIds(snapshot, participantId), task = `validate_issues#${owed.length}`;
             // Findings arrive one wave at a time, so the owed count grows: dedup on the prefix or the same seat
             // collects validate_issues#2, #5, #9 as separate durable items and separate wake-ups.
-            if (!owed.length || this.store.listInbox(participantId).some(item => item.type.split('#')[0] === 'validate_issues'))
+            if (!owed.length ||
+                this.store.listInbox(participantId).some(item => item.type.split('#')[0] === 'validate_issues'))
                 continue;
-            this.push(sessionId, participantId, task, { phase: session.phase, round: session.round, owed: owed.length });
-            this.record(sessionId, 'task_assigned', { participantId, task, phase: session.phase, round: session.round, early: true });
+            this.push(sessionId, participantId, task, {
+                phase: session.phase,
+                round: session.round,
+                owed: owed.length
+            });
+            this.record(sessionId, 'task_assigned', {
+                participantId,
+                task,
+                phase: session.phase,
+                round: session.round,
+                early: true
+            });
             assigned.push(participantId);
         }
         return assigned;
@@ -1624,7 +2481,9 @@ export class CollabHub {
     }
     /** Queues the task for every participant that now owes work. Managed agents are woken from this queue. */
     dispatch(sessionId) {
-        const session = this.store.getSession(sessionId), participants = this.store.listParticipants(sessionId).filter(participant => participant.state === 'active');
+        const session = this.store.getSession(sessionId), participants = this.store
+            .listParticipants(sessionId)
+            .filter(participant => participant.state === 'active');
         const targets = new Map();
         if (session.phase === 'implementing')
             for (const participantId of waitingOn(this.snapshot(sessionId)))
@@ -1632,7 +2491,8 @@ export class CollabHub {
         // In build-then-review the implementer is writing code, not filing reverse findings, so it gets no task here.
         if (session.phase === 'collecting')
             for (const participant of participants)
-                if (participant.role !== 'moderator' && !(session.policy.implementationFirst && participant.role === 'implementer'))
+                if (participant.role !== 'moderator' &&
+                    !(session.policy.implementationFirst && participant.role === 'implementer'))
                     targets.set(participant.participantId, participant.role === 'reviewer' ? 'file_findings' : 'file_findings_optional');
         if (session.phase === 'validating')
             for (const participantId of waitingOn(this.snapshot(sessionId)))
@@ -1648,21 +2508,44 @@ export class CollabHub {
                 targets.set(participantId, 'reconsider_issue_votes');
         for (const [participantId, task] of targets) {
             this.push(sessionId, participantId, task, { phase: session.phase, round: session.round });
-            this.record(sessionId, 'task_assigned', { participantId, task, phase: session.phase, round: session.round });
+            this.record(sessionId, 'task_assigned', {
+                participantId,
+                task,
+                phase: session.phase,
+                round: session.round
+            });
         }
     }
     applyApprovedMerges(sessionId) {
-        const panel = this.store.listParticipants(sessionId).filter(participant => participant.role === 'reviewer' && participant.state !== 'left'), session = this.store.getSession(sessionId), proposals = this.store.listMergeProposals(sessionId).filter(proposal => proposal.round === session.round), parent = new Map();
-        const root = (id) => { const value = parent.get(id); if (!value) {
-            parent.set(id, id);
-            return id;
-        } if (value === id)
-            return id; const resolved = root(value); parent.set(id, resolved); return resolved; };
-        const join = (a, b) => { const left = root(a), right = root(b); if (left !== right)
-            parent.set(right, left); };
+        const panel = this.store
+            .listParticipants(sessionId)
+            .filter(participant => participant.role === 'reviewer' && participant.state !== 'left'), session = this.store.getSession(sessionId), proposals = this.store
+            .listMergeProposals(sessionId)
+            .filter(proposal => proposal.round === session.round), parent = new Map();
+        const root = (id) => {
+            const value = parent.get(id);
+            if (!value) {
+                parent.set(id, id);
