noteconnection 1.8.0 → 1.9.0

package/dist/src/learning/answerReleaseReview.test.js

@@ -1,6 +1,7 @@
 "use strict";
 Object.defineProperty(exports, "__esModule", { value: true });
 const answerReleaseReview_1 = require("./answerReleaseReview");
+const graphAnswerPlan_1 = require("./graphAnswerPlan");
 const scopedWaterglass = {
     source: 'scoped',
     workspaceId: 'waterglass',
@@ -202,6 +203,228 @@ function makeComparisonGraphContext(relationKind, leftTitle, rightTitle, overrid
     };
 }
 describe('answerReleaseReview', () => {
+    test('does not treat standalone mathematical variable definitions as subject conflicts', () => {
+        const point = makeKnowledgePoint({
+            summary: 'The VFT model describes supercooled liquid viscosity as temperature changes.',
+            evidenceSnippet: 'The VFT model describes supercooled liquid viscosity as temperature changes.',
+        });
+        const review = (0, answerReleaseReview_1.reviewAnswerRelease)({
+            message: 'what is water glass?',
+            draftAnswer: 'Water glass is a transparent container. The VFT model describes supercooled liquid viscosity as temperature changes. $\\eta(T)$ is the viscosity at temperature T.',
+            knowledgePoints: [point],
+            citations: [point.citation],
+            usedScope: scopedWaterglass,
+            graphContext: makeGraphContext(),
+            ragContextPack: {
+                query: 'what is water glass?',
+                generatedAt: '2026-07-12T00:00:00.000Z',
+                sourceBoundary: 'direct_span_only',
+                budget: { maxFragments: 2, maxCharsPerFragment: 500, maxTotalChars: 900 },
+                fragments: [{
+                        fragmentId: 'vft_context',
+                        role: 'direct_support',
+                        text: 'The VFT model describes supercooled liquid viscosity as temperature changes. $\\eta(T)$ is the viscosity at temperature T.',
+                        atomId: point.atomId,
+                        documentId: point.documentId || '',
+                        sourcePath: point.sourcePath || '',
+                        title: point.title,
+                        headingPath: [point.title],
+                        charCount: 120,
+                        tokenEstimate: 30,
+                        truncated: false,
+                        citationIds: [point.citation?.citationId || 'citation_water_glass'],
+                        relationEdgeIds: [],
+                        sourceBoundary: 'direct_span_only',
+                    }],
+                sourceDecisions: [],
+                totalCharCount: 120,
+                tokenEstimate: 30,
+            },
+            reviewedAt: '2026-07-12T00:00:00.000Z',
+        });
+        expect(review.failedGateIds).not.toContain('claim_subject_consistency');
+    });
+    test('does not treat a formula variable sentence with multiple math spans as an entity subject conflict', () => {
+        const point = makeKnowledgePoint({
+            title: '核心概念与数学基础',
+            summary: '描述过冷液体粘度随温度变化的常用模型。',
+            evidenceSnippet: '描述过冷液体粘度随温度变化的常用模型。',
+            sourcePath: 'Knowledge_Base/waterglass/Amorphous ice.md',
+        });
+        const review = (0, answerReleaseReview_1.reviewAnswerRelease)({
+            message: '什么是非晶冰？我应该通过哪些知识点学习？',
+            draftAnswer: '描述过冷液体粘度随温度变化的常用模型。$\\eta(T)$ 是在温度 $T$ 下的粘度。',
+            knowledgePoints: [point],
+            citations: [point.citation],
+            usedScope: scopedWaterglass,
+            graphContext: makeGraphContext({ anchorTitle: '非晶冰' }),
+            ragContextPack: {
+                query: '什么是非晶冰？我应该通过哪些知识点学习？',
+                generatedAt: '2026-07-12T00:00:00.000Z',
+                sourceBoundary: 'direct_span_only',
+                budget: { maxFragments: 1, maxCharsPerFragment: 500, maxTotalChars: 500 },
+                fragments: [{
+                        fragmentId: 'amorphous_math_variable',
+                        role: 'direct_support',
+                        atomId: point.atomId,
+                        documentId: point.documentId || '',
+                        sourcePath: point.sourcePath || '',
+                        title: point.title,
+                        headingPath: [point.title],
+                        text: '描述过冷液体粘度随温度变化的常用模型。$\\eta(T)$ 是在温度 $T$ 下的粘度。',
+                        charCount: 80,
+                        tokenEstimate: 20,
+                        truncated: false,
+                        citationIds: [point.citation?.citationId || 'citation_water_glass'],
+                        relationEdgeIds: [],
+                        sourceBoundary: 'direct_span_only',
+                    }],
+                sourceDecisions: [],
+                totalCharCount: 80,
+                tokenEstimate: 20,
+            },
+            reviewedAt: '2026-07-12T00:00:00.000Z',
+        });
+        expect(review.failedGateIds).not.toContain('claim_subject_consistency');
+    });
+    test('does not release a definition-only draft for a compound learning request', () => {
+        const point = makeKnowledgePoint({
+            atomId: 'atom_amorphous_ice',
+            atomIds: ['atom_amorphous_ice', 'atom_water_structure', 'atom_rdf'],
+            documentId: 'doc_amorphous_ice',
+            sourcePath: 'Knowledge_Base/waterglass/Amorphous ice.md',
+            title: 'Amorphous Ice',
+            summary: 'Amorphous ice is a solid form of water without long-range crystalline order.',
+            evidenceSnippet: 'Amorphous ice is a solid form of water without long-range crystalline order.',
+            matchedSpans: [
+                {
+                    atomId: 'atom_amorphous_ice',
+                    title: 'Amorphous Ice',
+                    snippet: 'Amorphous ice is a solid form of water without long-range crystalline order.',
+                    sourcePath: 'Knowledge_Base/waterglass/Amorphous ice.md',
+                    score: 0.94,
+                    citation: null,
+                },
+                {
+                    atomId: 'atom_water_structure',
+                    title: 'Water Molecular Structure',
+                    snippet: 'Water molecules and hydrogen bonding explain the local structure of ice.',
+                    sourcePath: 'Knowledge_Base/waterglass/Amorphous ice.md',
+                    score: 0.86,
+                    citation: null,
+                },
+                {
+                    atomId: 'atom_rdf',
+                    title: 'Radial Distribution Function',
+                    snippet: 'The radial distribution function g(r) distinguishes short-range from long-range order.',
+                    sourcePath: 'Knowledge_Base/waterglass/Amorphous ice.md',
+                    score: 0.84,
+                    citation: null,
+                },
+            ],
+        });
+        const message = 'what is amorphous ice? Which knowledge points should I learn?';
+        const graphContext = makeGraphContext({
+            anchorAtomId: 'atom_amorphous_ice',
+            anchorTitle: 'Amorphous Ice',
+        });
+        const graphAnswerPlan = (0, graphAnswerPlan_1.buildGraphAnswerPlan)({
+            message,
+            knowledgePoints: [point],
+            graphContext,
+        });
+        const review = (0, answerReleaseReview_1.reviewAnswerRelease)({
+            message,
+            draftAnswer: 'Amorphous ice is a solid form of water without long-range crystalline order.',
+            knowledgePoints: [point],
+            citations: [],
+            usedScope: scopedWaterglass,
+            graphContext,
+            graphAnswerPlan,
+            reviewedAt: '2026-07-12T00:00:00.000Z',
+        });
+        expect(review.draftAnswerTaskCoverage).toEqual(expect.objectContaining({
+            passed: false,
+            missingRequiredSubtaskIds: expect.arrayContaining(['learning_route']),
+        }));
+        expect(review.failedGateIds).toContain('subtask_coverage');
+        expect(review.failedGateIds).toContain('deliverable_completeness');
+        expect(review.decision).toBe('revise');
+        expect(review.answerTaskCoverage?.passed).toBe(true);
+    });
+    test('abstains when grounded evidence belongs to a different requested subject', () => {
+        const waterGlassPoint = makeKnowledgePoint({
+            title: 'Water Glass',
+            summary: 'Water glass is a transparent container filled with water.',
+            evidenceSnippet: 'Water glass is a transparent container filled with water.',
+        });
+        const review = (0, answerReleaseReview_1.reviewAnswerRelease)({
+            message: '什么是非晶冰？我应该通过哪些知识点学习？',
+            draftAnswer: '水杯是一个用于盛水的透明容器。',
