open-research-protocol 0.3.0

package/packs/erdos-open-problems/docs/SUNFLOWER_ADAPTER_DEPENDENCIES.md

@@ -0,0 +1,63 @@
+# Sunflower Adapter Dependencies (857/20/367)
+
+This pack keeps ORP core generic while exposing optional sunflower-coda adapters.
+
+When you install `erdos-open-problems` with:
+
+`./scripts/orp pack install --pack-id erdos-open-problems ...`
+
+ORP writes an install report with dependency audit counts.
+By default, ORP also scaffolds starter adapter files for 857/20/367 (`--no-bootstrap` disables this).
+
+## Component dependency matrix
+
+### `live_compare` (Problems 857/20/367)
+
+Required in target repo:
+
+- `analysis/problem857_counting_gateboard.json`
+- `analysis/problem20_k3_gateboard.json`
+- `analysis/problem367_sharp_gateboard.json`
+- `scripts/problem857_ops_board.py`
+- `scripts/problem20_ops_board.py`
+- `scripts/problem367_ops_board.py`
+- `scripts/frontier_status.py`
+
+### `problem857` (discovery profile)
+
+Required in target repo:
+
+- all `live_compare` dependencies relevant to Problem 857
+- `docs/PROBLEM857_COUNTING_OPS_BOARD.md`
+- `orchestrator/v2/scopes/problem_857.yaml`
+- `orchestrator/problem857_public_spec_check.py`
+- `sunflower_lean/`
+
+In `PROBLEM857_SOURCE_MODE=public_repo`, ORP can satisfy these by syncing the public
+`sunflower-lean` repo into `sunflower_lean/` and generating the missing ORP bridge
+files itself.
+
+### `governance` (mathlib collaboration)
+
+Required in target repo:
+
+- `docs/MATHLIB_SUBMISSION_CHECKLIST.md`
+- `docs/MATHLIB_DRAFT_PR_TEMPLATE.md`
+- `docs/MATHLIB_ISSUE_VIABILITY_GATE.md`
+- `docs/UPSTREAM_PR_LANE.md`
+- `analysis/UPSTREAM_PR_PLAN.yaml`
+- `scripts/upstream-pr-plan.py`
+- `scripts/upstream-pr-lane.sh`
+- `scripts/mathlib-issue-viability-gate.py`
+- `scripts/mathlib-naturality-snippet.sh`
+- `scripts/mathlib-issue-local-gate.sh`
+- `scripts/mathlib-tighten-fine-tooth-gate.sh`
+- `scripts/mathlib-ready-to-draft-gate.sh`
+- `scripts/mathlib-pr-body-preflight.py`
+
+## Recommendation
+
+- Use `catalog` for immediate public adoption.
+- Add `live_compare` once board scripts/data exist in target repo.
+- Add `problem857` in `public_repo` mode for public `sunflower-lean` adoption, or use starter/private adapters when you need richer host-repo workflow state.
+- Add `governance` when those private/workflow dependencies are available.

package/packs/erdos-open-problems/pack.yml

@@ -0,0 +1,131 @@
+schema_version: "1.0.0"
+pack_id: erdos-open-problems
+name: Erdos Open Problems Pack
+version: "0.1.3"
+description: >
+  ORP profile templates for sunflower/Erdos open-problem workflows, including
+  live gate compare profiles for Problems 857, 20, and 367 plus mathlib PR
+  governance profiles for local-first collaboration lanes and Erdos catalog
+  sync profiles.
+orp_version_min: "0.1.0"
+
+variables:
+  TARGET_REPO_ROOT:
+    description: Absolute path to the user's target repo (for example sunflower-coda clone).
+    required: true
+  ORP_TIMEOUT_SEC:
+    description: Default gate timeout in seconds.
+    required: false
+    default: "1200"
+  PROBLEM857_LEAN_BUILD_COMMAND:
+    description: Command used by Problem 857 discovery profile for Lean build gate.