+                return id;
+            }
+            if (value === id)
+                return id;
+            const resolved = root(value);
+            parent.set(id, resolved);
+            return resolved;
+        };
+        const join = (a, b) => {
+            const left = root(a), right = root(b);
+            if (left !== right)
+                parent.set(right, left);
+        };
         for (const proposal of proposals) {
             const approved = panel.every(reviewer => proposal.votes.some(vote => vote.participantId === reviewer.participantId && vote.stance === 'approve'));
-            this.record(sessionId, approved ? 'merge_proposal_approved' : 'merge_proposal_rejected', { proposalId: proposal.proposalId, issueIds: proposal.issueIds, votes: proposal.votes });
+            this.record(sessionId, approved ? 'merge_proposal_approved' : 'merge_proposal_rejected', {
+                proposalId: proposal.proposalId,
+                issueIds: proposal.issueIds,
+                votes: proposal.votes
+            });
             if (approved)
                 for (const issueId of proposal.issueIds.slice(1))
                     join(proposal.issueIds[0], issueId);
@@ -1673,12 +2556,17 @@ export class CollabHub {
             groups.set(key, [...(groups.get(key) ?? []), issueId]);
         }
         for (const ids of groups.values()) {
-            const issues = ids.map(id => this.store.getIssue(id)).sort((a, b) => a.createdAt.localeCompare(b.createdAt) || a.issueId.localeCompare(b.issueId)), primary = issues[0];
+            const issues = ids
+                .map(id => this.store.getIssue(id))
+                .sort((a, b) => a.createdAt.localeCompare(b.createdAt) || a.issueId.localeCompare(b.issueId)), primary = issues[0];
             for (const duplicate of issues.slice(1)) {
                 if (duplicate.status !== 'open')
                     continue;
                 this.store.updateIssue(duplicate.issueId, { status: 'duplicate', mergedInto: primary.issueId });
-                this.record(sessionId, 'issues_merged', { primaryIssueId: primary.issueId, duplicateIssueId: duplicate.issueId });
+                this.record(sessionId, 'issues_merged', {
+                    primaryIssueId: primary.issueId,
+                    duplicateIssueId: duplicate.issueId
+                });
             }
         }
         this.store.markPhaseComplete(sessionId, session.round, 'merge_voting', 'system');
@@ -1696,37 +2584,95 @@ export class CollabHub {
             if (resolution.disposition !== 'escalate') {
                 const status = resolution.disposition === 'majority_confirmed' ? 'confirmed' : 'wontfix';
                 this.store.updateIssue(issue.issueId, { status });
-                this.store.addIssueMessage(issue.issueId, session.round, 'system', 'ruling', { decision: resolution.disposition, rationale: resolution.reason,
-                    supporters: resolution.supporters, rejecters: resolution.rejecters, consensusRound: session.debateRound });
-                this.record(session.sessionId, 'issue_panel_ruled', { issueId: issue.issueId, disposition: resolution.disposition, reason: resolution.reason, status,
-                    severity: issue.severity, supporters: resolution.supporters, rejecters: resolution.rejecters });
+                this.store.addIssueMessage(issue.issueId, session.round, 'system', 'ruling', {
+                    decision: resolution.disposition,
+                    rationale: resolution.reason,
+                    supporters: resolution.supporters,
+                    rejecters: resolution.rejecters,
+                    consensusRound: session.debateRound
+                });
+                this.record(session.sessionId, 'issue_panel_ruled', {
+                    issueId: issue.issueId,
+                    disposition: resolution.disposition,
+                    reason: resolution.reason,
+                    status,
+                    severity: issue.severity,
+                    supporters: resolution.supporters,
+                    rejecters: resolution.rejecters
+                });
                 continue;
             }
             if (this.store.findPendingEscalation(session.sessionId, 'issue_dispute', issue.issueId))
                 continue;
             this.store.updateIssue(issue.issueId, { status: 'escalated' });
-            const voteHistory = this.store.listIssueVotes(session.sessionId).filter(vote => vote.issueId === issue.issueId).map(vote => ({ participantId: vote.participantId, stance: `vote round ${vote.consensusRound}: ${vote.stance}`, rationale: vote.rationale ?? 'approved without an additional rationale' }));