+            knowledgePoints: [waterGlassPoint],
+            citations: [waterGlassPoint.citation],
+            usedScope: scopedWaterglass,
+            graphContext: makeGraphContext({
+                anchorTitle: 'Water Glass',
+                supportingTitles: ['Amorphous Ice'],
+                supportingAtomIds: ['atom_amorphous_ice'],
+            }),
+            ragContextPack: {
+                query: '什么是非晶冰？我应该通过哪些知识点学习？',
+                generatedAt: '2026-07-08T00:00:00.000Z',
+                sourceBoundary: 'full_document',
+                budget: {
+                    maxFragments: 4,
+                    maxCharsPerFragment: 600,
+                    maxTotalChars: 1600,
+                },
+                fragments: [{
+                        fragmentId: 'rag_water_glass',
+                        role: 'direct_support',
+                        text: '水杯是一个用于盛水的透明容器。',
+                        atomId: 'atom_water_glass',
+                        documentId: 'doc_water_glass',
+                        sourcePath: 'Knowledge_Base/waterglass/water-glass.md',
+                        title: 'Water Glass',
+                        headingPath: ['Water Glass'],
+                        charCount: 20,
+                        tokenEstimate: 10,
+                        truncated: false,
+                        citationIds: ['citation_water_glass'],
+                        sourceBoundary: 'direct_span_only',
+                    }],
+                sourceDecisions: [],
+                totalCharCount: 20,
+                tokenEstimate: 10,
+            },
+            ragSufficiencyReview: {
+                reviewedAt: '2026-07-08T00:00:00.000Z',
+                status: 'sufficient',
+                score: 0.9,
+                reasons: [],
+                deterministic: true,
+            },
+            reviewedAt: '2026-07-08T00:00:01.000Z',
+        });
+        expect(review.decision).toBe('abstain');
+        expect(review.failedGateIds).toContain('query_subject_alignment');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).toContain('非晶冰');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).not.toContain('水杯是一个用于盛水的透明容器');
+    });
+    test('keeps definition answers when the requested subject is supported by the evidence title', () => {
+        const review = (0, answerReleaseReview_1.reviewAnswerRelease)({
+            message: 'what is water glass?',
+            draftAnswer: 'A water glass is a transparent container filled with water.',
+            knowledgePoints: [makeKnowledgePoint()],
+            citations: [makeKnowledgePoint().citation],
+            usedScope: scopedWaterglass,
+            graphContext: makeGraphContext(),
+            reviewedAt: '2026-07-08T00:01:00.000Z',
+        });
+        expect(review.decision).toBe('release');
+        expect(review.failedGateIds).not.toContain('query_subject_alignment');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).toContain('water glass');
+    });
     test('downgrades unsupported debug-style answers into concise abstentions', () => {
         const review = (0, answerReleaseReview_1.reviewAnswerRelease)({
             message: '什么是waterglass?',
@@ -427,7 +650,39 @@ describe('answerReleaseReview', () => {
         expect(review.publicAnswer).toContain('紧邻前置节点包括 材料科学');
         expect(review.publicAnswer).toContain('后续分支包括 热量传递模型');
     });
-    test('enriches releasable definition answers with bounded evidence and graph context', () => {
+    test('does not cut a public evidence highlight through a mathematical expression', () => {
+        const longFormulaClause = [
+            'The thermal field has a grounded physical interpretation',
+            ...Array.from({ length: 12 }, () => 'with a stable source-backed description'),
+            'and is governed by $$\\frac{\\partial T}{\\partial t}=\\alpha\\nabla^2 T$$, where alpha is the thermal diffusivity and the complete clause remains readable for the public answer.',
+        ].join(' ');
+        expect(longFormulaClause.length).toBeGreaterThan(480);
+        const thermalCitation = {
+            ...makeKnowledgePoint().citation,
+            citationId: 'citation_thermal_formula',
+            atomId: 'atom_thermal_formula',
+            title: 'Thermal Model',
+            snippet: longFormulaClause,
+        };
+        const point = makeKnowledgePoint({
+            citations: [makeKnowledgePoint().citation, thermalCitation],
+        });
+        const review = (0, answerReleaseReview_1.reviewAnswerRelease)({
+            message: 'what is water glass',
+            draftAnswer: 'This technical document analyzes water glass as a physical system.',
+            knowledgePoints: [point],
+            citations: [point.citation, thermalCitation],
+            usedScope: scopedWaterglass,
+            graphContext: makeGraphContext(),
+            reviewedAt: '2026-07-12T00:05:00.000Z',
+        });
+        expect(review.decision).toBe('revise');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).toContain('$$\n\\frac{\\partial T}{\\partial t}=\\alpha\\nabla^2 T\n$$');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).toContain('the complete clause remains readable for the public answer.');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).not.toContain('...');
+        expect((review.publicAnswer.match(/\$\$/gu) || []).length % 2).toBe(0);
+    });
+    test('releases a complete definition draft without replacing its natural answer shape', () => {
         const baseCitation = makeKnowledgePoint().citation;
         const thermalCitation = {
             ...baseCitation,
@@ -515,18 +770,770 @@ describe('answerReleaseReview', () => {
             reviewedAt: '2026-07-04T08:20:00.000Z',
         });
         expect(review.decision).toBe('release');
-        expect(review.revised).toBe(true);
+        expect(review.revised).toBe(false);
         expect(review.publicAnswer).toContain('Water glass is a transparent container filled with water.');
-        expect(review.publicAnswer).toContain('The same knowledge point also covers Thermal Model.');
-        expect(review.publicAnswer).toContain('Evidence highlights: Thermal Model');
-        expect(review.publicAnswer).toContain('Water Glass has 1 incoming and 1 outgoing links');
-        expect(review.publicAnswer).toContain('its immediate predecessors include Container Physics');
-        expect(review.publicAnswer).toContain('likely next nodes include Thermal Model');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).not.toContain('The same knowledge point also covers Thermal Model.');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).not.toContain('Evidence highlights: Thermal Model');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).not.toContain('Water Glass has 1 incoming and 1 outgoing links');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).not.toContain('its immediate predecessors include Container Physics');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).not.toContain('likely next nodes include Thermal Model');
         expect(review.publicAnswer).not.toContain('predecessors include Water Glass');
         expect(review.publicAnswer).not.toContain('next nodes include Water Glass');
         expect(review.publicAnswer).not.toContain('(mermaid block)');
         expect(review.publicAnswer).not.toContain('```');
     });
+    test('does not reject an evidence-grounded answer merely because it exceeds 900 characters', () => {
+        const point = makeKnowledgePoint();
+        const groundedSentence = 'Water glass is a transparent container filled with water and its wall separates the liquid from the surrounding environment.';
+        const longGroundedAnswer = Array.from({ length: 9 }, (_, index) => `${groundedSentence} Detail ${index + 1}.`).join(' ');
+        const review = (0, answerReleaseReview_1.reviewAnswerRelease)({
+            message: 'what is water glass',
+            draftAnswer: longGroundedAnswer,
+            knowledgePoints: [point],
+            citations: [point.citation],
+            usedScope: scopedWaterglass,
+            graphContext: makeGraphContext(),
+            reviewedAt: '2026-07-11T09:00:00.000Z',
+        });
+        expect(longGroundedAnswer.length).toBeGreaterThan(900);
+        expect(review.failedGateIds).not.toContain('public_surface_contraction');
+    });
+    test('deduplicates a formula-only definition claim already carried by contextual evidence', () => {
+        const point = makeKnowledgePoint({
+            title: 'Water Glass',
+            summary: 'Water glass is a transparent vessel designed to hold water.',
+            evidenceSnippet: 'Water glass is a transparent vessel designed to hold water.',
+        });
+        const documentId = point.documentId || 'doc_water_glass';