+    required: false
+    default: "lake build SunflowerLean.Balance"
+  PROBLEM857_SOURCE_MODE:
+    description: Problem 857 bootstrap mode (starter|public_repo).
+    required: false
+    default: "starter"
+  PROBLEM857_PUBLIC_REPO_URL:
+    description: Public git repo used to sync the real Problem 857 workspace surface.
+    required: false
+    default: "https://github.com/SproutSeeds/sunflower-lean"
+  PROBLEM857_PUBLIC_REPO_REF:
+    description: Branch, tag, or commit to checkout when PROBLEM857_SOURCE_MODE=public_repo.
+    required: false
+    default: "main"
+  MATHLIB_REPO_ROOT:
+    description: Path to local mathlib checkout used by local/tighten/ready gates.
+    required: false
+    default: "$HOME/Documents/code/mathlib4"
+  MATHLIB_GITHUB_REPO:
+    description: GitHub repo used for viability checks.
+    required: false
+    default: "leanprover-community/mathlib4"
+  MATHLIB_GITHUB_AUTHOR:
+    description: GitHub login used for overlap/ownership checks.
+    required: false
+    default: "SproutSeeds"
+  DEFAULT_PR_BODY_FILE:
+    description: Default PR body file path relative to TARGET_REPO_ROOT.
+    required: false
+    default: "analysis/MATHLIB_DRAFT_PR_BODY.md"
+  READY_TO_DRAFT_NOTE:
+    description: Default micro-pass note used by ready-to-draft gate.
+    required: false
+    default: "micro-pass complete: naming/docstring-tone/readability"
+  UPSTREAM_SUBMISSION_MODE:
+    description: Expected submission mode in analysis/UPSTREAM_PR_PLAN.yaml.
+    required: false
+    default: "hold"
+  MAX_PRS_PER_SESSION:
+    description: Expected anti-spam queue cap from upstream-pr-plan policy summary.
+    required: false
+    default: "2"
+  REQUIRE_EXPLICIT_APPROVAL:
+    description: Expected explicit-approval queue policy value from summary output.
+    required: false
+    default: "True"
+  ORP_REPO_ROOT:
+    description: Absolute path to ORP repo root (needed for shared ORP sync scripts).
+    required: false
+    default: "."
+  ERDOS_SOURCE_URL:
+    description: Source URL for canonical Erdos problem listing scrape.
+    required: false
+    default: "https://erdosproblems.com/range/1-end"
+  ERDOS_DATA_SUBDIR:
+    description: Output directory under TARGET_REPO_ROOT for synced problem snapshots.
+    required: false
+    default: "analysis/erdos_problems"
+  ERDOS_OPEN_LIST_FILE:
+    description: Markdown file path (relative to TARGET_REPO_ROOT) for open-problem direct-link list.
+    required: false
+    default: "analysis/erdos_problems/erdos_open_problems.md"
+  ERDOS_TIMEOUT_SEC:
+    description: HTTP timeout for Erdos catalog sync.
+    required: false
+    default: "90"
+  ERDOS_ACTIVE_STATUS:
+    description: Active subset to publish in erdos_problems.active.json (open|closed|all).
+    required: false
+    default: "open"
+
+templates:
+  sunflower_live_compare_suite:
+    path: profiles/sunflower-live-compare.yml.tmpl
+    description: Side-by-side live gate parity config for Problems 857/20/367.
+    output_hint: orp.erdos-live-compare.yml
+    default_profiles:
+      - sunflower_live_compare_857
+      - sunflower_live_compare_20
+      - sunflower_live_compare_367
+
+  sunflower_problem857_discovery:
+    path: profiles/sunflower-problem857-discovery.yml.tmpl
+    description: Discovery-first atomic profile for Problem 857.