-            const discussions = this.store.listIssueMessages(issue.issueId).filter(message => message.kind === 'discussion').map(message => ({ participantId: message.authorId, stance: `discussion round ${message.payload.consensusRound ?? '?'}`, rationale: String(message.payload.argument ?? '') }));
+            const voteHistory = this.store
+                .listIssueVotes(session.sessionId)
+                .filter(vote => vote.issueId === issue.issueId)
+                .map(vote => ({
+                participantId: vote.participantId,
+                stance: `vote round ${vote.consensusRound}: ${vote.stance}`,
+                rationale: vote.rationale ?? 'approved without an additional rationale'
+            }));
+            const discussions = this.store
+                .listIssueMessages(issue.issueId)
+                .filter(message => message.kind === 'discussion')
+                .map(message => ({
+                participantId: message.authorId,
+                stance: `discussion round ${message.payload.consensusRound ?? '?'}`,
+                rationale: String(message.payload.argument ?? '')
+            }));
             const current = issueConsensus(snapshot).find(entry => entry.issueId === issue.issueId);
-            const implicit = (current?.positions ?? []).filter(position => position.implicit).map(position => ({ participantId: position.participantId, stance: 'initial approve (reporter)', rationale: 'issue reporter implicitly approves' }));
-            const escalation = this.store.createEscalation({ sessionId: session.sessionId, kind: 'issue_dispute', refId: issue.issueId, raisedBy: 'system',
+            const implicit = (current?.positions ?? [])
+                .filter(position => position.implicit)
+                .map(position => ({
+                participantId: position.participantId,
+                stance: 'initial approve (reporter)',
+                rationale: 'issue reporter implicitly approves'
+            }));
+            const escalation = this.store.createEscalation({
+                sessionId: session.sessionId,
+                kind: 'issue_dispute',
+                refId: issue.issueId,
+                raisedBy: 'system',
                 summary: resolution.reason === 'panel_unanimously_rejected'
                     ? `Every other reviewer rejected this ${issue.severity} finding, but its reporter did not withdraw it: ${issue.title}`
                     : `The panel split on this ${issue.severity} finding and did not converge in ${session.debateRound} discussion round(s): ${issue.title}`,
-                positions: [...implicit, ...voteHistory, ...discussions], question: `Should "${issue.title}" proceed to implementation?`,
-                options: ['valid issue', 'not an issue', 'needs more investigation'], urgency: issue.severity === 'blocker' || issue.severity === 'critical' ? 'high' : 'normal' });
-            this.record(session.sessionId, 'escalation_raised', { escalationId: escalation.escalationId, kind: 'issue_dispute', refId: issue.issueId, reason: resolution.reason,
-                supporters: resolution.supporters, rejecters: resolution.rejecters });
+                positions: [...implicit, ...voteHistory, ...discussions],
+                question: `Should "${issue.title}" proceed to implementation?`,
+                options: ['valid issue', 'not an issue', 'needs more investigation'],
+                urgency: issue.severity === 'blocker' || issue.severity === 'critical' ? 'high' : 'normal'
+            });
+            this.record(session.sessionId, 'escalation_raised', {
+                escalationId: escalation.escalationId,
+                kind: 'issue_dispute',
+                refId: issue.issueId,
+                reason: resolution.reason,
+                supporters: resolution.supporters,
+                rejecters: resolution.rejecters
+            });
         }
     }
     raiseDeadlockEscalation(session) {
         if (this.store.findPendingEscalation(session.sessionId, 'other'))
             return;
-        const open = this.store.listIssues(session.sessionId).filter(issue => ['open', 'answered', 'escalated'].includes(issue.status));
-        const escalation = this.store.createEscalation({ sessionId: session.sessionId, kind: 'other', raisedBy: 'system',
+        const open = this.store
+            .listIssues(session.sessionId)
+            .filter(issue => ['open', 'answered', 'escalated'].includes(issue.status));
+        const escalation = this.store.createEscalation({
+            sessionId: session.sessionId,
+            kind: 'other',
+            raisedBy: 'system',
             summary: `The session reached its ${session.policy.maxTotalRounds}-round cap with ${open.length} issue(s) still open.`,