+        const sourcePath = point.sourcePath || 'Knowledge_Base/waterglass/water-glass.md';
+        const equation = '$$\\frac{\\partial T}{\\partial t}=\\alpha\\nabla^2 T$$';
+        const graphAnswerPlan = {
+            intent: 'definition',
+            depth: 'standard',
+            anchorAtomId: point.atomId,
+            leadClaimId: 'claim_definition',
+            requiredRoles: ['definition'],
+            omittedCandidates: [],
+            claims: [
+                {
+                    claimId: 'claim_definition',
+                    role: 'definition',
+                    required: true,
+                    priority: 1,
+                    statement: 'Water glass is a transparent vessel designed to hold water.',
+                    subjectAtomId: point.atomId,
+                    supportingAtomIds: [],
+                    supportingEdgeIds: [],
+                    evidenceRefs: [{
+                            evidenceId: 'citation_water_glass',
+                            atomId: point.atomId,
+                            sourcePath,
+                            citationIds: ['citation_water_glass'],
+                            text: point.evidenceSnippet,
+                        }],
+                    confidence: 0.96,
+                },
+                {
+                    claimId: 'claim_thermal_context',
+                    role: 'definition',
+                    required: true,
+                    priority: 2,
+                    statement: `Its thermal field is modeled by ${equation} where T is temperature and alpha is thermal diffusivity.`,
+                    subjectAtomId: point.atomId,
+                    supportingAtomIds: [],
+                    supportingEdgeIds: [],
+                    evidenceRefs: [{
+                            evidenceId: 'citation_thermal_context',
+                            atomId: point.atomId,
+                            sourcePath,
+                            citationIds: ['citation_thermal_context'],
+                            text: `Its thermal field is modeled by ${equation} where T is temperature and alpha is thermal diffusivity.`,
+                        }],
+                    confidence: 0.95,
+                },
+                {
+                    claimId: 'claim_thermal_formula',
+                    role: 'definition',
+                    required: true,
+                    priority: 3,
+                    statement: equation,
+                    subjectAtomId: point.atomId,
+                    supportingAtomIds: [],
+                    supportingEdgeIds: [],
+                    evidenceRefs: [{
+                            evidenceId: 'citation_thermal_formula',
+                            atomId: point.atomId,
+                            sourcePath,
+                            citationIds: ['citation_thermal_formula'],
+                            text: equation,
+                        }],
+                    confidence: 0.94,
+                },
+            ],
+        };
+        const ragContextPack = {
+            query: 'what is water glass?',
+            generatedAt: '2026-08-24T00:00:00.000Z',
+            sourceBoundary: 'direct_span_only',
+            budget: { maxFragments: 3, maxCharsPerFragment: 600, maxTotalChars: 1200 },
+            fragments: [{
+                    fragmentId: 'water_glass_formula_context',
+                    role: 'direct_support',
+                    text: `Water glass is a transparent vessel designed to hold water. Its thermal field is modeled by ${equation} where T is temperature and alpha is thermal diffusivity.`,
+                    atomId: point.atomId,
+                    documentId,
+                    sourcePath,
+                    title: point.title,
+                    headingPath: ['Water Glass'],
+                    startLine: 1,
+                    endLine: 5,
+                    charCount: 180,
+                    tokenEstimate: 45,
+                    truncated: false,
+                    citationIds: ['citation_water_glass', 'citation_thermal_context'],
+                    sourceBoundary: 'direct_span_only',
+                }],
+            sourceDecisions: [],
+            totalCharCount: 180,
+            tokenEstimate: 45,
+        };
+        const review = (0, answerReleaseReview_1.reviewAnswerRelease)({
+            message: 'what is water glass?',
+            draftAnswer: [
+                'Water glass is a transparent vessel designed to hold water.',
+                `Its thermal field is modeled by ${equation} where T is temperature and alpha is thermal diffusivity.`,
+                equation,
+            ].join(' '),
+            knowledgePoints: [point],
+            citations: [point.citation],
+            usedScope: scopedWaterglass,
+            graphContext: makeGraphContext(),
+            graphAnswerPlan,
+            ragContextPack,
+            ragSufficiencyReview: {
+                reviewedAt: '2026-08-24T00:00:00.000Z',
+                status: 'sufficient',
+                score: 0.95,
+                reasons: [],
+                deterministic: true,
+                recoveryAttempted: false,
+                llmJudgeUsed: false,
+                degradationState: 'none',
+            },
+            reviewedAt: '2026-08-24T00:00:00.000Z',
+        });
+        expect((review.publicAnswer.match(/\\frac\{\\partial T\}\{\\partial t\}=\\alpha\\nabla\^2 T/gu) || [])).toHaveLength(1);
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).toContain('where T is temperature and alpha is thermal diffusivity.');
+    });
+    test('projects every eligible definition claim without a RAG pack and records coverage on the final public answer', () => {
+        const point = makeKnowledgePoint({
+            title: 'Water Glass',
+            summary: 'A water glass is a transparent vessel used to hold water.',
+            evidenceSnippet: 'A water glass is a transparent vessel used to hold water.',
+        });
+        const sourcePath = point.sourcePath || 'Knowledge_Base/waterglass/water-glass.md';
+        const graphAnswerPlan = {
+            intent: 'definition',
+            depth: 'standard',
+            anchorAtomId: point.atomId,
+            leadClaimId: 'claim_definition',
+            requiredRoles: ['definition', 'composition', 'boundary', 'mechanism', 'application', 'contrast'],
+            omittedCandidates: [],
+            claims: [
+                {
+                    claimId: 'claim_definition',
+                    role: 'definition',
+                    required: true,
+                    priority: 1,
+                    statement: 'A water glass is a transparent vessel used to hold water.',
+                    subjectAtomId: point.atomId,
+                    supportingAtomIds: [],
+                    supportingEdgeIds: [],
+                    evidenceRefs: [{ evidenceId: 'definition', atomId: point.atomId, sourcePath, citationIds: [], text: point.evidenceSnippet }],
+                    confidence: 0.98,
+                },
+                {
+                    claimId: 'claim_composition',
+                    role: 'composition',
+                    required: true,
+                    priority: 2,
+                    statement: 'It combines a glass vessel with the water it contains.',
+                    subjectAtomId: point.atomId,
+                    supportingAtomIds: [],
+                    supportingEdgeIds: [],
+                    evidenceRefs: [{ evidenceId: 'composition', atomId: point.atomId, sourcePath, citationIds: [], text: 'It combines a glass vessel with the water it contains.' }],
+                    confidence: 0.97,
+                },
+                {
+                    claimId: 'claim_boundary',
+                    role: 'boundary',
+                    required: true,
+                    priority: 3,
+                    statement: 'Its wall separates the liquid from the surrounding air.',
+                    subjectAtomId: point.atomId,
+                    supportingAtomIds: [],
+                    supportingEdgeIds: [],
+                    evidenceRefs: [{ evidenceId: 'boundary', atomId: point.atomId, sourcePath, citationIds: [], text: 'Its wall separates the liquid from the surrounding air.' }],
+                    confidence: 0.96,
+                },
+                {
+                    claimId: 'claim_mechanism',
+                    role: 'mechanism',
+                    required: true,
+                    priority: 4,
+                    statement: 'Light refracts at the air-glass-water interfaces.',
+                    subjectAtomId: point.atomId,
+                    supportingAtomIds: [],
+                    supportingEdgeIds: [],