+    output_hint: orp.erdos-problem857.yml
+    default_profiles:
+      - sunflower_problem857_discovery
+
+  sunflower_problem857_discovery_public_repo:
+    path: profiles/sunflower-problem857-discovery-public-repo.yml.tmpl
+    description: Discovery-first atomic profile for Problem 857 against a synced public repo workspace.
+    output_hint: orp.erdos-problem857.yml
+    default_profiles:
+      - sunflower_problem857_discovery
+
+  sunflower_mathlib_pr_governance:
+    path: profiles/sunflower-mathlib-pr-governance.yml.tmpl
+    description: Local-first mathlib PR governance profiles (pre-open, draft-readiness, full flow).
+    output_hint: orp.erdos-mathlib-pr-governance.yml
+    default_profiles:
+      - sunflower_mathlib_pre_open
+      - sunflower_mathlib_draft_readiness
+      - sunflower_mathlib_full_flow
+
+  erdos_problems_catalog_sync:
+    path: profiles/erdos-problems-catalog-sync.yml.tmpl
+    description: Sync all Erdos problems and materialize open/closed/active datasets.
+    output_hint: orp.erdos-catalog-sync.yml
+    default_profiles:
+      - erdos_catalog_sync_active

package/packs/erdos-open-problems/profiles/erdos-problems-catalog-sync.yml.tmpl

@@ -0,0 +1,99 @@
+version: "1"
+
+project:
+  name: erdos-problems-catalog-sync
+  repo_root: .
+  canonical_paths:
+    erdos_all_json: {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}/{{ERDOS_DATA_SUBDIR}}/erdos_problems.all.json
+    erdos_open_json: {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}/{{ERDOS_DATA_SUBDIR}}/erdos_problems.open.json
+    erdos_closed_json: {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}/{{ERDOS_DATA_SUBDIR}}/erdos_problems.closed.json
+    erdos_active_json: {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}/{{ERDOS_DATA_SUBDIR}}/erdos_problems.active.json
+
+runtime:
+  shell: /bin/bash
+  default_timeout_sec: {{ORP_TIMEOUT_SEC}}
+  artifacts_root: orp/artifacts
+
+packet:
+  default_kind: problem_scope
+  output_dir: orp/packets
+  write_markdown: true
+  deterministic_mode: true
+
+epistemic_status:
+  overall: public_data_sync
+  starter_scaffold: false
+  strongest_evidence_paths:
+    - {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}/{{ERDOS_DATA_SUBDIR}}/erdos_problems.active.json
+    - {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}/{{ERDOS_OPEN_LIST_FILE}}
+  notes:
+    - This profile writes public Erdos catalog snapshots that are useful evidence inputs for later workflows.
+
+lifecycle:
+  claim_status_map:
+    Draft: draft
+    In review: ready
+    Verified: reviewed
+    Blocked: blocked
+    Retracted: retracted
+  atom_status_map:
+    todo: draft
+    in_progress: ready
+    blocked: blocked
+    done: reviewed
+  claim_level_values:
+    - Exact
+    - Verified
+    - Heuristic
+    - Conjecture
+
+gates:
+  - id: erdos_catalog_sync
+    description: Sync all Erdos problems from erdosproblems.com and publish open/closed/active snapshots.