-            positions: [], question: 'How should the remaining issues be handled?', options: ['rule on each issue', 'raise the round cap', 'close the session as is'], urgency: 'high' });
-        this.record(session.sessionId, 'escalation_raised', { escalationId: escalation.escalationId, kind: 'other', reason: 'max_total_rounds_reached' });
+            positions: [],
+            question: 'How should the remaining issues be handled?',
+            options: ['rule on each issue', 'raise the round cap', 'close the session as is'],
+            urgency: 'high'
+        });
+        this.record(session.sessionId, 'escalation_raised', {
+            escalationId: escalation.escalationId,
+            kind: 'other',
+            reason: 'max_total_rounds_reached'
+        });
     }
     /** Marks a stall for humans and dashboards. It deliberately does not change the phase. */
     /**
@@ -1750,7 +2696,10 @@ export class CollabHub {
     }
     /** Participants plus the fact a human needs when a session looks frozen: what is still queued undelivered. */
     participantsForHuman(sessionId) {
-        return this.store.listParticipants(sessionId).map(participant => ({ ...participant, pendingTasks: this.store.listInbox(participant.participantId).length }));
+        return this.store.listParticipants(sessionId).map(participant => ({
+            ...participant,
+            pendingTasks: this.store.listInbox(participant.participantId).length
+        }));
     }
     checkStalls() {
         const changed = [];
@@ -1758,7 +2707,9 @@ export class CollabHub {
             const snapshot = this.snapshot(session.sessionId), allPending = waitingOn(snapshot), participants = this.store.listParticipants(session.sessionId);
             // A long review can legitimately exceed the warning window. `streaming`/`starting` means Pi is still
             // actively doing the assigned work, not that the seat forgot to submit its API result.
-            const busy = new Set(participants.filter(participant => ['starting', 'streaming', 'stopping'].includes(this.options.agentStatus?.(participant.agentId) ?? '')).map(participant => participant.participantId));
+            const busy = new Set(participants
+                .filter(participant => ['starting', 'streaming', 'stopping'].includes(this.options.agentStatus?.(participant.agentId) ?? ''))
+                .map(participant => participant.participantId));
             const pending = allPending.filter(participantId => !busy.has(participantId));
             const unclaimed = this.undeliveredTaskOwners(session.sessionId, session.policy.overdueWarningSec, pending);
             if (session.stalled) {
@@ -1778,16 +2729,29 @@ export class CollabHub {
                 continue;
             }
             if (unclaimed.length) {
-                const updated = this.store.updateSession(session.sessionId, { stalled: { since: new Date(this.now()).toISOString(), waitingOn: unclaimed } });
-                this.record(session.sessionId, 'participant_overdue', { waitingOn: unclaimed, overdueBySec: 0, phase: session.phase, reason: 'task_never_delivered' });
+                const updated = this.store.updateSession(session.sessionId, {
+                    stalled: { since: new Date(this.now()).toISOString(), waitingOn: unclaimed }
+                });
+                this.record(session.sessionId, 'participant_overdue', {
+                    waitingOn: unclaimed,
+                    overdueBySec: 0,
+                    phase: session.phase,
+                    reason: 'task_never_delivered'
+                });
                 changed.push(updated);
                 continue;
             }
             const check = stallCheck(snapshot, Date.parse(session.updatedAt), this.now());
             if (!check.stalled || !pending.length)
                 continue;
-            const updated = this.store.updateSession(session.sessionId, { stalled: { since: new Date(this.now()).toISOString(), waitingOn: pending } });
-            this.record(session.sessionId, 'participant_overdue', { waitingOn: pending, overdueBySec: check.overdueBySec, phase: session.phase });
+            const updated = this.store.updateSession(session.sessionId, {
+                stalled: { since: new Date(this.now()).toISOString(), waitingOn: pending }
+            });
+            this.record(session.sessionId, 'participant_overdue', {
+                waitingOn: pending,
+                overdueBySec: check.overdueBySec,
+                phase: session.phase
+            });
             changed.push(updated);
         }
         return changed;
@@ -1797,10 +2761,21 @@ export class CollabHub {
      * for review feedback would sit there forever (or start polling), because a clean review pushes no other task.