+                    evidenceRefs: [{ evidenceId: 'mechanism', atomId: point.atomId, sourcePath, citationIds: [], text: 'Light refracts at the air-glass-water interfaces.' }],
+                    confidence: 0.95,
+                },
+                {
+                    claimId: 'claim_application',
+                    role: 'application',
+                    required: true,
+                    priority: 5,
+                    statement: 'Its thermal field can be modeled by $$\\frac{\\partial T}{\\partial t}=\\alpha\\nabla^2 T$$, where T is temperature.',
+                    subjectAtomId: point.atomId,
+                    supportingAtomIds: [],
+                    supportingEdgeIds: [],
+                    evidenceRefs: [{ evidenceId: 'thermal', atomId: point.atomId, sourcePath, citationIds: [], text: 'Its thermal field can be modeled by $$\\frac{\\partial T}{\\partial t}=\\alpha\\nabla^2 T$$, where T is temperature.' }],
+                    confidence: 0.94,
+                },
+                {
+                    claimId: 'claim_contrast',
+                    role: 'contrast',
+                    required: true,
+                    priority: 6,
+                    statement: 'Plastic cups are a different category of container.',
+                    subjectAtomId: point.atomId,
+                    supportingAtomIds: [],
+                    supportingEdgeIds: [],
+                    evidenceRefs: [{ evidenceId: 'contrast', atomId: point.atomId, sourcePath, citationIds: [], text: 'Plastic cups are a different category of container.' }],
+                    confidence: 0.93,
+                },
+            ],
+        };
+        const review = (0, answerReleaseReview_1.reviewAnswerRelease)({
+            message: 'what is water glass?',
+            draftAnswer: 'A water glass is a transparent vessel used to hold water. Plastic cups are a different category of container.',
+            knowledgePoints: [point],
+            citations: [point.citation],
+            usedScope: scopedWaterglass,
+            graphContext: makeGraphContext(),
+            graphAnswerPlan,
+            reviewedAt: '2026-08-24T00:10:00.000Z',
+        });
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).toContain('It combines a glass vessel with the water it contains.');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).toContain('Its wall separates the liquid from the surrounding air.');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).toContain('Light refracts at the air-glass-water interfaces.');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).toContain('$$\n\\frac{\\partial T}{\\partial t}=\\alpha\\nabla^2 T\n$$');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).not.toContain('Plastic cups');
+        expect(review.publicGraphAnswerPlan.claims.map((claim) => claim.claimId)).toEqual([
+            'claim_definition',
+            'claim_composition',
+            'claim_boundary',
+            'claim_mechanism',
+            'claim_application',
+        ]);
+        expect(review.graphAnswerCoverage).toEqual(expect.objectContaining({
+            passed: true,
+            missingRequiredClaimIds: [],
+        }));
+    });
+    test('keeps distinct complete formula contexts in a full-document definition projection', () => {
+        const point = makeKnowledgePoint({
+            title: '水杯 (water glass)',
+            summary: '此处的“水杯”被定义为一个由水和玻璃杯组成的物理系统。',
+            evidenceSnippet: '此处的“水杯”被定义为一个由水和玻璃杯组成的物理系统。',
+        });
+        const sourcePath = point.sourcePath || 'Knowledge_Base/waterglass/water-glass.md';
+        const thermalEquation = '$$\\frac{\\partial T}{\\partial t}=\\alpha\\nabla^2 T$$';
+        const opticalEquation = '$$n_1\\sin(\\theta_1)=n_2\\sin(\\theta_2)$$';
+        const claim = (claimId, role, statement, priority) => ({
+            claimId,
+            role,
+            required: true,
+            priority,
+            statement,
+            subjectAtomId: point.atomId,
+            supportingAtomIds: [],
+            supportingEdgeIds: [],
+            evidenceRefs: [{
+                    evidenceId: claimId,
+                    atomId: point.atomId,
+                    sourcePath,
+                    citationIds: [point.citation?.citationId || 'citation_water_glass'],
+                    text: statement,
+                }],
+            confidence: 0.96,
+        });
+        const graphAnswerPlan = {
+            intent: 'definition',
+            depth: 'deep',
+            anchorAtomId: point.atomId,
+            leadClaimId: 'definition',
+            requiredRoles: ['definition', 'mechanism'],
+            omittedCandidates: [],
+            claims: [
+                claim('definition', 'definition', '此处的“水杯”被定义为一个由水和玻璃杯组成的物理系统。', 100),
+                claim('thermal_context', 'definition', `系统内部的温度分布由热传导方程描述：${thermalEquation} 其中 $T$ 是温度场。`, 100),
+                claim('optical_context', 'definition', `折射现象由斯涅尔定律描述：${opticalEquation} 其中 $n_1$ 和 $n_2$ 是介质折射率。`, 100),
+                claim('thermal_alpha', 'mechanism', '$\\alpha = \\frac{k}{\\rho c_p}$ 是热扩散率。', 360),
+                claim('thermal_k', 'mechanism', '$k$ 是热导率。', 360),
+                claim('thermal_cp', 'mechanism', '$c_p$ 是比热容。', 360),
+                claim('thermal_exchange', 'mechanism', '水杯系统与环境之间通过传导、对流和辐射进行热交换。', 360),
+                claim('chapter_marker', 'definition', '4. 热力学：热量传递', 100),
+            ],
+        };
+        const review = (0, answerReleaseReview_1.reviewAnswerRelease)({
+            message: '什么是waterglass?',
+            draftAnswer: [
+                '此处的“水杯”被定义为一个由水和玻璃杯组成的物理系统。',
+                `系统内部的温度分布由热传导方程描述：${thermalEquation} 其中 $T$ 是温度场。`,
+                `折射现象由斯涅尔定律描述：${opticalEquation} 其中 $n_1$ 和 $n_2$ 是介质折射率。`,
+                '本技术文档还包含技术规格和比较章节。',
+            ].join(' '),
+            knowledgePoints: [point],
+            citations: [point.citation],
+            usedScope: scopedWaterglass,
+            graphContext: makeGraphContext(),
+            graphAnswerPlan,
+            ragContextPack: {
+                query: '什么是waterglass?',
+                generatedAt: '2026-08-25T00:00:00.000Z',
+                sourceBoundary: 'full_document',
+                budget: { maxFragments: 14, maxCharsPerFragment: 1400, maxTotalChars: 5600 },
+                fragments: [{
+                        fragmentId: 'full_document_waterglass',
+                        role: 'direct_support',
+                        text: [
+                            '此处的“水杯”被定义为一个由水和玻璃杯组成的物理系统。',
+                            `系统内部的温度分布由热传导方程描述：${thermalEquation} 其中 $T$ 是温度场。`,
+                            `折射现象由斯涅尔定律描述：${opticalEquation} 其中 $n_1$ 和 $n_2$ 是介质折射率。`,
+                        ].join(' '),
+                        atomId: point.atomId,
+                        documentId: point.documentId || 'doc_water_glass',
+                        sourcePath,
+                        title: point.title,
+                        headingPath: [point.title],
+                        charCount: 240,
+                        tokenEstimate: 60,
+                        truncated: false,
+                        citationIds: [point.citation?.citationId || 'citation_water_glass'],
+                        sourceBoundary: 'full_document',
+                    }],
+                sourceDecisions: [],
+                totalCharCount: 240,
+                tokenEstimate: 60,
+            },
+            ragSufficiencyReview: {
+                reviewedAt: '2026-08-25T00:00:00.000Z',
+                status: 'sufficient',
+                score: 0.95,
+                reasons: [],
+                deterministic: true,
+                recoveryAttempted: false,
+                llmJudgeUsed: false,
+                degradationState: 'none',
+            },
+            reviewedAt: '2026-08-25T00:00:00.000Z',
+        });
+        const publicClaims = review.publicGraphAnswerPlan?.claims || [];
+        expect(publicClaims.map((entry) => entry.claimId)).toEqual([
+            'definition',
+            'thermal_context',
+            'optical_context',
+        ]);
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).toContain('$$\n\\frac{\\partial T}{\\partial t}=\\alpha\\nabla^2 T\n$$');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).toContain('$$\nn_1\\sin(\\theta_1)=n_2\\sin(\\theta_2)\n$$');
+        expect((review.publicAnswer.match(/\\frac\{\\partial T\}\{\\partial t\}=\\alpha\\nabla\^2 T/gu) || [])).toHaveLength(1);
+        expect((review.publicAnswer.match(/n_1\\sin\(\\theta_1\)=n_2\\sin\(\\theta_2\)/gu) || [])).toHaveLength(1);
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).not.toContain('$k$ 是热导率');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).not.toContain('4. 热力学');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).not.toContain('热交换');