+    phase: scope_lock
+    command: >
+      python3 {{ORP_REPO_ROOT}}/scripts/orp-erdos-problems-sync.py
+      --source-url {{ERDOS_SOURCE_URL}}
+      --timeout-sec {{ERDOS_TIMEOUT_SEC}}
+      --active-status {{ERDOS_ACTIVE_STATUS}}
+      --out-all {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}/{{ERDOS_DATA_SUBDIR}}/erdos_problems.all.json
+      --out-open {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}/{{ERDOS_DATA_SUBDIR}}/erdos_problems.open.json
+      --out-closed {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}/{{ERDOS_DATA_SUBDIR}}/erdos_problems.closed.json
+      --out-active {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}/{{ERDOS_DATA_SUBDIR}}/erdos_problems.active.json
+      --out-open-list {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}/{{ERDOS_OPEN_LIST_FILE}}
+    working_dir: {{ORP_REPO_ROOT}}
+    timeout_sec: {{ORP_TIMEOUT_SEC}}
+    pass:
+      exit_codes: [0]
+      stdout_must_contain:
+        - parsed_total=
+        - summary.open=
+        - summary.closed=
+        - active_status={{ERDOS_ACTIVE_STATUS}}
+        - out_open_list=
+      file_must_exist:
+        - {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}/{{ERDOS_DATA_SUBDIR}}/erdos_problems.all.json
+        - {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}/{{ERDOS_DATA_SUBDIR}}/erdos_problems.open.json
+        - {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}/{{ERDOS_DATA_SUBDIR}}/erdos_problems.closed.json
+        - {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}/{{ERDOS_DATA_SUBDIR}}/erdos_problems.active.json
+        - {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}/{{ERDOS_OPEN_LIST_FILE}}
+    evidence:
+      include_stdout: true
+      include_stderr: true
+      status: evidence
+      note: Catalog sync writes public data snapshots that can be cited as evidence inputs.
+      paths:
+        - {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}/{{ERDOS_DATA_SUBDIR}}/erdos_problems.all.json
+        - {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}/{{ERDOS_DATA_SUBDIR}}/erdos_problems.open.json
+        - {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}/{{ERDOS_DATA_SUBDIR}}/erdos_problems.closed.json
+        - {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}/{{ERDOS_DATA_SUBDIR}}/erdos_problems.active.json
+        - {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}/{{ERDOS_OPEN_LIST_FILE}}
+    on_fail: stop
+
+profiles:
+  erdos_catalog_sync_active:
+    description: Sync Erdos problem catalog with open-default active status (override via ERDOS_ACTIVE_STATUS).
+    mode: discovery
+    packet_kind: problem_scope
+    gate_ids:
+      - erdos_catalog_sync

package/packs/erdos-open-problems/profiles/sunflower-live-compare.yml.tmpl

@@ -0,0 +1,188 @@
+version: "1"
+
+project:
+  name: sunflower-coda-live-compare
+  repo_root: .
+  canonical_paths:
+    board_857_json: {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}/analysis/problem857_counting_gateboard.json
+    board_20_json: {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}/analysis/problem20_k3_gateboard.json
+    board_367_json: {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}/analysis/problem367_sharp_gateboard.json
+
+runtime:
+  shell: /bin/bash
+  default_timeout_sec: {{ORP_TIMEOUT_SEC}}
+  artifacts_root: orp/artifacts
+
+packet:
+  default_kind: problem_scope
+  output_dir: orp/packets
+  write_markdown: true
+  deterministic_mode: true
+
+epistemic_status:
+  overall: starter_compare_scaffold
+  starter_scaffold: true
+  notes:
+    - Live compare profiles operate on starter board scaffolding rendered by ORP pack install.
+    - These runs are useful for process visibility, not standalone mathematical evidence.
+
+lifecycle:
+  claim_status_map:
+    Draft: draft
+    In review: ready
+    Verified: reviewed
+    Blocked: blocked
+    Retracted: retracted
+  atom_status_map:
+    todo: draft
+    in_progress: ready
+    blocked: blocked
+    done: reviewed
+  claim_level_values:
+    - Exact
+    - Verified
+    - Heuristic
+    - Conjecture
+
+gates:
+  - id: p857_board_show
+    description: Problem 857 board show snapshot.
+    phase: verification
+    command: python3 scripts/problem857_ops_board.py show
+    working_dir: {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}
+    pass:
+      exit_codes: [0]
+      stdout_must_contain:
+        - route=counting_uniform
+        - route=container_v2
+        - ticket=T6
+        - ready_atoms=
+
+  - id: p857_board_ready
+    description: Problem 857 ready queue snapshot.