      */
     announceFinish(session) {
-        const participants = this.store.listParticipants(session.sessionId).filter(participant => participant.state !== 'left');
+        const participants = this.store
+            .listParticipants(session.sessionId)
+            .filter(participant => participant.state !== 'left');
         for (const participant of participants) {
-            this.push(session.sessionId, participant.participantId, 'session_result', { phase: session.phase, round: session.round, outcome: session.outcome ?? {} });
-            this.record(session.sessionId, 'task_assigned', { participantId: participant.participantId, task: 'session_result', phase: session.phase, round: session.round });
+            this.push(session.sessionId, participant.participantId, 'session_result', {
+                phase: session.phase,
+                round: session.round,
+                outcome: session.outcome ?? {}
+            });
+            this.record(session.sessionId, 'task_assigned', {
+                participantId: participant.participantId,
+                task: 'session_result',
+                phase: session.phase,
+                round: session.round
+            });
         }
     }
     outcome(sessionId) {
@@ -1809,14 +2784,27 @@ export class CollabHub {
             byStatus[issue.status] = (byStatus[issue.status] ?? 0) + 1;
         const snapshot = this.snapshot(sessionId), approval = approvalSummary(snapshot);
         const summary = this.reviewSummary(sessionId);
-        return { totalIssues: issues.length, byStatus,
+        return {
+            totalIssues: issues.length,
+            byStatus,
             // A review now closes with confirmed action items. The verdict describes the report, not whether every
             // finding went through the removed response/adjudication negotiation.
             verdict: summary.verdict,
             approval,
-            participants: this.store.listParticipants(sessionId).map(participant => ({ participantId: participant.participantId, displayName: participant.displayName, role: participant.role, model: participant.model, tokensUsed: participant.tokensUsed, tokensEstimated: participant.tokensEstimated, state: participant.state })) };
+            participants: this.store.listParticipants(sessionId).map(participant => ({
+                participantId: participant.participantId,
+                displayName: participant.displayName,
+                role: participant.role,
+                model: participant.model,
+                tokensUsed: participant.tokensUsed,
+                tokensEstimated: participant.tokensEstimated,
+                state: participant.state
+            }))
+        };
+    }
+    withHistory(issue) {
+        return { ...issue, history: this.store.listIssueMessages(issue.issueId) };
     }
-    withHistory(issue) { return { ...issue, history: this.store.listIssueMessages(issue.issueId) }; }
     /**
      * Flags likely duplicates without merging: a wrong merge silently drops a real defect. While collection is
      * blind the hint is restricted to issues the caller may already read, otherwise the id alone (and a GET on it)
@@ -1831,7 +2819,7 @@ export class CollabHub {
             if (!issue)
                 continue;
             for (const other of all) {
-                if (other.issueId === issueId || issueIds.includes(other.issueId) && other.issueId > issueId)
+                if (other.issueId === issueId || (issueIds.includes(other.issueId) && other.issueId > issueId))
                     continue;
                 if (other.issueId === issueId)
                     continue;
@@ -1844,37 +2832,57 @@ export class CollabHub {
         }
         return results;
     }
-    replay(participant, clientRequestId) { return this.store.getIdempotent(`${participant.participantId}:${clientRequestId}`); }
+    replay(participant, clientRequestId) {
+        return this.store.getIdempotent(`${participant.participantId}:${clientRequestId}`);
+    }
     finish(participant, clientRequestId, body, usage, response) {
         this.store.saveIdempotent(`${participant.participantId}:${clientRequestId}`, participant.sessionId, participant.participantId, response);
         this.chargeUsage(participant, body, usage);
     }
     /** An agent that reports real usage is charged that; one that stays silent is charged a byte-based estimate. */