+    });
+    test('does not reintroduce comparison or duplicate formula claims through conflict supplements', () => {
+        const point = makeKnowledgePoint({
+            title: 'Water Glass',
+            summary: 'Water glass is a transparent vessel designed to hold water.',
+            evidenceSnippet: 'Water glass is a transparent vessel designed to hold water.',
+        });
+        const sourcePath = point.sourcePath || 'Knowledge_Base/waterglass/water-glass.md';
+        const equation = '$$\\frac{\\partial T}{\\partial t}=\\alpha\\nabla^2 T$$';
+        const graphAnswerPlan = {
+            intent: 'definition',
+            depth: 'standard',
+            anchorAtomId: point.atomId,
+            leadClaimId: 'definition',
+            requiredRoles: ['definition'],
+            omittedCandidates: [],
+            claims: [
+                {
+                    claimId: 'definition', role: 'definition', required: true, priority: 1,
+                    statement: 'Water glass is a transparent vessel designed to hold water.',
+                    subjectAtomId: point.atomId, supportingAtomIds: [], supportingEdgeIds: [],
+                    evidenceRefs: [{ evidenceId: 'definition', atomId: point.atomId, sourcePath, citationIds: [], text: point.evidenceSnippet }], confidence: 0.98,
+                },
+                {
+                    claimId: 'formula_context', role: 'mechanism', required: true, priority: 2,
+                    statement: `Its thermal field follows ${equation}, where T is temperature.`,
+                    subjectAtomId: point.atomId, supportingAtomIds: [], supportingEdgeIds: [],
+                    evidenceRefs: [{ evidenceId: 'formula_context', atomId: point.atomId, sourcePath, citationIds: [], text: `Its thermal field follows ${equation}, where T is temperature.` }], confidence: 0.97,
+                },
+                {
+                    claimId: 'formula_only', role: 'mechanism', required: false, priority: 3,
+                    statement: equation,
+                    subjectAtomId: point.atomId, supportingAtomIds: [], supportingEdgeIds: [],
+                    evidenceRefs: [{ evidenceId: 'formula_only', atomId: point.atomId, sourcePath, citationIds: [], text: equation }], confidence: 0.96,
+                },
+                {
+                    claimId: 'comparison_artifact', role: 'contrast', required: false, priority: 4,
+                    statement: 'Water glass transparent vessel comparison with plastic cup has 20 cm reference height.',
+                    subjectAtomId: point.atomId, supportingAtomIds: [], supportingEdgeIds: [],
+                    evidenceRefs: [{ evidenceId: 'comparison_artifact', atomId: point.atomId, sourcePath, citationIds: [], text: 'Water glass transparent vessel comparison with plastic cup has 20 cm reference height.' }], confidence: 0.95,
+                },
+            ],
+        };
+        const review = (0, answerReleaseReview_1.reviewAnswerRelease)({
+            message: 'what is water glass?',
+            draftAnswer: `Water glass is a transparent vessel designed to hold water. Its thermal field follows ${equation}, where T is temperature.`,
+            knowledgePoints: [point],
+            citations: [point.citation],
+            usedScope: scopedWaterglass,
+            graphContext: makeGraphContext(),
+            graphAnswerPlan,
+            ragContextPack: {
+                query: 'what is water glass?',
+                generatedAt: '2026-08-24T00:20:00.000Z',
+                sourceBoundary: 'direct_span_only',
+                budget: { maxFragments: 1, maxCharsPerFragment: 600, maxTotalChars: 600 },
+                fragments: [{
+                        fragmentId: 'direct', role: 'direct_support', text: point.evidenceSnippet,
+                        atomId: point.atomId, documentId: point.documentId || 'doc_water_glass', sourcePath, title: point.title,
+                        headingPath: ['Water Glass'], charCount: point.evidenceSnippet.length, tokenEstimate: 16,
+                        truncated: false, citationIds: ['definition'], sourceBoundary: 'direct_span_only',
+                    }],
+                sourceDecisions: [], totalCharCount: point.evidenceSnippet.length, tokenEstimate: 16,
+            },
+            ragSufficiencyReview: {
+                reviewedAt: '2026-08-24T00:20:00.000Z', status: 'borderline', score: 0.6,
+                reasons: [], deterministic: true, degradationState: 'conflict',
+            },
+            reviewedAt: '2026-08-24T00:20:00.000Z',
+        });
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).not.toContain('plastic cup');
+        expect((review.publicAnswer.match(/\\frac\{\\partial T\}\{\\partial t\}=\\alpha\\nabla\^2 T/gu) || [])).toHaveLength(1);
+    });
+    test('rejects a math-bearing definition plan claim that ends in incomplete prose', () => {
+        const point = makeKnowledgePoint({
+            title: 'Water Glass',
+            summary: 'Water glass is a bounded physical system.',
+            evidenceSnippet: 'Water glass is a bounded physical system.',
+        });
+        const sourcePath = point.sourcePath || 'Knowledge_Base/waterglass/water-glass.md';
+        const equation = '$$\\frac{\\partial T}{\\partial t}=\\alpha\\nabla^2 T$$';
+        const fullStatement = `Water glass is a bounded physical system whose temperature field follows ${equation}, where T is temperature and alpha is thermal diffusivity across the interface.`;
+        const incompleteStatement = fullStatement.replace('the interface.', 't');
+        const graphAnswerPlan = {
+            intent: 'definition',
+            depth: 'compact',
+            anchorAtomId: point.atomId,
+            leadClaimId: 'incomplete_formula_claim',
+            requiredRoles: ['definition'],
+            omittedCandidates: [],
+            claims: [
+                {
+                    claimId: 'incomplete_formula_claim',
+                    role: 'definition',
+                    required: true,
+                    priority: 2,
+                    statement: incompleteStatement,
+                    subjectAtomId: point.atomId,
+                    supportingAtomIds: [],
+                    supportingEdgeIds: [],
+                    evidenceRefs: [{
+                            evidenceId: 'parent_context',
+                            atomId: point.atomId,
+                            sourcePath,
+                            citationIds: [],
+                            text: incompleteStatement,
+                        }],
+                    confidence: 0.94,
+                },
+                {
+                    claimId: 'complete_formula_claim',
+                    role: 'definition',
+                    required: true,
+                    priority: 1,
+                    statement: fullStatement,
+                    subjectAtomId: point.atomId,
+                    supportingAtomIds: [],
+                    supportingEdgeIds: [],
+                    evidenceRefs: [{
+                            evidenceId: 'direct_support',
+                            atomId: point.atomId,
+                            sourcePath,
+                            citationIds: [],
+                            text: fullStatement,
+                        }],
+                    confidence: 0.95,
+                },
+            ],
+        };
+        const review = (0, answerReleaseReview_1.reviewAnswerRelease)({
+            message: 'what is waterglass?',
+            draftAnswer: fullStatement,
+            knowledgePoints: [point],
+            citations: [point.citation],
+            usedScope: scopedWaterglass,
+            graphContext: makeGraphContext(),
+            graphAnswerPlan,
+            ragContextPack: {
+                query: 'what is waterglass?',
+                generatedAt: '2026-08-25T00:00:00.000Z',
+                sourceBoundary: 'direct_span_only',
+                budget: { maxFragments: 2, maxCharsPerFragment: 600, maxTotalChars: 1200 },
+                fragments: [
+                    {
+                        fragmentId: 'direct_support', role: 'direct_support', text: fullStatement,
+                        atomId: point.atomId, documentId: point.documentId || 'doc_water_glass', sourcePath, title: point.title,
+                        headingPath: ['Water Glass'], charCount: fullStatement.length, tokenEstimate: 60,
+                        truncated: false, citationIds: ['citation_water_glass'], sourceBoundary: 'direct_span_only',
+                    },
+                    {
+                        fragmentId: 'parent_context', role: 'parent_context', text: incompleteStatement,