+    phase: verification
+    command: python3 scripts/problem857_ops_board.py ready
+    working_dir: {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}
+    pass:
+      exit_codes: [0]
+      stdout_must_contain:
+        - ready_atoms=
+
+  - id: p857_frontier
+    description: Problem 857 strict/loose route status.
+    phase: verification
+    command: python3 scripts/frontier_status.py --problem 857
+    working_dir: {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}
+    pass:
+      exit_codes: [0]
+      stdout_must_contain:
+        - "== Strict Routes (857) =="
+        - counting_uniform
+        - container
+
+  - id: p20_board_show
+    description: Problem 20 board show snapshot.
+    phase: verification
+    command: python3 scripts/problem20_ops_board.py show
+    working_dir: {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}
+    pass:
+      exit_codes: [0]
+      stdout_must_contain:
+        - route=uniform_prize
+        - route=uniform_prize_final_k3
+        - ticket=T6
+        - ready_atoms=
+
+  - id: p20_board_ready
+    description: Problem 20 ready queue snapshot.
+    phase: verification
+    command: python3 scripts/problem20_ops_board.py ready
+    working_dir: {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}
+    pass:
+      exit_codes: [0]
+      stdout_must_contain:
+        - ready_atoms=
+
+  - id: p20_frontier
+    description: Problem 20 strict/loose route status.
+    phase: verification
+    command: python3 scripts/frontier_status.py --problem 20
+    working_dir: {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}
+    pass:
+      exit_codes: [0]
+      stdout_must_contain:
+        - "== Strict Routes (20) =="
+        - uniform_prize
+
+  - id: p367_board_show
+    description: Problem 367 board show snapshot.
+    phase: verification
+    command: python3 scripts/problem367_ops_board.py show
+    working_dir: {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}
+    pass:
+      exit_codes: [0]
+      stdout_must_contain:
+        - route=sieve_weighted_tail
+        - route=full
+        - ticket=T5
+        - ready_atoms=
+
+  - id: p367_board_ready
+    description: Problem 367 ready queue snapshot.
+    phase: verification
+    command: python3 scripts/problem367_ops_board.py ready --allow-no-go
+    working_dir: {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}
+    pass:
+      exit_codes: [0]
+      stdout_must_contain:
+        - no_go_active=
+        - ready_atoms=
+
+  - id: p367_frontier
+    description: Problem 367 strict/loose route status.
+    phase: verification
+    command: python3 scripts/frontier_status.py --problem 367
+    working_dir: {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}
+    pass:
+      exit_codes: [0]
+      stdout_must_contain:
+        - "== Strict Routes (367) =="
+        - sieve_weighted_tail
+        - "full:"
+
+profiles:
+  sunflower_live_compare_857:
+    description: Side-by-side compare profile for Problem 857.
+    mode: discovery
+    packet_kind: problem_scope
+    atomic_board:
+      enabled: true
+      board_path: {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}/analysis/problem857_counting_gateboard.json
+    gate_ids:
+      - p857_board_show
+      - p857_board_ready
+      - p857_frontier
+
+  sunflower_live_compare_20:
+    description: Side-by-side compare profile for Problem 20.
+    mode: discovery
+    packet_kind: problem_scope
+    atomic_board:
+      enabled: true
+      board_path: {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}/analysis/problem20_k3_gateboard.json
+    gate_ids:
+      - p20_board_show
+      - p20_board_ready
+      - p20_frontier
+
+  sunflower_live_compare_367:
+    description: Side-by-side compare profile for Problem 367.
+    mode: discovery
+    packet_kind: problem_scope
+    atomic_board:
+      enabled: true
+      board_path: {{TARGET_REPO_ROOT}}/analysis/problem367_sharp_gateboard.json
+    gate_ids:
+      - p367_board_show
+      - p367_board_ready
+      - p367_frontier