     chargeUsage(participant, body, usage) {
-        const reported = usage?.totalTokens ?? ((usage?.inputTokens ?? 0) + (usage?.outputTokens ?? 0));
+        const reported = usage?.totalTokens ?? (usage?.inputTokens ?? 0) + (usage?.outputTokens ?? 0);
         const estimated = !reported;
         const tokens = reported || Math.ceil((JSON.stringify(body)?.length ?? 0) / 4);
         const updated = this.store.addTokenUsage(participant.participantId, tokens, estimated);
         if (updated.state === 'budget_exhausted' && participant.state !== 'budget_exhausted') {
-            this.record(participant.sessionId, 'budget_exhausted', { participantId: participant.participantId, tokensUsed: updated.tokensUsed, tokenBudget: updated.tokenBudget });
+            this.record(participant.sessionId, 'budget_exhausted', {
+                participantId: participant.participantId,
+                tokensUsed: updated.tokensUsed,
+                tokenBudget: updated.tokenBudget
+            });
             if (!this.store.findPendingEscalation(participant.sessionId, 'budget_exhausted', participant.participantId)) {
-                const escalation = this.store.createEscalation({ sessionId: participant.sessionId, kind: 'budget_exhausted', refId: participant.participantId, raisedBy: 'system',
-                    summary: `${participant.displayName} spent its ${updated.tokenBudget} token budget and can no longer submit.`, positions: [],
-                    question: 'Raise the budget, replace the agent, or force the phase forward?', options: ['raise budget', 'replace participant', 'force advance'], urgency: 'high' });
-                this.record(participant.sessionId, 'escalation_raised', { escalationId: escalation.escalationId, kind: 'budget_exhausted', refId: participant.participantId });
+                const escalation = this.store.createEscalation({
+                    sessionId: participant.sessionId,
+                    kind: 'budget_exhausted',
+                    refId: participant.participantId,
+                    raisedBy: 'system',
+                    summary: `${participant.displayName} spent its ${updated.tokenBudget} token budget and can no longer submit.`,
+                    positions: [],
+                    question: 'Raise the budget, replace the agent, or force the phase forward?',
+                    options: ['raise budget', 'replace participant', 'force advance'],
+                    urgency: 'high'
+                });
+                this.record(participant.sessionId, 'escalation_raised', {
+                    escalationId: escalation.escalationId,
+                    kind: 'budget_exhausted',
+                    refId: participant.participantId
+                });
             }
         }
         return updated;
     }
-    toFlowParticipant(participant) { return { participantId: participant.participantId, role: participant.role, state: participant.state }; }
-    toFlowIssue(issue) { return { issueId: issue.issueId, reporterId: issue.reporterId, targetParticipantId: issue.targetParticipantId, status: issue.status, round: issue.round, severity: issue.severity }; }
-}
-const words = (value) => new Set(value.toLowerCase().split(/[^a-z0-9\u4e00-\u9fff]+/).filter(token => token.length > 1));
-function similarity(a, b) {
-    const overlapping = a.location.path === b.location.path &&
-        (a.location.startLine === undefined || b.location.startLine === undefined ||
-            Math.max(a.location.startLine, b.location.startLine) <= Math.min(a.location.endLine ?? a.location.startLine, b.location.endLine ?? b.location.startLine));
-    const left = words(`${a.title} ${a.suggestion ?? ''}`), right = words(`${b.title} ${b.suggestion ?? ''}`);
-    const shared = [...left].filter(token => right.has(token)).length, union = new Set([...left, ...right]).size;
-    return (overlapping ? 0.5 : 0) + (union ? 0.5 * (shared / union) : 0);
+    toFlowParticipant(participant) {
+        return { participantId: participant.participantId, role: participant.role, state: participant.state };
+    }
+    toFlowIssue(issue) {
+        return {
+            issueId: issue.issueId,
+            reporterId: issue.reporterId,
+            targetParticipantId: issue.targetParticipantId,
+            status: issue.status,
+            round: issue.round,
+            severity: issue.severity
+        };
+    }
 }