+                        atomId: point.atomId, documentId: point.documentId || 'doc_water_glass', sourcePath, title: point.title,
+                        headingPath: ['Water Glass'], charCount: incompleteStatement.length, tokenEstimate: 60,
+                        truncated: false, citationIds: ['citation_water_glass'], sourceBoundary: 'direct_span_only',
+                    },
+                ],
+                sourceDecisions: [], totalCharCount: fullStatement.length + incompleteStatement.length, tokenEstimate: 120,
+            },
+            ragSufficiencyReview: {
+                reviewedAt: '2026-08-25T00:00:00.000Z', status: 'sufficient', score: 0.95,
+                reasons: [], deterministic: true, recoveryAttempted: false, llmJudgeUsed: false, degradationState: 'none',
+            },
+            reviewedAt: '2026-08-25T00:00:00.000Z',
+        });
+        expect(review.publicGraphAnswerPlan?.claims.map((claim) => claim.claimId)).toEqual([
+            'complete_formula_claim',
+        ]);
+        expect((review.publicAnswer.match(/Water glass is a bounded physical system/gu) || [])).toHaveLength(1);
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).not.toContain('across t Water glass');
+    });
+    test('does not publish an unrelated CFL variable glossary in a waterglass definition', () => {
+        const point = makeKnowledgePoint({
+            title: '水杯 (water glass)',
+            summary: '此处的“水杯”被定义为一个由水和玻璃杯组成的物理系统。',
+            evidenceSnippet: '此处的“水杯”被定义为一个由水和玻璃杯组成的物理系统。',
+        });
+        const sourcePath = point.sourcePath || 'Knowledge_Base/waterglass/water-glass.md';
+        const graphAnswerPlan = {
+            intent: 'definition',
+            depth: 'standard',
+            anchorAtomId: point.atomId,
+            leadClaimId: 'waterglass_definition',
+            requiredRoles: ['definition', 'attribute'],
+            omittedCandidates: [],
+            claims: [
+                {
+                    claimId: 'waterglass_definition',
+                    role: 'definition',
+                    required: true,
+                    priority: 100,
+                    statement: '此处的“水杯”被定义为一个由水和玻璃杯组成的物理系统。',
+                    subjectAtomId: point.atomId,
+                    supportingAtomIds: [],
+                    supportingEdgeIds: [],
+                    evidenceRefs: [{
+                            evidenceId: 'waterglass_definition',
+                            atomId: point.atomId,
+                            sourcePath,
+                            citationIds: [],
+                            text: '此处的“水杯”被定义为一个由水和玻璃杯组成的物理系统。',
+                        }],
+                    confidence: 0.99,
+                },
+                {
+                    claimId: 'cfl_variable_glossary',
+                    role: 'attribute',
+                    required: true,
+                    priority: 88,
+                    statement: '其中 $C$ 是库朗数，$u$ 是特征速度，$\\Delta x$ 是网格尺寸。',
+                    subjectAtomId: point.atomId,
+                    supportingAtomIds: [],
+                    supportingEdgeIds: [],
+                    evidenceRefs: [{
+                            evidenceId: 'cfl_variable_glossary',
+                            atomId: point.atomId,
+                            sourcePath,
+                            citationIds: [],
+                            text: '其中 $C$ 是库朗数，$u$ 是特征速度，$\\Delta x$ 是网格尺寸。',
+                        }],
+                    confidence: 0.98,
+                },
+            ],
+        };
+        const review = (0, answerReleaseReview_1.reviewAnswerRelease)({
+            message: '什么是waterglass?',
+            draftAnswer: '此处的“水杯”被定义为一个由水和玻璃杯组成的物理系统。',
+            knowledgePoints: [point],
+            citations: [point.citation],
+            usedScope: scopedWaterglass,
+            graphContext: makeGraphContext(),
+            graphAnswerPlan,
+            ragContextPack: {
+                query: '什么是waterglass?',
+                generatedAt: '2026-08-25T00:00:00.000Z',
+                sourceBoundary: 'full_document',
+                budget: { maxFragments: 2, maxCharsPerFragment: 600, maxTotalChars: 1200 },
+                fragments: [{
+                        fragmentId: 'waterglass_full_document',
+                        role: 'direct_support',
+                        text: '此处的“水杯”被定义为一个由水和玻璃杯组成的物理系统。实现考量中的CFL变量 glossary 不属于定义。',
+                        atomId: point.atomId,
+                        documentId: point.documentId || 'doc_water_glass',
+                        sourcePath,
+                        title: point.title,
+                        headingPath: [point.title],
+                        charCount: 100,
+                        tokenEstimate: 25,
+                        truncated: false,
+                        citationIds: [point.citation?.citationId || 'citation_water_glass'],
+                        sourceBoundary: 'full_document',
+                    }],
+                sourceDecisions: [],
+                totalCharCount: 100,
+                tokenEstimate: 25,
+            },
+            ragSufficiencyReview: {
+                reviewedAt: '2026-08-25T00:00:00.000Z',
+                status: 'sufficient',
+                score: 0.95,
+                reasons: [],
+                deterministic: true,
+                recoveryAttempted: false,
+                llmJudgeUsed: false,
+                degradationState: 'none',
+            },
+            reviewedAt: '2026-08-25T00:00:00.000Z',
+        });
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).toContain('水杯”被定义');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).not.toContain('库朗数');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).not.toContain('网格尺寸');
+        expect(review.publicGraphAnswerPlan?.claims.map((claim) => claim.claimId)).toEqual([
+            'waterglass_definition',
+        ]);
+    });
+    test('keeps a CFL variable glossary when the query explicitly asks about CFL', () => {
+        const point = makeKnowledgePoint({
+            title: 'CFL stability condition',
+            summary: 'The CFL stability condition bounds the time step.',
+            evidenceSnippet: 'The CFL stability condition bounds the time step.',
+        });
+        const sourcePath = point.sourcePath || 'Knowledge_Base/waterglass/water-glass.md';
+        const glossary = 'where $C$ is the Courant number, $u$ is the characteristic velocity, and $\\Delta x$ is the grid size.';
+        const review = (0, answerReleaseReview_1.reviewAnswerRelease)({
+            message: 'What is the CFL stability condition?',
+            draftAnswer: `The CFL stability condition bounds the time step. ${glossary}`,
+            knowledgePoints: [point],
+            citations: [point.citation],
+            usedScope: scopedWaterglass,
+            graphContext: makeGraphContext({ anchorTitle: 'CFL stability condition' }),
+            graphAnswerPlan: {
+                intent: 'definition',
+                depth: 'standard',
+                anchorAtomId: point.atomId,
+                leadClaimId: 'cfl_definition',
+                requiredRoles: ['definition', 'attribute'],
+                omittedCandidates: [],
+                claims: [
+                    {
+                        claimId: 'cfl_definition',
+                        role: 'definition',
+                        required: true,
+                        priority: 100,
+                        statement: 'The CFL stability condition bounds the time step.',
+                        subjectAtomId: point.atomId,
+                        supportingAtomIds: [],
+                        supportingEdgeIds: [],
+                        evidenceRefs: [{ evidenceId: 'cfl_definition', atomId: point.atomId, sourcePath, citationIds: [], text: 'The CFL stability condition bounds the time step.' }],
+                        confidence: 0.99,
+                    },
+                    {
+                        claimId: 'cfl_glossary',
+                        role: 'attribute',
+                        required: true,
+                        priority: 88,
+                        statement: glossary,
+                        subjectAtomId: point.atomId,
+                        supportingAtomIds: [],
+                        supportingEdgeIds: [],
+                        evidenceRefs: [{ evidenceId: 'cfl_glossary', atomId: point.atomId, sourcePath, citationIds: [], text: glossary }],
+                        confidence: 0.98,
+                    },
+                ],
+            },
+            ragContextPack: {
+                query: 'What is the CFL stability condition?',
+                generatedAt: '2026-08-25T00:00:00.000Z',
+                sourceBoundary: 'full_document',
+                budget: { maxFragments: 1, maxCharsPerFragment: 600, maxTotalChars: 600 },
+                fragments: [{
+                        fragmentId: 'cfl_full_document',
+                        role: 'direct_support',
+                        text: `The CFL stability condition bounds the time step. ${glossary}`,
+                        atomId: point.atomId,
+                        documentId: point.documentId || 'doc_water_glass',
+                        sourcePath,
+                        title: point.title,
+                        headingPath: [point.title],
+                        charCount: 140,
+                        tokenEstimate: 35,
+                        truncated: false,
+                        citationIds: [point.citation?.citationId || 'citation_water_glass'],
+                        sourceBoundary: 'full_document',
+                    }],
+                sourceDecisions: [],
+                totalCharCount: 140,
+                tokenEstimate: 35,
+            },
+            ragSufficiencyReview: {
+                reviewedAt: '2026-08-25T00:00:00.000Z',
+                status: 'sufficient',
+                score: 0.95,
+                reasons: [],
+                deterministic: true,
+                recoveryAttempted: false,
+                llmJudgeUsed: false,
+                degradationState: 'none',
+            },
+            reviewedAt: '2026-08-25T00:00:00.000Z',
+        });
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).toContain('Courant number');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).toContain('grid size');
+        expect(review.publicGraphAnswerPlan?.claims.map((claim) => claim.claimId)).toEqual([
+            'cfl_definition',
+            'cfl_glossary',
+        ]);
+    });
+    test('honors an explicit Chinese answer language for English no-evidence abstentions', () => {
+        const review = (0, answerReleaseReview_1.reviewAnswerRelease)({
+            message: 'what is water glass?',
+            answerLanguage: 'zh',
+            draftAnswer: 'No scoped knowledge points matched "what is water glass?".',
+            knowledgePoints: [],
+            citations: [],
+            usedScope: scopedWaterglass,
+            graphContext: null,
+            reviewedAt: '2026-08-24T00:30:00.000Z',
+        });
+        expect(review.decision).toBe('abstain');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).toContain('当前范围');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).toContain('我暂时不能');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).not.toContain('I cannot give a grounded answer');
+    });
     test('keeps RAG evidence in revised definition answers after public-surface contraction', () => {
         const baseCitation = makeKnowledgePoint({
             title: 'Water Glass',
@@ -1357,6 +2364,33 @@ describe('answerReleaseReview', () => {
             }),
         ]));
     });
+    test('does not treat a scope-qualified heading and its source sentence as different subjects', () => {
+        const point = makeKnowledgePoint({
+            title: 'Staging Owner',
+            summary: '## Staging Owner The deployment owner is Release Ops in the staging environment.',
+            evidenceSnippet: '## Staging Owner The deployment owner is Release Ops in the staging environment.',
+            citation: {
+                ...makeKnowledgePoint().citation,
+                title: 'Staging Owner',
+                snippet: '## Staging Owner The deployment owner is Release Ops in the staging environment.',
+            },
+            citations: [{
+                    ...makeKnowledgePoint().citation,
+                    title: 'Staging Owner',
+                    snippet: '## Staging Owner The deployment owner is Release Ops in the staging environment.',
+                }],
+        });
+        const review = (0, answerReleaseReview_1.reviewAnswerRelease)({
+            message: 'compare staging and production deployment owners',
+            draftAnswer: 'Cross environment staging owner source records that the deployment owner is Release Ops in the staging environment.',
+            knowledgePoints: [point],
+            citations: point.citations || [],
+            usedScope: scopedWaterglass,
+            graphContext: makeGraphContext(),
+            reviewedAt: '2026-08-24T00:34:00.000Z',
+        });
+        expect(review.failedGateIds).not.toContain('claim_subject_consistency');
+    });
     test('revises grounded answers when same-subject attribute claims conflict with cited support', () => {
         const point = makeKnowledgePoint({
             title: 'Water Glass',
@@ -2110,6 +3144,28 @@ describe('answerReleaseReview', () => {
             }),
         ]));
     });
+    test('still rejects an unsupported polarity assertion written as a heading', () => {
+        const review = (0, answerReleaseReview_1.reviewAnswerRelease)({
+            message: 'what is water glass', responseMode: 'full',
+            draftAnswer: '# Water glass is not a transparent container filled with water.',
+            knowledgePoints: [makeKnowledgePoint()],
+            citations: [makeKnowledgePoint().citation],
+            usedScope: scopedWaterglass, graphContext: makeGraphContext(),
+        });
+        expect(review.failedGateIds).toContain('claim_polarity_consistency');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).not.toContain('is not a transparent container');
+    });
+    test('does not trust a source label attached to an unsupported assertion', () => {
+        const review = (0, answerReleaseReview_1.reviewAnswerRelease)({
+            message: 'what is water glass',
+            draftAnswer: 'Water Glass: Water glass is not a transparent container filled with water.',
+            knowledgePoints: [makeKnowledgePoint()],
+            citations: [makeKnowledgePoint().citation],
+            usedScope: scopedWaterglass, graphContext: makeGraphContext(),
+        });
+        expect(review.failedGateIds).toContain('claim_polarity_consistency');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).not.toContain('is not a transparent container');
+    });
     test('does not raise a polarity conflict when support includes an unrelated negative sentence', () => {
         const point = makeKnowledgePoint({
             summary: 'Water glass is not plastic. Water glass is a transparent container filled with water.',
@@ -2854,6 +3910,236 @@ describe('answerReleaseReview', () => {
             }),
         ]));
     });
+    test('does not restore a containment-conflicting graph plan after revising the answer', () => {
+        const point = makeKnowledgePoint({
+            title: 'Water Glass',
+            summary: 'Water Glass contains water.',
+            evidenceSnippet: 'Water Glass contains water.',
+            citation: {
+                ...makeKnowledgePoint().citation,
+                title: 'Water Glass',
+                snippet: 'Water Glass contains water.',
+            },
+            citations: [{
+                    ...makeKnowledgePoint().citation,
+                    title: 'Water Glass',
+                    snippet: 'Water Glass contains water.',
+                }],
+        });
+        const unsafePlan = {
+            intent: 'definition',
+            depth: 'compact',
+            anchorAtomId: point.atomId,
+            leadClaimId: 'claim_unsafe_containment',
+            requiredRoles: ['definition'],
+            omittedCandidates: [],
+            claims: [{
+                    claimId: 'claim_unsafe_containment',
+                    role: 'definition',
+                    required: true,
+                    priority: 1,
+                    statement: 'Water Glass contains mercury.',
+                    subjectAtomId: point.atomId,
+                    supportingAtomIds: [],
+                    supportingEdgeIds: [],
+                    evidenceRefs: [{
+                            evidenceId: 'unsafe_containment',
+                            atomId: point.atomId,
+                            sourcePath: point.sourcePath || 'Knowledge_Base/waterglass/water-glass.md',
+                            citationIds: ['citation_water_glass'],
+                            text: 'Water Glass contains mercury.',
+                        }],
+                    confidence: 0.9,
+                }],
+        };
+        const review = (0, answerReleaseReview_1.reviewAnswerRelease)({
+            message: 'what does water glass contain?',
+            draftAnswer: 'Water Glass contains mercury.',
+            knowledgePoints: [point],
+            citations: point.citations || [],
+            usedScope: scopedWaterglass,
+            graphContext: makeGraphContext(),
+            graphAnswerPlan: unsafePlan,
+            ragContextPack: {
+                query: 'what does water glass contain?',
+                generatedAt: '2026-08-24T00:30:00.000Z',
+                sourceBoundary: 'direct_span_only',
+                budget: { maxFragments: 1, maxCharsPerFragment: 600, maxTotalChars: 600 },
+                fragments: [{
+                        fragmentId: 'unsafe_plan_rag_context',
+                        role: 'direct_support',
+                        text: 'Water Glass contains water.',
+                        atomId: point.atomId,
+                        documentId: point.documentId || 'doc_water_glass',
+                        sourcePath: point.sourcePath || 'Knowledge_Base/waterglass/water-glass.md',
+                        title: point.title,
+                        headingPath: ['Water Glass'],
+                        charCount: 27,
+                        tokenEstimate: 7,
+                        truncated: false,
+                        citationIds: ['citation_water_glass'],
+                        sourceBoundary: 'direct_span_only',
+                    }],
+                sourceDecisions: [],
+                totalCharCount: 27,
+                tokenEstimate: 7,
+            },
+            ragSufficiencyReview: {
+                reviewedAt: '2026-08-24T00:30:00.000Z',
+                status: 'sufficient',
+                score: 0.9,
+                reasons: [],
+                deterministic: true,
+                recoveryAttempted: false,
+                llmJudgeUsed: false,
+                degradationState: 'none',
+            },
+            reviewedAt: '2026-08-24T00:30:00.000Z',
+        });
+        expect(review.decision).toBe('revise');
+        expect(review.failedGateIds).toContain('claim_containment_consistency');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).toContain('Water Glass contains water.');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).not.toContain('mercury');
+        expect(review.publicGraphAnswerPlan?.claims).toEqual([]);
+        expect(review.auditGraphAnswerPlan).toEqual(unsafePlan);
+        expect(review.graphAnswerCoverage).toEqual(expect.objectContaining({
+            applicable: false,
+        }));
+    });
+    test('drops a newly introduced unsafe plan claim during final public-answer validation', () => {
+        const point = makeKnowledgePoint({
+            title: 'Water Glass',
+            summary: 'Water Glass contains water.',
+            evidenceSnippet: 'Water Glass contains water.',
+            citation: {
+                ...makeKnowledgePoint().citation,
+                title: 'Water Glass',
+                snippet: 'Water Glass contains water.',
+            },
+        });
+        const unsafePlan = {
+            intent: 'definition',
+            depth: 'compact',
+            anchorAtomId: point.atomId,
+            leadClaimId: 'unsafe_plan_claim',
+            requiredRoles: ['definition'],
+            omittedCandidates: [],
+            claims: [{
+                    claimId: 'unsafe_plan_claim',
+                    role: 'definition',
+                    required: true,
+                    priority: 1,
+                    statement: 'Water Glass contains mercury.',
+                    subjectAtomId: point.atomId,
+                    supportingAtomIds: [],
+                    supportingEdgeIds: [],
+                    evidenceRefs: [{
+                            evidenceId: 'unsafe_plan_claim',
+                            atomId: point.atomId,
+                            sourcePath: point.sourcePath || 'Knowledge_Base/waterglass/water-glass.md',
+                            citationIds: [],
+                            text: 'Water Glass contains mercury.',
+                        }],
+                    confidence: 0.9,
+                }],
+        };
+        const review = (0, answerReleaseReview_1.reviewAnswerRelease)({
+            message: 'what does water glass contain?',
+            draftAnswer: 'Water Glass contains water.',
+            knowledgePoints: [point],
+            citations: [point.citation],
+            usedScope: scopedWaterglass,
+            graphContext: makeGraphContext(),
+            graphAnswerPlan: unsafePlan,
+            ragContextPack: {
+                query: 'what does water glass contain?',
+                generatedAt: '2026-08-24T00:32:00.000Z',
+                sourceBoundary: 'direct_span_only',
+                budget: { maxFragments: 1, maxCharsPerFragment: 600, maxTotalChars: 600 },
+                fragments: [{
+                        fragmentId: 'safe_support',
+                        role: 'direct_support',
+                        text: 'Water Glass contains water.',
+                        atomId: point.atomId,
+                        documentId: point.documentId || 'doc_water_glass',
+                        sourcePath: point.sourcePath || 'Knowledge_Base/waterglass/water-glass.md',
+                        title: point.title,
+                        headingPath: ['Water Glass'],
+                        charCount: 27,
+                        tokenEstimate: 7,
+                        truncated: false,
+                        citationIds: ['citation_water_glass'],
+                        sourceBoundary: 'direct_span_only',
+                    }],
+                sourceDecisions: [],
+                totalCharCount: 27,
+                tokenEstimate: 7,
+            },
+            ragSufficiencyReview: {
+                reviewedAt: '2026-08-24T00:32:00.000Z',
+                status: 'sufficient',
+                score: 0.9,
+                reasons: [],
+                deterministic: true,
+                recoveryAttempted: false,
+                llmJudgeUsed: false,
+                degradationState: 'none',
+            },
+            reviewedAt: '2026-08-24T00:32:00.000Z',
+        });
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).toBe('Water Glass contains water.');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).not.toContain('mercury');
+        expect(review.publicGraphAnswerPlan?.claims).toEqual([]);
+        expect(review.graphAnswerCoverage).toEqual(expect.objectContaining({ applicable: false }));
+    });
+    test('abstains when a required definition plan projects to zero public claims', () => {
+        const point = makeKnowledgePoint({
+            title: 'Water Glass',
+            summary: 'Water Glass is compared with a PET Plastic Cup.',
+            evidenceSnippet: 'Water Glass is compared with a PET Plastic Cup.',
+        });
+        const comparisonOnlyPlan = {
+            intent: 'definition',
+            depth: 'compact',
+            anchorAtomId: point.atomId,
+            leadClaimId: 'comparison_only',
+            requiredRoles: ['contrast'],
+            omittedCandidates: [],
+            claims: [{
+                    claimId: 'comparison_only',
+                    role: 'contrast',
+                    required: true,
+                    priority: 1,
+                    statement: 'Water Glass is compared with a PET Plastic Cup.',
+                    subjectAtomId: point.atomId,
+                    supportingAtomIds: [],
+                    supportingEdgeIds: [],
+                    evidenceRefs: [{
+                            evidenceId: 'comparison_only',
+                            atomId: point.atomId,
+                            sourcePath: point.sourcePath || 'Knowledge_Base/waterglass/water-glass.md',
+                            citationIds: [],
+                            text: 'Water Glass is compared with a PET Plastic Cup.',
+                        }],
+                    confidence: 0.91,
+                }],
+        };
+        const review = (0, answerReleaseReview_1.reviewAnswerRelease)({
+            message: 'what is water glass?',
+            draftAnswer: 'Water Glass is compared with a PET Plastic Cup.',
+            knowledgePoints: [point],
+            citations: [point.citation],
+            usedScope: scopedWaterglass,
+            graphContext: makeGraphContext(),
+            graphAnswerPlan: comparisonOnlyPlan,
+            reviewedAt: '2026-08-24T00:35:00.000Z',
+        });
+        expect(review.decision).toBe('abstain');
+        expect(review.failedGateIds).toContain('definition_projection_integrity');
+        expect(review.publicAnswer).not.toContain('PET Plastic Cup');
+        expect(review.publicGraphAnswerPlan?.claims).toEqual([]);
+        expect(review.auditGraphAnswerPlan).toEqual(comparisonOnlyPlan);
+    });
     test('revises grounded answers when a DAG analogy pair is incorrectly released as a Chinese contrast claim', () => {
         const point = makeKnowledgePoint({
             title: '层流',